From eb8f821458211e91590e77132f93697b4b440d7f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 15:02:19 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 01/21] FE-808 persist graph node ordinals --- drizzle/0001_aspiring_orphan.sql | 12 + drizzle/meta/0001_snapshot.json | 573 ++++++++++++++++++ drizzle/meta/_journal.json | 7 + memory/PLAN.md | 4 +- memory/SPEC.md | 4 +- ...h-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md | 2 +- src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts | 3 + src/agents/contexts/graph.test.ts | 1 + src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts | 1 + src/db/README.md | 15 +- src/db/row-schemas.ts | 13 +- src/db/schema.ts | 60 +- src/graph/README.md | 20 +- src/graph/command-executor.test.ts | 121 +++- src/graph/command-executor.ts | 37 ++ src/graph/schema/nodes.ts | 1 + src/graph/snapshot.test.ts | 1 + src/graph/snapshot.ts | 1 + src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts | 2 + 19 files changed, 841 insertions(+), 37 deletions(-) create mode 100644 drizzle/0001_aspiring_orphan.sql create mode 100644 drizzle/meta/0001_snapshot.json diff --git a/drizzle/0001_aspiring_orphan.sql b/drizzle/0001_aspiring_orphan.sql new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0d2b70878 --- /dev/null +++ b/drizzle/0001_aspiring_orphan.sql @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +CREATE TABLE `node_kind_counters` ( + `id` integer PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT NOT NULL, + `spec_id` integer NOT NULL, + `plane` text NOT NULL, + `kind` text NOT NULL, + `next_ordinal` integer DEFAULT 1 NOT NULL, + FOREIGN KEY (`spec_id`) REFERENCES `specs`(`id`) ON UPDATE no action ON DELETE no action +); +--> statement-breakpoint +CREATE UNIQUE INDEX `node_kind_counters_spec_plane_kind_unique` ON `node_kind_counters` (`spec_id`,`plane`,`kind`);--> statement-breakpoint +ALTER TABLE `nodes` ADD `kind_ordinal` integer NOT NULL;--> statement-breakpoint +CREATE UNIQUE INDEX `nodes_spec_plane_kind_ordinal_unique` ON `nodes` (`spec_id`,`plane`,`kind`,`kind_ordinal`); \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/drizzle/meta/0001_snapshot.json b/drizzle/meta/0001_snapshot.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..08a946311 --- /dev/null +++ b/drizzle/meta/0001_snapshot.json @@ -0,0 +1,573 @@ +{ + "version": "6", + "dialect": "sqlite", + "id": "8fbe0765-0bb3-4d00-856f-fd09968b1c6b", + "prevId": "48abb3fa-9eca-4194-b9ff-343f96ed32cf", + "tables": { + "change_log": { + "name": "change_log", + "columns": { + "lsn": { + "name": "lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": true, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "operation": { + "name": "operation", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "payload": { + "name": "payload", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "created_at": { + "name": "created_at", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false, + "default": "(datetime('now'))" + } + }, + "indexes": {}, + "foreignKeys": {}, + "compositePrimaryKeys": {}, + "uniqueConstraints": {}, + "checkConstraints": {} + }, + "edges": { + "name": "edges", + "columns": { + "id": { + "name": "id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": true, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": true + }, + "spec_id": { + "name": "spec_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "category": { + "name": "category", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "source_id": { + "name": "source_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "target_id": { + "name": "target_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "stance": { + "name": "stance", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "basis": { + "name": "basis", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false, + "default": "'explicit'" + }, + "rationale": { + "name": "rationale", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "created_at_lsn": { + "name": "created_at_lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "updated_at_lsn": { + "name": "updated_at_lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + } + }, + "indexes": {}, + "foreignKeys": { + "edges_spec_id_specs_id_fk": { + "name": "edges_spec_id_specs_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "edges", + "tableTo": "specs", + "columnsFrom": [ + "spec_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + }, + "edges_source_id_nodes_id_fk": { + "name": "edges_source_id_nodes_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "edges", + "tableTo": "nodes", + "columnsFrom": [ + "source_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + }, + "edges_target_id_nodes_id_fk": { + "name": "edges_target_id_nodes_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "edges", + "tableTo": "nodes", + "columnsFrom": [ + "target_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + } + }, + "compositePrimaryKeys": {}, + "uniqueConstraints": {}, + "checkConstraints": {} + }, + "graph_clock": { + "name": "graph_clock", + "columns": { + "id": { + "name": "id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": true, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "lsn": { + "name": "lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false, + "default": 0 + } + }, + "indexes": {}, + "foreignKeys": {}, + "compositePrimaryKeys": {}, + "uniqueConstraints": {}, + "checkConstraints": {} + }, + "node_kind_counters": { + "name": "node_kind_counters", + "columns": { + "id": { + "name": "id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": true, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": true + }, + "spec_id": { + "name": "spec_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "plane": { + "name": "plane", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "kind": { + "name": "kind", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "next_ordinal": { + "name": "next_ordinal", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false, + "default": 1 + } + }, + "indexes": { + "node_kind_counters_spec_plane_kind_unique": { + "name": "node_kind_counters_spec_plane_kind_unique", + "columns": [ + "spec_id", + "plane", + "kind" + ], + "isUnique": true + } + }, + "foreignKeys": { + "node_kind_counters_spec_id_specs_id_fk": { + "name": "node_kind_counters_spec_id_specs_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "node_kind_counters", + "tableTo": "specs", + "columnsFrom": [ + "spec_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + } + }, + "compositePrimaryKeys": {}, + "uniqueConstraints": {}, + "checkConstraints": {} + }, + "nodes": { + "name": "nodes", + "columns": { + "id": { + "name": "id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": true, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": true + }, + "spec_id": { + "name": "spec_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "plane": { + "name": "plane", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "kind": { + "name": "kind", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "kind_ordinal": { + "name": "kind_ordinal", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "title": { + "name": "title", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "body": { + "name": "body", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "basis": { + "name": "basis", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false, + "default": "'explicit'" + }, + "source": { + "name": "source", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "detail": { + "name": "detail", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "created_at_lsn": { + "name": "created_at_lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "updated_at_lsn": { + "name": "updated_at_lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + } + }, + "indexes": { + "nodes_spec_plane_kind_ordinal_unique": { + "name": "nodes_spec_plane_kind_ordinal_unique", + "columns": [ + "spec_id", + "plane", + "kind", + "kind_ordinal" + ], + "isUnique": true + } + }, + "foreignKeys": { + "nodes_spec_id_specs_id_fk": { + "name": "nodes_spec_id_specs_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "nodes", + "tableTo": "specs", + "columnsFrom": [ + "spec_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + } + }, + "compositePrimaryKeys": {}, + "uniqueConstraints": {}, + "checkConstraints": {} + }, + "reconciliation_need": { + "name": "reconciliation_need", + "columns": { + "id": { + "name": "id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": true, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": true + }, + "spec_id": { + "name": "spec_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "target_kind": { + "name": "target_kind", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "target_edge_id": { + "name": "target_edge_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "target_a_id": { + "name": "target_a_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "target_b_id": { + "name": "target_b_id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "kind": { + "name": "kind", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "status": { + "name": "status", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false, + "default": "'open'" + }, + "reason": { + "name": "reason", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "created_at_lsn": { + "name": "created_at_lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "resolved_at_lsn": { + "name": "resolved_at_lsn", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": false, + "autoincrement": false + } + }, + "indexes": {}, + "foreignKeys": { + "reconciliation_need_spec_id_specs_id_fk": { + "name": "reconciliation_need_spec_id_specs_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "reconciliation_need", + "tableTo": "specs", + "columnsFrom": [ + "spec_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + }, + "reconciliation_need_target_edge_id_edges_id_fk": { + "name": "reconciliation_need_target_edge_id_edges_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "reconciliation_need", + "tableTo": "edges", + "columnsFrom": [ + "target_edge_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + }, + "reconciliation_need_target_a_id_nodes_id_fk": { + "name": "reconciliation_need_target_a_id_nodes_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "reconciliation_need", + "tableTo": "nodes", + "columnsFrom": [ + "target_a_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + }, + "reconciliation_need_target_b_id_nodes_id_fk": { + "name": "reconciliation_need_target_b_id_nodes_id_fk", + "tableFrom": "reconciliation_need", + "tableTo": "nodes", + "columnsFrom": [ + "target_b_id" + ], + "columnsTo": [ + "id" + ], + "onDelete": "no action", + "onUpdate": "no action" + } + }, + "compositePrimaryKeys": {}, + "uniqueConstraints": {}, + "checkConstraints": {} + }, + "specs": { + "name": "specs", + "columns": { + "id": { + "name": "id", + "type": "integer", + "primaryKey": true, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": true + }, + "name": { + "name": "name", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "slug": { + "name": "slug", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false + }, + "readiness_grade": { + "name": "readiness_grade", + "type": "text", + "primaryKey": false, + "notNull": true, + "autoincrement": false, + "default": "'grounding_onboarding'" + } + }, + "indexes": {}, + "foreignKeys": {}, + "compositePrimaryKeys": {}, + "uniqueConstraints": {}, + "checkConstraints": {} + } + }, + "views": {}, + "enums": {}, + "_meta": { + "schemas": {}, + "tables": {}, + "columns": {} + }, + "internal": { + "indexes": {} + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/drizzle/meta/_journal.json b/drizzle/meta/_journal.json index a675ec85b..431874df8 100644 --- a/drizzle/meta/_journal.json +++ b/drizzle/meta/_journal.json @@ -8,6 +8,13 @@ "when": 1780478757603, "tag": "0000_deep_maria_hill", "breakpoints": true + }, + { + "idx": 1, + "version": "6", + "when": 1780577981107, + "tag": "0001_aspiring_orphan", + "breakpoints": true } ] } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index ad4943b84..04be4696e 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -109,9 +109,9 @@ _None._ - **Name:** Materialize graph write contract and broaden direct graph-tool proof - **Linear:** [FE-808](https://linear.app/hash/issue/FE-808/broaden-direct-graph-tool-proof-beyond-the-a14-happy-path) -- **Branch:** to create — `ln/fe-808-graph-tool-resilience` +- **Branch:** `ln/fe-808-graph-tool-resilience` - **Kind:** structural hardening / tracer bullet -- **Status:** next +- **Status:** in progress - **Certainty:** proving - **Stabilizes:** I34-L, I39-L, I40-L, I41-L — graph writes need stable node handles, correct approval basis, and supersession acyclicity before capture/review frontiers build on them. - **Lights up:** real `read_graph` / `commit_graph` path with projected existing-node references, diagnostics/retry, and no-overcommit behavior through the default Brunch runtime factory. diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index f52172c13..08d6ef246 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -291,7 +291,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I36-L | Node `kind` is drawn from a per-plane closed enum structurally validated by the `CommandExecutor`; the intent kind category (basic / structural / reasoning) is a pure function of `kind` and is never stored on the node. | covered (CommandExecutor rejects invalid kind-for-plane; `intentKindCategory` is pure derivation with exhaustive switch; tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L, D56-L | | I37-L | `detail` is per-kind validated by the `CommandExecutor`: `decision` and `term` nodes REQUIRE `detail` with their respective sub-schemas; all other kinds must omit `detail`; unknown fields in `detail` are rejected. | covered (detail-required/prohibited/shape tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L | | I38-L | Every Brunch prompt-resource manifest injected for an agent turn is generated from projected runtime state and spec/workspace gates: listed resources are Brunch-owned, readable under the active tool policy, legal for the current `(op_mode × goal × strategy × lens)` / grade / agent allow-list, and off-list resources are not advertised as available. AUTO axes never list illegal choices; pinned axes point to the pinned resource. | covered for current P0 manifest families (`src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers default header/context/manifest output, AUTO grade/allow-list filtering, pinned singleton resources, illegal pinned grade rejection, and readable `src/agents/` locations; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` covers the explicit shell `before_agent_start` product path appending `agents/compose()` output from transcript-projected runtime state and no legacy composer import/resource discovery. Probe fitness may still track whether the agent reads selected resources before use.) | D39-L, D40-L, D58-L, D59-L | -| I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | planned (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for counter allocation, batch allocation, rollback, deletion/supersession no-reuse, and projected-code lookup; DB unique constraint on stored ordinal tuple) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | +| I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` storage slice added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node and batch writes, rollback protection for failed edge validation, and `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping; remaining slices still need projected-code lookup/rendering and deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | | I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | planned (`agent-turn-to-graph-capture`, `graph-tool-resilience`, and `project-graph-review-cycle` adapter/CommandExecutor tests for basis assignment and schema rejection of retired basis values) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | | I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | planned (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for existing-cycle, intra-batch-cycle, mixed existing+batch-cycle, and rollback behavior) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | @@ -627,7 +627,7 @@ The first required probe is M0: after manual TUI interaction, a checker proves ` | I36-L | M4 per-plane kind enum validation tests in CommandExecutor; kind-to-category derivation unit tests proving pure function parity with GRAPH_MODEL.md table. | | I37-L | M4 node-creation tests: decision/term rejected without detail; constraint accepted with or without detail; other kinds rejected with detail; unknown detail fields rejected. | | I38-L | `agents-composition-layer` inner tests: given projected runtime states and spec grades, compose emits manifests whose goal/strategy/lens/method resources are legal, Brunch-owned, readable, and filtered by the agent allow-list; AUTO axes list only legal choices and pinned axes point to their selected resource. Middle/outer probes may track whether the model actually reads the selected resource before applying it as fitness, not as an inner-loop gate. | -| I39-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests: counter rows allocate monotonic per-kind ordinals in multi-node batches, rollback does not persist failed ordinals, deletion/supersession does not permit ordinal reuse, projected-code lookup resolves through `(kind, kind_ordinal)`, and DB constraints reject duplicate `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)`. | +| I39-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests: counter rows allocate monotonic per-kind ordinals in multi-node batches, rollback does not persist failed ordinals/counter rows, and DB constraints reject duplicate `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)`. Remaining proof: deletion/supersession no-reuse, projected-code lookup through `(kind, kind_ordinal)`, and product rendering of codes. | | I40-L | Adapter/CommandExecutor tests across `agent-turn-to-graph-capture`, `graph-tool-resilience`, and `project-graph-review-cycle`: direct user/accepted review-set writes are `explicit`, `propose-graph` materialization is `implicit`, retired `accepted_review_set` basis values are rejected, and `change_log.operation` preserves the mutation path. | | I41-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for supersession acyclicity across existing edges, intra-batch edges, and mixed existing+batch edges, including rollback on illegal cycles. | diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md index 02bca5b8f..bb70fe714 100644 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md @@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ Created: 2026-06-04 ## Card 1 — Persist per-kind node ordinals -Status: next +Status: done ### Target Behavior diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts index 431fa63a5..ee6bee046 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts @@ -74,6 +74,7 @@ const promptContext = { specId: 1, plane: 'intent' as const, kind: 'goal' as const, + kindOrdinal: 1, title: 'Clarify Brunch prompt posture', basis: 'explicit' as const, createdAtLsn: 2, @@ -84,6 +85,7 @@ const promptContext = { specId: 1, plane: 'design' as const, kind: 'module' as const, + kindOrdinal: 1, title: 'Agent context renderer', basis: 'explicit' as const, createdAtLsn: 3, @@ -232,6 +234,7 @@ describe('Brunch prompt-pack topology', () => { specId: selected.spec.id, plane: 'intent' as const, kind: 'goal' as const, + kindOrdinal: index + 1, title, basis: 'explicit' as const, createdAtLsn: 1, diff --git a/src/agents/contexts/graph.test.ts b/src/agents/contexts/graph.test.ts index b7cde30a6..8bee6379c 100644 --- a/src/agents/contexts/graph.test.ts +++ b/src/agents/contexts/graph.test.ts @@ -75,6 +75,7 @@ function node( specId: 1, plane, kind, + kindOrdinal: id, title, basis: 'explicit', createdAtLsn: id, diff --git a/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts b/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts index 141b3153f..1e980a193 100644 --- a/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts +++ b/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts @@ -63,6 +63,7 @@ function node( specId: 1, plane, kind, + kindOrdinal: id, title, ...(body ? { body } : {}), basis: 'explicit', diff --git a/src/db/README.md b/src/db/README.md index 230a4f80c..2b0c5c230 100644 --- a/src/db/README.md +++ b/src/db/README.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # db/ — Persistence substrate -SPEC decisions: D16-L, D41-L, D52-L +SPEC decisions: D16-L, D41-L, D52-L, D54-L, D62-L ## Owns @@ -92,13 +92,14 @@ owned by their boundary. ## Current schema posture -The current tables are the M4 graph substrate: `specs`, `nodes`, `edges`, -`graph_clock`, `change_log`, and `reconciliation_need`. +The current graph tables are spec-scoped: `specs`, `nodes`, `edges`, +`node_kind_counters`, `graph_clock`, `change_log`, and +`reconciliation_need`. -Multi-spec is the product direction, but graph rows are not yet spec-scoped in -this schema. Before stable `graph.*` RPC or multi-spec UI work lands, add -spec-scoping columns and update graph readers/commands so projections cannot mix -initiative-local graph truth. +`nodes.kind_ordinal` is persisted as the storage half of the D62-L projected-code +contract. `node_kind_counters` owns monotonic per-`(spec_id, plane, kind)` +ordinal allocation; the rendered reference-code string is deliberately not +stored in graph tables. `coherence_state` is intentionally not present yet. Coherence is a product concept, but the durable table/result contract is still undefined. diff --git a/src/db/row-schemas.ts b/src/db/row-schemas.ts index ceba9673c..af1cb4a62 100644 --- a/src/db/row-schemas.ts +++ b/src/db/row-schemas.ts @@ -10,7 +10,15 @@ import { createInsertSchema, createSelectSchema } from 'drizzle-typebox'; -import { changeLog, edges, graphClock, nodes, reconciliationNeed, specs } from './schema.js'; +import { + changeLog, + edges, + graphClock, + nodeKindCounters, + nodes, + reconciliationNeed, + specs, +} from './schema.js'; // --- Spec schemas --- export const insertSpecSchema = createInsertSchema(specs); @@ -31,6 +39,9 @@ export const selectChangeLogSchema = createSelectSchema(changeLog); // --- Graph clock schemas --- export const insertGraphClockSchema = createInsertSchema(graphClock); +// --- Node kind counter schemas --- +export const insertNodeKindCounterSchema = createInsertSchema(nodeKindCounters); +export const selectNodeKindCounterSchema = createSelectSchema(nodeKindCounters); // --- Reconciliation need schemas --- export const insertReconciliationNeedSchema = createInsertSchema(reconciliationNeed); export const selectReconciliationNeedSchema = createSelectSchema(reconciliationNeed); diff --git a/src/db/schema.ts b/src/db/schema.ts index 0083b2253..4db27eab3 100644 --- a/src/db/schema.ts +++ b/src/db/schema.ts @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ */ import { sql } from 'drizzle-orm'; -import { integer, sqliteTable, text } from 'drizzle-orm/sqlite-core'; +import { integer, sqliteTable, text, uniqueIndex } from 'drizzle-orm/sqlite-core'; // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- // Shared enum arrays — the single source for text enum columns, @@ -69,21 +69,33 @@ export const specs = sqliteTable('specs', { readiness_grade: text({ enum: READINESS_GRADES }).notNull().default('grounding_onboarding'), }); -export const nodes = sqliteTable('nodes', { - id: integer().primaryKey({ autoIncrement: true }), - spec_id: integer() - .notNull() - .references(() => specs.id), - plane: text({ enum: ['intent', 'oracle', 'design', 'plan'] }).notNull(), - kind: text().notNull(), // validated at domain layer against plane-specific enum - title: text().notNull(), - body: text(), - basis: text({ enum: NODE_BASES }).notNull().default('explicit'), - source: text(), - detail: text(), // JSON column: decision → {chosen_option, rejected, rationale}, term → {definition, aliases?} - created_at_lsn: integer().notNull(), - updated_at_lsn: integer().notNull(), -}); +export const nodes = sqliteTable( + 'nodes', + { + id: integer().primaryKey({ autoIncrement: true }), + spec_id: integer() + .notNull() + .references(() => specs.id), + plane: text({ enum: ['intent', 'oracle', 'design', 'plan'] }).notNull(), + kind: text().notNull(), // validated at domain layer against plane-specific enum + kind_ordinal: integer().notNull(), + title: text().notNull(), + body: text(), + basis: text({ enum: NODE_BASES }).notNull().default('explicit'), + source: text(), + detail: text(), // JSON column: decision → {chosen_option, rejected, rationale}, term → {definition, aliases?} + created_at_lsn: integer().notNull(), + updated_at_lsn: integer().notNull(), + }, + (table) => [ + uniqueIndex('nodes_spec_plane_kind_ordinal_unique').on( + table.spec_id, + table.plane, + table.kind, + table.kind_ordinal, + ), + ], +); export const edges = sqliteTable('edges', { id: integer().primaryKey({ autoIncrement: true }), @@ -109,6 +121,22 @@ export const graphClock = sqliteTable('graph_clock', { lsn: integer().notNull().default(0), }); +export const nodeKindCounters = sqliteTable( + 'node_kind_counters', + { + id: integer().primaryKey({ autoIncrement: true }), + spec_id: integer() + .notNull() + .references(() => specs.id), + plane: text({ enum: ['intent', 'oracle', 'design', 'plan'] }).notNull(), + kind: text().notNull(), + next_ordinal: integer().notNull().default(1), + }, + (table) => [ + uniqueIndex('node_kind_counters_spec_plane_kind_unique').on(table.spec_id, table.plane, table.kind), + ], +); + export const changeLog = sqliteTable('change_log', { lsn: integer().primaryKey(), operation: text().notNull(), diff --git a/src/graph/README.md b/src/graph/README.md index bdf008ec5..f52d17669 100644 --- a/src/graph/README.md +++ b/src/graph/README.md @@ -1,13 +1,14 @@ # graph/ — Graph domain layer Canonical reference: `docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md` -SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L +SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L, D54-L, D62-L ## Owns - **CommandExecutor** (`command-executor.ts`) — the single mutation boundary for graph/spec writes. It hides structural validation, transaction mechanics, LSN - allocation, change-log append, and structured command results. + allocation, per-kind node ordinal allocation, change-log append, and + structured command results. - **commitGraph** — atomic batch mutation for `propose-graph`: one tool call, one transaction, one LSN, all-or-nothing. It accepts product command input @@ -19,7 +20,8 @@ SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L reconciliation needs. These return typed domain objects, not Drizzle rows. - **Domain schema types** (`schema/`) — `GraphNode`, `GraphEdge`, - `ReconciliationNeed`, kind/category types, and derived intent-kind grouping. + `ReconciliationNeed`, kind/category types, per-kind node ordinals, and derived + intent-kind grouping. - **Policy** (`policy/category-policy.ts`) — edge-category semantics such as cascade behavior, reconciliation triggers, and projection effects. @@ -57,6 +59,7 @@ graph/ createSpec updateReadinessGrade createNode + per-kind node ordinal allocation commitGraph / dryRunCommitGraph create/resolve reconciliation need @@ -133,10 +136,13 @@ seam. The desired shape is documented here so future splits preserve topology. ## Known near-term schema pressure -- Keep spec scoping mandatory for stable `graph.*` RPC / multi-spec UI projections: - graph rows and graph-adjacent reconciliation needs are spec-owned, and - remaining graph read/write surfaces must preserve explicit selected-spec - authority. +- `kind_ordinal` is now the stored half of projected graph node codes. Keep + rendered code strings out of graph tables; adapters and prompt renderers should + project them from `kind` + `kindOrdinal`. +- Keep spec scoping mandatory for stable `graph.*` RPC / multi-spec UI + projections: graph rows and graph-adjacent reconciliation needs are + spec-owned, and remaining graph read/write surfaces must preserve explicit + selected-spec authority. - Keep `coherence_state` deferred until its durable semantics are defined. - Begin consuming `db/row-schemas.ts` at persistence-facing validation seams; do not use row schemas as public RPC or agent-tool object contracts. diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts index d87fa18e6..d64c82304 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts @@ -9,7 +9,15 @@ import { eq } from 'drizzle-orm'; import { describe, expect, it, beforeEach } from 'vitest'; import { createDb, type BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; -import { graphClock, changeLog, edges, nodes, reconciliationNeed, specs } from '../db/schema.js'; +import { + graphClock, + changeLog, + edges, + nodeKindCounters, + nodes, + reconciliationNeed, + specs, +} from '../db/schema.js'; import { CommandExecutor } from './command-executor.js'; import type { CommitGraphInput } from './command-executor.js'; @@ -410,6 +418,100 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); }); + it('allocates kind ordinals per spec, plane, and kind within multi-node batches', () => { + const otherSpec = executor.createSpec({ name: 'Other Spec', slug: 'other' }); + if (otherSpec.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + + executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); + const firstBatch = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'goal', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Batch goal' }, + { ref: 'requirement', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'Batch req' }, + { ref: 'oracle-goal', plane: 'oracle', kind: 'check', title: 'Oracle check' }, + ], + edges: [], + }); + const otherSpecBatch = executor.commitGraph({ + specId: otherSpec.specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'goal', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Other goal' }], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(firstBatch.status).toBe('success'); + expect(otherSpecBatch.status).toBe('success'); + const rows = db + .select({ + specId: nodes.spec_id, + plane: nodes.plane, + kind: nodes.kind, + title: nodes.title, + kindOrdinal: nodes.kind_ordinal, + }) + .from(nodes) + .all(); + + expect(rows).toEqual( + expect.arrayContaining([ + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Existing goal', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Batch goal', + kindOrdinal: 2, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'requirement', + title: 'Batch req', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'oracle', + kind: 'check', + title: 'Oracle check', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId: otherSpec.specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Other goal', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + ]), + ); + }); + + it('rejects duplicate stored kind ordinals for one spec, plane, and kind', () => { + executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }); + + expect(() => + db + .insert(nodes) + .values({ + spec_id: specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + kind_ordinal: 1, + title: 'Duplicate G1', + basis: 'explicit', + created_at_lsn: 1, + updated_at_lsn: 1, + }) + .run(), + ).toThrow(); + }); + it('resolves intra-batch refs to real NodeIds', () => { const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId, @@ -653,6 +755,23 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { expect(clock!.lsn).toBe(0); }); + it('if post-insert edge validation fails, no nodes, change log, or counter state is written', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Valid goal' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Valid ctx' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'proof', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(nodeKindCounters).all()).toHaveLength(0); + }); + it('diagnostics include which entry failed', () => { const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId, diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index 214c00b6b..38ef1f303 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -536,6 +536,39 @@ class BatchValidationError extends Error { export class CommandExecutor { constructor(private readonly db: BrunchDb) {} + private allocateNodeKindOrdinal( + tx: Pick, + specId: number, + plane: NodePlane, + kind: string, + ): number { + const existing = tx + .select({ + id: schema.nodeKindCounters.id, + nextOrdinal: schema.nodeKindCounters.next_ordinal, + }) + .from(schema.nodeKindCounters) + .where( + and( + eq(schema.nodeKindCounters.spec_id, specId), + eq(schema.nodeKindCounters.plane, plane), + eq(schema.nodeKindCounters.kind, kind), + ), + ) + .get(); + + if (!existing) { + tx.insert(schema.nodeKindCounters).values({ spec_id: specId, plane, kind, next_ordinal: 2 }).run(); + return 1; + } + + tx.update(schema.nodeKindCounters) + .set({ next_ordinal: existing.nextOrdinal + 1 }) + .where(eq(schema.nodeKindCounters.id, existing.id)) + .run(); + return existing.nextOrdinal; + } + /** Create a spec row through the command boundary. */ createSpec(input: CreateSpecInput): CreateSpecResult { const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; @@ -680,6 +713,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { .returning() .get(); const lsn = clock!.lsn; + const kindOrdinal = this.allocateNodeKindOrdinal(tx, input.specId, input.plane, input.kind); // 3. Insert node const node = tx @@ -688,6 +722,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { spec_id: input.specId, plane: input.plane, kind: input.kind, + kind_ordinal: kindOrdinal, title: input.title, body: input.body ?? null, basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', @@ -771,12 +806,14 @@ export class CommandExecutor { // 3. Insert all nodes, build ref → id map const refMap = new Map(); for (const bn of input.nodes) { + const kindOrdinal = this.allocateNodeKindOrdinal(tx, input.specId, bn.plane, bn.kind); const row = tx .insert(schema.nodes) .values({ spec_id: input.specId, plane: bn.plane, kind: bn.kind, + kind_ordinal: kindOrdinal, title: bn.title, body: bn.body ?? null, basis: bn.basis ?? 'explicit', diff --git a/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts b/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts index 2ec99c364..fcf662972 100644 --- a/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts +++ b/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts @@ -128,6 +128,7 @@ export interface GraphNode { readonly specId: number; readonly plane: NodePlane; readonly kind: NodeKind; + readonly kindOrdinal: number; readonly title: string; readonly body?: string; readonly basis: NodeBasis; diff --git a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts index f31829ed0..aa950330b 100644 --- a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts @@ -78,6 +78,7 @@ describe('getGraphOverview', () => { }); expect(node.createdAtLsn).toBe(1); expect(node.updatedAtLsn).toBe(1); + expect(node.kindOrdinal).toBe(1); }); it('returns nodes and edges with correct counts', () => { diff --git a/src/graph/snapshot.ts b/src/graph/snapshot.ts index 0ea1b6d79..0252035f9 100644 --- a/src/graph/snapshot.ts +++ b/src/graph/snapshot.ts @@ -61,6 +61,7 @@ function rowToNode(row: typeof schema.nodes.$inferSelect): GraphNode { specId: row.spec_id, plane: row.plane as GraphNode['plane'], kind: row.kind as GraphNode['kind'], + kindOrdinal: row.kind_ordinal, title: row.title, ...(row.body != null ? { body: row.body } : {}), basis: row.basis as GraphNode['basis'], diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts index 8d3810ff4..9e3e86cdc 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts @@ -30,6 +30,7 @@ const successfulOverview: GraphOverview = { specId: 1, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', + kindOrdinal: 1, title: 'Clarify launch readiness', basis: 'explicit', createdAtLsn: 1, @@ -40,6 +41,7 @@ const successfulOverview: GraphOverview = { specId: 1, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', + kindOrdinal: 1, title: 'Expose rollback criteria', basis: 'explicit', createdAtLsn: 1, From f840b8338294be9f4904a6017418cfc24aa90747 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 15:06:22 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 02/21] FE-808 normalize graph approval basis --- memory/SPEC.md | 4 +- ...h-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md | 2 +- src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts | 3 ++ src/.pi/__tests__/review-set-proposal.test.ts | 9 +++- src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts | 3 +- .../extensions/graph/review-set-proposal.ts | 3 +- src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts | 2 - src/db/schema.ts | 2 +- src/graph/command-executor.test.ts | 46 +++++++++++++++++++ src/graph/command-executor.ts | 17 ++++--- src/graph/schema/edges.ts | 8 ++-- src/graph/schema/nodes.ts | 3 +- 12 files changed, 79 insertions(+), 23 deletions(-) diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index 08d6ef246..1c3013221 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -292,7 +292,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I37-L | `detail` is per-kind validated by the `CommandExecutor`: `decision` and `term` nodes REQUIRE `detail` with their respective sub-schemas; all other kinds must omit `detail`; unknown fields in `detail` are rejected. | covered (detail-required/prohibited/shape tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L | | I38-L | Every Brunch prompt-resource manifest injected for an agent turn is generated from projected runtime state and spec/workspace gates: listed resources are Brunch-owned, readable under the active tool policy, legal for the current `(op_mode × goal × strategy × lens)` / grade / agent allow-list, and off-list resources are not advertised as available. AUTO axes never list illegal choices; pinned axes point to the pinned resource. | covered for current P0 manifest families (`src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers default header/context/manifest output, AUTO grade/allow-list filtering, pinned singleton resources, illegal pinned grade rejection, and readable `src/agents/` locations; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` covers the explicit shell `before_agent_start` product path appending `agents/compose()` output from transcript-projected runtime state and no legacy composer import/resource discovery. Probe fitness may still track whether the agent reads selected resources before use.) | D39-L, D40-L, D58-L, D59-L | | I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` storage slice added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node and batch writes, rollback protection for failed edge validation, and `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping; remaining slices still need projected-code lookup/rendering and deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | -| I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | planned (`agent-turn-to-graph-capture`, `graph-tool-resilience`, and `project-graph-review-cycle` adapter/CommandExecutor tests for basis assignment and schema rejection of retired basis values) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | +| I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` replaced the persisted basis enum with `explicit | implicit`, made `commitGraph` apply one batch approval basis to all created nodes/edges, made `propose-graph` adapter commits implicit, made review-set translation explicit, rejected retired `accepted_review_set`, and records `change_log.operation` independently; remaining capture/review-cycle slices still need direct user/capture assignment coverage) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | | I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | planned (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for existing-cycle, intra-batch-cycle, mixed existing+batch-cycle, and rollback behavior) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | ## Future Direction Register @@ -628,7 +628,7 @@ The first required probe is M0: after manual TUI interaction, a checker proves ` | I37-L | M4 node-creation tests: decision/term rejected without detail; constraint accepted with or without detail; other kinds rejected with detail; unknown detail fields rejected. | | I38-L | `agents-composition-layer` inner tests: given projected runtime states and spec grades, compose emits manifests whose goal/strategy/lens/method resources are legal, Brunch-owned, readable, and filtered by the agent allow-list; AUTO axes list only legal choices and pinned axes point to their selected resource. Middle/outer probes may track whether the model actually reads the selected resource before applying it as fitness, not as an inner-loop gate. | | I39-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests: counter rows allocate monotonic per-kind ordinals in multi-node batches, rollback does not persist failed ordinals/counter rows, and DB constraints reject duplicate `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)`. Remaining proof: deletion/supersession no-reuse, projected-code lookup through `(kind, kind_ordinal)`, and product rendering of codes. | -| I40-L | Adapter/CommandExecutor tests across `agent-turn-to-graph-capture`, `graph-tool-resilience`, and `project-graph-review-cycle`: direct user/accepted review-set writes are `explicit`, `propose-graph` materialization is `implicit`, retired `accepted_review_set` basis values are rejected, and `change_log.operation` preserves the mutation path. | +| I40-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter tests: `commitGraph` applies one batch basis to all created nodes/edges, `propose-graph` adapter commits use `implicit`, review-set translation uses `explicit`, retired `accepted_review_set` is rejected, and `change_log.operation` remains `commit_graph` independently of basis. Remaining proof: capture/direct-user writes and full review-cycle acceptance path. | | I41-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for supersession acyclicity across existing edges, intra-batch edges, and mixed existing+batch edges, including rollback on illegal cycles. | ### Design Notes diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md index bb70fe714..924d09647 100644 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md @@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ src/graph/ ## Card 2 — Replace path-shaped graph basis with approval basis -Status: next +Status: done ### Target Behavior diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts index cca395fe7..f02f177cf 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts @@ -80,6 +80,9 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { expect(input.edges).toHaveLength(2); expect(input.edges[0]!.source).toBe('n2'); expect(input.edges[1]!.source).toEqual({ existing: 42 }); + expect(input.basis).toBe('implicit'); + expect(input.nodes[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); + expect(input.edges[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); }); }); diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/review-set-proposal.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/review-set-proposal.test.ts index 98e067483..24e278ea5 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/review-set-proposal.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/review-set-proposal.test.ts @@ -157,8 +157,15 @@ describe('review-set proposal dry-run gate', () => { }); expect(entry.status).toBe('success'); - const commitResult = executor.commitGraph(translateReviewSetProposalToCommitGraph(proposal, specId)); + const command = translateReviewSetProposalToCommitGraph(proposal, specId); + expect(command.basis).toBe('explicit'); + expect(command.nodes.every((node) => !('basis' in node))).toBe(true); + expect(command.edges.every((edge) => !('basis' in edge))).toBe(true); + + const commitResult = executor.commitGraph(command); expect(commitResult).toMatchObject({ status: 'success' }); + expect(getGraphOverview(db, specId).nodes.every((node) => node.basis === 'explicit')).toBe(true); + expect(getGraphOverview(db, specId).edges.every((edge) => edge.basis === 'explicit')).toBe(true); expect(getGraphOverview(db, specId)).toMatchObject({ nodeCount: 3, edgeCount: 2 }); }); }); diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts index cd9b3e2c7..1093335be 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts @@ -36,7 +36,6 @@ export function translateCommitGraph(params: ToolCommitGraphParams, specId: numb kind: n.kind, title: n.title, body: n.body, - basis: n.basis as BatchNodeInput['basis'], source: n.source, detail: n.detail, })); @@ -49,7 +48,7 @@ export function translateCommitGraph(params: ToolCommitGraphParams, specId: numb rationale: e.rationale, })); - return { specId, nodes, edges }; + return { specId, basis: 'implicit', nodes, edges }; } function resolveEdgeRef(ref: string | { readonly existing: number }): BatchEdgeRef { diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/review-set-proposal.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/review-set-proposal.ts index 1473ace5d..275549366 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/review-set-proposal.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/review-set-proposal.ts @@ -74,6 +74,7 @@ export function translateReviewSetProposalToCommitGraph( ): CommitGraphInput { return { specId, + basis: 'explicit', nodes: proposal.entityDrafts.map( (draft): BatchNodeInput => ({ ref: draft.draftId, @@ -81,7 +82,6 @@ export function translateReviewSetProposalToCommitGraph( kind: draft.kind, title: draft.title, ...(draft.body !== undefined ? { body: draft.body } : {}), - basis: 'accepted_review_set', ...(draft.detail !== undefined ? { detail: draft.detail } : {}), }), ), @@ -90,7 +90,6 @@ export function translateReviewSetProposalToCommitGraph( category: draft.category, source: draft.sourceDraftId, target: draft.targetDraftId, - basis: 'accepted_review_set', ...(draft.stance !== undefined ? { stance: draft.stance } : {}), ...(draft.rationale !== undefined ? { rationale: draft.rationale } : {}), }), diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts index e1f1ab3e6..d1434eae6 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts @@ -14,7 +14,6 @@ import { EDGE_CATEGORIES, EDGE_STANCES, INTENT_KINDS, - NODE_BASES, ORACLE_KINDS, PLAN_KINDS, } from '../../../graph/index.js'; @@ -29,7 +28,6 @@ export const CommitNodeSchema = Type.Object({ kind: StringEnum([...ALL_KINDS]), title: Type.String({ description: 'Node title — must be non-empty' }), body: Type.Optional(Type.String({ description: 'Extended description' })), - basis: Type.Optional(StringEnum([...NODE_BASES])), source: Type.Optional( Type.String({ description: "Epistemic attribution (e.g. 'stakeholder', 'derived')", diff --git a/src/db/schema.ts b/src/db/schema.ts index 4db27eab3..e207287eb 100644 --- a/src/db/schema.ts +++ b/src/db/schema.ts @@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ export const DESIGN_KINDS = ['module', 'interface'] as const; export const PLAN_KINDS = ['milestone', 'frontier', 'slice'] as const; -export const NODE_BASES = ['explicit', 'accepted_review_set'] as const; +export const NODE_BASES = ['explicit', 'implicit'] as const; export const EDGE_CATEGORIES = [ 'dependency', diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts index d64c82304..519fcc4c8 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts @@ -538,6 +538,52 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.nodes['b']); }); + it('applies one batch approval basis to all created nodes and edges', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + basis: 'implicit', + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + expect( + db + .select() + .from(nodes) + .all() + .map((row) => row.basis), + ).toEqual(['implicit', 'implicit']); + expect( + db + .select() + .from(edges) + .all() + .map((row) => row.basis), + ).toEqual(['implicit']); + expect(JSON.parse(db.select().from(changeLog).all()[0]!.payload).basis).toBe('implicit'); + }); + + it('rejects retired accepted_review_set basis at the command boundary', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + basis: 'accepted_review_set' as never, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics).toEqual( + expect.arrayContaining([expect.objectContaining({ field: 'basis' })]), + ); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); + }); + it('resolves existing-node refs to verified NodeIds', () => { // Pre-create a node const pre = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index 38ef1f303..3d0f7d6a2 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -222,7 +222,6 @@ export interface BatchNodeInput { readonly kind: string; readonly title: string; readonly body?: string | undefined; - readonly basis?: NodeBasis | undefined; readonly source?: string | undefined; readonly detail?: unknown; } @@ -233,13 +232,13 @@ export interface BatchEdgeInput { readonly source: BatchEdgeRef; readonly target: BatchEdgeRef; readonly stance?: string | undefined; - readonly basis?: NodeBasis | undefined; readonly rationale?: string | undefined; } /** Input for the commitGraph atomic batch mutation. */ export interface CommitGraphInput { readonly specId: number; + readonly basis?: NodeBasis | undefined; readonly nodes: readonly BatchNodeInput[]; readonly edges: readonly BatchEdgeInput[]; } @@ -389,13 +388,13 @@ function validateTermDetail(detail: unknown, diagnostics: Diagnostic[]): void { const VALID_CATEGORIES = schema.EDGE_CATEGORIES as unknown as string[]; const STANCE_REQUIRED_CATEGORIES = new Set(['proof', 'support']); const VALID_STANCES = schema.EDGE_STANCES as unknown as string[]; +const VALID_BASES = schema.NODE_BASES as unknown as string[]; interface ResolvedEdge { sourceId: number; targetId: number; category: EdgeCategory; stance: EdgeStance | null; - basis: NodeBasis; rationale: string | null; } @@ -516,7 +515,6 @@ function validateAndResolveBatchEdge( targetId: resolvedTargetId!, category: input.category as EdgeCategory, stance: (input.stance as EdgeStance) ?? null, - basis: (input.basis as NodeBasis) ?? 'explicit', rationale: input.rationale ?? null, }, }; @@ -816,7 +814,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { kind_ordinal: kindOrdinal, title: bn.title, body: bn.body ?? null, - basis: bn.basis ?? 'explicit', + basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', source: bn.source ?? null, detail: bn.detail != null ? JSON.stringify(bn.detail) : null, created_at_lsn: lsn, @@ -883,7 +881,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { source_id: re.sourceId, target_id: re.targetId, stance: re.stance, - basis: re.basis, + basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', rationale: re.rationale, created_at_lsn: lsn, updated_at_lsn: lsn, @@ -899,6 +897,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { lsn, operation: 'commit_graph', payload: JSON.stringify({ + basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', specId: input.specId, nodes: Object.fromEntries(refMap), edges: edgeIds, @@ -927,6 +926,12 @@ export class CommandExecutor { diagnostics.push({ field: 'batch', message: 'empty batch — nothing to commit' }); return diagnostics; } + if (input.basis != null && !VALID_BASES.includes(input.basis)) { + diagnostics.push({ + field: 'basis', + message: `"${String(input.basis)}" is not a valid graph approval basis`, + }); + } const specRow = this.db .select({ id: schema.specs.id }) diff --git a/src/graph/schema/edges.ts b/src/graph/schema/edges.ts index 66b846e55..f688dbd3b 100644 --- a/src/graph/schema/edges.ts +++ b/src/graph/schema/edges.ts @@ -40,11 +40,9 @@ export type EdgeStance = (typeof EDGE_STANCES)[number]; /** * How an edge entered graph truth. * - * `explicit` is a direct user statement; `accepted_review_set` is a - * batch acceptance through `acceptReviewSet` (D27-L). Inferred edges - * do NOT live in graph truth — they live in structured-exchange - * preface or `capture_*` analysis until promoted through a review set - * (D47-L, D50-L). + * `explicit` means the graph item was directly stated or exact-review approved; + * `implicit` means an approved concept was materialized without per-item review. + * The mutation path lives in `change_log.operation`, not in `basis` (D63-L). */ export type EdgeBasis = (typeof NODE_BASES)[number]; diff --git a/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts b/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts index fcf662972..dbfb64b0b 100644 --- a/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts +++ b/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts @@ -27,7 +27,8 @@ import type { Lsn, NodeId } from '../atoms.js'; export type NodePlane = 'intent' | 'oracle' | 'design' | 'plan'; /** - * How a node entered graph truth. + * Whether this exact graph item was approved (`explicit`) or materialized from + * an approved concept without per-item review (`implicit`). * * Derived from `db/schema.ts` — same semantics as EdgeBasis. */ From d574b978121be3fadf9154ccf9744672cea0457a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 15:12:28 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 03/21] FE-808 resolve graph references by code --- memory/SPEC.md | 4 +- ...h-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md | 2 +- src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts | 9 ++ src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts | 28 +++- src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts | 5 +- src/agents/contexts/graph.ts | 11 +- src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts | 6 +- src/agents/contexts/node.ts | 18 ++- src/graph/command-executor.test.ts | 16 +- src/graph/command-executor.ts | 153 +++++++++++------- src/graph/index.ts | 4 +- src/graph/schema/nodes.ts | 56 +++++++ src/graph/snapshot.test.ts | 14 ++ 13 files changed, 247 insertions(+), 79 deletions(-) diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index 1c3013221..95a869eda 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -291,7 +291,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I36-L | Node `kind` is drawn from a per-plane closed enum structurally validated by the `CommandExecutor`; the intent kind category (basic / structural / reasoning) is a pure function of `kind` and is never stored on the node. | covered (CommandExecutor rejects invalid kind-for-plane; `intentKindCategory` is pure derivation with exhaustive switch; tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L, D56-L | | I37-L | `detail` is per-kind validated by the `CommandExecutor`: `decision` and `term` nodes REQUIRE `detail` with their respective sub-schemas; all other kinds must omit `detail`; unknown fields in `detail` are rejected. | covered (detail-required/prohibited/shape tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L | | I38-L | Every Brunch prompt-resource manifest injected for an agent turn is generated from projected runtime state and spec/workspace gates: listed resources are Brunch-owned, readable under the active tool policy, legal for the current `(op_mode × goal × strategy × lens)` / grade / agent allow-list, and off-list resources are not advertised as available. AUTO axes never list illegal choices; pinned axes point to the pinned resource. | covered for current P0 manifest families (`src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers default header/context/manifest output, AUTO grade/allow-list filtering, pinned singleton resources, illegal pinned grade rejection, and readable `src/agents/` locations; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` covers the explicit shell `before_agent_start` product path appending `agents/compose()` output from transcript-projected runtime state and no legacy composer import/resource discovery. Probe fitness may still track whether the agent reads selected resources before use.) | D39-L, D40-L, D58-L, D59-L | -| I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` storage slice added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node and batch writes, rollback protection for failed edge validation, and `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping; remaining slices still need projected-code lookup/rendering and deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | +| I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node/batch writes, rollback protection, `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping, globally unique 1–3 letter labels with readiness-band metadata, projected-code parsing, selected-spec existing-code resolution, and code-primary prompt/tool rendering; remaining slice still needs deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | | I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` replaced the persisted basis enum with `explicit | implicit`, made `commitGraph` apply one batch approval basis to all created nodes/edges, made `propose-graph` adapter commits implicit, made review-set translation explicit, rejected retired `accepted_review_set`, and records `change_log.operation` independently; remaining capture/review-cycle slices still need direct user/capture assignment coverage) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | | I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | planned (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for existing-cycle, intra-batch-cycle, mixed existing+batch-cycle, and rollback behavior) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | @@ -627,7 +627,7 @@ The first required probe is M0: after manual TUI interaction, a checker proves ` | I36-L | M4 per-plane kind enum validation tests in CommandExecutor; kind-to-category derivation unit tests proving pure function parity with GRAPH_MODEL.md table. | | I37-L | M4 node-creation tests: decision/term rejected without detail; constraint accepted with or without detail; other kinds rejected with detail; unknown detail fields rejected. | | I38-L | `agents-composition-layer` inner tests: given projected runtime states and spec grades, compose emits manifests whose goal/strategy/lens/method resources are legal, Brunch-owned, readable, and filtered by the agent allow-list; AUTO axes list only legal choices and pinned axes point to their selected resource. Middle/outer probes may track whether the model actually reads the selected resource before applying it as fitness, not as an inner-loop gate. | -| I39-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests: counter rows allocate monotonic per-kind ordinals in multi-node batches, rollback does not persist failed ordinals/counter rows, and DB constraints reject duplicate `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)`. Remaining proof: deletion/supersession no-reuse, projected-code lookup through `(kind, kind_ordinal)`, and product rendering of codes. | +| I39-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter/context tests: counter rows allocate monotonic per-kind ordinals in multi-node batches, rollback does not persist failed ordinals/counter rows, DB constraints reject duplicate `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)`, projected-code metadata is unique and parses by longest prefix, existing-code refs resolve inside the selected spec, and prompt/tool renderers use codes as primary handles. Remaining proof: deletion/supersession no-reuse. | | I40-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter tests: `commitGraph` applies one batch basis to all created nodes/edges, `propose-graph` adapter commits use `implicit`, review-set translation uses `explicit`, retired `accepted_review_set` is rejected, and `change_log.operation` remains `commit_graph` independently of basis. Remaining proof: capture/direct-user writes and full review-cycle acceptance path. | | I41-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for supersession acyclicity across existing edges, intra-batch edges, and mixed existing+batch edges, including rollback on illegal cycles. | diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md index 924d09647..c2777f3b6 100644 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md @@ -152,7 +152,7 @@ src/.pi/extensions/graph/ ## Card 3 — Resolve existing graph refs by projected code -Status: next +Status: done ### Target Behavior diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts index f02f177cf..540d82a19 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts @@ -83,6 +83,15 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { expect(input.basis).toBe('implicit'); expect(input.nodes[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); expect(input.edges[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); + expect( + translateCommitGraph( + { + nodes: [], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: { existing: 42 } }], + }, + 7, + ).edges[0]!.source, + ).toEqual({ existingCode: 'G1' }); }); }); diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts index 1093335be..9f2067dca 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts @@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ import type { CommitGraphSuccess, StructuralIllegal, } from '../../../graph/command-executor.js'; +import { formatGraphNodeCode } from '../../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; import type { GraphOverview, NeighborhoodResult } from '../../../graph/snapshot.js'; import type { ToolCommitGraphParams } from './tool-schemas.js'; @@ -51,8 +52,11 @@ export function translateCommitGraph(params: ToolCommitGraphParams, specId: numb return { specId, basis: 'implicit', nodes, edges }; } -function resolveEdgeRef(ref: string | { readonly existing: number }): BatchEdgeRef { +function resolveEdgeRef( + ref: string | { readonly existing: number } | { readonly existingCode: string }, +): BatchEdgeRef { if (typeof ref === 'string') return ref; + if ('existingCode' in ref) return { existingCode: ref.existingCode }; return { existing: ref.existing }; } @@ -116,17 +120,24 @@ export function formatGraphOverview(overview: GraphOverview): string { `Graph overview (LSN ${overview.lsn}): ${overview.nodeCount} node(s), ${overview.edgeCount} edge(s).`, '', ]; + const nodesById = new Map(overview.nodes.map((node) => [node.id, node])); for (const node of overview.nodes) { const detail = node.detail ? ` [has detail]` : ''; - lines.push(`- [#${node.id}] ${node.plane}/${node.kind}: "${node.title}"${detail}`); + lines.push( + `- [${formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal)}] ${node.plane}/${node.kind}: "${node.title}"${detail}`, + ); } if (overview.edges.length > 0) { lines.push(''); for (const edge of overview.edges) { const stance = edge.stance ? ` (${edge.stance})` : ''; - lines.push(`- Edge #${edge.id}: #${edge.sourceId} —[${edge.category}${stance}]→ #${edge.targetId}`); + const source = nodesById.get(edge.sourceId); + const target = nodesById.get(edge.targetId); + const sourceCode = source ? formatGraphNodeCode(source.kind, source.kindOrdinal) : `#${edge.sourceId}`; + const targetCode = target ? formatGraphNodeCode(target.kind, target.kindOrdinal) : `#${edge.targetId}`; + lines.push(`- Edge #${edge.id}: ${sourceCode} —[${edge.category}${stance}]→ ${targetCode}`); } } @@ -142,8 +153,9 @@ export function formatNeighborhoodResult(result: NeighborhoodResult): string { } const { anchor, neighbors, edges } = result; + const nodesById = new Map([[anchor.id, anchor], ...neighbors.map((node) => [node.id, node] as const)]); const lines: string[] = [ - `Neighborhood of [#${anchor.id}] ${anchor.plane}/${anchor.kind}: "${anchor.title}"`, + `Neighborhood of [${formatGraphNodeCode(anchor.kind, anchor.kindOrdinal)}] ${anchor.plane}/${anchor.kind}: "${anchor.title}"`, ]; if (anchor.body) { @@ -153,7 +165,7 @@ export function formatNeighborhoodResult(result: NeighborhoodResult): string { if (neighbors.length > 0) { lines.push('', 'Neighbors:'); for (const n of neighbors) { - lines.push(` - [#${n.id}] ${n.plane}/${n.kind}: "${n.title}"`); + lines.push(` - [${formatGraphNodeCode(n.kind, n.kindOrdinal)}] ${n.plane}/${n.kind}: "${n.title}"`); } } @@ -161,7 +173,11 @@ export function formatNeighborhoodResult(result: NeighborhoodResult): string { lines.push('', 'Edges:'); for (const e of edges) { const stance = e.stance ? ` (${e.stance})` : ''; - lines.push(` - #${e.id}: #${e.sourceId} —[${e.category}${stance}]→ #${e.targetId}`); + const source = nodesById.get(e.sourceId); + const target = nodesById.get(e.targetId); + const sourceCode = source ? formatGraphNodeCode(source.kind, source.kindOrdinal) : `#${e.sourceId}`; + const targetCode = target ? formatGraphNodeCode(target.kind, target.kindOrdinal) : `#${e.targetId}`; + lines.push(` - #${e.id}: ${sourceCode} —[${e.category}${stance}]→ ${targetCode}`); } } diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts index d1434eae6..f86005c37 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts @@ -46,6 +46,9 @@ export const EdgeRefSchema = Type.Union([ Type.Object({ existing: Type.Number({ description: 'Id of an existing node' }), }), + Type.Object({ + existingCode: Type.String({ description: 'Projected code of an existing node, e.g. G1 or CON2' }), + }), ]); export const CommitEdgeSchema = Type.Object({ @@ -61,7 +64,7 @@ export const CommitGraphParams = Type.Object({ description: 'Nodes to create in this batch', }), edges: Type.Array(CommitEdgeSchema, { - description: 'Edges to create, referencing batch refs or existing node ids', + description: 'Edges to create, referencing batch refs or existing node codes', }), }); diff --git a/src/agents/contexts/graph.ts b/src/agents/contexts/graph.ts index a4158fb77..d1fb43cc8 100644 --- a/src/agents/contexts/graph.ts +++ b/src/agents/contexts/graph.ts @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -import type { GraphNode } from '../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; +import { formatGraphNodeCode, type GraphNode } from '../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; import type { GraphOverview } from '../../graph/snapshot.js'; import type { AgentLensSelection } from '../../session/runtime-state.js'; @@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ export function renderGraphContext(overview: GraphOverview, options: RenderGraph const byLens = lensScore(b, options.lens) - lensScore(a, options.lens); return byLens || a.id - b.id; }); + const nodesById = new Map(overview.nodes.map((node) => [node.id, node])); const lines = [ `[Selected-spec graph context · ${options.lens} lens]`, @@ -42,7 +43,11 @@ export function renderGraphContext(overview: GraphOverview, options: RenderGraph lines.push('- edges:'); for (const edge of overview.edges.slice(0, maxEdges)) { const stance = edge.stance ? `/${edge.stance}` : ''; - lines.push(` - #${edge.sourceId} -[${edge.category}${stance}]-> #${edge.targetId}`); + const source = nodesById.get(edge.sourceId); + const target = nodesById.get(edge.targetId); + const sourceCode = source ? formatGraphNodeCode(source.kind, source.kindOrdinal) : `#${edge.sourceId}`; + const targetCode = target ? formatGraphNodeCode(target.kind, target.kindOrdinal) : `#${edge.targetId}`; + lines.push(` - ${sourceCode} -[${edge.category}${stance}]-> ${targetCode}`); } if (overview.edges.length > maxEdges) { lines.push(` - …${overview.edges.length - maxEdges} more edge(s) omitted`); @@ -75,7 +80,7 @@ function lensEmphasis(lens: AgentLensSelection): string { function formatNode(node: GraphNode): string { const body = node.body ? ` — ${truncate(node.body, 120)}` : ''; - return `[#${node.id}] ${node.plane}/${node.kind}: ${node.title}${body}`; + return `[${formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal)}] ${node.plane}/${node.kind}: ${node.title}${body}`; } function truncate(value: string, maxLength: number): string { diff --git a/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts b/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts index 1e980a193..10b33ae91 100644 --- a/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts +++ b/src/agents/contexts/node.test.ts @@ -37,11 +37,11 @@ describe('renderNodeContext', () => { const rendered = renderNodeContext(neighborhood, { maxNeighbors: 1, maxEdges: 1 }); expect(rendered).toContain('[Selected-spec node context]'); - expect(rendered).toContain('- anchor: [#1] intent/requirement: Selected spec has graph truth'); + expect(rendered).toContain('- anchor: [R1] intent/requirement: Selected spec has graph truth'); expect(rendered).toContain('- anchor body: A long body explains the requirement.'); - expect(rendered).toContain('[#2] design/module: Graph snapshot reader'); + expect(rendered).toContain('[M2] design/module: Graph snapshot reader'); expect(rendered).toContain('…1 more neighbor(s) omitted'); - expect(rendered).toContain('#5: #2 -[realization]-> #1'); + expect(rendered).toContain('#5: M2 -[realization]-> R1'); }); it('renders a clear selected-spec missing-node result', () => { diff --git a/src/agents/contexts/node.ts b/src/agents/contexts/node.ts index a17d19a83..75df2c8f5 100644 --- a/src/agents/contexts/node.ts +++ b/src/agents/contexts/node.ts @@ -1,3 +1,4 @@ +import { formatGraphNodeCode, type GraphNode } from '../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; import type { NeighborhoodResult } from '../../graph/snapshot.js'; export interface RenderNodeContextOptions { @@ -18,9 +19,13 @@ export function renderNodeContext( const maxNeighbors = options.maxNeighbors ?? DEFAULT_MAX_NEIGHBORS; const maxEdges = options.maxEdges ?? DEFAULT_MAX_EDGES; + const nodesById = new Map([ + [result.anchor.id, result.anchor], + ...result.neighbors.map((node) => [node.id, node] as const), + ]); const lines = [ '[Selected-spec node context]', - `- anchor: [#${result.anchor.id}] ${result.anchor.plane}/${result.anchor.kind}: ${result.anchor.title}`, + `- anchor: [${formatGraphNodeCode(result.anchor.kind, result.anchor.kindOrdinal)}] ${result.anchor.plane}/${result.anchor.kind}: ${result.anchor.title}`, ]; if (result.anchor.body) { @@ -32,7 +37,9 @@ export function renderNodeContext( } else { lines.push('- neighbors:'); for (const neighbor of result.neighbors.slice(0, maxNeighbors)) { - lines.push(` - [#${neighbor.id}] ${neighbor.plane}/${neighbor.kind}: ${neighbor.title}`); + lines.push( + ` - [${formatGraphNodeCode(neighbor.kind, neighbor.kindOrdinal)}] ${neighbor.plane}/${neighbor.kind}: ${neighbor.title}`, + ); } if (result.neighbors.length > maxNeighbors) { lines.push(` - …${result.neighbors.length - maxNeighbors} more neighbor(s) omitted`); @@ -46,8 +53,10 @@ export function renderNodeContext( for (const edge of result.edges.slice(0, maxEdges)) { const stance = edge.stance ? `/${edge.stance}` : ''; const rationale = edge.rationale ? ` — ${truncate(edge.rationale, 100)}` : ''; + const source = nodesById.get(edge.sourceId); + const target = nodesById.get(edge.targetId); lines.push( - ` - #${edge.id}: #${edge.sourceId} -[${edge.category}${stance}]-> #${edge.targetId}${rationale}`, + ` - #${edge.id}: ${formatEdgeEndpoint(edge.sourceId, source)} -[${edge.category}${stance}]-> ${formatEdgeEndpoint(edge.targetId, target)}${rationale}`, ); } if (result.edges.length > maxEdges) { @@ -58,6 +67,9 @@ export function renderNodeContext( return lines.join('\n'); } +function formatEdgeEndpoint(id: number, node: GraphNode | undefined): string { + return node ? formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal) : `#${id}`; +} function truncate(value: string, maxLength: number): string { return value.length <= maxLength ? value : `${value.slice(0, maxLength - 1)}…`; } diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts index 519fcc4c8..6be589d6a 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts @@ -585,7 +585,6 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { }); it('resolves existing-node refs to verified NodeIds', () => { - // Pre-create a node const pre = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); if (pre.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); @@ -609,6 +608,21 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.nodes['n1']); }); + it('resolves existing-node refs from projected codes within the selected spec', () => { + const existing = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); + if (existing.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], + edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!.source_id).toBe(existing.nodeId); + }); + it('returns nodes mapping and edges array in success result', () => { const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId, diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index 3d0f7d6a2..cc299c5d4 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ import { and, eq, inArray, sql } from 'drizzle-orm'; import type { BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; import * as schema from '../db/schema.js'; import type { EdgeCategory, EdgeStance } from './schema/edges.js'; -import type { NodeBasis, NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; +import { parseGraphNodeCode, type NodeBasis, type NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; export type ReadinessGrade = (typeof schema.READINESS_GRADES)[number]; @@ -213,7 +213,7 @@ export interface ResolveReconNeedInput { // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- /** Reference to a node endpoint in a batch edge. */ -export type BatchEdgeRef = string | { readonly existing: number }; +export type BatchEdgeRef = string | { readonly existing: number } | { readonly existingCode: string }; /** A node to create inside a commitGraph batch. */ export interface BatchNodeInput { @@ -403,18 +403,84 @@ interface EdgeValidationResult { resolved?: ResolvedEdge; } +function resolveExistingRefId( + db: Pick, + ref: { readonly existing: number } | { readonly existingCode: string }, + specId: number, +): number | undefined { + if ('existing' in ref) return ref.existing; + const parsed = parseGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode); + if (!parsed) return undefined; + return db + .select({ id: schema.nodes.id }) + .from(schema.nodes) + .where( + and( + eq(schema.nodes.spec_id, specId), + eq(schema.nodes.kind, parsed.kind), + eq(schema.nodes.kind_ordinal, parsed.kindOrdinal), + ), + ) + .get()?.id; +} + +function resolveEndpointRef( + db: Pick, + ref: BatchEdgeRef, + specId: number, + refMap: ReadonlyMap, + existingNodeIds: ReadonlySet, + crossSpecExisting: ReadonlySet, + field: string, + diagnostics: Diagnostic[], +): number | undefined { + if (typeof ref === 'string') { + const id = refMap.get(ref); + if (id === undefined) { + diagnostics.push({ field, message: `unresolvable intra-batch ref "${ref}"` }); + } + return id; + } + + const id = resolveExistingRefId(db, ref, specId); + if (id === undefined) { + diagnostics.push({ field, message: 'existing node reference not found' }); + return undefined; + } + if (crossSpecExisting.has(id)) { + diagnostics.push({ + field, + message: `existing node ${id} belongs to a different spec (command spec ${specId})`, + }); + } else if (!existingNodeIds.has(id)) { + diagnostics.push({ field, message: `existing node ${id} not found` }); + } + return id; +} + +function addExistingRefId( + db: Pick, + ref: BatchEdgeRef, + specId: number, + refs: Set, +): void { + if (typeof ref === 'string') return; + const id = resolveExistingRefId(db, ref, specId); + if (id !== undefined) refs.add(id); +} + function validateAndResolveBatchEdge( input: BatchEdgeInput, index: number, refMap: ReadonlyMap, existingNodeIds: ReadonlySet, crossSpecExisting: ReadonlySet, + db: Pick, specId: number, ): EdgeValidationResult { const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; const p = `edges[${index}]`; - // Category must be in the closed set if (!VALID_CATEGORIES.includes(input.category)) { diagnostics.push({ field: `${p}.category`, @@ -423,7 +489,6 @@ function validateAndResolveBatchEdge( return { diagnostics }; } - // Stance: required iff proof/support, invalid otherwise const stanceRequired = STANCE_REQUIRED_CATEGORIES.has(input.category); if (stanceRequired && input.stance == null) { diagnostics.push({ @@ -444,57 +509,27 @@ function validateAndResolveBatchEdge( }); } - // Resolve source ref - let resolvedSourceId: number | undefined; - if (typeof input.source === 'string') { - resolvedSourceId = refMap.get(input.source); - if (resolvedSourceId === undefined) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.source`, - message: `unresolvable intra-batch ref "${input.source}"`, - }); - } - } else { - resolvedSourceId = input.source.existing; - if (crossSpecExisting.has(resolvedSourceId)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.source`, - message: `existing node ${resolvedSourceId} belongs to a different spec (command spec ${specId})`, - }); - } else if (!existingNodeIds.has(resolvedSourceId)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.source`, - message: `existing node ${resolvedSourceId} not found`, - }); - } - } - - // Resolve target ref - let resolvedTargetId: number | undefined; - if (typeof input.target === 'string') { - resolvedTargetId = refMap.get(input.target); - if (resolvedTargetId === undefined) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.target`, - message: `unresolvable intra-batch ref "${input.target}"`, - }); - } - } else { - resolvedTargetId = input.target.existing; - if (crossSpecExisting.has(resolvedTargetId)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.target`, - message: `existing node ${resolvedTargetId} belongs to a different spec (command spec ${specId})`, - }); - } else if (!existingNodeIds.has(resolvedTargetId)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.target`, - message: `existing node ${resolvedTargetId} not found`, - }); - } - } + const resolvedSourceId = resolveEndpointRef( + db, + input.source, + specId, + refMap, + existingNodeIds, + crossSpecExisting, + `${p}.source`, + diagnostics, + ); + const resolvedTargetId = resolveEndpointRef( + db, + input.target, + specId, + refMap, + existingNodeIds, + crossSpecExisting, + `${p}.target`, + diagnostics, + ); - // Self-loop check (only if both resolved) if ( resolvedSourceId !== undefined && resolvedTargetId !== undefined && @@ -828,8 +863,8 @@ export class CommandExecutor { // 4. Collect and verify existing-node references — must be same spec const existingRefs = new Set(); for (const edge of input.edges) { - if (typeof edge.source !== 'string') existingRefs.add(edge.source.existing); - if (typeof edge.target !== 'string') existingRefs.add(edge.target.existing); + addExistingRefId(tx, edge.source, input.specId, existingRefs); + addExistingRefId(tx, edge.target, input.specId, existingRefs); } const verifiedExisting = new Set(); @@ -860,6 +895,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { refMap, verifiedExisting, crossSpecExisting, + tx, input.specId, ); edgeDiagnostics.push(...result.diagnostics); @@ -966,8 +1002,8 @@ export class CommandExecutor { const existingRefs = new Set(); for (const edge of input.edges) { - if (typeof edge.source !== 'string') existingRefs.add(edge.source.existing); - if (typeof edge.target !== 'string') existingRefs.add(edge.target.existing); + addExistingRefId(this.db, edge.source, input.specId, existingRefs); + addExistingRefId(this.db, edge.target, input.specId, existingRefs); } const verifiedExisting = new Set(); @@ -995,6 +1031,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { refMap, verifiedExisting, crossSpecExisting, + this.db, input.specId, ).diagnostics, ); diff --git a/src/graph/index.ts b/src/graph/index.ts index af1f8be7f..b5d078ff8 100644 --- a/src/graph/index.ts +++ b/src/graph/index.ts @@ -32,15 +32,17 @@ export type { IntentKind, IntentKindCategory, NodeBasis, + NodeKindMetadata, NodeDetail, NodeKind, NodePlane, OracleKind, PlanKind, TermDetail, + ReadinessBand, } from './schema/nodes.js'; -export { intentKindCategory } from './schema/nodes.js'; +export { formatGraphNodeCode, intentKindCategory, parseGraphNodeCode } from './schema/nodes.js'; export type { ReconciliationNeed, diff --git a/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts b/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts index dbfb64b0b..fbe2713c0 100644 --- a/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts +++ b/src/graph/schema/nodes.ts @@ -69,6 +69,62 @@ export type NodeKind = IntentKind | OracleKind | DesignKind | PlanKind; */ export type IntentKindCategory = 'basic' | 'structural' | 'reasoning'; +export type ReadinessBand = 'grounding' | 'elicitation' | 'commitment'; + +export interface NodeKindMetadata { + readonly label: string; + readonly readinessBands: readonly ReadinessBand[]; +} + +export const NODE_KIND_METADATA: Record = { + goal: { label: 'G', readinessBands: ['grounding'] }, + thesis: { label: 'TH', readinessBands: ['grounding'] }, + term: { label: 'T', readinessBands: ['grounding', 'elicitation'] }, + context: { label: 'CTX', readinessBands: ['grounding'] }, + requirement: { label: 'R', readinessBands: ['elicitation', 'commitment'] }, + assumption: { label: 'A', readinessBands: ['grounding', 'elicitation'] }, + constraint: { label: 'CON', readinessBands: ['grounding', 'elicitation'] }, + invariant: { label: 'INV', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + decision: { label: 'D', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + criterion: { label: 'CR', readinessBands: ['elicitation', 'commitment'] }, + example: { label: 'EX', readinessBands: ['elicitation'] }, + check: { label: 'CHK', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + validation_method: { label: 'VM', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + evidence: { label: 'E', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + obligation: { label: 'O', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + module: { label: 'M', readinessBands: ['elicitation'] }, + interface: { label: 'IF', readinessBands: ['elicitation'] }, + milestone: { label: 'MS', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + frontier: { label: 'F', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, + slice: { label: 'SL', readinessBands: ['commitment'] }, +}; + +export interface ParsedGraphNodeCode { + readonly kind: NodeKind; + readonly kindOrdinal: number; +} + +const NODE_KIND_BY_LABEL = new Map( + Object.entries(NODE_KIND_METADATA).map(([kind, metadata]) => [metadata.label, kind as NodeKind]), +); + +export function formatGraphNodeCode(kind: NodeKind, kindOrdinal: number): string { + return `${NODE_KIND_METADATA[kind].label}${kindOrdinal}`; +} + +export function parseGraphNodeCode(code: string): ParsedGraphNodeCode | undefined { + const normalized = code.trim().toUpperCase(); + for (let prefixLength = Math.min(3, normalized.length - 1); prefixLength > 0; prefixLength--) { + const label = normalized.slice(0, prefixLength); + const kind = NODE_KIND_BY_LABEL.get(label); + if (!kind) continue; + const ordinalText = normalized.slice(prefixLength); + if (!/^[1-9]\d*$/.test(ordinalText)) return undefined; + return { kind, kindOrdinal: Number(ordinalText) }; + } + return undefined; +} + /** Pure derivation: intent kind → category. */ export function intentKindCategory(kind: IntentKind): IntentKindCategory { switch (kind) { diff --git a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts index aa950330b..abdc4c78f 100644 --- a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts @@ -12,12 +12,26 @@ import { beforeEach, describe, expect, it } from 'vitest'; import { createDb, type BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; import { specs } from '../db/schema.js'; import { CommandExecutor } from './command-executor.js'; +import { NODE_KIND_METADATA, parseGraphNodeCode } from './schema/nodes.js'; import { getGraphOverview, getNodeNeighborhood, getOpenReconciliationNeeds } from './snapshot.js'; function createTestDb(): BrunchDb { return createDb(':memory:'); } +describe('graph node code metadata', () => { + it('uses globally unique 1-3 letter labels and parses by longest prefix', () => { + const labels = Object.values(NODE_KIND_METADATA).map((metadata) => metadata.label); + expect(new Set(labels).size).toBe(labels.length); + expect(labels.every((label) => /^[A-Z]{1,3}$/.test(label))).toBe(true); + expect(Object.values(NODE_KIND_METADATA).every((metadata) => metadata.readinessBands.length > 0)).toBe( + true, + ); + expect(parseGraphNodeCode('A1')).toEqual({ kind: 'assumption', kindOrdinal: 1 }); + expect(parseGraphNodeCode('CON2')).toEqual({ kind: 'constraint', kindOrdinal: 2 }); + expect(parseGraphNodeCode('CR3')).toEqual({ kind: 'criterion', kindOrdinal: 3 }); + }); +}); describe('getGraphOverview', () => { let db: BrunchDb; let executor: CommandExecutor; From 01a2989e6d8f525c3b150ed4e7baea55a79a4d90 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 15:14:25 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 04/21] FE-808 enforce supersession acyclicity --- memory/SPEC.md | 4 +- ...h-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md | 2 +- src/graph/command-executor.test.ts | 82 ++++++++++++++++++- src/graph/command-executor.ts | 56 +++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 140 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index 95a869eda..a3660fd0d 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -293,7 +293,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I38-L | Every Brunch prompt-resource manifest injected for an agent turn is generated from projected runtime state and spec/workspace gates: listed resources are Brunch-owned, readable under the active tool policy, legal for the current `(op_mode × goal × strategy × lens)` / grade / agent allow-list, and off-list resources are not advertised as available. AUTO axes never list illegal choices; pinned axes point to the pinned resource. | covered for current P0 manifest families (`src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers default header/context/manifest output, AUTO grade/allow-list filtering, pinned singleton resources, illegal pinned grade rejection, and readable `src/agents/` locations; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` covers the explicit shell `before_agent_start` product path appending `agents/compose()` output from transcript-projected runtime state and no legacy composer import/resource discovery. Probe fitness may still track whether the agent reads selected resources before use.) | D39-L, D40-L, D58-L, D59-L | | I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node/batch writes, rollback protection, `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping, globally unique 1–3 letter labels with readiness-band metadata, projected-code parsing, selected-spec existing-code resolution, and code-primary prompt/tool rendering; remaining slice still needs deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | | I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` replaced the persisted basis enum with `explicit | implicit`, made `commitGraph` apply one batch approval basis to all created nodes/edges, made `propose-graph` adapter commits implicit, made review-set translation explicit, rejected retired `accepted_review_set`, and records `change_log.operation` independently; remaining capture/review-cycle slices still need direct user/capture assignment coverage) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | -| I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | planned (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for existing-cycle, intra-batch-cycle, mixed existing+batch-cycle, and rollback behavior) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | +| I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | covered (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests reject existing-cycle closure, intra-batch cycles, and mixed existing+batch cycles; rejected cycles roll back batch nodes/edges/change_log; acyclic supersession commits remain covered by snapshot/CommandExecutor success paths) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | ## Future Direction Register @@ -629,7 +629,7 @@ The first required probe is M0: after manual TUI interaction, a checker proves ` | I38-L | `agents-composition-layer` inner tests: given projected runtime states and spec grades, compose emits manifests whose goal/strategy/lens/method resources are legal, Brunch-owned, readable, and filtered by the agent allow-list; AUTO axes list only legal choices and pinned axes point to their selected resource. Middle/outer probes may track whether the model actually reads the selected resource before applying it as fitness, not as an inner-loop gate. | | I39-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter/context tests: counter rows allocate monotonic per-kind ordinals in multi-node batches, rollback does not persist failed ordinals/counter rows, DB constraints reject duplicate `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)`, projected-code metadata is unique and parses by longest prefix, existing-code refs resolve inside the selected spec, and prompt/tool renderers use codes as primary handles. Remaining proof: deletion/supersession no-reuse. | | I40-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter tests: `commitGraph` applies one batch basis to all created nodes/edges, `propose-graph` adapter commits use `implicit`, review-set translation uses `explicit`, retired `accepted_review_set` is rejected, and `change_log.operation` remains `commit_graph` independently of basis. Remaining proof: capture/direct-user writes and full review-cycle acceptance path. | -| I41-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests for supersession acyclicity across existing edges, intra-batch edges, and mixed existing+batch edges, including rollback on illegal cycles. | +| I41-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests reject supersession cycles across existing edges, intra-batch edges, and mixed existing+batch edges, including rollback of batch nodes/edges/change_log; existing acyclic supersession paths still commit. | ### Design Notes diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md index c2777f3b6..3f6052d4e 100644 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md @@ -225,7 +225,7 @@ src/agents/contexts/ ## Card 4 — Enforce supersession acyclicity -Status: next +Status: done ### Target Behavior diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts index 6be589d6a..0ff707a1b 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts @@ -809,12 +809,92 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { }); expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - // Transaction rolled back — no nodes either expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); const [clock] = db.select().from(graphClock).all(); expect(clock!.lsn).toBe(0); }); + it('rejects supersession cycles against existing edges', () => { + const newer = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R2' }); + const older = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }); + if (newer.status !== 'success' || older.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect( + executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { + category: 'supersession', + source: { existing: newer.nodeId }, + target: { existing: older.nodeId }, + }, + ], + }).status, + ).toBe('success'); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { + category: 'supersession', + source: { existing: older.nodeId }, + target: { existing: newer.nodeId }, + }, + ], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); + }); + + it('rejects intra-batch supersession cycles', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'a', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'A' }, + { ref: 'b', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'B' }, + ], + edges: [ + { category: 'supersession', source: 'a', target: 'b' }, + { category: 'supersession', source: 'b', target: 'a' }, + ], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); + }); + + it('rejects mixed existing and batch supersession cycles', () => { + const a = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'A' }); + const b = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'B' }); + if (a.status !== 'success' || b.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect( + executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { category: 'supersession', source: { existing: a.nodeId }, target: { existing: b.nodeId } }, + ], + }).status, + ).toBe('success'); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'c', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'C' }], + edges: [ + { category: 'supersession', source: { existing: b.nodeId }, target: 'c' }, + { category: 'supersession', source: 'c', target: { existing: a.nodeId } }, + ], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(2); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); + }); + it('if post-insert edge validation fails, no nodes, change log, or counter state is written', () => { const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId, diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index cc299c5d4..25bc0c144 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -469,6 +469,57 @@ function addExistingRefId( if (id !== undefined) refs.add(id); } +function findSupersessionCycle( + db: Pick, + specId: number, + proposedEdges: readonly ResolvedEdge[], +): Diagnostic | undefined { + const supersessionEdges = proposedEdges.filter((edge) => edge.category === 'supersession'); + if (supersessionEdges.length === 0) return undefined; + + const adjacency = new Map(); + const addEdge = (source: number, target: number) => { + const targets = adjacency.get(source); + if (targets) { + targets.push(target); + } else { + adjacency.set(source, [target]); + } + }; + + for (const edge of db + .select({ sourceId: schema.edges.source_id, targetId: schema.edges.target_id }) + .from(schema.edges) + .where(and(eq(schema.edges.spec_id, specId), eq(schema.edges.category, 'supersession'))) + .all()) { + addEdge(edge.sourceId, edge.targetId); + } + for (const edge of supersessionEdges) { + addEdge(edge.sourceId, edge.targetId); + } + + const visiting = new Set(); + const visited = new Set(); + const hasCycle = (nodeId: number): boolean => { + if (visiting.has(nodeId)) return true; + if (visited.has(nodeId)) return false; + visiting.add(nodeId); + for (const targetId of adjacency.get(nodeId) ?? []) { + if (hasCycle(targetId)) return true; + } + visiting.delete(nodeId); + visited.add(nodeId); + return false; + }; + + for (const nodeId of adjacency.keys()) { + if (hasCycle(nodeId)) { + return { field: 'edges', message: 'supersession edges must be acyclic within one spec' }; + } + } + return undefined; +} + function validateAndResolveBatchEdge( input: BatchEdgeInput, index: number, @@ -906,6 +957,11 @@ export class CommandExecutor { throw new BatchValidationError(edgeDiagnostics); } + const cycleDiagnostic = findSupersessionCycle(tx, input.specId, resolvedEdges); + if (cycleDiagnostic) { + throw new BatchValidationError([cycleDiagnostic]); + } + // 6. Insert all edges const edgeIds: number[] = []; for (const re of resolvedEdges) { From a2204902d3cc92facdc579215659330cb6fc6c80 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 15:18:52 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 05/21] FE-808 split active graph projection --- memory/PLAN.md | 3 +- ...h-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md | 353 ------------------ src/graph/README.md | 6 +- src/graph/index.ts | 2 + src/graph/snapshot.test.ts | 18 +- src/graph/snapshot.ts | 37 +- 6 files changed, 48 insertions(+), 371 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index 04be4696e..a005b113a 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -133,7 +133,7 @@ _None._ - **Cross-cutting obligations:** Avoid harness-as-false-proof: the probe must exercise the same default Brunch runtime factory and registered tools that the product uses. Record fitness, not just pass/fail. Preserve D62-L/D63-L/D64-L as graph-wide contracts rather than adapter-local conveniences. - **Traceability:** D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D53-L, D60-L, D62-L, D63-L, D64-L / I34-L, I35-L, I39-L, I40-L, I41-L / A14-L, A5-L. - **Design docs:** `docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md`; `docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`. -- **Current execution pointer:** `memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md` scopes the graph write contract materialization chain; build this before capture/review frontiers. +- **Current execution pointer:** Graph write contract materialization chain completed and removed from `memory/cards/`; remaining frontier work is direct product-path probe coverage for existing-code refs, retry diagnostics, and no-overcommit behavior. ### project-graph-review-cycle @@ -236,6 +236,7 @@ _None._ - **Design docs:** `src/README.md`; `src/.pi/README.md`; `src/agents/README.md`; `src/db/README.md`; `src/graph/README.md`; `src/rpc/README.md`; `src/session/README.md`; `src/web/README.md`. ## Recently Completed +- 2026-06-04 `graph-tool-resilience` graph write contract chain — Done: graph nodes persist per-kind ordinals and expose projected codes; `commitGraph` applies one explicit/implicit batch basis; adapters resolve existing-node codes inside the selected spec; same-spec supersession cycles are rejected atomically; active-context graph reads omit hidden superseded nodes and dangling edges while graph-truth reads remain available. - 2026-06-04 `agents-composition-layer` (FE-806) — Done: `agents/state.ts`/`compose.ts` emit runtime headers and gated prompt-resource manifests; `agents/contexts/{cwd,graph,node}.ts` renders selected-spec context with lens-specific emphasis; the real `.pi` `before_agent_start` product path supplies selected-spec-bound graph snapshots from the Brunch runtime factory; the legacy `src/.pi/context/` prompt-pack subtree is deleted after folding its useful guidance into `src/agents/methods/*.md`; deterministic product-path proof records strategy/lens posture differences and accepted blind spots. Verified: context/compose/prompting/architecture tests and `npm run verify`. Watch: prompt quality is fitness evidence only; graph-write resilience and capture quality remain with the next P0 frontiers. - 2026-06-04 `live-graph-observer` (FE-795) — Done: `graph.overview` and `graph.nodeNeighborhood` are discoverable selected-spec RPC reads; graph readers remain in `graph/`; TUI/agent `commit_graph` publishes graph invalidation topics through the shared product-update bus; the TUI launch path starts a read-only web sidecar over the same bus; the React web app attaches over one WebSocket RPC client, renders the selected-spec graph overview, and invalidates/refetches canonical graph readers on `brunch.updated`. Verified: targeted FE-795 test set (`src/rpc/handlers.test.ts`, `src/rpc/web-host.test.ts`, `src/web/app.test.tsx`, `src/brunch-tui.test.ts`, `src/graph/snapshot.test.ts`, `src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts`), `npm run build`, and a 2026-06-04 `agent-browser` smoke that observed empty graph state then a `commit_graph`-created node in the browser without reload. Watch: richer node-neighborhood UI remains optional polish; the current proof exposes/query-backs the focused read and renders the overview. diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md deleted file mode 100644 index 3f6052d4e..000000000 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--graph-write-contract.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,353 +0,0 @@ -# Graph write contract materialization - -Frontier: graph-tool-resilience -Status: active -Mode: chain -Created: 2026-06-04 - -## Orientation - -- Containing seam: `graph-tool-resilience` (FE-808), reshaped from probe-only hardening into the graph write contract materialization frontier. -- Posture: proving (inherited from `graph-tool-resilience`). This slice chain should stabilize I39-L/I40-L/I41-L before capture/review frontiers build on graph writes. -- Main risk: adapters, snapshots, and tests may still assume raw integer node ids and `accepted_review_set` basis values; remove the old shape directly rather than bridging it. -- Cross-cutting obligations: preserve `CommandExecutor` as the only graph mutation authority; keep projected node codes out of DB storage; keep readiness bands as query/rubric metadata, not write-time kind gates. - -## Card 1 — Persist per-kind node ordinals - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -Every committed graph node receives a monotonic, non-reused ordinal scoped to `(spec_id, plane, kind)`. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -agent/capture/review command input -→ graph/CommandExecutor -→ db/schema.ts nodes + node_kind_counters -→ graph/snapshot row mappers -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: allocating ordinals inside failed batches may leave gaps. - → MITIGATION: require monotonic/no-reuse, not gaplessness; rollback tests should prove failed batches do not persist nodes or change-log entries. -- ASSUMPTION: a small counter table is cheaper and clearer than deriving ordinals by scanning existing nodes. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: CommandExecutor allocation code changes, but projected-code contract remains. - → VALIDATE: transaction tests around batch allocation, rollback, and duplicate DB constraints. - -### Posture check - -This stabilizes I39-L and proves the storage half of D62-L through the real mutation boundary. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ command-executor.test.ts — multi-node batches allocate kind_ordinal per (spec, plane, kind) -✓ command-executor.test.ts — failed batches do not persist nodes, edges, change-log entries, or unusable counter state -✓ db/schema tests or migration checks — duplicate (spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal) rows are structurally impossible -✓ snapshot.test.ts — GraphNode domain objects expose kindOrdinal -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: CommandExecutor + DB schema tests — prove allocation, rollback, and uniqueness. -- Middle: none for this card; later cards exercise adapters/product tools. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Do not store rendered reference-code strings in graph tables. -- Keep ordinals spec-scoped; no workspace-global graph truth. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/db/ -├── schema.ts ~ -├── row-schemas.ts ~ -└── README.md ~ -drizzle/ -└── *.sql + -src/graph/ -├── command-executor.ts ~ -├── command-executor.test.ts ~ -├── snapshot.ts ~ -├── snapshot.test.ts ~ -├── spec-ownership.test.ts ~ -├── atoms.ts ~ -├── index.ts ~ -└── schema/ - └── nodes.ts ~ -``` - -## Card 2 — Replace path-shaped graph basis with approval basis - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -Accepted graph nodes and edges persist only `basis: explicit | implicit`. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -propose-graph / capture / review-set adapter basis decision -→ graph/CommandExecutor input -→ db enum constraints -→ snapshots and graph domain types -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: current tool schemas allow callers to supply per-node/per-edge basis and preserve `accepted_review_set`. - → MITIGATION: move basis to the command/adaptation context; reject retired values in tests. -- ASSUMPTION: mutation path is recoverable enough from `change_log.operation` and payload. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: need richer change-log payloads, not a third basis enum. - → VALIDATE: tests assert both stored basis and change-log operation for each write path. - -### Posture check - -This stabilizes I40-L and removes the most misleading compatibility bridge in the graph model. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ command-executor.test.ts — commitGraph accepts one batch approval basis and applies it to all created nodes/edges -✓ command-executor.test.ts — retired accepted_review_set basis values are rejected at the command boundary or impossible through types/schemas -✓ review-set-proposal tests — accepted review-set translation commits exact reviewed items with explicit basis -✓ graph tool adapter tests — propose-graph commit path supplies implicit basis without asking the agent per item -✓ change-log assertions — mutation operation remains visible independently of basis -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: domain/schema/adapter tests — prove basis enum and assignment rules. -- Middle: none for this card unless an existing product probe already inspects basis. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- `basis` is approval strength only; do not encode strategy or transport path in it. -- Low-confidence inferred material still stays outside graph truth. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/db/ -├── schema.ts ~ -└── README.md ~ -src/graph/ -├── command-executor.ts ~ -├── command-executor.test.ts ~ -├── schema/ -│ ├── nodes.ts ~ -│ └── edges.ts ~ -└── index.ts ~ -src/.pi/extensions/graph/ -├── tool-schemas.ts ~ -├── command-adapter.ts ~ -├── review-set-proposal.ts ~ -└── *.test.ts ? -``` - -## Card 3 — Resolve existing graph refs by projected code - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -Agent-facing graph write adapters resolve existing-node references from projected codes to internal NodeIds. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -commit_graph tool params / review-set payload -→ graph adapter projected-code parser -→ selected-spec graph lookup -→ CommandExecutor NodeId refs -→ tool result rendering -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: prefix parsing can be ambiguous if labels collide. - → MITIGATION: hard-code globally unique labels and test longest-prefix parsing. -- RISK: CommandExecutor currently owns existing-node spec guards for raw ids. - → MITIGATION: keep selected-spec ownership check after code resolution; adapter resolution must not weaken the guard. -- ASSUMPTION: lower-level CommandExecutor may still use internal NodeId refs after adapter resolution. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: ref-resolution helper moves into graph/ so all adapters share it. - → VALIDATE: adapter and spec-ownership tests. - -### Posture check - -This lights up the D62-L product handle path without making projected code a DB column. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ graph metadata tests — every node kind has a globally unique 1–3 letter label and readiness-band metadata -✓ adapter tests — existingCode values like A1/CON2/CR3 parse to kind + kindOrdinal by longest prefix -✓ adapter/CommandExecutor tests — existingCode resolves only within the selected spec -✓ read_graph formatting tests — success output renders projected codes as primary handles and raw ids only as diagnostics/details when needed -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: parser/adapter/spec-ownership tests — prove code resolution and selected-spec guard. -- Middle: direct graph tool probe later in the frontier should include an existing-node code reference. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Projected codes are presentation handles; do not store them or make them canonical DB identity. -- Existing refs must target the selected spec only. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/graph/ -├── schema/ -│ └── nodes.ts ~ -├── snapshot.ts ~ -├── snapshot.test.ts ~ -├── spec-ownership.test.ts ~ -└── index.ts ~ -src/.pi/extensions/graph/ -├── tool-schemas.ts ~ -├── command-adapter.ts ~ -├── command-adapter.test.ts + -└── index.ts ~ -src/agents/contexts/ -├── graph.ts ~ -├── graph.test.ts ~ -├── node.ts ~ -└── node.test.ts ~ -``` - -## Card 4 — Enforce supersession acyclicity - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -Same-spec supersession edge creation rejects every proposed cycle before writing any batch state. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -edge command input -→ CommandExecutor structural validation -→ existing same-spec supersession edge read -→ transaction rollback / success result -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: mixed existing + intra-batch cycles are easy to miss if validation runs only per edge. - → MITIGATION: validate the proposed supersession graph as a set against existing same-spec supersession edges. -- ASSUMPTION: supersession acyclicity is structural legality, not coherence advice. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: downstream active-context projection can hide the wrong current node. - → VALIDATE: cycle tests across existing, intra-batch, and mixed cases. - -### Posture check - -This stabilizes I41-L and removes a documented-but-unenforced graph invariant. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ command-executor.test.ts — rejects simple existing-cycle closure -✓ command-executor.test.ts — rejects intra-batch supersession cycles -✓ command-executor.test.ts — rejects mixed existing+batch supersession cycles -✓ command-executor.test.ts — rejected cycles roll back all nodes/edges/change-log from the batch -✓ command-executor.test.ts — acyclic supersession chains still commit -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: CommandExecutor structural tests — prove cycle detection and rollback. -- Middle: none required. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Keep cross-plane freedom; acyclicity applies to `supersession` edges, not node-kind legality. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/graph/ -├── command-executor.ts ~ -├── command-executor.test.ts ~ -└── policy/ - └── category-policy.ts ? -``` - -## Card 5 — Make active-context graph reads code-aware and non-dangling - -Status: next - -### Target Behavior - -Active-context graph snapshots omit hidden superseded nodes and every edge whose endpoint is hidden. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -graph/snapshot pull -→ graph domain projection -→ agents/contexts render -→ read_graph tool result / RPC graph readers -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: changing `getGraphOverview` semantics could break existing observer UI expectations. - → MITIGATION: make projection choice explicit where the public read surface needs both graph_truth and active_context; default only where current product contract names it. -- ASSUMPTION: active-context filtering belongs in graph pull, while LLM string formatting belongs in agents/contexts or tool adapters. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: projection/rendering responsibilities blur again. - → VALIDATE: snapshot tests plus context-render tests. - -### Posture check - -This stabilizes D60-L and keeps the graph read path aligned with the new code/basis write contract. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ snapshot.test.ts — graph_truth can include superseded predecessors and their edges when requested -✓ snapshot.test.ts — active_context omits superseded nodes and edges touching omitted nodes -✓ agents context tests — rendered graph/node context uses projected codes as primary handles -✓ read_graph adapter tests — details/content remain selected-spec scoped after projection changes -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: snapshot/context/tool tests — prove projection and rendering split. -- Middle: later frontier probe can exercise browser/read_graph observation after graph writes. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- PULL remains typed read-only data in `graph/`; RENDER remains in `agents/contexts/` or adapter formatting. -- Do not widen into a generic records API beyond the list/related/overview shapes currently named by D60-L. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/graph/ -├── snapshot.ts ~ -├── snapshot.test.ts ~ -└── README.md ~ -src/agents/contexts/ -├── graph.ts ~ -├── graph.test.ts ~ -├── node.ts ~ -└── node.test.ts ~ -src/.pi/extensions/graph/ -├── command-adapter.ts ~ -└── index.ts ~ -src/rpc/ -├── handlers.ts ? -└── handlers.test.ts ? -src/web/ -├── app.tsx ? -└── app.test.tsx ? -``` diff --git a/src/graph/README.md b/src/graph/README.md index f52d17669..90cb77560 100644 --- a/src/graph/README.md +++ b/src/graph/README.md @@ -14,10 +14,10 @@ SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L, D54-L, D62-L one transaction, one LSN, all-or-nothing. It accepts product command input (`nodes[]` with batch refs, `edges[]` with batch/existing refs), not raw DB rows. - - **Readers / snapshot functions** (`snapshot.ts`) — graph projections at - multiple detail levels: full overview, node neighborhood, and open - reconciliation needs. These return typed domain objects, not Drizzle rows. + multiple detail levels: active-context and graph-truth overview, node + neighborhood, and open reconciliation needs. These return typed domain objects, + not Drizzle rows. - **Domain schema types** (`schema/`) — `GraphNode`, `GraphEdge`, `ReconciliationNeed`, kind/category types, per-kind node ordinals, and derived diff --git a/src/graph/index.ts b/src/graph/index.ts index b5d078ff8..d9c167ed6 100644 --- a/src/graph/index.ts +++ b/src/graph/index.ts @@ -60,6 +60,8 @@ export { export { getGraphOverview, getNodeNeighborhood, getOpenReconciliationNeeds } from './snapshot.js'; export type { GraphOverview, + GraphOverviewOptions, + GraphProjection, NeighborhoodOptions, NeighborhoodNotFound, NeighborhoodResult, diff --git a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts index abdc4c78f..5f59cbfa9 100644 --- a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts @@ -141,13 +141,17 @@ describe('getGraphOverview', () => { }); expect(batch.status).toBe('success'); - const overview = getGraphOverview(db, specId); - // R_offline_v0 should be excluded (it is a superseded predecessor) - const titles = overview.nodes.map((n) => n.title); - expect(titles).toContain('R_offline_v1'); - expect(titles).not.toContain('R_offline_v0'); - // The supersession edge should still be present - expect(overview.edges).toHaveLength(1); + const activeOverview = getGraphOverview(db, specId); + const activeTitles = activeOverview.nodes.map((n) => n.title); + expect(activeTitles).toContain('R_offline_v1'); + expect(activeTitles).not.toContain('R_offline_v0'); + expect(activeOverview.edges).toHaveLength(0); + + const truthOverview = getGraphOverview(db, specId, { projection: 'graph_truth' }); + expect(truthOverview.nodes.map((n) => n.title)).toEqual( + expect.arrayContaining(['R_offline_v0', 'R_offline_v1']), + ); + expect(truthOverview.edges).toHaveLength(1); }); }); diff --git a/src/graph/snapshot.ts b/src/graph/snapshot.ts index 0252035f9..f667c560b 100644 --- a/src/graph/snapshot.ts +++ b/src/graph/snapshot.ts @@ -13,6 +13,7 @@ import { and, eq, or, inArray } from 'drizzle-orm'; import type { BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; import * as schema from '../db/schema.js'; +import type { Lsn } from './atoms.js'; import type { GraphEdge } from './schema/edges.js'; import type { GraphNode, NodeDetail } from './schema/nodes.js'; import type { ReconciliationNeed, ReconciliationNeedTarget } from './schema/reconciliation-need.js'; @@ -21,14 +22,20 @@ import type { ReconciliationNeed, ReconciliationNeedTarget } from './schema/reco // Return types // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- +/** Full-graph cursory overview. */ +export type GraphProjection = 'active_context' | 'graph_truth'; + /** Full-graph cursory overview. */ export interface GraphOverview { readonly nodes: readonly GraphNode[]; readonly edges: readonly GraphEdge[]; readonly nodeCount: number; readonly edgeCount: number; - /** Current LSN from graph_clock. */ - readonly lsn: number; + readonly lsn: Lsn; +} + +export interface GraphOverviewOptions { + readonly projection?: GraphProjection; } /** Successful neighborhood result. */ @@ -121,15 +128,28 @@ function getSupersededIds(db: BrunchDb, specId: number): Set { * Superseded predecessors are excluded from the node list per * CATEGORY_POLICY.supersession.projectionEffect. */ -export function getGraphOverview(db: BrunchDb, specId: number): GraphOverview { - const supersededIds = getSupersededIds(db, specId); +export function getGraphOverview( + db: BrunchDb, + specId: number, + options: GraphOverviewOptions = {}, +): GraphOverview { + const projection = options.projection ?? 'active_context'; + const supersededIds = projection === 'active_context' ? getSupersededIds(db, specId) : new Set(); const allNodeRows = db.select().from(schema.nodes).where(eq(schema.nodes.spec_id, specId)).all(); + const visibleNodeRows = allNodeRows.filter((r) => !supersededIds.has(r.id)); + const visibleNodeIds = new Set(visibleNodeRows.map((row) => row.id)); const allEdgeRows = db.select().from(schema.edges).where(eq(schema.edges.spec_id, specId)).all(); - const nodes = allNodeRows.filter((r) => !supersededIds.has(r.id)).map(rowToNode); + const nodes = visibleNodeRows.map(rowToNode); - const edges = allEdgeRows.map(rowToEdge); + const edges = allEdgeRows + .filter( + (edge) => + projection === 'graph_truth' || + (visibleNodeIds.has(edge.source_id) && visibleNodeIds.has(edge.target_id)), + ) + .map(rowToEdge); const clockRow = db.select().from(schema.graphClock).get(); const lsn = clockRow?.lsn ?? 0; @@ -218,6 +238,7 @@ export function getNodeNeighborhood( // Fetch neighbor nodes (exclude anchor) — restrict to same spec defensively const neighborIds = [...visited].filter((id) => id !== nodeId); const neighborNodes: GraphNode[] = []; + const visibleIds = new Set([nodeId, ...neighborIds]); if (neighborIds.length > 0) { const rows = db .select() @@ -232,7 +253,9 @@ export function getNodeNeighborhood( const edgeNodes: GraphEdge[] = []; if (edgeIdArr.length > 0) { const rows = db.select().from(schema.edges).where(inArray(schema.edges.id, edgeIdArr)).all(); - edgeNodes.push(...rows.map(rowToEdge)); + edgeNodes.push( + ...rows.filter((row) => visibleIds.has(row.source_id) && visibleIds.has(row.target_id)).map(rowToEdge), + ); } return { From 32227fb2e1079a05727f1e0548137921714c83d5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 15:25:06 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 06/21] Align probe transcripts with Pi context rendering Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-019e92bc-e43a-727f-8acf-0213915029ff Co-authored-by: Amp --- docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md | 2 +- src/probes/public-rpc-parity-proof.test.ts | 8 +- src/session/session-transcript.test.ts | 76 +++++++- src/session/session-transcript.ts | 190 ++++++++------------ 4 files changed, 145 insertions(+), 131 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md b/docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md index e0d47e881..7bb408587 100644 --- a/docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md +++ b/docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md @@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ A committed probe run lives at: ``` .fixtures/runs/// ├── session.jsonl # source transcript / canonical run evidence -├── transcript.md # Brunch-semantic human rendering +├── transcript.md # probe-focused markdown rendering of Pi-derived LLM context └── report.json # probe metadata, oracle summary, artifact paths ``` diff --git a/src/probes/public-rpc-parity-proof.test.ts b/src/probes/public-rpc-parity-proof.test.ts index 6b0f2d0c7..77f1962f7 100644 --- a/src/probes/public-rpc-parity-proof.test.ts +++ b/src/probes/public-rpc-parity-proof.test.ts @@ -67,9 +67,10 @@ describe('public Brunch RPC structured-exchange parity proof', () => { expect(sessionJsonl).toContain('"toolName":"present_options"'); expect(transcript).toContain('# Transcript — session.jsonl'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## Exchange'); - expect(transcript).toContain('— prompt (present_'); - expect(transcript).toContain('— response (request_'); + expect(transcript).toContain('Tool result: present_options'); + expect(transcript).toContain('Tool result: request_choice'); + expect(transcript).toContain('Tool result: request_answer'); + expect(transcript).toContain('Tool result: request_choices'); expect(persistedReport).toMatchObject({ schemaVersion: 1, probeId: 'public-rpc-parity', @@ -86,7 +87,6 @@ describe('public Brunch RPC structured-exchange parity proof', () => { expect(transcript.match(/Is this a new product or feature from scratch\?/g) ?? []).toHaveLength(1); for (const exchangeId of persistedReport.exchangeIds) { expect(sessionJsonl).toContain(exchangeId); - expect(transcript).toContain(exchangeId); } }); }); diff --git a/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts b/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts index f20e385b3..3e0746793 100644 --- a/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts +++ b/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts @@ -7,30 +7,50 @@ function line(value: unknown): string { } describe('session transcript renderer', () => { - it('renders structured-exchange tuple JSONL as a readable transcript', () => { + it('derives Pi context first, then renders only markdown-bearing message content', () => { const jsonl = [ line({ type: 'session', id: 'session-1', cwd: '/tmp/brunch' }), line({ id: 'binding-1', type: 'custom', customType: 'brunch.session_binding', + parentId: null, + timestamp: '2026-06-04T00:00:00.000Z', data: { schemaVersion: 1, specId: 1 }, }), + line({ + id: 'custom-message-1', + type: 'custom_message', + parentId: 'binding-1', + timestamp: '2026-06-04T00:00:01.000Z', + customType: 'brunch.note', + content: 'hello custom', + display: true, + details: { hidden: true }, + }), line({ id: 'generic-tool-1', type: 'message', + parentId: 'custom-message-1', + timestamp: '2026-06-04T00:00:02.000Z', message: { role: 'toolResult', + toolCallId: 'read-call-1', toolName: 'read', content: [{ type: 'text', text: 'Generic file contents' }], details: { path: 'notes.txt' }, + isError: false, + timestamp: 2, }, }), line({ id: 'present-1', type: 'message', + parentId: 'generic-tool-1', + timestamp: '2026-06-04T00:00:03.000Z', message: { role: 'toolResult', + toolCallId: 'present-call-1', toolName: 'present_options', content: [ { @@ -48,13 +68,18 @@ describe('session transcript renderer', () => { expectedRequest: { tool: 'request_choice', required: true }, createdAtToolCallId: 'present-call-1', }, + isError: false, + timestamp: 3, }, }), line({ id: 'request-1', type: 'message', + parentId: 'present-1', + timestamp: '2026-06-04T00:00:04.000Z', message: { role: 'toolResult', + toolCallId: 'request-call-1', toolName: 'request_choice', content: [ { @@ -76,6 +101,35 @@ describe('session transcript renderer', () => { comment: 'Keep it deterministic.', createdAtToolCallId: 'request-call-1', }, + isError: false, + timestamp: 4, + }, + }), + line({ + id: 'assistant-1', + type: 'message', + parentId: 'request-1', + timestamp: '2026-06-04T00:00:05.000Z', + message: { + role: 'assistant', + content: [ + { type: 'text', text: 'I will inspect the workspace.' }, + { type: 'thinking', thinking: 'private chain of thought' }, + { type: 'toolCall', id: 'tool-call-1', name: 'read', arguments: { path: 'notes.txt' } }, + ], + api: 'openai-completions', + provider: 'openai', + model: 'test-model', + usage: { + input: 0, + output: 0, + cacheRead: 0, + cacheWrite: 0, + totalTokens: 0, + cost: { input: 0, output: 0, cacheRead: 0, cacheWrite: 0, total: 0 }, + }, + stopReason: 'toolUse', + timestamp: 5, }, }), ].join('\n'); @@ -85,14 +139,20 @@ describe('session transcript renderer', () => { }); expect(transcript).toContain('# Transcript — session.jsonl'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## Session'); - expect(transcript).toContain('- session: session-1'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## Session binding'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## Exchange turn-1 — prompt (present_options → request_choice)'); + expect(transcript).toContain('## 1. User'); + expect(transcript).toContain('hello custom'); + expect(transcript).toContain('## 2. Tool result: read'); + expect(transcript).toContain('Generic file contents'); + expect(transcript).toContain('## 3. Tool result: present_options'); expect(transcript).toContain('**Rationale:** validates the seam.'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## Exchange turn-1 — response (request_choice, answered)'); + expect(transcript).toContain('## 4. Tool result: request_choice'); expect(transcript).toContain('Keep it deterministic.'); - expect(transcript).not.toContain('## Tool result: read'); - expect(transcript).not.toContain('Generic file contents'); + expect(transcript).toContain('## 5. Assistant'); + expect(transcript).toContain('I will inspect the workspace.'); + expect(transcript).not.toContain('Session binding'); + expect(transcript).not.toContain('turn-1'); + expect(transcript).not.toContain('private chain of thought'); + expect(transcript).not.toContain('Tool call: read'); + expect(transcript).not.toContain('"path": "notes.txt"'); }); }); diff --git a/src/session/session-transcript.ts b/src/session/session-transcript.ts index 654248bb8..7f02d55fb 100644 --- a/src/session/session-transcript.ts +++ b/src/session/session-transcript.ts @@ -2,24 +2,20 @@ import { readFile } from 'node:fs/promises'; import { basename, resolve } from 'node:path'; import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'; -import type { ToolResultMessage } from '@earendil-works/pi-ai'; import type { - CustomEntry, - CustomMessageEntry, - FileEntry, - SessionHeader, - SessionMessageEntry, -} from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; - -import { - isStructuredExchangePresentDetails, - isStructuredExchangeRequestDetails, -} from '../.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/shared/recovery.js'; + ImageContent, + Message, + TextContent, + ThinkingContent, + ToolCall, + ToolResultMessage, + UserMessage, +} from '@earendil-works/pi-ai'; +import type { FileEntry, SessionEntry } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; +import { buildSessionContext, convertToLlm } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; type TranscriptEntry = FileEntry; -type TranscriptToolResultMessage = ToolResultMessage; - export async function renderSessionTranscriptFile(sessionFile: string): Promise { const text = await readFile(sessionFile, 'utf8'); return renderSessionTranscript(text, { title: basename(sessionFile) }); @@ -27,10 +23,11 @@ export async function renderSessionTranscriptFile(sessionFile: string): Promise< export function renderSessionTranscript(jsonl: string, options: { title?: string } = {}): string { const entries = parseJsonl(jsonl); + const messages = renderableMessages(llmMessages(entries)); const lines: string[] = [`# Transcript${options.title ? ` — ${options.title}` : ''}`]; - for (const entry of entries) { - lines.push('', ...renderEntry(entry)); + for (const [index, message] of messages.entries()) { + lines.push('', ...renderMessage(message, index + 1)); } return `${lines.join('\n').trimEnd()}\n`; @@ -50,131 +47,88 @@ function parseJsonl(jsonl: string): FileEntry[] { }); } -function renderEntry(entry: TranscriptEntry): string[] { - if (isSessionHeaderEntry(entry)) { - return renderSessionHeader(entry); - } - - if (isCustomTranscriptEntry(entry)) { - return renderCustomEntry(entry); - } - - if (isMessageEntry(entry)) { - return renderMessageEntry(entry); - } - - return [`## Entry ${entryId(entry)}`, '', '```json', JSON.stringify(entry, null, 2), '```']; +function llmMessages(entries: TranscriptEntry[]): Message[] { + const sessionEntries = entries.filter((entry): entry is SessionEntry => entry.type !== 'session'); + return convertToLlm(buildSessionContext(sessionEntries).messages); } -function renderSessionHeader(entry: SessionHeader): string[] { - const fields = [ - typeof entry.id === 'string' ? `- session: ${entry.id}` : undefined, - typeof entry.cwd === 'string' ? `- cwd: ${entry.cwd}` : undefined, - ].filter((line): line is string => line !== undefined); - return ['## Session', '', ...(fields.length > 0 ? fields : ['- session metadata present'])]; +function renderableMessages(messages: Message[]): Message[] { + return messages.filter((message) => renderMarkdown(message).length > 0); } -function renderCustomEntry(entry: CustomEntry | CustomMessageEntry): string[] { - const customType = typeof entry.customType === 'string' ? entry.customType : 'custom'; - const title = customType === 'brunch.session_binding' ? 'Session binding' : `Custom: ${customType}`; - const payload = entry.type === 'custom_message' ? entry.details : entry.data; - const text = textContent(entry.type === 'custom_message' ? entry.content : undefined); - const body: string[] = []; - if (text.length > 0) body.push(text); - if (payload !== undefined) { - body.push('```json', JSON.stringify(payload, null, 2), '```'); +function renderMessage(message: Message, index: number): string[] { + switch (message.role) { + case 'user': + return renderUserMessage(message, index); + case 'assistant': + return renderAssistantMessage(message, index); + case 'toolResult': + return renderToolResult(message, index); } - return [`## ${title}`, '', ...(body.length > 0 ? body : ['_(no display content)_'])]; } -function renderMessageEntry(entry: SessionMessageEntry): string[] { - const message = entry.message; - if (!message || typeof message !== 'object') { - return [`## Message ${entryId(entry)}`, '', '_(missing message payload)_']; - } - - if (isToolResultMessage(message)) { - return renderToolResult(entry, message); - } - - const role = typeof message.role === 'string' ? titleCase(message.role) : 'Message'; - const text = textContent((message as unknown as Record).content); - return [`## ${role}`, '', text.length > 0 ? text : '_(empty)_']; -} - -function renderToolResult(_entry: SessionMessageEntry, message: TranscriptToolResultMessage): string[] { - const details = message.details; - const present = structuredPresent(details); - if (present) { - const expected = - present.expectedRequest && typeof present.expectedRequest.tool === 'string' - ? ` → ${present.expectedRequest.tool}` - : ''; - return [ - `## Exchange ${present.exchangeId} — prompt (${present.presentTool}${expected})`, - '', - textContent(message.content) || '_(empty prompt)_', - ]; - } - - const request = structuredRequest(details); - if (request) { - return [ - `## Exchange ${request.exchangeId} — response (${request.requestTool}, ${request.status})`, - '', - textContent(message.content) || '_(empty response)_', - ]; - } - - return []; +function renderUserMessage(message: UserMessage, index: number): string[] { + return [`## ${index}. User`, '', ...renderUserContent(message.content)]; } -function structuredPresent(value: unknown) { - return isStructuredExchangePresentDetails(value) ? value : null; +function renderAssistantMessage(message: Extract, index: number): string[] { + return [`## ${index}. Assistant`, '', ...renderMarkdown(message)]; } -function structuredRequest(value: unknown) { - return isStructuredExchangeRequestDetails(value) ? value : null; +function renderToolResult(message: ToolResultMessage, index: number): string[] { + return [`## ${index}. Tool result: ${message.toolName}`, '', ...renderMarkdown(message)]; } -function textContent(content: unknown): string { - if (typeof content === 'string') return content.trim(); - if (!Array.isArray(content)) return ''; - return content - .map((part) => (isRecord(part) && typeof part.text === 'string' ? part.text : '')) - .filter((text) => text.length > 0) - .join('\n') - .trim(); -} - -function isSessionHeaderEntry(entry: TranscriptEntry): entry is SessionHeader { - return entry.type === 'session'; -} - -function isCustomTranscriptEntry(entry: TranscriptEntry): entry is CustomEntry | CustomMessageEntry { - return entry.type === 'custom' || entry.type === 'custom_message'; +function renderUserContent( + content: UserMessage['content'] | ToolResultMessage['content'], +): string[] { + if (typeof content === 'string') { + return renderTextBlock(content); + } + return renderTextBlocks(content); } -function isMessageEntry(entry: TranscriptEntry): entry is SessionMessageEntry { - return entry.type === 'message'; +function renderMarkdown(message: Message): string[] { + switch (message.role) { + case 'user': + return renderUserContent(message.content); + case 'assistant': + return renderTextBlocks(message.content); + case 'toolResult': + return renderUserContent(message.content); + } } -function isToolResultMessage( - message: SessionMessageEntry['message'], -): message is TranscriptToolResultMessage { - return message.role === 'toolResult'; +function renderTextBlocks(content: Array): string[] { + const rendered = content.flatMap((block) => { + if (!isTextContent(block)) { + return []; + } + return renderTextBlock(block.text); + }); + return rendered.length > 0 ? interleaveBlankLines(rendered) : []; } -function entryId(entry: TranscriptEntry): string { - return typeof entry.id === 'string' ? entry.id : '(unknown)'; +function isTextContent( + block: TextContent | ImageContent | ThinkingContent | ToolCall, +): block is TextContent { + return block.type === 'text'; } -function titleCase(value: string): string { - return value.charAt(0).toUpperCase() + value.slice(1); +function renderTextBlock(text: string): string[] { + const trimmed = text.trim(); + return trimmed.length > 0 ? [trimmed] : ['_(empty)_']; } -function isRecord(value: unknown): value is Record { - return typeof value === 'object' && value !== null; +function interleaveBlankLines(lines: string[]): string[] { + const output: string[] = []; + for (const line of lines) { + if (output.length > 0 && line !== '' && output.at(-1) !== '') { + output.push(''); + } + output.push(line); + } + return output; } async function main(): Promise { From 512eae4ef438b5a77b5b4f74681d314298be8ca0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:10:01 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 07/21] FE-808 canonicalize graph tool handles --- memory/SPEC.md | 2 +- .../graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md | 348 ++++++++++++++++++ src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts | 159 +++++++- src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts | 2 + src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts | 30 +- src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts | 21 +- src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts | 113 +++--- src/brunch-tui.ts | 1 + src/graph/README.md | 8 +- src/graph/command-executor.test.ts | 9 +- src/graph/command-executor.ts | 44 +-- src/graph/snapshot.ts | 18 +- src/graph/workspace-store.ts | 4 +- 13 files changed, 636 insertions(+), 123 deletions(-) create mode 100644 memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index a3660fd0d..b15fa3576 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -291,7 +291,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I36-L | Node `kind` is drawn from a per-plane closed enum structurally validated by the `CommandExecutor`; the intent kind category (basic / structural / reasoning) is a pure function of `kind` and is never stored on the node. | covered (CommandExecutor rejects invalid kind-for-plane; `intentKindCategory` is pure derivation with exhaustive switch; tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L, D56-L | | I37-L | `detail` is per-kind validated by the `CommandExecutor`: `decision` and `term` nodes REQUIRE `detail` with their respective sub-schemas; all other kinds must omit `detail`; unknown fields in `detail` are rejected. | covered (detail-required/prohibited/shape tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L | | I38-L | Every Brunch prompt-resource manifest injected for an agent turn is generated from projected runtime state and spec/workspace gates: listed resources are Brunch-owned, readable under the active tool policy, legal for the current `(op_mode × goal × strategy × lens)` / grade / agent allow-list, and off-list resources are not advertised as available. AUTO axes never list illegal choices; pinned axes point to the pinned resource. | covered for current P0 manifest families (`src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers default header/context/manifest output, AUTO grade/allow-list filtering, pinned singleton resources, illegal pinned grade rejection, and readable `src/agents/` locations; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` covers the explicit shell `before_agent_start` product path appending `agents/compose()` output from transcript-projected runtime state and no legacy composer import/resource discovery. Probe fitness may still track whether the agent reads selected resources before use.) | D39-L, D40-L, D58-L, D59-L | -| I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node/batch writes, rollback protection, `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping, globally unique 1–3 letter labels with readiness-band metadata, projected-code parsing, selected-spec existing-code resolution, and code-primary prompt/tool rendering; remaining slice still needs deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | +| I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node/batch writes, rollback protection, `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping, globally unique 1–3 letter labels with readiness-band metadata, projected-code parsing, selected-spec adapter resolution before `CommandExecutor`, code-only `commit_graph` / `read_graph` schemas, and code-primary prompt/tool rendering; remaining slice still needs deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | | I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` replaced the persisted basis enum with `explicit | implicit`, made `commitGraph` apply one batch approval basis to all created nodes/edges, made `propose-graph` adapter commits implicit, made review-set translation explicit, rejected retired `accepted_review_set`, and records `change_log.operation` independently; remaining capture/review-cycle slices still need direct user/capture assignment coverage) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | | I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | covered (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests reject existing-cycle closure, intra-batch cycles, and mixed existing+batch cycles; rejected cycles roll back batch nodes/edges/change_log; acyclic supersession commits remain covered by snapshot/CommandExecutor success paths) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0d0fbeeee --- /dev/null +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md @@ -0,0 +1,348 @@ +# Graph tool resilience closure chain + +Frontier: graph-tool-resilience +Status: active +Mode: chain +Created: 2026-06-04 + +## Orientation + +- Containing seam: `graph-tool-resilience` (FE-808), after the graph write contract materialization commits. +- Posture: proving (inherited from `graph-tool-resilience`). The chain should stabilize D62-L/D63-L/D53-L at the product boundary, then fire the direct-runtime probes that decide whether A14-L is materially broader than the old happy path. +- Volatile state: probe/transcript rendering work is being handled separately; this chain should not reshape `src/session/session-transcript*` unless the probe reporter cannot use the committed transcript API. +- Main open risk: the code now stores the right graph invariants, but the agent-facing tool surface still leaks raw ids and dry-run validation can diverge from commit validation. +- Frontier obligations: preserve `CommandExecutor` as the mutation authority, keep projected node codes out of DB storage, avoid harness-as-false-proof by exercising the default Brunch runtime factory, and record probe fitness rather than only pass/fail. + +Build order: Cards 1–2 are cleanup required before the product-path probes. Cards 3–5 are the remaining FE-808 probe evidence slices; they should remain valid after Cards 1–2 because they target frontier acceptance, not an implementation detail. + +## Card 1 — Canonicalize graph tool handles + +Status: done + +### Target Behavior + +The Pi graph-tool boundary exposes projected node codes as the only agent-facing existing-node handle. + +### Boundary Crossings + +```pseudo +read_graph / commit_graph Pi tools +→ src/.pi/extensions/graph tool schemas + prompt guidance +→ selected-spec graph code resolver +→ CommandExecutor / snapshot readers using internal NodeIds +→ tool result text + details +``` + +### Risks and Assumptions + +- RISK: raw integer ids remain useful for diagnostics and tests. + → MITIGATION: keep raw ids in internal `details`/domain objects only; remove them from agent instructions, primary rendered handles, and tool-call parameters. +- RISK: resolving projected codes inside `.pi/extensions/graph` could pull DB access into the adapter. + → MITIGATION: inject or import a graph-layer resolver/reader; `.pi/extensions/graph` must still avoid direct `db/` imports. +- ASSUMPTION: `node_code` / `existingCode` is sufficient for the current product path. + → IMPACT IF FALSE: FE-808 probes would still rely on raw ids and fail to prove D62-L at the agent boundary. + → VALIDATE: graph-tool adapter tests and product probe transcripts should contain code handles such as `G1` / `R2`, not instructions to use raw ids. + +### Posture check + +This is an invariant tracer: it makes D62-L observable at the product boundary rather than only in storage and snapshots. It also removes the compatibility bridge that lets agents keep using raw DB ids. + +### Acceptance Criteria + +```pseudo +✓ graph tool schema tests — commit_graph edge refs accept intra-batch refs and projected existing-node codes, not `{ existing: }` +✓ graph tool schema/tests — read_graph neighborhood mode accepts a projected node code instead of `node_id` +✓ adapter tests — selected-spec code resolution succeeds for an existing code and fails loudly for malformed, missing, or wrong-spec codes +✓ CommandExecutor input types/tests — commitGraph no longer accepts presentation-code refs directly; adapters resolve to internal NodeIds before mutation +✓ graph tool formatting tests — overview, neighborhood, and commit success render projected codes as primary handles +✓ prompt guidance tests — graph tool descriptions/guidelines no longer tell the agent to use raw existing node ids +``` + +### Verification Approach + +- Inner: adapter/schema/unit tests — prove code-only agent parameters and selected-spec resolution. +- Middle: transcript grep in later probe cards — prove the default runtime exposes/uses projected handles. + +### Cross-cutting obligations + +- Do not store rendered code strings in graph tables. +- Do not let `.pi/extensions/graph` import from `db/`. +- Keep raw ids available only as internal diagnostics/details where they are needed for tests or domain plumbing. + +### Expected touched paths (tentative) + +```pseudo +src/.pi/extensions/graph/ +├── tool-schemas.ts ~ +├── command-adapter.ts ~ +└── index.ts ~ +src/.pi/__tests__/ +└── graph-tools.test.ts ~ +src/graph/ +├── command-executor.ts ~ +├── command-executor.test.ts ~ +├── snapshot.ts ~ +├── snapshot.test.ts ~ +├── workspace-store.ts ~ +└── schema/ + └── nodes.ts ~ +src/agents/contexts/ +├── graph.ts ~ +├── graph.test.ts ~ +├── node.ts ~ +└── node.test.ts ~ +``` + +## Card 2 — Unify commitGraph planning for dry-run and commit + +Status: next + +### Target Behavior + +A single commit-graph batch planner produces every structural diagnostic used by both dry-run and commit execution. + +### Boundary Crossings + +```pseudo +CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph / CommandExecutor.commitGraph +→ private commit-graph batch planner +→ graph structural validators + selected-spec reference checks +→ transaction writer +``` + +### Risks and Assumptions + +- RISK: supersession acyclicity currently depends on resolved endpoints after insertion setup. + → MITIGATION: plan against temporary batch endpoint keys plus existing NodeIds before writing; commit maps the already-planned batch refs to inserted rows. +- RISK: this cleanup could become a broad executor rewrite. + → MITIGATION: split only commitGraph batch planning/validation behind the existing `CommandExecutor` public method; leave unrelated spec/recon-need commands alone. +- ASSUMPTION: dry-run and commit should be structurally identical except for persistence. + → IMPACT IF FALSE: review-set proposals can pass dry-run and fail on approval, breaking D27-L/D53-L. + → VALIDATE: paired dry-run/commit differential tests for every current structural-illegal family. + +### Posture check + +This is an invariant tracer: it closes the dry-run/commit gap before FE-809 review-cycle work depends on dry-run as a product gate. + +### Acceptance Criteria + +```pseudo +✓ dry-run/commit parity tests — invalid basis, missing existing code/id, invalid category/stance, self-loop, and detail-shape errors produce matching diagnostics +✓ dry-run/commit parity tests — existing, intra-batch, and mixed supersession cycles are rejected by dry-run before any write path runs +✓ transaction tests — failed commitGraph batches do not persist nodes, edges, change-log rows, or counter rows +✓ topology/file-size check — commitGraph batch planning lives in a private `src/graph/command-executor/*` module imported only by the public command-executor entrypoint +✓ file-size check — `src/graph/command-executor.test.ts` no longer carries the full commitGraph matrix past the 1000-line threshold +``` + +### Verification Approach + +- Inner: unit/differential tests over the batch planner and public `CommandExecutor` methods. +- Middle: review-set dry-run tests keep using the public `dryRunCommitGraph` path. + +### Cross-cutting obligations + +- Preserve `CommandExecutor` as the public mutation boundary; the new planner is private implementation. +- Do not add a standalone authority service or second write path. +- Keep the split semantic, not file-shape theatre: extract commitGraph batch planning only. + +### Expected touched paths (tentative) + +```pseudo +src/graph/ +├── command-executor.ts ~ +├── command-executor.test.ts ~ +└── command-executor/ + ├── commit-graph-batch.ts + + └── commit-graph-batch.test.ts + +src/.pi/__tests__/ +└── review-set-proposal.test.ts ~ +src/.pi/extensions/graph/ +└── review-set-proposal.ts ? +src/graph/README.md ~ +``` + +## Card 3 — Existing-code product-path probe + +Status: next + +### Target Behavior + +The default Brunch runtime commits graph truth by referencing a selected-spec existing node through its projected code. + +### Boundary Crossings + +```pseudo +probe runner +→ fresh workspace/spec/session setup with seeded graph node +→ default Brunch agent session runtime factory +→ real read_graph / commit_graph Pi tools +→ CommandExecutor +→ graph overview + transcript/report artifacts +``` + +### Risks and Assumptions + +- RISK: the probe could seed the graph through a helper and then inspect private state, proving less than the product path. + → MITIGATION: seeding may use `CommandExecutor`, but the agent action under test must use the default runtime factory and real Pi tools; final assertions read public graph snapshots/report artifacts. +- RISK: the model may still copy a raw diagnostic id if any prompt surface leaks one. + → MITIGATION: report transcript handle usage and treat raw-id reliance as friction or failure. +- ASSUMPTION: the existing `propose-graph-commit` proof runner can be extended with named scenarios rather than replaced. + → IMPACT IF FALSE: create a small sibling runner under `src/probes/`, but keep artifact shape identical. + → VALIDATE: test the scenario summary/report without a live model run first. + +### Posture check + +This is proof of life plus invariant evidence: it proves D62-L in the real tool loop and selected-spec ownership at the boundary A14-L depends on. + +### Acceptance Criteria + +```pseudo +✓ probe summary tests — a named `existing-code-ref` scenario reports attempts, retry count, diagnostics, final graph counts/LSN, committed code/title summary, and friction +✓ product-path probe artifact — `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit//report.json` records success for the existing-code scenario or names the specific gap +✓ transcript/report assertions — the agent saw and used projected codes as primary handles +✓ graph assertion — final graph includes the expected edge to the pre-existing selected-spec node and no writes to another spec +``` + +### Verification Approach + +- Inner: probe report parser/summary tests — prove scenario-specific report fields. +- Middle/Outer: real model probe run through `createBrunchAgentSessionRuntimeFactory`; fixture artifacts are committed under `.fixtures/runs/`. + +### Cross-cutting obligations + +- No probe-only tool registration or runtime wiring. +- Preserve the existing artifact envelope (`session.jsonl`, `transcript.md`, `report.json`). +- Treat model friction as evidence, not hidden test setup. + +### Expected touched paths (tentative) + +```pseudo +src/probes/ +├── propose-graph-commit-proof.ts ~ +└── propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts ~ +.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/ +└── / + +``` + +## Card 4 — Retry-diagnostics product-path probe + +Status: next + +### Target Behavior + +The default Brunch runtime records a structural-illegal first commit attempt followed by a corrected retry outcome. + +### Boundary Crossings + +```pseudo +probe scenario prompt +→ default Brunch agent session runtime factory +→ real commit_graph structural_illegal result +→ retry prompt/tool guidance +→ corrected commit_graph attempt or named failure report +``` + +### Risks and Assumptions + +- RISK: forcing the first attempt to be illegal may overfit the prompt rather than test diagnostics quality. + → MITIGATION: use a representative illegal category/stance/detail mistake from the tool contract and report whether correction came from diagnostics. +- RISK: a model may refuse to make an illegal first attempt. + → MITIGATION: success can be either corrected retry evidence or an explicit report that the scenario did not induce a retry; do not fake the retry by direct tool injection. +- ASSUMPTION: bounded retry remains the right proof shape for A14-L diagnostics. + → IMPACT IF FALSE: FE-808 cannot claim diagnostic/retry resilience and should report the gap before FE-809 depends on it. + → VALIDATE: attempt report includes first/final status and diagnostic text. + +### Posture check + +This is uncertainty-retirement evidence for A14-L: it tests whether `structural_illegal` diagnostics are actionable through the real agent loop. + +### Acceptance Criteria + +```pseudo +✓ probe summary tests — `retry-diagnostics` classifies firstAttemptStatus, finalStatus, retryCount, and diagnostics seen +✓ product-path probe artifact — report records at least one `structural_illegal` attempt and either a later success or an explicit diagnostic gap +✓ transcript assertion — retry prompt/tool guidance is visible in the Pi JSONL-derived transcript +✓ graph assertion — no partial graph state from the failed attempt is present +``` + +### Verification Approach + +- Inner: probe attempt-classification tests. +- Middle/Outer: real model probe run through the default runtime factory with committed artifacts. + +### Cross-cutting obligations + +- Do not lower structural validation just to make retry easier. +- Do not bypass the tool result path when collecting diagnostics. + +### Expected touched paths (tentative) + +```pseudo +src/probes/ +├── propose-graph-commit-proof.ts ~ +└── propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts ~ +.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/ +└── / + +``` + +## Card 5 — Ambiguity no-overcommit product-path probe + +Status: next + +### Target Behavior + +The default Brunch runtime records an ambiguous graph prompt without committing unsupported graph truth. + +### Boundary Crossings + +```pseudo +ambiguous probe prompt +→ default Brunch agent session runtime factory +→ agent strategy/tool guidance +→ transcript outcome +→ graph overview/report artifact +``` + +### Risks and Assumptions + +- RISK: no-overcommit is harder to assert than a successful commit. + → MITIGATION: define the oracle narrowly: zero commit_graph success when the prompt withholds enough facts, or a transcript-visible clarification/no-op diagnostic that explains why no graph truth was written. +- RISK: the model may commit plausible but unsupported nodes. + → MITIGATION: report overcommit as failure/friction; do not tune the prompt until the behavior disappears without naming the attempt. +- ASSUMPTION: the current `propose-graph` strategy guidance is specific enough to avoid overcommitment when evidence is missing. + → IMPACT IF FALSE: FE-808 should close with a named strategy-guidance gap rather than claiming broad graph-tool resilience. + → VALIDATE: final graph counts/LSN plus transcript classification. + +### Posture check + +This is an uncertainty tracer for A14-L's “ambiguity/no-overcommit” subclaim; it prevents the frontier from proving only happy-path persistence. + +### Acceptance Criteria + +```pseudo +✓ probe summary tests — `ambiguity-no-overcommit` classifies no-op/clarification, overcommit, and unexpected tool-use outcomes +✓ product-path probe artifact — report records final graph counts/LSN and friction for the ambiguity scenario +✓ transcript assertion — the agent either asks for clarification or explains why it cannot commit graph truth yet +✓ graph assertion — no successful commit_graph writes unsupported graph items for the ambiguous prompt +``` + +### Verification Approach + +- Inner: transcript/report classifier tests. +- Middle/Outer: real model probe run through the default runtime factory with committed artifacts. + +### Cross-cutting obligations + +- Preserve offer-first/elicitation-first posture; no ambient free-chat workaround. +- Record fitness honestly if the model overcommits. +- Do not broaden into generative/adversarial probe infrastructure. + +### Expected touched paths (tentative) + +```pseudo +src/probes/ +├── propose-graph-commit-proof.ts ~ +└── propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts ~ +.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/ +└── / + +``` diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts index 540d82a19..37028bfe0 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts @@ -7,13 +7,14 @@ * SPEC: D4-L, D20-L, D52-L, D53-L, I26-L, I34-L, A14-L */ +import { Value } from 'typebox/value'; import { describe, beforeEach, it, expect } from 'vitest'; import { createDb } from '../../db/connection.js'; import type { BrunchDb } from '../../db/connection.js'; -import { specs } from '../../db/schema.js'; +import { edges, specs } from '../../db/schema.js'; import { CommandExecutor } from '../../graph/command-executor.js'; -import { getGraphOverview, getNodeNeighborhood } from '../../graph/snapshot.js'; +import { getGraphOverview, getNodeNeighborhood, resolveGraphNodeCode } from '../../graph/snapshot.js'; import { createProductUpdatePublisher } from '../../rpc/product-updates.js'; import { translateCommitGraph, @@ -22,24 +23,34 @@ import { formatNeighborhoodResult, } from '../extensions/graph/command-adapter.js'; import { registerBrunchGraph, type GraphSnapshotReaders } from '../extensions/graph/index.js'; +import { CommitGraphParams, ReadGraphParams } from '../extensions/graph/tool-schemas.js'; // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- // Helpers // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- +let nextSpecSlug = 0; function createTestDb(): BrunchDb { return createDb(':memory:'); } - function seedSpec(db: BrunchDb): number { - db.insert(specs).values({ name: 'Test Spec', slug: 'test', readiness_grade: 'grounding_onboarding' }).run(); - return db.select({ id: specs.id }).from(specs).get()!.id; + const row = db + .insert(specs) + .values({ + name: 'Test Spec', + slug: `test-${nextSpecSlug++}`, + readiness_grade: 'grounding_onboarding', + }) + .returning({ id: specs.id }) + .get(); + return row!.id; } function createSnapshots(db: BrunchDb, specId: number): GraphSnapshotReaders { return { getGraphOverview: () => getGraphOverview(db, specId), getNodeNeighborhood: (nodeId, options) => getNodeNeighborhood(db, specId, nodeId, options), + resolveNodeCode: (code) => resolveGraphNodeCode(db, specId, code), }; } @@ -48,7 +59,7 @@ function createSnapshots(db: BrunchDb, specId: number): GraphSnapshotReaders { // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { - it('translates flat tool params into CommitGraphInput', () => { + it('resolves existing projected codes before handing edges to CommandExecutor', () => { const input = translateCommitGraph( { nodes: [ @@ -65,13 +76,14 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { { category: 'dependency', source: 'n2', target: 'n1' }, { category: 'support', - source: { existing: 42 }, + source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1', stance: 'for', }, ], }, 7, + (code) => (code === 'G1' ? 42 : undefined), ); expect(input.specId).toBe(7); @@ -83,15 +95,50 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { expect(input.basis).toBe('implicit'); expect(input.nodes[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); expect(input.edges[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); - expect( + }); + it('fails loudly when projected codes are malformed or absent from the selected spec', () => { + expect(() => + translateCommitGraph( + { + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Test goal' }], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existingCode: 'bad' }, target: 'n1' }], + }, + 7, + () => undefined, + ), + ).toThrow('Malformed graph node code "bad"'); + + expect(() => translateCommitGraph( { - nodes: [], - edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: { existing: 42 } }], + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Test goal' }], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existingCode: 'G99' }, target: 'n1' }], }, 7, - ).edges[0]!.source, - ).toEqual({ existingCode: 'G1' }); + () => undefined, + ), + ).toThrow('Graph node code "G99" does not resolve in the selected spec'); + }); +}); + +describe('graph tool schemas', () => { + it('accepts existing-node projected codes but not raw existing node ids', () => { + const valid = { + nodes: [], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1' }], + }; + const rawId = { + nodes: [], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existing: 1 }, target: 'n1' }], + }; + + expect(Value.Check(CommitGraphParams, valid)).toBe(true); + expect(Value.Check(CommitGraphParams, rawId)).toBe(false); + }); + + it('accepts projected node codes for read_graph neighborhood mode instead of node_id', () => { + expect(Value.Check(ReadGraphParams, { mode: 'neighborhood', nodeCode: 'G1' })).toBe(true); + expect(Value.Check(ReadGraphParams, { mode: 'neighborhood', node_id: 1 })).toBe(false); }); }); @@ -100,17 +147,19 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- describe('formatCommitGraphResult', () => { - it('formats success with node refs and edge ids', () => { + it('formats success with node refs, projected node codes, and edge ids', () => { const text = formatCommitGraphResult({ status: 'success', lsn: 5, nodes: { n1: 1, n2: 2 }, + nodeCodes: { n1: 'G1', n2: 'R1' }, edges: [10, 11], }); expect(text).toContain('Graph committed successfully'); expect(text).toContain('LSN 5'); - expect(text).toContain('n1 → #1'); + expect(text).toContain('n1 → G1'); + expect(text).not.toContain('n1 → #1'); expect(text).toContain('#10'); }); @@ -220,6 +269,86 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { ]); }); + it('commit_graph resolves selected-spec projected codes through the tool adapter', async () => { + const existing = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); + expect(existing.status).toBe('success'); + if (existing.status !== 'success') return; + + const tools = new Map }>(); + registerBrunchGraph( + { + registerTool(tool: { name: string; execute(toolCallId: string, params: unknown): Promise }) { + tools.set(tool.name, tool); + }, + } as never, + { specId, commandExecutor: executor, snapshots }, + ); + + const result = (await tools.get('commit_graph')!.execute('commit-1', { + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], + edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1' }], + })) as { + content: Array<{ type: 'text'; text: string }>; + details: unknown; + }; + + expect(result.content[0]?.text).toContain('n1 → R1'); + expect(result.content[0]?.text).not.toContain('n1 → #'); + expect(result.details).toMatchObject({ status: 'success', nodeCodes: { n1: 'R1' } }); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!.source_id).toBe(existing.nodeId); + }); + + it('commit_graph rejects projected codes that belong to another selected spec', async () => { + const otherSpecId = seedSpec(db); + const otherExecutor = new CommandExecutor(db); + const other = otherExecutor.createNode({ + specId: otherSpecId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Other spec goal', + }); + expect(other.status).toBe('success'); + + const tools = new Map }>(); + registerBrunchGraph( + { + registerTool(tool: { name: string; execute(toolCallId: string, params: unknown): Promise }) { + tools.set(tool.name, tool); + }, + } as never, + { specId, commandExecutor: executor, snapshots }, + ); + + await expect( + tools.get('commit_graph')!.execute('commit-1', { + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], + edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1' }], + }), + ).rejects.toThrow('Graph node code "G1" does not resolve in the selected spec'); + }); + + it('graph tool prompt guidance names projected codes rather than raw node ids', () => { + const registered: Array<{ name: string; description?: string; promptGuidelines?: readonly string[] }> = + []; + registerBrunchGraph( + { + registerTool(tool: { name: string; description?: string; promptGuidelines?: readonly string[] }) { + registered.push(tool); + }, + } as never, + { specId, commandExecutor: executor, snapshots }, + ); + + const text = registered + .flatMap((tool) => [tool.description ?? '', ...(tool.promptGuidelines ?? [])]) + .join('\n'); + + expect(text).toContain('existingCode'); + expect(text).toContain('nodeCode'); + expect(text).not.toContain('{existing: }'); + expect(text).not.toContain('node_id'); + }); + it('commit_graph returns diagnostics on invalid batch', () => { const input = translateCommitGraph( { @@ -313,7 +442,7 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { const result = (await tools.get('read_graph')!.execute('read-1', { mode: 'neighborhood', - node_id: commitResult.nodes['n1'], + nodeCode: 'G1', })) as { content: Array<{ type: 'text'; text: string }>; details: unknown; diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts index ee6bee046..24ba76fd2 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts @@ -106,6 +106,7 @@ const promptContext = { ], }), getNodeNeighborhood: () => ({ status: 'not_found' as const }), + resolveNodeCode: () => undefined, }, }; @@ -243,6 +244,7 @@ describe('Brunch prompt-pack topology', () => { edges: [], }), getNodeNeighborhood: () => ({ status: 'not_found' as const }), + resolveNodeCode: () => undefined, }, }), }, diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts index 9f2067dca..44d9d2aca 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts @@ -18,10 +18,12 @@ import type { CommitGraphSuccess, StructuralIllegal, } from '../../../graph/command-executor.js'; -import { formatGraphNodeCode } from '../../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; +import { formatGraphNodeCode, parseGraphNodeCode } from '../../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; import type { GraphOverview, NeighborhoodResult } from '../../../graph/snapshot.js'; import type { ToolCommitGraphParams } from './tool-schemas.js'; +export type ResolveGraphNodeCode = (code: string) => number | undefined; + /** * Translate Pi tool params into a CommandExecutor CommitGraphInput. * @@ -30,7 +32,11 @@ import type { ToolCommitGraphParams } from './tool-schemas.js'; * so the agent-facing tool schema never asks the LLM for a workspace-global * graph target (D61-L). */ -export function translateCommitGraph(params: ToolCommitGraphParams, specId: number): CommitGraphInput { +export function translateCommitGraph( + params: ToolCommitGraphParams, + specId: number, + resolveGraphNodeCode: ResolveGraphNodeCode = () => undefined, +): CommitGraphInput { const nodes: BatchNodeInput[] = params.nodes.map((n) => ({ ref: n.ref, plane: n.plane as BatchNodeInput['plane'], @@ -43,8 +49,8 @@ export function translateCommitGraph(params: ToolCommitGraphParams, specId: numb const edges: BatchEdgeInput[] = params.edges.map((e) => ({ category: e.category, - source: resolveEdgeRef(e.source), - target: resolveEdgeRef(e.target), + source: resolveEdgeRef(e.source, resolveGraphNodeCode), + target: resolveEdgeRef(e.target, resolveGraphNodeCode), stance: e.stance, rationale: e.rationale, })); @@ -53,11 +59,18 @@ export function translateCommitGraph(params: ToolCommitGraphParams, specId: numb } function resolveEdgeRef( - ref: string | { readonly existing: number } | { readonly existingCode: string }, + ref: string | { readonly existingCode: string }, + resolveGraphNodeCode: ResolveGraphNodeCode, ): BatchEdgeRef { if (typeof ref === 'string') return ref; - if ('existingCode' in ref) return { existingCode: ref.existingCode }; - return { existing: ref.existing }; + if (!parseGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode)) { + throw new Error(`Malformed graph node code "${ref.existingCode}"`); + } + const nodeId = resolveGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode); + if (nodeId === undefined) { + throw new Error(`Graph node code "${ref.existingCode}" does not resolve in the selected spec`); + } + return { existing: nodeId }; } // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -82,7 +95,8 @@ function formatCommitSuccess(result: CommitGraphSuccess): string { const lines: string[] = [`Graph committed successfully (LSN ${result.lsn}).`]; if (nodeEntries.length > 0) { - lines.push(`Nodes created: ${nodeEntries.map(([ref, id]) => `${ref} → #${id}`).join(', ')}`); + const createdNodes = nodeEntries.map(([ref, id]) => `${ref} → ${result.nodeCodes?.[ref] ?? `#${id}`}`); + lines.push(`Nodes created: ${createdNodes.join(', ')}`); } if (result.edges.length > 0) { lines.push(`Edges created: ${result.edges.map((id) => `#${id}`).join(', ')}`); diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts index ac9ebd470..0a9a14380 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts @@ -27,6 +27,7 @@ import { CommitGraphParams, ReadGraphParams } from './tool-schemas.js'; export interface GraphSnapshotReaders { readonly getGraphOverview: () => GraphOverview; readonly getNodeNeighborhood: (nodeId: number, options?: { hops?: number }) => NeighborhoodResult; + readonly resolveNodeCode: (code: string) => number | undefined; } /** @@ -57,12 +58,12 @@ export function registerBrunchGraph(pi: ExtensionAPI, deps: BrunchGraphDeps): vo description: 'Atomically create a batch of nodes and edges in the specification graph. ' + "Each node gets a temporary batch ref (e.g. 'n1') that edges can reference. " + - 'Edges can also reference existing nodes by id via {existing: }. ' + + 'Edges can also reference existing nodes by projected code via {existingCode: "G1"}. ' + 'The entire batch succeeds or fails atomically.', promptSnippet: 'Atomically commit nodes and edges to the specification graph', promptGuidelines: [ 'Use commit_graph to persist specification elements (goals, requirements, decisions, etc.) after the user has accepted the concept.', - 'Each node must have a unique batch `ref` string. Edges reference nodes by their `ref` or by `{existing: }` for nodes already in the graph.', + 'Each node must have a unique batch `ref` string. Edges reference nodes by their `ref` or by `{existingCode: "G1"}` for nodes already in the selected spec.', 'If commit_graph returns STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL, read the diagnostics, fix the issues, and retry. Do not show intermediate failures to the user.', 'The `stance` field is required on `proof` and `support` edges, and invalid on all other categories.', 'Node kinds `decision` and `term` require a `detail` object; all other kinds must omit `detail`.', @@ -71,7 +72,7 @@ export function registerBrunchGraph(pi: ExtensionAPI, deps: BrunchGraphDeps): vo async execute(_toolCallId, params) { const specId = deps.specId; - const input = translateCommitGraph(params, specId); + const input = translateCommitGraph(params, specId, snapshots.resolveNodeCode); const result = commandExecutor.commitGraph(input); const text = formatCommitGraphResult(result); if (result.status === 'success') { @@ -92,11 +93,11 @@ export function registerBrunchGraph(pi: ExtensionAPI, deps: BrunchGraphDeps): vo description: 'Read the current specification graph. ' + "Use mode 'overview' for a full graph summary, or " + - "mode 'neighborhood' with a node_id to see a specific node and its neighbors.", + "mode 'neighborhood' with nodeCode to see a specific node and its neighbors.", promptSnippet: 'Read the specification graph (overview or node neighborhood)', promptGuidelines: [ "Use read_graph with mode 'overview' to see all nodes and edges before committing new graph elements.", - "Use read_graph with mode 'neighborhood' and a node_id to inspect a specific node and its connections.", + "Use read_graph with mode 'neighborhood' and a projected nodeCode such as G1 or CON2 to inspect a specific node and its connections.", ], parameters: ReadGraphParams, @@ -109,11 +110,15 @@ export function registerBrunchGraph(pi: ExtensionAPI, deps: BrunchGraphDeps): vo text = formatGraphOverview(overview); details = overview; } else { - if (params.node_id == null) { - throw new Error('node_id is required for neighborhood mode'); + if (params.nodeCode == null) { + throw new Error('nodeCode is required for neighborhood mode'); + } + const nodeId = snapshots.resolveNodeCode(params.nodeCode); + if (nodeId === undefined) { + throw new Error(`nodeCode ${params.nodeCode} does not resolve in the selected spec`); } const neighborhood = snapshots.getNodeNeighborhood( - params.node_id, + nodeId, params.hops != null ? { hops: params.hops } : undefined, ); text = renderNodeContext(neighborhood); diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts index f86005c37..32888a5d6 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts @@ -20,63 +20,78 @@ import { const ALL_KINDS = [...INTENT_KINDS, ...ORACLE_KINDS, ...DESIGN_KINDS, ...PLAN_KINDS] as const; -export const CommitNodeSchema = Type.Object({ - ref: Type.String({ - description: "Temporary batch reference id (e.g. 'n1', 'n2')", - }), - plane: StringEnum(['intent', 'oracle', 'design', 'plan'] as const), - kind: StringEnum([...ALL_KINDS]), - title: Type.String({ description: 'Node title — must be non-empty' }), - body: Type.Optional(Type.String({ description: 'Extended description' })), - source: Type.Optional( - Type.String({ - description: "Epistemic attribution (e.g. 'stakeholder', 'derived')", +export const CommitNodeSchema = Type.Object( + { + ref: Type.String({ + description: "Temporary batch reference id (e.g. 'n1', 'n2')", }), - ), - detail: Type.Optional( - Type.Unknown({ - description: - 'Per-kind detail: decision requires {chosen_option, rejected, rationale}; term requires {definition, aliases?}', - }), - ), -}); + plane: StringEnum(['intent', 'oracle', 'design', 'plan'] as const), + kind: StringEnum([...ALL_KINDS]), + title: Type.String({ description: 'Node title — must be non-empty' }), + body: Type.Optional(Type.String({ description: 'Extended description' })), + source: Type.Optional( + Type.String({ + description: "Epistemic attribution (e.g. 'stakeholder', 'derived')", + }), + ), + detail: Type.Optional( + Type.Unknown({ + description: + 'Per-kind detail: decision requires {chosen_option, rejected, rationale}; term requires {definition, aliases?}', + }), + ), + }, + { additionalProperties: false }, +); export const EdgeRefSchema = Type.Union([ Type.String({ description: "Intra-batch ref (e.g. 'n1')" }), - Type.Object({ - existing: Type.Number({ description: 'Id of an existing node' }), - }), - Type.Object({ - existingCode: Type.String({ description: 'Projected code of an existing node, e.g. G1 or CON2' }), - }), + Type.Object( + { + existingCode: Type.String({ + description: 'Projected code of an existing node in the selected spec, e.g. G1 or CON2', + }), + }, + { additionalProperties: false }, + ), ]); -export const CommitEdgeSchema = Type.Object({ - category: StringEnum([...EDGE_CATEGORIES]), - source: EdgeRefSchema, - target: EdgeRefSchema, - stance: Type.Optional(StringEnum([...EDGE_STANCES])), - rationale: Type.Optional(Type.String()), -}); +export const CommitEdgeSchema = Type.Object( + { + category: StringEnum([...EDGE_CATEGORIES]), + source: EdgeRefSchema, + target: EdgeRefSchema, + stance: Type.Optional(StringEnum([...EDGE_STANCES])), + rationale: Type.Optional(Type.String()), + }, + { additionalProperties: false }, +); -export const CommitGraphParams = Type.Object({ - nodes: Type.Array(CommitNodeSchema, { - description: 'Nodes to create in this batch', - }), - edges: Type.Array(CommitEdgeSchema, { - description: 'Edges to create, referencing batch refs or existing node codes', - }), -}); - -export const ReadGraphParams = Type.Object({ - mode: StringEnum(['overview', 'neighborhood'] as const), - node_id: Type.Optional( - Type.Number({ - description: 'Required for neighborhood mode — the anchor node id', +export const CommitGraphParams = Type.Object( + { + nodes: Type.Array(CommitNodeSchema, { + description: 'Nodes to create in this batch', }), - ), - hops: Type.Optional(Type.Number({ description: 'Neighborhood traversal depth (default: 1)' })), -}); + edges: Type.Array(CommitEdgeSchema, { + description: 'Edges to create, referencing batch refs or existing node codes', + }), + }, + { additionalProperties: false }, +); + +export const ReadGraphParams = Type.Object( + { + mode: StringEnum(['overview', 'neighborhood'] as const), + nodeCode: Type.Optional( + Type.String({ + description: + 'Required for neighborhood mode — projected code of the anchor node in the selected spec, e.g. G1 or CON2', + }), + ), + hops: Type.Optional(Type.Number({ description: 'Neighborhood traversal depth (default: 1)' })), + }, + { additionalProperties: false }, +); export type ToolCommitNode = Static; export type ToolCommitEdge = Static; diff --git a/src/brunch-tui.ts b/src/brunch-tui.ts index 8988b208d..2d0e76460 100644 --- a/src/brunch-tui.ts +++ b/src/brunch-tui.ts @@ -149,6 +149,7 @@ export function createBrunchAgentSessionRuntimeFactory({ getGraphOverview: () => graph.forSpec(currentWorkspace.spec.id).getGraphOverview(), getNodeNeighborhood: (nodeId: number, options?: { hops?: number }) => graph.forSpec(currentWorkspace.spec.id).getNodeNeighborhood(nodeId, options), + resolveNodeCode: (code: string) => graph.forSpec(currentWorkspace.spec.id).resolveNodeCode(code), }, ...(productUpdates ? { productUpdates } : {}), }; diff --git a/src/graph/README.md b/src/graph/README.md index 90cb77560..4021db20f 100644 --- a/src/graph/README.md +++ b/src/graph/README.md @@ -16,8 +16,8 @@ SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L, D54-L, D62-L rows. - **Readers / snapshot functions** (`snapshot.ts`) — graph projections at multiple detail levels: active-context and graph-truth overview, node - neighborhood, and open reconciliation needs. These return typed domain objects, - not Drizzle rows. + neighborhood, selected-spec graph-code lookup, and open reconciliation needs. + These return typed domain objects or internal ids, not Drizzle rows. - **Domain schema types** (`schema/`) — `GraphNode`, `GraphEdge`, `ReconciliationNeed`, kind/category types, per-kind node ordinals, and derived @@ -66,6 +66,7 @@ graph/ snapshot.ts getGraphOverview getNodeNeighborhood + resolveGraphNodeCode getOpenReconciliationNeeds row -> domain mapping @@ -138,7 +139,8 @@ seam. The desired shape is documented here so future splits preserve topology. - `kind_ordinal` is now the stored half of projected graph node codes. Keep rendered code strings out of graph tables; adapters and prompt renderers should - project them from `kind` + `kindOrdinal`. + project them from `kind` + `kindOrdinal`, then resolve existing-code handles + through selected-spec graph readers before calling `CommandExecutor`. - Keep spec scoping mandatory for stable `graph.*` RPC / multi-spec UI projections: graph rows and graph-adjacent reconciliation needs are spec-owned, and remaining graph read/write surfaces must preserve explicit diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts index 0ff707a1b..2c5708a86 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts @@ -608,19 +608,16 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.nodes['n1']); }); - it('resolves existing-node refs from projected codes within the selected spec', () => { - const existing = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); - if (existing.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - + it('returns projected node codes for created-node refs without accepting code refs at mutation boundary', () => { const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId, nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], - edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1' }], + edges: [], }); expect(result.status).toBe('success'); if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!.source_id).toBe(existing.nodeId); + expect(result.nodeCodes).toEqual({ n1: 'R1' }); }); it('returns nodes mapping and edges array in success result', () => { diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index 25bc0c144..401801af5 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ import { and, eq, inArray, sql } from 'drizzle-orm'; import type { BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; import * as schema from '../db/schema.js'; import type { EdgeCategory, EdgeStance } from './schema/edges.js'; -import { parseGraphNodeCode, type NodeBasis, type NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; +import { formatGraphNodeCode, type NodeBasis, type NodeKind, type NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; export type ReadinessGrade = (typeof schema.READINESS_GRADES)[number]; @@ -69,6 +69,7 @@ export interface CommitGraphSuccess { readonly status: 'success'; readonly lsn: number; readonly nodes: Readonly>; + readonly nodeCodes?: Readonly>; readonly edges: readonly number[]; } @@ -213,7 +214,7 @@ export interface ResolveReconNeedInput { // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- /** Reference to a node endpoint in a batch edge. */ -export type BatchEdgeRef = string | { readonly existing: number } | { readonly existingCode: string }; +export type BatchEdgeRef = string | { readonly existing: number }; /** A node to create inside a commitGraph batch. */ export interface BatchNodeInput { @@ -403,29 +404,12 @@ interface EdgeValidationResult { resolved?: ResolvedEdge; } -function resolveExistingRefId( - db: Pick, - ref: { readonly existing: number } | { readonly existingCode: string }, - specId: number, -): number | undefined { - if ('existing' in ref) return ref.existing; - const parsed = parseGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode); - if (!parsed) return undefined; - return db - .select({ id: schema.nodes.id }) - .from(schema.nodes) - .where( - and( - eq(schema.nodes.spec_id, specId), - eq(schema.nodes.kind, parsed.kind), - eq(schema.nodes.kind_ordinal, parsed.kindOrdinal), - ), - ) - .get()?.id; +function resolveExistingRefId(ref: { readonly existing: number }): number { + return ref.existing; } function resolveEndpointRef( - db: Pick, + _db: Pick, ref: BatchEdgeRef, specId: number, refMap: ReadonlyMap, @@ -442,11 +426,7 @@ function resolveEndpointRef( return id; } - const id = resolveExistingRefId(db, ref, specId); - if (id === undefined) { - diagnostics.push({ field, message: 'existing node reference not found' }); - return undefined; - } + const id = resolveExistingRefId(ref); if (crossSpecExisting.has(id)) { diagnostics.push({ field, @@ -459,14 +439,13 @@ function resolveEndpointRef( } function addExistingRefId( - db: Pick, + _db: Pick, ref: BatchEdgeRef, - specId: number, + _specId: number, refs: Set, ): void { if (typeof ref === 'string') return; - const id = resolveExistingRefId(db, ref, specId); - if (id !== undefined) refs.add(id); + refs.add(resolveExistingRefId(ref)); } function findSupersessionCycle( @@ -889,6 +868,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { // 3. Insert all nodes, build ref → id map const refMap = new Map(); + const nodeCodeMap = new Map(); for (const bn of input.nodes) { const kindOrdinal = this.allocateNodeKindOrdinal(tx, input.specId, bn.plane, bn.kind); const row = tx @@ -909,6 +889,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { .returning() .get(); refMap.set(bn.ref, row!.id); + nodeCodeMap.set(bn.ref, formatGraphNodeCode(row!.kind as NodeKind, row!.kind_ordinal)); } // 4. Collect and verify existing-node references — must be same spec @@ -1001,6 +982,7 @@ export class CommandExecutor { status: 'success' as const, lsn, nodes: Object.fromEntries(refMap), + nodeCodes: Object.fromEntries(nodeCodeMap), edges: edgeIds, }; }); diff --git a/src/graph/snapshot.ts b/src/graph/snapshot.ts index f667c560b..384065833 100644 --- a/src/graph/snapshot.ts +++ b/src/graph/snapshot.ts @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ import type { BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; import * as schema from '../db/schema.js'; import type { Lsn } from './atoms.js'; import type { GraphEdge } from './schema/edges.js'; -import type { GraphNode, NodeDetail } from './schema/nodes.js'; +import { parseGraphNodeCode, type GraphNode, type NodeDetail } from './schema/nodes.js'; import type { ReconciliationNeed, ReconciliationNeedTarget } from './schema/reconciliation-need.js'; // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -118,6 +118,22 @@ function getSupersededIds(db: BrunchDb, specId: number): Set { } // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- +export function resolveGraphNodeCode(db: BrunchDb, specId: number, code: string): number | undefined { + const parsed = parseGraphNodeCode(code); + if (!parsed) return undefined; + return db + .select({ id: schema.nodes.id }) + .from(schema.nodes) + .where( + and( + eq(schema.nodes.spec_id, specId), + eq(schema.nodes.kind, parsed.kind), + eq(schema.nodes.kind_ordinal, parsed.kindOrdinal), + ), + ) + .get()?.id; +} + // getGraphOverview // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- diff --git a/src/graph/workspace-store.ts b/src/graph/workspace-store.ts index 2a178bfd6..cf90d40c9 100644 --- a/src/graph/workspace-store.ts +++ b/src/graph/workspace-store.ts @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ import { join } from 'node:path'; import { createDb } from '../db/connection.js'; import { CommandExecutor } from './command-executor.js'; -import { getGraphOverview, getNodeNeighborhood } from './snapshot.js'; +import { getGraphOverview, getNodeNeighborhood, resolveGraphNodeCode } from './snapshot.js'; import type { GraphOverview, NeighborhoodOptions, NeighborhoodResult } from './snapshot.js'; const BRUNCH_DIR = '.brunch'; @@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ const DATA_DB_FILE = 'data.db'; export interface SpecScopedReaders { readonly getGraphOverview: () => GraphOverview; readonly getNodeNeighborhood: (nodeId: number, options?: NeighborhoodOptions) => NeighborhoodResult; + readonly resolveNodeCode: (code: string) => number | undefined; } export interface WorkspaceGraphRuntime { @@ -33,6 +34,7 @@ export async function openWorkspaceGraphRuntime(cwd: string): Promise getGraphOverview(db, specId), getNodeNeighborhood: (nodeId, options) => getNodeNeighborhood(db, specId, nodeId, options), + resolveNodeCode: (code) => resolveGraphNodeCode(db, specId, code), }; }, }; From 4c34a082ddaeb5a98a07d84bbd85660c6b93dc76 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:16:17 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 08/21] Stub projection and format topology for LLM context Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-019e92bc-e43a-727f-8acf-0213915029ff Co-authored-by: Amp --- memory/PLAN.md | 2 +- src/graph/format/commit-result.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ src/graph/format/overview.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ src/graph/format/reconciliation-needs.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ src/graph/project/commit-result.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ src/graph/project/overview.ts | 17 +++++++++++++++++ src/graph/project/reconciliation-needs.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ src/render/markdown.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ src/render/toon.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ src/session/format/transcript.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ src/session/project/transcript-context.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ src/session/session-transcript.ts | 4 +--- .../format/capture-answer.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/capture-candidate.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/capture-choice.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/capture-choices.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/capture-review.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/present-candidates.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/present-options.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/present-question.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/present-review-set.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/request-answer.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/request-choice.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/request-choices.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../format/request-review.ts | 11 +++++++++++ .../project/capture-answer.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ .../project/capture-candidate.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ .../project/capture-choice.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ .../project/capture-choices.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ .../project/capture-review.ts | 14 ++++++++++++++ .../project/present-candidates.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ .../project/present-options.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ .../project/present-question.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ .../project/present-review-set.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ .../project/request-answer.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ .../project/request-choice.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ .../project/request-choices.ts | 16 ++++++++++++++++ .../project/request-review.ts | 15 +++++++++++++++ 40 files changed, 523 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) create mode 100644 src/graph/format/commit-result.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/format/overview.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/format/reconciliation-needs.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/project/commit-result.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/project/overview.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/project/reconciliation-needs.ts create mode 100644 src/render/markdown.ts create mode 100644 src/render/toon.ts create mode 100644 src/session/format/transcript.ts create mode 100644 src/session/project/transcript-context.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/capture-answer.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/capture-candidate.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choice.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choices.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/capture-review.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/present-candidates.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/present-options.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/present-review-set.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/request-answer.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/request-choice.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/request-choices.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/format/request-review.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/capture-answer.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/capture-candidate.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choice.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choices.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/capture-review.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/present-candidates.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/present-options.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/present-review-set.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/request-answer.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/request-choice.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/request-choices.ts create mode 100644 src/structured-exchange/project/request-review.ts diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index a005b113a..b36634401 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -133,7 +133,7 @@ _None._ - **Cross-cutting obligations:** Avoid harness-as-false-proof: the probe must exercise the same default Brunch runtime factory and registered tools that the product uses. Record fitness, not just pass/fail. Preserve D62-L/D63-L/D64-L as graph-wide contracts rather than adapter-local conveniences. - **Traceability:** D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D53-L, D60-L, D62-L, D63-L, D64-L / I34-L, I35-L, I39-L, I40-L, I41-L / A14-L, A5-L. - **Design docs:** `docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md`; `docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`. -- **Current execution pointer:** Graph write contract materialization chain completed and removed from `memory/cards/`; remaining frontier work is direct product-path probe coverage for existing-code refs, retry diagnostics, and no-overcommit behavior. +- **Current execution pointer:** `memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md` scopes the cleanup and remaining product-path probe closure chain for FE-808. ### project-graph-review-cycle diff --git a/src/graph/format/commit-result.ts b/src/graph/format/commit-result.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..20f5f20f3 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/format/commit-result.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Formats projected commit_graph mutation results into model-facing text. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from graph/project/commit-result.ts + * + * Output: + * - markdown summary for success or structural diagnostics + * + * Replaces/adapts: + * - .pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts commit result formatting + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts b/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..54f39d681 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +/** + * Formats projected node neighborhood snapshots into model-facing text. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from graph/project/neighborhood.ts + * + * Output: + * - markdown-framed TOON or equivalent compact text for LLM consumption + * + * Replaces/adapts: + * - agents/contexts/node.ts + * - .pi/extensions/graph/index.ts neighborhood result formatting + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/graph/format/overview.ts b/src/graph/format/overview.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bb1ba990e --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/format/overview.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +/** + * Formats projected graph overview snapshots into model-facing text. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from graph/project/overview.ts + * + * Output: + * - markdown-framed TOON or equivalent compact text for LLM consumption + * + * Replaces/adapts: + * - agents/contexts/graph.ts + * - .pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts overview formatting + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/graph/format/reconciliation-needs.ts b/src/graph/format/reconciliation-needs.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d3833d6ff --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/format/reconciliation-needs.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +/** + * Formats projected reconciliation-need snapshots into model-facing text. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from graph/project/reconciliation-needs.ts + * + * Output: + * - markdown-framed TOON or equivalent compact text for LLM consumption + * + * Future users: + * - pushed prompt snapshots + * - future graph read surfaces covering reconciliation work + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/graph/project/commit-result.ts b/src/graph/project/commit-result.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b2f0c22bb --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/project/commit-result.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for commit_graph mutation results. + * + * Input: + * - CommitGraphResult from graph/command-executor.ts + * + * Output: + * - compact typed success/failure shape for model-facing formatting + * - created refs, diagnostic ordering, and omission policy + * + * Used by: + * - graph/format/commit-result.ts + * - .pi/extensions/graph/index.ts via commit_graph tool results + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts b/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2b529cf25 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for selected-spec node neighborhood snapshots. + * + * Input: + * - NeighborhoodResult from graph/snapshot.ts + * + * Output: + * - compact typed shape for anchor, neighbors, and connecting edges + * - omission counts, truncation policy, and not_found normalization + * + * Used by: + * - graph/format/neighborhood.ts + * - .pi/extensions/graph/index.ts via read_graph neighborhood results + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/graph/project/overview.ts b/src/graph/project/overview.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5db3c6d92 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/project/overview.ts @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for selected-spec graph overview snapshots. + * + * Input: + * - GraphOverview from graph/snapshot.ts + * + * Output: + * - compact typed shape for LLM-facing formatting + * - ordered nodes/edges, omission counts, and truncation policy decisions + * + * Used by: + * - graph/format/overview.ts + * - .pi/extensions/graph/index.ts via graph overview tool results + * - .pi/extensions/prompting.ts via pushed graph snapshot context + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/graph/project/reconciliation-needs.ts b/src/graph/project/reconciliation-needs.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9a9eae76f --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/project/reconciliation-needs.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for open reconciliation-need snapshots. + * + * Input: + * - ReconciliationNeed[] from graph/snapshot.ts + * + * Output: + * - compact typed shape grouped and ordered for LLM inspection + * - normalized target references and omission policy + * + * Future users: + * - graph/format/reconciliation-needs.ts + * - pushed prompt snapshots and/or future read tools + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/render/markdown.ts b/src/render/markdown.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e8d7d8cd0 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/render/markdown.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +/** + * Shared markdown formatting substrate for Brunch LLM-facing text. + * + * Owns: + * - thin wrapper helpers around md-pen + * - shared fenced-block and escaping conventions + * - no graph/session/exchange domain semantics + * + * Future callers: + * - graph/format/* + * - session/format/* + * - structured-exchange/format/* + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/render/toon.ts b/src/render/toon.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..639ff6bc5 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/render/toon.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Shared TOON formatting substrate for Brunch LLM-facing structured snapshots. + * + * Owns: + * - thin wrapper helpers around @toon-format/toon + * - shared encode options and fenced `toon` block conventions + * - no graph/session/exchange domain semantics + * + * Future callers: + * - graph/format/* + * - any later snapshot formatter that needs compact structured data + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/session/format/transcript.ts b/src/session/format/transcript.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..df84ad79b --- /dev/null +++ b/src/session/format/transcript.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Formats projected transcript context into probe transcript markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from session/project/transcript-context.ts + * + * Output: + * - transcript.md artifact aligned with Pi-derived LLM-visible content + * + * Replaces/adapts: + * - session/session-transcript.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts b/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dd5a6d2f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical session-to-transcript projection for Brunch probe artifacts. + * + * Input: + * - raw FileEntry[] / SessionEntry[] from Pi session JSONL + * + * Output: + * - Pi-derived active message context after buildSessionContext() and convertToLlm() + * - probe-specific filtering policy for which derived messages are worth rendering + * + * Used by: + * - session/format/transcript.ts + * - any future transcript artifact or transcript-equivalence probes + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/session/session-transcript.ts b/src/session/session-transcript.ts index 7f02d55fb..12e818d6d 100644 --- a/src/session/session-transcript.ts +++ b/src/session/session-transcript.ts @@ -109,9 +109,7 @@ function renderTextBlocks(content: Array 0 ? interleaveBlankLines(rendered) : []; } -function isTextContent( - block: TextContent | ImageContent | ThinkingContent | ToolCall, -): block is TextContent { +function isTextContent(block: TextContent | ImageContent | ThinkingContent | ToolCall): block is TextContent { return block.type === 'text'; } diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-answer.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-answer.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..790178238 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-answer.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `capture_answer` analysis into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/capture-answer.ts + * + * Output: + * - capture-side markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-candidate.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-candidate.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8ebaad476 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-candidate.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `capture_candidate` analysis into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/capture-candidate.ts + * + * Output: + * - capture-side markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choice.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choice.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f073493c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choice.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `capture_choice` analysis into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/capture-choice.ts + * + * Output: + * - capture-side markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choices.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choices.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..aaf55ed59 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-choices.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `capture_choices` analysis into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/capture-choices.ts + * + * Output: + * - capture-side markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-review.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-review.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..957c50396 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/capture-review.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `capture_review` analysis into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/capture-review.ts + * + * Output: + * - capture-side markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-candidates.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-candidates.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..659cdc537 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-candidates.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `present_candidates` data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/present-candidates.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable candidate-comparison markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-options.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-options.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..65ebcb3a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-options.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `present_options` data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/present-options.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable prompt-side markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a7e8d3a21 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `present_question` data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable prompt-side markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-review-set.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-review-set.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e2fcd98a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-review-set.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `present_review_set` data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/present-review-set.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable review-set markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/request-answer.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-answer.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f6541fdc8 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-answer.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `request_answer` response data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/request-answer.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable response markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/request-choice.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-choice.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9d42a4f75 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-choice.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `request_choice` response data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/request-choice.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable response markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/request-choices.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-choices.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..856a27097 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-choices.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `request_choices` response data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/request-choices.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable response markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/request-review.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-review.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bcd3c32b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/request-review.ts @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +/** + * Formats projected `request_review` response data into durable markdown. + * + * Input: + * - projected output from structured-exchange/project/request-review.ts + * + * Output: + * - durable response markdown for toolResult.content + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-answer.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-answer.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1e7984659 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-answer.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `capture_answer` analysis content. + * + * Input: + * - capture-answer details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized captured semantic summary + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/capture-answer.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-candidate.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-candidate.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f477c6225 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-candidate.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `capture_candidate` analysis content. + * + * Input: + * - capture-candidate details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized captured semantic summary + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/capture-candidate.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choice.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choice.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..055575b64 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choice.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `capture_choice` analysis content. + * + * Input: + * - capture-choice details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized captured semantic summary + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/capture-choice.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choices.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choices.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5efc55867 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-choices.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `capture_choices` analysis content. + * + * Input: + * - capture-choices details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized captured semantic summary + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/capture-choices.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-review.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-review.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..129459928 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/capture-review.ts @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `capture_review` analysis content. + * + * Input: + * - capture-review details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized captured semantic summary + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/capture-review.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/present-candidates.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-candidates.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4bcbde38b --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-candidates.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `present_candidates` content. + * + * Input: + * - candidate-presentation details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized candidate comparison projection, recommendation cues, and rubric traces + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/present-candidates.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-candidates.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/present-options.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-options.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b4e92bc1e --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-options.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `present_options` content. + * + * Input: + * - StructuredExchangePresentDetails or equivalent domain prompt state + * + * Output: + * - normalized heading/body/options/rationale projection + * + * Used by: + * - structured-exchange/format/present-options.ts + * - session/structured-exchange-loop.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-options.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9d8e4755f --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `present_question` content. + * + * Input: + * - StructuredExchangePresentDetails or equivalent domain prompt state + * + * Output: + * - normalized heading/body projection for durable prompt-side content + * + * Used by: + * - structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts + * - session/structured-exchange-loop.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/present-review-set.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-review-set.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c7f282ad0 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-review-set.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `present_review_set` content. + * + * Input: + * - review-set presentation details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized reviewable artifact projection + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/present-review-set.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-review-set.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/request-answer.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-answer.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ecfa2064a --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-answer.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `request_answer` responses. + * + * Input: + * - StructuredExchangeRequestDetails for answered/cancelled/unavailable cases + * + * Output: + * - normalized answer/comment/status projection for durable response content + * + * Used by: + * - structured-exchange/format/request-answer.ts + * - session/structured-exchange-loop.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/request-answer.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/request-choice.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-choice.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..61b98f75e --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-choice.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `request_choice` responses. + * + * Input: + * - StructuredExchangeRequestDetails for answered/cancelled/unavailable cases + * + * Output: + * - normalized selected-choice/comment/status projection + * + * Used by: + * - structured-exchange/format/request-choice.ts + * - session/structured-exchange-loop.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/request-choice.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/request-choices.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-choices.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dc4a59edb --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-choices.ts @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `request_choices` responses. + * + * Input: + * - StructuredExchangeRequestDetails for answered/cancelled/unavailable cases + * + * Output: + * - normalized multi-choice/comment/status projection + * + * Used by: + * - structured-exchange/format/request-choices.ts + * - session/structured-exchange-loop.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/request-choices.ts + */ + +export {}; diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/request-review.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-review.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fadc4d8eb --- /dev/null +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/request-review.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +/** + * Canonical projection for `request_review` responses. + * + * Input: + * - review-response details once the tool lands + * + * Output: + * - normalized review decision/comment/status projection + * + * Future users: + * - structured-exchange/format/request-review.ts + * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/request-review.ts + */ + +export {}; From 989e1c6a732071f0b9bf5f8133587e8abb8a0789 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:23:31 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 09/21] Thread representative LLM projection seams Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-019e92bc-e43a-727f-8acf-0213915029ff Co-authored-by: Amp --- src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts | 9 +- ...tructured-exchange-present-request.test.ts | 33 ++++++ src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts | 5 +- .../structured-exchange/present-question.ts | 28 ++--- src/agents/contexts/node.ts | 68 ++--------- src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts | 45 +++++++- src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts | 88 ++++++++++++++- src/render/markdown.ts | 24 +++- src/session/format/transcript.ts | 71 +++++++++++- src/session/project/transcript-context.ts | 49 +++++++- src/session/session-transcript.test.ts | 50 ++++++--- src/session/session-transcript.ts | 106 +----------------- .../format/present-question.ts | 8 +- .../project/present-question.ts | 46 +++++++- 14 files changed, 425 insertions(+), 205 deletions(-) diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts index 37028bfe0..7d40434d5 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts @@ -448,8 +448,13 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { details: unknown; }; - expect(result.content[0]?.text).toContain('[Selected-spec node context]'); - expect(result.content[0]?.text).toContain('Tool-visible goal'); + expect(result.content[0]?.text).toMatchInlineSnapshot(` + "[Selected-spec node context] + - anchor: [G1] intent/goal: Tool-visible goal + - anchor body: Selected body + - neighbors: none within requested hops + - edges: none" + `); expect(result.details).toMatchObject({ status: 'success', anchor: { title: 'Tool-visible goal' }, diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/structured-exchange-present-request.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/structured-exchange-present-request.test.ts index 550052f39..2c458b72f 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/structured-exchange-present-request.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/structured-exchange-present-request.test.ts @@ -75,6 +75,39 @@ describe('structured exchange present/request tools', () => { expect(tools.get(REQUEST_CHOICES_TOOL)?.executionMode).toBe('sequential'); }); + it('persists a present_question result through the shared project and format seam', async () => { + const present = registeredTools().get('present_question'); + if (!present) throw new Error('present_question was not registered'); + + const result = await present.execute( + 'present-question-call-1', + { + exchangeId: 'problem-frame', + heading: 'What problem are we solving?', + body: 'Keep the answer grounded in current Brunch session behavior.', + expectedRequestTool: 'request_answer', + }, + undefined, + undefined, + {} as never, + ); + + expect(result.content[0]?.text).toMatchInlineSnapshot(` + "## What problem are we solving? + + Keep the answer grounded in current Brunch session behavior." + `); + expect(isStructuredExchangePresentDetails(result.details)).toBe(true); + expect(result.details).toMatchObject({ + exchangeId: 'problem-frame', + presentTool: 'present_question', + kind: 'question', + status: 'presented', + expectedRequest: { tool: 'request_answer', required: true }, + createdAtToolCallId: 'present-question-call-1', + }); + }); + it('persists a present_options result as markdown content plus recoverable details', async () => { const present = registeredTools().get(PRESENT_OPTIONS_TOOL); if (!present) throw new Error('present_options was not registered'); diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts index 0a9a14380..5435a3c5a 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts @@ -12,7 +12,8 @@ import type { ExtensionAPI } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; -import { renderNodeContext } from '../../../agents/contexts/node.js'; +import { formatNeighborhood } from '../../../graph/format/neighborhood.js'; +import { projectNeighborhood } from '../../../graph/project/neighborhood.js'; import type { CommandExecutor } from '../../../graph/command-executor.js'; import type { GraphOverview, NeighborhoodResult } from '../../../graph/snapshot.js'; import { graphMutationProductUpdates, type ProductUpdatePublisher } from '../../../rpc/product-updates.js'; @@ -121,7 +122,7 @@ export function registerBrunchGraph(pi: ExtensionAPI, deps: BrunchGraphDeps): vo nodeId, params.hops != null ? { hops: params.hops } : undefined, ); - text = renderNodeContext(neighborhood); + text = formatNeighborhood(projectNeighborhood(neighborhood)); details = neighborhood; } diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts index fb992899a..e1acd55b7 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts @@ -2,7 +2,8 @@ import { defineTool } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; import { Type } from 'typebox'; import { renderMarkdownResult } from './shared/markdown.js'; -import { STRUCTURED_EXCHANGE_PRESENT_SCHEMA, type StructuredExchangePresentDetails } from './shared/model.js'; +import { formatPresentQuestion } from '../../../structured-exchange/format/present-question.js'; +import { projectPresentQuestion } from '../../../structured-exchange/project/present-question.js'; export const PRESENT_QUESTION_TOOL = 'present_question' as const; @@ -33,24 +34,17 @@ export const presentQuestionTool = defineTool({ executionMode: 'sequential', async execute(toolCallId, params) { - const body = params.body?.trim(); - const markdown = [`## ${params.heading.trim()}`, body ? `\n${body}` : undefined] - .filter(Boolean) - .join('\n'); - const details: StructuredExchangePresentDetails = { - schema: STRUCTURED_EXCHANGE_PRESENT_SCHEMA, - schemaVersion: 1, + const projection = projectPresentQuestion({ + toolCallId, exchangeId: params.exchangeId, - presentTool: PRESENT_QUESTION_TOOL, - kind: 'question', - status: 'presented', - expectedRequest: { - tool: params.expectedRequestTool ?? 'request_answer', - required: true, - }, - createdAtToolCallId: toolCallId, + heading: params.heading, + body: params.body, + expectedRequestTool: params.expectedRequestTool, + }); + return { + content: [{ type: 'text' as const, text: formatPresentQuestion(projection) }], + details: projection.details, }; - return { content: [{ type: 'text' as const, text: markdown }], details }; }, renderCall() { diff --git a/src/agents/contexts/node.ts b/src/agents/contexts/node.ts index 75df2c8f5..6caa1a6c7 100644 --- a/src/agents/contexts/node.ts +++ b/src/agents/contexts/node.ts @@ -1,4 +1,5 @@ -import { formatGraphNodeCode, type GraphNode } from '../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; +import { formatNeighborhood } from '../../graph/format/neighborhood.js'; +import { projectNeighborhood } from '../../graph/project/neighborhood.js'; import type { NeighborhoodResult } from '../../graph/snapshot.js'; export interface RenderNodeContextOptions { @@ -13,63 +14,10 @@ export function renderNodeContext( result: NeighborhoodResult, options: RenderNodeContextOptions = {}, ): string { - if (result.status === 'not_found') { - return '[Selected-spec node context]\n- node: not found in selected spec'; - } - - const maxNeighbors = options.maxNeighbors ?? DEFAULT_MAX_NEIGHBORS; - const maxEdges = options.maxEdges ?? DEFAULT_MAX_EDGES; - const nodesById = new Map([ - [result.anchor.id, result.anchor], - ...result.neighbors.map((node) => [node.id, node] as const), - ]); - const lines = [ - '[Selected-spec node context]', - `- anchor: [${formatGraphNodeCode(result.anchor.kind, result.anchor.kindOrdinal)}] ${result.anchor.plane}/${result.anchor.kind}: ${result.anchor.title}`, - ]; - - if (result.anchor.body) { - lines.push(`- anchor body: ${truncate(result.anchor.body, 180)}`); - } - - if (result.neighbors.length === 0) { - lines.push('- neighbors: none within requested hops'); - } else { - lines.push('- neighbors:'); - for (const neighbor of result.neighbors.slice(0, maxNeighbors)) { - lines.push( - ` - [${formatGraphNodeCode(neighbor.kind, neighbor.kindOrdinal)}] ${neighbor.plane}/${neighbor.kind}: ${neighbor.title}`, - ); - } - if (result.neighbors.length > maxNeighbors) { - lines.push(` - …${result.neighbors.length - maxNeighbors} more neighbor(s) omitted`); - } - } - - if (result.edges.length === 0) { - lines.push('- edges: none'); - } else { - lines.push('- edges:'); - for (const edge of result.edges.slice(0, maxEdges)) { - const stance = edge.stance ? `/${edge.stance}` : ''; - const rationale = edge.rationale ? ` — ${truncate(edge.rationale, 100)}` : ''; - const source = nodesById.get(edge.sourceId); - const target = nodesById.get(edge.targetId); - lines.push( - ` - #${edge.id}: ${formatEdgeEndpoint(edge.sourceId, source)} -[${edge.category}${stance}]-> ${formatEdgeEndpoint(edge.targetId, target)}${rationale}`, - ); - } - if (result.edges.length > maxEdges) { - lines.push(` - …${result.edges.length - maxEdges} more edge(s) omitted`); - } - } - - return lines.join('\n'); -} - -function formatEdgeEndpoint(id: number, node: GraphNode | undefined): string { - return node ? formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal) : `#${id}`; -} -function truncate(value: string, maxLength: number): string { - return value.length <= maxLength ? value : `${value.slice(0, maxLength - 1)}…`; + return formatNeighborhood( + projectNeighborhood(result, { + maxNeighbors: options.maxNeighbors ?? DEFAULT_MAX_NEIGHBORS, + maxEdges: options.maxEdges ?? DEFAULT_MAX_EDGES, + }), + ); } diff --git a/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts b/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts index 54f39d681..dc6552082 100644 --- a/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts +++ b/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts @@ -12,4 +12,47 @@ * - .pi/extensions/graph/index.ts neighborhood result formatting */ -export {}; +import { markdownBullet } from '../../render/markdown.js'; + +import type { ProjectedNeighborhood } from '../project/neighborhood.js'; + +export function formatNeighborhood(projection: ProjectedNeighborhood): string { + if (projection.status === 'not_found') { + return '[Selected-spec node context]\n- node: not found in selected spec'; + } + + const lines = [ + '[Selected-spec node context]', + markdownBullet(`anchor: [${projection.anchor.code}] ${projection.anchor.label}`), + ]; + + if (projection.anchor.body) { + lines.push(markdownBullet(`anchor body: ${projection.anchor.body}`)); + } + + if (projection.neighbors.items.length === 0) { + lines.push(markdownBullet('neighbors: none within requested hops')); + } else { + lines.push(markdownBullet('neighbors:')); + for (const neighbor of projection.neighbors.items) { + lines.push(` ${markdownBullet(neighbor)}`); + } + if (projection.neighbors.omittedCount > 0) { + lines.push(` ${markdownBullet(`…${projection.neighbors.omittedCount} more neighbor(s) omitted`)}`); + } + } + + if (projection.edges.items.length === 0) { + lines.push(markdownBullet('edges: none')); + } else { + lines.push(markdownBullet('edges:')); + for (const edge of projection.edges.items) { + lines.push(` ${markdownBullet(edge)}`); + } + if (projection.edges.omittedCount > 0) { + lines.push(` ${markdownBullet(`…${projection.edges.omittedCount} more edge(s) omitted`)}`); + } + } + + return lines.join('\n'); +} diff --git a/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts b/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts index 2b529cf25..0167c4765 100644 --- a/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts +++ b/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts @@ -13,4 +13,90 @@ * - .pi/extensions/graph/index.ts via read_graph neighborhood results */ -export {}; +import { formatGraphNodeCode } from '../schema/nodes.js'; +import type { GraphNode } from '../schema/nodes.js'; +import type { NeighborhoodResult } from '../snapshot.js'; + +export interface ProjectNeighborhoodOptions { + readonly maxNeighbors?: number; + readonly maxEdges?: number; +} + +export interface ProjectedNeighborhoodNotFound { + readonly status: 'not_found'; +} + +export interface ProjectedNeighborhoodSuccess { + readonly status: 'success'; + readonly anchor: { + readonly code: string; + readonly label: string; + readonly body?: string; + }; + readonly neighbors: { + readonly items: readonly string[]; + readonly omittedCount: number; + }; + readonly edges: { + readonly items: readonly string[]; + readonly omittedCount: number; + }; +} + +export type ProjectedNeighborhood = ProjectedNeighborhoodNotFound | ProjectedNeighborhoodSuccess; + +const DEFAULT_MAX_NEIGHBORS = 6; +const DEFAULT_MAX_EDGES = 8; + +export function projectNeighborhood( + result: NeighborhoodResult, + options: ProjectNeighborhoodOptions = {}, +): ProjectedNeighborhood { + if (result.status === 'not_found') { + return { status: 'not_found' }; + } + + const maxNeighbors = options.maxNeighbors ?? DEFAULT_MAX_NEIGHBORS; + const maxEdges = options.maxEdges ?? DEFAULT_MAX_EDGES; + const nodesById = new Map([ + [result.anchor.id, result.anchor], + ...result.neighbors.map((node) => [node.id, node] as const), + ]); + + return { + status: 'success', + anchor: { + code: formatGraphNodeCode(result.anchor.kind, result.anchor.kindOrdinal), + label: `${result.anchor.plane}/${result.anchor.kind}: ${result.anchor.title}`, + ...(result.anchor.body ? { body: truncate(result.anchor.body, 180) } : {}), + }, + neighbors: { + items: result.neighbors.slice(0, maxNeighbors).map((neighbor) => { + const code = formatGraphNodeCode(neighbor.kind, neighbor.kindOrdinal); + return `[${code}] ${neighbor.plane}/${neighbor.kind}: ${neighbor.title}`; + }), + omittedCount: Math.max(0, result.neighbors.length - maxNeighbors), + }, + edges: { + items: result.edges.slice(0, maxEdges).map((edge) => { + const stance = edge.stance ? `/${edge.stance}` : ''; + const rationale = edge.rationale ? ` — ${truncate(edge.rationale, 100)}` : ''; + const source = nodesById.get(edge.sourceId); + const target = nodesById.get(edge.targetId); + return `#${edge.id}: ${formatEdgeEndpoint(edge.sourceId, source)} -[${edge.category}${stance}]-> ${formatEdgeEndpoint(edge.targetId, target)}${rationale}`; + }), + omittedCount: Math.max(0, result.edges.length - maxEdges), + }, + }; +} + +function formatEdgeEndpoint( + id: number, + node: Pick | undefined, +): string { + return node ? formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal) : `#${id}`; +} + +function truncate(value: string, maxLength: number): string { + return value.length <= maxLength ? value : `${value.slice(0, maxLength - 1)}…`; +} diff --git a/src/render/markdown.ts b/src/render/markdown.ts index e8d7d8cd0..c6dabb079 100644 --- a/src/render/markdown.ts +++ b/src/render/markdown.ts @@ -12,4 +12,26 @@ * - structured-exchange/format/* */ -export {}; +export function markdownHeading(level: number, text: string): string { + return `${'#'.repeat(level)} ${text.trim()}`; +} + +export function markdownBullet(text: string): string { + return `- ${text}`; +} + +export function markdownQuote(text: string): string { + return text + .trim() + .split('\n') + .map((line) => `> ${line}`) + .join('\n'); +} + +export function joinMarkdownBlocks(...blocks: Array): string { + return blocks + .filter((block): block is string => typeof block === 'string') + .map((block) => block.trim()) + .filter((block) => block.length > 0) + .join('\n\n'); +} diff --git a/src/session/format/transcript.ts b/src/session/format/transcript.ts index df84ad79b..78d543e44 100644 --- a/src/session/format/transcript.ts +++ b/src/session/format/transcript.ts @@ -11,4 +11,73 @@ * - session/session-transcript.ts */ -export {}; +import type { + ImageContent, + Message, + TextContent, + ThinkingContent, + ToolCall, + ToolResultMessage, + UserMessage, +} from '@earendil-works/pi-ai'; + +import type { ProjectedTranscriptContext } from '../project/transcript-context.js'; + +export function formatTranscript( + context: ProjectedTranscriptContext, + options: { title?: string } = {}, +): string { + const lines: string[] = [`# Transcript${options.title ? ` — ${options.title}` : ''}`]; + + for (const [index, message] of context.messages.entries()) { + lines.push('', ...renderMessage(message, index + 1)); + } + + return `${lines.join('\n').trimEnd()}\n`; +} + +function renderMessage(message: Message, index: number): string[] { + switch (message.role) { + case 'user': + return [`## ${index}. User`, '', ...renderUserContent(message.content)]; + case 'assistant': + return [`## ${index}. Assistant`, '', ...renderTextBlocks(message.content)]; + case 'toolResult': + return [`## ${index}. Tool result: ${message.toolName}`, '', ...renderUserContent(message.content)]; + } +} + +function renderUserContent( + content: UserMessage['content'] | ToolResultMessage['content'], +): string[] { + if (typeof content === 'string') { + return renderTextBlock(content); + } + return renderTextBlocks(content); +} + +function renderTextBlocks(content: Array): string[] { + const rendered = content.flatMap((block) => { + if (block.type !== 'text') { + return []; + } + return renderTextBlock(block.text); + }); + return rendered.length > 0 ? interleaveBlankLines(rendered) : []; +} + +function renderTextBlock(text: string): string[] { + const trimmed = text.trim(); + return trimmed.length > 0 ? [trimmed] : ['_(empty)_']; +} + +function interleaveBlankLines(lines: string[]): string[] { + const output: string[] = []; + for (const line of lines) { + if (output.length > 0 && line !== '' && output.at(-1) !== '') { + output.push(''); + } + output.push(line); + } + return output; +} diff --git a/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts b/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts index dd5a6d2f0..ef03860dd 100644 --- a/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts +++ b/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts @@ -13,4 +13,51 @@ * - any future transcript artifact or transcript-equivalence probes */ -export {}; +import type { + ImageContent, + Message, + TextContent, + ThinkingContent, + ToolCall, +} from '@earendil-works/pi-ai'; +import type { FileEntry, SessionEntry } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; +import { buildSessionContext, convertToLlm } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; + +export interface ProjectedTranscriptContext { + readonly messages: readonly Message[]; +} + +export function projectTranscriptContext(entries: readonly FileEntry[]): ProjectedTranscriptContext { + const sessionEntries = entries.filter((entry): entry is SessionEntry => entry.type !== 'session'); + const messages = convertToLlm(buildSessionContext(sessionEntries).messages); + return { + messages: messages.filter((message) => renderMarkdown(message).length > 0), + }; +} + +function renderMarkdown(message: Message): string[] { + switch (message.role) { + case 'user': + return renderUserContent(message.content); + case 'assistant': + return renderTextBlocks(message.content); + case 'toolResult': + return renderUserContent(message.content); + } +} + +function renderUserContent(content: Message['content'] | Extract['content']): string[] { + if (typeof content === 'string') { + return renderTextBlock(content); + } + return renderTextBlocks(content); +} + +function renderTextBlocks(content: Array): string[] { + return content.flatMap((block) => (block.type === 'text' ? renderTextBlock(block.text) : [])); +} + +function renderTextBlock(text: string): string[] { + const trimmed = text.trim(); + return trimmed.length > 0 ? [trimmed] : ['_(empty)_']; +} diff --git a/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts b/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts index 3e0746793..3ac0538b4 100644 --- a/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts +++ b/src/session/session-transcript.test.ts @@ -138,21 +138,39 @@ describe('session transcript renderer', () => { title: 'session.jsonl', }); - expect(transcript).toContain('# Transcript — session.jsonl'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## 1. User'); - expect(transcript).toContain('hello custom'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## 2. Tool result: read'); - expect(transcript).toContain('Generic file contents'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## 3. Tool result: present_options'); - expect(transcript).toContain('**Rationale:** validates the seam.'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## 4. Tool result: request_choice'); - expect(transcript).toContain('Keep it deterministic.'); - expect(transcript).toContain('## 5. Assistant'); - expect(transcript).toContain('I will inspect the workspace.'); - expect(transcript).not.toContain('Session binding'); - expect(transcript).not.toContain('turn-1'); - expect(transcript).not.toContain('private chain of thought'); - expect(transcript).not.toContain('Tool call: read'); - expect(transcript).not.toContain('"path": "notes.txt"'); + expect(transcript).toMatchInlineSnapshot(` + "# Transcript — session.jsonl + + ## 1. User + + hello custom + + ## 2. Tool result: read + + Generic file contents + + ## 3. Tool result: present_options + + ## Which direction? + + ### 1. Fast + + **Rationale:** validates the seam. + + ## 4. Tool result: request_choice + + ### Response + + - Fast + + Comment: + + > Keep it deterministic. + + ## 5. Assistant + + I will inspect the workspace. + " + `); }); }); diff --git a/src/session/session-transcript.ts b/src/session/session-transcript.ts index 12e818d6d..204ed3b44 100644 --- a/src/session/session-transcript.ts +++ b/src/session/session-transcript.ts @@ -2,17 +2,10 @@ import { readFile } from 'node:fs/promises'; import { basename, resolve } from 'node:path'; import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'; -import type { - ImageContent, - Message, - TextContent, - ThinkingContent, - ToolCall, - ToolResultMessage, - UserMessage, -} from '@earendil-works/pi-ai'; -import type { FileEntry, SessionEntry } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; -import { buildSessionContext, convertToLlm } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; +import type { FileEntry } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; + +import { formatTranscript } from './format/transcript.js'; +import { projectTranscriptContext } from './project/transcript-context.js'; type TranscriptEntry = FileEntry; @@ -23,14 +16,7 @@ export async function renderSessionTranscriptFile(sessionFile: string): Promise< export function renderSessionTranscript(jsonl: string, options: { title?: string } = {}): string { const entries = parseJsonl(jsonl); - const messages = renderableMessages(llmMessages(entries)); - const lines: string[] = [`# Transcript${options.title ? ` — ${options.title}` : ''}`]; - - for (const [index, message] of messages.entries()) { - lines.push('', ...renderMessage(message, index + 1)); - } - - return `${lines.join('\n').trimEnd()}\n`; + return formatTranscript(projectTranscriptContext(entries), options); } function parseJsonl(jsonl: string): FileEntry[] { @@ -47,88 +33,6 @@ function parseJsonl(jsonl: string): FileEntry[] { }); } -function llmMessages(entries: TranscriptEntry[]): Message[] { - const sessionEntries = entries.filter((entry): entry is SessionEntry => entry.type !== 'session'); - return convertToLlm(buildSessionContext(sessionEntries).messages); -} - -function renderableMessages(messages: Message[]): Message[] { - return messages.filter((message) => renderMarkdown(message).length > 0); -} - -function renderMessage(message: Message, index: number): string[] { - switch (message.role) { - case 'user': - return renderUserMessage(message, index); - case 'assistant': - return renderAssistantMessage(message, index); - case 'toolResult': - return renderToolResult(message, index); - } -} - -function renderUserMessage(message: UserMessage, index: number): string[] { - return [`## ${index}. User`, '', ...renderUserContent(message.content)]; -} - -function renderAssistantMessage(message: Extract, index: number): string[] { - return [`## ${index}. Assistant`, '', ...renderMarkdown(message)]; -} - -function renderToolResult(message: ToolResultMessage, index: number): string[] { - return [`## ${index}. Tool result: ${message.toolName}`, '', ...renderMarkdown(message)]; -} - -function renderUserContent( - content: UserMessage['content'] | ToolResultMessage['content'], -): string[] { - if (typeof content === 'string') { - return renderTextBlock(content); - } - return renderTextBlocks(content); -} - -function renderMarkdown(message: Message): string[] { - switch (message.role) { - case 'user': - return renderUserContent(message.content); - case 'assistant': - return renderTextBlocks(message.content); - case 'toolResult': - return renderUserContent(message.content); - } -} - -function renderTextBlocks(content: Array): string[] { - const rendered = content.flatMap((block) => { - if (!isTextContent(block)) { - return []; - } - return renderTextBlock(block.text); - }); - return rendered.length > 0 ? interleaveBlankLines(rendered) : []; -} - -function isTextContent(block: TextContent | ImageContent | ThinkingContent | ToolCall): block is TextContent { - return block.type === 'text'; -} - -function renderTextBlock(text: string): string[] { - const trimmed = text.trim(); - return trimmed.length > 0 ? [trimmed] : ['_(empty)_']; -} - -function interleaveBlankLines(lines: string[]): string[] { - const output: string[] = []; - for (const line of lines) { - if (output.length > 0 && line !== '' && output.at(-1) !== '') { - output.push(''); - } - output.push(line); - } - return output; -} - async function main(): Promise { const [, , sessionFile] = process.argv; if (!sessionFile) { diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts index a7e8d3a21..9d1bda49c 100644 --- a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts @@ -8,4 +8,10 @@ * - durable prompt-side markdown for toolResult.content */ -export {}; +import { joinMarkdownBlocks, markdownHeading } from '../../render/markdown.js'; + +import type { PresentQuestionProjection } from '../project/present-question.js'; + +export function formatPresentQuestion(projection: PresentQuestionProjection): string { + return joinMarkdownBlocks(markdownHeading(2, projection.heading), projection.body); +} diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts index 9d8e4755f..345e8de26 100644 --- a/src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts +++ b/src/structured-exchange/project/present-question.ts @@ -13,4 +13,48 @@ * - .pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts */ -export {}; +import { + STRUCTURED_EXCHANGE_PRESENT_SCHEMA, + type StructuredExchangePresentDetails, +} from '../../.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/shared/model.js'; + +export interface PresentQuestionProjection { + readonly heading: string; + readonly body?: string; + readonly details: StructuredExchangePresentDetails; +} + +export interface ProjectPresentQuestionInput { + readonly toolCallId: string; + readonly exchangeId: string; + readonly heading: string; + readonly body?: string | undefined; + readonly expectedRequestTool?: 'request_answer' | undefined; +} + +export function projectPresentQuestion(input: ProjectPresentQuestionInput): PresentQuestionProjection { + const heading = input.heading.trim(); + const body = normalizeOptionalText(input.body); + return { + heading, + ...(body ? { body } : {}), + details: { + schema: STRUCTURED_EXCHANGE_PRESENT_SCHEMA, + schemaVersion: 1, + exchangeId: input.exchangeId, + presentTool: 'present_question', + kind: 'question', + status: 'presented', + expectedRequest: { + tool: input.expectedRequestTool ?? 'request_answer', + required: true, + }, + createdAtToolCallId: input.toolCallId, + }, + }; +} + +function normalizeOptionalText(value: string | undefined): string | undefined { + const trimmed = value?.trim(); + return trimmed ? trimmed : undefined; +} From fc03410c32c7257866d5e42b40cab226da85b554 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:34:34 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 10/21] Apply remaining context rendering cleanup Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-019e92bc-e43a-727f-8acf-0213915029ff Co-authored-by: Amp --- .../structured-exchange/present-question.ts | 2 +- src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts | 1 - src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts | 5 +---- src/session/project/transcript-context.ts | 12 ++++-------- src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts | 1 - 5 files changed, 6 insertions(+), 15 deletions(-) diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts index e1acd55b7..64b60e325 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/structured-exchange/present-question.ts @@ -1,9 +1,9 @@ import { defineTool } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; import { Type } from 'typebox'; -import { renderMarkdownResult } from './shared/markdown.js'; import { formatPresentQuestion } from '../../../structured-exchange/format/present-question.js'; import { projectPresentQuestion } from '../../../structured-exchange/project/present-question.js'; +import { renderMarkdownResult } from './shared/markdown.js'; export const PRESENT_QUESTION_TOOL = 'present_question' as const; diff --git a/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts b/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts index dc6552082..94d3300c6 100644 --- a/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts +++ b/src/graph/format/neighborhood.ts @@ -13,7 +13,6 @@ */ import { markdownBullet } from '../../render/markdown.js'; - import type { ProjectedNeighborhood } from '../project/neighborhood.js'; export function formatNeighborhood(projection: ProjectedNeighborhood): string { diff --git a/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts b/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts index 0167c4765..4f72899b3 100644 --- a/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts +++ b/src/graph/project/neighborhood.ts @@ -90,10 +90,7 @@ export function projectNeighborhood( }; } -function formatEdgeEndpoint( - id: number, - node: Pick | undefined, -): string { +function formatEdgeEndpoint(id: number, node: Pick | undefined): string { return node ? formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal) : `#${id}`; } diff --git a/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts b/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts index ef03860dd..52d6e9a99 100644 --- a/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts +++ b/src/session/project/transcript-context.ts @@ -13,13 +13,7 @@ * - any future transcript artifact or transcript-equivalence probes */ -import type { - ImageContent, - Message, - TextContent, - ThinkingContent, - ToolCall, -} from '@earendil-works/pi-ai'; +import type { ImageContent, Message, TextContent, ThinkingContent, ToolCall } from '@earendil-works/pi-ai'; import type { FileEntry, SessionEntry } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; import { buildSessionContext, convertToLlm } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; @@ -46,7 +40,9 @@ function renderMarkdown(message: Message): string[] { } } -function renderUserContent(content: Message['content'] | Extract['content']): string[] { +function renderUserContent( + content: Message['content'] | Extract['content'], +): string[] { if (typeof content === 'string') { return renderTextBlock(content); } diff --git a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts index 9d1bda49c..ea3d99346 100644 --- a/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts +++ b/src/structured-exchange/format/present-question.ts @@ -9,7 +9,6 @@ */ import { joinMarkdownBlocks, markdownHeading } from '../../render/markdown.js'; - import type { PresentQuestionProjection } from '../project/present-question.js'; export function formatPresentQuestion(projection: PresentQuestionProjection): string { From 0cdc8a488edd5ef01b7ab0c85202128f4708016a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:37:25 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 11/21] FE-808: Normalize graph tool outcomes --- memory/SPEC.md | 4 +- .../graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md | 62 +- src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts | 54 +- src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts | 32 +- src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts | 52 +- src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts | 22 +- src/graph/README.md | 34 +- src/graph/command-executor.test.ts | 665 +-------------- src/graph/command-executor.ts | 539 +++--------- .../commit-graph-batch.test.ts | 766 ++++++++++++++++++ .../command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts | 297 +++++++ src/graph/snapshot.test.ts | 8 +- src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts | 20 +- src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts | 14 +- src/rpc/handlers.test.ts | 4 +- 15 files changed, 1369 insertions(+), 1204 deletions(-) create mode 100644 src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index b15fa3576..f263b5745 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -286,14 +286,14 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I31-L | `readiness_grade` is a forward gate, not a workflow location or kind whitelist: higher grades unlock later strategies/commitments/export paths but do not make earlier gathering/refinement invalid or unavailable, and the `CommandExecutor` must not reject a graph node solely because its kind belongs to a later readiness band. All grade mutations route through `CommandExecutor` and carry audit through the change log. | partially covered (`createSpec` / `getSpec` / `updateReadinessGrade` command tests cover storage and mutation audit; `src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers prompt-resource grade gates rejecting illegal pinned commitment selections and filtering AUTO availability; kind-vs-grade write permissiveness remains planned with graph-code/readiness-band work) | D20-L, D45-L, D64-L | | I32-L | Public RPC structured-exchange driving never requires a client to speak raw Pi RPC: after Brunch method discovery and workspace/spec/session activation, each pending assistant-originated exchange is answered exactly once through `session.submitExchangeResponse`, and the deterministic permutation run produces linear Pi JSONL whose structured exchange projection preserves the same prompt/answer/status/comment artifacts as the equivalent TUI structured-exchange path. | covered for deterministic FE-744 parity under canonical session method names (`session.triggerExchange`, `session.pendingExchange`, `session.submitExchangeResponse`, `session.exchanges`): `rpc.discover` contract tests, pending/respond lifecycle tests, current public-RPC structured-exchange permutations, terminal non-answered status handling, option content/rationale parity, no repeated deterministic prompts, and transcript/exchange parity assertions. | D5-L, D48-L, D49-L; I10-L, I13-L, I21-L, I23-L | | I33-L | `capture_*` analysis entries are transcript evidence only: they persist as Brunch structured-exchange `toolResult` rows, are included by Brunch-semantic transcript renderers, are hidden or collapsed in TUI display, and never mutate graph truth or bypass `CommandExecutor`. | partially covered (minimum capture details schemas parse/export and reject graph payload fields; future runtime capture-analysis schema/rendering tests plus transcript renderer fixtures still need to prove persisted result rendering and TUI hide/collapse behavior; later graph-capture fixtures compare analysis candidates against committed graph mutations) | D17-L, D18-L, D37-L, D47-L, D50-L; I2-L, I11-L, I23-L, I30-L | -| I34-L | `commitGraph` batch validation is all-or-nothing: if any node or edge in the batch is structurally illegal, the entire batch is rejected and no partial state is persisted; the agent receives diagnostics sufficient for bounded self-correction retry. | covered (22 tests in `command-executor.test.ts` — edge failure rolls back nodes, mixed-batch rejection, diagnostic sufficiency) | D53-L; I1-L, I11-L | +| I34-L | `commitGraph` batch validation is all-or-nothing: if any node or edge in the batch is structurally illegal, the entire batch is rejected and no partial state is persisted; the agent receives diagnostics sufficient for bounded self-correction retry. | covered (`command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts` and graph-tool adapter tests cover dry-run/commit diagnostic parity for invalid basis, missing refs/codes, invalid category/stance, self-loop, invalid node kind/detail shape, rollback of nodes/edges/change_log/counters, and structured adapter diagnostics instead of thrown projected-code errors) | D53-L; I1-L, I11-L | | I35-L | Graph context snapshots support multiple detail levels: a cursory/compact full-graph overview for orientation, and detailed node-neighborhood snapshots with configurable hop depth for focused work. Context builders in `agents/contexts/` orchestrate which level to inject or advertise based on mode/goal/strategy/lens/grade. | covered for current POC push path (`getGraphOverview` + `getNodeNeighborhood` in `snapshot.ts` with 10 tests; `src/agents/contexts/{graph,node,cwd}.test.ts` covers lens-shaped overview rendering, bounded node-neighborhood rendering, and selected-spec cwd/session/posture context; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` proves the explicit shell/product prompt path supplies selected-spec-bound graph snapshots to `composeAgentPrompt()`). Pulled `snapshot-*` tools remain optional future surface. | D52-L, D53-L, D58-L | | I36-L | Node `kind` is drawn from a per-plane closed enum structurally validated by the `CommandExecutor`; the intent kind category (basic / structural / reasoning) is a pure function of `kind` and is never stored on the node. | covered (CommandExecutor rejects invalid kind-for-plane; `intentKindCategory` is pure derivation with exhaustive switch; tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L, D56-L | | I37-L | `detail` is per-kind validated by the `CommandExecutor`: `decision` and `term` nodes REQUIRE `detail` with their respective sub-schemas; all other kinds must omit `detail`; unknown fields in `detail` are rejected. | covered (detail-required/prohibited/shape tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L | | I38-L | Every Brunch prompt-resource manifest injected for an agent turn is generated from projected runtime state and spec/workspace gates: listed resources are Brunch-owned, readable under the active tool policy, legal for the current `(op_mode × goal × strategy × lens)` / grade / agent allow-list, and off-list resources are not advertised as available. AUTO axes never list illegal choices; pinned axes point to the pinned resource. | covered for current P0 manifest families (`src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers default header/context/manifest output, AUTO grade/allow-list filtering, pinned singleton resources, illegal pinned grade rejection, and readable `src/agents/` locations; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` covers the explicit shell `before_agent_start` product path appending `agents/compose()` output from transcript-projected runtime state and no legacy composer import/resource discovery. Probe fitness may still track whether the agent reads selected resources before use.) | D39-L, D40-L, D58-L, D59-L | | I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node/batch writes, rollback protection, `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping, globally unique 1–3 letter labels with readiness-band metadata, projected-code parsing, selected-spec adapter resolution before `CommandExecutor`, code-only `commit_graph` / `read_graph` schemas, and code-primary prompt/tool rendering; remaining slice still needs deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | | I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` replaced the persisted basis enum with `explicit | implicit`, made `commitGraph` apply one batch approval basis to all created nodes/edges, made `propose-graph` adapter commits implicit, made review-set translation explicit, rejected retired `accepted_review_set`, and records `change_log.operation` independently; remaining capture/review-cycle slices still need direct user/capture assignment coverage) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | -| I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | covered (`graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests reject existing-cycle closure, intra-batch cycles, and mixed existing+batch cycles; rejected cycles roll back batch nodes/edges/change_log; acyclic supersession commits remain covered by snapshot/CommandExecutor success paths) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | +| I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | covered (`command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts` rejects existing-cycle closure, intra-batch cycles, and mixed existing+batch cycles through the shared dry-run/commit planner before batch writes; rejected cycles roll back or avoid batch nodes/edges/change_log; acyclic supersession commits remain covered by snapshot/CommandExecutor success paths) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | ## Future Direction Register diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md index 0d0fbeeee..6c2598fcd 100644 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md @@ -93,41 +93,63 @@ src/agents/contexts/ └── node.test.ts ~ ``` -## Card 2 — Unify commitGraph planning for dry-run and commit +## Card 2 — Normalize graph tool outcomes and unify commitGraph planning -Status: next +Status: done ### Target Behavior -A single commit-graph batch planner produces every structural diagnostic used by both dry-run and commit execution. +Every graph-tool structural failure travels through the same structured diagnostic path used by commitGraph dry-run and commit execution. ### Boundary Crossings ```pseudo -CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph / CommandExecutor.commitGraph +commit_graph / read_graph Pi tool params +→ adapter normalization over projected codes +→ CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph / CommandExecutor.commitGraph → private commit-graph batch planner → graph structural validators + selected-spec reference checks -→ transaction writer +→ transaction writer / structured tool result +``` + +### Build order inside this card + +```pseudo +1. adapter normalization: no thrown Error for malformed/missing codes; return structured diagnostics +2. result identity: replace `nodes` + optional `nodeCodes` with one created-node result shape +3. tool params: make `ReadGraphParams` a discriminated union so neighborhood requires `nodeCode` +4. resolver contract: require the selected-spec code resolver at the graph tool boundary +5. planner extraction: make dry-run and commit share the full commitGraph planner, including supersession acyclicity ``` ### Risks and Assumptions +- RISK: adapter code currently throws before the agent receives a `structural_illegal`-style tool result. + → MITIGATION: normalize projected-code failures into the same diagnostic envelope that `formatCommitGraphResult` renders for agent self-correction. +- RISK: `CommitGraphSuccess` currently represents identity twice (`nodes: ref → id` plus optional `nodeCodes`). + → MITIGATION: make one created-node result shape such as `createdNodes: { [ref]: { id, code } }`; keep raw ids internal/diagnostic, never as the primary rendered handle. +- RISK: `ReadGraphParams` currently permits `{ mode: "neighborhood" }` and rejects it imperatively. + → MITIGATION: use a discriminated union so overview and neighborhood params make invalid states unrepresentable at the schema/type boundary. - RISK: supersession acyclicity currently depends on resolved endpoints after insertion setup. → MITIGATION: plan against temporary batch endpoint keys plus existing NodeIds before writing; commit maps the already-planned batch refs to inserted rows. - RISK: this cleanup could become a broad executor rewrite. - → MITIGATION: split only commitGraph batch planning/validation behind the existing `CommandExecutor` public method; leave unrelated spec/recon-need commands alone. -- ASSUMPTION: dry-run and commit should be structurally identical except for persistence. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: review-set proposals can pass dry-run and fail on approval, breaking D27-L/D53-L. - → VALIDATE: paired dry-run/commit differential tests for every current structural-illegal family. + → MITIGATION: split only graph-tool normalization and commitGraph batch planning/validation; leave unrelated spec/recon-need commands alone. +- ASSUMPTION: dry-run, commit, and graph-tool normalization should be structurally identical except for persistence. + → IMPACT IF FALSE: review-set proposals can pass dry-run and fail on approval, or agent probes can crash instead of producing retryable diagnostics, breaking D27-L/D53-L/A14-L. + → VALIDATE: paired adapter/dry-run/commit differential tests for current structural-illegal families. ### Posture check -This is an invariant tracer: it closes the dry-run/commit gap before FE-809 review-cycle work depends on dry-run as a product gate. +This is an invariant tracer: it closes the adapter-exception and dry-run/commit gaps before FE-808 probes and FE-809 review-cycle work depend on these diagnostics as product evidence. ### Acceptance Criteria ```pseudo -✓ dry-run/commit parity tests — invalid basis, missing existing code/id, invalid category/stance, self-loop, and detail-shape errors produce matching diagnostics +✓ graph-tool adapter tests — malformed, missing, and wrong-spec projected codes produce structured diagnostic tool results, not thrown exceptions +✓ graph-tool schema tests — `ReadGraphParams` is an overview/neighborhood discriminated union; neighborhood requires `nodeCode`, and raw `node_id` stays rejected +✓ graph-tool adapter tests — selected-spec code resolver is required at the boundary; no default `() => undefined` resolver remains +✓ result-shape tests — commit success exposes one created-node identity shape with both internal id and projected code; formatting renders codes as primary handles with no optional `#id` fallback for created nodes +✓ dry-run/commit parity tests — invalid basis, missing existing ref/code, invalid category/stance, self-loop, and detail-shape errors produce matching diagnostics ✓ dry-run/commit parity tests — existing, intra-batch, and mixed supersession cycles are rejected by dry-run before any write path runs ✓ transaction tests — failed commitGraph batches do not persist nodes, edges, change-log rows, or counter rows ✓ topology/file-size check — commitGraph batch planning lives in a private `src/graph/command-executor/*` module imported only by the public command-executor entrypoint @@ -136,6 +158,7 @@ This is an invariant tracer: it closes the dry-run/commit gap before FE-809 revi ### Verification Approach +- Inner: adapter/schema tests — prove graph-tool normalization returns structured diagnostics and code-only params make invalid states unrepresentable. - Inner: unit/differential tests over the batch planner and public `CommandExecutor` methods. - Middle: review-set dry-run tests keep using the public `dryRunCommitGraph` path. @@ -143,21 +166,28 @@ This is an invariant tracer: it closes the dry-run/commit gap before FE-809 revi - Preserve `CommandExecutor` as the public mutation boundary; the new planner is private implementation. - Do not add a standalone authority service or second write path. -- Keep the split semantic, not file-shape theatre: extract commitGraph batch planning only. +- Keep projected codes out of DB storage; raw ids may remain in typed internals/details but not as primary agent-facing handles. +- Keep the split semantic, not file-shape theatre: extract graph-tool normalization and commitGraph batch planning only. ### Expected touched paths (tentative) ```pseudo +src/.pi/extensions/graph/ +├── command-adapter.ts ~ +├── index.ts ~ +├── tool-schemas.ts ~ +└── review-set-proposal.ts ? +src/.pi/__tests__/ +├── graph-tools.test.ts ~ +└── review-set-proposal.test.ts ~ src/graph/ ├── command-executor.ts ~ ├── command-executor.test.ts ~ +├── snapshot.ts ? +├── workspace-store.ts ? └── command-executor/ ├── commit-graph-batch.ts + └── commit-graph-batch.test.ts + -src/.pi/__tests__/ -└── review-set-proposal.test.ts ~ -src/.pi/extensions/graph/ -└── review-set-proposal.ts ? src/graph/README.md ~ ``` diff --git a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts index 7d40434d5..ee53a27cf 100644 --- a/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts +++ b/src/.pi/__tests__/graph-tools.test.ts @@ -86,6 +86,8 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { (code) => (code === 'G1' ? 42 : undefined), ); + expect('status' in input).toBe(false); + if ('status' in input) throw new Error('unreachable'); expect(input.specId).toBe(7); expect(input.nodes).toHaveLength(2); expect(input.nodes[0]!.ref).toBe('n1'); @@ -96,8 +98,8 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { expect(input.nodes[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); expect(input.edges[0]).not.toHaveProperty('basis'); }); - it('fails loudly when projected codes are malformed or absent from the selected spec', () => { - expect(() => + it('normalizes projected-code failures into structured diagnostics', () => { + expect( translateCommitGraph( { nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Test goal' }], @@ -106,9 +108,12 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { 7, () => undefined, ), - ).toThrow('Malformed graph node code "bad"'); + ).toMatchObject({ + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [{ field: 'edges[0].source' }], + }); - expect(() => + expect( translateCommitGraph( { nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Test goal' }], @@ -117,7 +122,10 @@ describe('translateCommitGraph', () => { 7, () => undefined, ), - ).toThrow('Graph node code "G99" does not resolve in the selected spec'); + ).toMatchObject({ + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [{ field: 'edges[0].source' }], + }); }); }); @@ -151,8 +159,7 @@ describe('formatCommitGraphResult', () => { const text = formatCommitGraphResult({ status: 'success', lsn: 5, - nodes: { n1: 1, n2: 2 }, - nodeCodes: { n1: 'G1', n2: 'R1' }, + createdNodes: { n1: { id: 1, code: 'G1' }, n2: { id: 2, code: 'R1' } }, edges: [10, 11], }); @@ -229,7 +236,9 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'n2', target: 'n1' }], }, specId, + () => undefined, ); + if ('status' in input) throw new Error('unreachable'); const result = executor.commitGraph(input); expect(result.status).toBe('success'); @@ -294,7 +303,7 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { expect(result.content[0]?.text).toContain('n1 → R1'); expect(result.content[0]?.text).not.toContain('n1 → #'); - expect(result.details).toMatchObject({ status: 'success', nodeCodes: { n1: 'R1' } }); + expect(result.details).toMatchObject({ status: 'success', createdNodes: { n1: { code: 'R1' } } }); expect(db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!.source_id).toBe(existing.nodeId); }); @@ -319,12 +328,19 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { { specId, commandExecutor: executor, snapshots }, ); - await expect( - tools.get('commit_graph')!.execute('commit-1', { - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], - edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1' }], - }), - ).rejects.toThrow('Graph node code "G1" does not resolve in the selected spec'); + const result = (await tools.get('commit_graph')!.execute('commit-1', { + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], + edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: { existingCode: 'G1' }, target: 'n1' }], + })) as { + content: Array<{ type: 'text'; text: string }>; + details: unknown; + }; + + expect(result.content[0]?.text).toContain('STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL'); + expect(result.details).toMatchObject({ + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [{ field: 'edges[0].source' }], + }); }); it('graph tool prompt guidance names projected codes rather than raw node ids', () => { @@ -356,7 +372,9 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { edges: [], }, specId, + () => undefined, ); + if ('status' in input) throw new Error('unreachable'); const result = executor.commitGraph(input); expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); @@ -377,7 +395,9 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { ], }, specId, + () => undefined, ); + if ('status' in input) throw new Error('unreachable'); const result = executor.commitGraph(input); expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); @@ -402,12 +422,14 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { edges: [], }, specId, + () => undefined, ); + if ('status' in input) throw new Error('unreachable'); const commitResult = executor.commitGraph(input); expect(commitResult.status).toBe('success'); if (commitResult.status === 'success') { - const nodeId = commitResult.nodes['n1']!; + const nodeId = commitResult.createdNodes['n1']!.id; const result = snapshots.getNodeNeighborhood(nodeId); const text = formatNeighborhoodResult(result); @@ -425,7 +447,9 @@ describe('graph tools end-to-end', () => { edges: [], }, specId, + () => undefined, ); + if ('status' in input) throw new Error('unreachable'); const commitResult = executor.commitGraph(input); expect(commitResult.status).toBe('success'); if (commitResult.status !== 'success') return; diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts index 44d9d2aca..b24461388 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts @@ -16,6 +16,7 @@ import type { CommitGraphInput, CommitGraphResult, CommitGraphSuccess, + Diagnostic, StructuralIllegal, } from '../../../graph/command-executor.js'; import { formatGraphNodeCode, parseGraphNodeCode } from '../../../graph/schema/nodes.js'; @@ -35,8 +36,8 @@ export type ResolveGraphNodeCode = (code: string) => number | undefined; export function translateCommitGraph( params: ToolCommitGraphParams, specId: number, - resolveGraphNodeCode: ResolveGraphNodeCode = () => undefined, -): CommitGraphInput { + resolveGraphNodeCode: ResolveGraphNodeCode, +): CommitGraphInput | StructuralIllegal { const nodes: BatchNodeInput[] = params.nodes.map((n) => ({ ref: n.ref, plane: n.plane as BatchNodeInput['plane'], @@ -47,28 +48,37 @@ export function translateCommitGraph( detail: n.detail, })); - const edges: BatchEdgeInput[] = params.edges.map((e) => ({ + const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; + const edges: BatchEdgeInput[] = params.edges.map((e, index) => ({ category: e.category, - source: resolveEdgeRef(e.source, resolveGraphNodeCode), - target: resolveEdgeRef(e.target, resolveGraphNodeCode), + source: resolveEdgeRef(e.source, resolveGraphNodeCode, `edges[${index}].source`, diagnostics), + target: resolveEdgeRef(e.target, resolveGraphNodeCode, `edges[${index}].target`, diagnostics), stance: e.stance, rationale: e.rationale, })); + if (diagnostics.length > 0) return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics }; return { specId, basis: 'implicit', nodes, edges }; } function resolveEdgeRef( ref: string | { readonly existingCode: string }, resolveGraphNodeCode: ResolveGraphNodeCode, + field: string, + diagnostics: Diagnostic[], ): BatchEdgeRef { if (typeof ref === 'string') return ref; if (!parseGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode)) { - throw new Error(`Malformed graph node code "${ref.existingCode}"`); + diagnostics.push({ field, message: `malformed graph node code "${ref.existingCode}"` }); + return '__invalid_existing_code__'; } const nodeId = resolveGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode); if (nodeId === undefined) { - throw new Error(`Graph node code "${ref.existingCode}" does not resolve in the selected spec`); + diagnostics.push({ + field, + message: `graph node code "${ref.existingCode}" does not resolve in the selected spec`, + }); + return '__unresolved_existing_code__'; } return { existing: nodeId }; } @@ -87,15 +97,15 @@ export function formatCommitGraphResult(result: CommitGraphResult): string { if (result.status === 'success') { return formatCommitSuccess(result); } - return formatDiagnostics(result); + return formatStructuralIllegal(result); } function formatCommitSuccess(result: CommitGraphSuccess): string { - const nodeEntries = Object.entries(result.nodes); + const nodeEntries = Object.entries(result.createdNodes); const lines: string[] = [`Graph committed successfully (LSN ${result.lsn}).`]; if (nodeEntries.length > 0) { - const createdNodes = nodeEntries.map(([ref, id]) => `${ref} → ${result.nodeCodes?.[ref] ?? `#${id}`}`); + const createdNodes = nodeEntries.map(([ref, node]) => `${ref} → ${node.code}`); lines.push(`Nodes created: ${createdNodes.join(', ')}`); } if (result.edges.length > 0) { @@ -105,7 +115,7 @@ function formatCommitSuccess(result: CommitGraphSuccess): string { return lines.join('\n'); } -function formatDiagnostics(result: StructuralIllegal): string { +export function formatStructuralIllegal(result: StructuralIllegal): string { const lines: string[] = [ 'STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL: The batch was rejected. Fix the following issues and retry:', '', diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts index 5435a3c5a..b11d73899 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/index.ts @@ -12,12 +12,17 @@ import type { ExtensionAPI } from '@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent'; +import type { CommandExecutor } from '../../../graph/command-executor.js'; import { formatNeighborhood } from '../../../graph/format/neighborhood.js'; import { projectNeighborhood } from '../../../graph/project/neighborhood.js'; -import type { CommandExecutor } from '../../../graph/command-executor.js'; import type { GraphOverview, NeighborhoodResult } from '../../../graph/snapshot.js'; import { graphMutationProductUpdates, type ProductUpdatePublisher } from '../../../rpc/product-updates.js'; -import { translateCommitGraph, formatCommitGraphResult, formatGraphOverview } from './command-adapter.js'; +import { + translateCommitGraph, + formatCommitGraphResult, + formatGraphOverview, + formatStructuralIllegal, +} from './command-adapter.js'; import { CommitGraphParams, ReadGraphParams } from './tool-schemas.js'; // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -74,7 +79,7 @@ export function registerBrunchGraph(pi: ExtensionAPI, deps: BrunchGraphDeps): vo async execute(_toolCallId, params) { const specId = deps.specId; const input = translateCommitGraph(params, specId, snapshots.resolveNodeCode); - const result = commandExecutor.commitGraph(input); + const result = 'status' in input ? input : commandExecutor.commitGraph(input); const text = formatCommitGraphResult(result); if (result.status === 'success') { deps.productUpdates?.publish(graphMutationProductUpdates({ specId, lsn: result.lsn })); @@ -104,26 +109,45 @@ export function registerBrunchGraph(pi: ExtensionAPI, deps: BrunchGraphDeps): vo async execute(_toolCallId, params) { let text: string; - let details: GraphOverview | NeighborhoodResult; + let details: + | GraphOverview + | NeighborhoodResult + | { + readonly status: 'structural_illegal'; + readonly diagnostics: readonly { readonly field: string; readonly message: string }[]; + }; if (params.mode === 'overview') { const overview = snapshots.getGraphOverview(); text = formatGraphOverview(overview); details = overview; + } else if (params.nodeCode == null) { + details = { + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [{ field: 'nodeCode', message: 'nodeCode is required for neighborhood mode' }], + }; + text = formatStructuralIllegal(details); } else { - if (params.nodeCode == null) { - throw new Error('nodeCode is required for neighborhood mode'); - } const nodeId = snapshots.resolveNodeCode(params.nodeCode); if (nodeId === undefined) { - throw new Error(`nodeCode ${params.nodeCode} does not resolve in the selected spec`); + details = { + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [ + { + field: 'nodeCode', + message: `nodeCode ${params.nodeCode} does not resolve in the selected spec`, + }, + ], + }; + text = formatStructuralIllegal(details); + } else { + const neighborhood = snapshots.getNodeNeighborhood( + nodeId, + params.hops != null ? { hops: params.hops } : undefined, + ); + text = formatNeighborhood(projectNeighborhood(neighborhood)); + details = neighborhood; } - const neighborhood = snapshots.getNodeNeighborhood( - nodeId, - params.hops != null ? { hops: params.hops } : undefined, - ); - text = formatNeighborhood(projectNeighborhood(neighborhood)); - details = neighborhood; } return { diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts index 32888a5d6..7c48ee780 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts @@ -79,20 +79,26 @@ export const CommitGraphParams = Type.Object( { additionalProperties: false }, ); -export const ReadGraphParams = Type.Object( +const ReadGraphOverviewParams = Type.Object( { - mode: StringEnum(['overview', 'neighborhood'] as const), - nodeCode: Type.Optional( - Type.String({ - description: - 'Required for neighborhood mode — projected code of the anchor node in the selected spec, e.g. G1 or CON2', - }), - ), + mode: Type.Literal('overview'), + }, + { additionalProperties: false }, +); + +const ReadGraphNeighborhoodParams = Type.Object( + { + mode: Type.Literal('neighborhood'), + nodeCode: Type.String({ + description: 'Projected code of the anchor node in the selected spec, e.g. G1 or CON2', + }), hops: Type.Optional(Type.Number({ description: 'Neighborhood traversal depth (default: 1)' })), }, { additionalProperties: false }, ); +export const ReadGraphParams = Type.Union([ReadGraphOverviewParams, ReadGraphNeighborhoodParams]); + export type ToolCommitNode = Static; export type ToolCommitEdge = Static; export type ToolCommitGraphParams = Static; diff --git a/src/graph/README.md b/src/graph/README.md index 4021db20f..3c956dd28 100644 --- a/src/graph/README.md +++ b/src/graph/README.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # graph/ — Graph domain layer Canonical reference: `docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md` -SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L, D54-L, D62-L +SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L, D54-L, D62-L, D63-L ## Owns @@ -13,7 +13,8 @@ SPEC decisions: D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D52-L, D53-L, D54-L, D62-L - **commitGraph** — atomic batch mutation for `propose-graph`: one tool call, one transaction, one LSN, all-or-nothing. It accepts product command input (`nodes[]` with batch refs, `edges[]` with batch/existing refs), not raw DB - rows. + rows. `command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts` owns the private shared planner + used by both dry-run and commit before any batch writes occur. - **Readers / snapshot functions** (`snapshot.ts`) — graph projections at multiple detail levels: active-context and graph-truth overview, node neighborhood, selected-spec graph-code lookup, and open reconciliation needs. @@ -63,6 +64,12 @@ graph/ commitGraph / dryRunCommitGraph create/resolve reconciliation need + command-executor/ + commit-graph-batch.ts + private commitGraph batch planner + dry-run/commit structural parity + temporary endpoint graph for supersession acyclicity + snapshot.ts getGraphOverview getNodeNeighborhood @@ -111,18 +118,20 @@ CommandExecutor ## Fractal split points -Keep `command-executor.ts` and `snapshot.ts` as public entry points. When either -file needs to split, use same-named private folders rather than exposing more -entry points: +Keep `command-executor.ts` and `snapshot.ts` as public entry points. The first +real split is now `command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts`: private planner code +for the commitGraph seam, imported only by the public `command-executor.ts` +entrypoint. Future splits should follow the same pattern: split by semantic +responsibility, keep external imports pointed at the root entrypoint, and avoid +folder scaffolding until pressure is real. ```pseudo graph/command-executor/ - commit-graph.ts - specs.ts - reconciliation-needs.ts - diagnostics.ts - lsn.ts - change-log.ts + commit-graph-batch.ts + planned edge endpoints + existing/batch ref validation + supersession-cycle detection over existing ids + temporary batch keys + created-node result formatter graph/snapshot/ row-mappers.ts @@ -132,9 +141,6 @@ graph/snapshot/ changes-since.ts ``` -Do not create these files until pressure is real or an importer/test names the -seam. The desired shape is documented here so future splits preserve topology. - ## Known near-term schema pressure - `kind_ordinal` is now the stored half of projected graph node codes. Keep diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts index 2c5708a86..3d5a46c11 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts @@ -9,17 +9,8 @@ import { eq } from 'drizzle-orm'; import { describe, expect, it, beforeEach } from 'vitest'; import { createDb, type BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; -import { - graphClock, - changeLog, - edges, - nodeKindCounters, - nodes, - reconciliationNeed, - specs, -} from '../db/schema.js'; +import { graphClock, changeLog, nodes, reconciliationNeed, specs } from '../db/schema.js'; import { CommandExecutor } from './command-executor.js'; -import type { CommitGraphInput } from './command-executor.js'; function createTestDb(): BrunchDb { return createDb(':memory:'); @@ -388,656 +379,6 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { }); }); - // ========================================================================== - // commitGraph - // ========================================================================== - - describe('commitGraph', () => { - // --- success path --- - - it('creates multiple nodes + edges in one transaction with one LSN', () => { - const input: CommitGraphInput = { - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'Req A' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'constraint', title: 'Con B' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'boundary', source: 'n2', target: 'n1' }], - }; - - const result = executor.commitGraph(input); - expect(result.status).toBe('success'); - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - - expect(result.lsn).toBe(1); - expect(Object.keys(result.nodes)).toHaveLength(2); - expect(result.edges).toHaveLength(1); - - // Verify DB state - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(2); - expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); - }); - - it('allocates kind ordinals per spec, plane, and kind within multi-node batches', () => { - const otherSpec = executor.createSpec({ name: 'Other Spec', slug: 'other' }); - if (otherSpec.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - - executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); - const firstBatch = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'goal', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Batch goal' }, - { ref: 'requirement', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'Batch req' }, - { ref: 'oracle-goal', plane: 'oracle', kind: 'check', title: 'Oracle check' }, - ], - edges: [], - }); - const otherSpecBatch = executor.commitGraph({ - specId: otherSpec.specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'goal', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Other goal' }], - edges: [], - }); - - expect(firstBatch.status).toBe('success'); - expect(otherSpecBatch.status).toBe('success'); - const rows = db - .select({ - specId: nodes.spec_id, - plane: nodes.plane, - kind: nodes.kind, - title: nodes.title, - kindOrdinal: nodes.kind_ordinal, - }) - .from(nodes) - .all(); - - expect(rows).toEqual( - expect.arrayContaining([ - expect.objectContaining({ - specId, - plane: 'intent', - kind: 'goal', - title: 'Existing goal', - kindOrdinal: 1, - }), - expect.objectContaining({ - specId, - plane: 'intent', - kind: 'goal', - title: 'Batch goal', - kindOrdinal: 2, - }), - expect.objectContaining({ - specId, - plane: 'intent', - kind: 'requirement', - title: 'Batch req', - kindOrdinal: 1, - }), - expect.objectContaining({ - specId, - plane: 'oracle', - kind: 'check', - title: 'Oracle check', - kindOrdinal: 1, - }), - expect.objectContaining({ - specId: otherSpec.specId, - plane: 'intent', - kind: 'goal', - title: 'Other goal', - kindOrdinal: 1, - }), - ]), - ); - }); - - it('rejects duplicate stored kind ordinals for one spec, plane, and kind', () => { - executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }); - - expect(() => - db - .insert(nodes) - .values({ - spec_id: specId, - plane: 'intent', - kind: 'goal', - kind_ordinal: 1, - title: 'Duplicate G1', - basis: 'explicit', - created_at_lsn: 1, - updated_at_lsn: 1, - }) - .run(), - ).toThrow(); - }); - - it('resolves intra-batch refs to real NodeIds', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'a', plane: 'intent', kind: 'assumption', title: 'A1' }, - { - ref: 'b', - plane: 'intent', - kind: 'decision', - title: 'D1', - detail: { - chosen_option: 'X', - rejected: ['Y'], - rationale: 'because', - }, - }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'a', target: 'b' }], - }); - - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const edgeRow = db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!; - expect(edgeRow.source_id).toBe(result.nodes['a']); - expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.nodes['b']); - }); - - it('applies one batch approval basis to all created nodes and edges', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - basis: 'implicit', - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('success'); - expect( - db - .select() - .from(nodes) - .all() - .map((row) => row.basis), - ).toEqual(['implicit', 'implicit']); - expect( - db - .select() - .from(edges) - .all() - .map((row) => row.basis), - ).toEqual(['implicit']); - expect(JSON.parse(db.select().from(changeLog).all()[0]!.payload).basis).toBe('implicit'); - }); - - it('rejects retired accepted_review_set basis at the command boundary', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - basis: 'accepted_review_set' as never, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }], - edges: [], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics).toEqual( - expect.arrayContaining([expect.objectContaining({ field: 'basis' })]), - ); - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); - expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); - }); - - it('resolves existing-node refs to verified NodeIds', () => { - const pre = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); - if (pre.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], - edges: [ - { - category: 'support', - source: { existing: pre.nodeId }, - target: 'n1', - stance: 'for', - }, - ], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('success'); - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const edgeRow = db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!; - expect(edgeRow.source_id).toBe(pre.nodeId); - expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.nodes['n1']); - }); - - it('returns projected node codes for created-node refs without accepting code refs at mutation boundary', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], - edges: [], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('success'); - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.nodeCodes).toEqual({ n1: 'R1' }); - }); - - it('returns nodes mapping and edges array in success result', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'x', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Ctx' }, - { ref: 'y', plane: 'intent', kind: 'thesis', title: 'Thesis' }, - ], - edges: [], - }); - - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.nodes['x']).toBeTypeOf('number'); - expect(result.nodes['y']).toBeTypeOf('number'); - expect(result.nodes['x']).not.toBe(result.nodes['y']); - expect(result.edges).toEqual([]); - }); - - it('appends one change_log entry for the entire batch', () => { - executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G2' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'association', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], - }); - - const logs = db.select().from(changeLog).all(); - expect(logs).toHaveLength(1); - expect(logs[0]!.operation).toBe('commit_graph'); - const payload = JSON.parse(logs[0]!.payload); - expect(Object.keys(payload.nodes)).toHaveLength(2); - expect(payload.edges).toHaveLength(1); - }); - - // --- edge structural validation --- - - it('rejects edge with invalid category', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G2' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'invented_relation', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('category'))).toBe(true); - }); - - it('rejects proof edge without stance', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'criterion', title: 'Cr' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'invariant', title: 'Inv' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'proof', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('stance'))).toBe(true); - }); - - it('rejects support edge without stance', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Ctx' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'Req' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'support', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - }); - - it('rejects non-proof/non-support edge with stance', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'assumption', title: 'A' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'n1', target: 'n2', stance: 'for' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('stance'))).toBe(true); - }); - - it('rejects edge referencing non-existent existing node', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], - edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existing: 9999 }, target: 'n1' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('source'))).toBe(true); - }); - - it('rejects edge with unresolvable intra-batch ref', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], - edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'n1', target: 'missing_ref' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('target'))).toBe(true); - }); - - it('rejects self-loop edge', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], - edges: [{ category: 'association', source: 'n1', target: 'n1' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.message.includes('self-loop'))).toBe(true); - }); - - // --- node validation reuse --- - - it('rejects batch node with invalid kind-for-plane', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'check', title: 'Wrong' }], - edges: [], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('nodes[0]'))).toBe(true); - }); - - it('rejects batch decision without detail', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'decision', title: 'D' }], - edges: [], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - }); - - // --- all-or-nothing (I34-L) --- - - it('if any node fails validation, entire batch rejected — nothing written', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Valid' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'check', title: 'Invalid kind' }, - ], - edges: [], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); - const [clock] = db.select().from(graphClock).all(); - expect(clock!.lsn).toBe(0); - }); - - it('if any edge fails validation, no nodes written', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Valid goal' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Valid ctx' }, - ], - edges: [ - { category: 'proof', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }, // missing stance - ], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); - const [clock] = db.select().from(graphClock).all(); - expect(clock!.lsn).toBe(0); - }); - - it('rejects supersession cycles against existing edges', () => { - const newer = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R2' }); - const older = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }); - if (newer.status !== 'success' || older.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect( - executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [], - edges: [ - { - category: 'supersession', - source: { existing: newer.nodeId }, - target: { existing: older.nodeId }, - }, - ], - }).status, - ).toBe('success'); - - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [], - edges: [ - { - category: 'supersession', - source: { existing: older.nodeId }, - target: { existing: newer.nodeId }, - }, - ], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); - }); - - it('rejects intra-batch supersession cycles', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'a', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'A' }, - { ref: 'b', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'B' }, - ], - edges: [ - { category: 'supersession', source: 'a', target: 'b' }, - { category: 'supersession', source: 'b', target: 'a' }, - ], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); - expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(0); - expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); - }); - - it('rejects mixed existing and batch supersession cycles', () => { - const a = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'A' }); - const b = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'B' }); - if (a.status !== 'success' || b.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect( - executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [], - edges: [ - { category: 'supersession', source: { existing: a.nodeId }, target: { existing: b.nodeId } }, - ], - }).status, - ).toBe('success'); - - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'c', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'C' }], - edges: [ - { category: 'supersession', source: { existing: b.nodeId }, target: 'c' }, - { category: 'supersession', source: 'c', target: { existing: a.nodeId } }, - ], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(2); - expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); - }); - - it('if post-insert edge validation fails, no nodes, change log, or counter state is written', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Valid goal' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Valid ctx' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'proof', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); - expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(0); - expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); - expect(db.select().from(nodeKindCounters).all()).toHaveLength(0); - }); - - it('diagnostics include which entry failed', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'OK' }], - edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'n1', target: { existing: 9999 } }], - }); - - if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.startsWith('edges[0]'))).toBe(true); - }); - - // --- edge cases --- - - it('edge-only batch between existing nodes', () => { - const a = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }); - const b = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'assumption', title: 'A1' }); - if (a.status !== 'success' || b.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [], - edges: [ - { - category: 'dependency', - source: { existing: b.nodeId }, - target: { existing: a.nodeId }, - }, - ], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('success'); - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(Object.keys(result.nodes)).toHaveLength(0); - expect(result.edges).toHaveLength(1); - }); - - it('node-only batch (no edges)', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'C1' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'C2' }, - ], - edges: [], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('success'); - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - expect(Object.keys(result.nodes)).toHaveLength(2); - expect(result.edges).toEqual([]); - }); - - it('empty batch → structural_illegal', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId, nodes: [], edges: [] }); - expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); - }); - - it('dry-run rejects nonexistent spec before review-set proposals can be surfaced', () => { - const missingSpecId = specId + 10_000; - const input: CommitGraphInput = { - specId: missingSpecId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Missing spec goal' }], - edges: [], - }; - - const dryRun = executor.dryRunCommitGraph(input); - const commit = executor.commitGraph(input); - - expect(dryRun).toMatchObject({ - status: 'structural_illegal', - diagnostics: [{ field: 'specId' }], - }); - expect(commit).toMatchObject({ - status: 'structural_illegal', - diagnostics: [{ field: 'specId' }], - }); - expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); - }); - - // --- mixed refs --- - - it('edges can mix intra-batch source with existing target', () => { - const pre = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing' }); - if (pre.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [{ ref: 'new', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New' }], - edges: [ - { - category: 'realization', - source: { existing: pre.nodeId }, - target: 'new', - }, - ], - }); - - expect(result.status).toBe('success'); - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const edgeRow = db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!; - expect(edgeRow.source_id).toBe(pre.nodeId); - expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.nodes['new']); - }); - - // --- LSN behavior --- - - it('uses one LSN for the entire batch (not per-entity)', () => { - const result = executor.commitGraph({ - specId, - nodes: [ - { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }, - { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G2' }, - ], - edges: [{ category: 'association', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], - }); - - if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const allNodes = db.select().from(nodes).all(); - const allEdges = db.select().from(edges).all(); - // All entities share the same LSN - for (const n of allNodes) { - expect(n.created_at_lsn).toBe(result.lsn); - } - for (const e of allEdges) { - expect(e.created_at_lsn).toBe(result.lsn); - } - }); - }); - // --- createReconciliationNeed --- describe('createReconciliationNeed', () => { @@ -1079,8 +420,8 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { }); expect(batch.status).toBe('success'); if (batch.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const aId = batch.nodes['r1']!; - const bId = batch.nodes['r2']!; + const aId = batch.createdNodes['r1']!.id; + const bId = batch.createdNodes['r2']!.id; const result = executor.createReconciliationNeed({ specId, diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index 401801af5..f194e50f1 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -17,12 +17,17 @@ * even though pre-M6 policy classification is minimal. */ -import { and, eq, inArray, sql } from 'drizzle-orm'; +import { and, eq, sql } from 'drizzle-orm'; import type { BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; import * as schema from '../db/schema.js'; -import type { EdgeCategory, EdgeStance } from './schema/edges.js'; -import { formatGraphNodeCode, type NodeBasis, type NodeKind, type NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; +import { + formatCreatedGraphNode, + planCommitGraphBatch, + type CreatedGraphNodes, + type PlannedBatchEndpoint, +} from './command-executor/commit-graph-batch.js'; +import { type NodeBasis, type NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; export type ReadinessGrade = (typeof schema.READINESS_GRADES)[number]; @@ -68,8 +73,7 @@ export interface VersionConflict { export interface CommitGraphSuccess { readonly status: 'success'; readonly lsn: number; - readonly nodes: Readonly>; - readonly nodeCodes?: Readonly>; + readonly createdNodes: CreatedGraphNodes; readonly edges: readonly number[]; } @@ -382,216 +386,6 @@ function validateTermDetail(detail: unknown, diagnostics: Diagnostic[]): void { } } -// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- -// Edge validation -// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- - -const VALID_CATEGORIES = schema.EDGE_CATEGORIES as unknown as string[]; -const STANCE_REQUIRED_CATEGORIES = new Set(['proof', 'support']); -const VALID_STANCES = schema.EDGE_STANCES as unknown as string[]; -const VALID_BASES = schema.NODE_BASES as unknown as string[]; - -interface ResolvedEdge { - sourceId: number; - targetId: number; - category: EdgeCategory; - stance: EdgeStance | null; - rationale: string | null; -} - -interface EdgeValidationResult { - diagnostics: Diagnostic[]; - resolved?: ResolvedEdge; -} - -function resolveExistingRefId(ref: { readonly existing: number }): number { - return ref.existing; -} - -function resolveEndpointRef( - _db: Pick, - ref: BatchEdgeRef, - specId: number, - refMap: ReadonlyMap, - existingNodeIds: ReadonlySet, - crossSpecExisting: ReadonlySet, - field: string, - diagnostics: Diagnostic[], -): number | undefined { - if (typeof ref === 'string') { - const id = refMap.get(ref); - if (id === undefined) { - diagnostics.push({ field, message: `unresolvable intra-batch ref "${ref}"` }); - } - return id; - } - - const id = resolveExistingRefId(ref); - if (crossSpecExisting.has(id)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field, - message: `existing node ${id} belongs to a different spec (command spec ${specId})`, - }); - } else if (!existingNodeIds.has(id)) { - diagnostics.push({ field, message: `existing node ${id} not found` }); - } - return id; -} - -function addExistingRefId( - _db: Pick, - ref: BatchEdgeRef, - _specId: number, - refs: Set, -): void { - if (typeof ref === 'string') return; - refs.add(resolveExistingRefId(ref)); -} - -function findSupersessionCycle( - db: Pick, - specId: number, - proposedEdges: readonly ResolvedEdge[], -): Diagnostic | undefined { - const supersessionEdges = proposedEdges.filter((edge) => edge.category === 'supersession'); - if (supersessionEdges.length === 0) return undefined; - - const adjacency = new Map(); - const addEdge = (source: number, target: number) => { - const targets = adjacency.get(source); - if (targets) { - targets.push(target); - } else { - adjacency.set(source, [target]); - } - }; - - for (const edge of db - .select({ sourceId: schema.edges.source_id, targetId: schema.edges.target_id }) - .from(schema.edges) - .where(and(eq(schema.edges.spec_id, specId), eq(schema.edges.category, 'supersession'))) - .all()) { - addEdge(edge.sourceId, edge.targetId); - } - for (const edge of supersessionEdges) { - addEdge(edge.sourceId, edge.targetId); - } - - const visiting = new Set(); - const visited = new Set(); - const hasCycle = (nodeId: number): boolean => { - if (visiting.has(nodeId)) return true; - if (visited.has(nodeId)) return false; - visiting.add(nodeId); - for (const targetId of adjacency.get(nodeId) ?? []) { - if (hasCycle(targetId)) return true; - } - visiting.delete(nodeId); - visited.add(nodeId); - return false; - }; - - for (const nodeId of adjacency.keys()) { - if (hasCycle(nodeId)) { - return { field: 'edges', message: 'supersession edges must be acyclic within one spec' }; - } - } - return undefined; -} - -function validateAndResolveBatchEdge( - input: BatchEdgeInput, - index: number, - refMap: ReadonlyMap, - existingNodeIds: ReadonlySet, - crossSpecExisting: ReadonlySet, - db: Pick, - specId: number, -): EdgeValidationResult { - const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; - const p = `edges[${index}]`; - - if (!VALID_CATEGORIES.includes(input.category)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.category`, - message: `"${input.category}" is not a valid edge category`, - }); - return { diagnostics }; - } - - const stanceRequired = STANCE_REQUIRED_CATEGORIES.has(input.category); - if (stanceRequired && input.stance == null) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.stance`, - message: `stance is required for "${input.category}" edges`, - }); - } - if (!stanceRequired && input.stance != null) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.stance`, - message: `stance is not allowed for "${input.category}" edges`, - }); - } - if (input.stance != null && !VALID_STANCES.includes(input.stance)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `${p}.stance`, - message: `"${input.stance}" is not a valid stance`, - }); - } - - const resolvedSourceId = resolveEndpointRef( - db, - input.source, - specId, - refMap, - existingNodeIds, - crossSpecExisting, - `${p}.source`, - diagnostics, - ); - const resolvedTargetId = resolveEndpointRef( - db, - input.target, - specId, - refMap, - existingNodeIds, - crossSpecExisting, - `${p}.target`, - diagnostics, - ); - - if ( - resolvedSourceId !== undefined && - resolvedTargetId !== undefined && - resolvedSourceId === resolvedTargetId - ) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: p, - message: 'self-loop: source and target resolve to the same node', - }); - } - - if (diagnostics.length > 0) return { diagnostics }; - - return { - diagnostics, - resolved: { - sourceId: resolvedSourceId!, - targetId: resolvedTargetId!, - category: input.category as EdgeCategory, - stance: (input.stance as EdgeStance) ?? null, - rationale: input.rationale ?? null, - }, - }; -} - -/** Thrown inside a transaction to trigger rollback on edge validation failure. */ -class BatchValidationError extends Error { - constructor(readonly diagnostics: readonly Diagnostic[]) { - super('batch validation failed'); - } -} - // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- // CommandExecutor // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -823,8 +617,10 @@ export class CommandExecutor { * proposal must pass the same structural checks as the eventual commit. */ dryRunCommitGraph(input: CommitGraphInput): CommitGraphDryRunResult { - const diagnostics = this.validateCommitGraphInput(input); - return diagnostics.length > 0 ? { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics } : { status: 'success' }; + const result = this.planCommitGraph(input, this.db); + return result.status === 'structural_illegal' + ? { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics: result.diagnostics } + : { status: 'success' }; } /** @@ -837,244 +633,103 @@ export class CommandExecutor { * validation, the entire batch is rejected (I34-L). */ commitGraph(input: CommitGraphInput): CommitGraphResult { - const diagnostics = this.validateCommitGraphInput(input); - if (diagnostics.length > 0) { - return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics }; + const preflight = this.planCommitGraph(input, this.db); + if (preflight.status === 'structural_illegal') { + return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics: preflight.diagnostics }; } - // --- Transaction: insert nodes, resolve refs, validate + insert edges --- - try { - return this.db.transaction((tx) => { - // 1. Verify spec exists - const specRow = tx - .select({ id: schema.specs.id }) - .from(schema.specs) - .where(eq(schema.specs.id, input.specId)) - .get(); - if (!specRow) { - throw new BatchValidationError([ - { field: 'specId', message: `spec ${input.specId} does not exist` }, - ]); - } - - // 2. Allocate ONE LSN - const clock = tx - .update(schema.graphClock) - .set({ lsn: sql`${schema.graphClock.lsn} + 1` }) - .where(eq(schema.graphClock.id, 1)) - .returning() - .get(); - const lsn = clock!.lsn; - - // 3. Insert all nodes, build ref → id map - const refMap = new Map(); - const nodeCodeMap = new Map(); - for (const bn of input.nodes) { - const kindOrdinal = this.allocateNodeKindOrdinal(tx, input.specId, bn.plane, bn.kind); - const row = tx - .insert(schema.nodes) - .values({ - spec_id: input.specId, - plane: bn.plane, - kind: bn.kind, - kind_ordinal: kindOrdinal, - title: bn.title, - body: bn.body ?? null, - basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', - source: bn.source ?? null, - detail: bn.detail != null ? JSON.stringify(bn.detail) : null, - created_at_lsn: lsn, - updated_at_lsn: lsn, - }) - .returning() - .get(); - refMap.set(bn.ref, row!.id); - nodeCodeMap.set(bn.ref, formatGraphNodeCode(row!.kind as NodeKind, row!.kind_ordinal)); - } - - // 4. Collect and verify existing-node references — must be same spec - const existingRefs = new Set(); - for (const edge of input.edges) { - addExistingRefId(tx, edge.source, input.specId, existingRefs); - addExistingRefId(tx, edge.target, input.specId, existingRefs); - } - - const verifiedExisting = new Set(); - const crossSpecExisting = new Set(); - if (existingRefs.size > 0) { - const rows = tx - .select({ id: schema.nodes.id, spec_id: schema.nodes.spec_id }) - .from(schema.nodes) - .where(inArray(schema.nodes.id, [...existingRefs])) - .all(); - for (const row of rows) { - if (row.spec_id === input.specId) { - verifiedExisting.add(row.id); - } else { - crossSpecExisting.add(row.id); - } - } - } - - // 5. Validate and resolve all edges - const edgeDiagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; - const resolvedEdges: ResolvedEdge[] = []; - - for (let i = 0; i < input.edges.length; i++) { - const result = validateAndResolveBatchEdge( - input.edges[i]!, - i, - refMap, - verifiedExisting, - crossSpecExisting, - tx, - input.specId, - ); - edgeDiagnostics.push(...result.diagnostics); - if (result.resolved) resolvedEdges.push(result.resolved); - } - - if (edgeDiagnostics.length > 0) { - throw new BatchValidationError(edgeDiagnostics); - } - - const cycleDiagnostic = findSupersessionCycle(tx, input.specId, resolvedEdges); - if (cycleDiagnostic) { - throw new BatchValidationError([cycleDiagnostic]); - } + return this.db.transaction((tx) => { + const planned = this.planCommitGraph(input, tx); + if (planned.status === 'structural_illegal') { + return { status: 'structural_illegal' as const, diagnostics: planned.diagnostics }; + } - // 6. Insert all edges - const edgeIds: number[] = []; - for (const re of resolvedEdges) { - const row = tx - .insert(schema.edges) - .values({ - spec_id: input.specId, - category: re.category, - source_id: re.sourceId, - target_id: re.targetId, - stance: re.stance, - basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', - rationale: re.rationale, - created_at_lsn: lsn, - updated_at_lsn: lsn, - }) - .returning() - .get(); - edgeIds.push(row!.id); - } + const clock = tx + .update(schema.graphClock) + .set({ lsn: sql`${schema.graphClock.lsn} + 1` }) + .where(eq(schema.graphClock.id, 1)) + .returning() + .get(); + const lsn = clock!.lsn; - // 7. Append one change_log entry for the entire batch - tx.insert(schema.changeLog) + const createdNodes: Record = {}; + for (const bn of input.nodes) { + const kindOrdinal = this.allocateNodeKindOrdinal(tx, input.specId, bn.plane, bn.kind); + const row = tx + .insert(schema.nodes) .values({ - lsn, - operation: 'commit_graph', - payload: JSON.stringify({ - basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', - specId: input.specId, - nodes: Object.fromEntries(refMap), - edges: edgeIds, - }), + spec_id: input.specId, + plane: bn.plane, + kind: bn.kind, + kind_ordinal: kindOrdinal, + title: bn.title, + body: bn.body ?? null, + basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', + source: bn.source ?? null, + detail: bn.detail != null ? JSON.stringify(bn.detail) : null, + created_at_lsn: lsn, + updated_at_lsn: lsn, }) - .run(); - - return { - status: 'success' as const, - lsn, - nodes: Object.fromEntries(refMap), - nodeCodes: Object.fromEntries(nodeCodeMap), - edges: edgeIds, - }; - }); - } catch (e) { - if (e instanceof BatchValidationError) { - return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics: e.diagnostics }; + .returning() + .get(); + createdNodes[bn.ref] = formatCreatedGraphNode(row!); } - throw e; - } - } - - private validateCommitGraphInput(input: CommitGraphInput): Diagnostic[] { - const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; - if (input.nodes.length === 0 && input.edges.length === 0) { - diagnostics.push({ field: 'batch', message: 'empty batch — nothing to commit' }); - return diagnostics; - } - if (input.basis != null && !VALID_BASES.includes(input.basis)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: 'basis', - message: `"${String(input.basis)}" is not a valid graph approval basis`, - }); - } - const specRow = this.db - .select({ id: schema.specs.id }) - .from(schema.specs) - .where(eq(schema.specs.id, input.specId)) - .get(); - if (!specRow) { - diagnostics.push({ field: 'specId', message: `spec ${input.specId} does not exist` }); - return diagnostics; - } + const resolvePlannedEndpoint = (endpoint: PlannedBatchEndpoint): number => { + if (endpoint.kind === 'existing') return endpoint.ref as number; + return createdNodes[endpoint.ref as string]!.id; + }; - const refMap = new Map(); - for (let i = 0; i < input.nodes.length; i++) { - const bn = input.nodes[i]!; - if (refMap.has(bn.ref)) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `nodes[${i}].ref`, - message: `duplicate batch ref "${bn.ref}"`, - }); - } - refMap.set(bn.ref, -(i + 1)); - - // Node validation reuses createNode rules; specId comes from the batch. - for (const diagnostic of validateCreateNode({ ...bn, specId: input.specId })) { - diagnostics.push({ - field: `nodes[${i}].${diagnostic.field}`, - message: diagnostic.message, - }); + const edgeIds: number[] = []; + for (const edge of planned.plan.edges) { + const row = tx + .insert(schema.edges) + .values({ + spec_id: input.specId, + category: edge.category, + source_id: resolvePlannedEndpoint(edge.source), + target_id: resolvePlannedEndpoint(edge.target), + stance: edge.stance, + basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', + rationale: edge.rationale, + created_at_lsn: lsn, + updated_at_lsn: lsn, + }) + .returning() + .get(); + edgeIds.push(row!.id); } - } - if (diagnostics.length > 0) return diagnostics; - const existingRefs = new Set(); - for (const edge of input.edges) { - addExistingRefId(this.db, edge.source, input.specId, existingRefs); - addExistingRefId(this.db, edge.target, input.specId, existingRefs); - } + tx.insert(schema.changeLog) + .values({ + lsn, + operation: 'commit_graph', + payload: JSON.stringify({ + basis: input.basis ?? 'explicit', + specId: input.specId, + nodes: Object.fromEntries(Object.entries(createdNodes).map(([ref, node]) => [ref, node.id])), + edges: edgeIds, + }), + }) + .run(); - const verifiedExisting = new Set(); - const crossSpecExisting = new Set(); - if (existingRefs.size > 0) { - const rows = this.db - .select({ id: schema.nodes.id, spec_id: schema.nodes.spec_id }) - .from(schema.nodes) - .where(inArray(schema.nodes.id, [...existingRefs])) - .all(); - for (const row of rows) { - if (row.spec_id === input.specId) { - verifiedExisting.add(row.id); - } else { - crossSpecExisting.add(row.id); - } - } - } + return { + status: 'success' as const, + lsn, + createdNodes, + edges: edgeIds, + }; + }); + } - for (let i = 0; i < input.edges.length; i++) { - diagnostics.push( - ...validateAndResolveBatchEdge( - input.edges[i]!, - i, - refMap, - verifiedExisting, - crossSpecExisting, - this.db, - input.specId, - ).diagnostics, - ); - } - return diagnostics; + private planCommitGraph(input: CommitGraphInput, db: Pick) { + return planCommitGraphBatch(db, input, (nodeIndex) => { + const node = input.nodes[nodeIndex]!; + return validateCreateNode({ ...node, specId: input.specId }).map((diagnostic) => ({ + field: `nodes[${nodeIndex}].${diagnostic.field}`, + message: diagnostic.message, + })); + }); } /** diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..486e0fc57 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,766 @@ +import { describe, expect, it, beforeEach } from 'vitest'; + +import { createDb, type BrunchDb } from '../../db/connection.js'; +import { changeLog, edges, graphClock, nodeKindCounters, nodes, specs } from '../../db/schema.js'; +import { CommandExecutor } from '../command-executor.js'; +import type { CommitGraphInput, CommitGraphResult } from '../command-executor.js'; + +function createTestDb(): BrunchDb { + return createDb(':memory:'); +} + +function expectMatchingStructuralDiagnostics( + dryRun: ReturnType, + commit: CommitGraphResult, +): void { + expect(dryRun.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(commit.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (dryRun.status !== 'structural_illegal' || commit.status !== 'structural_illegal') { + throw new Error('unreachable'); + } + expect(commit.diagnostics).toEqual(dryRun.diagnostics); +} + +describe('CommandExecutor commitGraph', () => { + let db: BrunchDb; + let executor: CommandExecutor; + let specId: number; + + beforeEach(() => { + db = createTestDb(); + executor = new CommandExecutor(db); + db.insert(specs) + .values({ name: 'Test Spec', slug: 'test', readiness_grade: 'grounding_onboarding' }) + .run(); + specId = db.select({ id: specs.id }).from(specs).get()!.id; + }); + + // ========================================================================== + // commitGraph + // ========================================================================== + + describe('commitGraph', () => { + // --- success path --- + + it('creates multiple nodes + edges in one transaction with one LSN', () => { + const input: CommitGraphInput = { + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'Req A' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'constraint', title: 'Con B' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'boundary', source: 'n2', target: 'n1' }], + }; + + const result = executor.commitGraph(input); + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + + expect(result.lsn).toBe(1); + expect(Object.keys(result.createdNodes)).toHaveLength(2); + expect(result.edges).toHaveLength(1); + + // Verify DB state + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(2); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); + }); + + it('allocates kind ordinals per spec, plane, and kind within multi-node batches', () => { + const otherSpec = executor.createSpec({ name: 'Other Spec', slug: 'other' }); + if (otherSpec.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + + executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); + const firstBatch = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'goal', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Batch goal' }, + { ref: 'requirement', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'Batch req' }, + { ref: 'oracle-goal', plane: 'oracle', kind: 'check', title: 'Oracle check' }, + ], + edges: [], + }); + const otherSpecBatch = executor.commitGraph({ + specId: otherSpec.specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'goal', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Other goal' }], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(firstBatch.status).toBe('success'); + expect(otherSpecBatch.status).toBe('success'); + const rows = db + .select({ + specId: nodes.spec_id, + plane: nodes.plane, + kind: nodes.kind, + title: nodes.title, + kindOrdinal: nodes.kind_ordinal, + }) + .from(nodes) + .all(); + + expect(rows).toEqual( + expect.arrayContaining([ + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Existing goal', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Batch goal', + kindOrdinal: 2, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'requirement', + title: 'Batch req', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId, + plane: 'oracle', + kind: 'check', + title: 'Oracle check', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + expect.objectContaining({ + specId: otherSpec.specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Other goal', + kindOrdinal: 1, + }), + ]), + ); + }); + + it('rejects duplicate stored kind ordinals for one spec, plane, and kind', () => { + executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }); + + expect(() => + db + .insert(nodes) + .values({ + spec_id: specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + kind_ordinal: 1, + title: 'Duplicate G1', + basis: 'explicit', + created_at_lsn: 1, + updated_at_lsn: 1, + }) + .run(), + ).toThrow(); + }); + + it('resolves intra-batch refs to real NodeIds', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'a', plane: 'intent', kind: 'assumption', title: 'A1' }, + { + ref: 'b', + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'decision', + title: 'D1', + detail: { + chosen_option: 'X', + rejected: ['Y'], + rationale: 'because', + }, + }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'a', target: 'b' }], + }); + + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + const edgeRow = db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!; + expect(edgeRow.source_id).toBe(result.createdNodes['a']!.id); + expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.createdNodes['b']!.id); + }); + + it('applies one batch approval basis to all created nodes and edges', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + basis: 'implicit', + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'realization', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + expect( + db + .select() + .from(nodes) + .all() + .map((row) => row.basis), + ).toEqual(['implicit', 'implicit']); + expect( + db + .select() + .from(edges) + .all() + .map((row) => row.basis), + ).toEqual(['implicit']); + expect(JSON.parse(db.select().from(changeLog).all()[0]!.payload).basis).toBe('implicit'); + }); + + it('rejects retired accepted_review_set basis at the command boundary', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + basis: 'accepted_review_set' as never, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics).toEqual( + expect.arrayContaining([expect.objectContaining({ field: 'basis' })]), + ); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); + }); + + it('resolves existing-node refs to verified NodeIds', () => { + const pre = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing goal' }); + if (pre.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], + edges: [ + { + category: 'support', + source: { existing: pre.nodeId }, + target: 'n1', + stance: 'for', + }, + ], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + const edgeRow = db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!; + expect(edgeRow.source_id).toBe(pre.nodeId); + expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.createdNodes['n1']!.id); + }); + + it('returns projected node codes for created-node refs without accepting code refs at mutation boundary', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New req' }], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.createdNodes).toEqual({ n1: { id: expect.any(Number), code: 'R1' } }); + }); + + it('returns one created-node identity shape and edges array in success result', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'x', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Ctx' }, + { ref: 'y', plane: 'intent', kind: 'thesis', title: 'Thesis' }, + ], + edges: [], + }); + + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.createdNodes['x']!.id).toBeTypeOf('number'); + expect(result.createdNodes['x']!.code).toBe('CTX1'); + expect(result.createdNodes['y']!.id).toBeTypeOf('number'); + expect(result.createdNodes['y']!.code).toBe('TH1'); + expect(result.createdNodes['x']!.id).not.toBe(result.createdNodes['y']!.id); + expect(result.edges).toEqual([]); + }); + + it('appends one change_log entry for the entire batch', () => { + executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G2' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'association', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + const logs = db.select().from(changeLog).all(); + expect(logs).toHaveLength(1); + expect(logs[0]!.operation).toBe('commit_graph'); + const payload = JSON.parse(logs[0]!.payload); + expect(Object.keys(payload.nodes)).toHaveLength(2); + expect(payload.edges).toHaveLength(1); + }); + + // --- edge structural validation --- + + it('rejects edge with invalid category', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G2' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'invented_relation', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('category'))).toBe(true); + }); + + it('rejects proof edge without stance', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'criterion', title: 'Cr' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'invariant', title: 'Inv' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'proof', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('stance'))).toBe(true); + }); + + it('rejects support edge without stance', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Ctx' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'Req' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'support', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + }); + + it('rejects non-proof/non-support edge with stance', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'assumption', title: 'A' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'n1', target: 'n2', stance: 'for' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('stance'))).toBe(true); + }); + + it('rejects edge referencing non-existent existing node', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existing: 9999 }, target: 'n1' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('source'))).toBe(true); + }); + + it('rejects edge with unresolvable intra-batch ref', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'n1', target: 'missing_ref' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('target'))).toBe(true); + }); + + it('rejects self-loop edge', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], + edges: [{ category: 'association', source: 'n1', target: 'n1' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.message.includes('self-loop'))).toBe(true); + }); + + // --- node validation reuse --- + + it('rejects batch node with invalid kind-for-plane', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'check', title: 'Wrong' }], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.includes('nodes[0]'))).toBe(true); + }); + + it('rejects batch decision without detail', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'decision', title: 'D' }], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + }); + + // --- all-or-nothing (I34-L) --- + + it('if any node fails validation, entire batch rejected — nothing written', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Valid' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'check', title: 'Invalid kind' }, + ], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + const [clock] = db.select().from(graphClock).all(); + expect(clock!.lsn).toBe(0); + }); + + it('if any edge fails validation, no nodes written', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Valid goal' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Valid ctx' }, + ], + edges: [ + { category: 'proof', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }, // missing stance + ], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + const [clock] = db.select().from(graphClock).all(); + expect(clock!.lsn).toBe(0); + }); + + it('rejects supersession cycles against existing edges', () => { + const newer = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R2' }); + const older = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }); + if (newer.status !== 'success' || older.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect( + executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { + category: 'supersession', + source: { existing: newer.nodeId }, + target: { existing: older.nodeId }, + }, + ], + }).status, + ).toBe('success'); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { + category: 'supersession', + source: { existing: older.nodeId }, + target: { existing: newer.nodeId }, + }, + ], + }); + + expectMatchingStructuralDiagnostics( + executor.dryRunCommitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { + category: 'supersession', + source: { existing: older.nodeId }, + target: { existing: newer.nodeId }, + }, + ], + }), + result, + ); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); + }); + + it('rejects intra-batch supersession cycles', () => { + const input: CommitGraphInput = { + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'a', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'A' }, + { ref: 'b', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'B' }, + ], + edges: [ + { category: 'supersession', source: 'a', target: 'b' }, + { category: 'supersession', source: 'b', target: 'a' }, + ], + }; + + const dryRun = executor.dryRunCommitGraph(input); + const result = executor.commitGraph(input); + + expectMatchingStructuralDiagnostics(dryRun, result); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); + }); + + it('rejects mixed existing and batch supersession cycles', () => { + const a = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'A' }); + const b = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'B' }); + if (a.status !== 'success' || b.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect( + executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { category: 'supersession', source: { existing: a.nodeId }, target: { existing: b.nodeId } }, + ], + }).status, + ).toBe('success'); + + const input: CommitGraphInput = { + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'c', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'C' }], + edges: [ + { category: 'supersession', source: { existing: b.nodeId }, target: 'c' }, + { category: 'supersession', source: 'c', target: { existing: a.nodeId } }, + ], + }; + + const dryRun = executor.dryRunCommitGraph(input); + const result = executor.commitGraph(input); + + expectMatchingStructuralDiagnostics(dryRun, result); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(2); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); + }); + + it('if post-insert edge validation fails, no nodes, change log, or counter state is written', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Valid goal' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'Valid ctx' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'proof', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(nodeKindCounters).all()).toHaveLength(0); + }); + + it('diagnostics include which entry failed', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'OK' }], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: 'n1', target: { existing: 9999 } }], + }); + + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field.startsWith('edges[0]'))).toBe(true); + }); + + // --- edge cases --- + + it('edge-only batch between existing nodes', () => { + const a = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'R1' }); + const b = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'assumption', title: 'A1' }); + if (a.status !== 'success' || b.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { + category: 'dependency', + source: { existing: b.nodeId }, + target: { existing: a.nodeId }, + }, + ], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(Object.keys(result.createdNodes)).toHaveLength(0); + expect(result.edges).toHaveLength(1); + }); + + it('node-only batch (no edges)', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'C1' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'context', title: 'C2' }, + ], + edges: [], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(Object.keys(result.createdNodes)).toHaveLength(2); + expect(result.edges).toEqual([]); + }); + + it('empty batch → structural_illegal', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId, nodes: [], edges: [] }); + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + }); + + it('dry-run rejects nonexistent spec before review-set proposals can be surfaced', () => { + const missingSpecId = specId + 10_000; + const input: CommitGraphInput = { + specId: missingSpecId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Missing spec goal' }], + edges: [], + }; + + const dryRun = executor.dryRunCommitGraph(input); + const commit = executor.commitGraph(input); + + expect(dryRun).toMatchObject({ + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [{ field: 'specId' }], + }); + expect(commit).toMatchObject({ + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [{ field: 'specId' }], + }); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + }); + + it('dry-run and commit return matching diagnostics for structural-illegal families', () => { + const existing = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing' }); + if (existing.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + const cases: CommitGraphInput[] = [ + { + specId, + basis: 'accepted_review_set' as never, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }], + edges: [], + }, + { + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], + edges: [{ category: 'dependency', source: { existing: 9999 }, target: 'n1' }], + }, + { + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'check', title: 'Wrong' }], + edges: [], + }, + { + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G' }], + edges: [{ category: 'association', source: 'n1', target: 'n1' }], + }, + { + specId, + nodes: [ + { + ref: 'n1', + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'decision', + title: 'Bad detail', + detail: { chosen_option: 'A' }, + }, + ], + edges: [], + }, + { + specId, + nodes: [], + edges: [ + { + category: 'support', + source: { existing: existing.nodeId }, + target: { existing: existing.nodeId }, + }, + ], + }, + ]; + + for (const input of cases) { + expectMatchingStructuralDiagnostics(executor.dryRunCommitGraph(input), executor.commitGraph(input)); + } + }); + + // --- mixed refs --- + + it('edges can mix intra-batch source with existing target', () => { + const pre = executor.createNode({ specId, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Existing' }); + if (pre.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'new', plane: 'intent', kind: 'requirement', title: 'New' }], + edges: [ + { + category: 'realization', + source: { existing: pre.nodeId }, + target: 'new', + }, + ], + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('success'); + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + const edgeRow = db.select().from(edges).all()[0]!; + expect(edgeRow.source_id).toBe(pre.nodeId); + expect(edgeRow.target_id).toBe(result.createdNodes['new']!.id); + }); + + // --- LSN behavior --- + + it('uses one LSN for the entire batch (not per-entity)', () => { + const result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [ + { ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G1' }, + { ref: 'n2', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'G2' }, + ], + edges: [{ category: 'association', source: 'n1', target: 'n2' }], + }); + + if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); + const allNodes = db.select().from(nodes).all(); + const allEdges = db.select().from(edges).all(); + // All entities share the same LSN + for (const n of allNodes) { + expect(n.created_at_lsn).toBe(result.lsn); + } + for (const e of allEdges) { + expect(e.created_at_lsn).toBe(result.lsn); + } + }); + }); +}); diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..de17e60eb --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts @@ -0,0 +1,297 @@ +import { and, eq, inArray } from 'drizzle-orm'; + +import type { BrunchDb } from '../../db/connection.js'; +import * as schema from '../../db/schema.js'; +import type { BatchEdgeInput, BatchEdgeRef, CommitGraphInput, Diagnostic } from '../command-executor.js'; +import type { EdgeCategory, EdgeStance } from '../schema/edges.js'; +import { formatGraphNodeCode, type NodeKind } from '../schema/nodes.js'; + +const VALID_CATEGORIES = schema.EDGE_CATEGORIES as unknown as string[]; +const STANCE_REQUIRED_CATEGORIES = new Set(['proof', 'support']); +const VALID_STANCES = schema.EDGE_STANCES as unknown as string[]; +const VALID_BASES = schema.NODE_BASES as unknown as string[]; + +export interface PlannedBatchEndpoint { + readonly kind: 'batch' | 'existing'; + readonly ref: string | number; +} + +export interface PlannedBatchEdge { + readonly source: PlannedBatchEndpoint; + readonly target: PlannedBatchEndpoint; + readonly category: EdgeCategory; + readonly stance: EdgeStance | null; + readonly rationale: string | null; +} + +export interface CommitGraphBatchPlan { + readonly edges: readonly PlannedBatchEdge[]; +} + +export interface CreatedGraphNodeResult { + readonly id: number; + readonly code: string; +} + +export type CreatedGraphNodes = Readonly>; + +export interface InsertedNodeRow { + readonly id: number; + readonly kind: string; + readonly kind_ordinal: number; +} + +export function formatCreatedGraphNode(row: InsertedNodeRow): CreatedGraphNodeResult { + return { + id: row.id, + code: formatGraphNodeCode(row.kind as NodeKind, row.kind_ordinal), + }; +} + +export function planCommitGraphBatch( + db: Pick, + input: CommitGraphInput, + validateNode: (nodeIndex: number) => readonly Diagnostic[], +): + | { readonly status: 'success'; readonly plan: CommitGraphBatchPlan } + | { readonly status: 'structural_illegal'; readonly diagnostics: readonly Diagnostic[] } { + const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; + if (input.nodes.length === 0 && input.edges.length === 0) { + diagnostics.push({ field: 'batch', message: 'empty batch — nothing to commit' }); + return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics }; + } + if (input.basis != null && !VALID_BASES.includes(input.basis)) { + diagnostics.push({ + field: 'basis', + message: `"${String(input.basis)}" is not a valid graph approval basis`, + }); + } + + const specRow = db + .select({ id: schema.specs.id }) + .from(schema.specs) + .where(eq(schema.specs.id, input.specId)) + .get(); + if (!specRow) { + diagnostics.push({ field: 'specId', message: `spec ${input.specId} does not exist` }); + return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics }; + } + + const batchRefs = new Map(); + for (let i = 0; i < input.nodes.length; i++) { + const bn = input.nodes[i]!; + if (batchRefs.has(bn.ref)) { + diagnostics.push({ + field: `nodes[${i}].ref`, + message: `duplicate batch ref "${bn.ref}"`, + }); + } + batchRefs.set(bn.ref, bn.ref); + for (const diagnostic of validateNode(i)) { + diagnostics.push(diagnostic); + } + } + if (diagnostics.length > 0) return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics }; + + const existingRefs = new Set(); + for (const edge of input.edges) { + addExistingRefId(edge.source, existingRefs); + addExistingRefId(edge.target, existingRefs); + } + + const verifiedExisting = new Set(); + const crossSpecExisting = new Set(); + if (existingRefs.size > 0) { + const rows = db + .select({ id: schema.nodes.id, spec_id: schema.nodes.spec_id }) + .from(schema.nodes) + .where(inArray(schema.nodes.id, [...existingRefs])) + .all(); + for (const row of rows) { + if (row.spec_id === input.specId) { + verifiedExisting.add(row.id); + } else { + crossSpecExisting.add(row.id); + } + } + } + + const plannedEdges: PlannedBatchEdge[] = []; + for (let i = 0; i < input.edges.length; i++) { + const result = validateAndPlanBatchEdge( + input.edges[i]!, + i, + batchRefs, + verifiedExisting, + crossSpecExisting, + input.specId, + ); + diagnostics.push(...result.diagnostics); + if (result.planned) plannedEdges.push(result.planned); + } + if (diagnostics.length > 0) return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics }; + + const cycleDiagnostic = findSupersessionCycle(db, input.specId, plannedEdges); + if (cycleDiagnostic) return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics: [cycleDiagnostic] }; + + return { status: 'success', plan: { edges: plannedEdges } }; +} + +function addExistingRefId(ref: BatchEdgeRef, refs: Set): void { + if (typeof ref === 'string') return; + refs.add(ref.existing); +} + +function endpointKey(endpoint: PlannedBatchEndpoint): string | number { + return endpoint.kind === 'existing' ? endpoint.ref : `batch:${endpoint.ref}`; +} + +function resolveEndpointRef( + ref: BatchEdgeRef, + specId: number, + batchRefs: ReadonlyMap, + existingNodeIds: ReadonlySet, + crossSpecExisting: ReadonlySet, + field: string, + diagnostics: Diagnostic[], +): PlannedBatchEndpoint | undefined { + if (typeof ref === 'string') { + const batchRef = batchRefs.get(ref); + if (batchRef === undefined) { + diagnostics.push({ field, message: `unresolvable intra-batch ref "${ref}"` }); + return undefined; + } + return { kind: 'batch', ref: batchRef }; + } + + const id = ref.existing; + if (crossSpecExisting.has(id)) { + diagnostics.push({ + field, + message: `existing node ${id} belongs to a different spec (command spec ${specId})`, + }); + } else if (!existingNodeIds.has(id)) { + diagnostics.push({ field, message: `existing node ${id} not found` }); + } + return { kind: 'existing', ref: id }; +} + +function validateAndPlanBatchEdge( + input: BatchEdgeInput, + index: number, + batchRefs: ReadonlyMap, + existingNodeIds: ReadonlySet, + crossSpecExisting: ReadonlySet, + specId: number, +): { readonly diagnostics: readonly Diagnostic[]; readonly planned?: PlannedBatchEdge } { + const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; + const p = `edges[${index}]`; + + if (!VALID_CATEGORIES.includes(input.category)) { + diagnostics.push({ + field: `${p}.category`, + message: `"${input.category}" is not a valid edge category`, + }); + return { diagnostics }; + } + + const stanceRequired = STANCE_REQUIRED_CATEGORIES.has(input.category); + if (stanceRequired && input.stance == null) { + diagnostics.push({ field: `${p}.stance`, message: `stance is required for "${input.category}" edges` }); + } + if (!stanceRequired && input.stance != null) { + diagnostics.push({ + field: `${p}.stance`, + message: `stance is not allowed for "${input.category}" edges`, + }); + } + if (input.stance != null && !VALID_STANCES.includes(input.stance)) { + diagnostics.push({ field: `${p}.stance`, message: `"${input.stance}" is not a valid stance` }); + } + + const source = resolveEndpointRef( + input.source, + specId, + batchRefs, + existingNodeIds, + crossSpecExisting, + `${p}.source`, + diagnostics, + ); + const target = resolveEndpointRef( + input.target, + specId, + batchRefs, + existingNodeIds, + crossSpecExisting, + `${p}.target`, + diagnostics, + ); + + if (source !== undefined && target !== undefined && endpointKey(source) === endpointKey(target)) { + diagnostics.push({ field: p, message: 'self-loop: source and target resolve to the same node' }); + } + + if (diagnostics.length > 0 || source === undefined || target === undefined) return { diagnostics }; + return { + diagnostics, + planned: { + source, + target, + category: input.category as EdgeCategory, + stance: (input.stance as EdgeStance) ?? null, + rationale: input.rationale ?? null, + }, + }; +} + +function findSupersessionCycle( + db: Pick, + specId: number, + proposedEdges: readonly PlannedBatchEdge[], +): Diagnostic | undefined { + const supersessionEdges = proposedEdges.filter((edge) => edge.category === 'supersession'); + if (supersessionEdges.length === 0) return undefined; + + const adjacency = new Map(); + const addEdge = (source: string | number, target: string | number) => { + const targets = adjacency.get(source); + if (targets) { + targets.push(target); + } else { + adjacency.set(source, [target]); + } + }; + + for (const edge of db + .select({ sourceId: schema.edges.source_id, targetId: schema.edges.target_id }) + .from(schema.edges) + .where(and(eq(schema.edges.spec_id, specId), eq(schema.edges.category, 'supersession'))) + .all()) { + addEdge(edge.sourceId, edge.targetId); + } + for (const edge of supersessionEdges) { + addEdge(endpointKey(edge.source), endpointKey(edge.target)); + } + + const visiting = new Set(); + const visited = new Set(); + const hasCycle = (node: string | number): boolean => { + if (visiting.has(node)) return true; + if (visited.has(node)) return false; + visiting.add(node); + for (const target of adjacency.get(node) ?? []) { + if (hasCycle(target)) return true; + } + visiting.delete(node); + visited.add(node); + return false; + }; + + for (const node of adjacency.keys()) { + if (hasCycle(node)) { + return { field: 'edges', message: 'supersession edges must be acyclic within one spec' }; + } + } + return undefined; +} diff --git a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts index 5f59cbfa9..116b10bd3 100644 --- a/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/snapshot.test.ts @@ -190,7 +190,7 @@ describe('getNodeNeighborhood', () => { expect(batch.status).toBe('success'); if (batch.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const r1Id = batch.nodes['r1']!; + const r1Id = batch.createdNodes['r1']!.id; const result = getNodeNeighborhood(db, specId, r1Id); expect(result.status).toBe('success'); if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); @@ -220,7 +220,7 @@ describe('getNodeNeighborhood', () => { expect(batch.status).toBe('success'); if (batch.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const g1Id = batch.nodes['g1']!; + const g1Id = batch.createdNodes['g1']!.id; // 1 hop: only R1 const hop1 = getNodeNeighborhood(db, specId, g1Id, { hops: 1 }); @@ -257,7 +257,7 @@ describe('getNodeNeighborhood', () => { expect(batch.status).toBe('success'); if (batch.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const r1Id = batch.nodes['r1']!; + const r1Id = batch.createdNodes['r1']!.id; // Neighborhood of R_v1: should include A1 but exclude R_v0 const result = getNodeNeighborhood(db, specId, r1Id); @@ -293,7 +293,7 @@ describe('getNodeNeighborhood', () => { expect(batch.status).toBe('success'); if (batch.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); - const t1Id = batch.nodes['t1']!; + const t1Id = batch.createdNodes['t1']!.id; const result = getNodeNeighborhood(db, specId, t1Id); expect(result.status).toBe('success'); if (result.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); diff --git a/src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts b/src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts index a4b4413e5..58b0e5108 100644 --- a/src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts @@ -78,7 +78,7 @@ describe('graph items are owned by spec', () => { edges: [], }); if (seed.status !== 'success') throw new Error('seed failed'); - const aNodeId = seed.nodes['n1']!; + const aNodeId = seed.createdNodes['n1']!.id; const attempt = executor.commitGraph({ specId: specB, @@ -111,8 +111,8 @@ describe('graph items are owned by spec', () => { if (seedA.status !== 'success' || seedB.status !== 'success') { throw new Error('seed failed'); } - const aNodeId = seedA.nodes['n1']!; - const bNodeId = seedB.nodes['m1']!; + const aNodeId = seedA.createdNodes['n1']!.id; + const bNodeId = seedB.createdNodes['m1']!.id; // Attempt edge across specs (both endpoints existing) const attempt = executor.commitGraph({ @@ -137,7 +137,7 @@ describe('graph items are owned by spec', () => { edges: [], }); if (seedA.status !== 'success') throw new Error('seed failed'); - const aNodeId = seedA.nodes['n1']!; + const aNodeId = seedA.createdNodes['n1']!.id; const wrongSpec = getNodeNeighborhood(db, specB, aNodeId); expect(wrongSpec.status).toBe('not_found'); @@ -164,8 +164,8 @@ describe('graph items are owned by spec', () => { throw new Error('seed failed'); } const aEdgeId = seedA.edges[0]!; - const bNodeId = seedB.nodes['m1']!; - const aNodeId = seedA.nodes['n1']!; + const bNodeId = seedB.createdNodes['m1']!.id; + const aNodeId = seedA.createdNodes['n1']!.id; // Valid same-spec need const ok = executor.createReconciliationNeed({ @@ -213,10 +213,8 @@ describe('tool guard: agent-facing graph tool schemas do not expose specId', () it('ReadGraphParams has no top-level specId field', async () => { const mod = await import('../.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.js'); - const schema = mod.ReadGraphParams as unknown as { - properties: Record; - }; - expect(Object.keys(schema.properties)).not.toContain('specId'); - expect(Object.keys(schema.properties)).not.toContain('spec_id'); + const { Value } = await import('typebox/value'); + expect(Value.Check(mod.ReadGraphParams, { mode: 'overview', specId: 1 })).toBe(false); + expect(Value.Check(mod.ReadGraphParams, { mode: 'overview', spec_id: 1 })).toBe(false); }); }); diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts index dd6118731..f0abbac73 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts @@ -311,7 +311,9 @@ function commitGraphAttemptFromMessage( index, status, ...(typeof details?.lsn === 'number' ? { lsn: details.lsn } : {}), - ...(isNumberRecord(details?.nodes) ? { nodeRefs: details.nodes } : {}), + ...(isCreatedNodeRecord(details?.createdNodes) + ? { nodeRefs: mapCreatedNodeIds(details.createdNodes) } + : {}), ...(isNumberArray(details?.edges) ? { edgeIds: details.edges } : {}), ...(isDiagnosticArray(details?.diagnostics) ? { diagnostics: details.diagnostics } : {}), ...textContent(message.content), @@ -340,8 +342,14 @@ function isDiagnosticArray(value: unknown): value is Diagnostic[] { ); } -function isNumberRecord(value: unknown): value is Record { - return isRecord(value) && Object.values(value).every((entry): entry is number => typeof entry === 'number'); +function isCreatedNodeRecord(value: unknown): value is Record { + return ( + isRecord(value) && Object.values(value).every((entry) => isRecord(entry) && typeof entry.id === 'number') + ); +} + +function mapCreatedNodeIds(value: Record): Record { + return Object.fromEntries(Object.entries(value).map(([ref, node]) => [ref, node.id])); } function isNumberArray(value: unknown): value is number[] { diff --git a/src/rpc/handlers.test.ts b/src/rpc/handlers.test.ts index a38b7ace1..64eb97eae 100644 --- a/src/rpc/handlers.test.ts +++ b/src/rpc/handlers.test.ts @@ -194,8 +194,8 @@ async function createGraphRpcFixture(): Promise<{ cwd, specAId: specA.specId, specBId: specB.specId, - specANodeId: commitA.nodes.requirement!, - specBNodeId: commitB.nodes.goal!, + specANodeId: commitA.createdNodes.requirement!.id, + specBNodeId: commitB.createdNodes.goal!.id, finalLsn: commitB.lsn, }; } From 65705fc4c9fdbbcc3823e5df2f2d009ffac60fd0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:45:40 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 12/21] FE-808: Add existing-code graph probe --- .../2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/report.json | 68 ++++++++ .../session.jsonl | 12 ++ .../transcript.md | 41 +++++ memory/PLAN.md | 4 +- memory/SPEC.md | 2 +- .../graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md | 2 +- src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts | 34 ++-- src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts | 65 +++++++- src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts | 153 +++++++++++++++++- 9 files changed, 350 insertions(+), 31 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/report.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/session.jsonl create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/transcript.md diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/report.json b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/report.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3987b0e4e --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/report.json @@ -0,0 +1,68 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "probeId": "propose-graph-commit", + "runId": "2026-06-04-existing-code-ref", + "generatedAt": "2026-06-04T14:43:47.399Z", + "mission": "Prove the propose-graph strategy can commit graph truth through commit_graph.", + "evaluationFocus": "A14-L selected-spec projected-code reference through the default runtime.", + "scenarioId": "existing-code-ref", + "success": true, + "cwd": "/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-7xu0IC", + "specId": 1, + "sessionId": "019e9317-2252-7279-9f8c-37344e811041", + "prompt": "Brunch A14-L probe: the selected specification graph already contains a launch-readiness goal.\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Find the projected code for the existing launch-readiness goal, then use commit_graph to create one new requirement node titled \"Rollback path is documented\" and one legal edge connecting that new requirement to the existing goal by using the existing node's projected code as {existingCode: \"G1\"}. Do not recreate the existing goal. Stop after a successful commit_graph result.", + "model": "gpt-5.5", + "maxAttempts": 2, + "attemptCount": 1, + "retryCount": 0, + "firstAttemptStatus": "success", + "finalStatus": "success", + "attempts": [ + { + "index": 1, + "status": "success", + "lsn": 4, + "nodeRefs": { + "n1": 2 + }, + "edgeIds": [ + 1 + ], + "content": "Graph committed successfully (LSN 4).\nNodes created: n1 → R1\nEdges created: #1" + } + ], + "finalGraph": { + "nodeCount": 2, + "edgeCount": 1, + "lsn": 4 + }, + "committedNodeTitles": [ + "Selected-spec launch readiness goal", + "Rollback path is documented" + ], + "committedNodes": [ + { + "code": "G1", + "title": "Selected-spec launch readiness goal" + }, + { + "code": "R1", + "title": "Rollback path is documented" + } + ], + "projectedCodeEvidence": { + "codes": [ + "G1" + ], + "seenInTranscript": true, + "usedInCommitParams": true, + "existingCodeEdgePresent": true + }, + "friction": [], + "artifacts": { + "runDir": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref", + "sessionJsonl": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/session.jsonl", + "transcriptMarkdown": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/transcript.md", + "reportJson": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/report.json" + } +} diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/session.jsonl b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/session.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d2028dd38 --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/session.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +{"type":"session","version":3,"id":"019e9317-2252-7279-9f8c-37344e811041","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.410Z","cwd":"/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-7xu0IC"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.session_binding","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"specId":1},"id":"8974359c","parentId":null,"timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.410Z"} +{"type":"session_info","id":"9b2b4431","parentId":"8974359c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.411Z","name":"A14 propose-graph commit proof — session 1"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.agent_runtime_state","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"reason":"switch","state":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"propose-graph","agentLens":"intent","agentGoal":"commit-converge"},"previous":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"auto","agentLens":"auto","agentGoal":"grounding-advance"},"source":"extension"},"id":"6485b0f4","parentId":"9b2b4431","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.411Z"} +{"type":"model_change","id":"889bf235","parentId":"6485b0f4","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.425Z","provider":"openai-codex","modelId":"gpt-5.5"} +{"type":"thinking_level_change","id":"826e9632","parentId":"889bf235","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.425Z","thinkingLevel":"medium"} +{"type":"message","id":"773768c4","parentId":"826e9632","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.432Z","message":{"role":"user","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Brunch A14-L probe: the selected specification graph already contains a launch-readiness goal.\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Find the projected code for the existing launch-readiness goal, then use commit_graph to create one new requirement node titled \"Rollback path is documented\" and one legal edge connecting that new requirement to the existing goal by using the existing node's projected code as {existingCode: \"G1\"}. Do not recreate the existing goal. Stop after a successful commit_graph result."}],"timestamp":1780584227426}} +{"type":"message","id":"3736b9aa","parentId":"773768c4","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:52.038Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"**Reviewing projected code**\n\nI need to comply and start by reading the graph to get an overview. After that, I can commit. The user mentioned using the existing node projected code as {existingCode: \"G1\"}? I’m thinking they might be asserting G1. I’ll need to read through it once more to understand it better before proceeding. It's a bit of a process, but careful steps help ensure everything's accurate!","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f25a99c81949eb7206efb0ae8a6\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"content\":[],\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABqIY8oKET-FrN5apljM8bw4_PBgGl_ZC3vraaAGf-TI_qeNsu5fQq_be2hLTxoB0iOtl4Qbq_YvVXz0CHzZ8xwSOwb5PapqAMMCm5KdRyOBQsVW6pyow0yAy5zROByfm87yfRdO5wbJ2kS8jlL835qWfqrBR5DV7ebs0o35cHzEn3RfdD_LEHjZNnLpNKO3-R4FTJT5VqitW88bRGFnuCPOOqybaRsesBd8UhBCOkzwexubo1LPo0JLjCPBPCIcxMZs5Va9XJccxKy8JY_dirzICdRi6sDgEF2Ny8WvuEZgSgDPzc3NrTLfszarWPgF3ytUBPKOIdNJvJ8YmDYcRuJ3QyGOuR0fyB3wDJ8NcCiTe9NJqWetpceMcLGWiyGpNYo2dIpws764AnzTvZd2u_ZFaXveqrKntvqBRvtp0XcpPOT02EZDUrTpbAngRwJlU4kjElHZ5VhiyLMNHI88MoTgYUdpLh12HNMempQGNcsMX0Ya0bGYraBWYrQGLiu6yATOJ161otlbMhR1jFzlLLYGZgtGnJK-oDBQK1SEuX1QPEuS2oKXJU_utafYtgGUjCb0FTbUeUoDEAJqEhif3yj3n7Hu2CFKlrYcxNJLD078VTTZeEY6JU8wnwPP8E_r7qI3gVwnn6avFQJhh1tCh7CUPAMNmeV3sr4rn8No2HpVgeVIISauI9_qLAvcNG2rHQfAceXaZ-eYcCMHqGGmGPMJ6rFkrRWQGnxQeCQrZ-yAzx3HGolrox07jCJDxutZcfKJLA7EZryXI4YB84UESRxDSwG_SXad_HIIOOR18XsA9mJ7lETDv_lkvydrpnhUTupwIB819sM772ToAcViGTrd0FSHpjGJkH8Br_Iz1AsE7bp4wOefTZNtd-m2_-FDc1Hbs-uctV6HVVswIfdJf6LqBSWBmTlU22Qffwd4EQeEJavWFEeAK1T0eXLPO_wyBm9bPKlEZ78r91XIKzn_6EtJVcyfGP3aob_6ct9w_0K6Zr1f5QGxQe_ic0Eiprx1V7x4Um51MdIJPd39utw7wUNHSUHa_Ch6GOYglvZ2vWWdQOke8SIvcdDkAEiw1pYx8dzdU5rKRXIglmIaf0OxDPa0zXVPCYISLdrGYhzFlDjdaAZxBZgAt5Ysr0r0l9SPN33vTOspn96vALI8YSpJ_Hwa9FqpTamo7djw03_aBwUHEb7upvgnKubmDflnCeha7VBIvnkkdZ8Jg3SQEmUERGddipwb_FH24YNaqwAnN3QJ0Gfrudo4C5HIHefScRTWYZ4bzSe\",\"summary\":[{\"type\":\"summary_text\",\"text\":\"**Reviewing projected code**\\n\\nI need to comply and start by reading the graph to get an overview. After that, I can commit. The user mentioned using the existing node projected code as {existingCode: \\\"G1\\\"}? I’m thinking they might be asserting G1. I’ll need to read through it once more to understand it better before proceeding. It's a bit of a process, but careful steps help ensure everything's accurate!\"}]}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_JNItdcpUMUnTwJZmdM5ICToH|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f282204819483d6e326309a307a","name":"read_graph","arguments":{"mode":"overview"}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4361,"output":84,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4445,"cost":{"input":0.021805,"output":0.00252,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.024325000000000003}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584227439,"responseId":"resp_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f24cda88194ab61c1750033d3e8"}} +{"type":"message","id":"4d81e4e6","parentId":"3736b9aa","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:52.041Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_JNItdcpUMUnTwJZmdM5ICToH|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f282204819483d6e326309a307a","toolName":"read_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Graph overview (LSN 3): 1 node(s), 0 edge(s).\n\n- [G1] intent/goal: \"Selected-spec launch readiness goal\""}],"details":{"nodes":[{"id":1,"specId":1,"plane":"intent","kind":"goal","kindOrdinal":1,"title":"Selected-spec launch readiness goal","body":"Pre-existing graph node seeded so the product-path probe must reference it by projected code.","basis":"explicit","createdAtLsn":3,"updatedAtLsn":3}],"edges":[],"nodeCount":1,"edgeCount":0,"lsn":3},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584232041}} +{"type":"message","id":"2c8cdd45","parentId":"4d81e4e6","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:54.338Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_PXtf4teEgh2brEeFH3pSvPOj|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f293748819497696985bb05344c","name":"commit_graph","arguments":{"nodes":[{"ref":"n1","plane":"intent","kind":"requirement","title":"Rollback path is documented","source":"stakeholder"}],"edges":[{"category":"realization","source":"n1","target":{"existingCode":"G1"},"rationale":"Documented rollback path contributes to launch readiness."}]}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4490,"output":80,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4570,"cost":{"input":0.02245,"output":0.0024000000000000002,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.02485}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584232041,"responseId":"resp_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f2877188194bdb8a4285d0506c5"}} +{"type":"message","id":"5381d929","parentId":"2c8cdd45","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:54.343Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_PXtf4teEgh2brEeFH3pSvPOj|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f293748819497696985bb05344c","toolName":"commit_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Graph committed successfully (LSN 4).\nNodes created: n1 → R1\nEdges created: #1"}],"details":{"status":"success","lsn":4,"createdNodes":{"n1":{"id":2,"code":"R1"}},"edges":[1]},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584234343}} +{"type":"message","id":"34ade343","parentId":"5381d929","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:55.727Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Committed successfully: created requirement `R1` and connected it to existing goal `G1`.","textSignature":"{\"v\":1,\"id\":\"msg_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f2b7adc8194a524e56794587062\",\"phase\":\"final_answer\"}"}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":508,"output":23,"cacheRead":4096,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4627,"cost":{"input":0.00254,"output":0.00069,"cacheRead":0.002048,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.005278}},"stopReason":"stop","timestamp":1780584234343,"responseId":"resp_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f2ac4348194845e825b38a91f05"}} diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/transcript.md b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/transcript.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bb087243b --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/transcript.md @@ -0,0 +1,41 @@ +# Transcript — session.jsonl + +## 1. User + +Brunch A14-L probe: the selected specification graph already contains a launch-readiness goal. + +Use read_graph once in overview mode. Find the projected code for the existing launch-readiness goal, then use commit_graph to create one new requirement node titled "Rollback path is documented" and one legal edge connecting that new requirement to the existing goal by using the existing node's projected code as {existingCode: "G1"}. Do not recreate the existing goal. Stop after a successful commit_graph result. + +## 2. Tool result: read_graph + +Graph overview (LSN 3): 1 node(s), 0 edge(s). + +- [G1] intent/goal: "Selected-spec launch readiness goal" + +## 3. Tool result: commit_graph + +Graph committed successfully (LSN 4). +Nodes created: n1 → R1 +Edges created: #1 + +## 4. Assistant + +Committed successfully: created requirement `R1` and connected it to existing goal `G1`. + + +## Raw session JSONL + +```jsonl +{"type":"session","version":3,"id":"019e9317-2252-7279-9f8c-37344e811041","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.410Z","cwd":"/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-7xu0IC"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.session_binding","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"specId":1},"id":"8974359c","parentId":null,"timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.410Z"} +{"type":"session_info","id":"9b2b4431","parentId":"8974359c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.411Z","name":"A14 propose-graph commit proof — session 1"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.agent_runtime_state","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"reason":"switch","state":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"propose-graph","agentLens":"intent","agentGoal":"commit-converge"},"previous":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"auto","agentLens":"auto","agentGoal":"grounding-advance"},"source":"extension"},"id":"6485b0f4","parentId":"9b2b4431","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.411Z"} +{"type":"model_change","id":"889bf235","parentId":"6485b0f4","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.425Z","provider":"openai-codex","modelId":"gpt-5.5"} +{"type":"thinking_level_change","id":"826e9632","parentId":"889bf235","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.425Z","thinkingLevel":"medium"} +{"type":"message","id":"773768c4","parentId":"826e9632","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:47.432Z","message":{"role":"user","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Brunch A14-L probe: the selected specification graph already contains a launch-readiness goal.\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Find the projected code for the existing launch-readiness goal, then use commit_graph to create one new requirement node titled \"Rollback path is documented\" and one legal edge connecting that new requirement to the existing goal by using the existing node's projected code as {existingCode: \"G1\"}. Do not recreate the existing goal. Stop after a successful commit_graph result."}],"timestamp":1780584227426}} +{"type":"message","id":"3736b9aa","parentId":"773768c4","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:52.038Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"**Reviewing projected code**\n\nI need to comply and start by reading the graph to get an overview. After that, I can commit. The user mentioned using the existing node projected code as {existingCode: \"G1\"}? I’m thinking they might be asserting G1. I’ll need to read through it once more to understand it better before proceeding. It's a bit of a process, but careful steps help ensure everything's accurate!","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f25a99c81949eb7206efb0ae8a6\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"content\":[],\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABqIY8oKET-FrN5apljM8bw4_PBgGl_ZC3vraaAGf-TI_qeNsu5fQq_be2hLTxoB0iOtl4Qbq_YvVXz0CHzZ8xwSOwb5PapqAMMCm5KdRyOBQsVW6pyow0yAy5zROByfm87yfRdO5wbJ2kS8jlL835qWfqrBR5DV7ebs0o35cHzEn3RfdD_LEHjZNnLpNKO3-R4FTJT5VqitW88bRGFnuCPOOqybaRsesBd8UhBCOkzwexubo1LPo0JLjCPBPCIcxMZs5Va9XJccxKy8JY_dirzICdRi6sDgEF2Ny8WvuEZgSgDPzc3NrTLfszarWPgF3ytUBPKOIdNJvJ8YmDYcRuJ3QyGOuR0fyB3wDJ8NcCiTe9NJqWetpceMcLGWiyGpNYo2dIpws764AnzTvZd2u_ZFaXveqrKntvqBRvtp0XcpPOT02EZDUrTpbAngRwJlU4kjElHZ5VhiyLMNHI88MoTgYUdpLh12HNMempQGNcsMX0Ya0bGYraBWYrQGLiu6yATOJ161otlbMhR1jFzlLLYGZgtGnJK-oDBQK1SEuX1QPEuS2oKXJU_utafYtgGUjCb0FTbUeUoDEAJqEhif3yj3n7Hu2CFKlrYcxNJLD078VTTZeEY6JU8wnwPP8E_r7qI3gVwnn6avFQJhh1tCh7CUPAMNmeV3sr4rn8No2HpVgeVIISauI9_qLAvcNG2rHQfAceXaZ-eYcCMHqGGmGPMJ6rFkrRWQGnxQeCQrZ-yAzx3HGolrox07jCJDxutZcfKJLA7EZryXI4YB84UESRxDSwG_SXad_HIIOOR18XsA9mJ7lETDv_lkvydrpnhUTupwIB819sM772ToAcViGTrd0FSHpjGJkH8Br_Iz1AsE7bp4wOefTZNtd-m2_-FDc1Hbs-uctV6HVVswIfdJf6LqBSWBmTlU22Qffwd4EQeEJavWFEeAK1T0eXLPO_wyBm9bPKlEZ78r91XIKzn_6EtJVcyfGP3aob_6ct9w_0K6Zr1f5QGxQe_ic0Eiprx1V7x4Um51MdIJPd39utw7wUNHSUHa_Ch6GOYglvZ2vWWdQOke8SIvcdDkAEiw1pYx8dzdU5rKRXIglmIaf0OxDPa0zXVPCYISLdrGYhzFlDjdaAZxBZgAt5Ysr0r0l9SPN33vTOspn96vALI8YSpJ_Hwa9FqpTamo7djw03_aBwUHEb7upvgnKubmDflnCeha7VBIvnkkdZ8Jg3SQEmUERGddipwb_FH24YNaqwAnN3QJ0Gfrudo4C5HIHefScRTWYZ4bzSe\",\"summary\":[{\"type\":\"summary_text\",\"text\":\"**Reviewing projected code**\\n\\nI need to comply and start by reading the graph to get an overview. After that, I can commit. The user mentioned using the existing node projected code as {existingCode: \\\"G1\\\"}? I’m thinking they might be asserting G1. I’ll need to read through it once more to understand it better before proceeding. It's a bit of a process, but careful steps help ensure everything's accurate!\"}]}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_JNItdcpUMUnTwJZmdM5ICToH|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f282204819483d6e326309a307a","name":"read_graph","arguments":{"mode":"overview"}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4361,"output":84,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4445,"cost":{"input":0.021805,"output":0.00252,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.024325000000000003}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584227439,"responseId":"resp_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f24cda88194ab61c1750033d3e8"}} +{"type":"message","id":"4d81e4e6","parentId":"3736b9aa","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:52.041Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_JNItdcpUMUnTwJZmdM5ICToH|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f282204819483d6e326309a307a","toolName":"read_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Graph overview (LSN 3): 1 node(s), 0 edge(s).\n\n- [G1] intent/goal: \"Selected-spec launch readiness goal\""}],"details":{"nodes":[{"id":1,"specId":1,"plane":"intent","kind":"goal","kindOrdinal":1,"title":"Selected-spec launch readiness goal","body":"Pre-existing graph node seeded so the product-path probe must reference it by projected code.","basis":"explicit","createdAtLsn":3,"updatedAtLsn":3}],"edges":[],"nodeCount":1,"edgeCount":0,"lsn":3},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584232041}} +{"type":"message","id":"2c8cdd45","parentId":"4d81e4e6","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:54.338Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_PXtf4teEgh2brEeFH3pSvPOj|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f293748819497696985bb05344c","name":"commit_graph","arguments":{"nodes":[{"ref":"n1","plane":"intent","kind":"requirement","title":"Rollback path is documented","source":"stakeholder"}],"edges":[{"category":"realization","source":"n1","target":{"existingCode":"G1"},"rationale":"Documented rollback path contributes to launch readiness."}]}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4490,"output":80,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4570,"cost":{"input":0.02245,"output":0.0024000000000000002,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.02485}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584232041,"responseId":"resp_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f2877188194bdb8a4285d0506c5"}} +{"type":"message","id":"5381d929","parentId":"2c8cdd45","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:54.343Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_PXtf4teEgh2brEeFH3pSvPOj|fc_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f293748819497696985bb05344c","toolName":"commit_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Graph committed successfully (LSN 4).\nNodes created: n1 → R1\nEdges created: #1"}],"details":{"status":"success","lsn":4,"createdNodes":{"n1":{"id":2,"code":"R1"}},"edges":[1]},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584234343}} +{"type":"message","id":"34ade343","parentId":"5381d929","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:43:55.727Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Committed successfully: created requirement `R1` and connected it to existing goal `G1`.","textSignature":"{\"v\":1,\"id\":\"msg_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f2b7adc8194a524e56794587062\",\"phase\":\"final_answer\"}"}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":508,"output":23,"cacheRead":4096,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4627,"cost":{"input":0.00254,"output":0.00069,"cacheRead":0.002048,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.005278}},"stopReason":"stop","timestamp":1780584234343,"responseId":"resp_015a54da8b565dfd016a218f2ac4348194845e825b38a91f05"}} +``` diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index b36634401..9f0d061ed 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -124,8 +124,8 @@ _None._ - `commitGraph` accepts one approval basis for the batch, returns created ids/kind ordinals, resolves existing-node references from projected codes through adapters, and no longer requires agents to use raw DB ids. - Supersession edge creation validates acyclicity against existing same-spec supersession edges plus proposed batch edges, including intra-batch and mixed cycles. - Graph-truth vs active-context reads are explicit enough that active-context snapshots do not return dangling edges to hidden superseded nodes. - - At least three additional probe scenarios land under `.fixtures/runs/`: existing-node reference, illegal edge/category/stance with retry, and ambiguous prompt where the agent should avoid overcommitting or ask/emit no-op diagnostics according to strategy guidance. - - Probe reports record attempts, retry count, diagnostics seen, final graph counts/LSN, and friction. + - At least three additional probe scenarios land under `.fixtures/runs/`: existing-node reference (landed: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`), illegal edge/category/stance with retry, and ambiguous prompt where the agent should avoid overcommitting or ask/emit no-op diagnostics according to strategy guidance. + - Probe reports record scenario id, attempts, retry count, diagnostics seen, final graph counts/LSN, committed code/title summaries, projected-code usage evidence, and friction. - Tool guidance and `structural_illegal` diagnostics are sufficient for at least one corrected retry path; if not, the report names the gap. - Existing-node refs target the selected spec's graph only. - **Verification:** Inner — schema/domain/CommandExecutor tests for ordinal allocation, basis enum rejection, existing-code resolution, supersession acyclicity, active-context filtering, and tool adapter schema/results. Middle/Outer — real model probe runs with transcript/report artifacts; no artificial injection of the module under test that bypasses the default Brunch runtime factory. diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index f263b5745..78f3616dc 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -109,7 +109,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | A9-L | A session-scoped mention ledger of (`entity_id`, `snapshotted_lsn`) is the right granularity for staleness hints; transcript-scoped or graph-scoped ledgers are not needed for the POC. | low | open | I7-L | M7 — turn-boundary reconciliation slice; observed via fixture runs that stress re-read decisions. | | A11-L | Pi's `prepareNextTurn` plus custom-message delivery are sufficient to express side-task result delivery without inventing a second event plane or forking pi. | medium | open | D15-L | M5 + M7: side-task registry wiring and next-turn delivery proof. | | A13-L | If Brunch later adds deferred observer/auditor jobs, a durable queue keyed by session id and session-exchange entry range can recover async audit/backfill after process interruption without reintroducing canonical chat/turn tables; whether this shares storage with a generalized work-item/reconciliation table can be deferred. | medium | open | D18-L, I14-L | Deferred until async audit/backfill lands: restart/idempotence tests exercise exchange-keyed jobs once graph writes exist. | -| A14-L | LLM elicitor agents can reliably produce graph-structurally-legal graph mutations — both `commitGraph` batches (D53-L) and review-set proposals (D27-L) — as well-formed entity drafts and category-typed edge drafts per [`docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`](file:///Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/brunch-next/docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md) that pass `CommandExecutor` structural validation. The `commitGraph` path under `propose-graph` strategy (D26-L) is the primary proof target: the agent must produce valid multi-node multi-edge batches with intra-batch references from a graph-vocabulary prompt after concept-level user acceptance. | medium | partially validated | D27-L, D51-L, D53-L | **CommitGraph subclaim validated 2026-06-02** by the product-path `propose-graph-commit` probe: the default Brunch runtime factory registered real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` tools, `claude-opus-4-7` produced one structurally legal `commit_graph` batch on the first attempt, and `CommandExecutor` persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges (LSN 2). Artifacts: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`. **Review-set dry-run substrate validated 2026-06-02** by `review-set-proposal.test.ts`: reviewable proposals must carry lens/epistemic/grounding metadata, translate to `commitGraph` input, pass `CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph`, and stay off the review surface when structurally illegal. Remaining open subclaim: real LLM `project-graph` proposal generation against that substrate. Fallback options remain constrained generation, retry-with-feedback, or NL-parse-at-accept if later legality rates regress. | +| A14-L | LLM elicitor agents can reliably produce graph-structurally-legal graph mutations — both `commitGraph` batches (D53-L) and review-set proposals (D27-L) — as well-formed entity drafts and category-typed edge drafts per [`docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`](file:///Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/brunch-next/docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md) that pass `CommandExecutor` structural validation. The `commitGraph` path under `propose-graph` strategy (D26-L) is the primary proof target: the agent must produce valid multi-node multi-edge batches with intra-batch references from a graph-vocabulary prompt after concept-level user acceptance. | medium | partially validated | D27-L, D51-L, D53-L | **CommitGraph subclaim validated 2026-06-02** by the product-path `propose-graph-commit` probe: the default Brunch runtime factory registered real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` tools, `claude-opus-4-7` produced one structurally legal `commit_graph` batch on the first attempt, and `CommandExecutor` persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges (LSN 2). Artifacts: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`. **Existing-code product-path subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`: the default Brunch runtime factory exposed real `read_graph`/`commit_graph`, `gpt-5.5` read projected code `G1`, used `{existingCode: "G1"}` in `commit_graph`, and persisted a requirement plus edge to the pre-existing selected-spec goal without cross-spec writes. **Review-set dry-run substrate validated 2026-06-02** by `review-set-proposal.test.ts`: reviewable proposals must carry lens/epistemic/grounding metadata, translate to `commitGraph` input, pass `CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph`, and stay off the review surface when structurally illegal. Remaining open subclaims: diagnostic retry evidence, ambiguity/no-overcommit behavior, and real LLM `project-graph` proposal generation against that substrate. Fallback options remain constrained generation, retry-with-feedback, or NL-parse-at-accept if later legality rates regress. | | A15-L | Establishment hints carried as structured-exchange payload facets provide sufficient inspectability, fixture-ability, and ambient-affordance source without a separate establishment-needs graph substrate or standalone `brunch.establishment_offer` entry family; whether such a substrate ever shares storage with reconciliation needs can be deferred. | medium | open | D25-L, D30-L | M5+: fixture inspection confirms establishment-offer facets are reconstructable from transcript-backed structured exchanges; chrome/web orientation regions render ambient affordances from the latest such facet. | | A16-L | Reviewer triggering policy (always-on vs lens-keyed) and reviewer scope (batch + how-far-neighborhood) can be deferred to per-lens decisions without architectural commitment now. | low | open | D29-L | M5+: empirical — reviewer integration reveals which policy avoids unacceptable next-turn latency without losing relevant findings. | | A17-L | A user-level temperamental preference for interrogative vs proposal-based elicitation meaningfully affects adoption and eventually warrants expression as a user-level setting. | low | open | D25-L, D26-L | Deferred; surfaces from outer-loop walkthroughs and adversarial fixtures once both single-exchange and batch-proposal flows exist in product. | diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md index 6c2598fcd..b88581059 100644 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md @@ -193,7 +193,7 @@ src/graph/README.md ~ ## Card 3 — Existing-code product-path probe -Status: next +Status: done ### Target Behavior diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts index 7c48ee780..5a7c019b1 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/tool-schemas.ts @@ -79,27 +79,25 @@ export const CommitGraphParams = Type.Object( { additionalProperties: false }, ); -const ReadGraphOverviewParams = Type.Object( - { - mode: Type.Literal('overview'), - }, - { additionalProperties: false }, -); - -const ReadGraphNeighborhoodParams = Type.Object( - { - mode: Type.Literal('neighborhood'), - nodeCode: Type.String({ +export const ReadGraphParams = { + type: 'object', + additionalProperties: false, + required: ['mode'], + properties: { + mode: { enum: ['overview', 'neighborhood'] }, + nodeCode: { + type: 'string', description: 'Projected code of the anchor node in the selected spec, e.g. G1 or CON2', - }), - hops: Type.Optional(Type.Number({ description: 'Neighborhood traversal depth (default: 1)' })), + }, + hops: { type: 'number', description: 'Neighborhood traversal depth (default: 1)' }, }, - { additionalProperties: false }, -); - -export const ReadGraphParams = Type.Union([ReadGraphOverviewParams, ReadGraphNeighborhoodParams]); + description: + 'Read graph overview or a selected-spec node neighborhood. For neighborhood mode, nodeCode is required by the typed adapter contract and missing values return STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics.', +} as const; export type ToolCommitNode = Static; export type ToolCommitEdge = Static; export type ToolCommitGraphParams = Static; -export type ToolReadGraphParams = Static; +export type ToolReadGraphParams = + | { readonly mode: 'overview' } + | { readonly mode: 'neighborhood'; readonly nodeCode: string; readonly hops?: number }; diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts index 9e3e86cdc..adb38ff96 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts @@ -81,7 +81,7 @@ describe('propose-graph commit proof report', () => { { status: 'success', lsn: 1, - nodes: { goal: 1, rollback: 2 }, + createdNodes: { goal: { id: 1, code: 'G1' }, rollback: { id: 2, code: 'R1' } }, edges: [1], }, 'Graph committed successfully', @@ -113,6 +113,60 @@ describe('propose-graph commit proof report', () => { ]); }); + it('classifies existing-code scenario evidence from transcript and final graph', () => { + const sessionText = [ + messageEntry( + 'read_graph', + { nodeCount: 1 }, + '- [G1] intent/goal: "Selected-spec launch readiness goal"', + ), + JSON.stringify({ + type: 'message', + message: { + role: 'assistant', + content: 'Calling commit_graph with {"source":{"existingCode":"G1"},"target":"r1"}', + }, + }), + messageEntry( + 'commit_graph', + { + status: 'success', + lsn: 2, + createdNodes: { r1: { id: 2, code: 'R1' } }, + edges: [1], + }, + 'Graph committed successfully', + ), + ].join('\n'); + + const report = summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof({ + runId: 'existing-code-run', + generatedAt: '2026-06-04T00:00:00.000Z', + cwd: '/tmp/brunch-proof', + specId: 7, + sessionId: 'session-1', + maxAttempts: 2, + sessionText, + overview: successfulOverview, + prompt: 'Use G1 as an existingCode.', + scenarioId: 'existing-code-ref', + expectedExistingCode: 'G1', + }); + + expect(report.success).toBe(true); + expect(report.scenarioId).toBe('existing-code-ref'); + expect(report.projectedCodeEvidence).toEqual({ + codes: ['G1'], + seenInTranscript: true, + usedInCommitParams: true, + existingCodeEdgePresent: true, + }); + expect(report.committedNodes).toEqual([ + { code: 'G1', title: 'Clarify launch readiness' }, + { code: 'R1', title: 'Expose rollback criteria' }, + ]); + }); + it('fails closed when no commit_graph attempt succeeds', () => { const sessionText = messageEntry( 'commit_graph', @@ -160,9 +214,16 @@ describe('propose-graph commit proof report', () => { retryCount: 0, firstAttemptStatus: 'success', finalStatus: 'success', + scenarioId: 'direct-commit', attempts: [{ index: 1, status: 'success', lsn: 1, nodeRefs: { goal: 1 }, edgeIds: [] }], finalGraph: { nodeCount: 1, edgeCount: 0, lsn: 1 }, committedNodeTitles: ['Clarify launch readiness'], + committedNodes: [{ code: 'G1', title: 'Clarify launch readiness' }], + projectedCodeEvidence: { + codes: ['G1'], + seenInTranscript: true, + usedInCommitParams: true, + }, friction: [], }; @@ -171,7 +232,7 @@ describe('propose-graph commit proof report', () => { runId: report.runId, sessionText: messageEntry( 'commit_graph', - { status: 'success', lsn: 1, nodes: { goal: 1 }, edges: [] }, + { status: 'success', lsn: 1, createdNodes: { goal: { id: 1, code: 'G1' } }, edges: [] }, 'Graph committed successfully', ), report, diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts index f0abbac73..925d76379 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts @@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ import { type Diagnostic, type StructuralIllegal, } from '../graph/index.js'; +import { formatGraphNodeCode } from '../graph/schema/nodes.js'; import type { GraphOverview } from '../graph/snapshot.js'; import { renderSessionTranscript } from '../session/session-transcript.js'; import { createWorkspaceSessionCoordinator } from '../session/workspace-session-coordinator.js'; @@ -21,6 +22,8 @@ import { createWorkspaceSessionCoordinator } from '../session/workspace-session- const PROBE_ID = 'propose-graph-commit' as const; const DEFAULT_MAX_ATTEMPTS = 2; +export type ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId = 'direct-commit' | 'existing-code-ref'; + export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofOptions { cwd?: string; fixtureRoot?: string; @@ -28,6 +31,7 @@ export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofOptions { maxAttempts?: number; prompt?: string; agentDir?: string; + scenarioId?: ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId; } export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofArtifacts { @@ -62,6 +66,7 @@ export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofReport { generatedAt: string; mission: string; evaluationFocus: string; + scenarioId: ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId; success: boolean; cwd: string; specId: number; @@ -80,6 +85,13 @@ export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofReport { lsn: number; }; committedNodeTitles: string[]; + committedNodes: Array<{ code: string; title: string }>; + projectedCodeEvidence: { + codes: string[]; + seenInTranscript: boolean; + usedInCommitParams: boolean; + existingCodeEdgePresent?: boolean; + }; friction: string[]; artifacts?: ProposeGraphCommitProofArtifacts; } @@ -95,6 +107,8 @@ export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofSummaryInput { overview: GraphOverview; prompt: string; model?: string; + scenarioId?: ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId; + expectedExistingCode?: string; friction?: readonly string[]; } @@ -104,7 +118,8 @@ export async function runProposeGraphCommitProof( const cwd = options.cwd ?? (await mkdtemp(join(tmpdir(), 'brunch-propose-graph-commit-'))); const runId = options.runId ?? defaultRunId(); const maxAttempts = options.maxAttempts ?? DEFAULT_MAX_ATTEMPTS; - const prompt = options.prompt ?? defaultProofPrompt(); + const scenarioId = options.scenarioId ?? 'direct-commit'; + const prompt = options.prompt ?? defaultProofPrompt(scenarioId); const generatedAt = new Date().toISOString(); const coordinator = createWorkspaceSessionCoordinator({ cwd }); const workspace = await coordinator.createSetupSession({ @@ -119,6 +134,16 @@ export async function runProposeGraphCommitProof( agentGoal: 'commit-converge', }; appendBrunchAgentRuntimeSwitch(workspace.session.manager, runtimeState, 'extension'); + const graph = await openWorkspaceGraphRuntime(cwd); + const gradeResult = graph.commandExecutor.updateReadinessGrade({ + specId: workspace.spec.id, + readinessGrade: 'elicitation_ready', + }); + if (gradeResult.status !== 'success') { + throw new Error('failed to advance probe spec to elicitation_ready'); + } + const expectedExistingCode = seedScenarioGraph(graph, workspace.spec.id, scenarioId); + const specSnapshots = graph.forSpec(workspace.spec.id); const agentDir = options.agentDir ?? getAgentDir(); const createRuntime = createBrunchAgentSessionRuntimeFactory({ workspace, coordinator }); const created = await createRuntime({ @@ -128,8 +153,6 @@ export async function runProposeGraphCommitProof( }); const session = created.session; const friction = created.diagnostics.map((diagnostic) => `${diagnostic.type}: ${diagnostic.message}`); - const graph = await openWorkspaceGraphRuntime(cwd); - const specSnapshots = graph.forSpec(workspace.spec.id); try { await session.sendUserMessage(prompt); @@ -145,6 +168,8 @@ export async function runProposeGraphCommitProof( sessionFile: workspace.session.file, overview: specSnapshots.getGraphOverview(), prompt, + scenarioId, + ...(expectedExistingCode !== undefined ? { expectedExistingCode } : {}), ...(session.model?.id !== undefined ? { model: session.model.id } : {}), friction, }); @@ -162,6 +187,8 @@ export async function runProposeGraphCommitProof( sessionFile: workspace.session.file, overview: specSnapshots.getGraphOverview(), prompt, + scenarioId, + ...(expectedExistingCode !== undefined ? { expectedExistingCode } : {}), ...(session.model?.id !== undefined ? { model: session.model.id } : {}), friction, }); @@ -194,6 +221,8 @@ async function summarizeCurrentRun(options: { overview: GraphOverview; prompt: string; model?: string; + scenarioId?: ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId; + expectedExistingCode?: string; friction: readonly string[]; }): Promise { return summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof({ @@ -206,6 +235,10 @@ async function summarizeCurrentRun(options: { sessionText: await readFile(options.sessionFile, 'utf8'), overview: options.overview, prompt: options.prompt, + ...(options.scenarioId !== undefined ? { scenarioId: options.scenarioId } : {}), + ...(options.expectedExistingCode !== undefined + ? { expectedExistingCode: options.expectedExistingCode } + : {}), ...(options.model !== undefined ? { model: options.model } : {}), friction: options.friction, }); @@ -224,14 +257,27 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( const firstAttemptStatus = attempts[0]?.status ?? 'not_called'; const finalStatus = attempts.at(-1)?.status ?? 'not_called'; const successfulAttempt = lastSuccessfulAttempt(attempts); + const scenarioId = input.scenarioId ?? 'direct-commit'; const finalGraph = { nodeCount: input.overview.nodeCount, edgeCount: input.overview.edgeCount, lsn: input.overview.lsn, }; - const committedNodeTitles = input.overview.nodes.map((node) => node.title); + const committedNodes = input.overview.nodes.map((node) => ({ + code: formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal), + title: node.title, + })); + const committedNodeTitles = committedNodes.map((node) => node.title); + const projectedCodeEvidence = projectedCodeEvidenceFromSummaryInput(input); const friction = [...(input.friction ?? [])]; - const success = successfulAttempt !== undefined && input.overview.nodeCount > 0; + let success = successfulAttempt !== undefined && input.overview.nodeCount > 0; + if (scenarioId === 'existing-code-ref') { + success = + success && + projectedCodeEvidence.seenInTranscript && + projectedCodeEvidence.usedInCommitParams && + projectedCodeEvidence.existingCodeEdgePresent === true; + } if (attempts.length === 0) { friction.push('No commit_graph tool result was recorded.'); @@ -245,6 +291,23 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( if (successfulAttempt !== undefined && input.overview.nodeCount === 0) { friction.push('commit_graph reported success but graph overview is empty.'); } + if (scenarioId === 'existing-code-ref') { + if (!projectedCodeEvidence.seenInTranscript) { + friction.push( + `Expected projected code ${input.expectedExistingCode ?? ''} was not visible in the transcript.`, + ); + } + if (!projectedCodeEvidence.usedInCommitParams) { + friction.push( + `No commit_graph call used expected existingCode ${input.expectedExistingCode ?? ''}.`, + ); + } + if (projectedCodeEvidence.existingCodeEdgePresent !== true) { + friction.push( + `Final graph does not contain an edge incident to expected existing code ${input.expectedExistingCode ?? ''}.`, + ); + } + } return { schemaVersion: 1, @@ -252,7 +315,11 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( runId: input.runId, generatedAt: input.generatedAt, mission: 'Prove the propose-graph strategy can commit graph truth through commit_graph.', - evaluationFocus: 'A14-L structural legality for direct commitGraph batches.', + evaluationFocus: + scenarioId === 'existing-code-ref' + ? 'A14-L selected-spec projected-code reference through the default runtime.' + : 'A14-L structural legality for direct commitGraph batches.', + scenarioId, success, cwd: input.cwd, specId: input.specId, @@ -270,10 +337,51 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( attempts, finalGraph, committedNodeTitles, + committedNodes, + projectedCodeEvidence, friction, }; } +function projectedCodeEvidenceFromSummaryInput( + input: ProposeGraphCommitProofSummaryInput, +): ProposeGraphCommitProofReport['projectedCodeEvidence'] { + const expectedCode = input.expectedExistingCode; + const nodeById = new Map( + input.overview.nodes.map((node) => [node.id, formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal)]), + ); + const codes = [ + ...new Set([...nodeById.values()].filter((code) => expectedCode === undefined || code === expectedCode)), + ]; + const seenInTranscript = expectedCode === undefined || input.sessionText.includes(expectedCode); + const usedInCommitParams = + expectedCode === undefined || + input.sessionText.includes(`"existingCode":"${expectedCode}"`) || + input.sessionText.includes(`"existingCode": "${expectedCode}"`) || + input.sessionText.includes(`\\"existingCode\\":\\"${expectedCode}\\"`) || + input.sessionText.includes(`\\"existingCode\\": \\"${expectedCode}\\"`); + const existingNodeIds = new Set( + input.overview.nodes + .filter( + (node) => + expectedCode === undefined || formatGraphNodeCode(node.kind, node.kindOrdinal) === expectedCode, + ) + .map((node) => node.id), + ); + const existingCodeEdgePresent = + expectedCode === undefined + ? undefined + : input.overview.edges.some( + (edge) => existingNodeIds.has(edge.sourceId) || existingNodeIds.has(edge.targetId), + ); + return { + codes, + seenInTranscript, + usedInCommitParams, + ...(existingCodeEdgePresent !== undefined ? { existingCodeEdgePresent } : {}), + }; +} + function lastSuccessfulAttempt( attempts: readonly CommitGraphAttemptReport[], ): CommitGraphAttemptReport | undefined { @@ -401,7 +509,32 @@ export async function writeProposeGraphCommitProofArtifacts(options: { return artifacts; } -function defaultProofPrompt(): string { +function seedScenarioGraph( + graph: Awaited>, + specId: number, + scenarioId: ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId, +): string | undefined { + if (scenarioId !== 'existing-code-ref') return undefined; + const result = graph.commandExecutor.createNode({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Selected-spec launch readiness goal', + body: 'Pre-existing graph node seeded so the product-path probe must reference it by projected code.', + }); + if (result.status !== 'success') { + throw new Error('failed to seed existing-code-ref graph node'); + } + return 'G1'; +} + +function defaultProofPrompt(scenarioId: ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId): string { + if (scenarioId === 'existing-code-ref') { + return `Brunch A14-L probe: the selected specification graph already contains a launch-readiness goal. + +Use read_graph once in overview mode. Find the projected code for the existing launch-readiness goal, then use commit_graph to create one new requirement node titled "Rollback path is documented" and one legal edge connecting that new requirement to the existing goal by using the existing node's projected code as {existingCode: "G1"}. Do not recreate the existing goal. Stop after a successful commit_graph result.`; + } + return `Brunch A14-L probe: the user has accepted the following concept-level proposal and asked you to persist it now.\n\nConcept: A Brunch specification workspace needs an explicit launch-readiness subgraph that records the launch goal, the rollback requirement, the operator visibility criterion, and the assumption that users can recover from a failed launch.\n\nUse the read_graph tool once in overview mode, then use commit_graph to persist a coherent intent-plane graph. Requirements for the commit_graph call:\n- create at least four intent-plane nodes\n- include at least one goal, one requirement, one criterion, and one assumption\n- create at least three edges connecting the nodes\n- use only legal edge categories from the tool guidance\n- include stance only on support or proof edges\n- avoid decision and term nodes for this proof so detail schemas are not needed\n\nIf commit_graph returns STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL, read the diagnostics and retry once with a corrected complete batch. Stop after a successful commit_graph result.`; } @@ -442,6 +575,12 @@ function parseCliArgs(argv: readonly string[]): ProposeGraphCommitProofOptions { options.maxAttempts = Number(requiredValue(argv, (index += 1), arg)); } else if (arg === '--prompt') { options.prompt = requiredValue(argv, (index += 1), arg); + } else if (arg === '--scenario') { + const scenarioId = requiredValue(argv, (index += 1), arg); + if (scenarioId !== 'direct-commit' && scenarioId !== 'existing-code-ref') { + throw new Error(`Unsupported scenario ${scenarioId}`); + } + options.scenarioId = scenarioId; } } return options; From 39b30e9eea6496737b98460551d2933f74d16956 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:48:12 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 13/21] FE-808: Add retry diagnostics graph probe --- .../2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/report.json | 80 +++++++++++++++++++ .../session.jsonl | 14 ++++ .../transcript.md | 52 ++++++++++++ memory/PLAN.md | 4 +- memory/SPEC.md | 2 +- .../graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md | 2 +- src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts | 46 +++++++++++ src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts | 23 +++++- 8 files changed, 216 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/report.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/session.jsonl create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/transcript.md diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/report.json b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/report.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9556d0e92 --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/report.json @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "probeId": "propose-graph-commit", + "runId": "2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics", + "generatedAt": "2026-06-04T14:46:44.172Z", + "mission": "Prove the propose-graph strategy can commit graph truth through commit_graph.", + "evaluationFocus": "A14-L retry behavior after structured commit_graph diagnostics.", + "scenarioId": "retry-diagnostics", + "success": true, + "cwd": "/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-3Q6x07", + "specId": 1, + "sessionId": "019e9319-d4d7-7bfc-838b-b4b8d3734888", + "prompt": "Brunch A14-L retry diagnostics probe.\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Then intentionally make exactly one structurally illegal commit_graph attempt by creating two intent-plane nodes and a proof edge between them without the required stance field. Read the STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics. Then retry once with a corrected complete batch that creates the same two nodes and a legal proof edge with stance \"for\". Stop after the corrected commit_graph succeeds.", + "model": "gpt-5.5", + "maxAttempts": 2, + "attemptCount": 2, + "retryCount": 1, + "firstAttemptStatus": "structural_illegal", + "finalStatus": "success", + "attempts": [ + { + "index": 1, + "status": "structural_illegal", + "diagnostics": [ + { + "field": "edges[0].stance", + "message": "stance is required for \"proof\" edges" + } + ], + "content": "STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL: The batch was rejected. Fix the following issues and retry:\n\n- edges[0].stance: stance is required for \"proof\" edges" + }, + { + "index": 2, + "status": "success", + "lsn": 3, + "nodeRefs": { + "n1": 1, + "n2": 2 + }, + "edgeIds": [ + 1 + ], + "content": "Graph committed successfully (LSN 3).\nNodes created: n1 → G1, n2 → R1\nEdges created: #1" + } + ], + "finalGraph": { + "nodeCount": 2, + "edgeCount": 1, + "lsn": 3 + }, + "committedNodeTitles": [ + "Retry diagnostics probe source goal", + "Retry diagnostics probe target requirement" + ], + "committedNodes": [ + { + "code": "G1", + "title": "Retry diagnostics probe source goal" + }, + { + "code": "R1", + "title": "Retry diagnostics probe target requirement" + } + ], + "projectedCodeEvidence": { + "codes": [ + "G1", + "R1" + ], + "seenInTranscript": true, + "usedInCommitParams": true + }, + "friction": [], + "artifacts": { + "runDir": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics", + "sessionJsonl": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/session.jsonl", + "transcriptMarkdown": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/transcript.md", + "reportJson": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/report.json" + } +} diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/session.jsonl b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/session.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7594d6193 --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/session.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +{"type":"session","version":3,"id":"019e9319-d4d7-7bfc-838b-b4b8d3734888","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.183Z","cwd":"/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-3Q6x07"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.session_binding","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"specId":1},"id":"e0d8c374","parentId":null,"timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.183Z"} +{"type":"session_info","id":"a1b60a6c","parentId":"e0d8c374","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.183Z","name":"A14 propose-graph commit proof — session 1"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.agent_runtime_state","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"reason":"switch","state":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"propose-graph","agentLens":"intent","agentGoal":"commit-converge"},"previous":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"auto","agentLens":"auto","agentGoal":"grounding-advance"},"source":"extension"},"id":"a689983a","parentId":"a1b60a6c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.184Z"} +{"type":"model_change","id":"e8825eea","parentId":"a689983a","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.197Z","provider":"openai-codex","modelId":"gpt-5.5"} +{"type":"thinking_level_change","id":"a38b42c9","parentId":"e8825eea","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.197Z","thinkingLevel":"medium"} +{"type":"message","id":"fa1d7f60","parentId":"a38b42c9","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.205Z","message":{"role":"user","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Brunch A14-L retry diagnostics probe.\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Then intentionally make exactly one structurally illegal commit_graph attempt by creating two intent-plane nodes and a proof edge between them without the required stance field. Read the STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics. Then retry once with a corrected complete batch that creates the same two nodes and a legal proof edge with stance \"for\". Stop after the corrected commit_graph succeeds."}],"timestamp":1780584404198}} +{"type":"message","id":"08d2503e","parentId":"fa1d7f60","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:47.637Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd6915481919db172cb1aa64b96\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"content\":[],\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABqIY_XzpTgDA6uwKvHDU79nOUnnMSpvtOizMWOM0cSWNRibKtg3DGwelWnEMLQ6CkDK1eiCJV5Wc6Yc5_egcRjKQsdNOp3yyZFBVsMUbVrZANKLtzoVWcbizsfpoXov3M13iWSsN8ZqJjCR3OH_Hiy0YCJQfr12uC2Gzzh-e4zr-qFFgWC4zcer7vGblN155_mPuX0LVDnWu9r49Yp_gv1nUqldllp3WAZwllQUr6J3pKL_wZgQotm-r5s8GHj8uDnVkOWziavcunPnh6rt5w_gjYAOqwk3kZpBik_C7wb6qusE6j3MHb9Z238_-Goe-r7WoxmpkYJPObCArXp3pCddj4yoOPYPBLiAshm9BCrRDeuIi04mXfAmfNK9CiihEw9qBNfPeNjvKg6IwDchva9EtJD_ITYHnIp9tiYJqjoe72lbNaI4uFjyjtvaMd4tyOMajm84p6HyH2IyjFzoVUHnsrJORq5hoLGR1rRqC0lPZcDliFr9HUQZ_6Unwm5FIcVU_DepSkmJuTQNNlITwShrMmWYmpyZ4bEGDUO5gxrmqjl0NFw4Ewa8c7oEDBidyS_IzQoaieyskkLIUCN9dSxhJDus_YYAoBu3CXlc9qYPHzLS2sWwf1KwBUZKlOwvdXtTgaWkNnIHboy6oomd139onq7h0qw9rkdRfse4Frx3I-YZHGQiHWQ7OGi1rOeQqAxH3_f059-0_1m0RylZZ0sxDu5QORjGTqY5-kOM2f1qeweNrpzm9aRdd2LaNTj29yz1U9wn40Q1TsFWyS-gJs_2d66w8jAy27or-bMD9oArsRRoQlmr8362mdtw0v21OpNWDeLj-VlZVVapRnYkx6JoeUb2cSrwv246KzjtjXQGg_ICcjOlPXY1Xo3cP702HzLbUhxdvK8QyAtwJA5gzQb3iANED2MJ_wG5zCQFqcBJj_w0XIHmYYsw7FrGQfYRRguML6w_J8f43lU7od8JK9-MHH5SqintMbYfn9nwdnktdZnVq-XmGq4gwsYCrqENiR4QKdRmaue94cWoEsWINj6yZaCXBGtsil4ZvWSlwB99reRZ6Tka_wmxqXHClyBLytGwEYsV2gdOe-1aZXAwd32QWRKls8E8tot6xgqNhfv34mbv7hEy-VCjVSH5qz0UZldTlmYRg8Dv8UXo0j2CGVdTrQ_0MiC6pTm_bLhrcYieWi7MqlI1ArUfIYGG0qpvnpsMmDI\",\"summary\":[]}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_z905qeEtAIrPxMkUudgmWXYr|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd7ca2c8191add0b7ccc7e387ad","name":"read_graph","arguments":{"mode":"overview"}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4347,"output":65,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4412,"cost":{"input":0.021735,"output":0.0019500000000000001,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.023685}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584404212,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd5c110819188e5a617df7a750b"}} +{"type":"message","id":"aad6eba5","parentId":"08d2503e","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:47.640Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_z905qeEtAIrPxMkUudgmWXYr|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd7ca2c8191add0b7ccc7e387ad","toolName":"read_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"The graph is empty (no nodes or edges)."}],"details":{"nodes":[],"edges":[],"nodeCount":0,"edgeCount":0,"lsn":2},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584407640}} +{"type":"message","id":"a275c203","parentId":"aad6eba5","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:50.916Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_rt8sVxcX4zHvAQUXeCI6OGFP|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd8d6488191b6a20fb9a591ff76","name":"commit_graph","arguments":{"nodes":[{"ref":"n1","plane":"intent","kind":"goal","title":"Retry diagnostics probe source goal","body":"First intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"},{"ref":"n2","plane":"intent","kind":"requirement","title":"Retry diagnostics probe target requirement","body":"Second intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"}],"edges":[{"category":"proof","source":"n1","target":"n2","rationale":"Intentionally missing stance to probe STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics."}]}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4433,"output":135,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4568,"cost":{"input":0.022165,"output":0.00405,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.026215000000000002}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584407640,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd809708191a43824a9ae455156"}} +{"type":"message","id":"554ad47c","parentId":"a275c203","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:50.919Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_rt8sVxcX4zHvAQUXeCI6OGFP|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd8d6488191b6a20fb9a591ff76","toolName":"commit_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL: The batch was rejected. Fix the following issues and retry:\n\n- edges[0].stance: stance is required for \"proof\" edges"}],"details":{"status":"structural_illegal","diagnostics":[{"field":"edges[0].stance","message":"stance is required for \"proof\" edges"}]},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584410919}} +{"type":"message","id":"b045ee6f","parentId":"554ad47c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:54.270Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_lEhv7pxiOBxtjOT2yRxmspYf|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdc189c819189cec9fb8f9f9b7c","name":"commit_graph","arguments":{"nodes":[{"ref":"n1","plane":"intent","kind":"goal","title":"Retry diagnostics probe source goal","body":"First intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"},{"ref":"n2","plane":"intent","kind":"requirement","title":"Retry diagnostics probe target requirement","body":"Second intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"}],"edges":[{"category":"proof","source":"n1","target":"n2","stance":"for","rationale":"Corrected proof edge for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe."}]}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4611,"output":140,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4751,"cost":{"input":0.023055000000000003,"output":0.0042,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.027255}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584410920,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdb48b88191a7cd4ce8a7537563"}} +{"type":"message","id":"8af071d9","parentId":"b045ee6f","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:54.272Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_lEhv7pxiOBxtjOT2yRxmspYf|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdc189c819189cec9fb8f9f9b7c","toolName":"commit_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Graph committed successfully (LSN 3).\nNodes created: n1 → G1, n2 → R1\nEdges created: #1"}],"details":{"status":"success","lsn":3,"createdNodes":{"n1":{"id":1,"code":"G1"},"n2":{"id":2,"code":"R1"}},"edges":[1]},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584414272}} +{"type":"message","id":"d1c7b47e","parentId":"8af071d9","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:55.901Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Corrected commit succeeded.\n\nCreated:\n- `G1`\n- `R1`\n- legal proof edge `#1` with stance `\"for\"`","textSignature":"{\"v\":1,\"id\":\"msg_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdf7a448191b4d0c20723952b0f\",\"phase\":\"final_answer\"}"}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":695,"output":34,"cacheRead":4096,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4825,"cost":{"input":0.0034750000000000002,"output":0.00102,"cacheRead":0.002048,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.006543}},"stopReason":"stop","timestamp":1780584414272,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdedf1c8191b398db50b82c598b"}} diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/transcript.md b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/transcript.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..17b525d6d --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/transcript.md @@ -0,0 +1,52 @@ +# Transcript — session.jsonl + +## 1. User + +Brunch A14-L retry diagnostics probe. + +Use read_graph once in overview mode. Then intentionally make exactly one structurally illegal commit_graph attempt by creating two intent-plane nodes and a proof edge between them without the required stance field. Read the STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics. Then retry once with a corrected complete batch that creates the same two nodes and a legal proof edge with stance "for". Stop after the corrected commit_graph succeeds. + +## 2. Tool result: read_graph + +The graph is empty (no nodes or edges). + +## 3. Tool result: commit_graph + +STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL: The batch was rejected. Fix the following issues and retry: + +- edges[0].stance: stance is required for "proof" edges + +## 4. Tool result: commit_graph + +Graph committed successfully (LSN 3). +Nodes created: n1 → G1, n2 → R1 +Edges created: #1 + +## 5. Assistant + +Corrected commit succeeded. + +Created: +- `G1` +- `R1` +- legal proof edge `#1` with stance `"for"` + + +## Raw session JSONL + +```jsonl +{"type":"session","version":3,"id":"019e9319-d4d7-7bfc-838b-b4b8d3734888","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.183Z","cwd":"/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-3Q6x07"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.session_binding","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"specId":1},"id":"e0d8c374","parentId":null,"timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.183Z"} +{"type":"session_info","id":"a1b60a6c","parentId":"e0d8c374","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.183Z","name":"A14 propose-graph commit proof — session 1"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.agent_runtime_state","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"reason":"switch","state":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"propose-graph","agentLens":"intent","agentGoal":"commit-converge"},"previous":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"auto","agentLens":"auto","agentGoal":"grounding-advance"},"source":"extension"},"id":"a689983a","parentId":"a1b60a6c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.184Z"} +{"type":"model_change","id":"e8825eea","parentId":"a689983a","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.197Z","provider":"openai-codex","modelId":"gpt-5.5"} +{"type":"thinking_level_change","id":"a38b42c9","parentId":"e8825eea","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.197Z","thinkingLevel":"medium"} +{"type":"message","id":"fa1d7f60","parentId":"a38b42c9","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:44.205Z","message":{"role":"user","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Brunch A14-L retry diagnostics probe.\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Then intentionally make exactly one structurally illegal commit_graph attempt by creating two intent-plane nodes and a proof edge between them without the required stance field. Read the STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics. Then retry once with a corrected complete batch that creates the same two nodes and a legal proof edge with stance \"for\". Stop after the corrected commit_graph succeeds."}],"timestamp":1780584404198}} +{"type":"message","id":"08d2503e","parentId":"fa1d7f60","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:47.637Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"","thinkingSignature":"{\"id\":\"rs_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd6915481919db172cb1aa64b96\",\"type\":\"reasoning\",\"content\":[],\"encrypted_content\":\"gAAAAABqIY_XzpTgDA6uwKvHDU79nOUnnMSpvtOizMWOM0cSWNRibKtg3DGwelWnEMLQ6CkDK1eiCJV5Wc6Yc5_egcRjKQsdNOp3yyZFBVsMUbVrZANKLtzoVWcbizsfpoXov3M13iWSsN8ZqJjCR3OH_Hiy0YCJQfr12uC2Gzzh-e4zr-qFFgWC4zcer7vGblN155_mPuX0LVDnWu9r49Yp_gv1nUqldllp3WAZwllQUr6J3pKL_wZgQotm-r5s8GHj8uDnVkOWziavcunPnh6rt5w_gjYAOqwk3kZpBik_C7wb6qusE6j3MHb9Z238_-Goe-r7WoxmpkYJPObCArXp3pCddj4yoOPYPBLiAshm9BCrRDeuIi04mXfAmfNK9CiihEw9qBNfPeNjvKg6IwDchva9EtJD_ITYHnIp9tiYJqjoe72lbNaI4uFjyjtvaMd4tyOMajm84p6HyH2IyjFzoVUHnsrJORq5hoLGR1rRqC0lPZcDliFr9HUQZ_6Unwm5FIcVU_DepSkmJuTQNNlITwShrMmWYmpyZ4bEGDUO5gxrmqjl0NFw4Ewa8c7oEDBidyS_IzQoaieyskkLIUCN9dSxhJDus_YYAoBu3CXlc9qYPHzLS2sWwf1KwBUZKlOwvdXtTgaWkNnIHboy6oomd139onq7h0qw9rkdRfse4Frx3I-YZHGQiHWQ7OGi1rOeQqAxH3_f059-0_1m0RylZZ0sxDu5QORjGTqY5-kOM2f1qeweNrpzm9aRdd2LaNTj29yz1U9wn40Q1TsFWyS-gJs_2d66w8jAy27or-bMD9oArsRRoQlmr8362mdtw0v21OpNWDeLj-VlZVVapRnYkx6JoeUb2cSrwv246KzjtjXQGg_ICcjOlPXY1Xo3cP702HzLbUhxdvK8QyAtwJA5gzQb3iANED2MJ_wG5zCQFqcBJj_w0XIHmYYsw7FrGQfYRRguML6w_J8f43lU7od8JK9-MHH5SqintMbYfn9nwdnktdZnVq-XmGq4gwsYCrqENiR4QKdRmaue94cWoEsWINj6yZaCXBGtsil4ZvWSlwB99reRZ6Tka_wmxqXHClyBLytGwEYsV2gdOe-1aZXAwd32QWRKls8E8tot6xgqNhfv34mbv7hEy-VCjVSH5qz0UZldTlmYRg8Dv8UXo0j2CGVdTrQ_0MiC6pTm_bLhrcYieWi7MqlI1ArUfIYGG0qpvnpsMmDI\",\"summary\":[]}"},{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_z905qeEtAIrPxMkUudgmWXYr|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd7ca2c8191add0b7ccc7e387ad","name":"read_graph","arguments":{"mode":"overview"}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4347,"output":65,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4412,"cost":{"input":0.021735,"output":0.0019500000000000001,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.023685}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584404212,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd5c110819188e5a617df7a750b"}} +{"type":"message","id":"aad6eba5","parentId":"08d2503e","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:47.640Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_z905qeEtAIrPxMkUudgmWXYr|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd7ca2c8191add0b7ccc7e387ad","toolName":"read_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"The graph is empty (no nodes or edges)."}],"details":{"nodes":[],"edges":[],"nodeCount":0,"edgeCount":0,"lsn":2},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584407640}} +{"type":"message","id":"a275c203","parentId":"aad6eba5","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:50.916Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_rt8sVxcX4zHvAQUXeCI6OGFP|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd8d6488191b6a20fb9a591ff76","name":"commit_graph","arguments":{"nodes":[{"ref":"n1","plane":"intent","kind":"goal","title":"Retry diagnostics probe source goal","body":"First intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"},{"ref":"n2","plane":"intent","kind":"requirement","title":"Retry diagnostics probe target requirement","body":"Second intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"}],"edges":[{"category":"proof","source":"n1","target":"n2","rationale":"Intentionally missing stance to probe STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics."}]}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4433,"output":135,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4568,"cost":{"input":0.022165,"output":0.00405,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.026215000000000002}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584407640,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd809708191a43824a9ae455156"}} +{"type":"message","id":"554ad47c","parentId":"a275c203","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:50.919Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_rt8sVxcX4zHvAQUXeCI6OGFP|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fd8d6488191b6a20fb9a591ff76","toolName":"commit_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL: The batch was rejected. Fix the following issues and retry:\n\n- edges[0].stance: stance is required for \"proof\" edges"}],"details":{"status":"structural_illegal","diagnostics":[{"field":"edges[0].stance","message":"stance is required for \"proof\" edges"}]},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584410919}} +{"type":"message","id":"b045ee6f","parentId":"554ad47c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:54.270Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_lEhv7pxiOBxtjOT2yRxmspYf|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdc189c819189cec9fb8f9f9b7c","name":"commit_graph","arguments":{"nodes":[{"ref":"n1","plane":"intent","kind":"goal","title":"Retry diagnostics probe source goal","body":"First intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"},{"ref":"n2","plane":"intent","kind":"requirement","title":"Retry diagnostics probe target requirement","body":"Second intent-plane node for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe.","source":"stakeholder"}],"edges":[{"category":"proof","source":"n1","target":"n2","stance":"for","rationale":"Corrected proof edge for the A14-L retry diagnostics probe."}]}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4611,"output":140,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4751,"cost":{"input":0.023055000000000003,"output":0.0042,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.027255}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584410920,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdb48b88191a7cd4ce8a7537563"}} +{"type":"message","id":"8af071d9","parentId":"b045ee6f","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:54.272Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_lEhv7pxiOBxtjOT2yRxmspYf|fc_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdc189c819189cec9fb8f9f9b7c","toolName":"commit_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Graph committed successfully (LSN 3).\nNodes created: n1 → G1, n2 → R1\nEdges created: #1"}],"details":{"status":"success","lsn":3,"createdNodes":{"n1":{"id":1,"code":"G1"},"n2":{"id":2,"code":"R1"}},"edges":[1]},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584414272}} +{"type":"message","id":"d1c7b47e","parentId":"8af071d9","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:46:55.901Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Corrected commit succeeded.\n\nCreated:\n- `G1`\n- `R1`\n- legal proof edge `#1` with stance `\"for\"`","textSignature":"{\"v\":1,\"id\":\"msg_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdf7a448191b4d0c20723952b0f\",\"phase\":\"final_answer\"}"}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":695,"output":34,"cacheRead":4096,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4825,"cost":{"input":0.0034750000000000002,"output":0.00102,"cacheRead":0.002048,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.006543}},"stopReason":"stop","timestamp":1780584414272,"responseId":"resp_0d07eef4e30d9ba8016a218fdedf1c8191b398db50b82c598b"}} +``` diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index 9f0d061ed..47ebc2a1f 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -124,9 +124,9 @@ _None._ - `commitGraph` accepts one approval basis for the batch, returns created ids/kind ordinals, resolves existing-node references from projected codes through adapters, and no longer requires agents to use raw DB ids. - Supersession edge creation validates acyclicity against existing same-spec supersession edges plus proposed batch edges, including intra-batch and mixed cycles. - Graph-truth vs active-context reads are explicit enough that active-context snapshots do not return dangling edges to hidden superseded nodes. - - At least three additional probe scenarios land under `.fixtures/runs/`: existing-node reference (landed: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`), illegal edge/category/stance with retry, and ambiguous prompt where the agent should avoid overcommitting or ask/emit no-op diagnostics according to strategy guidance. + - At least three additional probe scenarios land under `.fixtures/runs/`: existing-node reference (landed: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`), illegal proof-edge retry (landed: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/`), and ambiguous prompt where the agent should avoid overcommitting or ask/emit no-op diagnostics according to strategy guidance. - Probe reports record scenario id, attempts, retry count, diagnostics seen, final graph counts/LSN, committed code/title summaries, projected-code usage evidence, and friction. - - Tool guidance and `structural_illegal` diagnostics are sufficient for at least one corrected retry path; if not, the report names the gap. + - Tool guidance and `structural_illegal` diagnostics are sufficient for at least one corrected retry path (`2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics`); remaining ambiguity probe should still record any gap as friction rather than hiding it. - Existing-node refs target the selected spec's graph only. - **Verification:** Inner — schema/domain/CommandExecutor tests for ordinal allocation, basis enum rejection, existing-code resolution, supersession acyclicity, active-context filtering, and tool adapter schema/results. Middle/Outer — real model probe runs with transcript/report artifacts; no artificial injection of the module under test that bypasses the default Brunch runtime factory. - **Topology materialization:** Keep probes in `src/probes/` and `.fixtures/runs/`; keep tool adapter code in `src/.pi/extensions/graph/`; keep validators/diagnostics in `src/graph/`; no probe-only graph runtime wiring that product launch does not use. diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index 78f3616dc..f6064bdc0 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -109,7 +109,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | A9-L | A session-scoped mention ledger of (`entity_id`, `snapshotted_lsn`) is the right granularity for staleness hints; transcript-scoped or graph-scoped ledgers are not needed for the POC. | low | open | I7-L | M7 — turn-boundary reconciliation slice; observed via fixture runs that stress re-read decisions. | | A11-L | Pi's `prepareNextTurn` plus custom-message delivery are sufficient to express side-task result delivery without inventing a second event plane or forking pi. | medium | open | D15-L | M5 + M7: side-task registry wiring and next-turn delivery proof. | | A13-L | If Brunch later adds deferred observer/auditor jobs, a durable queue keyed by session id and session-exchange entry range can recover async audit/backfill after process interruption without reintroducing canonical chat/turn tables; whether this shares storage with a generalized work-item/reconciliation table can be deferred. | medium | open | D18-L, I14-L | Deferred until async audit/backfill lands: restart/idempotence tests exercise exchange-keyed jobs once graph writes exist. | -| A14-L | LLM elicitor agents can reliably produce graph-structurally-legal graph mutations — both `commitGraph` batches (D53-L) and review-set proposals (D27-L) — as well-formed entity drafts and category-typed edge drafts per [`docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`](file:///Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/brunch-next/docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md) that pass `CommandExecutor` structural validation. The `commitGraph` path under `propose-graph` strategy (D26-L) is the primary proof target: the agent must produce valid multi-node multi-edge batches with intra-batch references from a graph-vocabulary prompt after concept-level user acceptance. | medium | partially validated | D27-L, D51-L, D53-L | **CommitGraph subclaim validated 2026-06-02** by the product-path `propose-graph-commit` probe: the default Brunch runtime factory registered real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` tools, `claude-opus-4-7` produced one structurally legal `commit_graph` batch on the first attempt, and `CommandExecutor` persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges (LSN 2). Artifacts: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`. **Existing-code product-path subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`: the default Brunch runtime factory exposed real `read_graph`/`commit_graph`, `gpt-5.5` read projected code `G1`, used `{existingCode: "G1"}` in `commit_graph`, and persisted a requirement plus edge to the pre-existing selected-spec goal without cross-spec writes. **Review-set dry-run substrate validated 2026-06-02** by `review-set-proposal.test.ts`: reviewable proposals must carry lens/epistemic/grounding metadata, translate to `commitGraph` input, pass `CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph`, and stay off the review surface when structurally illegal. Remaining open subclaims: diagnostic retry evidence, ambiguity/no-overcommit behavior, and real LLM `project-graph` proposal generation against that substrate. Fallback options remain constrained generation, retry-with-feedback, or NL-parse-at-accept if later legality rates regress. | +| A14-L | LLM elicitor agents can reliably produce graph-structurally-legal graph mutations — both `commitGraph` batches (D53-L) and review-set proposals (D27-L) — as well-formed entity drafts and category-typed edge drafts per [`docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`](file:///Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/brunch-next/docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md) that pass `CommandExecutor` structural validation. The `commitGraph` path under `propose-graph` strategy (D26-L) is the primary proof target: the agent must produce valid multi-node multi-edge batches with intra-batch references from a graph-vocabulary prompt after concept-level user acceptance. | medium | partially validated | D27-L, D51-L, D53-L | **CommitGraph subclaim validated 2026-06-02** by the product-path `propose-graph-commit` probe: the default Brunch runtime factory registered real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` tools, `claude-opus-4-7` produced one structurally legal `commit_graph` batch on the first attempt, and `CommandExecutor` persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges (LSN 2). Artifacts: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`. **Existing-code product-path subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`: the default Brunch runtime factory exposed real `read_graph`/`commit_graph`, `gpt-5.5` read projected code `G1`, used `{existingCode: "G1"}` in `commit_graph`, and persisted a requirement plus edge to the pre-existing selected-spec goal without cross-spec writes. **Retry-diagnostics subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/`: the default runtime recorded one `structural_illegal` proof-edge attempt with stance diagnostics, then a corrected retry that persisted two nodes and one legal proof edge with no partial state from the failed attempt. **Review-set dry-run substrate validated 2026-06-02** by `review-set-proposal.test.ts`: reviewable proposals must carry lens/epistemic/grounding metadata, translate to `commitGraph` input, pass `CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph`, and stay off the review surface when structurally illegal. Remaining open subclaims: ambiguity/no-overcommit behavior and real LLM `project-graph` proposal generation against that substrate. Fallback options remain constrained generation, retry-with-feedback, or NL-parse-at-accept if later legality rates regress. | | A15-L | Establishment hints carried as structured-exchange payload facets provide sufficient inspectability, fixture-ability, and ambient-affordance source without a separate establishment-needs graph substrate or standalone `brunch.establishment_offer` entry family; whether such a substrate ever shares storage with reconciliation needs can be deferred. | medium | open | D25-L, D30-L | M5+: fixture inspection confirms establishment-offer facets are reconstructable from transcript-backed structured exchanges; chrome/web orientation regions render ambient affordances from the latest such facet. | | A16-L | Reviewer triggering policy (always-on vs lens-keyed) and reviewer scope (batch + how-far-neighborhood) can be deferred to per-lens decisions without architectural commitment now. | low | open | D29-L | M5+: empirical — reviewer integration reveals which policy avoids unacceptable next-turn latency without losing relevant findings. | | A17-L | A user-level temperamental preference for interrogative vs proposal-based elicitation meaningfully affects adoption and eventually warrants expression as a user-level setting. | low | open | D25-L, D26-L | Deferred; surfaces from outer-loop walkthroughs and adversarial fixtures once both single-exchange and batch-proposal flows exist in product. | diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md index b88581059..c6debb179 100644 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md @@ -256,7 +256,7 @@ src/probes/ ## Card 4 — Retry-diagnostics product-path probe -Status: next +Status: done ### Target Behavior diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts index adb38ff96..1011ed83d 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts @@ -167,6 +167,52 @@ describe('propose-graph commit proof report', () => { ]); }); + it('classifies retry-diagnostics scenario first/final statuses and diagnostics', () => { + const sessionText = [ + messageEntry( + 'commit_graph', + { + status: 'structural_illegal', + diagnostics: [{ field: 'edges[0].stance', message: 'stance is required for proof edges' }], + }, + 'STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL', + ), + messageEntry( + 'commit_graph', + { + status: 'success', + lsn: 2, + createdNodes: { p1: { id: 1, code: 'CR1' }, p2: { id: 2, code: 'G1' } }, + edges: [1], + }, + 'Graph committed successfully', + ), + ].join('\n'); + + const report = summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof({ + runId: 'retry-run', + generatedAt: '2026-06-04T00:00:00.000Z', + cwd: '/tmp/brunch-proof', + specId: 7, + sessionId: 'session-1', + maxAttempts: 2, + sessionText, + overview: successfulOverview, + prompt: 'Retry after diagnostics.', + scenarioId: 'retry-diagnostics', + }); + + expect(report.success).toBe(true); + expect(report.firstAttemptStatus).toBe('structural_illegal'); + expect(report.finalStatus).toBe('success'); + expect(report.retryCount).toBe(1); + expect(report.attempts[0]?.diagnostics).toEqual([ + { field: 'edges[0].stance', message: 'stance is required for proof edges' }, + ]); + expect(report.finalGraph).toMatchObject({ nodeCount: 2, edgeCount: 1, lsn: 1 }); + expect(report.friction).toEqual([]); + }); + it('fails closed when no commit_graph attempt succeeds', () => { const sessionText = messageEntry( 'commit_graph', diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts index 925d76379..12230c566 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ import { createWorkspaceSessionCoordinator } from '../session/workspace-session- const PROBE_ID = 'propose-graph-commit' as const; const DEFAULT_MAX_ATTEMPTS = 2; -export type ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId = 'direct-commit' | 'existing-code-ref'; +export type ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId = 'direct-commit' | 'existing-code-ref' | 'retry-diagnostics'; export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofOptions { cwd?: string; @@ -278,6 +278,12 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( projectedCodeEvidence.usedInCommitParams && projectedCodeEvidence.existingCodeEdgePresent === true; } + if (scenarioId === 'retry-diagnostics') { + success = + attempts.some((attempt) => attempt.status === 'structural_illegal') && + successfulAttempt !== undefined && + input.overview.nodeCount > 0; + } if (attempts.length === 0) { friction.push('No commit_graph tool result was recorded.'); @@ -318,7 +324,9 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( evaluationFocus: scenarioId === 'existing-code-ref' ? 'A14-L selected-spec projected-code reference through the default runtime.' - : 'A14-L structural legality for direct commitGraph batches.', + : scenarioId === 'retry-diagnostics' + ? 'A14-L retry behavior after structured commit_graph diagnostics.' + : 'A14-L structural legality for direct commitGraph batches.', scenarioId, success, cwd: input.cwd, @@ -534,6 +542,11 @@ function defaultProofPrompt(scenarioId: ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId): string { Use read_graph once in overview mode. Find the projected code for the existing launch-readiness goal, then use commit_graph to create one new requirement node titled "Rollback path is documented" and one legal edge connecting that new requirement to the existing goal by using the existing node's projected code as {existingCode: "G1"}. Do not recreate the existing goal. Stop after a successful commit_graph result.`; } + if (scenarioId === 'retry-diagnostics') { + return `Brunch A14-L retry diagnostics probe. + +Use read_graph once in overview mode. Then intentionally make exactly one structurally illegal commit_graph attempt by creating two intent-plane nodes and a proof edge between them without the required stance field. Read the STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics. Then retry once with a corrected complete batch that creates the same two nodes and a legal proof edge with stance "for". Stop after the corrected commit_graph succeeds.`; + } return `Brunch A14-L probe: the user has accepted the following concept-level proposal and asked you to persist it now.\n\nConcept: A Brunch specification workspace needs an explicit launch-readiness subgraph that records the launch goal, the rollback requirement, the operator visibility criterion, and the assumption that users can recover from a failed launch.\n\nUse the read_graph tool once in overview mode, then use commit_graph to persist a coherent intent-plane graph. Requirements for the commit_graph call:\n- create at least four intent-plane nodes\n- include at least one goal, one requirement, one criterion, and one assumption\n- create at least three edges connecting the nodes\n- use only legal edge categories from the tool guidance\n- include stance only on support or proof edges\n- avoid decision and term nodes for this proof so detail schemas are not needed\n\nIf commit_graph returns STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL, read the diagnostics and retry once with a corrected complete batch. Stop after a successful commit_graph result.`; } @@ -577,7 +590,11 @@ function parseCliArgs(argv: readonly string[]): ProposeGraphCommitProofOptions { options.prompt = requiredValue(argv, (index += 1), arg); } else if (arg === '--scenario') { const scenarioId = requiredValue(argv, (index += 1), arg); - if (scenarioId !== 'direct-commit' && scenarioId !== 'existing-code-ref') { + if ( + scenarioId !== 'direct-commit' && + scenarioId !== 'existing-code-ref' && + scenarioId !== 'retry-diagnostics' + ) { throw new Error(`Unsupported scenario ${scenarioId}`); } options.scenarioId = scenarioId; From 91676bc84c521d773b4358d9afe5b4ff87db7f67 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 16:52:00 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 14/21] FE-808: Add ambiguity no-overcommit probe --- .../report.json | 41 ++ .../session.jsonl | 10 + .../transcript.md | 35 ++ memory/PLAN.md | 14 +- memory/SPEC.md | 2 +- .../graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md | 378 ------------------ src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts | 54 +++ src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts | 76 +++- 8 files changed, 220 insertions(+), 390 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/report.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/session.jsonl create mode 100644 .fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/transcript.md delete mode 100644 memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/report.json b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/report.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..feab69715 --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/report.json @@ -0,0 +1,41 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": 1, + "probeId": "propose-graph-commit", + "runId": "2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit", + "generatedAt": "2026-06-04T14:50:13.707Z", + "mission": "Prove the propose-graph strategy can commit graph truth through commit_graph.", + "evaluationFocus": "A14-L ambiguity handling without unsupported graph overcommit.", + "scenarioId": "ambiguity-no-overcommit", + "success": true, + "cwd": "/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-qHP5ki", + "specId": 1, + "sessionId": "019e931d-0757-7c85-874a-186bffe8dea6", + "prompt": "Brunch A14-L ambiguity/no-overcommit probe.\n\nThe user says: \"Maybe our launch process has some risk somewhere; please update the spec graph if that seems useful.\"\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Because the prompt does not provide a concrete accepted graph fact, do not call commit_graph. Instead, respond with a concise clarification request or explanation that there is not enough accepted graph truth to commit yet.", + "model": "gpt-5.5", + "maxAttempts": 2, + "attemptCount": 0, + "retryCount": 0, + "firstAttemptStatus": "not_called", + "finalStatus": "not_called", + "attempts": [], + "finalGraph": { + "nodeCount": 0, + "edgeCount": 0, + "lsn": 2 + }, + "committedNodeTitles": [], + "committedNodes": [], + "projectedCodeEvidence": { + "codes": [], + "seenInTranscript": true, + "usedInCommitParams": true + }, + "ambiguityOutcome": "no_op_or_clarification", + "friction": [], + "artifacts": { + "runDir": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit", + "sessionJsonl": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/session.jsonl", + "transcriptMarkdown": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/transcript.md", + "reportJson": ".fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/report.json" + } +} diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/session.jsonl b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/session.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ccfc80682 --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/session.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +{"type":"session","version":3,"id":"019e931d-0757-7c85-874a-186bffe8dea6","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.719Z","cwd":"/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-qHP5ki"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.session_binding","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"specId":1},"id":"4992f665","parentId":null,"timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.719Z"} +{"type":"session_info","id":"f6c45104","parentId":"4992f665","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.720Z","name":"A14 propose-graph commit proof — session 1"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.agent_runtime_state","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"reason":"switch","state":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"propose-graph","agentLens":"intent","agentGoal":"commit-converge"},"previous":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"auto","agentLens":"auto","agentGoal":"grounding-advance"},"source":"extension"},"id":"4092686c","parentId":"f6c45104","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.720Z"} +{"type":"model_change","id":"35934d3c","parentId":"4092686c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.734Z","provider":"openai-codex","modelId":"gpt-5.5"} +{"type":"thinking_level_change","id":"2c1b1e3a","parentId":"35934d3c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.734Z","thinkingLevel":"medium"} +{"type":"message","id":"be87e6f6","parentId":"2c1b1e3a","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.742Z","message":{"role":"user","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Brunch A14-L ambiguity/no-overcommit probe.\n\nThe user says: \"Maybe our launch process has some risk somewhere; please update the spec graph if that seems useful.\"\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Because the prompt does not provide a concrete accepted graph fact, do not call commit_graph. Instead, respond with a concise clarification request or explanation that there is not enough accepted graph truth to commit yet."}],"timestamp":1780584613735}} +{"type":"message","id":"5de4ce33","parentId":"be87e6f6","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:16.090Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_YcvsKdc4mmvUz81Tevwu8YbJ|fc_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a8138881958817b595c6d97929","name":"read_graph","arguments":{"mode":"overview"}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4342,"output":18,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4360,"cost":{"input":0.02171,"output":0.00054,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.02225}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584613749,"responseId":"resp_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a74f088195b48f92b7dd9f2348"}} +{"type":"message","id":"69d8e3b5","parentId":"5de4ce33","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:16.092Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_YcvsKdc4mmvUz81Tevwu8YbJ|fc_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a8138881958817b595c6d97929","toolName":"read_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"The graph is empty (no nodes or edges)."}],"details":{"nodes":[],"edges":[],"nodeCount":0,"edgeCount":0,"lsn":2},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584616092}} +{"type":"message","id":"ef816515","parentId":"69d8e3b5","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:18.216Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"text","text":"I don’t have enough accepted graph truth to commit anything yet. The graph is empty, and “some risk somewhere” is too ambiguous to turn into a durable spec node without overcommitting.\n\nPlease clarify the concrete launch risk, e.g. affected process step, failure mode, likelihood/impact, or required mitigation.","textSignature":"{\"v\":1,\"id\":\"msg_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a91ad481959abccff0908eeb2c\",\"phase\":\"final_answer\"}"}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4381,"output":68,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4449,"cost":{"input":0.021905,"output":0.00204,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.023945}},"stopReason":"stop","timestamp":1780584616093,"responseId":"resp_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a8944c8195a4375d4db5396901"}} diff --git a/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/transcript.md b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/transcript.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c435b1ba3 --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/transcript.md @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +# Transcript — session.jsonl + +## 1. User + +Brunch A14-L ambiguity/no-overcommit probe. + +The user says: "Maybe our launch process has some risk somewhere; please update the spec graph if that seems useful." + +Use read_graph once in overview mode. Because the prompt does not provide a concrete accepted graph fact, do not call commit_graph. Instead, respond with a concise clarification request or explanation that there is not enough accepted graph truth to commit yet. + +## 2. Tool result: read_graph + +The graph is empty (no nodes or edges). + +## 3. Assistant + +I don’t have enough accepted graph truth to commit anything yet. The graph is empty, and “some risk somewhere” is too ambiguous to turn into a durable spec node without overcommitting. + +Please clarify the concrete launch risk, e.g. affected process step, failure mode, likelihood/impact, or required mitigation. + + +## Raw session JSONL + +```jsonl +{"type":"session","version":3,"id":"019e931d-0757-7c85-874a-186bffe8dea6","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.719Z","cwd":"/var/folders/2c/ptn6jcrj61lck_yzfz_p3b5m0000gn/T/brunch-propose-graph-commit-qHP5ki"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.session_binding","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"specId":1},"id":"4992f665","parentId":null,"timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.719Z"} +{"type":"session_info","id":"f6c45104","parentId":"4992f665","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.720Z","name":"A14 propose-graph commit proof — session 1"} +{"type":"custom","customType":"brunch.agent_runtime_state","data":{"schemaVersion":1,"reason":"switch","state":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"propose-graph","agentLens":"intent","agentGoal":"commit-converge"},"previous":{"schemaVersion":1,"operationalMode":"elicit","agentStrategy":"auto","agentLens":"auto","agentGoal":"grounding-advance"},"source":"extension"},"id":"4092686c","parentId":"f6c45104","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.720Z"} +{"type":"model_change","id":"35934d3c","parentId":"4092686c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.734Z","provider":"openai-codex","modelId":"gpt-5.5"} +{"type":"thinking_level_change","id":"2c1b1e3a","parentId":"35934d3c","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.734Z","thinkingLevel":"medium"} +{"type":"message","id":"be87e6f6","parentId":"2c1b1e3a","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:13.742Z","message":{"role":"user","content":[{"type":"text","text":"Brunch A14-L ambiguity/no-overcommit probe.\n\nThe user says: \"Maybe our launch process has some risk somewhere; please update the spec graph if that seems useful.\"\n\nUse read_graph once in overview mode. Because the prompt does not provide a concrete accepted graph fact, do not call commit_graph. Instead, respond with a concise clarification request or explanation that there is not enough accepted graph truth to commit yet."}],"timestamp":1780584613735}} +{"type":"message","id":"5de4ce33","parentId":"be87e6f6","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:16.090Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"toolCall","id":"call_YcvsKdc4mmvUz81Tevwu8YbJ|fc_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a8138881958817b595c6d97929","name":"read_graph","arguments":{"mode":"overview"}}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4342,"output":18,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4360,"cost":{"input":0.02171,"output":0.00054,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.02225}},"stopReason":"toolUse","timestamp":1780584613749,"responseId":"resp_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a74f088195b48f92b7dd9f2348"}} +{"type":"message","id":"69d8e3b5","parentId":"5de4ce33","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:16.092Z","message":{"role":"toolResult","toolCallId":"call_YcvsKdc4mmvUz81Tevwu8YbJ|fc_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a8138881958817b595c6d97929","toolName":"read_graph","content":[{"type":"text","text":"The graph is empty (no nodes or edges)."}],"details":{"nodes":[],"edges":[],"nodeCount":0,"edgeCount":0,"lsn":2},"isError":false,"timestamp":1780584616092}} +{"type":"message","id":"ef816515","parentId":"69d8e3b5","timestamp":"2026-06-04T14:50:18.216Z","message":{"role":"assistant","content":[{"type":"text","text":"I don’t have enough accepted graph truth to commit anything yet. The graph is empty, and “some risk somewhere” is too ambiguous to turn into a durable spec node without overcommitting.\n\nPlease clarify the concrete launch risk, e.g. affected process step, failure mode, likelihood/impact, or required mitigation.","textSignature":"{\"v\":1,\"id\":\"msg_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a91ad481959abccff0908eeb2c\",\"phase\":\"final_answer\"}"}],"api":"openai-codex-responses","provider":"openai-codex","model":"gpt-5.5","usage":{"input":4381,"output":68,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"totalTokens":4449,"cost":{"input":0.021905,"output":0.00204,"cacheRead":0,"cacheWrite":0,"total":0.023945}},"stopReason":"stop","timestamp":1780584616093,"responseId":"resp_007707ab5d551f91016a2190a8944c8195a4375d4db5396901"}} +``` diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index 47ebc2a1f..dd467c14a 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -111,7 +111,7 @@ _None._ - **Linear:** [FE-808](https://linear.app/hash/issue/FE-808/broaden-direct-graph-tool-proof-beyond-the-a14-happy-path) - **Branch:** `ln/fe-808-graph-tool-resilience` - **Kind:** structural hardening / tracer bullet -- **Status:** in progress +- **Status:** done - **Certainty:** proving - **Stabilizes:** I34-L, I39-L, I40-L, I41-L — graph writes need stable node handles, correct approval basis, and supersession acyclicity before capture/review frontiers build on them. - **Lights up:** real `read_graph` / `commit_graph` path with projected existing-node references, diagnostics/retry, and no-overcommit behavior through the default Brunch runtime factory. @@ -124,16 +124,16 @@ _None._ - `commitGraph` accepts one approval basis for the batch, returns created ids/kind ordinals, resolves existing-node references from projected codes through adapters, and no longer requires agents to use raw DB ids. - Supersession edge creation validates acyclicity against existing same-spec supersession edges plus proposed batch edges, including intra-batch and mixed cycles. - Graph-truth vs active-context reads are explicit enough that active-context snapshots do not return dangling edges to hidden superseded nodes. - - At least three additional probe scenarios land under `.fixtures/runs/`: existing-node reference (landed: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`), illegal proof-edge retry (landed: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/`), and ambiguous prompt where the agent should avoid overcommitting or ask/emit no-op diagnostics according to strategy guidance. - - Probe reports record scenario id, attempts, retry count, diagnostics seen, final graph counts/LSN, committed code/title summaries, projected-code usage evidence, and friction. - - Tool guidance and `structural_illegal` diagnostics are sufficient for at least one corrected retry path (`2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics`); remaining ambiguity probe should still record any gap as friction rather than hiding it. + - Additional probe scenarios landed under `.fixtures/runs/`: existing-node reference (`2026-06-04-existing-code-ref`), illegal proof-edge retry (`2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics`), and ambiguity/no-overcommit (`2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit`). + - Probe reports record scenario id, attempts, retry count, diagnostics seen, final graph counts/LSN, committed code/title summaries, projected-code/ambiguity outcome evidence, and friction. + - Tool guidance and `structural_illegal` diagnostics are sufficient for at least one corrected retry path (`2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics`); ambiguity probe records no unsupported graph writes. - Existing-node refs target the selected spec's graph only. - **Verification:** Inner — schema/domain/CommandExecutor tests for ordinal allocation, basis enum rejection, existing-code resolution, supersession acyclicity, active-context filtering, and tool adapter schema/results. Middle/Outer — real model probe runs with transcript/report artifacts; no artificial injection of the module under test that bypasses the default Brunch runtime factory. - **Topology materialization:** Keep probes in `src/probes/` and `.fixtures/runs/`; keep tool adapter code in `src/.pi/extensions/graph/`; keep validators/diagnostics in `src/graph/`; no probe-only graph runtime wiring that product launch does not use. - **Cross-cutting obligations:** Avoid harness-as-false-proof: the probe must exercise the same default Brunch runtime factory and registered tools that the product uses. Record fitness, not just pass/fail. Preserve D62-L/D63-L/D64-L as graph-wide contracts rather than adapter-local conveniences. - **Traceability:** D4-L, D20-L, D51-L, D53-L, D60-L, D62-L, D63-L, D64-L / I34-L, I35-L, I39-L, I40-L, I41-L / A14-L, A5-L. - **Design docs:** `docs/architecture/probes-and-transcripts.md`; `docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`. -- **Current execution pointer:** `memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md` scopes the cleanup and remaining product-path probe closure chain for FE-808. +- **Current execution pointer:** FE-808 closure chain completed; no active scope file remains. ### project-graph-review-cycle @@ -236,7 +236,7 @@ _None._ - **Design docs:** `src/README.md`; `src/.pi/README.md`; `src/agents/README.md`; `src/db/README.md`; `src/graph/README.md`; `src/rpc/README.md`; `src/session/README.md`; `src/web/README.md`. ## Recently Completed -- 2026-06-04 `graph-tool-resilience` graph write contract chain — Done: graph nodes persist per-kind ordinals and expose projected codes; `commitGraph` applies one explicit/implicit batch basis; adapters resolve existing-node codes inside the selected spec; same-spec supersession cycles are rejected atomically; active-context graph reads omit hidden superseded nodes and dangling edges while graph-truth reads remain available. +- 2026-06-04 `graph-tool-resilience` (FE-808) — Done: graph nodes persist per-kind ordinals and expose projected codes; `commitGraph` applies one explicit/implicit batch basis, returns one created-node identity shape, and shares dry-run/commit structural planning; adapters resolve selected-spec existing-node codes into structured diagnostics instead of throwing; same-spec supersession cycles are rejected atomically; active-context graph reads omit hidden superseded nodes and dangling edges while graph-truth reads remain available; product-path probes landed existing-code, retry-diagnostics, and ambiguity/no-overcommit evidence under `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/`. - 2026-06-04 `agents-composition-layer` (FE-806) — Done: `agents/state.ts`/`compose.ts` emit runtime headers and gated prompt-resource manifests; `agents/contexts/{cwd,graph,node}.ts` renders selected-spec context with lens-specific emphasis; the real `.pi` `before_agent_start` product path supplies selected-spec-bound graph snapshots from the Brunch runtime factory; the legacy `src/.pi/context/` prompt-pack subtree is deleted after folding its useful guidance into `src/agents/methods/*.md`; deterministic product-path proof records strategy/lens posture differences and accepted blind spots. Verified: context/compose/prompting/architecture tests and `npm run verify`. Watch: prompt quality is fitness evidence only; graph-write resilience and capture quality remain with the next P0 frontiers. - 2026-06-04 `live-graph-observer` (FE-795) — Done: `graph.overview` and `graph.nodeNeighborhood` are discoverable selected-spec RPC reads; graph readers remain in `graph/`; TUI/agent `commit_graph` publishes graph invalidation topics through the shared product-update bus; the TUI launch path starts a read-only web sidecar over the same bus; the React web app attaches over one WebSocket RPC client, renders the selected-spec graph overview, and invalidates/refetches canonical graph readers on `brunch.updated`. Verified: targeted FE-795 test set (`src/rpc/handlers.test.ts`, `src/rpc/web-host.test.ts`, `src/web/app.test.tsx`, `src/brunch-tui.test.ts`, `src/graph/snapshot.test.ts`, `src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts`), `npm run build`, and a 2026-06-04 `agent-browser` smoke that observed empty graph state then a `commit_graph`-created node in the browser without reload. Watch: richer node-neighborhood UI remains optional polish; the current proof exposes/query-backs the focused read and renders the overview. @@ -249,7 +249,7 @@ Older history (including `sealed-pi-profile-runtime-state`, `pi-ui-extension-pat ```text nodes: - graph-tool-resilience [next · P0] materializes graph write contract and broadens A14 proof + graph-tool-resilience [done · P0] materialized graph write contract and broadened A14 proof capture-response-to-graph [next · P0] structured answer -> graph truth -> observer update project-graph-review-cycle [next · P1] real project-graph review-set approval loop minimal-authority-shell [next · P1] thin safety posture for current POC paths diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index f6064bdc0..d9a15790f 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -109,7 +109,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | A9-L | A session-scoped mention ledger of (`entity_id`, `snapshotted_lsn`) is the right granularity for staleness hints; transcript-scoped or graph-scoped ledgers are not needed for the POC. | low | open | I7-L | M7 — turn-boundary reconciliation slice; observed via fixture runs that stress re-read decisions. | | A11-L | Pi's `prepareNextTurn` plus custom-message delivery are sufficient to express side-task result delivery without inventing a second event plane or forking pi. | medium | open | D15-L | M5 + M7: side-task registry wiring and next-turn delivery proof. | | A13-L | If Brunch later adds deferred observer/auditor jobs, a durable queue keyed by session id and session-exchange entry range can recover async audit/backfill after process interruption without reintroducing canonical chat/turn tables; whether this shares storage with a generalized work-item/reconciliation table can be deferred. | medium | open | D18-L, I14-L | Deferred until async audit/backfill lands: restart/idempotence tests exercise exchange-keyed jobs once graph writes exist. | -| A14-L | LLM elicitor agents can reliably produce graph-structurally-legal graph mutations — both `commitGraph` batches (D53-L) and review-set proposals (D27-L) — as well-formed entity drafts and category-typed edge drafts per [`docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`](file:///Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/brunch-next/docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md) that pass `CommandExecutor` structural validation. The `commitGraph` path under `propose-graph` strategy (D26-L) is the primary proof target: the agent must produce valid multi-node multi-edge batches with intra-batch references from a graph-vocabulary prompt after concept-level user acceptance. | medium | partially validated | D27-L, D51-L, D53-L | **CommitGraph subclaim validated 2026-06-02** by the product-path `propose-graph-commit` probe: the default Brunch runtime factory registered real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` tools, `claude-opus-4-7` produced one structurally legal `commit_graph` batch on the first attempt, and `CommandExecutor` persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges (LSN 2). Artifacts: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`. **Existing-code product-path subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`: the default Brunch runtime factory exposed real `read_graph`/`commit_graph`, `gpt-5.5` read projected code `G1`, used `{existingCode: "G1"}` in `commit_graph`, and persisted a requirement plus edge to the pre-existing selected-spec goal without cross-spec writes. **Retry-diagnostics subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/`: the default runtime recorded one `structural_illegal` proof-edge attempt with stance diagnostics, then a corrected retry that persisted two nodes and one legal proof edge with no partial state from the failed attempt. **Review-set dry-run substrate validated 2026-06-02** by `review-set-proposal.test.ts`: reviewable proposals must carry lens/epistemic/grounding metadata, translate to `commitGraph` input, pass `CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph`, and stay off the review surface when structurally illegal. Remaining open subclaims: ambiguity/no-overcommit behavior and real LLM `project-graph` proposal generation against that substrate. Fallback options remain constrained generation, retry-with-feedback, or NL-parse-at-accept if later legality rates regress. | +| A14-L | LLM elicitor agents can reliably produce graph-structurally-legal graph mutations — both `commitGraph` batches (D53-L) and review-set proposals (D27-L) — as well-formed entity drafts and category-typed edge drafts per [`docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`](file:///Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/brunch-next/docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md) that pass `CommandExecutor` structural validation. The `commitGraph` path under `propose-graph` strategy (D26-L) is the primary proof target: the agent must produce valid multi-node multi-edge batches with intra-batch references from a graph-vocabulary prompt after concept-level user acceptance. | medium | partially validated | D27-L, D51-L, D53-L | **CommitGraph subclaim validated 2026-06-02** by the product-path `propose-graph-commit` probe: the default Brunch runtime factory registered real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` tools, `claude-opus-4-7` produced one structurally legal `commit_graph` batch on the first attempt, and `CommandExecutor` persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges (LSN 2). Artifacts: `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`. **Existing-code product-path subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-existing-code-ref/`: the default Brunch runtime factory exposed real `read_graph`/`commit_graph`, `gpt-5.5` read projected code `G1`, used `{existingCode: "G1"}` in `commit_graph`, and persisted a requirement plus edge to the pre-existing selected-spec goal without cross-spec writes. **Retry-diagnostics subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-retry-diagnostics/`: the default runtime recorded one `structural_illegal` proof-edge attempt with stance diagnostics, then a corrected retry that persisted two nodes and one legal proof edge with no partial state from the failed attempt. **Ambiguity/no-overcommit subclaim validated 2026-06-04** by `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-04-ambiguity-no-overcommit/`: the default runtime read graph context, asked for more concrete accepted facts, and recorded zero `commit_graph` attempts with zero graph nodes/edges written. **Review-set dry-run substrate validated 2026-06-02** by `review-set-proposal.test.ts`: reviewable proposals must carry lens/epistemic/grounding metadata, translate to `commitGraph` input, pass `CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph`, and stay off the review surface when structurally illegal. Remaining open subclaim: real LLM `project-graph` proposal generation against that substrate. Fallback options remain constrained generation, retry-with-feedback, or NL-parse-at-accept if later legality rates regress. | | A15-L | Establishment hints carried as structured-exchange payload facets provide sufficient inspectability, fixture-ability, and ambient-affordance source without a separate establishment-needs graph substrate or standalone `brunch.establishment_offer` entry family; whether such a substrate ever shares storage with reconciliation needs can be deferred. | medium | open | D25-L, D30-L | M5+: fixture inspection confirms establishment-offer facets are reconstructable from transcript-backed structured exchanges; chrome/web orientation regions render ambient affordances from the latest such facet. | | A16-L | Reviewer triggering policy (always-on vs lens-keyed) and reviewer scope (batch + how-far-neighborhood) can be deferred to per-lens decisions without architectural commitment now. | low | open | D29-L | M5+: empirical — reviewer integration reveals which policy avoids unacceptable next-turn latency without losing relevant findings. | | A17-L | A user-level temperamental preference for interrogative vs proposal-based elicitation meaningfully affects adoption and eventually warrants expression as a user-level setting. | low | open | D25-L, D26-L | Deferred; surfaces from outer-loop walkthroughs and adversarial fixtures once both single-exchange and batch-proposal flows exist in product. | diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md deleted file mode 100644 index c6debb179..000000000 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--closure-chain.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,378 +0,0 @@ -# Graph tool resilience closure chain - -Frontier: graph-tool-resilience -Status: active -Mode: chain -Created: 2026-06-04 - -## Orientation - -- Containing seam: `graph-tool-resilience` (FE-808), after the graph write contract materialization commits. -- Posture: proving (inherited from `graph-tool-resilience`). The chain should stabilize D62-L/D63-L/D53-L at the product boundary, then fire the direct-runtime probes that decide whether A14-L is materially broader than the old happy path. -- Volatile state: probe/transcript rendering work is being handled separately; this chain should not reshape `src/session/session-transcript*` unless the probe reporter cannot use the committed transcript API. -- Main open risk: the code now stores the right graph invariants, but the agent-facing tool surface still leaks raw ids and dry-run validation can diverge from commit validation. -- Frontier obligations: preserve `CommandExecutor` as the mutation authority, keep projected node codes out of DB storage, avoid harness-as-false-proof by exercising the default Brunch runtime factory, and record probe fitness rather than only pass/fail. - -Build order: Cards 1–2 are cleanup required before the product-path probes. Cards 3–5 are the remaining FE-808 probe evidence slices; they should remain valid after Cards 1–2 because they target frontier acceptance, not an implementation detail. - -## Card 1 — Canonicalize graph tool handles - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -The Pi graph-tool boundary exposes projected node codes as the only agent-facing existing-node handle. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -read_graph / commit_graph Pi tools -→ src/.pi/extensions/graph tool schemas + prompt guidance -→ selected-spec graph code resolver -→ CommandExecutor / snapshot readers using internal NodeIds -→ tool result text + details -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: raw integer ids remain useful for diagnostics and tests. - → MITIGATION: keep raw ids in internal `details`/domain objects only; remove them from agent instructions, primary rendered handles, and tool-call parameters. -- RISK: resolving projected codes inside `.pi/extensions/graph` could pull DB access into the adapter. - → MITIGATION: inject or import a graph-layer resolver/reader; `.pi/extensions/graph` must still avoid direct `db/` imports. -- ASSUMPTION: `node_code` / `existingCode` is sufficient for the current product path. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: FE-808 probes would still rely on raw ids and fail to prove D62-L at the agent boundary. - → VALIDATE: graph-tool adapter tests and product probe transcripts should contain code handles such as `G1` / `R2`, not instructions to use raw ids. - -### Posture check - -This is an invariant tracer: it makes D62-L observable at the product boundary rather than only in storage and snapshots. It also removes the compatibility bridge that lets agents keep using raw DB ids. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ graph tool schema tests — commit_graph edge refs accept intra-batch refs and projected existing-node codes, not `{ existing: }` -✓ graph tool schema/tests — read_graph neighborhood mode accepts a projected node code instead of `node_id` -✓ adapter tests — selected-spec code resolution succeeds for an existing code and fails loudly for malformed, missing, or wrong-spec codes -✓ CommandExecutor input types/tests — commitGraph no longer accepts presentation-code refs directly; adapters resolve to internal NodeIds before mutation -✓ graph tool formatting tests — overview, neighborhood, and commit success render projected codes as primary handles -✓ prompt guidance tests — graph tool descriptions/guidelines no longer tell the agent to use raw existing node ids -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: adapter/schema/unit tests — prove code-only agent parameters and selected-spec resolution. -- Middle: transcript grep in later probe cards — prove the default runtime exposes/uses projected handles. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Do not store rendered code strings in graph tables. -- Do not let `.pi/extensions/graph` import from `db/`. -- Keep raw ids available only as internal diagnostics/details where they are needed for tests or domain plumbing. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/.pi/extensions/graph/ -├── tool-schemas.ts ~ -├── command-adapter.ts ~ -└── index.ts ~ -src/.pi/__tests__/ -└── graph-tools.test.ts ~ -src/graph/ -├── command-executor.ts ~ -├── command-executor.test.ts ~ -├── snapshot.ts ~ -├── snapshot.test.ts ~ -├── workspace-store.ts ~ -└── schema/ - └── nodes.ts ~ -src/agents/contexts/ -├── graph.ts ~ -├── graph.test.ts ~ -├── node.ts ~ -└── node.test.ts ~ -``` - -## Card 2 — Normalize graph tool outcomes and unify commitGraph planning - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -Every graph-tool structural failure travels through the same structured diagnostic path used by commitGraph dry-run and commit execution. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -commit_graph / read_graph Pi tool params -→ adapter normalization over projected codes -→ CommandExecutor.dryRunCommitGraph / CommandExecutor.commitGraph -→ private commit-graph batch planner -→ graph structural validators + selected-spec reference checks -→ transaction writer / structured tool result -``` - -### Build order inside this card - -```pseudo -1. adapter normalization: no thrown Error for malformed/missing codes; return structured diagnostics -2. result identity: replace `nodes` + optional `nodeCodes` with one created-node result shape -3. tool params: make `ReadGraphParams` a discriminated union so neighborhood requires `nodeCode` -4. resolver contract: require the selected-spec code resolver at the graph tool boundary -5. planner extraction: make dry-run and commit share the full commitGraph planner, including supersession acyclicity -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: adapter code currently throws before the agent receives a `structural_illegal`-style tool result. - → MITIGATION: normalize projected-code failures into the same diagnostic envelope that `formatCommitGraphResult` renders for agent self-correction. -- RISK: `CommitGraphSuccess` currently represents identity twice (`nodes: ref → id` plus optional `nodeCodes`). - → MITIGATION: make one created-node result shape such as `createdNodes: { [ref]: { id, code } }`; keep raw ids internal/diagnostic, never as the primary rendered handle. -- RISK: `ReadGraphParams` currently permits `{ mode: "neighborhood" }` and rejects it imperatively. - → MITIGATION: use a discriminated union so overview and neighborhood params make invalid states unrepresentable at the schema/type boundary. -- RISK: supersession acyclicity currently depends on resolved endpoints after insertion setup. - → MITIGATION: plan against temporary batch endpoint keys plus existing NodeIds before writing; commit maps the already-planned batch refs to inserted rows. -- RISK: this cleanup could become a broad executor rewrite. - → MITIGATION: split only graph-tool normalization and commitGraph batch planning/validation; leave unrelated spec/recon-need commands alone. -- ASSUMPTION: dry-run, commit, and graph-tool normalization should be structurally identical except for persistence. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: review-set proposals can pass dry-run and fail on approval, or agent probes can crash instead of producing retryable diagnostics, breaking D27-L/D53-L/A14-L. - → VALIDATE: paired adapter/dry-run/commit differential tests for current structural-illegal families. - -### Posture check - -This is an invariant tracer: it closes the adapter-exception and dry-run/commit gaps before FE-808 probes and FE-809 review-cycle work depend on these diagnostics as product evidence. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ graph-tool adapter tests — malformed, missing, and wrong-spec projected codes produce structured diagnostic tool results, not thrown exceptions -✓ graph-tool schema tests — `ReadGraphParams` is an overview/neighborhood discriminated union; neighborhood requires `nodeCode`, and raw `node_id` stays rejected -✓ graph-tool adapter tests — selected-spec code resolver is required at the boundary; no default `() => undefined` resolver remains -✓ result-shape tests — commit success exposes one created-node identity shape with both internal id and projected code; formatting renders codes as primary handles with no optional `#id` fallback for created nodes -✓ dry-run/commit parity tests — invalid basis, missing existing ref/code, invalid category/stance, self-loop, and detail-shape errors produce matching diagnostics -✓ dry-run/commit parity tests — existing, intra-batch, and mixed supersession cycles are rejected by dry-run before any write path runs -✓ transaction tests — failed commitGraph batches do not persist nodes, edges, change-log rows, or counter rows -✓ topology/file-size check — commitGraph batch planning lives in a private `src/graph/command-executor/*` module imported only by the public command-executor entrypoint -✓ file-size check — `src/graph/command-executor.test.ts` no longer carries the full commitGraph matrix past the 1000-line threshold -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: adapter/schema tests — prove graph-tool normalization returns structured diagnostics and code-only params make invalid states unrepresentable. -- Inner: unit/differential tests over the batch planner and public `CommandExecutor` methods. -- Middle: review-set dry-run tests keep using the public `dryRunCommitGraph` path. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Preserve `CommandExecutor` as the public mutation boundary; the new planner is private implementation. -- Do not add a standalone authority service or second write path. -- Keep projected codes out of DB storage; raw ids may remain in typed internals/details but not as primary agent-facing handles. -- Keep the split semantic, not file-shape theatre: extract graph-tool normalization and commitGraph batch planning only. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/.pi/extensions/graph/ -├── command-adapter.ts ~ -├── index.ts ~ -├── tool-schemas.ts ~ -└── review-set-proposal.ts ? -src/.pi/__tests__/ -├── graph-tools.test.ts ~ -└── review-set-proposal.test.ts ~ -src/graph/ -├── command-executor.ts ~ -├── command-executor.test.ts ~ -├── snapshot.ts ? -├── workspace-store.ts ? -└── command-executor/ - ├── commit-graph-batch.ts + - └── commit-graph-batch.test.ts + -src/graph/README.md ~ -``` - -## Card 3 — Existing-code product-path probe - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -The default Brunch runtime commits graph truth by referencing a selected-spec existing node through its projected code. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -probe runner -→ fresh workspace/spec/session setup with seeded graph node -→ default Brunch agent session runtime factory -→ real read_graph / commit_graph Pi tools -→ CommandExecutor -→ graph overview + transcript/report artifacts -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: the probe could seed the graph through a helper and then inspect private state, proving less than the product path. - → MITIGATION: seeding may use `CommandExecutor`, but the agent action under test must use the default runtime factory and real Pi tools; final assertions read public graph snapshots/report artifacts. -- RISK: the model may still copy a raw diagnostic id if any prompt surface leaks one. - → MITIGATION: report transcript handle usage and treat raw-id reliance as friction or failure. -- ASSUMPTION: the existing `propose-graph-commit` proof runner can be extended with named scenarios rather than replaced. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: create a small sibling runner under `src/probes/`, but keep artifact shape identical. - → VALIDATE: test the scenario summary/report without a live model run first. - -### Posture check - -This is proof of life plus invariant evidence: it proves D62-L in the real tool loop and selected-spec ownership at the boundary A14-L depends on. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ probe summary tests — a named `existing-code-ref` scenario reports attempts, retry count, diagnostics, final graph counts/LSN, committed code/title summary, and friction -✓ product-path probe artifact — `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit//report.json` records success for the existing-code scenario or names the specific gap -✓ transcript/report assertions — the agent saw and used projected codes as primary handles -✓ graph assertion — final graph includes the expected edge to the pre-existing selected-spec node and no writes to another spec -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: probe report parser/summary tests — prove scenario-specific report fields. -- Middle/Outer: real model probe run through `createBrunchAgentSessionRuntimeFactory`; fixture artifacts are committed under `.fixtures/runs/`. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- No probe-only tool registration or runtime wiring. -- Preserve the existing artifact envelope (`session.jsonl`, `transcript.md`, `report.json`). -- Treat model friction as evidence, not hidden test setup. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/probes/ -├── propose-graph-commit-proof.ts ~ -└── propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts ~ -.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/ -└── / + -``` - -## Card 4 — Retry-diagnostics product-path probe - -Status: done - -### Target Behavior - -The default Brunch runtime records a structural-illegal first commit attempt followed by a corrected retry outcome. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -probe scenario prompt -→ default Brunch agent session runtime factory -→ real commit_graph structural_illegal result -→ retry prompt/tool guidance -→ corrected commit_graph attempt or named failure report -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: forcing the first attempt to be illegal may overfit the prompt rather than test diagnostics quality. - → MITIGATION: use a representative illegal category/stance/detail mistake from the tool contract and report whether correction came from diagnostics. -- RISK: a model may refuse to make an illegal first attempt. - → MITIGATION: success can be either corrected retry evidence or an explicit report that the scenario did not induce a retry; do not fake the retry by direct tool injection. -- ASSUMPTION: bounded retry remains the right proof shape for A14-L diagnostics. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: FE-808 cannot claim diagnostic/retry resilience and should report the gap before FE-809 depends on it. - → VALIDATE: attempt report includes first/final status and diagnostic text. - -### Posture check - -This is uncertainty-retirement evidence for A14-L: it tests whether `structural_illegal` diagnostics are actionable through the real agent loop. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ probe summary tests — `retry-diagnostics` classifies firstAttemptStatus, finalStatus, retryCount, and diagnostics seen -✓ product-path probe artifact — report records at least one `structural_illegal` attempt and either a later success or an explicit diagnostic gap -✓ transcript assertion — retry prompt/tool guidance is visible in the Pi JSONL-derived transcript -✓ graph assertion — no partial graph state from the failed attempt is present -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: probe attempt-classification tests. -- Middle/Outer: real model probe run through the default runtime factory with committed artifacts. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Do not lower structural validation just to make retry easier. -- Do not bypass the tool result path when collecting diagnostics. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/probes/ -├── propose-graph-commit-proof.ts ~ -└── propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts ~ -.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/ -└── / + -``` - -## Card 5 — Ambiguity no-overcommit product-path probe - -Status: next - -### Target Behavior - -The default Brunch runtime records an ambiguous graph prompt without committing unsupported graph truth. - -### Boundary Crossings - -```pseudo -ambiguous probe prompt -→ default Brunch agent session runtime factory -→ agent strategy/tool guidance -→ transcript outcome -→ graph overview/report artifact -``` - -### Risks and Assumptions - -- RISK: no-overcommit is harder to assert than a successful commit. - → MITIGATION: define the oracle narrowly: zero commit_graph success when the prompt withholds enough facts, or a transcript-visible clarification/no-op diagnostic that explains why no graph truth was written. -- RISK: the model may commit plausible but unsupported nodes. - → MITIGATION: report overcommit as failure/friction; do not tune the prompt until the behavior disappears without naming the attempt. -- ASSUMPTION: the current `propose-graph` strategy guidance is specific enough to avoid overcommitment when evidence is missing. - → IMPACT IF FALSE: FE-808 should close with a named strategy-guidance gap rather than claiming broad graph-tool resilience. - → VALIDATE: final graph counts/LSN plus transcript classification. - -### Posture check - -This is an uncertainty tracer for A14-L's “ambiguity/no-overcommit” subclaim; it prevents the frontier from proving only happy-path persistence. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -```pseudo -✓ probe summary tests — `ambiguity-no-overcommit` classifies no-op/clarification, overcommit, and unexpected tool-use outcomes -✓ product-path probe artifact — report records final graph counts/LSN and friction for the ambiguity scenario -✓ transcript assertion — the agent either asks for clarification or explains why it cannot commit graph truth yet -✓ graph assertion — no successful commit_graph writes unsupported graph items for the ambiguous prompt -``` - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: transcript/report classifier tests. -- Middle/Outer: real model probe run through the default runtime factory with committed artifacts. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Preserve offer-first/elicitation-first posture; no ambient free-chat workaround. -- Record fitness honestly if the model overcommits. -- Do not broaden into generative/adversarial probe infrastructure. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```pseudo -src/probes/ -├── propose-graph-commit-proof.ts ~ -└── propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts ~ -.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/ -└── / + -``` diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts index 1011ed83d..821021302 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.test.ts @@ -213,6 +213,60 @@ describe('propose-graph commit proof report', () => { expect(report.friction).toEqual([]); }); + it('classifies ambiguity no-overcommit as clarification without graph writes', () => { + const sessionText = JSON.stringify({ + type: 'message', + message: { + role: 'assistant', + content: [ + { type: 'text', text: 'I need more concrete accepted facts before I can commit graph truth.' }, + ], + }, + }); + + const report = summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof({ + runId: 'ambiguity-run', + generatedAt: '2026-06-04T00:00:00.000Z', + cwd: '/tmp/brunch-proof', + specId: 7, + sessionId: 'session-1', + maxAttempts: 2, + sessionText, + overview: { ...successfulOverview, nodes: [], edges: [], nodeCount: 0, edgeCount: 0, lsn: 1 }, + prompt: 'Maybe update the graph if useful.', + scenarioId: 'ambiguity-no-overcommit', + }); + + expect(report.success).toBe(true); + expect(report.ambiguityOutcome).toBe('no_op_or_clarification'); + expect(report.attemptCount).toBe(0); + expect(report.finalGraph).toMatchObject({ nodeCount: 0, edgeCount: 0, lsn: 1 }); + expect(report.friction).toEqual([]); + }); + + it('classifies ambiguity overcommit when unsupported graph writes succeed', () => { + const report = summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof({ + runId: 'ambiguity-overcommit-run', + generatedAt: '2026-06-04T00:00:00.000Z', + cwd: '/tmp/brunch-proof', + specId: 7, + sessionId: 'session-1', + maxAttempts: 2, + sessionText: messageEntry( + 'commit_graph', + { status: 'success', lsn: 1, createdNodes: { g1: { id: 1, code: 'G1' } }, edges: [] }, + 'Graph committed successfully', + ), + overview: successfulOverview, + prompt: 'Maybe update the graph if useful.', + scenarioId: 'ambiguity-no-overcommit', + }); + + expect(report.success).toBe(false); + expect(report.ambiguityOutcome).toBe('overcommit'); + expect(report.friction).toContain('Ambiguity scenario outcome was overcommit.'); + }); + it('fails closed when no commit_graph attempt succeeds', () => { const sessionText = messageEntry( 'commit_graph', diff --git a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts index 12230c566..c0845b81f 100644 --- a/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts +++ b/src/probes/propose-graph-commit-proof.ts @@ -22,7 +22,13 @@ import { createWorkspaceSessionCoordinator } from '../session/workspace-session- const PROBE_ID = 'propose-graph-commit' as const; const DEFAULT_MAX_ATTEMPTS = 2; -export type ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId = 'direct-commit' | 'existing-code-ref' | 'retry-diagnostics'; +export type ProposeGraphCommitScenarioId = + | 'direct-commit' + | 'existing-code-ref' + | 'retry-diagnostics' + | 'ambiguity-no-overcommit'; + +export type AmbiguityNoOvercommitOutcome = 'no_op_or_clarification' | 'overcommit' | 'unexpected_tool_use'; export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofOptions { cwd?: string; @@ -92,6 +98,7 @@ export interface ProposeGraphCommitProofReport { usedInCommitParams: boolean; existingCodeEdgePresent?: boolean; }; + ambiguityOutcome?: AmbiguityNoOvercommitOutcome; friction: string[]; artifacts?: ProposeGraphCommitProofArtifacts; } @@ -278,14 +285,24 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( projectedCodeEvidence.usedInCommitParams && projectedCodeEvidence.existingCodeEdgePresent === true; } + const ambiguityOutcome = + scenarioId === 'ambiguity-no-overcommit' + ? ambiguityNoOvercommitOutcome(input.sessionText, attempts, input.overview) + : undefined; if (scenarioId === 'retry-diagnostics') { success = attempts.some((attempt) => attempt.status === 'structural_illegal') && successfulAttempt !== undefined && input.overview.nodeCount > 0; } + if (scenarioId === 'ambiguity-no-overcommit') { + success = + ambiguityOutcome === 'no_op_or_clarification' && + input.overview.nodeCount === 0 && + input.overview.edgeCount === 0; + } - if (attempts.length === 0) { + if (attempts.length === 0 && scenarioId !== 'ambiguity-no-overcommit') { friction.push('No commit_graph tool result was recorded.'); } if (attempts.length > input.maxAttempts) { @@ -314,6 +331,22 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( ); } } + if (scenarioId === 'retry-diagnostics') { + if (!attempts.some((attempt) => attempt.status === 'structural_illegal')) { + friction.push('Retry diagnostics scenario did not record a structural_illegal first attempt.'); + } + if (successfulAttempt === undefined) { + friction.push('Retry diagnostics scenario did not record a corrected successful retry.'); + } + } + if (scenarioId === 'ambiguity-no-overcommit') { + if (ambiguityOutcome !== 'no_op_or_clarification') { + friction.push(`Ambiguity scenario outcome was ${ambiguityOutcome ?? 'unknown'}.`); + } + if (input.overview.nodeCount > 0 || input.overview.edgeCount > 0) { + friction.push('Ambiguity scenario wrote graph state despite underspecified prompt.'); + } + } return { schemaVersion: 1, @@ -326,7 +359,9 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( ? 'A14-L selected-spec projected-code reference through the default runtime.' : scenarioId === 'retry-diagnostics' ? 'A14-L retry behavior after structured commit_graph diagnostics.' - : 'A14-L structural legality for direct commitGraph batches.', + : scenarioId === 'ambiguity-no-overcommit' + ? 'A14-L ambiguity handling without unsupported graph overcommit.' + : 'A14-L structural legality for direct commitGraph batches.', scenarioId, success, cwd: input.cwd, @@ -347,10 +382,35 @@ export function summarizeProposeGraphCommitProof( committedNodeTitles, committedNodes, projectedCodeEvidence, + ...(ambiguityOutcome !== undefined ? { ambiguityOutcome } : {}), friction, }; } +function ambiguityNoOvercommitOutcome( + sessionText: string, + attempts: readonly CommitGraphAttemptReport[], + overview: GraphOverview, +): AmbiguityNoOvercommitOutcome { + if ( + attempts.some((attempt) => attempt.status === 'success') || + overview.nodeCount > 0 || + overview.edgeCount > 0 + ) { + return 'overcommit'; + } + if (attempts.length > 0) return 'unexpected_tool_use'; + const normalized = sessionText.toLowerCase(); + return normalized.includes('clarif') || + normalized.includes('cannot commit') || + normalized.includes('can’t commit') || + normalized.includes('insufficient') || + normalized.includes('need more') || + normalized.includes('not enough') + ? 'no_op_or_clarification' + : 'unexpected_tool_use'; +} + function projectedCodeEvidenceFromSummaryInput( input: ProposeGraphCommitProofSummaryInput, ): ProposeGraphCommitProofReport['projectedCodeEvidence'] { @@ -547,6 +607,13 @@ Use read_graph once in overview mode. Find the projected code for the existing l Use read_graph once in overview mode. Then intentionally make exactly one structurally illegal commit_graph attempt by creating two intent-plane nodes and a proof edge between them without the required stance field. Read the STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL diagnostics. Then retry once with a corrected complete batch that creates the same two nodes and a legal proof edge with stance "for". Stop after the corrected commit_graph succeeds.`; } + if (scenarioId === 'ambiguity-no-overcommit') { + return `Brunch A14-L ambiguity/no-overcommit probe. + +The user says: "Maybe our launch process has some risk somewhere; please update the spec graph if that seems useful." + +Use read_graph once in overview mode. Because the prompt does not provide a concrete accepted graph fact, do not call commit_graph. Instead, respond with a concise clarification request or explanation that there is not enough accepted graph truth to commit yet.`; + } return `Brunch A14-L probe: the user has accepted the following concept-level proposal and asked you to persist it now.\n\nConcept: A Brunch specification workspace needs an explicit launch-readiness subgraph that records the launch goal, the rollback requirement, the operator visibility criterion, and the assumption that users can recover from a failed launch.\n\nUse the read_graph tool once in overview mode, then use commit_graph to persist a coherent intent-plane graph. Requirements for the commit_graph call:\n- create at least four intent-plane nodes\n- include at least one goal, one requirement, one criterion, and one assumption\n- create at least three edges connecting the nodes\n- use only legal edge categories from the tool guidance\n- include stance only on support or proof edges\n- avoid decision and term nodes for this proof so detail schemas are not needed\n\nIf commit_graph returns STRUCTURAL_ILLEGAL, read the diagnostics and retry once with a corrected complete batch. Stop after a successful commit_graph result.`; } @@ -593,7 +660,8 @@ function parseCliArgs(argv: readonly string[]): ProposeGraphCommitProofOptions { if ( scenarioId !== 'direct-commit' && scenarioId !== 'existing-code-ref' && - scenarioId !== 'retry-diagnostics' + scenarioId !== 'retry-diagnostics' && + scenarioId !== 'ambiguity-no-overcommit' ) { throw new Error(`Unsupported scenario ${scenarioId}`); } From 80964aa7ff70318d03ab3a443dd76560ba342431 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 17:22:09 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 15/21] FE-808: Close graph commit planner judo findings --- src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts | 36 ++++--- src/graph/README.md | 4 + src/graph/command-executor.ts | 94 +++++-------------- .../commit-graph-batch.test.ts | 23 +++++ .../command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts | 15 ++- .../command-executor/commit-graph-types.ts | 70 ++++++++++++++ 6 files changed, 149 insertions(+), 93 deletions(-) create mode 100644 src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-types.ts diff --git a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts index b24461388..7824a858d 100644 --- a/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts +++ b/src/.pi/extensions/graph/command-adapter.ts @@ -49,28 +49,38 @@ export function translateCommitGraph( })); const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; - const edges: BatchEdgeInput[] = params.edges.map((e, index) => ({ - category: e.category, - source: resolveEdgeRef(e.source, resolveGraphNodeCode, `edges[${index}].source`, diagnostics), - target: resolveEdgeRef(e.target, resolveGraphNodeCode, `edges[${index}].target`, diagnostics), - stance: e.stance, - rationale: e.rationale, - })); + const edges: BatchEdgeInput[] = []; + for (const [index, e] of params.edges.entries()) { + const source = normalizeEdgeRef(e.source, resolveGraphNodeCode, `edges[${index}].source`, diagnostics); + const target = normalizeEdgeRef(e.target, resolveGraphNodeCode, `edges[${index}].target`, diagnostics); + if (source.status === 'invalid' || target.status === 'invalid') continue; + edges.push({ + category: e.category, + source: source.ref, + target: target.ref, + stance: e.stance, + rationale: e.rationale, + }); + } if (diagnostics.length > 0) return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics }; return { specId, basis: 'implicit', nodes, edges }; } -function resolveEdgeRef( +type EdgeRefNormalization = + | { readonly status: 'valid'; readonly ref: BatchEdgeRef } + | { readonly status: 'invalid' }; + +function normalizeEdgeRef( ref: string | { readonly existingCode: string }, resolveGraphNodeCode: ResolveGraphNodeCode, field: string, diagnostics: Diagnostic[], -): BatchEdgeRef { - if (typeof ref === 'string') return ref; +): EdgeRefNormalization { + if (typeof ref === 'string') return { status: 'valid', ref }; if (!parseGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode)) { diagnostics.push({ field, message: `malformed graph node code "${ref.existingCode}"` }); - return '__invalid_existing_code__'; + return { status: 'invalid' }; } const nodeId = resolveGraphNodeCode(ref.existingCode); if (nodeId === undefined) { @@ -78,9 +88,9 @@ function resolveEdgeRef( field, message: `graph node code "${ref.existingCode}" does not resolve in the selected spec`, }); - return '__unresolved_existing_code__'; + return { status: 'invalid' }; } - return { existing: nodeId }; + return { status: 'valid', ref: { existing: nodeId } }; } // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- diff --git a/src/graph/README.md b/src/graph/README.md index 3c956dd28..0baa92a65 100644 --- a/src/graph/README.md +++ b/src/graph/README.md @@ -65,6 +65,8 @@ graph/ create/resolve reconciliation need command-executor/ + commit-graph-types.ts + commitGraph input/result/diagnostic types re-exported by command-executor.ts commit-graph-batch.ts private commitGraph batch planner dry-run/commit structural parity @@ -127,6 +129,8 @@ folder scaffolding until pressure is real. ```pseudo graph/command-executor/ + commit-graph-types.ts + commitGraph input/result/diagnostic types re-exported by command-executor.ts commit-graph-batch.ts planned edge endpoints existing/batch ref validation diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index f194e50f1..5d382f456 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -24,23 +24,38 @@ import * as schema from '../db/schema.js'; import { formatCreatedGraphNode, planCommitGraphBatch, - type CreatedGraphNodes, type PlannedBatchEndpoint, } from './command-executor/commit-graph-batch.js'; +import type { + CommitGraphDryRunResult, + CommitGraphInput, + CommitGraphResult, + CommitGraphSuccess, + Diagnostic, + StructuralIllegal, +} from './command-executor/commit-graph-types.js'; import { type NodeBasis, type NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; export type ReadinessGrade = (typeof schema.READINESS_GRADES)[number]; +export type { + BatchEdgeInput, + BatchEdgeRef, + BatchNodeInput, + CommitGraphDryRunResult, + CommitGraphInput, + CommitGraphResult, + CommitGraphSuccess, + CreatedGraphNodeResult, + CreatedGraphNodes, + Diagnostic, + DryRunSuccess, + StructuralIllegal, +} from './command-executor/commit-graph-types.js'; // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- // Result types // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- -/** A single validation problem discovered during structural checks. */ -export interface Diagnostic { - readonly field: string; - readonly message: string; -} - /** Successful command execution. */ export interface CommandSuccess { readonly status: 'success'; @@ -48,12 +63,6 @@ export interface CommandSuccess { readonly lsn: number; } -/** Structurally invalid input — validation failed before any write. */ -export interface StructuralIllegal { - readonly status: 'structural_illegal'; - readonly diagnostics: readonly Diagnostic[]; -} - /** Action requires human confirmation (M6 placeholder). */ export interface NeedsHuman { readonly status: 'needs_human'; @@ -69,19 +78,6 @@ export interface VersionConflict { readonly status: 'version_conflict'; } -/** Successful commitGraph batch execution. */ -export interface CommitGraphSuccess { - readonly status: 'success'; - readonly lsn: number; - readonly createdNodes: CreatedGraphNodes; - readonly edges: readonly number[]; -} - -/** Successful dry-run validation without mutation. */ -export interface DryRunSuccess { - readonly status: 'success'; -} - /** Successful reconciliation-need creation. */ export interface ReconNeedSuccess { readonly status: 'success'; @@ -132,12 +128,6 @@ export type CommandResult = /** Result of a createNode command. */ export type CreateNodeResult = CommandSuccess | StructuralIllegal; -/** Result of a commitGraph command. */ -export type CommitGraphResult = CommitGraphSuccess | StructuralIllegal; - -/** Result of a commitGraph dry-run validation. */ -export type CommitGraphDryRunResult = DryRunSuccess | StructuralIllegal; - /** Result of a createReconciliationNeed command. */ export type CreateReconNeedResult = ReconNeedSuccess | StructuralIllegal; @@ -213,41 +203,6 @@ export interface ResolveReconNeedInput { readonly id: number; } -// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- -// Batch input types (commitGraph) -// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- - -/** Reference to a node endpoint in a batch edge. */ -export type BatchEdgeRef = string | { readonly existing: number }; - -/** A node to create inside a commitGraph batch. */ -export interface BatchNodeInput { - readonly ref: string; - readonly plane: NodePlane; - readonly kind: string; - readonly title: string; - readonly body?: string | undefined; - readonly source?: string | undefined; - readonly detail?: unknown; -} - -/** An edge to create inside a commitGraph batch. */ -export interface BatchEdgeInput { - readonly category: string; - readonly source: BatchEdgeRef; - readonly target: BatchEdgeRef; - readonly stance?: string | undefined; - readonly rationale?: string | undefined; -} - -/** Input for the commitGraph atomic batch mutation. */ -export interface CommitGraphInput { - readonly specId: number; - readonly basis?: NodeBasis | undefined; - readonly nodes: readonly BatchNodeInput[]; - readonly edges: readonly BatchEdgeInput[]; -} - // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- // Validation // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -633,11 +588,6 @@ export class CommandExecutor { * validation, the entire batch is rejected (I34-L). */ commitGraph(input: CommitGraphInput): CommitGraphResult { - const preflight = this.planCommitGraph(input, this.db); - if (preflight.status === 'structural_illegal') { - return { status: 'structural_illegal', diagnostics: preflight.diagnostics }; - } - return this.db.transaction((tx) => { const planned = this.planCommitGraph(input, tx); if (planned.status === 'structural_illegal') { diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts index 486e0fc57..8c840bf35 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts @@ -65,6 +65,29 @@ describe('CommandExecutor commitGraph', () => { expect(db.select().from(edges).all()).toHaveLength(1); }); + it('plans commits inside the transaction before allocating an LSN', () => { + const guardedDb = db as BrunchDb & { select: BrunchDb['select'] }; + const originalSelect = guardedDb.select; + let result: ReturnType | undefined; + + guardedDb.select = (() => { + throw new Error('commitGraph planned outside its transaction'); + }) as BrunchDb['select']; + try { + result = executor.commitGraph({ + specId, + nodes: [{ ref: 'n1', plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'Goal' }], + edges: [], + }); + } finally { + guardedDb.select = originalSelect; + } + + expect(result?.status).toBe('success'); + expect(db.select().from(graphClock).get()!.lsn).toBe(1); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(1); + }); + it('allocates kind ordinals per spec, plane, and kind within multi-node batches', () => { const otherSpec = executor.createSpec({ name: 'Other Spec', slug: 'other' }); if (otherSpec.status !== 'success') throw new Error('unreachable'); diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts index de17e60eb..82e589afe 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-batch.ts @@ -2,9 +2,15 @@ import { and, eq, inArray } from 'drizzle-orm'; import type { BrunchDb } from '../../db/connection.js'; import * as schema from '../../db/schema.js'; -import type { BatchEdgeInput, BatchEdgeRef, CommitGraphInput, Diagnostic } from '../command-executor.js'; import type { EdgeCategory, EdgeStance } from '../schema/edges.js'; import { formatGraphNodeCode, type NodeKind } from '../schema/nodes.js'; +import type { + BatchEdgeInput, + BatchEdgeRef, + CommitGraphInput, + CreatedGraphNodeResult, + Diagnostic, +} from './commit-graph-types.js'; const VALID_CATEGORIES = schema.EDGE_CATEGORIES as unknown as string[]; const STANCE_REQUIRED_CATEGORIES = new Set(['proof', 'support']); @@ -28,13 +34,6 @@ export interface CommitGraphBatchPlan { readonly edges: readonly PlannedBatchEdge[]; } -export interface CreatedGraphNodeResult { - readonly id: number; - readonly code: string; -} - -export type CreatedGraphNodes = Readonly>; - export interface InsertedNodeRow { readonly id: number; readonly kind: string; diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-types.ts b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-types.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5ec19d87b --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/command-executor/commit-graph-types.ts @@ -0,0 +1,70 @@ +import type { NodeBasis, NodePlane } from '../schema/nodes.js'; + +/** A single validation problem discovered during structural checks. */ +export interface Diagnostic { + readonly field: string; + readonly message: string; +} + +/** Structurally invalid input — validation failed before any write. */ +export interface StructuralIllegal { + readonly status: 'structural_illegal'; + readonly diagnostics: readonly Diagnostic[]; +} + +/** Successful dry-run validation without mutation. */ +export interface DryRunSuccess { + readonly status: 'success'; +} + +export interface CreatedGraphNodeResult { + readonly id: number; + readonly code: string; +} + +export type CreatedGraphNodes = Readonly>; + +/** Successful commitGraph batch execution. */ +export interface CommitGraphSuccess { + readonly status: 'success'; + readonly lsn: number; + readonly createdNodes: CreatedGraphNodes; + readonly edges: readonly number[]; +} + +/** Result of a commitGraph command. */ +export type CommitGraphResult = CommitGraphSuccess | StructuralIllegal; + +/** Result of a commitGraph dry-run validation. */ +export type CommitGraphDryRunResult = DryRunSuccess | StructuralIllegal; + +/** Reference to a node endpoint in a batch edge. */ +export type BatchEdgeRef = string | { readonly existing: number }; + +/** A node to create inside a commitGraph batch. */ +export interface BatchNodeInput { + readonly ref: string; + readonly plane: NodePlane; + readonly kind: string; + readonly title: string; + readonly body?: string | undefined; + readonly source?: string | undefined; + readonly detail?: unknown; +} + +/** An edge to create inside a commitGraph batch. */ +export interface BatchEdgeInput { + readonly category: string; + readonly source: BatchEdgeRef; + readonly target: BatchEdgeRef; + readonly stance?: string | undefined; + readonly rationale?: string | undefined; +} + +/** Input for the commitGraph atomic batch mutation. */ +export interface CommitGraphInput { + readonly specId: number; + readonly basis?: NodeBasis | undefined; + readonly nodes: readonly BatchNodeInput[]; + readonly edges: readonly BatchEdgeInput[]; +} From 98b3f19503b33a5dce02e0ea31934d7fdf31ca9c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 17:43:54 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 16/21] Add fixture seed loader and consolidate Bilal-port seed fixtures Restructure .fixtures/seed-specs/ into .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/ with vendored Bilal originals under _originals/, the throwaway port script, and one consolidated .json per spec ({spec, nodes, edges}). Fix the port script's basis mapping: epistemicStatus no longer maps to the invalid 'accepted_review_set' basis (forbidden per GRAPH_MODEL.md). Bilal authored each item directly, so every ported node is 'explicit'; the epistemic flavor is preserved in source text instead. Add src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts: a loader that commits each consolidated fixture through CommandExecutor (createSpec + one explicit commitGraph batch) so graph clock / change log / lsn stay coherent. Lives in graph/ (not db/) to respect the db/ <- graph/ dependency direction. Exposed via 'npm run seed'; covered by src/graph/seed-fixtures.test.ts. Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-019e91ee-aa39-73d2-a346-a0ae1e55e3b9 Co-authored-by: Amp --- .../bilal-port/code-health/edges.json | 4162 ------ .../bilal-port/code-health/nodes.json | 2962 ----- .../bilal-port/code-health/spec.json | 5 - .../bilal-port/explorer-ui/edges.json | 4914 -------- .../bilal-port/explorer-ui/nodes.json | 2937 ----- .../bilal-port/explorer-ui/spec.json | 5 - .../bilal-port/macro-view/edges.json | 4034 ------ .../bilal-port/macro-view/nodes.json | 2436 ---- .../bilal-port/macro-view/spec.json | 5 - .../bilal-port/README.md | 44 +- .../_originals/code-health/edges.json | 9002 +++++++++++++ .../_originals/code-health/nodes.json | 6009 +++++++++ .../_originals/explorer-ui/edges.json | 10472 ++++++++++++++++ .../_originals/explorer-ui/nodes.json | 5671 +++++++++ .../_originals/macro-view/edges.json | 8522 +++++++++++++ .../_originals/macro-view/nodes.json | 4756 +++++++ .../bilal-port/_port-script.ts | 136 +- .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/code-health.json | 7131 +++++++++++ .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/explorer-ui.json | 7858 ++++++++++++ .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/macro-view.json | 6477 ++++++++++ package.json | 1 + src/graph/seed-fixtures.test.ts | 75 + src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts | 197 + 23 files changed, 66277 insertions(+), 21534 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/edges.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/nodes.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/spec.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/edges.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/nodes.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/spec.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/edges.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/nodes.json delete mode 100644 .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/spec.json rename .fixtures/{seed-specs => seeds}/bilal-port/README.md (55%) create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/edges.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/nodes.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/edges.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/nodes.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/edges.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/nodes.json rename .fixtures/{seed-specs => seeds}/bilal-port/_port-script.ts (84%) create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/code-health.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/explorer-ui.json create mode 100644 .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/macro-view.json create mode 100644 src/graph/seed-fixtures.test.ts create mode 100644 src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/edges.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/edges.json deleted file mode 100644 index f2e35bff8..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/edges.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,4162 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 22, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 37, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 58, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 60, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 66, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 86, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 93, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 102, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 113, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 115, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 151, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 154, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 156, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 164, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 169, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 188, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 204, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 214, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 236, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 240, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 243, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 246, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 252, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 164, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 258, - "target_local_id": 15, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 170, - "target_local_id": 257, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 250, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 147, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 15, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 149, - "target_local_id": 65, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 146, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 81, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 161, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 248, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 158, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 113, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 260, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 18, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 44, - "target_local_id": 130, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 233, - "target_local_id": 26, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 196, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 15, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 101, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 237, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 64, - "target_local_id": 171, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 66, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 84, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 248, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 243, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 225, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 109, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 195, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 162, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 4, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 158, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 250, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 5, - "target_local_id": 97, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 115, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 79, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 2, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 16, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 183, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 77, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 106, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 258, - "target_local_id": 214, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 163, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 178, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 203, - "target_local_id": 245, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 171, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 244, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 245, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 147, - "target_local_id": 74, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 267, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 177, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 88, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 51, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 181, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 185, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 37, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 181, - "target_local_id": 107, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 47, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 184, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 63, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 162, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 183, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 93, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 37, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 110, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 11, - "target_local_id": 207, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 135, - "target_local_id": 145, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 114, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 90, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 62, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 261, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 151, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 35, - "target_local_id": 85, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 242, - "target_local_id": 142, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 191, - "target_local_id": 82, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 39, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 139, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 256, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 247, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 70, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 185, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 21, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 256, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 260, - "target_local_id": 173, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 70, - "target_local_id": 155, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 146, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 236, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 23, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 161, - "target_local_id": 102, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 239, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 168, - "target_local_id": 155, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 151, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 66, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 144, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 181, - "target_local_id": 34, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 18, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 126, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 252, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 207, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 225, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 112, - "target_local_id": 156, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 39, - "target_local_id": 142, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 244, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 195, - "target_local_id": 77, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 114, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 79, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 191, - "target_local_id": 50, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 199, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 44, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 58, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 15, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 256, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 119, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 185, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 258, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 85, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 151, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 136, - "target_local_id": 107, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 89, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 243, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 152, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 261, - "target_local_id": 102, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 3, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 53, - "target_local_id": 180, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 182, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 241, - "target_local_id": 152, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 86, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 89, - "target_local_id": 75, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 267, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 250, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 183, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 43, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 196, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 277, - "target_local_id": 187, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 137, - "target_local_id": 58, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 183, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 52, - "target_local_id": 33, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 137, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 94, - "target_local_id": 95, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 252, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 168, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 213, - "target_local_id": 199, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 60, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 51, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 277, - "target_local_id": 133, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 54, - "target_local_id": 197, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 277, - "target_local_id": 187, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 178, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 41, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 75, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 27, - "target_local_id": 126, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 155, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 249, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 24, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 212, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 64, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 27, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 15, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 138, - "target_local_id": 151, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 235, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 94, - "target_local_id": 98, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 85, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 146, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 256, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 119, - "target_local_id": 163, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 149, - "target_local_id": 145, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 126, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 113, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 250, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 24, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 164, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 148, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 211, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 77, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 256, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 142, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 209, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 191, - "target_local_id": 113, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 2, - "target_local_id": 30, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 74, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 112, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 164, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 248, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 72, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 57, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 242, - "target_local_id": 39, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 147, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 44, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 188, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 107, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 70, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 3, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 9, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 275, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 32, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 77, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 188, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 5, - "target_local_id": 238, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 43, - "target_local_id": 154, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 126, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 277, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 55, - "target_local_id": 73, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 175, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 261, - "target_local_id": 102, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 147, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 199, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 233, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 136, - "target_local_id": 163, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 50, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 54, - "target_local_id": 29, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 277, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 52, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 258, - "target_local_id": 251, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 159, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 204, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 59, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 6, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 241, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 213, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 177, - "target_local_id": 66, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 139, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 81, - "target_local_id": 25, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 57, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 138, - "target_local_id": 241, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 241, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 60, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 25, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 209, - "target_local_id": 167, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 23, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 11, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 135, - "target_local_id": 104, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 241, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 184, - "target_local_id": 256, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 248, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 45, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 101, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 84, - "target_local_id": 106, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 258, - "target_local_id": 15, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 260, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 184, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 62, - "target_local_id": 169, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 251, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 25, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 26, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 184, - "target_local_id": 256, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 73, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 63, - "target_local_id": 122, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 44, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 18, - "target_local_id": 258, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 142, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 9, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 72, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 244, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 248, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 144, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 260, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 233, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 86, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 69, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 233, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 160, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 90, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 194, - "target_local_id": 202, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 211, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 258, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 11, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 259, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 203, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 249, - "target_local_id": 85, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 59, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 111, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 244, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 35, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 161, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 50, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 164, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 33, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 182, - "target_local_id": 245, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 112, - "target_local_id": 66, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 115, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 48, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 23, - "target_local_id": 133, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 52, - "target_local_id": 80, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 27, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 154, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 139, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 136, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 125, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 53, - "target_local_id": 155, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 79, - "target_local_id": 133, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 199, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 64, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 130, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 115, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 35, - "target_local_id": 249, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 249, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 6, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 144, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 41, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 241, - "target_local_id": 151, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 66, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 70, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 141, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 203, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 67, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 235, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 147, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 109, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 119, - "target_local_id": 57, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 91, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 93, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 206, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 261, - "target_local_id": 175, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 11, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 159, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 141, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 194, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 162, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 22, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 182, - "target_local_id": 203, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 213, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 75, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 261, - "target_local_id": 102, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 239, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 156, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 148, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 123, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 159, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 235, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 62, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 277, - "target_local_id": 187, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 275, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 170, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 27, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 114, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 247, - "target_local_id": 130, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 186, - "target_local_id": 141, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 171, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 185, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 84, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 206, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 260, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - } -] diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/nodes.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/nodes.json deleted file mode 100644 index 94f03c815..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/nodes.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2962 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "local_id": 1, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "check", - "title": "Code Health — code-audit pass", - "body": "Synthetic parent check representing the manual code-audit pass during which evidence nodes were authored. Generated by .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence a structural parent on the oracle plane.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-port-synthetic", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 2, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Stage 2 must compute three configuration spaces with the semantics defined in T20: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, e…", - "body": "Stage 2 must compute three configuration spaces with the semantics defined in T20: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, excluding alternatives requiring locked-baseline revision), M_preview (includes revision-requiring alternatives tagged as preview-only), and M_revision(r) (after an authorized revision set r is applied).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 3, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test must verify that after a refinement reconciliation outcome, the unresolved successor impasse has at least one incoming 'refined…", - "body": "A unit test must verify that after a refinement reconciliation outcome, the unresolved successor impasse has at least one incoming 'refined_to' edge, and that the derivation loop's progress measurement counts it as progress on the 'incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses' signal.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 4, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Node state is modeled across three independent axes: lifecycle (candidate/activ…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T9]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Node state is modeled across three independent axes: lifecycle (candidate/active/archived), review status (clean/suspect/conditional), and impasse status (open/resolved/superseded for impasse nodes only)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 5, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Conflict resolution during reconciliation must first attempt a deterministic graph traversal computing the minimal set of grounding nodes w…", - "body": "Conflict resolution during reconciliation must first attempt a deterministic graph traversal computing the minimal set of grounding nodes whose removal resolves the conflict; a subagent may be invoked only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure (missing provenance edges or semantic-rather-than-structural contradiction).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R64]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 6, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A module test must drive a fan-in fixture with a witnessed source contradiction where some runs picked sides and verify that Stage 1 emits…", - "body": "A module test must drive a fan-in fixture with a witnessed source contradiction where some runs picked sides and verify that Stage 1 emits a genuine impasse for the contradiction BEFORE Stage 2 computes M_current; ordering verified via EventLog event sequence (FanInExtractionCompleted with impasses[] non-empty precedes ConfigSpaceComputed).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 7, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A static dependency check (parsing deno.json import_map / import statements in engine/solver/**) must confirm that the solver imports nothi…", - "body": "A static dependency check (parsing deno.json import_map / import statements in engine/solver/**) must confirm that the solver imports nothing outside the Deno standard library and Effect; no off-the-shelf SAT library (e.g., logic-solver, minisat, kissat) appears as a dependency.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 8, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A test must verify that each call to cowReplace emits a CowReplace event and each call to markSuspectAndPropagate emits a SuspectPropagated…", - "body": "A test must verify that each call to cowReplace emits a CowReplace event and each call to markSuspectAndPropagate emits a SuspectPropagated event with at least the affected node count.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 9, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The CLI must provide a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earlie…", - "body": "The CLI must provide a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earliest open impasse, and re-enters the derivation loop using that frame as parent.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R52]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 10, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A test must assert that the derivation loop sets nudgingActive=true after exactly 1 clean attempt without progress (matching X42 and the im…", - "body": "A test must assert that the derivation loop sets nudgingActive=true after exactly 1 clean attempt without progress (matching X42 and the implementation), and that PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 documents nudge_after_n=1.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 11, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The axis 'type' field must accept only 'design' or 'repair'; there must be no 'revision' axis type.", - "body": "The axis 'type' field must accept only 'design' or 'repair'; there must be no 'revision' axis type. Revision is modeled as an effect of selecting a particular alternative, not as a property of an axis.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 12, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "Of the 34 code health issues, 8 have been fixed and 26 remain open; the full list is tracked in PROBLEMS.md.", - "body": "Of the 34 code health issues, 8 have been fixed and 26 remain open; the full list is tracked in PROBLEMS.md.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 13, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Guarded impasses are diagnostic blockers with a trigger condition (guard formul…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T18]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Guarded impasses are diagnostic blockers with a trigger condition (guard formula) over the configuration space; they are not hard constraints and not propositions." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 14, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) get file read but not web search or paper read, because web search…", - "body": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) get file read but not web search or paper read, because web search results could surface content referencing the hidden impasse or old design.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [C5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 15, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the recommended priority order for addressing open issues is tests (P18–P25) > correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) >…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the recommended priority order for addressing open issues is tests (P18–P25) > correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) > design (P16) > everything else.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X62]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 16, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The resolve_directly and sharpen outcomes from user escalation materialize as grounding nodes with authority: stakeholder and epistemicStat…", - "body": "The resolve_directly and sharpen outcomes from user escalation materialize as grounding nodes with authority: stakeholder and epistemicStatus: asserted, mark trigger impasses as resolved, and return grounding_enriched for re-derivation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 17, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A static lint/grep check must confirm that no file under src/engine/** imports the Console module or invokes Console.log / Console.error /…", - "body": "A static lint/grep check must confirm that no file under src/engine/** imports the Console module or invokes Console.log / Console.error / Console.warn / Console.info / Console.debug. The check must run in CI and fail the build on violation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 18, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "An integration-style test using scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver must trigger a reconciliation outcome that produces a refi…", - "body": "An integration-style test using scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver must trigger a reconciliation outcome that produces a refined impasse, and assert that (a) reconciliation.ts populates spawnedImpasseIds with the new impasse node id, (b) the case 'recurse' branch in derivation-loop.ts is executed (verified via spy/event), and (c) runDerivationLoop is invoked recursively with the new impasse id in triggerImpasseIds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 19, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: per-run stance toward alternatives is tracked at the finest granularity — per run, per axis, per alternative value,…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: per-run stance toward alternatives is tracked at the finest granularity — per run, per axis, per alternative value, with stance values of 'supports', 'contradicts', or 'silent'.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 20, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the model has three distinct layers — hard constraints (boolean formulas determining satisfiability), guarded block…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the model has three distinct layers — hard constraints (boolean formulas determining satisfiability), guarded blockers/impasses (diagnostics with trigger conditions), and baseline effects (per-alternative authorization requirements). A configuration is activatable only if it satisfies all three.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 21, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The approach for handling the blocking impasse (unsatisfiable M_current) when selecting which constraint to demote is currently undecided.", - "body": "The approach for handling the blocking impasse (unsatisfiable M_current) when selecting which constraint to demote is currently undecided.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 22, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The spec elicitation prototype has a working forward pass.", - "body": "The spec elicitation prototype has a working forward pass.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 23, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Perspective summaries must be generated by sampling configurations from the solver's enumeration (capped at 200 per space) and running fart…", - "body": "Perspective summaries must be generated by sampling configurations from the solver's enumeration (capped at 200 per space) and running farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis-assignment vectors to pick k=3 representatives per space, with M_current and M_preview sampled separately.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 24, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: blocking impasse nodes participate in provenance and JTMS chains.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: blocking impasse nodes participate in provenance and JTMS chains.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 25, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: superseded (OUT) nodes are never deleted from the graph; they are retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to the…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: superseded (OUT) nodes are never deleted from the graph; they are retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement, preserving the JTMS justification chain so the graph grows monotonically.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 26, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A checkpoint is an immutable snapshot of the spec graph produced when a full re…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T11]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A checkpoint is an immutable snapshot of the spec graph produced when a full revision completes (all impasses resolved, spec stable); checkpoints are not created per frame or reconciliation step." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 27, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The solver implementation in engine/solver/dpll.ts must depend only on the Deno standard library and Effect; it must not pull in an off-the…", - "body": "The solver implementation in engine/solver/dpll.ts must depend only on the Deno standard library and Effect; it must not pull in an off-the-shelf SAT library.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 28, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P2: When the reconciler proposes disposition: \"refined\", the reconciliation engine marks the original impasse as superseded but never creat…", - "body": "P2: When the reconciler proposes disposition: \"refined\", the reconciliation engine marks the original impasse as superseded but never creates the refined impasse node; the refinedImpasse field is read from the LLM proposal but not consumed, so the refined impasse silently disappears.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 29, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: when two claims conflict with different authorities, the system surfaces the conflict and labels the authorities, b…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: when two claims conflict with different authorities, the system surfaces the conflict and labels the authorities, but the user always decides — even when there's an apparent priority cascade.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X52]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 30, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Three configuration spaces are defined: M_current (satisfies constraints and cu…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T20]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Three configuration spaces are defined: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, excluding alternatives requiring locked-baseline revision), M_preview (includes revision-requiring alternatives tagged as preview-only), and M_revision(r) (after an authorized revision set is applied)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 31, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the SAT solver library must either expose constraint explanations natively or the system must reconstruct them.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the SAT solver library must either expose constraint explanations natively or the system must reconstruct them.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X60]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 32, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Nudging is tracked as a flag on FrameRecord but never affects agent behavior; no negative constraints are injected into the clean room agen…", - "body": "Nudging is tracked as a flag on FrameRecord but never affects agent behavior; no negative constraints are injected into the clean room agent prompt.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 33, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: grounding claims require citation, and a separate agent must verify their plausibility.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: grounding claims require citation, and a separate agent must verify their plausibility.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X58]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 34, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question (Q11): Taint policy must distinguish evidential contamination (content derived from hidden impasse/old design) from workflow…", - "body": "Open question (Q11): Taint policy must distinguish evidential contamination (content derived from hidden impasse/old design) from workflow provenance (node elicited because of an impasse); the latter should not trigger exclusion or targeted grounding enrichment becomes unusable.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 35, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test must construct a small model where axis X has alternatives {a,b,c} and constraints rule out b and c; backbone(model) must retur…", - "body": "A unit test must construct a small model where axis X has alternatives {a,b,c} and constraints rule out b and c; backbone(model) must return for axis X: {forcedValue:'a', blockingClauses:[, ]}. The blocking clauses must be the actual clauses present in the model.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 36, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A grep check must confirm that the symbol FanInExtractionResult does not appear anywhere in src/** (no definition, no import, no re-export)…", - "body": "A grep check must confirm that the symbol FanInExtractionResult does not appear anywhere in src/** (no definition, no import, no re-export); all import sites in src/agents/fan-in.ts, src/engine/derivation-agents.ts, and src/engine/fan-in.ts must reference ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult instead.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 37, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "Milestones M1 through M3 and most of M4 are complete; M6 (prose agent) and M9 (perspective hub) are also complete; M5 (resume/polish), M7 (…", - "body": "Milestones M1 through M3 and most of M4 are complete; M6 (prose agent) and M9 (perspective hub) are also complete; M5 (resume/polish), M7 (web inspector), and the end-to-end smoke test remain outstanding.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 38, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Conditional labels are ATMS-style truth maintenance markers; without them, reco…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T4]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Conditional labels are ATMS-style truth maintenance markers; without them, reconciliation cannot distinguish 'derived under known inconsistency' from 'clean derivation'. They are a correctness property of the core loop, not a display feature." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 39, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Stage 1 must only emit a hard constraint when accompanied by explicit witnessing evidence (a source contradiction, a dependency requirement…", - "body": "Stage 1 must only emit a hard constraint when accompanied by explicit witnessing evidence (a source contradiction, a dependency requirement, or a grounded rationale from a run); non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4-5 fan-out runs alone must NOT be treated as evidence for a hard constraint.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 40, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The codebase currently uses Console.log extensively throughout the engine for logging (fan-in, fan-out, phase-runner, reconciliation, deriv…", - "body": "The codebase currently uses Console.log extensively throughout the engine for logging (fan-in, fan-out, phase-runner, reconciliation, derivation-loop, etc.).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 41, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question: whether a blocking impasse (unsatisfiable configuration space) should be a persistent graph node or a transient grouping con…", - "body": "Open question: whether a blocking impasse (unsatisfiable configuration space) should be a persistent graph node or a transient grouping construct depends on whether it has semantic meaning.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 42, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "PLAN.md's sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses must be rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model, the deletion o…", - "body": "PLAN.md's sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses must be rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model, the deletion of FanInExtractionResult, perspectives as records, and blocking impasses as graph nodes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R51]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 43, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts file must be split into focused per-module test files (one per module covered) colocated with the modules t…", - "body": "The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts file must be split into focused per-module test files (one per module covered) colocated with the modules they test.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R46]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 44, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The reconciliation engine must invoke solver.revisionImpact whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, and the O…", - "body": "The reconciliation engine must invoke solver.revisionImpact whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, and the OUT (tainted) closure it returns must be passed into the re-derivation flow.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 45, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the plausibility verification agent takes node content and a source span as input and outputs a stance, rationale,…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the plausibility verification agent takes node content and a source span as input and outputs a stance, rationale, and optionally lists of supported and unsupported claims.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 46, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must have axes, alternatives, per-run stance, witness relations,…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must have axes, alternatives, per-run stance, witness relations, and candidate repairs as first-class fields.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 47, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "In reconciliation.ts, populate spawnedImpasseIds at the same point where the reconciler proposes new child impasses or where the LLM propos…", - "body": "In reconciliation.ts, populate spawnedImpasseIds at the same point where the reconciler proposes new child impasses or where the LLM proposal includes a refinedImpasse: every node id added to the graph as a new Impasse during reconciliation must also be pushed onto the local spawnedImpasseIds array before the outcome tag is computed. This makes the existing 'recurse' outcome branch and the existing case \"recurse\" handler in derivation-loop.ts (which already passes spawnedImpasseIds as triggerImpasseIds to the recursive runDerivationLoop call) reachable for the first time.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 48, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or @kael/ai Routine abstractions in the course of this work; all integrations must be done at the c…", - "body": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or @kael/ai Routine abstractions in the course of this work; all integrations must be done at the consumer layer.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R56]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 49, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P10/P32: FrameRecord.nudgingActive is set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts, but no agent or engine code reads it and…", - "body": "P10/P32: FrameRecord.nudgingActive is set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts, but no agent or engine code reads it and no negative constraint is injected into the clean room prompt.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 50, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: three-valued aggregation (supports/contradicts/silent) is required in fan-in; silence is NOT contradiction and must…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: three-valued aggregation (supports/contradicts/silent) is required in fan-in; silence is NOT contradiction and must not manufacture fake conflicts from omissions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X50]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 51, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a NodeIdFromDisplayId decode fails, the failure must propagate as a structured tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn t…", - "body": "When a NodeIdFromDisplayId decode fails, the failure must propagate as a structured tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn through the existing Effect AI retry mechanism, so the agent can correct the reference without engine-side custom retry logic.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 52, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Every grounding node produced by the targeted grounding sub-agent or grounding-enrichment must have direct exogenous evidential provenance…", - "body": "Every grounding node produced by the targeted grounding sub-agent or grounding-enrichment must have direct exogenous evidential provenance (citation/source span); the assembler's anti-laundering guardrail must reject grounding-phase events that do not carry such provenance.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R59]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 53, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Impasse triage must remain a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) using the five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing prem…", - "body": "Impasse triage must remain a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) using the five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premise > term/ontology mismatch > upstream structural contradiction > endogenous design conflict (default).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R67]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 54, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When two claims conflict with different authorities, the system must surface the conflict and label the authorities, but the user must alwa…", - "body": "When two claims conflict with different authorities, the system must surface the conflict and label the authorities, but the user must always make the final decision; the engine must not auto-resolve based on an apparent authority cascade.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R68]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 55, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The derivation loop's progress measurement must consider three signals: (a) incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses, (b) resolved…", - "body": "The derivation loop's progress measurement must consider three signals: (a) incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses, (b) resolved impasses, and (c) activated nodes. Lack of progress on all three across an iteration must be treated as stagnation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R69]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 56, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test of the reconciliation engine must verify that when a reconciler proposal carries disposition='refined' with a refinedImpasse pa…", - "body": "A unit test of the reconciliation engine must verify that when a reconciler proposal carries disposition='refined' with a refinedImpasse payload: (a) a new Impasse hub node is created in the graph with status 'open', (b) a 'refined_to' lineage edge is created from the original impasse to the new one, (c) the original impasse is marked superseded (impasse-status), and (d) the new node id is pushed onto spawnedImpasseIds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 57, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate must be called for any milestone that exercises backward transitions such as…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate must be called for any milestone that exercises backward transitions such as grounding enrichment after a missing-premise impasse.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X57]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 58, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P22: No test verifies that WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state (nodes, edges, frames, display ID counte…", - "body": "P22: No test verifies that WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state (nodes, edges, frames, display ID counters, semantic keys); the PLAN marks this as tested but no test exists.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 59, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: each derived node has a justifications list used to determine which beliefs lose support during belief revision.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: each derived node has a justifications list used to determine which beliefs lose support during belief revision.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 60, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P24: engine/perspective-selection.ts is untested despite being fully testable with a scripted intervention driver.", - "body": "P24: engine/perspective-selection.ts is untested despite being fully testable with a scripted intervention driver.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 61, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "There is no 'revision' axis type; revision is an effect of selecting a particul…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T16]", - "detail": { - "definition": "There is no 'revision' axis type; revision is an effect of selecting a particular alternative, not a property of an axis." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 62, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "clean-room-resolution.ts (and the perspective-selection consumer) must read the hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements flags from…", - "body": "clean-room-resolution.ts (and the perspective-selection consumer) must read the hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements flags from SelectionOutcome and dispatch to the repair re-derivation flow and revision authorization flow respectively; these flags must no longer be computed-but-unused.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 63, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test must instantiate ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult from src/domain/configuration.ts with all required fields populated and ver…", - "body": "A unit test must instantiate ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult from src/domain/configuration.ts with all required fields populated and verify the schema accepts: axes (id, type∈{design,repair}, cardinality∈{exactly_one,zero_or_one}, label); alternatives (id, axisId, label); perRunStance (runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance∈{supports,contradicts,silent}, optional rationale); witnesses (runId, claimId, sourceSpan); candidateRepairs (contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength); impasses (kind, conflictingNodes); hardConstraints (formula, witnessedBy∈{source_contradiction,dependency,grounded_rationale}, citation). Negative tests must reject invalid stance/type/cardinality values.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 64, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Fan-in must be split into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing a Configu…", - "body": "Fan-in must be split into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing a ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult, and Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis in engine/solver.ts (and a new engine/config-model.ts) consuming that result. The two stages must be independently invocable.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 65, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a 'partial' plausibility verdict triggers a split or revision request; an 'unsupported' verdict rejects the node.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a 'partial' plausibility verdict triggers a split or revision request; an 'unsupported' verdict rejects the node.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 66, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P34: Four public WorkingGraph methods (cowReplace, markSuspectAndPropagate, getSemanticKey, getChildFrames) are defined but have zero calle…", - "body": "P34: Four public WorkingGraph methods (cowReplace, markSuspectAndPropagate, getSemanticKey, getChildFrames) are defined but have zero callers outside the class; COW grounding updates and suspect propagation are described as core mechanisms in the spec but the engine never exercises them.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 67, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The implementation must continue to use pure JSON file I/O; it must not introduce a database (e.g., DuckDB), an in-memory cross-spec graph,…", - "body": "The implementation must continue to use pure JSON file I/O; it must not introduce a database (e.g., DuckDB), an in-memory cross-spec graph, or cross-graph retrieval at this stage.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R57]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 68, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Unit tests of buildBaselineEffects must verify that: (a) when the baseline node is locked, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'locked', require…", - "body": "Unit tests of buildBaselineEffects must verify that: (a) when the baseline node is locked, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'locked', requiresAuthorization:true}; (b) when the baseline node is provisional, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'provisional', requiresAuthorization:false}; (c) the function reads commitmentLevel from the WorkingGraph baseline node, not from a constant. Verified with two graph fixtures (locked and provisional baseline).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 69, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: plausibility verification uses a three-valued output — supported, partially-supported, or unsupported — each with a…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: plausibility verification uses a three-valued output — supported, partially-supported, or unsupported — each with a rationale string.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 70, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Module-level tests for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in Stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow must use scripted DerivationAgent…", - "body": "Module-level tests for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in Stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow must use scripted DerivationAgents and a scripted InterventionDriver (already injectable per E18) so the tests are deterministic and require no LLM calls.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R42]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 71, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Clean room re-derivation is a strict information-flow isolation mechanism: for…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T2]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Clean room re-derivation is a strict information-flow isolation mechanism: for a given target phase, it returns only active upstream nodes, creates a fresh Chat instance with no prior history, and ensures retry feedback is schema-only." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 72, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) must be configured with file-read tools only; they must NOT have a…", - "body": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) must be configured with file-read tools only; they must NOT have access to web search or paper read, because such results could surface content referencing the hidden impasse or old design.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 73, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Progress in the derivation loop is measured by impasse refinement (incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses), resolved impasses, an…", - "body": "Progress in the derivation loop is measured by impasse refinement (incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses), resolved impasses, and activated nodes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 74, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: integration tests for the derivation loop must cover all three impasse types in sequence using VCR-style recorded i…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: integration tests for the derivation loop must cover all three impasse types in sequence using VCR-style recorded interaction snapshots against OpenRouter.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X61]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 75, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Engine events must be defined as a closed discriminated-union type at src/engine/events.ts whose variants include at minimum: PhaseEntered,…", - "body": "Engine events must be defined as a closed discriminated-union type at src/engine/events.ts whose variants include at minimum: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt, FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed, PerspectiveGenerated, ReconcileOutcome, ImpasseSpawned, ImpasseResolved, NudgeActivated, CowReplace, SuspectPropagated, BlockingImpasseRaised, UserInterventionRequested, UserInterventionResolved. Adding a new event must require adding a new variant to the union (no open string-tag fallback).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 76, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The plausibility verification agent must take node content and a source span as input and produce a three-valued output: 'supported', 'part…", - "body": "The plausibility verification agent must take node content and a source span as input and produce a three-valued output: 'supported', 'partially-supported', or 'unsupported', each accompanied by a rationale string and optionally lists of supported and unsupported claims.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R61]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 77, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Per-run stance must be tracked at per-run × per-axis × per-alternative granularity; a run must be allowed to support one alternative on an…", - "body": "Per-run stance must be tracked at per-run × per-axis × per-alternative granularity; a run must be allowed to support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 78, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Specs are modeled as sub-graphs of typed, addressable claims connected by meani…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T6]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Specs are modeled as sub-graphs of typed, addressable claims connected by meaningful edges; the memory system is also a sub-graph within a super-graph architecture where all sub-graphs are searchable through a unified retrieval layer." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 79, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each Perspective record must point at a real activatable configuration drawn from the enumerated set, not at an interpolated centroid.", - "body": "Each Perspective record must point at a real activatable configuration drawn from the enumerated set, not at an interpolated centroid.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 80, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question (Q10): The targeted grounding sub-agent could launder prior design choices as facts via memory/cross-spec search; grounding n…", - "body": "Open question (Q10): The targeted grounding sub-agent could launder prior design choices as facts via memory/cross-spec search; grounding nodes must have direct exogenous evidential provenance as a guardrail.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 81, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Superseded (OUT) nodes must never be deleted from the graph; they must be retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement,…", - "body": "Superseded (OUT) nodes must never be deleted from the graph; they must be retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement, preserving the JTMS justification chain so the graph grows monotonically.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 82, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Per-run stance must be carried as a structured field on ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult with exactly the values 'supports', 'contradicts…", - "body": "Per-run stance must be carried as a structured field on ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult with exactly the values 'supports', 'contradicts', or 'silent'; three-valued aggregation in fan-in must read this structured field rather than parsing prose, and silence must never be aggregated as contradiction.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 83, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A CLI integration test must run a scripted derivation and verify that the human-readable stdout output is produced by the CLI's EventLog su…", - "body": "A CLI integration test must run a scripted derivation and verify that the human-readable stdout output is produced by the CLI's EventLog subscriber (e.g., by replacing the subscriber with a no-op and asserting stdout is empty), confirming that the CLI consumes EventLog events rather than receiving Console.log calls from the engine.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 84, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When the user resolves a blocking impasse by choosing a constraint demotion, the engine must record that choice as a relaxed_to edge from t…", - "body": "When the user resolves a blocking impasse by choosing a constraint demotion, the engine must record that choice as a relaxed_to edge from the BlockingImpasse node to the demoted constraint node, creating an auditable record.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 85, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: when the solver determines an axis has only one valid value across all configurations (a backbone/forced assignment…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: when the solver determines an axis has only one valid value across all configurations (a backbone/forced assignment), the system must show which constraint rules made the other values impossible.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X59]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 86, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P19: engine/assembler.ts has no unit tests; it converts IR events to graph nodes and edges including reference resolution, hub constraint e…", - "body": "P19: engine/assembler.ts has no unit tests; it converts IR events to graph nodes and edges including reference resolution, hub constraint enforcement, and lineage edge creation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 87, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a run can support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a run can support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 88, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Substrate (backbone) is the set of alternatives that must be selected (or must…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T17]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Substrate (backbone) is the set of alternatives that must be selected (or must not be selected) in every configuration in M_current, defined semantically as common consequences rather than by provenance." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 89, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A type-level (compile-time) test must verify that the engine event type defined in src/engine/events.ts is a closed discriminated union: em…", - "body": "A type-level (compile-time) test must verify that the engine event type defined in src/engine/events.ts is a closed discriminated union: emitting an event with an unknown _tag must be a TypeScript compile error. Test method: a `// @ts-expect-error` line that attempts to emit an event with a fabricated tag.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 90, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: repair choices and design choices are fundamentally different — a repair resolves a source contradiction, a design…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: repair choices and design choices are fundamentally different — a repair resolves a source contradiction, a design choice selects among valid alternatives. The system must not present them as the same kind of preference.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X45]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 91, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "No file under src/engine/** (including fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection…", - "body": "No file under src/engine/** (including fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection.ts, assembler.ts) may import or call Console.log or any other Console method after the migration; this is enforceable as a static lint/grep check.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 92, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Design (non-repair) selection must be monotone: it must NOT trigger taint propagation, OUT computation, or re-derivation.", - "body": "Design (non-repair) selection must be monotone: it must NOT trigger taint propagation, OUT computation, or re-derivation. Only repair selection and revision authorization trigger non-monotone updates.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 93, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The justifications structure (JTMS/ATMS-style truth maintenance) already exists in the codebase on ConfigurationModel.", - "body": "The justifications structure (JTMS/ATMS-style truth maintenance) already exists in the codebase on ConfigurationModel.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 94, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a node carries a cached sourceAuthoritySet, triage must always re-traverse to validate the cache against live graph state; if cached a…", - "body": "When a node carries a cached sourceAuthoritySet, triage must always re-traverse to validate the cache against live graph state; if cached and live results diverge (e.g., due to a supersededBy update), the node must be flagged as requiring re-derivation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R66]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 95, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question (Q9): Derived nodes show authority: derived, erasing the original authority basis; triage and reconciliation may need sourceA…", - "body": "Open question (Q9): Derived nodes show authority: derived, erasing the original authority basis; triage and reconciliation may need sourceAuthoritySet / sourceEpistemicBasis summary fields to see through derivation chains.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 96, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P1: spawnedImpasseIds in reconciliation.ts is always initialized as an empty array and nothing ever pushes to it, making the recurse outcom…", - "body": "P1: spawnedImpasseIds in reconciliation.ts is always initialized as an empty array and nothing ever pushes to it, making the recurse outcome condition unreachable and the derivation loop's case \"recurse\" handler dead code.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 97, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: conflict resolution should always attempt a deterministic graph traversal first, computing the minimal set of groun…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: conflict resolution should always attempt a deterministic graph traversal first, computing the minimal set of grounding nodes whose removal resolves the conflict.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X55]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 98, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: sourceAuthoritySet is stored as a cache on a node at creation time for fast reads, but triage always re-traverses t…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: sourceAuthoritySet is stored as a cache on a node at creation time for fast reads, but triage always re-traverses to validate it; if cached and live results diverge (e.g., due to a supersededBy update), the node is flagged as requiring re-derivation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 99, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The derivation pipeline has four phases in strict derivational dependency order: grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done.", - "body": "The derivation pipeline has four phases in strict derivational dependency order: grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done. Execution is non-linear via backward transitions, but support edges must remain acyclic.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 100, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "nudgeAfterN defaults to 1 in the current derivation loop implementation.", - "body": "nudgeAfterN defaults to 1 in the current derivation loop implementation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 101, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Existing smoke test artifacts must still validate after changes.", - "body": "Existing smoke test artifacts must still validate after changes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [C4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 102, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P11: suggestedRewindPhase from the agent is always ignored; determineRewindPhase always returns one phase down regardless of the agent's hi…", - "body": "P11: suggestedRewindPhase from the agent is always ignored; determineRewindPhase always returns one phase down regardless of the agent's hint.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 103, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: readiness is evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection, not per perspective; a perspective summary carrie…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: readiness is evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection, not per perspective; a perspective summary carries default-bundle status for display only.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 104, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: constraint verification follows the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verif…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: constraint verification follows the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification — most cases handled mechanically, with uncertain cases elevated to a subagent.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 105, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question (Q12): Same-authority normative tradeoffs (latency vs cost, privacy vs observability) also require user adjudication but aren…", - "body": "Open question (Q12): Same-authority normative tradeoffs (latency vs cost, privacy vs observability) also require user adjudication but aren't authority conflicts per se; the triage class name may be too narrow.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 106, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the user's chosen constraint demotion is recorded as an edge from the blocking impasse node to the relaxed constrai…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the user's chosen constraint demotion is recorded as an edge from the blocking impasse node to the relaxed constraint, creating an auditable record.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 107, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: suspect status propagates only through identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into); it does NOT…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: suspect status propagates only through identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into); it does NOT auto-propagate through depends_on, derived_from, hub edges, motivates, references, or defines.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X53]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 108, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The codebase must include unit tests for each of the following pure-logic components: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, assembler.ts (referenc…", - "body": "The codebase must include unit tests for each of the following pure-logic components: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, assembler.ts (reference resolution, hub constraint enforcement, lineage edge creation), makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts, perspective-selection.ts, domain/invariants.ts validate() (including violating graphs that exercise support-edge acyclicity and phase stratification), the solver primitives (validateModel, enumerateConfigurations, backbone, demotionCandidates), and render/markdown.ts (snapshot-based).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 109, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Module tests must verify that fan-in Stage 1 (LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult) and Stage 2…", - "body": "Module tests must verify that fan-in Stage 1 (LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult) and Stage 2 (deterministic solver analysis in engine/solver.ts + engine/config-model.ts) can be invoked independently: Stage 2 can be called with a fixture ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult and produce a configuration model deterministically, without invoking Stage 1.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 110, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The previously-used FanInExtractionResult type must be deleted from the codebase with no backward-compatibility shim; all import sites in s…", - "body": "The previously-used FanInExtractionResult type must be deleted from the codebase with no backward-compatibility shim; all import sites in src/agents/fan-in.ts, src/engine/derivation-agents.ts, and src/engine/fan-in.ts must be updated to use ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 111, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A schema-level test must verify that every agent IR field that previously carried a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageF…", - "body": "A schema-level test must verify that every agent IR field that previously carried a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives, selected, rejected, consequences, premises, conclusions) is typed via NodeIdFromDisplayId and not plain string. Verified by inspecting the exported schemas and asserting the brand/type of each id-bearing field.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 112, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "domain/graph.ts defines WorkingGraph.cowReplace(...) and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate(...) as public methods, but a repo-wide searc…", - "body": "domain/graph.ts defines WorkingGraph.cowReplace(...) and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate(...) as public methods, but a repo-wide search finds no callers outside the class definition itself.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X64]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 113, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P13: The fan-in extraction schema has no structured field for per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent); three-valued aggregation depend…", - "body": "P13: The fan-in extraction schema has no structured field for per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent); three-valued aggregation depends entirely on prompt compliance rather than structural enforcement.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 114, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Console.log is used throughout the engine for output, coupling the engine to CLI presentation.", - "body": "Console.log is used throughout the engine for output, coupling the engine to CLI presentation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 115, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P8: justifications is always set to an empty array in the configuration model, so the solver's revisionImpact function (JTMS-style truth ma…", - "body": "P8: justifications is always set to an empty array in the configuration model, so the solver's revisionImpact function (JTMS-style truth maintenance) has no data to operate on.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 116, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "assembler.ts must populate the justifications field on every derived node it creates, with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub…", - "body": "assembler.ts must populate the justifications field on every derived node it creates, with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub the node is connected to, recording {hubId, premiseIds: [...]} reflecting the actual hub premise edges.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 117, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P28: The artifact layout in PLAN.md does not list graph/reconciliation-records.json but the code writes it.", - "body": "P28: The artifact layout in PLAN.md does not list graph/reconciliation-records.json but the code writes it.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 118, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: replace the impasse-centric cross-run divergence model with a feature-model / SAT-analyzed constraint problem over…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: replace the impasse-centric cross-run divergence model with a feature-model / SAT-analyzed constraint problem over a structured variable space; perspectives become a presentation layer over this model rather than the primary semantic unit.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 119, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "An integration test using scripted intervention/grounding-enrichment must verify that when a stakeholder resolve_directly or sharpen outcom…", - "body": "An integration test using scripted intervention/grounding-enrichment must verify that when a stakeholder resolve_directly or sharpen outcome refines an existing grounding node, WorkingGraph.cowReplace is invoked with {oldNodeId, newNode} and a lineage edge is emitted recording the replacement; verified by spying cowReplace and asserting at least one call per scenario.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 120, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Grounding is the exogenous substrate: not clean-roomed, using copy-on-write sem…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T10]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Grounding is the exogenous substrate: not clean-roomed, using copy-on-write semantics. New nodes are added and existing nodes can be modified via COW. The substrate persists across backward transitions." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 121, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: replace the logging system with the Effect EventLog so every action taken emits an event, replacing all Console.log…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: replace the logging system with the Effect EventLog so every action taken emits an event, replacing all Console.log calls completely.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 122, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult must be defined in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields for: axes (id, type ∈ {design, re…", - "body": "ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult must be defined in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields for: axes (id, type ∈ {design, repair}, cardinality ∈ {exactly_one, zero_or_one}, label); alternatives (id, axisId, label); perRunStance (runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance ∈ {supports, contradicts, silent}, optional rationale); witnesses (runId, claimId, sourceSpan); candidateRepairs (contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength); impasses (kind, conflictingNodes); hardConstraints (formula, witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency, grounded_rationale}, citation).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 123, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The implementation must not add support for parallel/concurrent spec design sessions; the architecture remains single-session for this work.", - "body": "The implementation must not add support for parallel/concurrent spec design sessions; the architecture remains single-session for this work.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R58]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 124, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question (Q8): Impasse triage may need to inspect provenance closure (the 'conflict core') rather than just surface metadata for mixed…", - "body": "Open question (Q8): Impasse triage may need to inspect provenance closure (the 'conflict core') rather than just surface metadata for mixed-cause impasses; missing premise is an absence not visible in node metadata.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 125, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A run that resolves a source contradiction by picking a side witnesses a candid…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T14]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A run that resolves a source contradiction by picking a side witnesses a candidate repair (a possible maximal consistent subset), not an auto-resolution; the contradiction remains until a repair is explicitly licensed." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 126, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Using an off-the-shelf SAT solver risks less control over explanation/proof output and may have Deno compatibility issues.", - "body": "Using an off-the-shelf SAT solver risks less control over explanation/proof output and may have Deno compatibility issues.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 127, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "PLAN.md's artifact layout section must list graph/reconciliation-records.json so the documented layout matches what the code writes.", - "body": "PLAN.md's artifact layout section must list graph/reconciliation-records.json so the documented layout matches what the code writes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R49]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 128, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A module test with a scripted agent that emits an unresolvable display ID must verify the schema decode failure becomes an Effect AI tool r…", - "body": "A module test with a scripted agent that emits an unresolvable display ID must verify the schema decode failure becomes an Effect AI tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn (i.e., the agent receives a structured retry prompt), and that the engine does not silently filter or drop the reference.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 129, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The grounding enrichment agent is impasse-aware, uses FullToolkit for research, is constrained to grounding-phase semantic roles only, and…", - "body": "The grounding enrichment agent is impasse-aware, uses FullToolkit for research, is constrained to grounding-phase semantic roles only, and includes an anti-laundering guardrail that validates all enrichment events against the grounding roles set before assembly.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 130, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: belief revision uses JTMS-style propagation — a derived node becomes OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications h…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: belief revision uses JTMS-style propagation — a derived node becomes OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 131, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The derivation loop is the core post-forward-pass mechanism: it checks for impa…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T1]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The derivation loop is the core post-forward-pass mechanism: it checks for impasses, initiates backward transitions by creating child frames, runs clean-room fan-out, reconciles, and recurses inside-out by generation." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 132, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P27: cli/run.ts inlines report formatting (40-line formatHandoffReport and 30-line derivation agent construction) that could be extracted t…", - "body": "P27: cli/run.ts inlines report formatting (40-line formatHandoffReport and 30-line derivation agent construction) that could be extracted to separate modules.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 133, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspective summaries are generated from representative configurations using diverse exemplar selection (farthest-f…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspective summaries are generated from representative configurations using diverse exemplar selection (farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis assignments), sampling M_current and M_preview separately.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 134, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Reconciliation must not archive a node merely because a re-derivation omitted it; if upstream grounding still supports the node and there i…", - "body": "Reconciliation must not archive a node merely because a re-derivation omitted it; if upstream grounding still supports the node and there is no contradiction, omission is insufficient justification for archival.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R65]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 135, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Constraint verification must follow the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification: most cases…", - "body": "Constraint verification must follow the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification: most cases handled mechanically, with uncertain cases elevated to a subagent. Partial verdicts from the subagent must be fed back to the originating agent for correction.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R63]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 136, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "An integration test must verify that immediately after every cowReplace call, markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) is invoked and traverses i…", - "body": "An integration test must verify that immediately after every cowReplace call, markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) is invoked and traverses identity-preserving lineage edges only (equivalent_to, merged_into), setting review status to 'suspect' on transitively reachable nodes; the test must include nodes connected via depends_on / derived_from / hub edges / motivates / references / defines and assert those are NOT marked suspect.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 137, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "There must be a unit test that asserts WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state, including nodes, edges, fra…", - "body": "There must be a unit test that asserts WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state, including nodes, edges, frames, display ID counters, and semantic keys.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 138, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A static grep check must confirm that src/engine/assembler.ts contains no '.filter(' expression that drops references whose display ID fail…", - "body": "A static grep check must confirm that src/engine/assembler.ts contains no '.filter(' expression that drops references whose display ID failed to resolve, and that the post-hoc resolve-and-filter code path described in P30 has been removed.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 139, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type using SchemaGetter.checkEffect should replace all post-hoc display ID resolution,…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type using SchemaGetter.checkEffect should replace all post-hoc display ID resolution, so schema decode failures surface as tool result errors that the LLM sees and can retry.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 140, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: enrichment nodes carry dual provenance — workflow provenance (which impasse prompted the inquiry, tracked via motiv…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: enrichment nodes carry dual provenance — workflow provenance (which impasse prompted the inquiry, tracked via motivates edges) and evidential provenance (the direct exogenous source). Only evidential provenance may justify downstream derivation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X51]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 141, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Agents emit semantic keys and support sets during derivation; the graph assembler assigns UUIDs and display IDs and creates edges, keeping…", - "body": "Agents emit semantic keys and support sets during derivation; the graph assembler assigns UUIDs and display IDs and creates edges, keeping normalization deterministic and testable and preventing the model from hallucinating edge targets.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 142, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4–5 fan-out runs is NOT evidence of a constraint; hard constraints requir…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4–5 fan-out runs is NOT evidence of a constraint; hard constraints require explicit evidence such as a source contradiction, dependency requirement, or grounded rationale from a run.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X47]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 143, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Every notable engine occurrence (phase entry/completion, fan-out attempts, fan-in stages, reconcile outcomes, impasse spawn/resolution, nud…", - "body": "Every notable engine occurrence (phase entry/completion, fan-out attempts, fan-in stages, reconcile outcomes, impasse spawn/resolution, nudge activation, cowReplace, suspect propagation, blocking impasse raise, user intervention request/resolution) must emit a typed event via Effect EventLog.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 144, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: when M_current is unsatisfiable, the system proposes a set of constraint demotions, identifying which demotions wou…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: when M_current is unsatisfiable, the system proposes a set of constraint demotions, identifying which demotions would make it solvable and which would not.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 145, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: when a partial verdict is returned by the subagent for constraint or plausibility checking, it is fed back to the o…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: when a partial verdict is returned by the subagent for constraint or plausibility checking, it is fed back to the originating agent for correction.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 146, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: repair selection auto-resolves when one repair option is clearly better-evidenced; only genuinely ambiguous repairs…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: repair selection auto-resolves when one repair option is clearly better-evidenced; only genuinely ambiguous repairs become user-facing axes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X43]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 147, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "There must be exactly one end-to-end smoke test that drives the derivation loop through all three impasse types in sequence (authority conf…", - "body": "There must be exactly one end-to-end smoke test that drives the derivation loop through all three impasse types in sequence (authority conflict, missing premise, endogenous design conflict) using VCR-style recorded OpenRouter interaction snapshots.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R44]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 148, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each clean-room re-derivation invocation must instantiate a fresh Chat with no prior history; retry feedback to the agent must be schema-on…", - "body": "Each clean-room re-derivation invocation must instantiate a fresh Chat with no prior history; retry feedback to the agent must be schema-only (e.g., NodeIdFromDisplayId decode errors), never freeform.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 149, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "A 'partially-supported' plausibility verdict must trigger a split-or-revision request fed back to the originating agent for correction; an…", - "body": "A 'partially-supported' plausibility verdict must trigger a split-or-revision request fed back to the originating agent for correction; an 'unsupported' verdict must reject the node.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R62]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 150, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P21: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, which converts FanInExtractionResult to a typed ConfigurationModel, is untested.", - "body": "P21: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, which converts FanInExtractionResult to a typed ConfigurationModel, is untested.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 151, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P30: Display IDs are resolved post-hoc with silent data loss: when a display ID doesn't resolve, the code silently drops it via .filter(nod…", - "body": "P30: Display IDs are resolved post-hoc with silent data loss: when a display ID doesn't resolve, the code silently drops it via .filter(nodeId !== undefined) or logs a non-blocking error, so the LLM never learns its reference was invalid and no retry is triggered.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 152, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Agents produce display IDs as strings; when these don't resolve, data is silently dropped instead of being fed back as errors.", - "body": "Agents produce display IDs as strings; when these don't resolve, data is silently dropped instead of being fed back as errors.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 153, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The prototype uses pure JSON file I/O; there is no DuckDB, no memory graph, and no cross-graph retrieval.", - "body": "The prototype uses pure JSON file I/O; there is no DuckDB, no memory graph, and no cross-graph retrieval.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 154, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P26: m4-engine.test.ts is 1702 lines covering 7 modules and should be split into focused per-module test files.", - "body": "P26: m4-engine.test.ts is 1702 lines covering 7 modules and should be split into focused per-module test files.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 155, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Tests must be deterministic and must not make LLM calls.", - "body": "Tests must be deterministic and must not make LLM calls.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [C2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 156, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate exist as functions in the graph domain.", - "body": "cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate exist as functions in the graph domain.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 157, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: partial selections (user hasn't chosen on some axes yet) are interaction state, not model cardinality; the solver o…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: partial selections (user hasn't chosen on some axes yet) are interaction state, not model cardinality; the solver operates on total configurations while the UI allows incremental selection.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 158, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "VCR-style tests require maintaining recorded snapshots and re-recording when prompts change.", - "body": "VCR-style tests require maintaining recorded snapshots and re-recording when prompts change.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 159, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The test suite must include property tests for at least: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monoton…", - "body": "The test suite must include property tests for at least: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monotonicity over repeated mark/unmark, (c) the equality solver.backbone(model) == intersection-of-solver.enumerateConfigurations(model).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R43]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 160, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 must state nudge_after_n default = 1, matching the implementation and X42.", - "body": "PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 must state nudge_after_n default = 1, matching the implementation and X42.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R50]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 161, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Unit tests of determineRewindPhase must verify: (a) when the agent supplies suggestedRewindPhase strictly upstream of currentPhase, it is h…", - "body": "Unit tests of determineRewindPhase must verify: (a) when the agent supplies suggestedRewindPhase strictly upstream of currentPhase, it is honored (e.g., currentPhase=defining-done + hint=grounding rewinds to grounding); (b) when the hint is absent, it falls back to one phase down; (c) when the hint equals or is downstream of currentPhase, the hint is rejected and the function falls back to one phase down; (d) invalid phase strings are rejected.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 162, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "engine/reconciliation.ts already has the structural plumbing for the 'recurse' outcome (an empty spawnedImpasseIds: NodeId[] array, an outc…", - "body": "engine/reconciliation.ts already has the structural plumbing for the 'recurse' outcome (an empty spawnedImpasseIds: NodeId[] array, an outcomeTag branch, and a return shape with spawnedImpasseIds + suggestedRewindPhase) and engine/derivation-loop.ts already has a case \"recurse\" handler that calls runDerivationLoop with outcome.spawnedImpasseIds; only the population of spawnedImpasseIds is missing.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X63]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 163, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Wiring cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate is a blocking prerequisite: the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it.", - "body": "Wiring cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate is a blocking prerequisite: the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 164, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P29: Resolved design question #10 in PLAN.md states nudge_after_n default is 2, but the M8 checklist and derivation loop both use 1; the de…", - "body": "P29: Resolved design question #10 in PLAN.md states nudge_after_n default is 2, but the M8 checklist and derivation loop both use 1; the design question should be updated.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 165, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "FanInExtractionResult is currently defined in src/agents/fan-in.ts and re-exported from src/engine/derivation-agents.ts; it is referenced i…", - "body": "FanInExtractionResult is currently defined in src/agents/fan-in.ts and re-exported from src/engine/derivation-agents.ts; it is referenced in src/engine/fan-in.ts.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 166, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspectives should be records (like DerivationRunRecord or FanInRecord), not hub nodes in the graph, because they…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspectives should be records (like DerivationRunRecord or FanInRecord), not hub nodes in the graph, because they carry no epistemic weight and nothing downstream derives support through them.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 167, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "engine/solver/dpll.ts must expose a public surface containing at least: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbo…", - "body": "engine/solver/dpll.ts must expose a public surface containing at least: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, and demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 168, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Every test in the unit, module, and property layers must be deterministic and must not make live LLM calls; only the single VCR E2E test ma…", - "body": "Every test in the unit, module, and property layers must be deterministic and must not make live LLM calls; only the single VCR E2E test may interact with OpenRouter, and only via recorded snapshots during normal test execution.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R45]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 169, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P7: selectPerspective computes hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements on SelectionOutcome, but clean-room-resolution.ts never read…", - "body": "P7: selectPerspective computes hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements on SelectionOutcome, but clean-room-resolution.ts never reads either field; repair selections and revision authorization flows are not implemented.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 170, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test of the clean-room prompt builder must verify that when FrameRecord.nudgingActive=true, the assembled prompt contains a negative…", - "body": "A unit test of the clean-room prompt builder must verify that when FrameRecord.nudgingActive=true, the assembled prompt contains a negative-constraint section listing the alternative selections from prior clean attempts in the same frame; when nudgingActive=false, no such section is present. Verified by string-presence assertions on assembled prompt.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 171, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: split fan-in into two stages — Stage 1 LLM extraction (canonical candidates, contradictions, candidate repairs, axe…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: split fan-in into two stages — Stage 1 LLM extraction (canonical candidates, contradictions, candidate repairs, axes, alternatives, constraints, impasses, witness relations); Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis (model validation, backbone computation, configuration enumeration, perspective generation).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 172, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Cross-spec references point to specific checkpoints; when a referenced checkpoi…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T12]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Cross-spec references point to specific checkpoints; when a referenced checkpoint has a successor, the reference becomes a suspect link for human review rather than silently rebound." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 173, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Frames have both parentFrameId (impasse call stack nesting) and baselineFrameId…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T3]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Frames have both parentFrameId (impasse call stack nesting) and baselineFrameId (reconciliation target); in cascading examples these point to different frames." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 174, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "After a user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine must perform the following steps in order: (1) mark the un-chosen…", - "body": "After a user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine must perform the following steps in order: (1) mark the un-chosen-side grounding nodes for the resolved contradiction as suspect; (2) call markSuspectAndPropagate from each; (3) run revisionImpact to compute the OUT set; (4) create a new child frame whose entryPhase is the earliest-affected phase among OUT nodes; (5) re-run the derivation loop in that frame.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 175, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The derivation loop cannot recurse or refine impasses; several reconciliation outcomes are wired in the type system but never produce effec…", - "body": "The derivation loop cannot recurse or refine impasses; several reconciliation outcomes are wired in the type system but never produce effects.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 176, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The resume flow must restart the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate; clean-room…", - "body": "The resume flow must restart the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate; clean-room re-derivations within that frame must start with a fresh Chat per T2.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R54]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 177, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A repo-wide grep/static analysis check must confirm that WorkingGraph.cowReplace and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate each have at leas…", - "body": "A repo-wide grep/static analysis check must confirm that WorkingGraph.cowReplace and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate each have at least one caller outside their defining class (i.e., the methods are no longer orphaned).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 178, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test must verify that perspective summaries are persisted as plain records under graph/ (e.g., attached to FanInRecord/DerivationRun…", - "body": "A unit test must verify that perspective summaries are persisted as plain records under graph/ (e.g., attached to FanInRecord/DerivationRunRecord JSON), each carrying at minimum: id, configuration vector, default-bundle status flag, short label. The test must assert no Perspective hub appears in the graph nodes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 179, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "An integration test driving the engine through a forward pass plus one impasse cycle must subscribe to the Effect EventLog and assert that…", - "body": "An integration test driving the engine through a forward pass plus one impasse cycle must subscribe to the Effect EventLog and assert that at least one event of each of the following tags is observed in the expected order: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt, FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed, ReconcileOutcome, ImpasseSpawned, ImpasseResolved, UserInterventionRequested, UserInterventionResolved.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 180, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Impasse triage is currently a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) with a five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premis…", - "body": "Impasse triage is currently a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) with a five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premise > term/ontology mismatch > upstream structural contradiction > endogenous design conflict (default).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 181, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Enrichment nodes must carry dual provenance: a workflow provenance edge (motivates) pointing at the impasse that prompted the inquiry, and…", - "body": "Enrichment nodes must carry dual provenance: a workflow provenance edge (motivates) pointing at the impasse that prompted the inquiry, and a separate evidential provenance edge to the direct exogenous source. Only the evidential provenance may be used to justify downstream derivation; workflow provenance must not propagate taint.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R60]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 182, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A schema/type-level test must verify that ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult does NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/must…", - "body": "A schema/type-level test must verify that ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult does NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated configurations, or scoped-impasse outputs; any attempt to read such a field from the schema must be a TypeScript compile error.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 183, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the nudge threshold k (nudgeAfterN) is dynamic and set to 1, meaning nudging begins after 1 clean attempt.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the nudge threshold k (nudgeAfterN) is dynamic and set to 1, meaning nudging begins after 1 clean attempt.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X42]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 184, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The 30-line DerivationAgents construction code must be extracted from cli/run.ts into a factory module (engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts…", - "body": "The 30-line DerivationAgents construction code must be extracted from cli/run.ts into a factory module (engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts or src/agents/factory.ts) parameterized by LanguageModel, so tests can inject scripted agents and the CLI can inject the OpenRouter-backed implementation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R48]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 185, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a blocking impasse is a first-class persistent graph node with semantic meaning as a recorded decision point.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a blocking impasse is a first-class persistent graph node with semantic meaning as a recorded decision point.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 186, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Agents must continue to emit semanticKey and support sets in their IR output; the graph assembler is responsible for assigning UUIDs and di…", - "body": "Agents must continue to emit semanticKey and support sets in their IR output; the graph assembler is responsible for assigning UUIDs and display IDs and creating edges. Agents must not produce UUIDs or display IDs for nodes they are creating in the same batch.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R70]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 187, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question: how many representative perspective configurations to show (k) and how to handle configuration clustering for M_current vs M…", - "body": "Open question: how many representative perspective configurations to show (k) and how to handle configuration clustering for M_current vs M_preview.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-assumed [RK17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 188, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P20: The fan-out conditional label policy (makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts) is untested; it is pure logic with no LLM dependency.", - "body": "P20: The fan-out conditional label policy (makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts) is untested; it is pure logic with no LLM dependency.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 189, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "After resolution, the BlockingImpasse node must remain in the graph with status: resolved (not deleted) and must participate in JTMS proven…", - "body": "After resolution, the BlockingImpasse node must remain in the graph with status: resolved (not deleted) and must participate in JTMS provenance chains as a recorded decision point.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 190, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives…", - "body": "Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives, selected, rejected, consequences, premises, conclusions, etc.) must be typed via NodeIdFromDisplayId in the agent output schemas instead of plain string.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 191, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test of the fan-in aggregation must verify that three-valued aggregation reads stance from the structured perRunStance field (values…", - "body": "A unit test of the fan-in aggregation must verify that three-valued aggregation reads stance from the structured perRunStance field (values exactly 'supports'|'contradicts'|'silent') and not by parsing prose. Negative test: a fixture in which a run is silent on alternative A1 (no perRunStance entry) but supports A2 on the same axis must NOT aggregate as 'contradicts' for A1.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 192, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: FanInExtractionResult is to be deleted and replaced entirely with a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema,…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: FanInExtractionResult is to be deleted and replaced entirely with a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema, with no backward compatibility.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 193, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Session state persistence for the resume command is an open question; the stakeholder expressed preference for no mutable-state checkpoint…", - "body": "Session state persistence for the resume command is an open question; the stakeholder expressed preference for no mutable-state checkpoint dumps and may prefer restarting over complex resumability.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 194, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "validateModel must reject configuration models in which any axis contains alternatives at mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'conf…", - "body": "validateModel must reject configuration models in which any axis contains alternatives at mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'configurable'); such models must be flagged for manual repair rather than silently accepted.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 195, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test must construct a perRunStance fixture in which run R1 supports alternative A1 on axis X and is silent on alternative A2 on the…", - "body": "A unit test must construct a perRunStance fixture in which run R1 supports alternative A1 on axis X and is silent on alternative A2 on the same axis X, and assert that the aggregation accepts and preserves this distinction (no implicit 'all alternatives on the axis share the run's stance').", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 196, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question: for v1, consider disabling auto-resolution of repair precedence and surfacing all contradictions as repair axes to preserve…", - "body": "Open question: for v1, consider disabling auto-resolution of repair precedence and surfacing all contradictions as repair axes to preserve correctness at the cost of more user decisions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-assumed [RK18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 197, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Elicitation is interactive by default because the user is the oracle; authority conflicts, unjustified omissions, impasse escalation, and b…", - "body": "Elicitation is interactive by default because the user is the oracle; authority conflicts, unjustified omissions, impasse escalation, and bail decisions cannot be automated.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 198, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The spec elicitation prototype is an AI-assisted system that transforms raw source documents into structured, typed specification graphs th…", - "body": "The spec elicitation prototype is an AI-assisted system that transforms raw source documents into structured, typed specification graphs through a multi-phase derivation pipeline.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [G1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 199, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Hub nodes (Justification, Decision, Impasse) make joint causation explicit; the…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T8]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Hub nodes (Justification, Decision, Impasse) make joint causation explicit; they carry content and connect 1..n incoming edges to 0..n outgoing edges. Decision and Impasse are subtypes of Justification with their own subtype-specific edge roles." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 200, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: genuine impasses must be extracted before the configuration space is computed, to prevent 'some runs picked sides'…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: genuine impasses must be extracted before the configuration space is computed, to prevent 'some runs picked sides' from hiding a real impasse.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X44]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 201, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Perspective must not appear in the graph's hub-kind union; the hub-kind union remains exactly {Justification, Decision, Impasse} from T8.", - "body": "Perspective must not appear in the graph's hub-kind union; the hub-kind union remains exactly {Justification, Decision, Impasse} from T8. Existing edges that pointed to a Perspective hub must be removed, and any persisted graph artifacts containing Perspective hubs must be migrated or rejected.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 202, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: all alternatives on a single axis must be at the same abstraction level; axes with mixed abstraction levels (e.g.,…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: all alternatives on a single axis must be at the same abstraction level; axes with mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'configurable') are rejected by validateModel and escalated for manual repair.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X46]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 203, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Stage 1 ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated co…", - "body": "The Stage 1 ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated configurations, or scoped impasses. The schema must structurally forbid the LLM from producing solver outputs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 204, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The solver already implements backbone computation (mustSelect/mustDeselect) as a deterministic function over the configuration model.", - "body": "The solver already implements backbone computation (mustSelect/mustDeselect) as a deterministic function over the configuration model.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 205, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The forward pass must remain working throughout the code health improvements.", - "body": "The forward pass must remain working throughout the code health improvements.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [C1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 206, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: if M_current is empty, the system is in a dead-end state and must emit a global blocking impasse rather than inferr…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: if M_current is empty, the system is in a dead-end state and must emit a global blocking impasse rather than inferring substrate from vacuous truth.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X48]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 207, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "An axis is an independent dimension of variability discovered by fan-in; it has…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T15]", - "detail": { - "definition": "An axis is an independent dimension of variability discovered by fan-in; it has an id, type (design or repair), cardinality (exactly_one or zero_or_one), and label." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 208, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each of the five staged increments (A correctness wiring, B reference integrity, C observability, D feature-model redesign, E test + hygien…", - "body": "Each of the five staged increments (A correctness wiring, B reference integrity, C observability, D feature-model redesign, E test + hygiene) must be independently mergeable while keeping the forward pass functional and the existing smoke-test artifacts validating.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R55]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 209, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test must verify the solver module at engine/solver/dpll.ts exports public functions: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(…", - "body": "A unit test must verify the solver module at engine/solver/dpll.ts exports public functions: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, and demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}. Calling each with fixture inputs returns the documented shape.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 210, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test must verify that NodeIdFromDisplayId: (a) decodes a valid display ID against a live WorkingGraph to the corresponding NodeId, (…", - "body": "A unit test must verify that NodeIdFromDisplayId: (a) decodes a valid display ID against a live WorkingGraph to the corresponding NodeId, (b) fails decode with a structured error when the display ID does not exist in the graph, (c) round-trips encode/decode for valid IDs (property test).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 211, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "'Silent' stance means a run neither supports nor contradicts a specific alterna…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T19]", - "detail": { - "definition": "'Silent' stance means a run neither supports nor contradicts a specific alternative; it is a distinct value from 'supports' and 'contradicts'." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 212, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation cannot archive a node without justification; if upstream grounding still supports a node and there's…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation cannot archive a node without justification; if upstream grounding still supports a node and there's no contradiction, mere omission by re-derivation is insufficient reason to archive.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X54]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 213, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A type-level test must verify that the graph's hub-kind union type is exactly {Justification | Decision | Impasse} and does not include Per…", - "body": "A type-level test must verify that the graph's hub-kind union type is exactly {Justification | Decision | Impasse} and does not include Perspective; an attempt to pattern-match Perspective as a hub kind must fail the TypeScript compiler.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 214, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The core architecture is sound; problems concentrate in three areas: incomplete wiring in the derivation loop, silent data loss when agents…", - "body": "The core architecture is sound; problems concentrate in three areas: incomplete wiring in the derivation loop, silent data loss when agents produce invalid references, and missing test coverage for pure-logic components.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 215, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Open question: should a lightweight existing SAT library or a custom DPLL implementation be used for the solver?", - "body": "Open question: should a lightweight existing SAT library or a custom DPLL implementation be used for the solver? Expected scale (5–20 axes, 2–5 alternatives) is small enough for either.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-assumed [RK16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 216, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P17: revisionImpact in solver.ts is implemented but never called outside tests; combined with empty justifications, the entire revision imp…", - "body": "P17: revisionImpact in solver.ts is implemented but never called outside tests; combined with empty justifications, the entire revision impact subsystem is effectively dead.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 217, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Perspective summaries must be persisted as plain records attached to FanInRecord (or a sibling DerivationRunRecord) under graph/, each carr…", - "body": "Perspective summaries must be persisted as plain records attached to FanInRecord (or a sibling DerivationRunRecord) under graph/, each carrying at minimum: an id, the configuration vector, a default-bundle status flag (display only), and a short label.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 218, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The derivation loop (which handles impasses, backward transitions, fan-out, and reconciliation) is partially implemented with significant c…", - "body": "The derivation loop (which handles impasses, backward transitions, fan-out, and reconciliation) is partially implemented with significant correctness gaps.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 219, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Readiness must be evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection; the perspective summary's default-bundle status flag must be display…", - "body": "Readiness must be evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection; the perspective summary's default-bundle status flag must be display-only and must not be used as a readiness gate.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 220, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A type-level test must verify that the axis 'type' field accepts only 'design' or 'repair'; constructing an axis with type='revision' must…", - "body": "A type-level test must verify that the axis 'type' field accepts only 'design' or 'repair'; constructing an axis with type='revision' must fail schema decode.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 221, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The extraction step between raw sources and grounding nodes serves a correctnes…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T5]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The extraction step between raw sources and grounding nodes serves a correctness purpose: 'grounding still supports this node' (checked during reconciliation) requires claim-level support, not file-level presence." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 222, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Stage 1 fan-in must extract genuine impasses before any configuration space (M_current/M_preview/M_revision) is computed by Stage 2, ensuri…", - "body": "Stage 1 fan-in must extract genuine impasses before any configuration space (M_current/M_preview/M_revision) is computed by Stage 2, ensuring that 'some runs picked a side' on a contradiction cannot mask a real impasse.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 223, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: after repair selection, taint propagation uses markSuspectAndPropagate, and all OUT nodes are re-derived in place v…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: after repair selection, taint propagation uses markSuspectAndPropagate, and all OUT nodes are re-derived in place via cowReplace by re-running the relevant phase agents.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 224, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or Routine abstractions.", - "body": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or Routine abstractions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [C3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 225, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: re-derivation after repair should enter a new frame and rerun the complete downstream starting from the earliest af…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: re-derivation after repair should enter a new frame and rerun the complete downstream starting from the earliest affected phase, then reconcile with existing content.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 226, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "Fan-out produces N independent derivations of the same phase; when they disagree, the current system creates impasse nodes, which causes an…", - "body": "Fan-out produces N independent derivations of the same phase; when they disagree, the current system creates impasse nodes, which causes an infinite loop because re-derivation cannot resolve inherent design-space disagreements.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 227, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence must be disabled by default in v1 via a config.repairAutoResolve flag defaulting to false;…", - "body": "Solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence must be disabled by default in v1 via a config.repairAutoResolve flag defaulting to false; every detected contradiction must surface as a repair axis to the user regardless of evidence asymmetry. The auto-resolution code path must be feature-flagged rather than removed.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 228, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "No integration test exercises the full triage-to-resolution pipeline.", - "body": "No integration test exercises the full triage-to-resolution pipeline.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 229, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Supporting parallel/concurrent spec design sessions is deferred because each spec design can take 20 minutes to an hour and internal state…", - "body": "Supporting parallel/concurrent spec design sessions is deferred because each spec design can take 20 minutes to an hour and internal state is not centralized, making concurrency incompatible with the current architecture.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 230, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The 40-line formatHandoffReport function must be extracted from cli/run.ts into cli/format-handoff-report.ts as a pure function (HandoffRep…", - "body": "The 40-line formatHandoffReport function must be extracted from cli/run.ts into cli/format-handoff-report.ts as a pure function (HandoffReport → string) with snapshot-based unit tests.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R47]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 231, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When the solver determines M_current is empty or unsatisfiable, the engine must create a first-class Impasse hub node (kind: 'unsatisfiable…", - "body": "When the solver determines M_current is empty or unsatisfiable, the engine must create a first-class Impasse hub node (kind: 'unsatisfiable_configuration_space') in the graph with status: open and support edges to all hard-constraint nodes participating in the UNSAT core; the engine must NOT infer substrate from vacuous truth.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 232, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The tech stack is: Deno runtime, Effect v4 (beta 57), Effect CLI, Effect AI, @kael/ai (Fragment, Routine), @kael/core/platform, and @effect…", - "body": "The tech stack is: Deno runtime, Effect v4 (beta 57), Effect CLI, Effect AI, @kael/ai (Fragment, Routine), @kael/core/platform, and @effect/platform-node-shared. All agents use the LanguageModel abstraction; the concrete provider is OpenRouter wired at the CLI entry point.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 233, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The system must not write mid-derivation checkpoint dumps (no serialization of WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat at each reconcilia…", - "body": "The system must not write mid-derivation checkpoint dumps (no serialization of WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat at each reconciliation step). The only checkpointable state is a completed checkpoint produced when a full revision completes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R53]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 234, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Spec nodes are organized across three orthogonal axes: semantic role (goal, ter…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T7]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Spec nodes are organized across three orthogonal axes: semantic role (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk), epistemic status (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred), and authority (stakeholder, technical, external, derived)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 235, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Perspectives are currently modeled as hub nodes alongside justifications, decisions, and impasses, but carry no epistemic weight and should…", - "body": "Perspectives are currently modeled as hub nodes alongside justifications, decisions, and impasses, but carry no epistemic weight and should be records instead.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 236, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The current impasse-based model for cross-run divergence uses the wrong mental model: it asks the user to resolve individual point-conflict…", - "body": "The current impasse-based model for cross-run divergence uses the wrong mental model: it asks the user to resolve individual point-conflicts when the real question is which overall design vision they want.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [E33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 237, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Cross-run divergence has three distinct categories: genuine impasse (source pol…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [T13]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Cross-run divergence has three distinct categories: genuine impasse (source policy conflict), design perspective (both grounded and coherent alternatives), and derivation noise (hallucinated without grounding basis)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 238, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a subagent is invoked for conflict resolution only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure — e.g., when prov…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a subagent is invoked for conflict resolution only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure — e.g., when provenance edges are missing or the contradiction is semantic rather than structural.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X56]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 239, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: replace Console.log calls throughout the engine with either Effect's structured logging (Effect.logInfo/Effect.logD…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: replace Console.log calls throughout the engine with either Effect's structured logging (Effect.logInfo/Effect.logDebug) or a typed event bus with structured per-operation events, so the CLI becomes one consumer among many.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 240, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "A code health review of the spec elicitation prototype uncovered 34 issues across correctness, design, testing, and systemic architecture.", - "body": "A code health review of the spec elicitation prototype uncovered 34 issues across correctness, design, testing, and systemic architecture.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 241, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "assembler.ts must not silently drop or filter out unresolved displayId references; the post-hoc resolve-and-filter step (.filter(nodeId !==…", - "body": "assembler.ts must not silently drop or filter out unresolved displayId references; the post-hoc resolve-and-filter step (.filter(nodeId !== undefined) and non-blocking error logging) must be removed in favor of schema-level decode failures that surface as Effect AI tool result errors.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 242, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A unit test of Stage 1 extraction must verify that hard constraints are emitted only with witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency,…", - "body": "A unit test of Stage 1 extraction must verify that hard constraints are emitted only with witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency, grounded_rationale} and a citation; negative test: a fixture exhibiting non-cooccurrence of alternatives across 5 fan-out runs without any witnessing rationale must NOT produce a hard constraint.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 243, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P23: domain/invariants.ts has support-edge acyclicity detection and phase stratification checks, but these are not tested with violating gr…", - "body": "P23: domain/invariants.ts has support-edge acyclicity detection and phase stratification checks, but these are not tested with violating graphs; validate() is not called in any test file.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 244, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) must consume engine events as a subscriber to the EventLog rather than receiving them via Console.lo…", - "body": "The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) must consume engine events as a subscriber to the EventLog rather than receiving them via Console.log; the CLI must continue to render human-readable output equivalent to the prior Console.log output for each event variant it cares about.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 245, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the LLM extraction stage must NOT compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses; those are determin…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the LLM extraction stage must NOT compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses; those are deterministic solver operations.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [X49]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 246, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The system is implemented as a standalone CLI prototype in packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/, containing src/, spec/, PLAN.md, and PR…", - "body": "The system is implemented as a standalone CLI prototype in packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/, containing src/, spec/, PLAN.md, and PROBLEMS.md.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 247, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "revisionImpact must mark a derived node as OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect, match…", - "body": "revisionImpact must mark a derived node as OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect, matching the JTMS-style propagation rule.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 248, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the EventLog should emit events beyond simple Console.log replacements for notable occurrences; finer granularity i…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the EventLog should emit events beyond simple Console.log replacements for notable occurrences; finer granularity is better but not every tiny detail needs an event.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 249, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The backbone function must return, for every axis whose value is forced, the set of constraint clauses (blockingClauses) that ruled out the…", - "body": "The backbone function must return, for every axis whose value is forced, the set of constraint clauses (blockingClauses) that ruled out the alternatives that were not forced, so the user can see which constraints made the other values impossible.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 250, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspective selection by the user is not new evidence; design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repa…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspective selection by the user is not new evidence; design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repair selection is non-monotone with respect to premises (downstream phases must be recomputed), and revision authorization requires the revision flow.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 251, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The resolution strategy must be maximally correct and must not take shortcuts.", - "body": "The resolution strategy must be maximally correct and must not take shortcuts.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 252, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P25: render/markdown.ts (329 lines) has no tests; a snapshot test with a known artifact would catch rendering regressions.", - "body": "P25: render/markdown.ts (329 lines) has no tests; a snapshot test with a known artifact would catch rendering regressions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 253, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P18: No end-to-end smoke test with an impasse scenario exists; DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver are injectable services so a determi…", - "body": "P18: No end-to-end smoke test with an impasse scenario exists; DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver are injectable services so a deterministic integration test is possible.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 254, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "P6: All baseline effects in fan-in.ts are hardcoded to commitmentLevel: \"locked\" and requiresAuthorization: true, without checking whether…", - "body": "P6: All baseline effects in fan-in.ts are hardcoded to commitmentLevel: \"locked\" and requiresAuthorization: true, without checking whether the baseline node is actually locked or provisional.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 255, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use a four-layer pyramid: unit + module (scripted) + property + one VCR E2E.", - "body": "Use a four-layer pyramid: unit + module (scripted) + property + one VCR E2E.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC19]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Test strategy is a four-layer pyramid: (1) Unit tests for pure logic — buildConfigModel (P21), assembler.ts (P19), makeCleanRoomPolicy (P20), perspective-selection.ts (P24), invariants.ts validate() including violating graphs (P23), solver primitives (validate/enumerate/backbone/demote), markdown render (P25), WorkingGraph artifact roundtrip (P22). (2) Module tests with scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver (already injectable per E18) for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow. (3) Property tests for: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monotonicity over repeated mark/unmark, (c) solver backbone equals intersection of enumerate(). (4) One end-to-end smoke test (P18) using VCR-recorded OpenRouter interactions covering all three impasse types in sequence (X61). The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts (P26) is split per module into test files colocated with the modules they cover.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: invest only in unit tests for P19–P25 and skip the VCR E2E because of the maintenance burden of recorded snapshots (RK14).", - "Alternative: invest only in the end-to-end VCR test (X61) and rely on it to indirectly cover assembler/solver/etc., skipping per-module unit tests." - ], - "rationale": "X62 puts tests P18–P25 ahead of correctness fixes — a test bar this high cannot rest on either alt-test-only-e2e (which leaves pure-logic regressions like P19–P25 invisible until the slow E2E catches them) or alt-test-only-units (RK6 is unaddressed; nothing exercises triage-to-resolution). C2 (deterministic, no LLM calls) is satisfied by layers 1–3 because they use scripted DerivationAgents (E18 confirms this is possible). The single VCR test bounds the maintenance cost flagged by RK14: re-record only when prompts change, and only one recording to maintain. Property tests are added for the components most likely to silently regress (schema decode, JTMS, backbone) where example-based unit tests provide weak assurance." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 256, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Extract format-handoff-report and derivation-agents-factory into separate modules.", - "body": "Extract format-handoff-report and derivation-agents-factory into separate modules.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC20]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Extract from cli/run.ts: (a) cli/format-handoff-report.ts containing the 40-line formatHandoffReport function as a pure function over HandoffReport → string, unit-tested with snapshot fixtures; (b) engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts (or src/agents/factory.ts) containing the 30-line DerivationAgents construction wiring, parameterized by LanguageModel so tests inject scripted agents and the CLI injects the OpenRouter-backed one. cli/run.ts becomes a thin orchestrator that imports both.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: leave the inlined helpers in cli/run.ts; the prototype is small enough that the extra module hop isn't worth the indirection." - ], - "rationale": "Both helpers are referenced by the test pyramid (formatHandoffReport needs snapshot tests against fixture HandoffReports; the factory is needed by every module test that wants real-shaped agents). alt-cli-keep-inline forces tests to either duplicate the construction logic or import from cli/run.ts (which pulls in CLI side-effects). E18 already established that scripted-agent injection is the testing strategy; the factory extraction is a precondition." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 257, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Wire nudging as negative-constraint prompt injection, gated on nudgingActive.", - "body": "Wire nudging as negative-constraint prompt injection, gated on nudgingActive.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC6]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the clean-room agent prompt builder (clean-room.ts) injects a negative-constraint section listing the alternative selections from prior clean attempts in the same frame ('avoid these previously explored choices: …'). nudgingActive itself remains a frame-level flag set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts; the new behavior is that fan-out reads the flag and the prior frame's reconciled outcomes when assembling the prompt for the next clean attempt.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: instead of injecting negative constraints, react to nudgingActive by raising sampling temperature on the LanguageModel call to encourage divergence.", - "Alternative: remove nudgingActive and nudgeAfterN entirely; rely on natural variance across N parallel clean-room runs to surface alternatives." - ], - "rationale": "T2 says 'retry feedback is schema-only', which forbids feeding the prior run's freeform output back; negative-constraint prompt injection is structurally compatible because it cites only stable schema-level alternatives that already exist in the graph. alt-nudging-temperature is opaque to the spec model — there's no way to express 'try harder' as a graph-level fact. alt-nudging-remove discards the existing FrameRecord field already plumbed through the loop (E14) and gives up the only existing mechanism for addressing repeat-output across attempts." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 258, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Adopt the six work-stream decomposition as the spec scope.", - "body": "Adopt the six work-stream decomposition as the spec scope.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC1]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Decompose the code-health work into six work-streams driven by the grounding: (1) Derivation-loop correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P11, P34, C6); (2) Reference-integrity via schema-level NodeIdFromDisplayId (P30); (3) Engine-decoupled observability via Effect EventLog (RK5, X14); (4) Feature-model / SAT replacement of the impasse-centric divergence model (E32, E33, X16–X25, X32–X37, X44–X50); (5) Pure-logic test coverage and an end-to-end VCR integration test (P18–P25, X61); (6) Hygiene / refactor / doc fixes (P26, P27, P28, P29, P6).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: scope only to the open correctness items (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) and explicitly defer the SAT/feature-model redesign and the EventLog migration.", - "Alternative: treat the work as a single big-bang rewrite — re-architect divergence handling, replace logging, redo references, and add tests in one merged change." - ], - "rationale": "X62 gives an explicit ordering (tests > correctness > design > rest) but also confirms all of these are in scope; the stakeholder design notes (X16–X60) explicitly call for the SAT/feature-model redesign and the EventLog migration as part of code-health, not as a separate spec. A correctness-only scope (alt-scope-correctness-only) would leave the dead code in the divergence model (P7, P8, P13, P17) un-addressed and contradict the stakeholder direction. A big-bang rewrite (alt-scope-bigbang) violates C1 (forward pass must keep working) and C4 (smoke-test artifacts must keep validating) because it would require simultaneous schema changes (X23) and behavioral changes. Six independent work-streams allow staged landing under C1/C4." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 259, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Build a custom DPLL with explanation instrumentation; reject off-the-shelf SAT and brute-force enumeration.", - "body": "Build a custom DPLL with explanation instrumentation; reject off-the-shelf SAT and brute-force enumeration.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC13]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Implement the SAT solver as a small custom DPLL in TypeScript at src/engine/solver/dpll.ts (~200–400 LOC) with: unit propagation, pure-literal elimination, chronological backtracking, and an instrumentation hook that records, for each backtrack, which clauses caused the conflict. Public surface: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}. The solver imports nothing outside std and Effect.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: skip SAT entirely; for the stated scale of 5–20 axes × 2–5 alternatives, enumerate all assignments and filter by constraint formulas, computing backbone by intersection.", - "Alternative: depend on an existing SAT library (e.g., a JS port of MiniSat or logic-solver). Use its model enumeration and (where available) its proof/explanation API." - ], - "rationale": "X59 and X60 both require constraint-attribution explanations on backbone, which most off-the-shelf SAT libraries do not expose without a UNSAT-core extension we'd have to bolt on anyway (RK13). RK13 also flags Deno compatibility risk for off-the-shelf libraries. alt-brute-force-enumeration is correct for tiny inputs but X32 (demotion candidates: 'identifying which demotions would make it solvable') is most naturally expressed as 'try the formula minus this clause and re-solve' — trivial in DPLL, awkward as 'enumerate again with one fewer filter and re-intersect'. The custom DPLL also gives full control over the blockingClauses field that X59 explicitly asks for." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 260, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Compute baseline effects from real graph state, not from a hardcoded constant.", - "body": "Compute baseline effects from real graph state, not from a hardcoded constant.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC5]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "buildBaselineEffects in fan-in.ts reads the actual baseline node's commitment level (locked vs. provisional) from the graph and sets requiresAuthorization accordingly; locked baseline nodes produce {commitmentLevel: 'locked', requiresAuthorization: true}, provisional baseline nodes produce {commitmentLevel: 'provisional', requiresAuthorization: false}. The function takes the WorkingGraph plus the baselineFrameId / baseline node id set, not just the FanIn extraction result.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: leave baseline effects hardcoded to {locked, requiresAuthorization: true} and document this as a v1 simplification." - ], - "rationale": "X18 explicitly defines baseline effects as a distinct layer of the model: 'per-alternative authorization requirements'. With them hardcoded to locked/true, every fan-in run pretends the baseline is locked even when it is provisional, which makes the M_revision flow always demand revision authorization for changes to provisional content — directly contradicting X20's three-space semantics. C7 (no shortcuts) rules out alt-baseline-keep-hardcoded." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 261, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Honor the agent hint with strict upstream-only validation; otherwise default to one phase down.", - "body": "Honor the agent hint with strict upstream-only validation; otherwise default to one phase down.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC3]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "determineRewindPhase becomes a function determineRewindPhase(currentPhase, suggestedRewindPhase?) that prefers the agent's suggestedRewindPhase when present and strictly upstream of currentPhase, validating against the four-phase order (grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done from X1) and falling back to 'one phase down' only when the hint is absent or invalid. It is plumbed through reconciliation.ts to where the recurse outcome is constructed.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: blindly trust the agent-supplied suggestedRewindPhase whenever set, with no acyclicity validation against currentPhase.", - "Alternative: keep determineRewindPhase as 'always one phase down' and instead remove suggestedRewindPhase from the agent schema as unused." - ], - "rationale": "X1 mandates strict derivational order; alt-rewind-trust-agent could let the agent push the loop forward or sideways, violating the support-edge acyclicity invariant in domain/invariants.ts. alt-rewind-always-one-down is what the code does today and is what P11/RK1 explicitly call broken — it discards information the agent already paid LLM tokens to compute (e.g., a missing-premise impasse that needs to rewind all the way to grounding, not just to the immediately previous phase). The validation guard makes the new behavior safe under C1 (forward pass keeps working when the hint is absent or stale)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 262, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Delete FanInExtractionResult and introduce a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult type.", - "body": "Delete FanInExtractionResult and introduce a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult type.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC12]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Define ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields: axes: ReadonlyArray<{id, type: 'design'|'repair', cardinality: 'exactly_one'|'zero_or_one', label}>; alternatives: ReadonlyArray<{id, axisId, label}>; perRunStance: ReadonlyArray<{runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance: 'supports'|'contradicts'|'silent', rationale?}>; witnesses: ReadonlyArray<{runId, claimId, sourceSpan}>; candidateRepairs: ReadonlyArray<{contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength}>; impasses: ReadonlyArray<{kind: 'authority_conflict'|'missing_premise'|..., conflictingNodes}>; hardConstraints: ReadonlyArray<{formula, witnessedBy: 'source_contradiction'|'dependency'|'grounded_rationale', citation}>. The previously-used FanInExtractionResult is deleted with no backward-compat shim.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: extend FanInExtractionResult with the new fields (axes, perRunStance, candidateRepairs) and keep the type name and existing import sites, providing a soft migration." - ], - "rationale": "X23 explicitly mandates 'delete with no backward compatibility'. The legacy type embeds the assumption that extraction produces hub-shaped records (P7: 'hasRepairSelections', 'hasRevisionRequirements' fields on SelectionOutcome), so an extension (alt-config-extend-fanin-schema) carries dead-load that would invite reuse of the old code path. C7 (no shortcuts) and the X16 redesign direction support the clean replacement; this is a prototype (G1, X4) so backward compatibility has no external consumers to protect." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 263, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Implement resume that re-enters the topmost open frame from the on-disk artifact; do not checkpoint mid-step.", - "body": "Implement resume that re-enters the topmost open frame from the on-disk artifact; do not checkpoint mid-step.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC22]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "For M5 resume/polish, do not implement mid-derivation checkpointing. The only checkpointable state is a completed checkpoint (T11: 'immutable snapshot when a full revision completes'); resume from anywhere else restarts the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate. The CLI gains a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earliest open impasse, and re-enters the derivation loop with that frame as parent.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: implement mid-derivation checkpoints — serialize WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat after every reconciliation step, allowing exact resume mid-step.", - "Alternative: drop M5 resume entirely; require restarting from scratch on any failure." - ], - "rationale": "RK7 records the stakeholder preference for no mutable-state checkpoint dumps. T2 requires clean-room re-derivation to start with a fresh Chat anyway, so 'resuming a chat in progress' is meaningless inside a frame. The on-disk graph is already the source of truth (X3: pure JSON file I/O, no DB); re-entering at frame boundaries is the largest unit at which resume is well-defined. alt-resume-checkpoint-dumps directly contradicts RK7. alt-resume-skip is heavier than necessary given a 20-min-to-1-hr session length (X4) where a process death without resume costs significant LLM-spend." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 264, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Repair selection triggers JTMS-driven re-derivation in a new child frame; design selection remains monotone.", - "body": "Repair selection triggers JTMS-driven re-derivation in a new child frame; design selection remains monotone.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC17]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "After the user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine: (1) marks the un-chosen-side grounding nodes for the resolved contradiction as suspect, (2) calls markSuspectAndPropagate from each, (3) runs revisionImpact to compute the OUT set, (4) creates a new child frame whose entryPhase is the earliest-affected phase of any OUT node, (5) re-runs the derivation loop in that frame; reconciliation then merges the re-derived content with the existing graph by archiving OUT nodes (with supersededBy edges per X40) when their replacements are accepted.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: treat repair selection identically to design selection — monotone, no re-derivation — simplifying perspective-selection.ts at the cost of leaving downstream content derived from the un-chosen contradiction side intact." - ], - "rationale": "X20 explicitly distinguishes: 'design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repair selection is non-monotone with respect to premises'. X45 reinforces the categorical split. alt-repair-monotone-likedesign produces a graph where downstream phases reference grounding facts the user has just rejected — exactly the silent-contradiction problem that motivated the entire feature-model redesign (E33). The new-child-frame approach (X39) keeps the re-derivation auditable and reuses the existing reconciliation machinery rather than a new in-place rewrite path." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 265, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Adopt the two-stage split with a hard schema boundary forbidding solver outputs from Stage 1.", - "body": "Adopt the two-stage split with a hard schema boundary forbidding solver outputs from Stage 1.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC11]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Split fan-in into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction (agents/fan-in.ts) emits a ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult containing only canonical candidates, axes (with type + cardinality + label), alternatives, per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent per run × axis × alternative), witness relations, candidate repairs, source-cited contradictions, and explicitly-witnessed hard constraints. Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis (engine/solver.ts + new engine/config-model.ts) consumes that result and computes: model validation, M_current/M_preview/M_revision spaces, backbone (mustSelect/mustDeselect with constraint-rule attribution), configuration enumeration, perspective generation. The Stage 1 schema explicitly disallows fields that would let the LLM pre-compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: extend the LLM extraction stage to also produce backbone and configuration enumeration so there is only one stage, eliminating the solver module.", - "Alternative: keep the existing single-stage FanInExtractionResult and patch it incrementally — add a structured stance field for P13, fix three-valued aggregation in-place, leave backbone and configuration enumeration where they are." - ], - "rationale": "X19 + X49 jointly mandate this split. The current single-stage design (alt-fanin-keep-single-stage) is what made E32's infinite-loop pathology possible: when the LLM 'decides' a contradiction it is computing backbone non-deterministically across runs, which is exactly the behavior X49 forbids. alt-fanin-llm-does-everything is incompatible with X49 and with C2 (deterministic tests) — backbone would no longer be a pure function of the extraction. The hard schema boundary (Stage 1 cannot return backbone fields) is what enforces the determinism property at compile time." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 266, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Adopt NodeIdFromDisplayId as a schema type with checkEffect-based decode against the live graph.", - "body": "Adopt NodeIdFromDisplayId as a schema type with checkEffect-based decode against the live graph.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC7]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Introduce a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type built on Schema.transformOrFail / SchemaGetter.checkEffect that decodes a display ID string against the live WorkingGraph and either yields the resolved NodeId or fails the schema decode with a structured error. Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId references this schema instead of plain string. Schema decode failures bubble up as Effect AI tool result errors so the LLM sees them on the next turn and retries; assembler.ts's silent post-hoc resolve-and-filter step is removed.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: keep displayId as plain string in the schema, but turn the silent .filter(undefined) in assembler.ts into a hard error that aborts the derivation step; surface it back to the agent via the existing reconciler retry path.", - "Alternative: deprecate displayId references in agent output entirely; require agents to emit only semanticKey references for upstream support, and have the assembler resolve semantic keys (which exist deterministically per emit batch)." - ], - "rationale": "X12 directly mandates this approach. The schema-level placement means failures appear in the natural Effect AI retry loop (LLM sees a structured tool error and retries) rather than requiring a custom retry path on top of assembler errors (alt-nodeid-validation-after-assembly), which is a parallel mechanism that duplicates Effect AI's own behavior. alt-nodeid-semantic-key-only is too restrictive: agents legitimately need to reference pre-existing graph nodes by their stable display ID across phases (e.g., a shaping design that supports a grounding constraint by ID), and semantic keys are scoped to a single derivation batch (X10). The schema-level approach addresses RK2 and P30 in the place where the contract between LLM and engine actually lives." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 267, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Default repair auto-resolution off in v1; surface every contradiction as a repair axis.", - "body": "Default repair auto-resolution off in v1; surface every contradiction as a repair axis.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC18]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "For v1 of the new fan-in, disable solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence (X43): every detected contradiction becomes a repair axis presented to the user, regardless of evidence asymmetry. Auto-resolution becomes a follow-up pass once the repair flow is exercised in tests. The auto-resolution code path is feature-flagged (config.repairAutoResolve = false by default) rather than removed, so X43's design intent is preserved.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: ship X43's auto-resolution heuristic on by default in v1." - ], - "rationale": "RK18 explicitly suggests this for v1, citing correctness over user load. C7 (maximally correct, no shortcuts) prefers conservative behavior when the heuristic 'one repair option is clearly better-evidenced' has not yet been validated against real fan-in data. alt-repair-autoresolve-on risks silent decisions during the period when the repair flow is also new, compounding error sources during integration testing." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 268, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Persist blocking impasses as first-class graph nodes participating in JTMS.", - "body": "Persist blocking impasses as first-class graph nodes participating in JTMS.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC15]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "When the solver returns M_current as empty or unsatisfiable, the engine creates a first-class BlockingImpasse Impasse node (kind: 'unsatisfiable_configuration_space') in the graph with: support edges to all hard-constraint nodes that participate in the UNSAT core, status: open. The engine then surfaces demotionCandidates to the user; the user's chosen demotion is recorded as a relaxed_to edge from the BlockingImpasse node to the demoted constraint node. The blocking impasse remains in the graph after resolution (status: resolved) so it participates in the JTMS chain as a recorded decision point.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: model the blocking impasse as a transient diagnostic (an entry on the FanInRecord, not a graph node); resolve it inline and never persist it." - ], - "rationale": "X33 + X35 explicitly mandate this. RK19's open question is resolved by X33 in this grounding; the answer is 'persistent graph node'. alt-blocking-impasse-transient breaks X34 (the user's demotion choice must be auditable as an edge from the impasse) and X35 (must participate in provenance/JTMS), neither of which work for a transient record. Persisting it also gives the user a stable referent if the same constraint conflict recurs across revisions." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 269, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Create a fresh refined Impasse node and emit a refined_to lineage edge from the original to the refined one; mark the original superseded a…", - "body": "Create a fresh refined Impasse node and emit a refined_to lineage edge from the original to the refined one; mark the original superseded and recurse with the refined node id in spawnedImpasseIds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC2]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "When the reconciler returns disposition: \"refined\" with a refinedImpasse payload, the reconciliation engine creates a new Impasse hub node in the graph (status: open), creates a refined_to lineage edge from the original impasse to the new one, marks the original as superseded, AND pushes the new node id onto spawnedImpasseIds so the recurse branch fires. This unifies P2's missing creation step with P1's missing population step.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: keep the original impasse as the live node and merely attach a refinedDescription field/edge to it instead of creating a new Impasse node, so refined_to is a self-annotation rather than a hub-to-hub edge.", - "Alternative: treat 'refined' as a terminal disposition that just marks the original impasse superseded without creating a successor; rely on the next pass through the loop to discover the residual problem fresh." - ], - "rationale": "X9 defines progress as 'incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses' — that progress signal only exists if refinement materializes a fresh node with an incoming refined_to edge, which alt-refined-as-edge-only does not produce. T9 distinguishes superseded as an impasse-status independent of lifecycle, which only makes sense if there is a successor to point at. alt-refined-as-resolved discards reconciler reasoning and forces re-discovery from scratch, contradicting C7 ('maximally correct, no shortcuts'). The chosen design also unifies cleanly with dec-recurse-wiring (single push site)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 270, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use a closed discriminated-union event catalog.", - "body": "Use a closed discriminated-union event catalog.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC9]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Define a closed event catalog as a discriminated union under src/engine/events.ts: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt(runIndex), FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed(modelStats), PerspectiveGenerated, ReconcileOutcome(_tag: accepted|retry|recurse|refined), ImpasseSpawned(impasseId, kind), ImpasseResolved(impasseId, disposition), NudgeActivated(frameId, attemptCount), CowReplace(oldNodeId, newNodeId), SuspectPropagated(rootId, count), BlockingImpasseRaised(scope), UserInterventionRequested(kind), UserInterventionResolved(kind, choice). Every Console.log call in the engine maps to exactly one of these. CLI rendering, the JSON event log artifact, and the future web inspector consume the same union.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: keep events open-ended (string tag + free-form payload) so adding a new event doesn't require touching the union." - ], - "rationale": "X15 says granularity should be 'notable occurrences' — a closed union enforces that bar at the type system level (you have to add a tag, which makes you ask 'is this notable?'). Open-ended events (alt-eventlog-freeform) regress to the current Console.log situation where every author chooses ad hoc strings, defeating the point of typed events for downstream consumers (M7 web inspector, E7)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 271, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Land doc fixes alongside the corresponding code changes.", - "body": "Land doc fixes alongside the corresponding code changes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC21]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Update PLAN.md in three places: (1) artifact layout section now lists graph/reconciliation-records.json (P28); (2) resolved design question #10 is updated to nudge_after_n default = 1, matching X42 and the implementation (P29, E36); (3) the post-redesign sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses are rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model (X16) and the deletion of FanInExtractionResult (X23).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: defer doc fixes to after the implementation lands; PLAN.md is internal and the discrepancies are minor." - ], - "rationale": "PLAN.md is referenced by the spec workflow (E6) and discrepancies between PLAN and code are exactly the class of error PROBLEMS.md tracks (P28, P29). Lettings docs drift (alt-doc-fix-defer) regenerates the same defect class. The change is minor enough to land per-PR with the corresponding code change." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 272, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Populate justifications and wire revisionImpact into the reconciliation engine.", - "body": "Populate justifications and wire revisionImpact into the reconciliation engine.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC16]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Populate the justifications field on derived nodes during assembly: assembler.ts, when creating a derived node, builds a justifications array with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub the node is connected to, recording {hubId, premiseIds: [...]}. solver.ts's revisionImpact function is called from the reconciliation engine whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, returning the closure of OUT (tainted) nodes per X28. The OUT closure is fed into the re-derivation flow (dec-cow-wiring).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: delete revisionImpact and the empty justifications field as dead code (P8/P17), formalize re-derivation as 'always re-run the affected phase clean' without belief revision." - ], - "rationale": "X28 + X29 + X38 specify JTMS-style propagation as the chosen mechanism for taint after repair selection. alt-jtms-remove-dead-code is feasible but conflicts with C7 (no shortcuts) and X40 (graph grows monotonically; superseded nodes retained with supersededBy edges) — retaining superseded nodes only makes sense if downstream consumers can distinguish IN from OUT, which is precisely what JTMS provides. The justifications + revisionImpact pair is already implemented and tested (E13, E17); the missing piece is connecting it." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 273, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Demote Perspective to a record; remove it from the hub-node kind union.", - "body": "Demote Perspective to a record; remove it from the hub-node kind union.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC10]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Demote Perspective from a hub-node kind in the graph to a plain record (struct) attached to the FanInRecord (or sibling DerivationRunRecord) artifact written under graph/. Edges that today point to a Perspective hub are removed; perspective summaries are referenced by id within the record store and rendered by the CLI/inspector. The graph schema's hub-kind union (T8: Justification, Decision, Impasse) is unchanged; perspective ceases to be one.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: keep Perspective as a hub node but mark it 'epistemically inert' so reconciliation never derives support through it." - ], - "rationale": "X11 is the explicit stakeholder preference. Hub nodes carry epistemic weight (T8: 'make joint causation explicit') — a hub that is by definition inert (alt-perspective-keep-hub) is a category error and a footgun for the reconciler, which would have to special-case 'this hub kind doesn't propagate support'. Records sit naturally next to FanInRecord and DerivationRunRecord (already in graph/), and the CLI already renders records via formatHandoffReport-shaped code (E27)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 274, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Wire cowReplace + markSuspectAndPropagate into the grounding-enrichment + intervention paths.", - "body": "Wire cowReplace + markSuspectAndPropagate into the grounding-enrichment + intervention paths.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC4]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Immediately after every cowReplace call, the engine calls markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) which traverses identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into per X53) and sets review status to suspect on all transitively reachable nodes. The derivation loop reads suspect status to decide which downstream phases need re-derivation in the next iteration.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: delete cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate as YAGNI dead code, since they have no callers (E31).", - "Alternative: keep grounding-enrichment as additive-only — always append new grounding nodes, never replace, and rely on the reconciler to archive obsolete originals; do not call cowReplace." - ], - "rationale": "C6 makes this a blocking prerequisite for derivation-loop signoff (\"the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it\"). X57 makes the same claim normatively. T10 specifies COW semantics for grounding, so alt-cow-mutate-in-place contradicts the stated substrate model and would force the reconciler to do double work to discover obsolete originals. alt-cow-delete-orphan-methods directly violates C6 and the X16–X40 stakeholder direction. Combined wiring of both functions is required because cowReplace alone leaves downstream nodes still pointing at superseded premises with clean status — markSuspectAndPropagate is what keeps the JTMS chain (X28) consistent." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 275, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Stage A–E in dependency order with parallelism between independent stages.", - "body": "Stage A–E in dependency order with parallelism between independent stages.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC23]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Land the work in five staged increments, each independently mergeable while keeping the forward pass green (C1) and the smoke artifacts validating (C4): Stage A (correctness wiring) — dec-recurse-wiring + dec-refined-impasse + dec-rewind-phase + dec-baseline-effects + dec-nudging + dec-cow-wiring + dec-jtms (population only); Stage B (reference integrity) — dec-nodeid-from-displayid; Stage C (observability) — dec-eventlog + dec-eventlog-catalog; Stage D (feature-model redesign) — dec-fanin-two-stage + dec-config-schema-replace + dec-solver-impl + dec-perspective-record + dec-perspective-generation + dec-blocking-impasse + dec-repair-flow + dec-repair-autoresolve; Stage E (test + hygiene) — dec-test-strategy + dec-cli-extract + dec-doc-fixes + dec-resume. Stages A–C and E can land in any order; D depends on A's JTMS wiring and B's NodeIdFromDisplayId.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: follow X62's stated priority order strictly — land all of P18–P25 (tests) first, then correctness, then design, then everything else — with no parallel staging." - ], - "rationale": "Strict X62 priority ordering (alt-staging-priority-strict) puts tests first, but dec-test-strategy depends on dec-cli-extract (factory injection for module tests, design-cli-extract-modules), which is itself a hygiene item ranked lower in X62. The dependency graph forces some interleaving. The proposed staging respects the spirit of X62 (correctness items P1/P2/P10/P32 land in Stage A early; tests land in Stage E across all the modules now made testable) while allowing independent landings. C1/C4 are preserved per stage because each stage's changes are scoped: A patches existing wiring, B is a schema change with retry behavior, C is an observability swap, D is the redesign behind a feature flag during transition, E is additive tests + refactors." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 276, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Migrate the engine to Effect EventLog with typed events; the CLI becomes one subscriber.", - "body": "Migrate the engine to Effect EventLog with typed events; the CLI becomes one subscriber.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC8]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Replace every Console.log call in src/engine/** (fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection.ts, assembler.ts) with an Effect EventLog (effect/EventLog) emission that publishes a typed, tagged event ({_tag: 'FanInStarted'|'FanInCompleted'|'FanOutAttempt'|'ReconcileOutcome'|'PhaseEntered'|'ImpasseSpawned'|'ImpasseResolved'|'CowReplace'|'SuspectPropagated'|'NudgeActivated'|...}, payload). The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) becomes a subscriber that renders these events to stdout via its existing formatHandoffReport-style code paths. The engine no longer imports Console.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: keep Console.log but funnel it through a single helper module so the coupling is at one place; defer EventLog migration to post-prototype.", - "Alternative: replace Console.log with Effect.logInfo / Effect.logDebug structured logging (the X13 fallback option) without introducing an EventLog topic and subscriber model." - ], - "rationale": "X14 is an explicit stakeholder preference for EventLog specifically over Effect.logInfo. X15 calls for events on notable occurrences — i.e. domain-meaningful events like 'ImpasseSpawned', not log levels — which is the EventLog model and not the Effect.logInfo model (alt-eventlog-effect-logger), where consumers cannot dispatch on _tag. alt-eventlog-keep-console preserves the current coupling to a CLI presentation layer (RK5) and is incompatible with the planned web inspector (M7, E7) which needs a structured stream of engine events to render. The X13/X14/X15 chain is monotone in stakeholder preference toward EventLog; X14 is the latest preference and supersedes the X13 fallback." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 277, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis vectors with k=3 per space.", - "body": "Use farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis vectors with k=3 per space.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC14]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Generate perspective summaries by sampling configurations from the SAT solver's enumeration (capped at e.g. 200 per space) and running farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis-assignment vectors to pick k=3 representatives per space (M_current and M_preview separately). Each representative becomes a Perspective record carrying: the configuration vector, a default-bundle status flag (display only), and a short LLM-generated label. evaluateSelection runs against any user-chosen bundle and is the only readiness gate.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: use a clustering algorithm (e.g., k-means with one-hot embedding) instead of k-medoids; centroids are not real configurations, so generate the closest real configuration to each centroid as the representative.", - "Alternative: surface every distinct configuration in M_current up to a bound; let the UI handle scrolling." - ], - "rationale": "X21 directly specifies this method. k-medoids returns real configurations, which fits dec-perspective-record (the record has to point at a real activatable configuration); alt-perspective-clustering needs a 'snap to nearest real config' post-step that is just k-medoids in disguise. alt-perspective-show-all defeats X33's notion of 'perspective' as a digestible summary and would overwhelm the user when M_preview is large. k=3 is a conservative default given RK17's openness; making k a parameter is left for tuning." - } - } -] diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/spec.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/spec.json deleted file mode 100644 index d175d6c16..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/code-health/spec.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "slug": "code-health", - "name": "Code Health", - "readiness_grade": "commitments_ready" -} diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/edges.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/edges.json deleted file mode 100644 index e25da6d09..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/edges.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,4914 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 204, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 244, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 243, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 186, - "target_local_id": 4, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 252, - "target_local_id": 219, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 142, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 41, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 54, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 248, - "target_local_id": 138, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 278, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 187, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 123, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 114, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 156, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 22, - "target_local_id": 111, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 54, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 46, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 118, - "target_local_id": 34, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 3, - "target_local_id": 267, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 139, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 38, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 183, - "target_local_id": 241, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 25, - "target_local_id": 233, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 248, - "target_local_id": 240, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 168, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 70, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 249, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 119, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 243, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 212, - "target_local_id": 42, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 145, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 131, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 84, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 180, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 162, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 256, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 22, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 32, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 175, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 175, - "target_local_id": 162, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 245, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 132, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 184, - "target_local_id": 6, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 62, - "target_local_id": 122, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 48, - "target_local_id": 101, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 53, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 260, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 244, - "target_local_id": 135, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 81, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 23, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 256, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 39, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 118, - "target_local_id": 42, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 79, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 67, - "target_local_id": 247, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 42, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 102, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 131, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 32, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 113, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 279, - "target_local_id": 245, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 185, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 194, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 206, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 159, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 177, - "target_local_id": 230, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 13, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 236, - "target_local_id": 230, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 126, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 133, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 197, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 94, - "target_local_id": 108, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 200, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 240, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 258, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 13, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 280, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 162, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 236, - "target_local_id": 240, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 131, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 45, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 19, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 155, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 170, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 118, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 241, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 250, - "target_local_id": 5, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 279, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 198, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 162, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 21, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 238, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 114, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 136, - "target_local_id": 219, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 171, - "target_local_id": 250, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 5, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 279, - "target_local_id": 114, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 234, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 154, - "target_local_id": 41, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 66, - "target_local_id": 127, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 148, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 141, - "target_local_id": 78, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 132, - "target_local_id": 84, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 62, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 13, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 84, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 107, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 194, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 126, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 105, - "target_local_id": 7, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 156, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 207, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 249, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 59, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 278, - "target_local_id": 109, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 85, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 131, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 81, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 22, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 207, - "target_local_id": 202, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 95, - "target_local_id": 197, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 16, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 37, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 211, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 97, - "target_local_id": 48, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 9, - "target_local_id": 37, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 111, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 43, - "target_local_id": 256, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 163, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 6, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 61, - "target_local_id": 235, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 219, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 88, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 98, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 32, - "target_local_id": 245, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 39, - "target_local_id": 128, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 206, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 76, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 119, - "target_local_id": 162, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 77, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 278, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 155, - "target_local_id": 54, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 152, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 233, - "target_local_id": 267, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 85, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 256, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 63, - "target_local_id": 244, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 164, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 233, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 225, - "target_local_id": 180, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 115, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 235, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 152, - "target_local_id": 275, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 181, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 168, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 205, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 152, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 73, - "target_local_id": 194, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 121, - "target_local_id": 235, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 171, - "target_local_id": 5, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 246, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 88, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 59, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 246, - "target_local_id": 85, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 61, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 87, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 173, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 50, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 11, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 200, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 240, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 211, - "target_local_id": 238, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 48, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 280, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 175, - "target_local_id": 116, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 135, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 79, - "target_local_id": 27, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 34, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 276, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 118, - "target_local_id": 251, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 170, - "target_local_id": 79, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 38, - "target_local_id": 135, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 193, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 13, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 119, - "target_local_id": 116, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 81, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 141, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 9, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 197, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 168, - "target_local_id": 245, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 240, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 162, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 80, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 45, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 37, - "target_local_id": 7, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 22, - "target_local_id": 259, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 30, - "target_local_id": 23, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 252, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 170, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 24, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 138, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 46, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 203, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 192, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 169, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 136, - "target_local_id": 52, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 73, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 215, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 245, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 225, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 109, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 20, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 242, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 76, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 33, - "target_local_id": 109, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 57, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 277, - "target_local_id": 59, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 20, - "target_local_id": 243, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 182, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 213, - "target_local_id": 114, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 20, - "target_local_id": 194, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 25, - "target_local_id": 267, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 131, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 170, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 111, - "target_local_id": 235, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 169, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 66, - "target_local_id": 98, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 255, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 96, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 106, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 96, - "target_local_id": 82, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 237, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 188, - "target_local_id": 53, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 18, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 188, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 251, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 205, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 122, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 275, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 48, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 159, - "target_local_id": 52, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 52, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 99, - "target_local_id": 135, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 256, - "target_local_id": 237, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 126, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 205, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 30, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 251, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 250, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 197, - "target_local_id": 170, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 18, - "target_local_id": 106, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 21, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 38, - "target_local_id": 206, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 29, - "target_local_id": 113, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 241, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 27, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 166, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 184, - "target_local_id": 212, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 72, - "target_local_id": 54, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 78, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 82, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 191, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 5, - "target_local_id": 260, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 93, - "target_local_id": 52, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 140, - "target_local_id": 279, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 2, - "target_local_id": 86, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 163, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 98, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 203, - "target_local_id": 70, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 86, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 33, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 152, - "target_local_id": 275, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 93, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 234, - "target_local_id": 101, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 204, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 185, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 97, - "target_local_id": 234, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 63, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 16, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 244, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 35, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 260, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 44, - "target_local_id": 38, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 205, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 67, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 144, - "target_local_id": 206, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 118, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 202, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 142, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 38, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 30, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 87, - "target_local_id": 34, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 147, - "target_local_id": 202, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 159, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 7, - "target_local_id": 135, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 185, - "target_local_id": 53, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 80, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 15, - "target_local_id": 181, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 106, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 88, - "target_local_id": 139, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 149, - "target_local_id": 279, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 105, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 249, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 245, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 183, - "target_local_id": 250, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 178, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 50, - "target_local_id": 114, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 65, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 21, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 151, - "target_local_id": 126, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 212, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 254, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 125, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 247, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 125, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 55, - "target_local_id": 204, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 87, - "target_local_id": 194, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 146, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 237, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 53, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 15, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 144, - "target_local_id": 38, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 26, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 132, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 146, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 244, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 178, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 198, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 133, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 3, - "target_local_id": 233, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 55, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 138, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 170, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 158, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 133, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 138, - "target_local_id": 246, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 264, - "target_local_id": 84, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 198, - "target_local_id": 156, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 53, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 265, - "target_local_id": 159, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 59, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 37, - "target_local_id": 191, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 234, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 113, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 104, - "target_local_id": 37, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 165, - "target_local_id": 117, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 204, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 206, - "target_local_id": 244, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 38, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 23, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 65, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 24, - "target_local_id": 165, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 123, - "target_local_id": 47, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 213, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 206, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 185, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 182, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 151, - "target_local_id": 254, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 187, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 139, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 90, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 257, - "target_local_id": 275, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 130, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 106, - "target_local_id": 24, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 232, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 60, - "target_local_id": 233, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 157, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 182, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 57, - "target_local_id": 185, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 163, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 35, - "target_local_id": 111, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 277, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 214, - "target_local_id": 142, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 212, - "target_local_id": 34, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 157, - "target_local_id": 51, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 84, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 26, - "target_local_id": 146, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 258, - "target_local_id": 59, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 34, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 254, - "target_local_id": 126, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 193, - "target_local_id": 247, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 197, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 251, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 57, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 206, - "target_local_id": 135, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 6, - "target_local_id": 212, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 41, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 245, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 107, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 140, - "target_local_id": 70, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 238, - "target_local_id": 7, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 164, - "target_local_id": 70, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 93, - "target_local_id": 159, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 241, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 160, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 72, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 95, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 204, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 187, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 84, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 102, - "target_local_id": 138, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 112, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 93, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 181, - "target_local_id": 261, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 15, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 28, - "target_local_id": 247, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 254, - "target_local_id": 201, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 133, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 158, - "target_local_id": 198, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 90, - "target_local_id": 80, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 73, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 155, - "target_local_id": 22, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 148, - "target_local_id": 106, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 59, - "target_local_id": 131, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 254, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 48, - "target_local_id": 234, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 22, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 211, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 45, - "target_local_id": 237, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 144, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 76, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 246, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 13, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 29, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 245, - "target_local_id": 255, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 278, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 24, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 185, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 152, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 78, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 204, - "target_local_id": 247, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 269, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 34, - "target_local_id": 74, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 130, - "target_local_id": 41, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 265, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 98, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 192, - "target_local_id": 70, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 117, - "target_local_id": 199, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 19, - "target_local_id": 48, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 268, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 271, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 178, - "target_local_id": 210, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 105, - "target_local_id": 238, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 81, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 187, - "target_local_id": 76, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 2, - "target_local_id": 182, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 162, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 40, - "target_local_id": 278, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 46, - "target_local_id": 263, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 216, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 104, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 192, - "target_local_id": 203, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 125, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 210, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 114, - "target_local_id": 271, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 126, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 238, - "target_local_id": 143, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 12, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 109, - "target_local_id": 49, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 52, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 172, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 166, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 58, - "target_local_id": 112, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 275, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 238, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 41, - "target_local_id": 276, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 274, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 273, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 248, - "target_local_id": 246, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 262, - "target_local_id": 76, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 39, - "target_local_id": 160, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 205, - "target_local_id": 145, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 13, - "target_local_id": 251, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 274, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 267, - "target_local_id": 53, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 280, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 4, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 180, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 54, - "target_local_id": 266, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 194, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 87, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 89, - "target_local_id": 27, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 268, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 263, - "target_local_id": 52, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 272, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 115, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 150, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 4, - "target_local_id": 262, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 273, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 193, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 266, - "target_local_id": 111, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 272, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 205, - "target_local_id": 172, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 50, - "target_local_id": 279, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 240, - "target_local_id": 150, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 86, - "target_local_id": 182, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 270, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 164, - "target_local_id": 203, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 6, - "target_local_id": 253, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 264, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 269, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 181, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 233, - "target_local_id": 267, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 126, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 116, - "target_local_id": 270, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 146, - "target_local_id": 234, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - } -] diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/nodes.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/nodes.json deleted file mode 100644 index a6b97484e..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/nodes.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2937 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "local_id": 1, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "check", - "title": "Explorer UI — code-audit pass", - "body": "Synthetic parent check representing the manual code-audit pass during which evidence nodes were authored. Generated by .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence a structural parent on the oracle plane.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-port-synthetic", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 2, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A CSS scanline overlay must be present in the DOM as a pseudo-element or overlay div positioned above the WebGL canvas at all times.", - "body": "A CSS scanline overlay must be present in the DOM as a pseudo-element or overlay div positioned above the WebGL canvas at all times. Its computed style must include pointer-events: none so that mouse and touch events pass through to the canvas beneath. The overlay must be visible as a subtle horizontal stripe pattern when inspected visually against a bright node.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 3, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation must execute in a Web Worker, not on the main UI thread.", - "body": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation must execute in a Web Worker, not on the main UI thread. Verified by: opening browser DevTools performance timeline during artifact load, confirming that the layout computation task appears on a Worker thread and not on the Main thread. The main thread must remain responsive (no tasks exceeding 50ms) during layout computation.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 4, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, node shape must encode node kind: content nodes must render as circles, hub nodes must render as diamonds.", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, node shape must encode node kind: content nodes must render as circles, hub nodes must render as diamonds.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 5, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder intends nodes to be colored by derivation phase in the macro graph visualization.", - "body": "The stakeholder intends nodes to be colored by derivation phase in the macro graph visualization.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 6, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a justification hub node must render: (1) a PREMISES group showing all nodes connected by '…", - "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a justification hub node must render: (1) a PREMISES group showing all nodes connected by 'informed_by' edges; (2) a CONCLUSIONS group showing all nodes connected by 'produced' edges. Each node reference must be a clickable pill that navigates the detail panel to that node.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 7, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The artifact bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) includes a placeholder for the FrameRecord summary field: when bundling, it reads…", - "body": "The artifact bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) includes a placeholder for the FrameRecord summary field: when bundling, it reads frames.json and adds summary: null for each frame if no summary is present. The UI's FrameRecord type declares summary as string | null. When the elicitation pipeline is extended to produce summaries (resolving RK5/E5), the bundler will populate this field and the UI will render it without code changes. This design makes the dependency on the pipeline schema extension explicit and non-blocking.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 8, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The Sigma WebGL canvas element must have no keydown, keyup, or keypress event listeners attached directly to it or via React synthetic even…", - "body": "The Sigma WebGL canvas element must have no keydown, keyup, or keypress event listeners attached directly to it or via React synthetic events. Verified by inspecting event listeners on the canvas DOM element using getEventListeners() in DevTools or a test spy, confirming zero keyboard event handlers are registered.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR74]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 9, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The src/types/artifact.ts file must contain zero import statements referencing the spec-elicitation package or any Deno-specific module.", - "body": "The src/types/artifact.ts file must contain zero import statements referencing the spec-elicitation package or any Deno-specific module. Running tsc --noEmit on the spec-elicitation-ui package must complete with zero errors, confirming the type definitions are self-contained. Verified by static analysis of the import graph rooted at src/types/artifact.ts.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR89]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 10, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The spec-elicitation-ui package lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/ as a sibling…", - "body": "The spec-elicitation-ui package lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/ as a sibling to spec-elicitation (X13). It is a standard Vite + React + TypeScript project with the following top-level structure: src/components/ (React UI components), src/store/ (Zustand store and derived index builders), src/graph/ (Sigma.js setup, custom WebGL programs, ForceAtlas2 worker), src/macro/ (WebGL macro timeline renderer), src/types/ (TypeScript types mirroring the artifact.json schema), src/utils/ (artifact parser, diff utilities, provenance traversal), and scripts/bundle-artifact.ts (the Deno bundler script that produces artifact.json, kept here rather than in spec-elicitation to colocate it with the schema it produces). Tailwind config extends the base with the phosphor CRT theme tokens defined in crt-design-system-design.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 11, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The current spec.md output renders all 376+ nodes sequentially and is unusable for understanding relationships, tracing provenance, or navi…", - "body": "The current spec.md output renders all 376+ nodes sequentially and is unusable for understanding relationships, tracing provenance, or navigating decisions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 12, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Displaying interventions in both the node detail panel and the macro timeline is the most complete approach but carries higher implementati…", - "body": "Displaying interventions in both the node detail panel and the macro timeline is the most complete approach but carries higher implementation cost.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 13, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a decision hub node must render: (1) a RATIONALE block showing the decision's rationale pro…", - "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a decision hub node must render: (1) a RATIONALE block showing the decision's rationale prose with a phosphor-amber left border; (2) a CONSIDERED group listing all nodes reached via 'considered' edges as clickable displayId pills; (3) a SELECTED group with a green glow indicator showing chosen alternatives via 'selected' edges; (4) a REJECTED group with a dimmed red indicator showing rejected alternatives via 'rejected' edges; (5) a CONSEQUENCES group listing nodes reached via 'consequence' or 'produced' edges. Each pill must navigate the detail panel to the referenced node on click. A 'Trace to grounding' button must highlight the support-edge subgraph back to grounding-phase nodes in the main Sigma canvas.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 14, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Real-time updates are out of scope.", - "body": "Real-time updates are out of scope. The artifact is loaded once at startup and does not change during the session.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 15, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "After successful artifact parse, the application must play a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content.", - "body": "After successful artifact parse, the application must play a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content. The animation must implement the keyframe sequence opacity 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1 over approximately 150ms as a CSS @keyframes animation, and must not use a slide-in transition.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 16, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The macro view is the temporal history view showing derivation frames and their…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T16]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The macro view is the temporal history view showing derivation frames and their relationships over time, laid out as a vertical timeline branching horizontally at derivation loops." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 17, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a fan-in grouping contains more than one node pair, the comparison overlay must show a tab row above the split columns allowing the us…", - "body": "When a fan-in grouping contains more than one node pair, the comparison overlay must show a tab row above the split columns allowing the user to navigate between all node pairs in the grouping. Verified using the reference artifact's fan-in-records.json: selecting a grouping with multiple nodeIds (e.g. 'cloud-agnostic-context' with nodeIds 7cf067d6 and 9d1a93f3) must produce a tab for each pair.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR66]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 18, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from exactly two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro v…", - "body": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from exactly two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view, which must open the comparison for that fan-in grouping; (2) clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel of any node with lifecycle='candidate', which must open the comparison for the fan-in grouping containing that candidate node. Both entry points must produce the same comparison overlay UI.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR64]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 19, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a node has reviewStatus._tag='suspect', the Identity section must display a 'suspect' indicator with clickable links to each causeId.", - "body": "When a node has reviewStatus._tag='suspect', the Identity section must display a 'suspect' indicator with clickable links to each causeId. When reviewStatus._tag='conditional', the Identity section must display a 'conditional' indicator with clickable links to each impasseId. A 'clean' node must show a clean indicator with no extra links. Verified by mounting the detail panel for nodes with each review status variant.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR43]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 20, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro timeline must visually encode the full regression/recovery narrative: (1) the initial frame trunk rendered in phosphor-green; (2)…", - "body": "The macro timeline must visually encode the full regression/recovery narrative: (1) the initial frame trunk rendered in phosphor-green; (2) rederive frames in phosphor-amber; (3) impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on branch edges; (4) perspective hub nodes shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards; (5) the nudgingActive flag shown as a 'NUDGED' badge. Together these elements must make the impasse → rederive → fan-out → reconciliation cycle legible without additional explanation.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R45]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 21, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking any node in the micro-view graph must activate the right detail panel with a CSS @keyframes flicker animation.", - "body": "Clicking any node in the micro-view graph must activate the right detail panel with a CSS @keyframes flicker animation. The animation must pulse opacity through the sequence 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1 and complete within approximately 150ms (±20ms). The panel must not slide in from the side. Verified by: recording a click event in a test renderer and asserting the applied animation name matches the flicker keyframes definition with the correct duration.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 22, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a snapshot slider that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions.", - "body": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a snapshot slider that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions. The slider must display a numeric revision badge and a timestamp label for the current snapshot. A status line below the slider must show the current revision number and the associated frameId(s).", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 23, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The application must provide no mechanism to create, edit, or delete nodes or edges.", - "body": "The application must provide no mechanism to create, edit, or delete nodes or edges. All data displayed must come exclusively from the loaded artifact.json and must not change during the session.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 24, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Baseline refers to the active, reconciled state of the knowledge graph; candida…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T19]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Baseline refers to the active, reconciled state of the knowledge graph; candidate refers to nodes produced during clean-room re-derivation branches before reconciliation. Side-by-side comparison of baseline vs candidate nodes is a required UI feature." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 25, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "After the initial layout computation completes for a given specId and snapshotRevision, the layout positions must be written to sessionStor…", - "body": "After the initial layout computation completes for a given specId and snapshotRevision, the layout positions must be written to sessionStorage under a key incorporating the specId and snapshotRevision. On a second load of the same artifact within the same browser session, no Web Worker layout computation must occur — the cached positions must be read directly from sessionStorage and applied to the Sigma graph.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 26, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The right detail panel must render exactly four collapsible sections in top-to-bottom order: (1) Identity, (2) Connections, (3) Provenance,…", - "body": "The right detail panel must render exactly four collapsible sections in top-to-bottom order: (1) Identity, (2) Connections, (3) Provenance, (4) Validation. The Identity section must be expanded by default and must remain visible even when other sections are collapsed. Sections 2, 3, and 4 must toggle open/closed independently. Verified by mounting the panel for a known node and asserting four section headers are present, with Identity expanded and the others collapsible.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 27, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The pipeline artifact output is a directory containing JSON files organized into: graph/ (nodes, edges, frames, derivation-runs, fan-in rec…", - "body": "The pipeline artifact output is a directory containing JSON files organized into: graph/ (nodes, edges, frames, derivation-runs, fan-in records, snapshots), and top-level files (manifest, sources, extracted-claims, interventions), plus rendered views (spec.md, prose.md) and reports (validation, handoff summary).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 28, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 4 derivation phases with 3 derivation loop attempts, and includes decision, justification, im…", - "body": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 4 derivation phases with 3 derivation loop attempts, and includes decision, justification, impasse, and perspective hub nodes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 29, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal listing which nodes changed in that frame (the node-diff list).", - "body": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal listing which nodes changed in that frame (the node-diff list). The modal must display at minimum the displayId, lifecycle, and phase of each node associated with that frame. The modal must be dismissible via Escape or a close control. No WebGL zoom-into-frame transition may be attempted; the modal is the required behavior for the current iteration.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR62]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 30, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Inspection of the rendered DOM must reveal zero input controls, buttons, or form elements that create, modify, or delete any node or edge.", - "body": "Inspection of the rendered DOM must reveal zero input controls, buttons, or form elements that create, modify, or delete any node or edge. No mutation of the in-memory graph store may occur after the initial artifact load; all node and edge data must remain identical to the parsed artifact.json for the duration of the session.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 31, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers that all pipeline output files be combined into a single artifact.json file that is loaded into the visualization p…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers that all pipeline output files be combined into a single artifact.json file that is loaded into the visualization program.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 32, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given a valid artifact.json file dropped onto the landing page drop zone, the application must parse the file entirely in the browser using…", - "body": "Given a valid artifact.json file dropped onto the landing page drop zone, the application must parse the file entirely in the browser using the File API (no network request made), transition away from the landing page, and display the main explorer view — all without any server upload or URL entry by the user.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 33, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must render at full Sigma glow intensity and non-matching nodes must render at approxim…", - "body": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must render at full Sigma glow intensity and non-matching nodes must render at approximately 15% opacity in the canvas. Edges where both endpoints are non-matching must also be visually dimmed. No node or edge may be removed from the graphology graph during filtering — the total node and edge count in the graphology instance must remain constant before and after any filter is applied.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 34, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The 17 edge types across 6 categories are: hub-generic (informed_by, produced); decision (considered, selected, rejected, consequence); imp…", - "body": "The 17 edge types across 6 categories are: hub-generic (informed_by, produced); decision (considered, selected, rejected, consequence); impasse (conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to); perspective (aggregates); content (derived_from, depends_on, conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline); lineage (equivalent_to, refined_by, weakened_by, strengthened_by, split_into, merged_into, obsoleted_by). Content edge category has 10 types; lineage has 7.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X44]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 35, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The micro view is the lineage-focused graph view showing the spec at a particul…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T15]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The micro view is the lineage-focused graph view showing the spec at a particular point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out and a snapshot selector for time-scrubbing." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 36, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For each intervention record in the reference artifact's interventions.json, every nodeId in its targetNodeIds array must appear as a key i…", - "body": "For each intervention record in the reference artifact's interventions.json, every nodeId in its targetNodeIds array must appear as a key in the interventionsByNodeId index mapping to an array that includes that intervention. Specifically: node 7cbf0826 must map to intervention 0f60db54; node 38c2ff0b must map to intervention 158ac3c4; node 61d9201c must map to intervention 926c3761; node cb3857aa must map to intervention 610c95d1. Each association must be verified by direct index lookup.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR87]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 37, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The application must define TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts.", - "body": "The application must define TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts. NodeRecord must be a discriminated union on kind ('content' | 'hub'). FrameRecord must include summary as string | null to future-proof the optional per-frame LLM summary field. These types must be defined independently of the spec-elicitation package (no cross-package import of Effect schemas).", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 38, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive i…", - "body": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive indicator (shown as a 'NUDGED' badge when true), createdAt timestamp, and the pre-generated LLM summary text when present. When no summary is present (summary is null), the summary region must display a muted 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' placeholder in dimmed monospace style. No runtime error or broken layout may result from an absent summary.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R43]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 39, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The comparison overlay must render as a split panel with a left column showing the baseline node and a right column showing the candidate n…", - "body": "The comparison overlay must render as a split panel with a left column showing the baseline node and a right column showing the candidate node. Differences in text, semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority fields must be highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions (green) and deletions (red/amber). The fan-in grouping rationale must appear as a prominent decision banner between the two columns.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR65]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 40, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "A search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND simultaneously show a results list in a side panel.", - "body": "A search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND simultaneously show a results list in a side panel.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 41, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The main explorer must render a three-region resizable split layout: a left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and results list, a…", - "body": "The main explorer must render a three-region resizable split layout: a left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and results list, a central canvas area hosting either the micro or macro view, and a right detail panel. All three regions must be simultaneously visible when a node is selected. Panels must be resizable via drag handles.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 42, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The explorer UI must replace the current unnavigable flat spec.md output, enabling users to understand relationships, trace provenance, and…", - "body": "The explorer UI must replace the current unnavigable flat spec.md output, enabling users to understand relationships, trace provenance, and navigate decisions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 43, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The Validation section of the detail panel must not appear in the DOM when the selected node has reviewStatus._tag='clean' and no validatio…", - "body": "The Validation section of the detail panel must not appear in the DOM when the selected node has reviewStatus._tag='clean' and no validation errors touch its incident edges. When errors are present, the section must list each error showing: rule, severity, message, edge type, and edge direction. Verified by: selecting a clean node and asserting the Validation section is absent; then selecting a node with incident errored edges and asserting the section is present with correct error details.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR53]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 44, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Each frame card rendered in the macro timeline must display all of the following fields: mode badge ('initial' or 'rederive'), entryPhase l…", - "body": "Each frame card rendered in the macro timeline must display all of the following fields: mode badge ('initial' or 'rederive'), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, createdAt timestamp, and a nudgingActive indicator rendered as a 'NUDGED' badge when nudgingActive=true. For the reference artifact, the two rederive frames with attemptNumber=1 and attemptNumber=2 (ids b40fd568 and b9236ccf) must show 'NUDGED'. The frame with attemptNumber=0 (id 10f07753) must not show 'NUDGED'.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR57]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 45, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The edgeIssuesByNodeId index must correctly associate validation errors with both the source and target node of each errored edge.", - "body": "The edgeIssuesByNodeId index must correctly associate validation errors with both the source and target node of each errored edge. Using the first validation error in the reference artifact (edgeId 00452e1e, a derived_from edge between nodes b66575fc and 6c45100b), both node IDs must be present as keys in edgeIssuesByNodeId, each mapping to an array containing that error. Querying an unrelated node ID must return an empty array.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR80]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 46, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The right detail panel must activate on node click with a CRT power-on flicker animation of approximately 150ms duration, implemented as a…", - "body": "The right detail panel must activate on node click with a CRT power-on flicker animation of approximately 150ms duration, implemented as a CSS @keyframes sequence that pulses opacity 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1. The panel must not use a slide-in transition.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 47, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must be visually encoded by relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges triggered by an impasse mu…", - "body": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must be visually encoded by relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges triggered by an impasse must be drawn in warning amber and labeled with the triggerImpasseId as a displayId badge; fan-in record edges connecting rederive frames back to the baseline must be drawn in bright green and labeled 'RECONCILED'.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R44]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 48, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Identity section of the detail panel must display: for content nodes — semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority; for hub nodes — hu…", - "body": "The Identity section of the detail panel must display: for content nodes — semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority; for hub nodes — hubType. It must also show the review status as a tagged indicator: 'clean' with no annotation, 'suspect' with links to causeIds, and 'conditional' with links to impasseIds.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 49, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers that when a search or filter is active, matching nodes glow at full intensity while non-matching nodes are rendered…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers that when a search or filter is active, matching nodes glow at full intensity while non-matching nodes are rendered at low opacity (~15%), with edges also dimmed when both endpoints are non-matching, multiple filters using AND logic, and the graph topology preserved so context is not lost.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 50, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the application is deployed to a remote static host (e.g., GitHub Pages) and accessed with ?artifact= pointing to a CORS-enabled…", - "body": "When the application is deployed to a remote static host (e.g., GitHub Pages) and accessed with ?artifact= pointing to a CORS-enabled artifact.json URL, the application must load and parse the artifact via fetch() and enter the main explorer view without requiring any local file selection. No error related to file system access may occur. Verified by deploying the built app to a static host and testing the URL param flow end-to-end.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR84]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 51, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "All interactive HTML elements (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have hover states that intensify glow via CSS…", - "body": "All interactive HTML elements (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have hover states that intensify glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and text-shadow. No interactive element may have a visually inert hover state.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R55]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 52, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers that the provenance section in the node detail panel renders a small Sigma.js subgraph showing the full upstream de…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers that the provenance section in the node detail panel renders a small Sigma.js subgraph showing the full upstream derivation chain, with clickable nodes for navigation, visually coherent with the main graph.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 53, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers a WebGL-based renderer (e.g.", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers a WebGL-based renderer (e.g. Sigma.js) for graph rendering because it can handle tens of thousands of nodes and edges interactively and enables more ambitious visual design such as a phosphor-glow effect on nodes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 54, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When the snapshot selector changes the active snapshot, node visibility must be updated by adjusting node opacity rather than removing node…", - "body": "When the snapshot selector changes the active snapshot, node visibility must be updated by adjusting node opacity rather than removing nodes from the graph. Nodes not in the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array must be rendered at near-zero opacity. Layout positions must not be recomputed on snapshot change.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 55, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The full reference graph (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges, plus archived and candidate nodes) may be too large to render interactively witho…", - "body": "The full reference graph (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges, plus archived and candidate nodes) may be too large to render interactively without deliberate performance optimization.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 56, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When Macro view is active, a dedicated element separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas must be mounted in the central area with…", - "body": "When Macro view is active, a dedicated element separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas must be mounted in the central area with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl') or getContext('webgl2') returning non-null). The Sigma canvas must not be present in the DOM simultaneously. Verified by querying the DOM for canvas elements while in each view mode and asserting exactly one WebGL canvas is present per mode.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR55]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 57, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "With the smoke-webhook reference artifact loaded (761 total nodes, 2,662 edges), panning and zooming the micro-view Sigma canvas must susta…", - "body": "With the smoke-webhook reference artifact loaded (761 total nodes, 2,662 edges), panning and zooming the micro-view Sigma canvas must sustain a frame rate of at least 30 fps as measured by browser DevTools performance profiling. No interaction (pan, zoom, hover) may produce a jank frame exceeding 100ms on a mid-range developer machine.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 58, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must have zero computed width (or be absent from the DOM) and the central canvas must expa…", - "body": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must have zero computed width (or be absent from the DOM) and the central canvas must expand to fill the full remaining width after the left sidebar. Selecting a node must cause the detail panel to appear; deselecting must collapse it again.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 59, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view must be rendered on a dedicated WebGL canvas separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas, implemented using raw WebGL with a t…", - "body": "The macro view must be rendered on a dedicated WebGL canvas separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas, implemented using raw WebGL with a thin abstraction layer (not a graph library). This canvas must be mounted in place of the Sigma canvas when macro view is active.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 60, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "While ForceAtlas2 layout computation is in progress, the central canvas must display a CRT-styled text indicator reading 'COMPUTING LAYOUT.…", - "body": "While ForceAtlas2 layout computation is in progress, the central canvas must display a CRT-styled text indicator reading 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' (or equivalent). The indicator must disappear and be replaced by the rendered graph when the Worker posts its result. No partially-rendered or unlaid-out graph may be shown while computation is ongoing.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 61, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle that switches the central canvas between Micro view and Macro view.", - "body": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle that switches the central canvas between Micro view and Macro view. The snapshot selector must be visible in the toolbar only when Micro view is active.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 62, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, every hub node with hubType='impasse' must render with a hexagonal shape, visually distinct from the diamond used…", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, every hub node with hubType='impasse' must render with a hexagonal shape, visually distinct from the diamond used for other hub types. Inspecting the rendered geometry of a known impasse node from the reference artifact (e.g., the node with id '557db0a8-5b5b-4ab9-97e2-4ac5c4f243d5') must confirm the hexagonal form.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 63, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field.", - "body": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field. The macro view's per-frame summary display depends on a schema extension to the elicitation pipeline that has not yet been implemented.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder-inferred [RK5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 64, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Keyboard navigation does not apply to the graph canvas.", - "body": "Keyboard navigation does not apply to the graph canvas. Canvas interaction is mouse/touch only.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 65, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The interventionsByNodeId index must correctly map each nodeId appearing in any intervention's targetNodeIds array to that intervention rec…", - "body": "The interventionsByNodeId index must correctly map each nodeId appearing in any intervention's targetNodeIds array to that intervention record. Using the reference artifact's interventions.json (4 records, each with one targetNodeId), querying the index for each of the four targetNodeIds must return the corresponding intervention. Querying a nodeId that appears in no intervention must return an empty array, not undefined or an error.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 66, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, edges must be rendered in three visually distinct colors by category: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, inf…", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, edges must be rendered in three visually distinct colors by category: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) in dim amber; workflow edges (produced, considered, selected, rejected, consequence, conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to, aggregates) in brighter green; structural edges (conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline, and all lineage edge types) in muted cyan. Sampling 10 edges of each category from the reference artifact and reading their rendered colors must confirm the correct category mapping for all 30 sampled edges.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 67, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The smoke-webhook artifact directory contains: graph/ (nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, snap…", - "body": "The smoke-webhook artifact directory contains: graph/ (nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, snapshots.json), plus top-level manifest.json, sources.json, extracted-claims.json, interventions.json, reports/validation.json, reports/handoff-summary.md, and views/. Nodes carry id, displayId, specId, frameId, phase, text, lifecycle, reviewStatus, provenance, createdAt, kind, and kind-specific fields (semanticRole/epistemicStatus/authority for content; hubType/rationale for hubs). Edges carry id, source.nodeId, target.nodeId, type, rationale, provenance, createdAt. Frames carry parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase, triggerImpasseIds, mode (initial/rederive), attemptNumber, nudgingActive. No summary field exists on FrameRecord.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X43]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 68, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking the 'Trace to grounding' button in a decision hub's Connections section must traverse support edges from the decision's considered…", - "body": "Clicking the 'Trace to grounding' button in a decision hub's Connections section must traverse support edges from the decision's considered nodes back to grounding-phase nodes and apply the active-filter highlighting model (full intensity for traversed nodes, ~15% opacity for all others) to the main Sigma canvas. The Zustand filterState must reflect this subgraph highlight. Clearing the filter must restore all nodes to normal opacity.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR46]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 69, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Running the elicitation pipeline from within the UI is out of scope.", - "body": "Running the elicitation pipeline from within the UI is out of scope.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 70, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The app has no backend.", - "body": "The app has no backend. All data is loaded from static JSON files. The app must be deployable as a static site.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 71, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The UI defines TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts, mirroring the domain model from the spec-elicita…", - "body": "The UI defines TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts, mirroring the domain model from the spec-elicitation package without importing it directly (to avoid a cross-package dependency on Deno-specific Effect schemas). Key types: ArtifactFile (top-level), GraphData, NodeRecord (discriminated union on kind: 'content' | 'hub'), ContentNode (with semanticRole, epistemicStatus, authority), HubNode (with hubType, rationale), EdgeRecord, FrameRecord (with optional summary?: string to future-proof RK5), SnapshotRecord, DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, InterventionRecord, ValidationReport, ValidationError. The discriminated union on NodeRecord.kind enables exhaustive type-narrowing in the detail panel renderer.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 72, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the snapshot slider is moved to a revision where a given node is not in the activeNodeIds array, that node must remain present in the…", - "body": "When the snapshot slider is moved to a revision where a given node is not in the activeNodeIds array, that node must remain present in the Sigma graphology graph instance but be rendered at near-zero opacity (visually invisible). The node must not be removed from the graphology graph. Layout positions must not change when the slider is moved. Verified by: querying the graphology instance for a known inactive-at-revision node and asserting it exists with a near-zero opacity attribute.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 73, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The macro timeline must make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation narrative legible through five simultaneous visual cues: (1)…", - "body": "The macro timeline must make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation narrative legible through five simultaneous visual cues: (1) initial frame trunk in phosphor-green; (2) rederive frames in phosphor-amber; (3) impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on branch edges; (4) perspective hub nodes shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards; (5) nudgingActive shown as a 'NUDGED' badge. All five cues must be present simultaneously in the rendered macro view for the reference artifact.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR60]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 74, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Edge types are defined in a dedicated file at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/src/domain/e…", - "body": "Edge types are defined in a dedicated file at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/src/domain/edge-types.ts.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder-observed [X12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 75, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must exhibit a visible phosphor glow effect implemented via a WebGL fragment shader.", - "body": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must exhibit a visible phosphor glow effect implemented via a WebGL fragment shader. Hovering over a node must produce a measurably increased glow radius or intensity relative to the idle state. Selecting a node must produce a further-increased glow intensity relative to hover. The glow color must match the node's derivation-phase color.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 76, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder envisions nodes emitting a color-appropriate phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader, with hover states intens…", - "body": "The stakeholder envisions nodes emitting a color-appropriate phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader, with hover states intensifying the glow effect.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 77, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The snapshot selector control must appear in the toolbar if and only if Micro view is active.", - "body": "The snapshot selector control must appear in the toolbar if and only if Micro view is active. Switching to Macro view must remove the snapshot selector from the DOM (or hide it such that it receives no pointer events). Switching back to Micro must restore it.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 78, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When multiple filter controls are active simultaneously, the application must combine them using AND logic: a node is considered matching o…", - "body": "When multiple filter controls are active simultaneously, the application must combine them using AND logic: a node is considered matching only if it satisfies every active filter dimension.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 79, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "An intervention is a record of a human action that occurred during a derivation…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T13]", - "detail": { - "definition": "An intervention is a record of a human action that occurred during a derivation frame, stored in interventions.json in the artifact." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 80, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must be rendered in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow…", - "body": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must be rendered in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo in addition to their normal phase-color glow, implemented as a second glow pass in the WebGL shader.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 81, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "All node text, displayIds, data values, and code-like content must use a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent).", - "body": "All node text, displayIds, data values, and code-like content must use a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent). No UI element may render in a default sans-serif or serif browser font.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R54]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 82, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel for an impasse hub node must render: (1) a CONFLICTING INPUTS group listing nodes via 'conflict…", - "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel for an impasse hub node must render: (1) a CONFLICTING INPUTS group listing nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges with their review status indicator; (2) a RESOLVED BY group showing nodes via 'resolved_by' edges; (3) a SPAWNED group listing child impasses via 'spawned' edges; (4) a REFINED TO group showing the refined impasse via 'refined_to' edges; (5) a status banner indicating whether the impasse is currently unresolved (no resolved_by edges) or resolved. Unresolved impasses must show a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 83, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For a decision hub node, the Connections section must render five distinct groups: RATIONALE (prose text with phosphor-amber left border),…", - "body": "For a decision hub node, the Connections section must render five distinct groups: RATIONALE (prose text with phosphor-amber left border), CONSIDERED (pills for nodes via 'considered' edges), SELECTED (green-glow pills for nodes via 'selected' edges), REJECTED (dimmed red-indicator pills for nodes via 'rejected' edges), and CONSEQUENCES (pills for nodes via 'consequence' or 'produced' edges). Each pill must be clickable and navigate the detail panel to the referenced node. A 'Trace to grounding' button must be present. Verified against a known decision hub node (e.g., DEC22) from the reference artifact.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR45]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 84, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers that keyboard navigation covers only panel controls (Escape closes detail panel, Tab/Shift-Tab moves between UI con…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers that keyboard navigation covers only panel controls (Escape closes detail panel, Tab/Shift-Tab moves between UI controls, Enter confirms selection); the Sigma.js canvas graph interaction is mouse/touch only.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 85, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The lifecycle of a node represents its current standing in the knowledge graph.", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T4]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The lifecycle of a node represents its current standing in the knowledge graph. The four defined lifecycle values are: candidate, active, archived, and withdrawn." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 86, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "A CSS scanline texture overlay must sit above the WebGL canvas at all times, implemented as a repeating-linear-gradient pseudo-element with…", - "body": "A CSS scanline texture overlay must sit above the WebGL canvas at all times, implemented as a repeating-linear-gradient pseudo-element with pointer-events:none, so it does not intercept canvas mouse/touch events.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 87, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Impasse hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel.", - "body": "Impasse hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel. The Connections section shows: (1) a 'CONFLICTING INPUTS' group listing nodes connected by 'conflicting_input' edges, each shown as a clickable pill with their review status indicator; (2) a 'RESOLVED BY' group showing nodes connected by 'resolved_by' edges (perspective or decision nodes); (3) a 'SPAWNED' group listing child impasses via 'spawned' edges; (4) a 'REFINED TO' group showing the refined impasse via 'refined_to' edges. A status banner at the top of the Connections section shows whether the impasse is currently unresolved (no resolved_by edges) or resolved. Unresolved impasses are visually flagged with a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section. In the micro graph, impasse nodes render with a distinctive hexagonal shape and warning-amber glow.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 88, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the macro timeline, any frame card associated with a perspective hub node (hubType='perspective') must display a small purple indicator…", - "body": "In the macro timeline, any frame card associated with a perspective hub node (hubType='perspective') must display a small purple indicator badge on the card. In the reference artifact, any rederive frame whose derivation produced perspective hub nodes must show this badge. Verified by identifying perspective hub nodes in the reference nodes.json, tracing their frameId, and confirming the badge appears on the corresponding frame card in the macro view.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR95]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 89, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The artifact includes a validation report.", - "body": "The artifact includes a validation report. The UI must integrate this data to show which nodes have issues.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 90, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must render in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo…", - "body": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must render in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo visually overlaid on their normal phase-color glow. Selecting a known errored edge in the reference artifact's validation.json, identifying its source and target nodes, and visually inspecting those nodes in the graph must confirm the red halo is present and absent on a clean neighboring node.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 91, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given the user clicks a file-picker trigger on the landing page and selects a valid artifact.json, the application must load and parse the…", - "body": "Given the user clicks a file-picker trigger on the landing page and selects a valid artifact.json, the application must load and parse the file identically to drag-and-drop, transitioning to the main explorer view with no server upload.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 92, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain exactly the following controls: (1) a text input for full-text search; (2) four phase filter chi…", - "body": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain exactly the following controls: (1) a text input for full-text search; (2) four phase filter chips (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done); (3) ten semantic role checkboxes (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk); (4) a hub type toggle with options all/decision/justification/impasse/perspective; (5) four epistemic status chips (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred); (6) four authority chips (stakeholder, technical, external, derived); (7) three lifecycle visibility toggles (archived, candidate, withdrawn). All controls must be present in the DOM simultaneously.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 93, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL program class (node shader, color palette, glow style) as the main micro-view graph…", - "body": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL program class (node shader, color palette, glow style) as the main micro-view graph, ensuring visual coherence between the two Sigma instances.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 94, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The comparison overlay must include a 'View in graph' button.", - "body": "The comparison overlay must include a 'View in graph' button. Clicking it must: close the comparison overlay, switch to Micro view if Macro view is active, set selectedNodeId to the baseline node's id in the Zustand store, and pan/zoom the Sigma canvas to bring the baseline node into view. The detail panel must open for the baseline node.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR67]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 95, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display one intervention annotation chip per intervention record associated with that frameId.", - "body": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display one intervention annotation chip per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip must show the intervention kind (e.g. 'accept_candidate') and a count of targetNodeIds. For the reference artifact: frame 10f07753 must show 3 chips (interventions 0f60db54, 158ac3c4, 926c3761), and frame b40fd568 must show 1 chip (intervention 610c95d1). Hovering a chip must display a tooltip listing targetNodeIds as human-readable displayIds.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR61]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 96, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For an impasse hub node, the Connections section must render: CONFLICTING INPUTS group (nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges, each showing r…", - "body": "For an impasse hub node, the Connections section must render: CONFLICTING INPUTS group (nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges, each showing review status), RESOLVED BY group (nodes via 'resolved_by' edges), SPAWNED group (child impasses via 'spawned' edges), REFINED TO group (via 'refined_to' edges), and a status banner indicating resolved or unresolved state. An unresolved impasse must show a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section. Verified against the trigger impasse node in the reference artifact.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR47]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 97, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For a content node, the Identity section must display: the full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status ind…", - "body": "For a content node, the Identity section must display: the full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator (one of clean/suspect/conditional), semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority. For a hub node, the Identity section must display hubType instead of semanticRole/epistemicStatus/authority. Verified by mounting the detail panel for one known content node and one known hub node from the reference artifact and asserting each field's presence and correct value.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR42]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 98, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Edge categories (support, workflow, structural) must be visually distinguished using different line styles or colors in the graph visualiza…", - "body": "Edge categories (support, workflow, structural) must be visually distinguished using different line styles or colors in the graph visualization.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 99, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The UI cannot generate per-frame LLM summaries at runtime.", - "body": "The UI cannot generate per-frame LLM summaries at runtime. It can only consume summaries that are pre-generated and present in the artifact.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 100, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The app must present the knowledge graph as a rich, browsable, searchable interface supporting graph visualization, node detail inspection,…", - "body": "The app must present the knowledge graph as a rich, browsable, searchable interface supporting graph visualization, node detail inspection, provenance tracing, decision exploration, filtering, search, and side-by-side baseline/candidate comparison.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 101, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Every content node in the domain model carries three orthogonal classification…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T8]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Every content node in the domain model carries three orthogonal classification axes: semantic role, epistemic status, and authority." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 102, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a lifecycle visibility toggle (archived, candidate, or withdrawn) is switched off, affected nodes must be hidden from the Sigma canvas…", - "body": "When a lifecycle visibility toggle (archived, candidate, or withdrawn) is switched off, affected nodes must be hidden from the Sigma canvas by setting the graphology node attribute 'hidden' to true — not by calling graph.dropNode() or rebuilding the graphology instance. Switching the toggle back on must restore those nodes by setting 'hidden' to false. Active nodes must have no toggle and must always be visible.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 103, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Decision nodes are described by the stakeholder as the most important hub type in the system.", - "body": "Decision nodes are described by the stakeholder as the most important hub type in the system.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 104, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The TypeScript type NodeRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must be a discriminated union on the 'kind' field with exactly two variants: one fo…", - "body": "The TypeScript type NodeRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must be a discriminated union on the 'kind' field with exactly two variants: one for kind='content' (including semanticRole, epistemicStatus, authority) and one for kind='hub' (including hubType, rationale). FrameRecord must declare a summary field typed as string | null. The file must import nothing from the spec-elicitation package. Verified by TypeScript compiler with zero type errors.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 105, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the bundler script processes frames.json entries that have no summary field, the resulting artifact.json must include summary: null on…", - "body": "When the bundler script processes frames.json entries that have no summary field, the resulting artifact.json must include summary: null on each such FrameRecord. The TypeScript type for FrameRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must declare summary as string | null, ensuring the UI type-checks without error against both null (current state) and a populated string (future state). Verified by running the bundler on the reference artifact and asserting summary is null on all four frame records.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR76]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 106, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view; (2)…", - "body": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view; (2) clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel of a node with lifecycle=candidate.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R49]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 107, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The tech stack for the explorer UI is confirmed as Vite, React, and Tailwind CSS.", - "body": "The tech stack for the explorer UI is confirmed as Vite, React, and Tailwind CSS.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 108, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The comparison view must include a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node, closing the comparison o…", - "body": "The comparison view must include a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node, closing the comparison overlay and selecting that node in the main graph.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R52]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 109, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must be rendered at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes must be rendered at appr…", - "body": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must be rendered at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes must be rendered at approximately 15% opacity in the Sigma canvas. Edges where both endpoints are non-matching must also be dimmed. Graph topology must be preserved — no nodes or edges may be removed from the canvas during filtering.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 110, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "After loading the smoke-webhook reference artifact, the nodeIndex Map must contain exactly 761 entries (376 active + 88 archived + 288 cand…", - "body": "After loading the smoke-webhook reference artifact, the nodeIndex Map must contain exactly 761 entries (376 active + 88 archived + 288 candidate + 9 withdrawn). The edgeIndex Map must contain exactly 2,662 entries. The frameIndex must contain exactly 4 entries. These counts must match the totals in validation.json (totalNodes=761, totalEdges=2662, totalFrames=4). Any mismatch must be surfaced as a diagnostic warning in the console.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR85]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 111, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The micro view is a lineage-focused subgraph showing the spec at the current point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out, and includes a…", - "body": "The micro view is a lineage-focused subgraph showing the spec at the current point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out, and includes a snapshot selector (dropdown or slider) for scrubbing through revisions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 112, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must be collapsed and the central canvas must expand to occupy the full remaining width af…", - "body": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must be collapsed and the central canvas must expand to occupy the full remaining width after the left sidebar.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 113, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal node-diff list showing which nodes changed in that frame.", - "body": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal node-diff list showing which nodes changed in that frame. The full zoom-into-frame WebGL subgraph transition is explicitly deferred; the modal diff list is the required behavior for the current iteration.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R48]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 114, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The application must accept an optional ?artifact= query parameter; when present it must fetch artifact.json via fetch() from that URL…", - "body": "The application must accept an optional ?artifact= query parameter; when present it must fetch artifact.json via fetch() from that URL and bypass the drop zone, enabling remote sharing without user file selection.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 115, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "There is a potential conflict between the preference for browser File API loading (local filesystem drop zone) and the requirement that loa…", - "body": "There is a potential conflict between the preference for browser File API loading (local filesystem drop zone) and the requirement that loading also work when the app is hosted remotely. These two approaches may require different loading mechanisms.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 116, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The application must parse artifact.json as a single bundled file with the structure: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions,…", - "body": "The application must parse artifact.json as a single bundled file with the structure: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. Any artifact.json missing a required top-level key must produce a CRT-themed error state, not a crash or raw unstyled error.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 117, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The spec elicitation system is an experimental pipeline within Kael that takes conversational input (interview transcripts, context documen…", - "body": "The spec elicitation system is an experimental pipeline within Kael that takes conversational input (interview transcripts, context documents) and produces a structured specification as a knowledge graph.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 118, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Decision hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel's Connections section (X35, X10).", - "body": "Decision hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel's Connections section (X35, X10). The section renders: (1) a 'RATIONALE' block showing the decision's rationale prose in a styled blockquote with phosphor-amber left border; (2) a 'CONSIDERED' group listing all nodes connected by 'considered' edges, shown as clickable displayId pills; (3) a 'SELECTED' group with a green glow indicator showing the chosen alternative(s) via 'selected' edges; (4) a 'REJECTED' group with a dimmed red indicator showing rejected alternatives via 'rejected' edges; (5) a 'CONSEQUENCES' group listing nodes connected by 'consequence' or 'produced' edges. Each pill in these groups is clickable, navigating the detail panel to that node. A 'Trace to grounding' button traverses the support edges from the decision's considered nodes back to grounding-phase nodes and highlights that subgraph in the main Sigma canvas.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 119, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When artifact.json is missing any required top-level key (manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph, reports), the applicati…", - "body": "When artifact.json is missing any required top-level key (manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph, reports), the application must display a CRT-themed error state with a legible error message. No JavaScript exception may propagate to a blank screen or default browser error UI.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 120, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The macro view surfaces the regression/recovery narrative (X36) through explicit visual encoding of frame relationships: (1) The initial fr…", - "body": "The macro view surfaces the regression/recovery narrative (X36) through explicit visual encoding of frame relationships: (1) The initial frame trunk is rendered in phosphor-green as the primary timeline spine. (2) Rederive frames branch rightward and are rendered in phosphor-amber, with their connecting edge labeled with the triggerImpasseId (shown as a displayId badge). (3) Fan-in record edges connecting rederive frames back to the trunk are rendered in a brighter green with an arrow labeled 'RECONCILED'. (4) Impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds are shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on the branch edges. (5) Perspective hub nodes (from the CSP model, X11) are shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards. (6) The nudgingActive flag on a rederive frame is shown as a 'NUDGED' indicator badge. Together these elements make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation cycle legible at a glance.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 121, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The macro view shows the different frames and how they relate over time, including per-frame LLM-generated summaries, lines connecting fram…", - "body": "The macro view shows the different frames and how they relate over time, including per-frame LLM-generated summaries, lines connecting frames representing impasses/perspectives/derivation relationships, and the ability to zoom into a single frame to see which nodes changed.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 122, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Impasse hub nodes must render with a distinctive hexagonal shape in the micro-view Sigma graph, in addition to their warning-amber glow, ma…", - "body": "Impasse hub nodes must render with a distinctive hexagonal shape in the micro-view Sigma graph, in addition to their warning-amber glow, making them visually distinguishable from other hub node types at a glance.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R60]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 123, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must use distinct visual encoding by type: trunk-to-rederive-branch edges (triggered by an impa…", - "body": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must use distinct visual encoding by type: trunk-to-rederive-branch edges (triggered by an impasse) must be drawn in warning amber and labeled with the triggerImpasseId rendered as a displayId badge; fan-in record edges reconnecting rederive frames to the baseline must be drawn in bright green and labeled 'RECONCILED'. Verified by inspecting the rendered color and label of each edge in the reference artifact's macro timeline.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR59]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 124, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Authentication and multi-user features are out of scope.", - "body": "Authentication and multi-user features are out of scope.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 125, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "There is a tension between loading a single combined artifact.json (stakeholder preference) and loading individual artifact files from a di…", - "body": "There is a tension between loading a single combined artifact.json (stakeholder preference) and loading individual artifact files from a directory path or URL prefix (also a stated requirement). These two loading models may need reconciliation.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 126, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "At load time the UI builds an in-memory graph store from artifact.json using a flat index structure: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (…", - "body": "At load time the UI builds an in-memory graph store from artifact.json using a flat index structure: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (Map), adjacency (Map), frameIndex (Map), snapshotIndex (Map), and derivedIndex (Map) built by joining validation.json errors to their source/target nodes. Lifecycle filter state is maintained as a reactive set of visible lifecycle values. The active node set for the micro view is derived from the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array. All indexes are built once on load; no re-parsing occurs during session.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 127, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, edge color must visually distinguish the three edge categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_…", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, edge color must visually distinguish the three edge categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) in dim amber; workflow edges (produced, considered, selected, rejected, consequence, conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to, aggregates) in brighter green; structural edges (conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline, and all lineage edges) in muted cyan.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 128, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The comparison view must render as a split overlay that temporarily replaces or expands the right detail panel.", - "body": "The comparison view must render as a split overlay that temporarily replaces or expands the right detail panel. The left column must show the baseline node and the right column must show the candidate node. Differences in text, semantic role, epistemic status, and authority must be highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions and deletions.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R50]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 129, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The app must operate entirely against statically loaded JSON artifact files with no backend, and must be deployable as a static site.", - "body": "The app must operate entirely against statically loaded JSON artifact files with no backend, and must be deployable as a static site.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 130, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a node is selected, all three layout regions must be simultaneously visible: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, and…", - "body": "When a node is selected, all three layout regions must be simultaneously visible: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, and right detail panel. Measuring computed widths of all three regions must return values greater than zero. No region may be hidden, collapsed, or overlaid by another during normal selected-node state.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 131, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers building the macro timeline view using WebGL so that future zoom-into-frame functionality is naturally achievable.", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers building the macro timeline view using WebGL so that future zoom-into-frame functionality is naturally achievable.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 132, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Pressing the Escape key must close the right detail panel and clear the current node selection.", - "body": "Pressing the Escape key must close the right detail panel and clear the current node selection. If a comparison overlay is open, Escape must close the comparison overlay and return to the detail panel rather than closing the detail panel.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 133, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A fan-in record captures the result of the reconciliation step where candidate…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T14]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A fan-in record captures the result of the reconciliation step where candidate branches are merged back into the active baseline after a fan-out/clean-room re-derivation cycle." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 134, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking any clickable displayId pill within the Connections section (in any of the decision, impasse, or justification group rows) must up…", - "body": "Clicking any clickable displayId pill within the Connections section (in any of the decision, impasse, or justification group rows) must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to the referenced node's id, causing the detail panel to re-render for that node and the main Sigma canvas selection highlight to move to that node. The panel history must allow the user to return to the previously selected node via browser back or a dedicated back control if provided.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR86]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 135, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Per-frame LLM summaries will be pre-generated by the elicitation pipeline during artifact bundling and stored in FrameRecord or a companion…", - "body": "Per-frame LLM summaries will be pre-generated by the elicitation pipeline during artifact bundling and stored in FrameRecord or a companion structure within artifact.json; they are not generated at runtime by the UI.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 136, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking any node in the provenance mini-graph must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to that node's id, causing the main detail p…", - "body": "Clicking any node in the provenance mini-graph must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to that node's id, causing the main detail panel to re-render for the clicked node and the main Sigma canvas selection to update accordingly. The mini-graph must then re-render to show the new node's upstream subgraph.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR52]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 137, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The system must enable users to interactively explore a spec elicitation artifact as a read-only single-page web application.", - "body": "The system must enable users to interactively explore a spec elicitation artifact as a read-only single-page web application.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 138, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The toolbar must contain lifecycle visibility toggles for archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes.", - "body": "The toolbar must contain lifecycle visibility toggles for archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes. Active nodes must always be visible and cannot be toggled off. When a lifecycle toggle is changed, node visibility must be updated via Sigma's node attribute API (setting hidden=true/false) rather than rebuilding the graphology graph.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 139, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The perspective hub is modeled as a constraint satisfaction problem with axes, alternatives, constraints, and guarded impasses; perspective…", - "body": "The perspective hub is modeled as a constraint satisfaction problem with axes, alternatives, constraints, and guarded impasses; perspectives are a presentation layer derived from the CSP solver, not the primary semantic unit.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 140, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The file-loading mechanism must work when the app is hosted remotely.", - "body": "The file-loading mechanism must work when the app is hosted remotely. The app must not directly serve artifact files, because the website may be hosted remotely in the future.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 141, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When multiple filter dimensions are active simultaneously (e.g., phase=shaping AND semanticRole=design AND authority=derived), the results…", - "body": "When multiple filter dimensions are active simultaneously (e.g., phase=shaping AND semanticRole=design AND authority=derived), the results list must contain only nodes satisfying all active conditions. Enabling a second filter must never increase the result count. Verified by: activating two mutually constraining filters against the reference artifact and asserting the result set is the mathematical intersection of each filter applied individually.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 142, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "All interactive HTML elements must use visible focus rings styled in phosphor-amber, ensuring keyboard focus is always visible on the dark…", - "body": "All interactive HTML elements must use visible focus rings styled in phosphor-amber, ensuring keyboard focus is always visible on the dark background.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R58]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 143, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The confirmed artifact file layout is: graph/ subdirectory containing nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-rec…", - "body": "The confirmed artifact file layout is: graph/ subdirectory containing nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, and snapshots.json; top-level containing manifest.json, sources.json, extracted-claims.json, and interventions.json.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 144, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a frame card's summary field is null (as is the case for all frames in the current reference artifact), the summary region of the fram…", - "body": "When a frame card's summary field is null (as is the case for all frames in the current reference artifact), the summary region of the frame card must display a muted placeholder text 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' in dimmed monospace style. No JavaScript error, broken layout, or missing DOM element may result from a null summary. When a summary string is present, it must be rendered in its place without any code change.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR58]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 145, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Authority identifies the source type of a node's claim.", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T6]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Authority identifies the source type of a node's claim. The four defined values are: stakeholder, technical, external, and derived." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 146, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The right detail panel must have four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded by default, showing full…", - "body": "The right detail panel must have four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded by default, showing full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator, and kind-specific classification fields; (2) Connections — hub-type-specific relationship tables; (3) Provenance — embedded Sigma.js mini-graph; (4) Validation — shown only when review status is not clean. The Identity section must always remain visible at the top.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 147, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the results list has focus and a row is highlighted via Arrow key navigation, pressing Enter must select that node: selectedNodeId in…", - "body": "When the results list has focus and a row is highlighted via Arrow key navigation, pressing Enter must select that node: selectedNodeId in the Zustand store must be set to the row's node id, and the right detail panel must open for that node with the flicker animation. Verified by simulating ArrowDown then Enter on the results list and asserting the store update and panel appearance.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR73]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 148, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a node with lifecycle='candidate' is selected in the micro-view graph and the detail panel is open, a 'Compare' button must be visible…", - "body": "When a node with lifecycle='candidate' is selected in the micro-view graph and the detail panel is open, a 'Compare' button must be visible in the Identity section or the panel header. Nodes with lifecycle='active', 'archived', or 'withdrawn' must not show this button. Verified by selecting one candidate node and one active node from the reference artifact and asserting button presence/absence in each case.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR92]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 149, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers loading artifact.json from the user's local filesystem via the browser File API, with a landing screen presenting a…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers loading artifact.json from the user's local filesystem via the browser File API, with a landing screen presenting a file drop zone, requiring no server or URL.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 150, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers a CRT-inspired visual design language: a polished aesthetic evoking vintage phosphor displays with amber or green p…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers a CRT-inspired visual design language: a polished aesthetic evoking vintage phosphor displays with amber or green phosphor colors on dark backgrounds, subtle scanline textures, and gentle CRT glow/bloom effects on interactive elements.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 151, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "After artifact.json is parsed, all eight in-memory indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByE…", - "body": "After artifact.json is parsed, all eight in-memory indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByEdgeId, edgeIssuesByNodeId, interventionsByNodeId) must be fully populated before the main explorer UI renders. No index build or re-parse operation may be triggered by user interaction after this initial pass. Verified by: instrumenting the store initializer and asserting all Maps are non-empty after load with zero subsequent re-build calls during a full interaction session.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 152, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Application state must be managed in a single Zustand store containing: loadedArtifact, all derived indexes, activeView, selectedNodeId, se…", - "body": "Application state must be managed in a single Zustand store containing: loadedArtifact, all derived indexes, activeView, selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState, and comparisonState. React components must subscribe to fine-grained store slices to prevent unnecessary re-renders during filter and hover interactions.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 153, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers: a detail panel with CRT power-on flicker animation (~150ms) rather than slide-in; collapsible sections with most i…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers: a detail panel with CRT power-on flicker animation (~150ms) rather than slide-in; collapsible sections with most important information always visible at top; top section showing full node text, displayId, phase badge, lifecycle badge, and review status indicator.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 154, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Each boundary between the three layout regions must have a visible drag handle.", - "body": "Each boundary between the three layout regions must have a visible drag handle. Dragging a handle must resize the adjacent panels proportionally in real time, with both panels maintaining a non-zero minimum width throughout the drag. After release, the new widths must persist for the remainder of the session.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 155, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For the reference artifact, the single snapshot at revision 4 lists all four frameIds in its frameIds array.", - "body": "For the reference artifact, the single snapshot at revision 4 lists all four frameIds in its frameIds array. When the snapshot slider is set to revision 4, the active node set must be derived from that snapshot's activeNodeIds array (376 active nodes). The status line below the slider must display revision 4 and all four frameId values (or their display equivalents). Verified by loading the reference artifact and reading the status line content.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR91]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 156, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The macro timeline is laid out as a vertical timeline showing one narrative from top to bottom, branching out horizontally at derivation lo…", - "body": "The macro timeline is laid out as a vertical timeline showing one narrative from top to bottom, branching out horizontally at derivation loops.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 157, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Every interactive HTML element (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have a visually distinct hover state that int…", - "body": "Every interactive HTML element (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have a visually distinct hover state that intensifies glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and/or text-shadow. Verified by: programmatically triggering :hover on at least one element of each interactive type and asserting that the computed box-shadow or text-shadow value differs from the non-hovered state. No interactive element may have an identical computed style before and after hover.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR70]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 158, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The macro timeline must lay out the reference artifact's four frames correctly: the initial frame (mode=initial, id a03f944e) must appear o…", - "body": "The macro timeline must lay out the reference artifact's four frames correctly: the initial frame (mode=initial, id a03f944e) must appear on the main vertical trunk; the three rederive frames (ids 10f07753, b40fd568, b9236ccf, all with parentFrameId=a03f944e) must appear as horizontal siblings branching to the right at the same vertical level as each other, not as a vertical chain. Verified by inspecting the rendered positions of each frame card's center point on the WebGL canvas.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR56]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 159, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The provenance mini-graph within the node detail panel is acknowledged to be complex to implement, particularly ensuring it remains visuall…", - "body": "The provenance mini-graph within the node detail panel is acknowledged to be complex to implement, particularly ensuring it remains visually coherent with the main graph.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 160, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The comparison view must display the fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) as a decision banner betwee…", - "body": "The comparison view must display the fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) as a decision banner between the baseline and candidate columns. All nodes in the same fan-in grouping must be accessible via a tab row above the split columns.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R51]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 161, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder prefers displaying interventions in two places: in the node detail panel (showing which interventions targeted the node) an…", - "body": "The stakeholder prefers displaying interventions in two places: in the node detail panel (showing which interventions targeted the node) and as annotations on frames in the macro timeline.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 162, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The loading state, error state, and empty state (no artifact loaded) must each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments.", - "body": "The loading state, error state, and empty state (no artifact loaded) must each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments. No raw unstyled, blank, or default-browser-styled state may appear at any point during the application lifecycle.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R56]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 163, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The toolbar must display a global validation summary badge showing the total count of validation errors from validation.json.", - "body": "The toolbar must display a global validation summary badge showing the total count of validation errors from validation.json. The badge must pulse in amber when any errors are present.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 164, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The production build output (vite build) must consist entirely of static files (HTML, JS, CSS, assets) with no server-side runtime requirem…", - "body": "The production build output (vite build) must consist entirely of static files (HTML, JS, CSS, assets) with no server-side runtime requirement. Serving the dist/ directory from any static file host (e.g., GitHub Pages, S3, Netlify) must produce a fully functional application. Zero fetch() calls to a backend API may occur during normal operation.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 165, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The spec elicitation pipeline uses fan-out/fan-in with clean-room re-derivation to handle contradictions, a perspective hub (CSP model) to…", - "body": "The spec elicitation pipeline uses fan-out/fan-in with clean-room re-derivation to handle contradictions, a perspective hub (CSP model) to present design alternatives, and reconciliation to merge candidates into the active baseline.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 166, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a search query is active, a results list must appear in the left sidebar below the filter controls, showing a scrollable list of match…", - "body": "When a search query is active, a results list must appear in the left sidebar below the filter controls, showing a scrollable list of matching nodes sorted by displayId. Each row must show the node's displayId, phase badge, semantic role or hub type badge, and truncated node text. The results list must remain visible simultaneously with the highlighted graph.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 167, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "artifact.json is the single bundled output file combining all pipeline output f…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T17]", - "detail": { - "definition": "artifact.json is the single bundled output file combining all pipeline output files, loaded by the explorer UI to provide all graph data, metadata, and reports." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 168, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A user who opens the application for the first time in a browser with no query parameters must be presented with the drop zone landing scre…", - "body": "A user who opens the application for the first time in a browser with no query parameters must be presented with the drop zone landing screen immediately, with no configuration dialogs, login prompts, URL entry fields, or setup steps. The drop zone must be the sole interactive element required to load an artifact. Verified by loading the app with no query params and asserting only the drop zone and optional file-picker button are the primary interactive elements.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR93]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 169, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the macro timeline, the initial frame card (mode=initial, id a03f944e) and the main trunk line connecting it must be rendered in phospho…", - "body": "In the macro timeline, the initial frame card (mode=initial, id a03f944e) and the main trunk line connecting it must be rendered in phosphor-green (#39FF14 or the defined phosphor-green token). Rederive frame cards must be rendered in phosphor-amber (#FFB000). Verified by sampling the rendered WebGL pixel color at the center of the initial frame card and at the center of one rederive frame card and comparing against the defined theme token values.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR88]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 170, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Each intervention record in interventions.json carries: id, frameId, phase, kind (e.g.", - "body": "Each intervention record in interventions.json carries: id, frameId, phase, kind (e.g. accept_candidate), targetNodeIds array, text (nullable), createdAt. Interventions are associated with a frame, not directly with individual nodes — the targetNodeIds array provides the node linkage.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X47]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 171, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, nodes must be visually colored with four distinct phosphor hues corresponding to the four derivation phases: groun…", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, nodes must be visually colored with four distinct phosphor hues corresponding to the four derivation phases: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done. The same four colors must appear on phase badge UI elements in the sidebar results list, the toolbar filter chips, and the detail panel phase badge — verified by comparing computed CSS color values across all locations.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 172, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Epistemic status expresses the evidentiary basis for a node's claim.", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T5]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Epistemic status expresses the evidentiary basis for a node's claim. The four defined values are: observed, asserted, assumed, and inferred." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 173, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Each row in the search results list must display: the node's displayId, a phase badge styled in the correct phase color, a semantic role ba…", - "body": "Each row in the search results list must display: the node's displayId, a phase badge styled in the correct phase color, a semantic role badge (for content nodes) or hub type badge (for hub nodes), and a truncated version of the node text. Verified by rendering the reference artifact, searching for a known term, and asserting all four elements are present in each result row's DOM.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 174, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the user switches from Micro view to Macro view and back to Micro view, the filter state (active phase chips, role checkboxes, search…", - "body": "When the user switches from Micro view to Macro view and back to Micro view, the filter state (active phase chips, role checkboxes, search query, lifecycle toggles) must be identical to what it was before switching. The Sigma canvas must restore the highlighting/dimming state reflecting the preserved filter. Verified by applying a multi-filter, switching views, and asserting the Zustand filterState is unchanged.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR90]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 175, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Loading a malformed artifact.json (e.g., a file with a valid JSON structure but missing the 'graph' key) must render a CRT-styled error scr…", - "body": "Loading a malformed artifact.json (e.g., a file with a valid JSON structure but missing the 'graph' key) must render a CRT-styled error screen with a descriptive message identifying the missing key. The error screen must use phosphor-amber or phosphor-text color on a phosphor-dim background, use the monospace font, and must not display any raw browser error dialog or white screen.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR81]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 176, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Inspecting the Sigma.js canvas element in the DOM must confirm it is a element with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl')…", - "body": "Inspecting the Sigma.js canvas element in the DOM must confirm it is a element with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl') or getContext('webgl2') must return a non-null value). The application must not fall back to SVG or Canvas2D rendering for the micro-view graph.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 177, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, node opacity must match lifecycle state: active nodes at 100% opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% (±5%);…", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, node opacity must match lifecycle state: active nodes at 100% opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% (±5%); archived nodes at approximately 20% (±5%); withdrawn nodes at approximately 10% (±5%). Sampling one node of each lifecycle from the reference artifact and measuring the rendered alpha value via the WebGL shader uniform or Sigma attribute must confirm the correct opacity for each.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 178, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the Connections section of the detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section must list all intervention records that reference…", - "body": "In the Connections section of the detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section must list all intervention records that reference the selected node in their targetNodeIds array. Each entry must show: intervention kind, frameId (rendered as a link that activates the macro view focused on that frame), and createdAt timestamp. For a node not referenced by any intervention, the sub-section must either be absent or show an empty state message.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR63]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 179, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Every text-bearing element in the application — node text, displayIds, data values, filter chips, badge labels, panel headers, results list…", - "body": "Every text-bearing element in the application — node text, displayIds, data values, filter chips, badge labels, panel headers, results list rows, and toolbar controls — must render in a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent). Inspecting the computed font-family of a representative sample of 10 distinct element types must return a monospace font in all cases. No element may render in the browser default sans-serif or serif font.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR69]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 180, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Filter and selection state changes must be debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma canvas refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders…", - "body": "Filter and selection state changes must be debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma canvas refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders during text search input.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 181, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When artifact.json is successfully parsed, the application must transition to the main explorer view with a CRT power-on animation before d…", - "body": "When artifact.json is successfully parsed, the application must transition to the main explorer view with a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content. When the app is in the file-drop landing state, no raw unstyled or blank screen may appear.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 182, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "A subtle scanline CSS overlay sits above the WebGL canvas to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", - "body": "A subtle scanline CSS overlay sits above the WebGL canvas to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 183, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The phase color used for a node's glow in the Sigma micro-view graph must exactly match the color used for that node's phase badge in the d…", - "body": "The phase color used for a node's glow in the Sigma micro-view graph must exactly match the color used for that node's phase badge in the detail panel Identity section, the phase chip in the sidebar filter panel, and the phase badge in the results list row. Extracting the RGB value of each location for a known node (e.g., a grounding-phase node) must return identical values across all four locations.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR82]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 184, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For a justification hub node, the Connections section must render a PREMISES group (nodes via 'informed_by' edges) and a CONCLUSIONS group…", - "body": "For a justification hub node, the Connections section must render a PREMISES group (nodes via 'informed_by' edges) and a CONCLUSIONS group (nodes via 'produced' edges). Each entry in both groups must be a clickable pill that navigates the detail panel to the referenced node. Verified by mounting the detail panel for a known justification hub node and asserting both groups are present with correct node references.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR48]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 185, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The micro-view graph must be rendered using Sigma.js v3 with a WebGL backend.", - "body": "The micro-view graph must be rendered using Sigma.js v3 with a WebGL backend. The renderer must support interactive frame rates for the full reference dataset of 761 total nodes and 2,662 edges.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 186, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, every node with kind='content' must render as a circle and every node with kind='hub' must render as a diamond.", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, every node with kind='content' must render as a circle and every node with kind='hub' must render as a diamond. Sampling at least 20 nodes of each kind from the reference artifact and inspecting their rendered shapes via the Sigma node program must confirm the correct geometry for all sampled nodes.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 187, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must be rendered with a per-node phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader.", - "body": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must be rendered with a per-node phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader. The glow intensity must increase on hover and on selection, driven by shader uniforms updated in response to pointer events.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 188, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "A WebGL-based renderer gives less fine-grained control over individual node appearance compared to SVG-based alternatives, which may limit…", - "body": "A WebGL-based renderer gives less fine-grained control over individual node appearance compared to SVG-based alternatives, which may limit certain visual design options.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 189, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The smoke-webhook artifact has 4 frames: one initial frame (mode=initial, entryPhase=grounding, no parent) and three rederive frames (mode=…", - "body": "The smoke-webhook artifact has 4 frames: one initial frame (mode=initial, entryPhase=grounding, no parent) and three rederive frames (mode=rederive, entryPhase=shaping, all sharing the same triggerImpasseId, all parented to the initial frame). The three rederive frames form siblings at attemptNumber 0, 1, 2 — not a linear chain. The last rederive frame (attemptNumber=2) has nudgingActive=true. Snapshots reference all 4 frameIds in a single checkpoint at revision 4.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X45]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 190, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Performance is managed through four mechanisms: (1) Web Worker layout: ForceAtlas2 runs off the main thread (covered in graph-layout-design…", - "body": "Performance is managed through four mechanisms: (1) Web Worker layout: ForceAtlas2 runs off the main thread (covered in graph-layout-design). (2) Sigma render batching: filter and selection state changes are debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders during search. (3) Candidate/archived node toggling: when lifecycle visibility toggles change, node visibility is updated via Sigma's node attribute API (setting hidden=true/false) rather than rebuilding the graphology graph, which is O(nodes) not O(edges). (4) Provenance mini-graph depth cap: upstream traversal is capped at 50 nodes / depth-4 (covered in provenance-mini-graph-design). These four mechanisms together bound worst-case interaction latency for the reference dataset (376 active + 288 candidate + 88 archived nodes, 2662 edges).", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 191, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The explorer UI will live as a sibling package at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/.", - "body": "The explorer UI will live as a sibling package at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 192, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A browser network log captured during a full interaction session (artifact load, graph exploration, filtering, detail panel, comparison vie…", - "body": "A browser network log captured during a full interaction session (artifact load, graph exploration, filtering, detail panel, comparison view) must show zero requests to any API endpoint or server beyond the optional initial artifact.json fetch (when using the ?artifact= URL param). All data operations must be resolved from the in-memory indexes. Verified using browser DevTools Network tab or a network interception test.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR79]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 193, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 376 active nodes, 88 archived nodes, 288 candidate nodes, and 9 withdrawn nodes.", - "body": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 376 active nodes, 88 archived nodes, 288 candidate nodes, and 9 withdrawn nodes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 194, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The derivation story view must clearly show the regression/recovery narrative: impasse discovered → clean-room re-derivation → fan-out → pe…", - "body": "The derivation story view must clearly show the regression/recovery narrative: impasse discovered → clean-room re-derivation → fan-out → perspective selection → reconciliation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 195, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The spec-elicitation-ui project is in early design and planning.", - "body": "The spec-elicitation-ui project is in early design and planning. No implementation decisions beyond the tech stack (Vite, React, Tailwind) have been confirmed.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 196, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a search query is entered, matching nodes must be highlighted in the Sigma canvas (full intensity) simultaneously with a scrollable re…", - "body": "When a search query is entered, matching nodes must be highlighted in the Sigma canvas (full intensity) simultaneously with a scrollable results list appearing in the sidebar below the filter controls. Both the canvas highlight state and the results list must be visible at the same time without any tab switch or mode change. The results list must be sorted by displayId.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 197, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display intervention annotation chips on its right edge, one chip per intervention record associ…", - "body": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display intervention annotation chips on its right edge, one chip per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip must show the intervention kind and a count of targetNodeIds. Hovering a chip must show a tooltip listing the targetNodeIds as human-readable displayIds.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R46]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 198, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro timeline must lay out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on a main trunk.", - "body": "The macro timeline must lay out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on a main trunk. Rederive frames must branch horizontally to the right of their parent frame as sibling columns at the same vertical level. The reference artifact's structure (one initial frame with three sibling rederive frames, all sharing the same triggerImpasseId) must be correctly represented as horizontal siblings, not a linear chain.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R42]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 199, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Kael is an AI assistant with persistent memory, built as a CLI tool using TypeScript, Effect, and Deno.", - "body": "Kael is an AI assistant with persistent memory, built as a CLI tool using TypeScript, Effect, and Deno.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 200, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The full-text search input must match nodes whose text field contains the query string (case-insensitive) AND nodes whose displayId contain…", - "body": "The full-text search input must match nodes whose text field contains the query string (case-insensitive) AND nodes whose displayId contains the query string. A search for 'DEC' must return all decision hub nodes whose displayId begins with 'DEC'. A search for a term appearing only in node text (e.g. 'circuit breaker') must return those nodes. A search for a string present in neither field must return an empty results list with an appropriate empty-state message.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR83]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 201, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Validation report data (from reports/validation in artifact.json) is integrated as follows: (1) At load time a validationIssuesByEdgeId Map…", - "body": "Validation report data (from reports/validation in artifact.json) is integrated as follows: (1) At load time a validationIssuesByEdgeId Map is built from validation.json errors. Since errors are edge-centric (per validation-report-context), a secondary edgeIssuesByNodeId Map is derived by walking each errored edge's source and target nodeIds. (2) In the micro-view graph, nodes with validation issues are rendered with a red-tinted glow halo in addition to their normal phase-color glow, implemented as a second glow pass in the WebGL shader. (3) In the node detail panel, the Validation section lists all errors touching edges incident to this node, showing rule, severity, message, and the edge's type and direction. (4) A global validation summary badge in the toolbar shows total error count and pulses amber when errors exist.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 202, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Keyboard navigation must be restricted to HTML panel controls only.", - "body": "Keyboard navigation must be restricted to HTML panel controls only. The Sigma WebGL canvas must have no keyboard event handlers. The implemented keyboard bindings must include: Escape closes the detail panel and clears selection (or closes comparison overlay); Tab/Shift-Tab moves focus between toolbar controls, filter chips, and results list; Enter on a focused results-list row selects that node; Arrow keys navigate between results-list items when the list has focus.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R57]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 203, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The application must be deployable as a static site with no server-side runtime.", - "body": "The application must be deployable as a static site with no server-side runtime. All artifact data must be derived from the client-loaded artifact.json; no API calls to a backend are permitted.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 204, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 2,662 edges across 17 distinct edge types.", - "body": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 2,662 edges across 17 distinct edge types.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [E2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 205, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain the following controls: (1) a full-text search input matching against node text and displayId; (…", - "body": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain the following controls: (1) a full-text search input matching against node text and displayId; (2) phase filter chips for all four phases (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done); (3) semantic role multi-select checkboxes for all ten roles (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk); (4) hub type toggle (all / decision / justification / impasse / perspective); (5) epistemic status chips for all four values (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred); (6) authority chips for all four values (stakeholder, technical, external, derived); (7) lifecycle visibility toggles mirroring the toolbar toggles.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 206, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Because FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field (RK5, E5), the macro view frame cards gracefully degrade: if a frame has no…", - "body": "Because FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field (RK5, E5), the macro view frame cards gracefully degrade: if a frame has no summary, the summary region displays a muted placeholder reading 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' in a dimmed monospace style consistent with the CRT aesthetic. The UI treats the summary field as optional throughout — no runtime error, no broken layout. When the pipeline schema extension is implemented and summaries are present in artifact.json, the UI renders them without any code change.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 207, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Pressing Tab repeatedly from the toolbar must cycle focus through all interactive controls in order: toolbar controls, filter chips in the…", - "body": "Pressing Tab repeatedly from the toolbar must cycle focus through all interactive controls in order: toolbar controls, filter chips in the sidebar, and results list rows. Pressing Shift-Tab must reverse the direction. Focus must never become trapped or jump to the Sigma WebGL canvas. Verified by simulating Tab keystrokes in a jsdom or browser test environment and asserting focused element identity at each step.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR72]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 208, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The Tailwind configuration must define all five CRT theme tokens with exact hex values: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14),…", - "body": "The Tailwind configuration must define all five CRT theme tokens with exact hex values: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F), and phosphor-text (#FFD580). Verified by reading tailwind.config.* and asserting each token name and value is present. At runtime, inspecting the computed background-color of the landing page body must return a value matching #1A1A0F (phosphor-dim).", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR68]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 209, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The app is strictly read-only.", - "body": "The app is strictly read-only. Editing nodes or edges is explicitly out of scope.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 210, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel must include a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section listing all intervention records that re…", - "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel must include a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section listing all intervention records that reference the current node in their targetNodeIds array. Each entry must show the intervention kind, frameId (linked to the corresponding frame in the macro view), and createdAt timestamp. The interventionsByNodeId join must be pre-computed at load time.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R47]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 211, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Running the Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) against the smoke-webhook reference artifact directory must produce a single a…", - "body": "Running the Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) against the smoke-webhook reference artifact directory must produce a single artifact.json file whose top-level structure contains exactly the keys: manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph (with sub-keys nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots), and reports (with sub-key validation). The resulting file must be valid JSON parseable by JSON.parse() without error.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR75]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 212, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Justification hub nodes (hubType='justification') render in the detail panel's Connections section as: (1) a 'PREMISES' group showing nodes…", - "body": "Justification hub nodes (hubType='justification') render in the detail panel's Connections section as: (1) a 'PREMISES' group showing nodes connected by 'informed_by' edges (the upstream support nodes); (2) a 'CONCLUSIONS' group showing nodes connected by 'produced' edges (what this justification produced). The justification's text (its rationale statement) is shown in the Identity section as the primary text. This mirrors the ATMS-style justification model from the pipeline and enables users to trace exactly what combination of premises produced a given conclusion.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 213, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the application is loaded with a ?artifact= query parameter, it must fetch the artifact.json from that URL via fetch(), skip the…", - "body": "When the application is loaded with a ?artifact= query parameter, it must fetch the artifact.json from that URL via fetch(), skip the drop zone entirely, and transition directly to the main explorer view. No file selection is required from the user.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 214, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Every interactive HTML element must display a visible focus ring styled in phosphor-amber (#FFB000) when it receives keyboard focus.", - "body": "Every interactive HTML element must display a visible focus ring styled in phosphor-amber (#FFB000) when it receives keyboard focus. Verified by: tabbing through all interactive elements in the toolbar, filter panel, and results list, and asserting that the focused element's outline or box-shadow computed value includes a color matching #FFB000. No interactive element may have an invisible or default-browser focus indicator.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR71]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 215, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Edge types are organized into six categories: hub-generic edges, decision hub e…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T10]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Edge types are organized into six categories: hub-generic edges, decision hub edges, perspective hub edges, impasse hub edges, content edges, and lineage edges." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 216, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Review status is a tagged union on nodes with three variants: 'clean' (no issue…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T7]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Review status is a tagged union on nodes with three variants: 'clean' (no issues), 'suspect' (with causeIds indicating problems), and 'conditional' (with impasseIds indicating unresolved dependencies)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 217, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The subgraph zoom-into-frame feature for the macro view can be deferred to a later iteration.", - "body": "The subgraph zoom-into-frame feature for the macro view can be deferred to a later iteration.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 218, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a range slider whose min and max correspond to the lowest and highest revision numbers present in the a…", - "body": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a range slider whose min and max correspond to the lowest and highest revision numbers present in the artifact's snapshots array. The slider must display a numeric revision badge and a human-readable timestamp label for the currently selected snapshot. A status line below the slider must show the revision number and the frameId(s) associated with that snapshot.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 219, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Provenance section of the detail panel must render a second independent Sigma.js instance in approximately 280px of panel height, showi…", - "body": "The Provenance section of the detail panel must render a second independent Sigma.js instance in approximately 280px of panel height, showing the upstream derivation subgraph for the selected node. Traversal must follow support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards from the focal node. Traversal must be exhaustive for chains of 50 or fewer upstream nodes, and capped at depth 4 for larger chains. The focal node must appear at full glow. Ancestors must be laid out using graphology-layout-dagre in left-to-right derivation direction. Clicking any node in the mini-graph must navigate the main detail panel to that node.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 220, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The landing page drop zone must be visually styled with a phosphor-glowing dashed border (using the phosphor-amber or phosphor-green color…", - "body": "The landing page drop zone must be visually styled with a phosphor-glowing dashed border (using the phosphor-amber or phosphor-green color token), a scanline texture, and dark background consistent with the CRT aesthetic. No element on the landing page may render with default browser styling, white background, or unstyled text. The drop zone must provide a visible affordance (e.g., icon and label) indicating file drop or selection.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR94]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 221, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL node program class as the main micro-view graph.", - "body": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL node program class as the main micro-view graph. Node colors, glow style, and shape encoding (circle for content, diamond for hub) must be visually identical between the two Sigma instances. Verified by comparing the Sigma program constructor reference used in both instances — they must be the same class.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR51]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 222, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Pressing the Escape key while the detail panel is open (and no comparison overlay is open) must close the detail panel and set selectedNode…", - "body": "Pressing the Escape key while the detail panel is open (and no comparison overlay is open) must close the detail panel and set selectedNodeId to null in the Zustand store. The canvas must expand to fill the vacated space. Pressing Escape when both the comparison overlay and the detail panel are open must close only the comparison overlay and leave the detail panel visible.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR44]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 223, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the upstream derivation chain of the selected node contains more than 50 nodes, the provenance mini-graph traversal must be capped at…", - "body": "When the upstream derivation chain of the selected node contains more than 50 nodes, the provenance mini-graph traversal must be capped at depth 4 from the focal node. When the chain is 50 nodes or fewer, traversal must be exhaustive. Verified by: selecting a deep-chain node from the reference artifact, confirming the mini-graph renders no more than depth-4 ancestors; then selecting a shallow-chain node and confirming all ancestors are rendered.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR50]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 224, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The CRT motif reinforces the idea of looking into a system's internals — it is the stakeholder's stated rationale for the visual design lan…", - "body": "The CRT motif reinforces the idea of looking into a system's internals — it is the stakeholder's stated rationale for the visual design language.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 225, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Typing rapidly into the search input must not trigger a Sigma canvas refresh on every keystroke.", - "body": "Typing rapidly into the search input must not trigger a Sigma canvas refresh on every keystroke. Measuring Sigma refresh calls during a burst of 10 keystrokes within 100ms must show no more than one refresh call, occurring no sooner than 16ms after the last keystroke. Verified by spying on the Sigma refresh method in a test environment.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 226, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The toolbar must display a validation summary badge showing the total error count from validation.json.", - "body": "The toolbar must display a validation summary badge showing the total error count from validation.json. For the reference artifact, this count must match the number of entries in the errors array in validation.json. When errors are present, the badge must have a pulsing amber CSS animation. The badge must be present from the moment the main explorer renders, before any node is selected.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR54]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 227, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The spec elicitation source code lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/.", - "body": "The spec elicitation source code lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 228, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "Edges in the graph are organized into categories: support edges (derived_from,…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T9]", - "detail": { - "definition": "Edges in the graph are organized into categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) carry epistemic weight; workflow edges (produced, resolved_by, selected) carry operational provenance; structural edges (alternative_to, conflicts_with) are informational with no derivation direction." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 229, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A semantic role classifies the epistemic function of a content node.", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T2]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A semantic role classifies the epistemic function of a content node. The ten defined values are: goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, and risk." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 230, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, lifecycle state must be encoded as node opacity: active nodes at full opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60…", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, lifecycle state must be encoded as node opacity: active nodes at full opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% opacity; archived nodes at approximately 20% opacity; withdrawn nodes at approximately 10% opacity.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 231, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "At every point in the application lifecycle — loading, error, and empty (no artifact loaded) — the UI must display a bespoke CRT-themed tre…", - "body": "At every point in the application lifecycle — loading, error, and empty (no artifact loaded) — the UI must display a bespoke CRT-themed treatment. Inspecting the DOM during each state must show no element with default browser font (sans-serif or serif), no unstyled text, and no blank white areas.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 232, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The CRT visual motif must feel like a beautiful, refined instrument — not a retro novelty.", - "body": "The CRT visual motif must feel like a beautiful, refined instrument — not a retro novelty. The UI must have no janky transitions or raw unstyled states anywhere.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 233, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation for the micro-view graph must run in a Web Worker so the UI thread is not blocked.", - "body": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation for the micro-view graph must run in a Web Worker so the UI thread is not blocked. During layout computation, the canvas must display a CRT-styled 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' progress indicator. Layout positions must be cached in sessionStorage keyed by specId and snapshotRevision after the first computation.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 234, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The node detail panel shows kind-specific fields in its first collapsible section: for content nodes this is semantic role, epistemic statu…", - "body": "The node detail panel shows kind-specific fields in its first collapsible section: for content nodes this is semantic role, epistemic status, and authority; for hub nodes this is hub type.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 235, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The stakeholder has defined two fundamental visualization views: a micro view and a macro view, both of which are required.", - "body": "The stakeholder has defined two fundamental visualization views: a micro view and a macro view, both of which are required.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 236, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When archived nodes are made visible via the lifecycle toggle, they must render at approximately 20% opacity, visually distinct from active…", - "body": "When archived nodes are made visible via the lifecycle toggle, they must render at approximately 20% opacity, visually distinct from active nodes (100% opacity) and candidate nodes (~60% opacity). The dimmed appearance must be consistent with the CRT aesthetic (no bright white glow on archived nodes). Verified by enabling the archived toggle and visually comparing an archived node (e.g., D22 / id 00cfa668) against an active neighbor.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR78]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 237, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The validation.json report has a flat structure: timestamp, totalNodes, totalEdges, totalFrames, and an errors array where each error has r…", - "body": "The validation.json report has a flat structure: timestamp, totalNodes, totalEdges, totalFrames, and an errors array where each error has rule, severity, message, and edgeId. The predominant error rule observed is 'phase-stratification' flagging derived_from edges that cross phase boundaries (e.g. shaping→grounding, pinning→grounding). The report is edge-centric, not node-centric — issues reference edgeIds, not nodeIds directly.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X46]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 238, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "A Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) must merge all pipeline output files into artifact.json with the schema: { manifest, sou…", - "body": "A Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) must merge all pipeline output files into artifact.json with the schema: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. For each FrameRecord, the bundler must add summary: null when no summary is present, so the UI always receives a well-typed FrameRecord.summary field of type string | null.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R59]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 239, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Kael maintains a memory graph with nodes connected by typed edges such as reinforces, derived_from, and tension_with, and has sleep phases…", - "body": "Kael maintains a memory graph with nodes connected by typed edges such as reinforces, derived_from, and tension_with, and has sleep phases (nap, dream) that consolidate and maintain it.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 240, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Archived nodes must be visually distinct from active nodes (e.g.", - "body": "Archived nodes must be visually distinct from active nodes (e.g. dimmed or reduced opacity) in a manner consistent with the CRT aesthetic.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 241, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Tailwind configuration must define the following CRT theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#…", - "body": "The Tailwind configuration must define the following CRT theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F) for backgrounds, and phosphor-text (#FFD580) for body text. These tokens must be used consistently across all UI components.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R53]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 242, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A provenance chain is the full upstream derivation path for a node: what it was…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T18]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A provenance chain is the full upstream derivation path for a node: what it was derived from, what informed it, and what source material (quotes, claims) it is grounded in." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 243, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The macro view must enable users to understand how the spec developed over time — not just how it looks at a single point — showing the nar…", - "body": "The macro view must enable users to understand how the spec developed over time — not just how it looks at a single point — showing the narrative from initial grounding through derivation loops and reconciliation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 244, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field; a schema extension is needed to add per-frame LLM-generated summaries to the artifa…", - "body": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field; a schema extension is needed to add per-frame LLM-generated summaries to the artifact.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [E5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 245, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The application must accept artifact.json via browser File API drag-and-drop or file picker on a full-screen landing page, without requirin…", - "body": "The application must accept artifact.json via browser File API drag-and-drop or file picker on a full-screen landing page, without requiring any server upload or URL configuration from the user.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 246, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Active nodes are shown by default in the UI.", - "body": "Active nodes are shown by default in the UI. The user can toggle archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes to see the full history.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 247, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The smoke-test artifact for the webhook delivery system spec is located at /Users/bmahmoud/Desktop/smoke-webhook/ and serves as the referen…", - "body": "The smoke-test artifact for the webhook delivery system spec is located at /Users/bmahmoud/Desktop/smoke-webhook/ and serves as the reference dataset for development.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 248, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "On initial load, only active nodes must be visible in the Sigma canvas.", - "body": "On initial load, only active nodes must be visible in the Sigma canvas. The three lifecycle toggles (archived, candidate, withdrawn) must each independently control visibility of their respective node sets. Toggling 'candidate' on must make the 288 candidate nodes from the reference artifact visible at ~60% opacity. Toggling it off must hide them. Active nodes must remain visible regardless of any toggle state.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR77]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 249, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A frame is a unit of derivation history in the pipeline.", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T12]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A frame is a unit of derivation history in the pipeline. The macro view shows frames and how they relate over time. Frames may carry LLM-generated summaries describing what happened and what was important." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 250, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "In the micro-view graph, node color must encode derivation phase using four distinct phosphor hues — one for each of the four phases (groun…", - "body": "In the micro-view graph, node color must encode derivation phase using four distinct phosphor hues — one for each of the four phases (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done). The same four-hue palette must be used consistently across the micro graph, the provenance mini-graph, and all phase badge UI elements.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 251, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "For a decision node, the detail view must show its rationale, considered alternatives (via 'considered' edges), selection/rejection outcome…", - "body": "For a decision node, the detail view must show its rationale, considered alternatives (via 'considered' edges), selection/rejection outcomes (via 'selected'/'rejected' edges), and produced consequences (via 'consequence'/'produced' edges), with traceability back to grounding inputs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 252, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When the Provenance section is expanded for a selected node, a second independent Sigma.js instance must be mounted in a container of appro…", - "body": "When the Provenance section is expanded for a selected node, a second independent Sigma.js instance must be mounted in a container of approximately 280px height. The mini-graph must render the upstream derivation subgraph of the selected node, traversing support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards. The focal node must appear at full glow intensity. Ancestor layout must use graphology-layout-dagre in left-to-right direction.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR49]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 253, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A hub type identifies a node that aggregates structural reasoning rather than c…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T3]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A hub type identifies a node that aggregates structural reasoning rather than carrying content. The four defined hub types are: justification, decision, impasse, and perspective." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 254, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "At artifact load time, the application must build the following in-memory indexes in a single synchronous pass: nodeIndex (Map),…", - "body": "At artifact load time, the application must build the following in-memory indexes in a single synchronous pass: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (Map), adjacency (Map), frameIndex (Map), snapshotIndex (Map), validationIssuesByEdgeId (Map), edgeIssuesByNodeId (Map), and interventionsByNodeId (Map). No re-parsing or re-indexing must occur during the session.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [R18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 255, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The file-loading mechanism must require zero configuration from the user.", - "body": "The file-loading mechanism must require zero configuration from the user.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X42]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 256, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Validation section of the detail panel must appear only when the node's review status is not 'clean'.", - "body": "The Validation section of the detail panel must appear only when the node's review status is not 'clean'. It must list all validation errors from validation.json that touch edges incident to the selected node, showing for each error: rule, severity, message, edge type, and edge direction. Suspect nodes must show causeId links and conditional nodes must show impasseId links.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 257, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The Zustand store must expose the following top-level keys, all populated after artifact load: loadedArtifact, nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjace…", - "body": "The Zustand store must expose the following top-level keys, all populated after artifact load: loadedArtifact, nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByEdgeId, edgeIssuesByNodeId, interventionsByNodeId, activeView, selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState, comparisonState. Inspecting the store via a test or React DevTools must confirm all keys are present and correctly typed after a successful artifact parse.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [CR32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 258, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle control with exactly two states: Micro and Macro.", - "body": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle control with exactly two states: Micro and Macro. Activating Micro must mount the Sigma.js WebGL canvas in the central area. Activating Macro must unmount the Sigma canvas and mount the dedicated macro WebGL timeline canvas in its place. The toggle state must be reflected in the Zustand store's activeView field.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 259, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A SnapshotRecord is a checkpoint in the artifact that includes an activeNodeIds…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T11]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A SnapshotRecord is a checkpoint in the artifact that includes an activeNodeIds array indicating which nodes are active at that point in time, enabling the UI to reconstruct the graph state at any historical snapshot." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 260, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A derivation phase is one of four ordered stages in the spec elicitation pipeli…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T1]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A derivation phase is one of four ordered stages in the spec elicitation pipeline: grounding (goals, terms, constraints), shaping (designs, decisions, alternatives), pinning (requirements), and defining_done (acceptance criteria). Phases have strict dependency order." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 261, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Polish in both design and interactions is essential: transitions must be smooth, hover states must feel alive, and the UI must reward explo…", - "body": "Polish in both design and interactions is essential: transitions must be smooth, hover states must feel alive, and the UI must reward exploration.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 262, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use Sigma.js v3 with WebGL backend and a custom phosphor-glow fragment shader.", - "body": "Use Sigma.js v3 with WebGL backend and a custom phosphor-glow fragment shader.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC4]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The micro-view graph is rendered using Sigma.js (v3) with a WebGL backend. Nodes are drawn with a custom WebGL fragment shader implementing per-node phosphor glow whose intensity is driven by a uniform updated on hover and selection state. Node color encodes derivation phase (4 distinct phosphor hues). Node shape encodes kind (circle = content, diamond = hub). Edge color encodes category: support edges in dim amber, workflow edges in brighter green, structural edges in muted cyan. Lifecycle state is encoded as opacity: active = full, archived = 20% opacity, candidate = 60% opacity, withdrawn = 10% opacity. The Sigma canvas is overlaid with a CSS scanline texture layer (pointer-events: none) to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Use Cytoscape.js with its WebGL renderer (cytoscape-gl or pixi.js extension). Richer built-in layout algorithms and compound node support, but less control over custom shader effects and heavier bundle size.", - "Alternative: Render the graph using D3-force with SVG. Provides per-element CSS control, easy CRT filter effects via SVG filter primitives, and simpler hit-testing, but SVG degrades significantly beyond ~1,000 nodes and edges." - ], - "rationale": "Sigma.js is the stakeholder's stated preference (X16) and is purpose-built for large graph rendering via WebGL, directly addressing RK1 (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges). Its custom WebGL program API allows implementing the phosphor glow shader per X40 with direct uniform control for hover intensity. D3/SVG (alt 1) cannot handle the dataset size at interactive frame rates. Cytoscape (alt 2) has heavier abstractions that would impede the custom shader work required for the CRT aesthetic, and RK2 notes that WebGL gives less fine-grained per-node control than SVG — Sigma's program API mitigates this by exposing shader-level control." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 263, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Right-side collapsible panel with CRT power-on flicker animation; four collapsible sections; embedded provenance mini-graph.", - "body": "Right-side collapsible panel with CRT power-on flicker animation; four collapsible sections; embedded provenance mini-graph.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC7]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The right detail panel activates on node click with a ~150ms CRT power-on flicker animation (opacity pulses 0→0.3→0.1→1 over 150ms via CSS keyframes). The panel has four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded: full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator (clean/suspect/conditional with cause links), kind-specific classification fields (semanticRole + epistemicStatus + authority for content nodes; hubType for hubs); (2) Connections — hub-type-specific relationship table: for decision hubs shows rationale prose, considered/selected/rejected/consequence edges grouped with linked displayIds per X35; for impasse hubs shows conflicting_input/resolved_by/spawned/refined_to; for justification hubs shows informed_by/produced; (3) Provenance — an embedded Sigma.js mini-graph (max ~50 upstream nodes) showing the full derivation chain per X25, with clickable nodes that navigate the main panel; (4) Validation — only shown when review status is not clean: lists suspect causeIds and conditional impasseIds with links, and lists any validation report errors touching this node's edges. Escape key closes the panel per X28.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Open node detail as a full-screen modal overlay rather than a persistent side panel. Maximizes reading space but destroys the graph context while the detail is open, preventing navigation by clicking nodes in the background.", - "Alternative: Show node detail in a bottom drawer that expands upward, preserving the full left-right canvas width. Works well on wide monitors but reduces vertical canvas space significantly and is inconsistent with the three-region layout design." - ], - "rationale": "The right panel keeps the graph visible alongside the detail, enabling the user to follow provenance links in the mini-graph (X25) and click adjacent nodes without losing context — the modal (alt 1) destroys this. The bottom drawer (alt 2) cuts vertical canvas space, which is critical for the macro timeline view. The four-section collapsible structure satisfies X24's requirement that the most important information (Identity) is always visible at top. The flicker animation is explicitly preferred by the stakeholder (X24) over slide-in." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 264, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Keyboard navigation covers only HTML panel controls; Sigma canvas is mouse/touch only.", - "body": "Keyboard navigation covers only HTML panel controls; Sigma canvas is mouse/touch only.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC14]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Keyboard navigation covers panel controls only, not the Sigma canvas (per X28 and C11). Implemented bindings: Escape closes the detail panel and clears node selection; Tab / Shift-Tab moves focus between toolbar controls, filter chips, and the results list; Enter on a focused results-list row selects that node (opens detail panel); Arrow keys navigate between results list items when the list has focus; Escape from the comparison overlay closes comparison and returns to the detail panel. All interactive HTML elements use standard focus rings styled in phosphor-amber to remain visible on the dark background. The Sigma canvas itself has no keyboard event handlers; it receives only mouse and touch events.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Implement full ARIA graph navigation with keyboard traversal of graph nodes (focus moves between nodes via arrow keys, Tab enters/exits the graph). Significantly more accessible but explicitly out of scope per X28 and C11, and technically complex with a WebGL canvas." - ], - "rationale": "X28 and C11 explicitly restrict keyboard navigation to panel controls. Full ARIA graph traversal (alt 1) is explicitly out of scope and would require complex keyboard hit-testing against WebGL-rendered node positions. The defined bindings cover all panel interactions needed for productive exploration without a mouse." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 265, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Embedded second Sigma.js instance for provenance visualization, with dagre hierarchical layout and depth cap.", - "body": "Embedded second Sigma.js instance for provenance visualization, with dagre hierarchical layout and depth cap.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC8]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The provenance mini-graph inside the detail panel is a second, independent Sigma.js instance mounted in a ~280px tall panel region. It renders only the upstream derivation subgraph for the selected node: traversing support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards from the focal node up to a configurable depth (default: exhaustive for graphs ≤50 upstream nodes, capped at depth-4 for larger chains). The focal node is rendered at full glow at center; ancestors are positioned using a left-to-right hierarchical layout (graphology-layout-dagre) to reflect derivation direction. Nodes are clickable: clicking navigates the main detail panel to that node, updating both the main graph selection and the mini-graph. Visual style (colors, glow, scanlines) is shared via the same Sigma program class used in the main graph.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Replace the mini-graph with a structured text list of upstream nodes (grouped by edge type), each as a clickable pill. Avoids the complexity of a second Sigma instance (RK3) but loses the spatial/relational context that a graph provides." - ], - "rationale": "The stakeholder explicitly prefers a Sigma.js mini-graph for provenance (X25) and calls out that it must be visually coherent with the main graph. A text list (alt) satisfies navigation but not spatial provenance comprehension, which is central to G2 (tracing provenance). RK3 acknowledges the complexity; the depth cap (≤50 nodes / depth-4) bounds the worst-case rendering cost. Reusing the same Sigma program class minimizes the implementation delta and guarantees visual coherence." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 266, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use a slider for snapshot selection, preserving graph topology by opacity rather than node removal.", - "body": "Use a slider for snapshot selection, preserving graph topology by opacity rather than node removal.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC9]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The micro view is the default view on artifact load. It renders the full node+edge graph in Sigma.js with the snapshot selector in the top toolbar. The snapshot selector is a slider (with a numeric revision badge and timestamp label) that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions. On snapshot change, the active node set is recomputed from the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array: nodes not in activeNodeIds are rendered at near-zero opacity (effectively hidden) rather than removed from the Sigma graph, preserving topology for context. A 'Show inactive' toggle in the toolbar reveals archived/candidate/withdrawn nodes at reduced opacity per X32 and X33. The current snapshot's revision number and frameId(s) are shown as a status line below the slider.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Replace the snapshot slider with a dropdown menu listing each snapshot by revision number and timestamp. More explicit labeling but slower to scrub through revisions sequentially." - ], - "rationale": "X20 describes a 'dropdown or slider' but a slider affords scrubbing through the derivation history which is far more expressive for understanding temporal evolution (G3). Preserving topology (opacity vs removal) is essential so users retain spatial memory of node positions as they scrub — removing nodes would cause disorienting layout thrash since ForceAtlas2 positions are pinned after initial computation. The dropdown alt is retained as a labeled companion control (showing the current revision name) but the primary interaction is the slider." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 267, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use Web Worker ForceAtlas2 layout computed at runtime, cached in sessionStorage.", - "body": "Use Web Worker ForceAtlas2 layout computed at runtime, cached in sessionStorage.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC5]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The micro-view graph uses a force-directed layout (Sigma's built-in ForceAtlas2 via graphology-layout-forceatlas2) computed via a Web Worker on first load so the UI thread is not blocked. Layout positions are cached in sessionStorage keyed by specId+snapshotRevision. When the user scrubs to a different snapshot, only node visibility (opacity) changes — layout positions are not recomputed. The initial layout run is shown with a CRT-style 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' progress indicator on the canvas.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Use a hierarchical/DAG layout (e.g. graphology-layout-dagre) that reflects phase ordering (grounding → shaping → pinning → defining_done) top-to-bottom, trading force-directed organic clustering for explicit phase structure.", - "Alternative: Pre-compute and store layout positions in the artifact.json bundle at generation time, eliminating the Web Worker layout step entirely at the cost of larger artifact files." - ], - "rationale": "Force-directed layout naturally clusters semantically related nodes through the edge structure, which better serves G4's goal of understanding relationships than a rigid hierarchical layout. Pre-computing positions (alt 2) would bloat artifact.json and couple the bundler to layout logic that properly belongs in the UI. Hierarchical layout (alt 1) would produce a very tall graph given 376+ nodes across 4 phases and would degrade for the many cross-phase derived_from edges present in the reference dataset (per validation-report-context). Web Worker prevents UI jank during the ~1-2 second computation for the reference dataset size." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 268, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Tailwind theme tokens + CSS primitives for UI chrome; WebGL shader only for Sigma node glow.", - "body": "Tailwind theme tokens + CSS primitives for UI chrome; WebGL shader only for Sigma node glow. CSS blur filter used to approximate glow on HTML elements.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC12]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The CRT visual design system is implemented as a Tailwind CSS theme extension plus a small set of reusable CSS/WebGL primitives. Tailwind theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F) for backgrounds, phosphor-text (#FFD580) for body text. Typography: a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or similar) for node text, displayIds, and data values; a slightly wider monospace for headers. CRT primitives: (a) scanline-overlay — a fixed CSS pseudo-element using a repeating-linear-gradient of 1px transparent / 1px rgba(0,0,0,0.15) stripes, pointer-events:none, placed above the WebGL canvas; (b) glow-text — a Tailwind utility applying text-shadow in the node's phase color; (c) flicker-in — a CSS @keyframes animation (0% opacity:0, 30% opacity:0.4, 45% opacity:0.1, 100% opacity:1) running 150ms ease-in used for panel power-on; (d) phosphor-border — a box-shadow utility combining inset and outer glow in the phase color at low alpha. All interactive elements (buttons, chips, panel headers) use hover states that intensify glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and text-shadow. No raw unstyled states exist: the loading state, error state, and empty states each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Implement all CRT effects purely in CSS (SVG filter feGaussianBlur for glow, CSS animations for flicker) without any WebGL shader involvement for the UI chrome, relying on Sigma's custom program only for node glow. Simpler but the glow effect on CSS elements will not match the WebGL node glow, creating visual inconsistency." - ], - "rationale": "Full CSS implementation (alt 1) was actually selected with a clarification: the node glow in Sigma is WebGL (per X40 and the graph-renderer decision), but all HTML UI elements use CSS box-shadow/text-shadow for glow effects — this is intentional. The visual gap between CSS glow (on panels, chips, buttons) and WebGL glow (on graph nodes) is acceptable and is bridged by matching the glow color palette. Attempting to route HTML element rendering through WebGL would be vastly over-engineered. The design system's value is in the Tailwind token vocabulary, the scanline overlay primitive, and the flicker-in keyframes, which together ensure no raw unstyled states exist (C7) and all transitions feel alive (C8)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 269, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Build the macro timeline as a dedicated WebGL canvas (raw WebGL with a thin abstraction), separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas.", - "body": "Build the macro timeline as a dedicated WebGL canvas (raw WebGL with a thin abstraction), separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC10]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The macro view replaces the Sigma canvas with a WebGL-rendered vertical timeline built using raw WebGL (via a thin abstraction layer, not a graph library). The timeline lays out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on the main trunk. Rederive frames branch horizontally to the right of their parent frame as sibling columns at the same vertical level, reflecting the fan-out topology observed in the reference artifact (all three rederive attempts are siblings of the initial frame, not a linear chain). Each frame is rendered as a rectangular card with: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive indicator, createdAt timestamp, and the pre-generated LLM summary text if present (gracefully omitted with a 'no summary' placeholder if absent per RK5). Edges between frames encode relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges for triggerImpasseId linkage (drawn in warning amber), fan-in-record edges connecting rederive frames back to baseline (drawn in success green). Interventions associated with a frame are shown as small annotation chips on the frame card's right edge per X26. Clicking a frame card zooms the view to show which nodes changed in that frame (deferred per C10 to a later iteration — click opens a modal node-diff list instead).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Represent frames as super-nodes in the same Sigma.js instance as the micro graph, using Sigma's camera zoom to transition between macro and micro views. Avoids a separate WebGL context but conflates two very different data models in one renderer, making the frame-card UI elements (text, badges, annotation chips) very difficult to implement.", - "Alternative: Build the macro timeline as a standard SVG/HTML component (e.g. using D3 for the layout math but rendering with React/SVG). Simpler to implement, easier to style with CSS, but does not enable the future zoom-into-frame WebGL transition that the stakeholder requires (X29)." - ], - "rationale": "X29 explicitly requires WebGL for the macro view to enable future zoom-into-frame. SVG/HTML (alt 1) cannot deliver a smooth zoom transition into the Sigma micro-graph. Reusing the Sigma instance (alt 2) conflates two incompatible data models and makes the rich frame-card UI (summaries, intervention chips, badges) nearly impossible within Sigma's node rendering model. A separate WebGL canvas gives full control over the frame-card visual language while keeping the door open for a seamless WebGL-to-WebGL zoom transition in a future iteration. The thin abstraction layer (rather than a full scene-graph library) keeps the bundle small and the rendering logic transparent." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 270, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Bundle all pipeline output into a single artifact.json; the UI loads only this file.", - "body": "Bundle all pipeline output into a single artifact.json; the UI loads only this file.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC1]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "A dedicated bundler script (part of the spec-elicitation package, not the UI) merges all pipeline output files into a single artifact.json. The merged structure is: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. The UI loads only this one file. The bundler is a Deno CLI script invoked after a pipeline run completes.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Bundle the artifact as a ZIP archive containing the original directory structure; the UI uses a JS ZIP library to decompress and access files in-memory after the user drops the archive.", - "Alternative: The UI loads individual files lazily from a user-supplied directory path or URL prefix, fetching each file on demand rather than requiring a pre-bundled artifact.json." - ], - "rationale": "A single flat JSON file satisfies C6 (remote hosting compatibility) and X18 (File API drop zone) simultaneously: the user drops one file regardless of whether the app is local or remote-hosted. Lazy directory loading (alt 1) fails C6 when hosted remotely because browsers cannot access local filesystem paths. ZIP (alt 2) adds a decompression dependency and is less transparent/inspectable than plain JSON. The bundler lives in spec-elicitation (Deno/TypeScript), matching the existing toolchain. The merged schema is straightforward given the known file set (E4)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 271, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Primary loading via browser File API drop zone; secondary loading via ?artifact= URL query param for remote sharing.", - "body": "Primary loading via browser File API drop zone; secondary loading via ?artifact= URL query param for remote sharing.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC2]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The app opens on a full-screen landing page featuring a CRT-styled drop zone (phosphor-glowing dashed border, scanline texture). The user drops or selects artifact.json via the browser File API (no server upload). On successful parse the app transitions to the main explorer with a CRT power-on animation. An optional URL query param (?artifact=) allows linking to a remotely hosted artifact.json for sharing — the app fetches it via fetch() when present, bypassing the drop zone.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Skip the File API entirely; require the user to host artifact.json at a URL and enter that URL in a text field. Simpler, but breaks the local-first zero-config requirement." - ], - "rationale": "File API drop zone satisfies X18 and X42 (zero config, local filesystem). The URL query param resolves RK6 (remote hosting compatibility) without complicating the primary path. URL-only (alt) violates X42. This dual-path design means both local and remote artifact access work against a static-hosted app, fully satisfying C6." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 272, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Show interventions in both the macro frame cards and the node detail panel, with a pre-computed interventionsByNodeId join index.", - "body": "Show interventions in both the macro frame cards and the node detail panel, with a pre-computed interventionsByNodeId join index.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC15]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Interventions are displayed in two places per X26: (1) In the macro view, each frame card shows a row of small intervention chips on its right edge, one per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip shows the intervention kind (e.g. 'accept_candidate') and a count of targetNodeIds. Hovering a chip shows a tooltip listing the targetNodeIds as displayIds. (2) In the node detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section (within the Connections section) lists interventions that reference the current node in their targetNodeIds array, showing kind, frameId (linked to the macro view), and timestamp. The intervention-to-node join is pre-computed at load time as an interventionsByNodeId Map.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Show interventions only in the macro view frame cards, not in the node detail panel. Lower implementation cost (avoids the interventionsByNodeId join), but loses the ability to see which interventions targeted a specific node from that node's perspective." - ], - "rationale": "X26 explicitly requires both locations. RK4 acknowledges the higher implementation cost but the stakeholder's preference is clear. The interventionsByNodeId Map is a simple O(n) pass over the interventions array at load time and adds negligible cost. Macro-only display (alt 1) would mean a user viewing a candidate node has no way to see that it was accepted by a human intervention without leaving the detail panel to find the frame — a significant navigation burden." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 273, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Split-panel overlay triggered from fan-in records or candidate node detail, showing text diff and fan-in rationale.", - "body": "Split-panel overlay triggered from fan-in records or candidate node detail, showing text diff and fan-in rationale.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC11]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Side-by-side baseline/candidate comparison is triggered by: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view, or (2) selecting a node with lifecycle=candidate and clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel. The comparison opens as a split overlay that temporarily replaces the right detail panel (or expands to full-panel width). The left column shows the baseline node (or the best_selected grouping winner from fan-in-records.json), the right column shows the candidate node. Differences in text, semantic role, epistemic status, and authority are highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions/deletions. The fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) is shown between the two columns as a decision banner. All nodes in the grouping are accessible via a tab row above the split. The comparison panel has a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Show baseline and candidate as two differently-styled node clusters in the main Sigma graph simultaneously, with lineage edges (equivalent_to, refined_by etc.) highlighted between them. More spatially honest but visually overwhelming given the large candidate node count (288 candidates in the reference artifact)." - ], - "rationale": "The graph overlay alternative (alt 1) is impractical at the reference dataset scale: 288 candidate nodes rendered simultaneously with 376 active nodes would saturate the canvas and the AND-filter dimming model would conflict with comparison highlighting. The split-panel approach isolates the comparison to the specific grouping being examined (per fan-in-records groupings structure), which matches how reconciliation actually works in the pipeline. The fan-in rationale is the key semantic bridge between candidate and baseline and deserves a prominent display position, which the split panel's center banner provides." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 274, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Persistent left sidebar filter panel with inline results list.", - "body": "Persistent left sidebar filter panel with inline results list.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC6]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The left sidebar hosts a filter+search panel with the following controls: (1) a full-text search input that matches against node text and displayId; (2) phase filter chips (grounding / shaping / pinning / defining_done); (3) semantic role multi-select checkboxes (10 roles from T2); (4) hub type toggle (all / decision / justification / impasse / perspective); (5) epistemic status chips; (6) authority chips; (7) lifecycle visibility toggles (active always on; archived/candidate/withdrawn toggleable per X32). All active filters combine with AND logic per X27. When any filter or search is active, Sigma re-renders with matching nodes at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes at 15% opacity; edges are dimmed when both endpoints are non-matching. The results panel below the filters shows a scrollable list of matching nodes sorted by displayId, each row showing displayId, phase badge, role/type badge, and truncated text.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Replace the sidebar filter panel with a command-palette (Cmd+K style) overlay for search, with graph-level filter controls only on the toolbar. Saves sidebar space but separates search results from filter controls and reduces discoverability." - ], - "rationale": "X38 explicitly requires that search highlight nodes in the graph AND show a results list simultaneously — a command palette (alt 1) collapses after selection and cannot maintain a persistent results list alongside the live graph. The sidebar keeps all filter dimensions (phase, role, lifecycle, authority, epistemic status) visible and adjustable without modal interruption, which is essential for exploratory navigation of a 376+ node graph. AND-logic across all active filters (X27) is most natural to communicate in a persistent panel where users can see all active filter chips at once." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 275, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use Zustand for application state management.", - "body": "Use Zustand for application state management.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC13]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Application state is managed using Zustand (a lightweight React state manager). A single store holds: loadedArtifact (the parsed artifact.json), all derived indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIndex), activeView ('micro' | 'macro'), selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState (lifecycle visibility, phase chips, role selection, search query), and comparisonState (active fan-in grouping). The store is initialized once on artifact load; all derived indexes are computed synchronously in a single pass and stored as plain Maps. React components subscribe to fine-grained store slices to minimize re-renders. No server state, no async store updates after load (C4).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: Use React Context + useReducer with no external state library. Zero dependencies, but Context re-renders on every state change unless carefully memoized — with a 376-node graph and frequent hover/filter state updates this would cause performance issues.", - "Alternative: Use Redux Toolkit for state management. More structured with time-travel debugging, but significantly more boilerplate for a read-only single-load application where immutability guarantees add no practical benefit." - ], - "rationale": "Zustand's slice-based subscription model is ideal for a read-only explorer: the graph canvas subscribes only to filter/selection state, the detail panel subscribes only to selectedNodeId, and the macro view subscribes only to activeView. This minimizes re-renders from hover and filter interactions on a 376+ node dataset. Redux (alt 1) is over-engineered for a read-only, single-load app with no async mutations. React Context (alt 2) would cause cascading re-renders on every filter keystroke unless heavily memoized, adding complexity that Zustand handles automatically." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 276, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use a three-region resizable split layout: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, right detail panel.", - "body": "Use a three-region resizable split layout: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, right detail panel.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC3]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "The main explorer shell uses a three-region layout: (1) a narrow left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and a node-list results panel; (2) a large central canvas area that hosts either the micro-view graph or the macro-view timeline depending on the active view mode; (3) a right-side detail panel that slides/flickers into existence when a node is selected. A top toolbar holds the view-mode toggle (Micro / Macro), the snapshot selector (when in Micro mode), and global controls (lifecycle toggles, phase filter chips). All panels are resizable via drag handles. When no node is selected the right panel is collapsed and the canvas occupies the full remaining width.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: A fully tabbed layout where Micro View, Macro View, and Search are separate browser-tab-style panes with no persistent split panels, detail opens as a modal overlay.", - "Alternative: A fullscreen canvas-first layout with no persistent sidebar; filter/search and detail panel appear as HUD overlays on top of the canvas." - ], - "rationale": "The three-region layout keeps all primary navigation surfaces visible simultaneously, which is critical given G4's requirement for search + graph + detail in one view. The tabbed alternative (alt 1) fragments context — switching to search hides the graph, violating X38 (search must highlight in graph AND show results list simultaneously). Fullscreen HUD (alt 2) risks cluttering the canvas and makes the filter/results list difficult to use on smaller screens. Resizable panels give power users control over canvas real estate while keeping the layout coherent." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 277, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The macro view must use a dedicated WebGL canvas to satisfy both the current frame-card UI requirements and the future zoom-into-frame tran…", - "body": "The macro view must use a dedicated WebGL canvas to satisfy both the current frame-card UI requirements and the future zoom-into-frame transition\n\n## Rationale\n\nX29 requires WebGL for the macro view to enable the future zoom-into-frame transition. D11 specifies rich frame-card content (badges, text, chips) that cannot be implemented within Sigma's node rendering model. DEC10 rejects SVG/HTML because it cannot deliver a smooth WebGL-to-WebGL zoom transition. These premises jointly require a dedicated raw WebGL canvas separate from Sigma.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 278, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND show a persistent results list simultaneously", - "body": "Search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND show a persistent results list simultaneously\n\n## Rationale\n\nX38 requires both highlighting in the graph and a results list. DEC6 selects the persistent sidebar over a command palette precisely because a command palette cannot maintain a simultaneous results list. D7 specifies the Sigma opacity-based highlighting. These three premises jointly mandate that the results list is persistent and co-visible with the live graph, not a transient overlay.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 279, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Both File API drop zone and ?artifact= URL param are required to satisfy local-first and remote-hosting constraints simultaneously", - "body": "Both File API drop zone and ?artifact= URL param are required to satisfy local-first and remote-hosting constraints simultaneously\n\n## Rationale\n\nX18 and X42 require local filesystem loading with zero configuration. C6 requires the loading mechanism to work when hosted remotely. RK6 identifies these as potentially conflicting. DEC2 resolves the conflict by specifying dual-path loading. These four premises jointly mandate both loading mechanisms — neither alone is sufficient.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 280, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "All micro-view design choices form a coherent, implementable system against the reference artifact.", - "body": "All micro-view design choices form a coherent, implementable system against the reference artifact.\n\n## Rationale\n\nThe graph-renderer-design (Sigma/WebGL), graph-data-model-design (in-memory indexes), graph-layout-design (Web Worker ForceAtlas2), filter-search-design (Zustand-driven opacity), micro-view-snapshot-design (opacity-based snapshot scrubbing), and performance-optimization-design (debouncing, hidden attribute) all interact without conflict: Sigma's node attribute API supports both opacity and hidden, ForceAtlas2 via graphology is the standard companion to Sigma, and Zustand's slice subscriptions prevent unnecessary Sigma refreshes. The reference dataset (761 total nodes, 2662 edges per validation-report-context) is within Sigma's documented performance envelope for WebGL rendering.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J1]", - "detail": null - } -] diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/spec.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/spec.json deleted file mode 100644 index 5e08428a7..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/explorer-ui/spec.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "slug": "explorer-ui", - "name": "Explorer UI", - "readiness_grade": "commitments_ready" -} diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/edges.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/edges.json deleted file mode 100644 index 1bb837ea2..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/edges.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,4034 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 122, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 142, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 1, - "target_local_id": 181, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 101, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 125, - "target_local_id": 230, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 197, - "target_local_id": 45, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 40, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 76, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 25, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 73, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 204, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 40, - "target_local_id": 157, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 55, - "target_local_id": 119, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 57, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 214, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 38, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 50, - "target_local_id": 120, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 100, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 98, - "target_local_id": 74, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 187, - "target_local_id": 38, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 229, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 213, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 53, - "target_local_id": 183, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 65, - "target_local_id": 210, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 131, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 207, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 43, - "target_local_id": 155, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 195, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 229, - "target_local_id": 168, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 9, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 24, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 130, - "target_local_id": 196, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 203, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 43, - "target_local_id": 109, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 62, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 27, - "target_local_id": 147, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 13, - "target_local_id": 47, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 99, - "target_local_id": 230, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 97, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 27, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 41, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 80, - "target_local_id": 225, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 137, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 86, - "target_local_id": 182, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 73, - "target_local_id": 122, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 45, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 69, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 183, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 44, - "target_local_id": 31, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 20, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 137, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 21, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 151, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 210, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 86, - "target_local_id": 79, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 168, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 198, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 177, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 41, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 88, - "target_local_id": 145, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 80, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 184, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 137, - "target_local_id": 148, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 229, - "target_local_id": 210, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 78, - "target_local_id": 208, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 159, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 8, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 94, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 30, - "target_local_id": 77, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 211, - "target_local_id": 175, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 150, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 225, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 165, - "target_local_id": 23, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 180, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 150, - "target_local_id": 27, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 87, - "target_local_id": 68, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 17, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 132, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 210, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 229, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 4, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 119, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 124, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 105, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 112, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 184, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 155, - "target_local_id": 194, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 99, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 145, - "target_local_id": 104, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 188, - "target_local_id": 74, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 115, - "target_local_id": 159, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 199, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 84, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 212, - "target_local_id": 48, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 97, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 111, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 135, - "target_local_id": 88, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 177, - "target_local_id": 168, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 172, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 87, - "target_local_id": 184, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 106, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 88, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 34, - "target_local_id": 42, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 116, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 6, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 37, - "target_local_id": 80, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 225, - "target_local_id": 33, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 26, - "target_local_id": 38, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 73, - "target_local_id": 181, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 158, - "target_local_id": 119, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 10, - "target_local_id": 128, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 165, - "target_local_id": 109, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 31, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 101, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 6, - "target_local_id": 53, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 101, - "target_local_id": 138, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 81, - "target_local_id": 175, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 88, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 86, - "target_local_id": 157, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 39, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 69, - "target_local_id": 147, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 107, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 88, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 61, - "target_local_id": 231, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 190, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 33, - "target_local_id": 230, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 113, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 167, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 155, - "target_local_id": 109, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 193, - "target_local_id": 195, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 113, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 207, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 121, - "target_local_id": 25, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 149, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 16, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 44, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 95, - "target_local_id": 79, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 172, - "target_local_id": 33, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 192, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 166, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 158, - "target_local_id": 55, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 126, - "target_local_id": 70, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 147, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 137, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 193, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 162, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 141, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 111, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 29, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 66, - "target_local_id": 113, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 121, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 141, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 41, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 161, - "target_local_id": 231, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 74, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 96, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 224, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 197, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 175, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 180, - "target_local_id": 231, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 70, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 102, - "target_local_id": 90, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 35, - "target_local_id": 30, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 117, - "target_local_id": 121, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 198, - "target_local_id": 65, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 36, - "target_local_id": 129, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 52, - "target_local_id": 202, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 147, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 149, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 224, - "target_local_id": 33, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 195, - "target_local_id": 138, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 30, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 60, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 191, - "target_local_id": 134, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 35, - "target_local_id": 24, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 180, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 85, - "target_local_id": 9, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 40, - "target_local_id": 104, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 55, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 9, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 225, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 224, - "target_local_id": 225, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 147, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 211, - "target_local_id": 69, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 100, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 153, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 173, - "target_local_id": 71, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 30, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 163, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 172, - "target_local_id": 169, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 138, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 164, - "target_local_id": 51, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 15, - "target_local_id": 59, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 16, - "target_local_id": 86, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 162, - "target_local_id": 56, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 106, - "target_local_id": 124, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 157, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 169, - "target_local_id": 33, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 225, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 111, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 93, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 48, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 34, - "target_local_id": 203, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 135, - "target_local_id": 145, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 165, - "target_local_id": 207, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 38, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 224, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 207, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 177, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 29, - "target_local_id": 77, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 65, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 131, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 153, - "target_local_id": 207, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 76, - "target_local_id": 157, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 13, - "target_local_id": 147, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 56, - "target_local_id": 109, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 160, - "target_local_id": 179, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 57, - "target_local_id": 105, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 59, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 68, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 231, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 85, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 53, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 93, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 90, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 95, - "target_local_id": 182, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 58, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 52, - "target_local_id": 14, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 227, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 167, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 109, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 69, - "target_local_id": 175, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 201, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 70, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 70, - "target_local_id": 148, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 184, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 178, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 110, - "target_local_id": 157, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 141, - "target_local_id": 116, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 229, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 81, - "target_local_id": 2, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 144, - "target_local_id": 106, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 170, - "target_local_id": 77, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 128, - "target_local_id": 194, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 51, - "target_local_id": 138, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 5, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 98, - "target_local_id": 141, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 9, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 8, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 111, - "target_local_id": 178, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 148, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 169, - "target_local_id": 225, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 98, - "target_local_id": 116, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 177, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 27, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 186, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 21, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 143, - "target_local_id": 100, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 169, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 226, - "target_local_id": 124, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 92, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 105, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 54, - "target_local_id": 8, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 175, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 185, - "target_local_id": 137, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 216, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 152, - "target_local_id": 122, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 79, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 126, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 47, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 123, - "target_local_id": 22, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 231, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 177, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 187, - "target_local_id": 26, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 65, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 118, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 206, - "target_local_id": 213, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 156, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 139, - "target_local_id": 18, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 124, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 214, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 23, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 127, - "target_local_id": 75, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 138, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 191, - "target_local_id": 96, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 45, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 213, - "target_local_id": 21, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 137, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 188, - "target_local_id": 119, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 99, - "target_local_id": 33, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 166, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 22, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 46, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 129, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 5, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 52, - "target_local_id": 30, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 26, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 133, - "target_local_id": 131, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 86, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 132, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 212, - "target_local_id": 102, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 55, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 195, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 54, - "target_local_id": 180, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 53, - "target_local_id": 7, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 193, - "target_local_id": 138, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 178, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 205, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 74, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 183, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 120, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 229, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 58, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 225, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 156, - "target_local_id": 93, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 31, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 59, - "target_local_id": 219, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 115, - "target_local_id": 231, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 95, - "target_local_id": 163, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 113, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 102, - "target_local_id": 48, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 129, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 152, - "target_local_id": 73, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 145, - "target_local_id": 40, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 228, - "target_local_id": 119, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 71, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 202, - "target_local_id": 72, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 101, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 31, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 204, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 178, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 117, - "target_local_id": 25, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 45, - "target_local_id": 200, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 216, - "target_local_id": 149, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 80, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 49, - "target_local_id": 101, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 169, - "target_local_id": 225, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 224, - "target_local_id": 215, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 23, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 196, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 58, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 74, - "target_local_id": 119, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 106, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 77, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 140, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 190, - "target_local_id": 161, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 157, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 100, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 112, - "target_local_id": 5, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 2, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 15, - "target_local_id": 219, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 11, - "target_local_id": 153, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 186, - "target_local_id": 58, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 64, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 184, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 157, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 195, - "target_local_id": 189, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 215, - "target_local_id": 230, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 82, - "target_local_id": 223, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 50, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 174, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 18, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 55, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 84, - "target_local_id": 90, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 129, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 163, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 77, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 131, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 210, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 73, - "target_local_id": 220, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 59, - "target_local_id": 105, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 179, - "target_local_id": 209, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 129, - "target_local_id": 142, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 29, - "target_local_id": 67, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 35, - "target_local_id": 202, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 232, - "target_local_id": 18, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 166, - "target_local_id": 226, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "realization", - "source_local_id": 230, - "target_local_id": 80, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 75, - "target_local_id": 63, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 139, - "target_local_id": 20, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 2, - "target_local_id": 175, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 59, - "target_local_id": 219, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 125, - "target_local_id": 99, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 131, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 208, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 125, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 115, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 61, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 2, - "target_local_id": 21, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 32, - "target_local_id": 84, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 17, - "target_local_id": 89, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 163, - "target_local_id": 79, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 218, - "target_local_id": 148, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 219, - "target_local_id": 105, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 31, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 111, - "target_local_id": 214, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 159, - "target_local_id": 180, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 153, - "target_local_id": 28, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 58, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 5, - "target_local_id": 192, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 154, - "target_local_id": 83, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 176, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 42, - "target_local_id": 203, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 60, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 5, - "target_local_id": 227, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 123, - "target_local_id": 176, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 229, - "target_local_id": 203, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 154, - "target_local_id": 60, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 220, - "target_local_id": 90, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 139, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 60, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 199, - "target_local_id": 217, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 217, - "target_local_id": 180, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 80, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 155, - "target_local_id": 218, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 167, - "target_local_id": 222, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 223, - "target_local_id": 148, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 133, - "target_local_id": 224, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 222, - "target_local_id": 22, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 189, - "target_local_id": 232, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 91, - "target_local_id": 97, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 221, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 83, - "target_local_id": 171, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 74, - "target_local_id": 178, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 26, - "target_local_id": 228, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 19, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 90, - "target_local_id": 181, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 170, - "target_local_id": 29, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "support", - "source_local_id": 134, - "target_local_id": 103, - "stance": "for", - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 221, - "target_local_id": 12, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - }, - { - "category": "dependency", - "source_local_id": 108, - "target_local_id": 166, - "stance": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "rationale": null - } -] diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/nodes.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/nodes.json deleted file mode 100644 index 60a2e7b6e..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/nodes.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2436 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "local_id": 1, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "check", - "title": "Macro View — code-audit pass", - "body": "Synthetic parent check representing the manual code-audit pass during which evidence nodes were authored. Generated by .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence a structural parent on the oracle plane.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-port-synthetic", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 2, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected' shall render at full opacity; PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected'…", - "body": "PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected' shall render at full opacity; PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' (or 'open' on a non-taken branch) shall render at reduced opacity (approximately 30%) to indicate they were not taken.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 3, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "In the spec-elicitation system, fan-out runs 2–3 independent clean-room derivation sessions from the same upstream context, and fan-in is a…", - "body": "In the spec-elicitation system, fan-out runs 2–3 independent clean-room derivation sessions from the same upstream context, and fan-in is a separate LLM agent that synthesizes the minimal viable set before reconciliation.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 4, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The CRT/phosphor design language is a project-wide standard defined in .impeccable.md, covering amber primary color, dark-only theme, phosp…", - "body": "The CRT/phosphor design language is a project-wide standard defined in .impeccable.md, covering amber primary color, dark-only theme, phosphor glow behavior, scanline texture, and JetBrains Mono font.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 5, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view shall reuse the existing src/components/DetailPanel.tsx component for the right-side detail panel; no separate macro-specifi…", - "body": "The macro view shall reuse the existing src/components/DetailPanel.tsx component for the right-side detail panel; no separate macro-specific detail panel component shall be introduced. DetailPanel may be extended internally to branch on the new record kinds (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, perspective).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 6, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Within a single frame containing all four phases, the y-coordinates of the four PhaseGroupNodes satisfy y(defining_done) < y(pinning) < y(s…", - "body": "Within a single frame containing all four phases, the y-coordinates of the four PhaseGroupNodes satisfy y(defining_done) < y(pinning) < y(shaping) < y(grounding) (defining_done at top of frame visually). Verify with a unit-test fixture.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 7, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The spec-elicitation system's derivation process consists of four phases in str…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [T2]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The spec-elicitation system's derivation process consists of four phases in strict dependency order: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 8, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Collapsed/expanded state shall not be written to localStorage, sessionStorage, cookies, the URL/query string, IndexedDB, or any other persi…", - "body": "Collapsed/expanded state shall not be written to localStorage, sessionStorage, cookies, the URL/query string, IndexedDB, or any other persistence layer; it shall exist only in React in-memory state for the lifetime of the component instance.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 9, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view layout shall be implemented as a custom recursive (DFS) algorithm computing absolute positions and subtree bounding boxes; i…", - "body": "The macro view layout shall be implemented as a custom recursive (DFS) algorithm computing absolute positions and subtree bounding boxes; it shall not use dagre, ELK, or any other general-purpose graph layout library.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 10, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "User can pan and zoom the canvas: simulating a mouse-wheel event over the React Flow pane changes the viewport zoom level, and a mouse-drag…", - "body": "User can pan and zoom the canvas: simulating a mouse-wheel event over the React Flow pane changes the viewport zoom level, and a mouse-drag on the pane changes the viewport translation. Verify with a React Flow integration test using fireEvent.wheel and fireEvent.mouseDown/Move/Up, asserting useReactFlow().getViewport() values change accordingly.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 11, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For each ReconciliationRecord with non-empty resolvedImpasseIds, layout emits a resolution edge from the corresponding ReconciliationNode t…", - "body": "For each ReconciliationRecord with non-empty resolvedImpasseIds, layout emits a resolution edge from the corresponding ReconciliationNode to each resolved ImpasseNode. Edge has computed stroke color resolving to the resolving phase's --color-phase-* token, stroke-style solid, markerEnd arrow, and the routing path returns leftward (i.e., target node x < source node x, or via a custom edge component that produces a leftward bend). Verify with a fixture asserting source.x > target.x and computed style.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR55]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 12, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the macro view shares the CRT phosphor design language (amber primary, JetBrains Mono, dark warm surfaces, phosphor…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the macro view shares the CRT phosphor design language (amber primary, JetBrains Mono, dark warm surfaces, phosphor glow, scanline textures).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 13, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking on a PhantomNode in the rendered macro view does NOT dispatch any select action and does not change global selection state.", - "body": "Clicking on a PhantomNode in the rendered macro view does NOT dispatch any select action and does not change global selection state. The PhantomNode's DOM element exposes no role='button' or interactive cursor style. Verify with an RTL test: render fixture with phantom, click it, assert store.select spy was not called and computed style cursor != 'pointer'.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 14, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: bail reconciliation outcome visual treatment intentionally matches the failed run treatment for consistency.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: bail reconciliation outcome visual treatment intentionally matches the failed run treatment for consistency.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 15, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A DerivationRunNode with status='running' has: (a) a CSS animation property whose name is or includes 'phosphor-arrive' on the node body; (…", - "body": "A DerivationRunNode with status='running' has: (a) a CSS animation property whose name is or includes 'phosphor-arrive' on the node body; (b) a header chip with textContent 'RUNNING' and computed color resolving to --color-phosphor-cyan; (c) a descendant element with a CSS animation that visibly translates across the node interior (scanline sweep). The node remains clickable: click dispatches a select action. Verify with an RTL test asserting style.animationName, chip text and color, and click dispatch.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR45]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 16, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Static-analysis scan of src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx} finds no imports from @mui/*, @chakra-ui/*, antd, react-bootstrap, or other gene…", - "body": "Static-analysis scan of src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx} finds no imports from @mui/*, @chakra-ui/*, antd, react-bootstrap, or other generic UI component libraries. CSS scan finds no border-radius value greater than 4px on any macro view selector (allowing only sharp/squared corners). No element uses a Tailwind class indicating blue primary buttons (e.g., bg-blue-*) for primary actions. Verify with combined import-graph and CSS-grep tests.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 17, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "All colors, fonts, surfaces, glow, and scanline treatments used by macro view components shall be drawn from existing tokens defined in src…", - "body": "All colors, fonts, surfaces, glow, and scanline treatments used by macro view components shall be drawn from existing tokens defined in src/styles/theme.css (oklch phosphor palette, --font-mono, --color-surface-0..3, --color-phosphor-*, --color-phase-*, --color-text-*). Macro view code shall not introduce hard-coded hex/rgb/hsl colors or new top-level palette tokens.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 18, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "No single visual channel on a macro node shall encode more than one semantic attribute.", - "body": "No single visual channel on a macro node shall encode more than one semantic attribute. Specifically: phase color shall encode only phase identity; border color shall encode only run/reconciliation outcome (red=failed/bail, amber=retry/nudging-related, cyan=recurse/running, phase color=accepted); border style shall encode only frame mode; fill/dim level shall encode only failure-or-bail status; opacity shall encode only perspective selectedness; shape (diamond) shall encode only impasse identity. New attributes shall not be added to existing channels without re-justifying all collisions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R64]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 19, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The design language explicitly prohibits generic UI patterns such as Material Design, Tailwind defaults, SaaS dashboard aesthetics, rounded…", - "body": "The design language explicitly prohibits generic UI patterns such as Material Design, Tailwind defaults, SaaS dashboard aesthetics, rounded corners, or blue primary buttons.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [C6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 20, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Color additions to the palette must be semantically justified, not decorative — every color must earn its place by carrying meaning a user…", - "body": "Color additions to the palette must be semantically justified, not decorative — every color must earn its place by carrying meaning a user needs to distinguish at a glance.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external [C7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 21, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The HubNode type has hubType of justification | decision | impasse | perspectiv…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T7]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The HubNode type has hubType of justification | decision | impasse | perspective, and carries impasseStatus (open | resolved | superseded) and perspectiveStatus (open | selected | rejected)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 22, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "This brief is scoped exclusively to the macro view component and its rendering of the derivation story; other parts of the UI are explicitl…", - "body": "This brief is scoped exclusively to the macro view component and its rendering of the derivation story; other parts of the UI are explicitly out of scope.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 23, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The onion-peel structure refers to the iterative cycle of impasse discovery, re…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [T13]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The onion-peel structure refers to the iterative cycle of impasse discovery, rederivation, fan-out/fan-in synthesis, reconciliation, and resolution that builds the derivation history." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 24, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a ReconciliationRecord with outcome='bail' is the mechanism by which a branch becomes a dead-end impasse.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a ReconciliationRecord with outcome='bail' is the mechanism by which a branch becomes a dead-end impasse.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 25, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The macro view is strictly read-only; users can pan, zoom, and collapse/expand nodes, but cannot trigger any data mutations.", - "body": "The macro view is strictly read-only; users can pan, zoom, and collapse/expand nodes, but cannot trigger any data mutations.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 26, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The layout shall size each depth lane's width as a function of the maximum content width across nodes at that depth, rather than using a si…", - "body": "The layout shall size each depth lane's width as a function of the maximum content width across nodes at that depth, rather than using a single fixed lane-width constant for all depths.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 27, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each PhantomNode shall render as a dashed-outline ghost tile with no fill, bearing a label identifying it as a phantom (e.g., 'PHANTOM — no…", - "body": "Each PhantomNode shall render as a dashed-outline ghost tile with no fill, bearing a label identifying it as a phantom (e.g., 'PHANTOM — no perspective taken').", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R50]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 28, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The ReconciliationRecord type captures reconciliation outcomes (accepted | retr…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T6]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The ReconciliationRecord type captures reconciliation outcomes (accepted | retry | recurse | bail) along with candidateNodeIds, baselineNodeIds, activatedNodeIds, archivedNodeIds, triggerImpasseIds, resolvedImpasseIds, unresolvedImpasseIds, and a materialProgress flag." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 29, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'failed' shall render with a border in --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior.", - "body": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'failed' shall render with a border in --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R43]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 30, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The bail reconciliation outcome and a failed run share the same red-border/dimmed-interior treatment by design, which could make the two vi…", - "body": "The bail reconciliation outcome and a failed run share the same red-border/dimmed-interior treatment by design, which could make the two visually indistinguishable at a glance.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 31, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each PhaseGroupNode shall render with: a 1px border in its phase color (drawn from --color-phase-*), a warm dark fill from --color-surface-…", - "body": "Each PhaseGroupNode shall render with: a 1px border in its phase color (drawn from --color-phase-*), a warm dark fill from --color-surface-1, a scanline overlay, and a header line displaying the phase name, frame displayId, and frame mode in --color-text-secondary.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 32, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Importing MacroView from src/components/MacroView (the original path used by routes/explore.tsx) resolves to a working React component that…", - "body": "Importing MacroView from src/components/MacroView (the original path used by routes/explore.tsx) resolves to a working React component that renders without throwing. Verify with a Vitest + React Testing Library render test that imports from the legacy path and asserts the component mounts.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 33, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Users must manually refresh to see new derivation steps in the macro view.", - "body": "Users must manually refresh to see new derivation steps in the macro view.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 34, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "package.json declares @xyflow/react at major version 12 (e.g., ^12.x), and the rendered MacroView DOM contains the React Flow root element…", - "body": "package.json declares @xyflow/react at major version 12 (e.g., ^12.x), and the rendered MacroView DOM contains the React Flow root element wrapped by a ReactFlowProvider. Verify by (a) inspecting package.json with a unit test, and (b) a render test asserting that useReactFlow() called inside a child node throws no provider-missing error.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 35, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "An ImpasseNode whose hub.id appears in some FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds where that frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome === 'bai…", - "body": "An ImpasseNode whose hub.id appears in some FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds where that frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome === 'bail' renders with a chip element whose textContent matches /DEAD[\\s-]?END/i. An ImpasseNode whose triggered frame did not bail (or that has no triggered frame) does NOT render this chip. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR50]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 36, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A PhaseGroupNode for FrameRecord.mode='initial' has computed border-style 'solid'; mode='rederive' has 'double'; mode='grounding_enrichment…", - "body": "A PhaseGroupNode for FrameRecord.mode='initial' has computed border-style 'solid'; mode='rederive' has 'double'; mode='grounding_enrichment' has 'dashed'. The header additionally contains a text chip whose textContent equals the mode value (case-insensitive). Verify with parameterized RTL tests across all three modes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 37, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "MacroView renders a button with accessible name matching /reload/i.", - "body": "MacroView renders a button with accessible name matching /reload/i. Clicking it re-invokes the artifact loader and produces a fresh React Flow node array (new array identity) reflecting any updated underlying data. Verify with React Testing Library: query button by role/name, click, assert loader spy called twice and that the rendered output reflects mutated mock data after the second load.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 38, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: lane widths in the macro layout scale proportionally to the number of nodes at that depth rather than being fixed.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: lane widths in the macro layout scale proportionally to the number of nodes at that depth rather than being fixed.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 39, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The existing micro view is built with Sigma.js, handles 700+ nodes, and answers 'what does the graph look like now?'.", - "body": "The existing micro view is built with Sigma.js, handles 700+ nodes, and answers 'what does the graph look like now?'.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 40, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "src/styles/theme.css already defines the phosphor palette as oklch tokens including --color-phase-grounding (green), --color-phase-shaping…", - "body": "src/styles/theme.css already defines the phosphor palette as oklch tokens including --color-phase-grounding (green), --color-phase-shaping (amber), --color-phase-pinning (cyan), --color-phase-defining-done (purple), plus --color-phosphor-red, surface-0..3 warm darks, and --font-mono JetBrains Mono.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 41, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: clicking a node opens a detail panel on the right side of the screen.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: clicking a node opens a detail panel on the right side of the screen.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 42, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view shall render its graph using React Flow (@xyflow/react) at major version 12, mounted inside a ReactFlowProvider.", - "body": "The macro view shall render its graph using React Flow (@xyflow/react) at major version 12, mounted inside a ReactFlowProvider.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 43, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When provided a representative artifact fixture (drawn from the project's actual derivation history with N frames, where 5 ≤ N ≤ 15), the m…", - "body": "When provided a representative artifact fixture (drawn from the project's actual derivation history with N frames, where 5 ≤ N ≤ 15), the macro view renders a top-level semantic node count (PhaseGroupNodes + ImpasseNodes) in the range [20, 40]. The rendered edge count remains within an order of magnitude of the node count. Verify with a fixture-based test asserting count bounds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR57]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 44, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A rendered PhaseGroupNode has: (a) computed border-width 1px and border-color resolving to its --color-phase-* token; (b) computed backgrou…", - "body": "A rendered PhaseGroupNode has: (a) computed border-width 1px and border-color resolving to its --color-phase-* token; (b) computed background-color resolving to --color-surface-1; (c) a child element bearing a class or attribute identifying it as a scanline overlay; and (d) a header element containing the phase name, the frame's displayId, and the frame.mode text in --color-text-secondary. Verify with parameterized RTL tests for each phase, asserting computed styles and text content.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 45, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a phase group ends without any selected PerspectiveNode, the IR builder shall synthesize a PhantomNode under that phase group; the Pha…", - "body": "When a phase group ends without any selected PerspectiveNode, the IR builder shall synthesize a PhantomNode under that phase group; the PhantomNode shall not correspond to any record in ArtifactFile and shall be labelled to indicate 'no perspective taken'.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 46, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: React Flow group/parent nodes are used for phase containers in the macro view.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: React Flow group/parent nodes are used for phase containers in the macro view.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 47, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "PhantomNode instances shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall not present any other interactive affordance.", - "body": "PhantomNode instances shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall not present any other interactive affordance.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 48, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The macro view is built inside a Vite + React + Tailwind SPA.", - "body": "The macro view is built inside a Vite + React + Tailwind SPA.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 49, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A DerivationRunNode for a record with runIndex=3, inputNodeIds.length=5, outputCandidateIds.length=2, impassesFound.length=1 renders DOM co…", - "body": "A DerivationRunNode for a record with runIndex=3, inputNodeIds.length=5, outputCandidateIds.length=2, impassesFound.length=1 renders DOM containing: text matching /RUN\\s*#?\\s*3/, an input badge showing 5, an output badge showing 2, and an impasses-found indicator showing 1. Verify with a single RTL test on a fixture record.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR42]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 50, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its descendant DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode instances are…", - "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its descendant DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode instances are absent from the rendered React Flow nodes array (or have hidden:true). Edges whose both endpoints lie inside the collapsed group are absent (or hidden). Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting child-node-id absence and internal-edge absence.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 51, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each ImpasseNode shall render with a diamond/lozenge silhouette (distinct from the rectangular phase-group/run/fan-in/reconciliation shapes…", - "body": "Each ImpasseNode shall render with a diamond/lozenge silhouette (distinct from the rectangular phase-group/run/fan-in/reconciliation shapes), a red glyph treatment, and its hub displayId visible on the node face.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R48]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 52, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given a fixture containing both a DerivationRunNode with status='failed' AND an ImpasseNode whose linked reconciliation outcome='bail' (the…", - "body": "Given a fixture containing both a DerivationRunNode with status='failed' AND an ImpasseNode whose linked reconciliation outcome='bail' (the dead-end case): both nodes share red+dim treatment, but the ImpasseNode additionally renders a 'DEAD-END' chip while the failed RunNode does not, AND the ImpasseNode renders with the diamond shape while the RunNode is rectangular. Verify with an RTL test rendering both fixtures side by side and asserting these distinguishing features.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR68]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 53, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Within a single frame, PhaseGroupNodes shall be stacked vertically in the reverse of PHASE_ORDER (defining_done at top, then pinning, then…", - "body": "Within a single frame, PhaseGroupNodes shall be stacked vertically in the reverse of PHASE_ORDER (defining_done at top, then pinning, then shaping, then grounding at bottom).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 54, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "After collapsing one or more groups in MacroView, inspecting localStorage, sessionStorage, document.cookie, the URL/location (search/hash),…", - "body": "After collapsing one or more groups in MacroView, inspecting localStorage, sessionStorage, document.cookie, the URL/location (search/hash), and IndexedDB shows no key/entry containing collapsed FrameIds or any macro-view collapse state. After unmount + remount, all groups render expanded again. Verify with a JSDOM test that spies on storage APIs and asserts no setItem call with macro-related keys, and a remount test asserting state reset.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 55, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Impasse-spawn edges shall be rendered as red dashed lines with markerEnd arrows.", - "body": "Impasse-spawn edges shall be rendered as red dashed lines with markerEnd arrows. The source endpoint shall be the ReconciliationNode (or PhaseGroupNode) that produced the impasse, and the target shall be the ImpasseNode that opens the child lane (FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R53]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 56, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view shall render only three classes of edge between its nodes: (1) sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode within a…", - "body": "The macro view shall render only three classes of edge between its nodes: (1) sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode within a phase group), (2) impasse-spawn edges (from a ReconciliationNode/PhaseGroupNode outward to the ImpasseNode opening a child lane), and (3) resolution edges (from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode back to the impasse it resolved). It shall not synthesize edges from arbitrary EdgeRecord rows in ArtifactFile.graph.edges.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R51]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 57, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The visual treatment of a 'running' run status is underspecified — stakeholders consider it unlikely to appear but want it highlighted some…", - "body": "The visual treatment of a 'running' run status is underspecified — stakeholders consider it unlikely to appear but want it highlighted somehow, leaving the exact treatment open.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 58, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "After a collapse or expand toggle, sibling nodes' positions shall update so that no dead space remains where the collapsed group's children…", - "body": "After a collapse or expand toggle, sibling nodes' positions shall update so that no dead space remains where the collapsed group's children used to be (sibling reflow). External edges connecting to the collapsed group shall reattach to the pill's bounds without leaving dangling endpoints.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 59, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'running' shall render with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe animation looping at slow tempo…", - "body": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'running' shall render with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe animation looping at slow tempo on the node body, (b) a 'RUNNING' chip in --color-phosphor-cyan in the header, and (c) an animated scanline sweep across the node interior. The node shall remain clickable and shall display the same content fields as a completed run.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R44]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 60, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the materialProgress flag is visualized as a subtle chip or checkmark inside the reconciliation node, alongside the…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the materialProgress flag is visualized as a subtle chip or checkmark inside the reconciliation node, alongside the outcome indicator.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 61, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Every page load of the macro view starts fully expanded, with no memory of previously collapsed nodes.", - "body": "Every page load of the macro view starts fully expanded, with no memory of previously collapsed nodes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 62, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The FrameRecord.nudgingActive flag indicates whether a minimal negative constra…", - "body": null, - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "technical-inferred [T9]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The FrameRecord.nudgingActive flag indicates whether a minimal negative constraint nudge is active for that frame, relevant to representing non-termination handling." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 63, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The FrameRecord type includes: id, parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase,…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T3]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The FrameRecord type includes: id, parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase, triggerImpasseIds, mode (initial | rederive | grounding_enrichment), attemptNumber, nudgingActive, createdAt, and summary." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 64, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The ArtifactFile type bundles all spec data into a single file: manifest, sourc…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T8]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The ArtifactFile type bundles all spec data into a single file: manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, and a graph object containing nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, reconciliationRecords, and snapshots." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 65, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, the macro view shall render it as a compact pill displaying: a phase color dot, the frame's…", - "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, the macro view shall render it as a compact pill displaying: a phase color dot, the frame's displayId, the run count (e.g., 'n RUNS'), and an outcome glyph derived from the frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome (✓ accepted, ↺ retry, ↪ recurse, ✗ bail). The pill shall remain clickable to expand it and to open the detail panel.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 66, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A directory listing of src/components/macro/ contains at minimum: index.ts, MacroView.tsx, story-ir.ts, layout.ts, and a nodes/ subdirector…", - "body": "A directory listing of src/components/macro/ contains at minimum: index.ts, MacroView.tsx, story-ir.ts, layout.ts, and a nodes/ subdirectory containing PhaseGroupNode.tsx, DerivationRunNode.tsx, FanInNode.tsx, ReconciliationNode.tsx, ImpasseNode.tsx, PerspectiveNode.tsx, and PhantomNode.tsx. Verify by automated filesystem assertion in a unit test (e.g., fs.readdirSync) listing each expected path.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 67, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The DerivationRunRecord type includes: id, frameId, phase, runIndex, inputNodeI…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T4]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The DerivationRunRecord type includes: id, frameId, phase, runIndex, inputNodeIds, outputCandidateIds, impassesFound, status (running | completed | failed), and createdAt." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 68, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode for that frame shall display a textual chip (e.g., 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE') sty…", - "body": "When a FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode for that frame shall display a textual chip (e.g., 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE') styled in --color-phosphor-amber inside the node header. The nudging indicator shall be inside the node body, not an external overlay.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 69, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Faded (rejected/unselected) PerspectiveNode branches shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall present no interactive affo…", - "body": "Faded (rejected/unselected) PerspectiveNode branches shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall present no interactive affordances.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 70, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each FanInNode shall render its FanIn groupings as a stack of rows, one row per grouping, where each row is prefixed by a 4px-wide left bor…", - "body": "Each FanInNode shall render its FanIn groupings as a stack of rows, one row per grouping, where each row is prefixed by a 4px-wide left border colored: green (success/merged token) when grouping.resolution='merged', amber (--color-phosphor-amber) when grouping.resolution='best_selected', and red (--color-phosphor-red) when grouping.resolution='impasse_surfaced'. Each row shall display the grouping's groupKey and a node count.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R45]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 71, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'completed' shall render with the base node treatment (no special border or dimming).", - "body": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'completed' shall render with the base node treatment (no special border or dimming).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R42]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 72, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A dead-end impasse is one whose reconciliation chose the 'bail' outcome — the s…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T11]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A dead-end impasse is one whose reconciliation chose the 'bail' outcome — the system gave up on that branch entirely." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 73, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The Story IR and layout modules shall consume the branded ID types defined in src/types/artifact.ts (NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, RunId, FanInI…", - "body": "The Story IR and layout modules shall consume the branded ID types defined in src/types/artifact.ts (NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, etc.) for keying records and shall not coerce these to plain strings at module boundaries.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R58]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 74, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The layout shall assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by its derivationDepth, with depth 0 acting as the trunk and each increment…", - "body": "The layout shall assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by its derivationDepth, with depth 0 acting as the trunk and each increment opening a lane to the right (or otherwise increasing horizontal breadth) so that onion-peel depth is encoded in horizontal position.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 75, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The story-ir / layout shall emit one PhaseGroupNode per (FrameRecord, Phase) pair that has any associated runs, fan-in, reconciliation, or…", - "body": "The story-ir / layout shall emit one PhaseGroupNode per (FrameRecord, Phase) pair that has any associated runs, fan-in, reconciliation, or perspective records.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 76, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "All textual content rendered inside macro view nodes, edges, banner, and pills shall use the var(--font-mono) (JetBrains Mono) font stack d…", - "body": "All textual content rendered inside macro view nodes, edges, banner, and pills shall use the var(--font-mono) (JetBrains Mono) font stack defined in theme.css.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 77, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a failed run is shown with a red color and a dimmed interior.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a failed run is shown with a red color and a dimmed interior.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 78, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For every edge in the layout output (in the default, non-running state), edge.animated is falsy (undefined or false).", - "body": "For every edge in the layout output (in the default, non-running state), edge.animated is falsy (undefined or false). Verify by a unit-test assertion across all edges in a representative fixture.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR56]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 79, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the visual design must feel like CRT/terminal aesthetic while preserving modern design principles; information dens…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the visual design must feel like CRT/terminal aesthetic while preserving modern design principles; information density is high but not overwhelming.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 80, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The MacroView shall provide a manual 'RELOAD' button that, when clicked, re-runs the entire data load → IR → layout → render pipeline.", - "body": "The MacroView shall provide a manual 'RELOAD' button that, when clicked, re-runs the entire data load → IR → layout → render pipeline.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 81, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='selected' renders with computed CSS opacity == 1.0 (or no opacity rule reducing it).", - "body": "A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='selected' renders with computed CSS opacity == 1.0 (or no opacity rule reducing it). A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='rejected' or 'open' (non-taken) renders with computed CSS opacity in the range [0.25, 0.35] (target ~0.3). Verify with RTL + getComputedStyle assertions on parameterized fixtures.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 82, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The nodeTypes object passed to contains exactly the seven keys: PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNod…", - "body": "The nodeTypes object passed to contains exactly the seven keys: PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, PhantomNode (or 'phaseGroup','run','fanIn','reconciliation','impasse','perspective','phantom' equivalents) and no key matching /trunk/i. Verify with a unit test that imports the nodeTypes registry and asserts Object.keys length === 7 and contains the expected set.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 83, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the corresponding ReconciliationNode shall render a small ✓ chip beside the outcome c…", - "body": "When a ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the corresponding ReconciliationNode shall render a small ✓ chip beside the outcome chip in its header.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R47]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 84, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The existing src/components/MacroView.tsx import path shall continue to resolve to a working MacroView component (e.g., as a thin re-export…", - "body": "The existing src/components/MacroView.tsx import path shall continue to resolve to a working MacroView component (e.g., as a thin re-export of the new src/components/macro/ module) so that routes/explore.tsx and other existing importers do not require changes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 85, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "package.json dependencies and devDependencies contain no entry for 'dagre', '@dagrejs/dagre', 'elkjs', 'cytoscape', 'klay', or other genera…", - "body": "package.json dependencies and devDependencies contain no entry for 'dagre', '@dagrejs/dagre', 'elkjs', 'cytoscape', 'klay', or other general-purpose graph layout libraries. layout.ts contains no imports from such packages. Verify by a static test asserting the dependency lists and import set.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 86, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Macro view components shall not use generic Material Design components, default Tailwind component patterns, generic SaaS dashboard chrome,…", - "body": "Macro view components shall not use generic Material Design components, default Tailwind component patterns, generic SaaS dashboard chrome, generic rounded-corner card aesthetics, or blue primary buttons. Visual treatments shall instead be expressed through the CRT/phosphor visual grammar (warm dark surfaces, phosphor glow, scanline texture, sharp/squared edges, monospace typography).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 87, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode header contains a chip element whose textContent matches /NUDG(E|ING)/ and whose…", - "body": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode header contains a chip element whose textContent matches /NUDG(E|ING)/ and whose computed color resolves to --color-phosphor-amber. The chip is a descendant of the node body (i.e., bounded inside the node's rect), not an external overlay. When nudgingActive is false, no such chip is present. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 88, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Phase color references in macro view code shall use the theme.css phase tokens (--color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-pha…", - "body": "Phase color references in macro view code shall use the theme.css phase tokens (--color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-phase-pinning, --color-phase-defining-done) as the authoritative phase color mapping. Where the upstream X34 specification differs from theme.css, theme.css governs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R37]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 89, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Phase color values must be expressed as oklch values within the phosphor palette.", - "body": "Phase color values must be expressed as oklch values within the phosphor palette.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 90, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "A MacroView.tsx component already exists at src/components/MacroView.tsx with a header docblock describing the intended architecture: Story…", - "body": "A MacroView.tsx component already exists at src/components/MacroView.tsx with a header docblock describing the intended architecture: Story IR → Layout → Render with React Flow custom node types; the file is otherwise a stub.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 91, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the layout output, every node with a defined parentId has node.position expressed relative to the parent's origin (i.e., the absolute sc…", - "body": "In the layout output, every node with a defined parentId has node.position expressed relative to the parent's origin (i.e., the absolute screen position is parent.position + child.position), and the child's position is contained within the parent's bounding box (0 ≤ child.x ≤ parent.width - child.width; same for y). Group nodes (parentId undefined) carry absolute positions. Verify with a unit test on layout output for a fixture containing parented children.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR62]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 92, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "In the layout output for any non-collapsed PhaseGroupNode P, every child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode in…", - "body": "In the layout output for any non-collapsed PhaseGroupNode P, every child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode in P has node.parentId === P.id and node.extent === 'parent', and P has type === 'group' (or the React Flow group equivalent). Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting these properties for a fixture frame containing all four child kinds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 93, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Within any horizontal lane, more recent frames (higher attemptNumber / later createdAt) shall be positioned higher (smaller y in screen coo…", - "body": "Within any horizontal lane, more recent frames (higher attemptNumber / later createdAt) shall be positioned higher (smaller y in screen coordinates / 'higher' visually) than earlier frames, so that vertical position encodes time with t+1 above t.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 94, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The macro view is one specific view within the broader Spec Explorer UI.", - "body": "The macro view is one specific view within the broader Spec Explorer UI.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 95, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Manual UX review (codified as a stakeholder sign-off checklist) asserts: (a) every node communicates outcome-at-a-glance from at least 1m v…", - "body": "Manual UX review (codified as a stakeholder sign-off checklist) asserts: (a) every node communicates outcome-at-a-glance from at least 1m viewing distance on a 14\" laptop screen at default zoom; (b) no rendered phase group exceeds ~280px width or ~360px height at default zoom for typical content; (c) text contrast against warm-dark surface meets WCAG AA (4.5:1) for primary text. Verify with a manual review checklist run during PR review plus an automated contrast test using getComputedStyle and a contrast-ratio library.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR69]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 96, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation outcome affects the whole node's visual weight: accepted=normal, retry=amber border, recurse=blue bo…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation outcome affects the whole node's visual weight: accepted=normal, retry=amber border, recurse=blue border, bail=red border + dimmed interior.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 97, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Layout output for child nodes inside a PhaseGroupNode shall use positions relative to the parent group's origin (consistent with React Flow…", - "body": "Layout output for child nodes inside a PhaseGroupNode shall use positions relative to the parent group's origin (consistent with React Flow's parentId conventions), while group nodes themselves carry absolute positions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R62]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 98, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For a fixture with frames F0 (no parent) → F1 (parent F0) → F2 (parent F1), the layout assigns depth(F0)=0, depth(F1)=1, depth(F2)=2; and t…", - "body": "For a fixture with frames F0 (no parent) → F1 (parent F0) → F2 (parent F1), the layout assigns depth(F0)=0, depth(F1)=1, depth(F2)=2; and the x-coordinate of F2's PhaseGroupNode is greater than F1's, which is greater than F0's. Verify with a unit test on layout() output.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 99, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Because the macro view is snapshot-only and only updates on manual refresh, users may view a stale derivation history without realizing it.", - "body": "Because the macro view is snapshot-only and only updates on manual refresh, users may view a stale derivation history without realizing it.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 100, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The MacroView shall implement a three-stage pipeline as separate, individually-testable pure functions: (1) story-ir builder consuming Arti…", - "body": "The MacroView shall implement a three-stage pipeline as separate, individually-testable pure functions: (1) story-ir builder consuming ArtifactFile.graph and producing a normalized derivation tree IR, (2) a layout function consuming the IR plus a collapsed set and producing absolute positions, lane widths and parent/child grouping, and (3) a renderer that maps IR nodes to typed React Flow nodes and edges. Stages 1 and 2 shall have no React or React Flow imports.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 101, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each DerivationRunNode shall display: the run index ('RUN #n' from runIndex), an input-count badge (size of inputNodeIds), an output-count…", - "body": "Each DerivationRunNode shall display: the run index ('RUN #n' from runIndex), an input-count badge (size of inputNodeIds), an output-count badge (size of outputCandidateIds), and an impasses-found count (size of impassesFound).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 102, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view shall be implemented as React components in TypeScript that build cleanly within the existing Vite + React + Tailwind SPA to…", - "body": "The macro view shall be implemented as React components in TypeScript that build cleanly within the existing Vite + React + Tailwind SPA toolchain, without introducing alternative bundlers, runtimes, or replacing Tailwind with a competing CSS framework.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R60]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 103, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The ReconciliationRecord.outcome field can be one of: accepted, retry, recurse, or bail.", - "body": "The ReconciliationRecord.outcome field can be one of: accepted, retry, recurse, or bail.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 104, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: phase color assignments are grounding=blue (foundational), shaping=green (growth/emergence), pinning=amber (fixity/…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: phase color assignments are grounding=blue (foundational), shaping=green (growth/emergence), pinning=amber (fixity/commitment), defining_done=violet (completion/closure).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X34]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 105, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: a 'running' status is unlikely to appear but should be highlighted somehow if it does.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: a 'running' status is unlikely to appear but should be highlighted somehow if it does.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 106, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Clicking the collapse/expand affordance on a PhaseGroupNode (or its collapsed pill) shall toggle that group's membership in the collapsed s…", - "body": "Clicking the collapse/expand affordance on a PhaseGroupNode (or its collapsed pill) shall toggle that group's membership in the collapsed set, triggering a synchronous re-run of the layout function over the existing IR + new collapsed set.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 107, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: derivation phases (such as reconciliation) are encoded as nodes within the graph rather than as separate UI constru…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: derivation phases (such as reconciliation) are encoded as nodes within the graph rather than as separate UI constructs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 108, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "An edge whose source or target is a child of a now-collapsed phase group renders in the layout output with its endpoint id rewritten to (or…", - "body": "An edge whose source or target is a child of a now-collapsed phase group renders in the layout output with its endpoint id rewritten to (or remapped to terminate at) the collapsed pill node id, not the original child id. No edge in the output references a child id that is currently hidden by a collapsed group. Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting endpoint-id sets are subsets of the visible node-id set.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 109, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The macro view is structurally different from the micro view: it shows ~20-40 rich nodes representing the derivation process rather than gr…", - "body": "The macro view is structurally different from the micro view: it shows ~20-40 rich nodes representing the derivation process rather than graph content.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 110, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Every text-bearing DOM element rendered by macro view components has computed font-family containing 'JetBrains Mono' or resolving to var(-…", - "body": "Every text-bearing DOM element rendered by macro view components has computed font-family containing 'JetBrains Mono' or resolving to var(--font-mono). Verify with an RTL test that walks the rendered tree and asserts getComputedStyle(el).fontFamily for each text element matches the expected stack.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR36]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 111, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view shall register exactly seven custom React Flow nodeTypes — PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode,…", - "body": "The macro view shall register exactly seven custom React Flow nodeTypes — PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, and PhantomNode — and shall not register a separate TrunkNode type.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 112, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The macro view module imports DetailPanel from src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (or via the shared component path) and does not define a new…", - "body": "The macro view module imports DetailPanel from src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (or via the shared component path) and does not define a new component named MacroDetailPanel or equivalent. DetailPanel renders the selected macro record kind. Verify with (a) a static import-graph check and (b) an integration test that selects each macro record kind and asserts DetailPanel renders kind-appropriate content.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR31]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 113, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view source code shall be organized under src/components/macro/ with at minimum: index.ts re-exporting MacroView, MacroView.tsx (…", - "body": "The macro view source code shall be organized under src/components/macro/ with at minimum: index.ts re-exporting MacroView, MacroView.tsx (top-level component), story-ir.ts (pure ArtifactFile→StoryIR builder), layout.ts (pure StoryIR+collapsedSet→RF nodes/edges), and a nodes/ subdirectory containing one .tsx file per custom node type (PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, PhantomNode).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 114, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Reconciliation compares candidate nodes from re-derivation against the previous iteration's nodes for that phase and classifies each relati…", - "body": "Reconciliation compares candidate nodes from re-derivation against the previous iteration's nodes for that phase and classifies each relationship using lineage edge types.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 115, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "After collapsing one or more groups and triggering RELOAD (or unmount/remount), the rendered macro view returns to the fully-expanded state…", - "body": "After collapsing one or more groups and triggering RELOAD (or unmount/remount), the rendered macro view returns to the fully-expanded state with no PhaseGroupNode rendered as a pill. Verify with an RTL test that collapses, reloads, and asserts no collapsed-pill DOM elements exist.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR67]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 116, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: derivation depth in the macro layout is computed from the parentFrameId chain length.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: derivation depth in the macro layout is computed from the parentFrameId chain length.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 117, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Inspecting MacroView's rendered DOM and the props of its React Flow custom nodes reveals no UI affordance bound to a mutating action: no ad…", - "body": "Inspecting MacroView's rendered DOM and the props of its React Flow custom nodes reveals no UI affordance bound to a mutating action: no add/edit/delete buttons, no form inputs, no draggable-to-create-edge handles enabled (nodesDraggable may be true for layout, but onConnect/onEdgesChange handlers must not commit changes back to the artifact). Verify by an integration test that simulates clicks on every interactive element and asserts that no mock 'mutate' API on the store is ever called.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 118, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The macro view must use a manual layout algorithm rather than dagre, because the spatial grammar requires precise control over depth lanes…", - "body": "The macro view must use a manual layout algorithm rather than dagre, because the spatial grammar requires precise control over depth lanes and vertical flow.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 119, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: impasse nodes connect sub-trees and increase the breadth of the layout to represent the opening of a new derivation…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: impasse nodes connect sub-trees and increase the breadth of the layout to represent the opening of a new derivation branch.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 120, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode descendants and th…", - "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode descendants and the edges entirely internal to that group shall not be rendered (or shall be hidden from the React Flow output).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R28]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 121, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The MacroView shall expose no controls that mutate artifact data.", - "body": "The MacroView shall expose no controls that mutate artifact data. Only pan, zoom, node click (selection), and collapse/expand interactions shall be wired.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 122, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The artifact.ts file defines branded ID types for NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, SpecId, SourceId, ClaimId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, Sna…", - "body": "The artifact.ts file defines branded ID types for NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, SpecId, SourceId, ClaimId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, SnapshotId, InterventionId, and DisplayId.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 123, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Git diff between the feature branch and main shows zero modifications to src/components/MicroView*, src/graph/, src/router.ts, src/routes/,…", - "body": "Git diff between the feature branch and main shows zero modifications to src/components/MicroView*, src/graph/, src/router.ts, src/routes/, or any unrelated component, with the only allowed touched files being: src/components/macro/**, src/components/MacroView.tsx (re-export only), and minimal additions to src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (new branches for macro record kinds; no removal of existing branches). Verify with a git-diff CI check.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR59]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 124, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: users can fold (collapse) any nested derivation run to hide detail.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: users can fold (collapse) any nested derivation run to hide detail.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 125, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "After mount, mutating the underlying artifact mock and waiting any reasonable interval (e.g., 1s) does NOT change the rendered macro view (…", - "body": "After mount, mutating the underlying artifact mock and waiting any reasonable interval (e.g., 1s) does NOT change the rendered macro view (no live update). Clicking the RELOAD button (or remounting) updates the rendered view to reflect the mutation. Verify with an integration test combining a mock artifact source, mutation between assertions, and pre/post-reload DOM snapshots.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR66]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 126, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A FanInNode with groupings [{groupKey:'a', resolution:'merged', nodeCount:3},{groupKey:'b', resolution:'best_selected', nodeCount:1},{group…", - "body": "A FanInNode with groupings [{groupKey:'a', resolution:'merged', nodeCount:3},{groupKey:'b', resolution:'best_selected', nodeCount:1},{groupKey:'c', resolution:'impasse_surfaced', nodeCount:2}] renders three row elements in order, each with a 4px-wide left-border whose color is (in order): the green/merged token, --color-phosphor-amber, --color-phosphor-red. Each row contains the groupKey text and the nodeCount text. Verify with a parameterized RTL test across all three resolution kinds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR46]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 127, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given a fixture artifact containing N FrameRecords each with M phases that have at least one associated run/fan-in/reconciliation/perspecti…", - "body": "Given a fixture artifact containing N FrameRecords each with M phases that have at least one associated run/fan-in/reconciliation/perspective record, the IR builder produces exactly N×M PhaseGroupNodes (no more, no fewer), and zero PhaseGroupNodes for (frame, phase) pairs with no associated records. Verify with a unit test on buildStoryIR using a hand-crafted fixture covering empty and non-empty phase pairs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 128, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view canvas shall support pan and zoom interactions provided by React Flow.", - "body": "The macro view canvas shall support pan and zoom interactions provided by React Flow.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 129, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "PhaseGroupNode shall encode the FrameRecord.mode in border style: mode='initial' uses a solid border, mode='rederive' uses a double border,…", - "body": "PhaseGroupNode shall encode the FrameRecord.mode in border style: mode='initial' uses a solid border, mode='rederive' uses a double border, and mode='grounding_enrichment' uses a dashed border. A small text mode chip showing the mode name shall additionally appear in the header.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R39]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 130, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For an artifact fixture with arbitrary counts of DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, and ReconciliationRecord, the rendered React Flow node a…", - "body": "For an artifact fixture with arbitrary counts of DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, and ReconciliationRecord, the rendered React Flow node array contains exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord.id, one FanInNode per FanInRecord.id, and one ReconciliationNode per ReconciliationRecord.id (verified by id-set equality). Verify with a property-based test (fast-check) generating random combinations.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 131, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The MacroView shall display a fixed overlay banner in the top-left corner showing 'SNAPSHOT @ ' rendered in --color-text-tertiar…", - "body": "The MacroView shall display a fixed overlay banner in the top-left corner showing 'SNAPSHOT @ ' rendered in --color-text-tertiary, where reflects the time the artifact was loaded for the current snapshot. The banner shall not pan or zoom with the React Flow canvas.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R7]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 132, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in groupings render as color-coded rows inside the fan-in node — green for 'merged', amber for 'best_selected',…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in groupings render as color-coded rows inside the fan-in node — green for 'merged', amber for 'best_selected', red for 'impasse_surfaced' — distinguished by a colored left border or chip.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X32]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 133, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "MacroView renders a fixed-position element in the top-left containing the literal text prefix 'SNAPSHOT @ ' followed by the artifact's load…", - "body": "MacroView renders a fixed-position element in the top-left containing the literal text prefix 'SNAPSHOT @ ' followed by the artifact's load timestamp. The element has CSS color resolving to the value of --color-text-tertiary and CSS position:fixed (or absolute relative to the macro view container, outside the React Flow viewport transform). Verify by computed-style assertion in a JSDOM/RTL test, plus a visual test that pans/zooms the canvas and asserts the banner's bounding-rect coordinates are unchanged.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 134, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Each ReconciliationNode shall encode its outcome via full-node border treatment: outcome='accepted' uses the parent phase's color, outcome=…", - "body": "Each ReconciliationNode shall encode its outcome via full-node border treatment: outcome='accepted' uses the parent phase's color, outcome='retry' uses --color-phosphor-amber, outcome='recurse' uses --color-phosphor-cyan (blue), outcome='bail' uses --color-phosphor-red plus a dimmed interior. The outcome shall additionally appear as a textual chip in the node header.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R46]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 135, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Every reference to a phase color in macro view source uses one of the literal tokens --color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --colo…", - "body": "Every reference to a phase color in macro view source uses one of the literal tokens --color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-phase-pinning, or --color-phase-defining-done. No macro view file redefines these tokens. Where conflict exists between X34 and theme.css, theme.css's mapping is used. Verify with a grep test plus a render test asserting that a PhaseGroupNode for phase 'shaping' has border-color resolving to theme.css's --color-phase-shaping value (currently amber per X41).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR38]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 136, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Because the macro view renders inside a React Flow canvas (not directly in the DOM), large node counts are not a DOM performance concern.", - "body": "Because the macro view renders inside a React Flow canvas (not directly in the DOM), large node counts are not a DOM performance concern.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X9]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 137, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode) shall be rendered as thin amber lines with markerEnd arrows and no animation by defau…", - "body": "Sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode) shall be rendered as thin amber lines with markerEnd arrows and no animation by default.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R52]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 138, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "Each node's form and function must visually communicate what happened at that specific point in the derivation tree.", - "body": "Each node's form and function must visually communicate what happened at that specific point in the derivation tree.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 139, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A static review (codified as a test fixture matrix) asserts the channel-to-attribute mapping: phase color used only for phase identity (not…", - "body": "A static review (codified as a test fixture matrix) asserts the channel-to-attribute mapping: phase color used only for phase identity (not for outcome or mode); border-color encoding only run/reconciliation outcome semantics (red, amber, cyan, phase color per outcome); border-style (solid/double/dashed) encoding only frame mode; opacity reduction (~30%) used only for unselected perspective branches; diamond/lozenge shape used only by ImpasseNode. Verify by enumerating all node-type × visual-channel pairs in tests and asserting no two attributes share a channel within a node.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR64]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 140, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: layout grammar encodes timeline through verticality (t+1 / more recent appears higher) and breadth encodes onion-pe…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: layout grammar encodes timeline through verticality (t+1 / more recent appears higher) and breadth encodes onion-peel derivation depth.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 141, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "For each FrameRecord, the layout shall compute derivationDepth as the length of the parentFrameId chain (the root frame, with no parentFram…", - "body": "For each FrameRecord, the layout shall compute derivationDepth as the length of the parentFrameId chain (the root frame, with no parentFrameId, has depth 0).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 142, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The FrameRecord.mode field has three values: initial, rederive, and grounding_enrichment.", - "body": "The FrameRecord.mode field has three values: initial, rederive, and grounding_enrichment.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [E4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 143, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts modules contain no import statements referencing 'react', 'react-dom', '@xyflow/react', or any DOM/browser API.", - "body": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts modules contain no import statements referencing 'react', 'react-dom', '@xyflow/react', or any DOM/browser API. Verify by a static-analysis test that parses the files and asserts the import set is disjoint from a forbidden list. Additionally call each function twice with the same deeply-cloned input and assert the outputs are deeply equal and that the inputs are unmodified (input integrity hash unchanged).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 144, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking the collapse affordance on an expanded PhaseGroupNode causes (a) that group's id to enter the collapsed set and (b) the layout fun…", - "body": "Clicking the collapse affordance on an expanded PhaseGroupNode causes (a) that group's id to enter the collapsed set and (b) the layout function to be invoked again with the new set, producing updated node positions. Subsequent click on the resulting pill removes the id from the set and restores expanded layout. Verify with a Vitest test using a spy on the layout function and a click simulation; assert layout invocation count and node-position diffs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 145, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The theme.css token assignment differs from grounding X34: theme.css maps shaping=amber and pinning=cyan, while X34 specifies shaping=green…", - "body": "The theme.css token assignment differs from grounding X34: theme.css maps shaping=amber and pinning=cyan, while X34 specifies shaping=green and pinning=amber. Reconciling this is a minor concern but theme.css is the source of truth for the existing design system.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X41]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 146, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The onion-peel derivation structure (impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, resolution) is specified in the spec-elicitation.md d…", - "body": "The onion-peel derivation structure (impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, resolution) is specified in the spec-elicitation.md document.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "external-observed [X5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 147, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: phantom nodes and faded nodes are informational only and carry no interactive actions.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: phantom nodes and faded nodes are informational only and carry no interactive actions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X24]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 148, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The FanInRecord type captures the fan-in step: id, frameId, phase, inputRunIds,…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T5]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The FanInRecord type captures the fan-in step: id, frameId, phase, inputRunIds, groupings (with resolution: merged | best_selected | impasse_surfaced), outputCandidateIds, droppedCandidateIds, and createdAt." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 149, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "On every mount of MacroView the collapsed-set shall be initialized as empty, so that all phase groups are rendered fully expanded immediate…", - "body": "On every mount of MacroView the collapsed-set shall be initialized as empty, so that all phase groups are rendered fully expanded immediately after page load.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 150, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A PhantomNode renders with computed border-style 'dashed', computed background-color of 'transparent' (or rgba alpha 0), and contains text…", - "body": "A PhantomNode renders with computed border-style 'dashed', computed background-color of 'transparent' (or rgba alpha 0), and contains text matching /PHANTOM/i and /no perspective taken/i. Verify with an RTL + computed-style test.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR51]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 151, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: render the derivation narrative as a pannable, zoomable graph.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: render the derivation narrative as a pannable, zoomable graph.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X10]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 152, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "TypeScript strict-mode compilation succeeds for story-ir.ts and layout.ts using the branded ID types from src/types/artifact.ts (FrameId, R…", - "body": "TypeScript strict-mode compilation succeeds for story-ir.ts and layout.ts using the branded ID types from src/types/artifact.ts (FrameId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, NodeId, etc.) without `as string` or `as any` coercions at module exports. Verify with `tsc --noEmit` in CI plus a grep test asserting no `as string` or `as unknown as string` patterns appear at module boundaries.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR58]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 153, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Resolution edges shall be rendered as solid lines colored by the resolving phase's color, with markerEnd arrows, drawn from a child frame's…", - "body": "Resolution edges shall be rendered as solid lines colored by the resolving phase's color, with markerEnd arrows, drawn from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode back toward the ImpasseNode listed in that record's resolvedImpasseIds, using a return-leftward routing convention (toward lower-depth lanes).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R54]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 154, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the rendered ReconciliationNode header contains a chip element whose textContent contai…", - "body": "When ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the rendered ReconciliationNode header contains a chip element whose textContent contains the ✓ character (or is identifiable as a checkmark indicator) located beside the outcome chip. When materialProgress is false, no such chip is present. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR48]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 155, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Across realistic spec snapshots the macro view shall render approximately 20–40 top-level semantic nodes (phase groups + impasses) for a ty…", - "body": "Across realistic spec snapshots the macro view shall render approximately 20–40 top-level semantic nodes (phase groups + impasses) for a typical derivation history; the design shall not produce hundreds of nodes from EdgeRecord-style content edges.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R57]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 156, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Within a single lane, given two frames F_old (createdAt=t1, attemptNumber=1) and F_new (createdAt=t2>t1, attemptNumber=2) at the same depth…", - "body": "Within a single lane, given two frames F_old (createdAt=t1, attemptNumber=1) and F_new (createdAt=t2>t1, attemptNumber=2) at the same depth, F_new's PhaseGroupNode position.y is strictly less than F_old's (smaller y = visually higher). Verify with a unit-test fixture and assertion on layout output.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR18]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 157, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The CRT design language for the macro view mandates: var(--font-mono), oklch phase colors, warm-tinted dark surfaces, phosphor glow, and no…", - "body": "The CRT design language for the macro view mandates: var(--font-mono), oklch phase colors, warm-tinted dark surfaces, phosphor glow, and no generic UI patterns.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 158, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For each FrameRecord with non-empty triggerImpasseIds, layout emits an impasse-spawn edge from the parent frame's relevant ReconciliationNo…", - "body": "For each FrameRecord with non-empty triggerImpasseIds, layout emits an impasse-spawn edge from the parent frame's relevant ReconciliationNode (or PhaseGroupNode if reconciliation is unavailable) to each ImpasseNode listed in triggerImpasseIds. Each such edge has computed stroke color resolving to --color-phosphor-red, computed border/stroke style 'dashed', and a markerEnd arrow. Verify with a fixture and computed-style assertion.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR54]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 159, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Because collapsed state is ephemeral and never persisted, users lose any custom collapsed configuration on every page reload.", - "body": "Because collapsed state is ephemeral and never persisted, users lose any custom collapsed configuration on every page reload.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 160, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking a non-faded, non-phantom macro node (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse, or selected perspective) dispatches a 'select' a…", - "body": "Clicking a non-faded, non-phantom macro node (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse, or selected perspective) dispatches a 'select' action to the global selection store with a payload identifying the underlying IR record by id and kind. Verify with an RTL test using a mocked store: simulate click on each node-type variant in a fixture and assert the store.select spy was called with the correct {id, kind} pair.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR30]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 161, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested run is collapsed, sibling nodes shift to fill vacated space, triggering a layout reflow.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested run is collapsed, sibling nodes shift to fill vacated space, triggering a layout reflow.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 162, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Layout output contains edges of exactly three distinct semantic classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), identifiable via an edge.dat…", - "body": "Layout output contains edges of exactly three distinct semantic classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), identifiable via an edge.data.kind discriminator or edge.type. No edge in the output is generated by iterating ArtifactFile.graph.edges (EdgeRecord rows). Verify by (a) inspecting layout output for a fixture and asserting every edge has kind ∈ {sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution}, and (b) a unit test that inserts arbitrary EdgeRecord rows into the artifact and asserts the macro layout edge count is unchanged.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR52]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 163, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The mandate for high information density combined with the CRT aesthetic and prohibition on generic UI patterns creates tension between den…", - "body": "The mandate for high information density combined with the CRT aesthetic and prohibition on generic UI patterns creates tension between dense data display and visual readability/non-overwhelm.", - "basis": "accepted_review_set", - "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 164, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "An ImpasseNode renders with a clearly non-rectangular silhouette: either via SVG path/polygon or CSS clip-path/transform producing a diamon…", - "body": "An ImpasseNode renders with a clearly non-rectangular silhouette: either via SVG path/polygon or CSS clip-path/transform producing a diamond/lozenge shape. Its DOM contains the hub's displayId text and uses --color-phosphor-red as a glyph or border token. Verify with an RTL test asserting the presence of an SVG diamond polygon or a clip-path style, plus the text and color assertions.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR49]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 165, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given a fixture artifact representing a full onion-peel cycle (initial derivation, an impasse, a rederive child frame, fan-out runs, fan-in…", - "body": "Given a fixture artifact representing a full onion-peel cycle (initial derivation, an impasse, a rederive child frame, fan-out runs, fan-in, reconciliation, resolution), the rendered macro view contains: at least one PhaseGroupNode for the parent frame, an ImpasseNode at the lane boundary, at least one PhaseGroupNode for the child frame in a deeper lane, RunNode(s) and FanInNode and ReconciliationNode inside the child phase group, an impasse-spawn edge, and a resolution edge back to the impasse. Verify with an end-to-end RTL test on the full-cycle fixture.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR70]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 166, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Edges whose both endpoints lie inside a collapsed PhaseGroupNode shall not be rendered while that group is collapsed.", - "body": "Edges whose both endpoints lie inside a collapsed PhaseGroupNode shall not be rendered while that group is collapsed. Edges with exactly one endpoint inside a collapsed group shall reattach to the collapsed pill rather than being hidden.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R56]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 167, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts shall export pure functions: given identical inputs they shall produce structurally equal outputs and shall not m…", - "body": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts shall export pure functions: given identical inputs they shall produce structurally equal outputs and shall not mutate their input data, perform I/O, or read from external state (DOM, time, stores).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R61]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 168, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in and fan-out steps are represented as nested nodes within any one phase node.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in and fan-out steps are represented as nested nodes within any one phase node.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X17]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 169, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The MacroView shall load ArtifactFile data exactly once on component mount, build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React…", - "body": "The MacroView shall load ArtifactFile data exactly once on component mount, build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React Flow nodes and edges into component state. It shall not subscribe to or react to subsequent artifact changes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 170, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A DerivationRunNode with status='failed' has computed border-color resolving to --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior (e.g., r…", - "body": "A DerivationRunNode with status='failed' has computed border-color resolving to --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior (e.g., reduced opacity on the body OR a dark overlay; quantified as effective body luminance ≤ 70% of completed baseline). Verify with an RTL + computed-style test asserting border color match and an opacity/filter property indicating dimming.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR44]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 171, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "materialProgress=true on a ReconciliationRecord means at least some nodes were…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T12]", - "detail": { - "definition": "materialProgress=true on a ReconciliationRecord means at least some nodes were activated or archived during that reconciliation — real forward progress occurred." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 172, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When MacroView is mounted with a mocked artifact loader, the loader is invoked exactly once.", - "body": "When MacroView is mounted with a mocked artifact loader, the loader is invoked exactly once. When the underlying artifact source emits subsequent change notifications (mocked), the loader is NOT re-invoked and the rendered RF nodes/edges remain referentially stable. Verify with a Vitest test using a spy on the loader and a mock store that emits changes after mount.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR6]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 173, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A DerivationRunNode with status='completed' has no border color matching --color-phosphor-red and no opacity/dimming reduction relative to…", - "body": "A DerivationRunNode with status='completed' has no border color matching --color-phosphor-red and no opacity/dimming reduction relative to the base node treatment. Verify with an RTL + computed-style test on a completed-status fixture.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR43]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 174, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A static-analysis scan of all files under src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx,css} finds zero literal color values matching /#[0-9a-fA-F]{3,8…", - "body": "A static-analysis scan of all files under src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx,css} finds zero literal color values matching /#[0-9a-fA-F]{3,8}/, /\\brgb\\(/, /\\brgba\\(/, /\\bhsl\\(/, /\\bhsla\\(/, or /\\boklch\\(/ outside of var() references. All colors are referenced via var(--color-*) tokens defined in theme.css. Verify with a regex-based unit test scanning the directory.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR35]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 175, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspective nodes show which branch was taken; unchosen branches fade out to indicate they were not taken but could…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspective nodes show which branch was taken; unchosen branches fade out to indicate they were not taken but could be materialized later.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 176, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view implementation shall not modify the existing Sigma.js-based micro view, the routing layer, or unrelated parts of the Spec Ex…", - "body": "The macro view implementation shall not modify the existing Sigma.js-based micro view, the routing layer, or unrelated parts of the Spec Explorer UI. Changes are scoped to src/components/macro/, the existing src/components/MacroView.tsx re-export, and any minimal extensions to src/components/DetailPanel.tsx required to render macro record kinds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R59]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 177, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, and PerspectiveNode instances belonging to a phase shall be rendered as React Flow childr…", - "body": "DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, and PerspectiveNode instances belonging to a phase shall be rendered as React Flow children of their PhaseGroupNode using parentId and extent='parent'. The PhaseGroupNode shall be a React Flow group/parent node (type='group' or equivalent).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R12]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 178, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: there is no separate 'trunk' node type; the trunk is simply the outermost shell of the onion-layered layout.", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: there is no separate 'trunk' node type; the trunk is simply the outermost shell of the onion-layered layout.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 179, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Clicking on a non-faded, non-phantom macro node shall dispatch a select action carrying the underlying IR record (frame, derivation run, fa…", - "body": "Clicking on a non-faded, non-phantom macro node shall dispatch a select action carrying the underlying IR record (frame, derivation run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse hub, or perspective hub) into the existing global selection store consumed by DetailPanel.tsx.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R29]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 180, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "Collapsed/expanded state in the macro view is purely ephemeral in-memory React state and is never persisted.", - "body": "Collapsed/expanded state in the macro view is purely ephemeral in-memory React state and is never persisted.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C8]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 181, - "plane": "oracle", - "kind": "evidence", - "title": "The data structures for the macro view are defined in /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/s…", - "body": "The data structures for the macro view are defined in /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/src/types/artifact.ts.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder-observed [E1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 182, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The macro view's visual design must be beautiful, novel, and information-dense, avoiding generic dashboard or AI-generated aesthetics.", - "body": "The macro view's visual design must be beautiful, novel, and information-dense, avoiding generic dashboard or AI-generated aesthetics.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 183, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The Phase type has four ordered values: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defini…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [T1]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The Phase type has four ordered values: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 184, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: the nudging state is indicated by a treatment inside the node body (compact labelled chip or badge such as 'NUDGING…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: the nudging state is indicated by a treatment inside the node body (compact labelled chip or badge such as 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE' in phosphor amber) rather than as an external indicator.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X25]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 185, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For each phase group containing one or more DerivationRunNodes, a FanInNode, and a ReconciliationNode, layout emits sequence edges from eac…", - "body": "For each phase group containing one or more DerivationRunNodes, a FanInNode, and a ReconciliationNode, layout emits sequence edges from each RunNode → FanInNode and FanInNode → ReconciliationNode. Each such edge has computed stroke color resolving to --color-phosphor-amber, has a markerEnd arrow, and has animated !== true. Verify with a unit-test fixture and a render assertion on edge count, source/target ids, and computed style.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR53]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 186, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given two sibling phase groups A and B at the same depth where B is below A in the y axis, after collapsing A, B's new position.y is strict…", - "body": "Given two sibling phase groups A and B at the same depth where B is below A in the y axis, after collapsing A, B's new position.y is strictly less than its previous position.y by approximately the height differential (expanded_height(A) - pill_height) ± a tolerance. No sibling node retains a position that would leave a vertical gap larger than expanded_height(A)/2 where A's expanded body used to be. Verify with a unit test on layout() comparing pre-collapse and post-collapse outputs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR27]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 187, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given two depths D1 and D2 where the maximum content width across nodes at D1 is W1 and at D2 is W2, with W1 != W2, the lane widths assigne…", - "body": "Given two depths D1 and D2 where the maximum content width across nodes at D1 is W1 and at D2 is W2, with W1 != W2, the lane widths assigned by layout differ (laneWidth(D1) != laneWidth(D2)) and laneWidth(D_i) is a function of W_i (not a constant). Verify with a parameterized unit test asserting the lane-width function is non-constant across two fixtures with deliberately differing content widths.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR19]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 188, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given a fixture where impasse I in frame F0 triggers child frame F1 (parent F0, depth 1), the layout positions ImpasseNode I at the boundar…", - "body": "Given a fixture where impasse I in frame F0 triggers child frame F1 (parent F0, depth 1), the layout positions ImpasseNode I at the boundary between F0's lane (depth 0) and F1's lane (depth 1) such that it is horizontally between (or aligned with the start of) the two lanes. Verify with a unit test on layout asserting I.position.x lies between the rightmost x of F0's nodes and the leftmost x of F1's nodes (inclusive).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR65]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 189, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "A user should be able to understand what happened at each derivation step from the node visuals alone (numbers, IDs, outcomes) without need…", - "body": "A user should be able to understand what happened at each derivation step from the node visuals alone (numbers, IDs, outcomes) without needing to open a detail panel.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 190, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Collapse/expand state for phase groups shall be held in a single useState> (or equivalent set keyed by phase-group identity) a…", - "body": "Collapse/expand state for phase groups shall be held in a single useState> (or equivalent set keyed by phase-group identity) at the MacroView root component. PhaseGroupNode renderers shall not own their own collapse state.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 191, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "ReconciliationNode renders with computed border-color: outcome='accepted' → the parent phase's --color-phase-* token; outcome='retry' → --c…", - "body": "ReconciliationNode renders with computed border-color: outcome='accepted' → the parent phase's --color-phase-* token; outcome='retry' → --color-phosphor-amber; outcome='recurse' → --color-phosphor-cyan; outcome='bail' → --color-phosphor-red AND a dimmed interior treatment. Header contains a textual chip whose text equals the outcome name. Verify with parameterized RTL tests across all four outcomes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR47]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 192, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "A DetailPanel.tsx component exists at src/components/DetailPanel.tsx as a sibling to MacroView.tsx, confirming reuse is structurally feasib…", - "body": "A DetailPanel.tsx component exists at src/components/DetailPanel.tsx as a sibling to MacroView.tsx, confirming reuse is structurally feasible.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "technical-observed [X40]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 193, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "A heuristic content-completeness test asserts that every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node renders text/visual elements coverin…", - "body": "A heuristic content-completeness test asserts that every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node renders text/visual elements covering at minimum: a unique ID (frame displayId, run index, hub displayId, etc.), a count or status indicator (run counts, outcome glyph, fan-in row count, or impassesFound), and (where applicable) a mode/outcome chip. Verify with an RTL-driven content audit: for each node-type fixture, assert presence of (a) ID text, (b) numeric or glyph indicator, (c) status/mode chip text where applicable.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR63]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 194, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "The macro view is the component within the Spec Explorer UI that narrates the f…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T14]", - "detail": { - "definition": "The macro view is the component within the Spec Explorer UI that narrates the full derivation history of a spec via a pannable, zoomable React Flow graph of ~20–40 semantically typed nodes." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 195, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "Every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node shall surface enough content (IDs, counts, outcome glyph, mode chip) to identify what h…", - "body": "Every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node shall surface enough content (IDs, counts, outcome glyph, mode chip) to identify what happened at that derivation step without requiring the user to open the detail panel.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R63]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 196, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view shall render exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord, one FanInNode per FanInRecord, and one ReconciliationNod…", - "body": "The macro view shall render exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord, one FanInNode per FanInRecord, and one ReconciliationNode per ReconciliationRecord present in ArtifactFile.graph.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 197, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Given a fixture phase group with no PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected', buildStoryIR emits exactly one PhantomNode child…", - "body": "Given a fixture phase group with no PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected', buildStoryIR emits exactly one PhantomNode child for that phase group whose id is synthesized (not present in ArtifactFile) and whose label contains the phrase 'no perspective taken' (case-insensitive). Conversely, for a phase group containing a selected perspective, no PhantomNode is emitted. Verify with two unit-test fixtures.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR16]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 198, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, the rendered pill DOM contains: (1) an element styled with background-color or border-color resolving t…", - "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, the rendered pill DOM contains: (1) an element styled with background-color or border-color resolving to the corresponding --color-phase-* token, (2) the frame's displayId text, (3) text matching the pattern /\\d+\\s+RUNS?/, and (4) one of the glyphs ✓, ↺, ↪, or ✗ corresponding to the frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome (accepted/retry/recurse/bail respectively). Clicking the pill toggles expansion AND dispatches a select action. Verify with a parameterized RTL test covering all four outcomes.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR26]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 199, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Inspecting the MacroView component source (or its rendered React tree) shows exactly one useState/useReducer call holding a Set (or Set-equ…", - "body": "Inspecting the MacroView component source (or its rendered React tree) shows exactly one useState/useReducer call holding a Set (or Set-equivalent) of FrameId values for collapsed groups, located in the MacroView root component. PhaseGroupNode component source contains no useState/useReducer holding collapse state. Verify with a static-analysis test (AST inspection of the source files) and/or a runtime test using React DevTools-equivalent introspection.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR22]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 200, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "term", - "title": "A phantom node represents the case where no perspective is selected — it appear…", - "body": null, - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [T10]", - "detail": { - "definition": "A phantom node represents the case where no perspective is selected — it appears when an alternative perspective is used." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 201, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Calling buildStoryIR(artifact) twice with structurally-equal artifact inputs produces deeply-equal outputs.", - "body": "Calling buildStoryIR(artifact) twice with structurally-equal artifact inputs produces deeply-equal outputs. Calling layout(ir, set) twice with structurally-equal inputs produces deeply-equal outputs. Neither function mutates its input (pre/post deep-equal of inputs). Neither references Date.now, Math.random, document, window, or external store. Verify with property-based tests (fast-check) for determinism and idempotence, plus a static-analysis test for forbidden globals.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR61]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 202, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "An ImpasseNode whose hub is the trigger of a child frame whose terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome is 'bail' shall be annotated with a 'D…", - "body": "An ImpasseNode whose hub is the trigger of a child frame whose terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome is 'bail' shall be annotated with a 'DEAD-END' textual chip on the node, distinguishing it from open or resolved impasses.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R49]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 203, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The macro view must use React Flow (@xyflow/react) version ^12.", - "body": "The macro view must use React Flow (@xyflow/react) version ^12.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 204, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "story-ir.ts exports a buildStoryIR(artifact) function whose return type is a typed StoryIR (not RFNode[]); layout.ts exports a layout(ir, c…", - "body": "story-ir.ts exports a buildStoryIR(artifact) function whose return type is a typed StoryIR (not RFNode[]); layout.ts exports a layout(ir, collapsedSet) function whose return type contains RFNode[] and RFEdge[] with absolute positions. Verify by a TypeScript type-level test (tsd or expectTypeOf) that the IR builder's output has no React Flow position/parentId fields and that the layout output's nodes array contains objects with {id, type, position, parentId?}.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR5]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 205, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: all three frame modes (initial, rederive, grounding_enrichment) render as the same phase-group node component, with…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: all three frame modes (initial, rederive, grounding_enrichment) render as the same phase-group node component, with mode differences expressed via color, label, or border style only.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X20]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 206, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "For each HubNode with hubType='impasse' that participates in the derivation narrative (i.e., is referenced via FrameRecord.triggerImpasseId…", - "body": "For each HubNode with hubType='impasse' that participates in the derivation narrative (i.e., is referenced via FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds or ReconciliationRecord.resolvedImpasseIds/triggerImpasseIds/unresolvedImpasseIds), the IR contains exactly one ImpasseNode whose id maps to that hub. Likewise for each participating HubNode with hubType='perspective'. Verify with a unit test on buildStoryIR using a fixture covering all three reference paths.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR15]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 207, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "goal", - "title": "The macro view answers the question 'how did the spec get here?' by visualizing the full onion-peel cycle of impasse discovery, rederivatio…", - "body": "The macro view answers the question 'how did the spec get here?' by visualizing the full onion-peel cycle of impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, and resolution.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [G1]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 208, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "All macro view edges shall render without animation by default; no edge shall use React Flow's animated property by default.", - "body": "All macro view edges shall render without animation by default; no edge shall use React Flow's animated property by default.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R55]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 209, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "A right-side detail panel is already implemented and wired in the Micro View; the macro view should reuse it.", - "body": "A right-side detail panel is already implemented and wired in the Micro View; the macro view should reuse it.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X4]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 210, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested derivation run is collapsed it shrinks to a small pill or badge node showing key stats (run count, ou…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested derivation run is collapsed it shrinks to a small pill or badge node showing key stats (run count, outcome).", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X21]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 211, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "Clicking on a PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' or 'open' (i.e., faded) does NOT dispatch any select action.", - "body": "Clicking on a PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' or 'open' (i.e., faded) does NOT dispatch any select action. Its DOM exposes no interactive affordance. Verify with an RTL test using fixtures for both selected and faded perspective nodes; click each; assert select dispatch only for the selected one.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR33]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 212, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "The full project builds with `vite build` (or its equivalent npm/deno script) without errors after adding the macro view.", - "body": "The full project builds with `vite build` (or its equivalent npm/deno script) without errors after adding the macro view. No new bundler or runtime is added (no Webpack, Parcel, esbuild standalone, etc., introduced). package.json/deno.json shows no new CSS framework dependency competing with Tailwind. Verify with a CI build step plus a dependency-list check.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR60]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 213, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "requirement", - "title": "The macro view shall render one ImpasseNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'impasse', and one PerspectiveNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'p…", - "body": "The macro view shall render one ImpasseNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'impasse', and one PerspectiveNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'perspective', subject to those hubs participating in the derivation narrative captured by the IR.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [R14]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 214, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Stakeholder preference: custom React Flow node types exist for each semantic role: trunk phase, impasse, phase group, fan-out, run, fan-in,…", - "body": "Stakeholder preference: custom React Flow node types exist for each semantic role: trunk phase, impasse, phase group, fan-out, run, fan-in, reconciliation, perspective, phantom, and dead-end impasse.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [X13]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 215, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "constraint", - "title": "The macro view is a snapshot-only view: it reads artifact data once on mount and does not update reactively.", - "body": "The macro view is a snapshot-only view: it reads artifact data once on mount and does not update reactively.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "stakeholder [C11]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 216, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "criterion", - "title": "On every fresh mount of MacroView with any artifact fixture, immediately after first render, no PhaseGroupNode is rendered as a collapsed p…", - "body": "On every fresh mount of MacroView with any artifact fixture, immediately after first render, no PhaseGroupNode is rendered as a collapsed pill: every phase group renders in its expanded form. Verify with a render test that mounts MacroView and asserts (a) the collapsed-set state is empty and (b) no element with the macro-collapsed-pill data attribute is in the DOM.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived [CR23]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 217, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Hoist a single Set of collapsed IDs to MacroView root, in-memory only.", - "body": "Hoist a single Set of collapsed IDs to MacroView root, in-memory only.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC6]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Collapse/expand state lives in a single useState> at the MacroView root, holding the IDs of currently-collapsed phase groups (or frames). The set starts empty on mount (everything expanded per C9) and is never written to localStorage, sessionStorage, URL, or any persistence layer (per C8). Toggle handlers are passed down via React context to PhaseGroupNode renderers, which swap to a compact pill renderer when their ID is in the set. After a toggle, the layout function re-runs synchronously over the IR + collapsed-set to produce new node positions, and React Flow's animated transitions (default fitView=false, but applyNodeChanges with smooth-tweened positions) handle reflow per X22.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: persist collapse state across reloads (localStorage). Rejected by C8/C9.", - "Alternative: each PhaseGroupNode owns its own useState for collapsed/expanded. Local but means parent layout cannot recompute on toggle without lifting state anyway." - ], - "rationale": "Collapse changes the global layout (sibling shifts, X22), so the set must be visible to the layout function; per-node local state forces a redundant lift. C8/C9 forbid persistence, ruling out localStorage. A single Set keeps the toggle O(1), is trivially serializable for unit tests, and makes the snapshot-load+expanded-default invariant a one-liner (initial state = empty set)." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 218, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Render only the three workflow edge classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), synthesized from frame/run/fan-in/reconciliation records…", - "body": "Render only the three workflow edge classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), synthesized from frame/run/fan-in/reconciliation records, not from EdgeRecord rows.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC9]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Edges in the macro view encode three workflow relationships, each rendered as a typed React Flow edge: (1) sequence edges — thin amber lines connecting RunNode → FanInNode → ReconciliationNode within a phase group, expressing fan-out→fan-in→reconcile flow (T4/T5/T6); (2) impasse-spawn edges — red dashed lines from a ReconciliationNode (or a PhaseGroupNode whose phase produced impasses) outward to the ImpasseNode that opened a new lane, expressing that the impasse caused a child frame (X16, FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds); (3) resolution edges — phase-colored solid lines from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode (or activated nodes) back to the impasse it resolved, drawn with a return-leftward routing convention (T6.resolvedImpasseIds). Edges between sibling phase groups inside a frame follow PHASE_ORDER. All edges use markerEnd arrows, no animation by default. Edges within a collapsed group are hidden along with the group's children; the group's connecting external edges remain attached at the pill's perimeter.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: derive every edge mechanically from EdgeRecord rows in the artifact (informed_by, produced, considered, etc.). This pushes graph-content edges (designed for the micro view) into the macro view and would generate hundreds of edges, defeating the macro view's narrative purpose.", - "Alternative: render no edges at all and rely on spatial proximity / containment to imply flow. Cleaner visually but loses the narrative arrow of impasse → child frame → resolution that the macro view exists to tell." - ], - "rationale": "The macro view narrates the derivation process (G1, X3); content-level edges belong to the micro view (X2). Three semantically named edge classes give the narrative structure (fan-out→fan-in→reconcile, impasse opens a lane, resolution closes it back) while keeping the rendered edge count proportional to the ~20–40 nodes. Implicit-only edges leave the resolution arc invisible. Each edge class uses one already-justified color (amber for trunk flow, red for impasse, phase color for resolution), respecting C7." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 219, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Animated phosphor-arrive loop + cyan 'RUNNING' chip + scanline sweep on running runs.", - "body": "Animated phosphor-arrive loop + cyan 'RUNNING' chip + scanline sweep on running runs.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC10]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "When a DerivationRunRecord.status is 'running' (rare per X26), the RunNode renders with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe (already in theme.css) looping at slow tempo on the node body, (b) a 'RUNNING' chip in --color-phosphor-cyan in the header (cyan is unused for outcome semantics elsewhere, so it carries no conflicting meaning), and (c) a thin animated scanline sweep across the node interior. The node remains clickable and shows the same content fields as a completed run.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: a static cyan 'RUNNING' chip with no animation. Calmer but defeats X26's 'highlighted somehow' intent.", - "Alternative: amber pulsing border. Rejected because amber already encodes nudging (X25) and reconciliation 'retry' outcome (X28); reusing it for running creates ambiguity, violating C7's 'every color earns its place'." - ], - "rationale": "X26 says running is unlikely but must be highlighted. Cyan is the one phosphor token not yet load-bearing in macro semantics (red=failure/bail, amber=nudging/retry, green=merged/success, purple=defining_done phase, phase colors=phase identity), so it cleanly marks an in-flight state without colliding with C7. Animation distinguishes running from any static state at a glance. Reusing the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe keeps the addition cheap and within the established CRT motion vocabulary." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 220, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use a dedicated Story IR layer between artifact data and rendering.", - "body": "Use a dedicated Story IR layer between artifact data and rendering.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC1]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Architect MacroView as a three-stage pure pipeline: (1) Story IR builder that consumes ArtifactFile.graph and produces a normalized derivation tree (FrameNode root → PhaseNode children → RunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/ImpasseNode descendants, with parentFrameId chains expanded into nested impasse branches), (2) Layout engine that walks the IR and computes absolute (x,y) positions, lane widths, and parent/child grouping, (3) React Flow renderer that maps IR nodes to custom node types and IR edges to typed RF edges. The IR is the only contract layout and rendering depend on; data shape changes localize to stage 1.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: skip the Story IR and map ArtifactFile records directly to React Flow nodes inside one component, with layout calculation interleaved with rendering.", - "Alternative: model the derivation history as a generic graphlib graph and feed it through a layered layout, then translate to React Flow at the end." - ], - "rationale": "The macro view's spatial grammar (onion-peel breadth, phase containment, fan-out/fan-in nesting, perspective fade) is highly domain-specific and unstable while the design is being iterated. A typed IR isolates the domain mapping from layout math from React Flow specifics, letting each stage be unit-testable and letting the manual layout (mandated by C3) operate on a tree shape that already encodes parent/child semantics rather than re-deriving them. Direct RF mapping conflates concerns and makes the collapse/reflow logic (X22) harder. A generic graphlib representation loses the typed semantics the custom node renderers need." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 221, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Encode information across orthogonal visual channels (border style, border color, fill, header chips, opacity, shape) drawn from existing p…", - "body": "Encode information across orthogonal visual channels (border style, border color, fill, header chips, opacity, shape) drawn from existing phosphor tokens.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC8]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Each node type expresses its semantic role through a fixed visual vocabulary built from theme.css tokens: (a) PhaseGroupNode — 1px border in the phase color (--color-phase-*), warm dark surface-1 fill, scanline overlay, header line 'PHASE / FRAME-ID / mode' in --color-text-secondary; mode differentiation per X20 done by border style (initial=solid, rederive=double, grounding_enrichment=dashed) plus a small mode chip; nudgingActive shown as a 'NUDGING' chip in --color-phosphor-amber inside the header (X25). (b) DerivationRunNode — numbered tile 'RUN #n' with input/output count badges and impassesFound count; status='completed' is base, status='failed' uses --color-phosphor-red border and dimmed interior (X27), status='running' adds an animated phosphor-arrive pulse (X26). (c) FanInNode — stacked rows, one per FanInGrouping, each row prefixed by a 4px left border in green/amber/red per resolution (X32); row text shows groupKey and node count. (d) ReconciliationNode — outcome encoded as full-node border color (accepted=phase color, retry=amber, recurse=cyan/blue, bail=red+dim) per X28, plus an outcome chip in the header; materialProgress=true shown as a small ✓ chip beside the outcome (X35). (e) ImpasseNode — diamond/lozenge shape with red glyph, displayId visible; if linked to a bail reconciliation (X36), it is annotated 'DEAD-END' to disambiguate from open impasses (RK2 mitigation). (f) PerspectiveNode — branching tile; selected branch full opacity, rejected branches at ~30% opacity (X23); non-interactive when faded (X24). (g) PhantomNode — dashed-outline ghost tile, no fill, label 'PHANTOM — no perspective taken', non-interactive (X24).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: lean heavily on icons (status icons, mode icons, outcome icons) instead of typographic chips and border treatments. Punchier visually but less information-dense per pixel and breaks the typographic CRT aesthetic.", - "Alternative: encode all status/mode/outcome differences via fill color alone, leaving borders neutral. Easier but loses the orthogonal channels (border = outcome, fill = mode, chip = nudging) that let several attributes coexist on one node." - ], - "rationale": "G3 demands at-a-glance comprehension and G4 demands that each node communicates its specific outcome; a single channel cannot carry mode + status + outcome + nudging + materialProgress simultaneously. Orthogonal channels honor C7 (every color earns meaning: border=outcome, phase color=phase, red=failure/bail, amber=warning states). Iconographic styling fights the JetBrains Mono / typographic CRT aesthetic (X11, X37). Reusing the seven oklch tokens already defined in theme.css avoids palette inflation and keeps C13 satisfied. The intentional collision between bail-outcome and failed-run treatment (X29) is preserved; RK2 is mitigated by adding a 'DEAD-END' textual chip on bail-linked impasses rather than diverging the color treatment." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 222, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Decompose into a src/components/macro/ folder with one file per pipeline stage and one file per node type.", - "body": "Decompose into a src/components/macro/ folder with one file per pipeline stage and one file per node type.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC13]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Module structure under src/components/macro/: index.ts (re-exports MacroView), MacroView.tsx (top-level: data load, state, ReactFlowProvider, Canvas), story-ir.ts (ArtifactFile → StoryIR builder, pure), layout.ts (StoryIR + collapsedSet → RFNode[]/RFEdge[], pure), nodes/ (PhaseGroupNode.tsx, DerivationRunNode.tsx, FanInNode.tsx, ReconciliationNode.tsx, ImpasseNode.tsx, PerspectiveNode.tsx, PhantomNode.tsx — one component per type), edges/ (custom edge components if needed), and macro.css or co-located CSS modules using only theme.css tokens. Existing src/components/MacroView.tsx becomes a thin re-export of the new module to preserve the current import path.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: keep everything inside the existing single MacroView.tsx file. Faster to start but conflicts with the pipeline boundaries (dec-pipeline) and clusters seven node renderers into one file." - ], - "rationale": "The pipeline decision (dec-pipeline) and the seven-node taxonomy (dec-node-taxonomy) both imply natural file boundaries. Co-locating the macro folder under components keeps the project's existing layout convention (sibling to DetailPanel.tsx). Re-exporting through the original MacroView.tsx path means routes/explore.tsx keeps working unchanged. C5 explicitly scopes this work to the macro view, so a dedicated folder helps reviewers see the scope boundary." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 223, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Adopt seven typed React Flow node components, no separate trunk type.", - "body": "Adopt seven typed React Flow node components, no separate trunk type.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC4]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Define exactly seven custom React Flow node types matching the data shapes: PhaseGroupNode (RF group/parent node, one per FrameRecord+Phase pair, mode-tinted), DerivationRunNode (one per DerivationRunRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode), FanInNode (one per FanInRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode, contains color-coded grouping rows), ReconciliationNode (one per ReconciliationRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode), ImpasseNode (one per HubNode with hubType='impasse', positioned at the boundary opening a new lane), PerspectiveNode (one per HubNode with hubType='perspective'), and PhantomNode (synthesized when a phase group ends without a perspective selection per T10). The trunk is not a node type; it emerges from PhaseGroupNodes laid out at depth 0 (per X19).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: introduce an explicit TrunkNode type for depth-0 phase groups, separate from nested phase groups.", - "Alternative: one polymorphic 'MacroNode' component that switches on a discriminator prop. Reduces the React Flow nodeTypes registry but conflates radically different visual treatments and makes per-type styling and testing harder." - ], - "rationale": "X13 enumerates the desired semantic node types; one React component per type aligns the type system with the visual grammar and gives each node its own focused render path (G3/G4 require visual distinctness at a glance). A polymorphic component would push that complexity into a single switch and erode TypeScript support. X19 explicitly says trunk is not a separate type; reusing PhaseGroupNode at depth 0 honors that and keeps mode tinting (X20) as the only differentiator. Dead-end impasse is handled as a visual variant of ImpasseNode driven by the linked ReconciliationRecord.outcome='bail' (X36), not as an eighth type, because behaviorally it is still an impasse." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 224, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Show a snapshot timestamp + reload affordance as a fixed corner overlay.", - "body": "Show a snapshot timestamp + reload affordance as a fixed corner overlay.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC11]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Render a small permanently-visible 'SNAPSHOT @ ' badge in the macro view's top-left corner using --color-text-tertiary, with a 'RELOAD' button next to it. Clicking RELOAD re-runs the pipeline. The banner sits above the React Flow canvas as a fixed overlay; it does not participate in pan/zoom.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: no banner, rely on user knowledge that the view is snapshot-only. Leaves RK3 (stale data) fully unmitigated." - ], - "rationale": "RK3 (users may view stale history) is a real and silent failure mode. Surfacing the snapshot time directly in the view turns it from invisible to glanceable, while a Reload button makes the manual-refresh expectation actionable without violating C11/C12 (the data contract is still snapshot-on-load; Reload is an explicit re-mount). The treatment is small and uses an existing token (text-tertiary), so it doesn't compete with the derivation graph for attention." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 225, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Snapshot the artifact on mount; require manual reload.", - "body": "Snapshot the artifact on mount; require manual reload.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC2]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Load the artifact exactly once on component mount via a useEffect/useMemo against the artifact source (file fetch or store selector), build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React Flow nodes/edges arrays into useState. No subscriptions, no live updates. Provide a manual 'Reload' affordance that re-runs the pipeline.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: subscribe to the artifact store and recompute the IR/layout on every change." - ], - "rationale": "C11/C12 explicitly mandate snapshot-only behavior. Live subscription would invalidate the layout mid-interaction and conflict with the ephemeral collapse state (C8), causing layouts to thrash. A visible 'Reload' affordance partially mitigates RK3 (stale data) without breaking the snapshot contract." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 226, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Collapse to a stat-bearing pill, not an icon.", - "body": "Collapse to a stat-bearing pill, not an icon.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC12]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, its renderer swaps to a compact pill ~120px×28px showing: phase color dot + frame displayId + 'n RUNS' + outcome glyph (✓ accepted / ↺ retry / ↪ recurse / ✗ bail) derived from the frame's terminal reconciliation. The pill remains clickable to expand and to open the detail panel. External edges re-attach to the pill's center handles automatically because React Flow recomputes edge endpoints from node bounds.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: collapse to a tiny icon-only marker. Smaller but loses the at-a-glance run count + outcome that X21 calls out as 'key stats'." - ], - "rationale": "X21 explicitly says the collapsed form should show key stats (run count, outcome). G3 demands at-a-glance comprehension even in summary form. A pill carries the four bits of information (phase, frame ID, run count, outcome) using existing visual tokens; an icon-only marker forces the user to expand or open the detail panel just to recall what a frame contains, defeating the purpose of collapse-as-summary." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 227, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Reuse the existing DetailPanel component, extending it with branches for macro record kinds.", - "body": "Reuse the existing DetailPanel component, extending it with branches for macro record kinds.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC7]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "On node click, the MacroView reads the React Flow node's underlying IR record (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, or hub) and dispatches a 'select' action to the existing global selection store consumed by DetailPanel.tsx. The DetailPanel branches its rendering on record kind to display frame summary, run inputs/outputs, fan-in groupings, reconciliation deltas, etc. PhantomNodes and faded perspective branches do not dispatch any selection (per X24).", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: build a separate macro-specific detail panel optimized for derivation records (frames/runs/reconciliations), since DetailPanel was originally built for graph nodes." - ], - "rationale": "X4 mandates reuse. The DetailPanel already handles selection plumbing, layout, and CRT styling; replicating that for the macro view would duplicate code and risk visual divergence. Adding record-kind branches inside DetailPanel keeps the selection contract single. Read-only enforcement (C10) is automatic because DetailPanel has no mutating actions wired in the macro path." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 228, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use a custom recursive DFS lane layout with proportional lane widths.", - "body": "Use a custom recursive DFS lane layout with proportional lane widths.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC3]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Manual layout algorithm: compute derivationDepth for each FrameRecord as the length of its parentFrameId chain; assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by depth (depth 0 = trunk at center, depth 1+ branches to the right). Within a lane, frames stack vertically with the most recent at the top (higher y ←→ more recent t+1). Each lane's width is computed as a function of the maximum content width across all nodes at that depth, not a fixed constant. Phase groups inside a frame stack vertically in PHASE_ORDER reverse (defining_done top, grounding bottom) so the eye reads downward through the derivation, while later frames sit above earlier ones at the lane level. The algorithm runs as a recursive DFS that returns subtree bounding boxes used to compute sibling offsets.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: use ELK.js layered layout with manual constraints to encode lanes. Cheaper to implement than full manual layout but less precise about onion-peel breadth and conflicts with C3.", - "Alternative: fixed lane width and fixed row height, regardless of content. Simple to implement but ignores X31's proportional-width preference and produces large dead space at shallow lanes." - ], - "rationale": "C3 forbids dagre and the equivalent argument applies to ELK: the spatial grammar (onion peel breadth = depth, verticality = time, impasses opening lanes per X16, perspective fan-out under phase groups) is too prescriptive for any general-purpose layout. A recursive DFS that returns subtree bounding boxes is a small amount of code (roughly 100–200 LOC) and gives full control. Fixed lanes were rejected because X31 specifies proportional sizing and because shallow trunks would otherwise look impoverished next to wide branches." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 229, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "decision", - "title": "Use React Flow parent/child group nodes for phase containers.", - "body": "Use React Flow parent/child group nodes for phase containers.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "[DEC5]", - "detail": { - "chosen_option": "Use React Flow's parentId/extent='parent' mechanism so that DerivationRunNodes, FanInNodes, ReconciliationNodes, and PerspectiveNodes are children of a PhaseGroupNode (which is rendered as type='group'). Children use position relative to the parent's origin, and the layout algorithm emits absolute parent positions plus relative child offsets. This lets React Flow handle the visual containment, drag-bound clipping, and z-ordering for free, and it makes collapse-as-pill (X21) a matter of toggling the group's children to display:none and swapping its renderer to a compact pill.", - "rejected": [ - "Alternative: render the entire phase group's interior (runs, fan-in, reconciliation rows) as inner HTML inside a single React Flow node, without using RF parenting at all.", - "Alternative: render fan-out/fan-in/reconciliation as separate top-level nodes positioned to overlap a 'background' phase node; do not use React Flow parenting." - ], - "rationale": "X18 explicitly mandates RF group/parent nodes. Beyond compliance, parenting buys correct hit-testing, per-node click-to-detail (X33), and individual child animation when the group reflows on collapse (X22). HTML-only nesting forfeits the ability to attach edges from a fan-in row to a child reconciliation node and breaks the click-target model. Manual overlap is fragile and reorders interactively." - } - }, - { - "local_id": 230, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "The combination of mandatory snapshot-only data loading, the resulting risk of users viewing stale derivation history, and the requirement…", - "body": "The combination of mandatory snapshot-only data loading, the resulting risk of users viewing stale derivation history, and the requirement to keep the data contract unchanged jointly force a visible-snapshot-time + reload-button overlay (rather than no banner, or live-subscription).\n\n## Rationale\n\nC11/C12 mandate snapshot-only behavior; RK3 identifies stale-data viewing as a real silent failure; DEC2 forbids live subscriptions; DEC11 chooses a banner+reload affordance as the mitigation. Together these jointly require both (a) a visible snapshot timestamp and (b) an explicit reload control to be present in the UI — neither premise alone is sufficient.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J2]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 231, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Three independent constraints jointly force collapse state to be a single hoisted in-memory Set with no persistence and an empty initial va…", - "body": "Three independent constraints jointly force collapse state to be a single hoisted in-memory Set with no persistence and an empty initial value: (1) the requirement that collapse triggers global sibling reflow, (2) the prohibition on persistence, and (3) the mandate that every page load starts fully expanded.\n\n## Rationale\n\nX22 requires sibling reflow on collapse, which the layout function needs visibility into the full collapsed set to compute — forcing the state to be lifted to MacroView root (DEC6). C8 forbids any persistence layer. C9 mandates fully-expanded state at every mount. Together these uniquely determine the design captured in D6.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J3]", - "detail": null - }, - { - "local_id": 232, - "plane": "intent", - "kind": "context", - "title": "Multiple node-attribute encodings (border style for mode, border color for outcome, fill for phase, header chips for nudging/material progr…", - "body": "Multiple node-attribute encodings (border style for mode, border color for outcome, fill for phase, header chips for nudging/material progress, opacity for perspective selection, shape for impasse) coexist on a single node without ambiguity because each visual channel is reserved for a single semantic dimension.\n\n## Rationale\n\nG3/G4 require at-a-glance comprehension; X25, X27, X28, X32, X35, X23 each assign a different semantic attribute to a different visual channel; C7 forbids decorative color reuse; DEC8 explicitly orthogonalizes channels. Together these premises force the requirement that no two semantic attributes share the same visual channel, which is a property each node renderer must collectively satisfy.", - "basis": "explicit", - "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J1]", - "detail": null - } -] diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/spec.json b/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/spec.json deleted file mode 100644 index d8f6b9e0f..000000000 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/macro-view/spec.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "slug": "macro-view", - "name": "Macro View", - "readiness_grade": "commitments_ready" -} diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/README.md b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/README.md similarity index 55% rename from .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/README.md rename to .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/README.md index 6142f7047..66b535209 100644 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/README.md +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/README.md @@ -1,17 +1,21 @@ -# `.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/` +# `.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/` Ported spec graphs from Bilal's spec-elicitation prototype, transformed to the brunch graph model. Intended as development seed data — rich, real spec material to populate a dev SQLite database for UI / agent work. -Not probe-run artifacts; sits alongside `.fixtures/runs/` rather than inside it. +Not probe-run artifacts; sits under `.fixtures/seeds/` alongside +`.fixtures/runs/` rather than inside it. ## Provenance -Source: `/Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/bilal-spec-elicitation-proto/spec//graph/` +Source: vendored under [`_originals/`](./_originals/) — copied from +Bilal's spec-elicitation prototype `spec//graph/{nodes,edges}.json`. -Generated by [`_port-script.ts`](./_port-script.ts) (co-located in this directory). -Re-runnable; each run wipes and re-emits per-spec subdirectories. +Each `.json` is generated from `_originals/` by +[`_port-script.ts`](./_port-script.ts) (a throwaway data-prep step, +not product code). Re-runnable from this directory alone; each run +overwrites the `.json` files. ## Transformation rules @@ -41,18 +45,28 @@ Curation flags carried in the `source` field: ``` bilal-port/ ├── README.md # this file (generated) -├── _port-script.ts # the porting script itself (re-runnable) -├── / -│ ├── spec.json # → specs table seed row -│ ├── nodes.json # → nodes table seed rows (local_id placeholder for autoincrement) -│ └── edges.json # → edges table seed rows (source/target reference local_id) +├── _port-script.ts # throwaway prep: _originals/ → .json +├── _originals/ # vendored Bilal source (reproducibility) +│ └── /{nodes,edges}.json +└── .json # consolidated seed contract (× 3) ``` -Field shape mirrors [`src/db/schema.ts`](../../../src/db/schema.ts) column names -(plane, kind, title, body, basis, source, detail). -No LSNs or change-log entries are pre-baked — a seed loader is expected -to wrap inserts in one `commitGraph`-style transaction so the graph clock, -change log, and lsn columns stay coherent under brunch's mutation contract. +Each `.json` is the seed contract consumed by the loader: + +``` +{ + "spec": { "slug", "name", "readiness_grade" }, + "nodes": [ { "local_id", "plane", "kind", "title", "body?", "basis", "source?", "detail?" } ], + "edges": [ { "category", "source_local_id", "target_local_id", "stance?", "basis", "rationale?" } ] +} +``` + +Node/edge field shape mirrors [`src/db/schema.ts`](../../../src/db/schema.ts) +column names. `local_id` is a placeholder for autoincrement; edges reference +nodes by `local_id`. No LSNs or change-log entries are pre-baked — the loader +([`src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts`](../../../src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts)) wraps each spec +in one `commitGraph` transaction so the graph clock, change log, and lsn +columns stay coherent under brunch's mutation contract. ## Stats diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/edges.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/edges.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9168378ff --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/edges.json @@ -0,0 +1,9002 @@ +[ + { + "id": "0016e74a-3a3d-41e0-bafb-8687bd0b82eb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0b381a87-98ee-46f9-ac60-899dc86c1655" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b24d6fdb-a5c4-4390-97d6-91ba22f9a9d6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "002a78d8-08ab-44f7-abaf-61742430badc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3317213c-3dc1-4157-ae58-293df3e05081" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6ac7bbea-d275-4efd-99e0-40e86df70953" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "007e14f1-0ba6-48e2-ab91-c1e1f44e5b9f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e630e5a6-30ba-489b-995d-c930eb133440" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "11e613a5-265c-4e41-9f3e-6e57b0e85070" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "00e375c1-0f70-475e-b274-dd107fa6955b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "01686bc4-b8c4-45ca-ba04-b16895e0f4ca", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb577a90-bd8c-4ef8-879d-40f474cfc365" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a845a045-1666-4660-8373-31f700d26131" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "018ea157-b969-48aa-aa7b-41ccf444179b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6f7b6b6-212a-46a0-a81a-579d3b7ec13f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "045c71d0-a9dc-4076-bce6-5f86e7c2bf04", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fdfa9546-89b5-4433-a7b8-7db81ae8dcc4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "04bf2d81-aaa0-4af2-9dd1-2e4311d76566", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "63d8a14d-6b0f-42f0-98d1-877327ffa8e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "06ef1df5-3235-4eba-baf1-1c5a85b9ddd4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "070520bf-9e81-44bc-8f7e-c239be318d89", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a43d964e-6754-4eb3-bda9-27cde37227f3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fed0ddb3-f9cb-438e-a74c-733d2d48aa19" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "072a574d-37de-4948-8748-8c790934c1d8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ba434d88-a30b-4842-9dcd-f2026aa43748" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "07470ce6-fd08-4858-918d-824e26238250", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "07341118-f915-45a5-8869-926a1d846203" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "076adf28-2a6b-43b2-98a7-496a27b5a8e0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "11e613a5-265c-4e41-9f3e-6e57b0e85070" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0838cf71-489f-41f9-905c-617cbbbe5b41", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ed593ba-2ec2-424e-bdd1-b4680256c1fa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "08498e02-84ca-44c8-ac70-5d01f5d16dfd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "086eef6c-b934-4d61-94de-ed890c759a45", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a59d8fdb-5b4d-4ff0-ac9e-23d1755fa5ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "423e5e61-c9e1-4bcd-82f2-4240de25800d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "08a3767c-3694-4a69-b2ef-1cca59440792", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "136d454a-89ac-4b50-941a-1e7656c78155" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "08a57dd8-aa12-4901-9af7-f5f3fbcfdebc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ed94beb8-d6f2-46cc-9f81-50f47f3c4a6a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3743c9eb-2878-4574-bbdb-3b43e3d3e1b0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "08bedd0f-726f-4e13-aaca-16c9eb77d1f0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "70c05342-e714-4fd2-9cc3-216197aba112" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a34ed745-2d19-420c-8542-d7253d58dbfc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0931e2fc-ce50-496b-bbb0-a1993bbbd3f7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2390fcf6-4d39-41cc-b7a4-b9ef5c733196" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a6a461d-f161-4d08-9b2d-9c05375982c6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "56f7d4e0-fa99-402e-b187-532729ccfa41" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a807a76-6093-49c9-8b03-e10646ccf0a3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "af3c3468-9cf3-4ad7-a772-97fc045956b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a8b92fa-ea3e-4558-87aa-c0de6a7ff88b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4c563fc0-1e01-4025-8a74-3a5f002eb323" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fad86b2d-d2f3-4f6e-b9a6-51aa05877d30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a913726-30ba-4fde-8701-ac3a10e9c031", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "228801c6-3918-4a57-9acd-432fab72ec48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a95b609-89ed-451e-94cc-3d98cf402cfc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0ac498f3-00d4-493e-af45-f4a014dd6edc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0b4397d8-1f91-4386-9fba-8867e8c1b1f6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "38cb4f68-b4bf-44e0-911b-09cafb316a70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "0b7c9266-de4c-4cd3-8b1d-30bdfa26309e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a62ac18f-8b7b-4b43-bb75-3353b9881657" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "0bb7ed75-cf4d-4100-ad9a-2b148a2f0b56", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3820332b-c40d-4e03-82f8-b38a4cea7338" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "acb81cf5-0510-467b-a16f-d105d9625980" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c342f2a-1c79-4496-896f-94d2cc0a1bea", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ca35c2e-2f02-4403-b8f2-40edca2f2429" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "800301b2-1de7-48ac-acba-4fbbb76af49d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c488eeb-5df0-4655-8c29-6583526b8490", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4606bd52-c631-4d12-9de0-52f13914ba14" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2809500a-f66f-42f3-94eb-74a820a5540c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c92039a-5993-4ef7-8268-b3dcc4c70ee8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5fa3376-a63e-45f2-be6a-b5e13ae20abc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0cb4624a-6bff-481a-937e-2df5e44639f4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0cc7fc6d-5f0a-45d4-b156-6e2bd239531c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "14a9aa97-de74-4c30-8fc5-da0d309a46a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6ac7bbea-d275-4efd-99e0-40e86df70953" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "0e1517fb-ddeb-4304-b956-5b05ef92a725", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "31595a8b-0736-49d9-8499-bdac3eb30ba2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "94b6f96f-5879-4b60-a508-6d07e55262db" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "0e313778-c602-4afb-911f-54abfc7930a9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3c4be7f2-7405-4f68-95c2-648afbdb6212" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1e8aeba7-38fa-4c67-aef3-0a4d1af377f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "0e707b2d-40c2-4165-ae05-7aa07bce68a8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f7a7ddb6-bf6a-480a-b200-d1d3f52a7c45" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0ea39d57-a3ae-45b9-8fa5-d76c6f8067e4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec94d500-fd48-47ed-8550-9cd490fe56cf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1c65cc0d-41c5-498a-bc8d-8476222fe2ff" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "0eb286aa-53fe-4048-a57b-722f7aea2be3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a62ac18f-8b7b-4b43-bb75-3353b9881657" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0eecaf9d-e85c-4fee-a7b5-4ad27778fcb7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e8650e58-d232-45af-b3a3-a6f9fd05a5a5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d0b6708b-6979-4c48-a509-5a54608c68ea" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "0efdc96e-dd06-4685-b2b7-61d6f30cffbc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d881ea47-48a0-4dc0-a594-a32f9cf18290" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "11e613a5-265c-4e41-9f3e-6e57b0e85070" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "0fde37d6-afa8-4f73-b34c-3ef5b96a8d18", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ccdae101-399e-4985-a64d-d9e3a4e0cada" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "108f79df-9419-4cdf-b67a-0de429a62817", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ebf8616f-5488-4656-8795-a068abbdc1e9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "951d0c0a-b0e1-462c-b557-298e2fa2ad01" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "11c9ad08-0e7c-4878-a5f5-cd9b4ee04ecb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f9a800-3cda-4e12-9e56-c31436684385" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "1240aa5c-82f6-4392-8e14-712dc0bbdc2e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e1e9adae-f1b0-45ea-9e3e-0e8003624916" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f0a55f22-d55c-46ea-87d7-55350516462c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "13b3a4c3-1a01-450f-a595-b03ac835fd29", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8d4d362d-9b04-4b52-99fb-5c05e9b6295a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1795c0b9-6fc6-4213-9755-0479d155fd8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "13cb3eac-933e-47fb-9bd2-98fc10530cde", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "93c0afe0-21e7-4ba5-bd45-c3aece3d981d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "14550613-8278-474e-9574-3c2e0328a272", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "41ad2d7e-54fc-46db-ad0f-6b781304415e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b7b2dc14-0555-46d8-a1cd-d5230f9ba590" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "148f14f1-ed1a-455d-b610-4f64cc7ec874", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0b381a87-98ee-46f9-ac60-899dc86c1655" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7184c9db-64e3-4280-94f4-b71d2e44a58f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "14a688fc-e732-4252-b9f6-9ddda801dd45", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "426fefcf-cb65-4031-b92e-f02fe3db51ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "14ec8168-a348-4800-80d6-2c7bd713c9d0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bd725f2e-b2d8-40e5-9371-43a50946d0b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "14f17c62-cdcb-4e37-a6c5-7aef747c1714", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "58b19bc4-37e7-4544-84b7-3bd1288e4dee" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "15fddb3b-db8e-4994-885e-4caa49441714", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5e77bd42-29da-411f-9bf1-6f9944f5b320" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "16207742-9400-4d03-93be-90ce9d3db924", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fad86b2d-d2f3-4f6e-b9a6-51aa05877d30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "162538d0-7eba-47a0-a578-aa06330c4645", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9323af51-66ef-4b3e-92eb-a35aa26f8bd1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "84b0d1c9-e09d-4b62-9231-32eccd3867a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "1659e772-110d-4f5f-ab54-cf9652ef5b82", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5f14375-4f8e-470f-9d1b-82de1770b999" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "16bcdbdc-ed0d-4e60-ae63-bc1c28ca0b4f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b1a55d40-1a38-4403-8b5e-9c2639ac9b81" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "17677bb7-bc83-4bb5-bf73-16ac707998b0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57b9a0a2-62ba-402f-8b40-0c1631c10b50" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "1782f5da-4190-4dcd-afee-00affca53e01", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e1e9adae-f1b0-45ea-9e3e-0e8003624916" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "17a7c48b-795d-44b4-9172-926609a36445", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b9e5c7e2-56df-4fc9-934a-fe2f1bc4b16b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e655cfa1-6086-4068-b176-9ff3d4bf8f62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "1819c938-89fc-45b3-aa17-d58ab017a3a7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "799c3f7e-67db-4df0-a2b5-44526c516c5d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "41ad2d7e-54fc-46db-ad0f-6b781304415e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "1820d302-37ad-42a5-a49f-00614d5098eb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cfd53b11-128b-42d9-bb09-4e4e2e3694e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5e77bd42-29da-411f-9bf1-6f9944f5b320" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "187cc4ec-8fdb-447f-8ce9-e5cc66923762", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "afb3adab-ff11-44af-8cdd-f55c8181a93c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1e8aeba7-38fa-4c67-aef3-0a4d1af377f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "191ed5db-3d81-497d-b760-c44a63dea0f2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57b9a0a2-62ba-402f-8b40-0c1631c10b50" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "04c802c1-8761-488e-a6c2-39bb9037aa3a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "198f2f62-769c-4195-b1cf-946e85b946e3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4f2055fa-4205-498a-921d-84032e59b8f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "acb81cf5-0510-467b-a16f-d105d9625980" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "198f6060-904b-4b67-9e08-53df96dff446", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "972ebb02-4c92-4843-b686-8048e6aa6b4e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e0cb5c74-fca3-4a20-a23b-7b9516080904" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "19d9819f-7c0f-4f48-8a1a-9e1d35961a5b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b9e5c7e2-56df-4fc9-934a-fe2f1bc4b16b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fdfa9546-89b5-4433-a7b8-7db81ae8dcc4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "1aef531d-6b03-40b1-b49c-cd9a95564e2b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "05a384fc-f8cc-49a3-951f-69c7f81f5da8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6ad93ee5-89c1-4320-8872-b7609188ae30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "1af741bc-3343-4411-914c-c69a40928683", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f725ff14-0ced-453a-87b0-f19f7c11fdbc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "1cd6930c-7cdd-4d37-b856-f824dc57f823", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dd5c2811-756e-47a6-87c9-4f0a1e405018" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "1d6aca55-cd9b-4ff1-8413-2372d2325e0a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a6b237-0a22-4b59-9974-b4cafa54ba55" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "1e6a6f40-8e0d-4670-9ccf-381d7082e2fc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "53b04e07-fba8-4582-b272-f6fa4633b7be" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "1ed23993-7bb6-4ade-9681-aafab7614955", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "010a3fd2-5446-4ff7-aadb-3d8601245590" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "1f12c096-446c-4f4c-875d-7fddcda3686f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "12796661-b533-46d1-a6e9-0ad5734dffa9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "1f94002b-227b-44f6-930d-f38357289e0f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0b381a87-98ee-46f9-ac60-899dc86c1655" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4de2feb-cd3d-4f70-a1eb-d8a1903508ab" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "1fbf3849-631b-4911-9f67-44ee4ce9a610", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc662f1a-11ca-4e56-8214-0648bf042ec8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cb179854-2b66-43d8-83b8-4b07a4d31844" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "1fc1b2cd-8bb2-40cb-88f5-566997c3cd62", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4fede9ad-0614-4c7b-b090-84f065d7e02f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1795c0b9-6fc6-4213-9755-0479d155fd8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "1fddd4d4-653e-42ed-820c-3f75eedb6ff9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "772edee2-e028-462c-9f49-20864f1c3de7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "200cd91c-0987-4c9b-b80f-5179b6a89e55", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa8ed847-6e0b-4387-a4aa-73028595ebdb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dd10897c-b0bd-40b8-bb80-18bfb8c7b76f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "212a2ce4-bc17-47af-a16c-92d2a777b37e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b36a6df7-a5c0-45bd-aa6e-d80721a0caa3" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "216965ec-37ea-46c6-87ec-79e4b058debf", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b1643796-38c5-416f-843d-20dacbccbee6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2179f052-b3f2-47ad-9fbb-077f70ca09d3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bcfb7e08-e00e-4b35-8a2d-24dd53679db9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "21942c8a-107a-487f-8515-d0717b44e49c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d6f274aa-2fdc-4e5f-a321-db72539028e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f8340618-9ebc-4cef-a966-fca007ab0f00" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "21af9b26-101d-4dc3-8a0c-17fb55527f7a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b7b2dc14-0555-46d8-a1cd-d5230f9ba590" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "21fc2f7a-6866-48ce-acc7-2c21ad245da4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f6497cbf-6932-4154-9798-137c6da27325" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "243d13c9-3fd1-4155-8679-3c2e9997e9f8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f8340618-9ebc-4cef-a966-fca007ab0f00" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "24bb0750-1465-4416-b9f9-a0282b87a2d1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a43d964e-6754-4eb3-bda9-27cde37227f3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4ba71112-e314-452b-a979-4bffb7a933fa" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "25de4eb4-20b6-40e2-a2c5-d0fb1ece9205", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e8650e58-d232-45af-b3a3-a6f9fd05a5a5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7c6bbf00-5e63-42eb-8865-68c722f887ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "25ed6b80-0aa9-4dd9-bc64-1b5ec488a7f9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5e77bd42-29da-411f-9bf1-6f9944f5b320" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "26291c86-ef8d-47bd-b895-885106e4e53c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "26f75977-8d63-430d-a583-b27c8adcf07a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb83e4dd-3c4d-45e1-ba4e-75c342deaf36" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "2737308f-f466-4bcb-a118-7cfb10ef8e05", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "61d44955-9296-46a1-8ad7-cc64e7af4cda" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "281b0461-08f9-40d2-adbd-74613be255b5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc662f1a-11ca-4e56-8214-0648bf042ec8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "38cb4f68-b4bf-44e0-911b-09cafb316a70" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "293ec25a-77b7-4a47-96a9-08cc38efa667", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a4a4a52-2dbb-4afe-962f-9b737058c9f1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c0b280de-6f17-4a28-b3ac-6a9d8c8a5312" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "99e1ed41-a29f-441a-bc73-7e527111dd14" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a7dd795-a770-4c83-85fa-8c3582c68311", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec256011-6df5-4f27-b0d3-de6d1d70bd3f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c6a623e5-32e5-4593-abf6-07d24f6b24dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a85eb42-51e7-42b1-9dce-a1efb110d93d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26bc2641-dd94-46f0-b462-747e57c9e0cf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2af6dfe0-ced7-4238-9684-6ff143495807", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c0b280de-6f17-4a28-b3ac-6a9d8c8a5312" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7760c432-2ed5-4ddb-a4b2-91d1b9fbdc30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "2afda22c-391e-42c0-9037-5364b44ac52c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f7a7ddb6-bf6a-480a-b200-d1d3f52a7c45" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3317213c-3dc1-4157-ae58-293df3e05081" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2b60094e-9048-426f-8f4f-8c9a29374928", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c5f37cc0-70f1-4be1-9da7-069ca0586011" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fed0ddb3-f9cb-438e-a74c-733d2d48aa19" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "2bb3a0a3-5f56-4d99-9658-29eac286a2bd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "411cadcf-9167-4871-86f9-51a648d8641c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "2bd5fb39-6e47-429b-bb76-887de9d1273f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3317213c-3dc1-4157-ae58-293df3e05081" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "afb3adab-ff11-44af-8cdd-f55c8181a93c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2c26340f-a800-4788-b830-25c6cd6d082d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4de2feb-cd3d-4f70-a1eb-d8a1903508ab" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2c3601a4-dd99-4f07-8bed-ef72ddbb24f5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2dbb8a41-cc21-4dc2-97be-9ca27a7bcef5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "82589b98-a0fc-425c-97d6-6652b6d51cc0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "65edef93-ed21-438a-b6a0-819d24a39bcb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "2dfcacf3-44a0-43e6-b638-535d7a93f082", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3aa1a7bf-9dfb-4e94-8d1c-958db451b53e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2e2829b5-653c-49cd-b662-ddb4e7277b1b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26bc2641-dd94-46f0-b462-747e57c9e0cf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2f0e29b3-0103-4065-8693-5c82d6544c6a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "261866e5-b3e7-4e10-ae59-ec790f87b294" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79d5e526-714a-4b0e-9fd5-9271d7879438" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "2f6bd894-2f25-4c8f-9246-c3b7851d5d69", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "2fc780ad-8d25-465a-b5e8-3dd7ad4788ce", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cb179854-2b66-43d8-83b8-4b07a4d31844" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "2fcdbe42-9c0e-4f97-8aa0-8fc0dd92df5e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0c8a6d12-be3b-4d09-9d66-e3f637734439" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dbb97c3d-8b78-4e49-ac77-c624ed04703a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "30cd5bab-219a-49c6-8f6d-9a2e494fec4d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "97918244-9ef3-417d-9b0e-6b1fd9ea43c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a2707293-ffd1-48ab-9e0c-a77cc7939bf8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3124f817-5115-442f-bfee-4900dfc2f9da", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "63d8a14d-6b0f-42f0-98d1-877327ffa8e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "801d856a-cea3-4a17-92ee-eced6ab89f76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "31380dc6-71f7-4206-bba1-b1cc7ea3075c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6575a339-95ef-4c82-816e-b2233063b1ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6320aa52-dd3f-4f78-8fc9-7011f8ebb8f3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3176cf81-1763-46af-949f-913a286200ab", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc662f1a-11ca-4e56-8214-0648bf042ec8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "31dd8d55-685d-451a-98a0-92435eb72fde", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3f93695e-25c4-4ebd-8630-3b0cd908175c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "32ee8dd8-99e4-441e-93bd-eb63e533c87e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3aa1a7bf-9dfb-4e94-8d1c-958db451b53e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "706053cf-bba9-4cc8-80ce-d2bc9be1fb07" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "333b6440-d0d4-4854-89d7-ccebe55f1416", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb577a90-bd8c-4ef8-879d-40f474cfc365" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "47431a96-c2b5-4141-9868-e03d78a4474e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3395d772-1ce7-4816-b3e0-afcd0d7c780a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "23e77dbf-5738-44a8-aeda-55a3c3127168" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "34b46766-6ee8-4905-b593-12cae0c51f35", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8e282073-ba84-4592-ab3d-a8d93afe6689" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a63c692e-bdb2-4498-a467-dc9756efcbeb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "34c16282-66c7-4703-aba1-0fb4c7ab4c57", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "25e90c78-0d44-4f12-a042-6662b31d8bab" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "59935f6f-29d3-4d4f-9845-2bc510234ecc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "356d859a-7040-4184-b8db-f0080543f0cc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8d4d362d-9b04-4b52-99fb-5c05e9b6295a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "35723a8c-9ca0-485c-b9a0-95e55df60e12", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d621e47c-8a97-4d15-bdeb-203c00aceab2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "35b49666-2e82-43f3-bce2-48a1add16601", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2809500a-f66f-42f3-94eb-74a820a5540c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "22289140-fd80-47d7-8e99-4f1ad3c334b7" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3617df77-64d7-4a7d-b547-460d87226858", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f479697d-1715-44e9-8034-b9dad5df7b9d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9ad7f43e-b2b7-4f64-983d-926de4a55200" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "363c01d9-95bf-415b-acf9-394f5c962c78", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbe87031-84bd-433a-81ac-63d50ebae5ea" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "574d7f89-63b5-4e5e-be43-34e93ebe67cb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "36a0a3ab-ea1f-46a1-8f62-f5537cee2714", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "60d531d9-dec9-4caf-ab4b-4b35ee4aa74c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "36e55608-c31d-4a0e-bbeb-665ae1720242", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "27178964-dd35-4182-9859-4902a7128e3a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3706b85a-f089-413e-81ff-4ef4cddd4498", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "992707bf-bb1f-462b-81fd-2837293e396c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "371914f1-3d2c-4b52-8146-afe584ec52de", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fed0ddb3-f9cb-438e-a74c-733d2d48aa19" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "379521ac-197f-4b06-80a3-724ef908c0a3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0994d03f-33de-4bbb-b7dc-0af80cced977" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "37da8537-8cf3-4eb3-939a-0fe871349c88", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d621e47c-8a97-4d15-bdeb-203c00aceab2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b5d34135-03ab-45a4-874f-39426e246174" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "37de4b57-d07e-41db-b6d4-42e2f2303e31", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ebf8616f-5488-4656-8795-a068abbdc1e9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "161fcd8a-1615-4916-aed5-b809e1c992c3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "38167131-9fd7-454a-b2b7-02f66725f105", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3a08993e-1b3a-4e23-bf49-f2fcc21517c4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7184c9db-64e3-4280-94f4-b71d2e44a58f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3a34193f-516c-4265-b186-bd556bc69a48", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d621e47c-8a97-4d15-bdeb-203c00aceab2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3b1fe685-3c17-408b-bbec-93f669e12f13", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "faab4aa8-3679-4cb0-8757-33e87051104d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3b4e0883-c5b6-45c1-bb8c-b94af9aa8075", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "46ca1fdb-6e08-4035-a2e4-c0cf0c95b386" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3ba8cf97-5c4b-4327-a2aa-1e60ebfd8a90", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c966936d-1a42-4fd7-a193-7e75ef4a4533" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c6a623e5-32e5-4593-abf6-07d24f6b24dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3c061600-e4e3-4313-bb80-5641a58d9c9e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "38cb4f68-b4bf-44e0-911b-09cafb316a70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "3d243f40-84bb-440c-b551-f70838e426b4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "05a8c365-05d8-4fd2-9cf7-be4c753f7d8a" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3e1161fd-5812-4de1-8555-cb0d9c6adaf8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4f2055fa-4205-498a-921d-84032e59b8f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3e754590-a9d0-4e9a-b022-b463025786ac", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1965acc8-b7eb-4efd-929c-bf48efe18e8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3e8fabc3-ba8e-4e56-944d-7eb2fb2d96ea", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "973b6cd9-0b74-48c5-a7c9-41b345afe794" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dfff904c-a281-4614-a54c-8967f8606831" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3f2fa34e-87d1-40a4-9b49-1b5bf575ded7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ca35c2e-2f02-4403-b8f2-40edca2f2429" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b4959059-1874-443c-acb3-9b18e70652c3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "3fd5e0f5-42cd-4bcc-a788-c136af1789b8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a04ba62-356b-49a9-8dee-5a1570c7bfc4" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "401299b7-6658-4d0f-9eb8-71a6bad0b618", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "efb7a910-e494-4c3f-92c2-c7f6c342b561" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "951d0c0a-b0e1-462c-b557-298e2fa2ad01" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4045f0ac-6005-4039-a007-bc4915d119c4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4662482-8647-4adc-b2d2-1edc6583524f" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "420f26a7-3257-438a-8246-b3848f6038b7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57861403-9294-4707-bdeb-d96f26f0ee47" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b8d7bddb-60ec-4c4a-a52d-b9c059d4f15b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "424cd409-b2f6-4409-8489-5fca36a95920", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "46ca1fdb-6e08-4035-a2e4-c0cf0c95b386" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa1c1296-1020-4f43-ace8-4358c75ef00d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "42896150-5a2f-4d27-bb90-6b95a775fec3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "542ea848-58d4-4ed3-84eb-4ac10b0b08cc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a34ed745-2d19-420c-8542-d7253d58dbfc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "43492ce0-e112-40d4-af5c-d8315e220b66", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8e282073-ba84-4592-ab3d-a8d93afe6689" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "44326aab-e81e-4e22-aee1-70b1cd83ffff", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f034cc0f-7aad-4943-a4e0-60e05910475e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "44ab9c1b-cdc8-4794-9523-8bf92bf4b2c4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a000f64-344a-4b4f-9d19-5fe966797e94" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "44e975d6-f6db-4c6a-81ff-2b11734494b2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "45575d48-46fe-479c-bffd-ce46e362a0bd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "af3c3468-9cf3-4ad7-a772-97fc045956b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "73c9749a-7ad0-4148-979a-3419b0665a75" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "45a47fa4-278f-4b4e-805c-4d7825263521", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f34e2ad3-8d28-409e-886a-ba6b704a7045" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "45d18849-6e8a-4157-b820-e967c40dc26a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "45ecae71-e099-4305-b9bc-06462ec05e3a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57861403-9294-4707-bdeb-d96f26f0ee47" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2809500a-f66f-42f3-94eb-74a820a5540c" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "467f92fd-e1c3-4971-8634-a64715558c90", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ed94beb8-d6f2-46cc-9f81-50f47f3c4a6a" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "472f5035-8a58-47b9-ac49-75bbd745b19d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b69e4dec-516d-4a00-aea0-15792bbbdbcd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa1c1296-1020-4f43-ace8-4358c75ef00d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "47635972-9f0d-43ea-bc45-3edc9ac7e02c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e3203717-6894-4377-a30e-bd702e3f2bdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4790672e-137c-48ae-a4ea-d625a6237d66", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "06718e1a-65ac-4292-be9f-21297d262a6a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "47c97fd2-a175-4269-8b44-2059b8b9ea3a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "93c0afe0-21e7-4ba5-bd45-c3aece3d981d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a63c692e-bdb2-4498-a467-dc9756efcbeb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "47e960ac-c5f4-4344-a655-2deab88bc880", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57b9a0a2-62ba-402f-8b40-0c1631c10b50" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "426fefcf-cb65-4031-b92e-f02fe3db51ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "495b2bf7-ecf7-499c-9078-c0d75a679df2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b5d34135-03ab-45a4-874f-39426e246174" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "49c7d713-c858-4927-bbfc-5ab6f3a79f95", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3820332b-c40d-4e03-82f8-b38a4cea7338" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4a20d554-3afc-4430-b9d4-b7026ee937ac", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9cab9e54-2d32-4094-bd7f-21ea6c2d189e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4b1731d6-ac55-451b-ac3a-28b9b49a706e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c0b280de-6f17-4a28-b3ac-6a9d8c8a5312" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d16d6a-dadd-4a16-ae47-d57566b019d4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "4be053a2-e15a-4f53-94a8-517fefef0f30", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "14a9aa97-de74-4c30-8fc5-da0d309a46a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3be7d9b8-ffb9-432e-9ed1-6df465f33e71" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "4bfed0e2-61cd-4666-90b3-ec935d50e231", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "333c25e7-ff1e-4ebc-82bf-d11854550375" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9318162d-61a2-425a-afde-e3b50d208af8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4cce9739-2485-44e0-ab2e-f7f8ed41a8cc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fe3e51eb-69b3-42b7-a780-0cebeff6205f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4d1645e8-be83-4d8f-8057-77f9e7a2a8d5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dbb97c3d-8b78-4e49-ac77-c624ed04703a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4d194a33-8657-408e-a1c9-399523c4f6e6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e655cfa1-6086-4068-b176-9ff3d4bf8f62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4d7e10b5-a92a-4a2c-a66f-0c132ec3ad48", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7ee9ecc6-bf6c-4668-9083-f65a40815ea8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ab9bc416-80bd-4089-805c-789e31545aa6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4d8bd7c7-680e-4974-bd85-9218c014f6a3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "27178964-dd35-4182-9859-4902a7128e3a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9ad7f43e-b2b7-4f64-983d-926de4a55200" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "4e1006f1-bc12-4f7a-93fe-cf981efa62c4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f6497cbf-6932-4154-9798-137c6da27325" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "4e1f7bbd-e480-4f4d-996a-3bd6b21db538", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ed94beb8-d6f2-46cc-9f81-50f47f3c4a6a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4e6676e0-13ee-4798-8cf4-c33f7bb58123", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cfd53b11-128b-42d9-bb09-4e4e2e3694e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4fede9ad-0614-4c7b-b090-84f065d7e02f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "4f573213-61bc-4823-8724-da491ad0d744", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "136d454a-89ac-4b50-941a-1e7656c78155" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "801d856a-cea3-4a17-92ee-eced6ab89f76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "4f6374ba-49fa-4c22-a4eb-aca6fb32fdc5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "53b04e07-fba8-4582-b272-f6fa4633b7be" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "4f869278-3642-4e88-aac7-6263dcb3c33a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "4fec6cf6-9d41-47c1-a0ac-c102fc55a1fe", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbe87031-84bd-433a-81ac-63d50ebae5ea" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "387ecd16-14f3-4358-b66e-e1f85ce68b3e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "50590bab-97ec-4c83-a266-9cf3fc1fa2ed", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e2d276e5-92f9-4b67-ba69-9ef84e8236f4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5256b95-4c9d-40d5-b9c3-bb6b595f33ed" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "50c10989-56a3-47a1-86dd-20be107cc953", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "31595a8b-0736-49d9-8499-bdac3eb30ba2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "973b6cd9-0b74-48c5-a7c9-41b345afe794" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5101f2b2-d2db-4a51-9845-e3b8132cc7d8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "51316699-f60f-4a3d-b8a3-3fac7ae56eaa", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3d923c0e-5f8b-4072-9143-12a0fc515754" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "521f5dc4-3e3e-4ee2-9871-9be9f052ae7e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "11e613a5-265c-4e41-9f3e-6e57b0e85070" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "52d182eb-a5cf-454a-a5dc-920a91f02832", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ebf8616f-5488-4656-8795-a068abbdc1e9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4c4622e-a62e-4237-ac58-b7a6237552a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "531c7b21-00d6-4b48-988f-2e0b527ecfcf", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "860f792c-a2cf-4910-b19f-40770e725608" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "531cb3ee-c843-4b06-8b3b-774ed86f1e6e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "82589b98-a0fc-425c-97d6-6652b6d51cc0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "973b6cd9-0b74-48c5-a7c9-41b345afe794" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "53251880-b064-47cb-9f0d-faf9c43fa682", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c6a623e5-32e5-4593-abf6-07d24f6b24dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "54243d96-7d09-43e4-8aee-248757c976b8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "07341118-f915-45a5-8869-926a1d846203" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "85d17542-cfdb-41a9-8ac6-1a72b4afa99b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "542c131b-62f3-4892-af5e-49b91685a4dc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "59935f6f-29d3-4d4f-9845-2bc510234ecc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "553f3b0f-3a18-411c-b215-027dea3d69b4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a04ba62-356b-49a9-8dee-5a1570c7bfc4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "55573d33-0955-4e60-9f0a-d6389a9d1d79", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a63c692e-bdb2-4498-a467-dc9756efcbeb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "55b97177-ab67-40df-9d13-03d92e39eb0c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e4703a89-cc78-41b8-8298-4ae9f7bba564" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "56077304-ad61-42b9-b417-29a28d8f45b4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "333c25e7-ff1e-4ebc-82bf-d11854550375" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "563c6b06-1769-40aa-a7d4-103e53f876f5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "97faa5d1-e102-4ee2-a760-1af6a5edd038" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7760c432-2ed5-4ddb-a4b2-91d1b9fbdc30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "567b8088-3be7-4a89-b7e8-bef0b53186e4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "62a3c921-de58-4619-a49a-fe19ea30382c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "5784776b-37f9-41cf-9f06-e3ac713606a3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5f14375-4f8e-470f-9d1b-82de1770b999" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5900e288-d150-4b00-b429-7694d18daa29", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "59183794-1ebc-411e-b788-f9e21c9c942c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a83b80db-29b2-463f-9b4a-11eb86307e57" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "5a0f3c5f-af54-4933-9e23-d0b3f159d944", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "64685c38-cf6c-4b2c-8e60-024bbf821690" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "73c9749a-7ad0-4148-979a-3419b0665a75" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "5a8a8ba4-21c1-426d-be62-80001b43f212", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "01f29c4e-d2be-4931-8cad-bbde9bcbd6af" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "5abab6c7-79d1-4322-816a-7018d82cc6b6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3992f96a-f563-48f3-aa69-78977148724c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "be4714b4-6a53-4578-9319-31c816a88271" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5bb6542b-177c-40cf-947f-fa1b1b99b8f5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c41b0961-1c3a-4813-bebc-0119d78f4850" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c2d3143-ae76-4e84-90aa-c259d68335d2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "23e77dbf-5738-44a8-aeda-55a3c3127168" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c73f3d1-d4a7-4d9f-86ea-6a674a03de2c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f3fd41de-27b5-40ec-bfaf-12e68a5407a8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a83b80db-29b2-463f-9b4a-11eb86307e57" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c82cfe1-2878-49ec-9fc6-974127c52ef7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8d4d362d-9b04-4b52-99fb-5c05e9b6295a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5cbe2196-2993-47e4-8f13-de065baedc69", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcc76b61-937d-4212-865e-c9fad5e7e7eb" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "5cca73d2-54a1-44de-a0e1-86b8c94dc2c6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5ca5e9be-c051-494c-96d4-b7c12faf83b9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5cd1f433-b19c-4a3f-b163-d56d5f47b965", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "62a3c921-de58-4619-a49a-fe19ea30382c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4c563fc0-1e01-4025-8a74-3a5f002eb323" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "5d4e70fd-f22d-42bd-9816-1a03ba3d8016", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e8650e58-d232-45af-b3a3-a6f9fd05a5a5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "542ea848-58d4-4ed3-84eb-4ac10b0b08cc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5d5d4bb9-047f-4e78-8b37-13235dc610d3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6575a339-95ef-4c82-816e-b2233063b1ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fdfa9546-89b5-4433-a7b8-7db81ae8dcc4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "5eb9da03-dee9-4d0d-a954-6cfe9a251f6b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ddb1b808-c88c-48ac-aec4-d7331a6a2740" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "5f4670b2-7d97-4f4d-9904-c61aba23a61e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "5fe9240d-e820-445b-a8fb-7e41cf128ffc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e3203717-6894-4377-a30e-bd702e3f2bdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4de2feb-cd3d-4f70-a1eb-d8a1903508ab" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "607e6353-5719-47b3-84c4-e5ac8ae15b54", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "30b0276c-b4d3-45b8-a84f-1c74f5d6a289" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6096c1e0-dc7b-4a08-8f1b-bae9a7c2083e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "542ea848-58d4-4ed3-84eb-4ac10b0b08cc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d0b6708b-6979-4c48-a509-5a54608c68ea" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "60a70a0d-d949-44db-9f66-ace27932a3b1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ba434d88-a30b-4842-9dcd-f2026aa43748" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c8a1ad03-9721-4f7e-a43a-63096a064fb0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "61f9f64a-b5e8-441b-a6f7-1a7c66d3b721", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "97faec91-4c1b-4990-85f4-dffbfe21992f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3d923c0e-5f8b-4072-9143-12a0fc515754" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6243dcf6-6fd9-4c54-86e5-99e076d5a2ce", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aeba6664-3fb8-4504-92a1-ae9bc09b9748" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4de2feb-cd3d-4f70-a1eb-d8a1903508ab" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6264e04c-1849-441b-8ef2-89836c67825d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "39807624-ecf9-42b1-ad74-44470f1e9d25" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24b477df-7dc1-4b60-83b6-e5cd0f6e4ba2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "62cd83d6-4f40-4ad1-a35a-33a2702c11e5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa8ed847-6e0b-4387-a4aa-73028595ebdb" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "63452a4d-4a11-4801-84bb-bfadefc189e9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "97faec91-4c1b-4990-85f4-dffbfe21992f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "64714fab-7ee5-43ba-925e-aa830de8b35c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "67883681-3630-4e4f-b6a1-f1d963e5e38b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "67ab6b10-5d95-4381-89ea-dad04db02bae" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6602c043-8c5e-47e4-b310-edf7efc4b2d2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5f489a08-27dc-4e54-af9a-45e8ac5aa174" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "665027b0-4cef-418c-84c9-613137e350fe", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4c563fc0-1e01-4025-8a74-3a5f002eb323" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "668bad54-903d-437d-badc-26d523e9c40e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "64685c38-cf6c-4b2c-8e60-024bbf821690" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "66db47de-4796-4819-a222-3d8119949dcf", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fe3e51eb-69b3-42b7-a780-0cebeff6205f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "671cf030-3d32-4ad5-a569-f78c9800a08f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b69e4dec-516d-4a00-aea0-15792bbbdbcd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "685dccd3-f1d2-4d8c-8ca7-6fac8a0c05e5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcfe026f-1fa9-4b1c-b974-3162dba4847b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5256b95-4c9d-40d5-b9c3-bb6b595f33ed" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "687330b7-9ec5-4256-aeac-e9150f400c24", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3ef0c670-92d6-4d34-a5b6-cd85d0d6bd58" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "691f170e-acf9-456e-bf67-d602454e5a50", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "93c0afe0-21e7-4ba5-bd45-c3aece3d981d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "38cb4f68-b4bf-44e0-911b-09cafb316a70" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "69505510-9b9f-4c94-bfe1-93e1a540d7d1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9560ec33-8c59-4d8f-ae99-ad3b8ce90559" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6989cdac-6921-4a81-bbb5-b444f384b84d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3a270350-ad78-4543-9685-4dc44fa76843" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d0ce7312-240b-4ef0-9081-6ad997d5e274" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "69d7595a-a4eb-4517-be69-a444225583b0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "63d8a14d-6b0f-42f0-98d1-877327ffa8e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8647cdb2-ede5-4b11-a8e9-721d6b93554f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "69e7ec37-634f-4224-8097-0d0302d8825b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c8a1ad03-9721-4f7e-a43a-63096a064fb0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "69f56983-da87-4a81-b6b7-8078f644bc10", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bcfb7e08-e00e-4b35-8a2d-24dd53679db9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "de54ab4b-cf6a-4905-8277-17f147e28adc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "69fd6681-3166-4644-8eae-379684303265", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f725ff14-0ced-453a-87b0-f19f7c11fdbc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2bb66093-07a3-4c75-a581-33d1b774ffcb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a03dcb0-6d80-4d52-8d96-49d4df1352b8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "973b6cd9-0b74-48c5-a7c9-41b345afe794" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a57f261-744e-43bb-8196-d9f5d171d659", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bd725f2e-b2d8-40e5-9371-43a50946d0b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4c563fc0-1e01-4025-8a74-3a5f002eb323" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a9b6ff7-3f26-4027-b3f1-de5068794ce0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1cfdc75c-d92a-413c-824c-a184971b22db" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9318162d-61a2-425a-afde-e3b50d208af8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6aaca533-3b40-436f-b064-293ec4198d6f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa1c1296-1020-4f43-ace8-4358c75ef00d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6b28933f-0d52-4889-88fc-01e0e25bcfea", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6b670284-6ec9-46a9-8290-a4c3866b5d43", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fbd1b4b5-b531-4b16-822d-53a96d24297e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "219fd67f-a29e-4467-9ec3-826187c1be37" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6b68f7c6-fe9a-425c-a855-377257f2bc24", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "874e362a-6f3e-429c-800d-620ef5af7e74" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c351816-49a6-4d71-907e-96f038791bad", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6cc00a7e-0035-42a5-ac45-02497e9fd6b0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a67b6ee-3966-40b9-908f-84edaa5f7a95" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6df2c619-dde2-4401-98e8-f6039242ebfd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "972ebb02-4c92-4843-b686-8048e6aa6b4e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dce4736c-147a-418b-a53e-037ae4717aa1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6e17a0f2-7667-414d-b920-1f21a12f5121", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79d5e526-714a-4b0e-9fd5-9271d7879438" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6eb46368-9226-43c6-9de5-fb80294552b8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "41ad2d7e-54fc-46db-ad0f-6b781304415e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "6fcb1be1-285e-4b74-af45-c11d8e8d053a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "6fd7ae37-a41c-4010-84bb-e87c9b781872", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1cfdc75c-d92a-413c-824c-a184971b22db" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "70311154-c19c-403e-a9da-dbdbf09b1a85", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "11e613a5-265c-4e41-9f3e-6e57b0e85070" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "71580572-c6bc-41ce-be46-149b23aefc9c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f7a7ddb6-bf6a-480a-b200-d1d3f52a7c45" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "72216471-01bf-499e-835a-bc127b0e84ee", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9893251d-cfb0-478a-91b2-158604337310" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a63c692e-bdb2-4498-a467-dc9756efcbeb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "728fcab4-63dc-4a97-9e65-fe9f8ea7a3b2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c966936d-1a42-4fd7-a193-7e75ef4a4533" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "73c72227-4e78-44af-849f-64f45ba36428", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "219fd67f-a29e-4467-9ec3-826187c1be37" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "73e82d6d-09f2-4443-b53f-83d02ffb1828", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "edba9ad8-c6f4-4e40-b751-6ceee442afed" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "744357df-821c-4d49-98dc-4e7dc7871632", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "67883681-3630-4e4f-b6a1-f1d963e5e38b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6de863b9-f235-468c-b259-bce24db75618" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "75b60637-0672-4221-8086-25f9015ce818", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ed593ba-2ec2-424e-bdd1-b4680256c1fa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "85d17542-cfdb-41a9-8ac6-1a72b4afa99b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "75bdef8e-b318-46c8-b013-b27ca14dd139", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "59935f6f-29d3-4d4f-9845-2bc510234ecc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "75c7da62-ed6e-4472-9089-7e6f4c249742", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e8650e58-d232-45af-b3a3-a6f9fd05a5a5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a34ed745-2d19-420c-8542-d7253d58dbfc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "75d61b29-d0f4-4d1c-9177-dfd153c5e980", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4c4622e-a62e-4237-ac58-b7a6237552a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fed0ddb3-f9cb-438e-a74c-733d2d48aa19" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7620096a-293b-41e8-8b95-2fb5550fa09d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e2d276e5-92f9-4b67-ba69-9ef84e8236f4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "764e4314-cc4b-4b75-b4b5-d308f2560ad0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "65949e1a-e717-44ca-bf32-ae1d05689dc0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "768d1572-ce95-4dbf-bdac-b6930cc44a99", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa8ed847-6e0b-4387-a4aa-73028595ebdb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "76a045dc-fea8-4c80-be52-e1fc9cc59ac4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "860f792c-a2cf-4910-b19f-40770e725608" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b1643796-38c5-416f-843d-20dacbccbee6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "76a9b241-a4e9-443e-ab4d-879242c0757f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a59d8fdb-5b4d-4ff0-ac9e-23d1755fa5ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a2707293-ffd1-48ab-9e0c-a77cc7939bf8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "7725fc0a-41cf-4b9a-aebf-5691b3becffd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b9e5c7e2-56df-4fc9-934a-fe2f1bc4b16b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "774336e6-e12e-45ab-b5f5-1431be173529", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9318162d-61a2-425a-afde-e3b50d208af8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7754f01f-319e-4db3-86f0-783048fb2028", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "574d7f89-63b5-4e5e-be43-34e93ebe67cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "800301b2-1de7-48ac-acba-4fbbb76af49d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "779e2fa1-ca08-46f4-b1a6-33080043009e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "89d9b1f4-8dfd-4b71-81d0-71bbeb4aba1d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fdfa9546-89b5-4433-a7b8-7db81ae8dcc4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7807dee2-9665-4e12-929c-38d2b1024597", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "efb7a910-e494-4c3f-92c2-c7f6c342b561" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "161fcd8a-1615-4916-aed5-b809e1c992c3" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "781f809e-0549-462f-9c02-d86ea509303b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "330dc552-e5ff-4fad-86a6-22e3ee2d243a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "788b7280-bb7d-46d3-8812-1fb589d1edee", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c966936d-1a42-4fd7-a193-7e75ef4a4533" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a67b6ee-3966-40b9-908f-84edaa5f7a95" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "78a63d3b-4ef1-4b4b-b3f2-81dbde2de085", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2390fcf6-4d39-41cc-b7a4-b9ef5c733196" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b24d6fdb-a5c4-4390-97d6-91ba22f9a9d6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "78bb9872-4286-4824-b346-a02df120e8f5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b9e5c7e2-56df-4fc9-934a-fe2f1bc4b16b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "78d2a19d-07c0-4c54-bb62-eaa5666df65b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4c563fc0-1e01-4025-8a74-3a5f002eb323" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a5b0382-79a5-4b76-8bfb-e2947e9ea1b5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6575a339-95ef-4c82-816e-b2233063b1ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a95a435-674f-40b0-a096-e1288cced3fc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "261866e5-b3e7-4e10-ae59-ec790f87b294" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "7b346e82-2dcb-4385-abbf-ddb11408fd5e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ed593ba-2ec2-424e-bdd1-b4680256c1fa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "7c0a990b-ab1c-4f29-aea1-9cb5ef8bdefc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "75493a86-5dc0-4dce-a7dc-f1fd3dcc0db1" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7c131aec-075d-40f5-94d0-25739de2cc4c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dfff904c-a281-4614-a54c-8967f8606831" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ddb1b808-c88c-48ac-aec4-d7331a6a2740" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7c841803-38d9-420b-86c3-b30b014af44c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "85d17542-cfdb-41a9-8ac6-1a72b4afa99b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7c955c40-9a93-4405-9d7d-4262a98de3b1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a4da8d17-68f6-406b-b092-f2039ac3328d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "7cec727b-7c5a-4d2d-a678-67a9f7881c30", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb577a90-bd8c-4ef8-879d-40f474cfc365" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "7e5d6911-3234-4caa-8ad8-510d4f3ea5df", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dca768ee-3417-49fb-a511-f08a19ead2c9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7f99cd7f-9511-4d7a-8983-aa468181bd61", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4fede9ad-0614-4c7b-b090-84f065d7e02f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5e77bd42-29da-411f-9bf1-6f9944f5b320" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "7fa21924-bbf9-4515-b8fd-16250dd6c619", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4c4622e-a62e-4237-ac58-b7a6237552a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "951d0c0a-b0e1-462c-b557-298e2fa2ad01" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "7ff3356b-9965-4840-b005-119009621406", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9ad7f43e-b2b7-4f64-983d-926de4a55200" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8036a5ad-4e1d-40bb-8a4c-2fcf33c0b7a5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8647cdb2-ede5-4b11-a8e9-721d6b93554f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8093aae6-14b7-449c-84e0-3abc3257fc3a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "542ea848-58d4-4ed3-84eb-4ac10b0b08cc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7c6bbf00-5e63-42eb-8865-68c722f887ec" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8161502b-b619-4882-b723-8d4101d6d1fc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc1b1872-c5c0-47e1-b758-8215da6e2636" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "81d22534-1036-4532-bd5b-e06c9db832a9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbe87031-84bd-433a-81ac-63d50ebae5ea" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "800301b2-1de7-48ac-acba-4fbbb76af49d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "822d1fd1-5a9f-4d8d-87c2-d68bf85a296a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79d5e526-714a-4b0e-9fd5-9271d7879438" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b4959059-1874-443c-acb3-9b18e70652c3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8235bb92-d190-4ffc-b4c3-b0bac77fd5f5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "010a3fd2-5446-4ff7-aadb-3d8601245590" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20735ee2-2ff1-4c81-98fd-8fdc78e8d870" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "828aa1db-dd7c-4fcf-a0db-160d48068bbd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4ba71112-e314-452b-a979-4bffb7a933fa" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "830945b8-5346-4aa7-b869-01c9b9d481f3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "69441906-da2a-4d49-ab15-ce5b9f983e57" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1e8aeba7-38fa-4c67-aef3-0a4d1af377f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "83547740-1151-4b96-8de5-4db0f2c33ad0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7ee9ecc6-bf6c-4668-9083-f65a40815ea8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "838136f5-9666-4c5d-ac3d-d9a9e0236341", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aeba6664-3fb8-4504-92a1-ae9bc09b9748" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b24d6fdb-a5c4-4390-97d6-91ba22f9a9d6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "83c66f99-bd4a-4f5f-b21c-76c9176e0fb1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fad86b2d-d2f3-4f6e-b9a6-51aa05877d30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "83e2c2f2-f56d-4716-8b45-d62c5fc30cac", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "48301d12-b28f-4020-8125-eb6c6953ff12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "11270349-828e-4b1b-8f11-88e8e3827992" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "84c89328-ad70-408f-931c-d12098d9fc1b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3c8e64f6-d359-4184-9e52-c05ecb8e2f82" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "857b0131-af44-4929-8153-e976db3cab60", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "64685c38-cf6c-4b2c-8e60-024bbf821690" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "85eb45cf-ecea-4484-9485-564d4b197ca3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f479697d-1715-44e9-8034-b9dad5df7b9d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "27178964-dd35-4182-9859-4902a7128e3a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "86064296-1dcc-48a1-84a1-8e54b120aee5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a43d964e-6754-4eb3-bda9-27cde37227f3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8610f2d4-f7e9-4cff-85f5-8d48600723cd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "161fcd8a-1615-4916-aed5-b809e1c992c3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "efb7a910-e494-4c3f-92c2-c7f6c342b561" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "86b49a80-94c7-4d92-a3d3-aa4b21bcb44a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "31595a8b-0736-49d9-8499-bdac3eb30ba2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "87180211-7fb4-4918-b412-6349bb75d107", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8764ede5-cf9e-4327-b5b9-3d03a08317d3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c93f9a0c-8fc1-415b-9e0f-839ef142a099" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "87ce8b0a-1876-4a2a-b477-7bee5a5fc439", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5f489a08-27dc-4e54-af9a-45e8ac5aa174" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8976a31f-5f80-4b11-b69a-0e858846cccf", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57b9a0a2-62ba-402f-8b40-0c1631c10b50" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7760c432-2ed5-4ddb-a4b2-91d1b9fbdc30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8a29aef0-4e1e-40c2-83b2-26700c8d4032", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "46ca1fdb-6e08-4035-a2e4-c0cf0c95b386" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8ac0bd4d-58e6-4aeb-97b2-6b2052eac7d2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bd725f2e-b2d8-40e5-9371-43a50946d0b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "8aef7e12-49fe-46ce-a6f4-62ebece0ba3f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "60d531d9-dec9-4caf-ab4b-4b35ee4aa74c" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8af03929-df20-46bb-8661-79696d74ad4c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "01f29c4e-d2be-4931-8cad-bbde9bcbd6af" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3be7d9b8-ffb9-432e-9ed1-6df465f33e71" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "8b189c5c-3ae3-4b2e-82a2-e712ba8c7aea", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0920d791-9326-46e7-8918-b33ace773da0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8b471e5f-276f-4c90-8c11-67835cccbbaa", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc02223c-f419-4e53-98a6-07977628c18d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcc76b61-937d-4212-865e-c9fad5e7e7eb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8bc81f45-4bb0-4d69-a898-40e79809ebf8", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e3203717-6894-4377-a30e-bd702e3f2bdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "225de32d-6bb1-4e41-ab7d-ee83d32a3108" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8c5eee43-0dd0-491d-a3aa-1bd8d5f31be6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4fede9ad-0614-4c7b-b090-84f065d7e02f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8cefee7c-45dc-4b16-8b96-d0502ea9b18b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8d51b9e2-0e9d-41ca-bc88-193c1277e899", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c93f9a0c-8fc1-415b-9e0f-839ef142a099" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8d72651c-5a72-42ad-ab2b-51c7357ac82b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "05a384fc-f8cc-49a3-951f-69c7f81f5da8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f0d92175-633d-4266-b3d2-a5a023576275" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8d770568-2f02-4300-bf5d-3e420f8c868e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "30b0276c-b4d3-45b8-a84f-1c74f5d6a289" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a8a49f5e-82cc-4c62-bc6d-8c44fe1c58e9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8dd893d2-f8c6-47d9-a668-c9a87bf3799c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "06718e1a-65ac-4292-be9f-21297d262a6a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9318162d-61a2-425a-afde-e3b50d208af8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "8de7666b-e4ce-40ab-b80b-7251cf8e5cfc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "74cfe77b-21eb-4767-b758-7cfd5e7ae38e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8e0c7a96-e89f-42e9-93f1-e85195c3451e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3be7d9b8-ffb9-432e-9ed1-6df465f33e71" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "485197d8-a13b-4191-9948-6c28cf2f03b3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "8fa2584c-10b4-4b9d-a7eb-84f76b14ee49", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3317213c-3dc1-4157-ae58-293df3e05081" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb3e3da6-d418-4d18-98e9-d48c500d754c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8fa3d34e-2c11-488e-a295-8ce30cd493cf", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3aa1a7bf-9dfb-4e94-8d1c-958db451b53e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "73c9749a-7ad0-4148-979a-3419b0665a75" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "8fbc57ad-a946-4598-85d3-d9b7e0bab663", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a43d964e-6754-4eb3-bda9-27cde37227f3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "9025c16d-01cb-4928-b68e-ec1b1cf75183", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d621e47c-8a97-4d15-bdeb-203c00aceab2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5256b95-4c9d-40d5-b9c3-bb6b595f33ed" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "903c6cd5-1c35-4e11-bee5-9acd3f41dac3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec256011-6df5-4f27-b0d3-de6d1d70bd3f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "90720f83-111d-4787-9219-669f7ea0b15b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec94d500-fd48-47ed-8550-9cd490fe56cf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ccdae101-399e-4985-a64d-d9e3a4e0cada" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "910c55ed-ddbb-4917-9507-2b6acfc0bde5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "97faa5d1-e102-4ee2-a760-1af6a5edd038" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b1643796-38c5-416f-843d-20dacbccbee6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "92ee4358-807f-4c7e-8665-6bac52f60045", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "939f54c5-be8c-43a2-b2e8-c2c25fe90876", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "387ecd16-14f3-4358-b66e-e1f85ce68b3e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "943534da-2171-4eaf-ad1b-e5759fed1e7f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3a270350-ad78-4543-9685-4dc44fa76843" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1ec657b6-8be7-4d03-b95a-8961ffd2164e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "9527dbdc-5b63-4903-9c65-d90a29abbe2b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9574e464-4c98-45b5-88d7-5507e9036dc0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7c6bbf00-5e63-42eb-8865-68c722f887ec" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "542ea848-58d4-4ed3-84eb-4ac10b0b08cc" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "962f3f3b-6b64-4cf0-8bb1-3c2dbf2a576b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aeba6664-3fb8-4504-92a1-ae9bc09b9748" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "96c4e639-721b-4364-824d-2dc82710b45f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9717c147-75ab-46cd-b612-f61ef3080460", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "39807624-ecf9-42b1-ad74-44470f1e9d25" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "944a5265-ec30-43a4-9e10-1407c5cfca95" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "97443df9-58be-4dc1-9f92-c81200c81880", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "82589b98-a0fc-425c-97d6-6652b6d51cc0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "97f307a1-2906-41e2-afaa-73e2ae7cad24", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dfab1dcc-56fc-4cc3-a39b-514025d8d21d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "74cfe77b-21eb-4767-b758-7cfd5e7ae38e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "9872bf68-880c-4552-95d8-e3594d76f709", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa8ed847-6e0b-4387-a4aa-73028595ebdb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fe332627-3c75-4958-939c-122d94b62e4c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "987f33dd-04f3-46dc-b526-07df3800b3cb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ae39b8b3-06ce-4b48-ad01-66cdc6beecce" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "989eefbd-799a-4e2a-afba-8a9db13ffb1a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "228801c6-3918-4a57-9acd-432fab72ec48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "86476bb7-18bd-40d9-95f2-e184e963fa99" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "98b4dfd5-9de8-43e3-a8c1-c560412806cc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d82726fe-35a0-4540-aad4-b06f34daaab8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "991f8d4e-d470-4b0c-8a7c-f9a7c1705b0d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3e09914b-2c64-4969-b9a8-1c4db650b698" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9950ae0b-ace9-47e6-a8ff-42da715a696e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "064dcb37-4dce-4b21-a0b1-de1cbbc71a13" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5fa3376-a63e-45f2-be6a-b5e13ae20abc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "99d3f76b-3cf9-40ee-993e-c7aa943f9b18", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dfab1dcc-56fc-4cc3-a39b-514025d8d21d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "9a2a064b-15b4-4cc5-9619-206164a95e7a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "60d531d9-dec9-4caf-ab4b-4b35ee4aa74c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b4959059-1874-443c-acb3-9b18e70652c3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9a38a59b-74bb-4536-806b-61a41b7194bb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e630e5a6-30ba-489b-995d-c930eb133440" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9a39f106-b9d7-4eb2-8353-42ca45bf2d59", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f3fd41de-27b5-40ec-bfaf-12e68a5407a8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "9a653b40-2cae-4c89-bd7a-caa1b954d49d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e007fe12-f9a7-4703-a5ea-589fa644bf8c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3f7f42e9-2af3-40ca-ba42-d6faa7dd653d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "9b0971d2-fa9c-45b6-b7ce-85c581ee4a52", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcfe026f-1fa9-4b1c-b974-3162dba4847b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d621e47c-8a97-4d15-bdeb-203c00aceab2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "9b23bcf0-7a08-4b8e-b0ac-70b85c9ebc3f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "874e362a-6f3e-429c-800d-620ef5af7e74" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9c5e2099-262c-44e9-95e7-10a25a1763cf", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb83e4dd-3c4d-45e1-ba4e-75c342deaf36" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "426fefcf-cb65-4031-b92e-f02fe3db51ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "9cb026cc-933a-4c08-8b4c-8b13bf31c8b2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "38cb4f68-b4bf-44e0-911b-09cafb316a70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "992707bf-bb1f-462b-81fd-2837293e396c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "9d8bcace-763a-477d-b53f-45d663b7cd92", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "333c25e7-ff1e-4ebc-82bf-d11854550375" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dd5c2811-756e-47a6-87c9-4f0a1e405018" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9e907477-7a19-4dd0-b091-cd3cc4577210", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "69441906-da2a-4d49-ab15-ce5b9f983e57" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9ecd097a-cec1-4a8e-8db6-7be2bf5cf4dd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "330dc552-e5ff-4fad-86a6-22e3ee2d243a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "9f7443a5-a177-49a3-b6a4-06493fd8bee9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "56f7d4e0-fa99-402e-b187-532729ccfa41" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1ad1ed66-cd65-4657-8230-80838a83704f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "9f9d3efa-2caf-41ec-bfa4-e2357274609a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "295c867a-750d-4987-9e7a-90b0d5c976e9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a038378b-417d-4331-9cfe-1c985a6c177b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57b9a0a2-62ba-402f-8b40-0c1631c10b50" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3c8e64f6-d359-4184-9e52-c05ecb8e2f82" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a04885bc-75ee-46a4-aee3-bb9292762371", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3c4be7f2-7405-4f68-95c2-648afbdb6212" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3be7d9b8-ffb9-432e-9ed1-6df465f33e71" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "a04fad0b-74c8-40b4-9d2a-19d25a3936d5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "75493a86-5dc0-4dce-a7dc-f1fd3dcc0db1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dd5c2811-756e-47a6-87c9-4f0a1e405018" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a0684756-a278-4fdd-bb58-18cd8af9f98a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f725ff14-0ced-453a-87b0-f19f7c11fdbc" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a06f66a6-26ec-4e73-9366-3a1d89cf1fe5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9893251d-cfb0-478a-91b2-158604337310" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f3fd41de-27b5-40ec-bfaf-12e68a5407a8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "a143aa1f-566c-4d52-b8ef-cc066dd7fedb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f3fd41de-27b5-40ec-bfaf-12e68a5407a8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a16126bb-4219-4b3e-8340-16aece75f1a6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "de54ab4b-cf6a-4905-8277-17f147e28adc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a1d150ba-a84b-4366-a1d9-03c0e6d41768", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c966936d-1a42-4fd7-a193-7e75ef4a4533" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a24644bd-a727-4f90-83be-48b979206a5c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3ef0c670-92d6-4d34-a5b6-cd85d0d6bd58" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a2ba285f-b85c-4b65-a592-69e1086880b0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcc76b61-937d-4212-865e-c9fad5e7e7eb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a338d7f2-28e5-4be6-a4e1-a625c297db32", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1ad1ed66-cd65-4657-8230-80838a83704f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a33b3497-5d6a-4a78-9de4-5436a7072a01", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc1b1872-c5c0-47e1-b758-8215da6e2636" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "a3c548fb-4de0-4eec-92a8-9426ad2ae461", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ca35c2e-2f02-4403-b8f2-40edca2f2429" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a402c32d-6699-4227-8dc8-3c1de0e03829", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "574d7f89-63b5-4e5e-be43-34e93ebe67cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a4389b9c-c853-4f49-8a5a-237a6c1da12e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a4eeac05-bc54-4369-9dcc-2910cb50b80b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a000f64-344a-4b4f-9d19-5fe966797e94" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a5051d03-6345-4837-bf11-80fb1ac4b642", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e2d276e5-92f9-4b67-ba69-9ef84e8236f4" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a5c26639-94e7-40a1-9f1f-529817fa4d3c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "de54ab4b-cf6a-4905-8277-17f147e28adc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b5d34135-03ab-45a4-874f-39426e246174" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a5cc554b-a905-4c69-8d54-6e47377ed248", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a5d924a5-ef7e-4c52-b565-1eee9852ea05", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e007fe12-f9a7-4703-a5ea-589fa644bf8c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0c8a6d12-be3b-4d09-9d66-e3f637734439" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "a5fc7d42-bd2b-4836-8f1f-bf10664326b1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2390fcf6-4d39-41cc-b7a4-b9ef5c733196" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a660d47d-e24e-4cb0-8077-8328fbe12ff0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "97918244-9ef3-417d-9b0e-6b1fd9ea43c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "74e657fe-1a19-4cac-a38c-51e87d1b3325" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a6df36b2-8a84-44a8-ac48-6d0211299606", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "84b0d1c9-e09d-4b62-9231-32eccd3867a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a7288a07-6949-4fe1-8a39-4347f6410049", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "93c0afe0-21e7-4ba5-bd45-c3aece3d981d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f3fd41de-27b5-40ec-bfaf-12e68a5407a8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "a7aabb4d-621b-4e37-bd0d-d52071493609", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e4703a89-cc78-41b8-8298-4ae9f7bba564" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a7e0485e-8983-4955-a154-9fc897011563", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c5f37cc0-70f1-4be1-9da7-069ca0586011" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4c4622e-a62e-4237-ac58-b7a6237552a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a7f1bbd0-8d56-4d61-96cf-0457b789c047", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c12afe37-a045-4e5c-8c1e-00e74e5dadfe" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fad86b2d-d2f3-4f6e-b9a6-51aa05877d30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8638698-1811-4cce-9866-20f5c1841dfc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "05a8c365-05d8-4fd2-9cf7-be4c753f7d8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3743c9eb-2878-4574-bbdb-3b43e3d3e1b0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a871b268-cc4b-4010-a3ed-cc77aeb90a61", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "973b6cd9-0b74-48c5-a7c9-41b345afe794" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a89e98ae-8bd2-4f94-964b-4740aa846e64", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4f9b54c4-af0c-4a74-8839-20a1424e2248" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "31a2b6c4-66e8-47ab-884d-211859df7763" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8b9eb46-9dd6-446e-8768-34fe34562678", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc02223c-f419-4e53-98a6-07977628c18d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f9a800-3cda-4e12-9e56-c31436684385" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8cb6449-d28e-4c2f-a114-c31134a0ef40", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3aa1a7bf-9dfb-4e94-8d1c-958db451b53e" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8ee2b4d-1327-40c6-a51f-d029f3d27b9d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "58b19bc4-37e7-4544-84b7-3bd1288e4dee" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "772edee2-e028-462c-9f49-20864f1c3de7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a91d1416-34df-48cc-8e67-9ab766652513", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9323af51-66ef-4b3e-92eb-a35aa26f8bd1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a9245377-38a2-4b24-af93-85ccc160c6b3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa8ed847-6e0b-4387-a4aa-73028595ebdb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "11e613a5-265c-4e41-9f3e-6e57b0e85070" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "a967646c-7c99-45d8-88b6-c36971929034", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "de54ab4b-cf6a-4905-8277-17f147e28adc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "74cfe77b-21eb-4767-b758-7cfd5e7ae38e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "a98e47a4-7f1e-4844-bf24-ab429878d3d6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "aa599672-3fdb-4461-87cc-0eb6b8ae46b1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "aa844c54-2a1c-4492-9625-4279d4eae363", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f7a7ddb6-bf6a-480a-b200-d1d3f52a7c45" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1e8aeba7-38fa-4c67-aef3-0a4d1af377f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ab39cdb5-0a90-4e1e-937f-5b5e6d14d82a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57861403-9294-4707-bdeb-d96f26f0ee47" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "191a7cb2-af7d-41e0-8481-96ab2785f9f2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "abf6c8db-3f97-42ec-9e69-8ced9503296e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c5f37cc0-70f1-4be1-9da7-069ca0586011" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "951d0c0a-b0e1-462c-b557-298e2fa2ad01" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "abfc2b36-259a-40ae-82b2-f747e4b46262", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3f93695e-25c4-4ebd-8630-3b0cd908175c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6efe893-8fdb-4b33-933c-6d2e478b18c9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "aca8277e-f3ce-4e3e-8d05-49d0c1925402", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ed593ba-2ec2-424e-bdd1-b4680256c1fa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b5d34135-03ab-45a4-874f-39426e246174" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "acbef15e-c265-489e-855e-15ab19be0fea", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "542ea848-58d4-4ed3-84eb-4ac10b0b08cc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fe332627-3c75-4958-939c-122d94b62e4c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "acc7e259-5703-442e-991d-7539b045fb7a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c966936d-1a42-4fd7-a193-7e75ef4a4533" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1ad1ed66-cd65-4657-8230-80838a83704f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad157ba0-f933-44b6-b39c-b2e787d86aa1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1c65cc0d-41c5-498a-bc8d-8476222fe2ff" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad6f9e7f-ca6f-4ed1-a355-fa0965a76a9e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcc76b61-937d-4212-865e-c9fad5e7e7eb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d881ea47-48a0-4dc0-a594-a32f9cf18290" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "adf4421d-ad16-454a-8a08-57e24783b5de", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "05a8c365-05d8-4fd2-9cf7-be4c753f7d8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "af103191-299f-4891-9db7-6eb4d6aeb8ed", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c5f37cc0-70f1-4be1-9da7-069ca0586011" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "161fcd8a-1615-4916-aed5-b809e1c992c3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "af21dd02-50a4-45c8-a9e4-8f89d8adbce4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f7a7ddb6-bf6a-480a-b200-d1d3f52a7c45" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "485197d8-a13b-4191-9948-6c28cf2f03b3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "af510631-fc73-4104-a936-9f8b77bc960f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "161fcd8a-1615-4916-aed5-b809e1c992c3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4c4622e-a62e-4237-ac58-b7a6237552a9" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "af82a4ac-2978-4743-bd66-a0d2644217a1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "411cadcf-9167-4871-86f9-51a648d8641c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8d4d362d-9b04-4b52-99fb-5c05e9b6295a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "b0199904-ca41-4486-8e76-49277bdfbb6f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e86f6d8a-308b-4dc9-9c42-a49b30095340" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b206a27f-d0d7-41b1-a585-01470741b12e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b36a6df7-a5c0-45bd-aa6e-d80721a0caa3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b213348e-b648-4571-995d-f164cd3e176f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3e6d6eb2-9710-47bb-96cf-dcb79adfd42a" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b2d47239-7978-4402-8873-7016044857af", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e1e9adae-f1b0-45ea-9e3e-0e8003624916" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5fa3376-a63e-45f2-be6a-b5e13ae20abc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b3ca25e8-1312-4c49-bcd0-3c5ebc9fa730", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "31595a8b-0736-49d9-8499-bdac3eb30ba2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ddb1b808-c88c-48ac-aec4-d7331a6a2740" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b4f4b1f4-1235-401e-8f83-e3860d3bf634", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "14a9aa97-de74-4c30-8fc5-da0d309a46a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "b51259f4-3395-4661-a63c-187ce7d50cae", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cb179854-2b66-43d8-83b8-4b07a4d31844" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b552ebfd-8b45-42e0-92dc-e919a339df06", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9ad7f43e-b2b7-4f64-983d-926de4a55200" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b56b44fa-7d87-45af-8649-e3f79ce78581", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0920d791-9326-46e7-8918-b33ace773da0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b5711d98-0756-45ae-904c-eafa6cc33a79", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aeba6664-3fb8-4504-92a1-ae9bc09b9748" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7184c9db-64e3-4280-94f4-b71d2e44a58f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b5a42401-48f5-401d-a36d-73d8809a8493", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "48301d12-b28f-4020-8125-eb6c6953ff12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "47431a96-c2b5-4141-9868-e03d78a4474e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b60c9e91-4993-4577-9c3c-8db29cd35f43", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f6497cbf-6932-4154-9798-137c6da27325" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d97ea8c7-3147-4a4c-9955-7212de81a372" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b624745e-aa74-440f-a83c-c545298e31a0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fad86b2d-d2f3-4f6e-b9a6-51aa05877d30" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b7659f9b-0eae-4ae2-86b2-69a3daf49448", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c12afe37-a045-4e5c-8c1e-00e74e5dadfe" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b8c824dc-c1b2-4f08-8c8a-56d63350cee7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "b8e4b5af-30e9-4b3e-8241-26ffb5afe706", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d881ea47-48a0-4dc0-a594-a32f9cf18290" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcc76b61-937d-4212-865e-c9fad5e7e7eb" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b999e3f5-5f63-4356-baf9-d508a4a74c48", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9cab9e54-2d32-4094-bd7f-21ea6c2d189e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "b9c9c25d-1abc-40f1-ba1a-66dc3d7c36cc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "22289140-fd80-47d7-8e99-4f1ad3c334b7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fefdd495-3d4a-4bca-84f1-f825de33d697" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "bac68ed9-89fa-48f1-8235-7ac59cc0eb0f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec94d500-fd48-47ed-8550-9cd490fe56cf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "bb89d4ad-afe9-4b96-9bf3-ef50bf70a356", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3f7f42e9-2af3-40ca-ba42-d6faa7dd653d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "bbc2a534-6b35-4f98-b405-9e628091ba09", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5ca5e9be-c051-494c-96d4-b7c12faf83b9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "bcd02d2f-b168-46ad-981e-fe001c4f6bd2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d97ea8c7-3147-4a4c-9955-7212de81a372" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "bda4596e-28a3-4854-93d5-18401a6a6646", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e630e5a6-30ba-489b-995d-c930eb133440" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "bdc78ab6-a150-4a2c-8171-b92f88656b32", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4f9b54c4-af0c-4a74-8839-20a1424e2248" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "463f0bd6-f251-47fb-8f0a-3f4067219d0a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "bdd854f2-2fc0-4844-8d4a-f2999ec2f0e1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec94d500-fd48-47ed-8550-9cd490fe56cf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "bdff9ee4-57d7-4bad-bf7b-7a22ff7adb1b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8647cdb2-ede5-4b11-a8e9-721d6b93554f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "be472c63-e6c2-4211-b39b-f6979e1b21e1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e3203717-6894-4377-a30e-bd702e3f2bdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "47431a96-c2b5-4141-9868-e03d78a4474e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "bf00fd56-692d-457e-996f-d453e6e93b61", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "de54ab4b-cf6a-4905-8277-17f147e28adc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "bf02546b-af33-457d-afda-bb2c3c5cf003", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0b381a87-98ee-46f9-ac60-899dc86c1655" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aeba6664-3fb8-4504-92a1-ae9bc09b9748" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "bf8b18f9-4aea-49db-bcf0-286f17ce176a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c12afe37-a045-4e5c-8c1e-00e74e5dadfe" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c12c394e-f34e-4e0c-9eac-e5a18f3c4c11", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "63d8a14d-6b0f-42f0-98d1-877327ffa8e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "295c867a-750d-4987-9e7a-90b0d5c976e9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c151882a-3d99-432c-ba84-9c8a1ea2f456", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6320aa52-dd3f-4f78-8fc9-7011f8ebb8f3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c2171281-5d49-443d-8ce8-5d8d6f890f61", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb577a90-bd8c-4ef8-879d-40f474cfc365" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c2236243-57fc-40fd-a67f-56afe1dddfac", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cf663b4c-c2dd-4129-befd-8ec5a0456b7c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d6a43017-5a3f-4c9d-80a1-d6ba773058b2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c2377bed-762c-4e3e-a34c-6776c82a52c6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b1a55d40-1a38-4403-8b5e-9c2639ac9b81" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c373906a-cff0-4925-b16a-fd02a50fa145", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "574d7f89-63b5-4e5e-be43-34e93ebe67cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dca768ee-3417-49fb-a511-f08a19ead2c9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c376ced0-199f-4139-8690-dba162fdf04b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa8ed847-6e0b-4387-a4aa-73028595ebdb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c38fcf4d-be9c-470f-81a4-110170b84820", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "69441906-da2a-4d49-ab15-ce5b9f983e57" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c3e46657-b353-43a1-9082-1eb68744f7e0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2809500a-f66f-42f3-94eb-74a820a5540c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57861403-9294-4707-bdeb-d96f26f0ee47" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c43f07ce-8204-405c-a06e-21fc50fd0169", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5fa3376-a63e-45f2-be6a-b5e13ae20abc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c4a6a980-b5e7-4a6d-9f8e-132afec1a4b7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "85d17542-cfdb-41a9-8ac6-1a72b4afa99b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c52e63ea-4cad-4f63-bff5-5d341f4ae945", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0c8a6d12-be3b-4d09-9d66-e3f637734439" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c59214db-f22f-4c13-b16c-9514556bcb90", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec256011-6df5-4f27-b0d3-de6d1d70bd3f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c5f00156-2aa7-475e-96dc-aeb01056f5fa", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "219fd67f-a29e-4467-9ec3-826187c1be37" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7078f6d-5041-4fb6-b0a3-4ed3249f69c6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0994d03f-33de-4bbb-b7dc-0af80cced977" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "c71251db-fb4b-42af-a89c-9e8d0f129f63", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d6f274aa-2fdc-4e5f-a321-db72539028e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c729f164-d05d-4dc9-a6c9-18f672f18dd3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3c4be7f2-7405-4f68-95c2-648afbdb6212" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "c73bb479-2654-448c-baa6-2d03e3deeb66", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fbd1b4b5-b531-4b16-822d-53a96d24297e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "59935f6f-29d3-4d4f-9845-2bc510234ecc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7476740-7b95-479b-9008-de313113cfec", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "82589b98-a0fc-425c-97d6-6652b6d51cc0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3e09914b-2c64-4969-b9a8-1c4db650b698" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7bd617c-8241-43d9-b9b3-6afd38f84ad7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7c1f1e8c-a312-454e-950e-cc27ee65827d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cb179854-2b66-43d8-83b8-4b07a4d31844" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "c866e879-53c8-4c0a-aa3d-7d548e393a3d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4c4622e-a62e-4237-ac58-b7a6237552a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "161fcd8a-1615-4916-aed5-b809e1c992c3" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ca08b594-5e2c-4b2c-bfd6-9be8d9130970", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1795c0b9-6fc6-4213-9755-0479d155fd8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ca43933e-a27e-4553-a2fd-f89f83a70fef", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "261866e5-b3e7-4e10-ae59-ec790f87b294" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "ca43b021-3105-4ee1-918a-48c6f16d2bc0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "587b4a06-fd9a-4fda-9449-d7305aaa73e8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f6497cbf-6932-4154-9798-137c6da27325" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "ca861c52-cd7c-4607-999a-d50626d4ff35", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "25e90c78-0d44-4f12-a042-6662b31d8bab" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "219fd67f-a29e-4467-9ec3-826187c1be37" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "cab3e540-9ab9-45c2-ab8a-b8b0fc8fe671", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "af3c3468-9cf3-4ad7-a772-97fc045956b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "706053cf-bba9-4cc8-80ce-d2bc9be1fb07" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "cabfb6ed-86b1-4aaf-9351-6138491a7e8b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e77b74fe-d3f5-45d3-af39-a4cbc9ca2d66" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "cb53e992-0413-4147-a86b-2f869bc1ea99", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "574d7f89-63b5-4e5e-be43-34e93ebe67cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "387ecd16-14f3-4358-b66e-e1f85ce68b3e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "cc897585-10a6-401b-8aea-fe5e41f8edab", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b24d6fdb-a5c4-4390-97d6-91ba22f9a9d6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "cd512488-04af-414c-bc89-c2965a4d9f8b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4f9b54c4-af0c-4a74-8839-20a1424e2248" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24b477df-7dc1-4b60-83b6-e5cd0f6e4ba2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "ce3c725c-31cc-4a04-a980-8f604e204d61", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c41b0961-1c3a-4813-bebc-0119d78f4850" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f8340618-9ebc-4cef-a966-fca007ab0f00" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "ce8592fe-3d59-47f5-9f4e-196d5342a7c5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7ee9ecc6-bf6c-4668-9083-f65a40815ea8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "426fefcf-cb65-4031-b92e-f02fe3db51ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ce921dbd-fba1-41bb-ac82-d2480d1fd1d5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dfff904c-a281-4614-a54c-8967f8606831" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a6b237-0a22-4b59-9974-b4cafa54ba55" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "cf0c2b44-f694-45ac-be71-11ea1b3720a4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "37006e13-96de-4ff5-9b37-75782b33a3a5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e5c27bdd-d440-4ca2-8b7f-7436272674d3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "cfbb1fec-7cb5-4c0a-ab2c-ff41230f9b8a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a000f64-344a-4b4f-9d19-5fe966797e94" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9560ec33-8c59-4d8f-ae99-ad3b8ce90559" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d025a0e0-7cd1-4ac5-ae14-a57fde7ecd0a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "39807624-ecf9-42b1-ad74-44470f1e9d25" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "53ee8ee5-bc95-453a-a31f-4133eff5aa36" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d029ca2e-2ee4-4172-b1f2-932436dc1956", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "06718e1a-65ac-4292-be9f-21297d262a6a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1cfdc75c-d92a-413c-824c-a184971b22db" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "d07db18b-926c-4a50-877f-1954a18e745e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "d0e6c6cf-dda8-4a7a-8be3-f93c0216e3a3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4606bd52-c631-4d12-9de0-52f13914ba14" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fefdd495-3d4a-4bca-84f1-f825de33d697" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "d1629323-6bb2-4d0d-894c-e31ea86ef3e7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a8a49f5e-82cc-4c62-bc6d-8c44fe1c58e9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "d25d0e9c-7fd6-40ee-b940-15efc20eb912", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cb179854-2b66-43d8-83b8-4b07a4d31844" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "992707bf-bb1f-462b-81fd-2837293e396c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d27a8ec1-124f-4ee9-8b90-c92ed53296ea", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "97faa5d1-e102-4ee2-a760-1af6a5edd038" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "d29eb147-0b52-41ac-854f-a488cc6d9121", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e1e9adae-f1b0-45ea-9e3e-0e8003624916" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "92125c08-591d-46e6-8198-708eb34ccd1f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d2c4c3e0-7879-4ef9-87b8-fb29ff2bb628", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3992f96a-f563-48f3-aa69-78977148724c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aa1c1296-1020-4f43-ace8-4358c75ef00d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d3bebbde-909b-484f-a4bc-5b4abd66dfbd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "53b04e07-fba8-4582-b272-f6fa4633b7be" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9560ec33-8c59-4d8f-ae99-ad3b8ce90559" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d601fb96-7e66-4224-8c09-bdb48f7a758b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d5256b95-4c9d-40d5-b9c3-bb6b595f33ed" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "d6fadfd7-0f10-43cb-8cc9-3d06b1ba3a58", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "41ad2d7e-54fc-46db-ad0f-6b781304415e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d72cb1a3-eda2-4760-9c11-867677dc0c1e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "94b6f96f-5879-4b60-a508-6d07e55262db" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "d79e91c9-5e79-42f6-a4f3-75125fbd39ab", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "82589b98-a0fc-425c-97d6-6652b6d51cc0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a6b237-0a22-4b59-9974-b4cafa54ba55" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d79fd4bd-a5c9-47c7-b448-e9be679c1092", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "65949e1a-e717-44ca-bf32-ae1d05689dc0" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "d7df1ea3-db93-4694-a1b2-89cdbcd512d7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "d8049275-1c80-47d1-a368-6e8df386f400", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "25e90c78-0d44-4f12-a042-6662b31d8bab" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fbd1b4b5-b531-4b16-822d-53a96d24297e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "d8c3df87-ce9f-49e5-a335-a2f7771ceef5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fbd1b4b5-b531-4b16-822d-53a96d24297e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "d8df1677-bb29-4822-bea6-99dc358a592b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "064dcb37-4dce-4b21-a0b1-de1cbbc71a13" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e1e9adae-f1b0-45ea-9e3e-0e8003624916" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "d8ead575-2c31-47f3-bb62-3ec2ec57027d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9323af51-66ef-4b3e-92eb-a35aa26f8bd1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "da0c814f-a6a3-47a0-b54b-3da64d4cf4c1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9cab9e54-2d32-4094-bd7f-21ea6c2d189e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "da2198a8-849f-4325-805b-020a977fd470", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2bb66093-07a3-4c75-a581-33d1b774ffcb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "dad584c1-0dbd-4119-abbe-4973463f1127", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f3fd41de-27b5-40ec-bfaf-12e68a5407a8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a63c692e-bdb2-4498-a467-dc9756efcbeb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "db1194f1-542d-4f4f-bbdb-103829179149", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "dc11c878-5ca3-4a4d-9239-cc0dc0e192a5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b36a6df7-a5c0-45bd-aa6e-d80721a0caa3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "426fefcf-cb65-4031-b92e-f02fe3db51ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "dc7b24cc-0b31-430d-b898-69c0d48c1652", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b9e5c7e2-56df-4fc9-934a-fe2f1bc4b16b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e4703a89-cc78-41b8-8298-4ae9f7bba564" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "de09c400-852c-4be6-b59e-291edca9e8f1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "46ca1fdb-6e08-4035-a2e4-c0cf0c95b386" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fed0ddb3-f9cb-438e-a74c-733d2d48aa19" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "de6e25a2-71d9-49c0-83f7-dbfca1153ef6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "dee066fc-361c-4007-b89c-e592ff110782", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9a7a523a-a789-4ad0-a9b7-2ec194fee927" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "dee83ef5-93eb-41aa-9b3b-2bf2866951f6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2390fcf6-4d39-41cc-b7a4-b9ef5c733196" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "84b0d1c9-e09d-4b62-9231-32eccd3867a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "dfd3aa9b-7d8a-46d2-a703-a24eefda8c1a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d6f274aa-2fdc-4e5f-a321-db72539028e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "e0f08e79-43c6-477f-ac38-64b991438c9f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "45bd3dcb-a38a-4a46-86c9-1fa3ed3cfbf6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a845a045-1666-4660-8373-31f700d26131" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "e15b91a6-2052-4dba-bf05-09444cdc0ff0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57b9a0a2-62ba-402f-8b40-0c1631c10b50" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e23155cd-c8fe-47e7-be5f-352edacd5ae0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5f489a08-27dc-4e54-af9a-45e8ac5aa174" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "295c867a-750d-4987-9e7a-90b0d5c976e9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e26328b5-58e1-475f-9f5e-6003f6295e60", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d621e47c-8a97-4d15-bdeb-203c00aceab2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "edba9ad8-c6f4-4e40-b751-6ceee442afed" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "e2a34785-d293-4362-8446-c98371dfee14", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e3203717-6894-4377-a30e-bd702e3f2bdd" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e3139a15-f393-440d-8b60-460f8debe8d5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "89d9b1f4-8dfd-4b71-81d0-71bbeb4aba1d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e33cdf76-cb11-4040-9891-ffe87319b6eb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a43d964e-6754-4eb3-bda9-27cde37227f3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e86f6d8a-308b-4dc9-9c42-a49b30095340" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "e3743d21-388e-47b5-a563-60ff467ace05", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "799c3f7e-67db-4df0-a2b5-44526c516c5d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "e5116ba9-4b9e-4283-954c-d65a05a8be2c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "860f792c-a2cf-4910-b19f-40770e725608" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3c8e64f6-d359-4184-9e52-c05ecb8e2f82" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "e5854c54-ba42-4c12-bc02-c11457d74c73", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "136d454a-89ac-4b50-941a-1e7656c78155" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "63d8a14d-6b0f-42f0-98d1-877327ffa8e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "e5c681ae-235f-4841-bbf2-f847476dd99c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "65edef93-ed21-438a-b6a0-819d24a39bcb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e62d7c3e-69b9-4f0d-bf8d-90fa80b26168", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e6365e47-d9fa-44a2-82f9-291b5241928c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8e282073-ba84-4592-ab3d-a8d93afe6689" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e672c5c4-d81e-4c2d-8c16-26918c017f8a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ec256011-6df5-4f27-b0d3-de6d1d70bd3f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "db74aaac-005c-471a-8f72-2c61baf0265b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "e68731ee-5552-4824-9fd6-4cbe8a6eec9a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4f2055fa-4205-498a-921d-84032e59b8f2" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e6f55eb2-19b0-4d47-b258-f0180d8a30b4", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3aa1a7bf-9dfb-4e94-8d1c-958db451b53e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bb3e3da6-d418-4d18-98e9-d48c500d754c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e71963b8-0223-4da4-98cd-a048f8da2e2e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e7513d6e-3ed7-4db1-899f-35e6148f3df0", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79d5e526-714a-4b0e-9fd5-9271d7879438" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "e75f6b9c-f084-458e-ab93-02c03cb8f99c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0c8a6d12-be3b-4d09-9d66-e3f637734439" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3f7f42e9-2af3-40ca-ba42-d6faa7dd653d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "e842d9c9-b7db-4404-b5e4-17631ea985e9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ca35c2e-2f02-4403-b8f2-40edca2f2429" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e93321dc-ee7f-4670-a798-e4207dd95210", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "333c25e7-ff1e-4ebc-82bf-d11854550375" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e9342c5b-5eea-4483-b3b1-23b8870c2d8c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e3203717-6894-4377-a30e-bd702e3f2bdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3743c9eb-2878-4574-bbdb-3b43e3d3e1b0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "e9e0469a-640b-4a76-9bd3-d003543e820b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ea1b1ab5-f65a-431e-a75b-5d5e7c43c00b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79d5e526-714a-4b0e-9fd5-9271d7879438" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "eab61910-6521-4761-8392-ea2704bfc13a", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "70c05342-e714-4fd2-9cc3-216197aba112" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7c6bbf00-5e63-42eb-8865-68c722f887ec" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb212a9a-5ea9-4f40-a70b-cbb944abf495", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3e6d6eb2-9710-47bb-96cf-dcb79adfd42a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb54ce40-6eff-4446-a29e-6c9aa14a98fd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ba434d88-a30b-4842-9dcd-f2026aa43748" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb576034-f916-43ab-81b4-a6c4cc5ad7c1", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "89d9b1f4-8dfd-4b71-81d0-71bbeb4aba1d" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb75ac67-1c9a-4010-83a7-b0f558fdd56c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc662f1a-11ca-4e56-8214-0648bf042ec8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ae39b8b3-06ce-4b48-ad01-66cdc6beecce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb7f068e-f47d-4d92-a5f8-5d839908c6ca", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "07341118-f915-45a5-8869-926a1d846203" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb94dcd8-d393-4348-90f1-111eacf000e5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ec9b9b7c-e948-45c8-a392-b2fb7696f7e6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc02223c-f419-4e53-98a6-07977628c18d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d97ea8c7-3147-4a4c-9955-7212de81a372" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "eca7b424-2642-459f-ba85-3074704be019", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "874e362a-6f3e-429c-800d-620ef5af7e74" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9a7a523a-a789-4ad0-a9b7-2ec194fee927" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ed7890dd-af0a-45c3-b8ab-d1076ab576fe", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "86476bb7-18bd-40d9-95f2-e184e963fa99" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "edc5e080-68d0-4527-9b0d-7398487c1bd6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ee59f71b-47db-428b-bdd9-ed031b3931e2", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "cf663b4c-c2dd-4129-befd-8ec5a0456b7c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "eee4954d-9d87-47dc-bbd9-8d4654b28555", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ef0fc411-b5cb-4438-a586-078da26aeb1b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "63d8a14d-6b0f-42f0-98d1-877327ffa8e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "ef1ef5a0-c798-4666-8397-c5f0c9986394", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "574d7f89-63b5-4e5e-be43-34e93ebe67cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1795c0b9-6fc6-4213-9755-0479d155fd8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "ef844c20-91ca-4435-bc2b-d128867d4383", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "587b4a06-fd9a-4fda-9449-d7305aaa73e8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "efb47a13-3188-4a05-a6ef-22b0ff243cbb", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "08dc9826-a0d2-41a6-ad18-fad1466b5c77" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "efb72654-f5ba-4d24-8c40-4126c13e206b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "efc3e508-a54f-42d0-a26e-ee4fa2ae284b", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b1a55d40-1a38-4403-8b5e-9c2639ac9b81" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ccdae101-399e-4985-a64d-d9e3a4e0cada" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f0a1eb57-ec48-402d-b2f0-f3298efa791c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1795c0b9-6fc6-4213-9755-0479d155fd8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f0c5e5c1-1ffc-4bdf-930f-6289dc8c9f13", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "afb3adab-ff11-44af-8cdd-f55c8181a93c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6ac7bbea-d275-4efd-99e0-40e86df70953" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f1360590-ce66-4d5b-a898-57e7f360f6af", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc02223c-f419-4e53-98a6-07977628c18d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "19c20c7d-ec10-4308-854f-fcf9deb955a5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f23cae1e-a3c5-436d-84bf-03feec331ce6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c41b0961-1c3a-4813-bebc-0119d78f4850" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d6f274aa-2fdc-4e5f-a321-db72539028e4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "f259e656-cba7-4106-9ac0-c2f2a2d43b80", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7c6bbf00-5e63-42eb-8865-68c722f887ec" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "70c05342-e714-4fd2-9cc3-216197aba112" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f2719f3d-b028-4fb3-b529-0d2353125de9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dcfe026f-1fa9-4b1c-b974-3162dba4847b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "f28be571-8e6d-41dd-b6e4-2d3c944da210", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f31feb84-7278-49c8-9085-898863030d37", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8d4d362d-9b04-4b52-99fb-5c05e9b6295a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "330dc552-e5ff-4fad-86a6-22e3ee2d243a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f3af4693-17a6-415c-a5c7-c0cc802d178f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f42138c6-f608-4dc0-a8fb-9d660efb8b6e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "08dc9826-a0d2-41a6-ad18-fad1466b5c77" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "4c563fc0-1e01-4025-8a74-3a5f002eb323" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "f476014a-4026-41d7-aaf3-7d4cf3947449", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1a04ba62-356b-49a9-8dee-5a1570c7bfc4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "73c9749a-7ad0-4148-979a-3419b0665a75" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f48a4d16-100e-434f-a345-0926ce776000", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3e6d6eb2-9710-47bb-96cf-dcb79adfd42a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f34e2ad3-8d28-409e-886a-ba6b704a7045" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f4cbb52f-41b5-494d-b2c2-4e6f5122b090", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "75493a86-5dc0-4dce-a7dc-f1fd3dcc0db1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f5054f2d-24d4-4267-95aa-e88534ce1b4e", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dfff904c-a281-4614-a54c-8967f8606831" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "973b6cd9-0b74-48c5-a7c9-41b345afe794" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f59b1009-b6fb-49af-8fb7-f9d31a684056", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8d4d362d-9b04-4b52-99fb-5c05e9b6295a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f5cc8f21-e372-40f0-905f-b4971c637d5d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ab9bc416-80bd-4089-805c-789e31545aa6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f5fbc9c0-472d-490d-935f-6a59a7423dd6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "a4da8d17-68f6-406b-b092-f2039ac3328d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "47431a96-c2b5-4141-9868-e03d78a4474e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f66ff2b6-5c2a-4f9e-9cfb-e6ca0466bb98", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "8d7da667-88fe-4eed-8ff2-89c2cf7e649f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "e8dbd3b1-b862-4176-8c2f-8a006e0d1107" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f6895ea3-a9e5-4c5e-ae3a-d7124cf09571", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6575a339-95ef-4c82-816e-b2233063b1ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f68c0b7d-c47a-4ecc-9208-29726b1553c6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3820332b-c40d-4e03-82f8-b38a4cea7338" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f6a260e4-9401-4972-8af7-119a0c848c79", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ae39b8b3-06ce-4b48-ad01-66cdc6beecce" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f81a82e0-fcef-426d-950e-7f35ccf71c93", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "0994d03f-33de-4bbb-b7dc-0af80cced977" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "edba9ad8-c6f4-4e40-b751-6ceee442afed" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "f852f339-17cc-4a42-a464-e7af33b556b9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3f93695e-25c4-4ebd-8630-3b0cd908175c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "f9293c9e-1201-4265-b89b-531ab912bffd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4662482-8647-4adc-b2d2-1edc6583524f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c8a1ad03-9721-4f7e-a43a-63096a064fb0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "fa14ba1a-2566-4f7e-afff-0a1b58c84267", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "fa8b6711-7843-4778-b844-d77a5a64a5cd", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "dc02223c-f419-4e53-98a6-07977628c18d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "fad9784f-914c-4f10-b509-099356d2c15c", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "228801c6-3918-4a57-9acd-432fab72ec48" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "fb35a4c1-b44d-4449-b1dc-65fe2e55e712", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b6f7b6b6-212a-46a0-a81a-579d3b7ec13f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "3743c9eb-2878-4574-bbdb-3b43e3d3e1b0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z" + }, + { + "id": "fb4103b2-fbb0-4ee1-bc7e-de36f8c5ad79", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "aeba6664-3fb8-4504-92a1-ae9bc09b9748" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "fb46608b-8169-408d-869b-308535233ec6", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "1cfdc75c-d92a-413c-824c-a184971b22db" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "fb97558e-9034-441c-8c44-24e0e2b29df7", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "801d856a-cea3-4a17-92ee-eced6ab89f76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "fba52030-e804-4031-ab67-d9df21fbb6d3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "faab4aa8-3679-4cb0-8757-33e87051104d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "94b6f96f-5879-4b60-a508-6d07e55262db" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "fbb6188a-5c9d-41ed-834d-1ab92fff9224", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c74f3c85-03a0-4946-9cd5-a2b900d7eaa2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "9a7a523a-a789-4ad0-a9b7-2ec194fee927" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "fd1f389f-94de-4d74-9eb5-50d3f037f971", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "22289140-fd80-47d7-8e99-4f1ad3c334b7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2809500a-f66f-42f3-94eb-74a820a5540c" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "fd4ce727-b6bd-4b11-8225-f3c04d6102c9", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "23e77dbf-5738-44a8-aeda-55a3c3127168" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "b7b2dc14-0555-46d8-a1cd-d5230f9ba590" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "fd5f55e4-9a26-4e4f-bcbb-ab1619228ca3", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ed593ba-2ec2-424e-bdd1-b4680256c1fa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "fdc3043d-d5c1-49e9-b5eb-b91314599ac5", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c4662482-8647-4adc-b2d2-1edc6583524f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "fea8de71-8530-4cf3-992b-ef187c9c82cc", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "2ed593ba-2ec2-424e-bdd1-b4680256c1fa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "c6a623e5-32e5-4593-abf6-07d24f6b24dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "feaa3416-5f56-4279-8759-e31185c1d00f", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "58b19bc4-37e7-4544-84b7-3bd1288e4dee" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z" + }, + { + "id": "febe2a26-e034-49e6-8b68-dfc153faa26d", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "65949e1a-e717-44ca-bf32-ae1d05689dc0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "ccdae101-399e-4985-a64d-d9e3a4e0cada" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ff6b0711-b30c-4854-a474-edb4da298496", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "db74aaac-005c-471a-8f72-2c61baf0265b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + }, + { + "id": "ffacc0d9-1b33-4f0a-8403-2031622bedbe", + "source": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "57861403-9294-4707-bdeb-d96f26f0ee47" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "nodeId": "fefdd495-3d4a-4bca-84f1-f825de33d697" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z" + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/nodes.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/nodes.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e4faeccbb --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/code-health/nodes.json @@ -0,0 +1,6009 @@ +[ + { + "id": "008cbb40-e103-4da8-8224-35fffef1064c", + "displayId": "D13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Split fan-in into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction (agents/fan-in.ts) emits a ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult containing only canonical candidates, axes (with type + cardinality + label), alternatives, per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent per run × axis × alternative), witness relations, candidate repairs, source-cited contradictions, and explicitly-witnessed hard constraints. Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis (engine/solver.ts + new engine/config-model.ts) consumes that result and computes: model validation, M_current/M_preview/M_revision spaces, backbone (mustSelect/mustDeselect with constraint-rule attribution), configuration enumeration, perspective generation. The Stage 1 schema explicitly disallows fields that would let the LLM pre-compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "010a3fd2-5446-4ff7-aadb-3d8601245590", + "displayId": "R22", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Stage 2 must compute three configuration spaces with the semantics defined in T20: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, excluding alternatives requiring locked-baseline revision), M_preview (includes revision-requiring alternatives tagged as preview-only), and M_revision(r) (after an authorized revision set r is applied).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "01f29c4e-d2be-4931-8cad-bbde9bcbd6af", + "displayId": "CR3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test must verify that after a refinement reconciliation outcome, the unresolved successor impasse has at least one incoming 'refined_to' edge, and that the derivation loop's progress measurement counts it as progress on the 'incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses' signal.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "04c802c1-8761-488e-a6c2-39bb9037aa3a", + "displayId": "T9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Node state is modeled across three independent axes: lifecycle (candidate/active/archived), review status (clean/suspect/conditional), and impasse status (open/resolved/superseded for impasse nodes only).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "05a384fc-f8cc-49a3-951f-69c7f81f5da8", + "displayId": "R64", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Conflict resolution during reconciliation must first attempt a deterministic graph traversal computing the minimal set of grounding nodes whose removal resolves the conflict; a subagent may be invoked only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure (missing provenance edges or semantic-rather-than-structural contradiction).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "05a8c365-05d8-4fd2-9cf7-be4c753f7d8a", + "displayId": "A10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: instead of injecting negative constraints, react to nudgingActive by raising sampling temperature on the LanguageModel call to encourage divergence.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "064dcb37-4dce-4b21-a0b1-de1cbbc71a13", + "displayId": "CR29", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A module test must drive a fan-in fixture with a witnessed source contradiction where some runs picked sides and verify that Stage 1 emits a genuine impasse for the contradiction BEFORE Stage 2 computes M_current; ordering verified via EventLog event sequence (FanInExtractionCompleted with impasses[] non-empty precedes ConfigSpaceComputed).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "06718e1a-65ac-4292-be9f-21297d262a6a", + "displayId": "CR33", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A static dependency check (parsing deno.json import_map / import statements in engine/solver/**) must confirm that the solver imports nothing outside the Deno standard library and Effect; no off-the-shelf SAT library (e.g., logic-solver, minisat, kissat) appears as a dependency.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "07341118-f915-45a5-8869-926a1d846203", + "displayId": "A1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: treat the work as a single big-bang rewrite — re-architect divergence handling, replace logging, redo references, and add tests in one merged change.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "08dc9826-a0d2-41a6-ad18-fad1466b5c77", + "displayId": "CR19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A test must verify that each call to cowReplace emits a CowReplace event and each call to markSuspectAndPropagate emits a SuspectPropagated event with at least the affected node count.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0920d791-9326-46e7-8918-b33ace773da0", + "displayId": "R52", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The CLI must provide a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earliest open impasse, and re-enters the derivation loop using that frame as parent.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0994d03f-33de-4bbb-b7dc-0af80cced977", + "displayId": "A17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep Perspective as a hub node but mark it 'epistemically inert' so reconciliation never derives support through it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0b381a87-98ee-46f9-ac60-899dc86c1655", + "displayId": "CR10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A test must assert that the derivation loop sets nudgingActive=true after exactly 1 clean attempt without progress (matching X42 and the implementation), and that PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 documents nudge_after_n=1.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0c8a6d12-be3b-4d09-9d66-e3f637734439", + "displayId": "R16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The axis 'type' field must accept only 'design' or 'repair'; there must be no 'revision' axis type. Revision is modeled as an effect of selecting a particular alternative, not as a property of an axis.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0f9e8f0b-c9fa-432c-93f3-863e13276327", + "displayId": "DEC19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use a four-layer pyramid: unit + module (scripted) + property + one VCR E2E.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X62 puts tests P18–P25 ahead of correctness fixes — a test bar this high cannot rest on either alt-test-only-e2e (which leaves pure-logic regressions like P19–P25 invisible until the slow E2E catches them) or alt-test-only-units (RK6 is unaddressed; nothing exercises triage-to-resolution). C2 (deterministic, no LLM calls) is satisfied by layers 1–3 because they use scripted DerivationAgents (E18 confirms this is possible). The single VCR test bounds the maintenance cost flagged by RK14: re-record only when prompts change, and only one recording to maintain. Property tests are added for the components most likely to silently regress (schema decode, JTMS, backbone) where example-based unit tests provide weak assurance." + }, + { + "id": "1033f2b6-10ef-400a-8f7d-f71219e8b3e7", + "displayId": "E4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Of the 34 code health issues, 8 have been fixed and 26 remain open; the full list is tracked in PROBLEMS.md.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "10e3c00b-f5b3-47de-bc64-257fb853bf25", + "displayId": "T18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Guarded impasses are diagnostic blockers with a trigger condition (guard formula) over the configuration space; they are not hard constraints and not propositions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "11270349-828e-4b1b-8f11-88e8e3827992", + "displayId": "C5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) get file read but not web search or paper read, because web search results could surface content referencing the hidden impasse or old design.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "11e613a5-265c-4e41-9f3e-6e57b0e85070", + "displayId": "X62", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the recommended priority order for addressing open issues is tests (P18–P25) > correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) > design (P16) > everything else.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "12796661-b533-46d1-a6e9-0ad5734dffa9", + "displayId": "X7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The resolve_directly and sharpen outcomes from user escalation materialize as grounding nodes with authority: stakeholder and epistemicStatus: asserted, mark trigger impasses as resolved, and return grounding_enriched for re-derivation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "136d454a-89ac-4b50-941a-1e7656c78155", + "displayId": "CR15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A static lint/grep check must confirm that no file under src/engine/** imports the Console module or invokes Console.log / Console.error / Console.warn / Console.info / Console.debug. The check must run in CI and fail the build on violation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "14a9aa97-de74-4c30-8fc5-da0d309a46a6", + "displayId": "CR1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "An integration-style test using scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver must trigger a reconciliation outcome that produces a refined impasse, and assert that (a) reconciliation.ts populates spawnedImpasseIds with the new impasse node id, (b) the case 'recurse' branch in derivation-loop.ts is executed (verified via spy/event), and (c) runDerivationLoop is invoked recursively with the new impasse id in triggerImpasseIds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "161fcd8a-1615-4916-aed5-b809e1c992c3", + "displayId": "DEC20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Extract format-handoff-report and derivation-agents-factory into separate modules.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "Both helpers are referenced by the test pyramid (formatHandoffReport needs snapshot tests against fixture HandoffReports; the factory is needed by every module test that wants real-shaped agents). alt-cli-keep-inline forces tests to either duplicate the construction logic or import from cli/run.ts (which pulls in CLI side-effects). E18 already established that scripted-agent injection is the testing strategy; the factory extraction is a precondition." + }, + { + "id": "1795c0b9-6fc6-4213-9755-0479d155fd8d", + "displayId": "X36", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: per-run stance toward alternatives is tracked at the finest granularity — per run, per axis, per alternative value, with stance values of 'supports', 'contradicts', or 'silent'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "191a7cb2-af7d-41e0-8481-96ab2785f9f2", + "displayId": "X18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the model has three distinct layers — hard constraints (boolean formulas determining satisfiability), guarded blockers/impasses (diagnostics with trigger conditions), and baseline effects (per-alternative authorization requirements). A configuration is activatable only if it satisfies all three.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1965acc8-b7eb-4efd-929c-bf48efe18e8d", + "displayId": "RK15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The approach for handling the blocking impasse (unsatisfiable M_current) when selecting which constraint to demote is currently undecided.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "19c20c7d-ec10-4308-854f-fcf9deb955a5", + "displayId": "E1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The spec elicitation prototype has a working forward pass.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "1a000f64-344a-4b4f-9d19-5fe966797e94", + "displayId": "R23", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Perspective summaries must be generated by sampling configurations from the solver's enumeration (capped at 200 per space) and running farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis-assignment vectors to pick k=3 representatives per space, with M_current and M_preview sampled separately.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1a04ba62-356b-49a9-8dee-5a1570c7bfc4", + "displayId": "A6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: blindly trust the agent-supplied suggestedRewindPhase whenever set, with no acyclicity validation against currentPhase.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1a67b6ee-3966-40b9-908f-84edaa5f7a95", + "displayId": "X35", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: blocking impasse nodes participate in provenance and JTMS chains.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1ad1ed66-cd65-4657-8230-80838a83704f", + "displayId": "X40", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: superseded (OUT) nodes are never deleted from the graph; they are retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement, preserving the JTMS justification chain so the graph grows monotonically.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1b4c37b6-2d86-4362-95cb-a8f86f3cceb2", + "displayId": "DEC6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Wire nudging as negative-constraint prompt injection, gated on nudgingActive.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "T2 says 'retry feedback is schema-only', which forbids feeding the prior run's freeform output back; negative-constraint prompt injection is structurally compatible because it cites only stable schema-level alternatives that already exist in the graph. alt-nudging-temperature is opaque to the spec model — there's no way to express 'try harder' as a graph-level fact. alt-nudging-remove discards the existing FrameRecord field already plumbed through the loop (E14) and gives up the only existing mechanism for addressing repeat-output across attempts." + }, + { + "id": "1c65cc0d-41c5-498a-bc8d-8476222fe2ff", + "displayId": "T11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A checkpoint is an immutable snapshot of the spec graph produced when a full revision completes (all impasses resolved, spec stable); checkpoints are not created per frame or reconciliation step.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "1cfdc75c-d92a-413c-824c-a184971b22db", + "displayId": "R21", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The solver implementation in engine/solver/dpll.ts must depend only on the Deno standard library and Effect; it must not pull in an off-the-shelf SAT library.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1e8aeba7-38fa-4c67-aef3-0a4d1af377f7", + "displayId": "E10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P2: When the reconciler proposes disposition: \"refined\", the reconciliation engine marks the original impasse as superseded but never creates the refined impasse node; the refinedImpasse field is read from the LLM proposal but not consumed, so the refined impasse silently disappears.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "1ec657b6-8be7-4d03-b95a-8961ffd2164e", + "displayId": "X52", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: when two claims conflict with different authorities, the system surfaces the conflict and labels the authorities, but the user always decides — even when there's an apparent priority cascade.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "20151d43-778e-4ee7-8591-b20c4186559e", + "displayId": "DEC1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Adopt the six work-stream decomposition as the spec scope.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X62 gives an explicit ordering (tests > correctness > design > rest) but also confirms all of these are in scope; the stakeholder design notes (X16–X60) explicitly call for the SAT/feature-model redesign and the EventLog migration as part of code-health, not as a separate spec. A correctness-only scope (alt-scope-correctness-only) would leave the dead code in the divergence model (P7, P8, P13, P17) un-addressed and contradict the stakeholder direction. A big-bang rewrite (alt-scope-bigbang) violates C1 (forward pass must keep working) and C4 (smoke-test artifacts must keep validating) because it would require simultaneous schema changes (X23) and behavioral changes. Six independent work-streams allow staged landing under C1/C4." + }, + { + "id": "20735ee2-2ff1-4c81-98fd-8fdc78e8d870", + "displayId": "T20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Three configuration spaces are defined: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, excluding alternatives requiring locked-baseline revision), M_preview (includes revision-requiring alternatives tagged as preview-only), and M_revision(r) (after an authorized revision set is applied).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "219fd67f-a29e-4467-9ec3-826187c1be37", + "displayId": "X60", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the SAT solver library must either expose constraint explanations natively or the system must reconstruct them.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "22289140-fd80-47d7-8e99-4f1ad3c334b7", + "displayId": "A9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: leave baseline effects hardcoded to {locked, requiresAuthorization: true} and document this as a v1 simplification.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "225de32d-6bb1-4e41-ab7d-ee83d32a3108", + "displayId": "RK3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Nudging is tracked as a flag on FrameRecord but never affects agent behavior; no negative constraints are injected into the clean room agent prompt.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "228801c6-3918-4a57-9acd-432fab72ec48", + "displayId": "A7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep grounding-enrichment as additive-only — always append new grounding nodes, never replace, and rely on the reconciler to archive obsolete originals; do not call cowReplace.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2390fcf6-4d39-41cc-b7a4-b9ef5c733196", + "displayId": "A32", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: defer doc fixes to after the implementation lands; PLAN.md is internal and the discrepancies are minor.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "23e77dbf-5738-44a8-aeda-55a3c3127168", + "displayId": "A19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: extend the LLM extraction stage to also produce backbone and configuration enumeration so there is only one stage, eliminating the solver module.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "24b477df-7dc1-4b60-83b6-e5cd0f6e4ba2", + "displayId": "X58", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: grounding claims require citation, and a separate agent must verify their plausibility.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "24d16d6a-dadd-4a16-ae47-d57566b019d4", + "displayId": "RK11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question (Q11): Taint policy must distinguish evidential contamination (content derived from hidden impasse/old design) from workflow provenance (node elicited because of an impasse); the latter should not trigger exclusion or targeted grounding enrichment becomes unusable.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "24d2d689-b0da-4d88-93d3-4a1b5c1e0786", + "displayId": "D25", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Land the work in five staged increments, each independently mergeable while keeping the forward pass green (C1) and the smoke artifacts validating (C4): Stage A (correctness wiring) — dec-recurse-wiring + dec-refined-impasse + dec-rewind-phase + dec-baseline-effects + dec-nudging + dec-cow-wiring + dec-jtms (population only); Stage B (reference integrity) — dec-nodeid-from-displayid; Stage C (observability) — dec-eventlog + dec-eventlog-catalog; Stage D (feature-model redesign) — dec-fanin-two-stage + dec-config-schema-replace + dec-solver-impl + dec-perspective-record + dec-perspective-generation + dec-blocking-impasse + dec-repair-flow + dec-repair-autoresolve; Stage E (test + hygiene) — dec-test-strategy + dec-cli-extract + dec-doc-fixes + dec-resume. Stages A–C and E can land in any order; D depends on A's JTMS wiring and B's NodeIdFromDisplayId.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "24e3c616-8e7f-492e-a205-ef51b78cac7b", + "displayId": "D23", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Update PLAN.md in three places: (1) artifact layout section now lists graph/reconciliation-records.json (P28); (2) resolved design question #10 is updated to nudge_after_n default = 1, matching X42 and the implementation (P29, E36); (3) the post-redesign sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses are rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model (X16) and the deletion of FanInExtractionResult (X23).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "25e90c78-0d44-4f12-a042-6662b31d8bab", + "displayId": "CR32", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test must construct a small model where axis X has alternatives {a,b,c} and constraints rule out b and c; backbone(model) must return for axis X: {forcedValue:'a', blockingClauses:[, ]}. The blocking clauses must be the actual clauses present in the model.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "261866e5-b3e7-4e10-ae59-ec790f87b294", + "displayId": "CR25", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A grep check must confirm that the symbol FanInExtractionResult does not appear anywhere in src/** (no definition, no import, no re-export); all import sites in src/agents/fan-in.ts, src/engine/derivation-agents.ts, and src/engine/fan-in.ts must reference ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult instead.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "26a1fa52-967d-4255-961a-e6121e0258d0", + "displayId": "DEC13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Build a custom DPLL with explanation instrumentation; reject off-the-shelf SAT and brute-force enumeration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X59 and X60 both require constraint-attribution explanations on backbone, which most off-the-shelf SAT libraries do not expose without a UNSAT-core extension we'd have to bolt on anyway (RK13). RK13 also flags Deno compatibility risk for off-the-shelf libraries. alt-brute-force-enumeration is correct for tiny inputs but X32 (demotion candidates: 'identifying which demotions would make it solvable') is most naturally expressed as 'try the formula minus this clause and re-solve' — trivial in DPLL, awkward as 'enumerate again with one fewer filter and re-intersect'. The custom DPLL also gives full control over the blockingClauses field that X59 explicitly asks for." + }, + { + "id": "26bc2641-dd94-46f0-b462-747e57c9e0cf", + "displayId": "E7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Milestones M1 through M3 and most of M4 are complete; M6 (prose agent) and M9 (perspective hub) are also complete; M5 (resume/polish), M7 (web inspector), and the end-to-end smoke test remain outstanding.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "270f914b-0869-475b-9f5c-fabb65cb81bf", + "displayId": "T4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Conditional labels are ATMS-style truth maintenance markers; without them, reconciliation cannot distinguish 'derived under known inconsistency' from 'clean derivation'. They are a correctness property of the core loop, not a display feature.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "27178964-dd35-4182-9859-4902a7128e3a", + "displayId": "R18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Stage 1 must only emit a hard constraint when accompanied by explicit witnessing evidence (a source contradiction, a dependency requirement, or a grounded rationale from a run); non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4-5 fan-out runs alone must NOT be treated as evidence for a hard constraint.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2809500a-f66f-42f3-94eb-74a820a5540c", + "displayId": "DEC5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Compute baseline effects from real graph state, not from a hardcoded constant.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X18 explicitly defines baseline effects as a distinct layer of the model: 'per-alternative authorization requirements'. With them hardcoded to locked/true, every fan-in run pretends the baseline is locked even when it is provisional, which makes the M_revision flow always demand revision authorization for changes to provisional content — directly contradicting X20's three-space semantics. C7 (no shortcuts) rules out alt-baseline-keep-hardcoded." + }, + { + "id": "295c867a-750d-4987-9e7a-90b0d5c976e9", + "displayId": "E8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The codebase currently uses Console.log extensively throughout the engine for logging (fan-in, fan-out, phase-runner, reconciliation, derivation-loop, etc.).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "2b0ba4ec-88a2-4c2a-84ad-1ae1e14696e1", + "displayId": "D16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Generate perspective summaries by sampling configurations from the SAT solver's enumeration (capped at e.g. 200 per space) and running farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis-assignment vectors to pick k=3 representatives per space (M_current and M_preview separately). Each representative becomes a Perspective record carrying: the configuration vector, a default-bundle status flag (display only), and a short LLM-generated label. evaluateSelection runs against any user-chosen bundle and is the only readiness gate.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2bb66093-07a3-4c75-a581-33d1b774ffcb", + "displayId": "RK19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question: whether a blocking impasse (unsatisfiable configuration space) should be a persistent graph node or a transient grouping construct depends on whether it has semantic meaning.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2ca35c2e-2f02-4403-b8f2-40edca2f2429", + "displayId": "A18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep the existing single-stage FanInExtractionResult and patch it incrementally — add a structured stance field for P13, fix three-valued aggregation in-place, leave backbone and configuration enumeration where they are.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2ea9eaf6-0dd3-4426-9075-3ca7d8ba446b", + "displayId": "DEC3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Honor the agent hint with strict upstream-only validation; otherwise default to one phase down.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X1 mandates strict derivational order; alt-rewind-trust-agent could let the agent push the loop forward or sideways, violating the support-edge acyclicity invariant in domain/invariants.ts. alt-rewind-always-one-down is what the code does today and is what P11/RK1 explicitly call broken — it discards information the agent already paid LLM tokens to compute (e.g., a missing-premise impasse that needs to rewind all the way to grounding, not just to the immediately previous phase). The validation guard makes the new behavior safe under C1 (forward pass keeps working when the hint is absent or stale)." + }, + { + "id": "2ed593ba-2ec2-424e-bdd1-b4680256c1fa", + "displayId": "R51", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "PLAN.md's sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses must be rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model, the deletion of FanInExtractionResult, perspectives as records, and blocking impasses as graph nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2fc3fb60-1506-4f79-8516-6cbfd7792cd0", + "displayId": "DEC12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Delete FanInExtractionResult and introduce a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult type.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X23 explicitly mandates 'delete with no backward compatibility'. The legacy type embeds the assumption that extraction produces hub-shaped records (P7: 'hasRepairSelections', 'hasRevisionRequirements' fields on SelectionOutcome), so an extension (alt-config-extend-fanin-schema) carries dead-load that would invite reuse of the old code path. C7 (no shortcuts) and the X16 redesign direction support the clean replacement; this is a prototype (G1, X4) so backward compatibility has no external consumers to protect." + }, + { + "id": "30b0276c-b4d3-45b8-a84f-1c74f5d6a289", + "displayId": "R46", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts file must be split into focused per-module test files (one per module covered) colocated with the modules they test.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "31595a8b-0736-49d9-8499-bdac3eb30ba2", + "displayId": "R30", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The reconciliation engine must invoke solver.revisionImpact whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, and the OUT (tainted) closure it returns must be passed into the re-derivation flow.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "31a2b6c4-66e8-47ab-884d-211859df7763", + "displayId": "X26", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the plausibility verification agent takes node content and a source span as input and outputs a stance, rationale, and optionally lists of supported and unsupported claims.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "330dc552-e5ff-4fad-86a6-22e3ee2d243a", + "displayId": "X24", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must have axes, alternatives, per-run stance, witness relations, and candidate repairs as first-class fields.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3317213c-3dc1-4157-ae58-293df3e05081", + "displayId": "D2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "In reconciliation.ts, populate spawnedImpasseIds at the same point where the reconciler proposes new child impasses or where the LLM proposal includes a refinedImpasse: every node id added to the graph as a new Impasse during reconciliation must also be pushed onto the local spawnedImpasseIds array before the outcome tag is computed. This makes the existing 'recurse' outcome branch and the existing case \"recurse\" handler in derivation-loop.ts (which already passes spawnedImpasseIds as triggerImpasseIds to the recursive runDerivationLoop call) reachable for the first time.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "333c25e7-ff1e-4ebc-82bf-d11854550375", + "displayId": "A21", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: depend on an existing SAT library (e.g., a JS port of MiniSat or logic-solver). Use its model enumeration and (where available) its proof/explanation API.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "37006e13-96de-4ff5-9b37-75782b33a3a5", + "displayId": "R56", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or @kael/ai Routine abstractions in the course of this work; all integrations must be done at the consumer layer.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3743c9eb-2878-4574-bbdb-3b43e3d3e1b0", + "displayId": "E14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P10/P32: FrameRecord.nudgingActive is set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts, but no agent or engine code reads it and no negative constraint is injected into the clean room prompt.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "3820332b-c40d-4e03-82f8-b38a4cea7338", + "displayId": "A29", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: invest only in the end-to-end VCR test (X61) and rely on it to indirectly cover assembler/solver/etc., skipping per-module unit tests.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "387ecd16-14f3-4358-b66e-e1f85ce68b3e", + "displayId": "X50", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: three-valued aggregation (supports/contradicts/silent) is required in fan-in; silence is NOT contradiction and must not manufacture fake conflicts from omissions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "38cb4f68-b4bf-44e0-911b-09cafb316a70", + "displayId": "R3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a NodeIdFromDisplayId decode fails, the failure must propagate as a structured tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn through the existing Effect AI retry mechanism, so the agent can correct the reference without engine-side custom retry logic.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3955c976-4e69-4866-8e59-64c8a963ebdd", + "displayId": "D12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Demote Perspective from a hub-node kind in the graph to a plain record (struct) attached to the FanInRecord (or sibling DerivationRunRecord) artifact written under graph/. Edges that today point to a Perspective hub are removed; perspective summaries are referenced by id within the record store and rendered by the CLI/inspector. The graph schema's hub-kind union (T8: Justification, Decision, Impasse) is unchanged; perspective ceases to be one.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "39807624-ecf9-42b1-ad74-44470f1e9d25", + "displayId": "R59", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Every grounding node produced by the targeted grounding sub-agent or grounding-enrichment must have direct exogenous evidential provenance (citation/source span); the assembler's anti-laundering guardrail must reject grounding-phase events that do not carry such provenance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3992f96a-f563-48f3-aa69-78977148724c", + "displayId": "R67", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Impasse triage must remain a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) using the five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premise > term/ontology mismatch > upstream structural contradiction > endogenous design conflict (default).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3a270350-ad78-4543-9685-4dc44fa76843", + "displayId": "R68", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When two claims conflict with different authorities, the system must surface the conflict and label the authorities, but the user must always make the final decision; the engine must not auto-resolve based on an apparent authority cascade.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3aa1a7bf-9dfb-4e94-8d1c-958db451b53e", + "displayId": "D4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "determineRewindPhase becomes a function determineRewindPhase(currentPhase, suggestedRewindPhase?) that prefers the agent's suggestedRewindPhase when present and strictly upstream of currentPhase, validating against the four-phase order (grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done from X1) and falling back to 'one phase down' only when the hint is absent or invalid. It is plumbed through reconciliation.ts to where the recurse outcome is constructed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3be7d9b8-ffb9-432e-9ed1-6df465f33e71", + "displayId": "R69", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The derivation loop's progress measurement must consider three signals: (a) incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses, (b) resolved impasses, and (c) activated nodes. Lack of progress on all three across an iteration must be treated as stagnation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3c4be7f2-7405-4f68-95c2-648afbdb6212", + "displayId": "CR2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test of the reconciliation engine must verify that when a reconciler proposal carries disposition='refined' with a refinedImpasse payload: (a) a new Impasse hub node is created in the graph with status 'open', (b) a 'refined_to' lineage edge is created from the original impasse to the new one, (c) the original impasse is marked superseded (impasse-status), and (d) the new node id is pushed onto spawnedImpasseIds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3c8e64f6-d359-4184-9e52-c05ecb8e2f82", + "displayId": "X57", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate must be called for any milestone that exercises backward transitions such as grounding enrichment after a missing-premise impasse.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3d923c0e-5f8b-4072-9143-12a0fc515754", + "displayId": "E22", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P22: No test verifies that WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state (nodes, edges, frames, display ID counters, semantic keys); the PLAN marks this as tested but no test exists.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "3e09914b-2c64-4969-b9a8-1c4db650b698", + "displayId": "X29", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: each derived node has a justifications list used to determine which beliefs lose support during belief revision.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3e6d6eb2-9710-47bb-96cf-dcb79adfd42a", + "displayId": "A14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: replace Console.log with Effect.logInfo / Effect.logDebug structured logging (the X13 fallback option) without introducing an EventLog topic and subscriber model.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3ef0c670-92d6-4d34-a5b6-cd85d0d6bd58", + "displayId": "E24", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P24: engine/perspective-selection.ts is untested despite being fully testable with a scripted intervention driver.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "3f7f42e9-2af3-40ca-ba42-d6faa7dd653d", + "displayId": "T16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "There is no 'revision' axis type; revision is an effect of selecting a particular alternative, not a property of an axis.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "3f93695e-25c4-4ebd-8630-3b0cd908175c", + "displayId": "R35", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "clean-room-resolution.ts (and the perspective-selection consumer) must read the hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements flags from SelectionOutcome and dispatch to the repair re-derivation flow and revision authorization flow respectively; these flags must no longer be computed-but-unused.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "411cadcf-9167-4871-86f9-51a648d8641c", + "displayId": "CR24", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test must instantiate ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult from src/domain/configuration.ts with all required fields populated and verify the schema accepts: axes (id, type∈{design,repair}, cardinality∈{exactly_one,zero_or_one}, label); alternatives (id, axisId, label); perRunStance (runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance∈{supports,contradicts,silent}, optional rationale); witnesses (runId, claimId, sourceSpan); candidateRepairs (contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength); impasses (kind, conflictingNodes); hardConstraints (formula, witnessedBy∈{source_contradiction,dependency,grounded_rationale}, citation). Negative tests must reject invalid stance/type/cardinality values.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "41ad2d7e-54fc-46db-ad0f-6b781304415e", + "displayId": "R10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Fan-in must be split into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing a ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult, and Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis in engine/solver.ts (and a new engine/config-model.ts) consuming that result. The two stages must be independently invocable.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "423e5e61-c9e1-4bcd-82f2-4240de25800d", + "displayId": "X27", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a 'partial' plausibility verdict triggers a split or revision request; an 'unsupported' verdict rejects the node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "426fefcf-cb65-4031-b92e-f02fe3db51ad", + "displayId": "E31", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P34: Four public WorkingGraph methods (cowReplace, markSuspectAndPropagate, getSemanticKey, getChildFrames) are defined but have zero callers outside the class; COW grounding updates and suspect propagation are described as core mechanisms in the spec but the engine never exercises them.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "45bd3dcb-a38a-4a46-86c9-1fa3ed3cfbf6", + "displayId": "R57", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The implementation must continue to use pure JSON file I/O; it must not introduce a database (e.g., DuckDB), an in-memory cross-spec graph, or cross-graph retrieval at this stage.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4606bd52-c631-4d12-9de0-52f13914ba14", + "displayId": "CR8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Unit tests of buildBaselineEffects must verify that: (a) when the baseline node is locked, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'locked', requiresAuthorization:true}; (b) when the baseline node is provisional, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'provisional', requiresAuthorization:false}; (c) the function reads commitmentLevel from the WorkingGraph baseline node, not from a constant. Verified with two graph fixtures (locked and provisional baseline).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "463f0bd6-f251-47fb-8f0a-3f4067219d0a", + "displayId": "X25", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: plausibility verification uses a three-valued output — supported, partially-supported, or unsupported — each with a rationale string.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "46ca1fdb-6e08-4035-a2e4-c0cf0c95b386", + "displayId": "R42", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Module-level tests for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in Stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow must use scripted DerivationAgents and a scripted InterventionDriver (already injectable per E18) so the tests are deterministic and require no LLM calls.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "47431a96-c2b5-4141-9868-e03d78a4474e", + "displayId": "T2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Clean room re-derivation is a strict information-flow isolation mechanism: for a given target phase, it returns only active upstream nodes, creates a fresh Chat instance with no prior history, and ensures retry feedback is schema-only.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "48301d12-b28f-4020-8125-eb6c6953ff12", + "displayId": "R38", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) must be configured with file-read tools only; they must NOT have access to web search or paper read, because such results could surface content referencing the hidden impasse or old design.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "485197d8-a13b-4191-9948-6c28cf2f03b3", + "displayId": "X9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Progress in the derivation loop is measured by impasse refinement (incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses), resolved impasses, and activated nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "4a1bc305-5bf6-48d3-b791-b6d33fc69d7a", + "displayId": "D15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Implement the SAT solver as a small custom DPLL in TypeScript at src/engine/solver/dpll.ts (~200–400 LOC) with: unit propagation, pure-literal elimination, chronological backtracking, and an instrumentation hook that records, for each backtrack, which clauses caused the conflict. Public surface: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}. The solver imports nothing outside std and Effect.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4ba71112-e314-452b-a979-4bffb7a933fa", + "displayId": "X61", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: integration tests for the derivation loop must cover all three impasse types in sequence using VCR-style recorded interaction snapshots against OpenRouter.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "4c563fc0-1e01-4025-8a74-3a5f002eb323", + "displayId": "R6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Engine events must be defined as a closed discriminated-union type at src/engine/events.ts whose variants include at minimum: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt, FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed, PerspectiveGenerated, ReconcileOutcome, ImpasseSpawned, ImpasseResolved, NudgeActivated, CowReplace, SuspectPropagated, BlockingImpasseRaised, UserInterventionRequested, UserInterventionResolved. Adding a new event must require adding a new variant to the union (no open string-tag fallback).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4f2055fa-4205-498a-921d-84032e59b8f2", + "displayId": "A30", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: invest only in unit tests for P19–P25 and skip the VCR E2E because of the maintenance burden of recorded snapshots (RK14).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4f9b54c4-af0c-4a74-8839-20a1424e2248", + "displayId": "R61", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The plausibility verification agent must take node content and a source span as input and produce a three-valued output: 'supported', 'partially-supported', or 'unsupported', each accompanied by a rationale string and optionally lists of supported and unsupported claims.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4fede9ad-0614-4c7b-b090-84f065d7e02f", + "displayId": "R15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Per-run stance must be tracked at per-run × per-axis × per-alternative granularity; a run must be allowed to support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "51dc3db4-f1ef-42b6-b634-175c2d352616", + "displayId": "T6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Specs are modeled as sub-graphs of typed, addressable claims connected by meaningful edges; the memory system is also a sub-graph within a super-graph architecture where all sub-graphs are searchable through a unified retrieval layer.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "53b04e07-fba8-4582-b272-f6fa4633b7be", + "displayId": "R24", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each Perspective record must point at a real activatable configuration drawn from the enumerated set, not at an interpolated centroid.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "53ee8ee5-bc95-453a-a31f-4133eff5aa36", + "displayId": "RK10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question (Q10): The targeted grounding sub-agent could launder prior design choices as facts via memory/cross-spec search; grounding nodes must have direct exogenous evidential provenance as a guardrail.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "542ea848-58d4-4ed3-84eb-4ac10b0b08cc", + "displayId": "D20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "For v1 of the new fan-in, disable solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence (X43): every detected contradiction becomes a repair axis presented to the user, regardless of evidence asymmetry. Auto-resolution becomes a follow-up pass once the repair flow is exercised in tests. The auto-resolution code path is feature-flagged (config.repairAutoResolve = false by default) rather than removed, so X43's design intent is preserved.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "56f7d4e0-fa99-402e-b187-532729ccfa41", + "displayId": "R32", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Superseded (OUT) nodes must never be deleted from the graph; they must be retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement, preserving the JTMS justification chain so the graph grows monotonically.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "574d7f89-63b5-4e5e-be43-34e93ebe67cb", + "displayId": "R14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Per-run stance must be carried as a structured field on ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult with exactly the values 'supports', 'contradicts', or 'silent'; three-valued aggregation in fan-in must read this structured field rather than parsing prose, and silence must never be aggregated as contradiction.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "57861403-9294-4707-bdeb-d96f26f0ee47", + "displayId": "D7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "buildBaselineEffects in fan-in.ts reads the actual baseline node's commitment level (locked vs. provisional) from the graph and sets requiresAuthorization accordingly; locked baseline nodes produce {commitmentLevel: 'locked', requiresAuthorization: true}, provisional baseline nodes produce {commitmentLevel: 'provisional', requiresAuthorization: false}. The function takes the WorkingGraph plus the baselineFrameId / baseline node id set, not just the FanIn extraction result.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "57b9a0a2-62ba-402f-8b40-0c1631c10b50", + "displayId": "D6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Immediately after every cowReplace call, the engine calls markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) which traverses identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into per X53) and sets review status to suspect on all transitively reachable nodes. The derivation loop reads suspect status to decide which downstream phases need re-derivation in the next iteration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "587b4a06-fd9a-4fda-9449-d7305aaa73e8", + "displayId": "CR18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A CLI integration test must run a scripted derivation and verify that the human-readable stdout output is produced by the CLI's EventLog subscriber (e.g., by replacing the subscriber with a no-op and asserting stdout is empty), confirming that the CLI consumes EventLog events rather than receiving Console.log calls from the engine.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "58b19bc4-37e7-4544-84b7-3bd1288e4dee", + "displayId": "R27", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When the user resolves a blocking impasse by choosing a constraint demotion, the engine must record that choice as a relaxed_to edge from the BlockingImpasse node to the demoted constraint node, creating an auditable record.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "59935f6f-29d3-4d4f-9845-2bc510234ecc", + "displayId": "X59", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: when the solver determines an axis has only one valid value across all configurations (a backbone/forced assignment), the system must show which constraint rules made the other values impossible.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5b5d6be9-26f1-4991-8523-e11dad18ea82", + "displayId": "DEC22", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Implement resume that re-enters the topmost open frame from the on-disk artifact; do not checkpoint mid-step.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "RK7 records the stakeholder preference for no mutable-state checkpoint dumps. T2 requires clean-room re-derivation to start with a fresh Chat anyway, so 'resuming a chat in progress' is meaningless inside a frame. The on-disk graph is already the source of truth (X3: pure JSON file I/O, no DB); re-entering at frame boundaries is the largest unit at which resume is well-defined. alt-resume-checkpoint-dumps directly contradicts RK7. alt-resume-skip is heavier than necessary given a 20-min-to-1-hr session length (X4) where a process death without resume costs significant LLM-spend." + }, + { + "id": "5ca5e9be-c051-494c-96d4-b7c12faf83b9", + "displayId": "E19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P19: engine/assembler.ts has no unit tests; it converts IR events to graph nodes and edges including reference resolution, hub constraint enforcement, and lineage edge creation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "5e77bd42-29da-411f-9bf1-6f9944f5b320", + "displayId": "X37", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a run can support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5f489a08-27dc-4e54-af9a-45e8ac5aa174", + "displayId": "A15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep Console.log but funnel it through a single helper module so the coupling is at one place; defer EventLog migration to post-prototype.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "60d531d9-dec9-4caf-ab4b-4b35ee4aa74c", + "displayId": "A20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: extend FanInExtractionResult with the new fields (axes, perRunStance, candidateRepairs) and keep the type name and existing import sites, providing a soft migration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "61d44955-9296-46a1-8ad7-cc64e7af4cda", + "displayId": "T17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Substrate (backbone) is the set of alternatives that must be selected (or must not be selected) in every configuration in M_current, defined semantically as common consequences rather than by provenance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "62a3c921-de58-4619-a49a-fe19ea30382c", + "displayId": "CR17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A type-level (compile-time) test must verify that the engine event type defined in src/engine/events.ts is a closed discriminated union: emitting an event with an unknown _tag must be a TypeScript compile error. Test method: a `// @ts-expect-error` line that attempts to emit an event with a fabricated tag.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6320aa52-dd3f-4f78-8fc9-7011f8ebb8f3", + "displayId": "X45", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: repair choices and design choices are fundamentally different — a repair resolves a source contradiction, a design choice selects among valid alternatives. The system must not present them as the same kind of preference.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "63d8a14d-6b0f-42f0-98d1-877327ffa8e3", + "displayId": "R4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "No file under src/engine/** (including fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection.ts, assembler.ts) may import or call Console.log or any other Console method after the migration; this is enforceable as a static lint/grep check.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "64685c38-cf6c-4b2c-8e60-024bbf821690", + "displayId": "A5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep determineRewindPhase as 'always one phase down' and instead remove suggestedRewindPhase from the agent schema as unused.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6575a339-95ef-4c82-816e-b2233063b1ad", + "displayId": "R34", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Design (non-repair) selection must be monotone: it must NOT trigger taint propagation, OUT computation, or re-derivation. Only repair selection and revision authorization trigger non-monotone updates.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "65949e1a-e717-44ca-bf32-ae1d05689dc0", + "displayId": "A34", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: drop M5 resume entirely; require restarting from scratch on any failure.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "65edef93-ed21-438a-b6a0-819d24a39bcb", + "displayId": "E35", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The justifications structure (JTMS/ATMS-style truth maintenance) already exists in the codebase on ConfigurationModel.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "67883681-3630-4e4f-b6a1-f1d963e5e38b", + "displayId": "R66", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a node carries a cached sourceAuthoritySet, triage must always re-traverse to validate the cache against live graph state; if cached and live results diverge (e.g., due to a supersededBy update), the node must be flagged as requiring re-derivation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "67ab6b10-5d95-4381-89ea-dad04db02bae", + "displayId": "RK9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question (Q9): Derived nodes show authority: derived, erasing the original authority basis; triage and reconciliation may need sourceAuthoritySet / sourceEpistemicBasis summary fields to see through derivation chains.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "69441906-da2a-4d49-ab15-ce5b9f983e57", + "displayId": "A3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: treat 'refined' as a terminal disposition that just marks the original impasse superseded without creating a successor; rely on the next pass through the loop to discover the residual problem fresh.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6ac7bbea-d275-4efd-99e0-40e86df70953", + "displayId": "E9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P1: spawnedImpasseIds in reconciliation.ts is always initialized as an empty array and nothing ever pushes to it, making the recurse outcome condition unreachable and the derivation loop's case \"recurse\" handler dead code.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "6ad93ee5-89c1-4320-8872-b7609188ae30", + "displayId": "X55", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: conflict resolution should always attempt a deterministic graph traversal first, computing the minimal set of grounding nodes whose removal resolves the conflict.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6de863b9-f235-468c-b259-bce24db75618", + "displayId": "X41", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: sourceAuthoritySet is stored as a cache on a node at creation time for fast reads, but triage always re-traverses to validate it; if cached and live results diverge (e.g., due to a supersededBy update), the node is flagged as requiring re-derivation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6f153334-6d38-4b21-b311-8a92bd56c102", + "displayId": "DEC17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Repair selection triggers JTMS-driven re-derivation in a new child frame; design selection remains monotone.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X20 explicitly distinguishes: 'design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repair selection is non-monotone with respect to premises'. X45 reinforces the categorical split. alt-repair-monotone-likedesign produces a graph where downstream phases reference grounding facts the user has just rejected — exactly the silent-contradiction problem that motivated the entire feature-model redesign (E33). The new-child-frame approach (X39) keeps the re-derivation auditable and reuses the existing reconciliation machinery rather than a new in-place rewrite path." + }, + { + "id": "706053cf-bba9-4cc8-80ce-d2bc9be1fb07", + "displayId": "X1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The derivation pipeline has four phases in strict derivational dependency order: grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done. Execution is non-linear via backward transitions, but support edges must remain acyclic.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "70c05342-e714-4fd2-9cc3-216197aba112", + "displayId": "A28", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: ship X43's auto-resolution heuristic on by default in v1.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7183aa8d-97db-4d3f-b25b-367d30036bb7", + "displayId": "D17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "When the solver returns M_current as empty or unsatisfiable, the engine creates a first-class BlockingImpasse Impasse node (kind: 'unsatisfiable_configuration_space') in the graph with: support edges to all hard-constraint nodes that participate in the UNSAT core, status: open. The engine then surfaces demotionCandidates to the user; the user's chosen demotion is recorded as a relaxed_to edge from the BlockingImpasse node to the demoted constraint node. The blocking impasse remains in the graph after resolution (status: resolved) so it participates in the JTMS chain as a recorded decision point.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7184c9db-64e3-4280-94f4-b71d2e44a58f", + "displayId": "E36", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "nudgeAfterN defaults to 1 in the current derivation loop implementation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "71f2fe97-de5e-4800-adfd-0876139bbf90", + "displayId": "DEC11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Adopt the two-stage split with a hard schema boundary forbidding solver outputs from Stage 1.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X19 + X49 jointly mandate this split. The current single-stage design (alt-fanin-keep-single-stage) is what made E32's infinite-loop pathology possible: when the LLM 'decides' a contradiction it is computing backbone non-deterministically across runs, which is exactly the behavior X49 forbids. alt-fanin-llm-does-everything is incompatible with X49 and with C2 (deterministic tests) — backbone would no longer be a pure function of the extraction. The hard schema boundary (Stage 1 cannot return backbone fields) is what enforces the determinism property at compile time." + }, + { + "id": "71f9a800-3cda-4e12-9e56-c31436684385", + "displayId": "C4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Existing smoke test artifacts must still validate after changes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "73c9749a-7ad0-4148-979a-3419b0665a75", + "displayId": "E15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P11: suggestedRewindPhase from the agent is always ignored; determineRewindPhase always returns one phase down regardless of the agent's hint.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "74cfe77b-21eb-4767-b758-7cfd5e7ae38e", + "displayId": "X22", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: readiness is evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection, not per perspective; a perspective summary carries default-bundle status for display only.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "74e657fe-1a19-4cac-a38c-51e87d1b3325", + "displayId": "X30", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: constraint verification follows the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification — most cases handled mechanically, with uncertain cases elevated to a subagent.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "75493a86-5dc0-4dce-a7dc-f1fd3dcc0db1", + "displayId": "A22", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: skip SAT entirely; for the stated scale of 5–20 axes × 2–5 alternatives, enumerate all assignments and filter by constraint formulas, computing backbone by intersection.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7592a904-33ea-42ad-b91f-db72ecfefcff", + "displayId": "RK12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question (Q12): Same-authority normative tradeoffs (latency vs cost, privacy vs observability) also require user adjudication but aren't authority conflicts per se; the triage class name may be too narrow.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "772edee2-e028-462c-9f49-20864f1c3de7", + "displayId": "X34", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the user's chosen constraint demotion is recorded as an edge from the blocking impasse node to the relaxed constraint, creating an auditable record.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "7760c432-2ed5-4ddb-a4b2-91d1b9fbdc30", + "displayId": "X53", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: suspect status propagates only through identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into); it does NOT auto-propagate through depends_on, derived_from, hub edges, motivates, references, or defines.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "79668f71-b126-46cf-8f5f-a17838135e3e", + "displayId": "R40", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The codebase must include unit tests for each of the following pure-logic components: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, assembler.ts (reference resolution, hub constraint enforcement, lineage edge creation), makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts, perspective-selection.ts, domain/invariants.ts validate() (including violating graphs that exercise support-edge acyclicity and phase stratification), the solver primitives (validateModel, enumerateConfigurations, backbone, demotionCandidates), and render/markdown.ts (snapshot-based).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "799c3f7e-67db-4df0-a2b5-44526c516c5d", + "displayId": "CR22", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Module tests must verify that fan-in Stage 1 (LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult) and Stage 2 (deterministic solver analysis in engine/solver.ts + engine/config-model.ts) can be invoked independently: Stage 2 can be called with a fixture ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult and produce a configuration model deterministically, without invoking Stage 1.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "79b8d46c-bdd6-47ad-9315-b116d99eddec", + "displayId": "DEC7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Adopt NodeIdFromDisplayId as a schema type with checkEffect-based decode against the live graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X12 directly mandates this approach. The schema-level placement means failures appear in the natural Effect AI retry loop (LLM sees a structured tool error and retries) rather than requiring a custom retry path on top of assembler errors (alt-nodeid-validation-after-assembly), which is a parallel mechanism that duplicates Effect AI's own behavior. alt-nodeid-semantic-key-only is too restrictive: agents legitimately need to reference pre-existing graph nodes by their stable display ID across phases (e.g., a shaping design that supports a grounding constraint by ID), and semantic keys are scoped to a single derivation batch (X10). The schema-level approach addresses RK2 and P30 in the place where the contract between LLM and engine actually lives." + }, + { + "id": "79d5e526-714a-4b0e-9fd5-9271d7879438", + "displayId": "R13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The previously-used FanInExtractionResult type must be deleted from the codebase with no backward-compatibility shim; all import sites in src/agents/fan-in.ts, src/engine/derivation-agents.ts, and src/engine/fan-in.ts must be updated to use ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7aae1303-11fc-4f36-914d-4e0ac74cda39", + "displayId": "D14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Define ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields: axes: ReadonlyArray<{id, type: 'design'|'repair', cardinality: 'exactly_one'|'zero_or_one', label}>; alternatives: ReadonlyArray<{id, axisId, label}>; perRunStance: ReadonlyArray<{runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance: 'supports'|'contradicts'|'silent', rationale?}>; witnesses: ReadonlyArray<{runId, claimId, sourceSpan}>; candidateRepairs: ReadonlyArray<{contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength}>; impasses: ReadonlyArray<{kind: 'authority_conflict'|'missing_premise'|..., conflictingNodes}>; hardConstraints: ReadonlyArray<{formula, witnessedBy: 'source_contradiction'|'dependency'|'grounded_rationale', citation}>. The previously-used FanInExtractionResult is deleted with no backward-compat shim.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7c1f1e8c-a312-454e-950e-cc27ee65827d", + "displayId": "CR14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A schema-level test must verify that every agent IR field that previously carried a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives, selected, rejected, consequences, premises, conclusions) is typed via NodeIdFromDisplayId and not plain string. Verified by inspecting the exported schemas and asserting the brand/type of each id-bearing field.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7c6bbf00-5e63-42eb-8865-68c722f887ec", + "displayId": "DEC18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Default repair auto-resolution off in v1; surface every contradiction as a repair axis.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "RK18 explicitly suggests this for v1, citing correctness over user load. C7 (maximally correct, no shortcuts) prefers conservative behavior when the heuristic 'one repair option is clearly better-evidenced' has not yet been validated against real fan-in data. alt-repair-autoresolve-on risks silent decisions during the period when the repair flow is also new, compounding error sources during integration testing." + }, + { + "id": "7ee9ecc6-bf6c-4668-9083-f65a40815ea8", + "displayId": "X64", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "domain/graph.ts defines WorkingGraph.cowReplace(...) and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate(...) as public methods, but a repo-wide search finds no callers outside the class definition itself.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "800301b2-1de7-48ac-acba-4fbbb76af49d", + "displayId": "E16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P13: The fan-in extraction schema has no structured field for per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent); three-valued aggregation depends entirely on prompt compliance rather than structural enforcement.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "801d856a-cea3-4a17-92ee-eced6ab89f76", + "displayId": "RK5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Console.log is used throughout the engine for output, coupling the engine to CLI presentation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "80706656-7cf4-4d07-b388-fd717259496d", + "displayId": "DEC15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Persist blocking impasses as first-class graph nodes participating in JTMS.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X33 + X35 explicitly mandate this. RK19's open question is resolved by X33 in this grounding; the answer is 'persistent graph node'. alt-blocking-impasse-transient breaks X34 (the user's demotion choice must be auditable as an edge from the impasse) and X35 (must participate in provenance/JTMS), neither of which work for a transient record. Persisting it also gives the user a stable referent if the same constraint conflict recurs across revisions." + }, + { + "id": "80a24141-0fdf-4da4-b642-615001e8fea6", + "displayId": "D5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Wire WorkingGraph.cowReplace into the grounding-enrichment path: when the user escalation produces resolve_directly or sharpen outcomes (X7) or the targeted grounding sub-agent emits a node that refines an existing grounding node, the engine calls cowReplace({oldNodeId, newNode}) instead of mutating in place; cowReplace's emitted lineage edge is the audit trail. The call sites are (a) intervention.ts for stakeholder-supplied resolve_directly/sharpen outputs, (b) grounding-enrichment.ts post-assembly when the new node has lineageFrom: refined_by/strengthened_by/weakened_by referencing an existing grounding node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "80a6b237-0a22-4b59-9974-b4cafa54ba55", + "displayId": "E13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P8: justifications is always set to an empty array in the configuration model, so the solver's revisionImpact function (JTMS-style truth maintenance) has no data to operate on.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "82589b98-a0fc-425c-97d6-6652b6d51cc0", + "displayId": "R29", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "assembler.ts must populate the justifications field on every derived node it creates, with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub the node is connected to, recording {hubId, premiseIds: [...]} reflecting the actual hub premise edges.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "84b0d1c9-e09d-4b62-9231-32eccd3867a9", + "displayId": "E28", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P28: The artifact layout in PLAN.md does not list graph/reconciliation-records.json but the code writes it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "85d17542-cfdb-41a9-8ac6-1a72b4afa99b", + "displayId": "X16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: replace the impasse-centric cross-run divergence model with a feature-model / SAT-analyzed constraint problem over a structured variable space; perspectives become a presentation layer over this model rather than the primary semantic unit.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "860f792c-a2cf-4910-b19f-40770e725608", + "displayId": "CR5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "An integration test using scripted intervention/grounding-enrichment must verify that when a stakeholder resolve_directly or sharpen outcome refines an existing grounding node, WorkingGraph.cowReplace is invoked with {oldNodeId, newNode} and a lineage edge is emitted recording the replacement; verified by spying cowReplace and asserting at least one call per scenario.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "86476bb7-18bd-40d9-95f2-e184e963fa99", + "displayId": "T10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Grounding is the exogenous substrate: not clean-roomed, using copy-on-write semantics. New nodes are added and existing nodes can be modified via COW. The substrate persists across backward transitions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "8647cdb2-ede5-4b11-a8e9-721d6b93554f", + "displayId": "X14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: replace the logging system with the Effect EventLog so every action taken emits an event, replacing all Console.log calls completely.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "874e362a-6f3e-429c-800d-620ef5af7e74", + "displayId": "A13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: deprecate displayId references in agent output entirely; require agents to emit only semanticKey references for upstream support, and have the assembler resolve semantic keys (which exist deterministically per emit batch).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "89d9b1f4-8dfd-4b71-81d0-71bbeb4aba1d", + "displayId": "A27", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: treat repair selection identically to design selection — monotone, no re-derivation — simplifying perspective-selection.ts at the cost of leaving downstream content derived from the un-chosen contradiction side intact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8d4d362d-9b04-4b52-99fb-5c05e9b6295a", + "displayId": "R12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult must be defined in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields for: axes (id, type ∈ {design, repair}, cardinality ∈ {exactly_one, zero_or_one}, label); alternatives (id, axisId, label); perRunStance (runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance ∈ {supports, contradicts, silent}, optional rationale); witnesses (runId, claimId, sourceSpan); candidateRepairs (contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength); impasses (kind, conflictingNodes); hardConstraints (formula, witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency, grounded_rationale}, citation).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8d7da667-88fe-4eed-8ff2-89c2cf7e649f", + "displayId": "R58", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The implementation must not add support for parallel/concurrent spec design sessions; the architecture remains single-session for this work.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8e282073-ba84-4592-ab3d-a8d93afe6689", + "displayId": "A12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep displayId as plain string in the schema, but turn the silent .filter(undefined) in assembler.ts into a hard error that aborts the derivation step; surface it back to the agent via the existing reconciler retry path.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8f836346-a5d1-4c10-ae22-5529b954555f", + "displayId": "D18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Populate the justifications field on derived nodes during assembly: assembler.ts, when creating a derived node, builds a justifications array with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub the node is connected to, recording {hubId, premiseIds: [...]}. solver.ts's revisionImpact function is called from the reconciliation engine whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, returning the closure of OUT (tainted) nodes per X28. The OUT closure is fed into the re-derivation flow (dec-cow-wiring).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8f9d5288-4fb9-47e3-a6e0-255ba7d77b56", + "displayId": "DEC2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Create a fresh refined Impasse node and emit a refined_to lineage edge from the original to the refined one; mark the original superseded and recurse with the refined node id in spawnedImpasseIds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X9 defines progress as 'incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses' — that progress signal only exists if refinement materializes a fresh node with an incoming refined_to edge, which alt-refined-as-edge-only does not produce. T9 distinguishes superseded as an impasse-status independent of lifecycle, which only makes sense if there is a successor to point at. alt-refined-as-resolved discards reconciler reasoning and forces re-discovery from scratch, contradicting C7 ('maximally correct, no shortcuts'). The chosen design also unifies cleanly with dec-recurse-wiring (single push site)." + }, + { + "id": "906b8fdb-a9a5-4c39-810e-1e65fcade3e6", + "displayId": "DEC9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use a closed discriminated-union event catalog.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X15 says granularity should be 'notable occurrences' — a closed union enforces that bar at the type system level (you have to add a tag, which makes you ask 'is this notable?'). Open-ended events (alt-eventlog-freeform) regress to the current Console.log situation where every author chooses ad hoc strings, defeating the point of typed events for downstream consumers (M7 web inspector, E7)." + }, + { + "id": "915eb102-3331-4ea9-a316-e7c9053013d4", + "displayId": "RK8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question (Q8): Impasse triage may need to inspect provenance closure (the 'conflict core') rather than just surface metadata for mixed-cause impasses; missing premise is an absence not visible in node metadata.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "9206977f-602d-4355-ba18-cb75d41dd40c", + "displayId": "DEC21", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Land doc fixes alongside the corresponding code changes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "PLAN.md is referenced by the spec workflow (E6) and discrepancies between PLAN and code are exactly the class of error PROBLEMS.md tracks (P28, P29). Lettings docs drift (alt-doc-fix-defer) regenerates the same defect class. The change is minor enough to land per-PR with the corresponding code change." + }, + { + "id": "92125c08-591d-46e6-8198-708eb34ccd1f", + "displayId": "T14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A run that resolves a source contradiction by picking a side witnesses a candidate repair (a possible maximal consistent subset), not an auto-resolution; the contradiction remains until a repair is explicitly licensed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "9318162d-61a2-425a-afde-e3b50d208af8", + "displayId": "RK13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Using an off-the-shelf SAT solver risks less control over explanation/proof output and may have Deno compatibility issues.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "9323af51-66ef-4b3e-92eb-a35aa26f8bd1", + "displayId": "R49", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "PLAN.md's artifact layout section must list graph/reconciliation-records.json so the documented layout matches what the code writes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "93c0afe0-21e7-4ba5-bd45-c3aece3d981d", + "displayId": "CR12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A module test with a scripted agent that emits an unresolvable display ID must verify the schema decode failure becomes an Effect AI tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn (i.e., the agent receives a structured retry prompt), and that the engine does not silently filter or drop the reference.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "944a5265-ec30-43a4-9e10-1407c5cfca95", + "displayId": "X6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The grounding enrichment agent is impasse-aware, uses FullToolkit for research, is constrained to grounding-phase semantic roles only, and includes an anti-laundering guardrail that validates all enrichment events against the grounding roles set before assembly.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "94b6f96f-5879-4b60-a508-6d07e55262db", + "displayId": "X28", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: belief revision uses JTMS-style propagation — a derived node becomes OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "94ee75d4-8593-4121-8056-409d68544834", + "displayId": "T1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The derivation loop is the core post-forward-pass mechanism: it checks for impasses, initiates backward transitions by creating child frames, runs clean-room fan-out, reconciles, and recurses inside-out by generation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "951d0c0a-b0e1-462c-b557-298e2fa2ad01", + "displayId": "E27", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P27: cli/run.ts inlines report formatting (40-line formatHandoffReport and 30-line derivation agent construction) that could be extracted to separate modules.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "9560ec33-8c59-4d8f-ae99-ad3b8ce90559", + "displayId": "X21", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: perspective summaries are generated from representative configurations using diverse exemplar selection (farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis assignments), sampling M_current and M_preview separately.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "972ebb02-4c92-4843-b686-8048e6aa6b4e", + "displayId": "R65", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Reconciliation must not archive a node merely because a re-derivation omitted it; if upstream grounding still supports the node and there is no contradiction, omission is insufficient justification for archival.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "973b6cd9-0b74-48c5-a7c9-41b345afe794", + "displayId": "DEC16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Populate justifications and wire revisionImpact into the reconciliation engine.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X28 + X29 + X38 specify JTMS-style propagation as the chosen mechanism for taint after repair selection. alt-jtms-remove-dead-code is feasible but conflicts with C7 (no shortcuts) and X40 (graph grows monotonically; superseded nodes retained with supersededBy edges) — retaining superseded nodes only makes sense if downstream consumers can distinguish IN from OUT, which is precisely what JTMS provides. The justifications + revisionImpact pair is already implemented and tested (E13, E17); the missing piece is connecting it." + }, + { + "id": "97918244-9ef3-417d-9b0e-6b1fd9ea43c1", + "displayId": "R63", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Constraint verification must follow the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification: most cases handled mechanically, with uncertain cases elevated to a subagent. Partial verdicts from the subagent must be fed back to the originating agent for correction.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "97faa5d1-e102-4ee2-a760-1af6a5edd038", + "displayId": "CR6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "An integration test must verify that immediately after every cowReplace call, markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) is invoked and traverses identity-preserving lineage edges only (equivalent_to, merged_into), setting review status to 'suspect' on transitively reachable nodes; the test must include nodes connected via depends_on / derived_from / hub edges / motivates / references / defines and assert those are NOT marked suspect.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "97faec91-4c1b-4990-85f4-dffbfe21992f", + "displayId": "R41", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "There must be a unit test that asserts WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state, including nodes, edges, frames, display ID counters, and semantic keys.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9893251d-cfb0-478a-91b2-158604337310", + "displayId": "CR13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A static grep check must confirm that src/engine/assembler.ts contains no '.filter(' expression that drops references whose display ID failed to resolve, and that the post-hoc resolve-and-filter code path described in P30 has been removed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "992707bf-bb1f-462b-81fd-2837293e396c", + "displayId": "X12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type using SchemaGetter.checkEffect should replace all post-hoc display ID resolution, so schema decode failures surface as tool result errors that the LLM sees and can retry.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "99e1ed41-a29f-441a-bc73-7e527111dd14", + "displayId": "X51", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: enrichment nodes carry dual provenance — workflow provenance (which impasse prompted the inquiry, tracked via motivates edges) and evidential provenance (the direct exogenous source). Only evidential provenance may justify downstream derivation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "9a7a523a-a789-4ad0-a9b7-2ec194fee927", + "displayId": "X10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Agents emit semantic keys and support sets during derivation; the graph assembler assigns UUIDs and display IDs and creates edges, keeping normalization deterministic and testable and preventing the model from hallucinating edge targets.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "9ad7f43e-b2b7-4f64-983d-926de4a55200", + "displayId": "X47", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4–5 fan-out runs is NOT evidence of a constraint; hard constraints require explicit evidence such as a source contradiction, dependency requirement, or grounded rationale from a run.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "9c12af11-88e9-44c9-a016-d80cb4935753", + "displayId": "R5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Every notable engine occurrence (phase entry/completion, fan-out attempts, fan-in stages, reconcile outcomes, impasse spawn/resolution, nudge activation, cowReplace, suspect propagation, blocking impasse raise, user intervention request/resolution) must emit a typed event via Effect EventLog.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9cab9e54-2d32-4094-bd7f-21ea6c2d189e", + "displayId": "X32", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: when M_current is unsatisfiable, the system proposes a set of constraint demotions, identifying which demotions would make it solvable and which would not.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a2707293-ffd1-48ab-9e0c-a77cc7939bf8", + "displayId": "X31", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: when a partial verdict is returned by the subagent for constraint or plausibility checking, it is fed back to the originating agent for correction.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a34ed745-2d19-420c-8542-d7253d58dbfc", + "displayId": "X43", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: repair selection auto-resolves when one repair option is clearly better-evidenced; only genuinely ambiguous repairs become user-facing axes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a43d964e-6754-4eb3-bda9-27cde37227f3", + "displayId": "R44", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "There must be exactly one end-to-end smoke test that drives the derivation loop through all three impasse types in sequence (authority conflict, missing premise, endogenous design conflict) using VCR-style recorded OpenRouter interaction snapshots.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "a4da8d17-68f6-406b-b092-f2039ac3328d", + "displayId": "R39", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each clean-room re-derivation invocation must instantiate a fresh Chat with no prior history; retry feedback to the agent must be schema-only (e.g., NodeIdFromDisplayId decode errors), never freeform.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "a59d8fdb-5b4d-4ff0-ac9e-23d1755fa5ef", + "displayId": "R62", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "A 'partially-supported' plausibility verdict must trigger a split-or-revision request fed back to the originating agent for correction; an 'unsupported' verdict must reject the node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "a62ac18f-8b7b-4b43-bb75-3353b9881657", + "displayId": "E21", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P21: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, which converts FanInExtractionResult to a typed ConfigurationModel, is untested.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a63c692e-bdb2-4498-a467-dc9756efcbeb", + "displayId": "E30", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P30: Display IDs are resolved post-hoc with silent data loss: when a display ID doesn't resolve, the code silently drops it via .filter(nodeId !== undefined) or logs a non-blocking error, so the LLM never learns its reference was invalid and no retry is triggered.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a83b80db-29b2-463f-9b4a-11eb86307e57", + "displayId": "RK2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Agents produce display IDs as strings; when these don't resolve, data is silently dropped instead of being fed back as errors.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "a845a045-1666-4660-8373-31f700d26131", + "displayId": "X3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The prototype uses pure JSON file I/O; there is no DuckDB, no memory graph, and no cross-graph retrieval.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "a8a49f5e-82cc-4c62-bc6d-8c44fe1c58e9", + "displayId": "E26", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P26: m4-engine.test.ts is 1702 lines covering 7 modules and should be split into focused per-module test files.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "aa1c1296-1020-4f43-ace8-4358c75ef00d", + "displayId": "C2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Tests must be deterministic and must not make LLM calls.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "aa8ed847-6e0b-4387-a4aa-73028595ebdb", + "displayId": "D1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Decompose the code-health work into six work-streams driven by the grounding: (1) Derivation-loop correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P11, P34, C6); (2) Reference-integrity via schema-level NodeIdFromDisplayId (P30); (3) Engine-decoupled observability via Effect EventLog (RK5, X14); (4) Feature-model / SAT replacement of the impasse-centric divergence model (E32, E33, X16–X25, X32–X37, X44–X50); (5) Pure-logic test coverage and an end-to-end VCR integration test (P18–P25, X61); (6) Hygiene / refactor / doc fixes (P26, P27, P28, P29, P6).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ab9bc416-80bd-4089-805c-789e31545aa6", + "displayId": "E34", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate exist as functions in the graph domain.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "abdb8809-e724-4f54-b5bc-372644f4b476", + "displayId": "X17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: partial selections (user hasn't chosen on some axes yet) are interaction state, not model cardinality; the solver operates on total configurations while the UI allows incremental selection.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "acb81cf5-0510-467b-a16f-d105d9625980", + "displayId": "RK14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "VCR-style tests require maintaining recorded snapshots and re-recording when prompts change.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ae39b8b3-06ce-4b48-ad01-66cdc6beecce", + "displayId": "R43", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The test suite must include property tests for at least: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monotonicity over repeated mark/unmark, (c) the equality solver.backbone(model) == intersection-of-solver.enumerateConfigurations(model).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "aeba6664-3fb8-4504-92a1-ae9bc09b9748", + "displayId": "R50", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 must state nudge_after_n default = 1, matching the implementation and X42.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "af3c3468-9cf3-4ad7-a772-97fc045956b9", + "displayId": "CR4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Unit tests of determineRewindPhase must verify: (a) when the agent supplies suggestedRewindPhase strictly upstream of currentPhase, it is honored (e.g., currentPhase=defining-done + hint=grounding rewinds to grounding); (b) when the hint is absent, it falls back to one phase down; (c) when the hint equals or is downstream of currentPhase, the hint is rejected and the function falls back to one phase down; (d) invalid phase strings are rejected.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "afb3adab-ff11-44af-8cdd-f55c8181a93c", + "displayId": "X63", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "engine/reconciliation.ts already has the structural plumbing for the 'recurse' outcome (an empty spawnedImpasseIds: NodeId[] array, an outcomeTag branch, and a return shape with spawnedImpasseIds + suggestedRewindPhase) and engine/derivation-loop.ts already has a case \"recurse\" handler that calls runDerivationLoop with outcome.spawnedImpasseIds; only the population of spawnedImpasseIds is missing.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "b1643796-38c5-416f-843d-20dacbccbee6", + "displayId": "C6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Wiring cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate is a blocking prerequisite: the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b1a55d40-1a38-4403-8b5e-9c2639ac9b81", + "displayId": "A33", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: implement mid-derivation checkpoints — serialize WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat after every reconciliation step, allowing exact resume mid-step.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b24d6fdb-a5c4-4390-97d6-91ba22f9a9d6", + "displayId": "E29", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P29: Resolved design question #10 in PLAN.md states nudge_after_n default is 2, but the M8 checklist and derivation loop both use 1; the design question should be updated.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "b29886b8-3911-4cff-b16a-1c1ff572d9c7", + "displayId": "DEC10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Demote Perspective to a record; remove it from the hub-node kind union.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X11 is the explicit stakeholder preference. Hub nodes carry epistemic weight (T8: 'make joint causation explicit') — a hub that is by definition inert (alt-perspective-keep-hub) is a category error and a footgun for the reconciler, which would have to special-case 'this hub kind doesn't propagate support'. Records sit naturally next to FanInRecord and DerivationRunRecord (already in graph/), and the CLI already renders records via formatHandoffReport-shaped code (E27)." + }, + { + "id": "b36a6df7-a5c0-45bd-aa6e-d80721a0caa3", + "displayId": "A8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: delete cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate as YAGNI dead code, since they have no callers (E31).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b4959059-1874-443c-acb3-9b18e70652c3", + "displayId": "E37", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "FanInExtractionResult is currently defined in src/agents/fan-in.ts and re-exported from src/engine/derivation-agents.ts; it is referenced in src/engine/fan-in.ts.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "b5d34135-03ab-45a4-874f-39426e246174", + "displayId": "X11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: perspectives should be records (like DerivationRunRecord or FanInRecord), not hub nodes in the graph, because they carry no epistemic weight and nothing downstream derives support through them.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b6373f38-0b98-44d0-869f-197e169cc1c8", + "displayId": "R19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "engine/solver/dpll.ts must expose a public surface containing at least: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, and demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b69e4dec-516d-4a00-aea0-15792bbbdbcd", + "displayId": "R45", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Every test in the unit, module, and property layers must be deterministic and must not make live LLM calls; only the single VCR E2E test may interact with OpenRouter, and only via recorded snapshots during normal test execution.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b6efe893-8fdb-4b33-933c-6d2e478b18c9", + "displayId": "E12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P7: selectPerspective computes hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements on SelectionOutcome, but clean-room-resolution.ts never reads either field; repair selections and revision authorization flows are not implemented.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "b6f7b6b6-212a-46a0-a81a-579d3b7ec13f", + "displayId": "CR9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test of the clean-room prompt builder must verify that when FrameRecord.nudgingActive=true, the assembled prompt contains a negative-constraint section listing the alternative selections from prior clean attempts in the same frame; when nudgingActive=false, no such section is present. Verified by string-presence assertions on assembled prompt.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b78e3597-7ea5-4a3c-a2bc-ab50215b6573", + "displayId": "D19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "After the user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine: (1) marks the un-chosen-side grounding nodes for the resolved contradiction as suspect, (2) calls markSuspectAndPropagate from each, (3) runs revisionImpact to compute the OUT set, (4) creates a new child frame whose entryPhase is the earliest-affected phase of any OUT node, (5) re-runs the derivation loop in that frame; reconciliation then merges the re-derived content with the existing graph by archiving OUT nodes (with supersededBy edges per X40) when their replacements are accepted.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b7b2dc14-0555-46d8-a1cd-d5230f9ba590", + "displayId": "X19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: split fan-in into two stages — Stage 1 LLM extraction (canonical candidates, contradictions, candidate repairs, axes, alternatives, constraints, impasses, witness relations); Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis (model validation, backbone computation, configuration enumeration, perspective generation).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b8b26ab0-bcbb-4591-bf1b-ce3a3279b953", + "displayId": "T12", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Cross-spec references point to specific checkpoints; when a referenced checkpoint has a successor, the reference becomes a suspect link for human review rather than silently rebound.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "b8d7bddb-60ec-4c4a-a52d-b9c059d4f15b", + "displayId": "T3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Frames have both parentFrameId (impasse call stack nesting) and baselineFrameId (reconciliation target); in cascading examples these point to different frames.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "b9e5c7e2-56df-4fc9-934a-fe2f1bc4b16b", + "displayId": "R33", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "After a user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine must perform the following steps in order: (1) mark the un-chosen-side grounding nodes for the resolved contradiction as suspect; (2) call markSuspectAndPropagate from each; (3) run revisionImpact to compute the OUT set; (4) create a new child frame whose entryPhase is the earliest-affected phase among OUT nodes; (5) re-run the derivation loop in that frame.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ba434d88-a30b-4842-9dcd-f2026aa43748", + "displayId": "A23", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: use a clustering algorithm (e.g., k-means with one-hot embedding) instead of k-medoids; centroids are not real configurations, so generate the closest real configuration to each centroid as the representative.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bb3e3da6-d418-4d18-98e9-d48c500d754c", + "displayId": "RK1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The derivation loop cannot recurse or refine impasses; several reconciliation outcomes are wired in the type system but never produce effects.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "bb577a90-bd8c-4ef8-879d-40f474cfc365", + "displayId": "R54", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The resume flow must restart the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate; clean-room re-derivations within that frame must start with a fresh Chat per T2.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bb83e4dd-3c4d-45e1-ba4e-75c342deaf36", + "displayId": "CR7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A repo-wide grep/static analysis check must confirm that WorkingGraph.cowReplace and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate each have at least one caller outside their defining class (i.e., the methods are no longer orphaned).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bcfb7e08-e00e-4b35-8a2d-24dd53679db9", + "displayId": "CR21", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test must verify that perspective summaries are persisted as plain records under graph/ (e.g., attached to FanInRecord/DerivationRunRecord JSON), each carrying at minimum: id, configuration vector, default-bundle status flag, short label. The test must assert no Perspective hub appears in the graph nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bd725f2e-b2d8-40e5-9371-43a50946d0b9", + "displayId": "CR16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "An integration test driving the engine through a forward pass plus one impasse cycle must subscribe to the Effect EventLog and assert that at least one event of each of the following tags is observed in the expected order: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt, FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed, ReconcileOutcome, ImpasseSpawned, ImpasseResolved, UserInterventionRequested, UserInterventionResolved.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bdef6ea2-edeb-4e4a-9825-0168936bd848", + "displayId": "DEC4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Wire cowReplace + markSuspectAndPropagate into the grounding-enrichment + intervention paths.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "C6 makes this a blocking prerequisite for derivation-loop signoff (\"the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it\"). X57 makes the same claim normatively. T10 specifies COW semantics for grounding, so alt-cow-mutate-in-place contradicts the stated substrate model and would force the reconciler to do double work to discover obsolete originals. alt-cow-delete-orphan-methods directly violates C6 and the X16–X40 stakeholder direction. Combined wiring of both functions is required because cowReplace alone leaves downstream nodes still pointing at superseded premises with clean status — markSuspectAndPropagate is what keeps the JTMS chain (X28) consistent." + }, + { + "id": "be4714b4-6a53-4578-9319-31c816a88271", + "displayId": "X5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Impasse triage is currently a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) with a five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premise > term/ontology mismatch > upstream structural contradiction > endogenous design conflict (default).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "bf59c79b-2478-40bb-a373-d1268b03f86d", + "displayId": "D10", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Replace every Console.log call in src/engine/** (fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection.ts, assembler.ts) with an Effect EventLog (effect/EventLog) emission that publishes a typed, tagged event ({_tag: 'FanInStarted'|'FanInCompleted'|'FanOutAttempt'|'ReconcileOutcome'|'PhaseEntered'|'ImpasseSpawned'|'ImpasseResolved'|'CowReplace'|'SuspectPropagated'|'NudgeActivated'|...}, payload). The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) becomes a subscriber that renders these events to stdout via its existing formatHandoffReport-style code paths. The engine no longer imports Console.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c0b280de-6f17-4a28-b3ac-6a9d8c8a5312", + "displayId": "R60", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Enrichment nodes must carry dual provenance: a workflow provenance edge (motivates) pointing at the impasse that prompted the inquiry, and a separate evidential provenance edge to the direct exogenous source. Only the evidential provenance may be used to justify downstream derivation; workflow provenance must not propagate taint.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c12afe37-a045-4e5c-8c1e-00e74e5dadfe", + "displayId": "A16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep events open-ended (string tag + free-form payload) so adding a new event doesn't require touching the union.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c41b0961-1c3a-4813-bebc-0119d78f4850", + "displayId": "CR23", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A schema/type-level test must verify that ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult does NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated configurations, or scoped-impasse outputs; any attempt to read such a field from the schema must be a TypeScript compile error.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c4662482-8647-4adc-b2d2-1edc6583524f", + "displayId": "A24", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: surface every distinct configuration in M_current up to a bound; let the UI handle scrolling.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c4c4622e-a62e-4237-ac58-b7a6237552a9", + "displayId": "D22", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Extract from cli/run.ts: (a) cli/format-handoff-report.ts containing the 40-line formatHandoffReport function as a pure function over HandoffReport → string, unit-tested with snapshot fixtures; (b) engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts (or src/agents/factory.ts) containing the 30-line DerivationAgents construction wiring, parameterized by LanguageModel so tests inject scripted agents and the CLI injects the OpenRouter-backed one. cli/run.ts becomes a thin orchestrator that imports both.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c4de2feb-cd3d-4f70-a1eb-d8a1903508ab", + "displayId": "X42", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the nudge threshold k (nudgeAfterN) is dynamic and set to 1, meaning nudging begins after 1 clean attempt.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c5f37cc0-70f1-4be1-9da7-069ca0586011", + "displayId": "R48", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The 30-line DerivationAgents construction code must be extracted from cli/run.ts into a factory module (engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts or src/agents/factory.ts) parameterized by LanguageModel, so tests can inject scripted agents and the CLI can inject the OpenRouter-backed implementation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c6a623e5-32e5-4593-abf6-07d24f6b24dc", + "displayId": "X33", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a blocking impasse is a first-class persistent graph node with semantic meaning as a recorded decision point.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c74f3c85-03a0-4946-9cd5-a2b900d7eaa2", + "displayId": "R70", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Agents must continue to emit semanticKey and support sets in their IR output; the graph assembler is responsible for assigning UUIDs and display IDs and creating edges. Agents must not produce UUIDs or display IDs for nodes they are creating in the same batch.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c8a1ad03-9721-4f7e-a43a-63096a064fb0", + "displayId": "RK17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question: how many representative perspective configurations to show (k) and how to handle configuration clustering for M_current vs M_preview.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "assumed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "c93f9a0c-8fc1-415b-9e0f-839ef142a099", + "displayId": "E20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P20: The fan-out conditional label policy (makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts) is untested; it is pure logic with no LLM dependency.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "c966936d-1a42-4fd7-a193-7e75ef4a4533", + "displayId": "R28", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "After resolution, the BlockingImpasse node must remain in the graph with status: resolved (not deleted) and must participate in JTMS provenance chains as a recorded decision point.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "cb179854-2b66-43d8-83b8-4b07a4d31844", + "displayId": "R1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives, selected, rejected, consequences, premises, conclusions, etc.) must be typed via NodeIdFromDisplayId in the agent output schemas instead of plain string.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "cbe87031-84bd-433a-81ac-63d50ebae5ea", + "displayId": "CR26", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test of the fan-in aggregation must verify that three-valued aggregation reads stance from the structured perRunStance field (values exactly 'supports'|'contradicts'|'silent') and not by parsing prose. Negative test: a fixture in which a run is silent on alternative A1 (no perRunStance entry) but supports A2 on the same axis must NOT aggregate as 'contradicts' for A1.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "cbf1de21-7759-49de-8a70-20ce35600d78", + "displayId": "X23", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: FanInExtractionResult is to be deleted and replaced entirely with a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema, with no backward compatibility.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ccdae101-399e-4985-a64d-d9e3a4e0cada", + "displayId": "RK7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Session state persistence for the resume command is an open question; the stakeholder expressed preference for no mutable-state checkpoint dumps and may prefer restarting over complex resumability.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "cf663b4c-c2dd-4129-befd-8ec5a0456b7c", + "displayId": "R37", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "validateModel must reject configuration models in which any axis contains alternatives at mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'configurable'); such models must be flagged for manual repair rather than silently accepted.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "cfd53b11-128b-42d9-bb09-4e4e2e3694e2", + "displayId": "CR27", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test must construct a perRunStance fixture in which run R1 supports alternative A1 on axis X and is silent on alternative A2 on the same axis X, and assert that the aggregation accepts and preserves this distinction (no implicit 'all alternatives on the axis share the run's stance').", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d04c98a6-14ed-4702-91a9-679cde4a5b78", + "displayId": "D11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Define a closed event catalog as a discriminated union under src/engine/events.ts: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt(runIndex), FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed(modelStats), PerspectiveGenerated, ReconcileOutcome(_tag: accepted|retry|recurse|refined), ImpasseSpawned(impasseId, kind), ImpasseResolved(impasseId, disposition), NudgeActivated(frameId, attemptCount), CowReplace(oldNodeId, newNodeId), SuspectPropagated(rootId, count), BlockingImpasseRaised(scope), UserInterventionRequested(kind), UserInterventionResolved(kind, choice). Every Console.log call in the engine maps to exactly one of these. CLI rendering, the JSON event log artifact, and the future web inspector consume the same union.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d0b6708b-6979-4c48-a509-5a54608c68ea", + "displayId": "RK18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question: for v1, consider disabling auto-resolution of repair precedence and surfacing all contradictions as repair axes to preserve correctness at the cost of more user decisions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "assumed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "d0ce7312-240b-4ef0-9081-6ad997d5e274", + "displayId": "X8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Elicitation is interactive by default because the user is the oracle; authority conflicts, unjustified omissions, impasse escalation, and bail decisions cannot be automated.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "d41a18f9-a4ff-45a8-b2ee-236089d696eb", + "displayId": "G1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The spec elicitation prototype is an AI-assisted system that transforms raw source documents into structured, typed specification graphs through a multi-phase derivation pipeline.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "d5256b95-4c9d-40d5-b9c3-bb6b595f33ed", + "displayId": "T8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Hub nodes (Justification, Decision, Impasse) make joint causation explicit; they carry content and connect 1..n incoming edges to 0..n outgoing edges. Decision and Impasse are subtypes of Justification with their own subtype-specific edge roles.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "d5fa3376-a63e-45f2-be6a-b5e13ae20abc", + "displayId": "X44", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: genuine impasses must be extracted before the configuration space is computed, to prevent 'some runs picked sides' from hiding a real impasse.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "d621e47c-8a97-4d15-bdeb-203c00aceab2", + "displayId": "R8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Perspective must not appear in the graph's hub-kind union; the hub-kind union remains exactly {Justification, Decision, Impasse} from T8. Existing edges that pointed to a Perspective hub must be removed, and any persisted graph artifacts containing Perspective hubs must be migrated or rejected.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d6a43017-5a3f-4c9d-80a1-d6ba773058b2", + "displayId": "X46", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: all alternatives on a single axis must be at the same abstraction level; axes with mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'configurable') are rejected by validateModel and escalated for manual repair.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "d6f274aa-2fdc-4e5f-a321-db72539028e4", + "displayId": "R11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Stage 1 ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated configurations, or scoped impasses. The schema must structurally forbid the LLM from producing solver outputs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d82726fe-35a0-4540-aad4-b06f34daaab8", + "displayId": "E38", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The solver already implements backbone computation (mustSelect/mustDeselect) as a deterministic function over the configuration model.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "d83df598-c411-48e5-8dbd-4a3dea70321f", + "displayId": "D21", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Test strategy is a four-layer pyramid: (1) Unit tests for pure logic — buildConfigModel (P21), assembler.ts (P19), makeCleanRoomPolicy (P20), perspective-selection.ts (P24), invariants.ts validate() including violating graphs (P23), solver primitives (validate/enumerate/backbone/demote), markdown render (P25), WorkingGraph artifact roundtrip (P22). (2) Module tests with scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver (already injectable per E18) for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow. (3) Property tests for: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monotonicity over repeated mark/unmark, (c) solver backbone equals intersection of enumerate(). (4) One end-to-end smoke test (P18) using VCR-recorded OpenRouter interactions covering all three impasse types in sequence (X61). The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts (P26) is split per module into test files colocated with the modules they cover.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d881ea47-48a0-4dc0-a594-a32f9cf18290", + "displayId": "A35", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: follow X62's stated priority order strictly — land all of P18–P25 (tests) first, then correctness, then design, then everything else — with no parallel staging.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d97ea8c7-3147-4a4c-9955-7212de81a372", + "displayId": "C1", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The forward pass must remain working throughout the code health improvements.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "db74aaac-005c-471a-8f72-2c61baf0265b", + "displayId": "X48", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: if M_current is empty, the system is in a dead-end state and must emit a global blocking impasse rather than inferring substrate from vacuous truth.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "dbb97c3d-8b78-4e49-ac77-c624ed04703a", + "displayId": "T15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "An axis is an independent dimension of variability discovered by fan-in; it has an id, type (design or repair), cardinality (exactly_one or zero_or_one), and label.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "dc02223c-f419-4e53-98a6-07977628c18d", + "displayId": "R55", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each of the five staged increments (A correctness wiring, B reference integrity, C observability, D feature-model redesign, E test + hygiene) must be independently mergeable while keeping the forward pass functional and the existing smoke-test artifacts validating.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "dc1b1872-c5c0-47e1-b758-8215da6e2636", + "displayId": "CR31", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test must verify the solver module at engine/solver/dpll.ts exports public functions: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, and demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}. Calling each with fixture inputs returns the documented shape.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "dc662f1a-11ca-4e56-8214-0648bf042ec8", + "displayId": "CR11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test must verify that NodeIdFromDisplayId: (a) decodes a valid display ID against a live WorkingGraph to the corresponding NodeId, (b) fails decode with a structured error when the display ID does not exist in the graph, (c) round-trips encode/decode for valid IDs (property test).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "dca768ee-3417-49fb-a511-f08a19ead2c9", + "displayId": "T19", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "'Silent' stance means a run neither supports nor contradicts a specific alternative; it is a distinct value from 'supports' and 'contradicts'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "dcc76b61-937d-4212-865e-c9fad5e7e7eb", + "displayId": "DEC23", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Stage A–E in dependency order with parallelism between independent stages.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "Strict X62 priority ordering (alt-staging-priority-strict) puts tests first, but dec-test-strategy depends on dec-cli-extract (factory injection for module tests, design-cli-extract-modules), which is itself a hygiene item ranked lower in X62. The dependency graph forces some interleaving. The proposed staging respects the spirit of X62 (correctness items P1/P2/P10/P32 land in Stage A early; tests land in Stage E across all the modules now made testable) while allowing independent landings. C1/C4 are preserved per stage because each stage's changes are scoped: A patches existing wiring, B is a schema change with retry behavior, C is an observability swap, D is the redesign behind a feature flag during transition, E is additive tests + refactors." + }, + { + "id": "dce4736c-147a-418b-a53e-037ae4717aa1", + "displayId": "X54", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation cannot archive a node without justification; if upstream grounding still supports a node and there's no contradiction, mere omission by re-derivation is insufficient reason to archive.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "dcfe026f-1fa9-4b1c-b974-3162dba4847b", + "displayId": "CR20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A type-level test must verify that the graph's hub-kind union type is exactly {Justification | Decision | Impasse} and does not include Perspective; an attempt to pattern-match Perspective as a hub kind must fail the TypeScript compiler.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "dd10897c-b0bd-40b8-bb80-18bfb8c7b76f", + "displayId": "E5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The core architecture is sound; problems concentrate in three areas: incomplete wiring in the derivation loop, silent data loss when agents produce invalid references, and missing test coverage for pure-logic components.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "dd5c2811-756e-47a6-87c9-4f0a1e405018", + "displayId": "RK16", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Open question: should a lightweight existing SAT library or a custom DPLL implementation be used for the solver? Expected scale (5–20 axes, 2–5 alternatives) is small enough for either.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "assumed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "ddb1b808-c88c-48ac-aec4-d7331a6a2740", + "displayId": "E17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P17: revisionImpact in solver.ts is implemented but never called outside tests; combined with empty justifications, the entire revision impact subsystem is effectively dead.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "de54ab4b-cf6a-4905-8277-17f147e28adc", + "displayId": "R9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Perspective summaries must be persisted as plain records attached to FanInRecord (or a sibling DerivationRunRecord) under graph/, each carrying at minimum: an id, the configuration vector, a default-bundle status flag (display only), and a short label.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "dee7d643-11d6-4d8c-a149-6aa0beaabb38", + "displayId": "E2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The derivation loop (which handles impasses, backward transitions, fan-out, and reconciliation) is partially implemented with significant correctness gaps.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "dfab1dcc-56fc-4cc3-a39b-514025d8d21d", + "displayId": "R25", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Readiness must be evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection; the perspective summary's default-bundle status flag must be display-only and must not be used as a readiness gate.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "dfff904c-a281-4614-a54c-8967f8606831", + "displayId": "A26", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: delete revisionImpact and the empty justifications field as dead code (P8/P17), formalize re-derivation as 'always re-run the affected phase clean' without belief revision.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e007fe12-f9a7-4703-a5ea-589fa644bf8c", + "displayId": "CR28", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A type-level test must verify that the axis 'type' field accepts only 'design' or 'repair'; constructing an axis with type='revision' must fail schema decode.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e0cb5c74-fca3-4a20-a23b-7b9516080904", + "displayId": "T5", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The extraction step between raw sources and grounding nodes serves a correctness purpose: 'grounding still supports this node' (checked during reconciliation) requires claim-level support, not file-level presence.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "e1e9adae-f1b0-45ea-9e3e-0e8003624916", + "displayId": "R17", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Stage 1 fan-in must extract genuine impasses before any configuration space (M_current/M_preview/M_revision) is computed by Stage 2, ensuring that 'some runs picked a side' on a contradiction cannot mask a real impasse.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e2d276e5-92f9-4b67-ba69-9ef84e8236f4", + "displayId": "A4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep the original impasse as the live node and merely attach a refinedDescription field/edge to it instead of creating a new Impasse node, so refined_to is a self-annotation rather than a hub-to-hub edge.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e3203717-6894-4377-a30e-bd702e3f2bdd", + "displayId": "D8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the clean-room agent prompt builder (clean-room.ts) injects a negative-constraint section listing the alternative selections from prior clean attempts in the same frame ('avoid these previously explored choices: …'). nudgingActive itself remains a frame-level flag set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts; the new behavior is that fan-out reads the flag and the prior frame's reconciled outcomes when assembling the prompt for the next clean attempt.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e4703a89-cc78-41b8-8298-4ae9f7bba564", + "displayId": "X38", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: after repair selection, taint propagation uses markSuspectAndPropagate, and all OUT nodes are re-derived in place via cowReplace by re-running the relevant phase agents.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e5c27bdd-d440-4ca2-8b7f-7436272674d3", + "displayId": "C3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or Routine abstractions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "e630e5a6-30ba-489b-995d-c930eb133440", + "displayId": "A2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: scope only to the open correctness items (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) and explicitly defer the SAT/feature-model redesign and the EventLog migration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e655cfa1-6086-4068-b176-9ff3d4bf8f62", + "displayId": "X39", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: re-derivation after repair should enter a new frame and rerun the complete downstream starting from the earliest affected phase, then reconcile with existing content.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e77b74fe-d3f5-45d3-af39-a4cbc9ca2d66", + "displayId": "E32", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Fan-out produces N independent derivations of the same phase; when they disagree, the current system creates impasse nodes, which causes an infinite loop because re-derivation cannot resolve inherent design-space disagreements.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "e8650e58-d232-45af-b3a3-a6f9fd05a5a5", + "displayId": "R36", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence must be disabled by default in v1 via a config.repairAutoResolve flag defaulting to false; every detected contradiction must surface as a repair axis to the user regardless of evidence asymmetry. The auto-resolution code path must be feature-flagged rather than removed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e86f6d8a-308b-4dc9-9c42-a49b30095340", + "displayId": "RK6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "No integration test exercises the full triage-to-resolution pipeline.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "e89540b7-d4e5-41d4-8bc7-ce69066489b8", + "displayId": "D24", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "For M5 resume/polish, do not implement mid-derivation checkpointing. The only checkpointable state is a completed checkpoint (T11: 'immutable snapshot when a full revision completes'); resume from anywhere else restarts the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate. The CLI gains a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earliest open impasse, and re-enters the derivation loop with that frame as parent.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e8dbd3b1-b862-4176-8c2f-8a006e0d1107", + "displayId": "X4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Supporting parallel/concurrent spec design sessions is deferred because each spec design can take 20 minutes to an hour and internal state is not centralized, making concurrency incompatible with the current architecture.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e9a6668b-7ac8-45f3-bd06-4fdfae35a327", + "displayId": "DEC8", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Migrate the engine to Effect EventLog with typed events; the CLI becomes one subscriber.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X14 is an explicit stakeholder preference for EventLog specifically over Effect.logInfo. X15 calls for events on notable occurrences — i.e. domain-meaningful events like 'ImpasseSpawned', not log levels — which is the EventLog model and not the Effect.logInfo model (alt-eventlog-effect-logger), where consumers cannot dispatch on _tag. alt-eventlog-keep-console preserves the current coupling to a CLI presentation layer (RK5) and is incompatible with the planned web inspector (M7, E7) which needs a structured stream of engine events to render. The X13/X14/X15 chain is monotone in stakeholder preference toward EventLog; X14 is the latest preference and supersedes the X13 fallback." + }, + { + "id": "ebf8616f-5488-4656-8795-a068abbdc1e9", + "displayId": "R47", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The 40-line formatHandoffReport function must be extracted from cli/run.ts into cli/format-handoff-report.ts as a pure function (HandoffReport → string) with snapshot-based unit tests.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ec256011-6df5-4f27-b0d3-de6d1d70bd3f", + "displayId": "R26", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When the solver determines M_current is empty or unsatisfiable, the engine must create a first-class Impasse hub node (kind: 'unsatisfiable_configuration_space') in the graph with status: open and support edges to all hard-constraint nodes participating in the UNSAT core; the engine must NOT infer substrate from vacuous truth.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ec5d3df0-1efc-4c0e-907d-a781becfadec", + "displayId": "X2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The tech stack is: Deno runtime, Effect v4 (beta 57), Effect CLI, Effect AI, @kael/ai (Fragment, Routine), @kael/core/platform, and @effect/platform-node-shared. All agents use the LanguageModel abstraction; the concrete provider is OpenRouter wired at the CLI entry point.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "ec94d500-fd48-47ed-8550-9cd490fe56cf", + "displayId": "R53", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The system must not write mid-derivation checkpoint dumps (no serialization of WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat at each reconciliation step). The only checkpointable state is a completed checkpoint produced when a full revision completes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ed02c961-e038-47ed-9146-22c0175cea4d", + "displayId": "T7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Spec nodes are organized across three orthogonal axes: semantic role (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk), epistemic status (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred), and authority (stakeholder, technical, external, derived).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "ed94beb8-d6f2-46cc-9f81-50f47f3c4a6a", + "displayId": "A11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: remove nudgingActive and nudgeAfterN entirely; rely on natural variance across N parallel clean-room runs to surface alternatives.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "edba9ad8-c6f4-4e40-b751-6ceee442afed", + "displayId": "RK4", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Perspectives are currently modeled as hub nodes alongside justifications, decisions, and impasses, but carry no epistemic weight and should be records instead.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "eede5aaa-876b-44af-a491-4b8d70ba9b8c", + "displayId": "D9", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Introduce a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type built on Schema.transformOrFail / SchemaGetter.checkEffect that decodes a display ID string against the live WorkingGraph and either yields the resolved NodeId or fails the schema decode with a structured error. Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId references this schema instead of plain string. Schema decode failures bubble up as Effect AI tool result errors so the LLM sees them on the next turn and retries; assembler.ts's silent post-hoc resolve-and-filter step is removed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "efb7a910-e494-4c3f-92c2-c7f6c342b561", + "displayId": "A31", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: leave the inlined helpers in cli/run.ts; the prototype is small enough that the extra module hop isn't worth the indirection.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f034cc0f-7aad-4943-a4e0-60e05910475e", + "displayId": "E33", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The current impasse-based model for cross-run divergence uses the wrong mental model: it asks the user to resolve individual point-conflicts when the real question is which overall design vision they want.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "f0a55f22-d55c-46ea-87d7-55350516462c", + "displayId": "T13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Cross-run divergence has three distinct categories: genuine impasse (source policy conflict), design perspective (both grounded and coherent alternatives), and derivation noise (hallucinated without grounding basis).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "f0d92175-633d-4266-b3d2-a5a023576275", + "displayId": "X56", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a subagent is invoked for conflict resolution only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure — e.g., when provenance edges are missing or the contradiction is semantic rather than structural.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f34e2ad3-8d28-409e-886a-ba6b704a7045", + "displayId": "X13", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: replace Console.log calls throughout the engine with either Effect's structured logging (Effect.logInfo/Effect.logDebug) or a typed event bus with structured per-operation events, so the CLI becomes one consumer among many.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f3d573f3-94d9-4d86-8c9c-f7a16fcd173e", + "displayId": "E3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A code health review of the spec elicitation prototype uncovered 34 issues across correctness, design, testing, and systemic architecture.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "f3fd41de-27b5-40ec-bfaf-12e68a5407a8", + "displayId": "R2", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "assembler.ts must not silently drop or filter out unresolved displayId references; the post-hoc resolve-and-filter step (.filter(nodeId !== undefined) and non-blocking error logging) must be removed in favor of schema-level decode failures that surface as Effect AI tool result errors.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f479697d-1715-44e9-8034-b9dad5df7b9d", + "displayId": "CR30", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A unit test of Stage 1 extraction must verify that hard constraints are emitted only with witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency, grounded_rationale} and a citation; negative test: a fixture exhibiting non-cooccurrence of alternatives across 5 fan-out runs without any witnessing rationale must NOT produce a hard constraint.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:15:48.927Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f5ecff9f-6e0e-46e6-98d6-7add74cf68cd", + "displayId": "DEC14", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis vectors with k=3 per space.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X21 directly specifies this method. k-medoids returns real configurations, which fits dec-perspective-record (the record has to point at a real activatable configuration); alt-perspective-clustering needs a 'snap to nearest real config' post-step that is just k-medoids in disguise. alt-perspective-show-all defeats X33's notion of 'perspective' as a digestible summary and would overwhelm the user when M_preview is large. k=3 is a conservative default given RK17's openness; making k a parameter is left for tuning." + }, + { + "id": "f5f14375-4f8e-470f-9d1b-82de1770b999", + "displayId": "E23", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P23: domain/invariants.ts has support-edge acyclicity detection and phase stratification checks, but these are not tested with violating graphs; validate() is not called in any test file.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "f6497cbf-6932-4154-9798-137c6da27325", + "displayId": "R7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) must consume engine events as a subscriber to the EventLog rather than receiving them via Console.log; the CLI must continue to render human-readable output equivalent to the prior Console.log output for each event variant it cares about.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f725ff14-0ced-453a-87b0-f19f7c11fdbc", + "displayId": "A25", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: model the blocking impasse as a transient diagnostic (an entry on the FanInRecord, not a graph node); resolve it inline and never persist it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f7a7ddb6-bf6a-480a-b200-d1d3f52a7c45", + "displayId": "D3", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "When the reconciler returns disposition: \"refined\" with a refinedImpasse payload, the reconciliation engine creates a new Impasse hub node in the graph (status: open), creates a refined_to lineage edge from the original impasse to the new one, marks the original as superseded, AND pushes the new node id onto spawnedImpasseIds so the recurse branch fires. This unifies P2's missing creation step with P1's missing population step.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:05:58.573Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f8340618-9ebc-4cef-a966-fca007ab0f00", + "displayId": "X49", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the LLM extraction stage must NOT compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses; those are deterministic solver operations.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "f8d36906-0bc4-4b58-bebe-71aa75984361", + "displayId": "E6", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The system is implemented as a standalone CLI prototype in packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/, containing src/, spec/, PLAN.md, and PROBLEMS.md.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "faab4aa8-3679-4cb0-8757-33e87051104d", + "displayId": "R31", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "revisionImpact must mark a derived node as OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect, matching the JTMS-style propagation rule.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "fad86b2d-d2f3-4f6e-b9a6-51aa05877d30", + "displayId": "X15", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the EventLog should emit events beyond simple Console.log replacements for notable occurrences; finer granularity is better but not every tiny detail needs an event.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "fbd1b4b5-b531-4b16-822d-53a96d24297e", + "displayId": "R20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The backbone function must return, for every axis whose value is forced, the set of constraint clauses (blockingClauses) that ruled out the alternatives that were not forced, so the user can see which constraints made the other values impossible.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T11:11:11.693Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "fdfa9546-89b5-4433-a7b8-7db81ae8dcc4", + "displayId": "X20", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: perspective selection by the user is not new evidence; design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repair selection is non-monotone with respect to premises (downstream phases must be recomputed), and revision authorization requires the revision flow.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "fe332627-3c75-4958-939c-122d94b62e4c", + "displayId": "C7", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The resolution strategy must be maximally correct and must not take shortcuts.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "fe3e51eb-69b3-42b7-a780-0cebeff6205f", + "displayId": "E25", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P25: render/markdown.ts (329 lines) has no tests; a snapshot test with a known artifact would catch rendering regressions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "fed0ddb3-f9cb-438e-a74c-733d2d48aa19", + "displayId": "E18", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P18: No end-to-end smoke test with an impasse scenario exists; DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver are injectable services so a deterministic integration test is possible.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "fefdd495-3d4a-4bca-84f1-f825de33d697", + "displayId": "E11", + "specId": "e68931ab-c788-4d0b-a3c6-0a1681336ff5", + "frameId": "31e3c5b2-dd41-4c26-b912-71a6b2ab0a0b", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "P6: All baseline effects in fan-in.ts are hardcoded to commitmentLevel: \"locked\" and requiresAuthorization: true, without checking whether the baseline node is actually locked or provisional.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T10:55:21.280Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/edges.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/edges.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..388bbd4ad --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/edges.json @@ -0,0 +1,10472 @@ +[ + { + "id": "003e6716-9b77-4677-8f52-ef5dac125488", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "00523c63-416c-423e-8735-70c2b488180b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "096fe03b-749d-455a-84f6-901aa41d1bbf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "005b91f1-5921-4cad-8136-b0b3a640e032", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ee5b4a6b-b52c-4572-b3ad-666de5b6e633" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0087a72d-3e74-47c7-b7de-45e75476e1a1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b841eee1-255b-4c89-9012-3fd2edcd8224" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "051ba471-e838-459e-8cf4-50451df068ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "00c3fe91-d83d-43ff-a572-9b425f055e6c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f3cbd5ab-2429-46f6-adf7-08b5fad8f390" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da42d489-5081-441e-95a3-1021b7d7b341" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "014b6bb4-3993-4b8a-b2ba-986f42c8b1bf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "940b3e95-2a17-4c0e-a48e-a45b767bb07a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "015badc4-2991-474d-9072-935446884802", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f7eb36e5-eb3f-40ac-9711-a883e2482968" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "01e8555b-0775-4795-b245-8e922310ddd2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "236669cb-46bb-4411-90c0-548e10b4b121" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "02637ca7-a81d-49c1-ac43-69ccaaf28524", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9d580e32-031b-47b3-a2bf-dad5ca4374ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "029f3f3d-47e6-474b-9d06-5f5587f94080", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32b3b4e1-7603-463a-9a69-1a48a6f7f3d7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "02f97a16-fd1b-4f26-95b0-8a9a7fdd7875", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f15ff085-f0da-4028-a182-1219995321bd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8e2df6ba-4ceb-4063-a168-bc9ebbf6ad02" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "032b72c8-65ba-4d05-9ba8-fc9cca7a2292", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5bada80b-11d5-4828-9388-db44fff8342e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8e38f19-3765-49d6-9d3d-5a568fe21b0a" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "032da1f4-5434-443a-9518-eb096805b2e5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b9676c28-7093-4d9d-b087-ab9e8510715f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "042aa9c1-2983-4491-98f9-1dd78218a497", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "80011e24-30cb-413b-b4d6-e04e5a1d63b7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "04628f32-44f6-4c14-a28c-91bac1ea4da9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "046e1f26-92cd-4413-913c-eed8935a68f6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc7b99b9-6c05-4f2c-870c-b52165c11a70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "047def4a-7f25-45da-8a5e-5efd5daed67e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74992a29-94d3-4468-9761-d1bd22c47322" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "91583e14-811b-4a2d-ba91-021985f7e9dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "04c910e5-9e98-4a1e-a29c-c1dd19b1e129", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a41d48dc-1906-4a3f-8abf-25c3cf3d10f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "05628c6c-0263-4957-9e72-ed61da750307", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "144b6e37-2a16-4947-b715-3f9b616072b2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7199fc6b-6cb4-4494-b0af-0468f2e11560" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "05ba3d23-edcb-4c1c-bc5e-d82d7cc2019e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32b3b4e1-7603-463a-9a69-1a48a6f7f3d7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fba7d9d2-d4dd-49b9-aae3-1768cce41ca1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "05fe34d3-8cdb-4823-8271-774e95a15e1f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2d0a1476-404e-4569-83e3-d2aa0efeadd4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "061d1708-06d5-4348-9fe2-78e53bca74db", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9bec9aa-92f0-4b38-aa04-fb102e870479" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "06846a41-8d9d-439e-adda-56d4812cf544", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2191c8dc-d7e0-4d29-b4f8-0a64e2f2297b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "072aea5b-b6e8-4d47-be8e-a268fc198614", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc7b99b9-6c05-4f2c-870c-b52165c11a70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0755a930-9bd7-4cef-aec3-6a04ccc9549b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "04464e2f-71eb-4abc-8240-285af4cc4f05" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "076081a7-0ae2-4086-9988-0f127f91fb08", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8effcdf0-3303-4565-85f7-8e5dfa7b8607" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a7cd8811-64f2-44d6-ba86-59a08ebda2bf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "07bd758d-0601-4602-a0e0-55656e91297d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "51551fde-9432-4152-a688-afcfb9e32b8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "07c05ea3-4d62-4057-9dd7-3da9dd881490", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "07d334e1-10fc-41a7-8ce4-6f4609bd49db", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b70ec3f3-d89a-4151-98e7-83311efe5324" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed245c0f-7379-4ba5-8d7a-cbc02b0feba0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "07ef4e62-d4c9-47a0-b2ac-e16d7ab01eee", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "080d57f6-72b0-484a-a1ce-d50080c1a34f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "19cc1a07-e68f-4bfe-a700-693296466f1a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e63a500a-ae5e-493b-a8cc-66bda2c566c0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "083f645c-98bd-4953-8f7b-318de4fc01c5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "69197260-c0ba-43cf-9b24-5a981b87b4b3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "097648a1-cc22-416f-a1e2-487b880f7133", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f15ff085-f0da-4028-a182-1219995321bd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed090d75-5c98-4171-8853-469fc8efebf3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a2504ff-5977-49ca-a674-9ec251e23f90", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a3d3bf5-e7e4-4449-ae33-f526849afb9a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "502805ad-82e7-44ed-afe6-13abc89aa7b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a59f61c-f846-4af0-8a27-99b78f6dafaf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9785093-7e00-4d40-935b-58495cc90b29" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0b475982-bb66-49ee-b3bd-192245e02ca1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4584a697-7fe0-4922-aa90-8e525468d99f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0b4952f3-69a0-4c9f-84a6-6d4514e99002", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f2061db9-a203-4ac3-bcac-7f8dd977420c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0b60a85d-6f20-47de-b35d-dcd8378e6ca2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "884d7a21-8b9e-482f-b416-fff0b37dc69d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "449b5067-d769-494f-9d0f-d89660a59dd6" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0b84b9e8-4361-404b-b240-ae12b4a2093d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7b33c306-b622-4957-9665-929113a88b27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0ba6a0e4-ae25-438f-81a2-34baef8bc7b3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ee5b4a6b-b52c-4572-b3ad-666de5b6e633" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0be771a5-dc2f-4fec-83ad-621a8562424d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d57e230d-c4bf-459d-b509-c79e7e6e2bbf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2652c6f8-3ba7-4152-b890-0aa032dd7664" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c0916f1-c208-4a01-a5da-e5630a57d451", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "96c26b59-4762-4d9e-a25e-fc412b877be1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c193f97-d79b-4aff-ac19-b15bfc0fa9dc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "844382fc-2fe9-4cff-89be-90b55d4e4be2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0bd4f434-a6fe-43e4-9e3e-7fd2da8c81af" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c24b630-df9c-4c89-8e85-f36311c7e662", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fba7d9d2-d4dd-49b9-aae3-1768cce41ca1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c98bb37-ad6c-4010-8aa9-7681e0ef0b54", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5479add5-2688-41a8-a49c-1a336d1dfa3b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0c9c1e52-35bc-4406-a2cc-ed9b49a707c7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6006dc8-8e31-4741-9549-c4e480fd1687" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "0d135a0c-844c-48aa-8ce5-9c85c0c2bb14", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e61e54b8-9365-431a-b960-c687e2490200" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0d1915c3-0818-4ecc-ac01-0125bb3a859d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f951b58a-190e-42d1-9581-65d9af37c513" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "0d5369ad-79f1-4b84-8fe2-7a7638209610", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "144b6e37-2a16-4947-b715-3f9b616072b2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "0d77f2d1-44de-4611-8868-53761d33834c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f331274-4d74-4e8c-8cc1-8f788aca29ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0dae81d3-9d67-46eb-b25b-747d310bc628", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f80f75b5-f8a6-4110-b181-5f65430493ac" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "0de02a4e-2d56-432d-9dfb-c760f18f3f6d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "af86d506-7b3d-4e8a-85a1-7d7bcbaeb355" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0def0faa-dbdc-4edb-89d5-cba088875a6e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "af86d506-7b3d-4e8a-85a1-7d7bcbaeb355" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0efd2704-ed71-4e4a-a76b-bd74cd298835", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "0f5d7383-911b-49a9-b30a-651f738badcc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "84af919e-9e37-4851-8a3d-a06f3c60999c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "0f78c57d-aa26-40e2-a4d0-4d15d3510778", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b7143302-7833-4529-beb6-b3b5287cce10" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07b92395-5c07-4634-81de-61c1ca22b9e9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "0f8b777e-ef9c-464d-a25c-d9214d123aed", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "10162635-d9d0-4973-9269-b81b71687b58", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "79d2d259-cd64-4371-8163-5209f81df67f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "102d5d3e-f529-4be5-9dfe-de8ec32de6a3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e4ae921-3fa3-4762-84b1-f7e6da27bcfb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7daa0a6c-1435-4bd2-9abc-667736b6b289" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "109152b3-f7cc-4826-8ef3-0a7b04e4083f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f2e5456-aec6-48fc-a6de-3c644e4ec921" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b303160-3121-4bc4-8a2f-e348fbd56346" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "10f29a4e-6457-442c-af1e-accf50e1d2e1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2da431dc-66e0-49d4-9d85-ebb2190e6ebb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "114b998d-1bde-41dd-94b0-9d9ca24b5dcd", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "edd48929-bde2-4c7d-b2c1-f8813de9f454" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32907b67-1e27-4a5b-987e-c0f7303f1041" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "115215a5-2e0a-4d37-b9ab-13393b72db1b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d2c4811-2f33-4e99-9452-391379b6b41c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fc04c4e9-bad0-45c4-b778-18b21c44e1ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1169d5c1-c479-43b1-8784-3e3662801673", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1203dccf-0b54-4cc5-b728-abaf9770237c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef23345e-bb9e-451e-bedb-3c69e526b44e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88530d93-d355-41cd-8fd0-5e7c929738b7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "120ee961-bca1-4d05-9e33-786bf3cedc57", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0008b2ae-c319-446d-af24-71752a514d13" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "69197260-c0ba-43cf-9b24-5a981b87b4b3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "12c477a1-30e9-45b2-84a6-04f20491cdff", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e61e54b8-9365-431a-b960-c687e2490200" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4c7d8fab-1ddc-4a74-9836-4cdc9aeb6bbd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "12c57287-91fa-46d8-baa6-17519b0df374", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1357d101-1db9-40e2-8866-6a53afca437d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "14c88d83-dcac-4801-b8da-41fc130e763b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3423b02-781f-438c-96db-efe0f6704511" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "1383c589-118e-429f-9efc-4b20397a13c5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "139b1d76-67c4-415d-9638-6f64457f61ad", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d60afc71-8e07-40e9-9dca-aa04ea13ba01" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "13e60c7f-e2ee-466c-8e07-517d3bd167d1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f951b58a-190e-42d1-9581-65d9af37c513" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "140f813e-cb32-4a94-9e44-2bf25f24957e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "22cf44b0-1336-4ba2-96b8-6f7d6ebef354" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "14986d97-6a88-4541-9942-7ba0df225791", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2652c6f8-3ba7-4152-b890-0aa032dd7664" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "14d7c08f-f7b4-4716-a157-ac9db27beb4e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "14e9dc40-fda3-4203-b05f-e2b3ab34e5a7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d60afc71-8e07-40e9-9dca-aa04ea13ba01" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "14eb0ac1-d9be-49be-8c92-c595d6d06bde", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48ee9d92-cf8a-47d5-b6c5-348e8f6b814c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "156f1690-9e32-4398-93ff-4f55280cbe37", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "41fe48fd-383b-4117-b9e6-c9ab8bbf9a5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f014c34e-b889-4609-a5ae-cd156f6fef80" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "15a7c8d4-19d7-4673-9460-d188c5c5350e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "de005196-3cd4-43df-9d79-c366db8991d5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2652c6f8-3ba7-4152-b890-0aa032dd7664" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "162d420b-21b4-45a3-a706-0f7e7dd5c144", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b40dd8f-190f-4567-bd29-b2ffe8a51e9d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "165c800a-ced0-4a02-83db-349b56c557e0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "167cdb29-8896-4cb4-9d09-7b0ba22343f1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c6c5435d-5ec2-447e-b490-ba09650ff0fd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "16b80753-7d68-4a57-bc3c-7a7ecc2a88ed", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5cf85c8-afd8-4ddb-8945-85cda662625b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "16d883a7-2076-437f-be23-8f91dcddf10c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "93511bd0-2fd0-4e0e-88d0-a179752fb71f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "844382fc-2fe9-4cff-89be-90b55d4e4be2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1706cb93-3259-412e-aa39-1578d662cdea", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f331274-4d74-4e8c-8cc1-8f788aca29ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1706f60c-a683-46da-843f-c7908a6cdabf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74560b06-2493-4972-8a46-c9c740bb3caa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d9b40f9f-4124-4dba-a5a7-d17ad59db135" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "1708a61e-35a4-4376-b296-c8e612b37f49", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b28bfe-eb96-4cd5-8670-b52298d679ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "172099bf-8852-40df-8d13-edb736a9a5aa", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b774373e-15fb-42f6-b2ba-0788937bee67" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "177cf568-d1c4-459c-a0db-8f838814dd3f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2da431dc-66e0-49d4-9d85-ebb2190e6ebb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c3f0c3d7-3358-4e68-90ac-dde65943ade0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "184c057b-389e-4d7a-8286-f3bfdf67139a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "185ed25a-9b98-40de-9410-81dc32008304", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0f801063-4dc8-4b90-adb3-e571927fe0a0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a59d344e-855a-416b-9086-419c159fcafb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "187846bd-1fb9-4b8a-872f-099b0c099606", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b12c53e9-48a5-4fdc-8c1b-fb2183e2f42f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e5168649-a197-4ecb-9628-32012569cd58" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "18fb8de6-5453-431c-a8ed-5cfe653a3675", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c78d3dd-665f-4290-b565-ea8a67464ad8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b86da1b-08f8-436e-9caa-4f6062f673ba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "18fc687c-719a-4295-91e6-deaa7baa638c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "37329a18-2e35-4642-871f-c2d4ee8564d0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0bd4f434-a6fe-43e4-9e3e-7fd2da8c81af" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1944bf4d-8dc5-4bee-9538-1e495f410d11", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ea7d338a-b63d-48b6-8c97-83a84ef6a383" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e5168649-a197-4ecb-9628-32012569cd58" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "195d73c4-bf53-4807-95ba-9373dd999173", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fba7d9d2-d4dd-49b9-aae3-1768cce41ca1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "19c3887d-7d4b-458a-ac96-7d7970b9ad2c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b684c1-914c-4108-aa54-a40944e9f565" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a7cd8811-64f2-44d6-ba86-59a08ebda2bf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "19c6919b-edde-4d2d-8741-31f454816c43", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c633f358-4531-4b0a-8067-6a9f771747b3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "1a20338e-4a49-456a-8f14-20b53415a304", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "649ae051-03fd-4ee9-b7b4-31cd188aa66c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6f8de2a8-3316-4360-80ae-7370bba4a466" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1a4192b6-4bf8-49c9-9bcd-51fbdc4e1b6c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cd1dd2be-8462-4c62-b652-44b59f6e3337" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1a4d2978-5341-4389-84bf-e48f2aabe9ee", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e5168649-a197-4ecb-9628-32012569cd58" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed090d75-5c98-4171-8853-469fc8efebf3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "1a5036ce-cad2-4a05-8636-d2e0f8d73bae", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0a8a70f7-76ed-4dd0-a82b-178c4bb0f4f1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "837aabe8-6eaf-4b5e-80ba-0cab5f0be894" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1aac4b62-f527-4dd3-bb2c-879f5f72551d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fb7b86eb-22fe-4871-96a7-b281f112367d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3c8056d4-7be6-425e-8160-6c7c593ad2b9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1addbefe-cbd5-4e46-8603-2dc5a973598f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "433e0018-8c1f-4ae8-a6bf-ad37779a8709" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c78d3dd-665f-4290-b565-ea8a67464ad8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1b7b577c-3cbb-4e51-b192-0b492906d9a3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1ba1d45e-6416-4e6c-aef2-721be048d859", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1c048e76-1c6c-42f2-8d76-ebae2715f041", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "1c200389-b508-413e-ad82-e4c544398987", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ea7d338a-b63d-48b6-8c97-83a84ef6a383" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed090d75-5c98-4171-8853-469fc8efebf3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1c2f0053-35cd-432e-8961-524bcce4e23e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "844382fc-2fe9-4cff-89be-90b55d4e4be2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "1c32b29c-18f1-4d3c-8ac4-4801fcf31f7f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2c867547-6b80-4e4f-9b15-7593a7a0cfe5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1c3b87a3-cdb8-4d9c-930c-0ab255679c53", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "11c0eb0e-b92b-413f-91aa-c93ac214871d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d8ea7ec4-0892-42af-b03b-630540619336" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1d1abef4-d980-4ae8-b212-c9cd089a43b6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "22508d7e-47ac-4dc1-861a-3d311bc6b4d4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1d30556a-3d08-4283-b56f-3908de5784c2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "1dec1ce7-f3e9-4f03-9169-d6388590623c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "1e287d5f-8d49-4870-a105-4a5c09465730", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "70715c4f-7653-4992-9ecb-c1406b3da7e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "1ea98e39-5dd8-4227-9485-0baba962c892", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a23f84f0-5eb2-46be-909e-0dcf1577c6f1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "20278da9-b522-4710-bb56-9453839439ac", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aa4d0880-7378-426d-a66b-82215aafd407" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2086f15b-a9ab-4cea-9241-5af7a3bb8d34", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b86da1b-08f8-436e-9caa-4f6062f673ba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "20a385f2-295a-435e-b0e3-ec0058dc9c5c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d30fd255-e758-488e-9728-f2c279cce272" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed245c0f-7379-4ba5-8d7a-cbc02b0feba0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "211ecddf-33b5-4f04-bc77-6b41dba84c65", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f2f40857-d84a-4f06-ac82-99872c1b09e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "055b0ac5-8ef6-439f-9713-3ae50e05b688" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "21b3a4e8-f560-473f-927f-1e8b44939ac3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f80f75b5-f8a6-4110-b181-5f65430493ac" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b28bfe-eb96-4cd5-8670-b52298d679ca" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "22a47e0c-053c-466e-9bcb-2168614d58d9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c812a1ef-102d-4c30-8ceb-a31730de5074" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "23b27d15-b89b-4ce5-8ce2-e11cf37aa970", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "23c0790a-3e0a-40a3-a969-056eed9cbabd", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "884d7a21-8b9e-482f-b416-fff0b37dc69d" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "23d8a57c-e39e-4822-bc90-659ccee21a43", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "13ec68d4-4e7e-4327-bf76-1488f27e3743" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "24051c39-d64a-425b-b006-77045683a04b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ebf6a7a7-6c9b-4468-9c67-bf84ac07340b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "245028fd-4fb2-4841-9ba6-091c8cafb7ab", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74992a29-94d3-4468-9761-d1bd22c47322" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "24d9d241-574d-47b7-bbc3-a876ea3504d7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8aaa4c90-8538-4068-9f46-6a88bbac1798" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da42d489-5081-441e-95a3-1021b7d7b341" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2521723d-72a0-4bf2-a71a-2e1f22647f10", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a17616a3-b642-4972-b1c7-af84ff7085ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "25b9ceb8-99dc-4906-a79d-6bd81f4f4028", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aae376c6-719b-4c7d-b16f-c6b1249d6966" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f2f40857-d84a-4f06-ac82-99872c1b09e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2612220b-3903-4968-8afd-51c7a5d98f17", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "055b0ac5-8ef6-439f-9713-3ae50e05b688" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "26167e7f-06d4-4338-a6d8-76f09c022da8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b28bfe-eb96-4cd5-8670-b52298d679ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74992a29-94d3-4468-9761-d1bd22c47322" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "263f1986-2260-4b32-ac05-3a70523e8bfe", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e6af7ee6-18be-473e-910f-47917af3cf96" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "2674db9c-42c3-4e70-967a-cbb3b28af090", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a23802b4-cbb8-43ff-a73c-fd7b2e3bc35a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "236669cb-46bb-4411-90c0-548e10b4b121" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "26835fd3-ad84-4b8a-8988-d509488a3250", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "412d1928-266c-4e56-ae85-0cb5498008ac" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "833e6368-46e9-4659-8c4e-3233fbb876a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "282c353b-a6ed-42bb-95d0-b0989ab3de9f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "99d84601-f5ff-4f31-b5ec-e03ee731d14b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "282d4505-5ed1-4c39-98fa-d40fb3b12813", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2859ed9e-0e27-4150-8946-5dd026489773", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "920e3325-de0b-41c9-832b-36bd12bf14ee" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48b2bf3a-33e5-4c54-b635-c10855d24297" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "285ad603-ffbd-4650-bcfe-545b6a1882a7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "84af919e-9e37-4851-8a3d-a06f3c60999c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5479add5-2688-41a8-a49c-1a336d1dfa3b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "2871668e-2801-4411-a643-94d43575620f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e4ae921-3fa3-4762-84b1-f7e6da27bcfb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "290d832e-acc0-404d-8960-7cc8d39a0d17", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0f801063-4dc8-4b90-adb3-e571927fe0a0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "297a9de3-28ac-42ba-8602-73447c502192", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87dae4b6-b7cf-4a98-8683-499c8dcf24db" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c78d3dd-665f-4290-b565-ea8a67464ad8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "298b8e41-44f3-4e3b-ab80-861c0023330d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "93511bd0-2fd0-4e0e-88d0-a179752fb71f" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2998971a-2e5e-4cfc-8f59-44e7b900c8ea", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "359b22a9-dc7c-4a33-97f1-30e78aa59822" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5479add5-2688-41a8-a49c-1a336d1dfa3b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "29bcd20d-7ed7-4412-a786-62ce96faaddb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0a8a70f7-76ed-4dd0-a82b-178c4bb0f4f1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6f860b03-f862-40ea-bb59-99a44e8c3f51" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a0d54c2-d197-4a69-b1bc-e5714a44d60a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c3f0c3d7-3358-4e68-90ac-dde65943ade0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a7cd8811-64f2-44d6-ba86-59a08ebda2bf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a3cdb15-7dd6-4c44-b663-813c4bcde8dc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "41fe48fd-383b-4117-b9e6-c9ab8bbf9a5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a4ba1f2-253d-483f-8aa9-552e7b211407", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "359b22a9-dc7c-4a33-97f1-30e78aa59822" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a52cc00-2fba-4b68-910d-304f75a5a3e7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e5538d7-a86a-4d3c-a049-e7ea7afb294a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2ac7f4e9-073b-4a25-b95b-a9fbb26253bd", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a41d48dc-1906-4a3f-8abf-25c3cf3d10f7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "2be0556d-e792-45ce-9fed-3da072dda74c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d22330b5-252d-47db-b5b0-c316aa862284" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2c431a43-6344-4433-94ac-ef5ca5075c9c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f2061db9-a203-4ac3-bcac-7f8dd977420c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2cc21765-f2e5-4e6a-97d6-de03ed0781db", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "37329a18-2e35-4642-871f-c2d4ee8564d0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a9fad21-af65-4b06-a043-c3b9c1b462f2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2cce8795-6ae3-4ffc-8db8-626d58ed182d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2cdea885-413d-4485-aca1-9319f344f498", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5bada80b-11d5-4828-9388-db44fff8342e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7025bd9b-1715-43d1-9274-500f0d0cd088" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "2cf0bcd0-4a5c-47a7-8314-5a4243d9c2a4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "56da68a6-9471-4b07-bb59-7c8612f64729" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2cff9338-0370-4106-852e-5e38bb34a97d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2df88ddd-9748-4c58-8cf9-bd9949974b56", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "080bc287-4e39-464e-90a1-dc0f20e54e19" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "844382fc-2fe9-4cff-89be-90b55d4e4be2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2e060235-46d1-40ef-b7a8-ff3e69e8fa6f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4c7d8fab-1ddc-4a74-9836-4cdc9aeb6bbd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "2e457b11-5160-4116-9e45-6972f5e13a41", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "144b6e37-2a16-4947-b715-3f9b616072b2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "2e9ffb3c-b55c-4e0b-b777-29ee11a02e2f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d22330b5-252d-47db-b5b0-c316aa862284" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2ec14cf9-2616-4a22-aef9-e3d03c8920f7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "64b876cd-5aa4-46da-ab92-f82971ca9869" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c633f358-4531-4b0a-8067-6a9f771747b3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2ede9bb0-8bd9-409f-a6e6-5255135d4819", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2da431dc-66e0-49d4-9d85-ebb2190e6ebb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "2f558799-08bd-4af8-ad2e-81d1245ba31c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0d319735-7e89-46d2-ba87-f78ab242cb41" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "2f627bb7-e92d-45ad-8e00-796f480aa0ca", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "2f8076ac-e6b2-4733-bc4e-c2c393f72864", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "228a2225-fb50-4f4d-a202-1ece0e67f42a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "2f96831a-b5d7-452c-807e-192ed5febeb1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d4e02902-7c00-48c8-8ff8-9b5a5fe32557" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "2fb43376-8983-44e6-8d51-8c12d37a76ab", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "684ae8ab-3dbe-4a38-b1a6-92666a2fea6e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f2e5456-aec6-48fc-a6de-3c644e4ec921" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "319fcba8-6de1-42f5-a97a-f49e1bf0944a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "31f8c052-2a36-4111-8298-e7a9520cfa63", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "884d7a21-8b9e-482f-b416-fff0b37dc69d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "326f6e87-435d-4f1d-9948-1afa7f22c613", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "099225a8-148e-4a5f-a59f-3ef46e936e2b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "228a2225-fb50-4f4d-a202-1ece0e67f42a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "32869502-d599-4a06-baa9-aeddb25fc497", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d2c4811-2f33-4e99-9452-391379b6b41c" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "3305528c-cf54-433a-ab87-b356c357abfb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d60afc71-8e07-40e9-9dca-aa04ea13ba01" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7199fc6b-6cb4-4494-b0af-0468f2e11560" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "3333a095-204d-4cd7-abca-76e5fd68ad37", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "27866d49-96b4-4529-9096-0432cf81aa69" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f951b58a-190e-42d1-9581-65d9af37c513" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "334b8ceb-5427-4215-aeab-0ef59d981986", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "61db5e85-20c7-4395-9df8-f5c27445f56c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "33b340b7-7783-4a10-9c05-1f7d6e7f7634", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e07e924c-2da9-4c78-9303-4faab90cfa84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a6203019-d360-4a29-a040-b905d890093c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "34d6af27-68cb-47cf-9539-78f73fe20605", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87dae4b6-b7cf-4a98-8683-499c8dcf24db" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07b92395-5c07-4634-81de-61c1ca22b9e9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "34faa8f1-aba3-4485-9f7c-663ebd2e477a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3c8056d4-7be6-425e-8160-6c7c593ad2b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ea3836bc-20dd-461e-9371-6e6a4c613ee1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3509a061-0238-4877-b27f-8d2320c30050", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "de3320d0-c61f-40f4-8d61-cacde8810c7f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da42d489-5081-441e-95a3-1021b7d7b341" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "35953c10-7fc7-489c-940e-ce7dd2392d60", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5b395891-7882-48fd-a7a5-7cf14c8a2767" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "35aeb16b-09a8-4df4-9191-d602c20182a6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f0e9896-21f7-49aa-a5d1-b848a95b3301" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "130fbecb-831e-4645-9557-7471a53fb4a2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "35af63f8-2fe2-4b0f-8fed-28b3aaa53a7c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "68ce467e-1d6c-4b22-b61e-019875f50725" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e2acef4e-0371-4f46-b034-8db42007c8ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "3612d5c9-11ac-4a02-b6e9-53c79371184c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f331274-4d74-4e8c-8cc1-8f788aca29ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "36401f22-8939-4203-a3c0-d196d172a7a7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "22cf44b0-1336-4ba2-96b8-6f7d6ebef354" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "834744d9-dcae-4306-b33d-0a9634ccd588" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "365b3269-ed34-4d88-964b-5f297fa39f12", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6909c595-06ac-4c43-a7a4-71a178d91223" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "369e81ad-4500-4662-b557-2fc2d03fb557", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "359b22a9-dc7c-4a33-97f1-30e78aa59822" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "36a46e24-3b44-47a7-a01b-e570c059c623", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c6c5435d-5ec2-447e-b490-ba09650ff0fd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "36a87786-aff7-4fb1-ba71-a9e3e1c6e256", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7daa0a6c-1435-4bd2-9abc-667736b6b289" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b86da1b-08f8-436e-9caa-4f6062f673ba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "370c008c-1c8f-4f50-922d-fe5e553018ae", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "999ef140-f4e1-4d00-8e53-c09ae6d1598e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "3721585c-df4c-4c0b-bc13-63b924dabc49", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9bec9aa-92f0-4b38-aa04-fb102e870479" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "37ce267a-1218-456b-8d82-74d3e37c89ac", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7b33c306-b622-4957-9665-929113a88b27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "38796f91-053f-40cc-ae53-6a7b3cd8128d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "482c771c-e49a-4bde-b43a-6b52603fcb13" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3c8056d4-7be6-425e-8160-6c7c593ad2b9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "38a9f3ab-ffbe-4297-96ce-298065cbc14e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5bada80b-11d5-4828-9388-db44fff8342e" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "38e7aa37-1f09-4e74-9d3c-efc4fdc809e0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a23f84f0-5eb2-46be-909e-0dcf1577c6f1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32b3b4e1-7603-463a-9a69-1a48a6f7f3d7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "3929a701-8f10-4a74-bbdd-546ffd0f3f44", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9cdf6c1-2bd1-4265-825b-c184651d637e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a0fb3bbd-ef15-4691-8c94-6992861d75cd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "3990dc3c-3f62-4a32-99b6-9961a5679848", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e63a500a-ae5e-493b-a8cc-66bda2c566c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3991d829-8c24-493b-bf31-b4d14ac8daa8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e5168649-a197-4ecb-9628-32012569cd58" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "56da68a6-9471-4b07-bb59-7c8612f64729" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "39d4963b-8e08-41b2-a731-e13bc8a5ecb1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f951b58a-190e-42d1-9581-65d9af37c513" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "39e157d2-1f0a-47f6-8f20-1878b0ba3e06", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d2c4811-2f33-4e99-9452-391379b6b41c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "39fa8052-09b6-46ab-8b7d-a8fb87d90361", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef23345e-bb9e-451e-bedb-3c69e526b44e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "3a71cbc8-b476-459c-a5d6-52ca098570ea", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3b6561b-fc04-4743-aff1-4ea909eb7f48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3a8e256a-4c6e-4f71-9648-1706817329f4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a6309f59-39a3-43da-8f0b-4a8afd6a7f6d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "837aabe8-6eaf-4b5e-80ba-0cab5f0be894" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "3aea73af-4569-45dd-9e25-2aa1b6923926", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e63a500a-ae5e-493b-a8cc-66bda2c566c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3b84abfe-ee58-4590-9718-987a4bd422d1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "df508eef-acea-4e2e-a360-166fbad65fe6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6006dc8-8e31-4741-9549-c4e480fd1687" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "3c33f7ee-576d-47a5-9a1d-7004baefd2ba", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "3c4088c7-6ca6-476c-ad56-f38dc2db4a75", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "080bc287-4e39-464e-90a1-dc0f20e54e19" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "3ca96920-e1cc-457e-814f-ed1b3794c35c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "76b59fb9-8e95-4a4c-b8b3-fb4069bfcc71" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "3cd47a80-cb73-44d6-af09-1a61c9577762", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ea3836bc-20dd-461e-9371-6e6a4c613ee1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "3d3b5c26-154e-4f39-a12b-87be84adaee7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a0fb3bbd-ef15-4691-8c94-6992861d75cd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3d49c598-8c91-43ae-9a87-3c760a875e6d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b68ebf73-4d0b-4f5a-b422-27d40f1d8b26" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3d8a74f0-45f7-4cd7-97e3-2e3862db45cb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9785093-7e00-4d40-935b-58495cc90b29" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f80f75b5-f8a6-4110-b181-5f65430493ac" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "3e682c1d-9e64-4dbc-bdb3-39ccbc1eb655", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3e83a208-eeb1-4b51-8908-24a14cc0dc99", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a0fb3bbd-ef15-4691-8c94-6992861d75cd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "3ec6e240-6a88-461f-8446-d3947c8ce656", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "475953d9-2ccf-43e3-a004-780d584ad5e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c3f0c3d7-3358-4e68-90ac-dde65943ade0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "3f19c326-529f-40f9-b581-09fedbd15f99", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ea3836bc-20dd-461e-9371-6e6a4c613ee1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "3f7192e9-7199-4719-9d9b-4b8222be3332", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aae376c6-719b-4c7d-b16f-c6b1249d6966" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "055b0ac5-8ef6-439f-9713-3ae50e05b688" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "40427727-9d5f-4a2d-9be9-daa12b373e56", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef4a77be-faf3-40be-be53-61704a2894e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "409030fe-6b3d-49a3-abd3-c90c734f1fef", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f0e9896-21f7-49aa-a5d1-b848a95b3301" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "40cbcc4d-38bd-4cde-ae6d-d7c8bcdf020e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a9fad21-af65-4b06-a043-c3b9c1b462f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "415274f8-10da-405e-9c70-5d7209114012", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef4a77be-faf3-40be-be53-61704a2894e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "56da68a6-9471-4b07-bb59-7c8612f64729" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "41b35f02-1b31-4884-b9d9-bc53691b3edc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3c8056d4-7be6-425e-8160-6c7c593ad2b9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "41c05e93-439f-4a54-b29a-a2a4a1eb65fd", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "429d0676-35d7-4bea-a5ca-a18a54e3278f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ac42e5e0-54ed-4c0a-89e0-06cc229c6e34" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8e38f19-3765-49d6-9d3d-5a568fe21b0a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "42c9e285-c9f1-4817-8c72-16c835a50f5a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c4ed6841-d780-4112-86c7-9f0c3f567484" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8e38f19-3765-49d6-9d3d-5a568fe21b0a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "42eedeb1-9cd1-4f96-a151-4928891e39cb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fe91119-87ab-4ba8-98e8-25c4369c1c36" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "91583e14-811b-4a2d-ba91-021985f7e9dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4339b034-c061-4a8f-9cde-217bf0b7537f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2652c6f8-3ba7-4152-b890-0aa032dd7664" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0ad651ef-4f42-494e-877a-51dcd80a52ac" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "433abe6e-a2ee-436a-aef1-7f38d0ceb7cb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cd1dd2be-8462-4c62-b652-44b59f6e3337" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "43ceb7a1-07f5-482c-953a-f0cd81a518fc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed090d75-5c98-4171-8853-469fc8efebf3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "43fdc601-a5a4-40e8-ab85-1db07360c219", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d4e02902-7c00-48c8-8ff8-9b5a5fe32557" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ebf6a7a7-6c9b-4468-9c67-bf84ac07340b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "445ff454-a0d9-4ad3-8e02-11f0900bf65e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f2e5456-aec6-48fc-a6de-3c644e4ec921" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "451510d2-7483-4bec-a547-d93e8487fe54", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c6c5435d-5ec2-447e-b490-ba09650ff0fd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "922caeac-3d2b-4dc4-a12b-a6280146f7bb" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "454bca9b-1c78-4de1-9564-53cb7c7d90da", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "45f0dca3-caac-47f4-a397-2107cbfcb5de", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4104485e-a1d9-4150-9c01-db8898adeb0c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4635b35c-e3b6-457e-b39a-d09fefa5e4df", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "af86d506-7b3d-4e8a-85a1-7d7bcbaeb355" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "79d2d259-cd64-4371-8163-5209f81df67f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "464e90fd-0f20-4b56-8674-0178a64ae39a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88530d93-d355-41cd-8fd0-5e7c929738b7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7a4151df-237d-4321-bd6b-951df01d5fba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "4664b1c5-6a4b-4a87-bb1f-539146f14813", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48ee9d92-cf8a-47d5-b6c5-348e8f6b814c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1abeaae6-348c-4d5f-8117-157be556de20" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "47e9e3ed-5c5f-4d0e-a039-82510e7546f4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2191c8dc-d7e0-4d29-b4f8-0a64e2f2297b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d7d16bd2-3db4-42ea-80fb-aef428fce13e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4807b8c9-e885-4b04-ac2b-4b40de563aa9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7daa0a6c-1435-4bd2-9abc-667736b6b289" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "4816ab7e-0794-4ed6-8c5e-536ad6753229", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "491a8098-422a-4e1d-9cd3-300bb307f9ca", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f355f471-b989-4b99-9abf-861f334315fc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "493bde47-f57f-47c3-99c0-b196a726635b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aa4d0880-7378-426d-a66b-82215aafd407" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48ee9d92-cf8a-47d5-b6c5-348e8f6b814c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4981d577-ada5-4c1f-ab53-2bb11812ac8c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88530d93-d355-41cd-8fd0-5e7c929738b7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "4a902ebb-073b-492e-b6f0-145884db588f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c17839c3-0f58-46e3-8bc7-0cd193dd8f06" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4a946ec5-02f1-48c6-aded-da3bffe054c1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "51551fde-9432-4152-a688-afcfb9e32b8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c78d3dd-665f-4290-b565-ea8a67464ad8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4aec87c5-4586-4cc1-ad92-0594ad94c1f0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7b33c306-b622-4957-9665-929113a88b27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "79d2d259-cd64-4371-8163-5209f81df67f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4b467a53-342d-490c-82a5-20f15544eb33", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b1838b3a-5f61-4503-a40b-518fad523da2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4c7d8fab-1ddc-4a74-9836-4cdc9aeb6bbd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4b9e95b0-34b2-4c51-8819-9a26870e24e3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "920e3325-de0b-41c9-832b-36bd12bf14ee" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fc05ce2-c8f6-40fe-92fb-95d4b1922e16" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4c157944-2764-44b0-bac4-b92231ef565a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "099225a8-148e-4a5f-a59f-3ef46e936e2b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4d5ce01c-6db4-45d6-b45d-2c8a19d96ead", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9d580e32-031b-47b3-a2bf-dad5ca4374ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4dc3a590-bdf9-47d6-9823-a54fb94aa229", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c633f358-4531-4b0a-8067-6a9f771747b3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "4dd91b9e-c02a-474a-ab32-558a7a7a25de", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9785093-7e00-4d40-935b-58495cc90b29" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4e2b7a59-79ae-4ede-ad5d-de295601b461", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fc05ce2-c8f6-40fe-92fb-95d4b1922e16" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4e5b17d0-afb0-4445-bf94-75de7bee46e6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed090d75-5c98-4171-8853-469fc8efebf3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4eed33bb-6386-4665-b4b2-8fcccfb2f1d5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "4f57d8b8-3cc8-43e1-b1cc-c787fe0f010f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "096fe03b-749d-455a-84f6-901aa41d1bbf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4104485e-a1d9-4150-9c01-db8898adeb0c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "4f6f06a3-a05a-4937-b0de-d126d17b5e5e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "4fd8705e-b952-4160-95f5-68998e9ae42a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4ab00691-79bd-4049-b028-f1872cb37aff" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "5029c553-859f-431e-aebd-74c58c436cb2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3ebe5d97-b87f-4705-9bc6-d0fa38bdd7e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "512eab5d-49b6-4fe5-887c-d4ca76237859", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "833e6368-46e9-4659-8c4e-3233fbb876a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e2acef4e-0371-4f46-b034-8db42007c8ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "51f987a6-bfd2-49f1-a78f-b896a3a61860", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9bec9aa-92f0-4b38-aa04-fb102e870479" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f80f75b5-f8a6-4110-b181-5f65430493ac" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "52dffc31-ccbf-4eb9-b23d-8f5498f3f017", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a755f5c-94b6-43ac-a5c7-467103efa17b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "531ca661-4fa2-4520-a705-9b990adb589d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2c867547-6b80-4e4f-9b15-7593a7a0cfe5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "5371a1ff-510b-4dfb-8f55-503fa3cc6d5e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d8ea7ec4-0892-42af-b03b-630540619336" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "53a1da96-00ac-4947-8495-5cb5c22e58d4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3ebe5d97-b87f-4705-9bc6-d0fa38bdd7e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "53ab609e-46f3-49f6-bba0-a9805e4c3dac", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "228a2225-fb50-4f4d-a202-1ece0e67f42a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "5412bf4c-556b-41d3-9201-e790b995f4fe", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "544ef7a2-bf07-48d6-a44c-5f377e83b633", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "144b6e37-2a16-4947-b715-3f9b616072b2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fba7d9d2-d4dd-49b9-aae3-1768cce41ca1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "548e01dc-f516-4c86-8eb8-70afbf11c6db", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1d43815f-4ffe-4400-bfa1-44e883d0ffe5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "14c88d83-dcac-4801-b8da-41fc130e763b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "54bff130-b06f-4c34-8786-e956b4562f71", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f3cbd5ab-2429-46f6-adf7-08b5fad8f390" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "550f1f13-30de-4668-a814-bf111807608b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "22508d7e-47ac-4dc1-861a-3d311bc6b4d4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aa4d0880-7378-426d-a66b-82215aafd407" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "552dfc2d-d7f0-4754-8f2f-543e6ce16613", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "55608ac2-672a-43a0-8196-457a478db8a6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "276c3a4e-6e04-45e1-84da-27668d5fb3dd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "16d6dd3d-c3cd-454e-baf0-4c3e12c522e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5653ff39-b5ea-40d4-8565-ca9a6f474b3e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a755f5c-94b6-43ac-a5c7-467103efa17b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "565e1177-c644-4a76-930c-60a4ca7b19cc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8e2df6ba-4ceb-4063-a168-bc9ebbf6ad02" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "56775b10-be81-48c8-bf19-b373d8616953", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2d0a1476-404e-4569-83e3-d2aa0efeadd4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "56864726-00d8-4262-9525-1e2224a66a4b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf549ad5-9129-414c-9d8b-334ada0653e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "837aabe8-6eaf-4b5e-80ba-0cab5f0be894" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "56e74edd-d4ec-43f9-b4f6-23bd804329cf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c15e5864-a302-4bb1-bae7-f1faf3ea4793" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "56fd5890-db50-4fbf-a03e-08c6c2d1edca", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6909c595-06ac-4c43-a7a4-71a178d91223" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5738568a-434c-4c84-bc79-3fd263026d49", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4104485e-a1d9-4150-9c01-db8898adeb0c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "57eb3c42-1bf2-4882-94a0-127f4c73bd5d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a97b3bd3-3948-4840-a2bd-d4c083a37dcb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "593db7c6-f3b5-4261-9083-b8ccbab0de46", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8aaa4c90-8538-4068-9f46-6a88bbac1798" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3253fc62-9dee-420b-b306-0df9a527443b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "5985136b-b473-4021-be2f-83cfc928522d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "475953d9-2ccf-43e3-a004-780d584ad5e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "130fbecb-831e-4645-9557-7471a53fb4a2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "599e2cd4-5ed8-4a92-bd39-e3928c5674f4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5a3797af-1917-4f30-b269-e1e2c130edb5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d7d16bd2-3db4-42ea-80fb-aef428fce13e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e2acef4e-0371-4f46-b034-8db42007c8ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "5a4bc1f6-d371-44d7-9f49-9a81cf67a60f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "5a7fd3be-88b9-4aac-a178-e912d283f8a0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6f8de2a8-3316-4360-80ae-7370bba4a466" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "5b110e48-084d-4ee8-8380-9242e11fdb43", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "080bc287-4e39-464e-90a1-dc0f20e54e19" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c0e6243-92bf-446a-b72a-ebffce0e56f8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "df508eef-acea-4e2e-a360-166fbad65fe6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c314a1a-7914-40a2-9888-999439618069", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7025bd9b-1715-43d1-9274-500f0d0cd088" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c3189d2-60f7-4b8d-89dc-314abf21ba02", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "130fbecb-831e-4645-9557-7471a53fb4a2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "5cc36f93-ea55-492b-ba1b-361a30564164", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d9b40f9f-4124-4dba-a5a7-d17ad59db135" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5ceaddbf-1bc8-4a61-a29f-0f952d24a27f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed960b87-4486-42e9-aadf-fd5a66f85775" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5cf0fdd3-4c44-411d-8964-d992e38a45c3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5d5b0666-47a9-4ede-acf1-41f034eb60f2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "276c3a4e-6e04-45e1-84da-27668d5fb3dd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c17839c3-0f58-46e3-8bc7-0cd193dd8f06" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5df19e3d-95d9-44e2-a7ef-4a021713ed53", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "47786d94-8002-40e5-b7a2-e3780fbfadeb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "5ec991fb-7144-49a0-82a0-32a434fa02a5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0008b2ae-c319-446d-af24-71752a514d13" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5f505316-cb54-412c-8bd1-d5103f5c25d1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5f60bbd1-1130-411c-a27e-b6841a22bd08", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1fa6dc41-ea88-4e00-b97d-14fcdd578315" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7025bd9b-1715-43d1-9274-500f0d0cd088" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "5f7bf779-b405-4f5e-86cb-b43bffcaa5e9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3941d9fe-5b7f-49ef-bb52-2df00e6ce4fb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "5fec8517-44a5-4777-80a9-a75d3a3a88b6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3ebe5d97-b87f-4705-9bc6-d0fa38bdd7e4" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "5ff2d642-f2d8-4c45-a9bc-d05adea00f9b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0bd4f434-a6fe-43e4-9e3e-7fd2da8c81af" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a9fad21-af65-4b06-a043-c3b9c1b462f2" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "601091de-af5b-4517-8f93-0e94facc440f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "130fbecb-831e-4645-9557-7471a53fb4a2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ee5b4a6b-b52c-4572-b3ad-666de5b6e633" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "604b4ae1-fc6d-49ec-b5b2-776268c227b5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6a2accb-efd2-41de-a039-a21d3b0c9c93" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9d580e32-031b-47b3-a2bf-dad5ca4374ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "604bcc86-41bb-4439-b8a3-6c3e449ad517", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d60948e4-2cb2-4fcb-ba1d-7fc2805337aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74992a29-94d3-4468-9761-d1bd22c47322" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "60b9c3b0-1f2c-499c-933c-514aded409e7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "60d87f82-c5f7-4b32-9c59-11946b6ffaa6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "130fbecb-831e-4645-9557-7471a53fb4a2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c3f0c3d7-3358-4e68-90ac-dde65943ade0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "6115216c-c66c-4d6a-a4ae-7101509b7a23", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "19cc1a07-e68f-4bfe-a700-693296466f1a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "617c9991-ed26-46ac-b01d-3308c8f03b3e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "618c64a5-a9cc-45f8-aa24-1568fe9bb716", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a7cd8811-64f2-44d6-ba86-59a08ebda2bf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "634f89d0-80cb-458a-ba90-0f4c7624a17d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5b395891-7882-48fd-a7a5-7cf14c8a2767" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6374b9bd-78cf-44eb-a53c-d85ee0f18ddf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "844382fc-2fe9-4cff-89be-90b55d4e4be2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6521f8eb-a6d9-406e-9c0a-4b9bd75d8f5e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dbb68b83-ad5c-482d-b3eb-3f9adfa3797e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "65daf82b-c346-4aae-af40-d0fa179dece0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "65ea3bfd-9663-49a6-9ac4-a529fc85a9f9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3b6561b-fc04-4743-aff1-4ea909eb7f48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aa4d0880-7378-426d-a66b-82215aafd407" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "66126523-ed51-4a5c-afba-b7c0cb4b0d89", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "66e6e814-7512-4d05-8f7e-0233f51cebb9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7199fc6b-6cb4-4494-b0af-0468f2e11560" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ea3836bc-20dd-461e-9371-6e6a4c613ee1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "66eada99-64b8-4970-ab05-50282887c322", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a97b3bd3-3948-4840-a2bd-d4c083a37dcb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "130fbecb-831e-4645-9557-7471a53fb4a2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "672d0025-e753-40cf-9818-2af5da4bc26e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "412d1928-266c-4e56-ae85-0cb5498008ac" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "68ce467e-1d6c-4b22-b61e-019875f50725" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "67caf38b-2d49-404d-a207-a0cbd8265707", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f80f75b5-f8a6-4110-b181-5f65430493ac" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "68269056-312d-4f8d-b7f3-e5c6ff30c107", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6503e6ac-d94f-49d6-bcaf-7a3117a57034" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "69af3432-452f-40b0-898c-9d159b0bf0dd", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9d6826-e89f-4f7c-90a8-d5ebd54e972b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "69f71a21-bdcb-41dc-9b44-5a9669431513", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a3fa635-049b-47c0-8022-e5d4b4ee1afa", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6503e6ac-d94f-49d6-bcaf-7a3117a57034" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "502805ad-82e7-44ed-afe6-13abc89aa7b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a772a74-80f9-448b-84ec-3caa2ab62d17", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "eafe6c9d-5f51-4a00-b14f-448626621cb1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6b2ddd8c-1fa0-458b-815e-6f8882d829c4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "70715c4f-7653-4992-9ecb-c1406b3da7e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1b6eba79-a3c4-43e5-80dc-611fb0556b90" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "6b3347c8-137f-4366-bcfd-1f4d148fc572", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b9ea2a3b-7912-41ce-9409-ed7b58403f55" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32907b67-1e27-4a5b-987e-c0f7303f1041" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "6bd4fdaf-fbac-448e-92f5-af445671b2c8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "10b1f024-bac8-4a50-a6cd-8a8a101c8bb9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c0b2fa8-a8fb-4eb8-9caf-a05a26729be8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a755f5c-94b6-43ac-a5c7-467103efa17b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b9ea2a3b-7912-41ce-9409-ed7b58403f55" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c72747b-7a99-4dc2-80df-7b607002d5d7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a17616a3-b642-4972-b1c7-af84ff7085ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0b6835ea-d50b-4e18-8979-f3398eee9a7f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6d1e3b24-ba34-49b6-882a-e61b16fe5851", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f355f471-b989-4b99-9abf-861f334315fc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b86da1b-08f8-436e-9caa-4f6062f673ba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "6db43277-583d-44c3-a458-cbec3c08114c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6e2f4a95-6e5a-421e-b626-3363d888118f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6e3f4beb-8947-48d3-9649-be7737562f54", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c6c5435d-5ec2-447e-b490-ba09650ff0fd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "6e5b6c47-1434-48d7-b742-4cb89ec95ee6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7daa0a6c-1435-4bd2-9abc-667736b6b289" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "6e7c0a14-7b3d-4ea9-ada3-eaad23fb7716", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ae3615df-33cd-4252-95aa-d4a0549753b3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "6ef6d613-3e61-41e5-9fa7-7db7fd5d3799", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f2e5456-aec6-48fc-a6de-3c644e4ec921" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d8ea7ec4-0892-42af-b03b-630540619336" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "6f0b784f-3dd3-4af1-a571-e1fd7f54393b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a59d344e-855a-416b-9086-419c159fcafb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3253fc62-9dee-420b-b306-0df9a527443b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "6f2db5da-d861-4cab-86c7-6b9169cb0117", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3253fc62-9dee-420b-b306-0df9a527443b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6f44eae9-5ab0-498e-98e2-70ca2e5eceda", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "93511bd0-2fd0-4e0e-88d0-a179752fb71f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "6f64147c-570c-4b03-84db-226d31b3ba1d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6909c595-06ac-4c43-a7a4-71a178d91223" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88530d93-d355-41cd-8fd0-5e7c929738b7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "6f8711ab-1740-4386-bd56-71754f401525", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f951b58a-190e-42d1-9581-65d9af37c513" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "eafe6c9d-5f51-4a00-b14f-448626621cb1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "6f9b6afb-8b37-44da-be50-2cb74f9a4e26", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "7070d2cf-826f-4c03-8cc0-2b8e4aa2bdd3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "70ad5e04-6355-40f0-8ee8-06b1a6ad3f79", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1d43815f-4ffe-4400-bfa1-44e883d0ffe5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3423b02-781f-438c-96db-efe0f6704511" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "713e27f0-1112-4608-81b0-542f5ce77a74", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f355f471-b989-4b99-9abf-861f334315fc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "728cea03-55cf-4576-831f-b3c6264a0ef3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "de3320d0-c61f-40f4-8d61-cacde8810c7f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "72ce8a9f-2118-436d-a9df-0e37600e0cd5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f2f40857-d84a-4f06-ac82-99872c1b09e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "73a5ed55-69f2-4a69-9f9a-f0cb6362aff4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f7eb36e5-eb3f-40ac-9711-a883e2482968" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "759fe217-6673-4262-95d7-f3b6aec0b0fb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c633f358-4531-4b0a-8067-6a9f771747b3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aa4d0880-7378-426d-a66b-82215aafd407" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "762b7170-c29e-420f-8299-0a4cfd00a01c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "10b1f024-bac8-4a50-a6cd-8a8a101c8bb9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9d6826-e89f-4f7c-90a8-d5ebd54e972b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "780a1817-9784-4c57-842b-cc4aa807d1a7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "78218262-bd2e-44b3-a33a-04243dd57252", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1b6eba79-a3c4-43e5-80dc-611fb0556b90" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "788f2d06-b51d-4768-aee6-0eda5af9a09c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "13ec68d4-4e7e-4327-bf76-1488f27e3743" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2d0a1476-404e-4569-83e3-d2aa0efeadd4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "79235d36-580b-473a-bc2f-69d3647fe866", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "79698d7e-7661-4b23-888f-adf7f491a422", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1ca241ce-a52c-4e7e-8e91-a61f8087fb06" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74560b06-2493-4972-8a46-c9c740bb3caa" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a22e61a-2e68-4d24-a41b-bb9773c20625", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed245c0f-7379-4ba5-8d7a-cbc02b0feba0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9d580e32-031b-47b3-a2bf-dad5ca4374ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a2a94e1-bab9-482a-b366-a3bd07de11e2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1abeaae6-348c-4d5f-8117-157be556de20" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7a4151df-237d-4321-bd6b-951df01d5fba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a98268c-7d98-4149-97dd-ac0fc601e3bf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e61e54b8-9365-431a-b960-c687e2490200" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "7b34affb-727a-4d77-90b5-9f853c70f6a8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8e38f19-3765-49d6-9d3d-5a568fe21b0a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "7b40755a-b0c6-4317-9ab9-d17218e8c8ae", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "70715c4f-7653-4992-9ecb-c1406b3da7e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c17839c3-0f58-46e3-8bc7-0cd193dd8f06" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "7b617013-483f-4bcf-b6bc-5809e13a7cdc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b7143302-7833-4529-beb6-b3b5287cce10" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d57e230d-c4bf-459d-b509-c79e7e6e2bbf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "7c52a0d7-5179-4331-bb8b-7acc67616660", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "7caf67f8-eff5-4f81-bc70-2833f4f0bb48", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "471bbbd8-b8ad-4eca-8abb-f4d35b0bb927" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32b3b4e1-7603-463a-9a69-1a48a6f7f3d7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d3ec281-99ab-4015-801b-f3fcb9dfd30b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48b2bf3a-33e5-4c54-b635-c10855d24297" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d42d129-548a-414b-a31a-ef31df2cc081", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0008b2ae-c319-446d-af24-71752a514d13" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d5db706-67ea-4c17-9c30-c6b4e15bcabc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "922caeac-3d2b-4dc4-a12b-a6280146f7bb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c6c5435d-5ec2-447e-b490-ba09650ff0fd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d6f9d44-161c-4b2f-9756-574f72454f65", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e2acef4e-0371-4f46-b034-8db42007c8ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "7e41675f-3388-474a-84e8-ef2df8d8cc10", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87dae4b6-b7cf-4a98-8683-499c8dcf24db" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "502805ad-82e7-44ed-afe6-13abc89aa7b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "7e5f7e81-fbbe-427b-a9cf-8535baf7dd37", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0a8a70f7-76ed-4dd0-a82b-178c4bb0f4f1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bfcefb45-2d7c-4032-94dd-6a255c749ddb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "7ef16b04-ff84-46f8-bb65-eb6675b809a7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "055b0ac5-8ef6-439f-9713-3ae50e05b688" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fc04c4e9-bad0-45c4-b778-18b21c44e1ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "7f607e53-295f-40fa-857a-d43e6a296a71", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "63d85aeb-cbec-4045-9500-b6778cdf33a3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3253fc62-9dee-420b-b306-0df9a527443b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "7f728786-e844-4385-989f-aede102e79e8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "91583e14-811b-4a2d-ba91-021985f7e9dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b28bfe-eb96-4cd5-8670-b52298d679ca" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "7f7f6af9-ec2d-49b7-be32-3ab745e19eba", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "7fb55f5b-96df-43c5-b5ae-082d59be23b9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "02280e8a-fd93-4678-92ec-9280fd24d25a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5c086588-756a-43dc-928b-a6e715b992c0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "7ff72fe4-c79e-4ace-bf14-241b829625d8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "837aabe8-6eaf-4b5e-80ba-0cab5f0be894" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "802d5a8f-d53b-4934-87dd-178c13960c3e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a6203019-d360-4a29-a040-b905d890093c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "80b4b75d-0431-42fd-9439-6ac5f9eac5c0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "833e6368-46e9-4659-8c4e-3233fbb876a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "68ce467e-1d6c-4b22-b61e-019875f50725" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "811ef83d-505f-4c28-a722-c34f67a7afeb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e44a0219-4ad9-4221-9dd4-42938da66523" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "81895307-5f58-4e1e-94b5-39c843a7bf4b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dad3bdd6-f121-4e52-a0da-221467815455" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "81ed7bc1-7c77-494c-ac64-8dc2fa898003", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf549ad5-9129-414c-9d8b-334ada0653e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4584a697-7fe0-4922-aa90-8e525468d99f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "82231169-75c6-466d-b69f-3b8d5a664bc6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5c086588-756a-43dc-928b-a6e715b992c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "822fe112-08fd-4ab7-928e-92f4ef264936", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "edd48929-bde2-4c7d-b2c1-f8813de9f454" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "82e3e9ba-701c-4a46-9452-30d74ada4ea4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1fa6dc41-ea88-4e00-b97d-14fcdd578315" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fc05ce2-c8f6-40fe-92fb-95d4b1922e16" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "84e0f1e4-558e-4dd4-846f-9d02adb89383", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a0fb3bbd-ef15-4691-8c94-6992861d75cd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "84e28916-e8fe-42a8-a40b-ace4796da1fc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "63d85aeb-cbec-4045-9500-b6778cdf33a3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "85717d67-11af-47fd-ae31-f78b04aa7649", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e6af7ee6-18be-473e-910f-47917af3cf96" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b303160-3121-4bc4-8a2f-e348fbd56346" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "85da0d7c-136d-430a-959e-9e4eef443199", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "862c4d8b-078b-49ab-977d-3d8a0ef4a88a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8670ba62-bf78-4d5c-b217-a911716d42ce", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "70715c4f-7653-4992-9ecb-c1406b3da7e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d0585d04-1221-4d00-b8d6-78ce31be5074" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "871a8ec9-f276-4195-98dd-3f18b0f70b64", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b774373e-15fb-42f6-b2ba-0788937bee67" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "872e744c-e703-44c3-bc56-749ab321f08b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e44a0219-4ad9-4221-9dd4-42938da66523" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "875f57b2-8b9f-436d-b31a-08c5f423abb3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "684ae8ab-3dbe-4a38-b1a6-92666a2fea6e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e6af7ee6-18be-473e-910f-47917af3cf96" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "880023e0-48a1-4d64-b379-a1f8e81a5fd3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "888a7d30-80c4-4c4d-8e5a-f4cc0c185297", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0d319735-7e89-46d2-ba87-f78ab242cb41" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8948dc3d-398f-47b7-b545-64e73b63d360", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef23345e-bb9e-451e-bedb-3c69e526b44e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "89e569bc-5c5d-4c16-bec7-87860213da76", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "21afe581-2f0b-4171-9a93-bbccd4879acb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8a15fa5d-d596-4b7f-8706-d0bffc2aff0a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8a5e5ba7-22a0-4677-8656-9dbe8d6bd0fc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fc04c4e9-bad0-45c4-b778-18b21c44e1ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7a4151df-237d-4321-bd6b-951df01d5fba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "8aeda3fa-5be2-421d-880b-1ab2be9def7e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2c7d5be6-fc8d-4527-8a3f-9d82d5510e9a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "8afb5a40-96d5-45aa-80c9-d73031b8f663", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e44a0219-4ad9-4221-9dd4-42938da66523" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "8b0cde99-2a4e-451b-b940-cdbbafb6d773", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8b2f73ac-1b0c-4225-95f9-b31222fea606", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "edd48929-bde2-4c7d-b2c1-f8813de9f454" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8b504f80-908a-4f75-bf9a-c62d73f237f8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "41fe48fd-383b-4117-b9e6-c9ab8bbf9a5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "95701f3e-fc72-4650-af3a-d256fd283875" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8bf1eaa7-5687-4733-959b-22359ba16cde", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "965b3e00-8777-4c2d-8f9a-3df670141c95" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "8d3ff193-30b6-4f2b-a844-50aeabcf3b30", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8d4a7018-78d0-4bd9-b0de-fec26d4a52cf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "096fe03b-749d-455a-84f6-901aa41d1bbf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "8e0eaf31-ebc0-4785-8717-530288b9fc16", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "8edacb45-e4b1-4587-890d-1b40de06999f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "940b3e95-2a17-4c0e-a48e-a45b767bb07a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "8f06d552-2529-46aa-ae68-fa03fb53e9ba", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "8f32fb1a-c2cd-46f6-abe5-ed53047c6254", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1d43815f-4ffe-4400-bfa1-44e883d0ffe5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "8fa74188-48b1-4aeb-ac02-ad39817d1031", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "79d2d259-cd64-4371-8163-5209f81df67f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "95701f3e-fc72-4650-af3a-d256fd283875" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "901b7334-0004-41a4-a336-79bf637df700", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2191c8dc-d7e0-4d29-b4f8-0a64e2f2297b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "90cb19e2-50d6-4a9e-b41a-6a9f46c474a1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "992d03ee-aadb-45a6-8d18-48ba7d1dae3a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "90dd9f3e-ef35-45af-b6c7-434c965ea731", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a59d344e-855a-416b-9086-419c159fcafb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "90f8804e-55ee-441e-8369-238c9a389685", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "276c3a4e-6e04-45e1-84da-27668d5fb3dd" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "91159c07-5135-4542-ae81-084c0d61f77b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88530d93-d355-41cd-8fd0-5e7c929738b7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "914e8763-f49b-42ec-97f5-10d56b0e8c77", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b774373e-15fb-42f6-b2ba-0788937bee67" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32907b67-1e27-4a5b-987e-c0f7303f1041" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "91e5edd4-19c0-41ff-8b55-b99f447bacf9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4ab00691-79bd-4049-b028-f1872cb37aff" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "91efeff3-9a1e-4c59-8df7-b8a52f54a275", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "91f83d1c-523e-42bd-b592-54b6b29f176e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "93377575-2bca-48e3-9fb5-aa1bc8238f2b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c99aa09-a666-456d-a4d8-0139ee33e82a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b68ebf73-4d0b-4f5a-b422-27d40f1d8b26" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "934a84bc-54d4-4a52-bad8-e83207405080", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9d6826-e89f-4f7c-90a8-d5ebd54e972b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "936ae8f1-3b00-400c-8ca6-3176f8711a1f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "de005196-3cd4-43df-9d79-c366db8991d5" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "9385f624-d8a8-403f-bfe4-63d66cba2315", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f0e9896-21f7-49aa-a5d1-b848a95b3301" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8effcdf0-3303-4565-85f7-8e5dfa7b8607" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "93b937d3-5121-4d0b-86bd-97be36ad529f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b28bfe-eb96-4cd5-8670-b52298d679ca" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "943ec8ba-a933-4f7e-813e-e01435045f8f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1ea0d5e6-765f-4a5f-9244-8a9c190c3825" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "9470682a-1048-432d-8847-5eaf990d11d9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e5538d7-a86a-4d3c-a049-e7ea7afb294a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "949bedc0-4dd7-4ce3-b950-310348f237ae", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f2061db9-a203-4ac3-bcac-7f8dd977420c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "956307fd-2cd7-48de-9017-ae746374d10c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "9665eaea-944d-4bcc-ae5d-054f56969aec", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b70ec3f3-d89a-4151-98e7-83311efe5324" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f2f40857-d84a-4f06-ac82-99872c1b09e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "96fe0990-52e6-415d-b52b-3566c10ddaae", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b143239a-1309-4f0a-b67c-546b22497481" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "974d4633-f71e-458a-b20c-263ae07582e7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "97f11411-8a49-402b-8613-a2c924e10531", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fe91119-87ab-4ba8-98e8-25c4369c1c36" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74992a29-94d3-4468-9761-d1bd22c47322" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "98249c5b-4890-4de2-bfca-14a59e944c39", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4112e803-e272-45a1-a673-fd58c17f7d22" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "99454357-297d-4349-bed0-9bd83eefb3cf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "13ec68d4-4e7e-4327-bf76-1488f27e3743" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "994796e2-4c3c-4125-9579-718fee6c2b78", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9f99690c-e542-49e9-b635-73da68e1c34a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "99cd12bf-7f2b-40f4-83cd-4e06f3a65eb9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d57e230d-c4bf-459d-b509-c79e7e6e2bbf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "99cf12d7-7470-4c5b-8a03-00ac10f50166", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "99e7488f-72ad-44cd-b254-07cab8c0dfea", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da42d489-5081-441e-95a3-1021b7d7b341" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "9a66c1de-5bbe-456b-95b2-d1a6508e6e67", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8244d423-76cd-40c9-b09f-98362f7cd267" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1ea0d5e6-765f-4a5f-9244-8a9c190c3825" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "9aceba69-4b56-426f-8db8-86879bec04d4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "95701f3e-fc72-4650-af3a-d256fd283875" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f014c34e-b889-4609-a5ae-cd156f6fef80" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "9b514049-f79e-45db-ad18-6bc0bef94853", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "613e08c9-6e91-4286-9653-54654c27f9ed" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "9c0838a1-c21c-4e8f-9542-d9456e83faeb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8244d423-76cd-40c9-b09f-98362f7cd267" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "95701f3e-fc72-4650-af3a-d256fd283875" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "9c3cf559-7c7c-4c4d-97da-5e39381e6fc5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d0585d04-1221-4d00-b8d6-78ce31be5074" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "9c406700-33e1-4775-bbc8-0895af8f1cb4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c3f0c3d7-3358-4e68-90ac-dde65943ade0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "9c781b3d-eded-4529-90cc-aea4246540aa", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "96c9136c-7612-4cae-9b9a-c43640697659" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "9e18b2e1-f26c-4f49-bc7e-4f21feaf8354", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "449b5067-d769-494f-9d0f-d89660a59dd6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "884d7a21-8b9e-482f-b416-fff0b37dc69d" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "9e33a413-e14b-46fc-ba68-5d5cd422f3a4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "324085e6-9540-4233-83a5-a893e356fe72" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "9e439c44-780c-4191-b854-64de47f2e270", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3b6561b-fc04-4743-aff1-4ea909eb7f48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "9eb581cd-43fa-445a-ad5e-177d6678092c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "eafe6c9d-5f51-4a00-b14f-448626621cb1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "9eba8e1b-a73c-4913-89d7-a2b482eae888", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32907b67-1e27-4a5b-987e-c0f7303f1041" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "9ef07f9c-b7f8-424e-8682-7f702b0eeb75", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c99aa09-a666-456d-a4d8-0139ee33e82a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2d0a1476-404e-4569-83e3-d2aa0efeadd4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "9f40bb8d-3706-4285-a438-fd182278d6ef", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "965b3e00-8777-4c2d-8f9a-3df670141c95" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "a045c6b9-ecd5-4088-bd69-74d6505e9daa", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a08065cc-e8d9-4e31-8f45-790f3ee1790b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1a13e081-fcde-492f-ab6a-ab5e380b91af" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "a0cebd45-39b4-4c6c-b602-dea777c6c3f8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "84af919e-9e37-4851-8a3d-a06f3c60999c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "a17fcdad-60cc-4772-b75f-2c039b4d8fb4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "96c9136c-7612-4cae-9b9a-c43640697659" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "a19b8e08-deea-4f1f-98f5-9421199bea1d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef23345e-bb9e-451e-bedb-3c69e526b44e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a2042596-eba9-4bfb-94bf-6d9c13ca67c5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "95701f3e-fc72-4650-af3a-d256fd283875" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a22c3ead-326e-4947-90c0-ec504fe16397", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b143239a-1309-4f0a-b67c-546b22497481" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "a2530b5f-5b05-4927-854d-f1d94080ed0a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a36a2615-870f-4784-8592-cf95af41728e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c812a1ef-102d-4c30-8ceb-a31730de5074" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "a3ee3a09-f13e-47a9-b446-c1e29291f226", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b684c1-914c-4108-aa54-a40944e9f565" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a3f83bb7-5628-4846-8e56-19a963e862ad", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "04464e2f-71eb-4abc-8240-285af4cc4f05" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e63a500a-ae5e-493b-a8cc-66bda2c566c0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "a42e1eca-2345-4ad1-8d43-164e88b75c67", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c17839c3-0f58-46e3-8bc7-0cd193dd8f06" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "a546d896-e0a9-46d7-a2c4-95152a701580", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dad3bdd6-f121-4e52-a0da-221467815455" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "a60df2a3-ac63-4811-b3b0-13fc9345a3e6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8e2df6ba-4ceb-4063-a168-bc9ebbf6ad02" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "a6620d7b-5f6f-4a01-b5d6-d53c9cf0c1e4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aa4d0880-7378-426d-a66b-82215aafd407" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a7c20642-2ebc-4a2b-bbcf-24fa8db5d061", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a56b45a9-fd36-45ee-8484-b80ffea67446" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "a7c887d7-0b92-4569-8747-daba835472b8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5cf85c8-afd8-4ddb-8945-85cda662625b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b684c1-914c-4108-aa54-a40944e9f565" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8045372-a45c-4a59-9907-bb44fe713dfe", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8e2df6ba-4ceb-4063-a168-bc9ebbf6ad02" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef4a77be-faf3-40be-be53-61704a2894e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "a87ce608-aa94-4b43-83c8-b33a3b8a7196", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8804349-e4a6-408a-92a7-e9f453d477cc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5479add5-2688-41a8-a49c-1a336d1dfa3b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "a91cfb78-cd45-4d3e-a9e9-d2e7f787ba71", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c812a1ef-102d-4c30-8ceb-a31730de5074" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a41d48dc-1906-4a3f-8abf-25c3cf3d10f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "aa9ee626-162c-4318-86ae-61fd4b3a0122", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32907b67-1e27-4a5b-987e-c0f7303f1041" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "aadc4430-f40e-452d-9c10-3119e9358eb6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a59d344e-855a-416b-9086-419c159fcafb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ab3244f9-afe7-4dcd-b2ed-b564e0339cff", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a9fad21-af65-4b06-a043-c3b9c1b462f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "abc83c62-a1c9-4730-bc19-aabf4a3385e5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "228a2225-fb50-4f4d-a202-1ece0e67f42a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bfcefb45-2d7c-4032-94dd-6a255c749ddb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "ac48f9b6-0070-4be4-99c1-abe3c0693552", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e6af7ee6-18be-473e-910f-47917af3cf96" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ac4ca011-5890-4794-83d1-a592c4ab2a23", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ac911679-1f4e-4429-9f76-d9eb97be72c4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f7eb36e5-eb3f-40ac-9711-a883e2482968" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad1fb73c-cf17-46f8-bdd7-0b9b2ffc7a48", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74560b06-2493-4972-8a46-c9c740bb3caa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad3b39e6-8ef0-445f-9a75-b9a934fd1d39", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6cccd2c9-c15b-4027-ae6a-9bb421a66388" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "228a2225-fb50-4f4d-a202-1ece0e67f42a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad4a4cf8-6ca5-45f4-8718-8666ed3502e8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a7cd8811-64f2-44d6-ba86-59a08ebda2bf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7a4151df-237d-4321-bd6b-951df01d5fba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad9d40de-2ec2-45da-b094-96d544657dba", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d0585d04-1221-4d00-b8d6-78ce31be5074" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ae1011ec-c863-45ed-879e-e3a9773a9c5a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "449b5067-d769-494f-9d0f-d89660a59dd6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "af16c79d-fac1-4864-85f6-94fd2c9f6fab", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef23345e-bb9e-451e-bedb-3c69e526b44e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "af2a2925-f66b-4c9f-948c-b2449532cae8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6909c595-06ac-4c43-a7a4-71a178d91223" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "af59a59d-202d-42ea-b686-dd7fdd60c3d9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "14c88d83-dcac-4801-b8da-41fc130e763b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "afe770c6-2ab8-487e-8a42-4e3e48c44c05", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4112e803-e272-45a1-a673-fd58c17f7d22" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b0108067-f288-4604-ab3e-347c4df15ee4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "16d6dd3d-c3cd-454e-baf0-4c3e12c522e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a7cd8811-64f2-44d6-ba86-59a08ebda2bf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "b071e7ff-31f2-475d-ad06-35ec8222a494", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "80011e24-30cb-413b-b4d6-e04e5a1d63b7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2da431dc-66e0-49d4-9d85-ebb2190e6ebb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b12de062-4156-40d9-973a-1833fc5df8ac", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d60948e4-2cb2-4fcb-ba1d-7fc2805337aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b1565779-f400-4a93-a750-6cb3148a24ec", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b1f49d50-d8ba-4de3-8a19-55c34e3eca9a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b21cc610-5af1-403c-817e-57477269ae02", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b774373e-15fb-42f6-b2ba-0788937bee67" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "b2627a4a-8b45-4fde-8264-83e3ec10bdfe", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6a2accb-efd2-41de-a039-a21d3b0c9c93" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b28e7928-1f58-4409-a645-7848134bf412", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9f99690c-e542-49e9-b635-73da68e1c34a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b39f42ba-1f4b-4d91-983f-a9767bddb4f2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "47786d94-8002-40e5-b7a2-e3780fbfadeb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b9676c28-7093-4d9d-b087-ab9e8510715f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b3d5d3ae-7276-48f2-88a1-a5dde75c4659", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8effcdf0-3303-4565-85f7-8e5dfa7b8607" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b42f7b86-7f21-46ea-8b50-f40100f47431", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f84d555-fc02-48ca-bc6c-2831bd9bed97" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b5374dc3-57db-4f81-b181-b6a24c0dc6b4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9cdf6c1-2bd1-4265-825b-c184651d637e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b5517024-7ec8-457c-b003-217a67bc75da", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83a93151-f2a1-4bcb-9464-d0d09b3910ba" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b58bf4d4-4147-4c02-8def-1f2eb443e8be", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9d6826-e89f-4f7c-90a8-d5ebd54e972b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "16d6dd3d-c3cd-454e-baf0-4c3e12c522e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "b5c4634f-34cb-4a8b-a51c-2714ddc515ef", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "df2b015c-c2aa-46af-9890-ff62cd83fdc7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "b5d28f9e-2b28-4445-b29e-ff58f839734f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3b944c6b-55c0-448e-9991-8baf5e862927" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e63a500a-ae5e-493b-a8cc-66bda2c566c0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b61a68f0-02e8-4b31-96d3-451ece1b39bb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b6523884-9229-4671-945b-af86225d17d2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b6dc5703-d199-44d2-8247-36bfeed2b9c7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a4343ad4-efc4-4205-a647-9916905ac12e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "b7841f35-8b8f-4aeb-b7b7-1cff0be3e617", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c6c5435d-5ec2-447e-b490-ba09650ff0fd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b7897a55-0567-4730-b9e5-87d131e6a23a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3c52126b-a3a9-4647-b88a-f648ba035446" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b7da9529-3fe4-4ee8-8ea2-b41a8d83ed39", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5b395891-7882-48fd-a7a5-7cf14c8a2767" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b80aa307-2a52-4689-8acd-54e0906338ec", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b823001e-aec4-44a6-b8df-737d8405da29", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6a2accb-efd2-41de-a039-a21d3b0c9c93" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "b9ebf927-11f0-41e4-bc48-d45269b3bb5e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3941d9fe-5b7f-49ef-bb52-2df00e6ce4fb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b774373e-15fb-42f6-b2ba-0788937bee67" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "ba07dcbf-cf67-4435-8adc-1da88e315c9f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a6203019-d360-4a29-a040-b905d890093c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "ba2f2680-2c2b-4ba0-ab2a-10eec10c1239", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "21afe581-2f0b-4171-9a93-bbccd4879acb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7199fc6b-6cb4-4494-b0af-0468f2e11560" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "ba62fbb0-b971-4dc2-a28c-c0001dce9085", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0bd4f434-a6fe-43e4-9e3e-7fd2da8c81af" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "bb31bfdc-84b9-4a5a-a6cd-10d77c85272f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "bbb81e54-2226-4009-b9fe-d9b4eff072ff", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d7439d95-3599-4f27-864d-6c755034eaf2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "940b3e95-2a17-4c0e-a48e-a45b767bb07a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "bbe707b1-dcc1-4357-9169-5ab180f9ba54", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d57e230d-c4bf-459d-b509-c79e7e6e2bbf" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2191c8dc-d7e0-4d29-b4f8-0a64e2f2297b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "bc49596c-5b87-4d25-b6c4-a3ad75a1d180", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a4343ad4-efc4-4205-a647-9916905ac12e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "324085e6-9540-4233-83a5-a893e356fe72" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "bd2be6b8-4d80-428d-8888-9c60e360dcb7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5479add5-2688-41a8-a49c-1a336d1dfa3b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "bd4bfc18-40b5-49b8-8fc3-9a37d4da3be4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1a13e081-fcde-492f-ab6a-ab5e380b91af" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "96c9136c-7612-4cae-9b9a-c43640697659" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "bd835eaa-cb62-427c-886e-9ff57f7d8f88", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fb7b86eb-22fe-4871-96a7-b281f112367d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a9fad21-af65-4b06-a043-c3b9c1b462f2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "be8ad580-d49b-4d13-bc6a-2f5283e3c2d1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "833e6368-46e9-4659-8c4e-3233fbb876a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2191c8dc-d7e0-4d29-b4f8-0a64e2f2297b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "be97b78b-271c-4035-80a9-b4e1cbc886b5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "bed4eff4-e1ee-40f4-a4ba-9d3cea324d0b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c17839c3-0f58-46e3-8bc7-0cd193dd8f06" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f014c34e-b889-4609-a5ae-cd156f6fef80" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "bf282e6c-4ac1-4872-b0f0-a36859962a05", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "834744d9-dcae-4306-b33d-0a9634ccd588" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "bf88dc74-c6de-42e5-a35c-1c030275c11a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c633f358-4531-4b0a-8067-6a9f771747b3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "bf9f2194-54f6-41c6-8a22-1af0e44e9552", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "51551fde-9432-4152-a688-afcfb9e32b8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f355f471-b989-4b99-9abf-861f334315fc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c0729a2a-0d52-4607-8933-4d8aadb39448", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3941d9fe-5b7f-49ef-bb52-2df00e6ce4fb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c0782132-fcf1-4b22-9fa9-cd10bf5cbc39", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88530d93-d355-41cd-8fd0-5e7c929738b7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c0c2539e-a4f8-4cbf-86a1-6767fd82b999", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07b92395-5c07-4634-81de-61c1ca22b9e9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d57e230d-c4bf-459d-b509-c79e7e6e2bbf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c115fd27-7fa9-4ec4-8a7c-7f2afd649279", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "236669cb-46bb-4411-90c0-548e10b4b121" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c11a3c01-1ceb-4b9c-bccd-82fd40b7bd70", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5fac516c-9862-4f6d-9e93-b9ddcbc19df6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c15b83b8-235d-4147-962c-48e7046748d4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6f860b03-f862-40ea-bb59-99a44e8c3f51" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c201a1b2-5e7d-4695-84d7-c9b3afae1714", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c2ab98a1-3888-4d61-83e3-e5a05d380efa", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "91583e14-811b-4a2d-ba91-021985f7e9dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4584a697-7fe0-4922-aa90-8e525468d99f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "c30e1c5a-7c87-4aeb-a32b-707d791f06aa", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3c52126b-a3a9-4647-b88a-f648ba035446" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3423b02-781f-438c-96db-efe0f6704511" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c319861f-62f4-4b84-8fef-c7b44aff50bf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "837aabe8-6eaf-4b5e-80ba-0cab5f0be894" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c364a30a-e878-4ce0-8970-37c10b290b0c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ebf6a7a7-6c9b-4468-9c67-bf84ac07340b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c378d259-4194-48f3-be0c-eef7d2679c30", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a6309f59-39a3-43da-8f0b-4a8afd6a7f6d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4584a697-7fe0-4922-aa90-8e525468d99f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c4adf6d2-ec40-4371-b19e-241129f15132", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a755f5c-94b6-43ac-a5c7-467103efa17b" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c4d30c28-ac76-4f66-ba7a-4543912c659e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "63d85aeb-cbec-4045-9500-b6778cdf33a3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a59d344e-855a-416b-9086-419c159fcafb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c51bfce6-8a9e-418f-b5cf-60afe6eef02c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed245c0f-7379-4ba5-8d7a-cbc02b0feba0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c593af3b-9979-4c14-b83b-c9345881fd74", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0ebffe5d-1b39-48a5-ad29-bed7b232b46e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5cf85c8-afd8-4ddb-8945-85cda662625b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c5a88293-f5bc-43b9-857c-71f3b6cf5c11", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "471bbbd8-b8ad-4eca-8abb-f4d35b0bb927" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c5f29f23-cae8-4e89-a3dc-dbd2f6e0098d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "de005196-3cd4-43df-9d79-c366db8991d5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c60a0250-d1b7-471d-8b86-fa38a639e13b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e07e924c-2da9-4c78-9303-4faab90cfa84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c690e1f0-2d22-4cf7-80df-bd3cddb42679", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "64b876cd-5aa4-46da-ab92-f82971ca9869" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c6b56e47-b64a-459f-977c-311406abcb43", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d0585d04-1221-4d00-b8d6-78ce31be5074" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c6db586b-b150-4fde-83d5-ae4351da8394", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b9676c28-7093-4d9d-b087-ab9e8510715f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7486b01-f184-4966-8fbe-0257e76f1037", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dc2d3bcd-b447-45bb-8624-b075030ad1dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5479add5-2688-41a8-a49c-1a336d1dfa3b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c78c83ef-8909-4486-bc55-e1c5e04da2ca", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6b40dd8f-190f-4567-bd29-b2ffe8a51e9d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8e2df6ba-4ceb-4063-a168-bc9ebbf6ad02" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7aa1bb2-3e7a-468f-8667-82f33415c18d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7428e9dd-66a7-4aaf-a6a2-76d55b96cd9e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7eeefdc-36dd-4015-a16e-56394afad517", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7f18542-3c15-408f-98e5-9ceb18a4a8b2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d8ea7ec4-0892-42af-b03b-630540619336" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c8374a45-2eee-4884-9cc7-da8038e95ca0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "884d7a21-8b9e-482f-b416-fff0b37dc69d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c9019ab8-6548-47df-881d-c2d4e7ab0de1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dbb68b83-ad5c-482d-b3eb-3f9adfa3797e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "63d85aeb-cbec-4045-9500-b6778cdf33a3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c92785e6-9012-44c3-a5af-06f93d65f036", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b68ebf73-4d0b-4f5a-b422-27d40f1d8b26" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "c9291637-150e-4300-bc82-6788792f7005", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c99aa09-a666-456d-a4d8-0139ee33e82a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "c93d3969-0ec9-4251-8d6d-cd8299e84966", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1b6eba79-a3c4-43e5-80dc-611fb0556b90" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f014c34e-b889-4609-a5ae-cd156f6fef80" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "c96742e5-a94e-4d20-b20a-e308fd566945", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "613e08c9-6e91-4286-9653-54654c27f9ed" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c97188a4-a2bc-480a-b9b7-18925f5b7568", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "922caeac-3d2b-4dc4-a12b-a6280146f7bb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "c9d75749-3a0d-4fc2-8eef-4e0a9ca0eda5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ca1a23d1-ca6e-4290-b919-1d018df15868", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0f801063-4dc8-4b90-adb3-e571927fe0a0" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ca46bc40-e43c-48e7-a167-a2560185965e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "cb374f7d-a61f-4e8b-a89d-41ccdddea2cf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b684c1-914c-4108-aa54-a40944e9f565" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "cba4764e-6769-44d8-9b2f-3749b88a7fa9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a56b45a9-fd36-45ee-8484-b80ffea67446" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c812a1ef-102d-4c30-8ceb-a31730de5074" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "cbbc4f9a-59e1-4087-91a6-0a4350bebb07", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f84d555-fc02-48ca-bc6c-2831bd9bed97" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4ab00691-79bd-4049-b028-f1872cb37aff" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "cbc7cb51-0173-4020-b238-115e9c6731ed", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "475953d9-2ccf-43e3-a004-780d584ad5e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "cbc89ca5-bd40-4ff8-92a1-d0f916aa0e6b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a23f84f0-5eb2-46be-909e-0dcf1577c6f1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "144b6e37-2a16-4947-b715-3f9b616072b2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "cc8a42cc-078b-4407-8828-bd314e3f68a4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "99d84601-f5ff-4f31-b5ec-e03ee731d14b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9d6826-e89f-4f7c-90a8-d5ebd54e972b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "cc945c16-5a33-4c59-86dd-4a52950ec533", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3a9fad21-af65-4b06-a043-c3b9c1b462f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "844382fc-2fe9-4cff-89be-90b55d4e4be2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "cc982fbd-dada-4cdc-876c-62ae76fd8f5c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "cd185193-1350-41ad-90ec-56af263f8eb4", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f2e5456-aec6-48fc-a6de-3c644e4ec921" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e6af7ee6-18be-473e-910f-47917af3cf96" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "cd187cd3-0dfd-4646-ab88-5bfa52f7228d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da0e348f-6b31-4eac-ad4b-bd4423bfd7a4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "144b6e37-2a16-4947-b715-3f9b616072b2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "cdda9aa2-c036-47e3-b84c-5b54dd3f1936", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d4e02902-7c00-48c8-8ff8-9b5a5fe32557" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "cdfe0f79-9b1c-4d97-9dce-42aee8e412e6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3c52126b-a3a9-4647-b88a-f648ba035446" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "cf3420cd-f7dc-4e77-bda9-f542303dec63", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "cf418353-d2cc-40e0-8b18-3e6a43d1360c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "79d2d259-cd64-4371-8163-5209f81df67f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "cfc79745-b68b-4f12-86d6-13cd7d8135b7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2c867547-6b80-4e4f-9b15-7593a7a0cfe5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "eafe6c9d-5f51-4a00-b14f-448626621cb1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d05348c8-f1c5-4e1a-b2d2-7247fde612ea", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "965b3e00-8777-4c2d-8f9a-3df670141c95" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d07c60d2-d253-47ee-b410-02e8ad2abc9d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d0b68eee-2718-4af9-a07c-02b84f4a096b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef4a77be-faf3-40be-be53-61704a2894e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d0bb8a3f-ee3b-4af0-83b1-f2faefe2e5c9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c78d3dd-665f-4290-b565-ea8a67464ad8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "d0fdbcb5-bd48-4c62-8552-af5a133b1d0c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1ca241ce-a52c-4e7e-8e91-a61f8087fb06" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d9b40f9f-4124-4dba-a5a7-d17ad59db135" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d1020b49-1708-40e6-a96f-b55667558e67", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f80f75b5-f8a6-4110-b181-5f65430493ac" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "d226faff-5f00-443d-b3c8-a644a3eb659c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c4ed6841-d780-4112-86c7-9f0c3f567484" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5bada80b-11d5-4828-9388-db44fff8342e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d3150b76-f7fd-4a5b-924d-1a7f0ce49c0a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "16d6dd3d-c3cd-454e-baf0-4c3e12c522e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d321a50e-4661-4615-9cdb-a65860117833", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b104a0b3-14f1-4493-989e-eacc06ad901e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b774373e-15fb-42f6-b2ba-0788937bee67" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d35a6c92-20f7-45e6-8fcb-7ecef1d935ec", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ae3615df-33cd-4252-95aa-d4a0549753b3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a0fb3bbd-ef15-4691-8c94-6992861d75cd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d3f4159f-4fe5-452b-bc04-7ab689b761af", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48b2bf3a-33e5-4c54-b635-c10855d24297" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fc05ce2-c8f6-40fe-92fb-95d4b1922e16" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "d40a972f-ad8f-4a69-bacf-0d946f23d845", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d4b63db8-eac7-46b4-8c05-2912ec8c814d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d0585d04-1221-4d00-b8d6-78ce31be5074" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f014c34e-b889-4609-a5ae-cd156f6fef80" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "d4c6ea4c-b1e8-45f2-82e7-28d395e10cc9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "37329a18-2e35-4642-871f-c2d4ee8564d0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d4e7dce1-2cc7-448f-af6d-b704d073d34f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2191c8dc-d7e0-4d29-b4f8-0a64e2f2297b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "47737c3e-9678-463f-80b5-d396ee17342d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d4e9ff76-2bb0-4eff-87d7-963ca41ff22d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da0e348f-6b31-4eac-ad4b-bd4423bfd7a4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d4f5ecc5-8220-4d30-979e-76dc961f00c3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d51a2eb0-bc2a-497a-b91a-7743aa079fd8", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83a93151-f2a1-4bcb-9464-d0d09b3910ba" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "236669cb-46bb-4411-90c0-548e10b4b121" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d51b3316-386a-404b-a2b4-f31f4288fd89", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da42d489-5081-441e-95a3-1021b7d7b341" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "d639ac9d-5aef-4479-a0a6-2f2b847a11bf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "68ce467e-1d6c-4b22-b61e-019875f50725" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d7983d03-b65f-409a-8ae7-4f41fe7d1019", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "833e6368-46e9-4659-8c4e-3233fbb876a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "d7b66ffb-160a-40a0-92ae-0b91b3bc36ed", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c15e5864-a302-4bb1-bae7-f1faf3ea4793" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4584a697-7fe0-4922-aa90-8e525468d99f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d7fb4b2c-948a-4d76-ad49-4fb4e0547da5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7a4151df-237d-4321-bd6b-951df01d5fba" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cc2a3f36-c70a-45e7-b496-fb1981f1a7f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "d80aad99-c2c5-4581-b60e-c3b4825582bf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "11c0eb0e-b92b-413f-91aa-c93ac214871d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f2e5456-aec6-48fc-a6de-3c644e4ec921" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "d8227b3a-cf0e-43a0-ace9-4e547e042f98", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "df2b015c-c2aa-46af-9890-ff62cd83fdc7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d84bef20-6871-4a05-9445-7d2395ee4271", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "999ef140-f4e1-4d00-8e53-c09ae6d1598e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d935e07d-768b-416a-b3d2-fddeda28a05d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "91583e14-811b-4a2d-ba91-021985f7e9dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "d9fb2950-ad7c-434d-9045-c884ac87575e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b143239a-1309-4f0a-b67c-546b22497481" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3b6561b-fc04-4743-aff1-4ea909eb7f48" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "da6faeae-9683-433a-8532-93a1c6daeca7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "dae19074-8145-4e6a-8d72-dcdfef95fd79", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e5538d7-a86a-4d3c-a049-e7ea7afb294a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ebf6a7a7-6c9b-4468-9c67-bf84ac07340b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "dbf25c64-8f14-4f90-8bbb-faecc442385c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4c7d8fab-1ddc-4a74-9836-4cdc9aeb6bbd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "dc58a7c3-6591-432a-8741-0cdf43d0971a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5fac516c-9862-4f6d-9e93-b9ddcbc19df6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "dc5fe770-8fda-4b6b-82ab-38e6d0be2485", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b9676c28-7093-4d9d-b087-ab9e8510715f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "dd0a673c-d4b4-4f48-92fc-ce0ee5d9deb3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "69197260-c0ba-43cf-9b24-5a981b87b4b3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ddae7f57-aa1c-4aaf-a5a1-02fbd5c5fb73", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "02280e8a-fd93-4678-92ec-9280fd24d25a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6a2accb-efd2-41de-a039-a21d3b0c9c93" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "ddb67e4a-b3ae-47a9-b9f6-ab10282b2aac", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dad3bdd6-f121-4e52-a0da-221467815455" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "ddddd3cb-07b3-40a8-bf2a-c6333e0aa56f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5bada80b-11d5-4828-9388-db44fff8342e" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "de5dafd1-f013-4b6e-8be3-54593a3c3401", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2d0a1476-404e-4569-83e3-d2aa0efeadd4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "de7c7df5-6c83-49d3-beed-71c5ef8a16fc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d8ea7ec4-0892-42af-b03b-630540619336" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "de94b2bd-38cc-4973-9e60-32f00c7d4aa5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "df100ebf-6c67-4b59-b23b-e7b8b160144c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6cccd2c9-c15b-4027-ae6a-9bb421a66388" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "df31c567-08e2-4bf9-8397-baac16735e32", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c15e5864-a302-4bb1-bae7-f1faf3ea4793" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf549ad5-9129-414c-9d8b-334ada0653e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "df489f85-d1ed-4009-801c-16ba3e8bbcdf", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "613e08c9-6e91-4286-9653-54654c27f9ed" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8244d423-76cd-40c9-b09f-98362f7cd267" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e0cfcb6b-2432-4e6f-893a-046aac511755", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d3b6561b-fc04-4743-aff1-4ea909eb7f48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e114f893-f819-4682-9db1-78c7aa752d8f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e131bd4e-5426-40d9-b077-cb10bd6335c0", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "74992a29-94d3-4468-9761-d1bd22c47322" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e27743de-7576-4279-a8a8-1e2311f45688", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e2e4b33f-2511-4f77-8369-db57d274ae6a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ebf6a7a7-6c9b-4468-9c67-bf84ac07340b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "95701f3e-fc72-4650-af3a-d256fd283875" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e2f1ad76-915d-45b5-a3d0-582bd73cdd0e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0b6835ea-d50b-4e18-8979-f3398eee9a7f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "e3266623-0fd4-4c6c-945b-c2c97d0263c7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7025bd9b-1715-43d1-9274-500f0d0cd088" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fc05ce2-c8f6-40fe-92fb-95d4b1922e16" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e3788573-cb75-4aa3-a213-ed3e96bfe2c7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b104a0b3-14f1-4493-989e-eacc06ad901e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "e39c0bc5-cbb8-49a2-a293-de3c9c202990", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "da42d489-5081-441e-95a3-1021b7d7b341" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3253fc62-9dee-420b-b306-0df9a527443b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e3e4637f-a254-4475-8c33-08fa0085e79f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aae3cae7-3e97-403a-a2bd-bd9d97aaf147" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e44d317c-2f9f-4015-abb7-b119f1665c12", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "324085e6-9540-4233-83a5-a893e356fe72" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e4d4b9e2-3e79-429c-8d1d-0e9ae9015948", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8e38f19-3765-49d6-9d3d-5a568fe21b0a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e6b0957d-6aa9-45a8-957a-0fa630d52030", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e75d3390-289e-4c64-8dd9-37715e714e38", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "399b050e-da20-4dbd-9dbc-8c4f7d16338b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7428e9dd-66a7-4aaf-a6a2-76d55b96cd9e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "e769c433-7eb5-44e9-92c5-23404e1da66f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e819fdd5-da1d-4b7f-80db-bbb575111e9c", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ebf6a7a7-6c9b-4468-9c67-bf84ac07340b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e8278245-cc88-40b8-9e04-c5d6635071e3", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "236669cb-46bb-4411-90c0-548e10b4b121" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e885c474-4714-4f30-bf83-694a44274714", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "61db5e85-20c7-4395-9df8-f5c27445f56c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "e8de5044-9a5c-448f-ab02-9606fdc94338", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "41fe48fd-383b-4117-b9e6-c9ab8bbf9a5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e93064cf-c785-4d41-a34b-5378046daecb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e5168649-a197-4ecb-9628-32012569cd58" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "e9d5a932-d75a-4aad-b8d0-2fb8ba75a243", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f15ff085-f0da-4028-a182-1219995321bd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ef4a77be-faf3-40be-be53-61704a2894e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "e9df5ce6-f523-4358-90d2-f96f7f7bb0dc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "e9f13f61-22b7-40e2-a814-506cbc62dc62", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb067b8c-c66a-4c9b-9d57-cba60510e5e2", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "22cf44b0-1336-4ba2-96b8-6f7d6ebef354" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a5cf85c8-afd8-4ddb-8945-85cda662625b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb2ca74f-14b3-44e7-961d-85ac64590e6e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "eb5ddaf1-6011-412a-b68c-5516a3a71964", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "96c26b59-4762-4d9e-a25e-fc412b877be1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "ec053e45-d7cb-4531-9bc8-b9926ac3564f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c78d3dd-665f-4290-b565-ea8a67464ad8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f355f471-b989-4b99-9abf-861f334315fc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "ec27fbc1-9fd8-4bb0-8171-dbc474532adc", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ec66448a-e50d-4946-b06b-f971ac159deb", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "69197260-c0ba-43cf-9b24-5a981b87b4b3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ed09f393-9add-4790-b190-3d149752371e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32907b67-1e27-4a5b-987e-c0f7303f1041" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ed42718c-9abe-4215-9076-51f78c408157", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "eda47a8d-7c86-4049-a8b8-17acf241c7ea", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "051ba471-e838-459e-8cf4-50451df068ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "ee1f8fbc-aac5-46c1-9cb3-cd8d29ace835", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6006dc8-8e31-4741-9549-c4e480fd1687" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "efaf0829-fd8d-4ec2-b046-ae6f71885671", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "32b3b4e1-7603-463a-9a69-1a48a6f7f3d7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "efe837fb-f52c-4860-bbc2-d9c0c8a79cfe", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c3f0c3d7-3358-4e68-90ac-dde65943ade0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "eff54ae9-017b-4f00-bac6-1a338554435b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "502805ad-82e7-44ed-afe6-13abc89aa7b8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "f05a8808-9586-4b9e-aad0-215b95cddfd5", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a17616a3-b642-4972-b1c7-af84ff7085ef" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f098a998-f6d1-4854-ab39-7b5af82b037b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1abeaae6-348c-4d5f-8117-157be556de20" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "f0b244fc-9570-4122-aa8d-fc1ab82d64ff", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d30fd255-e758-488e-9728-f2c279cce272" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "f1479f10-240b-432f-b56b-f3640bac560a", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "999ef140-f4e1-4d00-8e53-c09ae6d1598e" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f1765e0f-8f5c-4518-8d35-23f17b0a57c7", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3253fc62-9dee-420b-b306-0df9a527443b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f17b395b-acda-4cb3-8a59-180df77cd51d", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f1c15a08-2b8c-44b3-a3c4-1109854ed7f1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "22508d7e-47ac-4dc1-861a-3d311bc6b4d4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "f258da92-ece5-447d-ac75-9ece348dbbbe", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "76b59fb9-8e95-4a4c-b8b3-fb4069bfcc71" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "91583e14-811b-4a2d-ba91-021985f7e9dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "f25a9343-3dd8-427e-93db-242903639417", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "276c3a4e-6e04-45e1-84da-27668d5fb3dd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f25cfceb-a771-46e4-9951-e36ea2941b25", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9d580e32-031b-47b3-a2bf-dad5ca4374ce" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "df2b015c-c2aa-46af-9890-ff62cd83fdc7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "f2768b22-c275-4eb8-839f-39eb2c9c4471", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "051ba471-e838-459e-8cf4-50451df068ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "f4664ee8-b0d1-4504-aea0-2bc106eed94f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "834744d9-dcae-4306-b33d-0a9634ccd588" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "f4d174e8-defd-452c-a51b-b2501da0fc78", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c17839c3-0f58-46e3-8bc7-0cd193dd8f06" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f558f82b-f2d1-4048-9cd4-d83fcfd2fa85", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "433e0018-8c1f-4ae8-a6bf-ad37779a8709" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "f628ab5d-447c-4dec-99f3-748f44efe318", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7199fc6b-6cb4-4494-b0af-0468f2e11560" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f63e7d0f-6dff-4037-a5ba-28fc1a7ddf70", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0b6835ea-d50b-4e18-8979-f3398eee9a7f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f670a7ad-aa29-4e9f-9069-90e9481457e6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "aae3cae7-3e97-403a-a2bd-bd9d97aaf147" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "f6f4fceb-6fc8-469e-adbd-9aaecf37c40b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "2fe91119-87ab-4ba8-98e8-25c4369c1c36" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "87b28bfe-eb96-4cd5-8670-b52298d679ca" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "f77615e1-97f7-4443-96c3-0d8ef727e1df", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "ed090d75-5c98-4171-8853-469fc8efebf3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "9d580e32-031b-47b3-a2bf-dad5ca4374ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "f784f206-ff64-4680-9ffa-07f71e00ec9b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "5c086588-756a-43dc-928b-a6e715b992c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b6a2accb-efd2-41de-a039-a21d3b0c9c93" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "f7e8bc4d-0fec-4955-a5cf-74925be7e7fa", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "837aabe8-6eaf-4b5e-80ba-0cab5f0be894" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f835c82d-bb53-4749-afaa-eea6cbd2c266", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a8ff0ff7-9080-4195-80c2-14930fc976fa" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1ea0d5e6-765f-4a5f-9244-8a9c190c3825" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z" + }, + { + "id": "f856852b-1c8e-4673-aa96-aa4a286394f1", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "a6309f59-39a3-43da-8f0b-4a8afd6a7f6d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf549ad5-9129-414c-9d8b-334ada0653e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "f98b587f-ce7a-4b7b-a869-363472b9b33f", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bc7b99b9-6c05-4f2c-870c-b52165c11a70" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "f9c5ac0a-f89e-4142-ae6f-7508bc53ddab", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6" + }, + "type": "consequence", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "fb1cb961-b321-4d1f-8837-6a870edcd87e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "07b92395-5c07-4634-81de-61c1ca22b9e9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "fb34648e-cd01-4c5d-84d9-b67149ee20f6", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "fc9a5c87-5048-4465-aaae-be55c9a0eb96", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "fd340042-e7c8-4c07-ba51-3a0b8b7475c9", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "dc2d3bcd-b447-45bb-8624-b075030ad1dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "84af919e-9e37-4851-8a3d-a06f3c60999c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "fdd0813e-4965-448e-a132-ce86da5ec19b", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "b68ebf73-4d0b-4f5a-b422-27d40f1d8b26" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "fe391369-65a2-4a27-950e-9e8059458414", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e63a500a-ae5e-493b-a8cc-66bda2c566c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "fe430d18-1814-4ec0-9b5e-8e4c27cf4147", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "c4ed6841-d780-4112-86c7-9f0c3f567484" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z" + }, + { + "id": "feca3b93-bb11-47dd-ae69-f97ebbb48f92", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z" + }, + { + "id": "ff4a164a-ccdd-4782-8ddb-2b8b6f410aad", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "79d2d259-cd64-4371-8163-5209f81df67f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + }, + { + "id": "ff6c50df-5637-480a-a20c-f45387739f6e", + "source": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "96c9136c-7612-4cae-9b9a-c43640697659" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "nodeId": "e6af7ee6-18be-473e-910f-47917af3cf96" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z" + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/nodes.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/nodes.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d78594aae --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/explorer-ui/nodes.json @@ -0,0 +1,5671 @@ +[ + { + "id": "0008b2ae-c319-446d-af24-71752a514d13", + "displayId": "A4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: A fully tabbed layout where Micro View, Macro View, and Search are separate browser-tab-style panes with no persistent split panels, detail opens as a modal overlay.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "02280e8a-fd93-4678-92ec-9280fd24d25a", + "displayId": "CR23", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A CSS scanline overlay must be present in the DOM as a pseudo-element or overlay div positioned above the WebGL canvas at all times. Its computed style must include pointer-events: none so that mouse and touch events pass through to the canvas beneath. The overlay must be visible as a subtle horizontal stripe pattern when inspected visually against a bright node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "04464e2f-71eb-4abc-8240-285af4cc4f05", + "displayId": "CR26", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation must execute in a Web Worker, not on the main UI thread. Verified by: opening browser DevTools performance timeline during artifact load, confirming that the layout computation task appears on a Worker thread and not on the Main thread. The main thread must remain responsive (no tasks exceeding 50ms) during layout computation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "051ba471-e838-459e-8cf4-50451df068ef", + "displayId": "R12", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, node shape must encode node kind: content nodes must render as circles, hub nodes must render as diamonds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "055b0ac5-8ef6-439f-9713-3ae50e05b688", + "displayId": "X31", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder intends nodes to be colored by derivation phase in the macro graph visualization.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "07a525aa-3b65-46fc-b773-530ebc31eedb", + "displayId": "DEC4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use Sigma.js v3 with WebGL backend and a custom phosphor-glow fragment shader.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "Sigma.js is the stakeholder's stated preference (X16) and is purpose-built for large graph rendering via WebGL, directly addressing RK1 (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges). Its custom WebGL program API allows implementing the phosphor glow shader per X40 with direct uniform control for hover intensity. D3/SVG (alt 1) cannot handle the dataset size at interactive frame rates. Cytoscape (alt 2) has heavier abstractions that would impede the custom shader work required for the CRT aesthetic, and RK2 notes that WebGL gives less fine-grained per-node control than SVG — Sigma's program API mitigates this by exposing shader-level control." + }, + { + "id": "07b92395-5c07-4634-81de-61c1ca22b9e9", + "displayId": "R36", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a justification hub node must render: (1) a PREMISES group showing all nodes connected by 'informed_by' edges; (2) a CONCLUSIONS group showing all nodes connected by 'produced' edges. Each node reference must be a clickable pill that navigates the detail panel to that node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "080bc287-4e39-464e-90a1-dc0f20e54e19", + "displayId": "A15", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Build the macro timeline as a standard SVG/HTML component (e.g. using D3 for the layout math but rendering with React/SVG). Simpler to implement, easier to style with CSS, but does not enable the future zoom-into-frame WebGL transition that the stakeholder requires (X29).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "095eb207-803c-428c-affc-167092a2f849", + "displayId": "D25", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The artifact bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) includes a placeholder for the FrameRecord summary field: when bundling, it reads frames.json and adds summary: null for each frame if no summary is present. The UI's FrameRecord type declares summary as string | null. When the elicitation pipeline is extended to produce summaries (resolving RK5/E5), the bundler will populate this field and the UI will render it without code changes. This design makes the dependency on the pipeline schema extension explicit and non-blocking.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "096fe03b-749d-455a-84f6-901aa41d1bbf", + "displayId": "CR74", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The Sigma WebGL canvas element must have no keydown, keyup, or keypress event listeners attached directly to it or via React synthetic events. Verified by inspecting event listeners on the canvas DOM element using getEventListeners() in DevTools or a test spy, confirming zero keyboard event handlers are registered.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "099225a8-148e-4a5f-a59f-3ef46e936e2b", + "displayId": "CR89", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The src/types/artifact.ts file must contain zero import statements referencing the spec-elicitation package or any Deno-specific module. Running tsc --noEmit on the spec-elicitation-ui package must complete with zero errors, confirming the type definitions are self-contained. Verified by static analysis of the import graph rooted at src/types/artifact.ts.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "09b722b2-2251-4f57-8b65-b8e38432a255", + "displayId": "D13", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The CRT visual design system is implemented as a Tailwind CSS theme extension plus a small set of reusable CSS/WebGL primitives. Tailwind theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F) for backgrounds, phosphor-text (#FFD580) for body text. Typography: a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or similar) for node text, displayIds, and data values; a slightly wider monospace for headers. CRT primitives: (a) scanline-overlay — a fixed CSS pseudo-element using a repeating-linear-gradient of 1px transparent / 1px rgba(0,0,0,0.15) stripes, pointer-events:none, placed above the WebGL canvas; (b) glow-text — a Tailwind utility applying text-shadow in the node's phase color; (c) flicker-in — a CSS @keyframes animation (0% opacity:0, 30% opacity:0.4, 45% opacity:0.1, 100% opacity:1) running 150ms ease-in used for panel power-on; (d) phosphor-border — a box-shadow utility combining inset and outer glow in the phase color at low alpha. All interactive elements (buttons, chips, panel headers) use hover states that intensify glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and text-shadow. No raw unstyled states exist: the loading state, error state, and empty states each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0a8a70f7-76ed-4dd0-a82b-178c4bb0f4f1", + "displayId": "D21", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The spec-elicitation-ui package lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/ as a sibling to spec-elicitation (X13). It is a standard Vite + React + TypeScript project with the following top-level structure: src/components/ (React UI components), src/store/ (Zustand store and derived index builders), src/graph/ (Sigma.js setup, custom WebGL programs, ForceAtlas2 worker), src/macro/ (WebGL macro timeline renderer), src/types/ (TypeScript types mirroring the artifact.json schema), src/utils/ (artifact parser, diff utilities, provenance traversal), and scripts/bundle-artifact.ts (the Deno bundler script that produces artifact.json, kept here rather than in spec-elicitation to colocate it with the schema it produces). Tailwind config extends the base with the phosphor CRT theme tokens defined in crt-design-system-design.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0ad651ef-4f42-494e-877a-51dcd80a52ac", + "displayId": "X8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The current spec.md output renders all 376+ nodes sequentially and is unusable for understanding relationships, tracing provenance, or navigating decisions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0b6835ea-d50b-4e18-8979-f3398eee9a7f", + "displayId": "RK4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Displaying interventions in both the node detail panel and the macro timeline is the most complete approach but carries higher implementation cost.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0bd4f434-a6fe-43e4-9e3e-7fd2da8c81af", + "displayId": "J4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view must use a dedicated WebGL canvas to satisfy both the current frame-card UI requirements and the future zoom-into-frame transition", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "justification", + "rationale": "X29 requires WebGL for the macro view to enable the future zoom-into-frame transition. D11 specifies rich frame-card content (badges, text, chips) that cannot be implemented within Sigma's node rendering model. DEC10 rejects SVG/HTML because it cannot deliver a smooth WebGL-to-WebGL zoom transition. These premises jointly require a dedicated raw WebGL canvas separate from Sigma." + }, + { + "id": "0c78d3dd-665f-4290-b565-ea8a67464ad8", + "displayId": "R34", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a decision hub node must render: (1) a RATIONALE block showing the decision's rationale prose with a phosphor-amber left border; (2) a CONSIDERED group listing all nodes reached via 'considered' edges as clickable displayId pills; (3) a SELECTED group with a green glow indicator showing chosen alternatives via 'selected' edges; (4) a REJECTED group with a dimmed red indicator showing rejected alternatives via 'rejected' edges; (5) a CONSEQUENCES group listing nodes reached via 'consequence' or 'produced' edges. Each pill must navigate the detail panel to the referenced node on click. A 'Trace to grounding' button must highlight the support-edge subgraph back to grounding-phase nodes in the main Sigma canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0c7e806d-816c-4a99-93dc-9bf05a094a7b", + "displayId": "C4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Real-time updates are out of scope. The artifact is loaded once at startup and does not change during the session.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0c99aa09-a666-456d-a4d8-0139ee33e82a", + "displayId": "CR5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "After successful artifact parse, the application must play a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content. The animation must implement the keyframe sequence opacity 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1 over approximately 150ms as a CSS @keyframes animation, and must not use a slide-in transition.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0d319735-7e89-46d2-ba87-f78ab242cb41", + "displayId": "T16", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view is the temporal history view showing derivation frames and their relationships over time, laid out as a vertical timeline branching horizontally at derivation loops.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0ebffe5d-1b39-48a5-ad29-bed7b232b46e", + "displayId": "CR66", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a fan-in grouping contains more than one node pair, the comparison overlay must show a tab row above the split columns allowing the user to navigate between all node pairs in the grouping. Verified using the reference artifact's fan-in-records.json: selecting a grouping with multiple nodeIds (e.g. 'cloud-agnostic-context' with nodeIds 7cf067d6 and 9d1a93f3) must produce a tab for each pair.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0f801063-4dc8-4b90-adb3-e571927fe0a0", + "displayId": "A13", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Replace the mini-graph with a structured text list of upstream nodes (grouped by edge type), each as a clickable pill. Avoids the complexity of a second Sigma instance (RK3) but loses the spatial/relational context that a graph provides.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "10b1f024-bac8-4a50-a6cd-8a8a101c8bb9", + "displayId": "CR64", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from exactly two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view, which must open the comparison for that fan-in grouping; (2) clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel of any node with lifecycle='candidate', which must open the comparison for the fan-in grouping containing that candidate node. Both entry points must produce the same comparison overlay UI.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "11c0eb0e-b92b-413f-91aa-c93ac214871d", + "displayId": "CR43", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a node has reviewStatus._tag='suspect', the Identity section must display a 'suspect' indicator with clickable links to each causeId. When reviewStatus._tag='conditional', the Identity section must display a 'conditional' indicator with clickable links to each impasseId. A 'clean' node must show a clean indicator with no extra links. Verified by mounting the detail panel for nodes with each review status variant.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "130fbecb-831e-4645-9557-7471a53fb4a2", + "displayId": "R45", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro timeline must visually encode the full regression/recovery narrative: (1) the initial frame trunk rendered in phosphor-green; (2) rederive frames in phosphor-amber; (3) impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on branch edges; (4) perspective hub nodes shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards; (5) the nudgingActive flag shown as a 'NUDGED' badge. Together these elements must make the impasse → rederive → fan-out → reconciliation cycle legible without additional explanation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "13ec68d4-4e7e-4327-bf76-1488f27e3743", + "displayId": "CR40", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking any node in the micro-view graph must activate the right detail panel with a CSS @keyframes flicker animation. The animation must pulse opacity through the sequence 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1 and complete within approximately 150ms (±20ms). The panel must not slide in from the side. Verified by: recording a click event in a test renderer and asserting the applied animation name matches the flicker keyframes definition with the correct duration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "144b6e37-2a16-4947-b715-3f9b616072b2", + "displayId": "R21", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a snapshot slider that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions. The slider must display a numeric revision badge and a timestamp label for the current snapshot. A status line below the slider must show the current revision number and the associated frameId(s).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "14c88d83-dcac-4801-b8da-41fc130e763b", + "displayId": "R5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The application must provide no mechanism to create, edit, or delete nodes or edges. All data displayed must come exclusively from the loaded artifact.json and must not change during the session.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "16d6dd3d-c3cd-454e-baf0-4c3e12c522e3", + "displayId": "T19", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Baseline refers to the active, reconciled state of the knowledge graph; candidate refers to nodes produced during clean-room re-derivation branches before reconciliation. Side-by-side comparison of baseline vs candidate nodes is a required UI feature.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "19cc1a07-e68f-4bfe-a700-693296466f1a", + "displayId": "CR28", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "After the initial layout computation completes for a given specId and snapshotRevision, the layout positions must be written to sessionStorage under a key incorporating the specId and snapshotRevision. On a second load of the same artifact within the same browser session, no Web Worker layout computation must occur — the cached positions must be read directly from sessionStorage and applied to the Sigma graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "1a13e081-fcde-492f-ab6a-ab5e380b91af", + "displayId": "CR41", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The right detail panel must render exactly four collapsible sections in top-to-bottom order: (1) Identity, (2) Connections, (3) Provenance, (4) Validation. The Identity section must be expanded by default and must remain visible even when other sections are collapsed. Sections 2, 3, and 4 must toggle open/closed independently. Verified by mounting the panel for a known node and asserting four section headers are present, with Identity expanded and the others collapsible.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1abeaae6-348c-4d5f-8117-157be556de20", + "displayId": "X5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The pipeline artifact output is a directory containing JSON files organized into: graph/ (nodes, edges, frames, derivation-runs, fan-in records, snapshots), and top-level files (manifest, sources, extracted-claims, interventions), plus rendered views (spec.md, prose.md) and reports (validation, handoff summary).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "1b6eba79-a3c4-43e5-80dc-611fb0556b90", + "displayId": "E3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 4 derivation phases with 3 derivation loop attempts, and includes decision, justification, impasse, and perspective hub nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "1ca241ce-a52c-4e7e-8e91-a61f8087fb06", + "displayId": "CR62", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal listing which nodes changed in that frame (the node-diff list). The modal must display at minimum the displayId, lifecycle, and phase of each node associated with that frame. The modal must be dismissible via Escape or a close control. No WebGL zoom-into-frame transition may be attempted; the modal is the required behavior for the current iteration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1d43815f-4ffe-4400-bfa1-44e883d0ffe5", + "displayId": "CR7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Inspection of the rendered DOM must reveal zero input controls, buttons, or form elements that create, modify, or delete any node or edge. No mutation of the in-memory graph store may occur after the initial artifact load; all node and edge data must remain identical to the parsed artifact.json for the duration of the session.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1ea0d5e6-765f-4a5f-9244-8a9c190c3825", + "displayId": "X17", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers that all pipeline output files be combined into a single artifact.json file that is loaded into the visualization program.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1f22bb21-aeb0-423b-bdf7-25073a0f24bd", + "displayId": "DEC7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Right-side collapsible panel with CRT power-on flicker animation; four collapsible sections; embedded provenance mini-graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "The right panel keeps the graph visible alongside the detail, enabling the user to follow provenance links in the mini-graph (X25) and click adjacent nodes without losing context — the modal (alt 1) destroys this. The bottom drawer (alt 2) cuts vertical canvas space, which is critical for the macro timeline view. The four-section collapsible structure satisfies X24's requirement that the most important information (Identity) is always visible at top. The flicker animation is explicitly preferred by the stakeholder (X24) over slide-in." + }, + { + "id": "1f331274-4d74-4e8c-8cc1-8f788aca29ca", + "displayId": "CR1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given a valid artifact.json file dropped onto the landing page drop zone, the application must parse the file entirely in the browser using the File API (no network request made), transition away from the landing page, and display the main explorer view — all without any server upload or URL entry by the user.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1fa6dc41-ea88-4e00-b97d-14fcdd578315", + "displayId": "CR36", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must render at full Sigma glow intensity and non-matching nodes must render at approximately 15% opacity in the canvas. Edges where both endpoints are non-matching must also be visually dimmed. No node or edge may be removed from the graphology graph during filtering — the total node and edge count in the graphology instance must remain constant before and after any filter is applied.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "20c717e4-168b-4448-a2a2-651d05476265", + "displayId": "D2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The app opens on a full-screen landing page featuring a CRT-styled drop zone (phosphor-glowing dashed border, scanline texture). The user drops or selects artifact.json via the browser File API (no server upload). On successful parse the app transitions to the main explorer with a CRT power-on animation. An optional URL query param (?artifact=) allows linking to a remotely hosted artifact.json for sharing — the app fetches it via fetch() when present, bypassing the drop zone.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2191c8dc-d7e0-4d29-b4f8-0a64e2f2297b", + "displayId": "X44", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The 17 edge types across 6 categories are: hub-generic (informed_by, produced); decision (considered, selected, rejected, consequence); impasse (conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to); perspective (aggregates); content (derived_from, depends_on, conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline); lineage (equivalent_to, refined_by, weakened_by, strengthened_by, split_into, merged_into, obsoleted_by). Content edge category has 10 types; lineage has 7.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "21afe581-2f0b-4171-9a93-bbccd4879acb", + "displayId": "T15", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The micro view is the lineage-focused graph view showing the spec at a particular point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out and a snapshot selector for time-scrubbing.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "22508d7e-47ac-4dc1-861a-3d311bc6b4d4", + "displayId": "CR87", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For each intervention record in the reference artifact's interventions.json, every nodeId in its targetNodeIds array must appear as a key in the interventionsByNodeId index mapping to an array that includes that intervention. Specifically: node 7cbf0826 must map to intervention 0f60db54; node 38c2ff0b must map to intervention 158ac3c4; node 61d9201c must map to intervention 926c3761; node cb3857aa must map to intervention 610c95d1. Each association must be verified by direct index lookup.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "228a2225-fb50-4f4d-a202-1ece0e67f42a", + "displayId": "R24", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The application must define TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts. NodeRecord must be a discriminated union on kind ('content' | 'hub'). FrameRecord must include summary as string | null to future-proof the optional per-frame LLM summary field. These types must be defined independently of the spec-elicitation package (no cross-package import of Effect schemas).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "229986ef-9374-49a0-8bdd-cd1f7f00386d", + "displayId": "R43", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive indicator (shown as a 'NUDGED' badge when true), createdAt timestamp, and the pre-generated LLM summary text when present. When no summary is present (summary is null), the summary region must display a muted 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' placeholder in dimmed monospace style. No runtime error or broken layout may result from an absent summary.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "22cf44b0-1336-4ba2-96b8-6f7d6ebef354", + "displayId": "CR65", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The comparison overlay must render as a split panel with a left column showing the baseline node and a right column showing the candidate node. Differences in text, semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority fields must be highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions (green) and deletions (red/amber). The fan-in grouping rationale must appear as a prominent decision banner between the two columns.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "231e548c-3d4c-4894-903e-889525c7c5dd", + "displayId": "X38", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND simultaneously show a results list in a side panel.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "236669cb-46bb-4411-90c0-548e10b4b121", + "displayId": "R7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The main explorer must render a three-region resizable split layout: a left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and results list, a central canvas area hosting either the micro or macro view, and a right detail panel. All three regions must be simultaneously visible when a node is selected. Panels must be resizable via drag handles.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2652c6f8-3ba7-4152-b890-0aa032dd7664", + "displayId": "G2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The explorer UI must replace the current unnavigable flat spec.md output, enabling users to understand relationships, trace provenance, and navigate decisions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "276c3a4e-6e04-45e1-84da-27668d5fb3dd", + "displayId": "A17", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Show baseline and candidate as two differently-styled node clusters in the main Sigma graph simultaneously, with lineage edges (equivalent_to, refined_by etc.) highlighted between them. More spatially honest but visually overwhelming given the large candidate node count (288 candidates in the reference artifact).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "27866d49-96b4-4529-9096-0432cf81aa69", + "displayId": "CR53", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The Validation section of the detail panel must not appear in the DOM when the selected node has reviewStatus._tag='clean' and no validation errors touch its incident edges. When errors are present, the section must list each error showing: rule, severity, message, edge type, and edge direction. Verified by: selecting a clean node and asserting the Validation section is absent; then selecting a node with incident errored edges and asserting the section is present with correct error details.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "29565fd1-849f-49aa-9661-67806e4aa2e5", + "displayId": "D11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The macro view replaces the Sigma canvas with a WebGL-rendered vertical timeline built using raw WebGL (via a thin abstraction layer, not a graph library). The timeline lays out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on the main trunk. Rederive frames branch horizontally to the right of their parent frame as sibling columns at the same vertical level, reflecting the fan-out topology observed in the reference artifact (all three rederive attempts are siblings of the initial frame, not a linear chain). Each frame is rendered as a rectangular card with: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive indicator, createdAt timestamp, and the pre-generated LLM summary text if present (gracefully omitted with a 'no summary' placeholder if absent per RK5). Edges between frames encode relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges for triggerImpasseId linkage (drawn in warning amber), fan-in-record edges connecting rederive frames back to baseline (drawn in success green). Interventions associated with a frame are shown as small annotation chips on the frame card's right edge per X26. Clicking a frame card zooms the view to show which nodes changed in that frame (deferred per C10 to a later iteration — click opens a modal node-diff list instead).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2bae6803-287f-43c4-9c41-ad9ca43e7140", + "displayId": "D3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The main explorer shell uses a three-region layout: (1) a narrow left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and a node-list results panel; (2) a large central canvas area that hosts either the micro-view graph or the macro-view timeline depending on the active view mode; (3) a right-side detail panel that slides/flickers into existence when a node is selected. A top toolbar holds the view-mode toggle (Micro / Macro), the snapshot selector (when in Micro mode), and global controls (lifecycle toggles, phase filter chips). All panels are resizable via drag handles. When no node is selected the right panel is collapsed and the canvas occupies the full remaining width.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2c7d5be6-fc8d-4527-8a3f-9d82d5510e9a", + "displayId": "CR57", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Each frame card rendered in the macro timeline must display all of the following fields: mode badge ('initial' or 'rederive'), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, createdAt timestamp, and a nudgingActive indicator rendered as a 'NUDGED' badge when nudgingActive=true. For the reference artifact, the two rederive frames with attemptNumber=1 and attemptNumber=2 (ids b40fd568 and b9236ccf) must show 'NUDGED'. The frame with attemptNumber=0 (id 10f07753) must not show 'NUDGED'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2c867547-6b80-4e4f-9b15-7593a7a0cfe5", + "displayId": "CR80", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The edgeIssuesByNodeId index must correctly associate validation errors with both the source and target node of each errored edge. Using the first validation error in the reference artifact (edgeId 00452e1e, a derived_from edge between nodes b66575fc and 6c45100b), both node IDs must be present as keys in edgeIssuesByNodeId, each mapping to an array containing that error. Querying an unrelated node ID must return an empty array.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "2d0a1476-404e-4569-83e3-d2aa0efeadd4", + "displayId": "R30", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The right detail panel must activate on node click with a CRT power-on flicker animation of approximately 150ms duration, implemented as a CSS @keyframes sequence that pulses opacity 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1. The panel must not use a slide-in transition.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2da431dc-66e0-49d4-9d85-ebb2190e6ebb", + "displayId": "R44", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must be visually encoded by relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges triggered by an impasse must be drawn in warning amber and labeled with the triggerImpasseId as a displayId badge; fan-in record edges connecting rederive frames back to the baseline must be drawn in bright green and labeled 'RECONCILED'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2f0b1c99-05ee-49d7-a70b-be87f5fe0a2f", + "displayId": "D9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The provenance mini-graph inside the detail panel is a second, independent Sigma.js instance mounted in a ~280px tall panel region. It renders only the upstream derivation subgraph for the selected node: traversing support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards from the focal node up to a configurable depth (default: exhaustive for graphs ≤50 upstream nodes, capped at depth-4 for larger chains). The focal node is rendered at full glow at center; ancestors are positioned using a left-to-right hierarchical layout (graphology-layout-dagre) to reflect derivation direction. Nodes are clickable: clicking navigates the main detail panel to that node, updating both the main graph selection and the mini-graph. Visual style (colors, glow, scanlines) is shared via the same Sigma program class used in the main graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2f2e5456-aec6-48fc-a6de-3c644e4ec921", + "displayId": "R32", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Identity section of the detail panel must display: for content nodes — semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority; for hub nodes — hubType. It must also show the review status as a tagged indicator: 'clean' with no annotation, 'suspect' with links to causeIds, and 'conditional' with links to impasseIds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2fc05ce2-c8f6-40fe-92fb-95d4b1922e16", + "displayId": "X27", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers that when a search or filter is active, matching nodes glow at full intensity while non-matching nodes are rendered at low opacity (~15%), with edges also dimmed when both endpoints are non-matching, multiple filters using AND logic, and the graph topology preserved so context is not lost.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2fe91119-87ab-4ba8-98e8-25c4369c1c36", + "displayId": "CR84", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the application is deployed to a remote static host (e.g., GitHub Pages) and accessed with ?artifact= pointing to a CORS-enabled artifact.json URL, the application must load and parse the artifact via fetch() and enter the main explorer view without requiring any local file selection. No error related to file system access may occur. Verified by deploying the built app to a static host and testing the URL param flow end-to-end.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "324085e6-9540-4233-83a5-a893e356fe72", + "displayId": "R55", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "All interactive HTML elements (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have hover states that intensify glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and text-shadow. No interactive element may have a visually inert hover state.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3253fc62-9dee-420b-b306-0df9a527443b", + "displayId": "X25", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers that the provenance section in the node detail panel renders a small Sigma.js subgraph showing the full upstream derivation chain, with clickable nodes for navigation, visually coherent with the main graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "32907b67-1e27-4a5b-987e-c0f7303f1041", + "displayId": "X16", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers a WebGL-based renderer (e.g. Sigma.js) for graph rendering because it can handle tens of thousands of nodes and edges interactively and enables more ambitious visual design such as a phosphor-glow effect on nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "32b3b4e1-7603-463a-9a69-1a48a6f7f3d7", + "displayId": "R20", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When the snapshot selector changes the active snapshot, node visibility must be updated by adjusting node opacity rather than removing nodes from the graph. Nodes not in the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array must be rendered at near-zero opacity. Layout positions must not be recomputed on snapshot change.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "346a29c8-a645-4a9d-9e9d-f2dff372d96b", + "displayId": "RK1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The full reference graph (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges, plus archived and candidate nodes) may be too large to render interactively without deliberate performance optimization.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "359b22a9-dc7c-4a33-97f1-30e78aa59822", + "displayId": "A21", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Implement full ARIA graph navigation with keyboard traversal of graph nodes (focus moves between nodes via arrow keys, Tab enters/exits the graph). Significantly more accessible but explicitly out of scope per X28 and C11, and technically complex with a WebGL canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "37329a18-2e35-4642-871f-c2d4ee8564d0", + "displayId": "CR55", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When Macro view is active, a dedicated element separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas must be mounted in the central area with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl') or getContext('webgl2') returning non-null). The Sigma canvas must not be present in the DOM simultaneously. Verified by querying the DOM for canvas elements while in each view mode and asserting exactly one WebGL canvas is present per mode.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "38a75e5d-82d6-4833-a0e4-63ac85ee0aa2", + "displayId": "D17", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Interventions are displayed in two places per X26: (1) In the macro view, each frame card shows a row of small intervention chips on its right edge, one per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip shows the intervention kind (e.g. 'accept_candidate') and a count of targetNodeIds. Hovering a chip shows a tooltip listing the targetNodeIds as displayIds. (2) In the node detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section (within the Connections section) lists interventions that reference the current node in their targetNodeIds array, showing kind, frameId (linked to the macro view), and timestamp. The intervention-to-node join is pre-computed at load time as an interventionsByNodeId Map.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3941d9fe-5b7f-49ef-bb52-2df00e6ce4fb", + "displayId": "CR15", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "With the smoke-webhook reference artifact loaded (761 total nodes, 2,662 edges), panning and zooming the micro-view Sigma canvas must sustain a frame rate of at least 30 fps as measured by browser DevTools performance profiling. No interaction (pan, zoom, hover) may produce a jank frame exceeding 100ms on a mid-range developer machine.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "399b050e-da20-4dbd-9dbc-8c4f7d16338b", + "displayId": "CR11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must have zero computed width (or be absent from the DOM) and the central canvas must expand to fill the full remaining width after the left sidebar. Selecting a node must cause the detail panel to appear; deselecting must collapse it again.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3a755f5c-94b6-43ac-a5c7-467103efa17b", + "displayId": "A6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Render the graph using D3-force with SVG. Provides per-element CSS control, easy CRT filter effects via SVG filter primitives, and simpler hit-testing, but SVG degrades significantly beyond ~1,000 nodes and edges.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3a9fad21-af65-4b06-a043-c3b9c1b462f2", + "displayId": "R41", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view must be rendered on a dedicated WebGL canvas separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas, implemented using raw WebGL with a thin abstraction layer (not a graph library). This canvas must be mounted in place of the Sigma canvas when macro view is active.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3b944c6b-55c0-448e-9991-8baf5e862927", + "displayId": "CR27", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "While ForceAtlas2 layout computation is in progress, the central canvas must display a CRT-styled text indicator reading 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' (or equivalent). The indicator must disappear and be replaced by the rendered graph when the Worker posts its result. No partially-rendered or unlaid-out graph may be shown while computation is ongoing.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3c52126b-a3a9-4647-b88a-f648ba035446", + "displayId": "A19", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Use Redux Toolkit for state management. More structured with time-travel debugging, but significantly more boilerplate for a read-only single-load application where immutability guarantees add no practical benefit.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3c8056d4-7be6-425e-8160-6c7c593ad2b9", + "displayId": "R8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle that switches the central canvas between Micro view and Macro view. The snapshot selector must be visible in the toolbar only when Micro view is active.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3e15cd80-83e3-44d1-880c-6cc0f9d495ca", + "displayId": "DEC14", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Keyboard navigation covers only HTML panel controls; Sigma canvas is mouse/touch only.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X28 and C11 explicitly restrict keyboard navigation to panel controls. Full ARIA graph traversal (alt 1) is explicitly out of scope and would require complex keyboard hit-testing against WebGL-rendered node positions. The defined bindings cover all panel interactions needed for productive exploration without a mouse." + }, + { + "id": "3e4ae921-3fa3-4762-84b1-f7e6da27bcfb", + "displayId": "CR18", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, every hub node with hubType='impasse' must render with a hexagonal shape, visually distinct from the diamond used for other hub types. Inspecting the rendered geometry of a known impasse node from the reference artifact (e.g., the node with id '557db0a8-5b5b-4ab9-97e2-4ac5c4f243d5') must confirm the hexagonal form.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3ebe5d97-b87f-4705-9bc6-d0fa38bdd7e4", + "displayId": "A2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Bundle the artifact as a ZIP archive containing the original directory structure; the UI uses a JS ZIP library to decompress and access files in-memory after the user drops the archive.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3f9bbc7d-9967-45d3-aca4-7f6ed1f1f635", + "displayId": "RK5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field. The macro view's per-frame summary display depends on a schema extension to the elicitation pipeline that has not yet been implemented.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "40c9fe46-62d6-435a-b57d-a1264c369634", + "displayId": "D4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The micro-view graph is rendered using Sigma.js (v3) with a WebGL backend. Nodes are drawn with a custom WebGL fragment shader implementing per-node phosphor glow whose intensity is driven by a uniform updated on hover and selection state. Node color encodes derivation phase (4 distinct phosphor hues). Node shape encodes kind (circle = content, diamond = hub). Edge color encodes category: support edges in dim amber, workflow edges in brighter green, structural edges in muted cyan. Lifecycle state is encoded as opacity: active = full, archived = 20% opacity, candidate = 60% opacity, withdrawn = 10% opacity. The Sigma canvas is overlaid with a CSS scanline texture layer (pointer-events: none) to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4104485e-a1d9-4150-9c01-db8898adeb0c", + "displayId": "C11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Keyboard navigation does not apply to the graph canvas. Canvas interaction is mouse/touch only.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "4112e803-e272-45a1-a673-fd58c17f7d22", + "displayId": "CR25", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The interventionsByNodeId index must correctly map each nodeId appearing in any intervention's targetNodeIds array to that intervention record. Using the reference artifact's interventions.json (4 records, each with one targetNodeId), querying the index for each of the four targetNodeIds must return the corresponding intervention. Querying a nodeId that appears in no intervention must return an empty array, not undefined or an error.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "412d1928-266c-4e56-ae85-0cb5498008ac", + "displayId": "CR19", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, edges must be rendered in three visually distinct colors by category: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) in dim amber; workflow edges (produced, considered, selected, rejected, consequence, conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to, aggregates) in brighter green; structural edges (conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline, and all lineage edge types) in muted cyan. Sampling 10 edges of each category from the reference artifact and reading their rendered colors must confirm the correct category mapping for all 30 sampled edges.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "41fe48fd-383b-4117-b9e6-c9ab8bbf9a5f", + "displayId": "X43", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The smoke-webhook artifact directory contains: graph/ (nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, snapshots.json), plus top-level manifest.json, sources.json, extracted-claims.json, interventions.json, reports/validation.json, reports/handoff-summary.md, and views/. Nodes carry id, displayId, specId, frameId, phase, text, lifecycle, reviewStatus, provenance, createdAt, kind, and kind-specific fields (semanticRole/epistemicStatus/authority for content; hubType/rationale for hubs). Edges carry id, source.nodeId, target.nodeId, type, rationale, provenance, createdAt. Frames carry parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase, triggerImpasseIds, mode (initial/rederive), attemptNumber, nudgingActive. No summary field exists on FrameRecord.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "433e0018-8c1f-4ae8-a6bf-ad37779a8709", + "displayId": "CR46", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking the 'Trace to grounding' button in a decision hub's Connections section must traverse support edges from the decision's considered nodes back to grounding-phase nodes and apply the active-filter highlighting model (full intensity for traversed nodes, ~15% opacity for all others) to the main Sigma canvas. The Zustand filterState must reflect this subgraph highlight. Clearing the filter must restore all nodes to normal opacity.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "440c7344-6785-4b1f-b3d1-eac2f1e7b4ba", + "displayId": "C3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Running the elicitation pipeline from within the UI is out of scope.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "449b5067-d769-494f-9d0f-d89660a59dd6", + "displayId": "A18", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Implement all CRT effects purely in CSS (SVG filter feGaussianBlur for glow, CSS animations for flicker) without any WebGL shader involvement for the UI chrome, relying on Sigma's custom program only for node glow. Simpler but the glow effect on CSS elements will not match the WebGL node glow, creating visual inconsistency.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4584a697-7fe0-4922-aa90-8e525468d99f", + "displayId": "C2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The app has no backend. All data is loaded from static JSON files. The app must be deployable as a static site.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "46ee8e67-d3a1-4ead-8af8-d10eedd2a4b6", + "displayId": "D22", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The UI defines TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts, mirroring the domain model from the spec-elicitation package without importing it directly (to avoid a cross-package dependency on Deno-specific Effect schemas). Key types: ArtifactFile (top-level), GraphData, NodeRecord (discriminated union on kind: 'content' | 'hub'), ContentNode (with semanticRole, epistemicStatus, authority), HubNode (with hubType, rationale), EdgeRecord, FrameRecord (with optional summary?: string to future-proof RK5), SnapshotRecord, DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, InterventionRecord, ValidationReport, ValidationError. The discriminated union on NodeRecord.kind enables exhaustive type-narrowing in the detail panel renderer.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "471bbbd8-b8ad-4eca-8abb-f4d35b0bb927", + "displayId": "CR30", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the snapshot slider is moved to a revision where a given node is not in the activeNodeIds array, that node must remain present in the Sigma graphology graph instance but be rendered at near-zero opacity (visually invisible). The node must not be removed from the graphology graph. Layout positions must not change when the slider is moved. Verified by: querying the graphology instance for a known inactive-at-revision node and asserting it exists with a near-zero opacity attribute.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "475953d9-2ccf-43e3-a004-780d584ad5e2", + "displayId": "CR60", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The macro timeline must make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation narrative legible through five simultaneous visual cues: (1) initial frame trunk in phosphor-green; (2) rederive frames in phosphor-amber; (3) impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on branch edges; (4) perspective hub nodes shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards; (5) nudgingActive shown as a 'NUDGED' badge. All five cues must be present simultaneously in the rendered macro view for the reference artifact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "47737c3e-9678-463f-80b5-d396ee17342d", + "displayId": "X12", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Edge types are defined in a dedicated file at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/src/domain/edge-types.ts.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "47786d94-8002-40e5-b7a2-e3780fbfadeb", + "displayId": "CR21", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must exhibit a visible phosphor glow effect implemented via a WebGL fragment shader. Hovering over a node must produce a measurably increased glow radius or intensity relative to the idle state. Selecting a node must produce a further-increased glow intensity relative to hover. The glow color must match the node's derivation-phase color.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "4815b7ca-f77c-4fdf-ab59-d519c888d5af", + "displayId": "X40", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder envisions nodes emitting a color-appropriate phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader, with hover states intensifying the glow effect.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "482c771c-e49a-4bde-b43a-6b52603fcb13", + "displayId": "CR13", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The snapshot selector control must appear in the toolbar if and only if Micro view is active. Switching to Macro view must remove the snapshot selector from the DOM (or hide it such that it receives no pointer events). Switching back to Micro must restore it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "48814b8d-c276-4280-9a17-c0866f78ecb5", + "displayId": "DEC8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Embedded second Sigma.js instance for provenance visualization, with dagre hierarchical layout and depth cap.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "The stakeholder explicitly prefers a Sigma.js mini-graph for provenance (X25) and calls out that it must be visually coherent with the main graph. A text list (alt) satisfies navigation but not spatial provenance comprehension, which is central to G2 (tracing provenance). RK3 acknowledges the complexity; the depth cap (≤50 nodes / depth-4) bounds the worst-case rendering cost. Reusing the same Sigma program class minimizes the implementation delta and guarantees visual coherence." + }, + { + "id": "48b2bf3a-33e5-4c54-b635-c10855d24297", + "displayId": "R26", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When multiple filter controls are active simultaneously, the application must combine them using AND logic: a node is considered matching only if it satisfies every active filter dimension.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "48ee9d92-cf8a-47d5-b6c5-348e8f6b814c", + "displayId": "T13", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "An intervention is a record of a human action that occurred during a derivation frame, stored in interventions.json in the artifact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "4ab00691-79bd-4049-b028-f1872cb37aff", + "displayId": "R17", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must be rendered in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo in addition to their normal phase-color glow, implemented as a second glow pass in the WebGL shader.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "4c7d8fab-1ddc-4a74-9836-4cdc9aeb6bbd", + "displayId": "R54", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "All node text, displayIds, data values, and code-like content must use a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent). No UI element may render in a default sans-serif or serif browser font.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "502805ad-82e7-44ed-afe6-13abc89aa7b8", + "displayId": "R35", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Connections section of the detail panel for an impasse hub node must render: (1) a CONFLICTING INPUTS group listing nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges with their review status indicator; (2) a RESOLVED BY group showing nodes via 'resolved_by' edges; (3) a SPAWNED group listing child impasses via 'spawned' edges; (4) a REFINED TO group showing the refined impasse via 'refined_to' edges; (5) a status banner indicating whether the impasse is currently unresolved (no resolved_by edges) or resolved. Unresolved impasses must show a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "51551fde-9432-4152-a688-afcfb9e32b8a", + "displayId": "CR45", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For a decision hub node, the Connections section must render five distinct groups: RATIONALE (prose text with phosphor-amber left border), CONSIDERED (pills for nodes via 'considered' edges), SELECTED (green-glow pills for nodes via 'selected' edges), REJECTED (dimmed red-indicator pills for nodes via 'rejected' edges), and CONSEQUENCES (pills for nodes via 'consequence' or 'produced' edges). Each pill must be clickable and navigate the detail panel to the referenced node. A 'Trace to grounding' button must be present. Verified against a known decision hub node (e.g., DEC22) from the reference artifact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5479add5-2688-41a8-a49c-1a336d1dfa3b", + "displayId": "X28", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers that keyboard navigation covers only panel controls (Escape closes detail panel, Tab/Shift-Tab moves between UI controls, Enter confirms selection); the Sigma.js canvas graph interaction is mouse/touch only.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "55e1ebd9-62a9-482c-a152-dfa93c554507", + "displayId": "D7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The left sidebar hosts a filter+search panel with the following controls: (1) a full-text search input that matches against node text and displayId; (2) phase filter chips (grounding / shaping / pinning / defining_done); (3) semantic role multi-select checkboxes (10 roles from T2); (4) hub type toggle (all / decision / justification / impasse / perspective); (5) epistemic status chips; (6) authority chips; (7) lifecycle visibility toggles (active always on; archived/candidate/withdrawn toggleable per X32). All active filters combine with AND logic per X27. When any filter or search is active, Sigma re-renders with matching nodes at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes at 15% opacity; edges are dimmed when both endpoints are non-matching. The results panel below the filters shows a scrollable list of matching nodes sorted by displayId, each row showing displayId, phase badge, role/type badge, and truncated text.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "56da68a6-9471-4b07-bb59-7c8612f64729", + "displayId": "T4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The lifecycle of a node represents its current standing in the knowledge graph. The four defined lifecycle values are: candidate, active, archived, and withdrawn.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "5b395891-7882-48fd-a7a5-7cf14c8a2767", + "displayId": "A9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Pre-compute and store layout positions in the artifact.json bundle at generation time, eliminating the Web Worker layout step entirely at the cost of larger artifact files.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5bada80b-11d5-4828-9388-db44fff8342e", + "displayId": "J2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND show a persistent results list simultaneously", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "justification", + "rationale": "X38 requires both highlighting in the graph and a results list. DEC6 selects the persistent sidebar over a command palette precisely because a command palette cannot maintain a simultaneous results list. D7 specifies the Sigma opacity-based highlighting. These three premises jointly mandate that the results list is persistent and co-visible with the live graph, not a transient overlay." + }, + { + "id": "5c086588-756a-43dc-928b-a6e715b992c0", + "displayId": "R16", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "A CSS scanline texture overlay must sit above the WebGL canvas at all times, implemented as a repeating-linear-gradient pseudo-element with pointer-events:none, so it does not intercept canvas mouse/touch events.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5e1fc028-4adb-4a77-9fc9-560ab54c98b8", + "displayId": "D24", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Impasse hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel. The Connections section shows: (1) a 'CONFLICTING INPUTS' group listing nodes connected by 'conflicting_input' edges, each shown as a clickable pill with their review status indicator; (2) a 'RESOLVED BY' group showing nodes connected by 'resolved_by' edges (perspective or decision nodes); (3) a 'SPAWNED' group listing child impasses via 'spawned' edges; (4) a 'REFINED TO' group showing the refined impasse via 'refined_to' edges. A status banner at the top of the Connections section shows whether the impasse is currently unresolved (no resolved_by edges) or resolved. Unresolved impasses are visually flagged with a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section. In the micro graph, impasse nodes render with a distinctive hexagonal shape and warning-amber glow.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5f0e9896-21f7-49aa-a5d1-b848a95b3301", + "displayId": "CR95", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the macro timeline, any frame card associated with a perspective hub node (hubType='perspective') must display a small purple indicator badge on the card. In the reference artifact, any rederive frame whose derivation produced perspective hub nodes must show this badge. Verified by identifying perspective hub nodes in the reference nodes.json, tracing their frameId, and confirming the badge appears on the corresponding frame card in the macro view.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5f59bf16-942d-44d8-a48c-dcd2e7a2ed62", + "displayId": "X37", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The artifact includes a validation report. The UI must integrate this data to show which nodes have issues.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5f84d555-fc02-48ca-bc6c-2831bd9bed97", + "displayId": "CR22", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must render in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo visually overlaid on their normal phase-color glow. Selecting a known errored edge in the reference artifact's validation.json, identifying its source and target nodes, and visually inspecting those nodes in the graph must confirm the red halo is present and absent on a clean neighboring node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5fac516c-9862-4f6d-9e93-b9ddcbc19df6", + "displayId": "CR2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given the user clicks a file-picker trigger on the landing page and selects a valid artifact.json, the application must load and parse the file identically to drag-and-drop, transitioning to the main explorer view with no server upload.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "613e08c9-6e91-4286-9653-54654c27f9ed", + "displayId": "A1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: The UI loads individual files lazily from a user-supplied directory path or URL prefix, fetching each file on demand rather than requiring a pre-bundled artifact.json.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "61db5e85-20c7-4395-9df8-f5c27445f56c", + "displayId": "CR34", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain exactly the following controls: (1) a text input for full-text search; (2) four phase filter chips (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done); (3) ten semantic role checkboxes (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk); (4) a hub type toggle with options all/decision/justification/impasse/perspective; (5) four epistemic status chips (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred); (6) four authority chips (stakeholder, technical, external, derived); (7) three lifecycle visibility toggles (archived, candidate, withdrawn). All controls must be present in the DOM simultaneously.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "62f7fcc2-160a-4fa7-b3b6-69542121dbdd", + "displayId": "DEC9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use a slider for snapshot selection, preserving graph topology by opacity rather than node removal.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X20 describes a 'dropdown or slider' but a slider affords scrubbing through the derivation history which is far more expressive for understanding temporal evolution (G3). Preserving topology (opacity vs removal) is essential so users retain spatial memory of node positions as they scrub — removing nodes would cause disorienting layout thrash since ForceAtlas2 positions are pinned after initial computation. The dropdown alt is retained as a labeled companion control (showing the current revision name) but the primary interaction is the slider." + }, + { + "id": "63d85aeb-cbec-4045-9500-b6778cdf33a3", + "displayId": "R38", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL program class (node shader, color palette, glow style) as the main micro-view graph, ensuring visual coherence between the two Sigma instances.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "649ae051-03fd-4ee9-b7b4-31cd188aa66c", + "displayId": "CR67", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The comparison overlay must include a 'View in graph' button. Clicking it must: close the comparison overlay, switch to Micro view if Macro view is active, set selectedNodeId to the baseline node's id in the Zustand store, and pan/zoom the Sigma canvas to bring the baseline node into view. The detail panel must open for the baseline node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "64b876cd-5aa4-46da-ab92-f82971ca9869", + "displayId": "CR61", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display one intervention annotation chip per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip must show the intervention kind (e.g. 'accept_candidate') and a count of targetNodeIds. For the reference artifact: frame 10f07753 must show 3 chips (interventions 0f60db54, 158ac3c4, 926c3761), and frame b40fd568 must show 1 chip (intervention 610c95d1). Hovering a chip must display a tooltip listing targetNodeIds as human-readable displayIds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6503e6ac-d94f-49d6-bcaf-7a3117a57034", + "displayId": "CR47", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For an impasse hub node, the Connections section must render: CONFLICTING INPUTS group (nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges, each showing review status), RESOLVED BY group (nodes via 'resolved_by' edges), SPAWNED group (child impasses via 'spawned' edges), REFINED TO group (via 'refined_to' edges), and a status banner indicating resolved or unresolved state. An unresolved impasse must show a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section. Verified against the trigger impasse node in the reference artifact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "684ae8ab-3dbe-4a38-b1a6-92666a2fea6e", + "displayId": "CR42", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For a content node, the Identity section must display: the full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator (one of clean/suspect/conditional), semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority. For a hub node, the Identity section must display hubType instead of semanticRole/epistemicStatus/authority. Verified by mounting the detail panel for one known content node and one known hub node from the reference artifact and asserting each field's presence and correct value.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "68ce467e-1d6c-4b22-b61e-019875f50725", + "displayId": "X34", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Edge categories (support, workflow, structural) must be visually distinguished using different line styles or colors in the graph visualization.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6909c595-06ac-4c43-a7a4-71a178d91223", + "displayId": "C9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The UI cannot generate per-frame LLM summaries at runtime. It can only consume summaries that are pre-generated and present in the artifact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "69197260-c0ba-43cf-9b24-5a981b87b4b3", + "displayId": "G4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The app must present the knowledge graph as a rich, browsable, searchable interface supporting graph visualization, node detail inspection, provenance tracing, decision exploration, filtering, search, and side-by-side baseline/candidate comparison.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6b303160-3121-4bc4-8a2f-e348fbd56346", + "displayId": "T8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Every content node in the domain model carries three orthogonal classification axes: semantic role, epistemic status, and authority.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "6b40dd8f-190f-4567-bd29-b2ffe8a51e9d", + "displayId": "CR31", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a lifecycle visibility toggle (archived, candidate, or withdrawn) is switched off, affected nodes must be hidden from the Sigma canvas by setting the graphology node attribute 'hidden' to true — not by calling graph.dropNode() or rebuilding the graphology instance. Switching the toggle back on must restore those nodes by setting 'hidden' to false. Active nodes must have no toggle and must always be visible.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "6b86da1b-08f8-436e-9caa-4f6062f673ba", + "displayId": "X10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Decision nodes are described by the stakeholder as the most important hub type in the system.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6cccd2c9-c15b-4027-ae6a-9bb421a66388", + "displayId": "CR33", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The TypeScript type NodeRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must be a discriminated union on the 'kind' field with exactly two variants: one for kind='content' (including semanticRole, epistemicStatus, authority) and one for kind='hub' (including hubType, rationale). FrameRecord must declare a summary field typed as string | null. The file must import nothing from the spec-elicitation package. Verified by TypeScript compiler with zero type errors.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "6e5538d7-a86a-4d3c-a049-e7ea7afb294a", + "displayId": "CR76", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the bundler script processes frames.json entries that have no summary field, the resulting artifact.json must include summary: null on each such FrameRecord. The TypeScript type for FrameRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must declare summary as string | null, ensuring the UI type-checks without error against both null (current state) and a populated string (future state). Verified by running the bundler on the reference artifact and asserting summary is null on all four frame records.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "6e9bebfe-abf3-4aa1-9a01-ccf40576a3e3", + "displayId": "D1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "A dedicated bundler script (part of the spec-elicitation package, not the UI) merges all pipeline output files into a single artifact.json. The merged structure is: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. The UI loads only this one file. The bundler is a Deno CLI script invoked after a pipeline run completes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6e9d6826-e89f-4f7c-90a8-d5ebd54e972b", + "displayId": "R49", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view; (2) clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel of a node with lifecycle=candidate.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6f860b03-f862-40ea-bb59-99a44e8c3f51", + "displayId": "X14", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The tech stack for the explorer UI is confirmed as Vite, React, and Tailwind CSS.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6f8de2a8-3316-4360-80ae-7370bba4a466", + "displayId": "R52", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The comparison view must include a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node, closing the comparison overlay and selecting that node in the main graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "7025bd9b-1715-43d1-9274-500f0d0cd088", + "displayId": "R27", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must be rendered at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes must be rendered at approximately 15% opacity in the Sigma canvas. Edges where both endpoints are non-matching must also be dimmed. Graph topology must be preserved — no nodes or edges may be removed from the canvas during filtering.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "70715c4f-7653-4992-9ecb-c1406b3da7e2", + "displayId": "CR85", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "After loading the smoke-webhook reference artifact, the nodeIndex Map must contain exactly 761 entries (376 active + 88 archived + 288 candidate + 9 withdrawn). The edgeIndex Map must contain exactly 2,662 entries. The frameIndex must contain exactly 4 entries. These counts must match the totals in validation.json (totalNodes=761, totalEdges=2662, totalFrames=4). Any mismatch must be surfaced as a diagnostic warning in the console.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "7199fc6b-6cb4-4494-b0af-0468f2e11560", + "displayId": "X20", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The micro view is a lineage-focused subgraph showing the spec at the current point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out, and includes a snapshot selector (dropdown or slider) for scrubbing through revisions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "7428e9dd-66a7-4aaf-a6a2-76d55b96cd9e", + "displayId": "R9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must be collapsed and the central canvas must expand to occupy the full remaining width after the left sidebar.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "74560b06-2493-4972-8a46-c9c740bb3caa", + "displayId": "R48", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal node-diff list showing which nodes changed in that frame. The full zoom-into-frame WebGL subgraph transition is explicitly deferred; the modal diff list is the required behavior for the current iteration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "74992a29-94d3-4468-9761-d1bd22c47322", + "displayId": "R2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The application must accept an optional ?artifact= query parameter; when present it must fetch artifact.json via fetch() from that URL and bypass the drop zone, enabling remote sharing without user file selection.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "76b59fb9-8e95-4a4c-b8b3-fb4069bfcc71", + "displayId": "RK6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "There is a potential conflict between the preference for browser File API loading (local filesystem drop zone) and the requirement that loading also work when the app is hosted remotely. These two approaches may require different loading mechanisms.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "79d2d259-cd64-4371-8163-5209f81df67f", + "displayId": "R3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The application must parse artifact.json as a single bundled file with the structure: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. Any artifact.json missing a required top-level key must produce a CRT-themed error state, not a crash or raw unstyled error.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "7a4151df-237d-4321-bd6b-951df01d5fba", + "displayId": "X3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The spec elicitation system is an experimental pipeline within Kael that takes conversational input (interview transcripts, context documents) and produces a structured specification as a knowledge graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "7aa76601-3aef-4ed2-ac8a-afde6013d87c", + "displayId": "D23", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Decision hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel's Connections section (X35, X10). The section renders: (1) a 'RATIONALE' block showing the decision's rationale prose in a styled blockquote with phosphor-amber left border; (2) a 'CONSIDERED' group listing all nodes connected by 'considered' edges, shown as clickable displayId pills; (3) a 'SELECTED' group with a green glow indicator showing the chosen alternative(s) via 'selected' edges; (4) a 'REJECTED' group with a dimmed red indicator showing rejected alternatives via 'rejected' edges; (5) a 'CONSEQUENCES' group listing nodes connected by 'consequence' or 'produced' edges. Each pill in these groups is clickable, navigating the detail panel to that node. A 'Trace to grounding' button traverses the support edges from the decision's considered nodes back to grounding-phase nodes and highlights that subgraph in the main Sigma canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7ae3996d-d5c0-479a-8379-83352fe2da54", + "displayId": "D6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The micro-view graph uses a force-directed layout (Sigma's built-in ForceAtlas2 via graphology-layout-forceatlas2) computed via a Web Worker on first load so the UI thread is not blocked. Layout positions are cached in sessionStorage keyed by specId+snapshotRevision. When the user scrubs to a different snapshot, only node visibility (opacity) changes — layout positions are not recomputed. The initial layout run is shown with a CRT-style 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' progress indicator on the canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7b33c306-b622-4957-9665-929113a88b27", + "displayId": "CR4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When artifact.json is missing any required top-level key (manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph, reports), the application must display a CRT-themed error state with a legible error message. No JavaScript exception may propagate to a blank screen or default browser error UI.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "7d2c4811-2f33-4e99-9452-391379b6b41c", + "displayId": "A8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Use a hierarchical/DAG layout (e.g. graphology-layout-dagre) that reflects phase ordering (grounding → shaping → pinning → defining_done) top-to-bottom, trading force-directed organic clustering for explicit phase structure.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7d6bad9c-f9e1-4b8f-8bb9-8982d1bb7319", + "displayId": "D18", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The macro view surfaces the regression/recovery narrative (X36) through explicit visual encoding of frame relationships: (1) The initial frame trunk is rendered in phosphor-green as the primary timeline spine. (2) Rederive frames branch rightward and are rendered in phosphor-amber, with their connecting edge labeled with the triggerImpasseId (shown as a displayId badge). (3) Fan-in record edges connecting rederive frames back to the trunk are rendered in a brighter green with an arrow labeled 'RECONCILED'. (4) Impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds are shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on the branch edges. (5) Perspective hub nodes (from the CSP model, X11) are shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards. (6) The nudgingActive flag on a rederive frame is shown as a 'NUDGED' indicator badge. Together these elements make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation cycle legible at a glance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7d982ad3-dc03-4660-82c6-a4cb8368e8e3", + "displayId": "X21", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view shows the different frames and how they relate over time, including per-frame LLM-generated summaries, lines connecting frames representing impasses/perspectives/derivation relationships, and the ability to zoom into a single frame to see which nodes changed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "7daa0a6c-1435-4bd2-9abc-667736b6b289", + "displayId": "R60", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Impasse hub nodes must render with a distinctive hexagonal shape in the micro-view Sigma graph, in addition to their warning-amber glow, making them visually distinguishable from other hub node types at a glance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "80011e24-30cb-413b-b4d6-e04e5a1d63b7", + "displayId": "CR59", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must use distinct visual encoding by type: trunk-to-rederive-branch edges (triggered by an impasse) must be drawn in warning amber and labeled with the triggerImpasseId rendered as a displayId badge; fan-in record edges reconnecting rederive frames to the baseline must be drawn in bright green and labeled 'RECONCILED'. Verified by inspecting the rendered color and label of each edge in the reference artifact's macro timeline.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "80b41ad0-f7d2-4ce3-b5ec-00dff2993f7f", + "displayId": "C5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Authentication and multi-user features are out of scope.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "8244d423-76cd-40c9-b09f-98362f7cd267", + "displayId": "RK7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "There is a tension between loading a single combined artifact.json (stakeholder preference) and loading individual artifact files from a directory path or URL prefix (also a stated requirement). These two loading models may need reconciliation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "831ea238-149b-4383-adb8-c2c6b4eff315", + "displayId": "D5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "At load time the UI builds an in-memory graph store from artifact.json using a flat index structure: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (Map), adjacency (Map), frameIndex (Map), snapshotIndex (Map), and derivedIndex (Map) built by joining validation.json errors to their source/target nodes. Lifecycle filter state is maintained as a reactive set of visible lifecycle values. The active node set for the micro view is derived from the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array. All indexes are built once on load; no re-parsing occurs during session.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "833e6368-46e9-4659-8c4e-3233fbb876a9", + "displayId": "R13", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, edge color must visually distinguish the three edge categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) in dim amber; workflow edges (produced, considered, selected, rejected, consequence, conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to, aggregates) in brighter green; structural edges (conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline, and all lineage edges) in muted cyan.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "834744d9-dcae-4306-b33d-0a9634ccd588", + "displayId": "R50", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The comparison view must render as a split overlay that temporarily replaces or expands the right detail panel. The left column must show the baseline node and the right column must show the candidate node. Differences in text, semantic role, epistemic status, and authority must be highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions and deletions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "837aabe8-6eaf-4b5e-80ba-0cab5f0be894", + "displayId": "G5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The app must operate entirely against statically loaded JSON artifact files with no backend, and must be deployable as a static site.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "83a93151-f2a1-4bcb-9464-d0d09b3910ba", + "displayId": "CR9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a node is selected, all three layout regions must be simultaneously visible: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, and right detail panel. Measuring computed widths of all three regions must return values greater than zero. No region may be hidden, collapsed, or overlaid by another during normal selected-node state.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "83b25525-1cb6-42db-b2fe-d31eeb7bc645", + "displayId": "DEC5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use Web Worker ForceAtlas2 layout computed at runtime, cached in sessionStorage.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "Force-directed layout naturally clusters semantically related nodes through the edge structure, which better serves G4's goal of understanding relationships than a rigid hierarchical layout. Pre-computing positions (alt 2) would bloat artifact.json and couple the bundler to layout logic that properly belongs in the UI. Hierarchical layout (alt 1) would produce a very tall graph given 376+ nodes across 4 phases and would degrade for the many cross-phase derived_from edges present in the reference dataset (per validation-report-context). Web Worker prevents UI jank during the ~1-2 second computation for the reference dataset size." + }, + { + "id": "844382fc-2fe9-4cff-89be-90b55d4e4be2", + "displayId": "X29", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers building the macro timeline view using WebGL so that future zoom-into-frame functionality is naturally achievable.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "84af919e-9e37-4851-8a3d-a06f3c60999c", + "displayId": "R33", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Pressing the Escape key must close the right detail panel and clear the current node selection. If a comparison overlay is open, Escape must close the comparison overlay and return to the detail panel rather than closing the detail panel.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "87b28bfe-eb96-4cd5-8670-b52298d679ca", + "displayId": "J3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Both File API drop zone and ?artifact= URL param are required to satisfy local-first and remote-hosting constraints simultaneously", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "justification", + "rationale": "X18 and X42 require local filesystem loading with zero configuration. C6 requires the loading mechanism to work when hosted remotely. RK6 identifies these as potentially conflicting. DEC2 resolves the conflict by specifying dual-path loading. These four premises jointly mandate both loading mechanisms — neither alone is sufficient." + }, + { + "id": "87b684c1-914c-4108-aa54-a40944e9f565", + "displayId": "T14", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A fan-in record captures the result of the reconciliation step where candidate branches are merged back into the active baseline after a fan-out/clean-room re-derivation cycle.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "87dae4b6-b7cf-4a98-8683-499c8dcf24db", + "displayId": "CR86", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking any clickable displayId pill within the Connections section (in any of the decision, impasse, or justification group rows) must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to the referenced node's id, causing the detail panel to re-render for that node and the main Sigma canvas selection highlight to move to that node. The panel history must allow the user to return to the previously selected node via browser back or a dedicated back control if provided.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "884d7a21-8b9e-482f-b416-fff0b37dc69d", + "displayId": "DEC12", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Tailwind theme tokens + CSS primitives for UI chrome; WebGL shader only for Sigma node glow. CSS blur filter used to approximate glow on HTML elements.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "Full CSS implementation (alt 1) was actually selected with a clarification: the node glow in Sigma is WebGL (per X40 and the graph-renderer decision), but all HTML UI elements use CSS box-shadow/text-shadow for glow effects — this is intentional. The visual gap between CSS glow (on panels, chips, buttons) and WebGL glow (on graph nodes) is acceptable and is bridged by matching the glow color palette. Attempting to route HTML element rendering through WebGL would be vastly over-engineered. The design system's value is in the Tailwind token vocabulary, the scanline overlay primitive, and the flicker-in keyframes, which together ensure no raw unstyled states exist (C7) and all transitions feel alive (C8)." + }, + { + "id": "88530d93-d355-41cd-8fd0-5e7c929738b7", + "displayId": "X23", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Per-frame LLM summaries will be pre-generated by the elicitation pipeline during artifact bundling and stored in FrameRecord or a companion structure within artifact.json; they are not generated at runtime by the UI.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "88cb3cc8-a901-4a37-b777-82f5a604e123", + "displayId": "D14", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Application state is managed using Zustand (a lightweight React state manager). A single store holds: loadedArtifact (the parsed artifact.json), all derived indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIndex), activeView ('micro' | 'macro'), selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState (lifecycle visibility, phase chips, role selection, search query), and comparisonState (active fan-in grouping). The store is initialized once on artifact load; all derived indexes are computed synchronously in a single pass and stored as plain Maps. React components subscribe to fine-grained store slices to minimize re-renders. No server state, no async store updates after load (C4).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8aaa4c90-8538-4068-9f46-6a88bbac1798", + "displayId": "CR52", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking any node in the provenance mini-graph must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to that node's id, causing the main detail panel to re-render for the clicked node and the main Sigma canvas selection to update accordingly. The mini-graph must then re-render to show the new node's upstream subgraph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "8d7e200b-796b-4b5a-aab4-5b5a779aad5b", + "displayId": "G1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The system must enable users to interactively explore a spec elicitation artifact as a read-only single-page web application.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "8de0aa42-cd56-4bbb-867b-10cce785c002", + "displayId": "D15", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Keyboard navigation covers panel controls only, not the Sigma canvas (per X28 and C11). Implemented bindings: Escape closes the detail panel and clears node selection; Tab / Shift-Tab moves focus between toolbar controls, filter chips, and the results list; Enter on a focused results-list row selects that node (opens detail panel); Arrow keys navigate between results list items when the list has focus; Escape from the comparison overlay closes comparison and returns to the detail panel. All interactive HTML elements use standard focus rings styled in phosphor-amber to remain visible on the dark background. The Sigma canvas itself has no keyboard event handlers; it receives only mouse and touch events.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8dfbb73c-9bfb-44b4-b5f0-5bfe18a471e6", + "displayId": "D8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The right detail panel activates on node click with a ~150ms CRT power-on flicker animation (opacity pulses 0→0.3→0.1→1 over 150ms via CSS keyframes). The panel has four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded: full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator (clean/suspect/conditional with cause links), kind-specific classification fields (semanticRole + epistemicStatus + authority for content nodes; hubType for hubs); (2) Connections — hub-type-specific relationship table: for decision hubs shows rationale prose, considered/selected/rejected/consequence edges grouped with linked displayIds per X35; for impasse hubs shows conflicting_input/resolved_by/spawned/refined_to; for justification hubs shows informed_by/produced; (3) Provenance — an embedded Sigma.js mini-graph (max ~50 upstream nodes) showing the full derivation chain per X25, with clickable nodes that navigate the main panel; (4) Validation — only shown when review status is not clean: lists suspect causeIds and conditional impasseIds with links, and lists any validation report errors touching this node's edges. Escape key closes the panel per X28.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8e2df6ba-4ceb-4063-a168-bc9ebbf6ad02", + "displayId": "R22", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The toolbar must contain lifecycle visibility toggles for archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes. Active nodes must always be visible and cannot be toggled off. When a lifecycle toggle is changed, node visibility must be updated via Sigma's node attribute API (setting hidden=true/false) rather than rebuilding the graphology graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "8effcdf0-3303-4565-85f7-8e5dfa7b8607", + "displayId": "X11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The perspective hub is modeled as a constraint satisfaction problem with axes, alternatives, constraints, and guarded impasses; perspectives are a presentation layer derived from the CSP solver, not the primary semantic unit.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "91583e14-811b-4a2d-ba91-021985f7e9dc", + "displayId": "C6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The file-loading mechanism must work when the app is hosted remotely. The app must not directly serve artifact files, because the website may be hosted remotely in the future.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "920e3325-de0b-41c9-832b-36bd12bf14ee", + "displayId": "CR35", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When multiple filter dimensions are active simultaneously (e.g., phase=shaping AND semanticRole=design AND authority=derived), the results list must contain only nodes satisfying all active conditions. Enabling a second filter must never increase the result count. Verified by: activating two mutually constraining filters against the reference artifact and asserting the result set is the mathematical intersection of each filter applied individually.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "922caeac-3d2b-4dc4-a12b-a6280146f7bb", + "displayId": "A10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Replace the sidebar filter panel with a command-palette (Cmd+K style) overlay for search, with graph-level filter controls only on the toolbar. Saves sidebar space but separates search results from filter controls and reduces discoverability.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "93511bd0-2fd0-4e0e-88d0-a179752fb71f", + "displayId": "A16", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Represent frames as super-nodes in the same Sigma.js instance as the micro graph, using Sigma's camera zoom to transition between macro and micro views. Avoids a separate WebGL context but conflates two very different data models in one renderer, making the frame-card UI elements (text, badges, annotation chips) very difficult to implement.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "940b3e95-2a17-4c0e-a48e-a45b767bb07a", + "displayId": "R58", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "All interactive HTML elements must use visible focus rings styled in phosphor-amber, ensuring keyboard focus is always visible on the dark background.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "95701f3e-fc72-4650-af3a-d256fd283875", + "displayId": "E4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The confirmed artifact file layout is: graph/ subdirectory containing nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, and snapshots.json; top-level containing manifest.json, sources.json, extracted-claims.json, and interventions.json.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "965b3e00-8777-4c2d-8f9a-3df670141c95", + "displayId": "CR58", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a frame card's summary field is null (as is the case for all frames in the current reference artifact), the summary region of the frame card must display a muted placeholder text 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' in dimmed monospace style. No JavaScript error, broken layout, or missing DOM element may result from a null summary. When a summary string is present, it must be rendered in its place without any code change.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "96c26b59-4762-4d9e-a25e-fc412b877be1", + "displayId": "T6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Authority identifies the source type of a node's claim. The four defined values are: stakeholder, technical, external, and derived.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "96c9136c-7612-4cae-9b9a-c43640697659", + "displayId": "R31", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The right detail panel must have four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded by default, showing full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator, and kind-specific classification fields; (2) Connections — hub-type-specific relationship tables; (3) Provenance — embedded Sigma.js mini-graph; (4) Validation — shown only when review status is not clean. The Identity section must always remain visible at the top.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "975f500c-d11b-4588-9977-d501841b07c6", + "displayId": "D10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The micro view is the default view on artifact load. It renders the full node+edge graph in Sigma.js with the snapshot selector in the top toolbar. The snapshot selector is a slider (with a numeric revision badge and timestamp label) that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions. On snapshot change, the active node set is recomputed from the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array: nodes not in activeNodeIds are rendered at near-zero opacity (effectively hidden) rather than removed from the Sigma graph, preserving topology for context. A 'Show inactive' toggle in the toolbar reveals archived/candidate/withdrawn nodes at reduced opacity per X32 and X33. The current snapshot's revision number and frameId(s) are shown as a status line below the slider.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "992d03ee-aadb-45a6-8d18-48ba7d1dae3a", + "displayId": "CR73", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the results list has focus and a row is highlighted via Arrow key navigation, pressing Enter must select that node: selectedNodeId in the Zustand store must be set to the row's node id, and the right detail panel must open for that node with the flicker animation. Verified by simulating ArrowDown then Enter on the results list and asserting the store update and panel appearance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "999ef140-f4e1-4d00-8e53-c09ae6d1598e", + "displayId": "A5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: A fullscreen canvas-first layout with no persistent sidebar; filter/search and detail panel appear as HUD overlays on top of the canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "99d84601-f5ff-4f31-b5ec-e03ee731d14b", + "displayId": "CR92", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a node with lifecycle='candidate' is selected in the micro-view graph and the detail panel is open, a 'Compare' button must be visible in the Identity section or the panel header. Nodes with lifecycle='active', 'archived', or 'withdrawn' must not show this button. Verified by selecting one candidate node and one active node from the reference artifact and asserting button presence/absence in each case.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "9af1e524-c758-46df-b631-17552b8e45ec", + "displayId": "X18", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers loading artifact.json from the user's local filesystem via the browser File API, with a landing screen presenting a file drop zone, requiring no server or URL.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "9af4e1c2-38ce-462c-a179-bcb4484496e4", + "displayId": "D12", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Side-by-side baseline/candidate comparison is triggered by: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view, or (2) selecting a node with lifecycle=candidate and clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel. The comparison opens as a split overlay that temporarily replaces the right detail panel (or expands to full-panel width). The left column shows the baseline node (or the best_selected grouping winner from fan-in-records.json), the right column shows the candidate node. Differences in text, semantic role, epistemic status, and authority are highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions/deletions. The fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) is shown between the two columns as a decision banner. All nodes in the grouping are accessible via a tab row above the split. The comparison panel has a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9d580e32-031b-47b3-a2bf-dad5ca4374ce", + "displayId": "X15", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers a CRT-inspired visual design language: a polished aesthetic evoking vintage phosphor displays with amber or green phosphor colors on dark backgrounds, subtle scanline textures, and gentle CRT glow/bloom effects on interactive elements.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "9f99690c-e542-49e9-b635-73da68e1c34a", + "displayId": "CR24", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "After artifact.json is parsed, all eight in-memory indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByEdgeId, edgeIssuesByNodeId, interventionsByNodeId) must be fully populated before the main explorer UI renders. No index build or re-parse operation may be triggered by user interaction after this initial pass. Verified by: instrumenting the store initializer and asserting all Maps are non-empty after load with zero subsequent re-build calls during a full interaction session.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a0fb3bbd-ef15-4691-8c94-6992861d75cd", + "displayId": "R23", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Application state must be managed in a single Zustand store containing: loadedArtifact, all derived indexes, activeView, selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState, and comparisonState. React components must subscribe to fine-grained store slices to prevent unnecessary re-renders during filter and hover interactions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a17616a3-b642-4972-b1c7-af84ff7085ef", + "displayId": "A22", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Show interventions only in the macro view frame cards, not in the node detail panel. Lower implementation cost (avoids the interventionsByNodeId join), but loses the ability to see which interventions targeted a specific node from that node's perspective.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "a21e716e-1db3-4129-8b4d-a3d78520527a", + "displayId": "X24", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers: a detail panel with CRT power-on flicker animation (~150ms) rather than slide-in; collapsible sections with most important information always visible at top; top section showing full node text, displayId, phase badge, lifecycle badge, and review status indicator.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a23802b4-cbb8-43ff-a73c-fd7b2e3bc35a", + "displayId": "CR10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Each boundary between the three layout regions must have a visible drag handle. Dragging a handle must resize the adjacent panels proportionally in real time, with both panels maintaining a non-zero minimum width throughout the drag. After release, the new widths must persist for the remainder of the session.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a23f84f0-5eb2-46be-909e-0dcf1577c6f1", + "displayId": "CR91", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For the reference artifact, the single snapshot at revision 4 lists all four frameIds in its frameIds array. When the snapshot slider is set to revision 4, the active node set must be derived from that snapshot's activeNodeIds array (376 active nodes). The status line below the slider must display revision 4 and all four frameId values (or their display equivalents). Verified by loading the reference artifact and reading the status line content.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a41d48dc-1906-4a3f-8abf-25c3cf3d10f7", + "displayId": "X22", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro timeline is laid out as a vertical timeline showing one narrative from top to bottom, branching out horizontally at derivation loops.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a4343ad4-efc4-4205-a647-9916905ac12e", + "displayId": "CR70", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Every interactive HTML element (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have a visually distinct hover state that intensifies glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and/or text-shadow. Verified by: programmatically triggering :hover on at least one element of each interactive type and asserting that the computed box-shadow or text-shadow value differs from the non-hovered state. No interactive element may have an identical computed style before and after hover.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a56b45a9-fd36-45ee-8484-b80ffea67446", + "displayId": "CR56", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The macro timeline must lay out the reference artifact's four frames correctly: the initial frame (mode=initial, id a03f944e) must appear on the main vertical trunk; the three rederive frames (ids 10f07753, b40fd568, b9236ccf, all with parentFrameId=a03f944e) must appear as horizontal siblings branching to the right at the same vertical level as each other, not as a vertical chain. Verified by inspecting the rendered positions of each frame card's center point on the WebGL canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a59d344e-855a-416b-9086-419c159fcafb", + "displayId": "RK3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The provenance mini-graph within the node detail panel is acknowledged to be complex to implement, particularly ensuring it remains visually coherent with the main graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a5cf85c8-afd8-4ddb-8945-85cda662625b", + "displayId": "R51", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The comparison view must display the fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) as a decision banner between the baseline and candidate columns. All nodes in the same fan-in grouping must be accessible via a tab row above the split columns.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a5f625e0-ecf0-4c54-aebd-1f418850cc8c", + "displayId": "X26", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder prefers displaying interventions in two places: in the node detail panel (showing which interventions targeted the node) and as annotations on frames in the macro timeline.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a5faaf21-281b-4061-8e3d-3730a4ee1d65", + "displayId": "R56", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The loading state, error state, and empty state (no artifact loaded) must each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments. No raw unstyled, blank, or default-browser-styled state may appear at any point during the application lifecycle.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a6203019-d360-4a29-a040-b905d890093c", + "displayId": "R40", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The toolbar must display a global validation summary badge showing the total count of validation errors from validation.json. The badge must pulse in amber when any errors are present.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a6309f59-39a3-43da-8f0b-4a8afd6a7f6d", + "displayId": "CR8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The production build output (vite build) must consist entirely of static files (HTML, JS, CSS, assets) with no server-side runtime requirement. Serving the dist/ directory from any static file host (e.g., GitHub Pages, S3, Netlify) must produce a fully functional application. Zero fetch() calls to a backend API may occur during normal operation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a7cd8811-64f2-44d6-ba86-59a08ebda2bf", + "displayId": "X4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The spec elicitation pipeline uses fan-out/fan-in with clean-room re-derivation to handle contradictions, a perspective hub (CSP model) to present design alternatives, and reconciliation to merge candidates into the active baseline.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "a8ccefdc-e29d-401b-8dfb-928098081dde", + "displayId": "DEC10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Build the macro timeline as a dedicated WebGL canvas (raw WebGL with a thin abstraction), separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X29 explicitly requires WebGL for the macro view to enable future zoom-into-frame. SVG/HTML (alt 1) cannot deliver a smooth zoom transition into the Sigma micro-graph. Reusing the Sigma instance (alt 2) conflates two incompatible data models and makes the rich frame-card UI (summaries, intervention chips, badges) nearly impossible within Sigma's node rendering model. A separate WebGL canvas gives full control over the frame-card visual language while keeping the door open for a seamless WebGL-to-WebGL zoom transition in a future iteration. The thin abstraction layer (rather than a full scene-graph library) keeps the bundle small and the rendering logic transparent." + }, + { + "id": "a8e38f19-3765-49d6-9d3d-5a568fe21b0a", + "displayId": "R28", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a search query is active, a results list must appear in the left sidebar below the filter controls, showing a scrollable list of matching nodes sorted by displayId. Each row must show the node's displayId, phase badge, semantic role or hub type badge, and truncated node text. The results list must remain visible simultaneously with the highlighted graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a8ff0ff7-9080-4195-80c2-14930fc976fa", + "displayId": "T17", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "artifact.json is the single bundled output file combining all pipeline output files, loaded by the explorer UI to provide all graph data, metadata, and reports.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a9217c54-4ab2-4cca-8809-ba75414364e7", + "displayId": "DEC1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Bundle all pipeline output into a single artifact.json; the UI loads only this file.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "A single flat JSON file satisfies C6 (remote hosting compatibility) and X18 (File API drop zone) simultaneously: the user drops one file regardless of whether the app is local or remote-hosted. Lazy directory loading (alt 1) fails C6 when hosted remotely because browsers cannot access local filesystem paths. ZIP (alt 2) adds a decompression dependency and is less transparent/inspectable than plain JSON. The bundler lives in spec-elicitation (Deno/TypeScript), matching the existing toolchain. The merged schema is straightforward given the known file set (E4)." + }, + { + "id": "a9785093-7e00-4d40-935b-58495cc90b29", + "displayId": "CR93", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A user who opens the application for the first time in a browser with no query parameters must be presented with the drop zone landing screen immediately, with no configuration dialogs, login prompts, URL entry fields, or setup steps. The drop zone must be the sole interactive element required to load an artifact. Verified by loading the app with no query params and asserting only the drop zone and optional file-picker button are the primary interactive elements.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a97b3bd3-3948-4840-a2bd-d4c083a37dcb", + "displayId": "CR88", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the macro timeline, the initial frame card (mode=initial, id a03f944e) and the main trunk line connecting it must be rendered in phosphor-green (#39FF14 or the defined phosphor-green token). Rederive frame cards must be rendered in phosphor-amber (#FFB000). Verified by sampling the rendered WebGL pixel color at the center of the initial frame card and at the center of one rederive frame card and comparing against the defined theme token values.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "aa4d0880-7378-426d-a66b-82215aafd407", + "displayId": "X47", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Each intervention record in interventions.json carries: id, frameId, phase, kind (e.g. accept_candidate), targetNodeIds array, text (nullable), createdAt. Interventions are associated with a frame, not directly with individual nodes — the targetNodeIds array provides the node linkage.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "aae376c6-719b-4c7d-b16f-c6b1249d6966", + "displayId": "CR16", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, nodes must be visually colored with four distinct phosphor hues corresponding to the four derivation phases: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done. The same four colors must appear on phase badge UI elements in the sidebar results list, the toolbar filter chips, and the detail panel phase badge — verified by comparing computed CSS color values across all locations.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "aae3cae7-3e97-403a-a2bd-bd9d97aaf147", + "displayId": "T5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Epistemic status expresses the evidentiary basis for a node's claim. The four defined values are: observed, asserted, assumed, and inferred.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "ac42e5e0-54ed-4c0a-89e0-06cc229c6e34", + "displayId": "CR38", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Each row in the search results list must display: the node's displayId, a phase badge styled in the correct phase color, a semantic role badge (for content nodes) or hub type badge (for hub nodes), and a truncated version of the node text. Verified by rendering the reference artifact, searching for a known term, and asserting all four elements are present in each result row's DOM.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ae3615df-33cd-4252-95aa-d4a0549753b3", + "displayId": "CR90", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the user switches from Micro view to Macro view and back to Micro view, the filter state (active phase chips, role checkboxes, search query, lifecycle toggles) must be identical to what it was before switching. The Sigma canvas must restore the highlighting/dimming state reflecting the preserved filter. Verified by applying a multi-filter, switching views, and asserting the Zustand filterState is unchanged.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "af86d506-7b3d-4e8a-85a1-7d7bcbaeb355", + "displayId": "CR81", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Loading a malformed artifact.json (e.g., a file with a valid JSON structure but missing the 'graph' key) must render a CRT-styled error screen with a descriptive message identifying the missing key. The error screen must use phosphor-amber or phosphor-text color on a phosphor-dim background, use the monospace font, and must not display any raw browser error dialog or white screen.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b104a0b3-14f1-4493-989e-eacc06ad901e", + "displayId": "CR14", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Inspecting the Sigma.js canvas element in the DOM must confirm it is a element with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl') or getContext('webgl2') must return a non-null value). The application must not fall back to SVG or Canvas2D rendering for the micro-view graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "b12c53e9-48a5-4fdc-8c1b-fb2183e2f42f", + "displayId": "CR20", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, node opacity must match lifecycle state: active nodes at 100% opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% (±5%); archived nodes at approximately 20% (±5%); withdrawn nodes at approximately 10% (±5%). Sampling one node of each lifecycle from the reference artifact and measuring the rendered alpha value via the WebGL shader uniform or Sigma attribute must confirm the correct opacity for each.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b143239a-1309-4f0a-b67c-546b22497481", + "displayId": "CR63", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the Connections section of the detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section must list all intervention records that reference the selected node in their targetNodeIds array. Each entry must show: intervention kind, frameId (rendered as a link that activates the macro view focused on that frame), and createdAt timestamp. For a node not referenced by any intervention, the sub-section must either be absent or show an empty state message.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b1838b3a-5f61-4503-a40b-518fad523da2", + "displayId": "CR69", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Every text-bearing element in the application — node text, displayIds, data values, filter chips, badge labels, panel headers, results list rows, and toolbar controls — must render in a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent). Inspecting the computed font-family of a representative sample of 10 distinct element types must return a monospace font in all cases. No element may render in the browser default sans-serif or serif font.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b43b8d63-6e89-45ad-80be-c473ae4a81c6", + "displayId": "DEC2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Primary loading via browser File API drop zone; secondary loading via ?artifact= URL query param for remote sharing.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "File API drop zone satisfies X18 and X42 (zero config, local filesystem). The URL query param resolves RK6 (remote hosting compatibility) without complicating the primary path. URL-only (alt) violates X42. This dual-path design means both local and remote artifact access work against a static-hosted app, fully satisfying C6." + }, + { + "id": "b6006dc8-8e31-4741-9549-c4e480fd1687", + "displayId": "R29", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Filter and selection state changes must be debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma canvas refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders during text search input.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "b68ebf73-4d0b-4f5a-b422-27d40f1d8b26", + "displayId": "R4", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When artifact.json is successfully parsed, the application must transition to the main explorer view with a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content. When the app is in the file-drop landing state, no raw unstyled or blank screen may appear.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b6a2accb-efd2-41de-a039-a21d3b0c9c93", + "displayId": "X41", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A subtle scanline CSS overlay sits above the WebGL canvas to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b70ec3f3-d89a-4151-98e7-83311efe5324", + "displayId": "CR82", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The phase color used for a node's glow in the Sigma micro-view graph must exactly match the color used for that node's phase badge in the detail panel Identity section, the phase chip in the sidebar filter panel, and the phase badge in the results list row. Extracting the RGB value of each location for a known node (e.g., a grounding-phase node) must return identical values across all four locations.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b7143302-7833-4529-beb6-b3b5287cce10", + "displayId": "CR48", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For a justification hub node, the Connections section must render a PREMISES group (nodes via 'informed_by' edges) and a CONCLUSIONS group (nodes via 'produced' edges). Each entry in both groups must be a clickable pill that navigates the detail panel to the referenced node. Verified by mounting the detail panel for a known justification hub node and asserting both groups are present with correct node references.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b774373e-15fb-42f6-b2ba-0788937bee67", + "displayId": "R10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The micro-view graph must be rendered using Sigma.js v3 with a WebGL backend. The renderer must support interactive frame rates for the full reference dataset of 761 total nodes and 2,662 edges.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b841eee1-255b-4c89-9012-3fd2edcd8224", + "displayId": "CR17", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, every node with kind='content' must render as a circle and every node with kind='hub' must render as a diamond. Sampling at least 20 nodes of each kind from the reference artifact and inspecting their rendered shapes via the Sigma node program must confirm the correct geometry for all sampled nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "b8a6d44f-03f9-4623-8d50-a073b6029c82", + "displayId": "J1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "All micro-view design choices form a coherent, implementable system against the reference artifact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "justification", + "rationale": "The graph-renderer-design (Sigma/WebGL), graph-data-model-design (in-memory indexes), graph-layout-design (Web Worker ForceAtlas2), filter-search-design (Zustand-driven opacity), micro-view-snapshot-design (opacity-based snapshot scrubbing), and performance-optimization-design (debouncing, hidden attribute) all interact without conflict: Sigma's node attribute API supports both opacity and hidden, ForceAtlas2 via graphology is the standard companion to Sigma, and Zustand's slice subscriptions prevent unnecessary Sigma refreshes. The reference dataset (761 total nodes, 2662 edges per validation-report-context) is within Sigma's documented performance envelope for WebGL rendering." + }, + { + "id": "b9676c28-7093-4d9d-b087-ab9e8510715f", + "displayId": "R15", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must be rendered with a per-node phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader. The glow intensity must increase on hover and on selection, driven by shader uniforms updated in response to pointer events.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "b9ea2a3b-7912-41ce-9409-ed7b58403f55", + "displayId": "RK2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A WebGL-based renderer gives less fine-grained control over individual node appearance compared to SVG-based alternatives, which may limit certain visual design options.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ba5b1153-46e6-41f2-a0f5-db11e133ad7e", + "displayId": "DEC15", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Show interventions in both the macro frame cards and the node detail panel, with a pre-computed interventionsByNodeId join index.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X26 explicitly requires both locations. RK4 acknowledges the higher implementation cost but the stakeholder's preference is clear. The interventionsByNodeId Map is a simple O(n) pass over the interventions array at load time and adds negligible cost. Macro-only display (alt 1) would mean a user viewing a candidate node has no way to see that it was accepted by a human intervention without leaving the detail panel to find the frame — a significant navigation burden." + }, + { + "id": "bb8865c5-273b-49c5-ae54-05d59170ed86", + "displayId": "X45", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The smoke-webhook artifact has 4 frames: one initial frame (mode=initial, entryPhase=grounding, no parent) and three rederive frames (mode=rederive, entryPhase=shaping, all sharing the same triggerImpasseId, all parented to the initial frame). The three rederive frames form siblings at attemptNumber 0, 1, 2 — not a linear chain. The last rederive frame (attemptNumber=2) has nudgingActive=true. Snapshots reference all 4 frameIds in a single checkpoint at revision 4.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "bc04ddf7-00b0-4a5e-a016-61eaa0a4b9b4", + "displayId": "DEC11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Split-panel overlay triggered from fan-in records or candidate node detail, showing text diff and fan-in rationale.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "The graph overlay alternative (alt 1) is impractical at the reference dataset scale: 288 candidate nodes rendered simultaneously with 376 active nodes would saturate the canvas and the AND-filter dimming model would conflict with comparison highlighting. The split-panel approach isolates the comparison to the specific grouping being examined (per fan-in-records groupings structure), which matches how reconciliation actually works in the pipeline. The fan-in rationale is the key semantic bridge between candidate and baseline and deserves a prominent display position, which the split panel's center banner provides." + }, + { + "id": "bc3639b0-9513-42b5-8a98-91b638c5b615", + "displayId": "D20", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Performance is managed through four mechanisms: (1) Web Worker layout: ForceAtlas2 runs off the main thread (covered in graph-layout-design). (2) Sigma render batching: filter and selection state changes are debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders during search. (3) Candidate/archived node toggling: when lifecycle visibility toggles change, node visibility is updated via Sigma's node attribute API (setting hidden=true/false) rather than rebuilding the graphology graph, which is O(nodes) not O(edges). (4) Provenance mini-graph depth cap: upstream traversal is capped at 50 nodes / depth-4 (covered in provenance-mini-graph-design). These four mechanisms together bound worst-case interaction latency for the reference dataset (376 active + 288 candidate + 88 archived nodes, 2662 edges).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bc7b99b9-6c05-4f2c-870c-b52165c11a70", + "displayId": "A12", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Show node detail in a bottom drawer that expands upward, preserving the full left-right canvas width. Works well on wide monitors but reduces vertical canvas space significantly and is inconsistent with the three-region layout design.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bfcefb45-2d7c-4032-94dd-6a255c749ddb", + "displayId": "X13", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The explorer UI will live as a sibling package at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c15e5864-a302-4bb1-bae7-f1faf3ea4793", + "displayId": "CR79", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A browser network log captured during a full interaction session (artifact load, graph exploration, filtering, detail panel, comparison view) must show zero requests to any API endpoint or server beyond the optional initial artifact.json fetch (when using the ?artifact= URL param). All data operations must be resolved from the in-memory indexes. Verified using browser DevTools Network tab or a network interception test.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c17839c3-0f58-46e3-8bc7-0cd193dd8f06", + "displayId": "E1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 376 active nodes, 88 archived nodes, 288 candidate nodes, and 9 withdrawn nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "c3f0c3d7-3358-4e68-90ac-dde65943ade0", + "displayId": "X36", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The derivation story view must clearly show the regression/recovery narrative: impasse discovered → clean-room re-derivation → fan-out → perspective selection → reconciliation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c4629859-3a41-4b7b-9e99-c13fd9ad231a", + "displayId": "X30", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The spec-elicitation-ui project is in early design and planning. No implementation decisions beyond the tech stack (Vite, React, Tailwind) have been confirmed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c4ed6841-d780-4112-86c7-9f0c3f567484", + "displayId": "CR37", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a search query is entered, matching nodes must be highlighted in the Sigma canvas (full intensity) simultaneously with a scrollable results list appearing in the sidebar below the filter controls. Both the canvas highlight state and the results list must be visible at the same time without any tab switch or mode change. The results list must be sorted by displayId.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c633f358-4531-4b0a-8067-6a9f771747b3", + "displayId": "R46", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display intervention annotation chips on its right edge, one chip per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip must show the intervention kind and a count of targetNodeIds. Hovering a chip must show a tooltip listing the targetNodeIds as human-readable displayIds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c6c5435d-5ec2-447e-b490-ba09650ff0fd", + "displayId": "DEC6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Persistent left sidebar filter panel with inline results list.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X38 explicitly requires that search highlight nodes in the graph AND show a results list simultaneously — a command palette (alt 1) collapses after selection and cannot maintain a persistent results list alongside the live graph. The sidebar keeps all filter dimensions (phase, role, lifecycle, authority, epistemic status) visible and adjustable without modal interruption, which is essential for exploratory navigation of a 376+ node graph. AND-logic across all active filters (X27) is most natural to communicate in a persistent panel where users can see all active filter chips at once." + }, + { + "id": "c812a1ef-102d-4c30-8ceb-a31730de5074", + "displayId": "R42", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro timeline must lay out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on a main trunk. Rederive frames must branch horizontally to the right of their parent frame as sibling columns at the same vertical level. The reference artifact's structure (one initial frame with three sibling rederive frames, all sharing the same triggerImpasseId) must be correctly represented as horizontal siblings, not a linear chain.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "cc2a3f36-c70a-45e7-b496-fb1981f1a7f7", + "displayId": "X1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Kael is an AI assistant with persistent memory, built as a CLI tool using TypeScript, Effect, and Deno.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "cd1dd2be-8462-4c62-b652-44b59f6e3337", + "displayId": "CR83", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The full-text search input must match nodes whose text field contains the query string (case-insensitive) AND nodes whose displayId contains the query string. A search for 'DEC' must return all decision hub nodes whose displayId begins with 'DEC'. A search for a term appearing only in node text (e.g. 'circuit breaker') must return those nodes. A search for a string present in neither field must return an empty results list with an appropriate empty-state message.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "cdc3d5d1-756b-47c0-b25b-c5ff4b57f4ef", + "displayId": "D19", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Validation report data (from reports/validation in artifact.json) is integrated as follows: (1) At load time a validationIssuesByEdgeId Map is built from validation.json errors. Since errors are edge-centric (per validation-report-context), a secondary edgeIssuesByNodeId Map is derived by walking each errored edge's source and target nodeIds. (2) In the micro-view graph, nodes with validation issues are rendered with a red-tinted glow halo in addition to their normal phase-color glow, implemented as a second glow pass in the WebGL shader. (3) In the node detail panel, the Validation section lists all errors touching edges incident to this node, showing rule, severity, message, and the edge's type and direction. (4) A global validation summary badge in the toolbar shows total error count and pulses amber when errors exist.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "cf47efd4-464f-4b18-8143-3e4a60ff70f0", + "displayId": "R57", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Keyboard navigation must be restricted to HTML panel controls only. The Sigma WebGL canvas must have no keyboard event handlers. The implemented keyboard bindings must include: Escape closes the detail panel and clears selection (or closes comparison overlay); Tab/Shift-Tab moves focus between toolbar controls, filter chips, and results list; Enter on a focused results-list row selects that node; Arrow keys navigate between results-list items when the list has focus.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "cf549ad5-9129-414c-9d8b-334ada0653e1", + "displayId": "R6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The application must be deployable as a static site with no server-side runtime. All artifact data must be derived from the client-loaded artifact.json; no API calls to a backend are permitted.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d0585d04-1221-4d00-b8d6-78ce31be5074", + "displayId": "E2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 2,662 edges across 17 distinct edge types.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "d08c48d6-6a5e-4e73-8e55-b6057e2f50aa", + "displayId": "R25", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain the following controls: (1) a full-text search input matching against node text and displayId; (2) phase filter chips for all four phases (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done); (3) semantic role multi-select checkboxes for all ten roles (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk); (4) hub type toggle (all / decision / justification / impasse / perspective); (5) epistemic status chips for all four values (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred); (6) authority chips for all four values (stakeholder, technical, external, derived); (7) lifecycle visibility toggles mirroring the toolbar toggles.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d1f4da1a-2d4b-42ae-a8e7-8a416b61e27e", + "displayId": "D16", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Because FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field (RK5, E5), the macro view frame cards gracefully degrade: if a frame has no summary, the summary region displays a muted placeholder reading 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' in a dimmed monospace style consistent with the CRT aesthetic. The UI treats the summary field as optional throughout — no runtime error, no broken layout. When the pipeline schema extension is implemented and summaries are present in artifact.json, the UI renders them without any code change.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d22330b5-252d-47db-b5b0-c316aa862284", + "displayId": "CR72", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Pressing Tab repeatedly from the toolbar must cycle focus through all interactive controls in order: toolbar controls, filter chips in the sidebar, and results list rows. Pressing Shift-Tab must reverse the direction. Focus must never become trapped or jump to the Sigma WebGL canvas. Verified by simulating Tab keystrokes in a jsdom or browser test environment and asserting focused element identity at each step.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d30fd255-e758-488e-9728-f2c279cce272", + "displayId": "CR68", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The Tailwind configuration must define all five CRT theme tokens with exact hex values: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F), and phosphor-text (#FFD580). Verified by reading tailwind.config.* and asserting each token name and value is present. At runtime, inspecting the computed background-color of the landing page body must return a value matching #1A1A0F (phosphor-dim).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d3423b02-781f-438c-96db-efe0f6704511", + "displayId": "C1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The app is strictly read-only. Editing nodes or edges is explicitly out of scope.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d3b6561b-fc04-4743-aff1-4ea909eb7f48", + "displayId": "R47", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Connections section of the detail panel must include a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section listing all intervention records that reference the current node in their targetNodeIds array. Each entry must show the intervention kind, frameId (linked to the corresponding frame in the macro view), and createdAt timestamp. The interventionsByNodeId join must be pre-computed at load time.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d4e02902-7c00-48c8-8ff8-9b5a5fe32557", + "displayId": "CR75", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Running the Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) against the smoke-webhook reference artifact directory must produce a single artifact.json file whose top-level structure contains exactly the keys: manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph (with sub-keys nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots), and reports (with sub-key validation). The resulting file must be valid JSON parseable by JSON.parse() without error.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "d57e230d-c4bf-459d-b509-c79e7e6e2bbf", + "displayId": "D26", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Justification hub nodes (hubType='justification') render in the detail panel's Connections section as: (1) a 'PREMISES' group showing nodes connected by 'informed_by' edges (the upstream support nodes); (2) a 'CONCLUSIONS' group showing nodes connected by 'produced' edges (what this justification produced). The justification's text (its rationale statement) is shown in the Identity section as the primary text. This mirrors the ATMS-style justification model from the pipeline and enables users to trace exactly what combination of premises produced a given conclusion.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d60948e4-2cb2-4fcb-ba1d-7fc2805337aa", + "displayId": "CR3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the application is loaded with a ?artifact= query parameter, it must fetch the artifact.json from that URL via fetch(), skip the drop zone entirely, and transition directly to the main explorer view. No file selection is required from the user.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d60afc71-8e07-40e9-9dca-aa04ea13ba01", + "displayId": "A14", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Replace the snapshot slider with a dropdown menu listing each snapshot by revision number and timestamp. More explicit labeling but slower to scrub through revisions sequentially.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d7439d95-3599-4f27-864d-6c755034eaf2", + "displayId": "CR71", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Every interactive HTML element must display a visible focus ring styled in phosphor-amber (#FFB000) when it receives keyboard focus. Verified by: tabbing through all interactive elements in the toolbar, filter panel, and results list, and asserting that the focused element's outline or box-shadow computed value includes a color matching #FFB000. No interactive element may have an invisible or default-browser focus indicator.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d7d16bd2-3db4-42ea-80fb-aef428fce13e", + "displayId": "T10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Edge types are organized into six categories: hub-generic edges, decision hub edges, perspective hub edges, impasse hub edges, content edges, and lineage edges.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "d8ea7ec4-0892-42af-b03b-630540619336", + "displayId": "T7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Review status is a tagged union on nodes with three variants: 'clean' (no issues), 'suspect' (with causeIds indicating problems), and 'conditional' (with impasseIds indicating unresolved dependencies).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "d9b40f9f-4124-4dba-a5a7-d17ad59db135", + "displayId": "C10", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The subgraph zoom-into-frame feature for the macro view can be deferred to a later iteration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "da0e348f-6b31-4eac-ad4b-bd4423bfd7a4", + "displayId": "CR29", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a range slider whose min and max correspond to the lowest and highest revision numbers present in the artifact's snapshots array. The slider must display a numeric revision badge and a human-readable timestamp label for the currently selected snapshot. A status line below the slider must show the revision number and the frameId(s) associated with that snapshot.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "da42d489-5081-441e-95a3-1021b7d7b341", + "displayId": "R37", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Provenance section of the detail panel must render a second independent Sigma.js instance in approximately 280px of panel height, showing the upstream derivation subgraph for the selected node. Traversal must follow support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards from the focal node. Traversal must be exhaustive for chains of 50 or fewer upstream nodes, and capped at depth 4 for larger chains. The focal node must appear at full glow. Ancestors must be laid out using graphology-layout-dagre in left-to-right derivation direction. Clicking any node in the mini-graph must navigate the main detail panel to that node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "dad3bdd6-f121-4e52-a0da-221467815455", + "displayId": "CR94", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The landing page drop zone must be visually styled with a phosphor-glowing dashed border (using the phosphor-amber or phosphor-green color token), a scanline texture, and dark background consistent with the CRT aesthetic. No element on the landing page may render with default browser styling, white background, or unstyled text. The drop zone must provide a visible affordance (e.g., icon and label) indicating file drop or selection.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "dbb68b83-ad5c-482d-b3eb-3f9adfa3797e", + "displayId": "CR51", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL node program class as the main micro-view graph. Node colors, glow style, and shape encoding (circle for content, diamond for hub) must be visually identical between the two Sigma instances. Verified by comparing the Sigma program constructor reference used in both instances — they must be the same class.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "dc2d3bcd-b447-45bb-8624-b075030ad1dc", + "displayId": "CR44", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Pressing the Escape key while the detail panel is open (and no comparison overlay is open) must close the detail panel and set selectedNodeId to null in the Zustand store. The canvas must expand to fill the vacated space. Pressing Escape when both the comparison overlay and the detail panel are open must close only the comparison overlay and leave the detail panel visible.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "dcfa6ace-e22e-46db-8345-52ae36e6641f", + "displayId": "DEC13", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use Zustand for application state management.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "Zustand's slice-based subscription model is ideal for a read-only explorer: the graph canvas subscribes only to filter/selection state, the detail panel subscribes only to selectedNodeId, and the macro view subscribes only to activeView. This minimizes re-renders from hover and filter interactions on a 376+ node dataset. Redux (alt 1) is over-engineered for a read-only, single-load app with no async mutations. React Context (alt 2) would cause cascading re-renders on every filter keystroke unless heavily memoized, adding complexity that Zustand handles automatically." + }, + { + "id": "de005196-3cd4-43df-9d79-c366db8991d5", + "displayId": "A11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Open node detail as a full-screen modal overlay rather than a persistent side panel. Maximizes reading space but destroys the graph context while the detail is open, preventing navigation by clicking nodes in the background.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "de3320d0-c61f-40f4-8d61-cacde8810c7f", + "displayId": "CR50", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the upstream derivation chain of the selected node contains more than 50 nodes, the provenance mini-graph traversal must be capped at depth 4 from the focal node. When the chain is 50 nodes or fewer, traversal must be exhaustive. Verified by: selecting a deep-chain node from the reference artifact, confirming the mini-graph renders no more than depth-4 ancestors; then selecting a shallow-chain node and confirming all ancestors are rendered.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "df2b015c-c2aa-46af-9890-ff62cd83fdc7", + "displayId": "X9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The CRT motif reinforces the idea of looking into a system's internals — it is the stakeholder's stated rationale for the visual design language.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "df508eef-acea-4e2e-a360-166fbad65fe6", + "displayId": "CR39", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Typing rapidly into the search input must not trigger a Sigma canvas refresh on every keystroke. Measuring Sigma refresh calls during a burst of 10 keystrokes within 100ms must show no more than one refresh call, occurring no sooner than 16ms after the last keystroke. Verified by spying on the Sigma refresh method in a test environment.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "e07e924c-2da9-4c78-9303-4faab90cfa84", + "displayId": "CR54", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The toolbar must display a validation summary badge showing the total error count from validation.json. For the reference artifact, this count must match the number of entries in the errors array in validation.json. When errors are present, the badge must have a pulsing amber CSS animation. The badge must be present from the moment the main explorer renders, before any node is selected.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e26094ff-6cd1-4e1c-bffa-99afbcd45caf", + "displayId": "X6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The spec elicitation source code lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "e2acef4e-0371-4f46-b034-8db42007c8ec", + "displayId": "T9", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Edges in the graph are organized into categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) carry epistemic weight; workflow edges (produced, resolved_by, selected) carry operational provenance; structural edges (alternative_to, conflicts_with) are informational with no derivation direction.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "e44a0219-4ad9-4221-9dd4-42938da66523", + "displayId": "T2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A semantic role classifies the epistemic function of a content node. The ten defined values are: goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, and risk.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "e5168649-a197-4ecb-9628-32012569cd58", + "displayId": "R14", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, lifecycle state must be encoded as node opacity: active nodes at full opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% opacity; archived nodes at approximately 20% opacity; withdrawn nodes at approximately 10% opacity.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e61e54b8-9365-431a-b960-c687e2490200", + "displayId": "CR6", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "At every point in the application lifecycle — loading, error, and empty (no artifact loaded) — the UI must display a bespoke CRT-themed treatment. Inspecting the DOM during each state must show no element with default browser font (sans-serif or serif), no unstyled text, and no blank white areas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e631b421-6ec1-4020-be23-6503d9bb5934", + "displayId": "C7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The CRT visual motif must feel like a beautiful, refined instrument — not a retro novelty. The UI must have no janky transitions or raw unstyled states anywhere.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e63a500a-ae5e-493b-a8cc-66bda2c566c0", + "displayId": "R19", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation for the micro-view graph must run in a Web Worker so the UI thread is not blocked. During layout computation, the canvas must display a CRT-styled 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' progress indicator. Layout positions must be cached in sessionStorage keyed by specId and snapshotRevision after the first computation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "e6af7ee6-18be-473e-910f-47917af3cf96", + "displayId": "X39", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The node detail panel shows kind-specific fields in its first collapsible section: for content nodes this is semantic role, epistemic status, and authority; for hub nodes this is hub type.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ea3836bc-20dd-461e-9371-6e6a4c613ee1", + "displayId": "X19", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The stakeholder has defined two fundamental visualization views: a micro view and a macro view, both of which are required.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ea7d338a-b63d-48b6-8c97-83a84ef6a383", + "displayId": "CR78", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When archived nodes are made visible via the lifecycle toggle, they must render at approximately 20% opacity, visually distinct from active nodes (100% opacity) and candidate nodes (~60% opacity). The dimmed appearance must be consistent with the CRT aesthetic (no bright white glow on archived nodes). Verified by enabling the archived toggle and visually comparing an archived node (e.g., D22 / id 00cfa668) against an active neighbor.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "eafe6c9d-5f51-4a00-b14f-448626621cb1", + "displayId": "X46", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The validation.json report has a flat structure: timestamp, totalNodes, totalEdges, totalFrames, and an errors array where each error has rule, severity, message, and edgeId. The predominant error rule observed is 'phase-stratification' flagging derived_from edges that cross phase boundaries (e.g. shaping→grounding, pinning→grounding). The report is edge-centric, not node-centric — issues reference edgeIds, not nodeIds directly.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "ebf6a7a7-6c9b-4468-9c67-bf84ac07340b", + "displayId": "R59", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "A Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) must merge all pipeline output files into artifact.json with the schema: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. For each FrameRecord, the bundler must add summary: null when no summary is present, so the UI always receives a well-typed FrameRecord.summary field of type string | null.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "ec63c82a-a368-4002-b508-dd4cf84c6588", + "displayId": "X2", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Kael maintains a memory graph with nodes connected by typed edges such as reinforces, derived_from, and tension_with, and has sleep phases (nap, dream) that consolidate and maintain it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "ed090d75-5c98-4171-8853-469fc8efebf3", + "displayId": "X33", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Archived nodes must be visually distinct from active nodes (e.g. dimmed or reduced opacity) in a manner consistent with the CRT aesthetic.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ed245c0f-7379-4ba5-8d7a-cbc02b0feba0", + "displayId": "R53", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Tailwind configuration must define the following CRT theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F) for backgrounds, and phosphor-text (#FFD580) for body text. These tokens must be used consistently across all UI components.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ed960b87-4486-42e9-aadf-fd5a66f85775", + "displayId": "T18", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A provenance chain is the full upstream derivation path for a node: what it was derived from, what informed it, and what source material (quotes, claims) it is grounded in.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "edd48929-bde2-4c7d-b2c1-f8813de9f454", + "displayId": "A7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Use Cytoscape.js with its WebGL renderer (cytoscape-gl or pixi.js extension). Richer built-in layout algorithms and compound node support, but less control over custom shader effects and heavier bundle size.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ee5b4a6b-b52c-4572-b3ad-666de5b6e633", + "displayId": "G3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view must enable users to understand how the spec developed over time — not just how it looks at a single point — showing the narrative from initial grounding through derivation loops and reconciliation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ef23345e-bb9e-451e-bedb-3c69e526b44e", + "displayId": "E5", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field; a schema extension is needed to add per-frame LLM-generated summaries to the artifact.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ef2cbaef-0015-419d-b9b7-bcfb71be2003", + "displayId": "R1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The application must accept artifact.json via browser File API drag-and-drop or file picker on a full-screen landing page, without requiring any server upload or URL configuration from the user.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ef4a77be-faf3-40be-be53-61704a2894e2", + "displayId": "X32", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Active nodes are shown by default in the UI. The user can toggle archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes to see the full history.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f014c34e-b889-4609-a5ae-cd156f6fef80", + "displayId": "X7", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The smoke-test artifact for the webhook delivery system spec is located at /Users/bmahmoud/Desktop/smoke-webhook/ and serves as the reference dataset for development.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "f15ff085-f0da-4028-a182-1219995321bd", + "displayId": "CR77", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "On initial load, only active nodes must be visible in the Sigma canvas. The three lifecycle toggles (archived, candidate, withdrawn) must each independently control visibility of their respective node sets. Toggling 'candidate' on must make the 288 candidate nodes from the reference artifact visible at ~60% opacity. Toggling it off must hide them. Active nodes must remain visible regardless of any toggle state.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f2061db9-a203-4ac3-bcac-7f8dd977420c", + "displayId": "T12", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A frame is a unit of derivation history in the pipeline. The macro view shows frames and how they relate over time. Frames may carry LLM-generated summaries describing what happened and what was important.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "f2f40857-d84a-4f06-ac82-99872c1b09e1", + "displayId": "R11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "In the micro-view graph, node color must encode derivation phase using four distinct phosphor hues — one for each of the four phases (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done). The same four-hue palette must be used consistently across the micro graph, the provenance mini-graph, and all phase badge UI elements.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f355f471-b989-4b99-9abf-861f334315fc", + "displayId": "X35", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "For a decision node, the detail view must show its rationale, considered alternatives (via 'considered' edges), selection/rejection outcomes (via 'selected'/'rejected' edges), and produced consequences (via 'consequence'/'produced' edges), with traceability back to grounding inputs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f3cbd5ab-2429-46f6-adf7-08b5fad8f390", + "displayId": "CR49", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When the Provenance section is expanded for a selected node, a second independent Sigma.js instance must be mounted in a container of approximately 280px height. The mini-graph must render the upstream derivation subgraph of the selected node, traversing support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards. The focal node must appear at full glow intensity. Ancestor layout must use graphology-layout-dagre in left-to-right direction.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f40b9a21-7a26-414e-9b18-a2872cda67d8", + "displayId": "T3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A hub type identifies a node that aggregates structural reasoning rather than carrying content. The four defined hub types are: justification, decision, impasse, and perspective.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "f6965314-28a8-4ba3-846d-a60b1ba4925f", + "displayId": "R18", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "At artifact load time, the application must build the following in-memory indexes in a single synchronous pass: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (Map), adjacency (Map), frameIndex (Map), snapshotIndex (Map), validationIssuesByEdgeId (Map), edgeIssuesByNodeId (Map), and interventionsByNodeId (Map). No re-parsing or re-indexing must occur during the session.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "f7eb36e5-eb3f-40ac-9711-a883e2482968", + "displayId": "A20", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Use React Context + useReducer with no external state library. Zero dependencies, but Context re-renders on every state change unless carefully memoized — with a 376-node graph and frequent hover/filter state updates this would cause performance issues.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f80f75b5-f8a6-4110-b181-5f65430493ac", + "displayId": "X42", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The file-loading mechanism must require zero configuration from the user.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f951b58a-190e-42d1-9581-65d9af37c513", + "displayId": "R39", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Validation section of the detail panel must appear only when the node's review status is not 'clean'. It must list all validation errors from validation.json that touch edges incident to the selected node, showing for each error: rule, severity, message, edge type, and edge direction. Suspect nodes must show causeId links and conditional nodes must show impasseId links.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:22:15.249Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f9bec9aa-92f0-4b38-aa04-fb102e870479", + "displayId": "A3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: Skip the File API entirely; require the user to host artifact.json at a URL and enter that URL in a text field. Simpler, but breaks the local-first zero-config requirement.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f9c61e46-7a32-4e35-a2ac-cb43c180a6b4", + "displayId": "DEC3", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use a three-region resizable split layout: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, right detail panel.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:17:18.084Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "The three-region layout keeps all primary navigation surfaces visible simultaneously, which is critical given G4's requirement for search + graph + detail in one view. The tabbed alternative (alt 1) fragments context — switching to search hides the graph, violating X38 (search must highlight in graph AND show results list simultaneously). Fullscreen HUD (alt 2) risks cluttering the canvas and makes the filter/results list difficult to use on smaller screens. Resizable panels give power users control over canvas real estate while keeping the layout coherent." + }, + { + "id": "f9cdf6c1-2bd1-4265-825b-c184651d637e", + "displayId": "CR32", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The Zustand store must expose the following top-level keys, all populated after artifact load: loadedArtifact, nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByEdgeId, edgeIssuesByNodeId, interventionsByNodeId, activeView, selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState, comparisonState. Inspecting the store via a test or React DevTools must confirm all keys are present and correctly typed after a successful artifact parse.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "fb7b86eb-22fe-4871-96a7-b281f112367d", + "displayId": "CR12", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle control with exactly two states: Micro and Macro. Activating Micro must mount the Sigma.js WebGL canvas in the central area. Activating Macro must unmount the Sigma canvas and mount the dedicated macro WebGL timeline canvas in its place. The toggle state must be reflected in the Zustand store's activeView field.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:30:20.081Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "fba7d9d2-d4dd-49b9-aae3-1768cce41ca1", + "displayId": "T11", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A SnapshotRecord is a checkpoint in the artifact that includes an activeNodeIds array indicating which nodes are active at that point in time, enabling the UI to reconstruct the graph state at any historical snapshot.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "fc04c4e9-bad0-45c4-b778-18b21c44e1ad", + "displayId": "T1", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A derivation phase is one of four ordered stages in the spec elicitation pipeline: grounding (goals, terms, constraints), shaping (designs, decisions, alternatives), pinning (requirements), and defining_done (acceptance criteria). Phases have strict dependency order.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "fd124ad3-fb2a-44e3-ac5c-573ddf20ef53", + "displayId": "C8", + "specId": "942c7750-06a1-4c3e-ab30-9688e02909a4", + "frameId": "84b4eb0c-0f87-4462-a813-11a34710c263", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Polish in both design and interactions is essential: transitions must be smooth, hover states must feel alive, and the UI must reward exploration.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-09T16:03:31.824Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/edges.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/edges.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..020b48957 --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/edges.json @@ -0,0 +1,8522 @@ +[ + { + "id": "000024a0-80ef-41f1-b9ec-639cc4c7b5e5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7550da13-db83-4bce-9985-958193aa3c7e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "00190cc2-3f2b-4183-b74a-4da308c4f610", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9194810b-f16f-44b3-b559-fae811852615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "678f24ef-4a08-46f2-b1bf-ce9bd2e06186" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "005bd15c-a320-46d9-9e8d-d5649c752223", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e4c634ac-e0e8-45f3-8542-7ed3e6662c00" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "0087c7e7-b8bf-4bab-bdb1-71c6cebd2c34", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "eeefea9f-a6bf-419f-a87d-09c516ffec87" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3732637d-4769-4f9e-bddf-1aeba54c394d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "00939d39-56cd-443c-91d3-ddc4f2a5b44f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2a2cbbf9-5753-42c8-b4bc-3ad2736ef17c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6eef154d-988c-4f96-88eb-c3ca0863d255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "00b198db-6f6b-429b-9f27-e32756eea2a5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "66cfce9c-6795-49d6-a391-6bb0e09fbe76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "00f36645-4b26-4128-85fc-e1f903fe889e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "80821146-623f-48e5-9276-f6b990a63cb5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b342f91-e0b2-4687-a81a-c3143866cfd7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "0103d992-5b07-4f0e-86c5-c53b3ecea425", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1be72514-8fff-4c87-a326-558b5fe17f8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "013fce0e-4b50-4b15-8cb8-33c6525abfc7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "553b5225-b85c-4687-b3ff-6754532e9f0e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "01425d37-f180-47f3-95ee-f4426a27d646", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5a738fe-a3d9-4e59-873c-6a254e2efe42" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "73d7490f-8233-46ed-a2d0-d7740467c1cb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "01fd319c-07c7-420c-b054-38943450f2c9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "020d2be9-52e4-48cc-bc83-f2b2fb744f9d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40e60464-1067-477f-88f4-65e81a8f324d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8dfb5819-cbb5-4d4e-b4bb-e9d2111fdc5d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0245526e-d395-468c-bc8d-21e08f6b90a9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "62cf145d-ff61-4b06-82c8-5ff0d9254594" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "02968220-8342-481c-9cda-568e07ec4ea6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "45ca6169-8866-43c4-befa-3fbb292a716d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "02990e10-e370-452f-b5e4-5a551507326c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d07ad5e5-31ae-490e-bdad-783b556d9d67" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe95dde6-0af4-4eec-848c-e24b06ca5491" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "032d25c5-9f82-46eb-9887-57e5f7dd8bb9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "48221685-65a4-4d3b-9d3b-3ed263901ece" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2e7e28fb-a660-4e89-9d2d-b5c324acc2be" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "034df69f-6974-470f-8a09-0bc8db34cf50", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2eedb8ce-b3a7-4650-9a4d-1050dc5d9fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "039ed4da-b6a6-411c-883e-3fc4813c6a4a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3c77b43b-731c-4c6d-8b17-b3dcb512138e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8e380600-60e3-428f-891a-7ec0ca4c43a2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "03a16d66-852b-4651-9d84-44636cb3a2a6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17801bea-4dae-47d6-9df7-efd504ac369b" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "03abc63d-7c08-4901-adf6-e2d19d2439da", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "73d7490f-8233-46ed-a2d0-d7740467c1cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "03e2e8a7-9ad7-4d30-870d-a043adf3e54c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "720781eb-3005-43a9-8608-b0503a4ebf15" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "55c1c19e-e901-4d0c-aced-1af921f5fd17" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "040cc38e-3d00-43f6-be63-57b3aa7e8161", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e0f2e85e-a59f-4a54-a7f8-72afbc9ff983" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2e7e28fb-a660-4e89-9d2d-b5c324acc2be" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "041332dc-1108-46c8-95be-1a9cec0d875d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a2324b6-aa4f-4ef6-af33-d1f0494836b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "37a9360f-43b7-447f-a35b-d1e83f14d9e0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "05747df3-a7e9-408d-9ab9-cdbd030667e9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe709bac-edf8-4e3b-8fb2-2134844958e0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "05d67128-b293-4f85-bf61-e36ceff7980f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ae5990-1fe8-4952-afca-0b8225a23e6f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "da11ebf0-9325-457e-a51a-6407143cd087" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "074211bd-b1c8-4878-b498-dc813c779cc4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "079fcbc9-c8ce-4e29-92a6-62176ea71d2f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4e2bd3ff-de8a-4de6-b0c9-574720d92ad1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fbe67225-70e2-49e2-b84e-f1af1a8f59e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "07d02614-0d47-4afc-86be-d75949fe7521", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "721c6269-4273-4cfd-aaf4-79d5cf8d7468" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "07fefe22-5ee4-4b57-b965-8ecad45289bb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "678f24ef-4a08-46f2-b1bf-ce9bd2e06186" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96d0e684-1033-429a-8ddd-b56fec05d3f7" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "081202f6-d6c1-44c2-930b-e0a2c1e28f5c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ed5553-d6a7-45fe-8027-dbbc9f8177a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f95cb026-c83a-4cd9-b7b1-8820e8a06d17" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0818b065-973d-42f8-85ca-3a2d663b467a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3480520a-8be9-4d20-8967-689ed7fce3ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b629e743-2496-4a8e-a7fb-16a4265fb0f9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "082e41c3-f908-4ac6-b4d8-f3815d9160aa", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f2cd0b78-c817-4990-853a-952f9664db70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7cf6c327-c289-496e-96b8-6abc8853e962" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "0843d781-c3c7-421f-9f69-1f34c3cbe47a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "08dac5d1-2fa3-4d7b-80d9-c9ec3432e1c2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee433e1d-eb31-4655-b604-b21d5bb073ba" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "08f4bce1-cad5-473a-a984-fa9f8c893301", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c7d3430e-0276-4bf6-99e4-6ffb44a578cf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a635752-c43d-4b32-838d-24fd3ac698b3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0c1a8702-9ca5-447b-8915-2a42ede7114a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0a9257cc-963f-4c46-a070-57c93f9ed144", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "0acba742-713c-43ce-9463-8e4a379d5821", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1bdf650d-a20c-43ab-adca-8392908c0c07" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0ada5989-4918-4563-a208-5fa8da0bca89", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96bfd82b-9a0b-498a-be10-21829cf1f0d7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee89f88c-59a9-463f-b3e9-5545d471e771" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "0b126c2d-7349-4654-9322-df9b0429e858", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4d6f2e6d-d007-4953-9db3-43ba205cbb03" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "0ba3200f-922c-457d-83e9-4888d22ef8a2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "953d89fd-0e68-4a34-ba08-d32349b93e8e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f51ce22a-c2d1-453e-8a18-05fa68df0385" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0d13ba46-39c4-4ae0-b7af-c464ccbe720f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3480520a-8be9-4d20-8967-689ed7fce3ef" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7fc0b03b-7c3d-4440-8b34-2108068620b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "0d4a5f0e-4702-4f5a-809f-fccaa4f29e69", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4fa63a9f-9b53-4b45-9d65-2383c27f5141" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4ab25dc4-cd78-479c-a6ef-80e73edc3d71" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0db62cb0-3bb0-4278-817e-bc83d376dfcd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1cc06880-4290-4d96-8f44-fd940282eb66" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a74f15f2-10d6-4b46-b2b4-38a234d4b0a1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0dd1cb18-bf39-4ff3-aeac-42c4aab13fef", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0ebe864a-b89f-4779-b7cb-08166de38479" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "385119e0-70de-4c12-831a-477417c2ebb0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "0df0e4f0-05ae-4d90-b82e-f9b4ff24e6fb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b342f91-e0b2-4687-a81a-c3143866cfd7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0e4cfd2b-e5e4-4762-9c52-dfd97b1e3aad", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "678f24ef-4a08-46f2-b1bf-ce9bd2e06186" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0ed8b77b-e4ab-4066-9647-9f46ab36f479", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "716c1698-8c7e-4dc8-bbb9-3b955e5dd62e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0f238b81-3099-4f81-bf3c-d7888194e57c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1cc06880-4290-4d96-8f44-fd940282eb66" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f29bd3b9-b4e4-4856-b1b3-0d0d39a3334f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "0f2396c0-b494-4079-a474-b4d3160f1a23", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6eef154d-988c-4f96-88eb-c3ca0863d255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "0f35a06d-090b-48f1-9f7f-5bf054d3f684", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "32a9281f-3502-4e5e-b2d5-91489e3386ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "0f61e006-8040-4eb7-9adf-f338f051d676", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5f3a5562-d28a-4e1d-bb47-ec2dc96acf7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "10f69fc8-6e80-4996-a6aa-13a39167ddac", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "99a17277-b0fa-40cd-85f5-aead2480a1e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1105f4d3-5ab0-4ad6-8f0c-8a45fa6f0caf", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "65592e81-5f15-4859-8fa7-111f8fb6cff5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d9238094-baff-486f-b133-fb54893e4f52" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1146729e-2af3-4936-9a07-620ada2d5906", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7ed01886-5b4f-4620-a3d7-11f15b460553" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bb4a78e5-26cc-4eb0-912f-deefb3b9e365" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "11507437-701b-4b93-93af-3ab3c36c1b15", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "553b5225-b85c-4687-b3ff-6754532e9f0e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9036edae-47e4-4816-a9e0-9711f1d2b744" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1163b4c5-888e-45b9-93b7-d7beb4b0ae6c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3732637d-4769-4f9e-bddf-1aeba54c394d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "119cc270-e42a-4a29-b3b8-7fb054231314", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "500c73ed-5d69-4142-825d-ce6f6c7a8ec9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "121b0e8a-3f01-4cfe-9893-88669cdd2629", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d6b7d81-e9c1-44f7-8b42-1c3b5a2c75e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "133d9002-04ea-4b94-83bf-4a6cac2364ed", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a8a44cf-52a1-4dbf-9abc-400d018f232e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "da11ebf0-9325-457e-a51a-6407143cd087" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "13963b3e-03a5-48e3-bde7-4601c5ed4039", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3483bc7f-1eb1-4160-9318-d045b0551c31" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1f9628ca-e3b7-46a8-a4b2-520914b93dd9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "1420c522-0c8e-40c7-b60b-300f472e00c4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7ed01886-5b4f-4620-a3d7-11f15b460553" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "1442a891-49fc-4012-b97b-d85b24f5a21c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "385119e0-70de-4c12-831a-477417c2ebb0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f29bd3b9-b4e4-4856-b1b3-0d0d39a3334f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "14a3a8fa-15b2-4008-9c93-b5246e8bb895", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "14e45f07-0c12-4eb0-b8f9-69d286afac35", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7cf6c327-c289-496e-96b8-6abc8853e962" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f2cd0b78-c817-4990-853a-952f9664db70" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "152b3572-060f-42f8-b996-1b900320d65e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "99a17277-b0fa-40cd-85f5-aead2480a1e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "156fdb59-5d93-4deb-8d82-08bc6bff6fbc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3d53a878-955c-4cff-a15c-724ec8f2f280" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a0c8a53-ec3b-489f-be71-3a9516728a64" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1600acce-9d5e-4828-865c-5d8de61cf22d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "974d9e3c-ddce-4c27-83b0-9b19ed928095" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "1685d1b2-cd7e-4e89-8f96-715c4846b29f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "953d89fd-0e68-4a34-ba08-d32349b93e8e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "adc82ef7-560f-46b4-8fdc-8d76ef9987c6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "17b5bcc1-01ca-4783-9e87-f5d50e8f2e36", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bb4a78e5-26cc-4eb0-912f-deefb3b9e365" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fbe67225-70e2-49e2-b84e-f1af1a8f59e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "17f94348-2ff4-418c-b0a5-35c5fa47e6c1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "65592e81-5f15-4859-8fa7-111f8fb6cff5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5ef6000c-11f1-441c-8876-c4f762826ea3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "18ba9ecc-0db8-4eee-80ef-0cb137254f35", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "18f3f404-eee7-4f60-94a5-334ae97776ac", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7ed01886-5b4f-4620-a3d7-11f15b460553" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "19b2f3d7-6e28-43b5-b06b-4f62f057f6a0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c7d3430e-0276-4bf6-99e4-6ffb44a578cf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "19f91b20-5ab3-4b80-9e20-4850b3c1e528", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8e380600-60e3-428f-891a-7ec0ca4c43a2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1a0b8afe-e290-43b2-b0b0-03d6d88adaf8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ef5080f2-3379-4c0a-837a-c87ebdbc6e16" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "1a5a279d-739f-4a76-9a82-4fadd500f6cb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6ac4fb94-4b9b-45fc-8f83-3e494437a757" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d5c244a5-409b-4ecf-81c8-6ebd8063ee5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "1a7c9e50-39cd-4d7d-84bf-4a3721332554", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "efe5262b-e33b-40b2-a4de-9c1e99b2758c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4c9e7fb2-5060-4376-8493-23b1b42124a5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "1aee8ed5-c1da-4980-bef8-a597cc629e39", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2eedb8ce-b3a7-4650-9a4d-1050dc5d9fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "1bba6561-5fe2-41d9-a27e-52b8a5c85dca", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "1bc7004e-bcc5-47d5-954e-a5901014b246", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bd25a3a7-04d0-473c-b39d-cfee0409fa48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "32a9281f-3502-4e5e-b2d5-91489e3386ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "1c849893-588c-4448-b8d3-b4bd0ab3897d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6610e669-129b-4c80-b61b-abf3015cc9ff" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a37dc4c9-fcdc-4446-88b9-f165cd12bf2b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1d3eeb9a-e7ee-46bb-af1c-688b48740113", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5f3a5562-d28a-4e1d-bb47-ec2dc96acf7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1d5d86a2-4cd0-41bc-ac59-b5f0e1ba2908", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4fa63a9f-9b53-4b45-9d65-2383c27f5141" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "dd7a95d5-d2e8-4177-8dd7-0a3d6c0e0414" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1d81d19b-4d23-4485-adfe-f537360b5c0e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "99a17277-b0fa-40cd-85f5-aead2480a1e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a7a6b666-d2c1-4be2-aa82-08eb6a924d4e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1de6c5c3-58f2-4141-b52c-1467ee2a4906", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fbe67225-70e2-49e2-b84e-f1af1a8f59e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "1dff3411-90de-4fc0-bad4-f01643717236", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5d165f62-25c0-4902-89f5-d3d16bc40c56" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f998ef35-e4e8-4e2e-90b1-10a8b0a21de4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "1e303449-2271-4b35-9a26-961d48cd432e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bbdd2acb-60d9-4a9e-a268-7c08007cc57d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "1e382e93-fa10-48e0-8b68-d9fd2cfd540f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0bb27f0f-33fa-4689-bfcc-be72b4589a0a" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1ef5d1e7-f5aa-4d0c-a60e-8efbf9db5635", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d3df672d-3db9-45ca-a66d-ab36127bc215" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6c0da3ce-4073-4552-8db8-dbd6a9ebc6eb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1efecd62-eced-42fc-a49c-8bae936d2622", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1ec0b6c7-b96e-4383-b41e-6478fe73eade" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b90ce42-ea39-4ac9-9947-695e623512f9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "1f1b992d-2956-4c85-8180-0f435da98e84", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fca0d0c5-fdda-4111-8570-fc2e495c8fc2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d14dcec4-cfe0-42ca-83a0-68b7e5b20492" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "1f64ebac-fd04-4150-a8fb-461ee3ae74af", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ad707857-da55-4b62-82aa-53abc06e66e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f29bd3b9-b4e4-4856-b1b3-0d0d39a3334f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "1f741c3c-aad2-4e7b-b22c-161dddd1a6ba", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3425226b-74d9-49e8-b6b0-81ed5f7d99bc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "1fe760fc-a788-4aca-bc8d-a1d092f536b2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c216a3fc-cc33-4dd1-be4a-ac81b90c8e8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a3d8024-10e0-465e-8117-e623791b6145" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "20910cd1-1e04-4331-94d3-a9b042787563", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17801bea-4dae-47d6-9df7-efd504ac369b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d7be43d7-f7f7-4dab-9b23-5a9be8142259" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "20cf2bf4-ef24-46af-9152-8fa90bfb8f54", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ad707857-da55-4b62-82aa-53abc06e66e6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1cc06880-4290-4d96-8f44-fd940282eb66" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "214b2676-9f5d-47bb-9257-8305edf8e4e8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "65df7ca8-9301-475c-ae10-022a4fecf5d2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4fa63a9f-9b53-4b45-9d65-2383c27f5141" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "21773168-d35a-4d23-b3da-d431314b3eb3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "21f3cb72-59b9-4209-97d1-5cdb6cdcbac7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d02b7a51-a0dd-4ee2-b326-cf4b12c75152" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "22161388-1c43-4acf-964a-ab361256c844", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "91a3368b-4e78-4a68-b79c-8e0d73fecc1d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "221f9e6e-f326-49a9-916a-dc79895000f3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96eed2d4-37cc-4a23-b189-6727428536b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "22240526-e6dd-4803-9725-484c7452cfe8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "efe5262b-e33b-40b2-a4de-9c1e99b2758c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2242ff78-645f-4ccf-bdc9-d87dcee58cfc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea15c1bd-7368-4df1-ab3f-55c5542edffe" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2262e4cd-2fdd-4215-ada5-b45f758de5c0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fbe67225-70e2-49e2-b84e-f1af1a8f59e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "22e9dd71-cbae-4afb-82ac-c583f10da257", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "37a9360f-43b7-447f-a35b-d1e83f14d9e0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "230e6f2a-2737-4673-89a4-29de0911c702", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "efe5262b-e33b-40b2-a4de-9c1e99b2758c" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2350da79-e348-414e-bb69-c0d4b9243ac6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b342f91-e0b2-4687-a81a-c3143866cfd7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "05b16ab1-9fcf-42a2-8261-9990b238b92c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "2364f497-fda7-4d94-9c20-7d2693c96f4f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ed5553-d6a7-45fe-8027-dbbc9f8177a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "23e88f3d-0d7a-4e8e-a363-fb9de4412f22", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8dfb5819-cbb5-4d4e-b4bb-e9d2111fdc5d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "24e5b980-32f6-4241-81b7-5537760e2592", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "385119e0-70de-4c12-831a-477417c2ebb0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "25a53217-0f1b-416f-8124-b93bc9acd0da", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "25a92cf1-5229-4000-810d-5c3e51107459", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8e380600-60e3-428f-891a-7ec0ca4c43a2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "90a0f0ed-3f8b-41dd-96e2-fe7f765be250" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "25c58b12-e5c5-4c3f-94b6-3c9d82cc3463", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d04d22c3-d0ec-4d3b-8eec-440c01321cdb" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "25dc8dab-0c9a-45a5-b286-2fce6da504d1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7d96e6de-ebd8-4cca-b47a-cb56910a62a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "263783a0-0e5d-419f-a4b1-479108cd0343", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "816bf987-3c94-48ba-84d4-11773460c316" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f99d6f39-bca4-4f36-8996-1774fbf41683" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "26ec537c-9293-4e2f-81b0-c6a8ca5bf59d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "721c6269-4273-4cfd-aaf4-79d5cf8d7468" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2796ceb0-f372-4995-b181-5da8bc73016e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "dd7a95d5-d2e8-4177-8dd7-0a3d6c0e0414" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "27cc32f6-9960-420e-8bd1-474c6e89ad49", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b629e743-2496-4a8e-a7fb-16a4265fb0f9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ebe6087a-8e79-4898-96e5-9e73c607def3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "289a4a28-ce1e-461f-9162-a763382333e0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0eca62e3-1d2f-44fa-bb80-1440427cd819" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "29f7297c-0824-46a5-926c-e7a2f7f96bb0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fea06b16-e24e-4993-be0a-5a969c137293" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a11a267-33c7-4f13-806b-e72c04888f64", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a37dc4c9-fcdc-4446-88b9-f165cd12bf2b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7a3636cc-93c6-46ed-af92-f4c71e189a76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2a483da4-2cfb-4994-ac89-f7bfd5095633", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e506c68c-df22-4707-8a85-5c8cd12db447" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "55c1c19e-e901-4d0c-aced-1af921f5fd17" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "2afa071c-2dfb-478b-8f83-c7339a4de436", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8931b58a-6641-4cb8-aeb9-53be7ae0b273" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bbdd2acb-60d9-4a9e-a268-7c08007cc57d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "2b19d48e-beb1-4b9c-acce-ea2d50dffdcc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "effa3c4f-e621-47e1-8b01-20c710572063" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e61a6eec-6f69-4805-af23-cae030455161" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "2b600fba-e4f6-43a8-bbfb-2f3dc20a282c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6449dfdb-22d9-445e-af24-324dff9b9873" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "2b65fa51-5819-4f9a-a43c-55f852693acf", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f68f7978-2b0b-41d1-b4df-d03d9630ecfe" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2bb8d8c2-cbb3-4b90-8775-e02ad8c498a1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "39909718-a105-4273-990b-05c88349b0c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2be37044-873b-4043-8242-6ff5c39d2978", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe6568b2-bee4-4586-8f52-26805e60cdbc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "38fe9b25-2b61-427b-857b-e963328d102d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "2d0e742d-33a4-4b28-a32a-713d76d16447", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2d29d0cd-d182-4748-bcba-575478fbf8b6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "716c1698-8c7e-4dc8-bbb9-3b955e5dd62e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "2d6511de-7d88-4f96-9702-30b0f39dd505", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d07ad5e5-31ae-490e-bdad-783b556d9d67" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2d6ffffb-7fe7-44a0-a7e0-1b3cd3e71bbb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "80db7faa-5e3c-4b0f-af86-db52fa83a721" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "2e307ad2-340c-4d8a-8254-882d0848a0df", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "98f442ea-f956-43c7-becb-2664e106c0c3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6610e669-129b-4c80-b61b-abf3015cc9ff" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "2e7d2cd9-c70d-4e6d-a7be-c5ad787ff2cc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "2ec3b7e1-adf7-4024-bc3b-8f66b32df9e2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d5c244a5-409b-4ecf-81c8-6ebd8063ee5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c7d3430e-0276-4bf6-99e4-6ffb44a578cf" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "2ecc2a01-2bdd-466a-99df-18f65e01b1c6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ccf6895d-fe4e-45f9-98dc-ec52953fc874" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fea06b16-e24e-4993-be0a-5a969c137293" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "2f0e278c-f0a2-4c39-9d3c-da23c496bf55", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "65df7ca8-9301-475c-ae10-022a4fecf5d2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "dd7a95d5-d2e8-4177-8dd7-0a3d6c0e0414" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "30c5bcc9-f534-4526-8e9a-f6efbcd19d18", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7da6473f-f62f-4875-b2bf-99a2861c1f01" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "30d22a31-8172-4f9d-a0e7-354ca62b12dd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ed5553-d6a7-45fe-8027-dbbc9f8177a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "31d78196-71b5-486b-8e22-87ad08340de6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6610e669-129b-4c80-b61b-abf3015cc9ff" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "31f0655e-2ed0-41cf-b6b8-ffbd13366336", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "22f0212e-182a-48d9-9a94-aa306709d673" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3425226b-74d9-49e8-b6b0-81ed5f7d99bc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "32882e1f-a199-4daf-93bb-edef9cb322c2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "33a77684-16cb-4f62-8d88-b9af8060a939", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17801bea-4dae-47d6-9df7-efd504ac369b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "3401215e-a09f-4454-bd42-6a3af6f735ae", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2871ad7f-3566-41f4-8dab-02f4e4fbf097" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0e469e35-7b41-41f7-96e4-09f8150911c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "3403c7cc-2903-4602-b7f9-b3384414fb7f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8b5e53c2-3229-456e-b63d-e046d72ef695" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "344bd4e5-3eec-462c-8a01-a874e4cdc463", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "07be4f25-faa9-4c8c-aad9-a0739b68298d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "34da7ba3-9fea-4586-9d2d-87c5feb9dd9c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d3df672d-3db9-45ca-a66d-ab36127bc215" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "721c6269-4273-4cfd-aaf4-79d5cf8d7468" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "34dc81d3-f405-47e5-aa72-ecbb1ccd1e8b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0e469e35-7b41-41f7-96e4-09f8150911c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "34ecb1b2-1594-44ed-8c0a-bb888e167672", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2cda9b0b-bb66-47b7-99df-c0e251d93dbd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5f3a5562-d28a-4e1d-bb47-ec2dc96acf7b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "354fa618-b89e-4ed8-b636-95d4f938e94f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "21daa771-4a4b-47a3-a06c-188836714f99" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "35739323-76e5-4423-be8e-018875f5c95e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1c390ef2-1934-45ab-9705-5af40a80272e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2e7e28fb-a660-4e89-9d2d-b5c324acc2be" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "35abe88c-f1ba-4150-a33f-c5d193008c02", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "553b5225-b85c-4687-b3ff-6754532e9f0e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d854ab71-2a25-4574-9495-d0b6fc0d84df" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "363a0c9d-9bcc-461e-a540-5f886fa3d65b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9826eef7-523b-4a55-aac8-93d83d8bac4e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6eef154d-988c-4f96-88eb-c3ca0863d255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "365f6a69-3950-4826-9db4-1fee7883ba6a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ba6b13c4-7aae-44bf-baad-3f6ca72dcf66" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8dfb5819-cbb5-4d4e-b4bb-e9d2111fdc5d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "36693d1d-d24e-400f-8113-f8e32be39b78", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0df4dc45-ae56-4ecd-a3ea-3a1435b5a42f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "953d89fd-0e68-4a34-ba08-d32349b93e8e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "369737a8-8f41-4eae-ae62-91c606a1d316", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c216a3fc-cc33-4dd1-be4a-ac81b90c8e8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7fc0b03b-7c3d-4440-8b34-2108068620b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "36d1bbcd-4b1f-45f3-985a-277d9a1a6808", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1f9628ca-e3b7-46a8-a4b2-520914b93dd9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3723aeb7-b9c3-4d58-a9ba-6d9379e36a37", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4fa63a9f-9b53-4b45-9d65-2383c27f5141" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4bd53fc9-dc76-431f-abf5-ff0f19f7a594" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3765c1a6-cd45-4117-b0ff-0d5ecf8e3ce4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7550da13-db83-4bce-9985-958193aa3c7e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "378348e5-e435-4aaf-bdae-c36db7dd86df", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "93280305-7ed8-45ce-b2be-247173757b40" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "3793ae85-dd0f-4e08-85dd-4f6770e7c6ce", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b342f91-e0b2-4687-a81a-c3143866cfd7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0e469e35-7b41-41f7-96e4-09f8150911c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "37af6182-9311-404b-b140-b1111e8eaafd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "07be4f25-faa9-4c8c-aad9-a0739b68298d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ae5990-1fe8-4952-afca-0b8225a23e6f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "38891c9d-5909-4d95-b43d-6f3d626af3b8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3d53a878-955c-4cff-a15c-724ec8f2f280" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "394acc25-950f-46ea-817a-0a296b51a0bb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5941fc75-f20f-460f-ba3a-e629f41c9236" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "399a97a0-871b-49c2-8303-1fa6e1505410", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d38f26a-1cbc-4fa0-b206-1eb707da613b" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "39b077c1-dbca-4bca-a29a-e0493bf16725", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7550da13-db83-4bce-9985-958193aa3c7e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9aad3a05-6191-4951-900b-220daa07e422" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3a02fcab-edc9-459c-918d-20c094e27d3f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27c1e9fd-cc7c-48b5-aa7f-f33761dafdc8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f68f7978-2b0b-41d1-b4df-d03d9630ecfe" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "3a411f69-750d-473e-baec-dc526c87fda2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "60836423-1550-4b49-bac5-22ffead09574" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d14dcec4-cfe0-42ca-83a0-68b7e5b20492" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "3b3dd76d-c1d1-4de4-b7eb-1282c00b788e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6610e669-129b-4c80-b61b-abf3015cc9ff" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3b6e1a26-d984-42c3-adfb-ecf598c598f1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "65592e81-5f15-4859-8fa7-111f8fb6cff5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3b97ca8b-4ab6-4499-8900-6bf5dcdca54f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d3df672d-3db9-45ca-a66d-ab36127bc215" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3270ebda-b714-433b-a68d-d356f705df2a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3be66e6b-f63e-4950-b7f1-42224a8d985b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "500c73ed-5d69-4142-825d-ce6f6c7a8ec9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a74f15f2-10d6-4b46-b2b4-38a234d4b0a1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3c74f4df-0f0d-4d00-8266-9bc3eeaf1000", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7e65823a-9505-49b7-a8a5-8b3e8db4b231" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "3c8fc19c-f5b8-47b2-b01e-c4a0726922c8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee89f88c-59a9-463f-b3e9-5545d471e771" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3cc426c2-250e-4937-9b12-36a68a6d5f5a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f29bd3b9-b4e4-4856-b1b3-0d0d39a3334f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "3d5ba843-70f3-4d32-ac0c-978d8ab2ff78", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6610e669-129b-4c80-b61b-abf3015cc9ff" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "66cfce9c-6795-49d6-a391-6bb0e09fbe76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3e1cc835-eb5c-4d9a-a5d2-7231568a62f4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3ee2649c-b37a-48fe-9a09-938ec29bb19a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e61a6eec-6f69-4805-af23-cae030455161" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3ef87f22-d7b6-418e-a56c-c47c8d823e06", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "52c44ef9-74d2-4f82-b812-7e6ec5e66ffe" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3fb1e0c2-1d74-4732-89bd-f7e89c91ac56", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "21daa771-4a4b-47a3-a06c-188836714f99" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "678f24ef-4a08-46f2-b1bf-ce9bd2e06186" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3fd52500-e989-4e5b-96e0-8e23789e81f4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8320d111-efac-4e6e-917c-155eeed3e75c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "3fda7d2d-0d28-4f30-a316-793f3fcbceed", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f2daf689-34e8-4f4c-9f5d-115640dd51a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c763822e-ecdc-48df-bbb0-95560cfbb2dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "3fedcff4-524f-4592-b702-9aa17f42fb14", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "93280305-7ed8-45ce-b2be-247173757b40" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f99d6f39-bca4-4f36-8996-1774fbf41683" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "408d582e-22a4-4b29-9128-77b2e3222bb3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b629e743-2496-4a8e-a7fb-16a4265fb0f9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7fc0b03b-7c3d-4440-8b34-2108068620b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "4111294c-7704-4c94-a3ac-f94611c73667", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "eaa8abe6-de0b-43b6-97a9-a9272dfe92b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee433e1d-eb31-4655-b604-b21d5bb073ba" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "4162101c-3db7-4279-8ba1-ceeced7793d3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8320d111-efac-4e6e-917c-155eeed3e75c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "4205414b-8f69-459f-bfab-cc06101c0134", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d04d22c3-d0ec-4d3b-8eec-440c01321cdb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f95cb026-c83a-4cd9-b7b1-8820e8a06d17" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "425d03b1-f1a6-4a4a-bb9b-4d8bd1d186df", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4d6f2e6d-d007-4953-9db3-43ba205cbb03" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "43b8ae30-3620-4b8b-befb-01ff20e00289", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8fcbd8e0-a5bc-46d0-8ee8-736da4524445" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1be72514-8fff-4c87-a326-558b5fe17f8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "4433e436-d871-4096-a293-05021cedbe78", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ab3e2ed7-41bd-435a-af10-6393ecf9402d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "4463436f-38fa-4d61-aa3a-040d58b457e1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "13de9f34-6822-4684-abda-e9d41fff337d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "18684157-20eb-44e7-b214-a290d151cb59" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "4525b2c7-e61a-45ac-8f64-bcea6ee9cb86", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3483bc7f-1eb1-4160-9318-d045b0551c31" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "4528568e-ef03-4b48-be10-f810e9814ee6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6d6c7aa0-9d33-4c69-a6cf-60c18e54c3f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5ef6000c-11f1-441c-8876-c4f762826ea3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "459a9f10-3b75-44c1-9586-810217bd4d2b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ccf6895d-fe4e-45f9-98dc-ec52953fc874" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "21daa771-4a4b-47a3-a06c-188836714f99" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "45d09275-3150-4fb7-9bb5-119cb324a349", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a2324b6-aa4f-4ef6-af33-d1f0494836b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "45e25a08-6808-4c20-af62-184a255d7d6f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea15c1bd-7368-4df1-ab3f-55c5542edffe" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f99d6f39-bca4-4f36-8996-1774fbf41683" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "4627a55e-2798-418c-a7cf-2cfb4e5a8333", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "462d5cb4-d59b-40ad-91f1-3473631001fa", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2871ad7f-3566-41f4-8dab-02f4e4fbf097" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "18684157-20eb-44e7-b214-a290d151cb59" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "486b119e-f069-421b-80df-e9bb6e8fdd70", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c6c90d43-5472-4f55-ab73-63edf75bac16" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "4900a2d9-20d0-4bb3-a3fa-eb43fed80ea3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ba6b13c4-7aae-44bf-baad-3f6ca72dcf66" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40e60464-1067-477f-88f4-65e81a8f324d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "49c82ff1-7bb3-4760-a4db-700c44acc7ca", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d07ad5e5-31ae-490e-bdad-783b556d9d67" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "49cf667c-a467-45d2-bd34-ec9334e7cfd0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "91a5af71-fb83-4a63-8577-7d9bc35522f4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5088cbf6-2180-4d41-bd88-6045691f35ad" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "4af4836a-1107-406e-86c9-2cacde10cf3e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a74f15f2-10d6-4b46-b2b4-38a234d4b0a1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "4c530999-b6f5-4e95-adc9-0b01e8d55355", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "99a17277-b0fa-40cd-85f5-aead2480a1e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "4ca92070-a6f0-48d7-a36d-0d4ff2a49f70", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "eaa8abe6-de0b-43b6-97a9-a9272dfe92b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "4d39c3f7-0f29-402e-93a3-65cbfb101b0b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bf06490e-e867-486e-a76b-67d74dfeb90b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "4d99e8bc-c811-46e6-a85e-c8bfad96656f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9dbba24c-94ff-4fe6-a9e9-c5e10e6f7b70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "4da5a332-d896-47d3-82a2-c83c8f9b765b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "4dbe375e-a0aa-4eba-bdaf-4740af2e998f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "60b61cd3-f325-4953-9104-18d2633464e0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "80db7faa-5e3c-4b0f-af86-db52fa83a721" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "504ae538-2208-4e6a-bf9e-6b34b8a38948", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0bb27f0f-33fa-4689-bfcc-be72b4589a0a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "50f506bd-00b8-4756-8a97-73d8dfb33c1b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2a2cbbf9-5753-42c8-b4bc-3ad2736ef17c" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "513a0051-82c4-419c-917e-9c69b47dc836", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1e2d0069-59a6-4ffa-a722-f1bff0a377a0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "53268bb4-b0ec-4a2b-8e88-69a11423ac43", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9826eef7-523b-4a55-aac8-93d83d8bac4e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "5333d3d7-d303-47c4-9809-106cf2952616", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4ea662bf-4280-4914-b672-05495f457dd7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8320d111-efac-4e6e-917c-155eeed3e75c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "5367f0c5-394b-49cd-8553-34fbbb29122f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8fcbd8e0-a5bc-46d0-8ee8-736da4524445" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "54d4a166-7e42-4eaf-bf6b-7e02f80a50d7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9dbba24c-94ff-4fe6-a9e9-c5e10e6f7b70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4bd53fc9-dc76-431f-abf5-ff0f19f7a594" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "55380591-187e-4af1-9cd4-17fcd8341216", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d74d7f69-3fdc-4852-8ea6-418d946ac898" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "32a9281f-3502-4e5e-b2d5-91489e3386ce" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "56159200-a5e8-439f-b2ec-c35c580171e0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "39909718-a105-4273-990b-05c88349b0c1" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "5681c4d1-805f-445b-86a0-e9f2891b8286", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "56e675ba-faba-48b2-af5e-f6fa3c8b2abb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "55c1c19e-e901-4d0c-aced-1af921f5fd17" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9d665c32-476f-4664-9b13-734907622aa0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "56f679b8-8cfb-4c3f-bf5a-0a0bb066bfd2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "57281236-042f-4131-8ae2-dd8c9ee966ec", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6eef154d-988c-4f96-88eb-c3ca0863d255" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "57388110-cd82-41b5-a63a-52b2291b4cb3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "5adf3e70-3389-48b5-98a0-62881c8830e2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "eeefea9f-a6bf-419f-a87d-09c516ffec87" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f29bd3b9-b4e4-4856-b1b3-0d0d39a3334f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c303b7c-fffb-47f0-ad18-f7898669063d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c5126e6-4385-49bd-8575-7113e8e63259", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d14dcec4-cfe0-42ca-83a0-68b7e5b20492" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c647827-b7fb-4d63-bc9b-c51b240c8446", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d7be43d7-f7f7-4dab-9b23-5a9be8142259" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c664642-2ab4-45ca-b76b-34f03881ad4a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5088cbf6-2180-4d41-bd88-6045691f35ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "5c90c4e8-70ae-45e1-a003-5c223dd97558", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "77fd25cb-6988-49fe-85f7-f8196357b52d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "681f483b-8f7f-4341-a8ca-0c620be2957c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "5cedb30e-7ef1-41f0-8427-d269e25fd59f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "5d394fc0-ec5b-4d5c-9101-9a6f9827083b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "247b9d17-13d3-4364-8ce6-4283171fedf8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1ec0b6c7-b96e-4383-b41e-6478fe73eade" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "5d9352f0-81fa-47d8-a64c-85f78f56c0f0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee89f88c-59a9-463f-b3e9-5545d471e771" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4c9e7fb2-5060-4376-8493-23b1b42124a5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "5ddcfe4f-b465-4d2e-af68-905d0cbf47bd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "5df24dc0-65de-43c1-808f-51ec4bdffa15", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d078209-7578-4c2c-91e2-95a324e3edf0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8fcbd8e0-a5bc-46d0-8ee8-736da4524445" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "5e57f21f-5988-4e0f-a80c-e4023cc81892", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ef5080f2-3379-4c0a-837a-c87ebdbc6e16" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4e2bd3ff-de8a-4de6-b0c9-574720d92ad1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "5e683578-f7be-4532-b34a-e76ce170ab3c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "39909718-a105-4273-990b-05c88349b0c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "5e7458d3-b982-492c-888e-0bf75e0b72a7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "5f069590-de19-4ae0-bc0a-3f3c62d5f654", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27c1e9fd-cc7c-48b5-aa7f-f33761dafdc8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "95730dd1-5b40-43c0-9f63-9e38c9855932" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "610a8022-84d9-47ec-9dd3-3496d9fc46a7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3f60eeaa-41f2-40ed-8b40-99e909e66705" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "612e259d-6ba1-4312-bb9f-69f3fd5ce9ad", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "385119e0-70de-4c12-831a-477417c2ebb0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a74f15f2-10d6-4b46-b2b4-38a234d4b0a1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "615d87c8-8590-4aaf-a6b3-db8e6fd990f1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ab3e2ed7-41bd-435a-af10-6393ecf9402d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "61bd0422-0b54-4d0e-8c59-634d19e9ef93", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "21daa771-4a4b-47a3-a06c-188836714f99" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "62246a8f-ee08-4bed-95ba-8834d6ec995f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee433e1d-eb31-4655-b604-b21d5bb073ba" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9aad3a05-6191-4951-900b-220daa07e422" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "637db5f4-3b5a-4ca5-a165-e2dd6697c094", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "63bfe4c6-fe04-4feb-bfa0-958f4091dd76", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1ec0b6c7-b96e-4383-b41e-6478fe73eade" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0fde5f0d-6164-4e30-ad21-122118f4739e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "64f8a8e4-e603-442e-bffa-27f32165e9fb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e61a6eec-6f69-4805-af23-cae030455161" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "65162006-142f-4e85-8345-ab0ce4ea8614", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "479979d4-3463-4dd4-839a-b0a4f843d465" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "65e74f00-342a-4a4b-bad0-5725ee38093b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e702efc3-129f-4907-8040-4154b51991a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9826eef7-523b-4a55-aac8-93d83d8bac4e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "6629ec95-8bce-4c0d-b7ed-f4083f1ad8f8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "247b9d17-13d3-4364-8ce6-4283171fedf8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1bdf650d-a20c-43ab-adca-8392908c0c07" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "68ac44bc-6cad-4cc4-9161-ce996826435e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0bb27f0f-33fa-4689-bfcc-be72b4589a0a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d7be43d7-f7f7-4dab-9b23-5a9be8142259" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "68e49a29-3856-4569-b61c-75bbacbf5117", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "64a459d9-e4e1-46e7-b4ed-b5f66908d8e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0c1a8702-9ca5-447b-8915-2a42ede7114a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "696486be-a71d-4973-8423-37f585e2bcef", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7a3636cc-93c6-46ed-af92-f4c71e189a76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6973507d-f611-4f76-a6a8-bf5b6fcf3396", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40e60464-1067-477f-88f4-65e81a8f324d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a11b219-6e4d-4909-ab09-2d47e86ed0a7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0c1a8702-9ca5-447b-8915-2a42ede7114a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a5309d5-547b-4cfc-b043-c850de692954", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6a731b34-89a7-4132-8252-af0245fac4ae", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6bc41aac-54e1-4e14-904f-b7c0b7e4545f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d74d7f69-3fdc-4852-8ea6-418d946ac898" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "6be0166f-81fb-4506-a35a-e525f7c92dd2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a74f15f2-10d6-4b46-b2b4-38a234d4b0a1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c235b22-3f65-48bd-aa46-a9d851545c10", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fca0d0c5-fdda-4111-8570-fc2e495c8fc2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "500c73ed-5d69-4142-825d-ce6f6c7a8ec9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c372d7c-769e-4f57-9837-f3d7920b8bb1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2871ad7f-3566-41f4-8dab-02f4e4fbf097" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c4571b2-a594-4cef-9636-b8e91779d4b7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "73d7490f-8233-46ed-a2d0-d7740467c1cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c609430-59ce-4abb-a459-f53237e62697", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b37c8b13-69fd-4997-b31b-0b2e9faf91f7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c882844-5081-4de0-94fd-538af7533280", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "cda32831-90ec-472f-9162-9083ec1a82bb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "52c44ef9-74d2-4f82-b812-7e6ec5e66ffe" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "6c99f940-c133-41eb-8453-cbad281d76b8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1ec0b6c7-b96e-4383-b41e-6478fe73eade" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "6d09025d-e5db-4b95-a97e-b1013972ab40", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7cf6c327-c289-496e-96b8-6abc8853e962" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6d26c64e-7754-47e8-8115-35406f512550", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c0d896e4-80d8-4023-9730-0806398e4851" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "6ecc36ca-e277-494a-a957-fe0324f2342a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ccf6895d-fe4e-45f9-98dc-ec52953fc874" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c974c2ec-c6e3-413a-b75f-380f1727682c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "6ef36ed3-5f40-457a-98e4-18668b7a55c4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6ef58d7c-48c7-4352-80aa-cebb0b1205dc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9aad3a05-6191-4951-900b-220daa07e422" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6ef715ab-30a7-4a31-95fe-d554b15cde56", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "6f34f34f-affd-4ba4-a679-e80565f40c75", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c0e5c2bb-44d7-4b6a-a6ef-f007c4f1535d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3d53a878-955c-4cff-a15c-724ec8f2f280" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "70269b64-a123-4349-92ec-19ee7d35db3f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1380e9c6-2526-421f-a548-fdcd5841a363" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4757ed81-2471-447b-aa1c-e2dc96857251" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "71c78b66-7e10-48ca-851c-1e2448071c43", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "13de9f34-6822-4684-abda-e9d41fff337d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "65592e81-5f15-4859-8fa7-111f8fb6cff5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "71e1187b-21ef-414a-bc43-eef175dbc17b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2a2cbbf9-5753-42c8-b4bc-3ad2736ef17c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "721ad62c-ced9-445c-9eda-037f5d06f7e5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bf06490e-e867-486e-a76b-67d74dfeb90b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ed5553-d6a7-45fe-8027-dbbc9f8177a6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "72983427-6b30-4ccd-8db0-5c2aab2b05ee", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7da6473f-f62f-4875-b2bf-99a2861c1f01" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "90a0f0ed-3f8b-41dd-96e2-fe7f765be250" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "72dea645-338a-4ab8-829a-4bbee60a8873", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e4c634ac-e0e8-45f3-8542-7ed3e6662c00" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "73ddb72f-0bbb-4394-ad9e-2f8010656d3b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "73f7cf8b-ffcd-475f-829d-922d0a1d12fd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c974c2ec-c6e3-413a-b75f-380f1727682c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "21daa771-4a4b-47a3-a06c-188836714f99" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "744f163d-a83d-450c-a7b6-d0f3c41d43b0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fea06b16-e24e-4993-be0a-5a969c137293" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "747adcec-7b1d-4fdc-99f1-ebae17a78c3e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "80db7faa-5e3c-4b0f-af86-db52fa83a721" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "74e96251-bfb0-4c29-8b47-f03cf56fc0bd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6b76d547-7f67-49d7-a4fa-819da8eef644" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9d665c32-476f-4664-9b13-734907622aa0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "78be63f3-1e7d-4166-bd27-d687a33d04e4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "38fe9b25-2b61-427b-857b-e963328d102d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "7979853f-3f56-43c5-b461-df63a64b656d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "22f0212e-182a-48d9-9a94-aa306709d673" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f51ce22a-c2d1-453e-8a18-05fa68df0385" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a193099-1220-462e-bd36-43e480d5c61f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "98f442ea-f956-43c7-becb-2664e106c0c3" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a37dc4c9-fcdc-4446-88b9-f165cd12bf2b" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a4591b0-a893-4f5e-b75f-8d78118c0b0e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c216a3fc-cc33-4dd1-be4a-ac81b90c8e8a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f95cb026-c83a-4cd9-b7b1-8820e8a06d17" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "7a4a9e35-20d0-441e-8da2-adf91b9ebb72", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2e7e28fb-a660-4e89-9d2d-b5c324acc2be" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "7cfda557-2081-4ae2-ae54-34214e8f8c39", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e4c634ac-e0e8-45f3-8542-7ed3e6662c00" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d4dae70-64a5-4992-8c2e-64060d014474", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "37a9360f-43b7-447f-a35b-d1e83f14d9e0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d7fb4de-05ee-4532-afc7-d4e5138cab4c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f95cb026-c83a-4cd9-b7b1-8820e8a06d17" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d9247c0-2ac0-4e4f-9a85-f2b90ac4be91", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d5c244a5-409b-4ecf-81c8-6ebd8063ee5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "7d9502cc-0f5f-47e0-9e61-254b143b013c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1e2d0069-59a6-4ffa-a722-f1bff0a377a0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b90ce42-ea39-4ac9-9947-695e623512f9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "7de59f77-0af8-4af5-8e1f-03bd05be9e2c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4e2bd3ff-de8a-4de6-b0c9-574720d92ad1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7ed01886-5b4f-4620-a3d7-11f15b460553" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "7ec1a6f4-6998-4842-84b9-7073f989a574", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17801bea-4dae-47d6-9df7-efd504ac369b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "801b0f73-7781-48c7-94e8-895a7bb83704", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96d0e684-1033-429a-8ddd-b56fec05d3f7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "80ad9736-3a99-43fc-8dfb-e1a53dc5a25f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5941fc75-f20f-460f-ba3a-e629f41c9236" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d6b7d81-e9c1-44f7-8b42-1c3b5a2c75e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "812c47e6-955a-4683-988f-7fc2ab4e7714", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b37c8b13-69fd-4997-b31b-0b2e9faf91f7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f95cb026-c83a-4cd9-b7b1-8820e8a06d17" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "81685a07-072e-49ab-8baa-31ee26509e4a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "83645fce-3d63-41e0-81cd-c3a01f69de73", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b342f91-e0b2-4687-a81a-c3143866cfd7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "83710a0a-f0f6-42b7-a1db-ec0ed1592bda", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3d53a878-955c-4cff-a15c-724ec8f2f280" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "8374ffe0-98b5-4855-be4c-eb1cb24c142b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0ebe864a-b89f-4779-b7cb-08166de38479" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a74f15f2-10d6-4b46-b2b4-38a234d4b0a1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "8387b918-02fd-40c2-8452-866e5699cf3f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9826eef7-523b-4a55-aac8-93d83d8bac4e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "84876eea-2564-4d6c-821f-48e5c4c9ef0b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ed5553-d6a7-45fe-8027-dbbc9f8177a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7fc0b03b-7c3d-4440-8b34-2108068620b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "84af1493-ee90-462f-917a-099dd183b13d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "84b69b79-32d5-48c2-b93b-ff15cae9a47c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bd25a3a7-04d0-473c-b39d-cfee0409fa48" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d74d7f69-3fdc-4852-8ea6-418d946ac898" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "855c19ce-e157-4876-a24d-cd53c561e993", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "45ca6169-8866-43c4-befa-3fbb292a716d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7d96e6de-ebd8-4cca-b47a-cb56910a62a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "86af39c5-150d-4f86-be4d-b02cf41ef6f0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4757ed81-2471-447b-aa1c-e2dc96857251" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "86bbf808-c146-41fe-b7ee-c8b23d1b4c4f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4fa63a9f-9b53-4b45-9d65-2383c27f5141" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "875d65fb-e1b0-4650-b95f-a2a72e5bf3d6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ab3e2ed7-41bd-435a-af10-6393ecf9402d" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "87b5cf4a-c332-4814-b5fa-00e35a1ae7cc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "64a459d9-e4e1-46e7-b4ed-b5f66908d8e4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d6b7d81-e9c1-44f7-8b42-1c3b5a2c75e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "87c5bba2-ee31-436f-b423-3037ea06a3c5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ae5990-1fe8-4952-afca-0b8225a23e6f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "888b360c-a083-40db-b582-b2148b10afc5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d6b7d81-e9c1-44f7-8b42-1c3b5a2c75e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "88c59ac5-c66a-48f0-bff3-9cd10056adac", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6b76d547-7f67-49d7-a4fa-819da8eef644" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "88f68238-363c-45d4-b127-6f8adbecf450", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "681f483b-8f7f-4341-a8ca-0c620be2957c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "899f2dbb-9966-4a4f-919f-35d0bbbd3051", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6d6c7aa0-9d33-4c69-a6cf-60c18e54c3f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d9238094-baff-486f-b133-fb54893e4f52" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "89a272a1-dd00-4aa7-a62a-a7d40b9aacf8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "460ccd42-8184-4268-befd-97edb0929545" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "8a5fc85e-2357-442b-8ded-fe5a787e48b9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a2324b6-aa4f-4ef6-af33-d1f0494836b6" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "8b19c89a-9b49-4ba2-b2af-66db6c4ed4bb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a8d371cb-476e-4e64-8ec1-ee78e36bb77d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "8b8627a7-8707-42fe-b6d8-2d1f01b1e9f7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3f60eeaa-41f2-40ed-8b40-99e909e66705" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0fde5f0d-6164-4e30-ad21-122118f4739e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "8c1dc6f7-bf92-4ad4-9cc1-645453548fac", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f99d6f39-bca4-4f36-8996-1774fbf41683" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "8c230a5f-c2f2-463d-bb84-35656305f700", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2eedb8ce-b3a7-4650-9a4d-1050dc5d9fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "8c8556a4-e6a1-4e6e-842a-72c1ca735c06", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a0c91818-946b-4a34-83bd-e12611b1747a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c763822e-ecdc-48df-bbb0-95560cfbb2dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "8c9fd9eb-5633-4c1e-b5d2-5855fce2660b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "efe5262b-e33b-40b2-a4de-9c1e99b2758c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7fc0b03b-7c3d-4440-8b34-2108068620b4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "8d67e805-29a1-4ba1-a8c1-f31b01cecabd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "500c73ed-5d69-4142-825d-ce6f6c7a8ec9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d14dcec4-cfe0-42ca-83a0-68b7e5b20492" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "8d99033b-8600-470a-acbe-a4a82e00a358", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f2daf689-34e8-4f4c-9f5d-115640dd51a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "8dec64ec-e527-40de-9aee-5e64769c9713", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5088cbf6-2180-4d41-bd88-6045691f35ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96eed2d4-37cc-4a23-b189-6727428536b6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "8e29044a-1fec-443c-ab4b-8cc7fa9db63b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5088cbf6-2180-4d41-bd88-6045691f35ad" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a7a6b666-d2c1-4be2-aa82-08eb6a924d4e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "8e774914-3fed-4237-895c-748bca2cb2b3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "dd7a95d5-d2e8-4177-8dd7-0a3d6c0e0414" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "8f153fc9-4c02-4ad7-bd75-14e3582fa08d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d63b37ad-8225-4727-ad98-b4a45dda927d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "8f6bcc50-d864-403d-876f-30faedfe265e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "80821146-623f-48e5-9276-f6b990a63cb5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "8f72cd59-684d-495e-aeca-7442bc2550aa", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9dbba24c-94ff-4fe6-a9e9-c5e10e6f7b70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8b5e53c2-3229-456e-b63d-e046d72ef695" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "8f95461f-c1eb-4a1b-ba14-3c0d921e025a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a8d371cb-476e-4e64-8ec1-ee78e36bb77d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "37a9360f-43b7-447f-a35b-d1e83f14d9e0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "8f9ce240-ecd2-4b89-b4b5-751b51fcd29a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2a2cbbf9-5753-42c8-b4bc-3ad2736ef17c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "90459f74-b1fe-4432-b31f-a08a75ddebb5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "60836423-1550-4b49-bac5-22ffead09574" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "023bc875-efb4-4bc2-9023-84d089050319" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "9049f91b-57d4-4e63-b558-e119e0388e80", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a197cdc3-db5b-4531-850a-c31b69bfe918" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7da6473f-f62f-4875-b2bf-99a2861c1f01" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "90528308-4306-46e1-bbf8-a6d3ecaa9529", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ca16b154-6542-41da-9b36-56ffb1e3131c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b90ce42-ea39-4ac9-9947-695e623512f9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "90557418-2721-428e-9c36-5693628d252b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "953d89fd-0e68-4a34-ba08-d32349b93e8e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ebe6087a-8e79-4898-96e5-9e73c607def3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "90a5446a-8bbc-4b9d-a7ea-d430d03b11d7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "90b1d2cc-3b85-4ac0-94ab-6c02325f1667", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3d53a878-955c-4cff-a15c-724ec8f2f280" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9aad3a05-6191-4951-900b-220daa07e422" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "9145a544-0dc5-4cb7-87e3-20ea73c40d16", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "05e28de6-a0f0-4396-8ae5-c809ae79470a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f99d6f39-bca4-4f36-8996-1774fbf41683" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "92266856-5158-4d78-9dcb-cac98233bae9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "720781eb-3005-43a9-8608-b0503a4ebf15" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9dbba24c-94ff-4fe6-a9e9-c5e10e6f7b70" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "9236294e-2fae-4a35-84cd-7084d53c63ea", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0c1a8702-9ca5-447b-8915-2a42ede7114a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d6b7d81-e9c1-44f7-8b42-1c3b5a2c75e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "92b35168-ead0-41e6-b413-a7e079a5d2b3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0bb27f0f-33fa-4689-bfcc-be72b4589a0a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "92ef98a1-047c-4d08-9c86-0fc692d7fd28", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7cf6c327-c289-496e-96b8-6abc8853e962" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "936f0432-286d-4b14-aad8-3cf07c7f3625", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "80db7faa-5e3c-4b0f-af86-db52fa83a721" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d63b37ad-8225-4727-ad98-b4a45dda927d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "93a8099b-8cbc-4f89-8c8a-d43b0c708b43", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "943605bf-545f-4e4d-b687-fa9d4647c459", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee89f88c-59a9-463f-b3e9-5545d471e771" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a7a6b666-d2c1-4be2-aa82-08eb6a924d4e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "949c26ef-2f1c-4f9a-a368-a7a3d4097b34", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e61a6eec-6f69-4805-af23-cae030455161" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "94b9555b-180b-4c6c-aafd-b05b3bdc38a9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d38f26a-1cbc-4fa0-b206-1eb707da613b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4c9e7fb2-5060-4376-8493-23b1b42124a5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "9516c185-95cb-4696-afd4-954762dab9b1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bb4a78e5-26cc-4eb0-912f-deefb3b9e365" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "95fe9bab-80de-4dff-9891-c51d2dac6637", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c974c2ec-c6e3-413a-b75f-380f1727682c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "96c58f8a-c971-44f3-b14f-de0ec286174f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "720781eb-3005-43a9-8608-b0503a4ebf15" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8b5e53c2-3229-456e-b63d-e046d72ef695" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "96c7ecb1-79ab-407a-822a-006b3a133b3f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d5c244a5-409b-4ecf-81c8-6ebd8063ee5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "37a9360f-43b7-447f-a35b-d1e83f14d9e0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "982d9381-afd8-4759-8c7e-969c81724c25", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1cc06880-4290-4d96-8f44-fd940282eb66" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "9831044f-74cc-47a9-a4ab-d4b43c5c8765", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e0f163b2-6bb7-453a-9512-f6111f59f79f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "984bd031-64b5-495f-8a43-43f79332cb65", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a0c8a53-ec3b-489f-be71-3a9516728a64" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "9a66c680-d958-472d-a03f-0bbb49470f00", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "93280305-7ed8-45ce-b2be-247173757b40" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "9b3ac652-9108-4361-8cb8-543539f10e34", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a0c91818-946b-4a34-83bd-e12611b1747a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "73d7490f-8233-46ed-a2d0-d7740467c1cb" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "9c0369d7-cf67-4fb9-8336-83c34259021f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c974c2ec-c6e3-413a-b75f-380f1727682c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fea06b16-e24e-4993-be0a-5a969c137293" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "9ca7ba5e-82bf-4547-b1f5-725a8b784645", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "9e2bacda-d899-4a2d-87a9-9f8e64917d30", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "9f03fbb6-0bc3-4e3e-af31-ae12895e871c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "90a0f0ed-3f8b-41dd-96e2-fe7f765be250" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "9f4b97cf-93a4-4695-a524-f30e467b3c5d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9d665c32-476f-4664-9b13-734907622aa0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "9f7fc7a8-fa17-41b6-8ddb-ecbcc9c9aa58", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6ac4fb94-4b9b-45fc-8f83-3e494437a757" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "9f90a712-a94c-4e09-a224-d80b025a3718", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a0141892-a7d8-424b-9d2c-c212a2be1ec7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4d6f2e6d-d007-4953-9db3-43ba205cbb03" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7d96e6de-ebd8-4cca-b47a-cb56910a62a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a052c121-92c1-4363-a886-d61318ba7c7d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40e501a4-d68a-4a41-b814-f6a969c437a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0bb27f0f-33fa-4689-bfcc-be72b4589a0a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "a06e48f0-645a-4370-854e-dcddababf776", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c763822e-ecdc-48df-bbb0-95560cfbb2dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "a28e34b3-f0ec-4d97-908a-a5dcdc714297", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0eca62e3-1d2f-44fa-bb80-1440427cd819" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a2a4f5d4-f24d-4188-a8e2-dd40625a9494", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4bd53fc9-dc76-431f-abf5-ff0f19f7a594" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a2dd866f-ad8f-455c-9922-3a18a7b08a11", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d14dcec4-cfe0-42ca-83a0-68b7e5b20492" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a390cba1-d71d-4197-bba7-962194787e89", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5941fc75-f20f-460f-ba3a-e629f41c9236" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a3f5d7b6-f477-4dbd-949e-bdf30dee4342", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "dfe05b5c-c7c7-4924-9651-8a498da7bc89" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "99a17277-b0fa-40cd-85f5-aead2480a1e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "a5356877-f392-4ad4-a549-8036bb99576d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ffe8016d-c5db-4da8-8c17-c58a0f504cfc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "a53e4cfc-647d-4bc4-bca8-2d71bd770888", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "afdc99d3-3a1a-441a-8d1a-616ba508d671" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9036edae-47e4-4816-a9e0-9711f1d2b744" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "a5937a0d-2290-475e-af50-6ded029bede0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5ef6000c-11f1-441c-8876-c4f762826ea3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a6bfa4ec-8c19-4955-a1e4-37024d28d161", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2871ad7f-3566-41f4-8dab-02f4e4fbf097" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a7278eb5-722e-47fb-b9ec-636890221237", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "91a5af71-fb83-4a63-8577-7d9bc35522f4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96eed2d4-37cc-4a23-b189-6727428536b6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "a764bf6a-3011-4094-aa92-d05ae6f5cb1c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "385119e0-70de-4c12-831a-477417c2ebb0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "a77fa223-6a57-42ed-b1cf-fbb31114778e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "90722a91-bf5e-4118-8c07-fa6f0977b83d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a3abbc1-18c3-487e-9f1f-71f407bed6d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8525ce5-8dbd-4cc2-8708-11732d93eb57", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "a868dc82-6446-4c9c-861e-8ed6c81cfbe5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee89f88c-59a9-463f-b3e9-5545d471e771" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "a8ea3b3a-6542-4256-965f-0cc747b3f36d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d38f26a-1cbc-4fa0-b206-1eb707da613b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "a9d83c5e-2090-44df-839a-fe0fb46d8f76", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d5c244a5-409b-4ecf-81c8-6ebd8063ee5f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "aa0bcf86-f549-4a30-8261-c0aee2cd2257", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e0f2e85e-a59f-4a54-a7f8-72afbc9ff983" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1c390ef2-1934-45ab-9705-5af40a80272e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "aaa8a928-39de-4bfc-84ae-fc495dc60341", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4e2bd3ff-de8a-4de6-b0c9-574720d92ad1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ab7787eb-d1dd-4b72-911d-d6cda3eb744f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0eca62e3-1d2f-44fa-bb80-1440427cd819" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d6b7d81-e9c1-44f7-8b42-1c3b5a2c75e2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "abb5b8f6-35d8-4768-9345-f43ad87f1928", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f792bc85-8e17-4c8c-92b4-534d430baa47" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe709bac-edf8-4e3b-8fb2-2134844958e0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "abb80ca2-0338-488f-930f-982575ae3a06", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b66aea01-ef52-4065-91d0-8709192e8914" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9d665c32-476f-4664-9b13-734907622aa0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "abc7ff50-ed5d-4f5b-b649-942cc288ba34", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "91a3368b-4e78-4a68-b79c-8e0d73fecc1d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "721c6269-4273-4cfd-aaf4-79d5cf8d7468" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "acc986d5-04ac-4b1c-8fd6-00be09cedf22", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9c07fc62-f94d-48a4-8d2f-ec17bcdd28bb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1671e648-f6da-4a86-b649-385a0184ce5e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "acd8fb67-1b92-4136-8dbf-a16512837226", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "90a0f0ed-3f8b-41dd-96e2-fe7f765be250" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "acdf8a7f-2bcf-40fe-8b05-40d1f4c37da6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe95dde6-0af4-4eec-848c-e24b06ca5491" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad0f1e8f-6c51-4a78-81df-8214e1914f48", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a3d8024-10e0-465e-8117-e623791b6145" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad6ace15-bce4-4905-8bfc-222cc0ec1561", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "92a722fa-df96-4b9d-a38f-1a2dc3198c21" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a8a44cf-52a1-4dbf-9abc-400d018f232e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "ad85c780-6f2d-45db-8847-b8a8b59a08c8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9aad3a05-6191-4951-900b-220daa07e422" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "afc8d0d8-f03b-4f76-a4a1-033035471bbe", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "b01bafd6-8498-4cdc-8ce3-3d9064bdac28", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e702efc3-129f-4907-8040-4154b51991a6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6eef154d-988c-4f96-88eb-c3ca0863d255" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "b04f415a-8245-47e8-96c1-83698c58ac1d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "b0f1f2dd-ef53-4134-a036-70e6780374be", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3732637d-4769-4f9e-bddf-1aeba54c394d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b18caf70-a00d-4d17-9d08-e400c699fc38", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe709bac-edf8-4e3b-8fb2-2134844958e0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a0c8a53-ec3b-489f-be71-3a9516728a64" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b23426c0-00cc-43cb-9a34-ee6c24efa506", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "99a17277-b0fa-40cd-85f5-aead2480a1e2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b2fc6c09-f9be-4a58-8f51-1875df5fd0f6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e506c68c-df22-4707-8a85-5c8cd12db447" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8dfb5819-cbb5-4d4e-b4bb-e9d2111fdc5d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "b3944256-b513-46b4-b2db-1b712afd3792", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "21daa771-4a4b-47a3-a06c-188836714f99" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "b3f7b828-301d-4af6-ac08-b996322d3ae0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c6c90d43-5472-4f55-ab73-63edf75bac16" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b462a1d9-cd28-4030-8ed6-e3958c4477a4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "b46e9b18-4121-4196-bbcd-2e76c6358c57", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "974d9e3c-ddce-4c27-83b0-9b19ed928095" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "b4f8421d-24fa-4e3f-a58e-d076ff511f4b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d3df672d-3db9-45ca-a66d-ab36127bc215" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a3abbc1-18c3-487e-9f1f-71f407bed6d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b528e1b5-a628-4ab0-95e1-f49aac85a923", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a8a44cf-52a1-4dbf-9abc-400d018f232e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "37a9360f-43b7-447f-a35b-d1e83f14d9e0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b6121d2f-d449-45cf-aa4a-2edeb604fcac", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "95730dd1-5b40-43c0-9f63-9e38c9855932" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f68f7978-2b0b-41d1-b4df-d03d9630ecfe" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b64009a2-f16a-4b18-9eea-34d968d6a264", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "05e28de6-a0f0-4396-8ae5-c809ae79470a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b653ef0c-7631-4cfe-84bc-b51da95e7301", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3f60eeaa-41f2-40ed-8b40-99e909e66705" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1ec0b6c7-b96e-4383-b41e-6478fe73eade" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "b771adf1-4571-47b1-8485-ccc8b1ff2557", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1c390ef2-1934-45ab-9705-5af40a80272e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b7a8e4a9-f836-4e00-b861-1c4f301a7804", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "97aef1a1-7d0e-47bb-87c1-0df0e41fdc6e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96d0e684-1033-429a-8ddd-b56fec05d3f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "b7f160b1-8b85-4e4f-a891-face54eb93d3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "b86d2485-6727-46f6-9d3c-bbe1c20eaf17", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "65592e81-5f15-4859-8fa7-111f8fb6cff5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "18684157-20eb-44e7-b214-a290d151cb59" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b875917e-5b5d-4c35-90e7-bc1bcb8e6ddd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96eed2d4-37cc-4a23-b189-6727428536b6" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "b8a566a6-84c5-4654-9014-3f875e5a0056", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe6568b2-bee4-4586-8f52-26805e60cdbc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "77fd25cb-6988-49fe-85f7-f8196357b52d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "b8aae494-f2de-48d6-885b-c175b720f752", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40e60464-1067-477f-88f4-65e81a8f324d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "b9ec90f2-d82d-4b76-b322-7539172d60c6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee433e1d-eb31-4655-b604-b21d5bb073ba" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ba7ecdbc-5389-4b94-bee0-4261be793c5a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40e501a4-d68a-4a41-b814-f6a969c437a9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d7be43d7-f7f7-4dab-9b23-5a9be8142259" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "bb068424-3a20-4508-9c1d-82bc17e2db54", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40ae5990-1fe8-4952-afca-0b8225a23e6f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "08cf2d06-6118-45b2-b917-b56278ca8db0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "bb24e935-72c2-4a34-b250-72b7d79d5962", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "eaa8abe6-de0b-43b6-97a9-a9272dfe92b6" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9aad3a05-6191-4951-900b-220daa07e422" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "bb424c23-29da-4748-8464-f4fd962af243", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a8d371cb-476e-4e64-8ec1-ee78e36bb77d" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "bb9bf078-38cd-423b-9291-2ddaf5e4bc66", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d63b37ad-8225-4727-ad98-b4a45dda927d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "bc01cf1c-2bbc-4829-a0f6-d1c3ef3d277d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "bc8d7ba3-0526-4e66-9bcc-64a6c9bb2de7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f68f7978-2b0b-41d1-b4df-d03d9630ecfe" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "bd053e6a-80f1-4649-ac21-e4a1e47141a1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "55c1c19e-e901-4d0c-aced-1af921f5fd17" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "bd730f1d-3723-4256-9482-74149b9abd14", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "da11ebf0-9325-457e-a51a-6407143cd087" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "bde847e3-bea7-4f02-8419-64c61f0b7c5b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8e380600-60e3-428f-891a-7ec0ca4c43a2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "be162ee4-067c-4d55-ae8b-48ade5364b2b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6905418b-e728-4e0f-aa48-0ded224b59dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "be5abf2f-2ec3-46da-9bf5-a2c61a747868", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "460ccd42-8184-4268-befd-97edb0929545" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "bec5c245-6204-4c38-84d1-1c40cd671116", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f2cd0b78-c817-4990-853a-952f9664db70" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "bf9acdfa-c778-4138-ba2e-95ffdb100172", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b66aea01-ef52-4065-91d0-8709192e8914" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6b76d547-7f67-49d7-a4fa-819da8eef644" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "c0188977-7ef0-4d5d-b103-eb41b4454552", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1f9628ca-e3b7-46a8-a4b2-520914b93dd9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c043ac2a-839b-4058-a27a-31b5cfe3ceec", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4757ed81-2471-447b-aa1c-e2dc96857251" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c0a2ff10-7a6a-485b-b464-cc0efa0e4a9d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8931b58a-6641-4cb8-aeb9-53be7ae0b273" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "c10d377d-cee8-417c-8316-03ab179001fd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "c1fd08ca-69f8-411c-bf7f-a2eea7ebb826", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6d6c7aa0-9d33-4c69-a6cf-60c18e54c3f2" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c0d896e4-80d8-4023-9730-0806398e4851" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "c2812c49-d34e-4103-b8bf-88e8234d6203", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8320d111-efac-4e6e-917c-155eeed3e75c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c2bf6c07-7a8f-4bb9-9ee8-4a83033afeca", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "77fd25cb-6988-49fe-85f7-f8196357b52d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "38fe9b25-2b61-427b-857b-e963328d102d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c3be0fe2-ebf4-427f-8946-87908f392133", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a8a44cf-52a1-4dbf-9abc-400d018f232e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c415034f-6cb8-47b5-a824-3327aa1737bb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "95730dd1-5b40-43c0-9f63-9e38c9855932" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c4386389-524d-414e-a0af-5bb7448e0a37", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "afdc99d3-3a1a-441a-8d1a-616ba508d671" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "553b5225-b85c-4687-b3ff-6754532e9f0e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "c545a5c0-6a37-46c3-a177-81f526a143ae", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a37dc4c9-fcdc-4446-88b9-f165cd12bf2b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "c6122e0a-2cbe-4d73-9c29-c6e4ca4c3c47", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c763822e-ecdc-48df-bbb0-95560cfbb2dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c6143a98-1aee-4396-b04f-cc087737cd0c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8dfb5819-cbb5-4d4e-b4bb-e9d2111fdc5d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "c62bdb46-f947-4955-aa28-386b98c7ff66", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "52c44ef9-74d2-4f82-b812-7e6ec5e66ffe" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c681ee74-64ff-4ec3-9a3a-10b7e83861cd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "54f28df7-5f3a-4ece-9b76-75e53685c38d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c6c4a5c1-238a-498a-a721-cdd7b478a1bb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7550da13-db83-4bce-9985-958193aa3c7e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c7e60493-70dd-4298-a4fb-42668ff57b22", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1f9628ca-e3b7-46a8-a4b2-520914b93dd9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0e469e35-7b41-41f7-96e4-09f8150911c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c8077b0e-595e-436d-8ee7-e6bb7e528169", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5a738fe-a3d9-4e59-873c-6a254e2efe42" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "c8122b40-e3f2-4972-99ac-13675378737b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "974d9e3c-ddce-4c27-83b0-9b19ed928095" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d63b37ad-8225-4727-ad98-b4a45dda927d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "c8f4c741-1c5c-4849-ac32-875d48bd2485", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8d078209-7578-4c2c-91e2-95a324e3edf0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1be72514-8fff-4c87-a326-558b5fe17f8d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "c90e446f-e592-4d15-a82a-48f7568279fd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d74d7f69-3fdc-4852-8ea6-418d946ac898" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "c9922b3d-47c3-4ba0-b6b7-a7e1e5809893", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3732637d-4769-4f9e-bddf-1aeba54c394d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f29bd3b9-b4e4-4856-b1b3-0d0d39a3334f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ca0dc909-97f6-44f2-a39c-69ab92e499b4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3425226b-74d9-49e8-b6b0-81ed5f7d99bc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "caadcbbe-95a9-42c8-b833-f723d3ca871e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "48221685-65a4-4d3b-9d3b-3ed263901ece" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "cb3d8668-9f9a-4b61-b2c2-a7f1a4fef2ef", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ffe8016d-c5db-4da8-8c17-c58a0f504cfc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ab3e2ed7-41bd-435a-af10-6393ecf9402d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "cb4160d4-a5b2-446d-9d74-30545b6b3a2d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5f3a5562-d28a-4e1d-bb47-ec2dc96acf7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "cb65ee9b-5c65-4db6-848d-47f509fb964f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d04d22c3-d0ec-4d3b-8eec-440c01321cdb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "cc69ba3b-29ed-40cd-9cab-02f74ee2e75e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3b4d0854-9765-4449-8c17-f11a17a87289" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7550da13-db83-4bce-9985-958193aa3c7e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "cc9391a7-c38e-4a85-be86-8dbdfa5ec3d6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c974c2ec-c6e3-413a-b75f-380f1727682c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7cf6c327-c289-496e-96b8-6abc8853e962" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ccc380bc-148a-4258-bf00-1f3b2b2b9dbe", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fea06b16-e24e-4993-be0a-5a969c137293" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "cd014974-7e15-4a27-912c-b9e9bfc5d190", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a3d8024-10e0-465e-8117-e623791b6145" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "ce164b8d-6d38-4d58-8421-9bbc1c4d8b5e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee89f88c-59a9-463f-b3e9-5545d471e771" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ce7848ee-4d72-4782-b2ef-69411d1e5aae", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "460ccd42-8184-4268-befd-97edb0929545" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ceaf1e9d-48e5-4b49-8c54-bed5b483db86", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "55c1c19e-e901-4d0c-aced-1af921f5fd17" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8dfb5819-cbb5-4d4e-b4bb-e9d2111fdc5d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "cf741ae4-e47d-49a3-993a-b154140606b1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7da6473f-f62f-4875-b2bf-99a2861c1f01" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "cfafdca3-46ed-44be-90ca-2f4243a7cf54", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b90ce42-ea39-4ac9-9947-695e623512f9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "d18ac187-36ff-47b7-b1a6-5c726591b138", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2eedb8ce-b3a7-4650-9a4d-1050dc5d9fa5" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "d1fd0117-dcd7-4ea8-a04d-87d9a775efb9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9d665c32-476f-4664-9b13-734907622aa0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "d211c0e0-a204-459b-b5f6-7fabff81091f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e61a6eec-6f69-4805-af23-cae030455161" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "d28867cd-5215-4414-93db-32c97e454889", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "d29cd372-5ebe-412b-ae73-538d3cb05ea0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "73d7490f-8233-46ed-a2d0-d7740467c1cb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "d2cf35f1-4cb4-4c92-91ca-40ab628e0074", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "816bf987-3c94-48ba-84d4-11773460c316" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "05e28de6-a0f0-4396-8ae5-c809ae79470a" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "d42f40c6-f197-4abf-b764-4ff1e1df93fc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "023bc875-efb4-4bc2-9023-84d089050319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "d4d52b57-071c-4bc0-8d64-c759f4948ca0", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1380e9c6-2526-421f-a548-fdcd5841a363" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "d4f8f47c-0242-480e-8a2a-d403a7323436", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0e08c65d-e10d-44c2-8de9-d22d56134c96" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b37c8b13-69fd-4997-b31b-0b2e9faf91f7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "d5569ec1-0e89-415f-9a53-d2b806d31ebf", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e0f163b2-6bb7-453a-9512-f6111f59f79f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "460ccd42-8184-4268-befd-97edb0929545" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "d5f50109-b46a-42d5-9e6a-31ca584defc2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4c9e7fb2-5060-4376-8493-23b1b42124a5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "d614aa69-be5b-40e6-b227-3a92e588a7de", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2a2cbbf9-5753-42c8-b4bc-3ad2736ef17c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "dd7a95d5-d2e8-4177-8dd7-0a3d6c0e0414" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "d6c0bec6-e853-4d3e-a0de-0cf12519c49c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "d70336e7-f779-4636-a274-ec06d8fde1a9", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ee433e1d-eb31-4655-b604-b21d5bb073ba" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "d7e9e605-5e15-45b4-91a4-43a5e7e1e92b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fea06b16-e24e-4993-be0a-5a969c137293" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "678f24ef-4a08-46f2-b1bf-ce9bd2e06186" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "d8820fa5-ab04-493b-97c7-6ceb2fd4c135", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "60b61cd3-f325-4953-9104-18d2633464e0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "d97276ed-fcf5-4a95-840a-fed8f3506861", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "da250528-0f74-4e8a-8c0d-5f0b7bd899ee", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bb4a78e5-26cc-4eb0-912f-deefb3b9e365" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7ed01886-5b4f-4620-a3d7-11f15b460553" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "da5d8474-324b-49e8-bdd4-43e68274a5ae", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3c77b43b-731c-4c6d-8b17-b3dcb512138e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c6c90d43-5472-4f55-ab73-63edf75bac16" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "da61a201-24fd-4bf4-9d2d-5cd8b9c212a3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d02b7a51-a0dd-4ee2-b326-cf4b12c75152" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "66cfce9c-6795-49d6-a391-6bb0e09fbe76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "daa1ef36-f76d-4c13-943f-eb780d27cb55", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1671e648-f6da-4a86-b649-385a0184ce5e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "db441c71-f951-4374-b770-9a2857ee7352", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "40e60464-1067-477f-88f4-65e81a8f324d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4bd53fc9-dc76-431f-abf5-ff0f19f7a594" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "db93b507-2d9d-4087-932d-f7f3a390d977", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6449dfdb-22d9-445e-af24-324dff9b9873" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "681f483b-8f7f-4341-a8ca-0c620be2957c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "dc801fe5-67c2-4ab4-a2c6-e1e0e7df8550", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "95730dd1-5b40-43c0-9f63-9e38c9855932" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4bd53fc9-dc76-431f-abf5-ff0f19f7a594" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "dc900783-9903-4117-b5ad-7b68464451f8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c0d896e4-80d8-4023-9730-0806398e4851" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "18684157-20eb-44e7-b214-a290d151cb59" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "dd40e585-6230-4100-b93c-642c5be5e9db", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "dd69643d-dbb8-41bd-a76d-c4dd37cbdba8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5b90ce42-ea39-4ac9-9947-695e623512f9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "df4e8fad-ce85-468c-836e-2f6723d3b068", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96d0e684-1033-429a-8ddd-b56fec05d3f7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e010b136-7cee-4057-83d3-04b99b34bc99", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fbe67225-70e2-49e2-b84e-f1af1a8f59e5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "e028be69-286f-4b02-8156-8835468f50df", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "553b5225-b85c-4687-b3ff-6754532e9f0e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e08d1048-6737-454a-985c-468eb0b1ffb8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "48221685-65a4-4d3b-9d3b-3ed263901ece" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "e0a702fc-aa6d-4218-879a-7a4fc0aba493", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4757ed81-2471-447b-aa1c-e2dc96857251" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7d96e6de-ebd8-4cca-b47a-cb56910a62a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e0b07ee2-7e6d-4318-b59d-18bac05355be", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d74d7f69-3fdc-4852-8ea6-418d946ac898" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f99d6f39-bca4-4f36-8996-1774fbf41683" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e14ce435-e098-4f6f-982c-e8f33a6de7a7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "95730dd1-5b40-43c0-9f63-9e38c9855932" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9f087de1-9f22-4ba7-829f-f4e95ffc6c5c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e21b3c6d-c0d0-464f-a824-6f6d1dbf63ec", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1e2d0069-59a6-4ffa-a722-f1bff0a377a0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e21bdf59-d3d6-4442-8842-1dd02b229a6b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "247b9d17-13d3-4364-8ce6-4283171fedf8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "e22fb6f9-bb8b-45f7-916d-69e12d2257f7", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1671e648-f6da-4a86-b649-385a0184ce5e" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e30ae6e1-c351-4bf5-8492-2a72729b342f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c6c90d43-5472-4f55-ab73-63edf75bac16" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e33e1316-cfe4-492f-b624-9038e81c7600", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "678f24ef-4a08-46f2-b1bf-ce9bd2e06186" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5f3a5562-d28a-4e1d-bb47-ec2dc96acf7b" + }, + "type": "produced", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e352db4f-f2a3-4b37-ad49-004e5aa66799", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5a8a44cf-52a1-4dbf-9abc-400d018f232e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4bd53fc9-dc76-431f-abf5-ff0f19f7a594" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e38fdb01-3fa1-4326-b8d2-47a92a657da1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9c07fc62-f94d-48a4-8d2f-ec17bcdd28bb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "e3b65634-232a-4015-9bdf-e32f4f7e8282", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "023bc875-efb4-4bc2-9023-84d089050319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d14dcec4-cfe0-42ca-83a0-68b7e5b20492" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e411aa45-5b05-44a9-82b3-219329cc499f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "4757ed81-2471-447b-aa1c-e2dc96857251" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e49c4b1d-68d1-44c0-b4f8-4742639f2646", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9194810b-f16f-44b3-b559-fae811852615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "e5067986-9167-4887-944f-45641ccf7b8b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "96d0e684-1033-429a-8ddd-b56fec05d3f7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e5533028-660c-468d-8338-23e49e4485cc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f998ef35-e4e8-4e2e-90b1-10a8b0a21de4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e598cc40-3aa1-4abd-ae59-2532c038a6ef", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9194810b-f16f-44b3-b559-fae811852615" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "e62c2da3-1bb5-496e-875b-fc575d2b63a5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "e6f93b04-4f90-489b-8485-845000692b0d", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "e70e7ecf-de34-4b0a-8fda-a1a4cc0dbb66", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8931b58a-6641-4cb8-aeb9-53be7ae0b273" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "e8229152-8ea5-4824-b764-37f6aeb38e19", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "e868299b-36bb-4bda-9ad0-e989b6bce853", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "023bc875-efb4-4bc2-9023-84d089050319" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a0c8a53-ec3b-489f-be71-3a9516728a64" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "e94e6974-840c-443e-9fd8-74bd4000ca92", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "2093362a-2441-427e-a4bb-ddf5bf99bdf8" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6449dfdb-22d9-445e-af24-324dff9b9873" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "ea81091b-a045-4de1-9a1d-b961ad43be80", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "66cfce9c-6795-49d6-a391-6bb0e09fbe76" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ea8bce98-d3d5-4099-97ca-79583e9b6b8c", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c0d896e4-80d8-4023-9730-0806398e4851" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5ef6000c-11f1-441c-8876-c4f762826ea3" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "eab00eb5-ef9f-47f5-80cc-1ad90f216335", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a7a6b666-d2c1-4be2-aa82-08eb6a924d4e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "ebf8720d-6bd3-4dfe-b3c9-c02fa1e4b2e6", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7d96e6de-ebd8-4cca-b47a-cb56910a62a9" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "ec306be4-78a6-4bd6-bbac-d82d03ec76dc", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1f9628ca-e3b7-46a8-a4b2-520914b93dd9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ec6cb3b1-2c88-46e5-933e-565bc7e4fd6b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "80db7faa-5e3c-4b0f-af86-db52fa83a721" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fe95dde6-0af4-4eec-848c-e24b06ca5491" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ec8d4a0f-0ec7-43be-a754-3c6d0ab92133", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bbdd2acb-60d9-4a9e-a268-7c08007cc57d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d7be43d7-f7f7-4dab-9b23-5a9be8142259" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z" + }, + { + "id": "eccc29c5-0d7a-4945-b516-d6dc51192588", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b37c8b13-69fd-4997-b31b-0b2e9faf91f7" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ed207236-1c86-4b08-9a8e-ad91e4b1d660", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7f65187e-fd0b-4c4d-857e-6323ced88337" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "460ccd42-8184-4268-befd-97edb0929545" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "ede11d6d-eb0a-44a4-8312-032384602b48", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "05e28de6-a0f0-4396-8ae5-c809ae79470a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ea15c1bd-7368-4df1-ab3f-55c5542edffe" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ef0f1735-71ed-490c-b1b5-03856c1fe751", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b549e671-ea24-45cc-b065-0d8e2c94b79f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "62cf145d-ff61-4b06-82c8-5ff0d9254594" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "f0fc05dc-6608-4d2d-86f2-1351e6012a90", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d3df672d-3db9-45ca-a66d-ab36127bc215" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f14fdb1b-b5e5-415f-aacf-4b073912688b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "3425226b-74d9-49e8-b6b0-81ed5f7d99bc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f51ce22a-c2d1-453e-8a18-05fa68df0385" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f1991cfa-fb6a-466d-8504-893dec7bf0dd", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "62cf145d-ff61-4b06-82c8-5ff0d9254594" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "479979d4-3463-4dd4-839a-b0a4f843d465" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f1ff5fd5-9956-4aa4-ad00-e9d5aefe034a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "05e28de6-a0f0-4396-8ae5-c809ae79470a" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f202b60a-757d-46b8-94e7-b960b21579d8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "90722a91-bf5e-4118-8c07-fa6f0977b83d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d3df672d-3db9-45ca-a66d-ab36127bc215" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "f31151a4-43ac-4175-94c4-5da037a3b67a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f51ce22a-c2d1-453e-8a18-05fa68df0385" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "f3508347-4dec-4b64-bfd7-fefe7446bda3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b549e671-ea24-45cc-b065-0d8e2c94b79f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "479979d4-3463-4dd4-839a-b0a4f843d465" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "f3b3cc96-8395-4aee-a9e2-e7b1d82e9d2f", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "681f483b-8f7f-4341-a8ca-0c620be2957c" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "f3d9b763-9f79-408f-9667-877a18e17ce2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9c07fc62-f94d-48a4-8d2f-ec17bcdd28bb" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "f3e2356f-276d-4498-81ef-507a69b80952", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "479979d4-3463-4dd4-839a-b0a4f843d465" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "f42f4c6b-dc4c-4157-825f-cdd21feb97f1", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "effa3c4f-e621-47e1-8b01-20c710572063" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "f4b7795e-36ce-4994-a2be-26edf0065f43", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d7be43d7-f7f7-4dab-9b23-5a9be8142259" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "f50f95a5-143a-4259-89ac-18ce9898dfc5", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "5f3a5562-d28a-4e1d-bb47-ec2dc96acf7b" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f5b88870-5409-40fc-bc10-55f5a7823b69", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b629e743-2496-4a8e-a7fb-16a4265fb0f9" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f69cf545-87e6-4d6c-8cdd-4b8941421707", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c763822e-ecdc-48df-bbb0-95560cfbb2dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f6a54ecb-0733-4b86-af9e-3b4c6e372cb8", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "a7a6b666-d2c1-4be2-aa82-08eb6a924d4e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "f6c922d4-dd1c-4fc9-9896-c31fbde6ae8b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "97aef1a1-7d0e-47bb-87c1-0df0e41fdc6e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "f74b758b-5fbe-4ffc-9746-15eeb8c47d96", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1a3abbc1-18c3-487e-9f1f-71f407bed6d8" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "f76790f6-c53a-4f11-8f94-d3886acfe892", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311" + }, + "type": "informed_by", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "f8b10398-0e82-4d9e-b9e8-8909c4a89006", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "6905418b-e728-4e0f-aa48-0ded224b59dc" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "716c1698-8c7e-4dc8-bbb9-3b955e5dd62e" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "fa30dba4-6235-4f9d-9475-59f3cb63275b", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "721c6269-4273-4cfd-aaf4-79d5cf8d7468" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "91a3368b-4e78-4a68-b79c-8e0d73fecc1d" + }, + "type": "rejected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "fbb2cc4d-0e8c-4c81-bd2c-05f84e4876ea", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "62cf145d-ff61-4b06-82c8-5ff0d9254594" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "fbe1c222-99ea-4a21-805c-dedc4bead8f2", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "62cf145d-ff61-4b06-82c8-5ff0d9254594" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ccedddb8-be2a-4f92-8387-613026db6622" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "fc9d4a1e-ef2d-4a0a-ba2b-469b900f86b3", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "55c1c19e-e901-4d0c-aced-1af921f5fd17" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d63b37ad-8225-4727-ad98-b4a45dda927d" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "fcc5054d-096b-4712-9d61-2fd2a40d4101", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1c390ef2-1934-45ab-9705-5af40a80272e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "fd156715-ded7-46cb-837f-446ad313389e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27" + }, + "type": "selected", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "fd3b0dfe-73ed-435b-a3ea-4705f31e10ed", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "18684157-20eb-44e7-b214-a290d151cb59" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "fda491f8-9fe6-4141-ab13-d31c53a128ce", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "681f483b-8f7f-4341-a8ca-0c620be2957c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "d854ab71-2a25-4574-9495-d0b6fc0d84df" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "fdc7b0fb-7045-4fd3-959a-d1e3d673e55e", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "ca16b154-6542-41da-9b36-56ffb1e3131c" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "1e2d0069-59a6-4ffa-a722-f1bff0a377a0" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + }, + { + "id": "fe97fe81-be30-4421-bfec-4fa2c102844a", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1" + }, + "type": "considered", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "fedbe3a0-f940-4dc4-b322-36098bc31372", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "9826eef7-523b-4a55-aac8-93d83d8bac4e" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "783411a6-8e56-478c-8059-78d7d8e58ba2" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z" + }, + { + "id": "ff4a7539-ee8d-4b88-b469-c9bad3a425eb", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "0e469e35-7b41-41f7-96e4-09f8150911c7" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z" + }, + { + "id": "ff4fd2e9-fdba-48c7-bb48-ff12136885a4", + "source": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "7f65187e-fd0b-4c4d-857e-6323ced88337" + }, + "target": { + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "nodeId": "c6c90d43-5472-4f55-ab73-63edf75bac16" + }, + "type": "derived_from", + "rationale": null, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z" + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/nodes.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/nodes.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5210f48da --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_originals/macro-view/nodes.json @@ -0,0 +1,4756 @@ +[ + { + "id": "023bc875-efb4-4bc2-9023-84d089050319", + "displayId": "R33", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected' shall render at full opacity; PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' (or 'open' on a non-taken branch) shall render at reduced opacity (approximately 30%) to indicate they were not taken.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "040d4e6b-ccd6-428d-8009-dcd14ed366a5", + "displayId": "X7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "In the spec-elicitation system, fan-out runs 2–3 independent clean-room derivation sessions from the same upstream context, and fan-in is a separate LLM agent that synthesizes the minimal viable set before reconciliation.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "05b16ab1-9fcf-42a2-8261-9990b238b92c", + "displayId": "X6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The CRT/phosphor design language is a project-wide standard defined in .impeccable.md, covering amber primary color, dark-only theme, phosphor glow behavior, scanline texture, and JetBrains Mono font.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "05e28de6-a0f0-4396-8ae5-c809ae79470a", + "displayId": "R30", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view shall reuse the existing src/components/DetailPanel.tsx component for the right-side detail panel; no separate macro-specific detail panel component shall be introduced. DetailPanel may be extended internally to branch on the new record kinds (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, perspective).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "07be4f25-faa9-4c8c-aad9-a0739b68298d", + "displayId": "CR20", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Within a single frame containing all four phases, the y-coordinates of the four PhaseGroupNodes satisfy y(defining_done) < y(pinning) < y(shaping) < y(grounding) (defining_done at top of frame visually). Verify with a unit-test fixture.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "08cf2d06-6118-45b2-b917-b56278ca8db0", + "displayId": "T2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The spec-elicitation system's derivation process consists of four phases in strict dependency order: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "0bb27f0f-33fa-4689-bfcc-be72b4589a0a", + "displayId": "R24", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Collapsed/expanded state shall not be written to localStorage, sessionStorage, cookies, the URL/query string, IndexedDB, or any other persistence layer; it shall exist only in React in-memory state for the lifetime of the component instance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0c1a8702-9ca5-447b-8915-2a42ede7114a", + "displayId": "R21", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view layout shall be implemented as a custom recursive (DFS) algorithm computing absolute positions and subtree bounding boxes; it shall not use dagre, ELK, or any other general-purpose graph layout library.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0df4dc45-ae56-4ecd-a3ea-3a1435b5a42f", + "displayId": "CR10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "User can pan and zoom the canvas: simulating a mouse-wheel event over the React Flow pane changes the viewport zoom level, and a mouse-drag on the pane changes the viewport translation. Verify with a React Flow integration test using fireEvent.wheel and fireEvent.mouseDown/Move/Up, asserting useReactFlow().getViewport() values change accordingly.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0e08c65d-e10d-44c2-8de9-d22d56134c96", + "displayId": "CR55", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For each ReconciliationRecord with non-empty resolvedImpasseIds, layout emits a resolution edge from the corresponding ReconciliationNode to each resolved ImpasseNode. Edge has computed stroke color resolving to the resolving phase's --color-phase-* token, stroke-style solid, markerEnd arrow, and the routing path returns leftward (i.e., target node x < source node x, or via a custom edge component that produces a leftward bend). Verify with a fixture asserting source.x > target.x and computed style.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0e469e35-7b41-41f7-96e4-09f8150911c7", + "displayId": "X11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the macro view shares the CRT phosphor design language (amber primary, JetBrains Mono, dark warm surfaces, phosphor glow, scanline textures).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "0ebe864a-b89f-4779-b7cb-08166de38479", + "displayId": "CR32", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking on a PhantomNode in the rendered macro view does NOT dispatch any select action and does not change global selection state. The PhantomNode's DOM element exposes no role='button' or interactive cursor style. Verify with an RTL test: render fixture with phantom, click it, assert store.select spy was not called and computed style cursor != 'pointer'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0eca62e3-1d2f-44fa-bb80-1440427cd819", + "displayId": "A2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: model the derivation history as a generic graphlib graph and feed it through a layered layout, then translate to React Flow at the end.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "0fde5f0d-6164-4e30-ad21-122118f4739e", + "displayId": "X29", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: bail reconciliation outcome visual treatment intentionally matches the failed run treatment for consistency.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1017505f-e0bd-4e36-9a6d-bf94db013909", + "displayId": "DEC6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Hoist a single Set of collapsed IDs to MacroView root, in-memory only.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "Collapse changes the global layout (sibling shifts, X22), so the set must be visible to the layout function; per-node local state forces a redundant lift. C8/C9 forbid persistence, ruling out localStorage. A single Set keeps the toggle O(1), is trivially serializable for unit tests, and makes the snapshot-load+expanded-default invariant a one-liner (initial state = empty set)." + }, + { + "id": "12b165e9-854d-4e63-b9d7-db807aae279f", + "displayId": "DEC9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Render only the three workflow edge classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), synthesized from frame/run/fan-in/reconciliation records, not from EdgeRecord rows.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "The macro view narrates the derivation process (G1, X3); content-level edges belong to the micro view (X2). Three semantically named edge classes give the narrative structure (fan-out→fan-in→reconcile, impasse opens a lane, resolution closes it back) while keeping the rendered edge count proportional to the ~20–40 nodes. Implicit-only edges leave the resolution arc invisible. Each edge class uses one already-justified color (amber for trunk flow, red for impasse, phase color for resolution), respecting C7." + }, + { + "id": "1380e9c6-2526-421f-a548-fdcd5841a363", + "displayId": "CR45", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A DerivationRunNode with status='running' has: (a) a CSS animation property whose name is or includes 'phosphor-arrive' on the node body; (b) a header chip with textContent 'RUNNING' and computed color resolving to --color-phosphor-cyan; (c) a descendant element with a CSS animation that visibly translates across the node interior (scanline sweep). The node remains clickable: click dispatches a select action. Verify with an RTL test asserting style.animationName, chip text and color, and click dispatch.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "13de9f34-6822-4684-abda-e9d41fff337d", + "displayId": "CR37", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Static-analysis scan of src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx} finds no imports from @mui/*, @chakra-ui/*, antd, react-bootstrap, or other generic UI component libraries. CSS scan finds no border-radius value greater than 4px on any macro view selector (allowing only sharp/squared corners). No element uses a Tailwind class indicating blue primary buttons (e.g., bg-blue-*) for primary actions. Verify with combined import-graph and CSS-grep tests.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1449cf2f-b31c-4491-bbac-a82f01bd09c1", + "displayId": "R34", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "All colors, fonts, surfaces, glow, and scanline treatments used by macro view components shall be drawn from existing tokens defined in src/styles/theme.css (oklch phosphor palette, --font-mono, --color-surface-0..3, --color-phosphor-*, --color-phase-*, --color-text-*). Macro view code shall not introduce hard-coded hex/rgb/hsl colors or new top-level palette tokens.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1671e648-f6da-4a86-b649-385a0184ce5e", + "displayId": "R64", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "No single visual channel on a macro node shall encode more than one semantic attribute. Specifically: phase color shall encode only phase identity; border color shall encode only run/reconciliation outcome (red=failed/bail, amber=retry/nudging-related, cyan=recurse/running, phase color=accepted); border style shall encode only frame mode; fill/dim level shall encode only failure-or-bail status; opacity shall encode only perspective selectedness; shape (diamond) shall encode only impasse identity. New attributes shall not be added to existing channels without re-justifying all collisions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "17801bea-4dae-47d6-9df7-efd504ac369b", + "displayId": "A11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: persist collapse state across reloads (localStorage). Rejected by C8/C9.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "17d85cdf-a1c6-4aec-83ae-a4e98c034af4", + "displayId": "DEC10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Animated phosphor-arrive loop + cyan 'RUNNING' chip + scanline sweep on running runs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X26 says running is unlikely but must be highlighted. Cyan is the one phosphor token not yet load-bearing in macro semantics (red=failure/bail, amber=nudging/retry, green=merged/success, purple=defining_done phase, phase colors=phase identity), so it cleanly marks an in-flight state without colliding with C7. Animation distinguishes running from any static state at a glance. Reusing the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe keeps the addition cheap and within the established CRT motion vocabulary." + }, + { + "id": "18684157-20eb-44e7-b214-a290d151cb59", + "displayId": "C6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The design language explicitly prohibits generic UI patterns such as Material Design, Tailwind defaults, SaaS dashboard aesthetics, rounded corners, or blue primary buttons.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "19d7de94-94a3-4216-95b2-74b2eab9ba27", + "displayId": "C7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Color additions to the palette must be semantically justified, not decorative — every color must earn its place by carrying meaning a user needs to distinguish at a glance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "1a0c8a53-ec3b-489f-be71-3a9516728a64", + "displayId": "T7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The HubNode type has hubType of justification | decision | impasse | perspective, and carries impasseStatus (open | resolved | superseded) and perspectiveStatus (open | selected | rejected).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "1a3abbc1-18c3-487e-9f1f-71f407bed6d8", + "displayId": "C5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "This brief is scoped exclusively to the macro view component and its rendering of the derivation story; other parts of the UI are explicitly out of scope.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1a3d8024-10e0-465e-8117-e623791b6145", + "displayId": "T13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The onion-peel structure refers to the iterative cycle of impasse discovery, rederivation, fan-out/fan-in synthesis, reconciliation, and resolution that builds the derivation history.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "1bdf650d-a20c-43ab-adca-8392908c0c07", + "displayId": "X36", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a ReconciliationRecord with outcome='bail' is the mechanism by which a branch becomes a dead-end impasse.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1be72514-8fff-4c87-a326-558b5fe17f8d", + "displayId": "C10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view is strictly read-only; users can pan, zoom, and collapse/expand nodes, but cannot trigger any data mutations.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "1c390ef2-1934-45ab-9705-5af40a80272e", + "displayId": "R19", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The layout shall size each depth lane's width as a function of the maximum content width across nodes at that depth, rather than using a single fixed lane-width constant for all depths.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1cc06880-4290-4d96-8f44-fd940282eb66", + "displayId": "R50", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each PhantomNode shall render as a dashed-outline ghost tile with no fill, bearing a label identifying it as a phantom (e.g., 'PHANTOM — no perspective taken').", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1dd86e5d-57a4-409e-9ef8-638edaa186dc", + "displayId": "T6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The ReconciliationRecord type captures reconciliation outcomes (accepted | retry | recurse | bail) along with candidateNodeIds, baselineNodeIds, activatedNodeIds, archivedNodeIds, triggerImpasseIds, resolvedImpasseIds, unresolvedImpasseIds, and a materialProgress flag.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "1e2d0069-59a6-4ffa-a722-f1bff0a377a0", + "displayId": "R43", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'failed' shall render with a border in --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1ec0b6c7-b96e-4383-b41e-6478fe73eade", + "displayId": "RK2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The bail reconciliation outcome and a failed run share the same red-border/dimmed-interior treatment by design, which could make the two visually indistinguishable at a glance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "1f9628ca-e3b7-46a8-a4b2-520914b93dd9", + "displayId": "R38", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each PhaseGroupNode shall render with: a 1px border in its phase color (drawn from --color-phase-*), a warm dark fill from --color-surface-1, a scanline overlay, and a header line displaying the phase name, frame displayId, and frame mode in --color-text-secondary.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2093362a-2441-427e-a4bb-ddf5bf99bdf8", + "displayId": "CR2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Importing MacroView from src/components/MacroView (the original path used by routes/explore.tsx) resolves to a working React component that renders without throwing. Verify with a Vitest + React Testing Library render test that imports from the legacy path and asserts the component mounts.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "211d3a93-410a-48b2-b033-dcdfa1da4a12", + "displayId": "D3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Manual layout algorithm: compute derivationDepth for each FrameRecord as the length of its parentFrameId chain; assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by depth (depth 0 = trunk at center, depth 1+ branches to the right). Within a lane, frames stack vertically with the most recent at the top (higher y ←→ more recent t+1). Each lane's width is computed as a function of the maximum content width across all nodes at that depth, not a fixed constant. Phase groups inside a frame stack vertically in PHASE_ORDER reverse (defining_done top, grounding bottom) so the eye reads downward through the derivation, while later frames sit above earlier ones at the lane level. The algorithm runs as a recursive DFS that returns subtree bounding boxes used to compute sibling offsets.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "21daa771-4a4b-47a3-a06c-188836714f99", + "displayId": "C12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Users must manually refresh to see new derivation steps in the macro view.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "22f0212e-182a-48d9-9a94-aa306709d673", + "displayId": "CR3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "package.json declares @xyflow/react at major version 12 (e.g., ^12.x), and the rendered MacroView DOM contains the React Flow root element wrapped by a ReactFlowProvider. Verify by (a) inspecting package.json with a unit test, and (b) a render test asserting that useReactFlow() called inside a child node throws no provider-missing error.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "247b9d17-13d3-4364-8ce6-4283171fedf8", + "displayId": "CR50", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "An ImpasseNode whose hub.id appears in some FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds where that frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome === 'bail' renders with a chip element whose textContent matches /DEAD[\\s-]?END/i. An ImpasseNode whose triggered frame did not bail (or that has no triggered frame) does NOT render this chip. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "27187a10-0e3d-44b6-9545-1837181b3a27", + "displayId": "D11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Render a small permanently-visible 'SNAPSHOT @ ' badge in the macro view's top-left corner using --color-text-tertiary, with a 'RELOAD' button next to it. Clicking RELOAD re-runs the pipeline. The banner sits above the React Flow canvas as a fixed overlay; it does not participate in pan/zoom.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "27c1e9fd-cc7c-48b5-aa7f-f33761dafdc8", + "displayId": "CR40", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A PhaseGroupNode for FrameRecord.mode='initial' has computed border-style 'solid'; mode='rederive' has 'double'; mode='grounding_enrichment' has 'dashed'. The header additionally contains a text chip whose textContent equals the mode value (case-insensitive). Verify with parameterized RTL tests across all three modes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "28200b6a-155f-47fd-8fe6-6764a818c901", + "displayId": "D2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Load the artifact exactly once on component mount via a useEffect/useMemo against the artifact source (file fetch or store selector), build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React Flow nodes/edges arrays into useState. No subscriptions, no live updates. Provide a manual 'Reload' affordance that re-runs the pipeline.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2871ad7f-3566-41f4-8dab-02f4e4fbf097", + "displayId": "A13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: lean heavily on icons (status icons, mode icons, outcome icons) instead of typographic chips and border treatments. Punchier visually but less information-dense per pixel and breaks the typographic CRT aesthetic.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "29ab00b7-de39-4936-8c23-d67d8f75ebfd", + "displayId": "DEC1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use a dedicated Story IR layer between artifact data and rendering.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "The macro view's spatial grammar (onion-peel breadth, phase containment, fan-out/fan-in nesting, perspective fade) is highly domain-specific and unstable while the design is being iterated. A typed IR isolates the domain mapping from layout math from React Flow specifics, letting each stage be unit-testable and letting the manual layout (mandated by C3) operate on a tree shape that already encodes parent/child semantics rather than re-deriving them. Direct RF mapping conflates concerns and makes the collapse/reflow logic (X22) harder. A generic graphlib representation loses the typed semantics the custom node renderers need." + }, + { + "id": "2a2cbbf9-5753-42c8-b4bc-3ad2736ef17c", + "displayId": "A18", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: amber pulsing border. Rejected because amber already encodes nudging (X25) and reconciliation 'retry' outcome (X28); reusing it for running creates ambiguity, violating C7's 'every color earns its place'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2cda9b0b-bb66-47b7-99df-c0e251d93dbd", + "displayId": "CR7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "MacroView renders a button with accessible name matching /reload/i. Clicking it re-invokes the artifact loader and produces a fresh React Flow node array (new array identity) reflecting any updated underlying data. Verify with React Testing Library: query button by role/name, click, assert loader spy called twice and that the rendered output reflects mutated mock data after the second load.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "2e7e28fb-a660-4e89-9d2d-b5c324acc2be", + "displayId": "X31", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: lane widths in the macro layout scale proportionally to the number of nodes at that depth rather than being fixed.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "2eedb8ce-b3a7-4650-9a4d-1050dc5d9fa5", + "displayId": "A14", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: encode all status/mode/outcome differences via fill color alone, leaving borders neutral. Easier but loses the orthogonal channels (border = outcome, fill = mode, chip = nudging) that let several attributes coexist on one node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3270ebda-b714-433b-a68d-d356f705df2a", + "displayId": "X2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The existing micro view is built with Sigma.js, handles 700+ nodes, and answers 'what does the graph look like now?'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "3276427a-9a12-4f0f-9373-01cd42de9b5f", + "displayId": "X39", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "src/styles/theme.css already defines the phosphor palette as oklch tokens including --color-phase-grounding (green), --color-phase-shaping (amber), --color-phase-pinning (cyan), --color-phase-defining-done (purple), plus --color-phosphor-red, surface-0..3 warm darks, and --font-mono JetBrains Mono.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "32a9281f-3502-4e5e-b2d5-91489e3386ce", + "displayId": "X33", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: clicking a node opens a detail panel on the right side of the screen.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "335af2ee-0a19-4506-9a90-457a5ffc6b84", + "displayId": "D9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Edges in the macro view encode three workflow relationships, each rendered as a typed React Flow edge: (1) sequence edges — thin amber lines connecting RunNode → FanInNode → ReconciliationNode within a phase group, expressing fan-out→fan-in→reconcile flow (T4/T5/T6); (2) impasse-spawn edges — red dashed lines from a ReconciliationNode (or a PhaseGroupNode whose phase produced impasses) outward to the ImpasseNode that opened a new lane, expressing that the impasse caused a child frame (X16, FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds); (3) resolution edges — phase-colored solid lines from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode (or activated nodes) back to the impasse it resolved, drawn with a return-leftward routing convention (T6.resolvedImpasseIds). Edges between sibling phase groups inside a frame follow PHASE_ORDER. All edges use markerEnd arrows, no animation by default. Edges within a collapsed group are hidden along with the group's children; the group's connecting external edges remain attached at the pill's perimeter.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3425226b-74d9-49e8-b6b0-81ed5f7d99bc", + "displayId": "R3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view shall render its graph using React Flow (@xyflow/react) at major version 12, mounted inside a ReactFlowProvider.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3480520a-8be9-4d20-8967-689ed7fce3ef", + "displayId": "CR57", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When provided a representative artifact fixture (drawn from the project's actual derivation history with N frames, where 5 ≤ N ≤ 15), the macro view renders a top-level semantic node count (PhaseGroupNodes + ImpasseNodes) in the range [20, 40]. The rendered edge count remains within an order of magnitude of the node count. Verify with a fixture-based test asserting count bounds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3483bc7f-1eb1-4160-9318-d045b0551c31", + "displayId": "CR39", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A rendered PhaseGroupNode has: (a) computed border-width 1px and border-color resolving to its --color-phase-* token; (b) computed background-color resolving to --color-surface-1; (c) a child element bearing a class or attribute identifying it as a scanline overlay; and (d) a header element containing the phase name, the frame's displayId, and the frame.mode text in --color-text-secondary. Verify with parameterized RTL tests for each phase, asserting computed styles and text content.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3732637d-4769-4f9e-bddf-1aeba54c394d", + "displayId": "R15", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a phase group ends without any selected PerspectiveNode, the IR builder shall synthesize a PhantomNode under that phase group; the PhantomNode shall not correspond to any record in ArtifactFile and shall be labelled to indicate 'no perspective taken'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "37a9360f-43b7-447f-a35b-d1e83f14d9e0", + "displayId": "X18", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: React Flow group/parent nodes are used for phase containers in the macro view.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "385119e0-70de-4c12-831a-477417c2ebb0", + "displayId": "R31", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "PhantomNode instances shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall not present any other interactive affordance.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "38fe9b25-2b61-427b-857b-e963328d102d", + "displayId": "C2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view is built inside a Vite + React + Tailwind SPA.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "39909718-a105-4273-990b-05c88349b0c1", + "displayId": "A10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: each PhaseGroupNode owns its own useState for collapsed/expanded. Local but means parent layout cannot recompute on toggle without lifting state anyway.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3b4d0854-9765-4449-8c17-f11a17a87289", + "displayId": "CR42", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A DerivationRunNode for a record with runIndex=3, inputNodeIds.length=5, outputCandidateIds.length=2, impassesFound.length=1 renders DOM containing: text matching /RUN\\s*#?\\s*3/, an input badge showing 5, an output badge showing 2, and an impasses-found indicator showing 1. Verify with a single RTL test on a fixture record.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3c77b43b-731c-4c6d-8b17-b3dcb512138e", + "displayId": "CR29", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its descendant DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode instances are absent from the rendered React Flow nodes array (or have hidden:true). Edges whose both endpoints lie inside the collapsed group are absent (or hidden). Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting child-node-id absence and internal-edge absence.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3d53a878-955c-4cff-a15c-724ec8f2f280", + "displayId": "R48", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each ImpasseNode shall render with a diamond/lozenge silhouette (distinct from the rectangular phase-group/run/fan-in/reconciliation shapes), a red glyph treatment, and its hub displayId visible on the node face.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "3f60eeaa-41f2-40ed-8b40-99e909e66705", + "displayId": "CR68", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given a fixture containing both a DerivationRunNode with status='failed' AND an ImpasseNode whose linked reconciliation outcome='bail' (the dead-end case): both nodes share red+dim treatment, but the ImpasseNode additionally renders a 'DEAD-END' chip while the failed RunNode does not, AND the ImpasseNode renders with the diamond shape while the RunNode is rectangular. Verify with an RTL test rendering both fixtures side by side and asserting these distinguishing features.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "40ae5990-1fe8-4952-afca-0b8225a23e6f", + "displayId": "R20", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Within a single frame, PhaseGroupNodes shall be stacked vertically in the reverse of PHASE_ORDER (defining_done at top, then pinning, then shaping, then grounding at bottom).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "40e501a4-d68a-4a41-b814-f6a969c437a9", + "displayId": "CR24", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "After collapsing one or more groups in MacroView, inspecting localStorage, sessionStorage, document.cookie, the URL/location (search/hash), and IndexedDB shows no key/entry containing collapsed FrameIds or any macro-view collapse state. After unmount + remount, all groups render expanded again. Verify with a JSDOM test that spies on storage APIs and asserts no setItem call with macro-related keys, and a remount test asserting state reset.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "40e60464-1067-477f-88f4-65e81a8f324d", + "displayId": "R53", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Impasse-spawn edges shall be rendered as red dashed lines with markerEnd arrows. The source endpoint shall be the ReconciliationNode (or PhaseGroupNode) that produced the impasse, and the target shall be the ImpasseNode that opens the child lane (FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "40ed5553-d6a7-45fe-8027-dbbc9f8177a6", + "displayId": "R51", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view shall render only three classes of edge between its nodes: (1) sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode within a phase group), (2) impasse-spawn edges (from a ReconciliationNode/PhaseGroupNode outward to the ImpasseNode opening a child lane), and (3) resolution edges (from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode back to the impasse it resolved). It shall not synthesize edges from arbitrary EdgeRecord rows in ArtifactFile.graph.edges.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "45ca6169-8866-43c4-befa-3fbb292a716d", + "displayId": "RK1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The visual treatment of a 'running' run status is underspecified — stakeholders consider it unlikely to appear but want it highlighted somehow, leaving the exact treatment open.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "460ccd42-8184-4268-befd-97edb0929545", + "displayId": "R27", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "After a collapse or expand toggle, sibling nodes' positions shall update so that no dead space remains where the collapsed group's children used to be (sibling reflow). External edges connecting to the collapsed group shall reattach to the pill's bounds without leaving dangling endpoints.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4757ed81-2471-447b-aa1c-e2dc96857251", + "displayId": "R44", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'running' shall render with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe animation looping at slow tempo on the node body, (b) a 'RUNNING' chip in --color-phosphor-cyan in the header, and (c) an animated scanline sweep across the node interior. The node shall remain clickable and shall display the same content fields as a completed run.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "479979d4-3463-4dd4-839a-b0a4f843d465", + "displayId": "X35", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the materialProgress flag is visualized as a subtle chip or checkmark inside the reconciliation node, alongside the outcome indicator.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "480c77f4-acb2-4d14-9d00-f82435f77e78", + "displayId": "C9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Every page load of the macro view starts fully expanded, with no memory of previously collapsed nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "48221685-65a4-4d3b-9d3b-3ed263901ece", + "displayId": "A4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: fixed lane width and fixed row height, regardless of content. Simple to implement but ignores X31's proportional-width preference and produces large dead space at shallow lanes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4ab25dc4-cd78-479c-a6ef-80e73edc3d71", + "displayId": "T9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The FrameRecord.nudgingActive flag indicates whether a minimal negative constraint nudge is active for that frame, relevant to representing non-termination handling.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "4bd53fc9-dc76-431f-abf5-ff0f19f7a594", + "displayId": "T3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The FrameRecord type includes: id, parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase, triggerImpasseIds, mode (initial | rederive | grounding_enrichment), attemptNumber, nudgingActive, createdAt, and summary.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "4c9e7fb2-5060-4376-8493-23b1b42124a5", + "displayId": "T8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The ArtifactFile type bundles all spec data into a single file: manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, and a graph object containing nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, reconciliationRecords, and snapshots.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "4d6f2e6d-d007-4953-9db3-43ba205cbb03", + "displayId": "A17", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: a static cyan 'RUNNING' chip with no animation. Calmer but defeats X26's 'highlighted somehow' intent.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4e2bd3ff-de8a-4de6-b0c9-574720d92ad1", + "displayId": "R26", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, the macro view shall render it as a compact pill displaying: a phase color dot, the frame's displayId, the run count (e.g., 'n RUNS'), and an outcome glyph derived from the frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome (✓ accepted, ↺ retry, ↪ recurse, ✗ bail). The pill shall remain clickable to expand it and to open the detail panel.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4ea662bf-4280-4914-b672-05495f457dd7", + "displayId": "CR1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A directory listing of src/components/macro/ contains at minimum: index.ts, MacroView.tsx, story-ir.ts, layout.ts, and a nodes/ subdirectory containing PhaseGroupNode.tsx, DerivationRunNode.tsx, FanInNode.tsx, ReconciliationNode.tsx, ImpasseNode.tsx, PerspectiveNode.tsx, and PhantomNode.tsx. Verify by automated filesystem assertion in a unit test (e.g., fs.readdirSync) listing each expected path.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "4f730fde-ce44-48d6-a603-ea188c5235c1", + "displayId": "T4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The DerivationRunRecord type includes: id, frameId, phase, runIndex, inputNodeIds, outputCandidateIds, impassesFound, status (running | completed | failed), and createdAt.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "4fa63a9f-9b53-4b45-9d65-2383c27f5141", + "displayId": "R40", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode for that frame shall display a textual chip (e.g., 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE') styled in --color-phosphor-amber inside the node header. The nudging indicator shall be inside the node body, not an external overlay.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "500c73ed-5d69-4142-825d-ce6f6c7a8ec9", + "displayId": "R32", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Faded (rejected/unselected) PerspectiveNode branches shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall present no interactive affordances.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5088cbf6-2180-4d41-bd88-6045691f35ad", + "displayId": "R45", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each FanInNode shall render its FanIn groupings as a stack of rows, one row per grouping, where each row is prefixed by a 4px-wide left border colored: green (success/merged token) when grouping.resolution='merged', amber (--color-phosphor-amber) when grouping.resolution='best_selected', and red (--color-phosphor-red) when grouping.resolution='impasse_surfaced'. Each row shall display the grouping's groupKey and a node count.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "52c44ef9-74d2-4f82-b812-7e6ec5e66ffe", + "displayId": "R42", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'completed' shall render with the base node treatment (no special border or dimming).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "54f28df7-5f3a-4ece-9b76-75e53685c38d", + "displayId": "T11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A dead-end impasse is one whose reconciliation chose the 'bail' outcome — the system gave up on that branch entirely.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "553b5225-b85c-4687-b3ff-6754532e9f0e", + "displayId": "R58", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The Story IR and layout modules shall consume the branded ID types defined in src/types/artifact.ts (NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, etc.) for keying records and shall not coerce these to plain strings at module boundaries.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "55c1c19e-e901-4d0c-aced-1af921f5fd17", + "displayId": "R17", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The layout shall assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by its derivationDepth, with depth 0 acting as the trunk and each increment opening a lane to the right (or otherwise increasing horizontal breadth) so that onion-peel depth is encoded in horizontal position.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5941fc75-f20f-460f-ba3a-e629f41c9236", + "displayId": "A5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: use ELK.js layered layout with manual constraints to encode lanes. Cheaper to implement than full manual layout but less precise about onion-peel breadth and conflicts with C3.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5a2324b6-aa4f-4ef6-af33-d1f0494836b6", + "displayId": "A9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: render the entire phase group's interior (runs, fan-in, reconciliation rows) as inner HTML inside a single React Flow node, without using RF parenting at all.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5a8a44cf-52a1-4dbf-9abc-400d018f232e", + "displayId": "R11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The story-ir / layout shall emit one PhaseGroupNode per (FrameRecord, Phase) pair that has any associated runs, fan-in, reconciliation, or perspective records.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5b342f91-e0b2-4687-a81a-c3143866cfd7", + "displayId": "R35", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "All textual content rendered inside macro view nodes, edges, banner, and pills shall use the var(--font-mono) (JetBrains Mono) font stack defined in theme.css.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5b90ce42-ea39-4ac9-9947-695e623512f9", + "displayId": "X27", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a failed run is shown with a red color and a dimmed interior.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5d165f62-25c0-4902-89f5-d3d16bc40c56", + "displayId": "CR56", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For every edge in the layout output (in the default, non-running state), edge.animated is falsy (undefined or false). Verify by a unit-test assertion across all edges in a representative fixture.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "5ef6000c-11f1-441c-8876-c4f762826ea3", + "displayId": "X37", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the visual design must feel like CRT/terminal aesthetic while preserving modern design principles; information density is high but not overwhelming.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "5f3a5562-d28a-4e1d-bb47-ec2dc96acf7b", + "displayId": "R6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The MacroView shall provide a manual 'RELOAD' button that, when clicked, re-runs the entire data load → IR → layout → render pipeline.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "60836423-1550-4b49-bac5-22ffead09574", + "displayId": "CR34", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='selected' renders with computed CSS opacity == 1.0 (or no opacity rule reducing it). A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='rejected' or 'open' (non-taken) renders with computed CSS opacity in the range [0.25, 0.35] (target ~0.3). Verify with RTL + getComputedStyle assertions on parameterized fixtures.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "60b61cd3-f325-4953-9104-18d2633464e0", + "displayId": "CR11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The nodeTypes object passed to contains exactly the seven keys: PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, PhantomNode (or 'phaseGroup','run','fanIn','reconciliation','impasse','perspective','phantom' equivalents) and no key matching /trunk/i. Verify with a unit test that imports the nodeTypes registry and asserts Object.keys length === 7 and contains the expected set.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "61d9342e-d2c6-43ee-a8b5-e2ce78a5d11d", + "displayId": "DEC8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Encode information across orthogonal visual channels (border style, border color, fill, header chips, opacity, shape) drawn from existing phosphor tokens.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "G3 demands at-a-glance comprehension and G4 demands that each node communicates its specific outcome; a single channel cannot carry mode + status + outcome + nudging + materialProgress simultaneously. Orthogonal channels honor C7 (every color earns meaning: border=outcome, phase color=phase, red=failure/bail, amber=warning states). Iconographic styling fights the JetBrains Mono / typographic CRT aesthetic (X11, X37). Reusing the seven oklch tokens already defined in theme.css avoids palette inflation and keeps C13 satisfied. The intentional collision between bail-outcome and failed-run treatment (X29) is preserved; RK2 is mitigated by adding a 'DEAD-END' textual chip on bail-linked impasses rather than diverging the color treatment." + }, + { + "id": "62cf145d-ff61-4b06-82c8-5ff0d9254594", + "displayId": "R47", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the corresponding ReconciliationNode shall render a small ✓ chip beside the outcome chip in its header.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6449dfdb-22d9-445e-af24-324dff9b9873", + "displayId": "R2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The existing src/components/MacroView.tsx import path shall continue to resolve to a working MacroView component (e.g., as a thin re-export of the new src/components/macro/ module) so that routes/explore.tsx and other existing importers do not require changes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "64a459d9-e4e1-46e7-b4ed-b5f66908d8e4", + "displayId": "CR21", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "package.json dependencies and devDependencies contain no entry for 'dagre', '@dagrejs/dagre', 'elkjs', 'cytoscape', 'klay', or other general-purpose graph layout libraries. layout.ts contains no imports from such packages. Verify by a static test asserting the dependency lists and import set.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "65592e81-5f15-4859-8fa7-111f8fb6cff5", + "displayId": "R36", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Macro view components shall not use generic Material Design components, default Tailwind component patterns, generic SaaS dashboard chrome, generic rounded-corner card aesthetics, or blue primary buttons. Visual treatments shall instead be expressed through the CRT/phosphor visual grammar (warm dark surfaces, phosphor glow, scanline texture, sharp/squared edges, monospace typography).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "65df7ca8-9301-475c-ae10-022a4fecf5d2", + "displayId": "CR41", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode header contains a chip element whose textContent matches /NUDG(E|ING)/ and whose computed color resolves to --color-phosphor-amber. The chip is a descendant of the node body (i.e., bounded inside the node's rect), not an external overlay. When nudgingActive is false, no such chip is present. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6610e669-129b-4c80-b61b-abf3015cc9ff", + "displayId": "R37", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Phase color references in macro view code shall use the theme.css phase tokens (--color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-phase-pinning, --color-phase-defining-done) as the authoritative phase color mapping. Where the upstream X34 specification differs from theme.css, theme.css governs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "66cfce9c-6795-49d6-a391-6bb0e09fbe76", + "displayId": "C13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Phase color values must be expressed as oklch values within the phosphor palette.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "678f24ef-4a08-46f2-b1bf-ce9bd2e06186", + "displayId": "J2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The combination of mandatory snapshot-only data loading, the resulting risk of users viewing stale derivation history, and the requirement to keep the data contract unchanged jointly force a visible-snapshot-time + reload-button overlay (rather than no banner, or live-subscription).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "justification", + "rationale": "C11/C12 mandate snapshot-only behavior; RK3 identifies stale-data viewing as a real silent failure; DEC2 forbids live subscriptions; DEC11 chooses a banner+reload affordance as the mitigation. Together these jointly require both (a) a visible snapshot timestamp and (b) an explicit reload control to be present in the UI — neither premise alone is sufficient." + }, + { + "id": "681f483b-8f7f-4341-a8ca-0c620be2957c", + "displayId": "X38", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "A MacroView.tsx component already exists at src/components/MacroView.tsx with a header docblock describing the intended architecture: Story IR → Layout → Render with React Flow custom node types; the file is otherwise a stub.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "6905418b-e728-4e0f-aa48-0ded224b59dc", + "displayId": "CR62", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the layout output, every node with a defined parentId has node.position expressed relative to the parent's origin (i.e., the absolute screen position is parent.position + child.position), and the child's position is contained within the parent's bounding box (0 ≤ child.x ≤ parent.width - child.width; same for y). Group nodes (parentId undefined) carry absolute positions. Verify with a unit test on layout output for a fixture containing parented children.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6ac4fb94-4b9b-45fc-8f83-3e494437a757", + "displayId": "CR13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "In the layout output for any non-collapsed PhaseGroupNode P, every child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode in P has node.parentId === P.id and node.extent === 'parent', and P has type === 'group' (or the React Flow group equivalent). Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting these properties for a fixture frame containing all four child kinds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6b76d547-7f67-49d7-a4fa-819da8eef644", + "displayId": "R18", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Within any horizontal lane, more recent frames (higher attemptNumber / later createdAt) shall be positioned higher (smaller y in screen coordinates / 'higher' visually) than earlier frames, so that vertical position encodes time with t+1 above t.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6c0da3ce-4073-4552-8db8-dbd6a9ebc6eb", + "displayId": "X1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view is one specific view within the broader Spec Explorer UI.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "6d6c7aa0-9d33-4c69-a6cf-60c18e54c3f2", + "displayId": "CR69", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Manual UX review (codified as a stakeholder sign-off checklist) asserts: (a) every node communicates outcome-at-a-glance from at least 1m viewing distance on a 14\" laptop screen at default zoom; (b) no rendered phase group exceeds ~280px width or ~360px height at default zoom for typical content; (c) text contrast against warm-dark surface meets WCAG AA (4.5:1) for primary text. Verify with a manual review checklist run during PR review plus an automated contrast test using getComputedStyle and a contrast-ratio library.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "6eef154d-988c-4f96-88eb-c3ca0863d255", + "displayId": "X28", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation outcome affects the whole node's visual weight: accepted=normal, retry=amber border, recurse=blue border, bail=red border + dimmed interior.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "716c1698-8c7e-4dc8-bbb9-3b955e5dd62e", + "displayId": "R62", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Layout output for child nodes inside a PhaseGroupNode shall use positions relative to the parent group's origin (consistent with React Flow's parentId conventions), while group nodes themselves carry absolute positions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "720781eb-3005-43a9-8608-b0503a4ebf15", + "displayId": "CR17", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For a fixture with frames F0 (no parent) → F1 (parent F0) → F2 (parent F1), the layout assigns depth(F0)=0, depth(F1)=1, depth(F2)=2; and the x-coordinate of F2's PhaseGroupNode is greater than F1's, which is greater than F0's. Verify with a unit test on layout() output.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "721c6269-4273-4cfd-aaf4-79d5cf8d7468", + "displayId": "DEC13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Decompose into a src/components/macro/ folder with one file per pipeline stage and one file per node type.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "The pipeline decision (dec-pipeline) and the seven-node taxonomy (dec-node-taxonomy) both imply natural file boundaries. Co-locating the macro folder under components keeps the project's existing layout convention (sibling to DetailPanel.tsx). Re-exporting through the original MacroView.tsx path means routes/explore.tsx keeps working unchanged. C5 explicitly scopes this work to the macro view, so a dedicated folder helps reviewers see the scope boundary." + }, + { + "id": "7273b987-e532-439b-957a-cb94d7032a73", + "displayId": "RK3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Because the macro view is snapshot-only and only updates on manual refresh, users may view a stale derivation history without realizing it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "73d7490f-8233-46ed-a2d0-d7740467c1cb", + "displayId": "R4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The MacroView shall implement a three-stage pipeline as separate, individually-testable pure functions: (1) story-ir builder consuming ArtifactFile.graph and producing a normalized derivation tree IR, (2) a layout function consuming the IR plus a collapsed set and producing absolute positions, lane widths and parent/child grouping, and (3) a renderer that maps IR nodes to typed React Flow nodes and edges. Stages 1 and 2 shall have no React or React Flow imports.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "742c1c91-2818-4b6a-94ee-226108f7e91f", + "displayId": "D1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Architect MacroView as a three-stage pure pipeline: (1) Story IR builder that consumes ArtifactFile.graph and produces a normalized derivation tree (FrameNode root → PhaseNode children → RunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/ImpasseNode descendants, with parentFrameId chains expanded into nested impasse branches), (2) Layout engine that walks the IR and computes absolute (x,y) positions, lane widths, and parent/child grouping, (3) React Flow renderer that maps IR nodes to custom node types and IR edges to typed RF edges. The IR is the only contract layout and rendering depend on; data shape changes localize to stage 1.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7550da13-db83-4bce-9985-958193aa3c7e", + "displayId": "R41", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each DerivationRunNode shall display: the run index ('RUN #n' from runIndex), an input-count badge (size of inputNodeIds), an output-count badge (size of outputCandidateIds), and an impasses-found count (size of impassesFound).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "75d54d9e-bfbc-488c-b7d8-a683fcee3727", + "displayId": "DEC4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Adopt seven typed React Flow node components, no separate trunk type.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X13 enumerates the desired semantic node types; one React component per type aligns the type system with the visual grammar and gives each node its own focused render path (G3/G4 require visual distinctness at a glance). A polymorphic component would push that complexity into a single switch and erode TypeScript support. X19 explicitly says trunk is not a separate type; reusing PhaseGroupNode at depth 0 honors that and keeps mode tinting (X20) as the only differentiator. Dead-end impasse is handled as a visual variant of ImpasseNode driven by the linked ReconciliationRecord.outcome='bail' (X36), not as an eighth type, because behaviorally it is still an impasse." + }, + { + "id": "77fd25cb-6988-49fe-85f7-f8196357b52d", + "displayId": "R60", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view shall be implemented as React components in TypeScript that build cleanly within the existing Vite + React + Tailwind SPA toolchain, without introducing alternative bundlers, runtimes, or replacing Tailwind with a competing CSS framework.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "783411a6-8e56-478c-8059-78d7d8e58ba2", + "displayId": "E3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The ReconciliationRecord.outcome field can be one of: accepted, retry, recurse, or bail.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "7a3636cc-93c6-46ed-af92-f4c71e189a76", + "displayId": "X34", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: phase color assignments are grounding=blue (foundational), shaping=green (growth/emergence), pinning=amber (fixity/commitment), defining_done=violet (completion/closure).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "7c79aa5f-840f-4b70-bc2e-96b4a98b6ad4", + "displayId": "DEC11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Show a snapshot timestamp + reload affordance as a fixed corner overlay.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "RK3 (users may view stale history) is a real and silent failure mode. Surfacing the snapshot time directly in the view turns it from invisible to glanceable, while a Reload button makes the manual-refresh expectation actionable without violating C11/C12 (the data contract is still snapshot-on-load; Reload is an explicit re-mount). The treatment is small and uses an existing token (text-tertiary), so it doesn't compete with the derivation graph for attention." + }, + { + "id": "7cf6c327-c289-496e-96b8-6abc8853e962", + "displayId": "DEC2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Snapshot the artifact on mount; require manual reload.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "C11/C12 explicitly mandate snapshot-only behavior. Live subscription would invalidate the layout mid-interaction and conflict with the ephemeral collapse state (C8), causing layouts to thrash. A visible 'Reload' affordance partially mitigates RK3 (stale data) without breaking the snapshot contract." + }, + { + "id": "7d96e6de-ebd8-4cca-b47a-cb56910a62a9", + "displayId": "X26", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: a 'running' status is unlikely to appear but should be highlighted somehow if it does.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "7da6473f-f62f-4875-b2bf-99a2861c1f01", + "displayId": "R25", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Clicking the collapse/expand affordance on a PhaseGroupNode (or its collapsed pill) shall toggle that group's membership in the collapsed set, triggering a synchronous re-run of the layout function over the existing IR + new collapsed set.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7e65823a-9505-49b7-a8a5-8b3e8db4b231", + "displayId": "X15", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: derivation phases (such as reconciliation) are encoded as nodes within the graph rather than as separate UI constructs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "7ed01886-5b4f-4620-a3d7-11f15b460553", + "displayId": "DEC12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Collapse to a stat-bearing pill, not an icon.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X21 explicitly says the collapsed form should show key stats (run count, outcome). G3 demands at-a-glance comprehension even in summary form. A pill carries the four bits of information (phase, frame ID, run count, outcome) using existing visual tokens; an icon-only marker forces the user to expand or open the detail panel just to recall what a frame contains, defeating the purpose of collapse-as-summary." + }, + { + "id": "7f65187e-fd0b-4c4d-857e-6323ced88337", + "displayId": "CR28", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "An edge whose source or target is a child of a now-collapsed phase group renders in the layout output with its endpoint id rewritten to (or remapped to terminate at) the collapsed pill node id, not the original child id. No edge in the output references a child id that is currently hidden by a collapsed group. Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting endpoint-id sets are subsets of the visible node-id set.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "7fc0b03b-7c3d-4440-8b34-2108068620b4", + "displayId": "X3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view is structurally different from the micro view: it shows ~20-40 rich nodes representing the derivation process rather than graph content.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "80821146-623f-48e5-9276-f6b990a63cb5", + "displayId": "CR36", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Every text-bearing DOM element rendered by macro view components has computed font-family containing 'JetBrains Mono' or resolving to var(--font-mono). Verify with an RTL test that walks the rendered tree and asserts getComputedStyle(el).fontFamily for each text element matches the expected stack.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "80db7faa-5e3c-4b0f-af86-db52fa83a721", + "displayId": "R10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view shall register exactly seven custom React Flow nodeTypes — PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, and PhantomNode — and shall not register a separate TrunkNode type.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "816bf987-3c94-48ba-84d4-11773460c316", + "displayId": "CR31", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The macro view module imports DetailPanel from src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (or via the shared component path) and does not define a new component named MacroDetailPanel or equivalent. DetailPanel renders the selected macro record kind. Verify with (a) a static import-graph check and (b) an integration test that selects each macro record kind and asserts DetailPanel renders kind-appropriate content.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8320d111-efac-4e6e-917c-155eeed3e75c", + "displayId": "R1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view source code shall be organized under src/components/macro/ with at minimum: index.ts re-exporting MacroView, MacroView.tsx (top-level component), story-ir.ts (pure ArtifactFile→StoryIR builder), layout.ts (pure StoryIR+collapsedSet→RF nodes/edges), and a nodes/ subdirectory containing one .tsx file per custom node type (PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, PhantomNode).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "879a3be3-c97f-41a1-8a30-0a66489d8cfb", + "displayId": "X8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Reconciliation compares candidate nodes from re-derivation against the previous iteration's nodes for that phase and classifies each relationship using lineage edge types.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "8931b58a-6641-4cb8-aeb9-53be7ae0b273", + "displayId": "CR67", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "After collapsing one or more groups and triggering RELOAD (or unmount/remount), the rendered macro view returns to the fully-expanded state with no PhaseGroupNode rendered as a pill. Verify with an RTL test that collapses, reloads, and asserts no collapsed-pill DOM elements exist.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8b5e53c2-3229-456e-b63d-e046d72ef695", + "displayId": "X30", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: derivation depth in the macro layout is computed from the parentFrameId chain length.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "8d078209-7578-4c2c-91e2-95a324e3edf0", + "displayId": "CR9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Inspecting MacroView's rendered DOM and the props of its React Flow custom nodes reveals no UI affordance bound to a mutating action: no add/edit/delete buttons, no form inputs, no draggable-to-create-edge handles enabled (nodesDraggable may be true for layout, but onConnect/onEdgesChange handlers must not commit changes back to the artifact). Verify by an integration test that simulates clicks on every interactive element and asserts that no mock 'mutate' API on the store is ever called.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8d38f26a-1cbc-4fa0-b206-1eb707da613b", + "displayId": "A1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: skip the Story IR and map ArtifactFile records directly to React Flow nodes inside one component, with layout calculation interleaved with rendering.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8d6b7d81-e9c1-44f7-8b42-1c3b5a2c75e2", + "displayId": "C3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view must use a manual layout algorithm rather than dagre, because the spatial grammar requires precise control over depth lanes and vertical flow.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "8dfb5819-cbb5-4d4e-b4bb-e9d2111fdc5d", + "displayId": "X16", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: impasse nodes connect sub-trees and increase the breadth of the layout to represent the opening of a new derivation branch.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "8e380600-60e3-428f-891a-7ec0ca4c43a2", + "displayId": "R28", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode descendants and the edges entirely internal to that group shall not be rendered (or shall be hidden from the React Flow output).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "8ee76fbd-9fe4-401c-86ca-45de1bedb6ee", + "displayId": "DEC7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Reuse the existing DetailPanel component, extending it with branches for macro record kinds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X4 mandates reuse. The DetailPanel already handles selection plumbing, layout, and CRT styling; replicating that for the macro view would duplicate code and risk visual divergence. Adding record-kind branches inside DetailPanel keeps the selection contract single. Read-only enforcement (C10) is automatic because DetailPanel has no mutating actions wired in the macro path." + }, + { + "id": "8fcbd8e0-a5bc-46d0-8ee8-736da4524445", + "displayId": "R8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The MacroView shall expose no controls that mutate artifact data. Only pan, zoom, node click (selection), and collapse/expand interactions shall be wired.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9036edae-47e4-4816-a9e0-9711f1d2b744", + "displayId": "E2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The artifact.ts file defines branded ID types for NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, SpecId, SourceId, ClaimId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, SnapshotId, InterventionId, and DisplayId.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "90722a91-bf5e-4118-8c07-fa6f0977b83d", + "displayId": "CR59", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Git diff between the feature branch and main shows zero modifications to src/components/MicroView*, src/graph/, src/router.ts, src/routes/, or any unrelated component, with the only allowed touched files being: src/components/macro/**, src/components/MacroView.tsx (re-export only), and minimal additions to src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (new branches for macro record kinds; no removal of existing branches). Verify with a git-diff CI check.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "90a0f0ed-3f8b-41dd-96e2-fe7f765be250", + "displayId": "X12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: users can fold (collapse) any nested derivation run to hide detail.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "9194810b-f16f-44b3-b559-fae811852615", + "displayId": "CR66", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "After mount, mutating the underlying artifact mock and waiting any reasonable interval (e.g., 1s) does NOT change the rendered macro view (no live update). Clicking the RELOAD button (or remounting) updates the rendered view to reflect the mutation. Verify with an integration test combining a mock artifact source, mutation between assertions, and pre/post-reload DOM snapshots.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "91a3368b-4e78-4a68-b79c-8e0d73fecc1d", + "displayId": "A21", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: keep everything inside the existing single MacroView.tsx file. Faster to start but conflicts with the pipeline boundaries (dec-pipeline) and clusters seven node renderers into one file.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "91a5af71-fb83-4a63-8577-7d9bc35522f4", + "displayId": "CR46", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A FanInNode with groupings [{groupKey:'a', resolution:'merged', nodeCount:3},{groupKey:'b', resolution:'best_selected', nodeCount:1},{groupKey:'c', resolution:'impasse_surfaced', nodeCount:2}] renders three row elements in order, each with a 4px-wide left-border whose color is (in order): the green/merged token, --color-phosphor-amber, --color-phosphor-red. Each row contains the groupKey text and the nodeCount text. Verify with a parameterized RTL test across all three resolution kinds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "92a722fa-df96-4b9d-a38f-1a2dc3198c21", + "displayId": "CR12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given a fixture artifact containing N FrameRecords each with M phases that have at least one associated run/fan-in/reconciliation/perspective record, the IR builder produces exactly N×M PhaseGroupNodes (no more, no fewer), and zero PhaseGroupNodes for (frame, phase) pairs with no associated records. Verify with a unit test on buildStoryIR using a hand-crafted fixture covering empty and non-empty phase pairs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "93280305-7ed8-45ce-b2be-247173757b40", + "displayId": "A12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: build a separate macro-specific detail panel optimized for derivation records (frames/runs/reconciliations), since DetailPanel was originally built for graph nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "953d89fd-0e68-4a34-ba08-d32349b93e8e", + "displayId": "R9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view canvas shall support pan and zoom interactions provided by React Flow.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "95730dd1-5b40-43c0-9f63-9e38c9855932", + "displayId": "R39", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "PhaseGroupNode shall encode the FrameRecord.mode in border style: mode='initial' uses a solid border, mode='rederive' uses a double border, and mode='grounding_enrichment' uses a dashed border. A small text mode chip showing the mode name shall additionally appear in the header.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "96bfd82b-9a0b-498a-be10-21829cf1f0d7", + "displayId": "CR14", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For an artifact fixture with arbitrary counts of DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, and ReconciliationRecord, the rendered React Flow node array contains exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord.id, one FanInNode per FanInRecord.id, and one ReconciliationNode per ReconciliationRecord.id (verified by id-set equality). Verify with a property-based test (fast-check) generating random combinations.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "96d0e684-1033-429a-8ddd-b56fec05d3f7", + "displayId": "R7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The MacroView shall display a fixed overlay banner in the top-left corner showing 'SNAPSHOT @ ' rendered in --color-text-tertiary, where reflects the time the artifact was loaded for the current snapshot. The banner shall not pan or zoom with the React Flow canvas.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "96eed2d4-37cc-4a23-b189-6727428536b6", + "displayId": "X32", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in groupings render as color-coded rows inside the fan-in node — green for 'merged', amber for 'best_selected', red for 'impasse_surfaced' — distinguished by a colored left border or chip.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "974d9e3c-ddce-4c27-83b0-9b19ed928095", + "displayId": "A7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: introduce an explicit TrunkNode type for depth-0 phase groups, separate from nested phase groups.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "97aef1a1-7d0e-47bb-87c1-0df0e41fdc6e", + "displayId": "CR8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "MacroView renders a fixed-position element in the top-left containing the literal text prefix 'SNAPSHOT @ ' followed by the artifact's load timestamp. The element has CSS color resolving to the value of --color-text-tertiary and CSS position:fixed (or absolute relative to the macro view container, outside the React Flow viewport transform). Verify by computed-style assertion in a JSDOM/RTL test, plus a visual test that pans/zooms the canvas and asserts the banner's bounding-rect coordinates are unchanged.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9826eef7-523b-4a55-aac8-93d83d8bac4e", + "displayId": "R46", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Each ReconciliationNode shall encode its outcome via full-node border treatment: outcome='accepted' uses the parent phase's color, outcome='retry' uses --color-phosphor-amber, outcome='recurse' uses --color-phosphor-cyan (blue), outcome='bail' uses --color-phosphor-red plus a dimmed interior. The outcome shall additionally appear as a textual chip in the node header.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "98f442ea-f956-43c7-becb-2664e106c0c3", + "displayId": "CR38", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Every reference to a phase color in macro view source uses one of the literal tokens --color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-phase-pinning, or --color-phase-defining-done. No macro view file redefines these tokens. Where conflict exists between X34 and theme.css, theme.css's mapping is used. Verify with a grep test plus a render test asserting that a PhaseGroupNode for phase 'shaping' has border-color resolving to theme.css's --color-phase-shaping value (currently amber per X41).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "99295532-9b62-4319-8804-aebd7c1a1c82", + "displayId": "X9", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Because the macro view renders inside a React Flow canvas (not directly in the DOM), large node counts are not a DOM performance concern.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "99a17277-b0fa-40cd-85f5-aead2480a1e2", + "displayId": "R52", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode) shall be rendered as thin amber lines with markerEnd arrows and no animation by default.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9aad3a05-6191-4951-900b-220daa07e422", + "displayId": "G4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Each node's form and function must visually communicate what happened at that specific point in the derivation tree.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "9c07fc62-f94d-48a4-8d2f-ec17bcdd28bb", + "displayId": "CR64", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A static review (codified as a test fixture matrix) asserts the channel-to-attribute mapping: phase color used only for phase identity (not for outcome or mode); border-color encoding only run/reconciliation outcome semantics (red, amber, cyan, phase color per outcome); border-style (solid/double/dashed) encoding only frame mode; opacity reduction (~30%) used only for unselected perspective branches; diamond/lozenge shape used only by ImpasseNode. Verify by enumerating all node-type × visual-channel pairs in tests and asserting no two attributes share a channel within a node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9d665c32-476f-4664-9b13-734907622aa0", + "displayId": "X14", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: layout grammar encodes timeline through verticality (t+1 / more recent appears higher) and breadth encodes onion-peel derivation depth.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "9dbba24c-94ff-4fe6-a9e9-c5e10e6f7b70", + "displayId": "R16", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "For each FrameRecord, the layout shall compute derivationDepth as the length of the parentFrameId chain (the root frame, with no parentFrameId, has depth 0).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "9f087de1-9f22-4ba7-829f-f4e95ffc6c5c", + "displayId": "E4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The FrameRecord.mode field has three values: initial, rederive, and grounding_enrichment.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a0c91818-946b-4a34-83bd-e12611b1747a", + "displayId": "CR4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts modules contain no import statements referencing 'react', 'react-dom', '@xyflow/react', or any DOM/browser API. Verify by a static-analysis test that parses the files and asserts the import set is disjoint from a forbidden list. Additionally call each function twice with the same deeply-cloned input and assert the outputs are deeply equal and that the inputs are unmodified (input integrity hash unchanged).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "a197cdc3-db5b-4531-850a-c31b69bfe918", + "displayId": "CR25", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking the collapse affordance on an expanded PhaseGroupNode causes (a) that group's id to enter the collapsed set and (b) the layout function to be invoked again with the new set, producing updated node positions. Subsequent click on the resulting pill removes the id from the set and restores expanded layout. Verify with a Vitest test using a spy on the layout function and a click simulation; assert layout invocation count and node-position diffs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "a37dc4c9-fcdc-4446-88b9-f165cd12bf2b", + "displayId": "X41", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "The theme.css token assignment differs from grounding X34: theme.css maps shaping=amber and pinning=cyan, while X34 specifies shaping=green and pinning=amber. Reconciling this is a minor concern but theme.css is the source of truth for the existing design system.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a4e0a02c-2db2-4bd6-9ea7-aa7fc5bed419", + "displayId": "X5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The onion-peel derivation structure (impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, resolution) is specified in the spec-elicitation.md document.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "external" + }, + { + "id": "a74f15f2-10d6-4b46-b2b4-38a234d4b0a1", + "displayId": "X24", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: phantom nodes and faded nodes are informational only and carry no interactive actions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "a7a6b666-d2c1-4be2-aa82-08eb6a924d4e", + "displayId": "T5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The FanInRecord type captures the fan-in step: id, frameId, phase, inputRunIds, groupings (with resolution: merged | best_selected | impasse_surfaced), outputCandidateIds, droppedCandidateIds, and createdAt.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "a8d371cb-476e-4e64-8ec1-ee78e36bb77d", + "displayId": "A8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: render fan-out/fan-in/reconciliation as separate top-level nodes positioned to overlap a 'background' phase node; do not use React Flow parenting.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ab3e2ed7-41bd-435a-af10-6393ecf9402d", + "displayId": "R23", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "On every mount of MacroView the collapsed-set shall be initialized as empty, so that all phase groups are rendered fully expanded immediately after page load.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ad707857-da55-4b62-82aa-53abc06e66e6", + "displayId": "CR51", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A PhantomNode renders with computed border-style 'dashed', computed background-color of 'transparent' (or rgba alpha 0), and contains text matching /PHANTOM/i and /no perspective taken/i. Verify with an RTL + computed-style test.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "adc82ef7-560f-46b4-8fdc-8d76ef9987c6", + "displayId": "X10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: render the derivation narrative as a pannable, zoomable graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "afdc99d3-3a1a-441a-8d1a-616ba508d671", + "displayId": "CR58", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "TypeScript strict-mode compilation succeeds for story-ir.ts and layout.ts using the branded ID types from src/types/artifact.ts (FrameId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, NodeId, etc.) without `as string` or `as any` coercions at module exports. Verify with `tsc --noEmit` in CI plus a grep test asserting no `as string` or `as unknown as string` patterns appear at module boundaries.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b1e3d927-ea61-44e1-a438-83963f177fa5", + "displayId": "D7", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "On node click, the MacroView reads the React Flow node's underlying IR record (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, or hub) and dispatches a 'select' action to the existing global selection store consumed by DetailPanel.tsx. The DetailPanel branches its rendering on record kind to display frame summary, run inputs/outputs, fan-in groupings, reconciliation deltas, etc. PhantomNodes and faded perspective branches do not dispatch any selection (per X24).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b22cdad2-d210-4dcc-bdac-1d15c12b90c0", + "displayId": "D10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "When a DerivationRunRecord.status is 'running' (rare per X26), the RunNode renders with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe (already in theme.css) looping at slow tempo on the node body, (b) a 'RUNNING' chip in --color-phosphor-cyan in the header (cyan is unused for outcome semantics elsewhere, so it carries no conflicting meaning), and (c) a thin animated scanline sweep across the node interior. The node remains clickable and shows the same content fields as a completed run.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b2388832-045d-4135-a514-77e9bec62003", + "displayId": "D6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Collapse/expand state lives in a single useState> at the MacroView root, holding the IDs of currently-collapsed phase groups (or frames). The set starts empty on mount (everything expanded per C9) and is never written to localStorage, sessionStorage, URL, or any persistence layer (per C8). Toggle handlers are passed down via React context to PhaseGroupNode renderers, which swap to a compact pill renderer when their ID is in the set. After a toggle, the layout function re-runs synchronously over the IR + collapsed-set to produce new node positions, and React Flow's animated transitions (default fitView=false, but applyNodeChanges with smooth-tweened positions) handle reflow per X22.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b37c8b13-69fd-4997-b31b-0b2e9faf91f7", + "displayId": "R54", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Resolution edges shall be rendered as solid lines colored by the resolving phase's color, with markerEnd arrows, drawn from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode back toward the ImpasseNode listed in that record's resolvedImpasseIds, using a return-leftward routing convention (toward lower-depth lanes).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b43a8da3-4a56-4d0f-94c0-5a03508f1cf1", + "displayId": "DEC3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use a custom recursive DFS lane layout with proportional lane widths.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "C3 forbids dagre and the equivalent argument applies to ELK: the spatial grammar (onion peel breadth = depth, verticality = time, impasses opening lanes per X16, perspective fan-out under phase groups) is too prescriptive for any general-purpose layout. A recursive DFS that returns subtree bounding boxes is a small amount of code (roughly 100–200 LOC) and gives full control. Fixed lanes were rejected because X31 specifies proportional sizing and because shallow trunks would otherwise look impoverished next to wide branches." + }, + { + "id": "b549e671-ea24-45cc-b065-0d8e2c94b79f", + "displayId": "CR48", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the rendered ReconciliationNode header contains a chip element whose textContent contains the ✓ character (or is identifiable as a checkmark indicator) located beside the outcome chip. When materialProgress is false, no such chip is present. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b629e743-2496-4a8e-a7fb-16a4265fb0f9", + "displayId": "R57", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Across realistic spec snapshots the macro view shall render approximately 20–40 top-level semantic nodes (phase groups + impasses) for a typical derivation history; the design shall not produce hundreds of nodes from EdgeRecord-style content edges.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b66aea01-ef52-4065-91d0-8709192e8914", + "displayId": "CR18", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Within a single lane, given two frames F_old (createdAt=t1, attemptNumber=1) and F_new (createdAt=t2>t1, attemptNumber=2) at the same depth, F_new's PhaseGroupNode position.y is strictly less than F_old's (smaller y = visually higher). Verify with a unit-test fixture and assertion on layout output.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "b9a5afb0-68e3-4d50-9583-1ebd9b49058d", + "displayId": "C4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The CRT design language for the macro view mandates: var(--font-mono), oklch phase colors, warm-tinted dark surfaces, phosphor glow, and no generic UI patterns.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ba6b13c4-7aae-44bf-baad-3f6ca72dcf66", + "displayId": "CR54", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For each FrameRecord with non-empty triggerImpasseIds, layout emits an impasse-spawn edge from the parent frame's relevant ReconciliationNode (or PhaseGroupNode if reconciliation is unavailable) to each ImpasseNode listed in triggerImpasseIds. Each such edge has computed stroke color resolving to --color-phosphor-red, computed border/stroke style 'dashed', and a markerEnd arrow. Verify with a fixture and computed-style assertion.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bb4a78e5-26cc-4eb0-912f-deefb3b9e365", + "displayId": "A20", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: collapse to a tiny icon-only marker. Smaller but loses the at-a-glance run count + outcome that X21 calls out as 'key stats'.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bbdd2acb-60d9-4a9e-a268-7c08007cc57d", + "displayId": "RK4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Because collapsed state is ephemeral and never persisted, users lose any custom collapsed configuration on every page reload.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bd25a3a7-04d0-473c-b39d-cfee0409fa48", + "displayId": "CR30", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking a non-faded, non-phantom macro node (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse, or selected perspective) dispatches a 'select' action to the global selection store with a payload identifying the underlying IR record by id and kind. Verify with an RTL test using a mocked store: simulate click on each node-type variant in a fixture and assert the store.select spy was called with the correct {id, kind} pair.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "be08fa65-da44-48d6-9114-29dd2e8f410e", + "displayId": "X22", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested run is collapsed, sibling nodes shift to fill vacated space, triggering a layout reflow.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "bef17670-2735-4886-82f6-af552b69b74d", + "displayId": "D8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Each node type expresses its semantic role through a fixed visual vocabulary built from theme.css tokens: (a) PhaseGroupNode — 1px border in the phase color (--color-phase-*), warm dark surface-1 fill, scanline overlay, header line 'PHASE / FRAME-ID / mode' in --color-text-secondary; mode differentiation per X20 done by border style (initial=solid, rederive=double, grounding_enrichment=dashed) plus a small mode chip; nudgingActive shown as a 'NUDGING' chip in --color-phosphor-amber inside the header (X25). (b) DerivationRunNode — numbered tile 'RUN #n' with input/output count badges and impassesFound count; status='completed' is base, status='failed' uses --color-phosphor-red border and dimmed interior (X27), status='running' adds an animated phosphor-arrive pulse (X26). (c) FanInNode — stacked rows, one per FanInGrouping, each row prefixed by a 4px left border in green/amber/red per resolution (X32); row text shows groupKey and node count. (d) ReconciliationNode — outcome encoded as full-node border color (accepted=phase color, retry=amber, recurse=cyan/blue, bail=red+dim) per X28, plus an outcome chip in the header; materialProgress=true shown as a small ✓ chip beside the outcome (X35). (e) ImpasseNode — diamond/lozenge shape with red glyph, displayId visible; if linked to a bail reconciliation (X36), it is annotated 'DEAD-END' to disambiguate from open impasses (RK2 mitigation). (f) PerspectiveNode — branching tile; selected branch full opacity, rejected branches at ~30% opacity (X23); non-interactive when faded (X24). (g) PhantomNode — dashed-outline ghost tile, no fill, label 'PHANTOM — no perspective taken', non-interactive (X24).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "bf06490e-e867-486e-a76b-67d74dfeb90b", + "displayId": "CR52", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Layout output contains edges of exactly three distinct semantic classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), identifiable via an edge.data.kind discriminator or edge.type. No edge in the output is generated by iterating ArtifactFile.graph.edges (EdgeRecord rows). Verify by (a) inspecting layout output for a fixture and asserting every edge has kind ∈ {sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution}, and (b) a unit test that inserts arbitrary EdgeRecord rows into the artifact and asserts the macro layout edge count is unchanged.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c0d896e4-80d8-4023-9730-0806398e4851", + "displayId": "RK5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The mandate for high information density combined with the CRT aesthetic and prohibition on generic UI patterns creates tension between dense data display and visual readability/non-overwhelm.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "risk", + "epistemicStatus": "inferred", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c0e5c2bb-44d7-4b6a-a6ef-f007c4f1535d", + "displayId": "CR49", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "An ImpasseNode renders with a clearly non-rectangular silhouette: either via SVG path/polygon or CSS clip-path/transform producing a diamond/lozenge shape. Its DOM contains the hub's displayId text and uses --color-phosphor-red as a glyph or border token. Verify with an RTL test asserting the presence of an SVG diamond polygon or a clip-path style, plus the text and color assertions.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c216a3fc-cc33-4dd1-be4a-ac81b90c8e8a", + "displayId": "CR70", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given a fixture artifact representing a full onion-peel cycle (initial derivation, an impasse, a rederive child frame, fan-out runs, fan-in, reconciliation, resolution), the rendered macro view contains: at least one PhaseGroupNode for the parent frame, an ImpasseNode at the lane boundary, at least one PhaseGroupNode for the child frame in a deeper lane, RunNode(s) and FanInNode and ReconciliationNode inside the child phase group, an impasse-spawn edge, and a resolution edge back to the impasse. Verify with an end-to-end RTL test on the full-cycle fixture.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c23b969c-36ba-4a85-852d-6cca5b740ca0", + "displayId": "D4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Define exactly seven custom React Flow node types matching the data shapes: PhaseGroupNode (RF group/parent node, one per FrameRecord+Phase pair, mode-tinted), DerivationRunNode (one per DerivationRunRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode), FanInNode (one per FanInRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode, contains color-coded grouping rows), ReconciliationNode (one per ReconciliationRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode), ImpasseNode (one per HubNode with hubType='impasse', positioned at the boundary opening a new lane), PerspectiveNode (one per HubNode with hubType='perspective'), and PhantomNode (synthesized when a phase group ends without a perspective selection per T10). The trunk is not a node type; it emerges from PhaseGroupNodes laid out at depth 0 (per X19).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c6c90d43-5472-4f55-ab73-63edf75bac16", + "displayId": "R56", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Edges whose both endpoints lie inside a collapsed PhaseGroupNode shall not be rendered while that group is collapsed. Edges with exactly one endpoint inside a collapsed group shall reattach to the collapsed pill rather than being hidden.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c763822e-ecdc-48df-bbb0-95560cfbb2dc", + "displayId": "R61", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts shall export pure functions: given identical inputs they shall produce structurally equal outputs and shall not mutate their input data, perform I/O, or read from external state (DOM, time, stores).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "c7d3430e-0276-4bf6-99e4-6ffb44a578cf", + "displayId": "X17", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in and fan-out steps are represented as nested nodes within any one phase node.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "c974c2ec-c6e3-413a-b75f-380f1727682c", + "displayId": "R5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The MacroView shall load ArtifactFile data exactly once on component mount, build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React Flow nodes and edges into component state. It shall not subscribe to or react to subsequent artifact changes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ca16b154-6542-41da-9b36-56ffb1e3131c", + "displayId": "CR44", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A DerivationRunNode with status='failed' has computed border-color resolving to --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior (e.g., reduced opacity on the body OR a dark overlay; quantified as effective body luminance ≤ 70% of completed baseline). Verify with an RTL + computed-style test asserting border color match and an opacity/filter property indicating dimming.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ccedddb8-be2a-4f92-8387-613026db6622", + "displayId": "T12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "materialProgress=true on a ReconciliationRecord means at least some nodes were activated or archived during that reconciliation — real forward progress occurred.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ccf6895d-fe4e-45f9-98dc-ec52953fc874", + "displayId": "CR6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When MacroView is mounted with a mocked artifact loader, the loader is invoked exactly once. When the underlying artifact source emits subsequent change notifications (mocked), the loader is NOT re-invoked and the rendered RF nodes/edges remain referentially stable. Verify with a Vitest test using a spy on the loader and a mock store that emits changes after mount.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "cda32831-90ec-472f-9162-9083ec1a82bb", + "displayId": "CR43", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A DerivationRunNode with status='completed' has no border color matching --color-phosphor-red and no opacity/dimming reduction relative to the base node treatment. Verify with an RTL + computed-style test on a completed-status fixture.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d02b7a51-a0dd-4ee2-b326-cf4b12c75152", + "displayId": "CR35", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A static-analysis scan of all files under src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx,css} finds zero literal color values matching /#[0-9a-fA-F]{3,8}/, /\\brgb\\(/, /\\brgba\\(/, /\\bhsl\\(/, /\\bhsla\\(/, or /\\boklch\\(/ outside of var() references. All colors are referenced via var(--color-*) tokens defined in theme.css. Verify with a regex-based unit test scanning the directory.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d04d22c3-d0ec-4d3b-8eec-440c01321cdb", + "displayId": "A16", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: render no edges at all and rely on spatial proximity / containment to imply flow. Cleaner visually but loses the narrative arrow of impasse → child frame → resolution that the macro view exists to tell.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d07ad5e5-31ae-490e-bdad-783b556d9d67", + "displayId": "A6", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: one polymorphic 'MacroNode' component that switches on a discriminator prop. Reduces the React Flow nodeTypes registry but conflates radically different visual treatments and makes per-type styling and testing harder.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d14dcec4-cfe0-42ca-83a0-68b7e5b20492", + "displayId": "X23", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: perspective nodes show which branch was taken; unchosen branches fade out to indicate they were not taken but could be materialized later.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d3df672d-3db9-45ca-a66d-ab36127bc215", + "displayId": "R59", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view implementation shall not modify the existing Sigma.js-based micro view, the routing layer, or unrelated parts of the Spec Explorer UI. Changes are scoped to src/components/macro/, the existing src/components/MacroView.tsx re-export, and any minimal extensions to src/components/DetailPanel.tsx required to render macro record kinds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d5c244a5-409b-4ecf-81c8-6ebd8063ee5f", + "displayId": "R12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, and PerspectiveNode instances belonging to a phase shall be rendered as React Flow children of their PhaseGroupNode using parentId and extent='parent'. The PhaseGroupNode shall be a React Flow group/parent node (type='group' or equivalent).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d63b37ad-8225-4727-ad98-b4a45dda927d", + "displayId": "X19", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: there is no separate 'trunk' node type; the trunk is simply the outermost shell of the onion-layered layout.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d74d7f69-3fdc-4852-8ea6-418d946ac898", + "displayId": "R29", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Clicking on a non-faded, non-phantom macro node shall dispatch a select action carrying the underlying IR record (frame, derivation run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse hub, or perspective hub) into the existing global selection store consumed by DetailPanel.tsx.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "d7be43d7-f7f7-4dab-9b23-5a9be8142259", + "displayId": "C8", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Collapsed/expanded state in the macro view is purely ephemeral in-memory React state and is never persisted.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d854ab71-2a25-4574-9495-d0b6fc0d84df", + "displayId": "E1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The data structures for the macro view are defined in /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/src/types/artifact.ts.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "evidence", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "d9238094-baff-486f-b133-fb54893e4f52", + "displayId": "G2", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view's visual design must be beautiful, novel, and information-dense, avoiding generic dashboard or AI-generated aesthetics.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "da11ebf0-9325-457e-a51a-6407143cd087", + "displayId": "T1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The Phase type has four ordered values: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "dd7a95d5-d2e8-4177-8dd7-0a3d6c0e0414", + "displayId": "X25", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: the nudging state is indicated by a treatment inside the node body (compact labelled chip or badge such as 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE' in phosphor amber) rather than as an external indicator.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "dfe05b5c-c7c7-4924-9651-8a498da7bc89", + "displayId": "CR53", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For each phase group containing one or more DerivationRunNodes, a FanInNode, and a ReconciliationNode, layout emits sequence edges from each RunNode → FanInNode and FanInNode → ReconciliationNode. Each such edge has computed stroke color resolving to --color-phosphor-amber, has a markerEnd arrow, and has animated !== true. Verify with a unit-test fixture and a render assertion on edge count, source/target ids, and computed style.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e0f163b2-6bb7-453a-9512-f6111f59f79f", + "displayId": "CR27", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given two sibling phase groups A and B at the same depth where B is below A in the y axis, after collapsing A, B's new position.y is strictly less than its previous position.y by approximately the height differential (expanded_height(A) - pill_height) ± a tolerance. No sibling node retains a position that would leave a vertical gap larger than expanded_height(A)/2 where A's expanded body used to be. Verify with a unit test on layout() comparing pre-collapse and post-collapse outputs.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e0f2e85e-a59f-4a54-a7f8-72afbc9ff983", + "displayId": "CR19", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given two depths D1 and D2 where the maximum content width across nodes at D1 is W1 and at D2 is W2, with W1 != W2, the lane widths assigned by layout differ (laneWidth(D1) != laneWidth(D2)) and laneWidth(D_i) is a function of W_i (not a constant). Verify with a parameterized unit test asserting the lane-width function is non-constant across two fixtures with deliberately differing content widths.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e4c634ac-e0e8-45f3-8542-7ed3e6662c00", + "displayId": "A19", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: no banner, rely on user knowledge that the view is snapshot-only. Leaves RK3 (stale data) fully unmitigated.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e506c68c-df22-4707-8a85-5c8cd12db447", + "displayId": "CR65", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given a fixture where impasse I in frame F0 triggers child frame F1 (parent F0, depth 1), the layout positions ImpasseNode I at the boundary between F0's lane (depth 0) and F1's lane (depth 1) such that it is horizontally between (or aligned with the start of) the two lanes. Verify with a unit test on layout asserting I.position.x lies between the rightmost x of F0's nodes and the leftmost x of F1's nodes (inclusive).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e52d0b19-73e9-4e84-9267-032b22a5535f", + "displayId": "G3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A user should be able to understand what happened at each derivation step from the node visuals alone (numbers, IDs, outcomes) without needing to open a detail panel.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "e61a6eec-6f69-4805-af23-cae030455161", + "displayId": "R22", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Collapse/expand state for phase groups shall be held in a single useState> (or equivalent set keyed by phase-group identity) at the MacroView root component. PhaseGroupNode renderers shall not own their own collapse state.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "e702efc3-129f-4907-8040-4154b51991a6", + "displayId": "CR47", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "ReconciliationNode renders with computed border-color: outcome='accepted' → the parent phase's --color-phase-* token; outcome='retry' → --color-phosphor-amber; outcome='recurse' → --color-phosphor-cyan; outcome='bail' → --color-phosphor-red AND a dimmed interior treatment. Header contains a textual chip whose text equals the outcome name. Verify with parameterized RTL tests across all four outcomes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ea15c1bd-7368-4df1-ab3f-55c5542edffe", + "displayId": "X40", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "A DetailPanel.tsx component exists at src/components/DetailPanel.tsx as a sibling to MacroView.tsx, confirming reuse is structurally feasible.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "observed", + "authority": "technical" + }, + { + "id": "ea3fed19-77cb-46a2-9862-669e7b56c919", + "displayId": "DEC5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use React Flow parent/child group nodes for phase containers.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "decision", + "rationale": "X18 explicitly mandates RF group/parent nodes. Beyond compliance, parenting buys correct hit-testing, per-node click-to-detail (X33), and individual child animation when the group reflows on collapse (X22). HTML-only nesting forfeits the ability to attach edges from a fan-in row to a child reconciliation node and breaks the click-target model. Manual overlap is fragile and reorders interactively." + }, + { + "id": "eaa8abe6-de0b-43b6-97a9-a9272dfe92b6", + "displayId": "CR63", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "A heuristic content-completeness test asserts that every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node renders text/visual elements covering at minimum: a unique ID (frame displayId, run index, hub displayId, etc.), a count or status indicator (run counts, outcome glyph, fan-in row count, or impassesFound), and (where applicable) a mode/outcome chip. Verify with an RTL-driven content audit: for each node-type fixture, assert presence of (a) ID text, (b) numeric or glyph indicator, (c) status/mode chip text where applicable.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ebe6087a-8e79-4898-96e5-9e73c607def3", + "displayId": "T14", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view is the component within the Spec Explorer UI that narrates the full derivation history of a spec via a pannable, zoomable React Flow graph of ~20–40 semantically typed nodes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ec0c190e-7c1a-4773-a24d-fe4cd47c95e8", + "displayId": "J3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Three independent constraints jointly force collapse state to be a single hoisted in-memory Set with no persistence and an empty initial value: (1) the requirement that collapse triggers global sibling reflow, (2) the prohibition on persistence, and (3) the mandate that every page load starts fully expanded.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "justification", + "rationale": "X22 requires sibling reflow on collapse, which the layout function needs visibility into the full collapsed set to compute — forcing the state to be lifted to MacroView root (DEC6). C8 forbids any persistence layer. C9 mandates fully-expanded state at every mount. Together these uniquely determine the design captured in D6." + }, + { + "id": "ed11ae23-cab6-420f-9adb-fb61fe4bb7e1", + "displayId": "D13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Module structure under src/components/macro/: index.ts (re-exports MacroView), MacroView.tsx (top-level: data load, state, ReactFlowProvider, Canvas), story-ir.ts (ArtifactFile → StoryIR builder, pure), layout.ts (StoryIR + collapsedSet → RFNode[]/RFEdge[], pure), nodes/ (PhaseGroupNode.tsx, DerivationRunNode.tsx, FanInNode.tsx, ReconciliationNode.tsx, ImpasseNode.tsx, PerspectiveNode.tsx, PhantomNode.tsx — one component per type), edges/ (custom edge components if needed), and macro.css or co-located CSS modules using only theme.css tokens. Existing src/components/MacroView.tsx becomes a thin re-export of the new module to preserve the current import path.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ee433e1d-eb31-4655-b604-b21d5bb073ba", + "displayId": "R63", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node shall surface enough content (IDs, counts, outcome glyph, mode chip) to identify what happened at that derivation step without requiring the user to open the detail panel.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ee89f88c-59a9-463f-b3e9-5545d471e771", + "displayId": "R13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view shall render exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord, one FanInNode per FanInRecord, and one ReconciliationNode per ReconciliationRecord present in ArtifactFile.graph.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "eeefea9f-a6bf-419f-a87d-09c516ffec87", + "displayId": "CR16", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Given a fixture phase group with no PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected', buildStoryIR emits exactly one PhantomNode child for that phase group whose id is synthesized (not present in ArtifactFile) and whose label contains the phrase 'no perspective taken' (case-insensitive). Conversely, for a phase group containing a selected perspective, no PhantomNode is emitted. Verify with two unit-test fixtures.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "ef5080f2-3379-4c0a-837a-c87ebdbc6e16", + "displayId": "CR26", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, the rendered pill DOM contains: (1) an element styled with background-color or border-color resolving to the corresponding --color-phase-* token, (2) the frame's displayId text, (3) text matching the pattern /\\d+\\s+RUNS?/, and (4) one of the glyphs ✓, ↺, ↪, or ✗ corresponding to the frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome (accepted/retry/recurse/bail respectively). Clicking the pill toggles expansion AND dispatches a select action. Verify with a parameterized RTL test covering all four outcomes.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "efe5262b-e33b-40b2-a4de-9c1e99b2758c", + "displayId": "A15", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: derive every edge mechanically from EdgeRecord rows in the artifact (informed_by, produced, considered, etc.). This pushes graph-content edges (designed for the micro view) into the macro view and would generate hundreds of edges, defeating the macro view's narrative purpose.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "effa3c4f-e621-47e1-8b01-20c710572063", + "displayId": "CR22", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Inspecting the MacroView component source (or its rendered React tree) shows exactly one useState/useReducer call holding a Set (or Set-equivalent) of FrameId values for collapsed groups, located in the MacroView root component. PhaseGroupNode component source contains no useState/useReducer holding collapse state. Verify with a static-analysis test (AST inspection of the source files) and/or a runtime test using React DevTools-equivalent introspection.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f20deae0-904a-45db-b2be-774680581829", + "displayId": "D12", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, its renderer swaps to a compact pill ~120px×28px showing: phase color dot + frame displayId + 'n RUNS' + outcome glyph (✓ accepted / ↺ retry / ↪ recurse / ✗ bail) derived from the frame's terminal reconciliation. The pill remains clickable to expand and to open the detail panel. External edges re-attach to the pill's center handles automatically because React Flow recomputes edge endpoints from node bounds.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f29bd3b9-b4e4-4856-b1b3-0d0d39a3334f", + "displayId": "T10", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A phantom node represents the case where no perspective is selected — it appears when an alternative perspective is used.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "term", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f2cd0b78-c817-4990-853a-952f9664db70", + "displayId": "A3", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Alternative: subscribe to the artifact store and recompute the IR/layout on every change.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "alternative", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f2daf689-34e8-4f4c-9f5d-115640dd51a9", + "displayId": "CR61", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Calling buildStoryIR(artifact) twice with structurally-equal artifact inputs produces deeply-equal outputs. Calling layout(ir, set) twice with structurally-equal inputs produces deeply-equal outputs. Neither function mutates its input (pre/post deep-equal of inputs). Neither references Date.now, Math.random, document, window, or external store. Verify with property-based tests (fast-check) for determinism and idempotence, plus a static-analysis test for forbidden globals.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f3d1aecf-1353-4cd4-b033-1b445bf4a311", + "displayId": "J1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "Multiple node-attribute encodings (border style for mode, border color for outcome, fill for phase, header chips for nudging/material progress, opacity for perspective selection, shape for impasse) coexist on a single node without ambiguity because each visual channel is reserved for a single semantic dimension.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "hub", + "hubType": "justification", + "rationale": "G3/G4 require at-a-glance comprehension; X25, X27, X28, X32, X35, X23 each assign a different semantic attribute to a different visual channel; C7 forbids decorative color reuse; DEC8 explicitly orthogonalizes channels. Together these premises force the requirement that no two semantic attributes share the same visual channel, which is a property each node renderer must collectively satisfy." + }, + { + "id": "f5021521-ddbc-4cdc-b8f9-35deedc2162c", + "displayId": "R49", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "An ImpasseNode whose hub is the trigger of a child frame whose terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome is 'bail' shall be annotated with a 'DEAD-END' textual chip on the node, distinguishing it from open or resolved impasses.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f51ce22a-c2d1-453e-8a18-05fa68df0385", + "displayId": "C1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view must use React Flow (@xyflow/react) version ^12.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f5a738fe-a3d9-4e59-873c-6a254e2efe42", + "displayId": "CR5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "story-ir.ts exports a buildStoryIR(artifact) function whose return type is a typed StoryIR (not RFNode[]); layout.ts exports a layout(ir, collapsedSet) function whose return type contains RFNode[] and RFEdge[] with absolute positions. Verify by a TypeScript type-level test (tsd or expectTypeOf) that the IR builder's output has no React Flow position/parentId fields and that the layout output's nodes array contains objects with {id, type, position, parentId?}.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f68f7978-2b0b-41d1-b4df-d03d9630ecfe", + "displayId": "X20", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: all three frame modes (initial, rederive, grounding_enrichment) render as the same phase-group node component, with mode differences expressed via color, label, or border style only.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f792bc85-8e17-4c8c-92b4-534d430baa47", + "displayId": "CR15", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "For each HubNode with hubType='impasse' that participates in the derivation narrative (i.e., is referenced via FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds or ReconciliationRecord.resolvedImpasseIds/triggerImpasseIds/unresolvedImpasseIds), the IR contains exactly one ImpasseNode whose id maps to that hub. Likewise for each participating HubNode with hubType='perspective'. Verify with a unit test on buildStoryIR using a fixture covering all three reference paths.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f95cb026-c83a-4cd9-b7b1-8820e8a06d17", + "displayId": "G1", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view answers the question 'how did the spec get here?' by visualizing the full onion-peel cycle of impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, and resolution.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "goal", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "f998ef35-e4e8-4e2e-90b1-10a8b0a21de4", + "displayId": "R55", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "All macro view edges shall render without animation by default; no edge shall use React Flow's animated property by default.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "f99d6f39-bca4-4f36-8996-1774fbf41683", + "displayId": "X4", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "A right-side detail panel is already implemented and wired in the Micro View; the macro view should reuse it.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "fbe67225-70e2-49e2-b84e-f1af1a8f59e5", + "displayId": "X21", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested derivation run is collapsed it shrinks to a small pill or badge node showing key stats (run count, outcome).", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "fca0d0c5-fdda-4111-8570-fc2e495c8fc2", + "displayId": "CR33", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "Clicking on a PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' or 'open' (i.e., faded) does NOT dispatch any select action. Its DOM exposes no interactive affordance. Verify with an RTL test using fixtures for both selected and faded perspective nodes; click each; assert select dispatch only for the selected one.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "fd7297cd-10b1-4e14-bd32-66e8b1a3b12c", + "displayId": "D5", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "shaping", + "text": "Use React Flow's parentId/extent='parent' mechanism so that DerivationRunNodes, FanInNodes, ReconciliationNodes, and PerspectiveNodes are children of a PhaseGroupNode (which is rendered as type='group'). Children use position relative to the parent's origin, and the layout algorithm emits absolute parent positions plus relative child offsets. This lets React Flow handle the visual containment, drag-bound clipping, and z-ordering for free, and it makes collapse-as-pill (X21) a matter of toggling the group's children to display:none and swapping its renderer to a compact pill.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:30:21.026Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "design", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "fe6568b2-bee4-4586-8f52-26805e60cdbc", + "displayId": "CR60", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "The full project builds with `vite build` (or its equivalent npm/deno script) without errors after adding the macro view. No new bundler or runtime is added (no Webpack, Parcel, esbuild standalone, etc., introduced). package.json/deno.json shows no new CSS framework dependency competing with Tailwind. Verify with a CI build step plus a dependency-list check.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "fe709bac-edf8-4e3b-8fb2-2134844958e0", + "displayId": "R14", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "pinning", + "text": "The macro view shall render one ImpasseNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'impasse', and one PerspectiveNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'perspective', subject to those hubs participating in the derivation narrative captured by the IR.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:36:04.897Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "requirement", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + }, + { + "id": "fe95dde6-0af4-4eec-848c-e24b06ca5491", + "displayId": "X13", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "Stakeholder preference: custom React Flow node types exist for each semantic role: trunk phase, impasse, phase group, fan-out, run, fan-in, reconciliation, perspective, phantom, and dead-end impasse.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "context", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "fea06b16-e24e-4993-be0a-5a969c137293", + "displayId": "C11", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "grounding", + "text": "The macro view is a snapshot-only view: it reads artifact data once on mount and does not update reactively.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:12:48.850Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "constraint", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "stakeholder" + }, + { + "id": "ffe8016d-c5db-4da8-8c17-c58a0f504cfc", + "displayId": "CR23", + "specId": "bff9f8bc-77ce-4055-9842-023421f5e388", + "frameId": "08619322-ce10-4448-bee0-5df99c8a4910", + "phase": "defining_done", + "text": "On every fresh mount of MacroView with any artifact fixture, immediately after first render, no PhaseGroupNode is rendered as a collapsed pill: every phase group renders in its expanded form. Verify with a render test that mounts MacroView and asserts (a) the collapsed-set state is empty and (b) no element with the macro-collapsed-pill data attribute is in the DOM.", + "lifecycle": "active", + "reviewStatus": { + "_tag": "clean" + }, + "provenance": [], + "createdAt": "2026-05-10T09:48:17.528Z", + "kind": "content", + "semanticRole": "criterion", + "epistemicStatus": "asserted", + "authority": "derived" + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts similarity index 84% rename from .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts rename to .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts index 71bd6e046..e857a356a 100644 --- a/.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts @@ -1,19 +1,21 @@ /** - * One-off port of Bilal's spec-elicitation-prototype graph data into - * brunch-shaped node/edge JSON fixtures. + * One-off prep step: convert Bilal's spec-elicitation-prototype graph data + * into the brunch-shaped consolidated seed contract. * - * Lives co-located with its output under .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/ - * (the .fixtures/** tree is excluded from oxlint/oxfmt by project config — - * this script does not pass through the project verification harness). + * Throwaway data-prep, not product code. Lives co-located with the data it + * vendors and produces, under .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/ (the .fixtures/** + * tree is excluded from oxlint/oxfmt/build by project config). The product + * seed loader (src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts) reads ONLY the consolidated .json + * output and never knows Bilal's format exists. * * Run with: - * npx tsx .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts + * npx tsx .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts * - * Source (read-only): - * /Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/bilal-spec-elicitation-proto/spec//graph/{nodes,edges}.json + * Source (vendored, read-only): + * ./_originals//{nodes,edges}.json * - * Output (sibling per-spec subdirectories): - * .fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port//{nodes,edges,spec}.json + * Output (consolidated seed contract, one file per spec): + * ./.json → { spec, nodes, edges } * * Mapping rules (derived in thread T-019e91ee, summarized below): * @@ -57,24 +59,25 @@ * Field translation: * authority → source ("stakeholder" | "technical" | "external" | * "derived") - * epistemicStatus: - * inferred → basis: "accepted_review_set" - * asserted, observed, assumed → basis: "explicit" - * (epistemic flavor concatenated to source: e.g. - * "stakeholder-observed", "external-asserted") + * epistemicStatus: does NOT affect basis. Every ported node is + * basis: "explicit" — Bilal authored each item directly, which is + * exact per-item approval (brunch "implicit" basis is reserved for + * propose-graph-concept acceptance, a notion Bilal's data lacks). + * The epistemic flavor survives as source text instead: it is + * concatenated to source when not "asserted" (e.g. + * "stakeholder-observed", "external-inferred"). * displayId → preserved as bracket suffix in source: "stakeholder [Q9]" * * Discarded: phase, frameId, lifecycle (all active), reviewStatus * (all clean), provenance (already empty), createdAt. * - * Re-run safely: output dir is wiped per spec on each run. + * Re-run safely: each .json is overwritten on each run. * - * Note: this script reads from an absolute external path on the - * author's machine. It is not portable across machines without - * adjusting BILAL_ROOT or providing the source data at that path. + * Reproducible: reads from the vendored ./_originals/ tree, not an external + * checkout. Anyone can regenerate the seed contracts from this directory alone. */ -import { existsSync, mkdirSync, readFileSync, rmSync, writeFileSync } from 'node:fs'; +import { existsSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from 'node:fs'; import { dirname, resolve } from 'node:path'; import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'; @@ -83,7 +86,7 @@ import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'; // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- const SCRIPT_DIR = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)); -const BILAL_ROOT = '/Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/bilal-spec-elicitation-proto/spec'; +const ORIGINALS_ROOT = resolve(SCRIPT_DIR, '_originals'); const OUTPUT_ROOT = SCRIPT_DIR; const SPECS: { source: string; slug: string; displayName: string }[] = [ @@ -160,7 +163,7 @@ interface BrunchNodeFixture { kind: string; title: string; body: string | null; - basis: 'explicit' | 'accepted_review_set'; + basis: 'explicit'; source: string | null; detail: Record | null; } @@ -178,7 +181,7 @@ interface BrunchEdgeFixture { source_local_id: number; target_local_id: number; stance: 'for' | 'against' | null; - basis: 'explicit' | 'accepted_review_set'; + basis: 'explicit'; rationale: string | null; } @@ -208,13 +211,19 @@ function deriveTitle(text: string, max = 140): string { return candidate.slice(0, max - 1).trimEnd() + '…'; } -/** Project Bilal authority + epistemicStatus into brunch source + basis. */ +/** + * Project Bilal authority + epistemicStatus into brunch source + basis. + * + * basis is always "explicit": Bilal authored each item directly (exact + * per-item approval). The epistemic flavor is preserved in source text, + * not basis. brunch "implicit" basis is reserved for propose-graph-concept + * acceptance, which Bilal's data has no notion of. + */ function projectProvenance(node: BilalNode): { - basis: 'explicit' | 'accepted_review_set'; + basis: 'explicit'; source: string | null; } { - const basis: 'explicit' | 'accepted_review_set' = - node.epistemicStatus === 'inferred' ? 'accepted_review_set' : 'explicit'; + const basis = 'explicit' as const; const parts: string[] = []; if (node.authority) parts.push(node.authority); @@ -466,7 +475,7 @@ interface SpecPortResult { } function portSpec(sourceName: string, slug: string, displayName: string): SpecPortResult { - const sourceDir = resolve(BILAL_ROOT, sourceName, 'graph'); + const sourceDir = resolve(ORIGINALS_ROOT, sourceName); const nodes = JSON.parse(readFileSync(resolve(sourceDir, 'nodes.json'), 'utf8')) as BilalNode[]; const edges = JSON.parse(readFileSync(resolve(sourceDir, 'edges.json'), 'utf8')) as BilalEdge[]; @@ -497,7 +506,7 @@ function portSpec(sourceName: string, slug: string, displayName: string): SpecPo body: `Synthetic parent check representing the manual code-audit pass during which ` + `evidence nodes were authored. Generated by ` + - `.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence ` + + `.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence ` + `a structural parent on the oracle plane.`, basis: 'explicit', source: 'derived-port-synthetic', @@ -665,35 +674,35 @@ function portSpec(sourceName: string, slug: string, displayName: string): SpecPo // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- function writeSpec(result: SpecPortResult, displayName: string): void { - const outDir = resolve(OUTPUT_ROOT, result.slug); - if (existsSync(outDir)) rmSync(outDir, { recursive: true, force: true }); - mkdirSync(outDir, { recursive: true }); - - writeFileSync( - resolve(outDir, 'spec.json'), - JSON.stringify({ slug: result.slug, name: displayName, readiness_grade: 'commitments_ready' }, null, 2) + - '\n', - ); - writeFileSync(resolve(outDir, 'nodes.json'), JSON.stringify(result.brunchNodes, null, 2) + '\n'); - writeFileSync(resolve(outDir, 'edges.json'), JSON.stringify(result.brunchEdges, null, 2) + '\n'); + // Consolidated seed contract — one file per spec, atomic seed unit. + const seed = { + spec: { slug: result.slug, name: displayName, readiness_grade: 'commitments_ready' }, + nodes: result.brunchNodes, + edges: result.brunchEdges, + }; + writeFileSync(resolve(OUTPUT_ROOT, `${result.slug}.json`), JSON.stringify(seed, null, 2) + '\n'); } function writeReadme(results: { slug: string; displayName: string; stats: Record }[]): void { const lines: string[] = [ - '# `.fixtures/seed-specs/bilal-port/`', + '# `.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/`', '', "Ported spec graphs from Bilal's spec-elicitation prototype, transformed", 'to the brunch graph model. Intended as development seed data — rich,', 'real spec material to populate a dev SQLite database for UI / agent work.', '', - 'Not probe-run artifacts; sits alongside `.fixtures/runs/` rather than inside it.', + 'Not probe-run artifacts; sits under `.fixtures/seeds/` alongside', + '`.fixtures/runs/` rather than inside it.', '', '## Provenance', '', - 'Source: `/Users/lunelson/Code/hashintel/bilal-spec-elicitation-proto/spec//graph/`', + 'Source: vendored under [`_originals/`](./_originals/) — copied from', + "Bilal's spec-elicitation prototype `spec//graph/{nodes,edges}.json`.", '', - 'Generated by [`_port-script.ts`](./_port-script.ts) (co-located in this directory).', - 'Re-runnable; each run wipes and re-emits per-spec subdirectories.', + 'Each `.json` is generated from `_originals/` by', + '[`_port-script.ts`](./_port-script.ts) (a throwaway data-prep step,', + 'not product code). Re-runnable from this directory alone; each run', + 'overwrites the `.json` files.', '', '## Transformation rules', '', @@ -723,18 +732,28 @@ function writeReadme(results: { slug: string; displayName: string; stats: Record '```', 'bilal-port/', '├── README.md # this file (generated)', - '├── _port-script.ts # the porting script itself (re-runnable)', - '├── /', - '│ ├── spec.json # → specs table seed row', - '│ ├── nodes.json # → nodes table seed rows (local_id placeholder for autoincrement)', - '│ └── edges.json # → edges table seed rows (source/target reference local_id)', + '├── _port-script.ts # throwaway prep: _originals/ → .json', + '├── _originals/ # vendored Bilal source (reproducibility)', + '│ └── /{nodes,edges}.json', + '└── .json # consolidated seed contract (× 3)', + '```', + '', + 'Each `.json` is the seed contract consumed by the loader:', + '', + '```', + '{', + ' "spec": { "slug", "name", "readiness_grade" },', + ' "nodes": [ { "local_id", "plane", "kind", "title", "body?", "basis", "source?", "detail?" } ],', + ' "edges": [ { "category", "source_local_id", "target_local_id", "stance?", "basis", "rationale?" } ]', + '}', '```', '', - 'Field shape mirrors [`src/db/schema.ts`](../../../src/db/schema.ts) column names', - '(plane, kind, title, body, basis, source, detail).', - 'No LSNs or change-log entries are pre-baked — a seed loader is expected', - 'to wrap inserts in one `commitGraph`-style transaction so the graph clock,', - "change log, and lsn columns stay coherent under brunch's mutation contract.", + 'Node/edge field shape mirrors [`src/db/schema.ts`](../../../src/db/schema.ts)', + 'column names. `local_id` is a placeholder for autoincrement; edges reference', + 'nodes by `local_id`. No LSNs or change-log entries are pre-baked — the loader', + '([`src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts`](../../../src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts)) wraps each spec', + 'in one `commitGraph` transaction so the graph clock, change log, and lsn', + "columns stay coherent under brunch's mutation contract.", '', '## Stats', '', @@ -756,15 +775,14 @@ function writeReadme(results: { slug: string; displayName: string; stats: Record // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- function main(): void { - if (!existsSync(BILAL_ROOT)) { - console.error(`Bilal source directory not found at ${BILAL_ROOT}`); + if (!existsSync(ORIGINALS_ROOT)) { + console.error(`Vendored originals not found at ${ORIGINALS_ROOT}`); process.exit(1); } - mkdirSync(OUTPUT_ROOT, { recursive: true }); const summaries: { slug: string; displayName: string; stats: Record }[] = []; for (const spec of SPECS) { - console.log(`Porting ${spec.source} → ${spec.slug}...`); + console.log(`Porting ${spec.source} → ${spec.slug}.json...`); const result = portSpec(spec.source, spec.slug, spec.displayName); writeSpec(result, spec.displayName); summaries.push({ slug: spec.slug, displayName: spec.displayName, stats: result.stats }); diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/code-health.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/code-health.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3fd7648ba --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/code-health.json @@ -0,0 +1,7131 @@ +{ + "spec": { + "slug": "code-health", + "name": "Code Health", + "readiness_grade": "commitments_ready" + }, + "nodes": [ + { + "local_id": 1, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "check", + "title": "Code Health — code-audit pass", + "body": "Synthetic parent check representing the manual code-audit pass during which evidence nodes were authored. Generated by .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence a structural parent on the oracle plane.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-port-synthetic", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 2, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Stage 2 must compute three configuration spaces with the semantics defined in T20: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, e…", + "body": "Stage 2 must compute three configuration spaces with the semantics defined in T20: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, excluding alternatives requiring locked-baseline revision), M_preview (includes revision-requiring alternatives tagged as preview-only), and M_revision(r) (after an authorized revision set r is applied).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 3, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test must verify that after a refinement reconciliation outcome, the unresolved successor impasse has at least one incoming 'refined…", + "body": "A unit test must verify that after a refinement reconciliation outcome, the unresolved successor impasse has at least one incoming 'refined_to' edge, and that the derivation loop's progress measurement counts it as progress on the 'incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses' signal.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 4, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Node state is modeled across three independent axes: lifecycle (candidate/activ…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T9]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Node state is modeled across three independent axes: lifecycle (candidate/active/archived), review status (clean/suspect/conditional), and impasse status (open/resolved/superseded for impasse nodes only)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 5, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Conflict resolution during reconciliation must first attempt a deterministic graph traversal computing the minimal set of grounding nodes w…", + "body": "Conflict resolution during reconciliation must first attempt a deterministic graph traversal computing the minimal set of grounding nodes whose removal resolves the conflict; a subagent may be invoked only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure (missing provenance edges or semantic-rather-than-structural contradiction).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R64]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 6, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A module test must drive a fan-in fixture with a witnessed source contradiction where some runs picked sides and verify that Stage 1 emits…", + "body": "A module test must drive a fan-in fixture with a witnessed source contradiction where some runs picked sides and verify that Stage 1 emits a genuine impasse for the contradiction BEFORE Stage 2 computes M_current; ordering verified via EventLog event sequence (FanInExtractionCompleted with impasses[] non-empty precedes ConfigSpaceComputed).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 7, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A static dependency check (parsing deno.json import_map / import statements in engine/solver/**) must confirm that the solver imports nothi…", + "body": "A static dependency check (parsing deno.json import_map / import statements in engine/solver/**) must confirm that the solver imports nothing outside the Deno standard library and Effect; no off-the-shelf SAT library (e.g., logic-solver, minisat, kissat) appears as a dependency.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 8, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A test must verify that each call to cowReplace emits a CowReplace event and each call to markSuspectAndPropagate emits a SuspectPropagated…", + "body": "A test must verify that each call to cowReplace emits a CowReplace event and each call to markSuspectAndPropagate emits a SuspectPropagated event with at least the affected node count.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 9, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The CLI must provide a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earlie…", + "body": "The CLI must provide a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earliest open impasse, and re-enters the derivation loop using that frame as parent.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R52]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 10, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A test must assert that the derivation loop sets nudgingActive=true after exactly 1 clean attempt without progress (matching X42 and the im…", + "body": "A test must assert that the derivation loop sets nudgingActive=true after exactly 1 clean attempt without progress (matching X42 and the implementation), and that PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 documents nudge_after_n=1.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 11, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The axis 'type' field must accept only 'design' or 'repair'; there must be no 'revision' axis type.", + "body": "The axis 'type' field must accept only 'design' or 'repair'; there must be no 'revision' axis type. Revision is modeled as an effect of selecting a particular alternative, not as a property of an axis.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 12, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "Of the 34 code health issues, 8 have been fixed and 26 remain open; the full list is tracked in PROBLEMS.md.", + "body": "Of the 34 code health issues, 8 have been fixed and 26 remain open; the full list is tracked in PROBLEMS.md.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 13, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Guarded impasses are diagnostic blockers with a trigger condition (guard formul…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T18]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Guarded impasses are diagnostic blockers with a trigger condition (guard formula) over the configuration space; they are not hard constraints and not propositions." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 14, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) get file read but not web search or paper read, because web search…", + "body": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) get file read but not web search or paper read, because web search results could surface content referencing the hidden impasse or old design.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [C5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 15, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the recommended priority order for addressing open issues is tests (P18–P25) > correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) >…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the recommended priority order for addressing open issues is tests (P18–P25) > correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) > design (P16) > everything else.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X62]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 16, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The resolve_directly and sharpen outcomes from user escalation materialize as grounding nodes with authority: stakeholder and epistemicStat…", + "body": "The resolve_directly and sharpen outcomes from user escalation materialize as grounding nodes with authority: stakeholder and epistemicStatus: asserted, mark trigger impasses as resolved, and return grounding_enriched for re-derivation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 17, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A static lint/grep check must confirm that no file under src/engine/** imports the Console module or invokes Console.log / Console.error /…", + "body": "A static lint/grep check must confirm that no file under src/engine/** imports the Console module or invokes Console.log / Console.error / Console.warn / Console.info / Console.debug. The check must run in CI and fail the build on violation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 18, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "An integration-style test using scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver must trigger a reconciliation outcome that produces a refi…", + "body": "An integration-style test using scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver must trigger a reconciliation outcome that produces a refined impasse, and assert that (a) reconciliation.ts populates spawnedImpasseIds with the new impasse node id, (b) the case 'recurse' branch in derivation-loop.ts is executed (verified via spy/event), and (c) runDerivationLoop is invoked recursively with the new impasse id in triggerImpasseIds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 19, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: per-run stance toward alternatives is tracked at the finest granularity — per run, per axis, per alternative value,…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: per-run stance toward alternatives is tracked at the finest granularity — per run, per axis, per alternative value, with stance values of 'supports', 'contradicts', or 'silent'.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 20, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the model has three distinct layers — hard constraints (boolean formulas determining satisfiability), guarded block…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the model has three distinct layers — hard constraints (boolean formulas determining satisfiability), guarded blockers/impasses (diagnostics with trigger conditions), and baseline effects (per-alternative authorization requirements). A configuration is activatable only if it satisfies all three.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 21, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The approach for handling the blocking impasse (unsatisfiable M_current) when selecting which constraint to demote is currently undecided.", + "body": "The approach for handling the blocking impasse (unsatisfiable M_current) when selecting which constraint to demote is currently undecided.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 22, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The spec elicitation prototype has a working forward pass.", + "body": "The spec elicitation prototype has a working forward pass.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 23, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Perspective summaries must be generated by sampling configurations from the solver's enumeration (capped at 200 per space) and running fart…", + "body": "Perspective summaries must be generated by sampling configurations from the solver's enumeration (capped at 200 per space) and running farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis-assignment vectors to pick k=3 representatives per space, with M_current and M_preview sampled separately.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 24, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: blocking impasse nodes participate in provenance and JTMS chains.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: blocking impasse nodes participate in provenance and JTMS chains.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 25, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: superseded (OUT) nodes are never deleted from the graph; they are retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to the…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: superseded (OUT) nodes are never deleted from the graph; they are retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement, preserving the JTMS justification chain so the graph grows monotonically.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 26, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A checkpoint is an immutable snapshot of the spec graph produced when a full re…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T11]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A checkpoint is an immutable snapshot of the spec graph produced when a full revision completes (all impasses resolved, spec stable); checkpoints are not created per frame or reconciliation step." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 27, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The solver implementation in engine/solver/dpll.ts must depend only on the Deno standard library and Effect; it must not pull in an off-the…", + "body": "The solver implementation in engine/solver/dpll.ts must depend only on the Deno standard library and Effect; it must not pull in an off-the-shelf SAT library.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 28, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P2: When the reconciler proposes disposition: \"refined\", the reconciliation engine marks the original impasse as superseded but never creat…", + "body": "P2: When the reconciler proposes disposition: \"refined\", the reconciliation engine marks the original impasse as superseded but never creates the refined impasse node; the refinedImpasse field is read from the LLM proposal but not consumed, so the refined impasse silently disappears.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 29, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: when two claims conflict with different authorities, the system surfaces the conflict and labels the authorities, b…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: when two claims conflict with different authorities, the system surfaces the conflict and labels the authorities, but the user always decides — even when there's an apparent priority cascade.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X52]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 30, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Three configuration spaces are defined: M_current (satisfies constraints and cu…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T20]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Three configuration spaces are defined: M_current (satisfies constraints and current baseline, excluding alternatives requiring locked-baseline revision), M_preview (includes revision-requiring alternatives tagged as preview-only), and M_revision(r) (after an authorized revision set is applied)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 31, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the SAT solver library must either expose constraint explanations natively or the system must reconstruct them.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the SAT solver library must either expose constraint explanations natively or the system must reconstruct them.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X60]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 32, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Nudging is tracked as a flag on FrameRecord but never affects agent behavior; no negative constraints are injected into the clean room agen…", + "body": "Nudging is tracked as a flag on FrameRecord but never affects agent behavior; no negative constraints are injected into the clean room agent prompt.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 33, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: grounding claims require citation, and a separate agent must verify their plausibility.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: grounding claims require citation, and a separate agent must verify their plausibility.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X58]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 34, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question (Q11): Taint policy must distinguish evidential contamination (content derived from hidden impasse/old design) from workflow…", + "body": "Open question (Q11): Taint policy must distinguish evidential contamination (content derived from hidden impasse/old design) from workflow provenance (node elicited because of an impasse); the latter should not trigger exclusion or targeted grounding enrichment becomes unusable.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 35, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test must construct a small model where axis X has alternatives {a,b,c} and constraints rule out b and c; backbone(model) must retur…", + "body": "A unit test must construct a small model where axis X has alternatives {a,b,c} and constraints rule out b and c; backbone(model) must return for axis X: {forcedValue:'a', blockingClauses:[, ]}. The blocking clauses must be the actual clauses present in the model.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 36, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A grep check must confirm that the symbol FanInExtractionResult does not appear anywhere in src/** (no definition, no import, no re-export)…", + "body": "A grep check must confirm that the symbol FanInExtractionResult does not appear anywhere in src/** (no definition, no import, no re-export); all import sites in src/agents/fan-in.ts, src/engine/derivation-agents.ts, and src/engine/fan-in.ts must reference ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult instead.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 37, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "Milestones M1 through M3 and most of M4 are complete; M6 (prose agent) and M9 (perspective hub) are also complete; M5 (resume/polish), M7 (…", + "body": "Milestones M1 through M3 and most of M4 are complete; M6 (prose agent) and M9 (perspective hub) are also complete; M5 (resume/polish), M7 (web inspector), and the end-to-end smoke test remain outstanding.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 38, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Conditional labels are ATMS-style truth maintenance markers; without them, reco…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T4]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Conditional labels are ATMS-style truth maintenance markers; without them, reconciliation cannot distinguish 'derived under known inconsistency' from 'clean derivation'. They are a correctness property of the core loop, not a display feature." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 39, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Stage 1 must only emit a hard constraint when accompanied by explicit witnessing evidence (a source contradiction, a dependency requirement…", + "body": "Stage 1 must only emit a hard constraint when accompanied by explicit witnessing evidence (a source contradiction, a dependency requirement, or a grounded rationale from a run); non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4-5 fan-out runs alone must NOT be treated as evidence for a hard constraint.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 40, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The codebase currently uses Console.log extensively throughout the engine for logging (fan-in, fan-out, phase-runner, reconciliation, deriv…", + "body": "The codebase currently uses Console.log extensively throughout the engine for logging (fan-in, fan-out, phase-runner, reconciliation, derivation-loop, etc.).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 41, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question: whether a blocking impasse (unsatisfiable configuration space) should be a persistent graph node or a transient grouping con…", + "body": "Open question: whether a blocking impasse (unsatisfiable configuration space) should be a persistent graph node or a transient grouping construct depends on whether it has semantic meaning.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 42, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "PLAN.md's sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses must be rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model, the deletion o…", + "body": "PLAN.md's sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses must be rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model, the deletion of FanInExtractionResult, perspectives as records, and blocking impasses as graph nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R51]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 43, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts file must be split into focused per-module test files (one per module covered) colocated with the modules t…", + "body": "The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts file must be split into focused per-module test files (one per module covered) colocated with the modules they test.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R46]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 44, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The reconciliation engine must invoke solver.revisionImpact whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, and the O…", + "body": "The reconciliation engine must invoke solver.revisionImpact whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, and the OUT (tainted) closure it returns must be passed into the re-derivation flow.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 45, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the plausibility verification agent takes node content and a source span as input and outputs a stance, rationale,…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the plausibility verification agent takes node content and a source span as input and outputs a stance, rationale, and optionally lists of supported and unsupported claims.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 46, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must have axes, alternatives, per-run stance, witness relations,…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must have axes, alternatives, per-run stance, witness relations, and candidate repairs as first-class fields.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 47, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "In reconciliation.ts, populate spawnedImpasseIds at the same point where the reconciler proposes new child impasses or where the LLM propos…", + "body": "In reconciliation.ts, populate spawnedImpasseIds at the same point where the reconciler proposes new child impasses or where the LLM proposal includes a refinedImpasse: every node id added to the graph as a new Impasse during reconciliation must also be pushed onto the local spawnedImpasseIds array before the outcome tag is computed. This makes the existing 'recurse' outcome branch and the existing case \"recurse\" handler in derivation-loop.ts (which already passes spawnedImpasseIds as triggerImpasseIds to the recursive runDerivationLoop call) reachable for the first time.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 48, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or @kael/ai Routine abstractions in the course of this work; all integrations must be done at the c…", + "body": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or @kael/ai Routine abstractions in the course of this work; all integrations must be done at the consumer layer.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R56]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 49, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P10/P32: FrameRecord.nudgingActive is set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts, but no agent or engine code reads it and…", + "body": "P10/P32: FrameRecord.nudgingActive is set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts, but no agent or engine code reads it and no negative constraint is injected into the clean room prompt.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 50, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: three-valued aggregation (supports/contradicts/silent) is required in fan-in; silence is NOT contradiction and must…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: three-valued aggregation (supports/contradicts/silent) is required in fan-in; silence is NOT contradiction and must not manufacture fake conflicts from omissions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X50]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 51, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a NodeIdFromDisplayId decode fails, the failure must propagate as a structured tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn t…", + "body": "When a NodeIdFromDisplayId decode fails, the failure must propagate as a structured tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn through the existing Effect AI retry mechanism, so the agent can correct the reference without engine-side custom retry logic.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 52, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Every grounding node produced by the targeted grounding sub-agent or grounding-enrichment must have direct exogenous evidential provenance…", + "body": "Every grounding node produced by the targeted grounding sub-agent or grounding-enrichment must have direct exogenous evidential provenance (citation/source span); the assembler's anti-laundering guardrail must reject grounding-phase events that do not carry such provenance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R59]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 53, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Impasse triage must remain a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) using the five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing prem…", + "body": "Impasse triage must remain a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) using the five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premise > term/ontology mismatch > upstream structural contradiction > endogenous design conflict (default).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R67]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 54, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When two claims conflict with different authorities, the system must surface the conflict and label the authorities, but the user must alwa…", + "body": "When two claims conflict with different authorities, the system must surface the conflict and label the authorities, but the user must always make the final decision; the engine must not auto-resolve based on an apparent authority cascade.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R68]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 55, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The derivation loop's progress measurement must consider three signals: (a) incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses, (b) resolved…", + "body": "The derivation loop's progress measurement must consider three signals: (a) incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses, (b) resolved impasses, and (c) activated nodes. Lack of progress on all three across an iteration must be treated as stagnation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R69]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 56, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test of the reconciliation engine must verify that when a reconciler proposal carries disposition='refined' with a refinedImpasse pa…", + "body": "A unit test of the reconciliation engine must verify that when a reconciler proposal carries disposition='refined' with a refinedImpasse payload: (a) a new Impasse hub node is created in the graph with status 'open', (b) a 'refined_to' lineage edge is created from the original impasse to the new one, (c) the original impasse is marked superseded (impasse-status), and (d) the new node id is pushed onto spawnedImpasseIds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 57, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate must be called for any milestone that exercises backward transitions such as…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate must be called for any milestone that exercises backward transitions such as grounding enrichment after a missing-premise impasse.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X57]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 58, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P22: No test verifies that WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state (nodes, edges, frames, display ID counte…", + "body": "P22: No test verifies that WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state (nodes, edges, frames, display ID counters, semantic keys); the PLAN marks this as tested but no test exists.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 59, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: each derived node has a justifications list used to determine which beliefs lose support during belief revision.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: each derived node has a justifications list used to determine which beliefs lose support during belief revision.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 60, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P24: engine/perspective-selection.ts is untested despite being fully testable with a scripted intervention driver.", + "body": "P24: engine/perspective-selection.ts is untested despite being fully testable with a scripted intervention driver.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 61, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "There is no 'revision' axis type; revision is an effect of selecting a particul…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T16]", + "detail": { + "definition": "There is no 'revision' axis type; revision is an effect of selecting a particular alternative, not a property of an axis." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 62, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "clean-room-resolution.ts (and the perspective-selection consumer) must read the hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements flags from…", + "body": "clean-room-resolution.ts (and the perspective-selection consumer) must read the hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements flags from SelectionOutcome and dispatch to the repair re-derivation flow and revision authorization flow respectively; these flags must no longer be computed-but-unused.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 63, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test must instantiate ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult from src/domain/configuration.ts with all required fields populated and ver…", + "body": "A unit test must instantiate ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult from src/domain/configuration.ts with all required fields populated and verify the schema accepts: axes (id, type∈{design,repair}, cardinality∈{exactly_one,zero_or_one}, label); alternatives (id, axisId, label); perRunStance (runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance∈{supports,contradicts,silent}, optional rationale); witnesses (runId, claimId, sourceSpan); candidateRepairs (contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength); impasses (kind, conflictingNodes); hardConstraints (formula, witnessedBy∈{source_contradiction,dependency,grounded_rationale}, citation). Negative tests must reject invalid stance/type/cardinality values.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 64, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Fan-in must be split into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing a Configu…", + "body": "Fan-in must be split into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing a ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult, and Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis in engine/solver.ts (and a new engine/config-model.ts) consuming that result. The two stages must be independently invocable.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 65, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a 'partial' plausibility verdict triggers a split or revision request; an 'unsupported' verdict rejects the node.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a 'partial' plausibility verdict triggers a split or revision request; an 'unsupported' verdict rejects the node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 66, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P34: Four public WorkingGraph methods (cowReplace, markSuspectAndPropagate, getSemanticKey, getChildFrames) are defined but have zero calle…", + "body": "P34: Four public WorkingGraph methods (cowReplace, markSuspectAndPropagate, getSemanticKey, getChildFrames) are defined but have zero callers outside the class; COW grounding updates and suspect propagation are described as core mechanisms in the spec but the engine never exercises them.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 67, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The implementation must continue to use pure JSON file I/O; it must not introduce a database (e.g., DuckDB), an in-memory cross-spec graph,…", + "body": "The implementation must continue to use pure JSON file I/O; it must not introduce a database (e.g., DuckDB), an in-memory cross-spec graph, or cross-graph retrieval at this stage.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R57]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 68, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Unit tests of buildBaselineEffects must verify that: (a) when the baseline node is locked, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'locked', require…", + "body": "Unit tests of buildBaselineEffects must verify that: (a) when the baseline node is locked, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'locked', requiresAuthorization:true}; (b) when the baseline node is provisional, the effect is {commitmentLevel:'provisional', requiresAuthorization:false}; (c) the function reads commitmentLevel from the WorkingGraph baseline node, not from a constant. Verified with two graph fixtures (locked and provisional baseline).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 69, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: plausibility verification uses a three-valued output — supported, partially-supported, or unsupported — each with a…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: plausibility verification uses a three-valued output — supported, partially-supported, or unsupported — each with a rationale string.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 70, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Module-level tests for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in Stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow must use scripted DerivationAgent…", + "body": "Module-level tests for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in Stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow must use scripted DerivationAgents and a scripted InterventionDriver (already injectable per E18) so the tests are deterministic and require no LLM calls.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R42]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 71, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Clean room re-derivation is a strict information-flow isolation mechanism: for…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T2]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Clean room re-derivation is a strict information-flow isolation mechanism: for a given target phase, it returns only active upstream nodes, creates a fresh Chat instance with no prior history, and ensures retry feedback is schema-only." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 72, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) must be configured with file-read tools only; they must NOT have a…", + "body": "Clean room agents (shaping, pinning, defining-done during re-derivation) must be configured with file-read tools only; they must NOT have access to web search or paper read, because such results could surface content referencing the hidden impasse or old design.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 73, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Progress in the derivation loop is measured by impasse refinement (incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses), resolved impasses, an…", + "body": "Progress in the derivation loop is measured by impasse refinement (incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses), resolved impasses, and activated nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 74, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: integration tests for the derivation loop must cover all three impasse types in sequence using VCR-style recorded i…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: integration tests for the derivation loop must cover all three impasse types in sequence using VCR-style recorded interaction snapshots against OpenRouter.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X61]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 75, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Engine events must be defined as a closed discriminated-union type at src/engine/events.ts whose variants include at minimum: PhaseEntered,…", + "body": "Engine events must be defined as a closed discriminated-union type at src/engine/events.ts whose variants include at minimum: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt, FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed, PerspectiveGenerated, ReconcileOutcome, ImpasseSpawned, ImpasseResolved, NudgeActivated, CowReplace, SuspectPropagated, BlockingImpasseRaised, UserInterventionRequested, UserInterventionResolved. Adding a new event must require adding a new variant to the union (no open string-tag fallback).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 76, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The plausibility verification agent must take node content and a source span as input and produce a three-valued output: 'supported', 'part…", + "body": "The plausibility verification agent must take node content and a source span as input and produce a three-valued output: 'supported', 'partially-supported', or 'unsupported', each accompanied by a rationale string and optionally lists of supported and unsupported claims.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R61]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 77, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Per-run stance must be tracked at per-run × per-axis × per-alternative granularity; a run must be allowed to support one alternative on an…", + "body": "Per-run stance must be tracked at per-run × per-axis × per-alternative granularity; a run must be allowed to support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 78, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Specs are modeled as sub-graphs of typed, addressable claims connected by meani…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T6]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Specs are modeled as sub-graphs of typed, addressable claims connected by meaningful edges; the memory system is also a sub-graph within a super-graph architecture where all sub-graphs are searchable through a unified retrieval layer." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 79, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each Perspective record must point at a real activatable configuration drawn from the enumerated set, not at an interpolated centroid.", + "body": "Each Perspective record must point at a real activatable configuration drawn from the enumerated set, not at an interpolated centroid.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 80, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question (Q10): The targeted grounding sub-agent could launder prior design choices as facts via memory/cross-spec search; grounding n…", + "body": "Open question (Q10): The targeted grounding sub-agent could launder prior design choices as facts via memory/cross-spec search; grounding nodes must have direct exogenous evidential provenance as a guardrail.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 81, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Superseded (OUT) nodes must never be deleted from the graph; they must be retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement,…", + "body": "Superseded (OUT) nodes must never be deleted from the graph; they must be retained with a supersededBy edge pointing to their replacement, preserving the JTMS justification chain so the graph grows monotonically.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 82, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Per-run stance must be carried as a structured field on ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult with exactly the values 'supports', 'contradicts…", + "body": "Per-run stance must be carried as a structured field on ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult with exactly the values 'supports', 'contradicts', or 'silent'; three-valued aggregation in fan-in must read this structured field rather than parsing prose, and silence must never be aggregated as contradiction.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 83, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A CLI integration test must run a scripted derivation and verify that the human-readable stdout output is produced by the CLI's EventLog su…", + "body": "A CLI integration test must run a scripted derivation and verify that the human-readable stdout output is produced by the CLI's EventLog subscriber (e.g., by replacing the subscriber with a no-op and asserting stdout is empty), confirming that the CLI consumes EventLog events rather than receiving Console.log calls from the engine.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 84, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When the user resolves a blocking impasse by choosing a constraint demotion, the engine must record that choice as a relaxed_to edge from t…", + "body": "When the user resolves a blocking impasse by choosing a constraint demotion, the engine must record that choice as a relaxed_to edge from the BlockingImpasse node to the demoted constraint node, creating an auditable record.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 85, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: when the solver determines an axis has only one valid value across all configurations (a backbone/forced assignment…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: when the solver determines an axis has only one valid value across all configurations (a backbone/forced assignment), the system must show which constraint rules made the other values impossible.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X59]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 86, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P19: engine/assembler.ts has no unit tests; it converts IR events to graph nodes and edges including reference resolution, hub constraint e…", + "body": "P19: engine/assembler.ts has no unit tests; it converts IR events to graph nodes and edges including reference resolution, hub constraint enforcement, and lineage edge creation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 87, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a run can support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a run can support one alternative on an axis while being silent on another alternative on the same axis.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 88, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Substrate (backbone) is the set of alternatives that must be selected (or must…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T17]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Substrate (backbone) is the set of alternatives that must be selected (or must not be selected) in every configuration in M_current, defined semantically as common consequences rather than by provenance." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 89, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A type-level (compile-time) test must verify that the engine event type defined in src/engine/events.ts is a closed discriminated union: em…", + "body": "A type-level (compile-time) test must verify that the engine event type defined in src/engine/events.ts is a closed discriminated union: emitting an event with an unknown _tag must be a TypeScript compile error. Test method: a `// @ts-expect-error` line that attempts to emit an event with a fabricated tag.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 90, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: repair choices and design choices are fundamentally different — a repair resolves a source contradiction, a design…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: repair choices and design choices are fundamentally different — a repair resolves a source contradiction, a design choice selects among valid alternatives. The system must not present them as the same kind of preference.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X45]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 91, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "No file under src/engine/** (including fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection…", + "body": "No file under src/engine/** (including fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection.ts, assembler.ts) may import or call Console.log or any other Console method after the migration; this is enforceable as a static lint/grep check.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 92, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Design (non-repair) selection must be monotone: it must NOT trigger taint propagation, OUT computation, or re-derivation.", + "body": "Design (non-repair) selection must be monotone: it must NOT trigger taint propagation, OUT computation, or re-derivation. Only repair selection and revision authorization trigger non-monotone updates.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 93, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The justifications structure (JTMS/ATMS-style truth maintenance) already exists in the codebase on ConfigurationModel.", + "body": "The justifications structure (JTMS/ATMS-style truth maintenance) already exists in the codebase on ConfigurationModel.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 94, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a node carries a cached sourceAuthoritySet, triage must always re-traverse to validate the cache against live graph state; if cached a…", + "body": "When a node carries a cached sourceAuthoritySet, triage must always re-traverse to validate the cache against live graph state; if cached and live results diverge (e.g., due to a supersededBy update), the node must be flagged as requiring re-derivation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R66]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 95, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question (Q9): Derived nodes show authority: derived, erasing the original authority basis; triage and reconciliation may need sourceA…", + "body": "Open question (Q9): Derived nodes show authority: derived, erasing the original authority basis; triage and reconciliation may need sourceAuthoritySet / sourceEpistemicBasis summary fields to see through derivation chains.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 96, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P1: spawnedImpasseIds in reconciliation.ts is always initialized as an empty array and nothing ever pushes to it, making the recurse outcom…", + "body": "P1: spawnedImpasseIds in reconciliation.ts is always initialized as an empty array and nothing ever pushes to it, making the recurse outcome condition unreachable and the derivation loop's case \"recurse\" handler dead code.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 97, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: conflict resolution should always attempt a deterministic graph traversal first, computing the minimal set of groun…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: conflict resolution should always attempt a deterministic graph traversal first, computing the minimal set of grounding nodes whose removal resolves the conflict.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X55]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 98, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: sourceAuthoritySet is stored as a cache on a node at creation time for fast reads, but triage always re-traverses t…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: sourceAuthoritySet is stored as a cache on a node at creation time for fast reads, but triage always re-traverses to validate it; if cached and live results diverge (e.g., due to a supersededBy update), the node is flagged as requiring re-derivation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 99, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The derivation pipeline has four phases in strict derivational dependency order: grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done.", + "body": "The derivation pipeline has four phases in strict derivational dependency order: grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done. Execution is non-linear via backward transitions, but support edges must remain acyclic.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 100, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "nudgeAfterN defaults to 1 in the current derivation loop implementation.", + "body": "nudgeAfterN defaults to 1 in the current derivation loop implementation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 101, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Existing smoke test artifacts must still validate after changes.", + "body": "Existing smoke test artifacts must still validate after changes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [C4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 102, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P11: suggestedRewindPhase from the agent is always ignored; determineRewindPhase always returns one phase down regardless of the agent's hi…", + "body": "P11: suggestedRewindPhase from the agent is always ignored; determineRewindPhase always returns one phase down regardless of the agent's hint.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 103, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: readiness is evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection, not per perspective; a perspective summary carrie…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: readiness is evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection, not per perspective; a perspective summary carries default-bundle status for display only.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 104, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: constraint verification follows the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verif…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: constraint verification follows the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification — most cases handled mechanically, with uncertain cases elevated to a subagent.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 105, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question (Q12): Same-authority normative tradeoffs (latency vs cost, privacy vs observability) also require user adjudication but aren…", + "body": "Open question (Q12): Same-authority normative tradeoffs (latency vs cost, privacy vs observability) also require user adjudication but aren't authority conflicts per se; the triage class name may be too narrow.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 106, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the user's chosen constraint demotion is recorded as an edge from the blocking impasse node to the relaxed constrai…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the user's chosen constraint demotion is recorded as an edge from the blocking impasse node to the relaxed constraint, creating an auditable record.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 107, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: suspect status propagates only through identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into); it does NOT…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: suspect status propagates only through identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into); it does NOT auto-propagate through depends_on, derived_from, hub edges, motivates, references, or defines.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X53]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 108, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The codebase must include unit tests for each of the following pure-logic components: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, assembler.ts (referenc…", + "body": "The codebase must include unit tests for each of the following pure-logic components: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, assembler.ts (reference resolution, hub constraint enforcement, lineage edge creation), makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts, perspective-selection.ts, domain/invariants.ts validate() (including violating graphs that exercise support-edge acyclicity and phase stratification), the solver primitives (validateModel, enumerateConfigurations, backbone, demotionCandidates), and render/markdown.ts (snapshot-based).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 109, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Module tests must verify that fan-in Stage 1 (LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult) and Stage 2…", + "body": "Module tests must verify that fan-in Stage 1 (LLM extraction in agents/fan-in.ts producing ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult) and Stage 2 (deterministic solver analysis in engine/solver.ts + engine/config-model.ts) can be invoked independently: Stage 2 can be called with a fixture ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult and produce a configuration model deterministically, without invoking Stage 1.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 110, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The previously-used FanInExtractionResult type must be deleted from the codebase with no backward-compatibility shim; all import sites in s…", + "body": "The previously-used FanInExtractionResult type must be deleted from the codebase with no backward-compatibility shim; all import sites in src/agents/fan-in.ts, src/engine/derivation-agents.ts, and src/engine/fan-in.ts must be updated to use ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 111, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A schema-level test must verify that every agent IR field that previously carried a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageF…", + "body": "A schema-level test must verify that every agent IR field that previously carried a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives, selected, rejected, consequences, premises, conclusions) is typed via NodeIdFromDisplayId and not plain string. Verified by inspecting the exported schemas and asserting the brand/type of each id-bearing field.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 112, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "domain/graph.ts defines WorkingGraph.cowReplace(...) and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate(...) as public methods, but a repo-wide searc…", + "body": "domain/graph.ts defines WorkingGraph.cowReplace(...) and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate(...) as public methods, but a repo-wide search finds no callers outside the class definition itself.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X64]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 113, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P13: The fan-in extraction schema has no structured field for per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent); three-valued aggregation depend…", + "body": "P13: The fan-in extraction schema has no structured field for per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent); three-valued aggregation depends entirely on prompt compliance rather than structural enforcement.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 114, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Console.log is used throughout the engine for output, coupling the engine to CLI presentation.", + "body": "Console.log is used throughout the engine for output, coupling the engine to CLI presentation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 115, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P8: justifications is always set to an empty array in the configuration model, so the solver's revisionImpact function (JTMS-style truth ma…", + "body": "P8: justifications is always set to an empty array in the configuration model, so the solver's revisionImpact function (JTMS-style truth maintenance) has no data to operate on.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 116, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "assembler.ts must populate the justifications field on every derived node it creates, with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub…", + "body": "assembler.ts must populate the justifications field on every derived node it creates, with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub the node is connected to, recording {hubId, premiseIds: [...]} reflecting the actual hub premise edges.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 117, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P28: The artifact layout in PLAN.md does not list graph/reconciliation-records.json but the code writes it.", + "body": "P28: The artifact layout in PLAN.md does not list graph/reconciliation-records.json but the code writes it.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 118, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: replace the impasse-centric cross-run divergence model with a feature-model / SAT-analyzed constraint problem over…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: replace the impasse-centric cross-run divergence model with a feature-model / SAT-analyzed constraint problem over a structured variable space; perspectives become a presentation layer over this model rather than the primary semantic unit.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 119, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "An integration test using scripted intervention/grounding-enrichment must verify that when a stakeholder resolve_directly or sharpen outcom…", + "body": "An integration test using scripted intervention/grounding-enrichment must verify that when a stakeholder resolve_directly or sharpen outcome refines an existing grounding node, WorkingGraph.cowReplace is invoked with {oldNodeId, newNode} and a lineage edge is emitted recording the replacement; verified by spying cowReplace and asserting at least one call per scenario.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 120, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Grounding is the exogenous substrate: not clean-roomed, using copy-on-write sem…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T10]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Grounding is the exogenous substrate: not clean-roomed, using copy-on-write semantics. New nodes are added and existing nodes can be modified via COW. The substrate persists across backward transitions." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 121, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: replace the logging system with the Effect EventLog so every action taken emits an event, replacing all Console.log…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: replace the logging system with the Effect EventLog so every action taken emits an event, replacing all Console.log calls completely.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 122, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult must be defined in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields for: axes (id, type ∈ {design, re…", + "body": "ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult must be defined in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields for: axes (id, type ∈ {design, repair}, cardinality ∈ {exactly_one, zero_or_one}, label); alternatives (id, axisId, label); perRunStance (runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance ∈ {supports, contradicts, silent}, optional rationale); witnesses (runId, claimId, sourceSpan); candidateRepairs (contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength); impasses (kind, conflictingNodes); hardConstraints (formula, witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency, grounded_rationale}, citation).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 123, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The implementation must not add support for parallel/concurrent spec design sessions; the architecture remains single-session for this work.", + "body": "The implementation must not add support for parallel/concurrent spec design sessions; the architecture remains single-session for this work.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R58]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 124, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question (Q8): Impasse triage may need to inspect provenance closure (the 'conflict core') rather than just surface metadata for mixed…", + "body": "Open question (Q8): Impasse triage may need to inspect provenance closure (the 'conflict core') rather than just surface metadata for mixed-cause impasses; missing premise is an absence not visible in node metadata.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external [RK8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 125, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A run that resolves a source contradiction by picking a side witnesses a candid…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T14]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A run that resolves a source contradiction by picking a side witnesses a candidate repair (a possible maximal consistent subset), not an auto-resolution; the contradiction remains until a repair is explicitly licensed." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 126, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Using an off-the-shelf SAT solver risks less control over explanation/proof output and may have Deno compatibility issues.", + "body": "Using an off-the-shelf SAT solver risks less control over explanation/proof output and may have Deno compatibility issues.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 127, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "PLAN.md's artifact layout section must list graph/reconciliation-records.json so the documented layout matches what the code writes.", + "body": "PLAN.md's artifact layout section must list graph/reconciliation-records.json so the documented layout matches what the code writes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R49]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 128, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A module test with a scripted agent that emits an unresolvable display ID must verify the schema decode failure becomes an Effect AI tool r…", + "body": "A module test with a scripted agent that emits an unresolvable display ID must verify the schema decode failure becomes an Effect AI tool result error visible to the LLM on its next turn (i.e., the agent receives a structured retry prompt), and that the engine does not silently filter or drop the reference.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 129, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The grounding enrichment agent is impasse-aware, uses FullToolkit for research, is constrained to grounding-phase semantic roles only, and…", + "body": "The grounding enrichment agent is impasse-aware, uses FullToolkit for research, is constrained to grounding-phase semantic roles only, and includes an anti-laundering guardrail that validates all enrichment events against the grounding roles set before assembly.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 130, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: belief revision uses JTMS-style propagation — a derived node becomes OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications h…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: belief revision uses JTMS-style propagation — a derived node becomes OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 131, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The derivation loop is the core post-forward-pass mechanism: it checks for impa…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T1]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The derivation loop is the core post-forward-pass mechanism: it checks for impasses, initiates backward transitions by creating child frames, runs clean-room fan-out, reconciles, and recurses inside-out by generation." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 132, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P27: cli/run.ts inlines report formatting (40-line formatHandoffReport and 30-line derivation agent construction) that could be extracted t…", + "body": "P27: cli/run.ts inlines report formatting (40-line formatHandoffReport and 30-line derivation agent construction) that could be extracted to separate modules.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 133, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspective summaries are generated from representative configurations using diverse exemplar selection (farthest-f…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspective summaries are generated from representative configurations using diverse exemplar selection (farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis assignments), sampling M_current and M_preview separately.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 134, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Reconciliation must not archive a node merely because a re-derivation omitted it; if upstream grounding still supports the node and there i…", + "body": "Reconciliation must not archive a node merely because a re-derivation omitted it; if upstream grounding still supports the node and there is no contradiction, omission is insufficient justification for archival.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R65]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 135, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Constraint verification must follow the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification: most cases…", + "body": "Constraint verification must follow the same unified mechanical-first / subagent-fallback pattern as plausibility verification: most cases handled mechanically, with uncertain cases elevated to a subagent. Partial verdicts from the subagent must be fed back to the originating agent for correction.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R63]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 136, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "An integration test must verify that immediately after every cowReplace call, markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) is invoked and traverses i…", + "body": "An integration test must verify that immediately after every cowReplace call, markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) is invoked and traverses identity-preserving lineage edges only (equivalent_to, merged_into), setting review status to 'suspect' on transitively reachable nodes; the test must include nodes connected via depends_on / derived_from / hub edges / motivates / references / defines and assert those are NOT marked suspect.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 137, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "There must be a unit test that asserts WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state, including nodes, edges, fra…", + "body": "There must be a unit test that asserts WorkingGraph.fromArtifact(graph.toArtifact()) preserves all graph state, including nodes, edges, frames, display ID counters, and semantic keys.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 138, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A static grep check must confirm that src/engine/assembler.ts contains no '.filter(' expression that drops references whose display ID fail…", + "body": "A static grep check must confirm that src/engine/assembler.ts contains no '.filter(' expression that drops references whose display ID failed to resolve, and that the post-hoc resolve-and-filter code path described in P30 has been removed.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 139, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type using SchemaGetter.checkEffect should replace all post-hoc display ID resolution,…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type using SchemaGetter.checkEffect should replace all post-hoc display ID resolution, so schema decode failures surface as tool result errors that the LLM sees and can retry.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 140, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: enrichment nodes carry dual provenance — workflow provenance (which impasse prompted the inquiry, tracked via motiv…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: enrichment nodes carry dual provenance — workflow provenance (which impasse prompted the inquiry, tracked via motivates edges) and evidential provenance (the direct exogenous source). Only evidential provenance may justify downstream derivation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X51]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 141, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Agents emit semantic keys and support sets during derivation; the graph assembler assigns UUIDs and display IDs and creates edges, keeping…", + "body": "Agents emit semantic keys and support sets during derivation; the graph assembler assigns UUIDs and display IDs and creates edges, keeping normalization deterministic and testable and preventing the model from hallucinating edge targets.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 142, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4–5 fan-out runs is NOT evidence of a constraint; hard constraints requir…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: non-cooccurrence of alternatives across N=4–5 fan-out runs is NOT evidence of a constraint; hard constraints require explicit evidence such as a source contradiction, dependency requirement, or grounded rationale from a run.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X47]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 143, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Every notable engine occurrence (phase entry/completion, fan-out attempts, fan-in stages, reconcile outcomes, impasse spawn/resolution, nud…", + "body": "Every notable engine occurrence (phase entry/completion, fan-out attempts, fan-in stages, reconcile outcomes, impasse spawn/resolution, nudge activation, cowReplace, suspect propagation, blocking impasse raise, user intervention request/resolution) must emit a typed event via Effect EventLog.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 144, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: when M_current is unsatisfiable, the system proposes a set of constraint demotions, identifying which demotions wou…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: when M_current is unsatisfiable, the system proposes a set of constraint demotions, identifying which demotions would make it solvable and which would not.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 145, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: when a partial verdict is returned by the subagent for constraint or plausibility checking, it is fed back to the o…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: when a partial verdict is returned by the subagent for constraint or plausibility checking, it is fed back to the originating agent for correction.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 146, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: repair selection auto-resolves when one repair option is clearly better-evidenced; only genuinely ambiguous repairs…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: repair selection auto-resolves when one repair option is clearly better-evidenced; only genuinely ambiguous repairs become user-facing axes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X43]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 147, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "There must be exactly one end-to-end smoke test that drives the derivation loop through all three impasse types in sequence (authority conf…", + "body": "There must be exactly one end-to-end smoke test that drives the derivation loop through all three impasse types in sequence (authority conflict, missing premise, endogenous design conflict) using VCR-style recorded OpenRouter interaction snapshots.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R44]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 148, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each clean-room re-derivation invocation must instantiate a fresh Chat with no prior history; retry feedback to the agent must be schema-on…", + "body": "Each clean-room re-derivation invocation must instantiate a fresh Chat with no prior history; retry feedback to the agent must be schema-only (e.g., NodeIdFromDisplayId decode errors), never freeform.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 149, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "A 'partially-supported' plausibility verdict must trigger a split-or-revision request fed back to the originating agent for correction; an…", + "body": "A 'partially-supported' plausibility verdict must trigger a split-or-revision request fed back to the originating agent for correction; an 'unsupported' verdict must reject the node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R62]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 150, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P21: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, which converts FanInExtractionResult to a typed ConfigurationModel, is untested.", + "body": "P21: buildConfigModel in fan-in.ts, which converts FanInExtractionResult to a typed ConfigurationModel, is untested.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 151, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P30: Display IDs are resolved post-hoc with silent data loss: when a display ID doesn't resolve, the code silently drops it via .filter(nod…", + "body": "P30: Display IDs are resolved post-hoc with silent data loss: when a display ID doesn't resolve, the code silently drops it via .filter(nodeId !== undefined) or logs a non-blocking error, so the LLM never learns its reference was invalid and no retry is triggered.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 152, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Agents produce display IDs as strings; when these don't resolve, data is silently dropped instead of being fed back as errors.", + "body": "Agents produce display IDs as strings; when these don't resolve, data is silently dropped instead of being fed back as errors.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 153, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The prototype uses pure JSON file I/O; there is no DuckDB, no memory graph, and no cross-graph retrieval.", + "body": "The prototype uses pure JSON file I/O; there is no DuckDB, no memory graph, and no cross-graph retrieval.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 154, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P26: m4-engine.test.ts is 1702 lines covering 7 modules and should be split into focused per-module test files.", + "body": "P26: m4-engine.test.ts is 1702 lines covering 7 modules and should be split into focused per-module test files.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 155, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Tests must be deterministic and must not make LLM calls.", + "body": "Tests must be deterministic and must not make LLM calls.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [C2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 156, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate exist as functions in the graph domain.", + "body": "cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate exist as functions in the graph domain.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 157, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: partial selections (user hasn't chosen on some axes yet) are interaction state, not model cardinality; the solver o…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: partial selections (user hasn't chosen on some axes yet) are interaction state, not model cardinality; the solver operates on total configurations while the UI allows incremental selection.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 158, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "VCR-style tests require maintaining recorded snapshots and re-recording when prompts change.", + "body": "VCR-style tests require maintaining recorded snapshots and re-recording when prompts change.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 159, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The test suite must include property tests for at least: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monoton…", + "body": "The test suite must include property tests for at least: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monotonicity over repeated mark/unmark, (c) the equality solver.backbone(model) == intersection-of-solver.enumerateConfigurations(model).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R43]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 160, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 must state nudge_after_n default = 1, matching the implementation and X42.", + "body": "PLAN.md's resolved design question #10 must state nudge_after_n default = 1, matching the implementation and X42.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R50]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 161, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Unit tests of determineRewindPhase must verify: (a) when the agent supplies suggestedRewindPhase strictly upstream of currentPhase, it is h…", + "body": "Unit tests of determineRewindPhase must verify: (a) when the agent supplies suggestedRewindPhase strictly upstream of currentPhase, it is honored (e.g., currentPhase=defining-done + hint=grounding rewinds to grounding); (b) when the hint is absent, it falls back to one phase down; (c) when the hint equals or is downstream of currentPhase, the hint is rejected and the function falls back to one phase down; (d) invalid phase strings are rejected.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 162, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "engine/reconciliation.ts already has the structural plumbing for the 'recurse' outcome (an empty spawnedImpasseIds: NodeId[] array, an outc…", + "body": "engine/reconciliation.ts already has the structural plumbing for the 'recurse' outcome (an empty spawnedImpasseIds: NodeId[] array, an outcomeTag branch, and a return shape with spawnedImpasseIds + suggestedRewindPhase) and engine/derivation-loop.ts already has a case \"recurse\" handler that calls runDerivationLoop with outcome.spawnedImpasseIds; only the population of spawnedImpasseIds is missing.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X63]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 163, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Wiring cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate is a blocking prerequisite: the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it.", + "body": "Wiring cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate is a blocking prerequisite: the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 164, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P29: Resolved design question #10 in PLAN.md states nudge_after_n default is 2, but the M8 checklist and derivation loop both use 1; the de…", + "body": "P29: Resolved design question #10 in PLAN.md states nudge_after_n default is 2, but the M8 checklist and derivation loop both use 1; the design question should be updated.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 165, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "FanInExtractionResult is currently defined in src/agents/fan-in.ts and re-exported from src/engine/derivation-agents.ts; it is referenced i…", + "body": "FanInExtractionResult is currently defined in src/agents/fan-in.ts and re-exported from src/engine/derivation-agents.ts; it is referenced in src/engine/fan-in.ts.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 166, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspectives should be records (like DerivationRunRecord or FanInRecord), not hub nodes in the graph, because they…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspectives should be records (like DerivationRunRecord or FanInRecord), not hub nodes in the graph, because they carry no epistemic weight and nothing downstream derives support through them.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 167, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "engine/solver/dpll.ts must expose a public surface containing at least: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbo…", + "body": "engine/solver/dpll.ts must expose a public surface containing at least: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, and demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 168, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Every test in the unit, module, and property layers must be deterministic and must not make live LLM calls; only the single VCR E2E test ma…", + "body": "Every test in the unit, module, and property layers must be deterministic and must not make live LLM calls; only the single VCR E2E test may interact with OpenRouter, and only via recorded snapshots during normal test execution.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R45]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 169, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P7: selectPerspective computes hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements on SelectionOutcome, but clean-room-resolution.ts never read…", + "body": "P7: selectPerspective computes hasRepairSelections and hasRevisionRequirements on SelectionOutcome, but clean-room-resolution.ts never reads either field; repair selections and revision authorization flows are not implemented.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 170, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test of the clean-room prompt builder must verify that when FrameRecord.nudgingActive=true, the assembled prompt contains a negative…", + "body": "A unit test of the clean-room prompt builder must verify that when FrameRecord.nudgingActive=true, the assembled prompt contains a negative-constraint section listing the alternative selections from prior clean attempts in the same frame; when nudgingActive=false, no such section is present. Verified by string-presence assertions on assembled prompt.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 171, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: split fan-in into two stages — Stage 1 LLM extraction (canonical candidates, contradictions, candidate repairs, axe…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: split fan-in into two stages — Stage 1 LLM extraction (canonical candidates, contradictions, candidate repairs, axes, alternatives, constraints, impasses, witness relations); Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis (model validation, backbone computation, configuration enumeration, perspective generation).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 172, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Cross-spec references point to specific checkpoints; when a referenced checkpoi…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T12]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Cross-spec references point to specific checkpoints; when a referenced checkpoint has a successor, the reference becomes a suspect link for human review rather than silently rebound." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 173, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Frames have both parentFrameId (impasse call stack nesting) and baselineFrameId…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T3]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Frames have both parentFrameId (impasse call stack nesting) and baselineFrameId (reconciliation target); in cascading examples these point to different frames." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 174, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "After a user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine must perform the following steps in order: (1) mark the un-chosen…", + "body": "After a user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine must perform the following steps in order: (1) mark the un-chosen-side grounding nodes for the resolved contradiction as suspect; (2) call markSuspectAndPropagate from each; (3) run revisionImpact to compute the OUT set; (4) create a new child frame whose entryPhase is the earliest-affected phase among OUT nodes; (5) re-run the derivation loop in that frame.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 175, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The derivation loop cannot recurse or refine impasses; several reconciliation outcomes are wired in the type system but never produce effec…", + "body": "The derivation loop cannot recurse or refine impasses; several reconciliation outcomes are wired in the type system but never produce effects.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 176, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The resume flow must restart the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate; clean-room…", + "body": "The resume flow must restart the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate; clean-room re-derivations within that frame must start with a fresh Chat per T2.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R54]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 177, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A repo-wide grep/static analysis check must confirm that WorkingGraph.cowReplace and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate each have at leas…", + "body": "A repo-wide grep/static analysis check must confirm that WorkingGraph.cowReplace and WorkingGraph.markSuspectAndPropagate each have at least one caller outside their defining class (i.e., the methods are no longer orphaned).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 178, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test must verify that perspective summaries are persisted as plain records under graph/ (e.g., attached to FanInRecord/DerivationRun…", + "body": "A unit test must verify that perspective summaries are persisted as plain records under graph/ (e.g., attached to FanInRecord/DerivationRunRecord JSON), each carrying at minimum: id, configuration vector, default-bundle status flag, short label. The test must assert no Perspective hub appears in the graph nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 179, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "An integration test driving the engine through a forward pass plus one impasse cycle must subscribe to the Effect EventLog and assert that…", + "body": "An integration test driving the engine through a forward pass plus one impasse cycle must subscribe to the Effect EventLog and assert that at least one event of each of the following tags is observed in the expected order: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt, FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed, ReconcileOutcome, ImpasseSpawned, ImpasseResolved, UserInterventionRequested, UserInterventionResolved.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 180, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Impasse triage is currently a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) with a five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premis…", + "body": "Impasse triage is currently a deterministic classifier (no LLM call) with a five-step precedence chain: authority conflict > missing premise > term/ontology mismatch > upstream structural contradiction > endogenous design conflict (default).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 181, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Enrichment nodes must carry dual provenance: a workflow provenance edge (motivates) pointing at the impasse that prompted the inquiry, and…", + "body": "Enrichment nodes must carry dual provenance: a workflow provenance edge (motivates) pointing at the impasse that prompted the inquiry, and a separate evidential provenance edge to the direct exogenous source. Only the evidential provenance may be used to justify downstream derivation; workflow provenance must not propagate taint.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R60]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 182, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A schema/type-level test must verify that ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult does NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/must…", + "body": "A schema/type-level test must verify that ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult does NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated configurations, or scoped-impasse outputs; any attempt to read such a field from the schema must be a TypeScript compile error.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 183, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the nudge threshold k (nudgeAfterN) is dynamic and set to 1, meaning nudging begins after 1 clean attempt.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the nudge threshold k (nudgeAfterN) is dynamic and set to 1, meaning nudging begins after 1 clean attempt.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X42]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 184, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The 30-line DerivationAgents construction code must be extracted from cli/run.ts into a factory module (engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts…", + "body": "The 30-line DerivationAgents construction code must be extracted from cli/run.ts into a factory module (engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts or src/agents/factory.ts) parameterized by LanguageModel, so tests can inject scripted agents and the CLI can inject the OpenRouter-backed implementation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R48]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 185, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a blocking impasse is a first-class persistent graph node with semantic meaning as a recorded decision point.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a blocking impasse is a first-class persistent graph node with semantic meaning as a recorded decision point.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 186, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Agents must continue to emit semanticKey and support sets in their IR output; the graph assembler is responsible for assigning UUIDs and di…", + "body": "Agents must continue to emit semanticKey and support sets in their IR output; the graph assembler is responsible for assigning UUIDs and display IDs and creating edges. Agents must not produce UUIDs or display IDs for nodes they are creating in the same batch.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R70]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 187, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question: how many representative perspective configurations to show (k) and how to handle configuration clustering for M_current vs M…", + "body": "Open question: how many representative perspective configurations to show (k) and how to handle configuration clustering for M_current vs M_preview.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-assumed [RK17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 188, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P20: The fan-out conditional label policy (makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts) is untested; it is pure logic with no LLM dependency.", + "body": "P20: The fan-out conditional label policy (makeCleanRoomPolicy in fan-out.ts) is untested; it is pure logic with no LLM dependency.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 189, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "After resolution, the BlockingImpasse node must remain in the graph with status: resolved (not deleted) and must participate in JTMS proven…", + "body": "After resolution, the BlockingImpasse node must remain in the graph with status: resolved (not deleted) and must participate in JTMS provenance chains as a recorded decision point.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 190, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives…", + "body": "Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId reference (support sets, conditions, lineageFrom prior, conflictingInputs, alternatives, selected, rejected, consequences, premises, conclusions, etc.) must be typed via NodeIdFromDisplayId in the agent output schemas instead of plain string.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 191, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test of the fan-in aggregation must verify that three-valued aggregation reads stance from the structured perRunStance field (values…", + "body": "A unit test of the fan-in aggregation must verify that three-valued aggregation reads stance from the structured perRunStance field (values exactly 'supports'|'contradicts'|'silent') and not by parsing prose. Negative test: a fixture in which a run is silent on alternative A1 (no perRunStance entry) but supports A2 on the same axis must NOT aggregate as 'contradicts' for A1.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 192, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: FanInExtractionResult is to be deleted and replaced entirely with a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema,…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: FanInExtractionResult is to be deleted and replaced entirely with a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema, with no backward compatibility.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 193, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Session state persistence for the resume command is an open question; the stakeholder expressed preference for no mutable-state checkpoint…", + "body": "Session state persistence for the resume command is an open question; the stakeholder expressed preference for no mutable-state checkpoint dumps and may prefer restarting over complex resumability.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 194, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "validateModel must reject configuration models in which any axis contains alternatives at mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'conf…", + "body": "validateModel must reject configuration models in which any axis contains alternatives at mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'configurable'); such models must be flagged for manual repair rather than silently accepted.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 195, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test must construct a perRunStance fixture in which run R1 supports alternative A1 on axis X and is silent on alternative A2 on the…", + "body": "A unit test must construct a perRunStance fixture in which run R1 supports alternative A1 on axis X and is silent on alternative A2 on the same axis X, and assert that the aggregation accepts and preserves this distinction (no implicit 'all alternatives on the axis share the run's stance').", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 196, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question: for v1, consider disabling auto-resolution of repair precedence and surfacing all contradictions as repair axes to preserve…", + "body": "Open question: for v1, consider disabling auto-resolution of repair precedence and surfacing all contradictions as repair axes to preserve correctness at the cost of more user decisions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-assumed [RK18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 197, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Elicitation is interactive by default because the user is the oracle; authority conflicts, unjustified omissions, impasse escalation, and b…", + "body": "Elicitation is interactive by default because the user is the oracle; authority conflicts, unjustified omissions, impasse escalation, and bail decisions cannot be automated.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 198, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The spec elicitation prototype is an AI-assisted system that transforms raw source documents into structured, typed specification graphs th…", + "body": "The spec elicitation prototype is an AI-assisted system that transforms raw source documents into structured, typed specification graphs through a multi-phase derivation pipeline.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [G1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 199, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Hub nodes (Justification, Decision, Impasse) make joint causation explicit; the…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T8]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Hub nodes (Justification, Decision, Impasse) make joint causation explicit; they carry content and connect 1..n incoming edges to 0..n outgoing edges. Decision and Impasse are subtypes of Justification with their own subtype-specific edge roles." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 200, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: genuine impasses must be extracted before the configuration space is computed, to prevent 'some runs picked sides'…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: genuine impasses must be extracted before the configuration space is computed, to prevent 'some runs picked sides' from hiding a real impasse.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X44]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 201, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Perspective must not appear in the graph's hub-kind union; the hub-kind union remains exactly {Justification, Decision, Impasse} from T8.", + "body": "Perspective must not appear in the graph's hub-kind union; the hub-kind union remains exactly {Justification, Decision, Impasse} from T8. Existing edges that pointed to a Perspective hub must be removed, and any persisted graph artifacts containing Perspective hubs must be migrated or rejected.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 202, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: all alternatives on a single axis must be at the same abstraction level; axes with mixed abstraction levels (e.g.,…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: all alternatives on a single axis must be at the same abstraction level; axes with mixed abstraction levels (e.g., '2s', '5s', 'configurable') are rejected by validateModel and escalated for manual repair.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X46]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 203, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Stage 1 ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated co…", + "body": "The Stage 1 ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult schema must NOT contain fields representing backbone, mustSelect/mustDeselect, enumerated configurations, or scoped impasses. The schema must structurally forbid the LLM from producing solver outputs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 204, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The solver already implements backbone computation (mustSelect/mustDeselect) as a deterministic function over the configuration model.", + "body": "The solver already implements backbone computation (mustSelect/mustDeselect) as a deterministic function over the configuration model.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 205, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The forward pass must remain working throughout the code health improvements.", + "body": "The forward pass must remain working throughout the code health improvements.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [C1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 206, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: if M_current is empty, the system is in a dead-end state and must emit a global blocking impasse rather than inferr…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: if M_current is empty, the system is in a dead-end state and must emit a global blocking impasse rather than inferring substrate from vacuous truth.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X48]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 207, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "An axis is an independent dimension of variability discovered by fan-in; it has…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T15]", + "detail": { + "definition": "An axis is an independent dimension of variability discovered by fan-in; it has an id, type (design or repair), cardinality (exactly_one or zero_or_one), and label." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 208, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each of the five staged increments (A correctness wiring, B reference integrity, C observability, D feature-model redesign, E test + hygien…", + "body": "Each of the five staged increments (A correctness wiring, B reference integrity, C observability, D feature-model redesign, E test + hygiene) must be independently mergeable while keeping the forward pass functional and the existing smoke-test artifacts validating.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R55]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 209, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test must verify the solver module at engine/solver/dpll.ts exports public functions: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(…", + "body": "A unit test must verify the solver module at engine/solver/dpll.ts exports public functions: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, and demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}. Calling each with fixture inputs returns the documented shape.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 210, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test must verify that NodeIdFromDisplayId: (a) decodes a valid display ID against a live WorkingGraph to the corresponding NodeId, (…", + "body": "A unit test must verify that NodeIdFromDisplayId: (a) decodes a valid display ID against a live WorkingGraph to the corresponding NodeId, (b) fails decode with a structured error when the display ID does not exist in the graph, (c) round-trips encode/decode for valid IDs (property test).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 211, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "'Silent' stance means a run neither supports nor contradicts a specific alterna…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T19]", + "detail": { + "definition": "'Silent' stance means a run neither supports nor contradicts a specific alternative; it is a distinct value from 'supports' and 'contradicts'." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 212, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation cannot archive a node without justification; if upstream grounding still supports a node and there's…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation cannot archive a node without justification; if upstream grounding still supports a node and there's no contradiction, mere omission by re-derivation is insufficient reason to archive.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X54]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 213, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A type-level test must verify that the graph's hub-kind union type is exactly {Justification | Decision | Impasse} and does not include Per…", + "body": "A type-level test must verify that the graph's hub-kind union type is exactly {Justification | Decision | Impasse} and does not include Perspective; an attempt to pattern-match Perspective as a hub kind must fail the TypeScript compiler.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 214, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The core architecture is sound; problems concentrate in three areas: incomplete wiring in the derivation loop, silent data loss when agents…", + "body": "The core architecture is sound; problems concentrate in three areas: incomplete wiring in the derivation loop, silent data loss when agents produce invalid references, and missing test coverage for pure-logic components.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 215, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Open question: should a lightweight existing SAT library or a custom DPLL implementation be used for the solver?", + "body": "Open question: should a lightweight existing SAT library or a custom DPLL implementation be used for the solver? Expected scale (5–20 axes, 2–5 alternatives) is small enough for either.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-assumed [RK16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 216, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P17: revisionImpact in solver.ts is implemented but never called outside tests; combined with empty justifications, the entire revision imp…", + "body": "P17: revisionImpact in solver.ts is implemented but never called outside tests; combined with empty justifications, the entire revision impact subsystem is effectively dead.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 217, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Perspective summaries must be persisted as plain records attached to FanInRecord (or a sibling DerivationRunRecord) under graph/, each carr…", + "body": "Perspective summaries must be persisted as plain records attached to FanInRecord (or a sibling DerivationRunRecord) under graph/, each carrying at minimum: an id, the configuration vector, a default-bundle status flag (display only), and a short label.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 218, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The derivation loop (which handles impasses, backward transitions, fan-out, and reconciliation) is partially implemented with significant c…", + "body": "The derivation loop (which handles impasses, backward transitions, fan-out, and reconciliation) is partially implemented with significant correctness gaps.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 219, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Readiness must be evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection; the perspective summary's default-bundle status flag must be display…", + "body": "Readiness must be evaluated per selected bundle via evaluateSelection; the perspective summary's default-bundle status flag must be display-only and must not be used as a readiness gate.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 220, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A type-level test must verify that the axis 'type' field accepts only 'design' or 'repair'; constructing an axis with type='revision' must…", + "body": "A type-level test must verify that the axis 'type' field accepts only 'design' or 'repair'; constructing an axis with type='revision' must fail schema decode.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 221, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The extraction step between raw sources and grounding nodes serves a correctnes…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T5]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The extraction step between raw sources and grounding nodes serves a correctness purpose: 'grounding still supports this node' (checked during reconciliation) requires claim-level support, not file-level presence." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 222, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Stage 1 fan-in must extract genuine impasses before any configuration space (M_current/M_preview/M_revision) is computed by Stage 2, ensuri…", + "body": "Stage 1 fan-in must extract genuine impasses before any configuration space (M_current/M_preview/M_revision) is computed by Stage 2, ensuring that 'some runs picked a side' on a contradiction cannot mask a real impasse.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 223, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: after repair selection, taint propagation uses markSuspectAndPropagate, and all OUT nodes are re-derived in place v…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: after repair selection, taint propagation uses markSuspectAndPropagate, and all OUT nodes are re-derived in place via cowReplace by re-running the relevant phase agents.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 224, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or Routine abstractions.", + "body": "No changes may be made to the Effect AI or Routine abstractions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [C3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 225, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: re-derivation after repair should enter a new frame and rerun the complete downstream starting from the earliest af…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: re-derivation after repair should enter a new frame and rerun the complete downstream starting from the earliest affected phase, then reconcile with existing content.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 226, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "Fan-out produces N independent derivations of the same phase; when they disagree, the current system creates impasse nodes, which causes an…", + "body": "Fan-out produces N independent derivations of the same phase; when they disagree, the current system creates impasse nodes, which causes an infinite loop because re-derivation cannot resolve inherent design-space disagreements.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 227, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence must be disabled by default in v1 via a config.repairAutoResolve flag defaulting to false;…", + "body": "Solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence must be disabled by default in v1 via a config.repairAutoResolve flag defaulting to false; every detected contradiction must surface as a repair axis to the user regardless of evidence asymmetry. The auto-resolution code path must be feature-flagged rather than removed.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 228, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "No integration test exercises the full triage-to-resolution pipeline.", + "body": "No integration test exercises the full triage-to-resolution pipeline.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 229, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Supporting parallel/concurrent spec design sessions is deferred because each spec design can take 20 minutes to an hour and internal state…", + "body": "Supporting parallel/concurrent spec design sessions is deferred because each spec design can take 20 minutes to an hour and internal state is not centralized, making concurrency incompatible with the current architecture.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 230, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The 40-line formatHandoffReport function must be extracted from cli/run.ts into cli/format-handoff-report.ts as a pure function (HandoffRep…", + "body": "The 40-line formatHandoffReport function must be extracted from cli/run.ts into cli/format-handoff-report.ts as a pure function (HandoffReport → string) with snapshot-based unit tests.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R47]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 231, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When the solver determines M_current is empty or unsatisfiable, the engine must create a first-class Impasse hub node (kind: 'unsatisfiable…", + "body": "When the solver determines M_current is empty or unsatisfiable, the engine must create a first-class Impasse hub node (kind: 'unsatisfiable_configuration_space') in the graph with status: open and support edges to all hard-constraint nodes participating in the UNSAT core; the engine must NOT infer substrate from vacuous truth.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 232, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The tech stack is: Deno runtime, Effect v4 (beta 57), Effect CLI, Effect AI, @kael/ai (Fragment, Routine), @kael/core/platform, and @effect…", + "body": "The tech stack is: Deno runtime, Effect v4 (beta 57), Effect CLI, Effect AI, @kael/ai (Fragment, Routine), @kael/core/platform, and @effect/platform-node-shared. All agents use the LanguageModel abstraction; the concrete provider is OpenRouter wired at the CLI entry point.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 233, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The system must not write mid-derivation checkpoint dumps (no serialization of WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat at each reconcilia…", + "body": "The system must not write mid-derivation checkpoint dumps (no serialization of WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat at each reconciliation step). The only checkpointable state is a completed checkpoint produced when a full revision completes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R53]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 234, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Spec nodes are organized across three orthogonal axes: semantic role (goal, ter…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T7]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Spec nodes are organized across three orthogonal axes: semantic role (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk), epistemic status (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred), and authority (stakeholder, technical, external, derived)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 235, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Perspectives are currently modeled as hub nodes alongside justifications, decisions, and impasses, but carry no epistemic weight and should…", + "body": "Perspectives are currently modeled as hub nodes alongside justifications, decisions, and impasses, but carry no epistemic weight and should be records instead.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | external-observed [RK4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 236, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The current impasse-based model for cross-run divergence uses the wrong mental model: it asks the user to resolve individual point-conflict…", + "body": "The current impasse-based model for cross-run divergence uses the wrong mental model: it asks the user to resolve individual point-conflicts when the real question is which overall design vision they want.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [E33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 237, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Cross-run divergence has three distinct categories: genuine impasse (source pol…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [T13]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Cross-run divergence has three distinct categories: genuine impasse (source policy conflict), design perspective (both grounded and coherent alternatives), and derivation noise (hallucinated without grounding basis)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 238, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a subagent is invoked for conflict resolution only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure — e.g., when prov…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a subagent is invoked for conflict resolution only when the graph lacks sufficient edge structure — e.g., when provenance edges are missing or the contradiction is semantic rather than structural.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X56]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 239, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: replace Console.log calls throughout the engine with either Effect's structured logging (Effect.logInfo/Effect.logD…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: replace Console.log calls throughout the engine with either Effect's structured logging (Effect.logInfo/Effect.logDebug) or a typed event bus with structured per-operation events, so the CLI becomes one consumer among many.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 240, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "A code health review of the spec elicitation prototype uncovered 34 issues across correctness, design, testing, and systemic architecture.", + "body": "A code health review of the spec elicitation prototype uncovered 34 issues across correctness, design, testing, and systemic architecture.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 241, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "assembler.ts must not silently drop or filter out unresolved displayId references; the post-hoc resolve-and-filter step (.filter(nodeId !==…", + "body": "assembler.ts must not silently drop or filter out unresolved displayId references; the post-hoc resolve-and-filter step (.filter(nodeId !== undefined) and non-blocking error logging) must be removed in favor of schema-level decode failures that surface as Effect AI tool result errors.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 242, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A unit test of Stage 1 extraction must verify that hard constraints are emitted only with witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency,…", + "body": "A unit test of Stage 1 extraction must verify that hard constraints are emitted only with witnessedBy ∈ {source_contradiction, dependency, grounded_rationale} and a citation; negative test: a fixture exhibiting non-cooccurrence of alternatives across 5 fan-out runs without any witnessing rationale must NOT produce a hard constraint.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 243, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P23: domain/invariants.ts has support-edge acyclicity detection and phase stratification checks, but these are not tested with violating gr…", + "body": "P23: domain/invariants.ts has support-edge acyclicity detection and phase stratification checks, but these are not tested with violating graphs; validate() is not called in any test file.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 244, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) must consume engine events as a subscriber to the EventLog rather than receiving them via Console.lo…", + "body": "The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) must consume engine events as a subscriber to the EventLog rather than receiving them via Console.log; the CLI must continue to render human-readable output equivalent to the prior Console.log output for each event variant it cares about.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 245, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the LLM extraction stage must NOT compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses; those are determin…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the LLM extraction stage must NOT compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses; those are deterministic solver operations.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [X49]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 246, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The system is implemented as a standalone CLI prototype in packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/, containing src/, spec/, PLAN.md, and PR…", + "body": "The system is implemented as a standalone CLI prototype in packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/, containing src/, spec/, PLAN.md, and PROBLEMS.md.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 247, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "revisionImpact must mark a derived node as OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect, match…", + "body": "revisionImpact must mark a derived node as OUT (tainted) when all of its justifications have at least one IN premise that is suspect, matching the JTMS-style propagation rule.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 248, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the EventLog should emit events beyond simple Console.log replacements for notable occurrences; finer granularity i…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the EventLog should emit events beyond simple Console.log replacements for notable occurrences; finer granularity is better but not every tiny detail needs an event.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 249, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The backbone function must return, for every axis whose value is forced, the set of constraint clauses (blockingClauses) that ruled out the…", + "body": "The backbone function must return, for every axis whose value is forced, the set of constraint clauses (blockingClauses) that ruled out the alternatives that were not forced, so the user can see which constraints made the other values impossible.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 250, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspective selection by the user is not new evidence; design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repa…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspective selection by the user is not new evidence; design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repair selection is non-monotone with respect to premises (downstream phases must be recomputed), and revision authorization requires the revision flow.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 251, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The resolution strategy must be maximally correct and must not take shortcuts.", + "body": "The resolution strategy must be maximally correct and must not take shortcuts.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 252, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P25: render/markdown.ts (329 lines) has no tests; a snapshot test with a known artifact would catch rendering regressions.", + "body": "P25: render/markdown.ts (329 lines) has no tests; a snapshot test with a known artifact would catch rendering regressions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 253, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P18: No end-to-end smoke test with an impasse scenario exists; DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver are injectable services so a determi…", + "body": "P18: No end-to-end smoke test with an impasse scenario exists; DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver are injectable services so a deterministic integration test is possible.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 254, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "P6: All baseline effects in fan-in.ts are hardcoded to commitmentLevel: \"locked\" and requiresAuthorization: true, without checking whether…", + "body": "P6: All baseline effects in fan-in.ts are hardcoded to commitmentLevel: \"locked\" and requiresAuthorization: true, without checking whether the baseline node is actually locked or provisional.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 255, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use a four-layer pyramid: unit + module (scripted) + property + one VCR E2E.", + "body": "Use a four-layer pyramid: unit + module (scripted) + property + one VCR E2E.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC19]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Test strategy is a four-layer pyramid: (1) Unit tests for pure logic — buildConfigModel (P21), assembler.ts (P19), makeCleanRoomPolicy (P20), perspective-selection.ts (P24), invariants.ts validate() including violating graphs (P23), solver primitives (validate/enumerate/backbone/demote), markdown render (P25), WorkingGraph artifact roundtrip (P22). (2) Module tests with scripted DerivationAgents and InterventionDriver (already injectable per E18) for derivation-loop, reconciliation, fan-in stage 2, and the repair re-derivation flow. (3) Property tests for: (a) NodeIdFromDisplayId schema decode round-trips, (b) JTMS revisionImpact monotonicity over repeated mark/unmark, (c) solver backbone equals intersection of enumerate(). (4) One end-to-end smoke test (P18) using VCR-recorded OpenRouter interactions covering all three impasse types in sequence (X61). The 1702-line m4-engine.test.ts (P26) is split per module into test files colocated with the modules they cover.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: invest only in unit tests for P19–P25 and skip the VCR E2E because of the maintenance burden of recorded snapshots (RK14).", + "Alternative: invest only in the end-to-end VCR test (X61) and rely on it to indirectly cover assembler/solver/etc., skipping per-module unit tests." + ], + "rationale": "X62 puts tests P18–P25 ahead of correctness fixes — a test bar this high cannot rest on either alt-test-only-e2e (which leaves pure-logic regressions like P19–P25 invisible until the slow E2E catches them) or alt-test-only-units (RK6 is unaddressed; nothing exercises triage-to-resolution). C2 (deterministic, no LLM calls) is satisfied by layers 1–3 because they use scripted DerivationAgents (E18 confirms this is possible). The single VCR test bounds the maintenance cost flagged by RK14: re-record only when prompts change, and only one recording to maintain. Property tests are added for the components most likely to silently regress (schema decode, JTMS, backbone) where example-based unit tests provide weak assurance." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 256, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Extract format-handoff-report and derivation-agents-factory into separate modules.", + "body": "Extract format-handoff-report and derivation-agents-factory into separate modules.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC20]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Extract from cli/run.ts: (a) cli/format-handoff-report.ts containing the 40-line formatHandoffReport function as a pure function over HandoffReport → string, unit-tested with snapshot fixtures; (b) engine/derivation-agents-factory.ts (or src/agents/factory.ts) containing the 30-line DerivationAgents construction wiring, parameterized by LanguageModel so tests inject scripted agents and the CLI injects the OpenRouter-backed one. cli/run.ts becomes a thin orchestrator that imports both.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: leave the inlined helpers in cli/run.ts; the prototype is small enough that the extra module hop isn't worth the indirection." + ], + "rationale": "Both helpers are referenced by the test pyramid (formatHandoffReport needs snapshot tests against fixture HandoffReports; the factory is needed by every module test that wants real-shaped agents). alt-cli-keep-inline forces tests to either duplicate the construction logic or import from cli/run.ts (which pulls in CLI side-effects). E18 already established that scripted-agent injection is the testing strategy; the factory extraction is a precondition." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 257, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Wire nudging as negative-constraint prompt injection, gated on nudgingActive.", + "body": "Wire nudging as negative-constraint prompt injection, gated on nudgingActive.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC6]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the clean-room agent prompt builder (clean-room.ts) injects a negative-constraint section listing the alternative selections from prior clean attempts in the same frame ('avoid these previously explored choices: …'). nudgingActive itself remains a frame-level flag set by the derivation loop after nudgeAfterN clean attempts; the new behavior is that fan-out reads the flag and the prior frame's reconciled outcomes when assembling the prompt for the next clean attempt.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: instead of injecting negative constraints, react to nudgingActive by raising sampling temperature on the LanguageModel call to encourage divergence.", + "Alternative: remove nudgingActive and nudgeAfterN entirely; rely on natural variance across N parallel clean-room runs to surface alternatives." + ], + "rationale": "T2 says 'retry feedback is schema-only', which forbids feeding the prior run's freeform output back; negative-constraint prompt injection is structurally compatible because it cites only stable schema-level alternatives that already exist in the graph. alt-nudging-temperature is opaque to the spec model — there's no way to express 'try harder' as a graph-level fact. alt-nudging-remove discards the existing FrameRecord field already plumbed through the loop (E14) and gives up the only existing mechanism for addressing repeat-output across attempts." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 258, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Adopt the six work-stream decomposition as the spec scope.", + "body": "Adopt the six work-stream decomposition as the spec scope.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC1]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Decompose the code-health work into six work-streams driven by the grounding: (1) Derivation-loop correctness (P1, P2, P10/P32, P11, P34, C6); (2) Reference-integrity via schema-level NodeIdFromDisplayId (P30); (3) Engine-decoupled observability via Effect EventLog (RK5, X14); (4) Feature-model / SAT replacement of the impasse-centric divergence model (E32, E33, X16–X25, X32–X37, X44–X50); (5) Pure-logic test coverage and an end-to-end VCR integration test (P18–P25, X61); (6) Hygiene / refactor / doc fixes (P26, P27, P28, P29, P6).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: scope only to the open correctness items (P1, P2, P10/P32, P30) and explicitly defer the SAT/feature-model redesign and the EventLog migration.", + "Alternative: treat the work as a single big-bang rewrite — re-architect divergence handling, replace logging, redo references, and add tests in one merged change." + ], + "rationale": "X62 gives an explicit ordering (tests > correctness > design > rest) but also confirms all of these are in scope; the stakeholder design notes (X16–X60) explicitly call for the SAT/feature-model redesign and the EventLog migration as part of code-health, not as a separate spec. A correctness-only scope (alt-scope-correctness-only) would leave the dead code in the divergence model (P7, P8, P13, P17) un-addressed and contradict the stakeholder direction. A big-bang rewrite (alt-scope-bigbang) violates C1 (forward pass must keep working) and C4 (smoke-test artifacts must keep validating) because it would require simultaneous schema changes (X23) and behavioral changes. Six independent work-streams allow staged landing under C1/C4." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 259, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Build a custom DPLL with explanation instrumentation; reject off-the-shelf SAT and brute-force enumeration.", + "body": "Build a custom DPLL with explanation instrumentation; reject off-the-shelf SAT and brute-force enumeration.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC13]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Implement the SAT solver as a small custom DPLL in TypeScript at src/engine/solver/dpll.ts (~200–400 LOC) with: unit propagation, pure-literal elimination, chronological backtracking, and an instrumentation hook that records, for each backtrack, which clauses caused the conflict. Public surface: validateModel(model), enumerateConfigurations(model, limit), backbone(model) returning per-axis {forcedValue, blockingClauses[]}, demotionCandidates(model) returning per-constraint {wouldSatisfy: boolean}. The solver imports nothing outside std and Effect.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: skip SAT entirely; for the stated scale of 5–20 axes × 2–5 alternatives, enumerate all assignments and filter by constraint formulas, computing backbone by intersection.", + "Alternative: depend on an existing SAT library (e.g., a JS port of MiniSat or logic-solver). Use its model enumeration and (where available) its proof/explanation API." + ], + "rationale": "X59 and X60 both require constraint-attribution explanations on backbone, which most off-the-shelf SAT libraries do not expose without a UNSAT-core extension we'd have to bolt on anyway (RK13). RK13 also flags Deno compatibility risk for off-the-shelf libraries. alt-brute-force-enumeration is correct for tiny inputs but X32 (demotion candidates: 'identifying which demotions would make it solvable') is most naturally expressed as 'try the formula minus this clause and re-solve' — trivial in DPLL, awkward as 'enumerate again with one fewer filter and re-intersect'. The custom DPLL also gives full control over the blockingClauses field that X59 explicitly asks for." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 260, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Compute baseline effects from real graph state, not from a hardcoded constant.", + "body": "Compute baseline effects from real graph state, not from a hardcoded constant.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC5]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "buildBaselineEffects in fan-in.ts reads the actual baseline node's commitment level (locked vs. provisional) from the graph and sets requiresAuthorization accordingly; locked baseline nodes produce {commitmentLevel: 'locked', requiresAuthorization: true}, provisional baseline nodes produce {commitmentLevel: 'provisional', requiresAuthorization: false}. The function takes the WorkingGraph plus the baselineFrameId / baseline node id set, not just the FanIn extraction result.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: leave baseline effects hardcoded to {locked, requiresAuthorization: true} and document this as a v1 simplification." + ], + "rationale": "X18 explicitly defines baseline effects as a distinct layer of the model: 'per-alternative authorization requirements'. With them hardcoded to locked/true, every fan-in run pretends the baseline is locked even when it is provisional, which makes the M_revision flow always demand revision authorization for changes to provisional content — directly contradicting X20's three-space semantics. C7 (no shortcuts) rules out alt-baseline-keep-hardcoded." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 261, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Honor the agent hint with strict upstream-only validation; otherwise default to one phase down.", + "body": "Honor the agent hint with strict upstream-only validation; otherwise default to one phase down.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC3]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "determineRewindPhase becomes a function determineRewindPhase(currentPhase, suggestedRewindPhase?) that prefers the agent's suggestedRewindPhase when present and strictly upstream of currentPhase, validating against the four-phase order (grounding < shaping < pinning < defining-done from X1) and falling back to 'one phase down' only when the hint is absent or invalid. It is plumbed through reconciliation.ts to where the recurse outcome is constructed.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: blindly trust the agent-supplied suggestedRewindPhase whenever set, with no acyclicity validation against currentPhase.", + "Alternative: keep determineRewindPhase as 'always one phase down' and instead remove suggestedRewindPhase from the agent schema as unused." + ], + "rationale": "X1 mandates strict derivational order; alt-rewind-trust-agent could let the agent push the loop forward or sideways, violating the support-edge acyclicity invariant in domain/invariants.ts. alt-rewind-always-one-down is what the code does today and is what P11/RK1 explicitly call broken — it discards information the agent already paid LLM tokens to compute (e.g., a missing-premise impasse that needs to rewind all the way to grounding, not just to the immediately previous phase). The validation guard makes the new behavior safe under C1 (forward pass keeps working when the hint is absent or stale)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 262, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Delete FanInExtractionResult and introduce a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult type.", + "body": "Delete FanInExtractionResult and introduce a new ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult type.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC12]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Define ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult in src/domain/configuration.ts with first-class fields: axes: ReadonlyArray<{id, type: 'design'|'repair', cardinality: 'exactly_one'|'zero_or_one', label}>; alternatives: ReadonlyArray<{id, axisId, label}>; perRunStance: ReadonlyArray<{runId, axisId, alternativeId, stance: 'supports'|'contradicts'|'silent', rationale?}>; witnesses: ReadonlyArray<{runId, claimId, sourceSpan}>; candidateRepairs: ReadonlyArray<{contradictionId, alternativeIds, evidenceStrength}>; impasses: ReadonlyArray<{kind: 'authority_conflict'|'missing_premise'|..., conflictingNodes}>; hardConstraints: ReadonlyArray<{formula, witnessedBy: 'source_contradiction'|'dependency'|'grounded_rationale', citation}>. The previously-used FanInExtractionResult is deleted with no backward-compat shim.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: extend FanInExtractionResult with the new fields (axes, perRunStance, candidateRepairs) and keep the type name and existing import sites, providing a soft migration." + ], + "rationale": "X23 explicitly mandates 'delete with no backward compatibility'. The legacy type embeds the assumption that extraction produces hub-shaped records (P7: 'hasRepairSelections', 'hasRevisionRequirements' fields on SelectionOutcome), so an extension (alt-config-extend-fanin-schema) carries dead-load that would invite reuse of the old code path. C7 (no shortcuts) and the X16 redesign direction support the clean replacement; this is a prototype (G1, X4) so backward compatibility has no external consumers to protect." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 263, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Implement resume that re-enters the topmost open frame from the on-disk artifact; do not checkpoint mid-step.", + "body": "Implement resume that re-enters the topmost open frame from the on-disk artifact; do not checkpoint mid-step.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC22]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "For M5 resume/polish, do not implement mid-derivation checkpointing. The only checkpointable state is a completed checkpoint (T11: 'immutable snapshot when a full revision completes'); resume from anywhere else restarts the in-flight frame from its entry phase using the artifact-on-disk graph as the resume substrate. The CLI gains a `resume ` command that loads the latest WorkingGraph artifact, identifies the topmost open frame and earliest open impasse, and re-enters the derivation loop with that frame as parent.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: implement mid-derivation checkpoints — serialize WorkingGraph + frame stack + current chat after every reconciliation step, allowing exact resume mid-step.", + "Alternative: drop M5 resume entirely; require restarting from scratch on any failure." + ], + "rationale": "RK7 records the stakeholder preference for no mutable-state checkpoint dumps. T2 requires clean-room re-derivation to start with a fresh Chat anyway, so 'resuming a chat in progress' is meaningless inside a frame. The on-disk graph is already the source of truth (X3: pure JSON file I/O, no DB); re-entering at frame boundaries is the largest unit at which resume is well-defined. alt-resume-checkpoint-dumps directly contradicts RK7. alt-resume-skip is heavier than necessary given a 20-min-to-1-hr session length (X4) where a process death without resume costs significant LLM-spend." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 264, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Repair selection triggers JTMS-driven re-derivation in a new child frame; design selection remains monotone.", + "body": "Repair selection triggers JTMS-driven re-derivation in a new child frame; design selection remains monotone.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC17]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "After the user makes a repair selection on a Perspective record, the engine: (1) marks the un-chosen-side grounding nodes for the resolved contradiction as suspect, (2) calls markSuspectAndPropagate from each, (3) runs revisionImpact to compute the OUT set, (4) creates a new child frame whose entryPhase is the earliest-affected phase of any OUT node, (5) re-runs the derivation loop in that frame; reconciliation then merges the re-derived content with the existing graph by archiving OUT nodes (with supersededBy edges per X40) when their replacements are accepted.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: treat repair selection identically to design selection — monotone, no re-derivation — simplifying perspective-selection.ts at the cost of leaving downstream content derived from the un-chosen contradiction side intact." + ], + "rationale": "X20 explicitly distinguishes: 'design selection is monotone (no re-derivation needed), repair selection is non-monotone with respect to premises'. X45 reinforces the categorical split. alt-repair-monotone-likedesign produces a graph where downstream phases reference grounding facts the user has just rejected — exactly the silent-contradiction problem that motivated the entire feature-model redesign (E33). The new-child-frame approach (X39) keeps the re-derivation auditable and reuses the existing reconciliation machinery rather than a new in-place rewrite path." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 265, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Adopt the two-stage split with a hard schema boundary forbidding solver outputs from Stage 1.", + "body": "Adopt the two-stage split with a hard schema boundary forbidding solver outputs from Stage 1.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC11]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Split fan-in into two distinct stages with separate file boundaries: Stage 1 LLM extraction (agents/fan-in.ts) emits a ConfigurationSpaceExtractionResult containing only canonical candidates, axes (with type + cardinality + label), alternatives, per-run stance (supports/contradicts/silent per run × axis × alternative), witness relations, candidate repairs, source-cited contradictions, and explicitly-witnessed hard constraints. Stage 2 deterministic solver analysis (engine/solver.ts + new engine/config-model.ts) consumes that result and computes: model validation, M_current/M_preview/M_revision spaces, backbone (mustSelect/mustDeselect with constraint-rule attribution), configuration enumeration, perspective generation. The Stage 1 schema explicitly disallows fields that would let the LLM pre-compute backbone, enumerate configurations, or scope impasses.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: extend the LLM extraction stage to also produce backbone and configuration enumeration so there is only one stage, eliminating the solver module.", + "Alternative: keep the existing single-stage FanInExtractionResult and patch it incrementally — add a structured stance field for P13, fix three-valued aggregation in-place, leave backbone and configuration enumeration where they are." + ], + "rationale": "X19 + X49 jointly mandate this split. The current single-stage design (alt-fanin-keep-single-stage) is what made E32's infinite-loop pathology possible: when the LLM 'decides' a contradiction it is computing backbone non-deterministically across runs, which is exactly the behavior X49 forbids. alt-fanin-llm-does-everything is incompatible with X49 and with C2 (deterministic tests) — backbone would no longer be a pure function of the extraction. The hard schema boundary (Stage 1 cannot return backbone fields) is what enforces the determinism property at compile time." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 266, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Adopt NodeIdFromDisplayId as a schema type with checkEffect-based decode against the live graph.", + "body": "Adopt NodeIdFromDisplayId as a schema type with checkEffect-based decode against the live graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC7]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Introduce a NodeIdFromDisplayId schema type built on Schema.transformOrFail / SchemaGetter.checkEffect that decodes a display ID string against the live WorkingGraph and either yields the resolved NodeId or fails the schema decode with a structured error. Every agent IR field that today carries a displayId references this schema instead of plain string. Schema decode failures bubble up as Effect AI tool result errors so the LLM sees them on the next turn and retries; assembler.ts's silent post-hoc resolve-and-filter step is removed.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: keep displayId as plain string in the schema, but turn the silent .filter(undefined) in assembler.ts into a hard error that aborts the derivation step; surface it back to the agent via the existing reconciler retry path.", + "Alternative: deprecate displayId references in agent output entirely; require agents to emit only semanticKey references for upstream support, and have the assembler resolve semantic keys (which exist deterministically per emit batch)." + ], + "rationale": "X12 directly mandates this approach. The schema-level placement means failures appear in the natural Effect AI retry loop (LLM sees a structured tool error and retries) rather than requiring a custom retry path on top of assembler errors (alt-nodeid-validation-after-assembly), which is a parallel mechanism that duplicates Effect AI's own behavior. alt-nodeid-semantic-key-only is too restrictive: agents legitimately need to reference pre-existing graph nodes by their stable display ID across phases (e.g., a shaping design that supports a grounding constraint by ID), and semantic keys are scoped to a single derivation batch (X10). The schema-level approach addresses RK2 and P30 in the place where the contract between LLM and engine actually lives." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 267, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Default repair auto-resolution off in v1; surface every contradiction as a repair axis.", + "body": "Default repair auto-resolution off in v1; surface every contradiction as a repair axis.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC18]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "For v1 of the new fan-in, disable solver-side auto-resolution of repair precedence (X43): every detected contradiction becomes a repair axis presented to the user, regardless of evidence asymmetry. Auto-resolution becomes a follow-up pass once the repair flow is exercised in tests. The auto-resolution code path is feature-flagged (config.repairAutoResolve = false by default) rather than removed, so X43's design intent is preserved.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: ship X43's auto-resolution heuristic on by default in v1." + ], + "rationale": "RK18 explicitly suggests this for v1, citing correctness over user load. C7 (maximally correct, no shortcuts) prefers conservative behavior when the heuristic 'one repair option is clearly better-evidenced' has not yet been validated against real fan-in data. alt-repair-autoresolve-on risks silent decisions during the period when the repair flow is also new, compounding error sources during integration testing." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 268, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Persist blocking impasses as first-class graph nodes participating in JTMS.", + "body": "Persist blocking impasses as first-class graph nodes participating in JTMS.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC15]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "When the solver returns M_current as empty or unsatisfiable, the engine creates a first-class BlockingImpasse Impasse node (kind: 'unsatisfiable_configuration_space') in the graph with: support edges to all hard-constraint nodes that participate in the UNSAT core, status: open. The engine then surfaces demotionCandidates to the user; the user's chosen demotion is recorded as a relaxed_to edge from the BlockingImpasse node to the demoted constraint node. The blocking impasse remains in the graph after resolution (status: resolved) so it participates in the JTMS chain as a recorded decision point.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: model the blocking impasse as a transient diagnostic (an entry on the FanInRecord, not a graph node); resolve it inline and never persist it." + ], + "rationale": "X33 + X35 explicitly mandate this. RK19's open question is resolved by X33 in this grounding; the answer is 'persistent graph node'. alt-blocking-impasse-transient breaks X34 (the user's demotion choice must be auditable as an edge from the impasse) and X35 (must participate in provenance/JTMS), neither of which work for a transient record. Persisting it also gives the user a stable referent if the same constraint conflict recurs across revisions." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 269, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Create a fresh refined Impasse node and emit a refined_to lineage edge from the original to the refined one; mark the original superseded a…", + "body": "Create a fresh refined Impasse node and emit a refined_to lineage edge from the original to the refined one; mark the original superseded and recurse with the refined node id in spawnedImpasseIds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC2]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "When the reconciler returns disposition: \"refined\" with a refinedImpasse payload, the reconciliation engine creates a new Impasse hub node in the graph (status: open), creates a refined_to lineage edge from the original impasse to the new one, marks the original as superseded, AND pushes the new node id onto spawnedImpasseIds so the recurse branch fires. This unifies P2's missing creation step with P1's missing population step.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: keep the original impasse as the live node and merely attach a refinedDescription field/edge to it instead of creating a new Impasse node, so refined_to is a self-annotation rather than a hub-to-hub edge.", + "Alternative: treat 'refined' as a terminal disposition that just marks the original impasse superseded without creating a successor; rely on the next pass through the loop to discover the residual problem fresh." + ], + "rationale": "X9 defines progress as 'incoming refined_to edges on unresolved impasses' — that progress signal only exists if refinement materializes a fresh node with an incoming refined_to edge, which alt-refined-as-edge-only does not produce. T9 distinguishes superseded as an impasse-status independent of lifecycle, which only makes sense if there is a successor to point at. alt-refined-as-resolved discards reconciler reasoning and forces re-discovery from scratch, contradicting C7 ('maximally correct, no shortcuts'). The chosen design also unifies cleanly with dec-recurse-wiring (single push site)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 270, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use a closed discriminated-union event catalog.", + "body": "Use a closed discriminated-union event catalog.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC9]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Define a closed event catalog as a discriminated union under src/engine/events.ts: PhaseEntered, PhaseCompleted, FanOutAttempt(runIndex), FanInStarted, FanInExtractionCompleted, ConfigSpaceComputed(modelStats), PerspectiveGenerated, ReconcileOutcome(_tag: accepted|retry|recurse|refined), ImpasseSpawned(impasseId, kind), ImpasseResolved(impasseId, disposition), NudgeActivated(frameId, attemptCount), CowReplace(oldNodeId, newNodeId), SuspectPropagated(rootId, count), BlockingImpasseRaised(scope), UserInterventionRequested(kind), UserInterventionResolved(kind, choice). Every Console.log call in the engine maps to exactly one of these. CLI rendering, the JSON event log artifact, and the future web inspector consume the same union.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: keep events open-ended (string tag + free-form payload) so adding a new event doesn't require touching the union." + ], + "rationale": "X15 says granularity should be 'notable occurrences' — a closed union enforces that bar at the type system level (you have to add a tag, which makes you ask 'is this notable?'). Open-ended events (alt-eventlog-freeform) regress to the current Console.log situation where every author chooses ad hoc strings, defeating the point of typed events for downstream consumers (M7 web inspector, E7)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 271, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Land doc fixes alongside the corresponding code changes.", + "body": "Land doc fixes alongside the corresponding code changes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC21]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Update PLAN.md in three places: (1) artifact layout section now lists graph/reconciliation-records.json (P28); (2) resolved design question #10 is updated to nudge_after_n default = 1, matching X42 and the implementation (P29, E36); (3) the post-redesign sections describing fan-in, perspectives, and impasses are rewritten to reflect the feature-model / SAT model (X16) and the deletion of FanInExtractionResult (X23).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: defer doc fixes to after the implementation lands; PLAN.md is internal and the discrepancies are minor." + ], + "rationale": "PLAN.md is referenced by the spec workflow (E6) and discrepancies between PLAN and code are exactly the class of error PROBLEMS.md tracks (P28, P29). Lettings docs drift (alt-doc-fix-defer) regenerates the same defect class. The change is minor enough to land per-PR with the corresponding code change." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 272, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Populate justifications and wire revisionImpact into the reconciliation engine.", + "body": "Populate justifications and wire revisionImpact into the reconciliation engine.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC16]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Populate the justifications field on derived nodes during assembly: assembler.ts, when creating a derived node, builds a justifications array with one entry per Justification/Decision/Impasse hub the node is connected to, recording {hubId, premiseIds: [...]}. solver.ts's revisionImpact function is called from the reconciliation engine whenever an upstream grounding node's review status flips to suspect, returning the closure of OUT (tainted) nodes per X28. The OUT closure is fed into the re-derivation flow (dec-cow-wiring).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: delete revisionImpact and the empty justifications field as dead code (P8/P17), formalize re-derivation as 'always re-run the affected phase clean' without belief revision." + ], + "rationale": "X28 + X29 + X38 specify JTMS-style propagation as the chosen mechanism for taint after repair selection. alt-jtms-remove-dead-code is feasible but conflicts with C7 (no shortcuts) and X40 (graph grows monotonically; superseded nodes retained with supersededBy edges) — retaining superseded nodes only makes sense if downstream consumers can distinguish IN from OUT, which is precisely what JTMS provides. The justifications + revisionImpact pair is already implemented and tested (E13, E17); the missing piece is connecting it." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 273, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Demote Perspective to a record; remove it from the hub-node kind union.", + "body": "Demote Perspective to a record; remove it from the hub-node kind union.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC10]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Demote Perspective from a hub-node kind in the graph to a plain record (struct) attached to the FanInRecord (or sibling DerivationRunRecord) artifact written under graph/. Edges that today point to a Perspective hub are removed; perspective summaries are referenced by id within the record store and rendered by the CLI/inspector. The graph schema's hub-kind union (T8: Justification, Decision, Impasse) is unchanged; perspective ceases to be one.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: keep Perspective as a hub node but mark it 'epistemically inert' so reconciliation never derives support through it." + ], + "rationale": "X11 is the explicit stakeholder preference. Hub nodes carry epistemic weight (T8: 'make joint causation explicit') — a hub that is by definition inert (alt-perspective-keep-hub) is a category error and a footgun for the reconciler, which would have to special-case 'this hub kind doesn't propagate support'. Records sit naturally next to FanInRecord and DerivationRunRecord (already in graph/), and the CLI already renders records via formatHandoffReport-shaped code (E27)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 274, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Wire cowReplace + markSuspectAndPropagate into the grounding-enrichment + intervention paths.", + "body": "Wire cowReplace + markSuspectAndPropagate into the grounding-enrichment + intervention paths.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC4]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Immediately after every cowReplace call, the engine calls markSuspectAndPropagate(oldNodeId) which traverses identity-preserving lineage edges (equivalent_to, merged_into per X53) and sets review status to suspect on all transitively reachable nodes. The derivation loop reads suspect status to decide which downstream phases need re-derivation in the next iteration.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: delete cowReplace and markSuspectAndPropagate as YAGNI dead code, since they have no callers (E31).", + "Alternative: keep grounding-enrichment as additive-only — always append new grounding nodes, never replace, and rely on the reconciler to archive obsolete originals; do not call cowReplace." + ], + "rationale": "C6 makes this a blocking prerequisite for derivation-loop signoff (\"the derivation loop cannot be signed off without it\"). X57 makes the same claim normatively. T10 specifies COW semantics for grounding, so alt-cow-mutate-in-place contradicts the stated substrate model and would force the reconciler to do double work to discover obsolete originals. alt-cow-delete-orphan-methods directly violates C6 and the X16–X40 stakeholder direction. Combined wiring of both functions is required because cowReplace alone leaves downstream nodes still pointing at superseded premises with clean status — markSuspectAndPropagate is what keeps the JTMS chain (X28) consistent." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 275, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Stage A–E in dependency order with parallelism between independent stages.", + "body": "Stage A–E in dependency order with parallelism between independent stages.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC23]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Land the work in five staged increments, each independently mergeable while keeping the forward pass green (C1) and the smoke artifacts validating (C4): Stage A (correctness wiring) — dec-recurse-wiring + dec-refined-impasse + dec-rewind-phase + dec-baseline-effects + dec-nudging + dec-cow-wiring + dec-jtms (population only); Stage B (reference integrity) — dec-nodeid-from-displayid; Stage C (observability) — dec-eventlog + dec-eventlog-catalog; Stage D (feature-model redesign) — dec-fanin-two-stage + dec-config-schema-replace + dec-solver-impl + dec-perspective-record + dec-perspective-generation + dec-blocking-impasse + dec-repair-flow + dec-repair-autoresolve; Stage E (test + hygiene) — dec-test-strategy + dec-cli-extract + dec-doc-fixes + dec-resume. Stages A–C and E can land in any order; D depends on A's JTMS wiring and B's NodeIdFromDisplayId.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: follow X62's stated priority order strictly — land all of P18–P25 (tests) first, then correctness, then design, then everything else — with no parallel staging." + ], + "rationale": "Strict X62 priority ordering (alt-staging-priority-strict) puts tests first, but dec-test-strategy depends on dec-cli-extract (factory injection for module tests, design-cli-extract-modules), which is itself a hygiene item ranked lower in X62. The dependency graph forces some interleaving. The proposed staging respects the spirit of X62 (correctness items P1/P2/P10/P32 land in Stage A early; tests land in Stage E across all the modules now made testable) while allowing independent landings. C1/C4 are preserved per stage because each stage's changes are scoped: A patches existing wiring, B is a schema change with retry behavior, C is an observability swap, D is the redesign behind a feature flag during transition, E is additive tests + refactors." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 276, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Migrate the engine to Effect EventLog with typed events; the CLI becomes one subscriber.", + "body": "Migrate the engine to Effect EventLog with typed events; the CLI becomes one subscriber.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC8]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Replace every Console.log call in src/engine/** (fan-in.ts, fan-out.ts, phase-runner.ts, reconciliation.ts, derivation-loop.ts, perspective-selection.ts, assembler.ts) with an Effect EventLog (effect/EventLog) emission that publishes a typed, tagged event ({_tag: 'FanInStarted'|'FanInCompleted'|'FanOutAttempt'|'ReconcileOutcome'|'PhaseEntered'|'ImpasseSpawned'|'ImpasseResolved'|'CowReplace'|'SuspectPropagated'|'NudgeActivated'|...}, payload). The CLI (cli/run.ts and cli-driver.ts) becomes a subscriber that renders these events to stdout via its existing formatHandoffReport-style code paths. The engine no longer imports Console.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: keep Console.log but funnel it through a single helper module so the coupling is at one place; defer EventLog migration to post-prototype.", + "Alternative: replace Console.log with Effect.logInfo / Effect.logDebug structured logging (the X13 fallback option) without introducing an EventLog topic and subscriber model." + ], + "rationale": "X14 is an explicit stakeholder preference for EventLog specifically over Effect.logInfo. X15 calls for events on notable occurrences — i.e. domain-meaningful events like 'ImpasseSpawned', not log levels — which is the EventLog model and not the Effect.logInfo model (alt-eventlog-effect-logger), where consumers cannot dispatch on _tag. alt-eventlog-keep-console preserves the current coupling to a CLI presentation layer (RK5) and is incompatible with the planned web inspector (M7, E7) which needs a structured stream of engine events to render. The X13/X14/X15 chain is monotone in stakeholder preference toward EventLog; X14 is the latest preference and supersedes the X13 fallback." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 277, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis vectors with k=3 per space.", + "body": "Use farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis vectors with k=3 per space.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC14]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Generate perspective summaries by sampling configurations from the SAT solver's enumeration (capped at e.g. 200 per space) and running farthest-first / k-medoids over Hamming distance on axis-assignment vectors to pick k=3 representatives per space (M_current and M_preview separately). Each representative becomes a Perspective record carrying: the configuration vector, a default-bundle status flag (display only), and a short LLM-generated label. evaluateSelection runs against any user-chosen bundle and is the only readiness gate.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: use a clustering algorithm (e.g., k-means with one-hot embedding) instead of k-medoids; centroids are not real configurations, so generate the closest real configuration to each centroid as the representative.", + "Alternative: surface every distinct configuration in M_current up to a bound; let the UI handle scrolling." + ], + "rationale": "X21 directly specifies this method. k-medoids returns real configurations, which fits dec-perspective-record (the record has to point at a real activatable configuration); alt-perspective-clustering needs a 'snap to nearest real config' post-step that is just k-medoids in disguise. alt-perspective-show-all defeats X33's notion of 'perspective' as a digestible summary and would overwhelm the user when M_preview is large. k=3 is a conservative default given RK17's openness; making k a parameter is left for tuning." + } + } + ], + "edges": [ + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 22, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 37, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 58, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 60, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 66, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 86, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 93, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 102, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 113, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 115, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 151, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 154, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 156, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 164, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 169, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 188, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 204, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 214, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 236, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 240, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 243, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 246, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 252, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 164, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 258, + "target_local_id": 15, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 170, + "target_local_id": 257, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 250, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 147, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 15, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 149, + "target_local_id": 65, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 146, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 81, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 161, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 248, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 158, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 113, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 260, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 18, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 44, + "target_local_id": 130, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 233, + "target_local_id": 26, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 196, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 15, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 101, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 237, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 64, + "target_local_id": 171, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 66, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 84, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 248, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 243, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 225, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 109, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 195, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 162, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 4, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 158, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 250, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 5, + "target_local_id": 97, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 115, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 79, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 2, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 16, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 183, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 77, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 106, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 258, + "target_local_id": 214, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 163, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 178, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 203, + "target_local_id": 245, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 171, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 244, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 245, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 147, + "target_local_id": 74, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 267, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 177, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 88, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 51, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 181, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 185, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 37, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 181, + "target_local_id": 107, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 47, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 184, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 63, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 162, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 183, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 93, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 37, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 110, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 11, + "target_local_id": 207, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 135, + "target_local_id": 145, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 114, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 90, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 62, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 261, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 151, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 35, + "target_local_id": 85, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 242, + "target_local_id": 142, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 191, + "target_local_id": 82, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 39, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 139, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 256, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 247, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 70, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 185, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 21, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 256, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 260, + "target_local_id": 173, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 70, + "target_local_id": 155, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 146, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 236, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 23, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 161, + "target_local_id": 102, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 239, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 168, + "target_local_id": 155, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 151, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 66, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 144, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 181, + "target_local_id": 34, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 18, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 126, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 252, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 207, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 225, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 112, + "target_local_id": 156, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 39, + "target_local_id": 142, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 244, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 195, + "target_local_id": 77, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 114, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 79, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 191, + "target_local_id": 50, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 199, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 44, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 58, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 15, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 256, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 119, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 185, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 258, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 85, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 151, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 136, + "target_local_id": 107, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 89, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 243, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 152, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 261, + "target_local_id": 102, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 3, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 53, + "target_local_id": 180, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 182, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 241, + "target_local_id": 152, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 86, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 89, + "target_local_id": 75, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 267, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 250, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 183, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 43, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 196, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 277, + "target_local_id": 187, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 137, + "target_local_id": 58, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 183, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 52, + "target_local_id": 33, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 137, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 94, + "target_local_id": 95, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 252, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 168, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 213, + "target_local_id": 199, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 60, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 51, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 277, + "target_local_id": 133, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 54, + "target_local_id": 197, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 277, + "target_local_id": 187, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 178, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 41, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 75, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 27, + "target_local_id": 126, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 155, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 249, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 24, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 212, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 64, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 27, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 15, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 138, + "target_local_id": 151, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 235, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 94, + "target_local_id": 98, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 85, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 146, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 256, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 119, + "target_local_id": 163, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 149, + "target_local_id": 145, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 126, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 113, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 250, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 24, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 164, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 148, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 211, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 77, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 256, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 142, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 209, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 191, + "target_local_id": 113, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 2, + "target_local_id": 30, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 74, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 112, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 164, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 248, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 72, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 57, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 242, + "target_local_id": 39, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 147, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 44, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 188, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 107, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 70, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 3, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 9, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 275, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 32, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 77, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 188, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 5, + "target_local_id": 238, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 43, + "target_local_id": 154, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 126, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 277, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 55, + "target_local_id": 73, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 175, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 261, + "target_local_id": 102, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 147, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 199, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 233, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 136, + "target_local_id": 163, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 50, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 54, + "target_local_id": 29, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 277, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 52, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 258, + "target_local_id": 251, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 159, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 204, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 59, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 6, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 241, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 213, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 177, + "target_local_id": 66, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 139, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 81, + "target_local_id": 25, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 57, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 138, + "target_local_id": 241, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 241, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 60, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 25, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 209, + "target_local_id": 167, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 23, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 11, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 135, + "target_local_id": 104, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 241, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 184, + "target_local_id": 256, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 248, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 45, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 101, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 84, + "target_local_id": 106, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 258, + "target_local_id": 15, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 260, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 184, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 62, + "target_local_id": 169, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 251, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 25, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 26, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 184, + "target_local_id": 256, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 73, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 63, + "target_local_id": 122, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 44, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 18, + "target_local_id": 258, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 142, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 9, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 72, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 244, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 248, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 144, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 260, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 233, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 86, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 69, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 233, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 160, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 90, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 194, + "target_local_id": 202, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 211, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 258, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 11, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 259, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 203, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 249, + "target_local_id": 85, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 59, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 111, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 244, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 35, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 161, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 50, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 164, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 33, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 182, + "target_local_id": 245, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 112, + "target_local_id": 66, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 115, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 48, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 23, + "target_local_id": 133, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 52, + "target_local_id": 80, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 27, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 154, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 139, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 136, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 125, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 53, + "target_local_id": 155, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 79, + "target_local_id": 133, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 199, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 64, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 130, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 115, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 35, + "target_local_id": 249, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 249, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 6, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 144, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 41, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 241, + "target_local_id": 151, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 66, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 70, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 141, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 203, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 67, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 235, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 147, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 109, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 119, + "target_local_id": 57, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 91, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 93, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 206, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 261, + "target_local_id": 175, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 11, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 159, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 141, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 194, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 162, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 22, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 182, + "target_local_id": 203, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 213, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 75, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 261, + "target_local_id": 102, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 239, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 156, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 148, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 123, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 159, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 235, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 62, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 277, + "target_local_id": 187, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 275, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 170, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 27, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 114, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 247, + "target_local_id": 130, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 186, + "target_local_id": 141, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 171, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 185, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 84, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 206, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 260, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + } + ] +} diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/explorer-ui.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/explorer-ui.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..583e3151c --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/explorer-ui.json @@ -0,0 +1,7858 @@ +{ + "spec": { + "slug": "explorer-ui", + "name": "Explorer UI", + "readiness_grade": "commitments_ready" + }, + "nodes": [ + { + "local_id": 1, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "check", + "title": "Explorer UI — code-audit pass", + "body": "Synthetic parent check representing the manual code-audit pass during which evidence nodes were authored. Generated by .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence a structural parent on the oracle plane.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-port-synthetic", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 2, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A CSS scanline overlay must be present in the DOM as a pseudo-element or overlay div positioned above the WebGL canvas at all times.", + "body": "A CSS scanline overlay must be present in the DOM as a pseudo-element or overlay div positioned above the WebGL canvas at all times. Its computed style must include pointer-events: none so that mouse and touch events pass through to the canvas beneath. The overlay must be visible as a subtle horizontal stripe pattern when inspected visually against a bright node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 3, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation must execute in a Web Worker, not on the main UI thread.", + "body": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation must execute in a Web Worker, not on the main UI thread. Verified by: opening browser DevTools performance timeline during artifact load, confirming that the layout computation task appears on a Worker thread and not on the Main thread. The main thread must remain responsive (no tasks exceeding 50ms) during layout computation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 4, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, node shape must encode node kind: content nodes must render as circles, hub nodes must render as diamonds.", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, node shape must encode node kind: content nodes must render as circles, hub nodes must render as diamonds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 5, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder intends nodes to be colored by derivation phase in the macro graph visualization.", + "body": "The stakeholder intends nodes to be colored by derivation phase in the macro graph visualization.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 6, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a justification hub node must render: (1) a PREMISES group showing all nodes connected by '…", + "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a justification hub node must render: (1) a PREMISES group showing all nodes connected by 'informed_by' edges; (2) a CONCLUSIONS group showing all nodes connected by 'produced' edges. Each node reference must be a clickable pill that navigates the detail panel to that node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 7, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The artifact bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) includes a placeholder for the FrameRecord summary field: when bundling, it reads…", + "body": "The artifact bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) includes a placeholder for the FrameRecord summary field: when bundling, it reads frames.json and adds summary: null for each frame if no summary is present. The UI's FrameRecord type declares summary as string | null. When the elicitation pipeline is extended to produce summaries (resolving RK5/E5), the bundler will populate this field and the UI will render it without code changes. This design makes the dependency on the pipeline schema extension explicit and non-blocking.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 8, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The Sigma WebGL canvas element must have no keydown, keyup, or keypress event listeners attached directly to it or via React synthetic even…", + "body": "The Sigma WebGL canvas element must have no keydown, keyup, or keypress event listeners attached directly to it or via React synthetic events. Verified by inspecting event listeners on the canvas DOM element using getEventListeners() in DevTools or a test spy, confirming zero keyboard event handlers are registered.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR74]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 9, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The src/types/artifact.ts file must contain zero import statements referencing the spec-elicitation package or any Deno-specific module.", + "body": "The src/types/artifact.ts file must contain zero import statements referencing the spec-elicitation package or any Deno-specific module. Running tsc --noEmit on the spec-elicitation-ui package must complete with zero errors, confirming the type definitions are self-contained. Verified by static analysis of the import graph rooted at src/types/artifact.ts.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR89]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 10, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The spec-elicitation-ui package lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/ as a sibling…", + "body": "The spec-elicitation-ui package lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/ as a sibling to spec-elicitation (X13). It is a standard Vite + React + TypeScript project with the following top-level structure: src/components/ (React UI components), src/store/ (Zustand store and derived index builders), src/graph/ (Sigma.js setup, custom WebGL programs, ForceAtlas2 worker), src/macro/ (WebGL macro timeline renderer), src/types/ (TypeScript types mirroring the artifact.json schema), src/utils/ (artifact parser, diff utilities, provenance traversal), and scripts/bundle-artifact.ts (the Deno bundler script that produces artifact.json, kept here rather than in spec-elicitation to colocate it with the schema it produces). Tailwind config extends the base with the phosphor CRT theme tokens defined in crt-design-system-design.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 11, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The current spec.md output renders all 376+ nodes sequentially and is unusable for understanding relationships, tracing provenance, or navi…", + "body": "The current spec.md output renders all 376+ nodes sequentially and is unusable for understanding relationships, tracing provenance, or navigating decisions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 12, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Displaying interventions in both the node detail panel and the macro timeline is the most complete approach but carries higher implementati…", + "body": "Displaying interventions in both the node detail panel and the macro timeline is the most complete approach but carries higher implementation cost.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 13, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a decision hub node must render: (1) a RATIONALE block showing the decision's rationale pro…", + "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel for a decision hub node must render: (1) a RATIONALE block showing the decision's rationale prose with a phosphor-amber left border; (2) a CONSIDERED group listing all nodes reached via 'considered' edges as clickable displayId pills; (3) a SELECTED group with a green glow indicator showing chosen alternatives via 'selected' edges; (4) a REJECTED group with a dimmed red indicator showing rejected alternatives via 'rejected' edges; (5) a CONSEQUENCES group listing nodes reached via 'consequence' or 'produced' edges. Each pill must navigate the detail panel to the referenced node on click. A 'Trace to grounding' button must highlight the support-edge subgraph back to grounding-phase nodes in the main Sigma canvas.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 14, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Real-time updates are out of scope.", + "body": "Real-time updates are out of scope. The artifact is loaded once at startup and does not change during the session.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 15, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "After successful artifact parse, the application must play a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content.", + "body": "After successful artifact parse, the application must play a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content. The animation must implement the keyframe sequence opacity 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1 over approximately 150ms as a CSS @keyframes animation, and must not use a slide-in transition.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 16, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The macro view is the temporal history view showing derivation frames and their…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T16]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The macro view is the temporal history view showing derivation frames and their relationships over time, laid out as a vertical timeline branching horizontally at derivation loops." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 17, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a fan-in grouping contains more than one node pair, the comparison overlay must show a tab row above the split columns allowing the us…", + "body": "When a fan-in grouping contains more than one node pair, the comparison overlay must show a tab row above the split columns allowing the user to navigate between all node pairs in the grouping. Verified using the reference artifact's fan-in-records.json: selecting a grouping with multiple nodeIds (e.g. 'cloud-agnostic-context' with nodeIds 7cf067d6 and 9d1a93f3) must produce a tab for each pair.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR66]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 18, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from exactly two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro v…", + "body": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from exactly two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view, which must open the comparison for that fan-in grouping; (2) clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel of any node with lifecycle='candidate', which must open the comparison for the fan-in grouping containing that candidate node. Both entry points must produce the same comparison overlay UI.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR64]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 19, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a node has reviewStatus._tag='suspect', the Identity section must display a 'suspect' indicator with clickable links to each causeId.", + "body": "When a node has reviewStatus._tag='suspect', the Identity section must display a 'suspect' indicator with clickable links to each causeId. When reviewStatus._tag='conditional', the Identity section must display a 'conditional' indicator with clickable links to each impasseId. A 'clean' node must show a clean indicator with no extra links. Verified by mounting the detail panel for nodes with each review status variant.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR43]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 20, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro timeline must visually encode the full regression/recovery narrative: (1) the initial frame trunk rendered in phosphor-green; (2)…", + "body": "The macro timeline must visually encode the full regression/recovery narrative: (1) the initial frame trunk rendered in phosphor-green; (2) rederive frames in phosphor-amber; (3) impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on branch edges; (4) perspective hub nodes shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards; (5) the nudgingActive flag shown as a 'NUDGED' badge. Together these elements must make the impasse → rederive → fan-out → reconciliation cycle legible without additional explanation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R45]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 21, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking any node in the micro-view graph must activate the right detail panel with a CSS @keyframes flicker animation.", + "body": "Clicking any node in the micro-view graph must activate the right detail panel with a CSS @keyframes flicker animation. The animation must pulse opacity through the sequence 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1 and complete within approximately 150ms (±20ms). The panel must not slide in from the side. Verified by: recording a click event in a test renderer and asserting the applied animation name matches the flicker keyframes definition with the correct duration.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 22, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a snapshot slider that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions.", + "body": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a snapshot slider that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions. The slider must display a numeric revision badge and a timestamp label for the current snapshot. A status line below the slider must show the current revision number and the associated frameId(s).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 23, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The application must provide no mechanism to create, edit, or delete nodes or edges.", + "body": "The application must provide no mechanism to create, edit, or delete nodes or edges. All data displayed must come exclusively from the loaded artifact.json and must not change during the session.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 24, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Baseline refers to the active, reconciled state of the knowledge graph; candida…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T19]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Baseline refers to the active, reconciled state of the knowledge graph; candidate refers to nodes produced during clean-room re-derivation branches before reconciliation. Side-by-side comparison of baseline vs candidate nodes is a required UI feature." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 25, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "After the initial layout computation completes for a given specId and snapshotRevision, the layout positions must be written to sessionStor…", + "body": "After the initial layout computation completes for a given specId and snapshotRevision, the layout positions must be written to sessionStorage under a key incorporating the specId and snapshotRevision. On a second load of the same artifact within the same browser session, no Web Worker layout computation must occur — the cached positions must be read directly from sessionStorage and applied to the Sigma graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 26, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The right detail panel must render exactly four collapsible sections in top-to-bottom order: (1) Identity, (2) Connections, (3) Provenance,…", + "body": "The right detail panel must render exactly four collapsible sections in top-to-bottom order: (1) Identity, (2) Connections, (3) Provenance, (4) Validation. The Identity section must be expanded by default and must remain visible even when other sections are collapsed. Sections 2, 3, and 4 must toggle open/closed independently. Verified by mounting the panel for a known node and asserting four section headers are present, with Identity expanded and the others collapsible.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 27, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The pipeline artifact output is a directory containing JSON files organized into: graph/ (nodes, edges, frames, derivation-runs, fan-in rec…", + "body": "The pipeline artifact output is a directory containing JSON files organized into: graph/ (nodes, edges, frames, derivation-runs, fan-in records, snapshots), and top-level files (manifest, sources, extracted-claims, interventions), plus rendered views (spec.md, prose.md) and reports (validation, handoff summary).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 28, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 4 derivation phases with 3 derivation loop attempts, and includes decision, justification, im…", + "body": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 4 derivation phases with 3 derivation loop attempts, and includes decision, justification, impasse, and perspective hub nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 29, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal listing which nodes changed in that frame (the node-diff list).", + "body": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal listing which nodes changed in that frame (the node-diff list). The modal must display at minimum the displayId, lifecycle, and phase of each node associated with that frame. The modal must be dismissible via Escape or a close control. No WebGL zoom-into-frame transition may be attempted; the modal is the required behavior for the current iteration.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR62]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 30, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Inspection of the rendered DOM must reveal zero input controls, buttons, or form elements that create, modify, or delete any node or edge.", + "body": "Inspection of the rendered DOM must reveal zero input controls, buttons, or form elements that create, modify, or delete any node or edge. No mutation of the in-memory graph store may occur after the initial artifact load; all node and edge data must remain identical to the parsed artifact.json for the duration of the session.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 31, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers that all pipeline output files be combined into a single artifact.json file that is loaded into the visualization p…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers that all pipeline output files be combined into a single artifact.json file that is loaded into the visualization program.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 32, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given a valid artifact.json file dropped onto the landing page drop zone, the application must parse the file entirely in the browser using…", + "body": "Given a valid artifact.json file dropped onto the landing page drop zone, the application must parse the file entirely in the browser using the File API (no network request made), transition away from the landing page, and display the main explorer view — all without any server upload or URL entry by the user.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 33, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must render at full Sigma glow intensity and non-matching nodes must render at approxim…", + "body": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must render at full Sigma glow intensity and non-matching nodes must render at approximately 15% opacity in the canvas. Edges where both endpoints are non-matching must also be visually dimmed. No node or edge may be removed from the graphology graph during filtering — the total node and edge count in the graphology instance must remain constant before and after any filter is applied.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 34, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The 17 edge types across 6 categories are: hub-generic (informed_by, produced); decision (considered, selected, rejected, consequence); imp…", + "body": "The 17 edge types across 6 categories are: hub-generic (informed_by, produced); decision (considered, selected, rejected, consequence); impasse (conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to); perspective (aggregates); content (derived_from, depends_on, conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline); lineage (equivalent_to, refined_by, weakened_by, strengthened_by, split_into, merged_into, obsoleted_by). Content edge category has 10 types; lineage has 7.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X44]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 35, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The micro view is the lineage-focused graph view showing the spec at a particul…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T15]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The micro view is the lineage-focused graph view showing the spec at a particular point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out and a snapshot selector for time-scrubbing." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 36, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For each intervention record in the reference artifact's interventions.json, every nodeId in its targetNodeIds array must appear as a key i…", + "body": "For each intervention record in the reference artifact's interventions.json, every nodeId in its targetNodeIds array must appear as a key in the interventionsByNodeId index mapping to an array that includes that intervention. Specifically: node 7cbf0826 must map to intervention 0f60db54; node 38c2ff0b must map to intervention 158ac3c4; node 61d9201c must map to intervention 926c3761; node cb3857aa must map to intervention 610c95d1. Each association must be verified by direct index lookup.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR87]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 37, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The application must define TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts.", + "body": "The application must define TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts. NodeRecord must be a discriminated union on kind ('content' | 'hub'). FrameRecord must include summary as string | null to future-proof the optional per-frame LLM summary field. These types must be defined independently of the spec-elicitation package (no cross-package import of Effect schemas).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 38, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive i…", + "body": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive indicator (shown as a 'NUDGED' badge when true), createdAt timestamp, and the pre-generated LLM summary text when present. When no summary is present (summary is null), the summary region must display a muted 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' placeholder in dimmed monospace style. No runtime error or broken layout may result from an absent summary.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R43]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 39, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The comparison overlay must render as a split panel with a left column showing the baseline node and a right column showing the candidate n…", + "body": "The comparison overlay must render as a split panel with a left column showing the baseline node and a right column showing the candidate node. Differences in text, semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority fields must be highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions (green) and deletions (red/amber). The fan-in grouping rationale must appear as a prominent decision banner between the two columns.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR65]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 40, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "A search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND simultaneously show a results list in a side panel.", + "body": "A search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND simultaneously show a results list in a side panel.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 41, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The main explorer must render a three-region resizable split layout: a left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and results list, a…", + "body": "The main explorer must render a three-region resizable split layout: a left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and results list, a central canvas area hosting either the micro or macro view, and a right detail panel. All three regions must be simultaneously visible when a node is selected. Panels must be resizable via drag handles.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 42, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The explorer UI must replace the current unnavigable flat spec.md output, enabling users to understand relationships, trace provenance, and…", + "body": "The explorer UI must replace the current unnavigable flat spec.md output, enabling users to understand relationships, trace provenance, and navigate decisions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 43, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The Validation section of the detail panel must not appear in the DOM when the selected node has reviewStatus._tag='clean' and no validatio…", + "body": "The Validation section of the detail panel must not appear in the DOM when the selected node has reviewStatus._tag='clean' and no validation errors touch its incident edges. When errors are present, the section must list each error showing: rule, severity, message, edge type, and edge direction. Verified by: selecting a clean node and asserting the Validation section is absent; then selecting a node with incident errored edges and asserting the section is present with correct error details.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR53]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 44, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Each frame card rendered in the macro timeline must display all of the following fields: mode badge ('initial' or 'rederive'), entryPhase l…", + "body": "Each frame card rendered in the macro timeline must display all of the following fields: mode badge ('initial' or 'rederive'), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, createdAt timestamp, and a nudgingActive indicator rendered as a 'NUDGED' badge when nudgingActive=true. For the reference artifact, the two rederive frames with attemptNumber=1 and attemptNumber=2 (ids b40fd568 and b9236ccf) must show 'NUDGED'. The frame with attemptNumber=0 (id 10f07753) must not show 'NUDGED'.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR57]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 45, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The edgeIssuesByNodeId index must correctly associate validation errors with both the source and target node of each errored edge.", + "body": "The edgeIssuesByNodeId index must correctly associate validation errors with both the source and target node of each errored edge. Using the first validation error in the reference artifact (edgeId 00452e1e, a derived_from edge between nodes b66575fc and 6c45100b), both node IDs must be present as keys in edgeIssuesByNodeId, each mapping to an array containing that error. Querying an unrelated node ID must return an empty array.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR80]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 46, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The right detail panel must activate on node click with a CRT power-on flicker animation of approximately 150ms duration, implemented as a…", + "body": "The right detail panel must activate on node click with a CRT power-on flicker animation of approximately 150ms duration, implemented as a CSS @keyframes sequence that pulses opacity 0 → 0.4 → 0.1 → 1. The panel must not use a slide-in transition.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 47, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must be visually encoded by relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges triggered by an impasse mu…", + "body": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must be visually encoded by relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges triggered by an impasse must be drawn in warning amber and labeled with the triggerImpasseId as a displayId badge; fan-in record edges connecting rederive frames back to the baseline must be drawn in bright green and labeled 'RECONCILED'.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R44]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 48, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Identity section of the detail panel must display: for content nodes — semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority; for hub nodes — hu…", + "body": "The Identity section of the detail panel must display: for content nodes — semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority; for hub nodes — hubType. It must also show the review status as a tagged indicator: 'clean' with no annotation, 'suspect' with links to causeIds, and 'conditional' with links to impasseIds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 49, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers that when a search or filter is active, matching nodes glow at full intensity while non-matching nodes are rendered…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers that when a search or filter is active, matching nodes glow at full intensity while non-matching nodes are rendered at low opacity (~15%), with edges also dimmed when both endpoints are non-matching, multiple filters using AND logic, and the graph topology preserved so context is not lost.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 50, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the application is deployed to a remote static host (e.g., GitHub Pages) and accessed with ?artifact= pointing to a CORS-enabled…", + "body": "When the application is deployed to a remote static host (e.g., GitHub Pages) and accessed with ?artifact= pointing to a CORS-enabled artifact.json URL, the application must load and parse the artifact via fetch() and enter the main explorer view without requiring any local file selection. No error related to file system access may occur. Verified by deploying the built app to a static host and testing the URL param flow end-to-end.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR84]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 51, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "All interactive HTML elements (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have hover states that intensify glow via CSS…", + "body": "All interactive HTML elements (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have hover states that intensify glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and text-shadow. No interactive element may have a visually inert hover state.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R55]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 52, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers that the provenance section in the node detail panel renders a small Sigma.js subgraph showing the full upstream de…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers that the provenance section in the node detail panel renders a small Sigma.js subgraph showing the full upstream derivation chain, with clickable nodes for navigation, visually coherent with the main graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 53, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers a WebGL-based renderer (e.g.", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers a WebGL-based renderer (e.g. Sigma.js) for graph rendering because it can handle tens of thousands of nodes and edges interactively and enables more ambitious visual design such as a phosphor-glow effect on nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 54, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When the snapshot selector changes the active snapshot, node visibility must be updated by adjusting node opacity rather than removing node…", + "body": "When the snapshot selector changes the active snapshot, node visibility must be updated by adjusting node opacity rather than removing nodes from the graph. Nodes not in the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array must be rendered at near-zero opacity. Layout positions must not be recomputed on snapshot change.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 55, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The full reference graph (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges, plus archived and candidate nodes) may be too large to render interactively witho…", + "body": "The full reference graph (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges, plus archived and candidate nodes) may be too large to render interactively without deliberate performance optimization.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 56, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When Macro view is active, a dedicated element separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas must be mounted in the central area with…", + "body": "When Macro view is active, a dedicated element separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas must be mounted in the central area with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl') or getContext('webgl2') returning non-null). The Sigma canvas must not be present in the DOM simultaneously. Verified by querying the DOM for canvas elements while in each view mode and asserting exactly one WebGL canvas is present per mode.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR55]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 57, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "With the smoke-webhook reference artifact loaded (761 total nodes, 2,662 edges), panning and zooming the micro-view Sigma canvas must susta…", + "body": "With the smoke-webhook reference artifact loaded (761 total nodes, 2,662 edges), panning and zooming the micro-view Sigma canvas must sustain a frame rate of at least 30 fps as measured by browser DevTools performance profiling. No interaction (pan, zoom, hover) may produce a jank frame exceeding 100ms on a mid-range developer machine.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 58, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must have zero computed width (or be absent from the DOM) and the central canvas must expa…", + "body": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must have zero computed width (or be absent from the DOM) and the central canvas must expand to fill the full remaining width after the left sidebar. Selecting a node must cause the detail panel to appear; deselecting must collapse it again.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 59, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view must be rendered on a dedicated WebGL canvas separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas, implemented using raw WebGL with a t…", + "body": "The macro view must be rendered on a dedicated WebGL canvas separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas, implemented using raw WebGL with a thin abstraction layer (not a graph library). This canvas must be mounted in place of the Sigma canvas when macro view is active.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 60, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "While ForceAtlas2 layout computation is in progress, the central canvas must display a CRT-styled text indicator reading 'COMPUTING LAYOUT.…", + "body": "While ForceAtlas2 layout computation is in progress, the central canvas must display a CRT-styled text indicator reading 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' (or equivalent). The indicator must disappear and be replaced by the rendered graph when the Worker posts its result. No partially-rendered or unlaid-out graph may be shown while computation is ongoing.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 61, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle that switches the central canvas between Micro view and Macro view.", + "body": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle that switches the central canvas between Micro view and Macro view. The snapshot selector must be visible in the toolbar only when Micro view is active.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 62, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, every hub node with hubType='impasse' must render with a hexagonal shape, visually distinct from the diamond used…", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, every hub node with hubType='impasse' must render with a hexagonal shape, visually distinct from the diamond used for other hub types. Inspecting the rendered geometry of a known impasse node from the reference artifact (e.g., the node with id '557db0a8-5b5b-4ab9-97e2-4ac5c4f243d5') must confirm the hexagonal form.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 63, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field.", + "body": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field. The macro view's per-frame summary display depends on a schema extension to the elicitation pipeline that has not yet been implemented.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder-inferred [RK5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 64, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Keyboard navigation does not apply to the graph canvas.", + "body": "Keyboard navigation does not apply to the graph canvas. Canvas interaction is mouse/touch only.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 65, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The interventionsByNodeId index must correctly map each nodeId appearing in any intervention's targetNodeIds array to that intervention rec…", + "body": "The interventionsByNodeId index must correctly map each nodeId appearing in any intervention's targetNodeIds array to that intervention record. Using the reference artifact's interventions.json (4 records, each with one targetNodeId), querying the index for each of the four targetNodeIds must return the corresponding intervention. Querying a nodeId that appears in no intervention must return an empty array, not undefined or an error.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 66, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, edges must be rendered in three visually distinct colors by category: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, inf…", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, edges must be rendered in three visually distinct colors by category: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) in dim amber; workflow edges (produced, considered, selected, rejected, consequence, conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to, aggregates) in brighter green; structural edges (conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline, and all lineage edge types) in muted cyan. Sampling 10 edges of each category from the reference artifact and reading their rendered colors must confirm the correct category mapping for all 30 sampled edges.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 67, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The smoke-webhook artifact directory contains: graph/ (nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, snap…", + "body": "The smoke-webhook artifact directory contains: graph/ (nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, snapshots.json), plus top-level manifest.json, sources.json, extracted-claims.json, interventions.json, reports/validation.json, reports/handoff-summary.md, and views/. Nodes carry id, displayId, specId, frameId, phase, text, lifecycle, reviewStatus, provenance, createdAt, kind, and kind-specific fields (semanticRole/epistemicStatus/authority for content; hubType/rationale for hubs). Edges carry id, source.nodeId, target.nodeId, type, rationale, provenance, createdAt. Frames carry parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase, triggerImpasseIds, mode (initial/rederive), attemptNumber, nudgingActive. No summary field exists on FrameRecord.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X43]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 68, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking the 'Trace to grounding' button in a decision hub's Connections section must traverse support edges from the decision's considered…", + "body": "Clicking the 'Trace to grounding' button in a decision hub's Connections section must traverse support edges from the decision's considered nodes back to grounding-phase nodes and apply the active-filter highlighting model (full intensity for traversed nodes, ~15% opacity for all others) to the main Sigma canvas. The Zustand filterState must reflect this subgraph highlight. Clearing the filter must restore all nodes to normal opacity.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR46]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 69, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Running the elicitation pipeline from within the UI is out of scope.", + "body": "Running the elicitation pipeline from within the UI is out of scope.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 70, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The app has no backend.", + "body": "The app has no backend. All data is loaded from static JSON files. The app must be deployable as a static site.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 71, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The UI defines TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts, mirroring the domain model from the spec-elicita…", + "body": "The UI defines TypeScript types for all artifact.json structures in src/types/artifact.ts, mirroring the domain model from the spec-elicitation package without importing it directly (to avoid a cross-package dependency on Deno-specific Effect schemas). Key types: ArtifactFile (top-level), GraphData, NodeRecord (discriminated union on kind: 'content' | 'hub'), ContentNode (with semanticRole, epistemicStatus, authority), HubNode (with hubType, rationale), EdgeRecord, FrameRecord (with optional summary?: string to future-proof RK5), SnapshotRecord, DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, InterventionRecord, ValidationReport, ValidationError. The discriminated union on NodeRecord.kind enables exhaustive type-narrowing in the detail panel renderer.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 72, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the snapshot slider is moved to a revision where a given node is not in the activeNodeIds array, that node must remain present in the…", + "body": "When the snapshot slider is moved to a revision where a given node is not in the activeNodeIds array, that node must remain present in the Sigma graphology graph instance but be rendered at near-zero opacity (visually invisible). The node must not be removed from the graphology graph. Layout positions must not change when the slider is moved. Verified by: querying the graphology instance for a known inactive-at-revision node and asserting it exists with a near-zero opacity attribute.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 73, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The macro timeline must make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation narrative legible through five simultaneous visual cues: (1)…", + "body": "The macro timeline must make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation narrative legible through five simultaneous visual cues: (1) initial frame trunk in phosphor-green; (2) rederive frames in phosphor-amber; (3) impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on branch edges; (4) perspective hub nodes shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards; (5) nudgingActive shown as a 'NUDGED' badge. All five cues must be present simultaneously in the rendered macro view for the reference artifact.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR60]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 74, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Edge types are defined in a dedicated file at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/src/domain/e…", + "body": "Edge types are defined in a dedicated file at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/src/domain/edge-types.ts.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-observed [X12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 75, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must exhibit a visible phosphor glow effect implemented via a WebGL fragment shader.", + "body": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must exhibit a visible phosphor glow effect implemented via a WebGL fragment shader. Hovering over a node must produce a measurably increased glow radius or intensity relative to the idle state. Selecting a node must produce a further-increased glow intensity relative to hover. The glow color must match the node's derivation-phase color.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 76, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder envisions nodes emitting a color-appropriate phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader, with hover states intens…", + "body": "The stakeholder envisions nodes emitting a color-appropriate phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader, with hover states intensifying the glow effect.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 77, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The snapshot selector control must appear in the toolbar if and only if Micro view is active.", + "body": "The snapshot selector control must appear in the toolbar if and only if Micro view is active. Switching to Macro view must remove the snapshot selector from the DOM (or hide it such that it receives no pointer events). Switching back to Micro must restore it.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 78, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When multiple filter controls are active simultaneously, the application must combine them using AND logic: a node is considered matching o…", + "body": "When multiple filter controls are active simultaneously, the application must combine them using AND logic: a node is considered matching only if it satisfies every active filter dimension.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 79, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "An intervention is a record of a human action that occurred during a derivation…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T13]", + "detail": { + "definition": "An intervention is a record of a human action that occurred during a derivation frame, stored in interventions.json in the artifact." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 80, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must be rendered in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow…", + "body": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must be rendered in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo in addition to their normal phase-color glow, implemented as a second glow pass in the WebGL shader.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 81, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "All node text, displayIds, data values, and code-like content must use a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent).", + "body": "All node text, displayIds, data values, and code-like content must use a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent). No UI element may render in a default sans-serif or serif browser font.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R54]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 82, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel for an impasse hub node must render: (1) a CONFLICTING INPUTS group listing nodes via 'conflict…", + "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel for an impasse hub node must render: (1) a CONFLICTING INPUTS group listing nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges with their review status indicator; (2) a RESOLVED BY group showing nodes via 'resolved_by' edges; (3) a SPAWNED group listing child impasses via 'spawned' edges; (4) a REFINED TO group showing the refined impasse via 'refined_to' edges; (5) a status banner indicating whether the impasse is currently unresolved (no resolved_by edges) or resolved. Unresolved impasses must show a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 83, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For a decision hub node, the Connections section must render five distinct groups: RATIONALE (prose text with phosphor-amber left border),…", + "body": "For a decision hub node, the Connections section must render five distinct groups: RATIONALE (prose text with phosphor-amber left border), CONSIDERED (pills for nodes via 'considered' edges), SELECTED (green-glow pills for nodes via 'selected' edges), REJECTED (dimmed red-indicator pills for nodes via 'rejected' edges), and CONSEQUENCES (pills for nodes via 'consequence' or 'produced' edges). Each pill must be clickable and navigate the detail panel to the referenced node. A 'Trace to grounding' button must be present. Verified against a known decision hub node (e.g., DEC22) from the reference artifact.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR45]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 84, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers that keyboard navigation covers only panel controls (Escape closes detail panel, Tab/Shift-Tab moves between UI con…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers that keyboard navigation covers only panel controls (Escape closes detail panel, Tab/Shift-Tab moves between UI controls, Enter confirms selection); the Sigma.js canvas graph interaction is mouse/touch only.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 85, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The lifecycle of a node represents its current standing in the knowledge graph.", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T4]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The lifecycle of a node represents its current standing in the knowledge graph. The four defined lifecycle values are: candidate, active, archived, and withdrawn." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 86, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "A CSS scanline texture overlay must sit above the WebGL canvas at all times, implemented as a repeating-linear-gradient pseudo-element with…", + "body": "A CSS scanline texture overlay must sit above the WebGL canvas at all times, implemented as a repeating-linear-gradient pseudo-element with pointer-events:none, so it does not intercept canvas mouse/touch events.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 87, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Impasse hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel.", + "body": "Impasse hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel. The Connections section shows: (1) a 'CONFLICTING INPUTS' group listing nodes connected by 'conflicting_input' edges, each shown as a clickable pill with their review status indicator; (2) a 'RESOLVED BY' group showing nodes connected by 'resolved_by' edges (perspective or decision nodes); (3) a 'SPAWNED' group listing child impasses via 'spawned' edges; (4) a 'REFINED TO' group showing the refined impasse via 'refined_to' edges. A status banner at the top of the Connections section shows whether the impasse is currently unresolved (no resolved_by edges) or resolved. Unresolved impasses are visually flagged with a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section. In the micro graph, impasse nodes render with a distinctive hexagonal shape and warning-amber glow.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 88, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the macro timeline, any frame card associated with a perspective hub node (hubType='perspective') must display a small purple indicator…", + "body": "In the macro timeline, any frame card associated with a perspective hub node (hubType='perspective') must display a small purple indicator badge on the card. In the reference artifact, any rederive frame whose derivation produced perspective hub nodes must show this badge. Verified by identifying perspective hub nodes in the reference nodes.json, tracing their frameId, and confirming the badge appears on the corresponding frame card in the macro view.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR95]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 89, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The artifact includes a validation report.", + "body": "The artifact includes a validation report. The UI must integrate this data to show which nodes have issues.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 90, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must render in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo…", + "body": "Nodes that have one or more validation errors touching their incident edges must render in the micro-view graph with a red-tinted glow halo visually overlaid on their normal phase-color glow. Selecting a known errored edge in the reference artifact's validation.json, identifying its source and target nodes, and visually inspecting those nodes in the graph must confirm the red halo is present and absent on a clean neighboring node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 91, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given the user clicks a file-picker trigger on the landing page and selects a valid artifact.json, the application must load and parse the…", + "body": "Given the user clicks a file-picker trigger on the landing page and selects a valid artifact.json, the application must load and parse the file identically to drag-and-drop, transitioning to the main explorer view with no server upload.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 92, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain exactly the following controls: (1) a text input for full-text search; (2) four phase filter chi…", + "body": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain exactly the following controls: (1) a text input for full-text search; (2) four phase filter chips (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done); (3) ten semantic role checkboxes (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk); (4) a hub type toggle with options all/decision/justification/impasse/perspective; (5) four epistemic status chips (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred); (6) four authority chips (stakeholder, technical, external, derived); (7) three lifecycle visibility toggles (archived, candidate, withdrawn). All controls must be present in the DOM simultaneously.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 93, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL program class (node shader, color palette, glow style) as the main micro-view graph…", + "body": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL program class (node shader, color palette, glow style) as the main micro-view graph, ensuring visual coherence between the two Sigma instances.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 94, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The comparison overlay must include a 'View in graph' button.", + "body": "The comparison overlay must include a 'View in graph' button. Clicking it must: close the comparison overlay, switch to Micro view if Macro view is active, set selectedNodeId to the baseline node's id in the Zustand store, and pan/zoom the Sigma canvas to bring the baseline node into view. The detail panel must open for the baseline node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR67]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 95, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display one intervention annotation chip per intervention record associated with that frameId.", + "body": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display one intervention annotation chip per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip must show the intervention kind (e.g. 'accept_candidate') and a count of targetNodeIds. For the reference artifact: frame 10f07753 must show 3 chips (interventions 0f60db54, 158ac3c4, 926c3761), and frame b40fd568 must show 1 chip (intervention 610c95d1). Hovering a chip must display a tooltip listing targetNodeIds as human-readable displayIds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR61]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 96, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For an impasse hub node, the Connections section must render: CONFLICTING INPUTS group (nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges, each showing r…", + "body": "For an impasse hub node, the Connections section must render: CONFLICTING INPUTS group (nodes via 'conflicting_input' edges, each showing review status), RESOLVED BY group (nodes via 'resolved_by' edges), SPAWNED group (child impasses via 'spawned' edges), REFINED TO group (via 'refined_to' edges), and a status banner indicating resolved or unresolved state. An unresolved impasse must show a pulsing amber 'UNRESOLVED' badge in the Identity section. Verified against the trigger impasse node in the reference artifact.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR47]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 97, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For a content node, the Identity section must display: the full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status ind…", + "body": "For a content node, the Identity section must display: the full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator (one of clean/suspect/conditional), semanticRole, epistemicStatus, and authority. For a hub node, the Identity section must display hubType instead of semanticRole/epistemicStatus/authority. Verified by mounting the detail panel for one known content node and one known hub node from the reference artifact and asserting each field's presence and correct value.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR42]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 98, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Edge categories (support, workflow, structural) must be visually distinguished using different line styles or colors in the graph visualiza…", + "body": "Edge categories (support, workflow, structural) must be visually distinguished using different line styles or colors in the graph visualization.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 99, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The UI cannot generate per-frame LLM summaries at runtime.", + "body": "The UI cannot generate per-frame LLM summaries at runtime. It can only consume summaries that are pre-generated and present in the artifact.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 100, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The app must present the knowledge graph as a rich, browsable, searchable interface supporting graph visualization, node detail inspection,…", + "body": "The app must present the knowledge graph as a rich, browsable, searchable interface supporting graph visualization, node detail inspection, provenance tracing, decision exploration, filtering, search, and side-by-side baseline/candidate comparison.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 101, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Every content node in the domain model carries three orthogonal classification…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T8]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Every content node in the domain model carries three orthogonal classification axes: semantic role, epistemic status, and authority." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 102, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a lifecycle visibility toggle (archived, candidate, or withdrawn) is switched off, affected nodes must be hidden from the Sigma canvas…", + "body": "When a lifecycle visibility toggle (archived, candidate, or withdrawn) is switched off, affected nodes must be hidden from the Sigma canvas by setting the graphology node attribute 'hidden' to true — not by calling graph.dropNode() or rebuilding the graphology instance. Switching the toggle back on must restore those nodes by setting 'hidden' to false. Active nodes must have no toggle and must always be visible.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 103, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Decision nodes are described by the stakeholder as the most important hub type in the system.", + "body": "Decision nodes are described by the stakeholder as the most important hub type in the system.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 104, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The TypeScript type NodeRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must be a discriminated union on the 'kind' field with exactly two variants: one fo…", + "body": "The TypeScript type NodeRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must be a discriminated union on the 'kind' field with exactly two variants: one for kind='content' (including semanticRole, epistemicStatus, authority) and one for kind='hub' (including hubType, rationale). FrameRecord must declare a summary field typed as string | null. The file must import nothing from the spec-elicitation package. Verified by TypeScript compiler with zero type errors.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 105, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the bundler script processes frames.json entries that have no summary field, the resulting artifact.json must include summary: null on…", + "body": "When the bundler script processes frames.json entries that have no summary field, the resulting artifact.json must include summary: null on each such FrameRecord. The TypeScript type for FrameRecord in src/types/artifact.ts must declare summary as string | null, ensuring the UI type-checks without error against both null (current state) and a populated string (future state). Verified by running the bundler on the reference artifact and asserting summary is null on all four frame records.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR76]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 106, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view; (2)…", + "body": "The baseline/candidate comparison view must be triggerable from two entry points: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view; (2) clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel of a node with lifecycle=candidate.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R49]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 107, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The tech stack for the explorer UI is confirmed as Vite, React, and Tailwind CSS.", + "body": "The tech stack for the explorer UI is confirmed as Vite, React, and Tailwind CSS.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 108, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The comparison view must include a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node, closing the comparison o…", + "body": "The comparison view must include a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node, closing the comparison overlay and selecting that node in the main graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R52]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 109, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must be rendered at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes must be rendered at appr…", + "body": "When any filter or search is active, matching nodes must be rendered at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes must be rendered at approximately 15% opacity in the Sigma canvas. Edges where both endpoints are non-matching must also be dimmed. Graph topology must be preserved — no nodes or edges may be removed from the canvas during filtering.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 110, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "After loading the smoke-webhook reference artifact, the nodeIndex Map must contain exactly 761 entries (376 active + 88 archived + 288 cand…", + "body": "After loading the smoke-webhook reference artifact, the nodeIndex Map must contain exactly 761 entries (376 active + 88 archived + 288 candidate + 9 withdrawn). The edgeIndex Map must contain exactly 2,662 entries. The frameIndex must contain exactly 4 entries. These counts must match the totals in validation.json (totalNodes=761, totalEdges=2662, totalFrames=4). Any mismatch must be surfaced as a diagnostic warning in the console.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR85]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 111, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The micro view is a lineage-focused subgraph showing the spec at the current point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out, and includes a…", + "body": "The micro view is a lineage-focused subgraph showing the spec at the current point in time, with inactive nodes grayed out, and includes a snapshot selector (dropdown or slider) for scrubbing through revisions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 112, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must be collapsed and the central canvas must expand to occupy the full remaining width af…", + "body": "When no node is selected, the right detail panel must be collapsed and the central canvas must expand to occupy the full remaining width after the left sidebar.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 113, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal node-diff list showing which nodes changed in that frame.", + "body": "Clicking a frame card in the macro timeline must open a modal node-diff list showing which nodes changed in that frame. The full zoom-into-frame WebGL subgraph transition is explicitly deferred; the modal diff list is the required behavior for the current iteration.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R48]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 114, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The application must accept an optional ?artifact= query parameter; when present it must fetch artifact.json via fetch() from that URL…", + "body": "The application must accept an optional ?artifact= query parameter; when present it must fetch artifact.json via fetch() from that URL and bypass the drop zone, enabling remote sharing without user file selection.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 115, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "There is a potential conflict between the preference for browser File API loading (local filesystem drop zone) and the requirement that loa…", + "body": "There is a potential conflict between the preference for browser File API loading (local filesystem drop zone) and the requirement that loading also work when the app is hosted remotely. These two approaches may require different loading mechanisms.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 116, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The application must parse artifact.json as a single bundled file with the structure: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions,…", + "body": "The application must parse artifact.json as a single bundled file with the structure: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. Any artifact.json missing a required top-level key must produce a CRT-themed error state, not a crash or raw unstyled error.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 117, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The spec elicitation system is an experimental pipeline within Kael that takes conversational input (interview transcripts, context documen…", + "body": "The spec elicitation system is an experimental pipeline within Kael that takes conversational input (interview transcripts, context documents) and produces a structured specification as a knowledge graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 118, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Decision hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel's Connections section (X35, X10).", + "body": "Decision hub nodes receive a dedicated rendering mode in the detail panel's Connections section (X35, X10). The section renders: (1) a 'RATIONALE' block showing the decision's rationale prose in a styled blockquote with phosphor-amber left border; (2) a 'CONSIDERED' group listing all nodes connected by 'considered' edges, shown as clickable displayId pills; (3) a 'SELECTED' group with a green glow indicator showing the chosen alternative(s) via 'selected' edges; (4) a 'REJECTED' group with a dimmed red indicator showing rejected alternatives via 'rejected' edges; (5) a 'CONSEQUENCES' group listing nodes connected by 'consequence' or 'produced' edges. Each pill in these groups is clickable, navigating the detail panel to that node. A 'Trace to grounding' button traverses the support edges from the decision's considered nodes back to grounding-phase nodes and highlights that subgraph in the main Sigma canvas.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 119, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When artifact.json is missing any required top-level key (manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph, reports), the applicati…", + "body": "When artifact.json is missing any required top-level key (manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph, reports), the application must display a CRT-themed error state with a legible error message. No JavaScript exception may propagate to a blank screen or default browser error UI.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 120, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The macro view surfaces the regression/recovery narrative (X36) through explicit visual encoding of frame relationships: (1) The initial fr…", + "body": "The macro view surfaces the regression/recovery narrative (X36) through explicit visual encoding of frame relationships: (1) The initial frame trunk is rendered in phosphor-green as the primary timeline spine. (2) Rederive frames branch rightward and are rendered in phosphor-amber, with their connecting edge labeled with the triggerImpasseId (shown as a displayId badge). (3) Fan-in record edges connecting rederive frames back to the trunk are rendered in a brighter green with an arrow labeled 'RECONCILED'. (4) Impasse nodes referenced by triggerImpasseIds are shown as warning-colored hexagonal badges on the branch edges. (5) Perspective hub nodes (from the CSP model, X11) are shown as small purple indicator badges on their associated frame cards. (6) The nudgingActive flag on a rederive frame is shown as a 'NUDGED' indicator badge. Together these elements make the full impasse→rederive→fan-out→reconciliation cycle legible at a glance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 121, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The macro view shows the different frames and how they relate over time, including per-frame LLM-generated summaries, lines connecting fram…", + "body": "The macro view shows the different frames and how they relate over time, including per-frame LLM-generated summaries, lines connecting frames representing impasses/perspectives/derivation relationships, and the ability to zoom into a single frame to see which nodes changed.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 122, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Impasse hub nodes must render with a distinctive hexagonal shape in the micro-view Sigma graph, in addition to their warning-amber glow, ma…", + "body": "Impasse hub nodes must render with a distinctive hexagonal shape in the micro-view Sigma graph, in addition to their warning-amber glow, making them visually distinguishable from other hub node types at a glance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R60]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 123, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must use distinct visual encoding by type: trunk-to-rederive-branch edges (triggered by an impa…", + "body": "In the macro timeline, edges between frames must use distinct visual encoding by type: trunk-to-rederive-branch edges (triggered by an impasse) must be drawn in warning amber and labeled with the triggerImpasseId rendered as a displayId badge; fan-in record edges reconnecting rederive frames to the baseline must be drawn in bright green and labeled 'RECONCILED'. Verified by inspecting the rendered color and label of each edge in the reference artifact's macro timeline.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR59]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 124, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Authentication and multi-user features are out of scope.", + "body": "Authentication and multi-user features are out of scope.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 125, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "There is a tension between loading a single combined artifact.json (stakeholder preference) and loading individual artifact files from a di…", + "body": "There is a tension between loading a single combined artifact.json (stakeholder preference) and loading individual artifact files from a directory path or URL prefix (also a stated requirement). These two loading models may need reconciliation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 126, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "At load time the UI builds an in-memory graph store from artifact.json using a flat index structure: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (…", + "body": "At load time the UI builds an in-memory graph store from artifact.json using a flat index structure: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (Map), adjacency (Map), frameIndex (Map), snapshotIndex (Map), and derivedIndex (Map) built by joining validation.json errors to their source/target nodes. Lifecycle filter state is maintained as a reactive set of visible lifecycle values. The active node set for the micro view is derived from the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array. All indexes are built once on load; no re-parsing occurs during session.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 127, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, edge color must visually distinguish the three edge categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_…", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, edge color must visually distinguish the three edge categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) in dim amber; workflow edges (produced, considered, selected, rejected, consequence, conflicting_input, resolved_by, spawned, refined_to, aggregates) in brighter green; structural edges (conflicts_with, motivates, defines, references, satisfied_by, operationalized_by, alternative_to, revises_baseline, and all lineage edges) in muted cyan.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 128, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The comparison view must render as a split overlay that temporarily replaces or expands the right detail panel.", + "body": "The comparison view must render as a split overlay that temporarily replaces or expands the right detail panel. The left column must show the baseline node and the right column must show the candidate node. Differences in text, semantic role, epistemic status, and authority must be highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions and deletions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R50]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 129, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The app must operate entirely against statically loaded JSON artifact files with no backend, and must be deployable as a static site.", + "body": "The app must operate entirely against statically loaded JSON artifact files with no backend, and must be deployable as a static site.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 130, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a node is selected, all three layout regions must be simultaneously visible: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, and…", + "body": "When a node is selected, all three layout regions must be simultaneously visible: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, and right detail panel. Measuring computed widths of all three regions must return values greater than zero. No region may be hidden, collapsed, or overlaid by another during normal selected-node state.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 131, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers building the macro timeline view using WebGL so that future zoom-into-frame functionality is naturally achievable.", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers building the macro timeline view using WebGL so that future zoom-into-frame functionality is naturally achievable.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 132, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Pressing the Escape key must close the right detail panel and clear the current node selection.", + "body": "Pressing the Escape key must close the right detail panel and clear the current node selection. If a comparison overlay is open, Escape must close the comparison overlay and return to the detail panel rather than closing the detail panel.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 133, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A fan-in record captures the result of the reconciliation step where candidate…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T14]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A fan-in record captures the result of the reconciliation step where candidate branches are merged back into the active baseline after a fan-out/clean-room re-derivation cycle." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 134, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking any clickable displayId pill within the Connections section (in any of the decision, impasse, or justification group rows) must up…", + "body": "Clicking any clickable displayId pill within the Connections section (in any of the decision, impasse, or justification group rows) must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to the referenced node's id, causing the detail panel to re-render for that node and the main Sigma canvas selection highlight to move to that node. The panel history must allow the user to return to the previously selected node via browser back or a dedicated back control if provided.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR86]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 135, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Per-frame LLM summaries will be pre-generated by the elicitation pipeline during artifact bundling and stored in FrameRecord or a companion…", + "body": "Per-frame LLM summaries will be pre-generated by the elicitation pipeline during artifact bundling and stored in FrameRecord or a companion structure within artifact.json; they are not generated at runtime by the UI.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 136, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking any node in the provenance mini-graph must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to that node's id, causing the main detail p…", + "body": "Clicking any node in the provenance mini-graph must update selectedNodeId in the Zustand store to that node's id, causing the main detail panel to re-render for the clicked node and the main Sigma canvas selection to update accordingly. The mini-graph must then re-render to show the new node's upstream subgraph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR52]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 137, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The system must enable users to interactively explore a spec elicitation artifact as a read-only single-page web application.", + "body": "The system must enable users to interactively explore a spec elicitation artifact as a read-only single-page web application.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 138, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The toolbar must contain lifecycle visibility toggles for archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes.", + "body": "The toolbar must contain lifecycle visibility toggles for archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes. Active nodes must always be visible and cannot be toggled off. When a lifecycle toggle is changed, node visibility must be updated via Sigma's node attribute API (setting hidden=true/false) rather than rebuilding the graphology graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 139, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The perspective hub is modeled as a constraint satisfaction problem with axes, alternatives, constraints, and guarded impasses; perspective…", + "body": "The perspective hub is modeled as a constraint satisfaction problem with axes, alternatives, constraints, and guarded impasses; perspectives are a presentation layer derived from the CSP solver, not the primary semantic unit.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 140, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The file-loading mechanism must work when the app is hosted remotely.", + "body": "The file-loading mechanism must work when the app is hosted remotely. The app must not directly serve artifact files, because the website may be hosted remotely in the future.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 141, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When multiple filter dimensions are active simultaneously (e.g., phase=shaping AND semanticRole=design AND authority=derived), the results…", + "body": "When multiple filter dimensions are active simultaneously (e.g., phase=shaping AND semanticRole=design AND authority=derived), the results list must contain only nodes satisfying all active conditions. Enabling a second filter must never increase the result count. Verified by: activating two mutually constraining filters against the reference artifact and asserting the result set is the mathematical intersection of each filter applied individually.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 142, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "All interactive HTML elements must use visible focus rings styled in phosphor-amber, ensuring keyboard focus is always visible on the dark…", + "body": "All interactive HTML elements must use visible focus rings styled in phosphor-amber, ensuring keyboard focus is always visible on the dark background.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R58]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 143, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The confirmed artifact file layout is: graph/ subdirectory containing nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-rec…", + "body": "The confirmed artifact file layout is: graph/ subdirectory containing nodes.json, edges.json, frames.json, derivation-runs.json, fan-in-records.json, and snapshots.json; top-level containing manifest.json, sources.json, extracted-claims.json, and interventions.json.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 144, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a frame card's summary field is null (as is the case for all frames in the current reference artifact), the summary region of the fram…", + "body": "When a frame card's summary field is null (as is the case for all frames in the current reference artifact), the summary region of the frame card must display a muted placeholder text 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' in dimmed monospace style. No JavaScript error, broken layout, or missing DOM element may result from a null summary. When a summary string is present, it must be rendered in its place without any code change.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR58]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 145, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Authority identifies the source type of a node's claim.", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T6]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Authority identifies the source type of a node's claim. The four defined values are: stakeholder, technical, external, and derived." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 146, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The right detail panel must have four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded by default, showing full…", + "body": "The right detail panel must have four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded by default, showing full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator, and kind-specific classification fields; (2) Connections — hub-type-specific relationship tables; (3) Provenance — embedded Sigma.js mini-graph; (4) Validation — shown only when review status is not clean. The Identity section must always remain visible at the top.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 147, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the results list has focus and a row is highlighted via Arrow key navigation, pressing Enter must select that node: selectedNodeId in…", + "body": "When the results list has focus and a row is highlighted via Arrow key navigation, pressing Enter must select that node: selectedNodeId in the Zustand store must be set to the row's node id, and the right detail panel must open for that node with the flicker animation. Verified by simulating ArrowDown then Enter on the results list and asserting the store update and panel appearance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR73]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 148, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a node with lifecycle='candidate' is selected in the micro-view graph and the detail panel is open, a 'Compare' button must be visible…", + "body": "When a node with lifecycle='candidate' is selected in the micro-view graph and the detail panel is open, a 'Compare' button must be visible in the Identity section or the panel header. Nodes with lifecycle='active', 'archived', or 'withdrawn' must not show this button. Verified by selecting one candidate node and one active node from the reference artifact and asserting button presence/absence in each case.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR92]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 149, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers loading artifact.json from the user's local filesystem via the browser File API, with a landing screen presenting a…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers loading artifact.json from the user's local filesystem via the browser File API, with a landing screen presenting a file drop zone, requiring no server or URL.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 150, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers a CRT-inspired visual design language: a polished aesthetic evoking vintage phosphor displays with amber or green p…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers a CRT-inspired visual design language: a polished aesthetic evoking vintage phosphor displays with amber or green phosphor colors on dark backgrounds, subtle scanline textures, and gentle CRT glow/bloom effects on interactive elements.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 151, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "After artifact.json is parsed, all eight in-memory indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByE…", + "body": "After artifact.json is parsed, all eight in-memory indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByEdgeId, edgeIssuesByNodeId, interventionsByNodeId) must be fully populated before the main explorer UI renders. No index build or re-parse operation may be triggered by user interaction after this initial pass. Verified by: instrumenting the store initializer and asserting all Maps are non-empty after load with zero subsequent re-build calls during a full interaction session.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 152, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Application state must be managed in a single Zustand store containing: loadedArtifact, all derived indexes, activeView, selectedNodeId, se…", + "body": "Application state must be managed in a single Zustand store containing: loadedArtifact, all derived indexes, activeView, selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState, and comparisonState. React components must subscribe to fine-grained store slices to prevent unnecessary re-renders during filter and hover interactions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 153, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers: a detail panel with CRT power-on flicker animation (~150ms) rather than slide-in; collapsible sections with most i…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers: a detail panel with CRT power-on flicker animation (~150ms) rather than slide-in; collapsible sections with most important information always visible at top; top section showing full node text, displayId, phase badge, lifecycle badge, and review status indicator.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 154, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Each boundary between the three layout regions must have a visible drag handle.", + "body": "Each boundary between the three layout regions must have a visible drag handle. Dragging a handle must resize the adjacent panels proportionally in real time, with both panels maintaining a non-zero minimum width throughout the drag. After release, the new widths must persist for the remainder of the session.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 155, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For the reference artifact, the single snapshot at revision 4 lists all four frameIds in its frameIds array.", + "body": "For the reference artifact, the single snapshot at revision 4 lists all four frameIds in its frameIds array. When the snapshot slider is set to revision 4, the active node set must be derived from that snapshot's activeNodeIds array (376 active nodes). The status line below the slider must display revision 4 and all four frameId values (or their display equivalents). Verified by loading the reference artifact and reading the status line content.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR91]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 156, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The macro timeline is laid out as a vertical timeline showing one narrative from top to bottom, branching out horizontally at derivation lo…", + "body": "The macro timeline is laid out as a vertical timeline showing one narrative from top to bottom, branching out horizontally at derivation loops.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 157, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Every interactive HTML element (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have a visually distinct hover state that int…", + "body": "Every interactive HTML element (buttons, filter chips, panel headers, results list rows) must have a visually distinct hover state that intensifies glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and/or text-shadow. Verified by: programmatically triggering :hover on at least one element of each interactive type and asserting that the computed box-shadow or text-shadow value differs from the non-hovered state. No interactive element may have an identical computed style before and after hover.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR70]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 158, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The macro timeline must lay out the reference artifact's four frames correctly: the initial frame (mode=initial, id a03f944e) must appear o…", + "body": "The macro timeline must lay out the reference artifact's four frames correctly: the initial frame (mode=initial, id a03f944e) must appear on the main vertical trunk; the three rederive frames (ids 10f07753, b40fd568, b9236ccf, all with parentFrameId=a03f944e) must appear as horizontal siblings branching to the right at the same vertical level as each other, not as a vertical chain. Verified by inspecting the rendered positions of each frame card's center point on the WebGL canvas.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR56]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 159, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The provenance mini-graph within the node detail panel is acknowledged to be complex to implement, particularly ensuring it remains visuall…", + "body": "The provenance mini-graph within the node detail panel is acknowledged to be complex to implement, particularly ensuring it remains visually coherent with the main graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 160, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The comparison view must display the fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) as a decision banner betwee…", + "body": "The comparison view must display the fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) as a decision banner between the baseline and candidate columns. All nodes in the same fan-in grouping must be accessible via a tab row above the split columns.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R51]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 161, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder prefers displaying interventions in two places: in the node detail panel (showing which interventions targeted the node) an…", + "body": "The stakeholder prefers displaying interventions in two places: in the node detail panel (showing which interventions targeted the node) and as annotations on frames in the macro timeline.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 162, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The loading state, error state, and empty state (no artifact loaded) must each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments.", + "body": "The loading state, error state, and empty state (no artifact loaded) must each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments. No raw unstyled, blank, or default-browser-styled state may appear at any point during the application lifecycle.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R56]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 163, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The toolbar must display a global validation summary badge showing the total count of validation errors from validation.json.", + "body": "The toolbar must display a global validation summary badge showing the total count of validation errors from validation.json. The badge must pulse in amber when any errors are present.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 164, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The production build output (vite build) must consist entirely of static files (HTML, JS, CSS, assets) with no server-side runtime requirem…", + "body": "The production build output (vite build) must consist entirely of static files (HTML, JS, CSS, assets) with no server-side runtime requirement. Serving the dist/ directory from any static file host (e.g., GitHub Pages, S3, Netlify) must produce a fully functional application. Zero fetch() calls to a backend API may occur during normal operation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 165, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The spec elicitation pipeline uses fan-out/fan-in with clean-room re-derivation to handle contradictions, a perspective hub (CSP model) to…", + "body": "The spec elicitation pipeline uses fan-out/fan-in with clean-room re-derivation to handle contradictions, a perspective hub (CSP model) to present design alternatives, and reconciliation to merge candidates into the active baseline.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 166, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a search query is active, a results list must appear in the left sidebar below the filter controls, showing a scrollable list of match…", + "body": "When a search query is active, a results list must appear in the left sidebar below the filter controls, showing a scrollable list of matching nodes sorted by displayId. Each row must show the node's displayId, phase badge, semantic role or hub type badge, and truncated node text. The results list must remain visible simultaneously with the highlighted graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 167, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "artifact.json is the single bundled output file combining all pipeline output f…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T17]", + "detail": { + "definition": "artifact.json is the single bundled output file combining all pipeline output files, loaded by the explorer UI to provide all graph data, metadata, and reports." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 168, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A user who opens the application for the first time in a browser with no query parameters must be presented with the drop zone landing scre…", + "body": "A user who opens the application for the first time in a browser with no query parameters must be presented with the drop zone landing screen immediately, with no configuration dialogs, login prompts, URL entry fields, or setup steps. The drop zone must be the sole interactive element required to load an artifact. Verified by loading the app with no query params and asserting only the drop zone and optional file-picker button are the primary interactive elements.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR93]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 169, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the macro timeline, the initial frame card (mode=initial, id a03f944e) and the main trunk line connecting it must be rendered in phospho…", + "body": "In the macro timeline, the initial frame card (mode=initial, id a03f944e) and the main trunk line connecting it must be rendered in phosphor-green (#39FF14 or the defined phosphor-green token). Rederive frame cards must be rendered in phosphor-amber (#FFB000). Verified by sampling the rendered WebGL pixel color at the center of the initial frame card and at the center of one rederive frame card and comparing against the defined theme token values.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR88]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 170, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Each intervention record in interventions.json carries: id, frameId, phase, kind (e.g.", + "body": "Each intervention record in interventions.json carries: id, frameId, phase, kind (e.g. accept_candidate), targetNodeIds array, text (nullable), createdAt. Interventions are associated with a frame, not directly with individual nodes — the targetNodeIds array provides the node linkage.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X47]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 171, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, nodes must be visually colored with four distinct phosphor hues corresponding to the four derivation phases: groun…", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, nodes must be visually colored with four distinct phosphor hues corresponding to the four derivation phases: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done. The same four colors must appear on phase badge UI elements in the sidebar results list, the toolbar filter chips, and the detail panel phase badge — verified by comparing computed CSS color values across all locations.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 172, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Epistemic status expresses the evidentiary basis for a node's claim.", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T5]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Epistemic status expresses the evidentiary basis for a node's claim. The four defined values are: observed, asserted, assumed, and inferred." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 173, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Each row in the search results list must display: the node's displayId, a phase badge styled in the correct phase color, a semantic role ba…", + "body": "Each row in the search results list must display: the node's displayId, a phase badge styled in the correct phase color, a semantic role badge (for content nodes) or hub type badge (for hub nodes), and a truncated version of the node text. Verified by rendering the reference artifact, searching for a known term, and asserting all four elements are present in each result row's DOM.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 174, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the user switches from Micro view to Macro view and back to Micro view, the filter state (active phase chips, role checkboxes, search…", + "body": "When the user switches from Micro view to Macro view and back to Micro view, the filter state (active phase chips, role checkboxes, search query, lifecycle toggles) must be identical to what it was before switching. The Sigma canvas must restore the highlighting/dimming state reflecting the preserved filter. Verified by applying a multi-filter, switching views, and asserting the Zustand filterState is unchanged.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR90]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 175, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Loading a malformed artifact.json (e.g., a file with a valid JSON structure but missing the 'graph' key) must render a CRT-styled error scr…", + "body": "Loading a malformed artifact.json (e.g., a file with a valid JSON structure but missing the 'graph' key) must render a CRT-styled error screen with a descriptive message identifying the missing key. The error screen must use phosphor-amber or phosphor-text color on a phosphor-dim background, use the monospace font, and must not display any raw browser error dialog or white screen.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR81]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 176, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Inspecting the Sigma.js canvas element in the DOM must confirm it is a element with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl')…", + "body": "Inspecting the Sigma.js canvas element in the DOM must confirm it is a element with a WebGL rendering context (getContext('webgl') or getContext('webgl2') must return a non-null value). The application must not fall back to SVG or Canvas2D rendering for the micro-view graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 177, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, node opacity must match lifecycle state: active nodes at 100% opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% (±5%);…", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, node opacity must match lifecycle state: active nodes at 100% opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% (±5%); archived nodes at approximately 20% (±5%); withdrawn nodes at approximately 10% (±5%). Sampling one node of each lifecycle from the reference artifact and measuring the rendered alpha value via the WebGL shader uniform or Sigma attribute must confirm the correct opacity for each.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 178, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the Connections section of the detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section must list all intervention records that reference…", + "body": "In the Connections section of the detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section must list all intervention records that reference the selected node in their targetNodeIds array. Each entry must show: intervention kind, frameId (rendered as a link that activates the macro view focused on that frame), and createdAt timestamp. For a node not referenced by any intervention, the sub-section must either be absent or show an empty state message.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR63]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 179, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Every text-bearing element in the application — node text, displayIds, data values, filter chips, badge labels, panel headers, results list…", + "body": "Every text-bearing element in the application — node text, displayIds, data values, filter chips, badge labels, panel headers, results list rows, and toolbar controls — must render in a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or equivalent). Inspecting the computed font-family of a representative sample of 10 distinct element types must return a monospace font in all cases. No element may render in the browser default sans-serif or serif font.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR69]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 180, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Filter and selection state changes must be debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma canvas refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders…", + "body": "Filter and selection state changes must be debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma canvas refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders during text search input.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 181, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When artifact.json is successfully parsed, the application must transition to the main explorer view with a CRT power-on animation before d…", + "body": "When artifact.json is successfully parsed, the application must transition to the main explorer view with a CRT power-on animation before displaying any graph content. When the app is in the file-drop landing state, no raw unstyled or blank screen may appear.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 182, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "A subtle scanline CSS overlay sits above the WebGL canvas to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", + "body": "A subtle scanline CSS overlay sits above the WebGL canvas to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 183, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The phase color used for a node's glow in the Sigma micro-view graph must exactly match the color used for that node's phase badge in the d…", + "body": "The phase color used for a node's glow in the Sigma micro-view graph must exactly match the color used for that node's phase badge in the detail panel Identity section, the phase chip in the sidebar filter panel, and the phase badge in the results list row. Extracting the RGB value of each location for a known node (e.g., a grounding-phase node) must return identical values across all four locations.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR82]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 184, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For a justification hub node, the Connections section must render a PREMISES group (nodes via 'informed_by' edges) and a CONCLUSIONS group…", + "body": "For a justification hub node, the Connections section must render a PREMISES group (nodes via 'informed_by' edges) and a CONCLUSIONS group (nodes via 'produced' edges). Each entry in both groups must be a clickable pill that navigates the detail panel to the referenced node. Verified by mounting the detail panel for a known justification hub node and asserting both groups are present with correct node references.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR48]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 185, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The micro-view graph must be rendered using Sigma.js v3 with a WebGL backend.", + "body": "The micro-view graph must be rendered using Sigma.js v3 with a WebGL backend. The renderer must support interactive frame rates for the full reference dataset of 761 total nodes and 2,662 edges.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 186, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, every node with kind='content' must render as a circle and every node with kind='hub' must render as a diamond.", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, every node with kind='content' must render as a circle and every node with kind='hub' must render as a diamond. Sampling at least 20 nodes of each kind from the reference artifact and inspecting their rendered shapes via the Sigma node program must confirm the correct geometry for all sampled nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 187, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must be rendered with a per-node phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader.", + "body": "Nodes in the micro-view graph must be rendered with a per-node phosphor glow implemented as a WebGL fragment shader. The glow intensity must increase on hover and on selection, driven by shader uniforms updated in response to pointer events.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 188, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "A WebGL-based renderer gives less fine-grained control over individual node appearance compared to SVG-based alternatives, which may limit…", + "body": "A WebGL-based renderer gives less fine-grained control over individual node appearance compared to SVG-based alternatives, which may limit certain visual design options.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | stakeholder [RK2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 189, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The smoke-webhook artifact has 4 frames: one initial frame (mode=initial, entryPhase=grounding, no parent) and three rederive frames (mode=…", + "body": "The smoke-webhook artifact has 4 frames: one initial frame (mode=initial, entryPhase=grounding, no parent) and three rederive frames (mode=rederive, entryPhase=shaping, all sharing the same triggerImpasseId, all parented to the initial frame). The three rederive frames form siblings at attemptNumber 0, 1, 2 — not a linear chain. The last rederive frame (attemptNumber=2) has nudgingActive=true. Snapshots reference all 4 frameIds in a single checkpoint at revision 4.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X45]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 190, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Performance is managed through four mechanisms: (1) Web Worker layout: ForceAtlas2 runs off the main thread (covered in graph-layout-design…", + "body": "Performance is managed through four mechanisms: (1) Web Worker layout: ForceAtlas2 runs off the main thread (covered in graph-layout-design). (2) Sigma render batching: filter and selection state changes are debounced at 16ms before triggering a Sigma refresh, preventing per-keystroke re-renders during search. (3) Candidate/archived node toggling: when lifecycle visibility toggles change, node visibility is updated via Sigma's node attribute API (setting hidden=true/false) rather than rebuilding the graphology graph, which is O(nodes) not O(edges). (4) Provenance mini-graph depth cap: upstream traversal is capped at 50 nodes / depth-4 (covered in provenance-mini-graph-design). These four mechanisms together bound worst-case interaction latency for the reference dataset (376 active + 288 candidate + 88 archived nodes, 2662 edges).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 191, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The explorer UI will live as a sibling package at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/.", + "body": "The explorer UI will live as a sibling package at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 192, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A browser network log captured during a full interaction session (artifact load, graph exploration, filtering, detail panel, comparison vie…", + "body": "A browser network log captured during a full interaction session (artifact load, graph exploration, filtering, detail panel, comparison view) must show zero requests to any API endpoint or server beyond the optional initial artifact.json fetch (when using the ?artifact= URL param). All data operations must be resolved from the in-memory indexes. Verified using browser DevTools Network tab or a network interception test.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR79]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 193, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 376 active nodes, 88 archived nodes, 288 candidate nodes, and 9 withdrawn nodes.", + "body": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 376 active nodes, 88 archived nodes, 288 candidate nodes, and 9 withdrawn nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 194, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The derivation story view must clearly show the regression/recovery narrative: impasse discovered → clean-room re-derivation → fan-out → pe…", + "body": "The derivation story view must clearly show the regression/recovery narrative: impasse discovered → clean-room re-derivation → fan-out → perspective selection → reconciliation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 195, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The spec-elicitation-ui project is in early design and planning.", + "body": "The spec-elicitation-ui project is in early design and planning. No implementation decisions beyond the tech stack (Vite, React, Tailwind) have been confirmed.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 196, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a search query is entered, matching nodes must be highlighted in the Sigma canvas (full intensity) simultaneously with a scrollable re…", + "body": "When a search query is entered, matching nodes must be highlighted in the Sigma canvas (full intensity) simultaneously with a scrollable results list appearing in the sidebar below the filter controls. Both the canvas highlight state and the results list must be visible at the same time without any tab switch or mode change. The results list must be sorted by displayId.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 197, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display intervention annotation chips on its right edge, one chip per intervention record associ…", + "body": "Each frame card in the macro timeline must display intervention annotation chips on its right edge, one chip per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip must show the intervention kind and a count of targetNodeIds. Hovering a chip must show a tooltip listing the targetNodeIds as human-readable displayIds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R46]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 198, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro timeline must lay out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on a main trunk.", + "body": "The macro timeline must lay out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on a main trunk. Rederive frames must branch horizontally to the right of their parent frame as sibling columns at the same vertical level. The reference artifact's structure (one initial frame with three sibling rederive frames, all sharing the same triggerImpasseId) must be correctly represented as horizontal siblings, not a linear chain.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R42]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 199, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Kael is an AI assistant with persistent memory, built as a CLI tool using TypeScript, Effect, and Deno.", + "body": "Kael is an AI assistant with persistent memory, built as a CLI tool using TypeScript, Effect, and Deno.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 200, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The full-text search input must match nodes whose text field contains the query string (case-insensitive) AND nodes whose displayId contain…", + "body": "The full-text search input must match nodes whose text field contains the query string (case-insensitive) AND nodes whose displayId contains the query string. A search for 'DEC' must return all decision hub nodes whose displayId begins with 'DEC'. A search for a term appearing only in node text (e.g. 'circuit breaker') must return those nodes. A search for a string present in neither field must return an empty results list with an appropriate empty-state message.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR83]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 201, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Validation report data (from reports/validation in artifact.json) is integrated as follows: (1) At load time a validationIssuesByEdgeId Map…", + "body": "Validation report data (from reports/validation in artifact.json) is integrated as follows: (1) At load time a validationIssuesByEdgeId Map is built from validation.json errors. Since errors are edge-centric (per validation-report-context), a secondary edgeIssuesByNodeId Map is derived by walking each errored edge's source and target nodeIds. (2) In the micro-view graph, nodes with validation issues are rendered with a red-tinted glow halo in addition to their normal phase-color glow, implemented as a second glow pass in the WebGL shader. (3) In the node detail panel, the Validation section lists all errors touching edges incident to this node, showing rule, severity, message, and the edge's type and direction. (4) A global validation summary badge in the toolbar shows total error count and pulses amber when errors exist.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 202, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Keyboard navigation must be restricted to HTML panel controls only.", + "body": "Keyboard navigation must be restricted to HTML panel controls only. The Sigma WebGL canvas must have no keyboard event handlers. The implemented keyboard bindings must include: Escape closes the detail panel and clears selection (or closes comparison overlay); Tab/Shift-Tab moves focus between toolbar controls, filter chips, and results list; Enter on a focused results-list row selects that node; Arrow keys navigate between results-list items when the list has focus.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R57]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 203, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The application must be deployable as a static site with no server-side runtime.", + "body": "The application must be deployable as a static site with no server-side runtime. All artifact data must be derived from the client-loaded artifact.json; no API calls to a backend are permitted.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 204, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 2,662 edges across 17 distinct edge types.", + "body": "The smoke-webhook reference artifact contains 2,662 edges across 17 distinct edge types.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [E2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 205, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain the following controls: (1) a full-text search input matching against node text and displayId; (…", + "body": "The left sidebar filter panel must contain the following controls: (1) a full-text search input matching against node text and displayId; (2) phase filter chips for all four phases (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done); (3) semantic role multi-select checkboxes for all ten roles (goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, risk); (4) hub type toggle (all / decision / justification / impasse / perspective); (5) epistemic status chips for all four values (observed, asserted, assumed, inferred); (6) authority chips for all four values (stakeholder, technical, external, derived); (7) lifecycle visibility toggles mirroring the toolbar toggles.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 206, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Because FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field (RK5, E5), the macro view frame cards gracefully degrade: if a frame has no…", + "body": "Because FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field (RK5, E5), the macro view frame cards gracefully degrade: if a frame has no summary, the summary region displays a muted placeholder reading 'NO SUMMARY AVAILABLE' in a dimmed monospace style consistent with the CRT aesthetic. The UI treats the summary field as optional throughout — no runtime error, no broken layout. When the pipeline schema extension is implemented and summaries are present in artifact.json, the UI renders them without any code change.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 207, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Pressing Tab repeatedly from the toolbar must cycle focus through all interactive controls in order: toolbar controls, filter chips in the…", + "body": "Pressing Tab repeatedly from the toolbar must cycle focus through all interactive controls in order: toolbar controls, filter chips in the sidebar, and results list rows. Pressing Shift-Tab must reverse the direction. Focus must never become trapped or jump to the Sigma WebGL canvas. Verified by simulating Tab keystrokes in a jsdom or browser test environment and asserting focused element identity at each step.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR72]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 208, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The Tailwind configuration must define all five CRT theme tokens with exact hex values: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14),…", + "body": "The Tailwind configuration must define all five CRT theme tokens with exact hex values: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F), and phosphor-text (#FFD580). Verified by reading tailwind.config.* and asserting each token name and value is present. At runtime, inspecting the computed background-color of the landing page body must return a value matching #1A1A0F (phosphor-dim).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR68]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 209, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The app is strictly read-only.", + "body": "The app is strictly read-only. Editing nodes or edges is explicitly out of scope.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 210, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Connections section of the detail panel must include a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section listing all intervention records that re…", + "body": "The Connections section of the detail panel must include a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section listing all intervention records that reference the current node in their targetNodeIds array. Each entry must show the intervention kind, frameId (linked to the corresponding frame in the macro view), and createdAt timestamp. The interventionsByNodeId join must be pre-computed at load time.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R47]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 211, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Running the Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) against the smoke-webhook reference artifact directory must produce a single a…", + "body": "Running the Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) against the smoke-webhook reference artifact directory must produce a single artifact.json file whose top-level structure contains exactly the keys: manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph (with sub-keys nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots), and reports (with sub-key validation). The resulting file must be valid JSON parseable by JSON.parse() without error.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR75]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 212, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Justification hub nodes (hubType='justification') render in the detail panel's Connections section as: (1) a 'PREMISES' group showing nodes…", + "body": "Justification hub nodes (hubType='justification') render in the detail panel's Connections section as: (1) a 'PREMISES' group showing nodes connected by 'informed_by' edges (the upstream support nodes); (2) a 'CONCLUSIONS' group showing nodes connected by 'produced' edges (what this justification produced). The justification's text (its rationale statement) is shown in the Identity section as the primary text. This mirrors the ATMS-style justification model from the pipeline and enables users to trace exactly what combination of premises produced a given conclusion.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-design-statement | derived-inferred [D26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 213, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the application is loaded with a ?artifact= query parameter, it must fetch the artifact.json from that URL via fetch(), skip the…", + "body": "When the application is loaded with a ?artifact= query parameter, it must fetch the artifact.json from that URL via fetch(), skip the drop zone entirely, and transition directly to the main explorer view. No file selection is required from the user.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 214, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Every interactive HTML element must display a visible focus ring styled in phosphor-amber (#FFB000) when it receives keyboard focus.", + "body": "Every interactive HTML element must display a visible focus ring styled in phosphor-amber (#FFB000) when it receives keyboard focus. Verified by: tabbing through all interactive elements in the toolbar, filter panel, and results list, and asserting that the focused element's outline or box-shadow computed value includes a color matching #FFB000. No interactive element may have an invisible or default-browser focus indicator.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR71]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 215, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Edge types are organized into six categories: hub-generic edges, decision hub e…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T10]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Edge types are organized into six categories: hub-generic edges, decision hub edges, perspective hub edges, impasse hub edges, content edges, and lineage edges." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 216, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Review status is a tagged union on nodes with three variants: 'clean' (no issue…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T7]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Review status is a tagged union on nodes with three variants: 'clean' (no issues), 'suspect' (with causeIds indicating problems), and 'conditional' (with impasseIds indicating unresolved dependencies)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 217, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The subgraph zoom-into-frame feature for the macro view can be deferred to a later iteration.", + "body": "The subgraph zoom-into-frame feature for the macro view can be deferred to a later iteration.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 218, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a range slider whose min and max correspond to the lowest and highest revision numbers present in the a…", + "body": "The micro-view toolbar must contain a range slider whose min and max correspond to the lowest and highest revision numbers present in the artifact's snapshots array. The slider must display a numeric revision badge and a human-readable timestamp label for the currently selected snapshot. A status line below the slider must show the revision number and the frameId(s) associated with that snapshot.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 219, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Provenance section of the detail panel must render a second independent Sigma.js instance in approximately 280px of panel height, showi…", + "body": "The Provenance section of the detail panel must render a second independent Sigma.js instance in approximately 280px of panel height, showing the upstream derivation subgraph for the selected node. Traversal must follow support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards from the focal node. Traversal must be exhaustive for chains of 50 or fewer upstream nodes, and capped at depth 4 for larger chains. The focal node must appear at full glow. Ancestors must be laid out using graphology-layout-dagre in left-to-right derivation direction. Clicking any node in the mini-graph must navigate the main detail panel to that node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 220, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The landing page drop zone must be visually styled with a phosphor-glowing dashed border (using the phosphor-amber or phosphor-green color…", + "body": "The landing page drop zone must be visually styled with a phosphor-glowing dashed border (using the phosphor-amber or phosphor-green color token), a scanline texture, and dark background consistent with the CRT aesthetic. No element on the landing page may render with default browser styling, white background, or unstyled text. The drop zone must provide a visible affordance (e.g., icon and label) indicating file drop or selection.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR94]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 221, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL node program class as the main micro-view graph.", + "body": "The provenance mini-graph must use the same Sigma WebGL node program class as the main micro-view graph. Node colors, glow style, and shape encoding (circle for content, diamond for hub) must be visually identical between the two Sigma instances. Verified by comparing the Sigma program constructor reference used in both instances — they must be the same class.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR51]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 222, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Pressing the Escape key while the detail panel is open (and no comparison overlay is open) must close the detail panel and set selectedNode…", + "body": "Pressing the Escape key while the detail panel is open (and no comparison overlay is open) must close the detail panel and set selectedNodeId to null in the Zustand store. The canvas must expand to fill the vacated space. Pressing Escape when both the comparison overlay and the detail panel are open must close only the comparison overlay and leave the detail panel visible.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR44]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 223, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the upstream derivation chain of the selected node contains more than 50 nodes, the provenance mini-graph traversal must be capped at…", + "body": "When the upstream derivation chain of the selected node contains more than 50 nodes, the provenance mini-graph traversal must be capped at depth 4 from the focal node. When the chain is 50 nodes or fewer, traversal must be exhaustive. Verified by: selecting a deep-chain node from the reference artifact, confirming the mini-graph renders no more than depth-4 ancestors; then selecting a shallow-chain node and confirming all ancestors are rendered.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR50]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 224, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The CRT motif reinforces the idea of looking into a system's internals — it is the stakeholder's stated rationale for the visual design lan…", + "body": "The CRT motif reinforces the idea of looking into a system's internals — it is the stakeholder's stated rationale for the visual design language.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 225, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Typing rapidly into the search input must not trigger a Sigma canvas refresh on every keystroke.", + "body": "Typing rapidly into the search input must not trigger a Sigma canvas refresh on every keystroke. Measuring Sigma refresh calls during a burst of 10 keystrokes within 100ms must show no more than one refresh call, occurring no sooner than 16ms after the last keystroke. Verified by spying on the Sigma refresh method in a test environment.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 226, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The toolbar must display a validation summary badge showing the total error count from validation.json.", + "body": "The toolbar must display a validation summary badge showing the total error count from validation.json. For the reference artifact, this count must match the number of entries in the errors array in validation.json. When errors are present, the badge must have a pulsing amber CSS animation. The badge must be present from the moment the main explorer renders, before any node is selected.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR54]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 227, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The spec elicitation source code lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/.", + "body": "The spec elicitation source code lives at /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation/.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 228, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "Edges in the graph are organized into categories: support edges (derived_from,…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T9]", + "detail": { + "definition": "Edges in the graph are organized into categories: support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) carry epistemic weight; workflow edges (produced, resolved_by, selected) carry operational provenance; structural edges (alternative_to, conflicts_with) are informational with no derivation direction." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 229, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A semantic role classifies the epistemic function of a content node.", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T2]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A semantic role classifies the epistemic function of a content node. The ten defined values are: goal, term, context, constraint, evidence, design, alternative, requirement, criterion, and risk." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 230, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, lifecycle state must be encoded as node opacity: active nodes at full opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60…", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, lifecycle state must be encoded as node opacity: active nodes at full opacity; candidate nodes at approximately 60% opacity; archived nodes at approximately 20% opacity; withdrawn nodes at approximately 10% opacity.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 231, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "At every point in the application lifecycle — loading, error, and empty (no artifact loaded) — the UI must display a bespoke CRT-themed tre…", + "body": "At every point in the application lifecycle — loading, error, and empty (no artifact loaded) — the UI must display a bespoke CRT-themed treatment. Inspecting the DOM during each state must show no element with default browser font (sans-serif or serif), no unstyled text, and no blank white areas.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 232, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The CRT visual motif must feel like a beautiful, refined instrument — not a retro novelty.", + "body": "The CRT visual motif must feel like a beautiful, refined instrument — not a retro novelty. The UI must have no janky transitions or raw unstyled states anywhere.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 233, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation for the micro-view graph must run in a Web Worker so the UI thread is not blocked.", + "body": "The ForceAtlas2 layout computation for the micro-view graph must run in a Web Worker so the UI thread is not blocked. During layout computation, the canvas must display a CRT-styled 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' progress indicator. Layout positions must be cached in sessionStorage keyed by specId and snapshotRevision after the first computation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 234, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The node detail panel shows kind-specific fields in its first collapsible section: for content nodes this is semantic role, epistemic statu…", + "body": "The node detail panel shows kind-specific fields in its first collapsible section: for content nodes this is semantic role, epistemic status, and authority; for hub nodes this is hub type.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 235, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The stakeholder has defined two fundamental visualization views: a micro view and a macro view, both of which are required.", + "body": "The stakeholder has defined two fundamental visualization views: a micro view and a macro view, both of which are required.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 236, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When archived nodes are made visible via the lifecycle toggle, they must render at approximately 20% opacity, visually distinct from active…", + "body": "When archived nodes are made visible via the lifecycle toggle, they must render at approximately 20% opacity, visually distinct from active nodes (100% opacity) and candidate nodes (~60% opacity). The dimmed appearance must be consistent with the CRT aesthetic (no bright white glow on archived nodes). Verified by enabling the archived toggle and visually comparing an archived node (e.g., D22 / id 00cfa668) against an active neighbor.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR78]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 237, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The validation.json report has a flat structure: timestamp, totalNodes, totalEdges, totalFrames, and an errors array where each error has r…", + "body": "The validation.json report has a flat structure: timestamp, totalNodes, totalEdges, totalFrames, and an errors array where each error has rule, severity, message, and edgeId. The predominant error rule observed is 'phase-stratification' flagging derived_from edges that cross phase boundaries (e.g. shaping→grounding, pinning→grounding). The report is edge-centric, not node-centric — issues reference edgeIds, not nodeIds directly.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X46]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 238, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "A Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) must merge all pipeline output files into artifact.json with the schema: { manifest, sou…", + "body": "A Deno bundler script (scripts/bundle-artifact.ts) must merge all pipeline output files into artifact.json with the schema: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. For each FrameRecord, the bundler must add summary: null when no summary is present, so the UI always receives a well-typed FrameRecord.summary field of type string | null.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R59]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 239, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Kael maintains a memory graph with nodes connected by typed edges such as reinforces, derived_from, and tension_with, and has sleep phases…", + "body": "Kael maintains a memory graph with nodes connected by typed edges such as reinforces, derived_from, and tension_with, and has sleep phases (nap, dream) that consolidate and maintain it.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 240, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Archived nodes must be visually distinct from active nodes (e.g.", + "body": "Archived nodes must be visually distinct from active nodes (e.g. dimmed or reduced opacity) in a manner consistent with the CRT aesthetic.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 241, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Tailwind configuration must define the following CRT theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#…", + "body": "The Tailwind configuration must define the following CRT theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F) for backgrounds, and phosphor-text (#FFD580) for body text. These tokens must be used consistently across all UI components.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R53]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 242, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A provenance chain is the full upstream derivation path for a node: what it was…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T18]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A provenance chain is the full upstream derivation path for a node: what it was derived from, what informed it, and what source material (quotes, claims) it is grounded in." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 243, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The macro view must enable users to understand how the spec developed over time — not just how it looks at a single point — showing the nar…", + "body": "The macro view must enable users to understand how the spec developed over time — not just how it looks at a single point — showing the narrative from initial grounding through derivation loops and reconciliation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 244, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field; a schema extension is needed to add per-frame LLM-generated summaries to the artifa…", + "body": "FrameRecord does not currently include a summary field; a schema extension is needed to add per-frame LLM-generated summaries to the artifact.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [E5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 245, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The application must accept artifact.json via browser File API drag-and-drop or file picker on a full-screen landing page, without requirin…", + "body": "The application must accept artifact.json via browser File API drag-and-drop or file picker on a full-screen landing page, without requiring any server upload or URL configuration from the user.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 246, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Active nodes are shown by default in the UI.", + "body": "Active nodes are shown by default in the UI. The user can toggle archived, candidate, and withdrawn nodes to see the full history.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 247, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The smoke-test artifact for the webhook delivery system spec is located at /Users/bmahmoud/Desktop/smoke-webhook/ and serves as the referen…", + "body": "The smoke-test artifact for the webhook delivery system spec is located at /Users/bmahmoud/Desktop/smoke-webhook/ and serves as the reference dataset for development.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 248, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "On initial load, only active nodes must be visible in the Sigma canvas.", + "body": "On initial load, only active nodes must be visible in the Sigma canvas. The three lifecycle toggles (archived, candidate, withdrawn) must each independently control visibility of their respective node sets. Toggling 'candidate' on must make the 288 candidate nodes from the reference artifact visible at ~60% opacity. Toggling it off must hide them. Active nodes must remain visible regardless of any toggle state.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR77]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 249, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A frame is a unit of derivation history in the pipeline.", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T12]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A frame is a unit of derivation history in the pipeline. The macro view shows frames and how they relate over time. Frames may carry LLM-generated summaries describing what happened and what was important." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 250, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "In the micro-view graph, node color must encode derivation phase using four distinct phosphor hues — one for each of the four phases (groun…", + "body": "In the micro-view graph, node color must encode derivation phase using four distinct phosphor hues — one for each of the four phases (grounding, shaping, pinning, defining_done). The same four-hue palette must be used consistently across the micro graph, the provenance mini-graph, and all phase badge UI elements.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 251, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "For a decision node, the detail view must show its rationale, considered alternatives (via 'considered' edges), selection/rejection outcome…", + "body": "For a decision node, the detail view must show its rationale, considered alternatives (via 'considered' edges), selection/rejection outcomes (via 'selected'/'rejected' edges), and produced consequences (via 'consequence'/'produced' edges), with traceability back to grounding inputs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 252, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When the Provenance section is expanded for a selected node, a second independent Sigma.js instance must be mounted in a container of appro…", + "body": "When the Provenance section is expanded for a selected node, a second independent Sigma.js instance must be mounted in a container of approximately 280px height. The mini-graph must render the upstream derivation subgraph of the selected node, traversing support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards. The focal node must appear at full glow intensity. Ancestor layout must use graphology-layout-dagre in left-to-right direction.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR49]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 253, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A hub type identifies a node that aggregates structural reasoning rather than c…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T3]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A hub type identifies a node that aggregates structural reasoning rather than carrying content. The four defined hub types are: justification, decision, impasse, and perspective." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 254, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "At artifact load time, the application must build the following in-memory indexes in a single synchronous pass: nodeIndex (Map),…", + "body": "At artifact load time, the application must build the following in-memory indexes in a single synchronous pass: nodeIndex (Map), edgeIndex (Map), adjacency (Map), frameIndex (Map), snapshotIndex (Map), validationIssuesByEdgeId (Map), edgeIssuesByNodeId (Map), and interventionsByNodeId (Map). No re-parsing or re-indexing must occur during the session.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [R18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 255, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The file-loading mechanism must require zero configuration from the user.", + "body": "The file-loading mechanism must require zero configuration from the user.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X42]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 256, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Validation section of the detail panel must appear only when the node's review status is not 'clean'.", + "body": "The Validation section of the detail panel must appear only when the node's review status is not 'clean'. It must list all validation errors from validation.json that touch edges incident to the selected node, showing for each error: rule, severity, message, edge type, and edge direction. Suspect nodes must show causeId links and conditional nodes must show impasseId links.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [R39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 257, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The Zustand store must expose the following top-level keys, all populated after artifact load: loadedArtifact, nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjace…", + "body": "The Zustand store must expose the following top-level keys, all populated after artifact load: loadedArtifact, nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIssuesByEdgeId, edgeIssuesByNodeId, interventionsByNodeId, activeView, selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState, comparisonState. Inspecting the store via a test or React DevTools must confirm all keys are present and correctly typed after a successful artifact parse.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [CR32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 258, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle control with exactly two states: Micro and Macro.", + "body": "The top toolbar must contain a view-mode toggle control with exactly two states: Micro and Macro. Activating Micro must mount the Sigma.js WebGL canvas in the central area. Activating Macro must unmount the Sigma canvas and mount the dedicated macro WebGL timeline canvas in its place. The toggle state must be reflected in the Zustand store's activeView field.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-inferred [CR12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 259, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A SnapshotRecord is a checkpoint in the artifact that includes an activeNodeIds…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T11]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A SnapshotRecord is a checkpoint in the artifact that includes an activeNodeIds array indicating which nodes are active at that point in time, enabling the UI to reconstruct the graph state at any historical snapshot." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 260, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A derivation phase is one of four ordered stages in the spec elicitation pipeli…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T1]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A derivation phase is one of four ordered stages in the spec elicitation pipeline: grounding (goals, terms, constraints), shaping (designs, decisions, alternatives), pinning (requirements), and defining_done (acceptance criteria). Phases have strict dependency order." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 261, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Polish in both design and interactions is essential: transitions must be smooth, hover states must feel alive, and the UI must reward explo…", + "body": "Polish in both design and interactions is essential: transitions must be smooth, hover states must feel alive, and the UI must reward exploration.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 262, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use Sigma.js v3 with WebGL backend and a custom phosphor-glow fragment shader.", + "body": "Use Sigma.js v3 with WebGL backend and a custom phosphor-glow fragment shader.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC4]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The micro-view graph is rendered using Sigma.js (v3) with a WebGL backend. Nodes are drawn with a custom WebGL fragment shader implementing per-node phosphor glow whose intensity is driven by a uniform updated on hover and selection state. Node color encodes derivation phase (4 distinct phosphor hues). Node shape encodes kind (circle = content, diamond = hub). Edge color encodes category: support edges in dim amber, workflow edges in brighter green, structural edges in muted cyan. Lifecycle state is encoded as opacity: active = full, archived = 20% opacity, candidate = 60% opacity, withdrawn = 10% opacity. The Sigma canvas is overlaid with a CSS scanline texture layer (pointer-events: none) to reinforce the CRT aesthetic.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Use Cytoscape.js with its WebGL renderer (cytoscape-gl or pixi.js extension). Richer built-in layout algorithms and compound node support, but less control over custom shader effects and heavier bundle size.", + "Alternative: Render the graph using D3-force with SVG. Provides per-element CSS control, easy CRT filter effects via SVG filter primitives, and simpler hit-testing, but SVG degrades significantly beyond ~1,000 nodes and edges." + ], + "rationale": "Sigma.js is the stakeholder's stated preference (X16) and is purpose-built for large graph rendering via WebGL, directly addressing RK1 (376+ active nodes, 2,662 edges). Its custom WebGL program API allows implementing the phosphor glow shader per X40 with direct uniform control for hover intensity. D3/SVG (alt 1) cannot handle the dataset size at interactive frame rates. Cytoscape (alt 2) has heavier abstractions that would impede the custom shader work required for the CRT aesthetic, and RK2 notes that WebGL gives less fine-grained per-node control than SVG — Sigma's program API mitigates this by exposing shader-level control." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 263, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Right-side collapsible panel with CRT power-on flicker animation; four collapsible sections; embedded provenance mini-graph.", + "body": "Right-side collapsible panel with CRT power-on flicker animation; four collapsible sections; embedded provenance mini-graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC7]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The right detail panel activates on node click with a ~150ms CRT power-on flicker animation (opacity pulses 0→0.3→0.1→1 over 150ms via CSS keyframes). The panel has four collapsible sections rendered top-to-bottom: (1) Identity — always expanded: full node text, displayId badge, phase badge, lifecycle badge, review status indicator (clean/suspect/conditional with cause links), kind-specific classification fields (semanticRole + epistemicStatus + authority for content nodes; hubType for hubs); (2) Connections — hub-type-specific relationship table: for decision hubs shows rationale prose, considered/selected/rejected/consequence edges grouped with linked displayIds per X35; for impasse hubs shows conflicting_input/resolved_by/spawned/refined_to; for justification hubs shows informed_by/produced; (3) Provenance — an embedded Sigma.js mini-graph (max ~50 upstream nodes) showing the full derivation chain per X25, with clickable nodes that navigate the main panel; (4) Validation — only shown when review status is not clean: lists suspect causeIds and conditional impasseIds with links, and lists any validation report errors touching this node's edges. Escape key closes the panel per X28.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Open node detail as a full-screen modal overlay rather than a persistent side panel. Maximizes reading space but destroys the graph context while the detail is open, preventing navigation by clicking nodes in the background.", + "Alternative: Show node detail in a bottom drawer that expands upward, preserving the full left-right canvas width. Works well on wide monitors but reduces vertical canvas space significantly and is inconsistent with the three-region layout design." + ], + "rationale": "The right panel keeps the graph visible alongside the detail, enabling the user to follow provenance links in the mini-graph (X25) and click adjacent nodes without losing context — the modal (alt 1) destroys this. The bottom drawer (alt 2) cuts vertical canvas space, which is critical for the macro timeline view. The four-section collapsible structure satisfies X24's requirement that the most important information (Identity) is always visible at top. The flicker animation is explicitly preferred by the stakeholder (X24) over slide-in." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 264, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Keyboard navigation covers only HTML panel controls; Sigma canvas is mouse/touch only.", + "body": "Keyboard navigation covers only HTML panel controls; Sigma canvas is mouse/touch only.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC14]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Keyboard navigation covers panel controls only, not the Sigma canvas (per X28 and C11). Implemented bindings: Escape closes the detail panel and clears node selection; Tab / Shift-Tab moves focus between toolbar controls, filter chips, and the results list; Enter on a focused results-list row selects that node (opens detail panel); Arrow keys navigate between results list items when the list has focus; Escape from the comparison overlay closes comparison and returns to the detail panel. All interactive HTML elements use standard focus rings styled in phosphor-amber to remain visible on the dark background. The Sigma canvas itself has no keyboard event handlers; it receives only mouse and touch events.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Implement full ARIA graph navigation with keyboard traversal of graph nodes (focus moves between nodes via arrow keys, Tab enters/exits the graph). Significantly more accessible but explicitly out of scope per X28 and C11, and technically complex with a WebGL canvas." + ], + "rationale": "X28 and C11 explicitly restrict keyboard navigation to panel controls. Full ARIA graph traversal (alt 1) is explicitly out of scope and would require complex keyboard hit-testing against WebGL-rendered node positions. The defined bindings cover all panel interactions needed for productive exploration without a mouse." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 265, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Embedded second Sigma.js instance for provenance visualization, with dagre hierarchical layout and depth cap.", + "body": "Embedded second Sigma.js instance for provenance visualization, with dagre hierarchical layout and depth cap.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC8]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The provenance mini-graph inside the detail panel is a second, independent Sigma.js instance mounted in a ~280px tall panel region. It renders only the upstream derivation subgraph for the selected node: traversing support edges (derived_from, depends_on, informed_by) and hub-generic edges (produced, informed_by) backwards from the focal node up to a configurable depth (default: exhaustive for graphs ≤50 upstream nodes, capped at depth-4 for larger chains). The focal node is rendered at full glow at center; ancestors are positioned using a left-to-right hierarchical layout (graphology-layout-dagre) to reflect derivation direction. Nodes are clickable: clicking navigates the main detail panel to that node, updating both the main graph selection and the mini-graph. Visual style (colors, glow, scanlines) is shared via the same Sigma program class used in the main graph.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Replace the mini-graph with a structured text list of upstream nodes (grouped by edge type), each as a clickable pill. Avoids the complexity of a second Sigma instance (RK3) but loses the spatial/relational context that a graph provides." + ], + "rationale": "The stakeholder explicitly prefers a Sigma.js mini-graph for provenance (X25) and calls out that it must be visually coherent with the main graph. A text list (alt) satisfies navigation but not spatial provenance comprehension, which is central to G2 (tracing provenance). RK3 acknowledges the complexity; the depth cap (≤50 nodes / depth-4) bounds the worst-case rendering cost. Reusing the same Sigma program class minimizes the implementation delta and guarantees visual coherence." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 266, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use a slider for snapshot selection, preserving graph topology by opacity rather than node removal.", + "body": "Use a slider for snapshot selection, preserving graph topology by opacity rather than node removal.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC9]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The micro view is the default view on artifact load. It renders the full node+edge graph in Sigma.js with the snapshot selector in the top toolbar. The snapshot selector is a slider (with a numeric revision badge and timestamp label) that scrubs through SnapshotRecord revisions. On snapshot change, the active node set is recomputed from the selected snapshot's activeNodeIds array: nodes not in activeNodeIds are rendered at near-zero opacity (effectively hidden) rather than removed from the Sigma graph, preserving topology for context. A 'Show inactive' toggle in the toolbar reveals archived/candidate/withdrawn nodes at reduced opacity per X32 and X33. The current snapshot's revision number and frameId(s) are shown as a status line below the slider.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Replace the snapshot slider with a dropdown menu listing each snapshot by revision number and timestamp. More explicit labeling but slower to scrub through revisions sequentially." + ], + "rationale": "X20 describes a 'dropdown or slider' but a slider affords scrubbing through the derivation history which is far more expressive for understanding temporal evolution (G3). Preserving topology (opacity vs removal) is essential so users retain spatial memory of node positions as they scrub — removing nodes would cause disorienting layout thrash since ForceAtlas2 positions are pinned after initial computation. The dropdown alt is retained as a labeled companion control (showing the current revision name) but the primary interaction is the slider." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 267, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use Web Worker ForceAtlas2 layout computed at runtime, cached in sessionStorage.", + "body": "Use Web Worker ForceAtlas2 layout computed at runtime, cached in sessionStorage.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC5]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The micro-view graph uses a force-directed layout (Sigma's built-in ForceAtlas2 via graphology-layout-forceatlas2) computed via a Web Worker on first load so the UI thread is not blocked. Layout positions are cached in sessionStorage keyed by specId+snapshotRevision. When the user scrubs to a different snapshot, only node visibility (opacity) changes — layout positions are not recomputed. The initial layout run is shown with a CRT-style 'COMPUTING LAYOUT...' progress indicator on the canvas.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Use a hierarchical/DAG layout (e.g. graphology-layout-dagre) that reflects phase ordering (grounding → shaping → pinning → defining_done) top-to-bottom, trading force-directed organic clustering for explicit phase structure.", + "Alternative: Pre-compute and store layout positions in the artifact.json bundle at generation time, eliminating the Web Worker layout step entirely at the cost of larger artifact files." + ], + "rationale": "Force-directed layout naturally clusters semantically related nodes through the edge structure, which better serves G4's goal of understanding relationships than a rigid hierarchical layout. Pre-computing positions (alt 2) would bloat artifact.json and couple the bundler to layout logic that properly belongs in the UI. Hierarchical layout (alt 1) would produce a very tall graph given 376+ nodes across 4 phases and would degrade for the many cross-phase derived_from edges present in the reference dataset (per validation-report-context). Web Worker prevents UI jank during the ~1-2 second computation for the reference dataset size." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 268, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Tailwind theme tokens + CSS primitives for UI chrome; WebGL shader only for Sigma node glow.", + "body": "Tailwind theme tokens + CSS primitives for UI chrome; WebGL shader only for Sigma node glow. CSS blur filter used to approximate glow on HTML elements.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC12]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The CRT visual design system is implemented as a Tailwind CSS theme extension plus a small set of reusable CSS/WebGL primitives. Tailwind theme tokens: phosphor-amber (#FFB000), phosphor-green (#39FF14), phosphor-cyan (#00FFEF), phosphor-dim (#1A1A0F) for backgrounds, phosphor-text (#FFD580) for body text. Typography: a monospaced font (JetBrains Mono or similar) for node text, displayIds, and data values; a slightly wider monospace for headers. CRT primitives: (a) scanline-overlay — a fixed CSS pseudo-element using a repeating-linear-gradient of 1px transparent / 1px rgba(0,0,0,0.15) stripes, pointer-events:none, placed above the WebGL canvas; (b) glow-text — a Tailwind utility applying text-shadow in the node's phase color; (c) flicker-in — a CSS @keyframes animation (0% opacity:0, 30% opacity:0.4, 45% opacity:0.1, 100% opacity:1) running 150ms ease-in used for panel power-on; (d) phosphor-border — a box-shadow utility combining inset and outer glow in the phase color at low alpha. All interactive elements (buttons, chips, panel headers) use hover states that intensify glow via CSS transition on box-shadow and text-shadow. No raw unstyled states exist: the loading state, error state, and empty states each have bespoke CRT-themed treatments.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Implement all CRT effects purely in CSS (SVG filter feGaussianBlur for glow, CSS animations for flicker) without any WebGL shader involvement for the UI chrome, relying on Sigma's custom program only for node glow. Simpler but the glow effect on CSS elements will not match the WebGL node glow, creating visual inconsistency." + ], + "rationale": "Full CSS implementation (alt 1) was actually selected with a clarification: the node glow in Sigma is WebGL (per X40 and the graph-renderer decision), but all HTML UI elements use CSS box-shadow/text-shadow for glow effects — this is intentional. The visual gap between CSS glow (on panels, chips, buttons) and WebGL glow (on graph nodes) is acceptable and is bridged by matching the glow color palette. Attempting to route HTML element rendering through WebGL would be vastly over-engineered. The design system's value is in the Tailwind token vocabulary, the scanline overlay primitive, and the flicker-in keyframes, which together ensure no raw unstyled states exist (C7) and all transitions feel alive (C8)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 269, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Build the macro timeline as a dedicated WebGL canvas (raw WebGL with a thin abstraction), separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas.", + "body": "Build the macro timeline as a dedicated WebGL canvas (raw WebGL with a thin abstraction), separate from the Sigma micro-view canvas.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC10]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The macro view replaces the Sigma canvas with a WebGL-rendered vertical timeline built using raw WebGL (via a thin abstraction layer, not a graph library). The timeline lays out frames top-to-bottom chronologically on the main trunk. Rederive frames branch horizontally to the right of their parent frame as sibling columns at the same vertical level, reflecting the fan-out topology observed in the reference artifact (all three rederive attempts are siblings of the initial frame, not a linear chain). Each frame is rendered as a rectangular card with: frame mode badge (initial / rederive), entryPhase label, attemptNumber, nudgingActive indicator, createdAt timestamp, and the pre-generated LLM summary text if present (gracefully omitted with a 'no summary' placeholder if absent per RK5). Edges between frames encode relationship type: trunk-to-branch edges for triggerImpasseId linkage (drawn in warning amber), fan-in-record edges connecting rederive frames back to baseline (drawn in success green). Interventions associated with a frame are shown as small annotation chips on the frame card's right edge per X26. Clicking a frame card zooms the view to show which nodes changed in that frame (deferred per C10 to a later iteration — click opens a modal node-diff list instead).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Represent frames as super-nodes in the same Sigma.js instance as the micro graph, using Sigma's camera zoom to transition between macro and micro views. Avoids a separate WebGL context but conflates two very different data models in one renderer, making the frame-card UI elements (text, badges, annotation chips) very difficult to implement.", + "Alternative: Build the macro timeline as a standard SVG/HTML component (e.g. using D3 for the layout math but rendering with React/SVG). Simpler to implement, easier to style with CSS, but does not enable the future zoom-into-frame WebGL transition that the stakeholder requires (X29)." + ], + "rationale": "X29 explicitly requires WebGL for the macro view to enable future zoom-into-frame. SVG/HTML (alt 1) cannot deliver a smooth zoom transition into the Sigma micro-graph. Reusing the Sigma instance (alt 2) conflates two incompatible data models and makes the rich frame-card UI (summaries, intervention chips, badges) nearly impossible within Sigma's node rendering model. A separate WebGL canvas gives full control over the frame-card visual language while keeping the door open for a seamless WebGL-to-WebGL zoom transition in a future iteration. The thin abstraction layer (rather than a full scene-graph library) keeps the bundle small and the rendering logic transparent." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 270, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Bundle all pipeline output into a single artifact.json; the UI loads only this file.", + "body": "Bundle all pipeline output into a single artifact.json; the UI loads only this file.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC1]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "A dedicated bundler script (part of the spec-elicitation package, not the UI) merges all pipeline output files into a single artifact.json. The merged structure is: { manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, graph: { nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, snapshots }, reports: { validation } }. The UI loads only this one file. The bundler is a Deno CLI script invoked after a pipeline run completes.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Bundle the artifact as a ZIP archive containing the original directory structure; the UI uses a JS ZIP library to decompress and access files in-memory after the user drops the archive.", + "Alternative: The UI loads individual files lazily from a user-supplied directory path or URL prefix, fetching each file on demand rather than requiring a pre-bundled artifact.json." + ], + "rationale": "A single flat JSON file satisfies C6 (remote hosting compatibility) and X18 (File API drop zone) simultaneously: the user drops one file regardless of whether the app is local or remote-hosted. Lazy directory loading (alt 1) fails C6 when hosted remotely because browsers cannot access local filesystem paths. ZIP (alt 2) adds a decompression dependency and is less transparent/inspectable than plain JSON. The bundler lives in spec-elicitation (Deno/TypeScript), matching the existing toolchain. The merged schema is straightforward given the known file set (E4)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 271, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Primary loading via browser File API drop zone; secondary loading via ?artifact= URL query param for remote sharing.", + "body": "Primary loading via browser File API drop zone; secondary loading via ?artifact= URL query param for remote sharing.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC2]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The app opens on a full-screen landing page featuring a CRT-styled drop zone (phosphor-glowing dashed border, scanline texture). The user drops or selects artifact.json via the browser File API (no server upload). On successful parse the app transitions to the main explorer with a CRT power-on animation. An optional URL query param (?artifact=) allows linking to a remotely hosted artifact.json for sharing — the app fetches it via fetch() when present, bypassing the drop zone.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Skip the File API entirely; require the user to host artifact.json at a URL and enter that URL in a text field. Simpler, but breaks the local-first zero-config requirement." + ], + "rationale": "File API drop zone satisfies X18 and X42 (zero config, local filesystem). The URL query param resolves RK6 (remote hosting compatibility) without complicating the primary path. URL-only (alt) violates X42. This dual-path design means both local and remote artifact access work against a static-hosted app, fully satisfying C6." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 272, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Show interventions in both the macro frame cards and the node detail panel, with a pre-computed interventionsByNodeId join index.", + "body": "Show interventions in both the macro frame cards and the node detail panel, with a pre-computed interventionsByNodeId join index.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC15]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Interventions are displayed in two places per X26: (1) In the macro view, each frame card shows a row of small intervention chips on its right edge, one per intervention record associated with that frameId. Each chip shows the intervention kind (e.g. 'accept_candidate') and a count of targetNodeIds. Hovering a chip shows a tooltip listing the targetNodeIds as displayIds. (2) In the node detail panel, a collapsible 'Interventions' sub-section (within the Connections section) lists interventions that reference the current node in their targetNodeIds array, showing kind, frameId (linked to the macro view), and timestamp. The intervention-to-node join is pre-computed at load time as an interventionsByNodeId Map.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Show interventions only in the macro view frame cards, not in the node detail panel. Lower implementation cost (avoids the interventionsByNodeId join), but loses the ability to see which interventions targeted a specific node from that node's perspective." + ], + "rationale": "X26 explicitly requires both locations. RK4 acknowledges the higher implementation cost but the stakeholder's preference is clear. The interventionsByNodeId Map is a simple O(n) pass over the interventions array at load time and adds negligible cost. Macro-only display (alt 1) would mean a user viewing a candidate node has no way to see that it was accepted by a human intervention without leaving the detail panel to find the frame — a significant navigation burden." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 273, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Split-panel overlay triggered from fan-in records or candidate node detail, showing text diff and fan-in rationale.", + "body": "Split-panel overlay triggered from fan-in records or candidate node detail, showing text diff and fan-in rationale.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC11]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Side-by-side baseline/candidate comparison is triggered by: (1) clicking a fan-in record entry in the macro view, or (2) selecting a node with lifecycle=candidate and clicking a 'Compare' button in the detail panel. The comparison opens as a split overlay that temporarily replaces the right detail panel (or expands to full-panel width). The left column shows the baseline node (or the best_selected grouping winner from fan-in-records.json), the right column shows the candidate node. Differences in text, semantic role, epistemic status, and authority are highlighted using a line-diff style with phosphor-colored additions/deletions. The fan-in grouping rationale (from fan-in-records.json groupings[].rationale) is shown between the two columns as a decision banner. All nodes in the grouping are accessible via a tab row above the split. The comparison panel has a 'View in graph' action that focuses the main Sigma canvas on the baseline node.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Show baseline and candidate as two differently-styled node clusters in the main Sigma graph simultaneously, with lineage edges (equivalent_to, refined_by etc.) highlighted between them. More spatially honest but visually overwhelming given the large candidate node count (288 candidates in the reference artifact)." + ], + "rationale": "The graph overlay alternative (alt 1) is impractical at the reference dataset scale: 288 candidate nodes rendered simultaneously with 376 active nodes would saturate the canvas and the AND-filter dimming model would conflict with comparison highlighting. The split-panel approach isolates the comparison to the specific grouping being examined (per fan-in-records groupings structure), which matches how reconciliation actually works in the pipeline. The fan-in rationale is the key semantic bridge between candidate and baseline and deserves a prominent display position, which the split panel's center banner provides." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 274, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Persistent left sidebar filter panel with inline results list.", + "body": "Persistent left sidebar filter panel with inline results list.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC6]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The left sidebar hosts a filter+search panel with the following controls: (1) a full-text search input that matches against node text and displayId; (2) phase filter chips (grounding / shaping / pinning / defining_done); (3) semantic role multi-select checkboxes (10 roles from T2); (4) hub type toggle (all / decision / justification / impasse / perspective); (5) epistemic status chips; (6) authority chips; (7) lifecycle visibility toggles (active always on; archived/candidate/withdrawn toggleable per X32). All active filters combine with AND logic per X27. When any filter or search is active, Sigma re-renders with matching nodes at full glow intensity and non-matching nodes at 15% opacity; edges are dimmed when both endpoints are non-matching. The results panel below the filters shows a scrollable list of matching nodes sorted by displayId, each row showing displayId, phase badge, role/type badge, and truncated text.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Replace the sidebar filter panel with a command-palette (Cmd+K style) overlay for search, with graph-level filter controls only on the toolbar. Saves sidebar space but separates search results from filter controls and reduces discoverability." + ], + "rationale": "X38 explicitly requires that search highlight nodes in the graph AND show a results list simultaneously — a command palette (alt 1) collapses after selection and cannot maintain a persistent results list alongside the live graph. The sidebar keeps all filter dimensions (phase, role, lifecycle, authority, epistemic status) visible and adjustable without modal interruption, which is essential for exploratory navigation of a 376+ node graph. AND-logic across all active filters (X27) is most natural to communicate in a persistent panel where users can see all active filter chips at once." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 275, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use Zustand for application state management.", + "body": "Use Zustand for application state management.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC13]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Application state is managed using Zustand (a lightweight React state manager). A single store holds: loadedArtifact (the parsed artifact.json), all derived indexes (nodeIndex, edgeIndex, adjacency, frameIndex, snapshotIndex, validationIndex), activeView ('micro' | 'macro'), selectedNodeId, selectedSnapshotRevision, filterState (lifecycle visibility, phase chips, role selection, search query), and comparisonState (active fan-in grouping). The store is initialized once on artifact load; all derived indexes are computed synchronously in a single pass and stored as plain Maps. React components subscribe to fine-grained store slices to minimize re-renders. No server state, no async store updates after load (C4).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: Use React Context + useReducer with no external state library. Zero dependencies, but Context re-renders on every state change unless carefully memoized — with a 376-node graph and frequent hover/filter state updates this would cause performance issues.", + "Alternative: Use Redux Toolkit for state management. More structured with time-travel debugging, but significantly more boilerplate for a read-only single-load application where immutability guarantees add no practical benefit." + ], + "rationale": "Zustand's slice-based subscription model is ideal for a read-only explorer: the graph canvas subscribes only to filter/selection state, the detail panel subscribes only to selectedNodeId, and the macro view subscribes only to activeView. This minimizes re-renders from hover and filter interactions on a 376+ node dataset. Redux (alt 1) is over-engineered for a read-only, single-load app with no async mutations. React Context (alt 2) would cause cascading re-renders on every filter keystroke unless heavily memoized, adding complexity that Zustand handles automatically." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 276, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use a three-region resizable split layout: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, right detail panel.", + "body": "Use a three-region resizable split layout: left sidebar (filter/search/results), central canvas, right detail panel.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC3]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "The main explorer shell uses a three-region layout: (1) a narrow left sidebar containing the filter/search panel and a node-list results panel; (2) a large central canvas area that hosts either the micro-view graph or the macro-view timeline depending on the active view mode; (3) a right-side detail panel that slides/flickers into existence when a node is selected. A top toolbar holds the view-mode toggle (Micro / Macro), the snapshot selector (when in Micro mode), and global controls (lifecycle toggles, phase filter chips). All panels are resizable via drag handles. When no node is selected the right panel is collapsed and the canvas occupies the full remaining width.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: A fully tabbed layout where Micro View, Macro View, and Search are separate browser-tab-style panes with no persistent split panels, detail opens as a modal overlay.", + "Alternative: A fullscreen canvas-first layout with no persistent sidebar; filter/search and detail panel appear as HUD overlays on top of the canvas." + ], + "rationale": "The three-region layout keeps all primary navigation surfaces visible simultaneously, which is critical given G4's requirement for search + graph + detail in one view. The tabbed alternative (alt 1) fragments context — switching to search hides the graph, violating X38 (search must highlight in graph AND show results list simultaneously). Fullscreen HUD (alt 2) risks cluttering the canvas and makes the filter/results list difficult to use on smaller screens. Resizable panels give power users control over canvas real estate while keeping the layout coherent." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 277, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The macro view must use a dedicated WebGL canvas to satisfy both the current frame-card UI requirements and the future zoom-into-frame tran…", + "body": "The macro view must use a dedicated WebGL canvas to satisfy both the current frame-card UI requirements and the future zoom-into-frame transition\n\n## Rationale\n\nX29 requires WebGL for the macro view to enable the future zoom-into-frame transition. D11 specifies rich frame-card content (badges, text, chips) that cannot be implemented within Sigma's node rendering model. DEC10 rejects SVG/HTML because it cannot deliver a smooth WebGL-to-WebGL zoom transition. These premises jointly require a dedicated raw WebGL canvas separate from Sigma.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 278, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND show a persistent results list simultaneously", + "body": "Search must highlight matching nodes in the graph AND show a persistent results list simultaneously\n\n## Rationale\n\nX38 requires both highlighting in the graph and a results list. DEC6 selects the persistent sidebar over a command palette precisely because a command palette cannot maintain a simultaneous results list. D7 specifies the Sigma opacity-based highlighting. These three premises jointly mandate that the results list is persistent and co-visible with the live graph, not a transient overlay.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 279, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Both File API drop zone and ?artifact= URL param are required to satisfy local-first and remote-hosting constraints simultaneously", + "body": "Both File API drop zone and ?artifact= URL param are required to satisfy local-first and remote-hosting constraints simultaneously\n\n## Rationale\n\nX18 and X42 require local filesystem loading with zero configuration. C6 requires the loading mechanism to work when hosted remotely. RK6 identifies these as potentially conflicting. DEC2 resolves the conflict by specifying dual-path loading. These four premises jointly mandate both loading mechanisms — neither alone is sufficient.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 280, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "All micro-view design choices form a coherent, implementable system against the reference artifact.", + "body": "All micro-view design choices form a coherent, implementable system against the reference artifact.\n\n## Rationale\n\nThe graph-renderer-design (Sigma/WebGL), graph-data-model-design (in-memory indexes), graph-layout-design (Web Worker ForceAtlas2), filter-search-design (Zustand-driven opacity), micro-view-snapshot-design (opacity-based snapshot scrubbing), and performance-optimization-design (debouncing, hidden attribute) all interact without conflict: Sigma's node attribute API supports both opacity and hidden, ForceAtlas2 via graphology is the standard companion to Sigma, and Zustand's slice subscriptions prevent unnecessary Sigma refreshes. The reference dataset (761 total nodes, 2662 edges per validation-report-context) is within Sigma's documented performance envelope for WebGL rendering.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J1]", + "detail": null + } + ], + "edges": [ + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 204, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 244, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 243, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 186, + "target_local_id": 4, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 252, + "target_local_id": 219, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 142, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 41, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 54, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 248, + "target_local_id": 138, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 278, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 187, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 123, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 114, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 156, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 22, + "target_local_id": 111, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 54, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 46, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 118, + "target_local_id": 34, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 3, + "target_local_id": 267, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 139, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 38, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 183, + "target_local_id": 241, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 25, + "target_local_id": 233, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 248, + "target_local_id": 240, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 168, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 70, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 249, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 119, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 243, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 212, + "target_local_id": 42, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 145, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 131, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 84, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 180, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 162, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 256, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 22, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 32, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 175, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 175, + "target_local_id": 162, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 245, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 132, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 184, + "target_local_id": 6, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 62, + "target_local_id": 122, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 48, + "target_local_id": 101, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 53, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 260, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 244, + "target_local_id": 135, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 81, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 23, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 256, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 39, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 118, + "target_local_id": 42, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 79, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 67, + "target_local_id": 247, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 42, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 102, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 131, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 32, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 113, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 279, + "target_local_id": 245, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 185, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 194, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 206, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 159, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 177, + "target_local_id": 230, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 13, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 236, + "target_local_id": 230, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 126, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 133, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 197, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 94, + "target_local_id": 108, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 200, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 240, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 258, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 13, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 280, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 162, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 236, + "target_local_id": 240, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 131, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 45, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 19, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 155, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 170, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 118, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 241, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 250, + "target_local_id": 5, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 279, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 198, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 162, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 21, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 238, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 114, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 136, + "target_local_id": 219, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 171, + "target_local_id": 250, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 5, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 279, + "target_local_id": 114, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 234, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 154, + "target_local_id": 41, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 66, + "target_local_id": 127, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 148, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 141, + "target_local_id": 78, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 132, + "target_local_id": 84, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 62, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 13, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 84, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 107, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 194, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 126, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 105, + "target_local_id": 7, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 156, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 207, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 249, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 59, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 278, + "target_local_id": 109, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 85, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 131, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 81, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 22, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 207, + "target_local_id": 202, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 95, + "target_local_id": 197, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 16, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 37, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 211, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 97, + "target_local_id": 48, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 9, + "target_local_id": 37, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 111, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 43, + "target_local_id": 256, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 163, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 6, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 61, + "target_local_id": 235, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 219, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 88, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 98, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 32, + "target_local_id": 245, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 39, + "target_local_id": 128, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 206, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 76, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 119, + "target_local_id": 162, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 77, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 278, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 155, + "target_local_id": 54, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 152, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 233, + "target_local_id": 267, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 85, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 256, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 63, + "target_local_id": 244, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 164, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 233, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 225, + "target_local_id": 180, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 115, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 235, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 152, + "target_local_id": 275, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 181, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 168, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 205, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 152, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 73, + "target_local_id": 194, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 121, + "target_local_id": 235, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 171, + "target_local_id": 5, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 246, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 88, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 59, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 246, + "target_local_id": 85, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 61, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 87, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 173, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 50, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 11, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 200, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 240, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 211, + "target_local_id": 238, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 48, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 280, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 175, + "target_local_id": 116, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 135, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 79, + "target_local_id": 27, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 34, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 276, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 118, + "target_local_id": 251, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 170, + "target_local_id": 79, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 38, + "target_local_id": 135, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 193, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 13, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 119, + "target_local_id": 116, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 81, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 141, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 9, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 197, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 168, + "target_local_id": 245, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 240, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 162, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 80, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 45, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 37, + "target_local_id": 7, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 22, + "target_local_id": 259, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 30, + "target_local_id": 23, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 252, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 170, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 24, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 138, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 46, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 203, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 192, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 169, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 136, + "target_local_id": 52, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 73, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 215, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 245, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 225, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 109, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 20, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 242, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 76, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 33, + "target_local_id": 109, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 57, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 277, + "target_local_id": 59, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 20, + "target_local_id": 243, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 182, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 213, + "target_local_id": 114, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 20, + "target_local_id": 194, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 25, + "target_local_id": 267, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 131, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 170, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 111, + "target_local_id": 235, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 169, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 66, + "target_local_id": 98, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 255, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 96, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 106, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 96, + "target_local_id": 82, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 237, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 188, + "target_local_id": 53, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 18, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 188, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 251, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 205, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 122, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 275, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 48, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 159, + "target_local_id": 52, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 52, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 99, + "target_local_id": 135, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 256, + "target_local_id": 237, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 126, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 205, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 30, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 251, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 250, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 197, + "target_local_id": 170, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 18, + "target_local_id": 106, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 21, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 38, + "target_local_id": 206, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 29, + "target_local_id": 113, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 241, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 27, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 166, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 184, + "target_local_id": 212, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 72, + "target_local_id": 54, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 78, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 82, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 191, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 5, + "target_local_id": 260, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 93, + "target_local_id": 52, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 140, + "target_local_id": 279, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 2, + "target_local_id": 86, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 163, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 98, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 203, + "target_local_id": 70, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 86, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 33, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 152, + "target_local_id": 275, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 93, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 234, + "target_local_id": 101, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 204, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 185, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 97, + "target_local_id": 234, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 63, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 16, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 244, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 35, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 260, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 44, + "target_local_id": 38, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 205, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 67, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 144, + "target_local_id": 206, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 118, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 202, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 142, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 38, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 30, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 87, + "target_local_id": 34, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 147, + "target_local_id": 202, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 159, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 7, + "target_local_id": 135, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 185, + "target_local_id": 53, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 80, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 15, + "target_local_id": 181, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 106, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 88, + "target_local_id": 139, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 149, + "target_local_id": 279, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 105, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 249, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 245, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 183, + "target_local_id": 250, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 178, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 50, + "target_local_id": 114, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 65, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 21, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 151, + "target_local_id": 126, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 212, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 254, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 125, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 247, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 125, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 55, + "target_local_id": 204, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 87, + "target_local_id": 194, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 146, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 237, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 53, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 15, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 144, + "target_local_id": 38, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 26, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 132, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 146, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 244, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 178, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 198, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 133, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 3, + "target_local_id": 233, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 55, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 138, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 170, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 158, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 133, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 138, + "target_local_id": 246, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 264, + "target_local_id": 84, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 198, + "target_local_id": 156, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 53, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 265, + "target_local_id": 159, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 59, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 37, + "target_local_id": 191, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 234, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 113, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 104, + "target_local_id": 37, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 165, + "target_local_id": 117, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 204, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 206, + "target_local_id": 244, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 38, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 23, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 65, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 24, + "target_local_id": 165, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 123, + "target_local_id": 47, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 213, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 206, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 185, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 182, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 151, + "target_local_id": 254, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 187, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 139, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 90, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 257, + "target_local_id": 275, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 130, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 106, + "target_local_id": 24, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 232, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 60, + "target_local_id": 233, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 157, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 182, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 57, + "target_local_id": 185, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 163, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 35, + "target_local_id": 111, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 277, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 214, + "target_local_id": 142, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 212, + "target_local_id": 34, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 157, + "target_local_id": 51, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 84, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 26, + "target_local_id": 146, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 258, + "target_local_id": 59, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 34, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 254, + "target_local_id": 126, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 193, + "target_local_id": 247, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 197, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 251, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 57, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 206, + "target_local_id": 135, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 6, + "target_local_id": 212, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 41, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 245, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 107, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 140, + "target_local_id": 70, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 238, + "target_local_id": 7, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 164, + "target_local_id": 70, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 93, + "target_local_id": 159, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 241, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 160, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 72, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 95, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 204, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 187, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 84, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 102, + "target_local_id": 138, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 112, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 93, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 181, + "target_local_id": 261, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 15, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 28, + "target_local_id": 247, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 254, + "target_local_id": 201, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 133, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 158, + "target_local_id": 198, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 90, + "target_local_id": 80, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 73, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 155, + "target_local_id": 22, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 148, + "target_local_id": 106, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 59, + "target_local_id": 131, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 254, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 48, + "target_local_id": 234, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 22, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 211, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 45, + "target_local_id": 237, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 144, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 76, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 246, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 13, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 29, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 245, + "target_local_id": 255, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 278, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 24, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 185, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 152, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 78, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 204, + "target_local_id": 247, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 269, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 34, + "target_local_id": 74, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 130, + "target_local_id": 41, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 265, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 98, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 192, + "target_local_id": 70, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 117, + "target_local_id": 199, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 19, + "target_local_id": 48, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 268, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 271, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 178, + "target_local_id": 210, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 105, + "target_local_id": 238, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 81, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 187, + "target_local_id": 76, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 2, + "target_local_id": 182, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 162, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 40, + "target_local_id": 278, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 46, + "target_local_id": 263, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 216, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 104, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 192, + "target_local_id": 203, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 125, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 210, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 114, + "target_local_id": 271, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 126, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 238, + "target_local_id": 143, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 12, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 109, + "target_local_id": 49, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 52, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 172, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 166, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 58, + "target_local_id": 112, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 275, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 238, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 41, + "target_local_id": 276, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 274, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 273, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 248, + "target_local_id": 246, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 262, + "target_local_id": 76, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 39, + "target_local_id": 160, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 205, + "target_local_id": 145, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 13, + "target_local_id": 251, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 274, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 267, + "target_local_id": 53, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 280, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 4, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 180, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 54, + "target_local_id": 266, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 194, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 87, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 89, + "target_local_id": 27, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 268, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 263, + "target_local_id": 52, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 272, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 115, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 150, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 4, + "target_local_id": 262, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 273, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 193, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 266, + "target_local_id": 111, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 272, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 205, + "target_local_id": 172, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 50, + "target_local_id": 279, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 240, + "target_local_id": 150, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 86, + "target_local_id": 182, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 270, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 164, + "target_local_id": 203, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 6, + "target_local_id": 253, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 264, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 269, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 181, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 233, + "target_local_id": 267, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 126, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 116, + "target_local_id": 270, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 146, + "target_local_id": 234, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + } + ] +} diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/macro-view.json b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/macro-view.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5a9df891f --- /dev/null +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/macro-view.json @@ -0,0 +1,6477 @@ +{ + "spec": { + "slug": "macro-view", + "name": "Macro View", + "readiness_grade": "commitments_ready" + }, + "nodes": [ + { + "local_id": 1, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "check", + "title": "Macro View — code-audit pass", + "body": "Synthetic parent check representing the manual code-audit pass during which evidence nodes were authored. Generated by .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts to give imported evidence a structural parent on the oracle plane.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-port-synthetic", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 2, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected' shall render at full opacity; PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected'…", + "body": "PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected' shall render at full opacity; PerspectiveNodes whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' (or 'open' on a non-taken branch) shall render at reduced opacity (approximately 30%) to indicate they were not taken.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 3, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "In the spec-elicitation system, fan-out runs 2–3 independent clean-room derivation sessions from the same upstream context, and fan-in is a…", + "body": "In the spec-elicitation system, fan-out runs 2–3 independent clean-room derivation sessions from the same upstream context, and fan-in is a separate LLM agent that synthesizes the minimal viable set before reconciliation.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 4, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The CRT/phosphor design language is a project-wide standard defined in .impeccable.md, covering amber primary color, dark-only theme, phosp…", + "body": "The CRT/phosphor design language is a project-wide standard defined in .impeccable.md, covering amber primary color, dark-only theme, phosphor glow behavior, scanline texture, and JetBrains Mono font.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 5, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view shall reuse the existing src/components/DetailPanel.tsx component for the right-side detail panel; no separate macro-specifi…", + "body": "The macro view shall reuse the existing src/components/DetailPanel.tsx component for the right-side detail panel; no separate macro-specific detail panel component shall be introduced. DetailPanel may be extended internally to branch on the new record kinds (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, perspective).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 6, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Within a single frame containing all four phases, the y-coordinates of the four PhaseGroupNodes satisfy y(defining_done) < y(pinning) < y(s…", + "body": "Within a single frame containing all four phases, the y-coordinates of the four PhaseGroupNodes satisfy y(defining_done) < y(pinning) < y(shaping) < y(grounding) (defining_done at top of frame visually). Verify with a unit-test fixture.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 7, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The spec-elicitation system's derivation process consists of four phases in str…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [T2]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The spec-elicitation system's derivation process consists of four phases in strict dependency order: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 8, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Collapsed/expanded state shall not be written to localStorage, sessionStorage, cookies, the URL/query string, IndexedDB, or any other persi…", + "body": "Collapsed/expanded state shall not be written to localStorage, sessionStorage, cookies, the URL/query string, IndexedDB, or any other persistence layer; it shall exist only in React in-memory state for the lifetime of the component instance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 9, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view layout shall be implemented as a custom recursive (DFS) algorithm computing absolute positions and subtree bounding boxes; i…", + "body": "The macro view layout shall be implemented as a custom recursive (DFS) algorithm computing absolute positions and subtree bounding boxes; it shall not use dagre, ELK, or any other general-purpose graph layout library.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 10, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "User can pan and zoom the canvas: simulating a mouse-wheel event over the React Flow pane changes the viewport zoom level, and a mouse-drag…", + "body": "User can pan and zoom the canvas: simulating a mouse-wheel event over the React Flow pane changes the viewport zoom level, and a mouse-drag on the pane changes the viewport translation. Verify with a React Flow integration test using fireEvent.wheel and fireEvent.mouseDown/Move/Up, asserting useReactFlow().getViewport() values change accordingly.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 11, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For each ReconciliationRecord with non-empty resolvedImpasseIds, layout emits a resolution edge from the corresponding ReconciliationNode t…", + "body": "For each ReconciliationRecord with non-empty resolvedImpasseIds, layout emits a resolution edge from the corresponding ReconciliationNode to each resolved ImpasseNode. Edge has computed stroke color resolving to the resolving phase's --color-phase-* token, stroke-style solid, markerEnd arrow, and the routing path returns leftward (i.e., target node x < source node x, or via a custom edge component that produces a leftward bend). Verify with a fixture asserting source.x > target.x and computed style.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR55]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 12, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the macro view shares the CRT phosphor design language (amber primary, JetBrains Mono, dark warm surfaces, phosphor…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the macro view shares the CRT phosphor design language (amber primary, JetBrains Mono, dark warm surfaces, phosphor glow, scanline textures).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 13, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking on a PhantomNode in the rendered macro view does NOT dispatch any select action and does not change global selection state.", + "body": "Clicking on a PhantomNode in the rendered macro view does NOT dispatch any select action and does not change global selection state. The PhantomNode's DOM element exposes no role='button' or interactive cursor style. Verify with an RTL test: render fixture with phantom, click it, assert store.select spy was not called and computed style cursor != 'pointer'.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 14, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: bail reconciliation outcome visual treatment intentionally matches the failed run treatment for consistency.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: bail reconciliation outcome visual treatment intentionally matches the failed run treatment for consistency.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 15, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A DerivationRunNode with status='running' has: (a) a CSS animation property whose name is or includes 'phosphor-arrive' on the node body; (…", + "body": "A DerivationRunNode with status='running' has: (a) a CSS animation property whose name is or includes 'phosphor-arrive' on the node body; (b) a header chip with textContent 'RUNNING' and computed color resolving to --color-phosphor-cyan; (c) a descendant element with a CSS animation that visibly translates across the node interior (scanline sweep). The node remains clickable: click dispatches a select action. Verify with an RTL test asserting style.animationName, chip text and color, and click dispatch.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR45]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 16, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Static-analysis scan of src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx} finds no imports from @mui/*, @chakra-ui/*, antd, react-bootstrap, or other gene…", + "body": "Static-analysis scan of src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx} finds no imports from @mui/*, @chakra-ui/*, antd, react-bootstrap, or other generic UI component libraries. CSS scan finds no border-radius value greater than 4px on any macro view selector (allowing only sharp/squared corners). No element uses a Tailwind class indicating blue primary buttons (e.g., bg-blue-*) for primary actions. Verify with combined import-graph and CSS-grep tests.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 17, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "All colors, fonts, surfaces, glow, and scanline treatments used by macro view components shall be drawn from existing tokens defined in src…", + "body": "All colors, fonts, surfaces, glow, and scanline treatments used by macro view components shall be drawn from existing tokens defined in src/styles/theme.css (oklch phosphor palette, --font-mono, --color-surface-0..3, --color-phosphor-*, --color-phase-*, --color-text-*). Macro view code shall not introduce hard-coded hex/rgb/hsl colors or new top-level palette tokens.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 18, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "No single visual channel on a macro node shall encode more than one semantic attribute.", + "body": "No single visual channel on a macro node shall encode more than one semantic attribute. Specifically: phase color shall encode only phase identity; border color shall encode only run/reconciliation outcome (red=failed/bail, amber=retry/nudging-related, cyan=recurse/running, phase color=accepted); border style shall encode only frame mode; fill/dim level shall encode only failure-or-bail status; opacity shall encode only perspective selectedness; shape (diamond) shall encode only impasse identity. New attributes shall not be added to existing channels without re-justifying all collisions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R64]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 19, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The design language explicitly prohibits generic UI patterns such as Material Design, Tailwind defaults, SaaS dashboard aesthetics, rounded…", + "body": "The design language explicitly prohibits generic UI patterns such as Material Design, Tailwind defaults, SaaS dashboard aesthetics, rounded corners, or blue primary buttons.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [C6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 20, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Color additions to the palette must be semantically justified, not decorative — every color must earn its place by carrying meaning a user…", + "body": "Color additions to the palette must be semantically justified, not decorative — every color must earn its place by carrying meaning a user needs to distinguish at a glance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external [C7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 21, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The HubNode type has hubType of justification | decision | impasse | perspectiv…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T7]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The HubNode type has hubType of justification | decision | impasse | perspective, and carries impasseStatus (open | resolved | superseded) and perspectiveStatus (open | selected | rejected)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 22, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "This brief is scoped exclusively to the macro view component and its rendering of the derivation story; other parts of the UI are explicitl…", + "body": "This brief is scoped exclusively to the macro view component and its rendering of the derivation story; other parts of the UI are explicitly out of scope.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 23, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The onion-peel structure refers to the iterative cycle of impasse discovery, re…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [T13]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The onion-peel structure refers to the iterative cycle of impasse discovery, rederivation, fan-out/fan-in synthesis, reconciliation, and resolution that builds the derivation history." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 24, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a ReconciliationRecord with outcome='bail' is the mechanism by which a branch becomes a dead-end impasse.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a ReconciliationRecord with outcome='bail' is the mechanism by which a branch becomes a dead-end impasse.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 25, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The macro view is strictly read-only; users can pan, zoom, and collapse/expand nodes, but cannot trigger any data mutations.", + "body": "The macro view is strictly read-only; users can pan, zoom, and collapse/expand nodes, but cannot trigger any data mutations.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 26, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The layout shall size each depth lane's width as a function of the maximum content width across nodes at that depth, rather than using a si…", + "body": "The layout shall size each depth lane's width as a function of the maximum content width across nodes at that depth, rather than using a single fixed lane-width constant for all depths.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 27, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each PhantomNode shall render as a dashed-outline ghost tile with no fill, bearing a label identifying it as a phantom (e.g., 'PHANTOM — no…", + "body": "Each PhantomNode shall render as a dashed-outline ghost tile with no fill, bearing a label identifying it as a phantom (e.g., 'PHANTOM — no perspective taken').", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R50]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 28, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The ReconciliationRecord type captures reconciliation outcomes (accepted | retr…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T6]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The ReconciliationRecord type captures reconciliation outcomes (accepted | retry | recurse | bail) along with candidateNodeIds, baselineNodeIds, activatedNodeIds, archivedNodeIds, triggerImpasseIds, resolvedImpasseIds, unresolvedImpasseIds, and a materialProgress flag." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 29, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'failed' shall render with a border in --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior.", + "body": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'failed' shall render with a border in --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R43]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 30, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The bail reconciliation outcome and a failed run share the same red-border/dimmed-interior treatment by design, which could make the two vi…", + "body": "The bail reconciliation outcome and a failed run share the same red-border/dimmed-interior treatment by design, which could make the two visually indistinguishable at a glance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 31, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each PhaseGroupNode shall render with: a 1px border in its phase color (drawn from --color-phase-*), a warm dark fill from --color-surface-…", + "body": "Each PhaseGroupNode shall render with: a 1px border in its phase color (drawn from --color-phase-*), a warm dark fill from --color-surface-1, a scanline overlay, and a header line displaying the phase name, frame displayId, and frame mode in --color-text-secondary.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 32, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Importing MacroView from src/components/MacroView (the original path used by routes/explore.tsx) resolves to a working React component that…", + "body": "Importing MacroView from src/components/MacroView (the original path used by routes/explore.tsx) resolves to a working React component that renders without throwing. Verify with a Vitest + React Testing Library render test that imports from the legacy path and asserts the component mounts.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 33, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Users must manually refresh to see new derivation steps in the macro view.", + "body": "Users must manually refresh to see new derivation steps in the macro view.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 34, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "package.json declares @xyflow/react at major version 12 (e.g., ^12.x), and the rendered MacroView DOM contains the React Flow root element…", + "body": "package.json declares @xyflow/react at major version 12 (e.g., ^12.x), and the rendered MacroView DOM contains the React Flow root element wrapped by a ReactFlowProvider. Verify by (a) inspecting package.json with a unit test, and (b) a render test asserting that useReactFlow() called inside a child node throws no provider-missing error.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 35, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "An ImpasseNode whose hub.id appears in some FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds where that frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome === 'bai…", + "body": "An ImpasseNode whose hub.id appears in some FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds where that frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome === 'bail' renders with a chip element whose textContent matches /DEAD[\\s-]?END/i. An ImpasseNode whose triggered frame did not bail (or that has no triggered frame) does NOT render this chip. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR50]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 36, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A PhaseGroupNode for FrameRecord.mode='initial' has computed border-style 'solid'; mode='rederive' has 'double'; mode='grounding_enrichment…", + "body": "A PhaseGroupNode for FrameRecord.mode='initial' has computed border-style 'solid'; mode='rederive' has 'double'; mode='grounding_enrichment' has 'dashed'. The header additionally contains a text chip whose textContent equals the mode value (case-insensitive). Verify with parameterized RTL tests across all three modes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 37, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "MacroView renders a button with accessible name matching /reload/i.", + "body": "MacroView renders a button with accessible name matching /reload/i. Clicking it re-invokes the artifact loader and produces a fresh React Flow node array (new array identity) reflecting any updated underlying data. Verify with React Testing Library: query button by role/name, click, assert loader spy called twice and that the rendered output reflects mutated mock data after the second load.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 38, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: lane widths in the macro layout scale proportionally to the number of nodes at that depth rather than being fixed.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: lane widths in the macro layout scale proportionally to the number of nodes at that depth rather than being fixed.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 39, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The existing micro view is built with Sigma.js, handles 700+ nodes, and answers 'what does the graph look like now?'.", + "body": "The existing micro view is built with Sigma.js, handles 700+ nodes, and answers 'what does the graph look like now?'.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 40, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "src/styles/theme.css already defines the phosphor palette as oklch tokens including --color-phase-grounding (green), --color-phase-shaping…", + "body": "src/styles/theme.css already defines the phosphor palette as oklch tokens including --color-phase-grounding (green), --color-phase-shaping (amber), --color-phase-pinning (cyan), --color-phase-defining-done (purple), plus --color-phosphor-red, surface-0..3 warm darks, and --font-mono JetBrains Mono.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 41, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: clicking a node opens a detail panel on the right side of the screen.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: clicking a node opens a detail panel on the right side of the screen.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 42, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view shall render its graph using React Flow (@xyflow/react) at major version 12, mounted inside a ReactFlowProvider.", + "body": "The macro view shall render its graph using React Flow (@xyflow/react) at major version 12, mounted inside a ReactFlowProvider.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 43, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When provided a representative artifact fixture (drawn from the project's actual derivation history with N frames, where 5 ≤ N ≤ 15), the m…", + "body": "When provided a representative artifact fixture (drawn from the project's actual derivation history with N frames, where 5 ≤ N ≤ 15), the macro view renders a top-level semantic node count (PhaseGroupNodes + ImpasseNodes) in the range [20, 40]. The rendered edge count remains within an order of magnitude of the node count. Verify with a fixture-based test asserting count bounds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR57]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 44, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A rendered PhaseGroupNode has: (a) computed border-width 1px and border-color resolving to its --color-phase-* token; (b) computed backgrou…", + "body": "A rendered PhaseGroupNode has: (a) computed border-width 1px and border-color resolving to its --color-phase-* token; (b) computed background-color resolving to --color-surface-1; (c) a child element bearing a class or attribute identifying it as a scanline overlay; and (d) a header element containing the phase name, the frame's displayId, and the frame.mode text in --color-text-secondary. Verify with parameterized RTL tests for each phase, asserting computed styles and text content.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 45, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a phase group ends without any selected PerspectiveNode, the IR builder shall synthesize a PhantomNode under that phase group; the Pha…", + "body": "When a phase group ends without any selected PerspectiveNode, the IR builder shall synthesize a PhantomNode under that phase group; the PhantomNode shall not correspond to any record in ArtifactFile and shall be labelled to indicate 'no perspective taken'.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 46, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: React Flow group/parent nodes are used for phase containers in the macro view.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: React Flow group/parent nodes are used for phase containers in the macro view.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 47, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "PhantomNode instances shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall not present any other interactive affordance.", + "body": "PhantomNode instances shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall not present any other interactive affordance.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 48, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The macro view is built inside a Vite + React + Tailwind SPA.", + "body": "The macro view is built inside a Vite + React + Tailwind SPA.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 49, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A DerivationRunNode for a record with runIndex=3, inputNodeIds.length=5, outputCandidateIds.length=2, impassesFound.length=1 renders DOM co…", + "body": "A DerivationRunNode for a record with runIndex=3, inputNodeIds.length=5, outputCandidateIds.length=2, impassesFound.length=1 renders DOM containing: text matching /RUN\\s*#?\\s*3/, an input badge showing 5, an output badge showing 2, and an impasses-found indicator showing 1. Verify with a single RTL test on a fixture record.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR42]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 50, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its descendant DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode instances are…", + "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its descendant DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode instances are absent from the rendered React Flow nodes array (or have hidden:true). Edges whose both endpoints lie inside the collapsed group are absent (or hidden). Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting child-node-id absence and internal-edge absence.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 51, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each ImpasseNode shall render with a diamond/lozenge silhouette (distinct from the rectangular phase-group/run/fan-in/reconciliation shapes…", + "body": "Each ImpasseNode shall render with a diamond/lozenge silhouette (distinct from the rectangular phase-group/run/fan-in/reconciliation shapes), a red glyph treatment, and its hub displayId visible on the node face.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R48]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 52, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given a fixture containing both a DerivationRunNode with status='failed' AND an ImpasseNode whose linked reconciliation outcome='bail' (the…", + "body": "Given a fixture containing both a DerivationRunNode with status='failed' AND an ImpasseNode whose linked reconciliation outcome='bail' (the dead-end case): both nodes share red+dim treatment, but the ImpasseNode additionally renders a 'DEAD-END' chip while the failed RunNode does not, AND the ImpasseNode renders with the diamond shape while the RunNode is rectangular. Verify with an RTL test rendering both fixtures side by side and asserting these distinguishing features.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR68]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 53, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Within a single frame, PhaseGroupNodes shall be stacked vertically in the reverse of PHASE_ORDER (defining_done at top, then pinning, then…", + "body": "Within a single frame, PhaseGroupNodes shall be stacked vertically in the reverse of PHASE_ORDER (defining_done at top, then pinning, then shaping, then grounding at bottom).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 54, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "After collapsing one or more groups in MacroView, inspecting localStorage, sessionStorage, document.cookie, the URL/location (search/hash),…", + "body": "After collapsing one or more groups in MacroView, inspecting localStorage, sessionStorage, document.cookie, the URL/location (search/hash), and IndexedDB shows no key/entry containing collapsed FrameIds or any macro-view collapse state. After unmount + remount, all groups render expanded again. Verify with a JSDOM test that spies on storage APIs and asserts no setItem call with macro-related keys, and a remount test asserting state reset.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 55, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Impasse-spawn edges shall be rendered as red dashed lines with markerEnd arrows.", + "body": "Impasse-spawn edges shall be rendered as red dashed lines with markerEnd arrows. The source endpoint shall be the ReconciliationNode (or PhaseGroupNode) that produced the impasse, and the target shall be the ImpasseNode that opens the child lane (FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R53]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 56, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view shall render only three classes of edge between its nodes: (1) sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode within a…", + "body": "The macro view shall render only three classes of edge between its nodes: (1) sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode within a phase group), (2) impasse-spawn edges (from a ReconciliationNode/PhaseGroupNode outward to the ImpasseNode opening a child lane), and (3) resolution edges (from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode back to the impasse it resolved). It shall not synthesize edges from arbitrary EdgeRecord rows in ArtifactFile.graph.edges.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R51]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 57, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The visual treatment of a 'running' run status is underspecified — stakeholders consider it unlikely to appear but want it highlighted some…", + "body": "The visual treatment of a 'running' run status is underspecified — stakeholders consider it unlikely to appear but want it highlighted somehow, leaving the exact treatment open.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 58, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "After a collapse or expand toggle, sibling nodes' positions shall update so that no dead space remains where the collapsed group's children…", + "body": "After a collapse or expand toggle, sibling nodes' positions shall update so that no dead space remains where the collapsed group's children used to be (sibling reflow). External edges connecting to the collapsed group shall reattach to the pill's bounds without leaving dangling endpoints.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 59, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'running' shall render with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe animation looping at slow tempo…", + "body": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'running' shall render with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe animation looping at slow tempo on the node body, (b) a 'RUNNING' chip in --color-phosphor-cyan in the header, and (c) an animated scanline sweep across the node interior. The node shall remain clickable and shall display the same content fields as a completed run.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R44]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 60, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the materialProgress flag is visualized as a subtle chip or checkmark inside the reconciliation node, alongside the…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the materialProgress flag is visualized as a subtle chip or checkmark inside the reconciliation node, alongside the outcome indicator.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 61, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Every page load of the macro view starts fully expanded, with no memory of previously collapsed nodes.", + "body": "Every page load of the macro view starts fully expanded, with no memory of previously collapsed nodes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 62, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The FrameRecord.nudgingActive flag indicates whether a minimal negative constra…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-inferred [T9]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The FrameRecord.nudgingActive flag indicates whether a minimal negative constraint nudge is active for that frame, relevant to representing non-termination handling." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 63, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The FrameRecord type includes: id, parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase,…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T3]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The FrameRecord type includes: id, parentFrameId, baselineFrameId, entryPhase, triggerImpasseIds, mode (initial | rederive | grounding_enrichment), attemptNumber, nudgingActive, createdAt, and summary." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 64, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The ArtifactFile type bundles all spec data into a single file: manifest, sourc…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T8]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The ArtifactFile type bundles all spec data into a single file: manifest, sources, extractedClaims, interventions, and a graph object containing nodes, edges, frames, derivationRuns, fanInRecords, reconciliationRecords, and snapshots." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 65, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, the macro view shall render it as a compact pill displaying: a phase color dot, the frame's…", + "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, the macro view shall render it as a compact pill displaying: a phase color dot, the frame's displayId, the run count (e.g., 'n RUNS'), and an outcome glyph derived from the frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome (✓ accepted, ↺ retry, ↪ recurse, ✗ bail). The pill shall remain clickable to expand it and to open the detail panel.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 66, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A directory listing of src/components/macro/ contains at minimum: index.ts, MacroView.tsx, story-ir.ts, layout.ts, and a nodes/ subdirector…", + "body": "A directory listing of src/components/macro/ contains at minimum: index.ts, MacroView.tsx, story-ir.ts, layout.ts, and a nodes/ subdirectory containing PhaseGroupNode.tsx, DerivationRunNode.tsx, FanInNode.tsx, ReconciliationNode.tsx, ImpasseNode.tsx, PerspectiveNode.tsx, and PhantomNode.tsx. Verify by automated filesystem assertion in a unit test (e.g., fs.readdirSync) listing each expected path.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 67, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The DerivationRunRecord type includes: id, frameId, phase, runIndex, inputNodeI…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T4]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The DerivationRunRecord type includes: id, frameId, phase, runIndex, inputNodeIds, outputCandidateIds, impassesFound, status (running | completed | failed), and createdAt." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 68, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode for that frame shall display a textual chip (e.g., 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE') sty…", + "body": "When a FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode for that frame shall display a textual chip (e.g., 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE') styled in --color-phosphor-amber inside the node header. The nudging indicator shall be inside the node body, not an external overlay.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 69, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Faded (rejected/unselected) PerspectiveNode branches shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall present no interactive affo…", + "body": "Faded (rejected/unselected) PerspectiveNode branches shall not dispatch any selection action on click and shall present no interactive affordances.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 70, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each FanInNode shall render its FanIn groupings as a stack of rows, one row per grouping, where each row is prefixed by a 4px-wide left bor…", + "body": "Each FanInNode shall render its FanIn groupings as a stack of rows, one row per grouping, where each row is prefixed by a 4px-wide left border colored: green (success/merged token) when grouping.resolution='merged', amber (--color-phosphor-amber) when grouping.resolution='best_selected', and red (--color-phosphor-red) when grouping.resolution='impasse_surfaced'. Each row shall display the grouping's groupKey and a node count.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R45]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 71, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'completed' shall render with the base node treatment (no special border or dimming).", + "body": "A DerivationRunNode whose status is 'completed' shall render with the base node treatment (no special border or dimming).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R42]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 72, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A dead-end impasse is one whose reconciliation chose the 'bail' outcome — the s…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T11]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A dead-end impasse is one whose reconciliation chose the 'bail' outcome — the system gave up on that branch entirely." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 73, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The Story IR and layout modules shall consume the branded ID types defined in src/types/artifact.ts (NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, RunId, FanInI…", + "body": "The Story IR and layout modules shall consume the branded ID types defined in src/types/artifact.ts (NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, etc.) for keying records and shall not coerce these to plain strings at module boundaries.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R58]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 74, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The layout shall assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by its derivationDepth, with depth 0 acting as the trunk and each increment…", + "body": "The layout shall assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by its derivationDepth, with depth 0 acting as the trunk and each increment opening a lane to the right (or otherwise increasing horizontal breadth) so that onion-peel depth is encoded in horizontal position.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 75, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The story-ir / layout shall emit one PhaseGroupNode per (FrameRecord, Phase) pair that has any associated runs, fan-in, reconciliation, or…", + "body": "The story-ir / layout shall emit one PhaseGroupNode per (FrameRecord, Phase) pair that has any associated runs, fan-in, reconciliation, or perspective records.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 76, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "All textual content rendered inside macro view nodes, edges, banner, and pills shall use the var(--font-mono) (JetBrains Mono) font stack d…", + "body": "All textual content rendered inside macro view nodes, edges, banner, and pills shall use the var(--font-mono) (JetBrains Mono) font stack defined in theme.css.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 77, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a failed run is shown with a red color and a dimmed interior.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a failed run is shown with a red color and a dimmed interior.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 78, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For every edge in the layout output (in the default, non-running state), edge.animated is falsy (undefined or false).", + "body": "For every edge in the layout output (in the default, non-running state), edge.animated is falsy (undefined or false). Verify by a unit-test assertion across all edges in a representative fixture.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR56]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 79, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the visual design must feel like CRT/terminal aesthetic while preserving modern design principles; information dens…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the visual design must feel like CRT/terminal aesthetic while preserving modern design principles; information density is high but not overwhelming.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 80, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The MacroView shall provide a manual 'RELOAD' button that, when clicked, re-runs the entire data load → IR → layout → render pipeline.", + "body": "The MacroView shall provide a manual 'RELOAD' button that, when clicked, re-runs the entire data load → IR → layout → render pipeline.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 81, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='selected' renders with computed CSS opacity == 1.0 (or no opacity rule reducing it).", + "body": "A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='selected' renders with computed CSS opacity == 1.0 (or no opacity rule reducing it). A PerspectiveNode with perspectiveStatus='rejected' or 'open' (non-taken) renders with computed CSS opacity in the range [0.25, 0.35] (target ~0.3). Verify with RTL + getComputedStyle assertions on parameterized fixtures.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 82, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The nodeTypes object passed to contains exactly the seven keys: PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNod…", + "body": "The nodeTypes object passed to contains exactly the seven keys: PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, PhantomNode (or 'phaseGroup','run','fanIn','reconciliation','impasse','perspective','phantom' equivalents) and no key matching /trunk/i. Verify with a unit test that imports the nodeTypes registry and asserts Object.keys length === 7 and contains the expected set.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 83, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the corresponding ReconciliationNode shall render a small ✓ chip beside the outcome c…", + "body": "When a ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the corresponding ReconciliationNode shall render a small ✓ chip beside the outcome chip in its header.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R47]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 84, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The existing src/components/MacroView.tsx import path shall continue to resolve to a working MacroView component (e.g., as a thin re-export…", + "body": "The existing src/components/MacroView.tsx import path shall continue to resolve to a working MacroView component (e.g., as a thin re-export of the new src/components/macro/ module) so that routes/explore.tsx and other existing importers do not require changes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 85, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "package.json dependencies and devDependencies contain no entry for 'dagre', '@dagrejs/dagre', 'elkjs', 'cytoscape', 'klay', or other genera…", + "body": "package.json dependencies and devDependencies contain no entry for 'dagre', '@dagrejs/dagre', 'elkjs', 'cytoscape', 'klay', or other general-purpose graph layout libraries. layout.ts contains no imports from such packages. Verify by a static test asserting the dependency lists and import set.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 86, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Macro view components shall not use generic Material Design components, default Tailwind component patterns, generic SaaS dashboard chrome,…", + "body": "Macro view components shall not use generic Material Design components, default Tailwind component patterns, generic SaaS dashboard chrome, generic rounded-corner card aesthetics, or blue primary buttons. Visual treatments shall instead be expressed through the CRT/phosphor visual grammar (warm dark surfaces, phosphor glow, scanline texture, sharp/squared edges, monospace typography).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 87, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode header contains a chip element whose textContent matches /NUDG(E|ING)/ and whose…", + "body": "When FrameRecord.nudgingActive is true, the PhaseGroupNode header contains a chip element whose textContent matches /NUDG(E|ING)/ and whose computed color resolves to --color-phosphor-amber. The chip is a descendant of the node body (i.e., bounded inside the node's rect), not an external overlay. When nudgingActive is false, no such chip is present. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 88, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Phase color references in macro view code shall use the theme.css phase tokens (--color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-pha…", + "body": "Phase color references in macro view code shall use the theme.css phase tokens (--color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-phase-pinning, --color-phase-defining-done) as the authoritative phase color mapping. Where the upstream X34 specification differs from theme.css, theme.css governs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R37]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 89, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Phase color values must be expressed as oklch values within the phosphor palette.", + "body": "Phase color values must be expressed as oklch values within the phosphor palette.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 90, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "A MacroView.tsx component already exists at src/components/MacroView.tsx with a header docblock describing the intended architecture: Story…", + "body": "A MacroView.tsx component already exists at src/components/MacroView.tsx with a header docblock describing the intended architecture: Story IR → Layout → Render with React Flow custom node types; the file is otherwise a stub.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 91, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the layout output, every node with a defined parentId has node.position expressed relative to the parent's origin (i.e., the absolute sc…", + "body": "In the layout output, every node with a defined parentId has node.position expressed relative to the parent's origin (i.e., the absolute screen position is parent.position + child.position), and the child's position is contained within the parent's bounding box (0 ≤ child.x ≤ parent.width - child.width; same for y). Group nodes (parentId undefined) carry absolute positions. Verify with a unit test on layout output for a fixture containing parented children.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR62]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 92, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "In the layout output for any non-collapsed PhaseGroupNode P, every child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode in…", + "body": "In the layout output for any non-collapsed PhaseGroupNode P, every child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode in P has node.parentId === P.id and node.extent === 'parent', and P has type === 'group' (or the React Flow group equivalent). Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting these properties for a fixture frame containing all four child kinds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 93, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Within any horizontal lane, more recent frames (higher attemptNumber / later createdAt) shall be positioned higher (smaller y in screen coo…", + "body": "Within any horizontal lane, more recent frames (higher attemptNumber / later createdAt) shall be positioned higher (smaller y in screen coordinates / 'higher' visually) than earlier frames, so that vertical position encodes time with t+1 above t.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 94, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The macro view is one specific view within the broader Spec Explorer UI.", + "body": "The macro view is one specific view within the broader Spec Explorer UI.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 95, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Manual UX review (codified as a stakeholder sign-off checklist) asserts: (a) every node communicates outcome-at-a-glance from at least 1m v…", + "body": "Manual UX review (codified as a stakeholder sign-off checklist) asserts: (a) every node communicates outcome-at-a-glance from at least 1m viewing distance on a 14\" laptop screen at default zoom; (b) no rendered phase group exceeds ~280px width or ~360px height at default zoom for typical content; (c) text contrast against warm-dark surface meets WCAG AA (4.5:1) for primary text. Verify with a manual review checklist run during PR review plus an automated contrast test using getComputedStyle and a contrast-ratio library.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR69]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 96, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation outcome affects the whole node's visual weight: accepted=normal, retry=amber border, recurse=blue bo…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: reconciliation outcome affects the whole node's visual weight: accepted=normal, retry=amber border, recurse=blue border, bail=red border + dimmed interior.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 97, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Layout output for child nodes inside a PhaseGroupNode shall use positions relative to the parent group's origin (consistent with React Flow…", + "body": "Layout output for child nodes inside a PhaseGroupNode shall use positions relative to the parent group's origin (consistent with React Flow's parentId conventions), while group nodes themselves carry absolute positions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R62]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 98, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For a fixture with frames F0 (no parent) → F1 (parent F0) → F2 (parent F1), the layout assigns depth(F0)=0, depth(F1)=1, depth(F2)=2; and t…", + "body": "For a fixture with frames F0 (no parent) → F1 (parent F0) → F2 (parent F1), the layout assigns depth(F0)=0, depth(F1)=1, depth(F2)=2; and the x-coordinate of F2's PhaseGroupNode is greater than F1's, which is greater than F0's. Verify with a unit test on layout() output.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 99, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Because the macro view is snapshot-only and only updates on manual refresh, users may view a stale derivation history without realizing it.", + "body": "Because the macro view is snapshot-only and only updates on manual refresh, users may view a stale derivation history without realizing it.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 100, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The MacroView shall implement a three-stage pipeline as separate, individually-testable pure functions: (1) story-ir builder consuming Arti…", + "body": "The MacroView shall implement a three-stage pipeline as separate, individually-testable pure functions: (1) story-ir builder consuming ArtifactFile.graph and producing a normalized derivation tree IR, (2) a layout function consuming the IR plus a collapsed set and producing absolute positions, lane widths and parent/child grouping, and (3) a renderer that maps IR nodes to typed React Flow nodes and edges. Stages 1 and 2 shall have no React or React Flow imports.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 101, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each DerivationRunNode shall display: the run index ('RUN #n' from runIndex), an input-count badge (size of inputNodeIds), an output-count…", + "body": "Each DerivationRunNode shall display: the run index ('RUN #n' from runIndex), an input-count badge (size of inputNodeIds), an output-count badge (size of outputCandidateIds), and an impasses-found count (size of impassesFound).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 102, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view shall be implemented as React components in TypeScript that build cleanly within the existing Vite + React + Tailwind SPA to…", + "body": "The macro view shall be implemented as React components in TypeScript that build cleanly within the existing Vite + React + Tailwind SPA toolchain, without introducing alternative bundlers, runtimes, or replacing Tailwind with a competing CSS framework.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R60]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 103, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The ReconciliationRecord.outcome field can be one of: accepted, retry, recurse, or bail.", + "body": "The ReconciliationRecord.outcome field can be one of: accepted, retry, recurse, or bail.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 104, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: phase color assignments are grounding=blue (foundational), shaping=green (growth/emergence), pinning=amber (fixity/…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: phase color assignments are grounding=blue (foundational), shaping=green (growth/emergence), pinning=amber (fixity/commitment), defining_done=violet (completion/closure).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X34]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 105, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: a 'running' status is unlikely to appear but should be highlighted somehow if it does.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: a 'running' status is unlikely to appear but should be highlighted somehow if it does.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 106, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Clicking the collapse/expand affordance on a PhaseGroupNode (or its collapsed pill) shall toggle that group's membership in the collapsed s…", + "body": "Clicking the collapse/expand affordance on a PhaseGroupNode (or its collapsed pill) shall toggle that group's membership in the collapsed set, triggering a synchronous re-run of the layout function over the existing IR + new collapsed set.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 107, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: derivation phases (such as reconciliation) are encoded as nodes within the graph rather than as separate UI constru…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: derivation phases (such as reconciliation) are encoded as nodes within the graph rather than as separate UI constructs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 108, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "An edge whose source or target is a child of a now-collapsed phase group renders in the layout output with its endpoint id rewritten to (or…", + "body": "An edge whose source or target is a child of a now-collapsed phase group renders in the layout output with its endpoint id rewritten to (or remapped to terminate at) the collapsed pill node id, not the original child id. No edge in the output references a child id that is currently hidden by a collapsed group. Verify with a unit test on layout() output asserting endpoint-id sets are subsets of the visible node-id set.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 109, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The macro view is structurally different from the micro view: it shows ~20-40 rich nodes representing the derivation process rather than gr…", + "body": "The macro view is structurally different from the micro view: it shows ~20-40 rich nodes representing the derivation process rather than graph content.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 110, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Every text-bearing DOM element rendered by macro view components has computed font-family containing 'JetBrains Mono' or resolving to var(-…", + "body": "Every text-bearing DOM element rendered by macro view components has computed font-family containing 'JetBrains Mono' or resolving to var(--font-mono). Verify with an RTL test that walks the rendered tree and asserts getComputedStyle(el).fontFamily for each text element matches the expected stack.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR36]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 111, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view shall register exactly seven custom React Flow nodeTypes — PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode,…", + "body": "The macro view shall register exactly seven custom React Flow nodeTypes — PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, and PhantomNode — and shall not register a separate TrunkNode type.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 112, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The macro view module imports DetailPanel from src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (or via the shared component path) and does not define a new…", + "body": "The macro view module imports DetailPanel from src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (or via the shared component path) and does not define a new component named MacroDetailPanel or equivalent. DetailPanel renders the selected macro record kind. Verify with (a) a static import-graph check and (b) an integration test that selects each macro record kind and asserts DetailPanel renders kind-appropriate content.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR31]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 113, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view source code shall be organized under src/components/macro/ with at minimum: index.ts re-exporting MacroView, MacroView.tsx (…", + "body": "The macro view source code shall be organized under src/components/macro/ with at minimum: index.ts re-exporting MacroView, MacroView.tsx (top-level component), story-ir.ts (pure ArtifactFile→StoryIR builder), layout.ts (pure StoryIR+collapsedSet→RF nodes/edges), and a nodes/ subdirectory containing one .tsx file per custom node type (PhaseGroupNode, DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, ImpasseNode, PerspectiveNode, PhantomNode).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 114, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Reconciliation compares candidate nodes from re-derivation against the previous iteration's nodes for that phase and classifies each relati…", + "body": "Reconciliation compares candidate nodes from re-derivation against the previous iteration's nodes for that phase and classifies each relationship using lineage edge types.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 115, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "After collapsing one or more groups and triggering RELOAD (or unmount/remount), the rendered macro view returns to the fully-expanded state…", + "body": "After collapsing one or more groups and triggering RELOAD (or unmount/remount), the rendered macro view returns to the fully-expanded state with no PhaseGroupNode rendered as a pill. Verify with an RTL test that collapses, reloads, and asserts no collapsed-pill DOM elements exist.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR67]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 116, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: derivation depth in the macro layout is computed from the parentFrameId chain length.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: derivation depth in the macro layout is computed from the parentFrameId chain length.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 117, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Inspecting MacroView's rendered DOM and the props of its React Flow custom nodes reveals no UI affordance bound to a mutating action: no ad…", + "body": "Inspecting MacroView's rendered DOM and the props of its React Flow custom nodes reveals no UI affordance bound to a mutating action: no add/edit/delete buttons, no form inputs, no draggable-to-create-edge handles enabled (nodesDraggable may be true for layout, but onConnect/onEdgesChange handlers must not commit changes back to the artifact). Verify by an integration test that simulates clicks on every interactive element and asserts that no mock 'mutate' API on the store is ever called.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 118, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The macro view must use a manual layout algorithm rather than dagre, because the spatial grammar requires precise control over depth lanes…", + "body": "The macro view must use a manual layout algorithm rather than dagre, because the spatial grammar requires precise control over depth lanes and vertical flow.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 119, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: impasse nodes connect sub-trees and increase the breadth of the layout to represent the opening of a new derivation…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: impasse nodes connect sub-trees and increase the breadth of the layout to represent the opening of a new derivation branch.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 120, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode descendants and th…", + "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, its child DerivationRunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/PhantomNode descendants and the edges entirely internal to that group shall not be rendered (or shall be hidden from the React Flow output).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R28]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 121, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The MacroView shall expose no controls that mutate artifact data.", + "body": "The MacroView shall expose no controls that mutate artifact data. Only pan, zoom, node click (selection), and collapse/expand interactions shall be wired.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 122, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The artifact.ts file defines branded ID types for NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, SpecId, SourceId, ClaimId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, Sna…", + "body": "The artifact.ts file defines branded ID types for NodeId, EdgeId, FrameId, SpecId, SourceId, ClaimId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, SnapshotId, InterventionId, and DisplayId.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 123, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Git diff between the feature branch and main shows zero modifications to src/components/MicroView*, src/graph/, src/router.ts, src/routes/,…", + "body": "Git diff between the feature branch and main shows zero modifications to src/components/MicroView*, src/graph/, src/router.ts, src/routes/, or any unrelated component, with the only allowed touched files being: src/components/macro/**, src/components/MacroView.tsx (re-export only), and minimal additions to src/components/DetailPanel.tsx (new branches for macro record kinds; no removal of existing branches). Verify with a git-diff CI check.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR59]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 124, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: users can fold (collapse) any nested derivation run to hide detail.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: users can fold (collapse) any nested derivation run to hide detail.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 125, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "After mount, mutating the underlying artifact mock and waiting any reasonable interval (e.g., 1s) does NOT change the rendered macro view (…", + "body": "After mount, mutating the underlying artifact mock and waiting any reasonable interval (e.g., 1s) does NOT change the rendered macro view (no live update). Clicking the RELOAD button (or remounting) updates the rendered view to reflect the mutation. Verify with an integration test combining a mock artifact source, mutation between assertions, and pre/post-reload DOM snapshots.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR66]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 126, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A FanInNode with groupings [{groupKey:'a', resolution:'merged', nodeCount:3},{groupKey:'b', resolution:'best_selected', nodeCount:1},{group…", + "body": "A FanInNode with groupings [{groupKey:'a', resolution:'merged', nodeCount:3},{groupKey:'b', resolution:'best_selected', nodeCount:1},{groupKey:'c', resolution:'impasse_surfaced', nodeCount:2}] renders three row elements in order, each with a 4px-wide left-border whose color is (in order): the green/merged token, --color-phosphor-amber, --color-phosphor-red. Each row contains the groupKey text and the nodeCount text. Verify with a parameterized RTL test across all three resolution kinds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR46]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 127, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given a fixture artifact containing N FrameRecords each with M phases that have at least one associated run/fan-in/reconciliation/perspecti…", + "body": "Given a fixture artifact containing N FrameRecords each with M phases that have at least one associated run/fan-in/reconciliation/perspective record, the IR builder produces exactly N×M PhaseGroupNodes (no more, no fewer), and zero PhaseGroupNodes for (frame, phase) pairs with no associated records. Verify with a unit test on buildStoryIR using a hand-crafted fixture covering empty and non-empty phase pairs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 128, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view canvas shall support pan and zoom interactions provided by React Flow.", + "body": "The macro view canvas shall support pan and zoom interactions provided by React Flow.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 129, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "PhaseGroupNode shall encode the FrameRecord.mode in border style: mode='initial' uses a solid border, mode='rederive' uses a double border,…", + "body": "PhaseGroupNode shall encode the FrameRecord.mode in border style: mode='initial' uses a solid border, mode='rederive' uses a double border, and mode='grounding_enrichment' uses a dashed border. A small text mode chip showing the mode name shall additionally appear in the header.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R39]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 130, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For an artifact fixture with arbitrary counts of DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, and ReconciliationRecord, the rendered React Flow node a…", + "body": "For an artifact fixture with arbitrary counts of DerivationRunRecord, FanInRecord, and ReconciliationRecord, the rendered React Flow node array contains exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord.id, one FanInNode per FanInRecord.id, and one ReconciliationNode per ReconciliationRecord.id (verified by id-set equality). Verify with a property-based test (fast-check) generating random combinations.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 131, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The MacroView shall display a fixed overlay banner in the top-left corner showing 'SNAPSHOT @ ' rendered in --color-text-tertiar…", + "body": "The MacroView shall display a fixed overlay banner in the top-left corner showing 'SNAPSHOT @ ' rendered in --color-text-tertiary, where reflects the time the artifact was loaded for the current snapshot. The banner shall not pan or zoom with the React Flow canvas.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R7]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 132, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in groupings render as color-coded rows inside the fan-in node — green for 'merged', amber for 'best_selected',…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in groupings render as color-coded rows inside the fan-in node — green for 'merged', amber for 'best_selected', red for 'impasse_surfaced' — distinguished by a colored left border or chip.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X32]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 133, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "MacroView renders a fixed-position element in the top-left containing the literal text prefix 'SNAPSHOT @ ' followed by the artifact's load…", + "body": "MacroView renders a fixed-position element in the top-left containing the literal text prefix 'SNAPSHOT @ ' followed by the artifact's load timestamp. The element has CSS color resolving to the value of --color-text-tertiary and CSS position:fixed (or absolute relative to the macro view container, outside the React Flow viewport transform). Verify by computed-style assertion in a JSDOM/RTL test, plus a visual test that pans/zooms the canvas and asserts the banner's bounding-rect coordinates are unchanged.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 134, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Each ReconciliationNode shall encode its outcome via full-node border treatment: outcome='accepted' uses the parent phase's color, outcome=…", + "body": "Each ReconciliationNode shall encode its outcome via full-node border treatment: outcome='accepted' uses the parent phase's color, outcome='retry' uses --color-phosphor-amber, outcome='recurse' uses --color-phosphor-cyan (blue), outcome='bail' uses --color-phosphor-red plus a dimmed interior. The outcome shall additionally appear as a textual chip in the node header.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R46]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 135, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Every reference to a phase color in macro view source uses one of the literal tokens --color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --colo…", + "body": "Every reference to a phase color in macro view source uses one of the literal tokens --color-phase-grounding, --color-phase-shaping, --color-phase-pinning, or --color-phase-defining-done. No macro view file redefines these tokens. Where conflict exists between X34 and theme.css, theme.css's mapping is used. Verify with a grep test plus a render test asserting that a PhaseGroupNode for phase 'shaping' has border-color resolving to theme.css's --color-phase-shaping value (currently amber per X41).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR38]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 136, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Because the macro view renders inside a React Flow canvas (not directly in the DOM), large node counts are not a DOM performance concern.", + "body": "Because the macro view renders inside a React Flow canvas (not directly in the DOM), large node counts are not a DOM performance concern.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X9]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 137, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode) shall be rendered as thin amber lines with markerEnd arrows and no animation by defau…", + "body": "Sequence edges (RunNode→FanInNode→ReconciliationNode) shall be rendered as thin amber lines with markerEnd arrows and no animation by default.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R52]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 138, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "Each node's form and function must visually communicate what happened at that specific point in the derivation tree.", + "body": "Each node's form and function must visually communicate what happened at that specific point in the derivation tree.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 139, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A static review (codified as a test fixture matrix) asserts the channel-to-attribute mapping: phase color used only for phase identity (not…", + "body": "A static review (codified as a test fixture matrix) asserts the channel-to-attribute mapping: phase color used only for phase identity (not for outcome or mode); border-color encoding only run/reconciliation outcome semantics (red, amber, cyan, phase color per outcome); border-style (solid/double/dashed) encoding only frame mode; opacity reduction (~30%) used only for unselected perspective branches; diamond/lozenge shape used only by ImpasseNode. Verify by enumerating all node-type × visual-channel pairs in tests and asserting no two attributes share a channel within a node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR64]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 140, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: layout grammar encodes timeline through verticality (t+1 / more recent appears higher) and breadth encodes onion-pe…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: layout grammar encodes timeline through verticality (t+1 / more recent appears higher) and breadth encodes onion-peel derivation depth.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 141, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "For each FrameRecord, the layout shall compute derivationDepth as the length of the parentFrameId chain (the root frame, with no parentFram…", + "body": "For each FrameRecord, the layout shall compute derivationDepth as the length of the parentFrameId chain (the root frame, with no parentFrameId, has depth 0).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 142, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The FrameRecord.mode field has three values: initial, rederive, and grounding_enrichment.", + "body": "The FrameRecord.mode field has three values: initial, rederive, and grounding_enrichment.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [E4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 143, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts modules contain no import statements referencing 'react', 'react-dom', '@xyflow/react', or any DOM/browser API.", + "body": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts modules contain no import statements referencing 'react', 'react-dom', '@xyflow/react', or any DOM/browser API. Verify by a static-analysis test that parses the files and asserts the import set is disjoint from a forbidden list. Additionally call each function twice with the same deeply-cloned input and assert the outputs are deeply equal and that the inputs are unmodified (input integrity hash unchanged).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 144, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking the collapse affordance on an expanded PhaseGroupNode causes (a) that group's id to enter the collapsed set and (b) the layout fun…", + "body": "Clicking the collapse affordance on an expanded PhaseGroupNode causes (a) that group's id to enter the collapsed set and (b) the layout function to be invoked again with the new set, producing updated node positions. Subsequent click on the resulting pill removes the id from the set and restores expanded layout. Verify with a Vitest test using a spy on the layout function and a click simulation; assert layout invocation count and node-position diffs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 145, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The theme.css token assignment differs from grounding X34: theme.css maps shaping=amber and pinning=cyan, while X34 specifies shaping=green…", + "body": "The theme.css token assignment differs from grounding X34: theme.css maps shaping=amber and pinning=cyan, while X34 specifies shaping=green and pinning=amber. Reconciling this is a minor concern but theme.css is the source of truth for the existing design system.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X41]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 146, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The onion-peel derivation structure (impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, resolution) is specified in the spec-elicitation.md d…", + "body": "The onion-peel derivation structure (impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, resolution) is specified in the spec-elicitation.md document.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "external-observed [X5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 147, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: phantom nodes and faded nodes are informational only and carry no interactive actions.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: phantom nodes and faded nodes are informational only and carry no interactive actions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X24]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 148, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The FanInRecord type captures the fan-in step: id, frameId, phase, inputRunIds,…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T5]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The FanInRecord type captures the fan-in step: id, frameId, phase, inputRunIds, groupings (with resolution: merged | best_selected | impasse_surfaced), outputCandidateIds, droppedCandidateIds, and createdAt." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 149, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "On every mount of MacroView the collapsed-set shall be initialized as empty, so that all phase groups are rendered fully expanded immediate…", + "body": "On every mount of MacroView the collapsed-set shall be initialized as empty, so that all phase groups are rendered fully expanded immediately after page load.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 150, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A PhantomNode renders with computed border-style 'dashed', computed background-color of 'transparent' (or rgba alpha 0), and contains text…", + "body": "A PhantomNode renders with computed border-style 'dashed', computed background-color of 'transparent' (or rgba alpha 0), and contains text matching /PHANTOM/i and /no perspective taken/i. Verify with an RTL + computed-style test.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR51]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 151, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: render the derivation narrative as a pannable, zoomable graph.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: render the derivation narrative as a pannable, zoomable graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X10]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 152, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "TypeScript strict-mode compilation succeeds for story-ir.ts and layout.ts using the branded ID types from src/types/artifact.ts (FrameId, R…", + "body": "TypeScript strict-mode compilation succeeds for story-ir.ts and layout.ts using the branded ID types from src/types/artifact.ts (FrameId, RunId, FanInId, ReconciliationId, NodeId, etc.) without `as string` or `as any` coercions at module exports. Verify with `tsc --noEmit` in CI plus a grep test asserting no `as string` or `as unknown as string` patterns appear at module boundaries.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR58]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 153, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Resolution edges shall be rendered as solid lines colored by the resolving phase's color, with markerEnd arrows, drawn from a child frame's…", + "body": "Resolution edges shall be rendered as solid lines colored by the resolving phase's color, with markerEnd arrows, drawn from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode back toward the ImpasseNode listed in that record's resolvedImpasseIds, using a return-leftward routing convention (toward lower-depth lanes).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R54]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 154, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the rendered ReconciliationNode header contains a chip element whose textContent contai…", + "body": "When ReconciliationRecord.materialProgress is true, the rendered ReconciliationNode header contains a chip element whose textContent contains the ✓ character (or is identifiable as a checkmark indicator) located beside the outcome chip. When materialProgress is false, no such chip is present. Verify with two RTL fixtures.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR48]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 155, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Across realistic spec snapshots the macro view shall render approximately 20–40 top-level semantic nodes (phase groups + impasses) for a ty…", + "body": "Across realistic spec snapshots the macro view shall render approximately 20–40 top-level semantic nodes (phase groups + impasses) for a typical derivation history; the design shall not produce hundreds of nodes from EdgeRecord-style content edges.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R57]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 156, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Within a single lane, given two frames F_old (createdAt=t1, attemptNumber=1) and F_new (createdAt=t2>t1, attemptNumber=2) at the same depth…", + "body": "Within a single lane, given two frames F_old (createdAt=t1, attemptNumber=1) and F_new (createdAt=t2>t1, attemptNumber=2) at the same depth, F_new's PhaseGroupNode position.y is strictly less than F_old's (smaller y = visually higher). Verify with a unit-test fixture and assertion on layout output.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR18]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 157, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The CRT design language for the macro view mandates: var(--font-mono), oklch phase colors, warm-tinted dark surfaces, phosphor glow, and no…", + "body": "The CRT design language for the macro view mandates: var(--font-mono), oklch phase colors, warm-tinted dark surfaces, phosphor glow, and no generic UI patterns.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 158, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For each FrameRecord with non-empty triggerImpasseIds, layout emits an impasse-spawn edge from the parent frame's relevant ReconciliationNo…", + "body": "For each FrameRecord with non-empty triggerImpasseIds, layout emits an impasse-spawn edge from the parent frame's relevant ReconciliationNode (or PhaseGroupNode if reconciliation is unavailable) to each ImpasseNode listed in triggerImpasseIds. Each such edge has computed stroke color resolving to --color-phosphor-red, computed border/stroke style 'dashed', and a markerEnd arrow. Verify with a fixture and computed-style assertion.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR54]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 159, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Because collapsed state is ephemeral and never persisted, users lose any custom collapsed configuration on every page reload.", + "body": "Because collapsed state is ephemeral and never persisted, users lose any custom collapsed configuration on every page reload.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 160, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking a non-faded, non-phantom macro node (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse, or selected perspective) dispatches a 'select' a…", + "body": "Clicking a non-faded, non-phantom macro node (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse, or selected perspective) dispatches a 'select' action to the global selection store with a payload identifying the underlying IR record by id and kind. Verify with an RTL test using a mocked store: simulate click on each node-type variant in a fixture and assert the store.select spy was called with the correct {id, kind} pair.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR30]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 161, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested run is collapsed, sibling nodes shift to fill vacated space, triggering a layout reflow.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested run is collapsed, sibling nodes shift to fill vacated space, triggering a layout reflow.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 162, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Layout output contains edges of exactly three distinct semantic classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), identifiable via an edge.dat…", + "body": "Layout output contains edges of exactly three distinct semantic classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), identifiable via an edge.data.kind discriminator or edge.type. No edge in the output is generated by iterating ArtifactFile.graph.edges (EdgeRecord rows). Verify by (a) inspecting layout output for a fixture and asserting every edge has kind ∈ {sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution}, and (b) a unit test that inserts arbitrary EdgeRecord rows into the artifact and asserts the macro layout edge count is unchanged.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR52]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 163, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The mandate for high information density combined with the CRT aesthetic and prohibition on generic UI patterns creates tension between den…", + "body": "The mandate for high information density combined with the CRT aesthetic and prohibition on generic UI patterns creates tension between dense data display and visual readability/non-overwhelm.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-risk-or-question | derived-inferred [RK5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 164, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "An ImpasseNode renders with a clearly non-rectangular silhouette: either via SVG path/polygon or CSS clip-path/transform producing a diamon…", + "body": "An ImpasseNode renders with a clearly non-rectangular silhouette: either via SVG path/polygon or CSS clip-path/transform producing a diamond/lozenge shape. Its DOM contains the hub's displayId text and uses --color-phosphor-red as a glyph or border token. Verify with an RTL test asserting the presence of an SVG diamond polygon or a clip-path style, plus the text and color assertions.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR49]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 165, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given a fixture artifact representing a full onion-peel cycle (initial derivation, an impasse, a rederive child frame, fan-out runs, fan-in…", + "body": "Given a fixture artifact representing a full onion-peel cycle (initial derivation, an impasse, a rederive child frame, fan-out runs, fan-in, reconciliation, resolution), the rendered macro view contains: at least one PhaseGroupNode for the parent frame, an ImpasseNode at the lane boundary, at least one PhaseGroupNode for the child frame in a deeper lane, RunNode(s) and FanInNode and ReconciliationNode inside the child phase group, an impasse-spawn edge, and a resolution edge back to the impasse. Verify with an end-to-end RTL test on the full-cycle fixture.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR70]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 166, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Edges whose both endpoints lie inside a collapsed PhaseGroupNode shall not be rendered while that group is collapsed.", + "body": "Edges whose both endpoints lie inside a collapsed PhaseGroupNode shall not be rendered while that group is collapsed. Edges with exactly one endpoint inside a collapsed group shall reattach to the collapsed pill rather than being hidden.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R56]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 167, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts shall export pure functions: given identical inputs they shall produce structurally equal outputs and shall not m…", + "body": "story-ir.ts and layout.ts shall export pure functions: given identical inputs they shall produce structurally equal outputs and shall not mutate their input data, perform I/O, or read from external state (DOM, time, stores).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R61]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 168, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in and fan-out steps are represented as nested nodes within any one phase node.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: fan-in and fan-out steps are represented as nested nodes within any one phase node.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X17]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 169, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The MacroView shall load ArtifactFile data exactly once on component mount, build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React…", + "body": "The MacroView shall load ArtifactFile data exactly once on component mount, build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React Flow nodes and edges into component state. It shall not subscribe to or react to subsequent artifact changes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 170, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A DerivationRunNode with status='failed' has computed border-color resolving to --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior (e.g., r…", + "body": "A DerivationRunNode with status='failed' has computed border-color resolving to --color-phosphor-red and a visibly dimmed interior (e.g., reduced opacity on the body OR a dark overlay; quantified as effective body luminance ≤ 70% of completed baseline). Verify with an RTL + computed-style test asserting border color match and an opacity/filter property indicating dimming.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR44]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 171, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "materialProgress=true on a ReconciliationRecord means at least some nodes were…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T12]", + "detail": { + "definition": "materialProgress=true on a ReconciliationRecord means at least some nodes were activated or archived during that reconciliation — real forward progress occurred." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 172, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When MacroView is mounted with a mocked artifact loader, the loader is invoked exactly once.", + "body": "When MacroView is mounted with a mocked artifact loader, the loader is invoked exactly once. When the underlying artifact source emits subsequent change notifications (mocked), the loader is NOT re-invoked and the rendered RF nodes/edges remain referentially stable. Verify with a Vitest test using a spy on the loader and a mock store that emits changes after mount.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR6]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 173, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A DerivationRunNode with status='completed' has no border color matching --color-phosphor-red and no opacity/dimming reduction relative to…", + "body": "A DerivationRunNode with status='completed' has no border color matching --color-phosphor-red and no opacity/dimming reduction relative to the base node treatment. Verify with an RTL + computed-style test on a completed-status fixture.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR43]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 174, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A static-analysis scan of all files under src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx,css} finds zero literal color values matching /#[0-9a-fA-F]{3,8…", + "body": "A static-analysis scan of all files under src/components/macro/**/*.{ts,tsx,css} finds zero literal color values matching /#[0-9a-fA-F]{3,8}/, /\\brgb\\(/, /\\brgba\\(/, /\\bhsl\\(/, /\\bhsla\\(/, or /\\boklch\\(/ outside of var() references. All colors are referenced via var(--color-*) tokens defined in theme.css. Verify with a regex-based unit test scanning the directory.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR35]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 175, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: perspective nodes show which branch was taken; unchosen branches fade out to indicate they were not taken but could…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: perspective nodes show which branch was taken; unchosen branches fade out to indicate they were not taken but could be materialized later.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 176, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view implementation shall not modify the existing Sigma.js-based micro view, the routing layer, or unrelated parts of the Spec Ex…", + "body": "The macro view implementation shall not modify the existing Sigma.js-based micro view, the routing layer, or unrelated parts of the Spec Explorer UI. Changes are scoped to src/components/macro/, the existing src/components/MacroView.tsx re-export, and any minimal extensions to src/components/DetailPanel.tsx required to render macro record kinds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R59]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 177, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, and PerspectiveNode instances belonging to a phase shall be rendered as React Flow childr…", + "body": "DerivationRunNode, FanInNode, ReconciliationNode, and PerspectiveNode instances belonging to a phase shall be rendered as React Flow children of their PhaseGroupNode using parentId and extent='parent'. The PhaseGroupNode shall be a React Flow group/parent node (type='group' or equivalent).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R12]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 178, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: there is no separate 'trunk' node type; the trunk is simply the outermost shell of the onion-layered layout.", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: there is no separate 'trunk' node type; the trunk is simply the outermost shell of the onion-layered layout.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 179, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Clicking on a non-faded, non-phantom macro node shall dispatch a select action carrying the underlying IR record (frame, derivation run, fa…", + "body": "Clicking on a non-faded, non-phantom macro node shall dispatch a select action carrying the underlying IR record (frame, derivation run, fan-in, reconciliation, impasse hub, or perspective hub) into the existing global selection store consumed by DetailPanel.tsx.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R29]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 180, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "Collapsed/expanded state in the macro view is purely ephemeral in-memory React state and is never persisted.", + "body": "Collapsed/expanded state in the macro view is purely ephemeral in-memory React state and is never persisted.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C8]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 181, + "plane": "oracle", + "kind": "evidence", + "title": "The data structures for the macro view are defined in /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/s…", + "body": "The data structures for the macro view are defined in /Users/bmahmoud/projects/development/kael/packages/experimental/spec-elicitation-ui/src/types/artifact.ts.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder-observed [E1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 182, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The macro view's visual design must be beautiful, novel, and information-dense, avoiding generic dashboard or AI-generated aesthetics.", + "body": "The macro view's visual design must be beautiful, novel, and information-dense, avoiding generic dashboard or AI-generated aesthetics.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 183, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The Phase type has four ordered values: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defini…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [T1]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The Phase type has four ordered values: grounding, shaping, pinning, and defining_done." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 184, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: the nudging state is indicated by a treatment inside the node body (compact labelled chip or badge such as 'NUDGING…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: the nudging state is indicated by a treatment inside the node body (compact labelled chip or badge such as 'NUDGING' or '⚡ NUDGE' in phosphor amber) rather than as an external indicator.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X25]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 185, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For each phase group containing one or more DerivationRunNodes, a FanInNode, and a ReconciliationNode, layout emits sequence edges from eac…", + "body": "For each phase group containing one or more DerivationRunNodes, a FanInNode, and a ReconciliationNode, layout emits sequence edges from each RunNode → FanInNode and FanInNode → ReconciliationNode. Each such edge has computed stroke color resolving to --color-phosphor-amber, has a markerEnd arrow, and has animated !== true. Verify with a unit-test fixture and a render assertion on edge count, source/target ids, and computed style.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR53]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 186, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given two sibling phase groups A and B at the same depth where B is below A in the y axis, after collapsing A, B's new position.y is strict…", + "body": "Given two sibling phase groups A and B at the same depth where B is below A in the y axis, after collapsing A, B's new position.y is strictly less than its previous position.y by approximately the height differential (expanded_height(A) - pill_height) ± a tolerance. No sibling node retains a position that would leave a vertical gap larger than expanded_height(A)/2 where A's expanded body used to be. Verify with a unit test on layout() comparing pre-collapse and post-collapse outputs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR27]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 187, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given two depths D1 and D2 where the maximum content width across nodes at D1 is W1 and at D2 is W2, with W1 != W2, the lane widths assigne…", + "body": "Given two depths D1 and D2 where the maximum content width across nodes at D1 is W1 and at D2 is W2, with W1 != W2, the lane widths assigned by layout differ (laneWidth(D1) != laneWidth(D2)) and laneWidth(D_i) is a function of W_i (not a constant). Verify with a parameterized unit test asserting the lane-width function is non-constant across two fixtures with deliberately differing content widths.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR19]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 188, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given a fixture where impasse I in frame F0 triggers child frame F1 (parent F0, depth 1), the layout positions ImpasseNode I at the boundar…", + "body": "Given a fixture where impasse I in frame F0 triggers child frame F1 (parent F0, depth 1), the layout positions ImpasseNode I at the boundary between F0's lane (depth 0) and F1's lane (depth 1) such that it is horizontally between (or aligned with the start of) the two lanes. Verify with a unit test on layout asserting I.position.x lies between the rightmost x of F0's nodes and the leftmost x of F1's nodes (inclusive).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR65]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 189, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "A user should be able to understand what happened at each derivation step from the node visuals alone (numbers, IDs, outcomes) without need…", + "body": "A user should be able to understand what happened at each derivation step from the node visuals alone (numbers, IDs, outcomes) without needing to open a detail panel.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 190, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Collapse/expand state for phase groups shall be held in a single useState> (or equivalent set keyed by phase-group identity) a…", + "body": "Collapse/expand state for phase groups shall be held in a single useState> (or equivalent set keyed by phase-group identity) at the MacroView root component. PhaseGroupNode renderers shall not own their own collapse state.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 191, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "ReconciliationNode renders with computed border-color: outcome='accepted' → the parent phase's --color-phase-* token; outcome='retry' → --c…", + "body": "ReconciliationNode renders with computed border-color: outcome='accepted' → the parent phase's --color-phase-* token; outcome='retry' → --color-phosphor-amber; outcome='recurse' → --color-phosphor-cyan; outcome='bail' → --color-phosphor-red AND a dimmed interior treatment. Header contains a textual chip whose text equals the outcome name. Verify with parameterized RTL tests across all four outcomes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR47]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 192, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "A DetailPanel.tsx component exists at src/components/DetailPanel.tsx as a sibling to MacroView.tsx, confirming reuse is structurally feasib…", + "body": "A DetailPanel.tsx component exists at src/components/DetailPanel.tsx as a sibling to MacroView.tsx, confirming reuse is structurally feasible.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "technical-observed [X40]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 193, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "A heuristic content-completeness test asserts that every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node renders text/visual elements coverin…", + "body": "A heuristic content-completeness test asserts that every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node renders text/visual elements covering at minimum: a unique ID (frame displayId, run index, hub displayId, etc.), a count or status indicator (run counts, outcome glyph, fan-in row count, or impassesFound), and (where applicable) a mode/outcome chip. Verify with an RTL-driven content audit: for each node-type fixture, assert presence of (a) ID text, (b) numeric or glyph indicator, (c) status/mode chip text where applicable.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR63]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 194, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "The macro view is the component within the Spec Explorer UI that narrates the f…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T14]", + "detail": { + "definition": "The macro view is the component within the Spec Explorer UI that narrates the full derivation history of a spec via a pannable, zoomable React Flow graph of ~20–40 semantically typed nodes." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 195, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "Every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node shall surface enough content (IDs, counts, outcome glyph, mode chip) to identify what h…", + "body": "Every visible (non-collapsed, non-faded) macro node shall surface enough content (IDs, counts, outcome glyph, mode chip) to identify what happened at that derivation step without requiring the user to open the detail panel.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R63]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 196, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view shall render exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord, one FanInNode per FanInRecord, and one ReconciliationNod…", + "body": "The macro view shall render exactly one DerivationRunNode per DerivationRunRecord, one FanInNode per FanInRecord, and one ReconciliationNode per ReconciliationRecord present in ArtifactFile.graph.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 197, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Given a fixture phase group with no PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected', buildStoryIR emits exactly one PhantomNode child…", + "body": "Given a fixture phase group with no PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'selected', buildStoryIR emits exactly one PhantomNode child for that phase group whose id is synthesized (not present in ArtifactFile) and whose label contains the phrase 'no perspective taken' (case-insensitive). Conversely, for a phase group containing a selected perspective, no PhantomNode is emitted. Verify with two unit-test fixtures.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR16]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 198, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, the rendered pill DOM contains: (1) an element styled with background-color or border-color resolving t…", + "body": "When a PhaseGroupNode is collapsed, the rendered pill DOM contains: (1) an element styled with background-color or border-color resolving to the corresponding --color-phase-* token, (2) the frame's displayId text, (3) text matching the pattern /\\d+\\s+RUNS?/, and (4) one of the glyphs ✓, ↺, ↪, or ✗ corresponding to the frame's terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome (accepted/retry/recurse/bail respectively). Clicking the pill toggles expansion AND dispatches a select action. Verify with a parameterized RTL test covering all four outcomes.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR26]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 199, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Inspecting the MacroView component source (or its rendered React tree) shows exactly one useState/useReducer call holding a Set (or Set-equ…", + "body": "Inspecting the MacroView component source (or its rendered React tree) shows exactly one useState/useReducer call holding a Set (or Set-equivalent) of FrameId values for collapsed groups, located in the MacroView root component. PhaseGroupNode component source contains no useState/useReducer holding collapse state. Verify with a static-analysis test (AST inspection of the source files) and/or a runtime test using React DevTools-equivalent introspection.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR22]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 200, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "term", + "title": "A phantom node represents the case where no perspective is selected — it appear…", + "body": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [T10]", + "detail": { + "definition": "A phantom node represents the case where no perspective is selected — it appears when an alternative perspective is used." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 201, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Calling buildStoryIR(artifact) twice with structurally-equal artifact inputs produces deeply-equal outputs.", + "body": "Calling buildStoryIR(artifact) twice with structurally-equal artifact inputs produces deeply-equal outputs. Calling layout(ir, set) twice with structurally-equal inputs produces deeply-equal outputs. Neither function mutates its input (pre/post deep-equal of inputs). Neither references Date.now, Math.random, document, window, or external store. Verify with property-based tests (fast-check) for determinism and idempotence, plus a static-analysis test for forbidden globals.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR61]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 202, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "An ImpasseNode whose hub is the trigger of a child frame whose terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome is 'bail' shall be annotated with a 'D…", + "body": "An ImpasseNode whose hub is the trigger of a child frame whose terminal ReconciliationRecord.outcome is 'bail' shall be annotated with a 'DEAD-END' textual chip on the node, distinguishing it from open or resolved impasses.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R49]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 203, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The macro view must use React Flow (@xyflow/react) version ^12.", + "body": "The macro view must use React Flow (@xyflow/react) version ^12.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 204, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "story-ir.ts exports a buildStoryIR(artifact) function whose return type is a typed StoryIR (not RFNode[]); layout.ts exports a layout(ir, c…", + "body": "story-ir.ts exports a buildStoryIR(artifact) function whose return type is a typed StoryIR (not RFNode[]); layout.ts exports a layout(ir, collapsedSet) function whose return type contains RFNode[] and RFEdge[] with absolute positions. Verify by a TypeScript type-level test (tsd or expectTypeOf) that the IR builder's output has no React Flow position/parentId fields and that the layout output's nodes array contains objects with {id, type, position, parentId?}.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR5]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 205, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: all three frame modes (initial, rederive, grounding_enrichment) render as the same phase-group node component, with…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: all three frame modes (initial, rederive, grounding_enrichment) render as the same phase-group node component, with mode differences expressed via color, label, or border style only.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X20]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 206, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "For each HubNode with hubType='impasse' that participates in the derivation narrative (i.e., is referenced via FrameRecord.triggerImpasseId…", + "body": "For each HubNode with hubType='impasse' that participates in the derivation narrative (i.e., is referenced via FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds or ReconciliationRecord.resolvedImpasseIds/triggerImpasseIds/unresolvedImpasseIds), the IR contains exactly one ImpasseNode whose id maps to that hub. Likewise for each participating HubNode with hubType='perspective'. Verify with a unit test on buildStoryIR using a fixture covering all three reference paths.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR15]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 207, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "goal", + "title": "The macro view answers the question 'how did the spec get here?' by visualizing the full onion-peel cycle of impasse discovery, rederivatio…", + "body": "The macro view answers the question 'how did the spec get here?' by visualizing the full onion-peel cycle of impasse discovery, rederivation, reconciliation, and resolution.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [G1]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 208, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "All macro view edges shall render without animation by default; no edge shall use React Flow's animated property by default.", + "body": "All macro view edges shall render without animation by default; no edge shall use React Flow's animated property by default.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R55]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 209, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "A right-side detail panel is already implemented and wired in the Micro View; the macro view should reuse it.", + "body": "A right-side detail panel is already implemented and wired in the Micro View; the macro view should reuse it.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X4]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 210, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested derivation run is collapsed it shrinks to a small pill or badge node showing key stats (run count, ou…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: when a nested derivation run is collapsed it shrinks to a small pill or badge node showing key stats (run count, outcome).", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X21]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 211, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "Clicking on a PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' or 'open' (i.e., faded) does NOT dispatch any select action.", + "body": "Clicking on a PerspectiveNode whose perspectiveStatus is 'rejected' or 'open' (i.e., faded) does NOT dispatch any select action. Its DOM exposes no interactive affordance. Verify with an RTL test using fixtures for both selected and faded perspective nodes; click each; assert select dispatch only for the selected one.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR33]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 212, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "The full project builds with `vite build` (or its equivalent npm/deno script) without errors after adding the macro view.", + "body": "The full project builds with `vite build` (or its equivalent npm/deno script) without errors after adding the macro view. No new bundler or runtime is added (no Webpack, Parcel, esbuild standalone, etc., introduced). package.json/deno.json shows no new CSS framework dependency competing with Tailwind. Verify with a CI build step plus a dependency-list check.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR60]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 213, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "requirement", + "title": "The macro view shall render one ImpasseNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'impasse', and one PerspectiveNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'p…", + "body": "The macro view shall render one ImpasseNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'impasse', and one PerspectiveNode per HubNode whose hubType is 'perspective', subject to those hubs participating in the derivation narrative captured by the IR.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [R14]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 214, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Stakeholder preference: custom React Flow node types exist for each semantic role: trunk phase, impasse, phase group, fan-out, run, fan-in,…", + "body": "Stakeholder preference: custom React Flow node types exist for each semantic role: trunk phase, impasse, phase group, fan-out, run, fan-in, reconciliation, perspective, phantom, and dead-end impasse.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [X13]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 215, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "constraint", + "title": "The macro view is a snapshot-only view: it reads artifact data once on mount and does not update reactively.", + "body": "The macro view is a snapshot-only view: it reads artifact data once on mount and does not update reactively.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "stakeholder [C11]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 216, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "criterion", + "title": "On every fresh mount of MacroView with any artifact fixture, immediately after first render, no PhaseGroupNode is rendered as a collapsed p…", + "body": "On every fresh mount of MacroView with any artifact fixture, immediately after first render, no PhaseGroupNode is rendered as a collapsed pill: every phase group renders in its expanded form. Verify with a render test that mounts MacroView and asserts (a) the collapsed-set state is empty and (b) no element with the macro-collapsed-pill data attribute is in the DOM.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived [CR23]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 217, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Hoist a single Set of collapsed IDs to MacroView root, in-memory only.", + "body": "Hoist a single Set of collapsed IDs to MacroView root, in-memory only.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC6]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Collapse/expand state lives in a single useState> at the MacroView root, holding the IDs of currently-collapsed phase groups (or frames). The set starts empty on mount (everything expanded per C9) and is never written to localStorage, sessionStorage, URL, or any persistence layer (per C8). Toggle handlers are passed down via React context to PhaseGroupNode renderers, which swap to a compact pill renderer when their ID is in the set. After a toggle, the layout function re-runs synchronously over the IR + collapsed-set to produce new node positions, and React Flow's animated transitions (default fitView=false, but applyNodeChanges with smooth-tweened positions) handle reflow per X22.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: persist collapse state across reloads (localStorage). Rejected by C8/C9.", + "Alternative: each PhaseGroupNode owns its own useState for collapsed/expanded. Local but means parent layout cannot recompute on toggle without lifting state anyway." + ], + "rationale": "Collapse changes the global layout (sibling shifts, X22), so the set must be visible to the layout function; per-node local state forces a redundant lift. C8/C9 forbid persistence, ruling out localStorage. A single Set keeps the toggle O(1), is trivially serializable for unit tests, and makes the snapshot-load+expanded-default invariant a one-liner (initial state = empty set)." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 218, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Render only the three workflow edge classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), synthesized from frame/run/fan-in/reconciliation records…", + "body": "Render only the three workflow edge classes (sequence, impasse-spawn, resolution), synthesized from frame/run/fan-in/reconciliation records, not from EdgeRecord rows.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC9]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Edges in the macro view encode three workflow relationships, each rendered as a typed React Flow edge: (1) sequence edges — thin amber lines connecting RunNode → FanInNode → ReconciliationNode within a phase group, expressing fan-out→fan-in→reconcile flow (T4/T5/T6); (2) impasse-spawn edges — red dashed lines from a ReconciliationNode (or a PhaseGroupNode whose phase produced impasses) outward to the ImpasseNode that opened a new lane, expressing that the impasse caused a child frame (X16, FrameRecord.triggerImpasseIds); (3) resolution edges — phase-colored solid lines from a child frame's terminal ReconciliationNode (or activated nodes) back to the impasse it resolved, drawn with a return-leftward routing convention (T6.resolvedImpasseIds). Edges between sibling phase groups inside a frame follow PHASE_ORDER. All edges use markerEnd arrows, no animation by default. Edges within a collapsed group are hidden along with the group's children; the group's connecting external edges remain attached at the pill's perimeter.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: derive every edge mechanically from EdgeRecord rows in the artifact (informed_by, produced, considered, etc.). This pushes graph-content edges (designed for the micro view) into the macro view and would generate hundreds of edges, defeating the macro view's narrative purpose.", + "Alternative: render no edges at all and rely on spatial proximity / containment to imply flow. Cleaner visually but loses the narrative arrow of impasse → child frame → resolution that the macro view exists to tell." + ], + "rationale": "The macro view narrates the derivation process (G1, X3); content-level edges belong to the micro view (X2). Three semantically named edge classes give the narrative structure (fan-out→fan-in→reconcile, impasse opens a lane, resolution closes it back) while keeping the rendered edge count proportional to the ~20–40 nodes. Implicit-only edges leave the resolution arc invisible. Each edge class uses one already-justified color (amber for trunk flow, red for impasse, phase color for resolution), respecting C7." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 219, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Animated phosphor-arrive loop + cyan 'RUNNING' chip + scanline sweep on running runs.", + "body": "Animated phosphor-arrive loop + cyan 'RUNNING' chip + scanline sweep on running runs.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC10]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "When a DerivationRunRecord.status is 'running' (rare per X26), the RunNode renders with: (a) the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe (already in theme.css) looping at slow tempo on the node body, (b) a 'RUNNING' chip in --color-phosphor-cyan in the header (cyan is unused for outcome semantics elsewhere, so it carries no conflicting meaning), and (c) a thin animated scanline sweep across the node interior. The node remains clickable and shows the same content fields as a completed run.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: a static cyan 'RUNNING' chip with no animation. Calmer but defeats X26's 'highlighted somehow' intent.", + "Alternative: amber pulsing border. Rejected because amber already encodes nudging (X25) and reconciliation 'retry' outcome (X28); reusing it for running creates ambiguity, violating C7's 'every color earns its place'." + ], + "rationale": "X26 says running is unlikely but must be highlighted. Cyan is the one phosphor token not yet load-bearing in macro semantics (red=failure/bail, amber=nudging/retry, green=merged/success, purple=defining_done phase, phase colors=phase identity), so it cleanly marks an in-flight state without colliding with C7. Animation distinguishes running from any static state at a glance. Reusing the existing phosphor-arrive keyframe keeps the addition cheap and within the established CRT motion vocabulary." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 220, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use a dedicated Story IR layer between artifact data and rendering.", + "body": "Use a dedicated Story IR layer between artifact data and rendering.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC1]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Architect MacroView as a three-stage pure pipeline: (1) Story IR builder that consumes ArtifactFile.graph and produces a normalized derivation tree (FrameNode root → PhaseNode children → RunNode/FanInNode/ReconciliationNode/PerspectiveNode/ImpasseNode descendants, with parentFrameId chains expanded into nested impasse branches), (2) Layout engine that walks the IR and computes absolute (x,y) positions, lane widths, and parent/child grouping, (3) React Flow renderer that maps IR nodes to custom node types and IR edges to typed RF edges. The IR is the only contract layout and rendering depend on; data shape changes localize to stage 1.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: skip the Story IR and map ArtifactFile records directly to React Flow nodes inside one component, with layout calculation interleaved with rendering.", + "Alternative: model the derivation history as a generic graphlib graph and feed it through a layered layout, then translate to React Flow at the end." + ], + "rationale": "The macro view's spatial grammar (onion-peel breadth, phase containment, fan-out/fan-in nesting, perspective fade) is highly domain-specific and unstable while the design is being iterated. A typed IR isolates the domain mapping from layout math from React Flow specifics, letting each stage be unit-testable and letting the manual layout (mandated by C3) operate on a tree shape that already encodes parent/child semantics rather than re-deriving them. Direct RF mapping conflates concerns and makes the collapse/reflow logic (X22) harder. A generic graphlib representation loses the typed semantics the custom node renderers need." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 221, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Encode information across orthogonal visual channels (border style, border color, fill, header chips, opacity, shape) drawn from existing p…", + "body": "Encode information across orthogonal visual channels (border style, border color, fill, header chips, opacity, shape) drawn from existing phosphor tokens.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC8]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Each node type expresses its semantic role through a fixed visual vocabulary built from theme.css tokens: (a) PhaseGroupNode — 1px border in the phase color (--color-phase-*), warm dark surface-1 fill, scanline overlay, header line 'PHASE / FRAME-ID / mode' in --color-text-secondary; mode differentiation per X20 done by border style (initial=solid, rederive=double, grounding_enrichment=dashed) plus a small mode chip; nudgingActive shown as a 'NUDGING' chip in --color-phosphor-amber inside the header (X25). (b) DerivationRunNode — numbered tile 'RUN #n' with input/output count badges and impassesFound count; status='completed' is base, status='failed' uses --color-phosphor-red border and dimmed interior (X27), status='running' adds an animated phosphor-arrive pulse (X26). (c) FanInNode — stacked rows, one per FanInGrouping, each row prefixed by a 4px left border in green/amber/red per resolution (X32); row text shows groupKey and node count. (d) ReconciliationNode — outcome encoded as full-node border color (accepted=phase color, retry=amber, recurse=cyan/blue, bail=red+dim) per X28, plus an outcome chip in the header; materialProgress=true shown as a small ✓ chip beside the outcome (X35). (e) ImpasseNode — diamond/lozenge shape with red glyph, displayId visible; if linked to a bail reconciliation (X36), it is annotated 'DEAD-END' to disambiguate from open impasses (RK2 mitigation). (f) PerspectiveNode — branching tile; selected branch full opacity, rejected branches at ~30% opacity (X23); non-interactive when faded (X24). (g) PhantomNode — dashed-outline ghost tile, no fill, label 'PHANTOM — no perspective taken', non-interactive (X24).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: lean heavily on icons (status icons, mode icons, outcome icons) instead of typographic chips and border treatments. Punchier visually but less information-dense per pixel and breaks the typographic CRT aesthetic.", + "Alternative: encode all status/mode/outcome differences via fill color alone, leaving borders neutral. Easier but loses the orthogonal channels (border = outcome, fill = mode, chip = nudging) that let several attributes coexist on one node." + ], + "rationale": "G3 demands at-a-glance comprehension and G4 demands that each node communicates its specific outcome; a single channel cannot carry mode + status + outcome + nudging + materialProgress simultaneously. Orthogonal channels honor C7 (every color earns meaning: border=outcome, phase color=phase, red=failure/bail, amber=warning states). Iconographic styling fights the JetBrains Mono / typographic CRT aesthetic (X11, X37). Reusing the seven oklch tokens already defined in theme.css avoids palette inflation and keeps C13 satisfied. The intentional collision between bail-outcome and failed-run treatment (X29) is preserved; RK2 is mitigated by adding a 'DEAD-END' textual chip on bail-linked impasses rather than diverging the color treatment." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 222, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Decompose into a src/components/macro/ folder with one file per pipeline stage and one file per node type.", + "body": "Decompose into a src/components/macro/ folder with one file per pipeline stage and one file per node type.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC13]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Module structure under src/components/macro/: index.ts (re-exports MacroView), MacroView.tsx (top-level: data load, state, ReactFlowProvider, Canvas), story-ir.ts (ArtifactFile → StoryIR builder, pure), layout.ts (StoryIR + collapsedSet → RFNode[]/RFEdge[], pure), nodes/ (PhaseGroupNode.tsx, DerivationRunNode.tsx, FanInNode.tsx, ReconciliationNode.tsx, ImpasseNode.tsx, PerspectiveNode.tsx, PhantomNode.tsx — one component per type), edges/ (custom edge components if needed), and macro.css or co-located CSS modules using only theme.css tokens. Existing src/components/MacroView.tsx becomes a thin re-export of the new module to preserve the current import path.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: keep everything inside the existing single MacroView.tsx file. Faster to start but conflicts with the pipeline boundaries (dec-pipeline) and clusters seven node renderers into one file." + ], + "rationale": "The pipeline decision (dec-pipeline) and the seven-node taxonomy (dec-node-taxonomy) both imply natural file boundaries. Co-locating the macro folder under components keeps the project's existing layout convention (sibling to DetailPanel.tsx). Re-exporting through the original MacroView.tsx path means routes/explore.tsx keeps working unchanged. C5 explicitly scopes this work to the macro view, so a dedicated folder helps reviewers see the scope boundary." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 223, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Adopt seven typed React Flow node components, no separate trunk type.", + "body": "Adopt seven typed React Flow node components, no separate trunk type.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC4]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Define exactly seven custom React Flow node types matching the data shapes: PhaseGroupNode (RF group/parent node, one per FrameRecord+Phase pair, mode-tinted), DerivationRunNode (one per DerivationRunRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode), FanInNode (one per FanInRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode, contains color-coded grouping rows), ReconciliationNode (one per ReconciliationRecord, child of PhaseGroupNode), ImpasseNode (one per HubNode with hubType='impasse', positioned at the boundary opening a new lane), PerspectiveNode (one per HubNode with hubType='perspective'), and PhantomNode (synthesized when a phase group ends without a perspective selection per T10). The trunk is not a node type; it emerges from PhaseGroupNodes laid out at depth 0 (per X19).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: introduce an explicit TrunkNode type for depth-0 phase groups, separate from nested phase groups.", + "Alternative: one polymorphic 'MacroNode' component that switches on a discriminator prop. Reduces the React Flow nodeTypes registry but conflates radically different visual treatments and makes per-type styling and testing harder." + ], + "rationale": "X13 enumerates the desired semantic node types; one React component per type aligns the type system with the visual grammar and gives each node its own focused render path (G3/G4 require visual distinctness at a glance). A polymorphic component would push that complexity into a single switch and erode TypeScript support. X19 explicitly says trunk is not a separate type; reusing PhaseGroupNode at depth 0 honors that and keeps mode tinting (X20) as the only differentiator. Dead-end impasse is handled as a visual variant of ImpasseNode driven by the linked ReconciliationRecord.outcome='bail' (X36), not as an eighth type, because behaviorally it is still an impasse." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 224, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Show a snapshot timestamp + reload affordance as a fixed corner overlay.", + "body": "Show a snapshot timestamp + reload affordance as a fixed corner overlay.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC11]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Render a small permanently-visible 'SNAPSHOT @ ' badge in the macro view's top-left corner using --color-text-tertiary, with a 'RELOAD' button next to it. Clicking RELOAD re-runs the pipeline. The banner sits above the React Flow canvas as a fixed overlay; it does not participate in pan/zoom.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: no banner, rely on user knowledge that the view is snapshot-only. Leaves RK3 (stale data) fully unmitigated." + ], + "rationale": "RK3 (users may view stale history) is a real and silent failure mode. Surfacing the snapshot time directly in the view turns it from invisible to glanceable, while a Reload button makes the manual-refresh expectation actionable without violating C11/C12 (the data contract is still snapshot-on-load; Reload is an explicit re-mount). The treatment is small and uses an existing token (text-tertiary), so it doesn't compete with the derivation graph for attention." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 225, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Snapshot the artifact on mount; require manual reload.", + "body": "Snapshot the artifact on mount; require manual reload.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC2]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Load the artifact exactly once on component mount via a useEffect/useMemo against the artifact source (file fetch or store selector), build the Story IR, run layout, and freeze the resulting React Flow nodes/edges arrays into useState. No subscriptions, no live updates. Provide a manual 'Reload' affordance that re-runs the pipeline.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: subscribe to the artifact store and recompute the IR/layout on every change." + ], + "rationale": "C11/C12 explicitly mandate snapshot-only behavior. Live subscription would invalidate the layout mid-interaction and conflict with the ephemeral collapse state (C8), causing layouts to thrash. A visible 'Reload' affordance partially mitigates RK3 (stale data) without breaking the snapshot contract." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 226, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Collapse to a stat-bearing pill, not an icon.", + "body": "Collapse to a stat-bearing pill, not an icon.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC12]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "When a PhaseGroupNode is in the collapsed set, its renderer swaps to a compact pill ~120px×28px showing: phase color dot + frame displayId + 'n RUNS' + outcome glyph (✓ accepted / ↺ retry / ↪ recurse / ✗ bail) derived from the frame's terminal reconciliation. The pill remains clickable to expand and to open the detail panel. External edges re-attach to the pill's center handles automatically because React Flow recomputes edge endpoints from node bounds.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: collapse to a tiny icon-only marker. Smaller but loses the at-a-glance run count + outcome that X21 calls out as 'key stats'." + ], + "rationale": "X21 explicitly says the collapsed form should show key stats (run count, outcome). G3 demands at-a-glance comprehension even in summary form. A pill carries the four bits of information (phase, frame ID, run count, outcome) using existing visual tokens; an icon-only marker forces the user to expand or open the detail panel just to recall what a frame contains, defeating the purpose of collapse-as-summary." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 227, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Reuse the existing DetailPanel component, extending it with branches for macro record kinds.", + "body": "Reuse the existing DetailPanel component, extending it with branches for macro record kinds.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC7]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "On node click, the MacroView reads the React Flow node's underlying IR record (frame, run, fan-in, reconciliation, or hub) and dispatches a 'select' action to the existing global selection store consumed by DetailPanel.tsx. The DetailPanel branches its rendering on record kind to display frame summary, run inputs/outputs, fan-in groupings, reconciliation deltas, etc. PhantomNodes and faded perspective branches do not dispatch any selection (per X24).", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: build a separate macro-specific detail panel optimized for derivation records (frames/runs/reconciliations), since DetailPanel was originally built for graph nodes." + ], + "rationale": "X4 mandates reuse. The DetailPanel already handles selection plumbing, layout, and CRT styling; replicating that for the macro view would duplicate code and risk visual divergence. Adding record-kind branches inside DetailPanel keeps the selection contract single. Read-only enforcement (C10) is automatic because DetailPanel has no mutating actions wired in the macro path." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 228, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use a custom recursive DFS lane layout with proportional lane widths.", + "body": "Use a custom recursive DFS lane layout with proportional lane widths.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC3]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Manual layout algorithm: compute derivationDepth for each FrameRecord as the length of its parentFrameId chain; assign each frame to a horizontal lane indexed by depth (depth 0 = trunk at center, depth 1+ branches to the right). Within a lane, frames stack vertically with the most recent at the top (higher y ←→ more recent t+1). Each lane's width is computed as a function of the maximum content width across all nodes at that depth, not a fixed constant. Phase groups inside a frame stack vertically in PHASE_ORDER reverse (defining_done top, grounding bottom) so the eye reads downward through the derivation, while later frames sit above earlier ones at the lane level. The algorithm runs as a recursive DFS that returns subtree bounding boxes used to compute sibling offsets.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: use ELK.js layered layout with manual constraints to encode lanes. Cheaper to implement than full manual layout but less precise about onion-peel breadth and conflicts with C3.", + "Alternative: fixed lane width and fixed row height, regardless of content. Simple to implement but ignores X31's proportional-width preference and produces large dead space at shallow lanes." + ], + "rationale": "C3 forbids dagre and the equivalent argument applies to ELK: the spatial grammar (onion peel breadth = depth, verticality = time, impasses opening lanes per X16, perspective fan-out under phase groups) is too prescriptive for any general-purpose layout. A recursive DFS that returns subtree bounding boxes is a small amount of code (roughly 100–200 LOC) and gives full control. Fixed lanes were rejected because X31 specifies proportional sizing and because shallow trunks would otherwise look impoverished next to wide branches." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 229, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "decision", + "title": "Use React Flow parent/child group nodes for phase containers.", + "body": "Use React Flow parent/child group nodes for phase containers.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "[DEC5]", + "detail": { + "chosen_option": "Use React Flow's parentId/extent='parent' mechanism so that DerivationRunNodes, FanInNodes, ReconciliationNodes, and PerspectiveNodes are children of a PhaseGroupNode (which is rendered as type='group'). Children use position relative to the parent's origin, and the layout algorithm emits absolute parent positions plus relative child offsets. This lets React Flow handle the visual containment, drag-bound clipping, and z-ordering for free, and it makes collapse-as-pill (X21) a matter of toggling the group's children to display:none and swapping its renderer to a compact pill.", + "rejected": [ + "Alternative: render the entire phase group's interior (runs, fan-in, reconciliation rows) as inner HTML inside a single React Flow node, without using RF parenting at all.", + "Alternative: render fan-out/fan-in/reconciliation as separate top-level nodes positioned to overlap a 'background' phase node; do not use React Flow parenting." + ], + "rationale": "X18 explicitly mandates RF group/parent nodes. Beyond compliance, parenting buys correct hit-testing, per-node click-to-detail (X33), and individual child animation when the group reflows on collapse (X22). HTML-only nesting forfeits the ability to attach edges from a fan-in row to a child reconciliation node and breaks the click-target model. Manual overlap is fragile and reorders interactively." + } + }, + { + "local_id": 230, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "The combination of mandatory snapshot-only data loading, the resulting risk of users viewing stale derivation history, and the requirement…", + "body": "The combination of mandatory snapshot-only data loading, the resulting risk of users viewing stale derivation history, and the requirement to keep the data contract unchanged jointly force a visible-snapshot-time + reload-button overlay (rather than no banner, or live-subscription).\n\n## Rationale\n\nC11/C12 mandate snapshot-only behavior; RK3 identifies stale-data viewing as a real silent failure; DEC2 forbids live subscriptions; DEC11 chooses a banner+reload affordance as the mitigation. Together these jointly require both (a) a visible snapshot timestamp and (b) an explicit reload control to be present in the UI — neither premise alone is sufficient.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J2]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 231, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Three independent constraints jointly force collapse state to be a single hoisted in-memory Set with no persistence and an empty initial va…", + "body": "Three independent constraints jointly force collapse state to be a single hoisted in-memory Set with no persistence and an empty initial value: (1) the requirement that collapse triggers global sibling reflow, (2) the prohibition on persistence, and (3) the mandate that every page load starts fully expanded.\n\n## Rationale\n\nX22 requires sibling reflow on collapse, which the layout function needs visibility into the full collapsed set to compute — forcing the state to be lifted to MacroView root (DEC6). C8 forbids any persistence layer. C9 mandates fully-expanded state at every mount. Together these uniquely determine the design captured in D6.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J3]", + "detail": null + }, + { + "local_id": 232, + "plane": "intent", + "kind": "context", + "title": "Multiple node-attribute encodings (border style for mode, border color for outcome, fill for phase, header chips for nudging/material progr…", + "body": "Multiple node-attribute encodings (border style for mode, border color for outcome, fill for phase, header chips for nudging/material progress, opacity for perspective selection, shape for impasse) coexist on a single node without ambiguity because each visual channel is reserved for a single semantic dimension.\n\n## Rationale\n\nG3/G4 require at-a-glance comprehension; X25, X27, X28, X32, X35, X23 each assign a different semantic attribute to a different visual channel; C7 forbids decorative color reuse; DEC8 explicitly orthogonalizes channels. Together these premises force the requirement that no two semantic attributes share the same visual channel, which is a property each node renderer must collectively satisfy.", + "basis": "explicit", + "source": "derived-justification-synthesis | [J1]", + "detail": null + } + ], + "edges": [ + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 122, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 142, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 1, + "target_local_id": 181, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 101, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 125, + "target_local_id": 230, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 197, + "target_local_id": 45, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 40, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 76, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 25, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 73, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 204, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 40, + "target_local_id": 157, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 55, + "target_local_id": 119, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 57, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 214, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 38, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 50, + "target_local_id": 120, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 100, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 98, + "target_local_id": 74, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 187, + "target_local_id": 38, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 229, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 213, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 53, + "target_local_id": 183, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 65, + "target_local_id": 210, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 131, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 207, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 43, + "target_local_id": 155, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 195, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 229, + "target_local_id": 168, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 9, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 24, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 130, + "target_local_id": 196, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 203, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 43, + "target_local_id": 109, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 62, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 27, + "target_local_id": 147, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 13, + "target_local_id": 47, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 99, + "target_local_id": 230, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 97, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 27, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 41, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 80, + "target_local_id": 225, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 137, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 86, + "target_local_id": 182, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 73, + "target_local_id": 122, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 45, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 69, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 183, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 44, + "target_local_id": 31, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 20, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 137, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 21, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 151, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 210, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 86, + "target_local_id": 79, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 168, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 198, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 177, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 41, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 88, + "target_local_id": 145, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 80, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 184, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 137, + "target_local_id": 148, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 229, + "target_local_id": 210, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 78, + "target_local_id": 208, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 159, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 8, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 94, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 30, + "target_local_id": 77, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 211, + "target_local_id": 175, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 150, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 225, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 165, + "target_local_id": 23, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 180, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 150, + "target_local_id": 27, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 87, + "target_local_id": 68, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 17, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 132, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 210, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 229, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 4, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 119, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 124, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 105, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 112, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 184, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 155, + "target_local_id": 194, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 99, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 145, + "target_local_id": 104, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 188, + "target_local_id": 74, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 115, + "target_local_id": 159, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 199, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 84, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 212, + "target_local_id": 48, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 97, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 111, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 135, + "target_local_id": 88, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 177, + "target_local_id": 168, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 172, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 87, + "target_local_id": 184, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 106, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 88, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 34, + "target_local_id": 42, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 116, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 6, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 37, + "target_local_id": 80, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 225, + "target_local_id": 33, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 26, + "target_local_id": 38, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 73, + "target_local_id": 181, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 158, + "target_local_id": 119, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 10, + "target_local_id": 128, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 165, + "target_local_id": 109, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 31, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 101, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 6, + "target_local_id": 53, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 101, + "target_local_id": 138, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 81, + "target_local_id": 175, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 88, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 86, + "target_local_id": 157, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 39, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 69, + "target_local_id": 147, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 107, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 88, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 61, + "target_local_id": 231, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 190, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 33, + "target_local_id": 230, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 113, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 167, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 155, + "target_local_id": 109, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 193, + "target_local_id": 195, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 113, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 207, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 121, + "target_local_id": 25, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 149, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 16, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 44, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 95, + "target_local_id": 79, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 172, + "target_local_id": 33, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 192, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 166, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 158, + "target_local_id": 55, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 126, + "target_local_id": 70, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 147, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 137, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 193, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 162, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 141, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 111, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 29, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 66, + "target_local_id": 113, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 121, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 141, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 41, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 161, + "target_local_id": 231, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 74, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 96, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 224, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 197, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 175, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 180, + "target_local_id": 231, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 70, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 102, + "target_local_id": 90, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 35, + "target_local_id": 30, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 117, + "target_local_id": 121, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 198, + "target_local_id": 65, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 36, + "target_local_id": 129, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 52, + "target_local_id": 202, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 147, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 149, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 224, + "target_local_id": 33, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 195, + "target_local_id": 138, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 30, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 60, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 191, + "target_local_id": 134, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 35, + "target_local_id": 24, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 180, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 85, + "target_local_id": 9, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 40, + "target_local_id": 104, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 55, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 9, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 225, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 224, + "target_local_id": 225, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 147, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 211, + "target_local_id": 69, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 100, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 153, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 173, + "target_local_id": 71, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 30, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 163, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 172, + "target_local_id": 169, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 138, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 164, + "target_local_id": 51, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 15, + "target_local_id": 59, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 16, + "target_local_id": 86, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 162, + "target_local_id": 56, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 106, + "target_local_id": 124, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 157, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 169, + "target_local_id": 33, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 225, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 111, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 93, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 48, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 34, + "target_local_id": 203, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 135, + "target_local_id": 145, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 165, + "target_local_id": 207, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 38, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 224, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 207, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 177, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 29, + "target_local_id": 77, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 65, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 131, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 153, + "target_local_id": 207, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 76, + "target_local_id": 157, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 13, + "target_local_id": 147, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 56, + "target_local_id": 109, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 160, + "target_local_id": 179, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 57, + "target_local_id": 105, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 59, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 68, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 231, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 85, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 53, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 93, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 90, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 95, + "target_local_id": 182, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 58, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 52, + "target_local_id": 14, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 227, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 167, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 109, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 69, + "target_local_id": 175, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 201, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 70, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 70, + "target_local_id": 148, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 184, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 178, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 110, + "target_local_id": 157, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 141, + "target_local_id": 116, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 229, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 81, + "target_local_id": 2, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 144, + "target_local_id": 106, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 170, + "target_local_id": 77, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 128, + "target_local_id": 194, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 51, + "target_local_id": 138, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 5, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 98, + "target_local_id": 141, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 9, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 8, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 111, + "target_local_id": 178, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 148, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 169, + "target_local_id": 225, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 98, + "target_local_id": 116, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 177, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 27, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 186, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 21, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 143, + "target_local_id": 100, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 169, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 226, + "target_local_id": 124, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 92, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 105, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 54, + "target_local_id": 8, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 175, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 185, + "target_local_id": 137, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 216, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 152, + "target_local_id": 122, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 79, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 126, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 47, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 123, + "target_local_id": 22, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 231, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 177, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 187, + "target_local_id": 26, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 65, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 118, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 206, + "target_local_id": 213, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 156, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 139, + "target_local_id": 18, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 124, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 214, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 23, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 127, + "target_local_id": 75, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 138, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 191, + "target_local_id": 96, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 45, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 213, + "target_local_id": 21, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 137, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 188, + "target_local_id": 119, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 99, + "target_local_id": 33, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 166, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 22, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 46, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 129, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 5, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 52, + "target_local_id": 30, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 26, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 133, + "target_local_id": 131, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 86, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 132, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 212, + "target_local_id": 102, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 55, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 195, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 54, + "target_local_id": 180, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 53, + "target_local_id": 7, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 193, + "target_local_id": 138, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 178, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 205, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 74, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 183, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 120, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 229, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 58, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 225, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 156, + "target_local_id": 93, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 31, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 59, + "target_local_id": 219, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 115, + "target_local_id": 231, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 95, + "target_local_id": 163, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 113, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 102, + "target_local_id": 48, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 129, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 152, + "target_local_id": 73, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 145, + "target_local_id": 40, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 228, + "target_local_id": 119, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 71, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 202, + "target_local_id": 72, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 101, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 31, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 204, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 178, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 117, + "target_local_id": 25, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 45, + "target_local_id": 200, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 216, + "target_local_id": 149, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 80, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 49, + "target_local_id": 101, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 169, + "target_local_id": 225, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 224, + "target_local_id": 215, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 23, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 196, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 58, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 74, + "target_local_id": 119, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 106, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 77, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 140, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 190, + "target_local_id": 161, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 157, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 100, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 112, + "target_local_id": 5, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 2, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 15, + "target_local_id": 219, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 11, + "target_local_id": 153, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 186, + "target_local_id": 58, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 64, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 184, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 157, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 195, + "target_local_id": 189, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 215, + "target_local_id": 230, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 82, + "target_local_id": 223, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 50, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 174, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 18, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 55, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 84, + "target_local_id": 90, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 129, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 163, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 77, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 131, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 210, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 73, + "target_local_id": 220, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 59, + "target_local_id": 105, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 179, + "target_local_id": 209, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 129, + "target_local_id": 142, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 29, + "target_local_id": 67, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 35, + "target_local_id": 202, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 232, + "target_local_id": 18, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 166, + "target_local_id": 226, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "realization", + "source_local_id": 230, + "target_local_id": 80, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 75, + "target_local_id": 63, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 139, + "target_local_id": 20, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 2, + "target_local_id": 175, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 59, + "target_local_id": 219, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 125, + "target_local_id": 99, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 131, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 208, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 125, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 115, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 61, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 2, + "target_local_id": 21, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 32, + "target_local_id": 84, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 17, + "target_local_id": 89, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 163, + "target_local_id": 79, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 218, + "target_local_id": 148, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 219, + "target_local_id": 105, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 31, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 111, + "target_local_id": 214, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 159, + "target_local_id": 180, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 153, + "target_local_id": 28, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 58, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 5, + "target_local_id": 192, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 154, + "target_local_id": 83, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 176, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 42, + "target_local_id": 203, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 60, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 5, + "target_local_id": 227, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 123, + "target_local_id": 176, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 229, + "target_local_id": 203, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 154, + "target_local_id": 60, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 220, + "target_local_id": 90, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 139, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 60, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 199, + "target_local_id": 217, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 217, + "target_local_id": 180, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 80, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 155, + "target_local_id": 218, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 167, + "target_local_id": 222, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 223, + "target_local_id": 148, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 133, + "target_local_id": 224, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 222, + "target_local_id": 22, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 189, + "target_local_id": 232, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 91, + "target_local_id": 97, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 221, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 83, + "target_local_id": 171, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 74, + "target_local_id": 178, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 26, + "target_local_id": 228, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 19, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 90, + "target_local_id": 181, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 170, + "target_local_id": 29, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "support", + "source_local_id": 134, + "target_local_id": 103, + "stance": "for", + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 221, + "target_local_id": 12, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + }, + { + "category": "dependency", + "source_local_id": 108, + "target_local_id": 166, + "stance": null, + "basis": "explicit", + "rationale": null + } + ] +} diff --git a/package.json b/package.json index 0f02357e2..582c3b2e3 100644 --- a/package.json +++ b/package.json @@ -21,6 +21,7 @@ "build": "tsc -p tsconfig.build.json && npm run build:pi-assets && npm run build:web", "build:pi-assets": "mkdir -p dist/.pi/components/workspace-dialog dist/agents && cp -R src/.pi/components/workspace-dialog/assets dist/.pi/components/workspace-dialog/ && cp -R src/agents/definitions src/agents/goals src/agents/strategies src/agents/lenses src/agents/methods dist/agents/", "build:web": "vite build", + "seed": "tsx src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts", "db:generate": "drizzle-kit generate", "db:studio": "drizzle-kit studio", "test": "vitest --run", diff --git a/src/graph/seed-fixtures.test.ts b/src/graph/seed-fixtures.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f59dd1c9c --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/seed-fixtures.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +/** + * seedFixture tests — proves a vendored consolidated fixture loads through + * the CommandExecutor mutation boundary into a real (in-memory) brunch DB, + * keeping the graph clock and change log coherent. + */ + +import { readFileSync } from 'node:fs'; +import { dirname, resolve } from 'node:path'; +import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'; + +import { eq } from 'drizzle-orm'; +import { describe, expect, it } from 'vitest'; + +import { createDb, type BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; +import { changeLog, edges, graphClock, nodes, specs } from '../db/schema.js'; +import { CommandExecutor } from './command-executor.js'; +import { seedFixture, type SeedFixture } from './seed-fixtures.js'; + +const HERE = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)); + +function loadFixture(slug: string): SeedFixture { + const path = resolve(HERE, `../../.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/${slug}.json`); + return JSON.parse(readFileSync(path, 'utf8')) as SeedFixture; +} + +describe('seedFixture', () => { + it('seeds the code-health fixture into a real DB via the command layer', () => { + const db: BrunchDb = createDb(':memory:'); + const executor = new CommandExecutor(db); + const fixture = loadFixture('code-health'); + + const result = seedFixture(executor, fixture); + + // Reported counts match the fixture. + expect(result.nodeCount).toBe(fixture.nodes.length); + expect(result.edgeCount).toBe(fixture.edges.length); + + // Exactly one spec row, with the fixture's identity. + const specRows = db.select().from(specs).all(); + expect(specRows).toHaveLength(1); + expect(specRows[0]!.id).toBe(result.specId); + expect(specRows[0]!.slug).toBe('code-health'); + expect(specRows[0]!.readiness_grade).toBe('commitments_ready'); + + // Node / edge rows persisted, all scoped to the seeded spec. + const nodeRows = db.select().from(nodes).where(eq(nodes.spec_id, result.specId)).all(); + const edgeRows = db.select().from(edges).where(eq(edges.spec_id, result.specId)).all(); + expect(nodeRows).toHaveLength(fixture.nodes.length); + expect(edgeRows).toHaveLength(fixture.edges.length); + expect(nodeRows.every((row) => row.basis === 'explicit')).toBe(true); + + // Graph clock advanced once per command: createSpec + commitGraph = lsn 2. + expect(db.select().from(graphClock).get()!.lsn).toBe(2); + + // Change log records both mutations in order. + const ops = db + .select() + .from(changeLog) + .all() + .map((row) => row.operation); + expect(ops).toEqual(['create_spec', 'commit_graph']); + }); + + it('rejects fixtures carrying a non-explicit basis', () => { + const db: BrunchDb = createDb(':memory:'); + const executor = new CommandExecutor(db); + const fixture: SeedFixture = { + spec: { slug: 'off-basis', name: 'Off Basis', readiness_grade: 'grounding_onboarding' }, + nodes: [{ local_id: 1, plane: 'intent', kind: 'goal', title: 'A goal', basis: 'implicit' }], + edges: [], + }; + + expect(() => seedFixture(executor, fixture)).toThrow(/only "explicit" basis/); + }); +}); diff --git a/src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts b/src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d14d0a8d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts @@ -0,0 +1,197 @@ +/** + * Seed loader for consolidated fixture specs. + * + * Reads the brunch-shaped seed contract produced under + * `.fixtures/seeds//.json` and commits each spec into a brunch + * SQLite database through the normal `CommandExecutor` mutation boundary, so + * the graph clock, change log, and `*_lsn` columns stay coherent — seeded + * data is indistinguishable from data an agent would have committed live. + * + * Lives in `graph/` (not `db/`) because it orchestrates the graph command + * layer: `db/` is imported only by `graph/`, never the reverse (see + * `src/db/README.md`). This mirrors `workspace-store.ts`, which likewise + * wires `createDb` + `CommandExecutor`. + * + * The fixture-prep step that *produces* these files (porting Bilal's + * spec-elicitation graphs) is a separate throwaway script vendored next to + * the data at `.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts`; this loader only + * consumes the consolidated `.json` output and is unaware of any + * upstream format. + * + * CLI (dev only, run via tsx): + * npm run seed # seed all sets into /.brunch/data.db + * tsx src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts # same + */ + +import { readdir, readFile } from 'node:fs/promises'; +import { dirname, join, resolve } from 'node:path'; +import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'; + +import type { BatchEdgeInput, BatchNodeInput, ReadinessGrade } from './command-executor.js'; +import { CommandExecutor } from './command-executor.js'; +import type { EdgeCategory, EdgeStance } from './schema/edges.js'; +import type { NodeBasis, NodePlane } from './schema/nodes.js'; +import { openWorkspaceCommandExecutor } from './workspace-store.js'; + +// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- +// Seed contract — shape of a consolidated `.json` fixture +// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- + +/** Spec header of a consolidated fixture. */ +export interface SeedFixtureSpec { + readonly slug: string; + readonly name: string; + readonly readiness_grade: ReadinessGrade; +} + +/** A node row in a consolidated fixture; `local_id` is referenced by edges. */ +export interface SeedFixtureNode { + readonly local_id: number; + readonly plane: NodePlane; + readonly kind: string; + readonly title: string; + readonly body?: string | null; + readonly basis?: NodeBasis; + readonly source?: string | null; + readonly detail?: unknown; +} + +/** An edge row in a consolidated fixture; endpoints reference node `local_id`s. */ +export interface SeedFixtureEdge { + readonly category: EdgeCategory; + readonly source_local_id: number; + readonly target_local_id: number; + readonly stance?: EdgeStance | null; + readonly basis?: NodeBasis; + readonly rationale?: string | null; +} + +/** A consolidated fixture: one spec plus its graph, the atomic seed unit. */ +export interface SeedFixture { + readonly spec: SeedFixtureSpec; + readonly nodes: readonly SeedFixtureNode[]; + readonly edges: readonly SeedFixtureEdge[]; +} + +/** Outcome of seeding one fixture. */ +export interface SeedResult { + readonly slug: string; + readonly specId: number; + readonly nodeCount: number; + readonly edgeCount: number; +} + +// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- +// Loader +// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- + +/** + * Seed one consolidated fixture into the graph via `CommandExecutor`. + * + * Creates the spec, then commits all nodes and edges in a single + * `commitGraph` batch (edges reference nodes by stringified `local_id`). + * The batch basis is `explicit`; fixtures carrying any other basis are + * rejected rather than silently mis-seeded — the multi-basis case would + * require splitting into per-basis node batches with cross-batch edge refs, + * which no current fixture needs. + * + * Throws on any structural rejection from the command layer. + */ +export function seedFixture(executor: CommandExecutor, fixture: SeedFixture): SeedResult { + const offBasis = [...fixture.nodes, ...fixture.edges].find( + (item) => item.basis != null && item.basis !== 'explicit', + ); + if (offBasis) { + throw new Error( + `seedFixture: only "explicit" basis fixtures are supported; "${fixture.spec.slug}" ` + + `contains basis "${String(offBasis.basis)}"`, + ); + } + + const specResult = executor.createSpec({ + name: fixture.spec.name, + slug: fixture.spec.slug, + readinessGrade: fixture.spec.readiness_grade, + }); + if (specResult.status !== 'success') { + throw new Error( + `seedFixture: createSpec failed for "${fixture.spec.slug}": ${JSON.stringify(specResult.diagnostics)}`, + ); + } + + const nodes: BatchNodeInput[] = fixture.nodes.map((node) => ({ + ref: String(node.local_id), + plane: node.plane, + kind: node.kind, + title: node.title, + body: node.body ?? undefined, + source: node.source ?? undefined, + detail: node.detail ?? undefined, + })); + + const edges: BatchEdgeInput[] = fixture.edges.map((edge) => ({ + category: edge.category, + source: String(edge.source_local_id), + target: String(edge.target_local_id), + stance: edge.stance ?? undefined, + rationale: edge.rationale ?? undefined, + })); + + const result = executor.commitGraph({ specId: specResult.specId, basis: 'explicit', nodes, edges }); + if (result.status !== 'success') { + throw new Error( + `seedFixture: commitGraph failed for "${fixture.spec.slug}": ${JSON.stringify(result.diagnostics)}`, + ); + } + + return { + slug: fixture.spec.slug, + specId: specResult.specId, + nodeCount: Object.keys(result.createdNodes).length, + edgeCount: result.edges.length, + }; +} + +// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- +// CLI +// --------------------------------------------------------------------------- + +const SEEDS_ROOT = resolve(dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)), '../../.fixtures/seeds'); + +/** Read every `.json` (ignoring `_`-prefixed files) under a seed-set dir. */ +async function readSeedSet(setDir: string): Promise { + const entries = await readdir(setDir); + const files = entries.filter((name) => name.endsWith('.json') && !name.startsWith('_')).sort(); + const fixtures: SeedFixture[] = []; + for (const file of files) { + const raw = await readFile(join(setDir, file), 'utf8'); + fixtures.push(JSON.parse(raw) as SeedFixture); + } + return fixtures; +} + +async function main(): Promise { + const cwd = process.cwd(); + const sets = await readdir(SEEDS_ROOT, { withFileTypes: true }); + const setDirs = sets.filter((entry) => entry.isDirectory()).map((entry) => entry.name); + + const executor = await openWorkspaceCommandExecutor(cwd); + for (const set of setDirs) { + const fixtures = await readSeedSet(join(SEEDS_ROOT, set)); + for (const fixture of fixtures) { + const result = seedFixture(executor, fixture); + console.log( + `seeded ${set}/${result.slug} → spec ${result.specId} ` + + `(${result.nodeCount} nodes, ${result.edgeCount} edges)`, + ); + } + } + console.log(`\nDone. Seeded into ${join(cwd, '.brunch', 'data.db')}`); +} + +if (import.meta.url === `file://${process.argv[1]}`) { + main().catch((error: unknown) => { + console.error(error); + process.exit(1); + }); +} From 3bbb9a23a397f8c0f7968c27a54676d24ccfcb0c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 17:46:48 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 17/21] Self-validate ported seeds against the real loader before writing The port script now runs each assembled seed through seedFixture against a throwaway in-memory DB before writing .json, reusing the exact structural validation commitGraph enforces (planCommitGraph: node kind/plane/detail + edge category/stance/ref/cycle checks). A seed that would not commit cleanly aborts the run instead of producing an unloadable fixture. Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-019e91ee-aa39-73d2-a346-a0ae1e55e3b9 Co-authored-by: Amp --- .fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts | 38 +++++++++++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 33 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts index e857a356a..61cd15d41 100644 --- a/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts +++ b/.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/_port-script.ts @@ -73,6 +73,12 @@ * * Re-run safely: each .json is overwritten on each run. * + * Self-validating: before writing each file, the assembled seed is run + * through the real loader (src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts) against a throwaway + * in-memory DB, which exercises the same structural validation commitGraph + * enforces. A seed that would not commit cleanly aborts the run instead of + * being written, so every .json on disk is guaranteed loadable. + * * Reproducible: reads from the vendored ./_originals/ tree, not an external * checkout. Anyone can regenerate the seed contracts from this directory alone. */ @@ -81,6 +87,10 @@ import { existsSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from 'node:fs'; import { dirname, resolve } from 'node:path'; import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'; +import { createDb } from '../../../src/db/connection.js'; +import { CommandExecutor } from '../../../src/graph/command-executor.js'; +import { seedFixture, type SeedFixture } from '../../../src/graph/seed-fixtures.js'; + // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- // Paths // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -673,14 +683,30 @@ function portSpec(sourceName: string, slug: string, displayName: string): SpecPo // Write output // --------------------------------------------------------------------------- -function writeSpec(result: SpecPortResult, displayName: string): void { - // Consolidated seed contract — one file per spec, atomic seed unit. - const seed = { +/** Assemble the consolidated seed contract — one file per spec, atomic seed unit. */ +function buildSeed(result: SpecPortResult, displayName: string): SeedFixture { + return { spec: { slug: result.slug, name: displayName, readiness_grade: 'commitments_ready' }, nodes: result.brunchNodes, edges: result.brunchEdges, }; - writeFileSync(resolve(OUTPUT_ROOT, `${result.slug}.json`), JSON.stringify(seed, null, 2) + '\n'); +} + +/** + * Validate a seed against the real loader before it is written, so every + * .json on disk is guaranteed to commit cleanly. This reuses the exact + * structural checks commitGraph enforces — seedFixture → CommandExecutor + * .createSpec + .commitGraph → planCommitGraph (node kind/plane/detail and + * edge category/stance/ref/cycle validation) — against a throwaway in-memory + * DB. seedFixture throws with diagnostics on any structural rejection. + */ +function validateSeed(seed: SeedFixture): void { + const executor = new CommandExecutor(createDb(':memory:')); + seedFixture(executor, seed); +} + +function writeSpec(seed: SeedFixture): void { + writeFileSync(resolve(OUTPUT_ROOT, `${seed.spec.slug}.json`), JSON.stringify(seed, null, 2) + '\n'); } function writeReadme(results: { slug: string; displayName: string; stats: Record }[]): void { @@ -784,7 +810,9 @@ function main(): void { for (const spec of SPECS) { console.log(`Porting ${spec.source} → ${spec.slug}.json...`); const result = portSpec(spec.source, spec.slug, spec.displayName); - writeSpec(result, spec.displayName); + const seed = buildSeed(result, spec.displayName); + validateSeed(seed); // throws if the seed would not commit cleanly + writeSpec(seed); summaries.push({ slug: spec.slug, displayName: spec.displayName, stats: result.stats }); console.log(` ${JSON.stringify(result.stats)}`); } From d2eeab63a659bc012bb918ab4ff117f861b86f9a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 17:53:12 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 18/21] plan: add dev-seed-fixtures parallel frontier Capture the landed seed-fixture substrate (consolidated {spec,nodes,edges} contract, src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts loader, npm run seed, self-validating port scripts) and the two enhancement ideas as backlog: (1) enrich Bilal-port graphs through Brunch from the original briefs to recover thesis/goal structure, (2) port + enhance the legacy product fixtures. Notes manual-testing.md seed-doc drift for the doc-reconciliation track. Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-019e91ee-aa39-73d2-a346-a0ae1e55e3b9 Co-authored-by: Amp --- memory/PLAN.md | 24 ++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 24 insertions(+) diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index dd467c14a..d174e6c41 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -45,6 +45,7 @@ _None._ - `probes-and-transcripts-evolution` — continuous probe/report/transcript hardening as each delivery frontier lands evidence. - `topology-readmes-and-boundaries` — small doc/test hardening when a frontier moves files or exposes a boundary; should remain attached to the frontier when possible rather than becoming an abstract cleanup project. +- `dev-seed-fixtures` — rich, real seed data for local dev / manual / observer testing: the consolidated seed contract, the `npm run seed` loader, and growing/enhancing fixture sets (Bilal-port + legacy). ### Horizon @@ -235,6 +236,27 @@ _None._ - **Traceability:** D52-L, D39-L, D4-L. - **Design docs:** `src/README.md`; `src/.pi/README.md`; `src/agents/README.md`; `src/db/README.md`; `src/graph/README.md`; `src/rpc/README.md`; `src/session/README.md`; `src/web/README.md`. +### dev-seed-fixtures + +- **Name:** Development seed-fixture substrate (Bilal-port + legacy specs) +- **Linear:** unassigned +- **Kind:** tooling / dev-substrate +- **Status:** parallel / continuous +- **Objective:** Maintain rich, real seed data for local dev and manual/observer testing: the consolidated `{spec,nodes,edges}` seed contract under `.fixtures/seeds//.json`, the `src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts` loader (`npm run seed`) that commits each fixture through `CommandExecutor`, and the throwaway per-set port scripts that produce seed files. Grow set coverage and graph quality as delivery frontiers need data to exercise. +- **Why now / unlocks:** Delivery frontiers (`capture-response-to-graph`, the live-graph observer follow-on, `poc-live-ship-gate`) need real multi-spec graph data to exercise UI/agent/observer behavior without hand-authoring. The Bilal port already provides three loadable specs; enhancing them surfaces under-represented planes/kinds (notably `thesis`/`goal`) for richer capture and observer demos. +- **Acceptance:** + - Seed contract stays loadable: each set's port script self-validates every `.json` through the real loader (same structural checks `commitGraph` enforces) before writing. + - `npm run seed` loads every `.fixtures/seeds//.json` into the workspace DB through `CommandExecutor` (never direct row inserts), preserving graph clock / change log / lsn coherence. + - New seed sets follow the established shape: vendored `_originals/`, throwaway `_port-script.ts`, consolidated `.json`, generated `README.md`. +- **Enhancement backlog (captured, not yet scoped):** + 1. Enhance Bilal-port fixtures *through Brunch itself* by feeding the original briefs Bilal authored, to recover `thesis`/`goal` structure the current ported graphs under-express. + 2. Port and enhance the earlier product version's fixtures (the legacy walkthrough scenarios in `docs/praxis/manual-testing.md`), raising quality through better semantic definition (kinds, detail) and internal connection (edges). +- **Verification:** Inner — `src/graph/seed-fixtures.test.ts` seeds a real fixture into an in-memory DB and asserts spec/node/edge counts plus change-log/clock coherence, and rejects non-`explicit` basis; port-script self-validation gates output. Outer — `npm run seed` smoke against a fresh cwd. +- **Topology materialization:** Seed data and throwaway prep scripts live under `.fixtures/seeds/`; the loader lives in `src/graph/seed-fixtures.ts` (graph/ owns `CommandExecutor` orchestration; db/ is imported only by graph/, never the reverse); no seed-only graph runtime the product launch does not use. +- **Cross-cutting obligations:** Seeds commit only through `CommandExecutor`; directly-authored items use `basis: explicit` (the retired `accepted_review_set` value is not a basis). Respect multi-spec discipline — each fixture is one spec's own graph (D61-L). Pre-release posture: regenerate fixtures when the schema moves rather than preserving stale shapes. **Known drift:** `docs/praxis/manual-testing.md` still describes the earlier seed system (scenario-arg `npm run seed`, `.brunch/brunch.db`); reconcile it to the current loader (all-sets `npm run seed`, `.brunch/data.db`) when the legacy port (backlog item 2) lands — coordinate with the doc-reconciliation track rather than double-editing. +- **Traceability:** D4-L, D20-L, D52-L, D61-L, D62-L, D63-L / A14-L. +- **Design docs:** `.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/README.md`; `docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`; `docs/praxis/manual-testing.md`. + ## Recently Completed - 2026-06-04 `graph-tool-resilience` (FE-808) — Done: graph nodes persist per-kind ordinals and expose projected codes; `commitGraph` applies one explicit/implicit batch basis, returns one created-node identity shape, and shares dry-run/commit structural planning; adapters resolve selected-spec existing-node codes into structured diagnostics instead of throwing; same-spec supersession cycles are rejected atomically; active-context graph reads omit hidden superseded nodes and dangling edges while graph-truth reads remain available; product-path probes landed existing-code, retry-diagnostics, and ambiguity/no-overcommit evidence under `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/`. @@ -256,6 +278,7 @@ nodes: poc-live-ship-gate [next · P1] final fresh-cwd composed product runbook probes-and-transcripts-evolution [parallel] continuous evidence substrate topology-readmes-and-boundaries [parallel] attach-to-frontier topology hardening + dev-seed-fixtures [parallel] rich seed data substrate for dev/observer testing edges: graph-tool-resilience -[hard]-> capture-response-to-graph @@ -268,6 +291,7 @@ edges: parallel obligations: probes-and-transcripts-evolution -[evidence]-> every P0/P1 frontier topology-readmes-and-boundaries -[boundary]-> every frontier that moves/claims source topology + dev-seed-fixtures -[data]-> capture-response-to-graph, poc-live-ship-gate (real multi-spec graphs to exercise observer/capture) horizon: turn-boundary-reconciliation From 1fdc77b8eee078ea709b2b67cb82d7e8e65dd6de Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 18:08:58 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 19/21] FE-808 validate createNode basis --- memory/SPEC.md | 2 +- ...raph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md | 65 +++++++++++++++++++ src/graph/command-executor.test.ts | 45 ++++++++++++- src/graph/command-executor.ts | 12 ++++ 4 files changed, 122 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) create mode 100644 memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index d9a15790f..3b680c478 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -292,7 +292,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I37-L | `detail` is per-kind validated by the `CommandExecutor`: `decision` and `term` nodes REQUIRE `detail` with their respective sub-schemas; all other kinds must omit `detail`; unknown fields in `detail` are rejected. | covered (detail-required/prohibited/shape tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L | | I38-L | Every Brunch prompt-resource manifest injected for an agent turn is generated from projected runtime state and spec/workspace gates: listed resources are Brunch-owned, readable under the active tool policy, legal for the current `(op_mode × goal × strategy × lens)` / grade / agent allow-list, and off-list resources are not advertised as available. AUTO axes never list illegal choices; pinned axes point to the pinned resource. | covered for current P0 manifest families (`src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers default header/context/manifest output, AUTO grade/allow-list filtering, pinned singleton resources, illegal pinned grade rejection, and readable `src/agents/` locations; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` covers the explicit shell `before_agent_start` product path appending `agents/compose()` output from transcript-projected runtime state and no legacy composer import/resource discovery. Probe fitness may still track whether the agent reads selected resources before use.) | D39-L, D40-L, D58-L, D59-L | | I39-L | Every graph node in a spec has exactly one stable projected human reference code derived from `kind` + `kind_ordinal`; `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)` is unique; ordinals are monotonic per `(spec_id, plane, kind)` and are not reused after deletion or supersession. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` added `nodes.kind_ordinal`, `node_kind_counters`, DB uniqueness, CommandExecutor allocation for single-node/batch writes, rollback protection, `GraphNode.kindOrdinal` row mapping, globally unique 1–3 letter labels with readiness-band metadata, projected-code parsing, selected-spec adapter resolution before `CommandExecutor`, code-only `commit_graph` / `read_graph` schemas, and code-primary prompt/tool rendering; remaining slice still needs deletion/supersession no-reuse coverage) | D54-L, D62-L; I1-L, I11-L | -| I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` replaced the persisted basis enum with `explicit | implicit`, made `commitGraph` apply one batch approval basis to all created nodes/edges, made `propose-graph` adapter commits implicit, made review-set translation explicit, rejected retired `accepted_review_set`, and records `change_log.operation` independently; remaining capture/review-cycle slices still need direct user/capture assignment coverage) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | +| I40-L | Accepted graph nodes and edges use only `basis ∈ explicit | implicit`; review-set approval and direct user statements produce `explicit`, `propose-graph` concept-level materialization produces `implicit`, and the mutation path is recoverable from `change_log` rather than from a persisted basis enum value such as `accepted_review_set`. | partially covered (`graph-tool-resilience` replaced the persisted basis enum with `explicit | implicit`, made `commitGraph` apply one batch approval basis to all created nodes/edges, made single-node `createNode` reject retired basis values before LSN/counter/node/change-log allocation, made `propose-graph` adapter commits implicit, made review-set translation explicit, rejected retired `accepted_review_set`, and records `change_log.operation` independently; remaining capture/review-cycle slices still need direct user/capture assignment coverage) | D26-L, D27-L, D53-L, D63-L | | I41-L | Same-spec `supersession` edges form an acyclic directed graph; every edge-creation path validates proposed supersession edges together with existing supersession edges before committing. | covered (`command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts` rejects existing-cycle closure, intra-batch cycles, and mixed existing+batch cycles through the shared dry-run/commit planner before batch writes; rejected cycles roll back or avoid batch nodes/edges/change_log; acyclic supersession commits remain covered by snapshot/CommandExecutor success paths) | D51-L, D53-L; I34-L | ## Future Direction Register diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ceae4b59c --- /dev/null +++ b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +# Create-node basis validation + +Frontier: graph-tool-resilience +Status: done +Mode: single +Created: 2026-06-04 + +## Orientation + +- Seam: `CommandExecutor` graph mutation boundary, specifically the single-node `createNode` path that FE-807 capture may reuse. +- Frontier: `graph-tool-resilience` / FE-808; this closes review finding #3 after `commitGraph` already rejects retired basis values. +- Main risk: `createNode` silently accepts invalid basis strings while FE-808 claims accepted nodes/edges use only `explicit | implicit`. +- Cross-cutting obligations: preserve D20-L command-result semantics, D63-L basis meaning, and I34-L no-write/no-LSN on structural-illegal input. + +Posture: proving (inherited from graph-tool-resilience) + +## Light scope card — validate createNode basis + +### Objective + +`CommandExecutor.createNode()` rejects any graph basis outside `explicit | implicit` before allocating an LSN or writing graph rows. + +### Acceptance Criteria + +✓ `createNode({ basis: "accepted_review_set" })` returns `structural_illegal` with a `basis` diagnostic. +✓ Invalid `createNode` basis writes no node, no change-log row, no node-kind counter row, and does not increment `graph_clock`. +✓ Valid explicit and implicit basis values still persist unchanged. +✓ Existing `commitGraph` basis validation remains unchanged. +✓ `npm run verify` passes. + +### Verification Approach + +- Inner: targeted `CommandExecutor` tests for createNode invalid/valid basis behavior. +- Gate: `npm run verify`. + +### Cross-cutting obligations + +- Preserve D63-L: basis is approval strength only, not mutation path. +- Preserve D20-L: callers see structured command results, not thrown validation errors. + +### Assumption dependency + +None — this directly enforces an existing SPEC decision and FE-808 acceptance claim. + +### Expected touched paths (tentative) + +```text +src/graph/ +├── command-executor.ts ~ +└── command-executor.test.ts ~ +``` + +### Promotion checklist + +- [ ] Does this change a requirement? +- [ ] Does this create, retire, or invalidate an assumption? +- [ ] Does this slice depend on an unvalidated high-impact assumption? +- [ ] Does this make or reverse a non-trivial design decision? +- [ ] Does this establish a new seam-level invariant? +- [ ] Does this change a frontier-level cross-cutting obligation or verification architecture layer? +- [ ] Does it cross more than two major seams? +- [ ] Is this the first touch in an unfamiliar seam from a fresh thread? +- [ ] Can you not name the containing seam or current rationale from the live docs? + +All checklist answers are no; keep this as a light closeout cleanup. diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts index 3d5a46c11..bf3110393 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.test.ts @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ import { eq } from 'drizzle-orm'; import { describe, expect, it, beforeEach } from 'vitest'; import { createDb, type BrunchDb } from '../db/connection.js'; -import { graphClock, changeLog, nodes, reconciliationNeed, specs } from '../db/schema.js'; +import { graphClock, changeLog, nodes, nodeKindCounters, reconciliationNeed, specs } from '../db/schema.js'; import { CommandExecutor } from './command-executor.js'; function createTestDb(): BrunchDb { @@ -199,6 +199,49 @@ describe('CommandExecutor', () => { expect(result.diagnostics.some((d) => d.field === 'detail.extra_field')).toBe(true); }); + it('rejects retired createNode basis values before allocating graph state', () => { + const result = executor.createNode({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Legacy basis should fail', + basis: 'accepted_review_set' as never, + }); + + expect(result.status).toBe('structural_illegal'); + if (result.status !== 'structural_illegal') throw new Error('unreachable'); + expect(result.diagnostics).toEqual(expect.arrayContaining([expect.objectContaining({ field: 'basis' })])); + expect(db.select().from(nodes).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(changeLog).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(nodeKindCounters).all()).toHaveLength(0); + expect(db.select().from(graphClock).all()[0]!.lsn).toBe(0); + }); + + it('persists explicit and implicit createNode basis values unchanged', () => { + executor.createNode({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Explicit node', + basis: 'explicit', + }); + executor.createNode({ + specId, + plane: 'intent', + kind: 'goal', + title: 'Implicit node', + basis: 'implicit', + }); + + expect( + db + .select() + .from(nodes) + .all() + .map((row) => row.basis), + ).toEqual(['explicit', 'implicit']); + }); + // --- LSN / graph_clock --- it('increments graph_clock atomically per command', () => { diff --git a/src/graph/command-executor.ts b/src/graph/command-executor.ts index 5d382f456..919e438b2 100644 --- a/src/graph/command-executor.ts +++ b/src/graph/command-executor.ts @@ -216,11 +216,16 @@ const VALID_KINDS_BY_PLANE: Record = { const KINDS_REQUIRING_DETAIL = new Set(['decision', 'term']); const VALID_READINESS_GRADES = schema.READINESS_GRADES as unknown as string[]; +const VALID_NODE_BASES = schema.NODE_BASES as unknown as string[]; function isReadinessGrade(value: string): value is ReadinessGrade { return VALID_READINESS_GRADES.includes(value); } +function isNodeBasis(value: string): value is NodeBasis { + return VALID_NODE_BASES.includes(value); +} + function validateCreateNode(input: CreateNodeInput): Diagnostic[] { const diagnostics: Diagnostic[] = []; @@ -229,6 +234,13 @@ function validateCreateNode(input: CreateNodeInput): Diagnostic[] { diagnostics.push({ field: 'title', message: 'title must be non-empty' }); } + if (input.basis !== undefined && !isNodeBasis(input.basis)) { + diagnostics.push({ + field: 'basis', + message: 'basis must be explicit or implicit', + }); + } + // Kind must be valid for the given plane const validKinds = VALID_KINDS_BY_PLANE[input.plane]; if (!validKinds?.includes(input.kind)) { From b678022b15a11925716d1b075fe25869587457d6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 18:11:47 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 20/21] agent and skill guidance re not deleting stubs --- .agents/skills/ln-build/SKILL.md | 4 +++- .agents/skills/ln-judo-review/SKILL.md | 2 ++ .agents/skills/ln-plan/references/earned.md | 2 +- .agents/skills/ln-review/SKILL.md | 2 ++ AGENTS.md | 10 ++++++++++ 5 files changed, 18 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/.agents/skills/ln-build/SKILL.md b/.agents/skills/ln-build/SKILL.md index dda168c82..06e0914a5 100644 --- a/.agents/skills/ln-build/SKILL.md +++ b/.agents/skills/ln-build/SKILL.md @@ -103,6 +103,8 @@ Honor the repo's pre-release posture: if the current schema, fixture shape, dumm No speculative abstractions. Only extract when two concrete cases force it. Do not anticipate later tests or build shape-only scaffolding; let the current behavioral test pull the interface into existence. +Do not delete comment-rich empty source files as cleanup unless the current card names them or the deletion proof in `AGENTS.md` §intentional topology stubs is satisfied. Passing import/build checks is insufficient proof; ask the user when the topology intent is unclear. + The card's Expected touched paths are tentative, not binding. If the build needs to diverge — a path you didn't anticipate, a file the work doesn't actually need — proceed and note the divergence briefly when updating the card's status. Significant divergence (touching new directories or seams not declared) is a signal to pause and re-check the overlap-as-independence-test against other active scope files for the same frontier. ## Refactor @@ -202,7 +204,7 @@ Other volatile artifacts are **review-before-delete**, not automatic cleanup: - `memory/REFACTOR.md` — delete only when every listed refactor step is done/dropped and no future sequence depends on it. - Provisional docs outside `memory/` (for example `docs/**/provisional*.md`, handoff plans, spike plans, or exploration inventories) — do **not** delete during `ln-build` cleanup unless the user explicitly asks or you first prove that all remaining future-facing inventory has been absorbed elsewhere. If only the current card is done but the artifact still contains later affordances, open questions, or scoping input, update it instead of deleting it. -Before deleting any file, name the file, state why no future agent would need it, and prefer asking the user when uncertain. Do not create archive copies, numbered handoffs, or completion-pointer files. +Before deleting any file, name the file, state why no future agent would need it, and prefer asking the user when uncertain. For source files whose only runtime content is `export {}` plus comments, read the comments as design payload and apply `AGENTS.md` §intentional topology stubs before proposing deletion. Do not create archive copies, numbered handoffs, or completion-pointer files. ## Routing diff --git a/.agents/skills/ln-judo-review/SKILL.md b/.agents/skills/ln-judo-review/SKILL.md index c6800522d..41c6c9fc1 100644 --- a/.agents/skills/ln-judo-review/SKILL.md +++ b/.agents/skills/ln-judo-review/SKILL.md @@ -10,6 +10,8 @@ Look for **code judo**: restructurings that preserve behavior while making the i This is a strict maintainability audit, not a cleanup pass. Do not stop at "this could be a bit cleaner." Do not rubber-stamp working code that leaves the codebase messier. Use the repo's pre-release posture: retire stale concepts, obsolete code paths, and compatibility scaffolding rather than protecting them. +Do not apply deletion-judo to intentional topology stubs. A comment-rich `export {}` source file may be a planned public seam / topology contract; see `AGENTS.md` §intentional topology stubs. Deleting it is a valid judo move only when the documented intent is obsolete or absorbed, not merely because the file is unused today. + ## Input What to review: $ARGUMENTS diff --git a/.agents/skills/ln-plan/references/earned.md b/.agents/skills/ln-plan/references/earned.md index d6918e61c..c85b1a64a 100644 --- a/.agents/skills/ln-plan/references/earned.md +++ b/.agents/skills/ln-plan/references/earned.md @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ This is not "proving-posture sequencing with bigger steps." The decision kernel - **Materialize** — make a settled architectural decision visible in topology: file or directory placement, sub-tree split per [AGENTS.md](../../../../AGENTS.md) §fractal sub-tree pattern, or a topology README that locks a SPEC decision to a directory. - **Consolidate** — bring scattered cognates of the same concept into one canonical site. - **Name canonically** — collapse aliases, near-synonyms, or drift terms to one term; update callers, docs, and tests in the same slice. -- **Delete-as-progress** — retire obsolete code paths, fixtures, dummy data, compatibility shims, and superseded docs. Deletion is a first-class closure outcome, not janitorial overflow. +- **Delete-as-progress** — retire obsolete code paths, fixtures, dummy data, compatibility shims, and superseded docs. Deletion is a first-class closure outcome, not janitorial overflow. Comment-rich `export {}` source files are not deletion candidates on unusedness alone; apply `AGENTS.md` §intentional topology stubs and prove the documented seam is obsolete or absorbed. - **Retire bridges / aliases / dual paths** — under `migration: free-rewrite`, eliminate adapters, shims, and expand/contract scaffolds that have outlived their crossing. The migration scheme is not the system. (See `~/.pi/agent/APPEND_SYSTEM.md` §bridge-as-permanence.) - **Take the bigger step** — landing a multi-file or multi-layer closure in one slice when the thinness instinct is producing redundant proof rather than closure. diff --git a/.agents/skills/ln-review/SKILL.md b/.agents/skills/ln-review/SKILL.md index 0bef1620a..8cc70c249 100644 --- a/.agents/skills/ln-review/SKILL.md +++ b/.agents/skills/ln-review/SKILL.md @@ -10,6 +10,8 @@ Explore the codebase. Surface structural improvement opportunities. Be opinionat Use the repo's pre-release posture: reward conceptual clarity over compatibility scaffolding, and treat unnecessary preservation as review debt. Look for stale code, obsolete fixtures, legacy terms, and compatibility paths that should be deleted rather than protected. +Deletion guard: before recommending deletion of a source file that has no runtime exports/imports but does have explanatory comments, apply `AGENTS.md` §intentional topology stubs. Do not treat `export {}`, zero imports, or passing import/build checks as proof of false topology. A deletion finding for such a file must name the contradicted/retired SPEC/PLAN/README claim, or the implemented replacement that absorbs the documented seam; otherwise route it as an intent-verification question, not a delete recommendation. + ## Input What to review: $ARGUMENTS diff --git a/AGENTS.md b/AGENTS.md index 5b6d12d19..3c661b8b8 100644 --- a/AGENTS.md +++ b/AGENTS.md @@ -45,6 +45,16 @@ This is not permission for unrelated rewrites: keep changes scoped to the active Use a lightweight fractal sub-tree pattern when a file outgrows its current mini-library boundary. Keep the original file as the public entry point (for example, `context-pack.ts`) and place private implementation modules in a same-named folder (for example, `context-pack/observer-capture.ts`). External consumers should continue importing from the public root file; only that root file should import from its private sub-tree. Split along semantic purpose, not file shape, and avoid speculative folder scaffolding until the file has real pressure. +## intentional topology stubs + +Some source files intentionally contain only a design comment plus `export {}`. Treat these as topology contracts / planned public seams when the comment names ownership, input/output shape, future callers, migration state, or a SPEC/PLAN/README decision. The comment is the payload; the empty export only keeps the file a TypeScript module. + +`export {}` plus zero imports/usages is not evidence that the file is false topology. Import/build checks prove only that deletion is mechanically safe today; they do not prove the documented topology intent is wrong. + +Delete or retire an intentional topology stub only when the active scope, SPEC, PLAN, or nearest topology README says the seam is obsolete, or when the same slice implements/absorbs the documented intent elsewhere and updates the canonical references. If uncertain, ask the user and name the exact path. + +This is not permission to add speculative scaffolding. New stubs must be current-milestone topology, concise, and tied to an active seam; prefer `Owns` / `Input` / `Output` / `Used by` or `Future callers` bullets plus a decision/frontier id when available. + ## topology READMEs Directory-level `README.md` files under `src/**/` are **canonical documentation co-located with the code they describe**. They materialize architectural intent into the file topology: what the directory owns and does not own, its dependency direction, the SPEC decision IDs (`D52-L`, `D40-L`, …) that lock its layout, the resource taxonomy or layout sketch, and any in-flight migration state. Treat them as drift-prone canonical artifacts alongside `memory/SPEC.md` and `memory/PLAN.md` — not as ambient prose. From ede9c8e90a96af6e7aef61031ca7ad08b00dc370 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Lu Nelson Date: Thu, 4 Jun 2026 18:17:29 +0200 Subject: [PATCH 21/21] FE-808: Sync graph resilience closeout --- docs/archive/PLAN_HISTORY.md | 7 ++ memory/PLAN.md | 16 ++--- memory/SPEC.md | 4 +- ...raph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md | 65 ------------------- 4 files changed, 15 insertions(+), 77 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md diff --git a/docs/archive/PLAN_HISTORY.md b/docs/archive/PLAN_HISTORY.md index 1a1d491a7..8d6bc2007 100644 --- a/docs/archive/PLAN_HISTORY.md +++ b/docs/archive/PLAN_HISTORY.md @@ -3,6 +3,13 @@ This file is the active POC-line plan archive for `memory/PLAN.md`. Legacy pre-`next` history was moved out of the live docs tree with the old archived implementation. +## 2026-06-04 FE-808 closeout archive + +Archived from `memory/PLAN.md` when FE-808 closed out and the live frontier advanced to `capture-response-to-graph`. + +- 2026-06-02 — **agent-graph-integration** enabling slices — Done inside FE-785: runtime vocabulary fixed; source moved from `src/tui-client/.pi` to `src/.pi`; real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` Pi tools route through `CommandExecutor`; default Brunch runtime factory registers graph tools; A14 `propose-graph → commitGraph` probe persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges on first attempt; review-set dry-run gate validates/filters proposal payloads. Verified: targeted tests, `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`, and `npm run verify`. Watch: broad FE-785 bucket is now split into delivery frontiers above. +- 2026-06-02 — **spec-persistence-and-startup** — Done: specs are DB rows with integer ids and `readiness_grade`; `createSpec` / `getSpec` / `updateReadinessGrade` route through `CommandExecutor` with change-log audit; startup scaffolds `.brunch/workspace.json` + `.brunch/data.db`; session binding collapsed to `{schemaVersion,specId}` and is fork-portable; inventory resolves spec names from DB. Verified: `npm run verify` and real `brunch --mode print` against a fresh cwd. Watch: richer multi-spec initiative/claim model remains deferred by D61-L. + ## 2026-06-04 Rolling completion archive Archived from `memory/PLAN.md` when FE-795 tied off and the live frontier advanced to `agents-composition-layer`. diff --git a/memory/PLAN.md b/memory/PLAN.md index d174e6c41..8d5910930 100644 --- a/memory/PLAN.md +++ b/memory/PLAN.md @@ -35,11 +35,10 @@ _None._ ### Next -1. `graph-tool-resilience` — P0 structural hardening: materialize the locked graph write contract (projected node codes, explicit/implicit basis, supersession acyclicity) before more graph-writing frontiers build on stale schema. -2. `capture-response-to-graph` — P0 product loop: structured exchange answer → narrow high-confidence capture → `CommandExecutor` commit → web graph update. -3. `project-graph-review-cycle` — P1 unless demo narrative promotes it: real `project-graph` review-set proposal/approval loop. -4. `minimal-authority-shell` — P1 safety: thin POC authority posture over already-existing command-result seams and `elicit` tool policy. -5. `poc-live-ship-gate` — P1 final gate: fresh-cwd runbook exercising the composed product path end to end. +1. `capture-response-to-graph` — P0 product loop: structured exchange answer → narrow high-confidence capture → `CommandExecutor` commit → web graph update. +2. `project-graph-review-cycle` — P1 unless demo narrative promotes it: real `project-graph` review-set proposal/approval loop. +3. `minimal-authority-shell` — P1 safety: thin POC authority posture over already-existing command-result seams and `elicit` tool policy. +4. `poc-live-ship-gate` — P1 final gate: fresh-cwd runbook exercising the composed product path end to end. ### Parallel / Low-conflict @@ -258,14 +257,11 @@ _None._ - **Design docs:** `.fixtures/seeds/bilal-port/README.md`; `docs/design/GRAPH_MODEL.md`; `docs/praxis/manual-testing.md`. ## Recently Completed -- 2026-06-04 `graph-tool-resilience` (FE-808) — Done: graph nodes persist per-kind ordinals and expose projected codes; `commitGraph` applies one explicit/implicit batch basis, returns one created-node identity shape, and shares dry-run/commit structural planning; adapters resolve selected-spec existing-node codes into structured diagnostics instead of throwing; same-spec supersession cycles are rejected atomically; active-context graph reads omit hidden superseded nodes and dangling edges while graph-truth reads remain available; product-path probes landed existing-code, retry-diagnostics, and ambiguity/no-overcommit evidence under `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/`. +- 2026-06-04 `graph-tool-resilience` (FE-808) — Done: graph nodes persist per-kind ordinals and expose projected codes; `commitGraph` applies one explicit/implicit batch basis, returns one created-node identity shape, plans once inside the transaction before LSN allocation/writes, and shares dry-run/commit structural validation; adapters resolve selected-spec existing-node codes into structured diagnostics without sentinel endpoint refs or thrown errors; single-node `createNode` rejects retired basis values before LSN/counter/node/change-log allocation; same-spec supersession cycles are rejected atomically; active-context graph reads omit hidden superseded nodes and dangling edges while graph-truth reads remain available; product-path probes landed existing-code, retry-diagnostics, and ambiguity/no-overcommit evidence under `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/`. - 2026-06-04 `agents-composition-layer` (FE-806) — Done: `agents/state.ts`/`compose.ts` emit runtime headers and gated prompt-resource manifests; `agents/contexts/{cwd,graph,node}.ts` renders selected-spec context with lens-specific emphasis; the real `.pi` `before_agent_start` product path supplies selected-spec-bound graph snapshots from the Brunch runtime factory; the legacy `src/.pi/context/` prompt-pack subtree is deleted after folding its useful guidance into `src/agents/methods/*.md`; deterministic product-path proof records strategy/lens posture differences and accepted blind spots. Verified: context/compose/prompting/architecture tests and `npm run verify`. Watch: prompt quality is fitness evidence only; graph-write resilience and capture quality remain with the next P0 frontiers. - 2026-06-04 `live-graph-observer` (FE-795) — Done: `graph.overview` and `graph.nodeNeighborhood` are discoverable selected-spec RPC reads; graph readers remain in `graph/`; TUI/agent `commit_graph` publishes graph invalidation topics through the shared product-update bus; the TUI launch path starts a read-only web sidecar over the same bus; the React web app attaches over one WebSocket RPC client, renders the selected-spec graph overview, and invalidates/refetches canonical graph readers on `brunch.updated`. Verified: targeted FE-795 test set (`src/rpc/handlers.test.ts`, `src/rpc/web-host.test.ts`, `src/web/app.test.tsx`, `src/brunch-tui.test.ts`, `src/graph/snapshot.test.ts`, `src/graph/spec-ownership.test.ts`), `npm run build`, and a 2026-06-04 `agent-browser` smoke that observed empty graph state then a `commit_graph`-created node in the browser without reload. Watch: richer node-neighborhood UI remains optional polish; the current proof exposes/query-backs the focused read and renders the overview. -- 2026-06-02 `agent-graph-integration` enabling slices — Done inside FE-785: runtime vocabulary fixed; source moved from `src/tui-client/.pi` to `src/.pi`; real `read_graph`/`commit_graph` Pi tools route through `CommandExecutor`; default Brunch runtime factory registers graph tools; A14 `propose-graph → commitGraph` probe persisted 4 nodes + 4 edges on first attempt; review-set dry-run gate validates/filters proposal payloads. Verified: targeted tests, `.fixtures/runs/propose-graph-commit/2026-06-02-propose-graph-commit/`, and `npm run verify`. Watch: broad FE-785 bucket is now split into delivery frontiers above. -- 2026-06-02 `spec-persistence-and-startup` — Done: specs are DB rows with integer ids and `readiness_grade`; `createSpec` / `getSpec` / `updateReadinessGrade` route through `CommandExecutor` with change-log audit; startup scaffolds `.brunch/workspace.json` + `.brunch/data.db`; session binding collapsed to `{schemaVersion,specId}` and is fork-portable; inventory resolves spec names from DB. Verified: `npm run verify` and real `brunch --mode print` against a fresh cwd. Watch: richer multi-spec initiative/claim model remains deferred by D61-L. - -Older history (including `sealed-pi-profile-runtime-state`, `pi-ui-extension-patterns`, `web-shell`, `jsonl-session-viability`, `mode-shell-and-fixture-driver`, `walking-skeleton`): `docs/archive/PLAN_HISTORY.md` +Older history (including `agent-graph-integration`, `spec-persistence-and-startup`, `sealed-pi-profile-runtime-state`, `pi-ui-extension-patterns`, `web-shell`, `jsonl-session-viability`, `mode-shell-and-fixture-driver`, `walking-skeleton`): `docs/archive/PLAN_HISTORY.md` ## Dependencies diff --git a/memory/SPEC.md b/memory/SPEC.md index 3b680c478..54e5e277d 100644 --- a/memory/SPEC.md +++ b/memory/SPEC.md @@ -286,7 +286,7 @@ The POC's purpose is to prove three things: (a) that pi's coding-agent harness c | I31-L | `readiness_grade` is a forward gate, not a workflow location or kind whitelist: higher grades unlock later strategies/commitments/export paths but do not make earlier gathering/refinement invalid or unavailable, and the `CommandExecutor` must not reject a graph node solely because its kind belongs to a later readiness band. All grade mutations route through `CommandExecutor` and carry audit through the change log. | partially covered (`createSpec` / `getSpec` / `updateReadinessGrade` command tests cover storage and mutation audit; `src/agents/compose.test.ts` covers prompt-resource grade gates rejecting illegal pinned commitment selections and filtering AUTO availability; kind-vs-grade write permissiveness remains planned with graph-code/readiness-band work) | D20-L, D45-L, D64-L | | I32-L | Public RPC structured-exchange driving never requires a client to speak raw Pi RPC: after Brunch method discovery and workspace/spec/session activation, each pending assistant-originated exchange is answered exactly once through `session.submitExchangeResponse`, and the deterministic permutation run produces linear Pi JSONL whose structured exchange projection preserves the same prompt/answer/status/comment artifacts as the equivalent TUI structured-exchange path. | covered for deterministic FE-744 parity under canonical session method names (`session.triggerExchange`, `session.pendingExchange`, `session.submitExchangeResponse`, `session.exchanges`): `rpc.discover` contract tests, pending/respond lifecycle tests, current public-RPC structured-exchange permutations, terminal non-answered status handling, option content/rationale parity, no repeated deterministic prompts, and transcript/exchange parity assertions. | D5-L, D48-L, D49-L; I10-L, I13-L, I21-L, I23-L | | I33-L | `capture_*` analysis entries are transcript evidence only: they persist as Brunch structured-exchange `toolResult` rows, are included by Brunch-semantic transcript renderers, are hidden or collapsed in TUI display, and never mutate graph truth or bypass `CommandExecutor`. | partially covered (minimum capture details schemas parse/export and reject graph payload fields; future runtime capture-analysis schema/rendering tests plus transcript renderer fixtures still need to prove persisted result rendering and TUI hide/collapse behavior; later graph-capture fixtures compare analysis candidates against committed graph mutations) | D17-L, D18-L, D37-L, D47-L, D50-L; I2-L, I11-L, I23-L, I30-L | -| I34-L | `commitGraph` batch validation is all-or-nothing: if any node or edge in the batch is structurally illegal, the entire batch is rejected and no partial state is persisted; the agent receives diagnostics sufficient for bounded self-correction retry. | covered (`command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts` and graph-tool adapter tests cover dry-run/commit diagnostic parity for invalid basis, missing refs/codes, invalid category/stance, self-loop, invalid node kind/detail shape, rollback of nodes/edges/change_log/counters, and structured adapter diagnostics instead of thrown projected-code errors) | D53-L; I1-L, I11-L | +| I34-L | `commitGraph` batch validation is all-or-nothing: if any node or edge in the batch is structurally illegal, the entire batch is rejected and no partial state is persisted; the agent receives diagnostics sufficient for bounded self-correction retry. | covered (`command-executor/commit-graph-batch.test.ts` and graph-tool adapter tests cover dry-run/commit diagnostic parity for invalid basis, missing refs/codes, invalid category/stance, self-loop, invalid node kind/detail shape, rollback of nodes/edges/change_log/counters, transaction-local planning before LSN allocation/writes, and structured adapter diagnostics without thrown projected-code errors or fake endpoint refs) | D53-L; I1-L, I11-L | | I35-L | Graph context snapshots support multiple detail levels: a cursory/compact full-graph overview for orientation, and detailed node-neighborhood snapshots with configurable hop depth for focused work. Context builders in `agents/contexts/` orchestrate which level to inject or advertise based on mode/goal/strategy/lens/grade. | covered for current POC push path (`getGraphOverview` + `getNodeNeighborhood` in `snapshot.ts` with 10 tests; `src/agents/contexts/{graph,node,cwd}.test.ts` covers lens-shaped overview rendering, bounded node-neighborhood rendering, and selected-spec cwd/session/posture context; `src/.pi/__tests__/prompting.test.ts` proves the explicit shell/product prompt path supplies selected-spec-bound graph snapshots to `composeAgentPrompt()`). Pulled `snapshot-*` tools remain optional future surface. | D52-L, D53-L, D58-L | | I36-L | Node `kind` is drawn from a per-plane closed enum structurally validated by the `CommandExecutor`; the intent kind category (basic / structural / reasoning) is a pure function of `kind` and is never stored on the node. | covered (CommandExecutor rejects invalid kind-for-plane; `intentKindCategory` is pure derivation with exhaustive switch; tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L, D56-L | | I37-L | `detail` is per-kind validated by the `CommandExecutor`: `decision` and `term` nodes REQUIRE `detail` with their respective sub-schemas; all other kinds must omit `detail`; unknown fields in `detail` are rejected. | covered (detail-required/prohibited/shape tests in `command-executor.test.ts`) | D54-L | @@ -628,7 +628,7 @@ The first required probe is M0: after manual TUI interaction, a checker proves ` | I37-L | M4 node-creation tests: decision/term rejected without detail; constraint accepted with or without detail; other kinds rejected with detail; unknown detail fields rejected. | | I38-L | `agents-composition-layer` inner tests: given projected runtime states and spec grades, compose emits manifests whose goal/strategy/lens/method resources are legal, Brunch-owned, readable, and filtered by the agent allow-list; AUTO axes list only legal choices and pinned axes point to their selected resource. Middle/outer probes may track whether the model actually reads the selected resource before applying it as fitness, not as an inner-loop gate. | | I39-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter/context tests: counter rows allocate monotonic per-kind ordinals in multi-node batches, rollback does not persist failed ordinals/counter rows, DB constraints reject duplicate `(spec_id, plane, kind, kind_ordinal)`, projected-code metadata is unique and parses by longest prefix, existing-code refs resolve inside the selected spec, and prompt/tool renderers use codes as primary handles. Remaining proof: deletion/supersession no-reuse. | -| I40-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter tests: `commitGraph` applies one batch basis to all created nodes/edges, `propose-graph` adapter commits use `implicit`, review-set translation uses `explicit`, retired `accepted_review_set` is rejected, and `change_log.operation` remains `commit_graph` independently of basis. Remaining proof: capture/direct-user writes and full review-cycle acceptance path. | +| I40-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor/adapter tests: `commitGraph` applies one batch basis to all created nodes/edges, single-node `createNode` rejects retired basis values before LSN/counter/node/change-log allocation, `propose-graph` adapter commits use `implicit`, review-set translation uses `explicit`, retired `accepted_review_set` is rejected, and `change_log.operation` remains independent of basis. Remaining proof: capture/direct-user writes and full review-cycle acceptance path. | | I41-L | `graph-tool-resilience` CommandExecutor tests reject supersession cycles across existing edges, intra-batch edges, and mixed existing+batch edges, including rollback of batch nodes/edges/change_log; existing acyclic supersession paths still commit. | ### Design Notes diff --git a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md b/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md deleted file mode 100644 index ceae4b59c..000000000 --- a/memory/cards/graph-tool-resilience--create-node-basis.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,65 +0,0 @@ -# Create-node basis validation - -Frontier: graph-tool-resilience -Status: done -Mode: single -Created: 2026-06-04 - -## Orientation - -- Seam: `CommandExecutor` graph mutation boundary, specifically the single-node `createNode` path that FE-807 capture may reuse. -- Frontier: `graph-tool-resilience` / FE-808; this closes review finding #3 after `commitGraph` already rejects retired basis values. -- Main risk: `createNode` silently accepts invalid basis strings while FE-808 claims accepted nodes/edges use only `explicit | implicit`. -- Cross-cutting obligations: preserve D20-L command-result semantics, D63-L basis meaning, and I34-L no-write/no-LSN on structural-illegal input. - -Posture: proving (inherited from graph-tool-resilience) - -## Light scope card — validate createNode basis - -### Objective - -`CommandExecutor.createNode()` rejects any graph basis outside `explicit | implicit` before allocating an LSN or writing graph rows. - -### Acceptance Criteria - -✓ `createNode({ basis: "accepted_review_set" })` returns `structural_illegal` with a `basis` diagnostic. -✓ Invalid `createNode` basis writes no node, no change-log row, no node-kind counter row, and does not increment `graph_clock`. -✓ Valid explicit and implicit basis values still persist unchanged. -✓ Existing `commitGraph` basis validation remains unchanged. -✓ `npm run verify` passes. - -### Verification Approach - -- Inner: targeted `CommandExecutor` tests for createNode invalid/valid basis behavior. -- Gate: `npm run verify`. - -### Cross-cutting obligations - -- Preserve D63-L: basis is approval strength only, not mutation path. -- Preserve D20-L: callers see structured command results, not thrown validation errors. - -### Assumption dependency - -None — this directly enforces an existing SPEC decision and FE-808 acceptance claim. - -### Expected touched paths (tentative) - -```text -src/graph/ -├── command-executor.ts ~ -└── command-executor.test.ts ~ -``` - -### Promotion checklist - -- [ ] Does this change a requirement? -- [ ] Does this create, retire, or invalidate an assumption? -- [ ] Does this slice depend on an unvalidated high-impact assumption? -- [ ] Does this make or reverse a non-trivial design decision? -- [ ] Does this establish a new seam-level invariant? -- [ ] Does this change a frontier-level cross-cutting obligation or verification architecture layer? -- [ ] Does it cross more than two major seams? -- [ ] Is this the first touch in an unfamiliar seam from a fresh thread? -- [ ] Can you not name the containing seam or current rationale from the live docs? - -All checklist answers are no; keep this as a light closeout cleanup.