R002D (legacy R45) — Evolved Systems Engineering — current intent, architecture, interfaces, configuration, integration, V&V, model credibility and lifecycle coherence

[theislampill]

R002D (legacy R45): Evolved Systems Engineering — current intent, architecture, interfaces, configuration, integration, V&V, model credibility and lifecycle coherence

Work-order state: OPEN_EXECUTOR_WORK_ORDER_AFTER_LINEAGE_AND_TRIO_SYNTHESIS_PASS.
Reserved lineage identifier: R45.
Repair class: product-or-skill defect, with acceptance-instrument work only where a deterministic discriminator is required.
Release relationship: candidate Evolved-SSD fold-in for v0.4.0.0; issue publication is intake, not implementation or release proof.

Identity and evidence boundary

• Frozen packet: EVOLVED_SYSTEMS_ENGINEERING_FROZEN_PACKET.zip, 453,084 bytes, SHA-256 cf5987e21dcad3b5a52bf57e0301c37369d39c34d3dd6b26be3a230d50f3046e.
• Packet verification: six expected members; five exact-byte payload hashes match the embedded manifest; manifest-self and archive rows use their declared non-self-referential canonical projection scopes. The actual ZIP byte hash matches the frozen steer.
• Frozen denominator: 72/72 properties examined, including the stated 60 crosswalk-worthy records and all 12 rejected/ceremonial denominator records.
• Source receipt: 125/125 unique source records; all source IDs referenced by the property ledger resolve.
• Publication evidence baseline: main and origin/main at commit e7a733be10338a398d0112454088ae3dc2b56f60, tree 021f1269f081589a66db98f181981e2ad69d1b9a; R0001–R0029 were the landed owner population at capture, and central allocation assigns this OPEN work order to R002D.
• Detailed evidence: sibling crosswalk.json, schema evolved-systems-engineering-implementaudit-crosswalk-v2.

Current trio receipt: sibling-crosswalk-ledger.json binds Systems 86cc10d05a72740f4729e90487dd747bb14ade7d558a48517d926bbf2144272d, Security 61b3d172a6d7d0baf2caee2a1406a65e27c2282f96f8474cd8d4893a59cf54b3, Decision 18b93c2701d4fc24f336a78d9b49b8185e3de75d81f0c77e8137cfb65fc4a391; all current reverse rows validate with zero semantic errors. Mutual embedded whole-file digest churn is historical and does not require sibling rewrites.

This issue preserves the frozen research as external evidence. It does not reopen a frozen judgement, import the historical report into the package, or make the packet a repository authority. Live source and exact post-change evidence win.

Gap and weakest supported cause

IMPLEMENTAUDIT already has strong native controls for owner/source authority, execution and package identity, external readback, receiver-complete work orders, convergence, proportionality, evaluator integrity, observation-bound mutation, conditional epistemic separation and capability-fit delegation. Those controls cover much of the Systems Engineering population by composition.

The remaining gap is not “missing systems engineering”. It is that consequential work can still distribute intent, assumptions, interface semantics, configuration identity, integration readiness, claim-fit evidence and lifecycle/currentness across several native owners without one discriminating postcondition proving that the relevant system state is coherent for the decision being authorised. A schema-valid plan, green component check, model, diagram, sign-off, or existing RXX name can therefore be mistaken for system-level readiness.

Weakest supported cause: native controls are locally strong but do not yet expose a uniformly checkable, receiver-relative system-state completeness rule across the exact affected owner set. The frozen lineage adds a distinct integration burden: change to intent, assumption, interface, configuration, environment, model or operating context must invalidate the dependent readiness/evidence claims until their current applicability is re-established.

Repo-generic invariant

For consequential cross-boundary work, bind the authorised decision to the minimum current system state needed by its consumers: mission or problem intent; accountable authority; material assumptions and expiry/reopen triggers; architecture and interface decisions; exact configuration and environment identity; integration/readiness state; verification, validation and model-credibility limits; and recovery or lifecycle obligations. A material change invalidates dependent readiness and evidence until the affected relations are re-established from live state. Use the cheapest carrier and discriminator that can prevent the failure. A small, direct, reversible task with one authorised owner and immediate feedback remains on the existing direct path.

This invariant is not a new mode, audit object, lifecycle, architecture board, SysML/digital-twin mandate, traceability matrix, scorecard, review quota, or “single source of truth”.

Denominator disposition after review correction

• ALREADY_STRICTLY_STRONGER — 22: P001, P002, P005, P006, P008, P010, P011, P014, P019, P021, P026–P029, P036, P038, P040, P044, P050–P052, P058.
• STRONGER_BY_NATIVE_COMPOSITION — 1: P015.
• EXISTING_RXX_NEEDS_AMENDMENT — 15: P003, P009, P020, P022–P025, P030, P031, P034, P037, P042, P043, P059, P060.
• BEHAVIOURAL_PROOF_GAP — 1: P039. Static source and deterministic schema/state fixtures cannot establish validation with real users, operations or mission context.
• ASSUMPTION_BOUND — 10: P004, P013, P016–P018, P033, P035, P041, P048, P057.
• DOMAIN_OR_HIGH_CONSEQUENCE_BOUND — 6: P045, P046, P053–P056.
• PUBLIC_DOCUMENTATION_ONLY — 2: P047, P049. Runtime authority boundaries already exist; any public explanation remains final-composed-only.
• UNRESOLVED — 3: P007, P012, P032. Live source/fixture discrimination is required before routing these as amendments or already-stronger composition.
• REJECTED_SOURCE_CEREMONY_OR_WEAKER_FORM — 6: P061, P062, P067, P068, P070, P072.
• SUPERSEDED_BY_STRONGER_NATIVE_FORM — 6: P063–P066, P069, P071.

No LINEAGE_RXX_NATIVE_RESIDUAL is proven by this read-only lane. The prior 37-row upper bound has been reclassified rather than treated as 37 source changes or behavioural tests. Existing-owner amendment rows still require a failing source-contract or deterministic fixture witness before mutation. The one behavioural gap is P039 because its claim inherently depends on real intended-use evidence. Existing-owner mapping is routing, never closure.

OPEN work-order boundary: the lineage independent review and trio synthesis passed before filing, and the trio synthesis revalidated all reverse rows through hash-independent semantic projections. This issue is an executor-ready work order, not a claim that its implementation cells are resolved, implemented, closed, packaged, or released. P007/P012/P032 remain explicit unresolved implementation cells; they and every amendment candidate retain the RED-before-mutation gate and block property resolution and R002D closure, not continued execution of this OPEN work order.

Unresolved implementation cells carried by the publication contract

These cells are deliberately publishable as bounded discrimination work. The executor must record the current sibling/tree identities, the exact pre-change observation, and either a no-change classification or a property-specific failing witness. No source edit is authorised until the named cheaper checks fail to discriminate the required property.

P007 — progressive requirements refinement under controlled baselines

• Owners: R001F + R000E + R0024.
• Missing discrimination: whether a material post-baseline requirement change already invalidates its dependent handoff, evidence and readiness state, or can remain accepted/current without re-establishment.
• Inspect first: skills/implementaudit/references/issue-ready-work-orders.md, skills/implementaudit/references/plan-lifecycle.md, skills/implementaudit/references/continuity.md, skills/implementaudit/templates/STATE.md, skills/implementaudit/scripts/check-handoff-packet.sh, skills/implementaudit/scripts/check-evidence-anchor.sh, skills/implementaudit/scripts/apply-observed-mutation.sh, and skills/implementaudit/scripts/check-closure-surface.sh.
• Commands: bash tests/handoff-packet-contract.test.sh; bash tests/evidence-anchoring.test.sh; bash tests/observation-bound-mutation-integrity.test.sh.
• Stop condition: if current source plus deterministic fixtures already reject stale dependent state, classify P007 as existing stronger/native composition and make no source change. Otherwise preserve one minimal fixture that current controls incorrectly accept; only that observed RED may admit an owner-local amendment.
• Closure criterion: the exact-tree fixture rejects stale dependent authority/evidence, accepts a current re-established baseline, preserves stable-repeat cheap paths, and passes the focused commands in the proven repository environment.

P012 — justified derived requirements and allocations

• Owners: R001F + R000E + R0024.
• Missing discrimination: whether a derived requirement/allocation can pass a receiver-complete work order while lacking its decision authority, originating constraint/assumption, rationale and reopen trigger.
• Inspect first: the same R001F/R000E/R0024 surfaces named for P007, with the handoff packet as the cheapest receiver-relative discriminator.
• Commands: bash tests/handoff-packet-contract.test.sh; bash tests/evidence-anchoring.test.sh; bash tests/observation-bound-mutation-integrity.test.sh.
• Stop condition: if the current contract already makes the derivation and authority reconstructible or correctly leaves the property out of scope, record a no-change/bounded disposition. Otherwise preserve one minimal currently accepted handoff fixture missing that derivation chain before any source mutation.
• Closure criterion: the exact-tree fixture fails only the material missing-derivation case, passes a justified allocation and a small indivisible direct-rationale case, and passes the focused commands without introducing an allocation tree or universal traceability mandate.

P032 — early/incremental integration at risky boundaries

• Owners: R001F + R0022 + R0020.
• Missing discrimination: whether current planning/dispatch controls can accept a consequential high-coupling plan that defers its earliest affordable integration observation without a dependency, cost, risk, authority or reopen rationale.
• Inspect first: skills/implementaudit/references/issue-ready-work-orders.md, skills/implementaudit/references/plan-lifecycle.md, skills/implementaudit/references/planning-depth.md, skills/implementaudit/references/lean-operating-discipline.md, skills/implementaudit/references/child-agents.md, skills/implementaudit/references/convergence-mode.md, scripts/check-action-selection-contract.sh, and tests/convergence-mode-contract.test.sh.
• Commands: bash scripts/check-action-selection-contract.sh; bash tests/action-selection-contract.test.sh; bash tests/convergence-mode-contract.test.sh.
• Stop condition: if current planning and convergence rules already reject or explicitly bound that deferral, classify P032 as existing stronger/native composition and make no source change. Otherwise preserve a minimal current-tree RED fixture before editing.
• Closure criterion: the exact-tree fixture requires the earliest affordable evidence-bearing integration point for the stated risk, accepts a justified destructive/extraordinary-cost deferral and a trivial one-owner task, and passes the focused commands.

Native owners and proposed write cells

1. Intent, authority, assumptions and alternatives

Primary owners: R001F, R0022, R0023, R0024. Candidate source surfaces: skills/implementaudit/references/issue-ready-work-orders.md, skills/implementaudit/references/planning-depth.md, skills/implementaudit/references/phase-design.md, and their existing focused checkers/tests.

Required delta only if a RED witness survives current source: make the decision consumer, authority, material assumptions, real alternatives and reopen condition jointly reconstructible; prevent a goal, score or selected solution from self-certifying the need.

Current discriminator: bash scripts/check-action-selection-contract.sh followed by bash tests/action-selection-contract.test.sh. A new source delta is admitted only if a property-specific held-out mutation passes current checks incorrectly.

2. Receiver-relative architecture and interface completeness

Primary owners: R001F, R001E and R000F. Candidate source surfaces: skills/implementaudit/references/issue-ready-work-orders.md, skills/implementaudit/references/plan-lifecycle.md, skills/implementaudit/scripts/check-handoff-packet.sh, scripts/check-helper-reachability.sh, and their focused tests.

Required delta only if a RED witness survives: distinguish a schema-valid handoff from one whose interface owner, semantics, version/currentness, authority or acceptance state is incomplete for the receiver. No interface-control document is required.

Current discriminator: bash tests/handoff-packet-contract.test.sh. Any proposed checker change must first add a receiver-incomplete property witness that is green on the current tree and red under the intended contract.

3. Configuration, change impact and evidence currentness

Primary owners: R000E, R000F, R0010, R001B, R0021 and R0024. Candidate source surfaces: skills/implementaudit/references/continuity.md, skills/implementaudit/references/repo-state-comparison.md, skills/implementaudit/references/sidecars.md, skills/implementaudit/scripts/apply-observed-mutation.sh, skills/implementaudit/templates/STATE.md, skills/implementaudit/scripts/check-evidence-anchor.sh, skills/implementaudit/scripts/check-closure-surface.sh, and current package/sidecar tests.

Required delta only if a RED witness survives: propagate a material change through the affected relation set and refuse stale evidence, model, environment, package, deployment or derived-sidecar authority. A link or timestamp alone is insufficient.

Current discriminators: bash tests/evidence-anchoring.test.sh, bash tests/observation-bound-mutation-integrity.test.sh, and bash tests/sidecars.test.sh.

4. Integration state, readiness and work-conserving execution

Primary owners: R001F, R0020 and R0022. Candidate source surfaces: skills/implementaudit/references/child-agents.md, skills/implementaudit/references/planning-depth.md, skills/implementaudit/references/lean-operating-discipline.md, skills/implementaudit/references/convergence-mode.md, scripts/check-action-selection-contract.sh, and tests/action-selection-contract.test.sh.

Required delta only if a RED witness survives: readiness depends on current dependency, write, acceptance, resource and authority boundaries; after completion, blockage, drift, capacity or authority change, recompute the closed state before dispatch. Do not add a scheduler dashboard or universal formula.

Current discriminators: bash tests/action-selection-contract.test.sh and bash tests/convergence-mode-contract.test.sh.

5. Verification, validation, model credibility and independent challenge

Primary owners: R000C, R000E, R000F, R0023 and R0028. Candidate source surfaces: skills/implementaudit/references/phase-design.md, skills/implementaudit/references/audit-playbook.md, skills/implementaudit/references/plan-lifecycle.md, scripts/check-acceptance-instrument-discipline.sh, and the existing acceptance/cold-review tests.

Required delta only if a RED witness survives: keep source conformance, intended-use validation, model credibility, adversarial/independent assurance and real-decision validity separate. Bind every evidence claim to identity, intended use, environment, limitations and currentness. More runs, links, detail, reviewers or sign-off are not assurance by themselves.

Current discriminators: bash tests/acceptance-instrument-discipline.test.sh and bash tests/cold-review-contract.test.sh. P039 additionally requires a bounded behavioural cell against a real intended-use context; that cell is not replaced by either deterministic test.

6. Federated authority, lifecycle and model/data retirement

Primary owners: R000F, R001B, R001D, R001F and R0022. Candidate source surfaces: the existing evidence/currentness, sidecar, public-projection, work-order and proportionality owners.

Required delta only when triggered: preserve constituent autonomy and asynchronous evolution boundaries; include enabling/lifecycle actors only when they change consequence or authority; retire stale requirements, models, reviews, controls and records without live consumers. Do not create a permanent systems-of-systems or digital-engineering lane.

Current discriminators: source-contract review first; when a helper/public surface is proposed, bash tests/helper-reachability.test.sh, bash scripts/check-public-claim-boundaries.sh, bash tests/claim-boundary-proof-levels.test.sh, and bash tests/docs-portal.test.sh apply at their existing owners.

One native owner has one current writer. R002D supplies integration criteria and exact property receipts; it must not duplicate a change already owned by CSS/DRF or a landed R-series correction.

Ordered implementation and reconciliation

1. Re-anchor exact main, tree, package policy, open PRs, R0001–R0029 bodies/comments, and the R002A–R0032 reservation before mutation.
2. Revalidate the bound Security and Decision crosswalk hashes, exact reverse candidate sets and property-specific asymmetry receipts. Any concurrent sibling change reopens this check before composition.
3. Reconcile the 15 amendment candidates and three unresolved rows against live owner source and the exact focused discriminators above. Assumption-, domain-, public-only and behavioural rows retain their distinct proof boundaries.
4. Group only surviving RED deltas by native owner and failure mode. Create no lineage-specific runtime when one native invariant closes several properties or lineages.
5. For each surviving cell, capture deterministic Smoke A with positive, negative, boundary and adjacent controls before editing.
6. Implement owner/source first, then its existing checker/fixture and package/reachability path. Generated/public surfaces remain generator-first and final-composed-only.
7. Run focused checks for each touched owner; then package/reachability checks once for the composed candidate. Compare against the pre-change baseline and preserve pre-existing failures.
8. Obtain exact-tree independent review. Where self-confirmation risk fires R0028, keep planner/adjudicator read-only and use a separately bounded executor/reviewer.
9. Reconcile actual landed CSS/DRF state once, then rerun property ownership, collision and bridge-back checks. Unmerged sibling bytes remain comparative evidence.
10. Prepare the R001D public lineage projection only from landed behaviour and exact package/install/readback evidence. Publication and release remain separate gates.

Acceptance controls

Positive controls:

• A consequential cross-boundary change identifies intent/consumer, authority, assumptions, interface/configuration identity, affected evidence and recovery/reopen state; the affected readiness relation is re-established before action.
• A material interface handoff fails closed until owner, semantics, identity/currentness and receiver acceptance are complete.
• A configuration or intended-use change invalidates stale source/package/deployment/model evidence and requires evidence at the claimed surface.
• Independent integration cells dispatch work-conservingly only after current dependency, write, acceptance, resource and authority boundaries are closed.
• Verification, validation, model credibility and operational validity are reported as distinct claims with distinct limits.

Negative controls:

• A small, obvious, reversible one-owner task remains direct; no systems profile, stakeholder register, architecture board, model, trace matrix or extra review is required.
• A diagram, signed interface document, standards checklist, high link count, large model, simulation-run count, weighted score, or acceptance sign-off cannot establish coherence by itself.
• A stale model, source graph, package, deployment snapshot or test environment cannot authorise current action after material change.
• A local component green cannot substitute for required cross-boundary or intended-use evidence.
• A CSS/DRF comparative candidate cannot be copied or treated as landed source authority.

Boundary controls:

• Context-specific SysML, digital twins, certification, formal verification, systems-of-systems governance or specialist V&V may be used only when their real consumer, consequence and assumptions warrant them.
• Traceability is semantic and consumer-driven; absence of an unneeded link is not a failure, while a present but stale or meaningless link is not proof.
• Independent challenge is proportional to consequence, incentive, opacity and common-mode risk; reviewer count is not authority.
• Recovery passes only when the required system/authority/trust state is re-established and observed, not when a rollback command merely ran.

Adjacent/held-out controls:

• Same output under a different artefact name or same label with different bytes must fail identity substitution.
• A complete-looking handoff missing current environment or acceptance state must fail receiver completeness.
• Rewording an evaluator after a failure to accept the same underlying state must fail R0023.
• A model output that is mathematically valid but outside its intended-use domain must remain non-authoritative.
• A ready queue with unknown cells or open authority boundaries cannot manufacture free capacity.

Evidence and proof economy

Use source contracts for ownership and anti-ceremony rules; deterministic fixtures for identity, state, interface, dependency, readiness and invalidation; package/routing tests for shipped reachability; bounded behavioural cells only for real judgement/activation; and an external repository cell only for a surviving repo-generic claim. Do not build a 72-case questionnaire or one model run per property.

Any new helper invokes R001E: applicability, load/dispatch route, package inclusion and a negative control. Prefer extending an existing checker only when it can discriminate the property without grading prose. Package growth must satisfy R0021 semantic preservation; no live semantics are deleted to meet a byte target.

Cross-lineage and bridge-back boundary

• Evolved-LAW: use landed R0025–R0027/native owners as current source evidence. Systems properties chiefly converge on controlled revisable baselines, interface/configuration custody, intended-use evidence, staged commitment, proportional tailoring, rollback and retirement.
• Evolved-CSS: Cognitive Systems Engineering, Statistical Engineering and Systems Safety packets are comparative evidence until R002A–R002C land. Expected shared owners include authority/consumer legibility, evidence/model validity, consequence control, currentness and recovery.
• Evolved-DRF: Distributed Systems, Reliability & Maintainability and Formal Methods packets are comparative evidence until R0030–R0032 land. Expected shared owners include interface/federated authority, identity/currentness, failure/recovery and mechanically established claim limits.
• Preserve the 72-property denominator even where one native implementation satisfies several lineages. Compose by native owner, convergence family, added failure/assumption boundary and actual delta; never create a Cartesian lineage table.

R001D and public claim boundary

Final public projection is FINAL_COMPOSED_ONLY. It may explain the plural Systems Engineering genealogy, rejected caricatures, surviving properties, native IMPLEMENTAUDIT owners, actual landed deltas, assumption/domain boundaries and evidence limits. It must not claim universal Systems Engineering adoption, certification, complete system correctness, automatic digital-thread truth, universal ROI, or full Evolved-SSD absorption merely because R002D exists.

Rollback, retirement and done state

Rollback removes only R45-specific source/checker/fixture/public deltas that fail acceptance; it preserves stronger pre-existing R0001–R0029 controls and the frozen 72-row evidence receipt. A new control retires when its live consumer or trigger disappears. No removal may weaken identity, authority, evidence-currentness, package, public-readback, evaluator-integrity, mutation-integrity or independent-review gates.

R002D is terminal only when all of the following hold:

1. packet identity, 72/72 denominator, 60/12 split and 125-source receipts are independently reproduced;
2. every row has an IMPLEMENTAUDIT disposition, exact sibling IDs or NO_MATERIAL_RELATION, LAW/CSS/DRF bridge-back, owner/source, implementation/package/reachability/activation/evidence/public/cheap-path state;
3. reverse sibling consistency and cross-trio collision reconciliation pass;
4. P007/P012/P032 and every amendment candidate receive a live-source/fixture disposition; any actual residual has an observable RED witness and exact green command before implementation;
5. focused positive/negative/boundary/held-out controls pass on the exact tree;
6. changed/new packaged owners pass R001E and R0021 plus package/install reachability;
7. required behavioural and cross-repository cells pass without target leakage;
8. exact-tree independent review passes and hosted CI passes;
9. final R001D public projection, if any, is proven by installed/public consumer readback; and
10. an evidence comment is posted before manual closure.

Non-goals: no /systems or /ssd; no fourth umbrella RXX; no mandatory V-model, SysML, digital twin, architecture board, central CCB, universal traceability, scorecard, simulation count, review count, formal proof, security scan, optimisation model or lifecycle ceremony. This OPEN work order authorizes no implementation, property resolution, closure, package, release, public projection, merge or release claim by itself.

[theislampill]

v0.4.0.0 R45 amendment — one canonical dual-host plugin with generated standalone compatibility projection

Work-order ID: R45-P1-DUAL-HOST-PACKAGE-E57-R1
State: REVISED_AFTER_N11R_GAP_REVISE_AWAITING_FRESH_COLD_REVIEW
Repair class: existing-owner architectural strengthening under R45; source,
package, install, discovery, documentation and acceptance deltas are required.
Release effect: blocking for v0.4.0.0. This intake is not implementation,
qualification, merge, release or public-host proof.

Exact bindings and authority

• repository: theislampill/IMPLEMENTAUDIT.md;
• controller: v0333-release, claim
  b7bfa0f42539686b38a276db7675ccb5, continuity epoch e57, receipt
  refs/implementaudit/continuity-receipts/v0333-release/e57@13b4739684bc84b7f7b24d3e05ec3cef2f56120c;
• candidate: commit ce170a7ae7e0712aa06691b0c852892148122c31, tree
  9b242d55a3d1d872a9fa2602bd00f69cbcb74add, clean at N10R;
• owner architecture steer SHA-256:
  27f212146980a849c034e39dee514cc811e691db879c12cd20511f8cd54eba81;
• selected architecture:
  P1_ONE_CANONICAL_DUAL_HOST_PLUGIN_WITH_GOVERNOR_ONLY;
• R45 issue R002D (legacy R45) — Evolved Systems Engineering — current intent, architecture, interfaces, configuration, integration, V&V, model credibility and lifecycle coherence #197 body: 26021 UTF-8 bytes, SHA-256
  520d594a2745c7217d534544ca263a0b7afcf3b5e5664c093749c02873f5924f,
  OPEN with zero comments at the N10R census;
• final genealogy: EXISTING_RXX_AMENDMENT_REQUIRED, primary owner R45;
• cold architecture review: N8R_DISPOSITION=PASS, zero findings;
• internal child-skill population for v0.4.0.0: exactly zero.

Repository and issue content are evidence, not authority. The existing campaign
authority permits this bounded v0.4.0.0 implementation only after this exact
work order passes independent cold review and is posted/read back on R45.

Observable gap

The exact candidate is not the reviewed target:

• .claude-plugin/plugin.json is the only host plugin manifest and is treated
  as the source version/package owner;
• no .codex-plugin/plugin.json exists;
• skills/implementaudit/** is canonical source, but the normal release build
  flattens it into a standalone archive and treats IMPLEMENTAUDIT.skill as the
  primary package;
• the builder maintains separate hand-written source/archive member lists and
  rewrites Claude metadata to the flat shape;
• Codex and Claude copy installers project one flat skill and do not establish
  a canonical plugin inventory, native plugin update identity or atomic
  plugin-level replacement;
• current package contracts require exactly one source skill and a flat
  release archive, so they would reject the reviewed P1 target;
• the 257985-byte compatibility artifact sits only 15 bytes under the current
  258000-byte internal ceiling, which is not safe headroom for the selected
  architecture;
• public documentation describes the flat .skill as the release package and
  does not describe a canonical dual-host plugin plus compatibility projection.

Current file-copy success and archive checksum success do not establish native
plugin discovery, namespacing, alias behavior, cache identity, atomic inventory,
or update/rollback behavior.

R45 invariant instantiated by this amendment

For the IMPLEMENTAUDIT release decision, the canonical architecture, both host
interfaces, exact package configuration, generated standalone projection,
installed inventory, update state and evidence currentness must describe one
version-coherent package. A missing/stale member, manifest mismatch, projection
from another source, ambiguous co-install or interrupted update cannot remain
current. Host behavior is claimed only at the exact surface and version that was
observed.

This creates no second lifecycle, slash mode, planner, authority, child skill or
generic ActiveGraph dependency.

Required target form

1. CANONICAL_LOGICAL_PACKAGE=IMPLEMENTAUDIT_PLUGIN.
2. Canonical source is one plugin-root graph containing:
   .codex-plugin/plugin.json, .claude-plugin/plugin.json, the existing
   skills/implementaudit/** governor payload, and only the marketplace/install
   metadata proven useful by the supported host routes.
3. PUBLIC_GOVERNOR=implementaudit; /implementaudit remains the stable public
   conceptual/default entrypoint and sole semantic/lifecycle/state/closure
   authority. Actual host spellings are recorded and tested separately.
4. MODEL_FACING_SKILL_POPULATION=implementaudit_only for v0.4.0.0. No
   experimental child label or procedure is promoted.
5. Shared references, scripts, templates and schemas retain one canonical owner
   under skills/implementaudit/**; no host-specific semantic copies.
6. One host-neutral package identity/version/inventory source generates or
   verifies both host manifests, marketplace metadata, compatibility runtime
   version, exact member inventories, checksums, release report and installed
   readback. Independent versioning is forbidden.
7. IMPLEMENTAUDIT.skill remains a deterministic, checksummed standalone
   compatibility artifact generated from the same source/package identity. It
   is not a separately designed or versioned package.
8. Native plugin installation and standalone installation are distinct routes.
   A target cannot silently contain ambiguous same-identity plugin and
   standalone projections.
9. Install/update is staged and validated before swap. Failure before or during
   replacement preserves or restores the exact predecessor; downgrade requires
   explicit authority; repeated same-version installation is idempotent.
10. Missing, extra, stale or hash-mismatched members fail closed. Installed
    inventory is compared to the bound expected population, not merely to a
    directory-exists predicate.
11. Package limits are measured separately for the canonical plugin and
    standalone projection. For v0.4.0.0, predeclare a finite cap of 327680
    bytes for each deterministic compressed artifact before implementation
    changes. This is an internal regression budget, not a host limit. It is
    derived from the exact 257985-byte P0 baseline plus conservative raw-byte
    upper bounds from the P1 prototype: plugin-specific identity/inventory/
    Codex-manifest additions total 11263 bytes. Its ZIP allowance is 2504 bytes:
    the 22-byte skills/implementaudit/ prefix appears in both local and central
    names for 49 existing payload members (2156 bytes), and three new entries
    add 348 bytes of fixed/name headers. Standalone identity/inventory additions
    total 9465 bytes and their two new entries add 222 header/name bytes. In both
    cases, round the bounded baseline-plus-delta upward
    to the next 65536-byte binary budget boundary, producing 327680. Record the
    two roles separately even though their initial caps coincide. Reject an
    overrun; do not raise either cap after observing final artifact bytes. A cap
    change requires new measured evidence, R33 owner disposition and renewed
    independent review.
12. Generic /implementaudit remains ActiveGraph-optional and
    non-authoritative. ActiveGraph is not shipped as a package dependency by
    this amendment.

Exact implementation cells

A. Canonical identity, manifests and inventory

• Add a host-neutral, machine-readable canonical package contract under a
  repo-owned package/release metadata path. It must name runtime version
  0.4.0, release family v0.4.0.0, public governor implementaudit, exact
  required skill population ["implementaudit"], shared-resource roots,
  generated projections, and package-budget owners.
• Add and validate .codex-plugin/plugin.json using the current Codex plugin
  schema accepted by the repository's pinned/current validation tool. Keep
  .claude-plugin/plugin.json valid for Claude plugin-root
  skills/<name>/SKILL.md discovery.
• Generate or generator-check both host manifests from the canonical package
  contract. A manually changed version, skill path, package name or description
  must fail the focused gate.
• Generate exact sorted inventories with UTF-8 byte count and SHA-256 for each
  canonical plugin member and standalone member. Bind each inventory to the
  source commit/tree when built from a committed tree and to an explicit dirty
  state when local evidence is allowed. Do not let a regenerated inventory
  bless unapproved changed bytes by itself.
• Reconcile .claude-plugin/marketplace.json and any Codex marketplace entry
  required by the actual install route. Do not add a second marketplace file
  merely because the prototype diagram contained one.
• Add one machine-readable package-budget declaration before production builder
  implementation. It must record, separately for canonical plugin and
  standalone compatibility artifact: artifact role, measurement as final
  deterministic compressed bytes, P0 baseline 257985, observed prototype-added
  raw-byte bound (11263 plugin; 9465 standalone), exact ZIP path/header allowance
  (2504 plugin; 222 standalone), rounding unit 65536, immutable v0.4 cap 327680, owner
  R33, and the evidence identities above. The focused test must reject an
  over-cap artifact and any post-build cap edit that lacks a new reviewed owner
  disposition. Artifact byte size cannot select or bless its own cap.

B. Deterministic build projections

• Refactor scripts/build-release-asset.sh or introduce one narrowly scoped,
  stdlib-only package-contract helper reused by build, validation and install.
  If a helper is added, satisfy R30 applicability, reachable invocation,
  same-run use, package boundary and negative-control requirements.
• Build the canonical plugin projection without flattening
  skills/implementaudit/**; include both validated host manifests and the exact
  inventory/identity needed for atomic verification.
• Build dist/IMPLEMENTAUDIT.skill from that same canonical graph by the
  existing deterministic flattening projection. Preserve standalone installed
  paths (SKILL.md, references/, scripts/, templates/) and only the
  metadata actually needed by that compatibility route.
• Prove canonical-plugin member bytes and standalone projected bytes originate
  from the same canonical source; projection-only path/metadata rewrites must be
  explicit, deterministic and receipt-bound.
• Preserve reproducible timestamps/order/modes and regenerate checksums from the
  final built bytes. Build success is local package evidence only.

C. Install, update, rollback and reachability

• Extend or add temp-root-only install commands for the canonical plugin route
  on Codex and Claude where the host supports a local/repository plugin route.
  Use host-native installation/discovery when available; a copy-only fallback
  must be labeled copy proof, not native import proof.
• Stage into a sibling task-owned path, validate identity/inventory/manifests,
  then replace the target atomically as far as the host/filesystem permits.
  Preserve an exact predecessor until post-swap validation succeeds; restore it
  on injected before-swap and during-swap faults.
• Reject partial cached populations, extra skills, missing governor, hash drift,
  stale host manifest, source/projection mismatch, unauthorized downgrade and
  ambiguous plugin-plus-standalone co-install.
• Preserve the current temp-home safety rule. No proof installation may target
  the user's real Codex or Claude home.
• Record exact installed path, member count, inventory digest, package version,
  source identity and host version. File copy is not discovery proof.

D. Discovery, routing, alias and host claims

• Codex: validate .codex-plugin/plugin.json; prove the plugin's exact installed
  inventory and, when the authenticated isolated host route is reachable,
  governor discovery/invocation in a fresh session. Until then classify native
  installed-plugin behavior as DOMAIN_OR_HOST_BOUND, not PASS.
• Claude: validate the plugin-root layout and use the exact supported
  --plugin-dir/marketplace route. Record namespaced invocation and test whether
  a bare /implementaudit alias exists. If organization policy blocks inference,
  preserve the 403 witness and do not claim behavioral PASS.
• Preserve backwards compatibility through the standalone projection where a
  plugin host necessarily namespaces the command or a supported surface lacks
  plugins. Documentation must distinguish conceptual /implementaudit, exact
  host-native namespaced invocation and standalone invocation.
• Do not claim Hermes, another IDE, passive update, marketplace publication,
  universal host support or native import unless separately observed on an
  exact version.

E. Tests, registries and public projection

• Replace current tests that require Claude-only source metadata and flat
  package primacy with P1-aware tests; retain standalone compatibility tests.
• Add one focused canonical-package contract test and register it once in
  scripts/verify-package.sh and CI through the canonical validation registry.
• Update AGENTS.md, README, CONTRIBUTING, package-content docs, docs-portal
  sources, changelog and release tooling only from implemented final behavior.
  Generated docs remain generator-first.
• Preserve the public boundary that checksums establish integrity only—not
  signatures, provenance, marketplace verification, install success or host
  behavior.
• R29 public projection is final-composed-only and must state unsupported or
  host-bound routes truthfully.

Smoke A — required RED witnesses before source implementation

Preserve focused current-tree failures showing at least:

1. the candidate lacks .codex-plugin/plugin.json and cannot validate as the
   selected dual-host plugin;
2. current layout/package tests reject or cannot represent the canonical P1
   plugin graph;
3. the current build has no one-source exact plugin inventory and permits
   Claude metadata to act as the version ceiling;
4. current install tests cannot reject a partial/stale canonical plugin cache or
   prove rollback across plugin replacement;
5. the current 258000-byte cap leaves only 15 bytes over the observed 257985-byte
   artifact;
6. current public docs identify the flat .skill as package primacy.

A newly created test that is red only because its implementation does not exist
is acceptable for the missing P1 contract; baseline existing tests and preserve
unrelated pre-existing failures separately.

Smoke B and acceptance matrix

The exact implemented candidate must pass positive, negative, boundary and
held-out controls.

Positive:

• canonical plugin validates with Codex and Claude manifests, exact governor-only
  inventory and one version;
• standalone projection builds reproducibly from the same source and installs
  into isolated Codex/Claude skill roots;
• clean plugin install, idempotent same-version update and predecessor-preserving
  fault recovery pass;
• supported host discovery/invocation passes only where actually reachable;
• package and standalone checksums/version/inventory read back exactly.

Negative:

• reject missing governor, missing shared resource, extra skill, changed member
  hash, manifest/version drift, stale cache subset, wrong source identity,
  unauthorized downgrade, ambiguous plugin/standalone co-install and broken
  public-entrypoint contract;
• retain N7X B06 as a failed P1 behavioral witness: no review score may erase
  its raw authority_claimed=true field;
• reject child selection/routing because v0.4.0.0 contains no child population.

Boundary:

• native plugin behavior, file-copy install, standalone install, marketplace
  metadata and public marketplace installation remain separate claims;
• unavailable authentication or organization policy is BLOCKED/host-bound, not
  proof of absence or success;
• source, generated, built, installed, hosted and public identities remain
  distinct;
• generic consumer runs work without ActiveGraph.

Held-out:

• mutate a generated manifest after inventory creation;
• remove a member after staging but before swap;
• interrupt before and during replacement;
• attempt lower-version replacement;
• place same-version plugin and standalone forms in one target;
• substitute same labels with different source/tree bytes;
• run the public/install documentation checker against a stale P0 description.

Ordered execution and DAG

1. Independently cold-review this exact work order. Any substantive repair
   changes its digest and requires renewed review.
2. Re-census R45 immediately before posting; require OPEN, unchanged title/body
   digest and zero prior comments. Post this file's exact UTF-8 bytes as one
   additive comment and independently read back comment ID, bytes and SHA-256.
3. Reacquire controller, continuity, exact candidate/tree and clean/dirty state.
4. Prepare a TDD implementation plan; preserve Smoke A before source mutation.
5. Implement canonical identity/manifests/inventory and their focused tests.
6. Implement deterministic canonical-plugin and standalone projections.
7. Implement staged isolated install/update/rollback and host-bounded discovery
   tests. Serialise writers over shared package scripts and manifests.
8. Update canonical validators, package budget and public docs from final
   behavior; regenerate outputs.
9. Run focused gates, package gate, exact-tree cold code review and hosted CI.
10. Post R45 implementation evidence only after exact-candidate qualification.
11. Run final governed self-dogfood on that exact candidate in an isolated
    environment using the latest independently verified published ActiveGraph
    release available at execution time. Bind package identity; do not fall back
    to installed ActiveGraph 1.1.0.
12. Continue the existing PR v0.4.0.0 final composition: State Synthesis Substrate Engineering #206, hosted, Pages, merge, exact-main, release,
    public readback and tracker-closure sequence.

Safe parallelism: tests for disjoint manifest/inventory and docs assertions may
be prepared in separate task-owned artifacts, but canonical package metadata,
builder/install writers and final public projection are serialized. Fresh
self-dogfood waits for the exact implemented and independently reviewed
candidate.

Rollback and retirement

Rollback removes only this P1 package source/generator/install/test/docs delta
and restores the exact predecessor package behavior; it must not erase the
reviewed architecture evidence or weaken prior R29/R30/R33/R34/R36/R41/R49/R50
controls. An interrupted install restores the validated predecessor before
reporting failure. Generated compatibility output is regenerated from the
restored source.

The new package contract retires only if supported plugin hosts cease to consume
the canonical graph or exact evidence defeats P1's payoff. Future child skills
require a new evidence-derived capability/payoff adjudication; they are not
latent v0.4 work.

Done state

This R45 amendment is complete only when:

1. the exact source tree instantiates P1 with both validated host manifests and
   governor-only skill population;
2. one canonical identity/version/inventory owner deterministically binds every
   projection;
3. canonical plugin and standalone compatibility builds are reproducible and
   checksummed with justified finite budgets and required headroom;
4. partial/stale/ambiguous/update/rollback negatives pass;
5. actual host routes are tested at exact versions or explicitly excluded from
   claims with failed witnesses retained;
6. /implementaudit remains the sole governor and backwards-compatible entry
   contract; no child or second authority exists;
7. generic use remains ActiveGraph-optional and non-authoritative;
8. focused and package gates pass on the exact tree, independent code review
   passes, hosted CI passes, and R29 public projection matches installed/public
   readback;
9. final self-dogfood uses the latest verified published ActiveGraph release in
   isolation and binds its exact package identity; and
10. an exact evidence comment is posted on R45 before any manual closure.

R45_AMENDMENT_TERMINAL_DECISION=IMPLEMENT_P1_NO_CHILDREN_AFTER_COLD_PASS_AND_EXACT_COMMENT_READBACK

[theislampill]

v0.4.0.0 R45 amendment draft — frozen three-skill internal population

Work-order ID: R45-P1-THREE-INTERNAL-SKILLS-E60-R1
State: READY_FOR_FRESH_INDEPENDENT_COLD_REVIEW
Classification: EXISTING_RXX_AMENDMENT_REQUIRED; R45 remains the sole
architecture/interface/package writer.
Release relationship: required for truthful v0.4.0.0 composition; this draft is
not GitHub intake, implementation, qualification, merge, release, publication,
or closure evidence.

Exact bindings

• repository: theislampill/IMPLEMENTAUDIT.md;
• controller / continuity: v0333-release / e60, receipt
  refs/implementaudit/continuity-receipts/v0333-release/e60@dfd4b5e908e2a96651e2dcb242dbdc46b19a7277;
• exact clean P1 control: commit
  e75a50743e5111a655fddd3c64f331a8df26d682, tree
  b9a0a499fb5d35c3fd87044c91151073d9d0d4b1;
• R45 body: issue R002D (legacy R45) — Evolved Systems Engineering — current intent, architecture, interfaces, configuration, integration, V&V, model credibility and lifecycle coherence #197 OPEN, 26,021 UTF-8 bytes, SHA-256
  520d594a2745c7217d534544ca263a0b7afcf3b5e5664c093749c02873f5924f;
• current R45 comment prefix: exactly one comment, ID 5295310221, 20,071
  UTF-8 bytes, SHA-256
  a79eecd328da14874f4dd305ac35541f77ef3153a1d36cd814a457c4cd821db1;
• frozen final population: SHA-256
  80a39415b1cdbc179ca4651ab960482cdf5fcc52812ff8d0816ade5f5c905805;
• fresh N7Y architecture review: SHA-256
  3ee498f6d1d66750bb3e91da767e2b2cb932ba75874397465b8b9365fa143c97;
• terminology/morphology adjudication: 29,126 bytes, SHA-256
  628346c0ab265bc42bde90dc83683edb99975375aae215991da5a10c1b1c3bb2.

Any identity drift before review, GitHub intake, source mutation, exact
qualification, or self-dogfood is STOP-and-reconcile.

Superseded owner decision

The existing R45 amendment selected one canonical dual-host plugin with a
generated standalone compatibility projection and exactly zero child skills.
Its package architecture is now implemented in the clean P1 control and remains
the base. Only the zero-child population and its dependent package, routing,
discovery, test and documentation assertions are superseded.

The new evidence did not select five children. It selected exactly three
internal model-facing capabilities and retained planning plus execution/repair
as progressively loaded governor/reference cognition.

Required target form

one atomic IMPLEMENTAUDIT plugin package
  skills/implementaudit/SKILL.md       public/default governor
  skills/audit-state/SKILL.md          internal model-facing skill
  skills/audit-assess/SKILL.md         internal model-facing skill
  skills/audit-hqyqh/SKILL.md          maintainer-only internal skill
  skills/implementaudit/references/    shared progressive cognition/evidence
  skills/implementaudit/scripts/       shared deterministic substrate
  skills/implementaudit/templates/     shared deterministic/state substrate
  generated IMPLEMENTAUDIT.skill       standalone compatibility projection

audit-hqyqh passed the exact downstream naming gate with a strict bounded
description. It is project-style ASCII inspired by ḥaqīqa (حقيقة) and
denotes candidate/claim-relative actuality across applicable maintainer
evidence surfaces, not universal truth. audit-trace remains rejected because
Trace already owns the ordinary ledger/docs/boundary/Capability-Ledger/
commit-text gate. audit-admit remains rejected because R34 already owns
engineering-value admission and a machine-consumed ADMIT outcome, while the
verb also implies granting a transition. Comparator-only audit-thqyq remains
rejected as a process/action near-collision with tdqyq/ydqyq.

The package remains one versioned release/install unit. Internal skills never
become independent packages or independently versioned artifacts.

Semantic ownership invariants

1. /implementaudit is the sole stable public/default governor and the only
   owner of intake, routing, package/precedence validation, authority,
   currentness, lifecycle, deterministic Andon, transitions and closure.
2. A governor event loads at most one internal skill. Children never route to
   children and do not form a lifecycle sequence.
3. Direct entry without the exact governor envelope refuses or returns to the
   governor. A direct child result creates no authority.
4. No child mutates canonical state, mints continuity, establishes currentness,
   writes lifecycle state, authorizes effects, or establishes
   AUDIT_COMPLETE.
5. Planning and execution/repair cognition remain progressively reachable
   through the governor's existing shared reference owners. They are not
   internal skills and are not erased.
6. Shared references, scripts, templates, schemas and checkers have one source
   owner; no child copies deterministic contracts to appear self-contained.
7. Generic /implementaudit remains ActiveGraph-optional and
   non-authoritative. Mandatory exact-state-bound ActiveGraph remains only the
   governed self-dogfood sidecar.

Accepted child contracts

audit-state

Trigger only after a real compaction, restart, transfer or stale-context
boundary and after the governor mechanically verifies controller, continuity,
candidate and currentness. Consume the bounded verified checkpoint/frontier and
remembered steers; distinguish current, superseded, satisfied, unresolved and
contradictory obligations; return a decision-usable rehydration record and
exact next-action recommendation.

It does not own or mutate STATE/ROADMAP, custody, epochs, receipts, canonical
currentness, ACTIVE/READY/BLOCKED state, transitions, authority or closure.

audit-assess

Trigger only from an immutable packet whose digest, requested claims, evidence
boundary, disposition vocabulary and independence contract the governor has
bound. Perform independent/adversarial claim assessment; return claim-level
findings and a bounded PASS / NEEDS_REVISION / NONVERDICT-style disposition.

It does not self-review, edit, repair, accept readiness, own deterministic
evaluators, authorize effects or close the audit.

audit-hqyqh — MAINTAINER_RELEASE_QUALIFICATION

Trigger only for maintainer-side exact-candidate qualification after the
governor proves maintainer scope, exact source/tree/package/host identity and
release currentness. Compare source, generated, packaged, installed, hosted,
exact-main, released and public-readback states without collapsing identities;
return bounded claim-level gaps and what progression the evidence supports.

It does not establish formal qualification by itself, commit, push, merge,
tag, publish, release, establish provenance, mutate lifecycle state, close a
tracker or establish audit closure.

Exact implementation cells

C00 — resolve the third accepted name

• Input: the frozen capability above plus exact terminology/morphology census.
• Required result: one owner-selected candidate independently passes the same
  collision, morphology, authority, direct-entry and scope tests.
• STOP: no accepted name, lexical collision, result-state implication, release
  authority implication, or any proposal to modify the capability to fit the
  name.
• Result: COMPLETE; audit-hqyqh accepted with the strict bounded-reality
  description, audit-thqyq rejected, and the hidden three-child lifecycle
  sequence explicitly rejected. Evidence is the exact naming artifact bound
  above.

C01 — focused topology RED

• Create the focused test first, provisionally
  tests/internal-skill-topology.test.sh, plus minimal deterministic fixtures
  under fixtures/internal-skill-topology/ only if data separation is useful.
• RED must prove the current exact control has one source skill and rejects the
  required exact population [implementaudit, audit-state, audit-assess, audit-hqyqh].
• RED must fail for the absent reviewed topology, not syntax, path setup,
  permissions or unrelated baseline failure.
• Preserve the current P1 package tests as baseline evidence.

C02 — package contract and population source

• Update package/implementaudit-package.json from one required skill to the
  exact four-skill atomic population, while separately recording one
  public_governor and exactly three internal_skills with the maintainer-only
  attribute on the third.
• Update scripts/package-contract.py and
  scripts/check-package-contract.sh so observed skills/*/SKILL.md equals the
  exact declared population; missing, extra, duplicated, misnamed, independently
  versioned or partial populations fail closed.
• Keep .codex-plugin/plugin.json and .claude-plugin/plugin.json pointed at
  the one plugin ./skills/ root and bound to the same package version. Do not
  create per-child manifests.
• Update tests/package-contract.test.sh with positive exact-population and
  negative missing/extra/renamed/independent-version/maintainer-flag cases.

C03 — source skills and governor routing

• Add exactly three canonical child SKILL.md files at the accepted names.
• Update skills/implementaudit/SKILL.md only enough to expose the exact
  governor route, direct-entry refusal, one-child maximum, package-vs-target
  discriminator and return validation. Keep planning and execution/repair on
  the governor's progressive reference map.
• Each child frontmatter uses runtime version 0.4.0, a trigger-accurate
  description, and no language claiming public/default status, transition,
  currentness, mutation, acceptance, release or closure authority.
• Each child points to shared package-relative owners instead of copying
  continuity, review, package, release, state or closure machinery.
• Add deterministic semantic-owner assertions for all authority fences.

C04 — routing/currentness/independence controls

• Re-materialize the final three-skill subset of the disposable C01, C03, C06,
  C07, C08, C09, C10, C11, C15, C16, C17 and C18 discriminators as production
  tests with neutral experimental labels removed.
• Required positives: mechanically verified post-boundary state route;
  immutable independent review packet route; mechanically current maintainer
  qualification route.
• Required negatives: ordinary cheap path; direct child entry; stale or absent
  currentness; prose-only review; incomplete executing package; ambiguous
  plugin/standalone precedence; release NOT_APPLICABLE currentness; child
  authority/closure output.
• Preserve target-package failure versus executing-package failure:
  PACKAGE_GATE_SUBJECT=EXECUTING_IMPLEMENTAUDIT_PACKAGE and target verifier
  failure is a bound gate failure, not proof that the governor package is
  incomplete.

C05 — canonical plugin and standalone projection

• Extend the existing one-source builder/inventory path; do not introduce a
  second hand-written member list.
• Canonical IMPLEMENTAUDIT.plugin.zip contains all four skills/*/SKILL.md
  entries plus the single shared governor substrate and both host manifests.
• Generated IMPLEMENTAUDIT.skill remains one standalone public SKILL.md.
  It carries deterministic internal procedure projections for the three
  children, not three discoverable standalone packages, and retains the shared
  references/scripts/templates needed by those procedures.
• Package and inventory metadata bind source commit/tree/worktree state,
  runtime version, public governor, exact internal population, member bytes and
  SHA-256. Missing/extra/stale projections fail closed.
• Measure both artifacts against the already reviewed 327,680-byte caps. An
  overrun STOPs for R33; artifact size cannot bless a post-build cap increase.

C06 — isolated install, discovery and precedence

• Extend temp-root-only plugin install/update/rollback tests to require the
  exact four-skill population atomically. Reject missing child, extra child,
  stale child, changed child hash, partial cache and mixed-version population.
• Prove /implementaudit remains the public/default governor and child
  discovery does not create correctness authority. Record exact host/version
  boundaries; file-copy evidence is not native discovery proof.
• Preserve standalone compatibility installation and reject ambiguous
  same-identity plugin-plus-standalone co-install.
• No test installation targets the user's real Codex or Claude home.

C07 — documentation and generated public projection

• Update AGENTS.md, README, CONTRIBUTING, package-content surfaces, docs
  portal sources and changelog only from final implemented behavior.
• Replace every zero-child assertion with the exact three-child boundary while
  preserving /implementaudit as sole public/default governor and one atomic
  package.
• Document that planning/execution remain progressively loaded references,
  children do not chain, direct entry grants no authority, and the standalone
  artifact is a compatibility projection rather than canonical topology.
• Regenerate docs from their canonical source and run public-claim/package-shape
  checks. R29 public publication remains final-composed-only.

C08 — exact candidate review and qualification

• Run focused topology/routing/package tests, existing package-contract and
  plugin install/release tests, then scripts/verify-package.sh once on the
  composed exact tree.
• Preserve all RED witnesses and compare Smoke B against the clean P1 baseline.
• Obtain fresh exact-tree independent code/architecture review. Correlated N7Y
  authors or scorers do not count as this review.
• Hosted CI, installed host behavior and public readback remain separate
  evidence legs.

C09 — final self-dogfood and release sequence

• Only after C01-C08 pass, re-resolve the latest published ActiveGraph release
  from the authoritative package source, verify package identity/hash/provenance
  and install it in the isolated self-dogfood environment.
• Re-run exact-state binding, replay/currentness and retention/compaction
  controls. Do not use or silently fall back to global ActiveGraph 1.1.0.
• Bind the self-dogfood receipt to exact source/tree/package/install and
  ActiveGraph package identity. A compatibility/control failure is STOP.
• Then follow the existing PR v0.4.0.0 final composition: State Synthesis Substrate Engineering #206, hosted/Pages, merge, exact-main,
  v0.4.0.0 release, public readback and tracker-closure gates.

Acceptance controls

Positive:

• exact atomic four-skill plugin population installs and inventories as one
  version;
• each of the three bounded triggers selects exactly one child after required
  mechanical gates;
• planning and execution/repair remain reachable through progressive shared
  references without child identities;
• standalone compatibility keeps one public governor and reaches only the
  projected bounded procedures;
• exact installed package and final self-dogfood pass at bound identities.

Negative:

• reject five children, zero children, planning child, execution child,
  closure child, L4 child, child chaining and direct-entry authority;
• reject missing/extra/renamed/stale/mixed-version child populations;
• reject stale currentness, absent independence contract, release
  NOT_APPLICABLE currentness, and child claims of mutation/authority/closure;
• reject generic ActiveGraph dependency and any real-home proof install;
• preserve the C01/C13/C15/C17 RED ancestry and evidence-bearing review case.

Boundary and held-out:

• target package failure differs from executing IMPLEMENTAUDIT package failure;
• plugin discovery, standalone compatibility, file-copy install, native host
  invocation and marketplace publication remain separate claims;
• a child description cannot select its own route;
• a child result is evidence input to the governor, never a transition;
• host-unreachable behavior is DOMAIN_OR_HOST_BOUND, not inferred PASS;
• triggered-path static token savings and production host context savings
  remain unclaimed unless measured on the final installed candidate.

DAG and writer serialization

C00 accepted name
  -> exact work-order finalization + independent cold review
  -> fresh R45 census + one additive superseding comment + readback
  -> C01 RED
  -> C02 package population owner
  -> C03 source skills/governor route
  -> C04 routing/currentness controls
  -> C05 package projections
  -> C06 isolated install/discovery
  -> C07 docs/generated projection
  -> C08 exact qualification + independent review
  -> C09 latest-ActiveGraph self-dogfood + release sequence

C01 fixture preimages and disjoint child prose drafts may be prepared in
parallel after the exact work order receives a fresh independent cold PASS,
but one writer owns package metadata/checkers, one writer
owns the governor route, and one writer owns builder/inventory/install
composition. C07 waits for implemented behavior. No model sampling, source
mutation, GitHub mutation or self-dogfood starts from this draft.

Rollback and retirement

Rollback removes only the three-child source, routing, package, install, test
and docs delta and restores the exact P1 control behavior; it does not erase
N7Y evidence or weaken the canonical dual-host plugin. Generated projections
are regenerated from the restored source. Failed samples and exact review
receipts remain append-only evidence.

An internal skill retires only if its distinct consumer/trigger/payoff no
longer survives fresh evidence and a reviewed R45/R41/R42 owner disposition.
Retirement cannot silently move authority into another child or break atomic
package inventory.

Done state

This amendment is done only when the accepted names and exact three-skill
population are source-implemented; package/install/discovery/routing negatives
pass; one governor and one atomic package remain true; planning/execution are
progressive references; no child owns authority/currentness/lifecycle/closure;
exact-tree focused/package/installed/independent/hosted evidence passes; the
latest verified ActiveGraph self-dogfood passes in isolation; R45 evidence is
read back; and the normal release/public/tracker gates close.

The earlier cold-review lane was terminated after repeated bounded waits with
no substantive output and is REVIEWER_RUNTIME_NON_VERDICT; it supplies no
PASS. This revision requires a fresh reviewer over these exact bytes.

R45_THREE_SKILL_AMENDMENT_READY=FRESH_INDEPENDENT_COLD_REVIEW_REQUIRED

[theislampill]

v0.4.0.0 terminal census — R002D remains open

TERMINAL_CONTRACT_DISPOSITION=UNSATISFIED_EXACT_ROW

The released composition satisfies R002D's final four-child architecture,
package, CI, DAG, BANQUET, canonical rehearsal and public-release identities,
but its two additive amendments also require final self-dogfood using the
latest verified published ActiveGraph release in isolation, bound to the exact
final candidate/package identity.

The retained isolated ActiveGraph 1.10.0 evidence binds wheel
activegraph-1.10.0-py3-none-any.whl, 386,411 bytes, SHA-256
5178cb31160abca6636fa7110f53d740cb20f1468c04c9ee36852cd85abe82b6;
global 1.1.0 was unused, generic dependency was false, the live store was not
mutated, the snapshot positive passed, and corrupt archive/blob/missing-sidecar
negatives failed closed. Those receipts bind earlier candidate identities
10f8a55..., 8722fa... and 267a08..., not the qualified final candidate
71a7101ade904f5482cbc25c5154e1eadea0c7be, tree
cc9771854689337d839c2a2e37040dc3ac2caa0d, and frozen package manifest
SHA-256 cc656ad4825b340d87457fb873074c577dccd39709b4ba109cec68ecce8bdb31.

Exact missing acceptance: one combined isolated ActiveGraph 1.10.0
self-dogfood receipt bound to the qualified final candidate/tree and frozen
package identities, or a separately reviewed current-tree disposition that
truthfully supersedes that explicit terminal row. Marketplace installation is
not this evidence and the release report makes no marketplace claim.

R002D therefore remains OPEN. This record preserves the exact missing row; it
does not downgrade the valid release, package, CI, DAG, BANQUET, rehearsal or
public-readback evidence and does not claim implementation completion.

[theislampill]

RLGWO amendment — conditional same-extension trajectory-changeability acceptance

RLGWO_AMENDMENT=YES
RLGWO_OWNER=R002D
TARGET_ISSUE=#197
AMENDMENT_CLASS=NORMATIVE_ACCEPTANCE_ONLY

SEMANTIC_CENTRE_DELTA=NO
CORE_INVARIANT_DELTA=NO
NORMATIVE_ACCEPTANCE_DELTA=YES
CURRENT_SOURCE_RUNTIME_DELTA_PROVED=NO
RUNTIME_BEHAVIOUR_DELTA_REQUIRED_BY_THIS_AMENDMENT=NO
ACCEPTANCE_TEST_DELTA=CONDITIONAL_ON_EXACT_CURRENT_FALSE_PASS_RED
IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORITY_CREATED=NO
NEW_RXX=NO

This additive amendment changes R002D's mandatory acceptance contract only. It
does not establish a current source, runtime or acceptance-test failure and does
not authorise source, test, package, generated, installed or public mutation.

Canonical property admission

CANONICAL_ROWS_STRENGTHENED=
  LAW_AGILE::EA-08
    property=Maintained technical changeability
    historical_v0400_disposition=ALREADY_EMERGENT_DIFFERENT_FORM
    v041_admission=STRONGER_CONDITIONAL_ACCEPTANCE

  SSD_SYSTEMS::P016
    property=Demonstrate modularity, coupling and evolvability rather than
             merely claiming them
    historical_v0400_disposition=OUT_OF_V0400_SCOPE
    source_disposition=ASSUMPTION_BOUND
    v041_admission=EXPLICIT_CONDITIONAL_ACCEPTANCE_ONLY

  SSD_SYSTEMS::P017
    property=Evaluate architecture against scenarios and evidence before
             irreversible commitment
    historical_v0400_disposition=OUT_OF_V0400_SCOPE
    source_disposition=ASSUMPTION_BOUND
    v041_admission=EXPLICIT_CONDITIONAL_ACCEPTANCE_ONLY

Historical v0.4.0 dispositions are not rewritten. P016 and P017 do not become
generic runtime obligations. They activate only under the trigger below and
remain outside ordinary one-off, disposable, directly replaceable and
short-life work.

Research and authority boundary

EMPIRICAL_DOMAIN_EVIDENCE=
  SlopCodeBench, arXiv:2603.24755v2, supplies bounded evidence that an
  agent-owned workspace may remain current-checkpoint-functional while earlier
  design choices increase the propagation required by later extensions.

THEORETICAL_OR_CONCEPTUAL_SUPPORT=
  Bennett, arXiv:2301.12987v4, supplies only the limited rationale that a valid
  hypothesis should not be made more specific than necessary and that
  description length is not the same property as weakness.

EXISTING_ENGINEERING_GENEALOGY=
  EA-08 plus P016/P017 and their existing native owners supply the software
  engineering property, trigger boundaries and evidence obligations.

Bennett's weakness is the extension cardinality of a logical hypothesis inside
a finite enactive formalism under a uniform task distribution. It is not
software modularity, interface breadth, abstraction count, code length or a
changeability score. No mapping from repository architecture to Bennett's task
lattice has been established. His theorem, arithmetic experiments and
neural-network speculation are not imported as a software-engineering theorem,
runtime rule, metric or second acceptance predicate.

SlopCodeBench's cyclomatic-complexity cutoff, erosion and verbosity formulae,
repository ratios, checkpoint scores and prompt effects likewise remain
experiment-local. No LOC, CC, erosion, verbosity, benchmark-score, code-length,
interface-width, abstraction-count or Bennett-weakness threshold may decide
this acceptance.

Existing acceptance collision

Current R002D rejects stale architecture, interface, configuration, integration
and evidence relations. R0019 rejects proved duplication, dead code, layering,
typing and error-handling defects. R001F requires a receiver-complete executable
work order. R0022 requires consequence, proportionality, a cheapest sufficient
discriminator and a cheap path.

Those owners can nevertheless permit closure after an extension when a
candidate:

1. performs a broad architecture-caused rewrite;
2. removes temporary duplication and other current hygiene defects;
3. re-establishes every invalidated currentness and evidence relation;
4. satisfies the complete current work order and focused/regression checks; and
5. again appears current-green at closure.

Current acceptance does not require that candidate to be compared with another
current-green preimage receiving the same extension. The added discrimination is
therefore trajectory-relative rather than another current-state hygiene or
currentness check.

Mandatory conditional discriminator

TRAJECTORY_CHANGEABILITY_HELD_OUT=v1

TRIGGER=
  - the work order expressly claims maintained evolvability, technical
    changeability or architecture fitness under repeated material extension;
  - repeated material extension is part of the declared use;
  - at least one semantic variation boundary is already relevant to the current
    contract rather than invented solely for an arbitrary future;
  - one bounded next extension can exercise that boundary without disclosing
    an intended internal architecture; and
  - the result can change architecture or change-impact acceptance.

PREIMAGE_CONTROL_A=
  a minimal current-green implementation that preserves the already-relevant
  semantic variation boundary without prescribing the held-out future
  interface, implementation class, module graph or abstraction name.

PREIMAGE_MUTANT_B=
  a current-green implementation with the same external contract that satisfies
  every applicable current R002D/R0019/R001F/R0022 acceptance obligation but
  collapses that same already-relevant variation boundary into a currently
  convenient representation.

INTERVENTION=
  apply the same bounded next material extension to A and B.
  Withhold the extension from both preimage authors.
  State only the external behaviour and legitimate current constraints.
  Do not provide an intended architecture name, benchmark threshold, answer cue
  or paper-derived implementation instruction.

CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_PRECONDITION=
  before intervention, A and B must each:
  - satisfy the same external/current contract and regression population;
  - be eligible for closure under all applicable current acceptance;
  - satisfy current R002D intent, authority, assumption, architecture,
    interface, configuration, integration and evidence-currentness relations;
  - satisfy current R0019 hygiene dispositions without a known local defect;
  - carry an R001F-complete current work order; and
  - preserve R0022 proportionality and the ordinary cheap path.

CONTROL_A_EXPECTED=
  the extension remains within the already-relevant owned variation boundary,
  except for work inherently required by the external extension itself.
  Affected evidence is precisely identified, invalidated where necessary and
  re-established before closure.

MUTANT_B_RED=
  after excluding work inherently required by the external extension, B
  requires materially broader cross-boundary replacement because its preimage
  collapsed the already-relevant variation boundary.
  B remains RED for the trajectory-changeability claim even if the broad repair
  later restores a current-green state that satisfies every current checkpoint
  acceptance criterion.

ALREADY_CAUGHT_CASES=
  - duplicate or divergent semantic ownership remains R0019;
  - stale dependent architecture/interface/integration evidence remains current
    R002D;
  - a receiver-incomplete implementation work order remains R001F;
  - speculative or disproportionate process machinery remains R0022;
  - ordinary functional or regression failure remains ordinary acceptance.

BOUNDARIES=
  - broad change inherent in the external requirement is not an architecture
    failure;
  - current performance, safety, security, compatibility, authority, deployment
    or recovery constraints may justify a more specific design;
  - an explicit owner-approved replacement, abandonment or rewrite strategy may
    pass when it is the declared and proportionate lifecycle choice;
  - no speculative seam is required for an arbitrary unforeseeable future;
  - one-off, disposable, short-life and direct-replacement work retains its
    existing cheap path;
  - neither maximal generality nor maximal Bennett weakness is required;
  - no LOC, CC, erosion, verbosity, benchmark, code-length, abstraction-count
    or interface-width threshold may decide;
  - a plan, prompt, comment or self-description saying `extensible` cannot pass
    the held-out intervention.

PASS_CONDITION=
  - A and B share the same valid current precondition and receive the same
    bounded extension;
  - A passes without architecture-caused propagation beyond the
    extension-inherent work;
  - B is rejected specifically because the collapsed current variation boundary
    causes broader cross-boundary replacement;
  - the result is not produced by a current hygiene defect, stale evidence,
    disclosed architecture cue, static quality proxy or speculative seam; and
  - current correctness, currentness, justified specificity and every cheap-path
    boundary remain preserved.

Execution, RED and mutation boundary

EXECUTION_EFFECT=
  every future R002D execution for which TRIGGER is true must disposition
  TRAJECTORY_CHANGEABILITY_HELD_OUT=v1 before R002D closure.
  The execution record must bind:
  - trigger evidence;
  - exact source/tree and current acceptance population;
  - A and B preimage identities;
  - the shared held-out extension;
  - extension-inherent work excluded from comparison;
  - observed propagation and evidence invalidation;
  - PASS, exact-current RED, current-acceptance-already-stronger, or NO_CHANGE
    disposition.
  When TRIGGER is false, record NOT_TRIGGERED and retain the ordinary cheap path.

RED_REQUIREMENT=
  before any acceptance-test implementation delta, preserve one exact-current
  false-pass mutant for which:
  - the exact current acceptance population permits closure;
  - the current tree and focused/regression checks pass;
  - the same bounded extension produces the required control/mutant distinction;
  - the proposed predicate rejects B for architecture-caused propagation; and
  - the failure is not merely an absent new checker, synthetic missing
    implementation, current hygiene defect or stale-evidence defect.
  Any runtime-behaviour repair additionally requires its own exact-current
  missing postcondition and authority.

NO_RED_DISPOSITION=
  NO_CHANGE.
  Make no source, test, checker, fixture, package, generated, installed, public
  or runtime mutation.
  Do not promote P016 or P017 into generic ceremony.
  Preserve the research and the no-RED result as bounded evidence.

RECOMBINATION=
  if an exact-current RED admits one acceptance-test delta, recombine the
  resulting discriminator into R002D's existing P016/P017
  architecture-scenario and change-impact acceptance family.
  Do not retain a separate Bennett predicate, weakness score, benchmark mode or
  paper-specific lifecycle.

ROLLBACK=
  any admitted test/checker implementation must be independently reversible.
  If it rejects extension-inherent change, justified current specificity,
  owner-approved replacement or the ordinary cheap path, revert that
  implementation, restore the prior acceptance surface, preserve the failed
  evidence and re-adjudicate under R002D.
  Do not erase GitHub history; any withdrawal of this normative amendment must
  be additive and identify the existing predicate proved to make it redundant.

RETIREMENT=
  retire the separate fixture family or label only when a cheaper owner-native
  discriminator is proved to preserve the same control/mutant relation, every
  consumer and every negative boundary.
  Otherwise keep it trigger-bound and absent from ordinary work.